Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Sentimentality

Sentimentality refers to the indulgence in tender emotions, often characterized by an excessive or affected display of feeling that appeals to pathos, sometimes at the expense of authenticity or moral depth.^[1] In philosophical and aesthetic contexts, it involves idealizing objects or experiences to seek personal gratification and reassurance, potentially distorting reality through self-deception or evasion of harsher truths.^[2] This concept distinguishes itself from genuine sentiment, which encompasses sincere emotional responses, by emphasizing counterfeit or unearned emotions that prioritize emotional pleasure over objective evaluation.^[3] Historically, sentimentality emerged in the 18th century amid the rise of sentimentalism in British philosophy and literature, where it promoted empathy and moral sensibility through emotional narratives, influencing works that stirred compassion for the vulnerable.^[4] By the Victorian era, it became a prominent mode in novels and poetry, focusing on the evocation and interpretation of emotions to engage readers, as seen in Charles Dickens's depictions of domestic pathos and Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin, which mobilized sentimental appeals for social reform.^[4] In psychology and moral philosophy, sentimentality has been analyzed as a form of affective attachment that can reinforce social bonds and personal well-being, yet it often invites criticism for fostering superficiality or ethical complacency.^[2] Critics, including literary figures like Henry James and philosophers such as Anthony Savile, view sentimentality as an aesthetic and moral flaw, arguing that it involves falsifying aspects of experience to indulge in easy emotional rewards, thereby undermining genuine moral judgment or artistic integrity.^[5] Despite this, defenders like Robert C. Solomon highlight its potential ethical value in cultivating tenderness and compassion, particularly in literature, where it serves as a tool for emotional education without real-world harm.^[1] In contemporary discussions, sentimental value—distinct from instrumental or aesthetic worth—refers to the non-fungible significance of objects or memories tied to personal history, providing reasons for preservation and attachment that enrich moral psychology. Overall, sentimentality remains a double-edged concept, valued for its capacity to humanize but scrutinized for its risks of emotional excess and manipulation across art, ethics, and everyday life.

Definition and Characteristics

Etymology and Historical Meaning

The term "sentimentality" derives from the Latin verb sentire, meaning "to feel," which evolved through Medieval Latin sentimentum (feeling or opinion) and Old French sentiment (sense or emotion) into English "sentiment" by the late 14th century, initially denoting a personal feeling or judgment influenced by emotion.^[6] The adjective "sentimental" first appeared in English around 1749, formed from "sentiment" + "-al," and originally signified something pertaining to sentiment, particularly in moral philosophy where emotions guided ethical discernment, as in David Hume's discussions of moral sentiments in works like A Treatise of Human Nature (1739–1740).^[7]^[8] The noun "sentimentality" emerged shortly after, with its earliest recorded use in 1770 in the Monthly Review, extending the adjectival sense to describe a quality or tendency toward emotional sentiment.^[9] In the 18th-century Enlightenment, "sentimental" held a predominantly positive connotation, emphasizing the role of feelings in accessing moral truth as part of moral sense theory, which posited an innate emotional capacity for ethical judgment. Hume advanced this view by arguing that moral distinctions arise from sentiments rather than reason alone, influencing the term's adoption in philosophical discourse.^[8] Adam Smith's The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759) exemplified this usage, portraying moral sentiments—rooted in sympathy—as the mechanism by which individuals approve virtuous actions and cultivate social harmony, without implying excess.^[10]^[11] By the late 18th century, however, the term began acquiring negative overtones, suggesting emotional excess or undue reflection over genuine feeling.^[7] Friedrich Schiller's 1795 essay On Naïve and Sentimental Poetry marked a key critique, distinguishing "sentimental" poetry as reflective and idealistic—contrasting with the natural spontaneity of "naïve" works—but warning that excessive reflection could lead to artificiality or detachment from lived experience, thus diluting aesthetic authenticity.^[12] This shift intensified in the 19th century, where "sentimentality" increasingly denoted affected or insincere emotionalism in a contemptuous sense, as lexicographical sources began associating it with superficial tenderness rather than moral depth.^[13]

Core Features and Manifestations

Sentimentality is characterized by the indulgence in exaggerated, idealized emotions that are disproportionate to the realities of the situation, often centering on tender responses such as pity, nostalgia, or romantic affection. These emotions are typically unearned, stemming from a cognitive distortion that overemphasizes positive traits while disregarding flaws or complexities, leading to a form of self-gratification through the meta-pleasure of feeling compassionate.^[14]^[15] Manipulation of feelings frequently occurs via reliance on clichés or stereotypes, which simplify evocation of sympathy without requiring genuine justification or depth.^[14] In personal behavior, sentimentality manifests as overly effusive reactions to minor provocations, such as maudlin tears or gestures over trivial losses, which primarily serve to bolster the individual's self-perception as emotionally sensitive rather than addressing the event substantively.^[15] Rhetorically, it appears in persuasive appeals that prioritize emotional arousal over logical reasoning, employing sentimental narratives to elicit unreflective agreement by invoking idealized human bonds or sufferings.^[16] In aesthetic contexts, sentimentality simplifies complex experiences like death, love, or loss into unchallenging, formulaic depictions that provoke easy emotional responses, bypassing nuanced exploration of human frailty.^[14] Sentimentality differs from genuine empathy in its superficiality and self-orientation; whereas empathy involves a deep, justified sharing of another's perspective grounded in authentic concern, sentimentality yields shallow, unearned feelings that prioritize the expresser's emotional satisfaction over meaningful connection.^[15] It also relates to kitsch as an emotional precursor, with both involving superficial evocations of feeling, but kitsch emphasizes mass-produced aesthetic triviality, while sentimentality specifically targets the excess and artificiality of the emotional response itself.^[14] Modern manifestations include Hallmark greeting cards, which commodify standardized sentimental expressions to simulate intimacy and evoke unearned sympathy in routine social exchanges.^[17] Similarly, emotional content on social media can amplify reactions through high-arousal narratives that spread rapidly but may foster only fleeting compassion.^[18]

Historical Development

18th-Century Origins in Philosophy and Literature

The emergence of sentimentality in the 18th century can be traced to philosophical developments in moral sense theory, which posited that ethical judgments arise from innate emotional responses rather than pure reason. Anthony Ashley-Cooper, 3rd Earl of Shaftesbury, laid foundational ideas in his 1711 work Characteristics of Men, Manners, Opinions, Times, arguing that humans possess a natural moral sense that enables appreciation of virtue through harmony and proportion in nature and society.^[19] This theory influenced Francis Hutcheson, who in his 1725 An Inquiry into the Original of Our Ideas of Beauty and Virtue expanded on the moral sense as an internal faculty that approves benevolent actions and disapproves of vice, emphasizing disinterested affection as the basis of morality.^[20] David Hume further developed these ideas in his A Treatise of Human Nature (1739–1740), positing that sympathy—our capacity to share in others' feelings—underlies moral approbation and disapprobation, making emotions central to ethical discernment.^[21] Adam Smith refined these concepts in his 1759 The Theory of Moral Sentiments, where sympathy—the imaginative projection of oneself into others' situations—serves as the cornerstone of ethical behavior, fostering social bonds through shared emotional experiences.^[10] However, Immanuel Kant offered an early critique of this sentimental approach in works like the Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785), emphasizing duty and reason over emotional impulses and viewing sentimentality—such as the "ineffectual sharing of one's feelings"—as a deviation from moral sensitivity rooted in principled action rather than mere feeling.^[22] This philosophical shift occurred amid a broader cultural reaction against the neoclassical emphasis on rational restraint and classical imitation, which had dominated early 18th-century thought and art. Neoclassicism prioritized objective rules and decorum, but thinkers and writers increasingly championed "sensibility" as a refined emotional sensitivity that allowed for personal intuition and moral intuition over strict logic.^[23] Sensibility was viewed not as uncontrolled passion but as a cultivated capacity for delicate feeling, enabling individuals to respond empathetically to beauty, suffering, and virtue in everyday life.^[24] This promotion of emotional depth reflected Enlightenment ideals of human progress through inner experience, positioning sensibility as a counterbalance to the era's mechanistic worldview. In literature, these ideas manifested in the rise of the sentimental novel and comedy, genres that depicted virtuous characters enduring moral trials to evoke reader empathy. Samuel Richardson's Pamela; or, Virtue Rewarded (1740) pioneered the form with its epistolary narrative of a servant girl's resistance to seduction, highlighting the rewards of moral fortitude and emotional purity.^[25] His subsequent Clarissa (1748) intensified this approach, portraying the tragic suffering of a young woman under familial and social pressures, thereby illustrating how refined sensibility could affirm ethical resilience amid adversity.^[25] Complementing these, Richard Steele's comedy The Conscious Lovers (1722) shifted dramatic conventions by resolving conflicts through benevolence and mutual understanding rather than wit or intrigue, establishing sentimental comedy as a vehicle for moral instruction via emotional appeal.^[26] A pivotal literary milestone came with Laurence Sterne's A Sentimental Journey Through France and Italy (1768), a fragmented travelogue that intertwined personal anecdotes of compassion and humor to blend emotion with moral reflection, solidifying sentimentality's role in narrative innovation.^[27]

Evolution in the 19th and 20th Centuries

In the 19th century, sentimentality gained widespread popularity during the Victorian era, particularly in literature, where it blended Romantic emphases on emotion with melodramatic storytelling to evoke profound empathy from readers. Charles Dickens exemplified this trend in works like The Old Curiosity Shop (1841), whose death scene of the child character Little Nell provoked mass public grief, with reports of readers openly weeping in streets and theaters upon serialized installments revealing her fate. This emotional intensity reflected broader Victorian cultural values that celebrated sentiment as a moral force, fostering communal bonds through shared pathos in novels and theater.^[28]^[29] Philosophical critiques continued to position sentimentality as an excess that undermined rational autonomy. Friedrich Nietzsche extended this critique more forcefully, dismissing pity—a core element of sentimental responses—as a sign of weakness that perpetuates mediocrity and hinders human overcoming, as explored in Thus Spoke Zarathustra (1883–1885), where Zarathustra warns against commiserating with the suffering as it fosters dependency and enervates the strong.^[30] By the 20th century, modernism marked a sharp rejection of sentimentality, favoring irony, fragmentation, and detachment to capture the dislocations of modern life. James Joyce's Ulysses (1922) parodied sentimental tropes through its stylistic experiments, subverting emotional clichés in episodes that mock maudlin narratives while embracing a pragmatic, ironic semiotics over heartfelt excess. Despite this literary shift, sentimentality persisted in popular cultural forms, thriving in Hollywood films that deployed tear-jerking melodramas to affirm traditional values amid social upheaval, and in pulp romance novels, which amplified idealized emotions to appeal to mass audiences seeking escapist catharsis.^[31]^[32] Post-World War II, sentimentality experienced a decline influenced by existentialism's emphasis on absurdity, alienation, and the rejection of comforting illusions in the face of war's devastation, as philosophers like Jean-Paul Sartre highlighted individual authenticity over emotional consolation. This era's disillusionment tempered overt sentimental expressions in high culture, prioritizing stark realism. However, a revival occurred in the 1960s counterculture, where "flower power" idealism—manifest in pacifist movements and communal visions of love and harmony—reinfused sentimentality as a rebellious affirmation of human connection against institutional coldness.^[33]^[34]

Sentimentality in Arts and Culture

In Literature and Theater

In literature, sentimentality often employs techniques such as the pathetic fallacy, where human emotions are attributed to inanimate objects or nature to heighten emotional resonance and evoke sympathy in readers. This device, coined by critic John Ruskin, allows authors to externalize characters' inner states through environmental descriptions, amplifying the pathos of scenes without direct narration.^[35] For instance, in Charles Dickens's works, stormy weather mirrors characters' turmoil, reinforcing sentimental appeals to moral reform.^[36] Exaggerated pathos in dialogues further characterizes sentimental prose, with characters delivering overwrought speeches that prioritize emotional intensity over realism to stir audience feelings. Samuel Richardson's epistolary novels, like Pamela (1740), exemplify this through the protagonist's verbose expressions of virtue and suffering, designed to elicit tears and ethical reflection.^[37] Idealized characters, particularly suffering heroines, dominate sentimental narratives; Richardson's Pamela embodies moral purity amid adversity, while Dickens's figures like Little Nell in The Old Curiosity Shop (1841) represent innocence victimized by social ills, prompting readers to confront injustice through vicarious emotion.^[38] In theater, sentimentality manifested in 18th-century sentimental comedies, which shifted from Restoration wit to moral uplift through reformed rakes and virtuous resolutions. Colley Cibber's Love's Last Shift (1696) pioneered this genre, portraying a wayward husband reformed by his wife's feigned prostitution, culminating in familial reconciliation to affirm ethical values over bawdy humor.^[39] By the 19th century, sentimental elements evolved into melodramas, featuring sensational plots with clear villains, persecuted innocents, and tear-jerking resolutions that rewarded virtue. Plays like Dion Boucicault's The Octoroon (1859) used exaggerated emotional climaxes—such as sacrificial deaths—to manipulate audiences toward empathy and social commentary on issues like slavery.^[40] These techniques served broader impacts, manipulating audiences for moral instruction by channeling emotions toward ethical lessons, as sentimental works positioned feeling as a pathway to virtue.^[41] Feminist readings highlight how sentimental novels empowered female voices through emotional expression, allowing women authors and characters to assert agency in domestic spheres often denied rational discourse; for example, heroines' affective narratives challenged patriarchal constraints by valorizing sensitivity as moral strength.^[42] A seminal example is Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin (1852), which harnessed sentimentality as an abolitionist tool by depicting enslaved characters' sufferings—such as Tom's martyrdom and Eliza's maternal flight—to provoke moral outrage and galvanize anti-slavery sentiment among Northern readers.^[43] Stowe's use of idealized victims and pathetic scenes, like the death of Eva, amplified pathos to underscore Christianity's incompatibility with slavery, influencing public opinion and contributing to the Civil War's fervor.^[44] However, James Baldwin critiqued this approach in his essay "Everybody's Protest Novel" from Notes of a Native Son (1955), arguing that Stowe's self-righteous sentimentality reduced Black characters to stereotypes, prioritizing white moral catharsis over authentic racial complexity and perpetuating a "protest" literature that sentimentalized suffering without systemic change.^[45]

In Visual Arts, Music, and Modern Media

In the visual arts, sentimentality manifested prominently in 19th-century genre paintings that emphasized moralistic family scenes, as exemplified by Jean-Baptiste Greuze's works, which blended Rococo elegance with didactic narratives to evoke empathy for domestic virtues and filial piety.^[46] Greuze's paintings, such as The Father's Curse: The Ungrateful Son (1777), dramatized emotional conflicts through theatrical poses and expressive gestures, aiming to elicit tears and moral reflection from viewers as a form of public edification.^[47] This approach extended into Victorian illustrations, where artists like Briton Riviere captured scenes of human-animal bonds to stir pity and tenderness, portraying vulnerable figures in poignant, narrative-driven compositions that appealed to the era's cult of domestic sentiment.^[48] Such illustrations, often found in periodicals and books, reinforced emotional responses to themes of loss and compassion, aligning with broader Victorian values of sympathy and moral uplift.^[49] In music, sentimentality found expression through 19th-century parlor songs, which were sentimental ballads performed in middle-class homes to convey themes of love, nostalgia, and melancholy, fostering intimate emotional connections among listeners.^[50] Composers like Stephen Foster contributed pieces such as "Jeanie with the Light Brown Hair" (1854), characterized by simple melodies and heartfelt lyrics that evoked wistful longing, making them staples of domestic entertainment.^[50] This tradition influenced later forms, including film scores that induce nostalgia; in Steven Spielberg's E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982), John Williams's score employs soaring strings and tender motifs to heighten the film's sentimental portrayal of friendship and separation, amplifying emotional peaks like the bicycle flight scene.^[51] The music's deliberate orchestration of warmth and melancholy has been noted for its role in manipulating audience empathy, contributing to the film's enduring appeal as a tearjerker.^[52] In modern media, sentimentality permeates television tropes, particularly in holiday specials that deploy formulaic narratives of reconciliation and warmth to evoke familial bonds and seasonal joy, as seen in recurring motifs of redemption and heartwarming resolutions.^[53] Social media amplifies this through viral pet videos, which often feature adorable or poignant animal moments designed to trigger instant emotional responses like joy or empathy, driving shares and engagement via platforms' algorithms. Similarly, #ThrowbackThursday posts encourage users to share nostalgic content, blending personal sentiment with communal nostalgia to foster connections and emotional validation in digital communities. Postmodern art critiques these tendencies, as in Jeff Koons's Balloon Dog series (1994–2000), where inflated, kitsch-inspired stainless steel sculptures parody sentimental attachments to childhood innocence and consumer objects, inviting reflection on the banality of emotional commodification.^[54] Koons's work, by elevating everyday ephemera to high art, underscores the tension between genuine feeling and manufactured nostalgia in contemporary culture.^[55] Post-2000 examples highlight sentimentality's evolution in global media. In K-pop, ballads and trot-infused tracks increasingly incorporate positive emotional tones, as lyrics from 1990 to 2019 show a shift toward uplift and romance, reflecting societal preferences for feel-good escapism in acts like TVXQ and modern groups.^[56] This sentimental streak persists in trot's revival, with its maudlin storytelling appealing to intergenerational audiences through exaggerated heartbreak and redemption.^[57] TikTok challenges further exemplify this by leveraging short-form videos to elicit rapid emotional highs, such as nostalgic dances or pet reunions, which tap into users' desires for joy and belonging to boost participation and virality. In 2020s influencer culture, creators promote emotional consumerism by curating content that evokes aspiration and vulnerability, influencing purchases through relatable narratives that blend personal stories with product endorsements, often at the expense of authentic emotional depth.^[58] Studies indicate this approach enhances brand recall when tied to evoked feelings, underscoring sentimentality's role in driving consumer action amid ethical concerns over manipulation.^[59]

Psychological Interpretations

In early 20th-century analytical psychology, Carl Jung analyzed sentimentality as a psychological phenomenon often masking deeper conflicts within the psyche. He described it as "the superstructure erected upon brutality," implying that excessive emotional displays serve to conceal repressed aggressive or brutal impulses, preventing their conscious integration. This view positions sentimentality not as genuine emotion but as a compensatory mechanism for unacknowledged shadow aspects of the personality. Jung further connected sentimentality to the anima, the archetypal feminine image in the male unconscious, which embodies moodiness, intuition, and relational tendencies; when projected outward, the anima can manifest as overly sentimental attachments or idealizations, particularly if the conscious persona emphasizes rationality over feeling. In this framework, sentimentality arises from incomplete individuation, where emotional projections distort interpersonal dynamics. In modern psychological perspectives, sentimentality functions as a defense mechanism, particularly in contexts of loss and grief, where it facilitates avoidance of complex emotional realities through idealized mourning. Idealization, a minor image-distorting defense, involves exaggerating positive attributes of the deceased or lost object to minimize painful ambiguities, such as unresolved conflicts or imperfections in the relationship; this can lead to maudlin, overly romanticized recollections that buffer against profound sorrow. Attachment theory complements this by linking insecure attachment styles—formed from inconsistent early caregiving—to heightened emotional reactivity, including maudlin or excessively sentimental responses to relational threats or separations. Individuals with anxious or disorganized attachments may rely on sentimental idealization to maintain bonds, fostering emotional dependency as a way to mitigate fears of abandonment. Cognitively, sentimentality reflects emotional reasoning bias, a distortion where affective states are treated as empirical evidence, allowing feelings to supersede factual assessment. This bias manifests in sentimental judgments, such as presuming a relationship's value based solely on nostalgic warmth rather than behavioral evidence, potentially perpetuating maladaptive patterns. Relatedly, research on empathy fatigue highlights how compassion collapse—wherein empathy diminishes for large-scale suffering—prompts sentimental shortcuts, like fixating on singular, emotionally vivid stories to bypass cognitive overload from mass tragedies. Post-2010 studies demonstrate this through the affect heuristic, where individuals default to simplified emotional cues for decision-making under empathetic strain.^[60] Emerging neuroimaging research in the 2020s elucidates sentimentality's neural underpinnings, revealing activation of reward circuitry during exposure to sentimental stimuli, such as nostalgic memories. Functional MRI studies show that nostalgia, a core sentimental experience, engages the ventral striatum and midbrain—key reward areas—alongside autobiographical memory networks like the hippocampus, contrasting with rational processing that relies more on prefrontal control regions. This suggests sentimentality provides hedonic reinforcement, potentially explaining its persistence despite cognitive costs, as emotional rewards temporarily override analytical evaluation.^[61] Sentimentality serves as a mechanism for social cohesion by eliciting collective empathy and reinforcing group bonds through shared emotional experiences. In instances of national mourning, such as the widespread grief following Princess Diana's death in 1997, public displays of sentiment fostered a temporary unity across social divides, promoting emotional openness and a collective sense of humanity in British society.^[62] This aligns with Talcott Parsons' functionalist perspective, where emotions—including sentimental expressions—contribute to role stabilization and system integration by providing affective reinforcement to social norms and interpersonal relations, thereby maintaining societal equilibrium.^[63] Cultural perceptions of sentimentality vary significantly, often reflecting broader societal values. In collectivist cultures like Japan, it manifests positively as mono no aware, a poignant sensitivity to the transience of life that cultivates communal appreciation and emotional harmony without excess.^[64] Conversely, in individualistic societies, sentimentality is frequently critiqued as indulgent or manipulative, prioritizing personal feelings over rational detachment. Feminist theorists in the 1980s and 1990s, notably Jane Tompkins, reclaimed sentimentality by revaluing 19th-century sentimental novels—such as Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin—as potent tools for moral and social critique, challenging patriarchal dismissals of women's emotional writing as trivial and asserting its role in cultural transformation.^[65] In contemporary contexts, sentimentality fulfills diverse functions in politics, consumerism, and digital spaces. Humanitarian campaigns leverage sentimental appeals to generate empathy for remote crises, mobilizing public support through vivid portrayals of suffering that evoke moral outrage and charitable action, though critics argue this risks superficial "sentimental humanitarianism."^[66] In consumerism, advertising employs nostalgia—a sentimental longing for the past—to build brand loyalty and stimulate purchases, as consumers associate products with positive emotional memories, enhancing market engagement.^[67] On social media in the 2020s, algorithm-driven amplification of moral outrage content increases its virality and links to online activism, such as petition signing, though it does not necessarily translate to greater real-world action.^[68] Francis Fukuyama, in his 1992 analysis, connects shared emotional drives—rooted in thymos, the human desire for recognition—to democratic stability, positing that liberal democracies sustain cohesion by institutionalizing equal dignity and mutual affirmation of worth, preventing thymotic frustrations that fuel authoritarianism.^[69]

Criticisms and Analytical Concepts

Key Dissensions and Debates

Philosophical dissensions surrounding sentimentality often center on its artistic and existential implications, with critics viewing it as a distortion of authentic experience. In his 1889 essay "The Decay of Lying," Oscar Wilde contended that sentimental art, by idealizing life and nature, produces inferior imitations that life then mindlessly replicates, leading to a degraded reality where "all bad art comes from returning to Life and Nature, and elevating them into ideals."^[70] This perspective influenced later modernist critiques, which rejected sentimentality's unchecked emotionalism as manipulative and insincere. T.S. Eliot, in his 1919 essay "Tradition and the Individual Talent," advocated for poetic impersonality to escape "a continual extinction of personality," arguing that direct emotional expression—hallmark of sentimentality—results in mere self-indulgence rather than universal art. Eliot further elaborated this in his 1919 analysis of Shakespeare's Hamlet, introducing the "objective correlative" as a formulaic set of objects, situations, or events that evoke emotion externally, thereby avoiding the "artistic failure" of unmediated sentiment that overwhelms the work. Cultural debates highlight sentimentality's role in contemporary society, pitting postmodern simulations against rehabilitative defenses. Jean Baudrillard critiqued Western humanitarianism as involving simulated empathy that can mask deeper systemic issues, as discussed in works like The Transparency of Evil (1993). In contrast, philosopher Martha Nussbaum has championed sentimentality's value in moral and political education, arguing in Poetic Justice (1995) that literary sentiment fosters empathy essential for just public policy, while her capabilities approach—outlined in Women and Human Development (2000)—integrates emotions as core to human dignity and ethical judgment, countering dismissals of sentiment as superficial. Debates also intersect with gender and race, exposing sentimentality as a tool of oppression. James Baldwin, in essays like "Stranger in the Village" from Notes of a Native Son (1955), dissected white liberal sentimentality as a performative pity that conceals underlying racism, allowing whites to indulge in guilt without confronting the violent structures sustaining racial hierarchy. This critique resonates in 21st-century discussions of "toxic positivity," a phenomenon analyzed in psychological literature as enforced optimism that pathologizes valid negative emotions, often disproportionately burdening marginalized groups by demanding resilience amid systemic inequities; for instance, a 2021 study in the Journal of Positive Psychology links it to increased stress and emotional suppression, framing it as a modern sentimental evasion of hardship.^[71] Post-2020 discourses on sentimentality have intensified in climate activism, where emotional appeals are both lauded and contested against denialism. Critics argue that sentimental narratives—such as tearful testimonials on environmental loss—risk fostering passive empathy without mobilizing structural change, mirroring denialism's emotional avoidance by substituting feeling for policy. Defenders, however, see this emotional dimension as vital for countering denial by humanizing abstract threats, though debates persist on balancing pathos with pragmatism to avoid backlash.

The Sentimental Fallacy

The sentimental fallacy refers to the erroneous attribution of human emotions to inanimate objects, nature, or abstract forces, often as a perceptual or rhetorical device that distorts objective reality. This concept is closely tied to John Ruskin's term "pathetic fallacy," coined in his 1856 work Modern Painters Volume III, where he described it as a falseness in impressions of external things caused by violent feelings, such as portraying the sea as "cruel" or foam as "crawling" under the influence of grief or passion.^[72] In broader rhetorical usage, the sentimental fallacy extends to dismissing arguments that rely on emotion as inherently irrational, equating sentiment with logical weakness rather than evaluating their substantive merit. Literary examples illustrate this fallacy vividly, as in William Wordsworth's The Prelude (1850), where nature is anthropomorphized to reflect the poet's inner turmoil; during the "boat-stealing" episode, the cliffs and mountains appear to pursue the boy with a menacing presence, embodying his guilt and fear as if the landscape shares his agitation. In everyday language, phrases like the "crying sky" during funerals project human sorrow onto weather, implying nature mourns alongside people, which Ruskin critiqued as an emotional overlay rather than factual description.^[72] Philosophically, the sentimental fallacy intersects with debates on reason and emotion, echoing David Hume's view that reason serves the passions—emotions drive action, while reason merely directs it—against Immanuel Kant's prioritization of rational duty over sentimental impulses, where unchecked emotion risks moral distortion.^[73] In logical critiques, it aligns with the fallacy of appeal to pity (argumentum ad misericordiam), where evoking sympathy substitutes for evidence, as when a debater implores mercy for a flawed position without addressing its validity.^[74] The sentimental fallacy differs from genuine metaphor, which draws comparisons for insight without implying literal emotional transfer; for instance, calling a storm "furious" as a metaphor conveys intensity objectively, whereas pathetic fallacy infuses it with the speaker's subjective mood, as Ruskin noted in contrasting Homer's neutral "wine-dark sea" with modern poets' emotive projections.^[72] In contemporary contexts, this extends to AI ethics, where post-2020s discussions warn against sentimentalizing algorithms by attributing human-like intentions or empathy to them, leading to misguided moral judgments about machine "behavior."^[75]

References

[1]
(PDF) Sentimentality in Life & Literature - Academia.edu
Sentimentality, as defined by Solomon, is an appeal to tender emotions, often unfairly criticized. · Critics acknowledge ethical issues in real-life ...
[2]
https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/111551/
[3]
[PDF] Sentiment and Sentimentality in Music - HELDA
A sentiment is an emotion. Sentimentality is counterfeit emotion. Emotions are intentional, evaluative states with aspects that are both mental and bodily.
[4]
Sentimentality
### Summary of Sentimentality in Victorian Literature
[5]
[PDF] Sentimentality as an aesthetic flaw - CentAUR
According to. Savile, sentimentality is always reprehensible because it involves an element of self- deception: A sentimentalist falsifies certain aspects of ...
[6]
Sentiment - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
Originating from late 14th-century Old French and Medieval Latin, "sentiment" means personal feeling or opinion, derived from Latin "sentire," to feel.
[7]
Sentimental - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
Originating in 1749 from sentiment + -al, sentimentality means appealing to emotion over reason, often implying excessive tenderness or emotional sway.
[8]
David Hume - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Feb 26, 2001 · Hume concludes that belief must be some sentiment or feeling aroused in us independently of our wills, which accompanies those ideas that ...
[9]
sentimentality, n. meanings, etymology and more | Oxford English ...
The earliest known use of the noun sentimentality is in the late 1700s. OED's earliest evidence for sentimentality is from 1770, in Monthly Review.
[10]
Adam Smith's Moral and Political Philosophy
Feb 15, 2013 · Adam Smith developed a comprehensive and unusual version of moral sentimentalism in his Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759, TMS).Advantages of Smith's Moral... · Objections to Smith's Moral... · Bibliography
[11]
Theory of Moral Sentiments - Adam Smith - University of Glasgow
Smith argues sympathy is derived by imagining how we might feel if we were exposed to the same circumstances as some other person.
[12]
Schiller's On Naïve and Sentimental Poetry
This treatise first appeared in three segments with other writings: in 1795 in the second issue of Die Horen (November), under the title On the Naive; ...
[13]
(PDF) From Sentiment to Sentimentality: A Nineteenth-Century ...
Aug 6, 2025 · the nineteenth century extend and modify its meaning. The word ... pejoratively, denoting affectation 'in a contemptuous sense'. The.
[14]
On Kitsch and Sentimentality - jstor
It is this kind of kitsch that focusses our attention on sentimentality as such and which has attracted such critical abuse and has been accused of moral as ...
[15]
[PDF] Sentiment and Sentimentality: Affective Attachment in Life and Art
Excess feeling, as identified by Wilkie's (1967) survey of dictionary and literary handbooks, is the most commonly identified feature of sentimentality. The.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[16]
[PDF] The Sentimentalization of American Political Rhetoric
Mar 1, 2005 · 2 In spite of such examples of emotional advocacy and bonding, pathos and the sentimental appeal have regularly come under attack in the West.
[17]
The Greeting Card Industry's Approach to Commercial Sentiment
This article examines the techniques and narratives used in the industry, particularly by Hallmark. Cards (which controls more than 50% of the U.S. greeting ...Missing: analysis | Show results with:analysis
[18]
Attracting Views and Going Viral: How Message Features and News ...
Media messages characterized by high emotional evocativeness are also more likely to go viral (Berger, 2014).Content Analysis · Results · Discussion
[19]
Lord Shaftesbury [Anthony Ashley Cooper, 3rd Earl of Shaftesbury]
Mar 13, 2002 · Shaftesbury believed that humans are designed to appreciate order and harmony, and that proper appreciation of order and harmony is the basis of ...
[20]
Francis Hutcheson - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Apr 20, 2021 · Here it appears that Hutcheson holds that the moral sense is that which takes pleasure in actions. But it is also the case that the moral sense ...Hutcheson's Metaethics · The Senses · Hutcheson's Normative Ethics · Bibliography
[21]
The Long Eighteenth Century - Eastern Connecticut State University
Sentimental novels, also referred to as novels of sensibility, emerged as a genre in the second half of the 18th century. This was a reaction against the Age of ...
[22]
Sensibility: Passion, Emotion, Affect (Chapter 8)
Jun 15, 2021 · Refined feeling is at the heart of the eighteenth century's supreme regard for manners and politeness, both of which were central to Britons' ...
[23]
The Sentimental Novel in the Eighteenth Century - Academia.edu
This volume explores the sentimental novel in the eighteenth century, highlighting its origins in amatory fiction and its peak popularity during the 1770s ...
[24]
the complete plays of richard steele. - Project Gutenberg
The Conscious Lovers, a Comedy which had been long in preparation, was acted at Drury Lane Theatre on November 7, 1722, "with new scenes and all the ...Richard Steele. · The Funeral. · The Tender Husband. · The Conscious Lovers.
[25]
A Sentimental Journey Through France and Italy by Laurence Sterne
"A Sentimental Journey Through France and Italy" by Laurence Sterne is a travel narrative written in the late 18th century. The work follows Mr. Yorick, ...
[26]
The Broad Road to a Sentimental Death in The Old Curiosity Shop
the Gothic and sentimental genres that it conflates in Nell's dying scenes belong to a literary past that is becoming as unusual and dated as the pre ...
[27]
De-rerritorialisation and Re-territorialisation in Little Nell's Death ...
Jun 29, 2011 · During almost 200 years since Dickens published The Old Curiosity Shop (1841), this passage has provoked passionate reactions, which started ...
[28]
A Good Enough Heart: Kant and the Cultivation of Emotions
Aug 24, 2017 · Indeed, the contrast to sensitivity is sentimentality, which Kant describes later in the passage as 'ineffectual sharing of one's feelings ...Missing: rationalism contrasting excess
[29]
On Those Who Commiserate - Nietzsche's Zarathustra
In dealing with suffering friends, Zarathustra recommends providing a “hard bed”, a place of rest that does not indulge weakness. He speaks of a “great love ...
[30]
Ulysses and the Pragmatic Semiotics of Modernism - jstor
marvelous parody of nineteenth ... The degree to which Joyce embraced this vision is one reason Ulysses is considered the quintessential Modernist work.<|separator|>
[31]
[PDF] The Concept of Sentimentality in Critical Approaches to Film and its ...
This thesis examines how sentimentality, as a term central to film criticism, has been mobilized, denigrated, quarantined or ignored over 300 years of ...<|separator|>
[32]
How existentialism shaped—and then faded from—modern thought
Oct 8, 2024 · The post–World War II dominance of existentialism reflected a broader crisis of meaning across the Western world, driven by disillusionment ...
[33]
The Flower Children - Hippie Movement, Counterculture, 1960s
Sep 22, 2025 · The hippie community, like the youth of the nation at large, is deeply committed to the proposition that marijuana is less dangerous than alcohol.
[34]
Pathetic fallacy | The Poetry Foundation
Pathetic fallacy. The assignment of human feelings to inanimate objects, as coined by the Victorian literary critic John Ruskin. For him, a poet's tendency ...
[35]
Oppressed Consciences and Pathetic Fallacy - The Victorian Web
Dickens's treatment of nature illustrates his awareness of his use of pathetic fallacy. ... elements of fantasy away as realistic events which had occurred ...
[36]
Critical Fortunes (Part II) - Samuel Richardson in Context
Sep 21, 2017 · Samuel Richardson, a notorious reviser, poses a challenge to editors: he polished the rustic Pamela and blackened the seductive Lovelace in ...
[37]
(PDF) Sentiment and Vision in Charles Dickens's A Christmas Carol ...
Aug 6, 2025 · Within Dickens's writing, sentimentality is typically associated with the exaggerated emotional portrayal of pathetic scenes (particularly the ...
[38]
Sentimental comedy in the eighteenth century
the eighteenth century, and finally I followed out its rise in the early plays of Colley Cibber, Sir Richard Steele, and Mrs. Centlivre. At that point the.Missing: 18th- | Show results with:18th-
[39]
Melodrama, Two Ways - jstor
The preceding was an attempt to follow through the idea of Enoch Arden as a melodramatic work, not in the superficial sense of a tear- jerker, but as shaped by ...
[40]
[PDF] recent scholarship in the eighteenth-century sentimental - RUcore
Though one might scoff today, Samuel Richardson's works were some of the first novels deemed educational for children.
[41]
The Sentimental Novel and Its Feminist Critique - jstor
The sentimental novel, written by and for women, reflects women's reality, with themes like financial dependence, and is a way for women to deal with their own ...
[42]
Harriet Beecher Stowe's Critique of Slave Law in Uncle Tom's Cabin
Apr 24, 2015 · Southern proslavery writers recognized that the powerful imagery employed by abolitionist writers such as Harriet Beecher Stowe was among ...
[43]
“It Was Left for Others to Speak”: Uncle Tom's Cabin and the Civil War
Sep 20, 2021 · This article reviews elements of the critical and publication history of Uncle Tom's Cabin in order to examine the novel's place within American culture.
[44]
[PDF] Everybody's Protest Novel
Uncle Tom's Cabin is a very bad novel, having, in its self-righteous, virtuous sentimentality, much in common with Little Women. Sentimentality, the ...
[45]
Greuze and the Painting of Sentiment
In this book my aim is to get beyond the standard disdain for the 'sentimentality' of Greuze and his contemporaries and to establish exactly how and why the ...
[46]
Genre painting: Understanding a moral message – QAGOMA Stories
Oct 1, 2021 · Jean-Baptiste Greuze was an exceptional draftsman and portrait painter and he used symbolism to convey moral messages, he exhibited the painting ...
[47]
Briton Riviere: Victorian sentimentality and animals - Art UK
Jun 8, 2011 · Riviere's paintings are clearly Victorian in their subject matter as they promote the emotional side of the depicted narrative and are meant to appeal to the ...
[48]
Victorian Sentimentality – Culture and Anarchy
Jul 22, 2012 · These narrative paintings invite the viewer to fill in a back-story, and to respond in an emotional way, to take on the emotions of the figures ...
[49]
The Parlour Piano: American Popular Songs of the 1800's
Listening to this album is tantamount to pulling back the drapery and looking through a window into nineteenth-century middle-class America.
[50]
E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial at 40 – a deep meditation on loneliness ...
Jun 8, 2022 · Spielberg's films are to this day criticised as mawkish and overly sentimental, deliberately engineered to cynically manipulate our emotions.
[51]
ET at 40: Why the Spielberg classic feels so unusual today - BBC
Jun 9, 2022 · ET stands out most clearly for the wallop of its sentimental arc, which Spielberg brilliantly contrives from the heartfelt performances he ...
[52]
16 Hilariously Reliable Tropes You'll Find In These Made-For-TV ...
Dec 22, 2020 · Whether at a Christmas bakeoff or at a historic inn, we promise you these characters discover the magic of the holidays and live happily ever after.
[53]
Why Kids Love TikTok Challenges - Psychology Today
Feb 12, 2021 · Fun, dumb, or dangerous? TikTok challenges may have appeal because they offer connection and belonging.
[54]
Jeff Koons: 'People respond to banal things – they don't accept their ...
Jul 5, 2015 · When it sold for $58m, his Balloon Dog became the most expensive artwork by a living artist. Are the critics right to dismiss his work as 'smug' and 'baloney'?Missing: postmodern | Show results with:postmodern
[55]
Jeff Koons Art, Bio, Ideas | TheArtStory
Discussing his famous series of oversized Balloon Dog sculptures, he noted that "It's a balloon that a clown would maybe twist for you at a birthday party...
[56]
K-pop lyrics have become more positive over the past 30 years | BPS
Feb 1, 2023 · Authors argue that the change in the emotional content of K-pop lyrics reflects societal increases in positive emotions.
[57]
'It's like oxygen – it's everywhere!' Why Korea is hot for trot, the ...
Jun 8, 2022 · Known as music for grannies and scorned by fans of K-pop, trot is making a hip comeback – but can this wildly sentimental music ever break out of its home ...
[58]
The Psychology Behind Short Video Marketing: How It Taps into ...
Jan 4, 2024 · Short videos excel in triggering joy, fear, nostalgia, and other feelings that influence consumer behavior.
[59]
The 'dark side' of social media influencers and their impact on ...
Feb 24, 2025 · However, new research exposes a lesser-known side of influencer culture, one that raises ethical, psychological, and regulatory concerns.
[60]
New Study Reveals Emotional Impact of Creator Content ... - Influencer
Jun 26, 2024 · Brand Memory and Consumer Action: The ability of creators to evoke emotion enhances brand memory, a crucial factor in driving consumer action.
[61]
Compassion Fade: Affect and Charity Are Greatest for a Single Child ...
Our capacity to feel sympathy for people in need appears limited, and this form of compassion fatigue can lead to apathy and inaction.
[62]
Patterns of brain activity associated with nostalgia: a social-cognitive ...
In this prospective review, we postulate a neural model of nostalgia. Self-reflection, autobiographical memory, regulatory capacity and reward are core ...Autobiographical Memory · Emotion Regulation · Nostalgia Proneness
[63]
The Diana moment: a change for the better? - Prospect Magazine
We are a more relaxed and more emotionally healthy people than we used to be, and the "Diana moment," for all its weirdness and excess, marked this change.
[64]
Talcott Parsons and the Sociology of Emotion - ResearchGate
Aug 5, 2025 · This article offers a critical assessment of the importance accorded to religion and human emotion in Parsons's various readings of Durkheim ...<|separator|>
[65]
[PDF] Mono No Aware, and the Aesthetics of Impermanence - UTC
The term describes the feelings of sympathy a person feels upon becoming aware of the fleeting, impermanent nature of life. This is captured in the opening of ...<|separator|>
[66]
[PDF] Jane Tompkins. "Sentimental Power: Uncle Tom's Cabin and the ...
In this view, sentimental novels written by women in the nineteenth century were responsible for a series of cultural evils whose regrets still plague us: the ...Missing: reclamation | Show results with:reclamation
[67]
Sentimental Humanitarianism Plagues the West - AGON
Apr 25, 2023 · Sentimental humanitarianism begins with an abstraction—“Fair Trade” for example—but the sentimental humanitarian does not allow the complexities ...
[68]
Nostalgia and consumer behavior - ScienceDirect.com
The present review examines how and when nostalgia, a social emotion with a rich history in marketing, affects consumption-relevant outcomes.
[69]
Moral Outrage on Social Media Linked to Activism, Study Finds | SPSP
Apr 29, 2025 · A new study published in Social Psychological and Personality Science examines how expressions of moral outrage on social media are linked to online activism.Missing: sentimental 2020s
[70]
The End of History. Francis Fukuyama (1992)
I argued that liberal democracy may constitute the “end point of mankind's ideological evolution” and the “final form of human government,” and as such ...Missing: feelings | Show results with:feelings
[71]
Intentions, by Oscar Wilde - Project Gutenberg
What do you mean by saying that life, 'poor, probable, uninteresting human life,' will try to reproduce the marvels of art? I can quite understand your ...
[72]
Modern Painters. Vol. III., Containing Part IV., Of Many Things.
The Project Gutenberg EBook of Modern Painters Vol. III., by John Ruskin. This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no ...
[73]
Kant and Hume on Morality - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Mar 26, 2008 · Hume assigns reason to a subordinate role, while Kant takes reason to be the highest normative authority. However, it is important not to ...Kant's Relationship to Hume... · Reason and Emotion in Morality · Bibliography
[74]
Argumentum ad Misericordiam - Philosophy Home Page
Abstract: The ad misericordiam fallacy illicitly appeals to pity or a related emotion such as sympathy, compassion, or mercy in order to gain the acceptance of ...
[75]
Anthropomorphism in AI: hype and fallacy | AI and Ethics
Feb 5, 2024 · As a fallacy, anthropomorphism is shown to distort moral judgments about AI, such as those concerning its moral character and status, as well as ...