Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Sorcerer's Apprentice

The Sorcerer's Apprentice is a ballad poem written by the German author Johann Wolfgang von Goethe in 1797, recounting the tale of a young wizard's apprentice who, in his master's absence, attempts to use magic to automate his chores but unleashes uncontrollable chaos that floods his home until the sorcerer returns to restore order.^[1] The poem, structured in 14 stanzas with an unconventional rhyme scheme, draws from ancient folklore motifs dating back to at least the 2nd century CE in Lucian of Samosata's Philopseudes, where a similar story of an apprentice animating a pestle appears, and echoes even earlier narratives from Egyptian, Indian, and Mongolian traditions.^[2] Goethe's version, titled Der Zauberlehrling in the original German, explores themes of hubris, the perils of wielding power without wisdom, and the boundaries between human ambition and supernatural forces, reflecting Enlightenment-era concerns about knowledge and responsibility.^[3] In the narrative, the apprentice enchants a broom to fetch water from a distant brook, but when it refuses to stop, he hacks it in half—only for the pieces to multiply and exacerbate the flooding—culminating in the master's dramatic intervention with a counter-spell.^[4] This concise yet vivid depiction has made the poem a cornerstone of German Romantic literature, influencing discussions on "sorcerer's apprentice syndrome," a metaphor for self-perpetuating technological or social dilemmas.^[3] The story's enduring legacy extends through numerous adaptations across music, film, and literature, transforming it from an adult cautionary tale into a widely accessible narrative. French composer Paul Dukas immortalized it in his 1897 symphonic poem L'apprenti sorcier, which vividly captures the escalating frenzy through orchestral dynamics.^[2] Most notably, Walt Disney's 1940 animated segment in Fantasia, featuring Mickey Mouse as the apprentice, popularized the tale globally, shifting its tone toward whimsical humor while retaining the core warning about overreaching ambition and has since inspired countless references in popular culture.^[2]

Origins and Literary History

Ancient and Medieval Roots

The earliest known variant of the Sorcerer's Apprentice tale appears in Lucian of Samosata's Philopseudes (Lover of Lies), composed around AD 170. In this satirical work, the narrator Eucrates describes his time as a student accompanying the Egyptian magician Pancrates during a journey. Observing Pancrates animate everyday objects like a pestle to perform tasks such as fetching water, Eucrates secretly memorizes the three-syllable incantation. When Pancrates is absent, Eucrates applies the spell to the wooden pestle, commanding it to carry water from the Nile; however, the object obeys literally and endlessly, flooding their lodgings. Attempting to stop it by splitting the pestle with an axe, Eucrates unwittingly creates two animated halves that double the deluge. Pancrates returns, utters a counter-spell to restore order, and departs in disapproval, leaving Eucrates to reflect on his folly.^[5] This ancient narrative introduces key thematic elements that define the motif: the master's temporary absence, the apprentice's impulsive use of forbidden knowledge, and the chaotic multiplication of enchanted items beyond control. These motifs underscore warnings against hubris and the perils of partial mastery over arcane forces, drawing on Greco-Roman literary traditions of skeptical inquiry into superstition and divine intervention. Lucian's version, framed as a tall tale within a dialogue mocking credulity, highlights the apprentice's impatience as the catalyst for disaster, setting a pattern for later interpretations.^[6] The tale's motifs persisted and expanded through oral folklore transmission across medieval Europe, embedded in broader Indo-European narrative traditions that probed the boundaries between human ambition, magic, and cosmic order. Storytellers adapted the core structure to local contexts, emphasizing moral lessons on obedience and the hubris of youth in clerical or artisanal apprenticeships. By the early modern period, these evolutions surfaced in written form, as in Eustache Le Noble's 1700 French adaptation "L'apprenti magicien" from Le gage touché, where an apprentice clerk enchants a wooden figure to assist with chores like carrying water, only to unleash escalating magical chaos that requires the master's intervention—reinforcing the enduring cautionary essence while incorporating elements of shape-shifting and escape.^[6]

Goethe's 1797 Poem

Johann Wolfgang von Goethe wrote "Der Zauberlehrling" in 1797, first publishing it in 1797 in Friedrich Schiller's Musen-Almanach auf das Jahr 1798. The ballad draws loose inspiration from ancient folklore motifs, such as the second-century tale by Greek satirist Lucian of a sorcerer whose servant animates a pestle to perform chores, leading to uncontrollable replication. Goethe transforms these elements through his synthesis of Enlightenment rationality and proto-Romantic individualism, emphasizing the perils of human overreach into supernatural domains and the boundaries of mortal capability.^[5]^[7] The poem's structure comprises 14 stanzas alternating between eight and six lines, yielding 98 lines in total, composed primarily in iambic tetrameter—a rhythmic pattern of unstressed-stressed syllables evoking the steady march of the enchanted brooms. Its rhyme scheme employs cross-rhymes (abab cdcd in longer stanzas, with variations like abc cba in shorter ones), creating a ballad-like propulsion that heightens the narrative tension. Vivid imagery dominates, particularly the relentless flow of water as "torrents" and "cascades" inundating the house, and the brooms' animation as soldierly figures bearing pails in mechanical obedience, symbolizing the dehumanizing force of unchecked automation.^[1]^[8] In the narrative, the aging sorcerer departs, leaving his apprentice to mundane tasks like fetching water for a bath. Weary of toil, the youth recites a spell from his master's forbidden book, animating a broomstick to carry water from the brook. The broom complies efficiently at first, but upon filling the cistern, it continues relentlessly, ignoring the apprentice's commands. Desperate, he severs the broom with an axe, only for each half to sprout arms and legs, doubling into two identical servants that multiply further into a legion, pails overflowing in a deluge that floods the chambers and threatens to drown the household. The apprentice wails in futility, crying "Die Geister, die ich rief, werd' ich nun nicht mehr los," as stairs and furniture submerge in swirling chaos, until the sorcerer returns, intoning a counter-spell to shatter the brooms and restore order, sternly warning of magic's dangers beyond novice grasp.^[9] Goethe's linguistic innovation endures in the idiomatic expression "Die Geister, die ich rief, werd' ich nun nicht mehr los" ("The spirits that I called, I now cannot banish"), a proverb for situations where one's actions spawn uncontrollable repercussions, widely used in German to denote self-inflicted dilemmas.^[10]

Musical Adaptations

Paul Dukas' Symphonic Poem

Paul Dukas composed L'apprenti sorcier (The Sorcerer's Apprentice), a symphonic scherzo for orchestra, between 1896 and 1897, completing it as his most celebrated orchestral work. The piece premiered on May 18, 1897, at the Société Nationale de Musique in Paris, conducted by Paul Dukas, and it immediately established Dukas's reputation for vivid programmatic music.) Lasting approximately 12 minutes, the composition draws directly from Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's 1797 ballad Der Zauberlehrling, narrating the tale of an apprentice who enchants a broom to fetch water, only for the spell to spiral into uncontrollable chaos until the sorcerer's intervention.^[11]^[12] The musical structure adheres to sonata form, adapted as a scherzo in 3/4 time to mirror the poem's dramatic arc across four thematic elements and distinct sections: an introduction, exposition (bars 42–294), development (bars 295–620), recapitulation (bars 621–801), and coda (bars 802–811). The exposition introduces the primary themes—a flowing "water" motif in the strings, the lumbering "broom" theme on bassoon as the first subject, the playful "apprentice" theme on winds and glockenspiel as the second subject, and the authoritative "sorcerer" theme on trumpet and horns—evoking the apprentice's initial mischief with lively, youthful energy. The development section escalates into frenzied chaos through rapid thematic fragmentation, tonal instability with whole-tone scales and augmented intervals, and polyrhythmic layering, representing the multiplying brooms and flooding disaster. The recapitulation and coda then resolve the turmoil with the sorcerer's majestic return, restoring order through triumphant brass fanfares and a return to the water motif in serene strings.^[13] Dukas scored the work for a full Romantic orchestra, including piccolo, two flutes, two oboes, English horn, two clarinets, bass clarinet, three bassoons, contrabassoon, four horns, two trumpets, three trombones, timpani, glockenspiel, triangle, cymbals, bass drum, harp, and strings, emphasizing clarity and coloristic precision. Key instrumental highlights include the strings' pizzicato and bowed passages to depict the brooms' mechanical marching and multiplication; the harp's arpeggios to convey enchantment and magical sparks; the glockenspiel's sparkling timbre for the apprentice's impulsive magic; and the bassoon's ostinato for the broom's relentless motion. These choices underscore Dukas's mastery of orchestration, blending descriptive vividness with structural rigor without relying on leitmotifs or narrative voiceover.^[14] Intensely self-critical, Dukas viewed L'apprenti sorcier as his sole major orchestral success and refrained from producing further large-scale works, instead destroying or withholding many compositions due to his perfectionist standards, which limited his output despite his influence as a teacher and critic. This decision cemented the piece's status as the definitive musical embodiment of Goethe's tale, prioritizing quality over quantity in his legacy.^[11]^[15]

Other Compositions and Arrangements

The symphonic poem by Paul Dukas has served as the foundational piece for numerous arrangements, extending its reach to various ensembles and media while preserving the narrative drive of Goethe's ballad. In the early 20th century, Leopold Stokowski conducted a renowned recording of Dukas' work with the Philadelphia Orchestra, recorded in 1937 at the Academy of Music in Philadelphia, which emphasized the piece's dynamic contrasts and orchestral color.^[16] This interpretation, later adapted for broader use in Disney's Fantasia, highlighted Stokowski's signature lush string textures and rhythmic vitality, making it a staple in concert repertoires. Similarly, Lucien Garban produced a piano reduction in 1939 for Editions Durand, transcribing the full orchestral score into a two-hand solo format that captures the work's thematic motifs and dramatic swells for study and performance.^[17] Garban's version, praised for its fidelity to the original's programmatic elements, remains a standard for pianists seeking to explore the piece's structure without a full orchestra.^[18] Contemporary works have reimagined Dukas' score for smaller ensembles, such as Iain Farrington's 2011 arrangement for eight players (flute, clarinet, violin I and II, viola, cello, double bass, and piano), which retains the original's energy and humor while allowing for intimate performances in chamber settings.^[19] Farrington's transcription, published by Aria Editions, balances the symphonic scope with reduced forces, making it suitable for educational and professional groups. Another modern take is Farrington's version for wind quintet and piano, which emphasizes the woodwinds' role in depicting the apprentice's mischief.^[20] Concert performances and recordings of Dukas' work have been led by prominent conductors, including Leonard Bernstein's 1962 recording with the New York Philharmonic on Columbia Masterworks, noted for its vivid characterization and brisk tempo that underscores the narrative's urgency.^[21] This interpretation, part of Bernstein's educational series, brought the piece to wider audiences through its dramatic phrasing and orchestral precision. Beyond concerts, brief motifs from the score have appeared in non-Disney film scores, such as in the 2001 animated film Monsters, Inc., where composer Randy Newman incorporated subtle echoes of the main theme to evoke magical chaos in a scene involving animated brooms.^[22] Variations in style have further diversified the piece's legacy, with jazz interpretations like The Jazz Revue's swing-infused rendition on their 2023 album Jazz Sessions: Classical Favourites, which transforms the apprentice's march into an upbeat, improvisational number with syncopated rhythms and brass solos.^[23] In the 2000s, electronic remixes emerged, such as Gabriel Saban's 2023 electronic adaptation that layers synths and beats over the core melody, creating a dance-oriented version for modern media and playlists.^[24] These adaptations highlight the score's versatility, bridging classical roots with contemporary genres.

Performing Arts Adaptations

Ballet and Dance Versions

One of the earliest notable ballet adaptations of "The Sorcerer's Apprentice" was choreographed by Harald Lander for the Royal Danish Ballet in Copenhagen, premiering in 1940 to Paul Dukas' symphonic poem of the same name.^[25] Lander's version emphasized the tale's comedic and magical elements through classical ballet techniques, with the apprentice's mishap visualized through dynamic group movements representing the enchanted brooms.^[26] In the mid-20th century, Tatjana Gsovsky created a version for the Stuttgart Ballet in 1954, which was recorded as a short film in 1955 directed by Michael Powell and starring Sonia Arova as the apprentice.^[27] Gsovsky's choreography highlighted the narrative's chaos with precise, rhythmic footwork synchronized to Dukas' score, using an ensemble of dancers to depict the multiplying brooms in a whirlwind of synchronized steps that built tension toward the sorcerer's return.^[28] This production showcased Gsovsky's influence on German ballet, blending expressive mime with neoclassical forms to convey the apprentice's hubris and the uncontrollable magic. Later adaptations incorporated the story into educational and youth ballet programs, often using Dukas' music as the standard accompaniment. For instance, Andrew Rist's 1991 choreography for Ballet Minnesota featured a youthful cast portraying the apprentice's folly through playful, kinetic sequences where ensemble dancers mimicked the brooms' relentless marching with crisp, repetitive patterns that echoed the music's ostinato rhythms.^[29] Similarly, Scott Rink's co-production with Minnesota Dance Theatre, premiered in the early 2000s and later performed by American Ballet Theatre's Studio Company, employed a collage arrangement of Dukas' themes to explore the tale's themes of control and consequence via fluid, contemporary-inflected movements for the multiplying objects.^[30] Contemporary interpretations continue to innovate on choreographic elements, particularly the visualization of the brooms' proliferation. Ballet Ariel's 2015 family-oriented production used accessible classical steps to depict the apprentice enchanting household tools, culminating in a chaotic ensemble sequence that underscored rhythmic synchronization to Dukas' escalating themes, teaching lessons of humility without relying on animation.^[31] More recently, The Ballet Team's 2024 symphonic ballet adaptation incorporated multimedia elements alongside traditional dance theater, with dancers embodying the brooms through coordinated, multiplying formations that heightened the physical comedy and magical disorder of Goethe's poem.^[32] These works prioritize the tale's movement-based chaos, often employing large corps de ballet to represent the animated objects in ways that demand precise timing and spatial awareness.

Theatrical and Operatic Interpretations

Theatrical adaptations of Goethe's poem "Der Zauberlehrling" have emphasized dramatic dialogue and scenic magic, often employing puppetry to depict the apprentice's chaotic spellcasting. In Germany, marionette shows featuring the tale became popular in the 19th century as part of traditional folk theater traditions, where puppeteers used simple mechanisms to animate brooms and water effects, drawing audiences with the story's blend of humor and cautionary moral.^[33] These early productions laid the foundation for later stage interpretations that highlighted the apprentice's hubris through spoken narrative and visual illusions. In the 20th century, puppetry continued to evolve as a medium for the story, with community theater groups in the 1950s and 1970s staging simplified scripts for educational purposes, often incorporating live narration and basic props to convey the poem's themes of overreach and redemption. For example, productions like those documented in American theater archives used adapted dialogues from Goethe's original text to engage young audiences, focusing on the apprentice's dialogue with the enchanted broom. Staging techniques in these pre-digital eras relied on practical effects, such as trapdoors to simulate the broom's multiplication and selective lighting to create ethereal magical auras, enhancing the dramatic tension without modern technology. Operatic interpretations remain rare, with no full-length opera directly based on the poem, though motifs from the tale appear in incidental music for stage readings of Goethe's work, providing atmospheric underscoring during dramatic recitations. Modern theatrical versions have revitalized the story through innovative puppetry and musical elements. A contemporary highlight is the 2021 musical adaptation by Richard Hough and Ben Morales Frost at Southwark Playhouse, where detailed puppetry brings the brooms to life amid sung arias and spoken scenes, emphasizing family dynamics and magical illusions via lighting and mechanical effects.^[34] Similarly, Open Eye Figure Theatre's 2012 puppet production integrated shadow and rod puppets with live actors to underscore the narrative's tension, avoiding Disney influences in favor of Goethe's poetic dialogue.^[35] These adaptations showcase the tale's enduring appeal in live performance, prioritizing scenic innovation and character-driven storytelling.

Film and Animation Adaptations

Disney's Fantasia Segment

The Sorcerer's Apprentice segment in Disney's 1940 animated film Fantasia originated as a standalone short intended to revitalize the popularity of Mickey Mouse, which had waned in the mid-1930s due to the rise of other characters like Donald Duck.^[36] Walt Disney conceived the project in 1937, collaborating with conductor Leopold Stokowski to pair the story with Paul Dukas' 1897 symphonic poem of the same name.^[36] Directed by James Algar, the sequence featured Mickey Mouse as the apprentice and was animated primarily by Ward Kimball, who brought dynamic personality to the character's movements.^[37] Production began in early 1938, with animation starting on January 21, and the full Fantasia premiered on November 13, 1940, at New York's Broadway Theatre, conducted live by Stokowski and the Philadelphia Orchestra.^[38] Visually, the nine-minute segment masterfully synchronizes its narrative to Dukas' score, unfolding in a wizard's tower where the apprentice, weary of fetching water, enchants a broom to do the work, leading to chaotic multiplication of brooms and a flooding climax that the returning sorcerer resolves with a dramatic gesture.^[39] Innovative techniques, including the multiplane camera, create depth and fluidity, such as sweeping shots of stars and water effects that immerse viewers in the magical turmoil.^[40] The animation emphasizes Mickey's expressive curiosity turning to panic, with detailed broom designs—simple wooden figures gaining eerie autonomy—highlighting themes of hubris and unintended consequences. Upon release, the segment received immediate acclaim for its artistry and helped restore Mickey Mouse's iconic status, becoming the most enduring part of Fantasia despite the film's mixed overall reception due to its experimental format.^[41] It was re-released in Fantasia 2000 (1999), where the original footage underwent frame-by-frame digital restoration by Cinesite to enhance clarity and color while preserving its classic look.^[42] Behind the scenes, Disney initially planned the piece as a high-budget Silly Symphony short in the late 1930s, but escalating costs led to its expansion into the anthology film.^[43] To ensure fidelity to Goethe's original 1797 poem, the production team consulted literary experts on the source material, adapting its cautionary tale of overreaching ambition into a visually poetic sequence.^[44] Recording sessions in 1939 at Philadelphia's Academy of Music employed innovative multi-channel audio techniques, foreshadowing the film's pioneering Fantasound system.^[36]

Live-Action and Other Animated Films

The 2010 live-action film The Sorcerer's Apprentice, directed by Jon Turteltaub, reimagines the classic tale as a modern urban fantasy set in contemporary New York City.^[45] In this adaptation, Nicolas Cage portrays Balthazar Blake, a sorcerer and apprentice of Merlin who mentors physics student Dave Stutler (Jay Baruchel) in wielding "electric" magic derived from plasma energy to combat the evil sorcerer Maxim Horvath (Alfred Molina).^[45] The story incorporates elements of the original Goethe poem, such as an apprentice's misuse of power leading to chaos, but expands it into a full action-adventure narrative involving historical battles between good and evil sorcerers.^[46] The film received mixed critical reception, praised for its energetic effects and Cage's charismatic performance but criticized for formulaic plotting, earning a 40% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on 171 reviews.^[46] Commercially, it grossed $63.1 million domestically and $215.2 million worldwide against a $150 million budget.^[47] To enhance realism, the production emphasized practical effects like real fire and flash powder alongside CGI, with visual effects supervisor John Nelson overseeing over 1,200 shots including plasma battles and shape-shifting sequences.^[48]^[49] Earlier live-action adaptations include the 1930 short The Wizard's Apprentice, directed by Sidney Levee, which draws directly from Goethe's poem and uses the Paul Dukas symphonic score.^[50] In this experimental film, the apprentice (Fritz Feld) animates brooms through simple stop-motion techniques, employing painted matchsticks with legs to depict their multiplication and chaotic flooding, marking an early use of practical effects in sound-era cinema.^[51] These rudimentary stop-motion elements influenced later interpretations, showcasing the tale's visual potential before widespread animation.^[52] A notable television adaptation appeared in the 1962 episode "The Sorcerer's Apprentice" from Alfred Hitchcock Presents, written by Robert Bloch and inspired by Goethe's narrative.^[53] Directed by Joseph Lejtes, the episode features Brandon de Wilde as Hugo, a vulnerable runaway taken in by magician Sadini (Ian Wolfe), whose jealous wife (Diana Dors) manipulates the boy into a dark scheme echoing the poem's themes of misused power and unintended consequences.^[54] Filmed in 1961 but withheld from initial broadcast due to its grim content—depicting implied murder—it aired in syndication in the 1980s and is noted for its noir-style chiaroscuro cinematography and psychological tension.^[55] Among animated films, the 1978 Czechoslovak short Krabat – The Sorcerer's Apprentice (Čarodějův učeň), directed by Karel Zeman, offers a dark fantasy take using cutout animation techniques.^[56] Based loosely on the Sorcerer's Apprentice motif within a mill-setting narrative, it follows a beggar boy lured into sorcery by a one-eyed master, emphasizing themes of black magic and entrapment through stylized paper figures and painted backgrounds.^[57] Zeman's hybrid style blends 2D cutouts with subtle stop-motion for eerie effects, distinguishing it from traditional cel animation.^[56] A brief animated cameo appears in the 1988 hybrid live-action/animation film Who Framed Roger Rabbit, directed by Robert Zemeckis, where animated brooms inspired by the Sorcerer's Apprentice sweep streets in the surreal Toontown sequence.^[58] This nod integrates the multiplying brooms into the film's chaotic cartoon world, serving as a visual Easter egg amid the broader detective story.^[59] The evolution of special effects in these adaptations highlights a shift from practical and mechanical methods to digital integration. Early works like the 1930 short relied on handmade stop-motion for tangible, limited-scale chaos, while the 2010 film combined on-set pyrotechnics with extensive CGI to depict large-scale magical destruction in urban environments, reflecting advancements in visual effects technology.^[49] This progression allows for more immersive portrayals of the tale's core motif—the apprentice's spell gone awry—without the constraints of physical props.^[60]

Other Media Adaptations

Literature Expansions

One notable early 20th-century expansion is Hanns Heinz Ewers' 1910 novel Der Zauberlehrling (translated as The Sorcerer's Apprentice), which reimagines the tale as a decadent horror story centered on the protagonist Frank Braun, a manipulative figure who infiltrates and exploits a evangelical Christian cult in an isolated Italian village, evoking themes of occult control and moral decay.^[61] This work draws inspiration from Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's 1797 ballad as its core motif but transforms it into a psychological thriller, marking Ewers' debut novel and introducing his recurring anti-hero Braun.^[62] In 1948, Elspeth Huxley published The Sorcerer's Apprentice: A Journey through East Africa, a travelogue that employs the apprentice's misadventure as a metaphorical framework for her six-month expedition across Kenya, Tanganyika, Zanzibar, and Uganda, portraying colonial encounters with local customs, wildlife, and landscapes as chaotic magical experiments gone awry.^[63] Huxley's narrative blends observation with wry humor, using the tale to reflect on the hubris of European explorers meddling in unfamiliar terrains, much like the apprentice's overambitious spellcasting.^[64] Modern prose adaptations include Christopher Bulis' 1995 novel The Sorcerer's Apprentice, part of the Doctor Who Missing Adventures series, where the First Doctor and his companions arrive in a medieval fairy-tale realm disrupted by a 30th-century artifact and sinister manipulations, reinterpreting the story as a science fantasy cautionary tale about meddling with advanced technology. Similarly, Tahir Shah's 1998 memoir Sorcerer's Apprentice recounts his real-life initiation into the world of Indian illusionists and godmen, framing his apprenticeship to master conjurer Hakim Feroze as a contemporary echo of the classic narrative, interwoven with explorations of mystical traditions, sadhus, and the blurred line between trickery and spirituality. Anthologies have further expanded the tale's literary footprint, such as Jack Zipes' edited collection The Sorcerer's Apprentice: An Anthology of Magical Tales (2017), which compiles over two dozen international variants and retellings from ancient folklore to 20th-century interpretations, illustrated by Natalie Frank and emphasizing the motif's evolution across cultures as a parable of apprenticeship, magic, and unintended consequences. Earlier ideological allusions appear in Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels' 1848 Communist Manifesto, where they invoke the sorcerer's apprentice as a metaphor for the bourgeoisie's invocation of industrial forces that spiral beyond control, critiquing capitalism's self-destructive hubris in unleashing productive powers it cannot master.^[65] Post-World War II literature frequently delves into psychological dimensions of the tale, portraying the apprentice's hubris as a symbol of human overreach in contexts like colonialism and technological ambition; for instance, Huxley's work subtly psychoanalyzes the explorer's overconfidence as a form of magical delusion amid African realities, while broader interpretations in mid-century fiction link the motif to the era's anxieties over atomic power and imperial decline.^[66]

Television, Video Games, and Comics

In television, the tale of the Sorcerer's Apprentice has been adapted into episodic formats, often drawing on fairy tale mashups or parodies. The ABC series Once Upon a Time featured a significant arc in its fourth season (2014), where the Sorcerer's Apprentice serves as a guardian of magical artifacts, manipulated by Rumplestiltskin in a plot involving a hat that absorbs sorcery; this storyline spans episodes like "The Apprentice" (Season 4, Episode 4), blending the classic narrative with the show's ensemble of fairy tale characters.^[67] Earlier, the animated series Tiny Toon Adventures included a parody in the episode "Tiny Toon Music Television" (Season 1, Episode 51, aired February 1, 1991), where Buster Bunny spoofs the apprentice's mishap with enchanted brooms in a segment titled "Top Secret Apprentice," mimicking the chaotic animation style of Disney's Fantasia.^[68] Video games have incorporated the Sorcerer's Apprentice motif through interactive enemy designs and mechanics inspired by the enchanted brooms. In the Kingdom Hearts series, starting with the original game (2002) and continuing in sequels like Kingdom Hearts II (2005), the Enchanted Brooms appear as recurring enemies, originating from Mickey Mouse's portrayal in Fantasia's Sorcerer's Apprentice segment; these brooms swarm players in boss-like encounters, requiring strategic attacks to dismantle their magical animation.^[69] The series also features playable segments in worlds like Symphony of Sorcery (in Kingdom Hearts 3D: Dream Drop Distance, 2012), where players control Sorcerer Mickey amid broom-filled chaos, evoking the tale's flooding mayhem through dynamic platforming and spell-casting mini-games.^[70] In comics, adaptations emphasize visual storytelling, with Disney's versions tying directly to Mickey Mouse's iconic role. The Sorcerer's Apprentice appeared in early Disney anthology comics, such as those in Walt Disney's Comics and Stories during the 1940s and 1950s, where Mickey reprises his Fantasia persona in short tales of magical mishaps with animated objects, extending the segment's humor into sequential art formats. These appearances influenced later graphic works, though independent retellings in the 2010s often blend genres; for instance, promotional tie-ins for the 2010 live-action film included custom Magic: The Gathering-style cards depicting apprentice mechanics like spell amplification, appearing in digital formats to mirror the tale's uncontrolled magic.^[71]

Cultural Impact and Legacy

Idiomatic Expressions in Language

The tale of the Sorcerer's Apprentice has permeated idiomatic language across cultures, serving as a metaphor for individuals who initiate actions or summon forces they cannot subsequently control, often leading to chaotic or self-inflicted consequences. In German, the line "Die Geister, die ich rief, werd' ich nun nicht los" from Goethe's 1797 poem Der Zauberlehrling has evolved into a widespread proverb denoting troubles one has brought upon oneself and struggles to resolve. This expression appears frequently in literature, speeches, and everyday discourse to illustrate hubris or unintended escalation, with its origins directly tied to the apprentice's failed attempt to command the animated broom.^[72] In English, the phrase "sorcerer's apprentice" similarly denotes a scenario of unleashing uncontrollable processes, tracing its etymological roots to Goethe's ballad and gaining prominence through Paul Dukas's 1897 symphonic poem L'apprenti sorcier, which reinforced the story's cultural familiarity. By the mid-20th century, it entered dictionaries as a figurative term for such dilemmas, with "sorcerer's apprentice syndrome" emerging in technical and management contexts in the late 20th century to describe escalating errors in policy or systems implementation. For instance, in public policy analysis, the term critiques situations where initial interventions spawn compounding problems, as explored in anthropological studies of bureaucratic overreach.^[73]^[74] French employs "l'apprenti sorcier" as an idiom in political rhetoric, portraying leaders who provoke crises they fail to master, a usage documented in 20th-century commentary on governance missteps. This variant, directly from Dukas's title, underscores themes of overambition in power dynamics. In Spanish-speaking regions, "el aprendiz de brujo" functions analogously, integrated into Latin American expressions and 19th- to 20th-century journalism to critique technological or industrial mishaps where innovations spiral beyond human oversight, such as early automation experiments. The phrase's global diffusion reflects the story's evolution from Goethe's text into a universal cautionary archetype for unintended consequences by the early 1900s.^[75]^[76]

Modern References and Interpretations

In the 21st century, the tale of the Sorcerer's Apprentice has frequently been invoked as a metaphor for the risks associated with artificial intelligence and automation, particularly the dangers of deploying powerful technologies without adequate safeguards. Historian Yuval Noah Harari, in a 2024 analysis, draws direct parallels between the apprentice's enchanted broom causing a flood and AI systems that could generate uncontrollable outcomes, such as opaque financial algorithms leading to economic crises; he emphasizes the core lesson: "never summon powers you cannot control."^[77] By 2025, this analogy extended to labor markets, with University of the Witwatersrand scholars using the Disney segment to illustrate how AI, initially a productivity tool, might displace jobs if not regulated, though they stress its potential as a controllable enhancer rather than an autonomous threat.^[78] The narrative's themes of hubris and unintended consequences also permeate 2020s pop culture, echoing in fantasy media that explore magical mentorship and control. Motifs from the tale appear in the Marvel Cinematic Universe's Doctor Strange films, where protagonists grapple with wielding arcane powers beyond their initial grasp, reflecting the apprentice's overambitious spellcasting in a modern superhero context. These references build on Disney's Fantasia legacy, adapting the story's cautionary essence to contemporary tales of technological and mystical overreach. Recent scholarship has further interpreted the Sorcerer's Apprentice through lenses of global folklore and ethical frameworks in STEM fields. A 2025 paper in the *Cambridge Forum on AI Law and Governance* examines large language models under the EU AI Act, positioning developers as potential "sorcerer's apprentices" who risk unleashing unaligned systems without regulatory mastery, drawing on the tale's ancient roots in cautionary myths.^[79] These analyses highlight post-2020 developments, such as AI governance parallels, that have garnered increasing attention in academic discourse but remain underexplored in broader cultural critiques of Disney's influence.

References

[1]
"The Sorcerer's Apprentice" | Department of German Studies
A wizard's apprentice who learns the hard way that magic is not to be trifled with. It is a ballad written in fourteen stanzas with an unusual rhyme scheme.Missing: original | Show results with:original
[2]
[PDF] The Sorcerer's Apprentice: An Anthology of Magical Tales
By this I mean the original storytelling, which had been primarily intended for adults, including Goethe's poem, was transformed into a children's warning.
[3]
Goethe's "Sorcerer's Apprentice": Power Over Wisdom - WilderUtopia
Aug 13, 2014 · "Sorcerer's Apprentice" by Goethe, made famous by Disney's "Fantasia," illustrated the risk of human creations getting out of control.Missing: original | Show results with:original
[4]
None
### Extracted Content: Goethe's "The Sorcerer's Apprentice" Poem (English Translation by Laila Collins)
[5]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice
This episode (untitled in the original) is taken from the dialogue The Lover of Lies. Lucian of Samasota (ca. A.D. 125 - ca, A.D. 180) was an Assyrian ...Missing: earliest | Show results with:earliest
[6]
https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691172651/the-sorcerers-apprentice
[7]
Johann Wolfgang von Goethe - New World Encyclopedia
Goethe rewrote the formal rules of German poetry, helped to initiate literary Romanticism and German classicism, and embodied many of the contending strands in ...
[8]
Aufbau des Werkes • Der Zauberlehrling - Inhaltsangabe.de
Aug 12, 2024 · Die Ballade umfasst 98 Verse und besteht aus sieben sechsversigen und sieben achtversigen Strophen, die, beginnend mit einer achtversigen ...
[9]
THE SORCERER'S APPRENTICE
Der Zauberlehrling. (The ... erst hervor der alte Meister!” Johann Wolfgang von Goethe. Translation by Brigitte Dubiel. Good! The sorcerer, my old masterMissing: 1797 | Show results with:1797
[10]
https://www.gedichte7.de/der-zauberlehrling.html
[11]
DUKAS: The Sorcerer's Apprentice - Utah Symphony
Sep 20, 2021 · Duration: 12 minutes. THE COMPOSER – PAUL DUKAS (1865-1935) – It would have been possible, even advisable based on available facts, to foresee a ...
[12]
[PDF] chan 9225 dukas symphony in c major chandos
destined for the young conductor Paul Vidal... Vidal, a conservatoire ... et de L'Apprenti sorcier de Dukas. Recent releases featuring the. BBC ...
[13]
[PDF] The Sorcerer's Apprentice by Paul Dukas
Aug 6, 2025 · Dukas has used this classical structure to propel the story of Goethe's poem. Students develop variations based on a theme. Task 1. Use ...
[14]
Dukas, Paul: The Sorcerer's Apprentice | Fort Worth Symphony ...
Paul Dukas (1865-1935). The Sorcerer's Apprentice (1897) 12 minutes. Piccolo, 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, bass clarinet, 3 bassoons, contrabassoon, ...Missing: sorcier structure influences
[15]
[PDF] Paul Dukas (1865-1935) - Canton Symphony Orchestra
Paul Dukas was a French composer, teacher, and critic, best known for his orchestral works and his influence on French music at the turn of the 20th century ...
[16]
https://www.discogs.com/release/11560380-Leopold-StokowskiPhiladelphia-Orchestra-LApprenti-Sorrier-The-Sorcerers-Apprentice-Berceuse-From-The
[17]
Dukas Paul The Sorcerer's Apprentice Piano 1939 | eBay
The Sorcerer's Apprentice Based on a ballad by Goethe For Piano New transcription for Piano 2 hands By Lucien Garban Music by Paul DUKAS Paris, Durand & Cie ...Missing: arrangement | Show results with:arrangement
[18]
https://www.halleonard.com/product/50562807/lapprenti-sorcier-sorcerers-apprentice
[19]
Dukas Sorcerer's Apprentice (8) - Iain Farrington
This arrangement is for eight players, and captures the colour, spirit and energy of the original. It can be paired with Saint-Saëns's Carnival of the Animals ...Missing: modern | Show results with:modern
[20]
Dukas - The Sorcerer's Apprentice (wind quintet and piano)
Arranged for wind quintet and piano by Iain Farrington, Dukas' score brilliantly captures the humour and wildness of the poem.
[21]
https://www.discogs.com/release/8117107-Leonard-Bernstein-New-York-Philharmonic-The-Sorcerers-Apprentice
[22]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice - YouTube
May 18, 2021 · Comments · EASTHAMA duo: The Sorcerer's Apprentice · Paul Dukas - L'Apprenti Sorcier · Amadeus (1984): 10 Surprising Facts About the Film · Medieval ...Missing: notable arrangements
[23]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice - song and lyrics by The Jazz Revue
Listen to The Sorcerer's Apprentice on Spotify. Song · The Jazz Revue · 2023.
[24]
Stream The Sorcerer's Apprentice (Paul Dukas) by Gabriel Saban
Aug 17, 2023 · Stream The Sorcerer's Apprentice (Paul Dukas) by Gabriel Saban on desktop and mobile. Play over 320 million tracks for free on SoundCloud.
[25]
Sorcerer's Apprentice - Oxford Reference
Lander (Royal Danish Ballet, Copenhagen, 1940). From: Sorcerer's Apprentice, The in The Oxford Dictionary of Dance ». Subjects: Related content in Oxford ...Missing: Harald | Show results with:Harald
[26]
Harald Lander - Choreographer - BolshoiRussia.com
La Valse, music by Maurice Ravel (first performance 1939). The Sorcerer's Apprentice, music by Paul Dukas (first performance 1940). Quarrtsiluni, music by ...
[27]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice (Short 1955) - IMDb
Rating 6.3/10 (232) In a ballet rendition of this classic tale, a young inexperienced apprentice of a powerful wizard tries to use magic to get through her chores.
[28]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice - Michael Powell & Emeric Pressburger
A ballet created in Stuttgart, where Heckroth now worked, based on the story used as the basis of Paul Dukas's scherzo, which accompanies Disney's version ...Missing: choreography | Show results with:choreography
[29]
Sorcerer's Apprentice 2001 - BALLET MINNESOTA
Choreographer: Andrew Rist Composer: Paul Dukas Costumes: Cheryl Rist Sets: Lorelee Sathre PREMIERE 1991 3rd Minnesota Dance Festival St Paul Student Center ...
[30]
ABT News - American Ballet Theatre
A co-production with Minnesota Dance Theatre, The Sorcerer's Apprentice is set to a musical collage by Scott Marshall based on Paul Dukas' L'Apprenti Sorcier.
[31]
Dance: “Sorcerer's Apprentice” a moving lesson from Ballet Ariel
Feb 18, 2015 · Ballet Ariel's version of “The Sorcerer's Apprentice” lands at Cleo Parker Robinson Theatre Feb. 21-22. Saturday-Sunday: As a cartoon lesson in ...
[32]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice (2024) - The Ballet Team
"The Sorcerer's Apprentice", is a symphonic ballet adaptation of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's 1797 poem Der Zauberlehrling.
[33]
Why Goethe Matters - Travalanche - WordPress.com
Aug 28, 2021 · What every educated person should know is that Goethe is widely considered as THE giant of German culture, a kind of combination of Shakespeare, ...<|separator|>
[34]
Revisiting Composers Suppressed by the Nazis | The New Yorker
May 13, 2024 · Painting of Alexander von Zemlinsky with black silhouettes of illustrating his past escaping Europe and becoming. Zemlinsky, once regarded as ...
[35]
https://www.tcdailyplanet.net/sorcerers-apprentice-open-eye-theatre-review/
[36]
An Incomplete History of The San Francisco Bay Area Puppeteers ...
That year, Jim Henson would see their show at a puppet regional festival and hire them on the spot to form his new: Muppets! Jerry left at the end of the ...<|separator|>
[37]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice - Musical Theatre Musings
Rating 3.0 · Review by Sarah McPartlanFeb 26, 2021 · The Sorcerer's Apprentice is a new musical by Richard Hough and Ben Morales Frost. It tells of a Sorcerer and his daughter, Eva who has inherited his talent ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
[38]
THEATER | Open Eye Figure Theatre puts “The Sorcerer's ...
Feb 14, 2012 · The short, typically intense puppet play showcases many of Sommers's talents: his unflinching embrace of the macabre, his ingenuity with set ...Missing: German | Show results with:German
[39]
15 Fascinating Facts About Fantasia - D23
1. Dopey Might Have Been the Sorcerer's Apprentice Once again it all started with a Mouse. Walt wanted to star Mickey in an animated version of The Sorcerer's ...
[40]
James Algar dies at 85 - Variety
Mar 22, 1998 · James Algar, longtime Walt Disney Co. producer, writer and director, and helmer of “The Sorcerer's Apprentice,” died Feb. 26 at his home in ...
[41]
Fantasia - Rotten Tomatoes
Rating 95% (61) Distributor: Walt Disney ; Production Co: Walt Disney Productions ; Rating: G ; Original Language: English ; Release Date (Theaters): Nov 13, 1940, Limited.
[42]
Fantasia — A Visual Symphony - D23
Concept art from The Sorcerer's Apprentice animated segment.Missing: production | Show results with:production
[43]
Disney's 'Fantasia' at 75: Why there's still nothing like it - YourClassical
Jan 30, 2015 · The Sorcerer's Apprentice starring a new, cuter Mickey Mouse was a ... Snow White had made use of a multiplane camera that enhanced the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[44]
Disney's Fantasia Premieres | Research Starters - EBSCO
Disney's "Fantasia" premiered on November 13, 1940, at New York's Broadway Theater, emphasizing music over narrative.
[45]
Fantasia 2000 | Computer Graphics World
Jan 1, 2000 · ... digitally, including the original "Sorcerer's Apprentice," starring Mickey Mouse, which was restored one frame at a time at Cinesite (Los ...
[46]
Stokowski Arrives in Los Angeles to Record The Sorcerer's Apprentice
Jan 29, 2019 · Before the idea of Fantasia had been conceived, Walt planned to do a cartoon short of The Sorcerer's Apprentice, based on the classical ...Missing: production | Show results with:production
[47]
Disney, Goethe, and Paul Dukas L'Apprenti sorcier
Jul 15, 2019 · They devised a feature-length Technicolor film Fantasia, featuring a string of animated, narrative shorts accompanied by symphonic repertoire— ...
[48]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice (2010) - IMDb
Rating 6.1/10 (175,199) A protege of the magician Merlin must train his teacher's successor - an introverted but resourceful physics prodigy - in the art of sorcery.Full cast & crew · Nicolas Cage as Balthazar · Plot · The Sorcerer's Apprentice
[49]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice | Rotten Tomatoes
Rating 40% (171) Synopsis Dave Stutler (Jay Baruchel) is just an average guy, but the wizard Balthazar Blake (Nicolas Cage) sees in him a hidden talent for sorcery. He becomes ...100000+ Ratings · Cast and Crew · 171 Reviews
[50]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice - Box Office Mojo
Key:Estimated ... BoxOfficeMojo.com by IMDbPro - an IMDb company. © IMDb.com, Inc. or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Box Office Mojo and IMDb are trademarks ...
[51]
Special Effects Wizard John Nelson on <em>The Sorcerer's ...
Nov 25, 2010 · How many of the effects in The Sorcerer's Apprentice were CGI and how many were on-set practical effects and which type of effect do you prefer ...
[52]
Mopping up after the Apprentice - fxguide
Oct 7, 2010 · For The Sorcerer's Apprentice,visual effects supervisor John Nelson oversaw more than 1200 shots featuring plasma ball fights, ...
[53]
The Wizard's Apprentice (Short 1930) - IMDb
Rating 6.6/10 (74) A sorcerer leaves his apprentice unsupervised with a tiny nymph and a broom. An early live-action film based on the Goethe poem, using the Dukas score.
[54]
Short of the month: The Wizard's Apprentice (dir. Sidney Levee, 1930)
Jun 3, 2022 · While the film's special effects are simple, they are effective, especially the brooms. ... animation of Disney's broomsticks. One weird ...
[55]
'The Wizard's Apprentice' (1930) | - Cartoon Research
Apr 12, 2018 · A fun and surreal little track film produced in the early days of sound. It was directed by Sidney Leveem and stars Herbert Bunston, Fritz Feld and Greta ...
[56]
Robert Bloch on TV Part Eight-Alfred Hitchcock Presents
Feb 2, 2012 · Bloch adapted “The Sorcerer's Apprentice” for Alfred Hitchcock Presents, and the episode was filmed in the summer of 1961, probably in August.
[57]
"Alfred Hitchcock Presents" The Sorcerer's Apprentice (TV Episode ...
Rating 7.1/10 (887) A magician takes a simple-minded runaway under his wing. But the magician's wife has a sinister idea for the easily manipulated young man.
[58]
https://disney.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_cameos_in_Who_Framed_Roger_Rabbit
[59]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice (1978) - IMDb
Rating 7.5/10 (1,298) A young boy becomes an apprentice for a mysterious sorcerer, working at the sorcerer's strange and sinister mill where secretive black magic is being taught.
[60]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice (1978) - Moria Reviews
Sep 3, 2020 · Director: Karel Zeman ; Crew: Karel Zeman ; Themes: Animation, Magicians and Sorcerers, Magic, Animal Transformation, Magic Spells, Czech Cinema, ...
[61]
List of cameos in Who Framed Roger Rabbit | Disney Wiki - Fandom
Various Fantasia characters: The Brooms from The Sorcerer's Apprentice · Hyacinth Hippo and Madame Upanova from Dance of the Hours · Peter Pegasus, one of the ...
[62]
Who Framed Roger Rabbit (1988) - 'Toon Town' scene - YouTube
Jun 15, 2023 · Who Framed Roger Rabbit (1988) - 'Toon Town' scene · Comments.
[63]
Shape Shifting in 'The Sorcerer's Apprentice'
Jul 23, 2010 · There's a lot more to The Sorcerer's Apprentice than electrifying vfx -- there's also a lot of shape shifting courtesy of Asylum FX's 500 noteworthy shots.
[64]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice : Hanns Heinz Ewer's, Ludwig Lewisohn ...
Jan 6, 2023 · The Sorcerer's Apprentice. by: Hanns Heinz Ewer's, Ludwig Lewisohn, Mablon Blaine. Publication date: 1927. Publisher: New York The John Day ...
[65]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice by Hanns Heinz Ewers | Goodreads
Rating 4.0 (138) The story follows the journey of a young man named Anselmus, who becomes entangled in a world of magic and sorcery after falling in love with a woman named ...
[66]
The Sorcerers Apprentice
Here I watched a young elephant taking peanuts one by one from a boy'shand, giving each time a little flick of his trunk, and saw the ball of the sun drop ...
[67]
A Journey through East Africa. By Elspeth Huxley. 1948. London ...
The Sorcerer's Apprentice; A Journey through East Africa. By Elspeth Huxley. 1948. London: Chatto and Windus. Pp. xviii + 366, maps, plates. 18s. net.
[68]
Communist Manifesto (Chapter 1) - Marxists Internet Archive
Communists of various nationalities have assembled in London and sketched the following manifesto, to be published in the English, French, German, Italian, ...Missing: Apprentice | Show results with:Apprentice
[69]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice: A Journey through East Africa by Elspeth ...
May 14, 2020 · Between February and June of 1947, Huxley, a long-term English settler in Kenya, travelled through Eastern Kenya, then to Tanganyika, Zanzibar, ...
[70]
"Once Upon a Time" The Apprentice (TV Episode 2014) - Plot - IMDb
Back in the Fairy Tale Land that was, Rumplestiltskin uses Anna to acquire a magical box from the Sorcerer's apprentice.— ... ONCE UPON A TIME SEASON 4 (2014) ( ...The Apprentice · Once Upon A Time · Synopsis<|separator|>
[71]
Tiny Toon Music Television - IMDb
Rating 8.6/10 (101) Max sings motown, Buster spoofs the Sorcerer's Apprentice and Babs performs "Respect" in this parody of MTV.
[72]
Enchanted Brooms - Kingdom Hearts Insider
Enchanted Brooms. KINGDOM HEARTS. First Appearance: KINGDOM HEARTS (2002) Origin: The Sorcerer's Apprentice (1940). What used to be regular, run-of-the-mill ...
[73]
Enchanted Brooms - Kingdom Hearts Insider
First Appearance: KINGDOM HEARTS (2002) Origin: The Sorcerer's Apprentice (1940). Once just brooms that laid around Yen Sid's tower, Mickey enchanted them ...
[74]
The Sorcerer's Apprentice | MAGIC: THE GATHERING
Jul 12, 2010 · A look into the world of The Sorcerer's Apprentice through the prism of its four custom-made Drake Stone Magic cards that only appear in the magical world of ...Missing: inspiration 1990s
[75]
https://www.lesauterhin.eu/lapprenti-sorcier-une-ballade-de-goethe/
[76]
Sorcerer - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
Sorcerer's apprentice as a figure of one who unleashes forces he cannot control translates l'apprenti sorcier, title of a symphonic poem by Paul Dukas (1897) ...Missing: idiom | Show results with:idiom<|separator|>
[77]
L'apprenti sorcier, une ballade de Goethe - Le SauteRhin
Mar 26, 2017 · C'est une forme poétique qui raconte une histoire, qui décrit une action, un agir. ... Le succès de la métaphore de l'apprenti sorcier dépasse ...
[78]
La metáfora del aprendiz de brujo - Ethic
Feb 11, 2025 · De Goethe a Walt Disney, la metáfora del aprendiz de brujo muestra que el hombre lleva dentro de sí el miedo a ser superado por su creación.
[79]
'Never summon a power you can't control': Yuval Noah Harari on ...
Aug 24, 2024 · ... Sorcerer's Apprentice. Goethe's poem (later popularised as a Walt Disney animation starring Mickey Mouse) tells of an old sorcerer who ...
[80]
The Post-Human Desert by Slavoj Žižek - Project Syndicate
Apr 7, 2023 · The engineer of tomorrow will not be a sorcerer's apprentice because of his negligence or ignorance, but by choice.” Humanity is creating ...<|separator|>
[81]
The sorcerer's apprentice: The impact of AI on future jobs
Jan 24, 2025 · We look at the myths and realities, risks and opportunities posed by the adoption of AI. In Disney's The Sorcerer's Apprentice, Mickey Mouse ...
[82]
Artificial Intelligence in Education (AIED): Towards More Effective ...
... Sorcerer's Apprentice?” (2025) Cambridge Forum on AI: Law and. Governance 1, 1–13, 8. 35 J Koh, M Cowling, J Meena and KN Sim, “The Human Teacher, the AI ...