Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Subtractive color

Subtractive color mixing is a color model in which colors are produced by the selective absorption of wavelengths of light by pigments, dyes, or inks, with the remaining wavelengths reflected or transmitted to create the perceived color. Unlike additive color models that build colors by combining light, subtractive mixing starts with a white or light base and progressively darkens as more pigments are layered, as each pigment subtracts portions of the light spectrum.^[1] Subtractive systems employ different sets of primary colors depending on the context: traditionally red, yellow, and blue (RYB) in painting and art, and cyan, magenta, and yellow (CMY) in printing and scientific applications.^[2]^[3] In printing, the CMYK model extends CMY by incorporating a black (K) component to achieve deeper blacks, improve contrast, and reduce ink usage, addressing the limitations of CMY alone where equal mixtures produce a muddy brown rather than true black.^[4] This approach is essential to fields involving reflected light, such as printing, painting, photography, and textile dyeing. Subtractive color contrasts with additive systems like RGB used in digital displays, as it relies on absorption rather than emission.^[4]

Fundamentals

Definition and Principles

Subtractive color is the process by which colored materials, such as pigments, dyes, and inks, generate perceived hues by selectively absorbing specific wavelengths of incident white light, allowing the remaining wavelengths to be reflected or transmitted to the observer.^[5] This absorption results in the subtraction of certain spectral components from the full spectrum of white light, which contains all visible wavelengths approximately equally, leading to the appearance of complementary colors that are darker than the original light source.^[1] Unlike additive color mixing, which combines emitted light to build brighter colors, subtractive mixing inherently darkens the result as more absorbing materials are layered.^[6] The fundamental principle of subtractive color relies on the starting point of broadband white light illumination, from which portions of the spectrum are progressively removed through absorption to isolate desired wavelengths for perception.^[7] Materials like pigments achieve this by converting absorbed light energy into heat, while the non-absorbed light scatters diffusely in reflective media or passes through in transmissive ones, determining the final color observed.^[8] For instance, mixing yellow and magenta pigments produces red because the yellow pigment primarily absorbs shorter blue wavelengths (around 400-500 nm), transmitting longer red and green ones, while magenta absorbs mid-range green wavelengths (around 500-600 nm), transmitting red and blue; their combination absorbs both blue and green, leaving predominantly red wavelengths to reflect or transmit.^[6] Spectral absorption curves for these pigments illustrate this removal: yellow shows a strong absorption peak in the violet-blue region, tapering off toward red, whereas magenta peaks in the green-yellow region, confirming the selective subtraction that yields the mixed red hue.^[9] In subtractive media, the distinction between reflection and transmission modes is key to application: opaque pigments on surfaces, like paints, rely on diffuse reflection of unabsorbed light after incidence and scattering within the material, whereas transparent dyes or filters in inks permit transmission of unabsorbed wavelengths through the medium.^[7] Both processes follow the same absorption principle but differ in how light interacts with the material's structure—reflective for non-transmissive substrates and transmissive for clear layers—ensuring the perceived color emerges from the subtracted spectrum in either case.^[8]

Physics of Light Absorption

Light, as electromagnetic radiation, consists of waves spanning a spectrum of wavelengths, typically from about 400 to 700 nanometers for the visible range. When this light interacts with pigments or dyes in subtractive color systems, the materials selectively absorb certain wavelengths while reflecting or transmitting others, determining the observed color. This absorption occurs because the energy of incoming photons matches specific energy differences within the material, leading to the removal of those wavelengths from the incident light.^[5] At the molecular level, the absorption properties of pigments and dyes arise from their chemical structures, particularly conjugated systems of alternating single and double bonds in organic molecules. These structures enable electronic transitions where an electron is excited from a ground state (such as the highest occupied molecular orbital, HOMO) to a higher-energy excited state (like the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital, LUMO) upon absorbing a photon of appropriate energy. The specific wavelengths absorbed correspond to the energy gap between these orbitals, resulting in characteristic absorption spectra that define the color of the pigment—for instance, a pigment absorbing in the blue region (around 450 nm) will appear yellow by reflecting longer wavelengths. This phenomenon is well-documented in the ultraviolet-visible spectroscopy of organic compounds, where π → π* transitions in conjugated chromophores dominate visible absorption.^[10]^[11] The perceived color in subtractive systems emerges from the resultant spectrum after absorption, modeled simply as the incident white light spectrum minus the absorbed wavelengths. For an opaque pigment layer, the reflected intensity I_{\text{result}}(\lambda) at wavelength \lambda can be expressed as:

I_{\text{result}}(\lambda) = I_{\text{white}}(\lambda) \cdot (1 - A(\lambda))

where I_{\text{white}}(\lambda) is the incident spectral intensity (approximating uniform white light), and A(\lambda) is the wavelength-dependent absorptivity, ranging from 0 to 1. This equation reflects the basic principle of absorptance in non-transmissive media, where unabsorbed light is reflected, and the human eye integrates the resulting spectrum to perceive color.^[5]^[12] The absorption and subsequent reflectance are further modulated by the substrate and surrounding medium, which can alter the effective path length of light and scattering properties. For example, a porous substrate like paper absorbs more pigment and incident light, potentially reducing reflectance and shifting the perceived color toward darker tones compared to a smoother, less absorbent canvas that allows greater specular reflection of unabsorbed wavelengths. This interaction influences the overall spectral distribution, with studies showing that substrate absorbency can change surface chemistry and pigment distribution, thereby affecting color saturation and hue.^[13]^[14]

Historical Development

Early Concepts in Art and Science

The earliest evidence of subtractive color practices dates back to prehistoric cave paintings, where artists employed natural pigments such as red ochre, derived from iron oxide, to create vivid hues on rock surfaces. These pigments, applied during the Upper Paleolithic period around 40,000 years ago in sites such as El Castillo and Chauvet Cave, absorbed specific wavelengths of light, allowing for basic mixing with charcoal or other earth tones to produce darker shades and tonal variations, exemplifying subtractive color principles through the selective absorption of reflected light.^[15]^[16] In ancient Egypt, circa 3000 BCE, artisans utilized natural pigments including ochre for reds and yellows, alongside minerals like malachite for greens, which were ground and mixed with binders such as gum arabic to form paints for tomb decorations and artifacts. This subtractive approach enabled the creation of a limited palette where overlapping pigments resulted in muddier tones due to cumulative light absorption, as seen in the vibrant yet layered colors of artifacts from the Old Kingdom.^[17] Philosophical foundations for understanding color mixing emerged in the 4th century BCE with Aristotle, who proposed in his work Meteorologica that colors arise from the mixture of light and darkness, positing white as the extreme of light and black as the extreme of darkness, with intermediate hues formed by their combination. This rudimentary framework, emphasizing alteration through opposition, laid groundwork for later subtractive interpretations where pigments "darken" or absorb to modify colors, influencing artistic practices for centuries.^[18]^[19] During the medieval period, alchemists documented pigment recipes in illuminated manuscripts, such as the 12th-century De coloribus faciendis, detailing the grinding and mixing of minerals like vermilion (mercuric sulfide) and azurite with organic binders to achieve stable colors for book illumination. These recipes highlighted empirical observations of subtractive mixing, where combining pigments like red lead and ultramarine produced new tones through light filtration, often recorded in monastic scriptoria. In the Renaissance, artists like Leonardo da Vinci expanded these practices, experimenting with layered glazes of natural pigments such as lapis lazuli and lead-tin yellow to observe how successive applications absorbed light, creating depth and illusion in works like the Mona Lisa.^[20]^[21]^[22] A pivotal transition to more scientific inquiry occurred in 1666 with Isaac Newton's prism experiments, which decomposed white light into its spectral components, indirectly underscoring the contrast between additive light spectra and the absorptive nature of colored media like pigments. By demonstrating that colors are inherent in light rather than created by it, Newton's findings challenged earlier intuitive views and paved the way for 18th- and 19th-century developments in systematic color theory.^[23]^[18]

Evolution of Color Theory

The evolution of subtractive color theory gained momentum during the Enlightenment, building on earlier intuitive practices in art to develop more systematic frameworks for understanding pigment interactions. In 1766, English naturalist and engraver Moses Harris published The Natural System of Colours, featuring one of the earliest color wheels that explicitly incorporated subtractive mixing principles, demonstrating how red, yellow, and blue primaries could combine to produce secondary colors and ultimately black through absorption of light wavelengths.^[24] This representation emphasized the perceptual and physical outcomes of pigment blending, marking a shift toward empirical classification in color studies.^[25] The 19th century saw further refinement through scientific inquiry into optical effects and industrial applications. French chemist Michel Eugène Chevreul, director of the Gobelins tapestry manufactory, published The Principles of Harmony and Contrast of Colors in 1839, articulating the law of simultaneous contrast and its implications for how adjacent pigments alter perceived hues in subtractive mixtures.^[26] His work, motivated by complaints from textile dyers about inconsistent color vibrancy, highlighted how pigment interactions in fabrics could lead to unintended desaturation or shifts, influencing standardized approaches to dye formulation and mixing in manufacturing.^[27] These insights bridged artistic intuition with scientific precision, laying groundwork for controlled subtractive systems. The Industrial Revolution catalyzed the standardization of pigments, enabling more reliable subtractive color models through mass production of synthetic dyes. Beginning in the early 19th century, innovations like William Perkin's mauveine in 1856 initiated a "color revolution," where artificial coal-tar dyes replaced variable natural pigments, ensuring consistent absorption spectra for reproducible mixing in textiles, paints, and prints.^[28] This uniformity addressed longstanding variability in organic materials, fostering theoretical advancements in subtractive harmony. In the 20th century, subtractive principles found practical milestones in photography, with French inventor Louis Ducos du Hauron patenting three-color processes in 1868–1869 that adapted CMY (cyan, magenta, yellow) filters for subtractive synthesis, producing early color images around 1870 through layered absorption of light.^[29] His methods, which superimposed pigmented positives to filter white light, demonstrated the feasibility of subtractive reproduction, influencing later commercial adoption in film and printing despite initial technical challenges.^[30] These developments solidified subtractive theory as a cornerstone for industrial color technologies.

Color Models

RYB Model

The RYB model is a traditional subtractive color model employed primarily in artistic pigment mixing, designating red, yellow, and blue as the primary colors from which a broad gamut of hues can be derived through combination.^[31] This perceptual approach emphasizes how colors appear to the human eye when pigments are blended on a surface, rather than precise spectral interactions, making it foundational for color wheels in art education.^[32] The model's historical basis traces to 19th-century color theory, particularly Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's Theory of Colours (1810), where he identified red, yellow, and blue as the generative primaries capable of producing secondary hues like orange, green, and purple through mixing, influencing subsequent art educators in promoting RYB for practical pigment application.^[33] Goethe's framework prioritized physiological perception over Newtonian optics, establishing RYB as a tool for artists to explore color harmony and contrast. In terms of mixing rules, secondary colors emerge from equal pairwise combinations of the primaries: red and yellow produce orange, yellow and blue yield green, and blue and red generate purple (or violet). Tertiary colors arise from unequal ratios, such as two parts red to one part yellow for red-orange, or one part yellow to two parts blue for yellow-green, allowing for finer gradations within the model's wheel structure.^[34] Despite its utility in art, the RYB model exhibits limitations in color gamut, notably its inability to generate vibrant greens or magentas compared to modern subtractive systems. For instance, the green from yellow and blue pigments often appears muted because yellow pigments typically absorb in the blue-violet spectrum (around 400-450 nm), while blue pigments absorb in the yellow-orange range (around 550-600 nm), causing spectral overlap that reduces saturation and brightness in the mixture. Similarly, the purple from red and blue lacks magenta's purity, as traditional red pigments absorb broadly across green (500-550 nm) and some blue wavelengths, while blue absorbs red-orange, resulting in a desaturated outcome rather than a vivid, spectrum-gap magenta.^[32] In contrast to the CMY model, which optimizes for balanced absorption in printing, RYB prioritizes perceptual primaries suited to traditional painting.^[35]

CMY Model

The CMY model is a subtractive color system utilizing cyan, magenta, and yellow as primary colors, selected for their complementary absorption spectra to the additive RGB primaries. Cyan absorbs primarily red light, magenta absorbs green light, and yellow absorbs blue light, enabling the trio to theoretically cover the full visible spectrum by subtracting specific wavelengths from white light.^[36] This choice aims for complete spectral coverage, where the primaries' absorption bands overlap minimally while collectively blocking all incident light when combined.^[7] In ideal subtractive mixing, equal amounts of cyan, magenta, and yellow combine to produce black, or neutral density, by fully absorbing red, green, and blue components of white light, resulting in no reflected or transmitted color.^[36] This principle relies on the multiplicative nature of light transmittance through layered pigments or inks, where each primary subtracts its targeted wavelengths without introducing unintended absorptions in the ideal case.^[7] The mathematical basis for CMY mixing is rooted in optical density, defined as the negative base-10 logarithm of transmittance. For superimposed layers of cyan, magenta, and yellow, the total optical density D at a given wavelength adds linearly:

D = D_c + D_m + D_y

where D_c, D_m, and D_y are the optical densities contributed by each primary, respectively.^[36] This additivity arises because transmittance multiplies across layers (T = 10^{-D}), transforming the product into a sum in density space, providing a linear framework for predicting mixed colors.^[36] Theoretically, the CMY model serves as the foundation for colorimetry in halftone printing processes, where pigment mixtures are modeled using adapted additive principles such as the Neugebauer equations. These equations treat surface coverages of CMY inks as proportions contributing to overall reflectance, extending Grassmann's laws of additive color mixture—originally for lights—to subtractive pigment systems by linearizing interactions in coverage space.^[37] In practice, this ideal is often extended by adding black ink to form the CMYK model for improved neutrality and economy.

CMYK Model

The CMYK color model extends the CMY subtractive system by incorporating a black (K) ink component, which addresses limitations in achieving deep shadows, neutral grays, and true blacks while minimizing ink consumption and cost.^[38] This addition is essential because mixing cyan, magenta, and yellow inks alone often yields a muddy brown due to impurities and over-absorption of light, whereas pure black ink provides richer contrast and detail without excessive colored ink layering.^[38] In the CMYK printing process, typically employed in offset lithography, each color is applied separately using halftone screens that break continuous tones into patterns of dots varying in size and density, allowing simulation of a wide color gamut on paper.^[38] Overprinting occurs as the cyan, magenta, yellow, and black plates are sequentially impressed on the substrate, with the inks blending subtractively to form the final image; dot gain during transfer further influences perceived color intensity.^[38] The four-color wet process printing was advanced in the early 1900s by the Eagle Printing Ink Company using blue, red, yellow, and black inks in 1906, enabling efficient multicolor offset lithography for commercial applications like newspapers and magazines.^[39] Its standardization in proofing and production began in the late 1940s and solidified by the 1950s, as industry efforts aligned ink formulations and separation techniques for consistent results across presses.^[39] Key challenges in CMYK printing include color trapping and misregistration, where slight mechanical shifts between plate impressions can create visible white gaps or halos between overlapping colors.^[40] To mitigate this, trapping techniques slightly spread or choke adjacent colors (e.g., expanding a magenta edge by 0.1–0.2 mm to overlap cyan), compensating for tolerances up to 0.1 mm in high-speed offset runs.^[40] Additionally, total ink density is limited—typically to 200–320% cumulative coverage across all channels—to prevent ink bleed, slow drying, and substrate saturation, as exceeding this (e.g., 100% each of C, M, Y, and 20% K) risks mottling and reduced press efficiency.^[38]

Applications

In Painting and Visual Arts

In painting and visual arts, subtractive color principles underpin pigment mixing techniques that allow artists to selectively absorb wavelengths of light to create depth and vibrancy. Layering involves applying successive coats of paint to build opacity and intensity, where each layer absorbs additional light, resulting in darker, more saturated hues as light passes through and interacts with underlying pigments.^[8] Glazing, a related method, employs thin, transparent layers of oil or acrylic paint mixed with mediums to achieve luminous effects; this technique controls absorption by permitting light to penetrate multiple layers before reflecting back, enhancing color harmony without muddying tones.^[41] In oil painting, slow-drying properties facilitate precise layering, while acrylics' faster drying enables rapid glazing adjustments, both exemplifying subtractive mixing's reliance on pigment subtraction for tonal control.^[42] Impressionist artists, such as Claude Monet in the late 19th century, harnessed subtractive palettes to evoke transient light effects, mixing pigments on canvas to capture atmospheric luminosity. Monet's works, like his Water Lilies series, demonstrate this through broken brushwork and layered applications of primaries—red, yellow, and blue—where subtractive combinations produced subtle shifts in perceived brightness and shadow, simulating natural light diffusion. This approach marked a departure from earlier academic traditions, emphasizing en plein air observation to exploit pigment absorption for optical vibrancy. Pigments in painting vary by type, influencing subtractive color's longevity through their absorption properties. Organic pigments, derived from carbon-based compounds like plant extracts or synthetic dyes, offer intense chroma but are prone to fading when ultraviolet light absorption triggers photochemical breakdown, leading to color loss over time. Inorganic pigments, sourced from minerals such as ochres or oxides, provide greater permanence due to stable crystal structures that resist light-induced degradation, maintaining absorption spectra even under prolonged exposure.^[43] These differences guide artists in selecting materials for archival works, balancing vividness with durability in subtractive applications.^[44] The RYB model plays a central role in art education, teaching intuitive color harmony through subtractive mixing of red, yellow, and blue primaries to derive secondaries like orange, green, and purple. This traditional framework fosters conceptual understanding of pigment interactions, enabling students to explore complementary contrasts and analogous schemes for balanced compositions.^[45] Widely adopted in curricula, it emphasizes hands-on experimentation with paints to grasp how absorption yields harmonious results, bridging historical practices with creative expression.^[31]

In Printing and Reproduction

Subtractive color principles underpin printing processes that rely on inks to absorb specific wavelengths of light from a reflective substrate, typically white paper, to produce visible colors through the remaining reflected light. In the 19th century, letterpress printing advanced subtractive color reproduction by layering multiple ink passes, often using black and red inks on dampened paper for two-color outputs, achieving registration within about 1/16 inch despite challenges from paper expansion.^[46] Lithography, invented around 1796 by Alois Senefelder, evolved into chromolithography by the mid-19th century, employing multiple limestone or zinc plates inked with colored pigments to layer subtractive hues, enabling complex reproductions like the Ghent Altarpiece panel in 1877 using at least eight stones for blended tones.^[47]^[46] Offset printing, developed from lithography in the early 20th century, uses CMYK inks in a workflow where images are transferred from metal plates to rubber blankets before application to substrates, minimizing direct contact to preserve plate longevity. Ink formulation for CMYK involves spectrophotometric inspection of pigments, resins, and solvents; recipes are adjusted via software like InkFormulation to account for substrate color and film thickness, ensuring subtractive mixing yields target hues by absorbing complementary wavelengths—cyan for red, magenta for green, and yellow for blue.^[48] Substrate interactions are critical, as paper's whiteness reflects all light initially, but its porosity and brightness influence ink absorption and final color density; for instance, coated stocks reduce dot gain compared to uncoated ones, preserving subtractive accuracy.^[48] Digital printing adapts this subtractive approach with toner-based CMYK, applying pigmented particles electrostatically to substrates before fusing, though workflows emphasize rapid, on-demand layering to mimic offset results without plates.^[6] Quality control in these processes employs International Color Consortium (ICC) profiles to calibrate subtractive outputs, mapping device-specific CMYK values to a device-independent space like CIELAB for consistent color across presses and proofers. Profiles are generated by printing and measuring characterization targets, such as IT8.7/3 charts, with spectrophotometers to build lookup tables that correct for ink-substrate variations, achieving tolerances via metrics like Delta E.^[49] Environmental concerns in subtractive printing arise from CMYK ink components, including volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in solvent-based formulations that contribute to air pollution, though emissions are regulated under directives such as the EU Solvent Emissions Directive (1999/13/EC), with processes like publication gravure achieving over 98% solvent recovery.^[50] Toxicity is mitigated by excluding heavy metals like lead and mercury per industry standards, with trace levels kept below hazardous thresholds to protect aquatic life.^[50] Recycling efforts focus on de-inking printed paper, where water-based and UV-cured CMYK variants generally facilitate higher recovery rates than traditional solvent inks, supporting circular economies through energy recovery from waste.^[51]

In Photography and Digital Imaging

In analog photography, subtractive color is realized through multilayered color negative films that incorporate cyan, magenta, and yellow (CMY) dye layers to form images by selective absorption of light. These films typically consist of three emulsion layers, each sensitized to a primary color range—blue, green, and red—where exposure creates latent silver halide images that, upon development, generate complementary subtractive dyes: yellow in the blue-sensitive layer, magenta in the green-sensitive layer, and cyan in the red-sensitive layer. A seminal example is Kodachrome, introduced in 1935 as a subtractive three-color reversal film with thin emulsion layers and non-wandering dyes, employing a complex K-14 processing method to produce vibrant, stable positives through controlled dye formation.^[52]^[53] Dye transfer and chromogenic methods further exemplify subtractive principles by relying on chemical couplers embedded in the emulsion layers to form dyes during processing. In chromogenic processes, oxidized color developers react with these couplers in the presence of exposed silver halide grains, producing subtractive dyes that are insoluble and localized to the image site, enabling high-resolution color negatives or positives without dye diffusion. This approach, dominant in modern color films, ensures that the resulting image density corresponds to light absorption by the CMY dyes, with the silver images removed in subsequent bleaching and fixing steps to reveal the pure dye record.^[54]^[55] The adaptation of subtractive color to digital imaging involves converting additive RGB data captured by sensors into CMY values for output on subtractive media like inkjet prints. This RGB-to-CMY transformation accounts for the printer's ink gamut by mapping device-independent color spaces, such as CIE XYZ, to subtractive primaries, often incorporating undercolor removal to optimize ink usage and prevent muddy blacks. In inkjet workflows, this conversion ensures that digital images from RGB cameras reproduce accurately via layered cyan, magenta, and yellow inks on paper, bridging analog subtractive heritage with computational precision.^[56]^[57] Advancements in subtractive photography have focused on refining silver halide emulsions' spectral sensitivity to better match human vision and mitigate imperfections like unwanted dye absorption. Emulsions are spectrally tuned using sensitizing dyes to extend sensitivity into green and red regions, with blue-sensitive layers naturally responsive but red layers requiring precise control to avoid crosstalk, as seen in color negative films where peak sensitivities align at approximately 450 nm (blue), 550 nm (green), and 650 nm (red). Masking techniques, such as orange masking in color negative films, correct these subtractive flaws by adding low-level opposite dyes during manufacturing, compensating for spectral impurities and improving color fidelity in prints without altering the primary image exposure.^[58]^[59]^[60]

Limitations and Comparisons

Challenges in Subtractive Systems

Subtractive color systems, which rely on pigments or inks that absorb specific wavelengths of light to produce color through reflection or transmission, face inherent gamut limitations due to the incomplete and overlapping spectral absorption profiles of available colorants. In models like RYB or CMY, certain vibrant hues, such as bright blues, cannot be accurately reproduced because cyan pigments, intended to absorb red light, often exhibit secondary absorptions in the blue-green region, resulting in desaturated or muddy tones rather than pure spectral blues. This restriction arises from the physical properties of dyes and pigments, which rarely achieve ideal "blocker" absorption across the entire complementary spectrum without unintended spillover, confining the reproducible color space to a subset of the visible gamut for standard CMYK printing.^[7]^[61] Metamerism presents another significant challenge in subtractive systems, where colors formulated from different pigment combinations may appear identical under one illuminant but diverge under another due to variations in their absorption and reflectance profiles across the spectrum. For instance, two blue paints—one using ultramarine and another phthalo blue—might match under daylight (illuminant D65) but shift hues under incandescent light because their spectral curves intersect at multiple points, leading to differing tristimulus values for alternative light sources. This phenomenon, quantified using CIELAB color differences (e.g., ΔE values exceeding 2.0 for observer metamerism), complicates color matching in printing and art reproduction, as the non-spectral nature of pigment absorption exacerbates mismatches compared to more uniform additive systems.^[62] The stability of subtractive colors is further compromised by fading and degradation, particularly from ultraviolet (UV) exposure, which breaks molecular bonds in pigments and alters their absorption characteristics over time. Organic pigments like alizarin (a red lake used in historical paintings) can shift from vibrant crimson to faded pink or gray, as observed in conservation studies of 19th-century portraits where sleeve details in alizarin-based glazes exhibited increased lightness (higher L* values in CIELAB). Inorganic pigments, such as vermilion (mercuric sulfide), may darken instead, converting to metacinnabar gray through photochemical reduction, a process accelerated in binding media like oil that yellows concurrently, thus distorting the overall color balance in artworks. These changes, monitored via spectrophotometry and Kubelka-Munk theory for absorption/scattering ratios, underscore the need for UV-filtering in conservation to preserve subtractive color integrity.^[62] In printing applications, ink spread and dot gain degrade the precision of subtractive color reproduction by causing halftone dots to enlarge beyond their intended size, thereby reducing contrast and compressing the tonal range. Physical dot gain occurs as ink spreads laterally on the substrate due to absorption and smearing, while optical dot gain results from light scattering within the paper, creating illusory enlargement through subsurface shadows. Together, these effects lead to darker midtones and loss of detail in CMYK prints, as modeled by the Yule-Nielsen equation which accounts for non-linear transmittance in halftone layers.^[63] Modern printing technologies, such as expanded color sets with additional inks, help mitigate some gamut and stability limitations.^[64]

Relation to Additive Color

Subtractive color models operate by starting with a white substrate, such as paper, and producing colors through the absorption of specific wavelengths of light by pigments or dyes, which progressively darkens the result as more colorants are applied. In contrast, additive color models begin from a black background and generate colors by combining emitted light from sources like red, green, and blue (RGB) primaries, resulting in brighter outputs as light intensities increase. This fundamental opposition arises because subtractive systems rely on reflected light, where unwanted wavelengths are removed, while additive systems involve direct transmission of light.^[65]^[4] The subtractive primaries—cyan, magenta, and yellow (CMY)—exhibit spectral complementarity to the additive RGB primaries, as each CMY colorant selectively absorbs one of the RGB wavelengths: cyan absorbs red light, magenta absorbs green, and yellow absorbs blue. This relationship enables the two systems to cover a broad color gamut collectively and is mathematically represented through linear algebra transformations. For instance, a basic idealized conversion from normalized CMY values (ranging from 0 to 1) to RGB is given by:

\begin{align*} R &= 1 - C, \\ G &= 1 - M, \\ B &= 1 - Y, \end{align*}

where more precise device-dependent conversions employ transformation matrices that map through intermediate tristimulus spaces, accounting for spectral sensitivities.^[65]^[66] In practical applications, additive and subtractive systems interconnect via color management workflows, where RGB data from digital displays or cameras is transformed to CMY(K) for subtractive printing to maintain visual consistency. This calibration typically uses the device-independent CIE XYZ color space as an intermediary, which represents colors based on human visual response functions (X, Y, Z tristimuli), allowing accurate mapping between emitted light (additive) and reflected/absorbed light (subtractive) across media.^[64]^[67] Historically, James Clerk Maxwell's 1861 experiments with additive color synthesis—projecting superimposed red, green, and blue filtered images to recreate full color—provided the theoretical basis for modern color reproduction, profoundly influencing subtractive photography by inspiring the adaptation of three-color separation to CMY-based dye processes, as pioneered by Louis Ducos du Hauron in 1869.^[29]

References

[1]
Subtractive Color Mixing - UW–Madison Physics
Subtractive primary colors are important in the mixing pigments in paint or ink, in color printing, color photography and overlapping multiple filters.
[2]
Additive & Subtractive Color Models - DINFOS Pavilion
Oct 1, 2024 · In the subtractive color model, pigment produces color using reflected light. This color model is used in printing, silk-screening, painting ...
[3]
Subtractive Color Mixing: Principles & Practical Applications - EPACK
Dec 27, 2024 · Subtractive color mixing is a process where colors are produced by removing specific wavelengths of light, using materials like pigments, dyes, or inks.<|control11|><|separator|>
[4]
Color Subtraction - The Physics Classroom
A yellow pigment is capable of absorbing blue light. Thus, blue is subtracted from the light that shines on the paper. This leaves red light. If the paper ...
[5]
Subtractive CMYK Color Mixing | Color Models - X-Rite
Sep 28, 2020 · Printing Yellow + Magenta creates Red; Printing Cyan + Magenta + Yellow in equal quantities blocks all colors to create Black. As more ink is ...
[6]
[PDF] Chapter 8 SUBTRACTIVE COLOR MIXING - cs.wisc.edu
Paints, inks and pigments in general behave just like filter, but in diffusely reflected light, instead of transmitted light. Page 7. Chapter 8 – page 7.
[7]
additive & subtractive color mixing - Handprint.com
In subtractive color mixing, colorants absorb or subtract wavelengths from filtered or reflected light. This was pointed out by several 18th century artists and ...
[8]
Three sets of absorption spectra of cyan, magenta, and yellow dyes ...
Download scientific diagram | Three sets of absorption spectra of cyan, magenta, and yellow dyes at four different concentrations. from publication: A ...
[9]
9.10: Electronic Spectra of Organic Molecules - Chemistry LibreTexts
Jul 31, 2021 · Absorption of light in the ultraviolet and visible regions produces changes in the electronic energies of molecules associated with excitation of an electron.<|separator|>
[10]
UV-Visible Spectroscopy - MSU chemistry
Thus, absorption of 420-430 nm light renders a substance yellow, and absorption of 500-520 nm light makes it red. Green is unique in that it can be created ...
[11]
Electronic Spectroscopy - Interpretation - Chemistry LibreTexts
Jan 29, 2023 · Many electronic transitions can be visible in the spectrum if the energy of the incident light matches or surpasses the quantum of energy ...
[12]
[PDF] PIGMENTED COLORANTS: DEPENDENCE ON MEDIA AND TIME
We present a physically based model for predicting the visual appearance of artists' paint, which is dependent on both time and the material that binds the.
[13]
and cochineal-based pigments by fiber optics reflectance ... - Nature
Nov 8, 2019 · In all brightly colored layers of paint, the higher the concentration of pigment, the higher the absorption. In FORS, samples are defined as ...
[14]
Pigments through the Ages - Intro to the reds - Webexhibits
The oldest pigment was probably red ochre, which was used in cave art. The ancient world had red madder lake, artificially-made red lead, and vermilion.
[15]
Ocher: The world's first red paint | Live Science
Nov 20, 2018 · Ocher, one of the world's oldest pigments, helped prehistoric people paint ancient cave art.Missing: subtractive | Show results with:subtractive
[16]
The Many Shades of Ancient Egyptian Pigments - Brooklyn Museum
Apr 30, 2024 · In ancient Egypt, pigments were sourced from minerals such as iron, copper, and cobalt, which were mixed with liquid binders to create colorful paints.Missing: 3000 natural subtractive
[17]
The Science of Color - Smithsonian Libraries
Aristotle developed the first known theory of color, suggesting that all colors came from white and black (lightness and darkness) and related them to the four ...
[18]
Theories of primary colours - HueValueChroma
The idea that painters can mix all colours except three can be traced back to Aristotle in his Meteorologica [c. 350 B.C.], but surprisingly Aristotle (Fig. 6.2 ...
[19]
The book on how to make all the colour paints for illuminating books
Jul 27, 2018 · This medieval treatise describes the main steps and ingredients for producing painting materials, such as mosaic gold, red lead, verdigris, brazilwood lake ...
[20]
The Alchemy of Color in Medieval Manuscripts (Getty Exhibitions)
This exhibition examines colorants made from plants, minerals, and metals, as well as medieval recipes for pigments and imitation gold in a presentation that ...Missing: mixing | Show results with:mixing
[21]
Pigments through the Ages - Renaissance and Baroque (1400-1600)
The Renaissance palette mirrored that of the Medieval Age but for three pigments: Naples yellow, smalt and carmine lake (cochineal).Missing: observations | Show results with:observations
[22]
Newton and the Color Spectrum - Webexhibits
Newton set up a prism near his window, and projected a beautiful spectrum 22 feet onto the far wall. Further, to prove that the prism was not coloring the light ...Missing: absorption subtractive media
[23]
[PDF] Color Theorists - Harding University
Nov 1, 2018 · Harris showed what is now known as the subtractive mixing of colours, with his most important observation showing that black will be formed ...
[24]
[PDF] &RORU 3HUFHSWLRQ LQ $UW %H\RQG WKH (\H LQWR WKH ...
Moses Harris (ca 1766), who published the first known example of a color ... He elaborated on additive and subtractive color mix- tures and the effects ...
[25]
Michel-Eugène Chevreul and the Phenomenology of Color
Jun 1, 2025 · Michel-Eugène Chevreul's 1839 treatise on simultaneous contrast is seen as an early empirical study of perceptual interaction that does provide such guidance.
[26]
Using color - Smithsonian Libraries
Colorful dots demonstrate “simultaneous contrast,” the optical effect that two colors have on each other. The French chemist Chevreul was hired by a textile ...
[27]
From the Industrial Revolution to the 'colour revolution'|ERC
Oct 19, 2021 · A 'colour revolution' took place following the invention of the first artificial coal-tar dyes. New attitudes towards colour production and perception shaped ...
[28]
A short history of colour photography
Jul 7, 2020 · Nearly 200 years later, in 1861, a young Scottish physicist, James Clerk Maxwell, conducted an experiment to show that all colours can be made ...Missing: CMY | Show results with:CMY
[29]
Proposal of a variety of processes of three-color photography
In it du Hauron suggested that it would be possible to obtain a color picture by obtaining separate photographic records of the 'red, yellow, and blue' portions ...
[30]
[PDF] The RYB, CMYK, RGB, HSV and Hexadecimal Color Models
The RGB color model is described below. • The RYB Color Model is a subtractive system. A mixture of two primary colors is darker than the original colors. A ...Missing: history rules limitations
[31]
A Historical Approach to Understanding Differentiation of RYB vs RGB
Jul 9, 2024 · This article defines the roles of colors and presents their historical development as a fundamental means of expression within artwork. It also ...
[32]
The Project Gutenberg eBook of Goethe's Theory of Colours, by ...
We naturally place these colours first, because they belong altogether, or in a great degree, to the subject[1]—to the eye itself. They are the foundation of ...
[33]
What are Primary, Secondary & Tertiary Colors? - Adobe
These are color combinations created by the equal mixture of two primary colors. On the color wheel, secondary colors are located between primary colors.
[34]
Primary Colors Are Red, Yellow and Blue, Right? Not Exactly
Nov 6, 2024 · Tertiary colors are a mix of a primary color with a neighboring secondary color, resulting in hues like red-orange, yellow-green, and blue- ...
[35]
[PDF] Digital Color Reproduction - Stanford University
shaping which approaches the subtractive color primaries (Conner, 1992). ... multiply, the optical densities add: od(λ) log10[ Π i 1,2. (1 ai(λ))] od1(λ) ...
[36]
None
### Summary of Neugebauer Equation and CMY in Halftone Colorimetry
[37]
Beyond CMYK in Color Printing | X-Rite Blog
Feb 10, 2023 · Using UCR and GCR, total ink coverage in CMYK printing is typically limited to somewhere between 200 – 320%. GCR can be set when creating your ...Missing: trapping misregistration
[38]
History of Printing Timeline
The Society of Printers established in Boston. 1906, Ludlow Typograph hot metal typesetting system developed. CMYK four-color wet process inks developed by the ...
[39]
Thomas A. Lenci and the Eagle Printing Ink Company - CMYK History
Jul 5, 2020 · The process of standardizing cyan, magenta, yellow, and black did not begin (at least for proofing) until the late 1940s, and continued for many ...
[40]
Trapping color (Acrobat Pro) - Adobe Help Center
Oct 30, 2023 · The default value is 100%, and it's best to use a value no lower than 70% for optimal results. Black Density: Indicates the neutral density ...
[41]
The Dimensions of Colour, colour mixing in paints - HueValueChroma
In glazing (Fig. 6.1.3), most light will pass through both layers, resulting in subtractive mixing. However some light will be scattered by the top layer unless ...
[42]
Glazing with Acrylics, Oils and Watercolors | Just Paint
May 29, 2019 · Glazing is a translucent layer of color applied on top of a base. Acrylics use quick drying layers, oils use thin layers, and watercolors use ...
[43]
On the stability of mediaeval inorganic pigments: a literature review ...
Mar 29, 2017 · The fading of red lead pigment in wall paintings: tracking the physico-chemical transformations by means of complementary micro-analysis ...
[44]
Parameters that affect the photodegradation of dyes and pigments in ...
It has been known for many years that dyes and pigments are subject to light-induced degradation, or photodegradation, when exposed to light.
[45]
Primary Colors Are Red, Yellow and Blue, Right? Not Exactly
Nov 6, 2024 · The idea that the subtractive primaries are red, yellow and blue (RYB) is confusing and should not be taught.
[46]
Color Printing | The Printed Picture - Yale University
Color printing began with the simple expedient of using inks of different colors—if a particular color was needed then an ink was mixed to match it. In the ...
[47]
Lithography in the Nineteenth Century
Lithography was invented around 1796 in Germany by an otherwise unknown Bavarian playwright, Alois Senefelder.
[48]
Offset Printing Ink Formulation | X-Rite Blog
Nov 7, 2022 · Offset ink formulation involves inspecting incoming ink, defining target color, measuring substrate, creating a recipe, mixing, and measuring ...Missing: interactions | Show results with:interactions
[49]
[PDF] ICC colour management for print production
– Print to standard printing condition. • relatively small effort to create a profile. – Use profile for standard printing condition and adjust output to suit.
[50]
[PDF] Environmental impact of printing inks – March 2013 - Eupia
Printing ink manufacture results in the potential emissions of VOCs and pigment/extender dusts to atmosphere.
[51]
Analysis of proper ink management impact on overall environmental ...
Aug 17, 2024 · The paper addresses ink management in terms of environmental issues in the label printing industry, focusing on its environmental implications.Ink Management System · Results · Discussion And ConclusionMissing: toxicity | Show results with:toxicity
[52]
Kodachrome | Timeline of Historical Colors in Photography and Film
Kodachrome, launched in 1935, is a subtractive 3-color film with three thin emulsion layers, using non-wandering dyes, and a complex processing method.
[53]
The long-term development of three-color Kodachrome. An odyssey ...
The introduction of three-color Kodachrome in 1935 was possible thanks to the long collaboration between the independent inventors Leopold Mannes and ...
[54]
Chromogenic - Graphics Atlas: Identification
Chromogenic is a subtractive color process using dye couplers to form color dyes. The final image is composed of three superimposed gelatin layers with yellow, ...<|separator|>
[55]
[PDF] Main processes for color photography Subtractive - Cultural Heritage
Color Photography from 1861 to 1981, Josef-Haubrich-Kunsthalle Koln, 1981, page 47. Page 25. Chromogenic. Chromogenic (dye coupler): some major products.
[56]
[PDF] The Chromaticity Diagram • Color Images • RGB Color Cube
... and copiers convert. RGB to CMY. To get a good black on color printers a separate “black” is used. C. M. Y. = 1. 1. 1. R. G. B. Page 23. EECS490: Digital Image ...
[57]
[PDF] A Neural Network Approach to Color Reproduction in Color Printers
This mapping is a conversion from the CIE-. XYZ color space onto the printer CMY color space. This is also equivalent to the conversion from XYZ onto RGB.
[58]
Color Negative Film Processing Errors - Molecular Expressions
Nov 13, 2015 · The top emulsion responds only to the blue third of the spectrum, while the middle and lower emulsion layers respond only to the green and red ...
[59]
[PDF] Short Red Spectral Sensitization of Emulsions for Color Negative Films
The short red emulsion sensitivity shown in. Figure 2 is a good compromise between the ideal color matching function and the capability of silver halide.
[60]
The Theory of Subtractive Color PhotographyI. The Conditions for ...
The contrasts of the masks must conform to those calculated from the effective densities of the image components by means of the following formulas: (1) When ...Missing: techniques | Show results with:techniques
[61]
None
### Summary of Gamut Limitations in Subtractive Color Systems (CMY/CMYK Printing)
[62]
[PDF] Color Science in the Examination of Museum Objects
Primary colors for additive color mixture are not the same as the primary colors of the dyes or pigments used in subtractive colorant mixture. For additive ...
[63]
(PDF) Dot Gain in Colour Halftones - ResearchGate
... print. A typical reason for physical dot gain is. ink smearing and spreading in the printing process. Optical dot gain is an effect that occurs because the ...
[64]
Why are red, yellow, and blue the primary colors in painting but ...
Jan 22, 2015 · In summary, the most effective color systems are red-green-blue for additive color systems and cyan-magenta-yellow for subtractive color systems ...
[65]
[PDF] Colour Space Conversions - Charles Poynton
Most of these colour spaces are linear transforms from RGB and are therefore device dependent and non–linear. Their advantage lies in the extremely intuitive ...
[66]
Color Spaces – color models, LMS, CIE XYZ, RGB ... - RP Photonics
Subtractive models, like CMYK for printing, start with white and use pigments to absorb (subtract) wavelengths of light.
[67]
Color Management: Understanding Color Spaces
CIE xyz is based on a direct graph of the signals from each of the three types of color sensors in the human eye. These are also referred to as the X, Y and Z ...Missing: additive subtractive