Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

United Democratic Movement

The United Democratic Movement (UDM) is a South African political party founded on 27 September 1997 by retired Major General , a former leader expelled from the (ANC) for exposing corruption, and , a ex-National Party cabinet minister involved in apartheid-era negotiations. The party's formation aimed to unite South Africans across historical divides, emphasizing , efforts, and a non-racial "South Africanism" to address post-apartheid challenges through ethical leadership and economic pragmatism. Holomisa, elected as the UDM's inaugural and enduring president, built the party's platform on his credibility from Truth and Reconciliation Commission testimonies revealing under , positioning the UDM as a against similar abuses in the democratic era. In its debut 1999 , the UDM secured parliamentary representation as an early alternative to the dominant ANC, though electoral support has since fluctuated, yielding three seats in the 400-member after the 2024 polls. The UDM has distinguished itself through persistent advocacy for accountability, including legal challenges against state entities like for service failures and calls for probes into public fund mismanagement, reflecting a to institutional amid South Africa's crises. Following the ANC's loss of majority in 2024, the UDM joined the Government of National Unity, with Holomisa appointed as of Defence and Military Veterans, enabling influence on policy amid coalition dynamics. While lacking the mass base of larger parties, the UDM's focus on moral and cross-ideological appeal underscores its role as a principled, if marginal, force in South African politics.

Founding and Initial Rise

Background to Formation

In the mid-1990s, South Africa's political landscape was marked by tensions within both the ruling African National Congress (ANC) and the main opposition National Party (NP), as early governance challenges, including corruption allegations, eroded trust in established parties. Bantu Holomisa, a retired major general who had led the Transkei homeland and joined the ANC after its unbanning, became a prominent critic of internal ANC misconduct. In 1995, Holomisa disclosed that the ANC had solicited and received a R2 million bribe from a construction company linked to apartheid-era tenders, prompting his dismissal as Deputy Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism by President Nelson Mandela. Holomisa's conflicts escalated through his testimony at the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) in 1996, where he alleged that had asked him to arrange the elimination of a witness in a 1988 kidnapping and assault case involving her entourage. The ANC's disciplinary committee found him guilty of misconduct and bringing the party into disrepute, confirming his expulsion on September 30, 1996, after a hearing marked by procedural disputes. Holomisa maintained the action stemmed from manipulation by ANC leaders to suppress dissent rather than organizational failings. Concurrently, Roelf Meyer, the NP's chief negotiator during the 1990-1994 transition talks and later its secretary-general, grew disillusioned with the party's direction under leader F.W. de Klerk. Meyer resigned from Cabinet in 1996 and, on May 17, 1997, quit the NP and Parliament, arguing for a fundamental restructuring of opposition politics to counter ANC dominance more effectively. His proposals, including disbanding the NP to form a revitalized entity, were opposed by conservative factions, leading to his isolation. These parallel exits converged when Holomisa, in November 1996, publicly initiated consultations on forming a new party to address perceived leadership failures across the spectrum. Holomisa and Meyer, representing black nationalist and Afrikaner reformist perspectives respectively, began conferring in early 1997 to build a multi-racial platform emphasizing integrity and democratic renewal, setting the stage for the UDM's official launch later that year.

Launch and Key Founders

The United Democratic Movement (UDM) was officially launched on 27 September 1997 at the World Trade Centre in . This event marked the formal establishment of the party as a multi-racial political alternative amid dissatisfaction with the dominant (ANC) and National Party (NP). The launch followed an alliance formed earlier in 1997 between key figures disillusioned with their respective former parties. Bantu Holomisa, a retired and former leader of the homeland, served as the primary founder and was elected as the UDM's first president at the launch. Holomisa had been expelled from the ANC in 1996 over corruption allegations against a party colleague, prompting his shift toward independent politics. His military background and advocacy for clean governance attracted support from ANC critics seeking accountability. Roelf Meyer, a former NP cabinet minister and chief negotiator during South Africa's transition to democracy, co-founded the UDM with Holomisa. Meyer resigned from the NP in , citing its failure to adapt to post-apartheid realities and attract broader voter bases, particularly among younger urban whites. His involvement bridged racial divides, positioning the UDM as a centrist option emphasizing unity and reform.

1999 Electoral Breakthrough

The United Democratic Movement (UDM) contested Africa's and provincial elections for the first time on June 2, 1999, less than two years after its formation in 1997. Nationally, the secured 546,790 votes, representing 3.42% of the total valid votes cast for the , which translated into 14 seats in the 400-member chamber under the system. This performance positioned the UDM as the fifth-largest in the legislature, behind the (ANC), (IFP), (DP), and New National Party (NNP), but ahead of established groups like the (ACDP). The UDM's results marked a notable breakthrough for a nascent multi-racial party, drawing support primarily from disillusioned ANC voters in provinces like the , where former leader Holomisa's regional influence among Xhosa-speaking communities proved decisive, alongside appeals to white conservatives via co-leader Roelf Meyer's National Party background. The party's emphasized national unity, measures, and economic renewal as alternatives to ANC dominance, resonating in a electorate seeking accountability amid post-apartheid transition challenges. Analysts attributed the UDM's cross-racial appeal—rooted in Holomisa's anti-ANC expulsion stance and Meyer's negotiation-era credibility—to its positioning as a "truly multi-racial" force amid polarized politics. Provincially, the UDM gained traction in the , capturing approximately 20% of the vote and 9 seats in the 63-member legislature, establishing a foothold in Holomisa's home base while underperforming elsewhere due to limited organizational reach. This debut success validated the party's strategy of bridging black nationalist and liberal reformist elements, though it fell short of expectations in urban centers and among IFP strongholds. The outcome underscored voter fragmentation beyond the ANC's 66% national share, signaling potential for centrist challengers in subsequent cycles.

Ideology and Policy Positions

Core Principles and Multi-Racial Appeal

The United Democratic Movement (UDM) upholds core principles that prioritize individual rights and ethical governance, including respect for the life, dignity, and human worth of every individual; integrity in public and private life; the right to self-determination; supremacy of the constitution; democracy and accountability; equality before the law; freedom of expression; and separation of powers. These tenets form the foundation of the party's platform, which seeks to foster a moral framework in both social and economic spheres while emphasizing personal responsibility over collectivist ideologies. Central to the UDM's ideology is a commitment to non-racialism, positioning the party as a "political home of all , united in the spirit of South Africanism." This appeal was evident from its inception on September 27, 1997, when it was co-founded by , a black former ANC Youth League leader and Transkei military figure, and , a white ex-National Party minister involved in apartheid-era negotiations, symbolizing a deliberate cross-racial alliance against perceived failures in the post-1994 political landscape. The party's constitution explicitly frames it as a multiracial entity grounded in principles of and civil order, aiming to unite diverse groups disillusioned by ethnic or racial divisions in other parties. The UDM's multi-racial strategy differentiates it from racially oriented formations, promoting unity through shared national identity rather than ethnic mobilization, as articulated in its vision of mobilizing ' "common passion for our Country." This approach has historically drawn support from voters across racial lines seeking alternatives to the African National Congress's dominance, though electoral gains have been limited by competition from larger parties. By rejecting racial and advocating pro-diversity policies, the UDM appeals to those prioritizing and over identity-based .

Economic and Social Policies

The United Democratic Movement (UDM) positions itself as a social democratic party emphasizing a strong moral framework in both economic and social spheres, advocating for policies that promote individual responsibility, wealth creation, and reduced dependence on government handouts. In economic policy, the party prioritizes job creation through large-scale infrastructure projects and support for small businesses, including the establishment of sector-specific banks and local stock exchanges to foster entrepreneurship. It commits to fiscal discipline by targeting manageable public debt and budget deficits, pledging to introduce a Debt Management Bill within the first 100 days of governance and ensuring policy consistency to bolster investor confidence. The UDM also calls for a new national economic consensus to develop a shared policy framework, while protecting domestic labor markets from competition by illegal immigrants. On social policies, the UDM supports access but critiques the administrative inefficiencies of the scheme, proposing instead to decentralize infrastructure closer to underserved communities, improve clinic hygiene, and establish robust referral systems. It advocates integrating services with social welfare, , , , , and , while regulating traditional healing practices to include referral mechanisms and limiting pharmaceutical sales to citizens. In education, the party targets eradicating pit latrines in schools beyond 2025, reopening teacher training colleges, creating a permanent commission for curriculum stability, and providing fee-free for poor and working-class students with performance monitoring. Further social commitments include empowering women via community projects and monitoring across government departments, launching campaigns on rights for LGBTQIA+ individuals and people with , and creating programs for those with disabilities alongside accessible . The UDM opposes unregulated land grabs to safeguard , favoring an indaba to assess expropriation's effects on and economic stability, and seeks to criminalize practices like ukuthwala () while addressing period through a Sanitary Dignity Policy. These positions reflect the party's emphasis on ethical and moral , linking social progress to personal agency and economic self-sufficiency.

Stances on Governance and Corruption

The United Democratic Movement (UDM) advocates for ethical governance characterized by , , and merit-based administration, positioning itself as a bulwark against the institutional decay observed in South Africa's public sector. Party leader has emphasized the UDM's longstanding commitment to promoting the ethics of , criticizing the (ANC)-led administration for systemic failures that undermine . In its 2024 election manifesto, the UDM highlights ignored recommendations from commissions such as the Zondo and Mpati inquiries into and financial misconduct, attributing these lapses to a lack of political will and executive interference, including Cyril Ramaphosa's withholding of performance reports. On corruption, the UDM maintains a zero-tolerance stance, viewing it as a primary destroyer of democratic freedoms and economic progress, with Holomisa accusing the ANC of enabling institutionalized graft over 30 years in power, including scandals involving Bosasa, the Guptas, and misuse of funds from entities like the Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF) and National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS). The party estimates corruption has cost South Africa approximately R1 billion in recent instances alone and proposes rigorous enforcement measures, such as establishing independent provincial anti-corruption task teams, fast-track special courts for graft cases, and "name and shame" programs coupled with blacklisting of offenders to ensure severe consequences beyond mere reprimands. Holomisa has personally agitated against specific cases, such as irregularities at the Public Investment Corporation (PIC), contributing to investigations that exposed executive-linked misconduct. Regarding governance reforms, the UDM calls for professionalizing the by restoring powers to accounting officers, reducing reliance on external consultants, and enforcing merit-based appointments over cadre deployment, which it links to and policy implementation failures. The party also seeks to untangle in state-owned enterprises (SOEs), strengthen the (NPA), and reduce judicial backlogs to bolster consequence management and integrity. Historically, the UDM opposed practices like floor-crossing in the early , framing it as an immoral erosion of voter mandate and . These positions reflect the party's foundational ethos, rooted in Holomisa's experience combating during his tenure in the homeland administration.

Organizational Structure and Leadership

Leadership Evolution

The United Democratic Movement (UDM) was co-founded on September 27, 1997, by , a former military leader and ANC member expelled in 1996 for corruption allegations against a cabinet minister, and , a former National Party minister involved in apartheid-era negotiations. Initially, the duo provided joint leadership, with Holomisa emphasizing anti- and multi-party democracy appeals, while Meyer contributed white voter outreach rooted in his negotiation experience. At the UDM's inaugural national congress in June 1998, was elected as the party's first president, solidifying his role as the primary figurehead. was elected deputy president at the same congress, but he departed the party in 2000 amid reported strategic disagreements, later joining the ANC. Sifiso Nkabinde, who served as general secretary and was a key early organizer, was assassinated on February 25, 2000, in Richmond, , in an incident linked to , depriving the party of a rising black figure. Following these early disruptions, the UDM maintained leadership continuity under Holomisa, who retained the through subsequent national conferences without recorded challenges to his position. By the mid-2000s, the party stabilized with Holomisa as the enduring leader, focusing on roles. Nqabayomzi Kwankwa emerged as deputy president in later years, handling legislative duties, while other roles like national deputy chairperson rotated among figures such as Sangolibanzi Nobongoza. Holomisa's long tenure, spanning over 25 years as of 2025, reflects the party's reliance on his personal stature for credibility amid electoral marginalization, though critics have noted limited internal renewal. In June 2024, following the UDM's entry into the Government of National Unity, Holomisa was appointed of Defence and Military Veterans, extending his influence beyond party confines while retaining the UDM presidency.

Party Organization and Membership

The United Democratic Movement maintains a centralized national leadership structure, with the President serving as the principal executive authority. has held the presidency since the party's inception on September 27, 1997, and was re-elected at subsequent national congresses. The Deputy President, Nqabayomzi Kwankwa, assists in executive functions and represents the party in parliamentary matters. Additional key roles include National Deputy Chairperson Sangolibanzi Nobongoza, responsible for coordinating party activities, and Acting Treasurer-General Zandile Phiri, overseeing financial operations. This leadership is elected by party delegates at national conferences, ensuring accountability to internal structures. The party's organizational framework follows a hierarchical model typical of South African political entities, comprising national, provincial, and local branch levels to facilitate policy implementation and member engagement. The national executive committee, drawn from elected leaders, sets strategic direction and enforces discipline in accordance with the party's , which emphasizes democratic internal processes and adherence to the Republic's foundational principles. Provincial structures handle regional coordination, while branches serve as the units for and , though detailed branch counts or operational specifics remain undisclosed in public records. Membership in the UDM is open to South African citizens aged 18 and older who subscribe to its principles of non-racialism and ethical , as outlined in its foundational documents. Exact membership figures are not routinely published, reflecting the party's status as a smaller opposition entity with limited public disclosure requirements beyond electoral filings. The UDM's modest parliamentary representation—three seats in the following the May 29, 2024, elections—suggests a constrained organizational footprint compared to larger parties like the ANC or . Internal recruitment focuses on multi-racial appeal and anti-corruption advocacy to sustain loyalty amid electoral challenges.

Electoral Performance

National Assembly Results

The United Democratic Movement (UDM) contested its first national election in 1999, achieving a breakthrough by securing 14 seats in the 400-member with 546,782 votes, equivalent to 3.39% of the national vote share. This performance positioned the UDM as the fourth-largest party, reflecting initial appeal amid dissatisfaction with the (ANC) and other established parties. Subsequent elections marked a period of decline. In 2004, the UDM received 255,372 votes (1.60%), translating to 7 seats. By 2009, support fell further to 149,618 votes (0.81%), yielding 4 seats. The party stabilized at this level in 2014 with 184,636 votes (0.51%) for 4 seats, and again in 2019 with 148,601 votes (0.42%) retaining 4 seats, despite competition from newer opposition parties like the (). In the 2024 general election, the UDM garnered approximately 57,000 votes (0.32%), securing 2 seats amid fragmented opposition dynamics and the emergence of uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) as a major contender. This reduction reflected ongoing challenges in voter mobilization, though the party's representation enabled participation in post-election negotiations leading to the Government of National Unity (GNU).
YearVotesPercentageSeatsChange
1999546,7823.3914/400
2004255,3721.607/400 7
2009149,6180.814/400 3
2014184,6360.514/400 0
2019148,6010.424/400 0
2024~57,0000.322/400 2

Provincial Legislature Results

The United Democratic Movement's provincial legislature performance has been limited almost exclusively to the , its regional stronghold, with no seats won in the other eight provinces across elections from 1999 to 2024. In the 1999 provincial elections held on June 2, the party secured its peak result of 9 seats in the Provincial Legislature out of 63 total seats, capturing 296,015 votes or 13.60% of the provincial vote share. Support eroded in subsequent contests. In the 2004 provincial elections on April 14, the UDM received 205,993 votes in the , equating to roughly 9% of the vote and yielding 6 seats under . By the , , and elections, the party's representation dwindled to 1 or 2 seats in the Eastern Cape amid national vote shares below 1%, reflecting organizational challenges and voter shifts toward larger parties like the ANC and emerging competitors. In the 2024 provincial elections on May 29, the UDM regained modest ground in the , winning 3 seats in the 63-seat legislature, consistent with its 0.49% national vote but bolstered by local leadership under figures like Lennox Gaehler. This outcome underscores the party's persistent but marginal provincial footprint, confined to oversight roles without executive influence.

Municipal Election Outcomes

The United Democratic Movement (UDM) has participated in South African municipal elections since 2000, primarily contesting as an opposition party with a focus on the province, where it has historically drawn support from Xhosa-speaking communities disillusioned with ANC governance. In its debut 2000 local polls, the UDM established a notable presence in the , positioning itself as a viable alternative to the dominant ANC in rural and small-town councils, though exact seat totals reflected regional rather than national strength. Performance declined in subsequent cycles amid competition from larger parties and internal challenges. The 2006 and 2011 elections saw further erosion, with the UDM struggling to retain even localized influence as and fragmentation favored established players like the ANC and emerging ones like the Democratic Alliance. By , the party secured marginal representation in metropolitan areas, for instance attaining 1.91% of votes and 2 seats in select metros, indicative of its limited urban appeal. In the 2021 municipal elections, held on 1 November, the UDM received 0.47% of the national vote, yielding 51 councillor seats out of over 64,000 available across 257 municipalities. This outcome underscored ongoing marginalization, with no outright council control and concentration of gains in wards, reflecting voter prioritization of service delivery and platforms over the UDM's multi-racial federalist appeals. Overall, municipal results highlight the UDM's role as a niche vehicle rather than a broad-based contender, hampered by resource constraints and failure to expand beyond ethnic-regional bases.

Period of Decline

Post-1999 Electoral Setbacks

Following the relatively strong performance in the 1999 general election, where the United Democratic Movement (UDM) secured 546,790 votes (3.42 percent) and 14 seats in the 400-member , the party experienced a marked decline in subsequent national polls. In the 2004 general election held on April 14, the UDM's national vote share dropped to 2.28 percent (363,244 votes), translating to 7 seats amid intensified competition from established opposition parties like the Democratic Alliance and the , as well as the African National Congress's continued dominance. This downward trajectory continued in the 2009 general election on April 22, with the UDM garnering only 0.85 percent of the vote (162,240 votes) and retaining 4 seats, reflecting challenges in broadening its appeal beyond its stronghold and amid voter consolidation toward larger opposition formations. The pattern persisted in the 2014 election on May 7, where the party achieved approximately 0.99 percent (184,636 votes) for 4 seats, and further eroded in the 2019 election on May 8 to 0.42 percent, yielding just 2 seats in the . These results underscored a steady contraction in parliamentary representation from 14 seats in 1999 to 2 by 2019, limiting the UDM's influence in national legislative processes. Provincially, similar setbacks materialized, particularly in the , where the UDM had initially performed credibly in 1999 (9 seats in the 63-member legislature). By 2004, its seats fell to 2, and in later cycles, it struggled to maintain even nominal presence amid ANC and fragmentation of anti-ANC votes. The party's inability to capitalize on critiques or form effective coalitions contributed to marginalization, as evidenced by its exclusion from key provincial executive roles post-elections.

Internal and External Factors

The United Democratic Movement (UDM) experienced significant internal challenges following its strong debut in the 1999 elections, where it secured 14 seats in the . A key setback was the departure of co-founder , a former National Party figure who had helped craft the party's multi-racial appeal, in January 2000; Meyer cited personal reasons for quitting politics, but his exit diminished the UDM's cross-racial credibility and organizational depth. Over-reliance on leader emerged as a persistent weakness, limiting the development of a broader leadership cadre and contributing to the party's stagnation, as Holomisa's personal stature failed to translate into sustained institutional growth. Additionally, defections among local councillors, such as those in Benoni and the South East regions, signaled organizational fragility and difficulties in maintaining grassroots cohesion amid resource constraints. Externally, the UDM contended with South Africa's entrenched under the (ANC), which consolidated power through patronage networks and historical liberation credentials, eroding the appeal of breakaway opposition parties like the UDM. The ANC's improved governance image under President , coupled with economic expansion from 2000 to 2007, reduced voter discontent that had initially fueled the UDM's platform in 1999. Competition intensified as the Democratic Alliance (DA) emerged as the primary non-ANC opposition, absorbing much of the disaffected white and urban vote, while the UDM's regionally concentrated support in the struggled against ANC dominance in black rural constituencies. This fragmentation, exacerbated by the system's tendency to reward larger parties with greater visibility and resources, led to the UDM's seat reduction to 7 in the elections.

Recent Developments and Government Role

2024 Elections and GNU Entry

In the general election held on 29 May 2024, the United Democratic Movement (UDM) received 78,786 votes, representing 0.41% of the national vote share, which secured the party two seats in the 400-member . This performance maintained the UDM's parliamentary presence despite a competitive field of over 50 parties and a of 58.64%. The election resulted in the (ANC) obtaining 40.18% of the vote, ending its unchallenged majority and necessitating coalition arrangements to form a government. On 14 June 2024, President announced the formation of a Government of National Unity (GNU), initially comprising the ANC, Democratic Alliance (DA), (IFP), and (PA), with provisions for additional parties meeting certain criteria. The UDM formally joined on 21 June 2024, following negotiations with the ANC, becoming one of ten parties in the by late June. UDM leader stated that the decision prioritized national stability over opposition isolation, proposing a technical to align policies by reviewing party manifestos. In the ensuing under , Holomisa was appointed Deputy Minister of Defence and Military Veterans on 30 June 2024. This entry into the GNU represented a strategic shift for the UDM, enabling executive influence after years in opposition, though the party's limited seats underscored its marginal electoral base amid voter fragmentation.

Post-2024 Activities and Critiques

Following the 2024 general elections, the United Democratic Movement (UDM) joined South Africa's , with party leader appointed as Deputy Minister of Defence and Military Veterans in June 2024. In this role, Holomisa focused on addressing longstanding issues within the , including efforts to resolve misclassification problems, enhance financial transparency, and develop a roadmap for operational improvements, as outlined in his 100-day review released in October 2024. By June 2025, Holomisa issued a year-in-review report highlighting initiatives such as advocating for compensation for ex-mineworkers suffering from occupational illnesses, a cause the UDM had long supported, alongside broader pushes for military veterans' welfare and defence sector accountability. The UDM also endorsed the African National Congress's (ANC) proposal to expand coalition beyond its initial 10 parties in August 2025, positioning the party as supportive of stabilizing the multi-party government amid internal tensions. Holomisa publicly downplayed partisan clashes within , describing them as "laced with silliness" in November 2024 and dismissing political posturing by larger parties like the Democratic Alliance (DA) and ANC as inconsequential in June 2025, emphasizing public support for the coalition over opposition alternatives. Critiques of UDM's post-2024 role have centered on Holomisa's and the party's limited influence as a small partner holding only three seats. In August 2025, Holomisa sparked controversy during a live Gagasi broadcast on August 21, where he clashed with a caller questioning his age and political longevity, responding by telling both the listener and host Alex Jay to "go to hell," an outburst widely reported as indicative of arrogance and unprofessionalism in public office. An opinion piece in September 2025 argued that these remarks exemplified the 's broader dismissive attitude toward public accountability, suggesting Holomisa's defensiveness reflected deeper flaws. Additionally, a April 2025 reader commentary accused Holomisa of shifting from a vocal ANC critic in opposition to prioritizing personal and party interests once in government, a view attributing UDM's participation to rather than substantive . Rumors in March 2025 speculated that Holomisa might step down as UDM amid pressures, which he dismissed as "high-level gossip" without merit, reaffirming his commitment despite the party's marginal electoral standing. Holomisa's June 2025 scorecard on defence reforms acknowledged a "turbulent" first year marked by entrenched challenges, calling for enhanced parliamentary oversight, though critics have questioned the tangible progress given ongoing SANDF constraints and operational inefficiencies. Overall, while UDM's contributions have been framed internally as targeted , external assessments highlight the party's constrained leverage in a dominated by larger entities, with limited evidence of transformative impact beyond Holomisa's ministerial portfolio.

Controversies and Criticisms

In 2002, the United Democratic Movement challenged the constitutionality of legislation permitting members of to defect from their parties without forfeiting seats, arguing it undermined the anti-defection provisions in the . The declared the First Amendment Act, Local Government Amendment Act, and Membership Act invalid to the extent they authorized floor-crossing, emphasizing that such changes required explicit rather than implied permission through parliamentary rules. The UDM pursued a landmark parliamentary dispute in 2017 by applying to the to compel a secret for a against , following his dismissal of Finance Minister on March 31, 2017. The Court ruled that section 102(2) of the Constitution grants the discretion to prescribe a secret vote when necessary to fulfill Parliament's oversight role, remitting the matter back to Baleka for reconsideration, though the subsequent vote on August 8, 2017, proceeded openly and failed. This decision affirmed secret ballots as a tool to mitigate on members, particularly within the ruling . In 2022, UDM leader faced a suit from Lebashe Investment Group after publicly accusing the firm and associates of in a R816 million deal involving the , labeling them "thieves" and "fraudsters" in media statements. The upheld that the statements bore an ordinarily meaning but dismissed the UDM's appeal against an interim barring repetition, prioritizing protection of the respondents' reputations pending trial while noting Holomisa's defense rooted in oversight duties. The Supreme Court of Appeal in March 2025 rejected Lebashe's exception to the UDM's plea, allowing Holomisa to argue fair comment in the ongoing R2 million damages claim, marking a procedural win for the UDM. The UDM initiated legal action against in 2023, contending that persistent loadshedding violated constitutional rights to dignity, health, and by disrupting services in hospitals, schools, and police stations. The in heard arguments on December 1, 2023, focusing on whether Eskom's failures constituted unlawful conduct, though no final ruling mandated specific remedies beyond acknowledging the humanitarian impacts. These cases reflect the UDM's role in litigating against perceived overreach and as an opposition party.

Accusations of Ineffectiveness and Alliances

The United Democratic Movement (UDM) has faced accusations of political ineffectiveness, primarily stemming from its persistent electoral underperformance and limited influence in despite nearly three decades in existence. Founded in 1997 as an anti-corruption alternative to the (ANC), the party achieved a peak of 546,741 votes (3.07%) in the 1999 general election, securing 14 seats, but has since declined sharply, garnering only 0.81% (148,630 votes) in 2019 and around 0.5% in 2024. Critics, including political analysts and rival opposition figures, attribute this to the UDM's failure to broaden its appeal beyond its stronghold and military veteran base, as well as leadership centered on , which has hindered organizational renewal and mobilization. Holomisa himself has acknowledged the party's challenges, blaming ANC-orchestrated member poaching via floor-crossing laws (2002–2009) and financial inducements for stunting growth, though detractors argue internal strategic shortcomings, such as over-reliance on Holomisa's personal stature rather than policy innovation, bear primary responsibility. The UDM's alliance strategies have amplified these ineffectiveness claims, with opponents arguing that opportunistic partnerships dilute its principled opposition identity and yield minimal policy gains. Prior to 2024, the party's involvement in loose opposition fronts, like the Multi-Party Charter, was criticized for lacking cohesion and failing to dent ANC dominance, as evidenced by its negligible role in municipal coalitions post-2016 where it often played junior partner without securing transformative concessions. The most pointed critiques emerged after the UDM's June 2024 decision to join the Government of National Unity (GNU), abandoning the "Progressive Caucus" (aligned with EFF and MK Party) amid the ANC's loss of majority. Left-leaning critics accused the move of betraying the UDM's anti-corruption ethos by aligning with the DA—viewed as ideologically incompatible—and propping up ANC figures, effectively rendering the party a marginal enabler rather than a reformer. Holomisa countered that joining was not "selling out" but a pragmatic step for national stability, emphasizing the UDM's deputy ministerial portfolio for Defence and Military Veterans as evidence of influence, yet observers noted the party's single cabinet position in a 10-party coalition underscored its diminished bargaining power. Post-GNU entry, accusations intensified regarding the UDM's perceived quiescence and ineffectiveness in holding partners accountable. Holomisa's pre-2024 vocal exposés of ANC "crooks" (amasela) and scandals, such as the Phala Phala farm controversy, contrasted with a more restrained tone after assuming office, prompting claims that access to power has muted the party's watchdog role. For example, while the UDM advocated for ex-mineworker compensation and military reforms in 2025, critics from the and argued these efforts were symbolic, yielding no major legislative breakthroughs amid GNU infighting over budgets and . The party's small (two MPs in 2024) limits its leverage, reinforcing narratives of irrelevance, though supporters cite Holomisa's interventions in defence oversight as tangible contributions. These dynamics highlight broader tensions in South Africa's fragmented , where minor parties like the UDM risk absorption into ruling pacts without proportional impact.

References

  1. [1]
    History of The United Democratic Movement | UDM
    The United Democratic Movement was launched at the World Trade Centre, in Kempton Park, on 27 September 1997. Bantu Holomisa was elected the party's first ...
  2. [2]
    United Democratic Movement | UDM - UDM Political Party | South ...
    We are the political home of all South Africans, united in the spirit of South Africanism by our common passion for our Country.About > UDM History · About · Structures · Campaigns
  3. [3]
    National Leadership: UDM - United Democratic Movement
    Bantu Holomisa co-founded the United Democratic Movement in 1997 with Mr Roelf Meyer. Mr Holomisa serves as the UDM's President.
  4. [4]
    SOUTH AFRICA: parliamentary elections National Assembly
    Background and outcome of elections: On 3 March 1999, President of the Republic Nelson Mandela announced to the Parliament that South Africa's second all-race ...
  5. [5]
    Which parties make up South Africa's unity government? - Reuters
    Jun 24, 2024 · UNITED DEMOCRATIC MOVEMENT​​ The UDM won three seats. It had originally sided with a political alliance formed in opposition to the government of ...
  6. [6]
    United Democratic Movement and Others v Eskom Holdings SOC ...
    Dec 1, 2023 · The court found that the preventable failure to provide electricity amounted to Constitutional breaches and ordered the Minister of Electricity to take certain ...
  7. [7]
    Bantu Holomisa is dismissed - South African History Online
    Bantu Holomisa was dismissed as Deputy Environment and Tourism Minister after revealing that the African National Congress (ANC), received a sum of R2 million.
  8. [8]
    Bantubonke "Bantu" Harrington Holomisa, Mr
    In 1996, Mr Holomisa was expelled from the ANC after testifying at the Truth and Reconciliation Commission about issues and activities concerning the Transkei.
  9. [9]
    HOLOMISA SAYS HIS EXPULSION FROM ANC IS CONFIRMED
    Sep 30, 1996 · The disciplinary committee on August 30 found Holomisa guilty of bringing the party into disrepute by a remark to the Truth and Reconciliation ...
  10. [10]
    ANC expels former Transkei ruler - The Irish Times
    Aug 31, 1996 · Gen Holomisa, whose popularity won him the highest vote in elections to the ANC executive in December 1994, was found guilty of misconduct, ...
  11. [11]
    01 Nov 1996: Holomisa, Bantu - O'Malley - The Heart of Hope
    Nov 1, 1996 · It's not the ANC as an organisation which I know which is after my expulsion, but it's the work of manipulation by the powerful leaders ...<|separator|>
  12. [12]
    How Roelf broke the rules – The Mail & Guardian
    FALLEN National Party hero, Roelf Meyer, has been outmanoeuvred by his opponents. His more conservative colleagues, led by executive director Marthinus van ...
  13. [13]
    De Klerk Quits As Party Chief In South Africa - The New York Times
    ... Roelf Meyer, from a key position in the party. In response, Mr. Meyer quit the National Party to start his own, and dozens of National Party leaders have ...
  14. [14]
    Frequently asked questions - United Democratic Movement | UDM
    In November 1996 Holomisa publicly announced consulting South Africans on the need or not for a new political party. With this objective, the National ...
  15. [15]
    UDM celebrates 27 years of existence - Polity.org
    Sep 27, 2024 · On 27 September 1997, a significant moment in South Africa's political history unfolded with the formation of the United Democratic Movement (UDM).
  16. [16]
    Africa | What is the UDM? - BBC News
    Jan 31, 1999 · Early in 1997, he and Mr Holomisa formed the alliance that led to the formation of the UDM, Mr Meyer attracting support mostly from young urban ...
  17. [17]
    Bantu Holomisa :: People's Assembly
    He co-founded the United Democratic Movement in 1997 with Mr Roelf Meyer and continues to serve as its President. Gen. Holomisa is a fervent advocate for the ...
  18. [18]
    [PDF] Results Report - National
    UNITED DEMOCRATIC MOVEMENT. UDM. 546,790. 3.42 %. 281,748. 12.88 %. 18,073. 1.65 ... Electoral Event: National Elections 1999. Province: All Provinces.
  19. [19]
    June 2, 1999 General Election Results - Republic of South Africa ...
    United Democratic Movement (UDM), 546,790, 3.4, 14. African Christian Democratic Party (ACDP), 228,975, 1.4, 6. Vryheidsfront / Freedom Front (VF/FF), 127,217 ...
  20. [20]
    [PDF] Continuity and Change: Political Allegiances and Attitudes in the ...
    standing the presence of Roelf Meyer, the bulk of the UDM's support came from Xhosa-speaking voters. It is evident that. Holomisa has been able to draw on a ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  21. [21]
    Newsroom > 1999 Archive - United Democratic Movement
    UDM Manifesto Launch Election 1999 “The future hope for all South Africans”. Address by Mr Bantu Holomisa, MP in Johannesburg, Gauteng It is most ...
  22. [22]
    South Africa Elections | United Democratic Movement - BBC News
    Of all the parties contesting the elections, the United Democratic Movement perhaps has the clearest claim to be a truly multi-racial party.
  23. [23]
    1999 Provincial Legislature Elections in South Africa
    Party, Number of Votes, % of Votes, Number of Seats (63). African National Congress (ANC), 1,606,856, 73.80%, 47. United Democratic Movement (UDM), 296,015 ...
  24. [24]
    [PDF] South Africa's Second Democratic Election 1999
    The literature reflects a renewed interest in the efficacy of the Proportional. Representation system employed, in electoral system design, and in the debates, ...
  25. [25]
    Core Values - United Democratic Movement | UDM
    The Core Values, which the United Democratic Movement will uphold and promote | respect for life, dignity and human worth of every individual.
  26. [26]
    #Elections2019: Everything you need to know about the UDM - IOL
    Apr 15, 2019 · The UDM believes in the respect for life, dignity and human worth of every individual; integrity in public- and private life; the individual ...
  27. [27]
    [PDF] UDM
    It was founded by former Transkei homeland leader Bantu Holomisa after his expulsion from the ANC following his allegations of Apartheid era corruption against ...
  28. [28]
    [PDF] Manifesto - Parliamentary Monitoring Group
    Mar 4, 2024 · The United Democratic Movement (UDM) is a social democratic party with a strong moral sense, in both the social and economic areas. We ...
  29. [29]
    [PDF] UDM Election Manifesto 2024 - #CorruptionDestroysOurFreedom
    May 27, 2024 · United Democratic Movement | UDM. Admin. 65–83 minutes. Foreword by the President. Thirty years into our democracy and our beautiful country, ...Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  30. [30]
    UDM 2024 Election Manifesto - Polity.org.za
    Mar 19, 2024 · South Africa requires a new dispensation that shall appoint government officials based on merit. Where the justice system receives immediate ...
  31. [31]
    Election promises: United Democratic Movement - Bhekisisa
    May 7, 2024 · We look at the UDM's manifesto to find out how they plan to manage universal healthcare, food security and other key health issues.
  32. [32]
    Bantu Holomisa's keynote address at the launch of the UDM's ...
    This kind of institutionalised corruption must be exposed for what it is, without fear nor favour. So, I ask you: how can South Africans trust the ANC? The ...
  33. [33]
    UDM takes strong anti-corruption stance at manifesto launch
    Mar 2, 2024 · UDM takes strong anti-corruption stance at manifesto launch · 30 years after democracy · UDM launches its elections 2024 manifesto: · UDM Manifesto ...
  34. [34]
    Get To Know Bantu Holomisa - People's Assembly
    Mar 28, 2022 · The UDM fought its first national and provincial elections in 1999 and I have been a Member of Parliament for the UDM since then. 2. What is ...
  35. [35]
    United Democratic Movement (UDM) Manifesto - Elections24
    Explore the UDM manifesto on Elections24, detailing policies on Good governance, Economy, Infrastructure, Environment, Safety and Security in South Af.
  36. [36]
    COMRADES IN CORRUPTION I | UDM | South Africa
    ANC: Holomisa's Military Council did not reverse the trend of corruption inherited from the Matanzima era. Holomisa: At least you acknowledge that this trend ...
  37. [37]
    Africa | What is the UDM? - BBC News
    Jan 30, 1999 · It is only in the past year that the UDM, led by Bantu Holomisa, Roelf Meyer and Sifiso Nkabinde, has emerged as a political force. According to ...
  38. [38]
    1. South Africa (1910-present) - University of Central Arkansas
    General Secretary Sifiso Nkabinde of the United Democratic Movement (UDM) was killed in political violence in the town of Richmond in Kwazulu-Natal province on ...
  39. [39]
    Bantu Holomisa Resume - United Democratic Movement | UDM
    In the same year he received the most votes at the ANC National Congress. In 1996 Mr Holomisa was expelled from the ANC after testifying at the Truth and ...
  40. [40]
    [PDF] the udm constitution
    The United Democratic Movement (hereafter the Party) subscribes to the principles of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa. 1.2. The formation of ...
  41. [41]
    National Assembly - Parliament of South Africa
    The National Assembly has 400 members. The number of seats that a party has in the Assembly is in proportion to the number of voters that voted for it in the ...Missing: results | Show results with:results
  42. [42]
    Republic of South Africa General Election Results Lookup
    April 14, 2004 General Election Results - Republic of South Africa Totals: National Assembly. Registered Electors, 20,674,926. Voters, 15,863,558, 76.7%.
  43. [43]
    April 22, 2009 General Election Results - Republic of South Africa ...
    April 22, 2009 General Election Results - Republic of South Africa Totals: National Assembly. Registered Electors, 23,181,997. Voters, 17,919,966, 77.3%.
  44. [44]
    Election Results and Allocation of Seats in Parliament and ...
    May 13, 2019 · With the final results announced officially by the IEC on Saturday, 11 May 2019, the ANC has won the sixth general election.
  45. [45]
    NPE Results Dashboard 2024 - IEC election results
    National Assembly - 2024. 100%. Complete. 23 292 of 23 292 Voting Districts completed. Voter Turnout. 58.64%. Out of. Country. Results Finder · Downloadable
  46. [46]
    [PDF] ELECTION OF 2 JUNE 1999: CONTEXTUAL OVERVIEW AND ...
    EASTERN CAPE. PARTY. SEATS. VOTES. African National Congress (ANC). 47. 1606 856. United Democratic Movement (UDM). 9. 296 015. Democratic Party (DP). 4. 136 ...
  47. [47]
    2004 Provincial Legislature Elections in South Africa
    African National Congress (ANC), 1,768,987, 79.27%, 51. United Democratic Movement (UDM), 205,993, 9.23%, 6. Democratic Alliance (DA), 163,785, 7.34%, 5. Pan ...
  48. [48]
    UDM prepares for comeback at national, provincial elections
    Feb 28, 2024 · The party, one of the first breakaways from the African National Congress (ANC) during the early years of democracy, has been in decline since ...
  49. [49]
    UDM Public Representatives in Parliament and Provincial Legislature
    UDM Members of Parliament: Mr Bantu Holomisa, MP, Deputy Minister of Defence and Military Veterans, jana@udm.org.za
  50. [50]
    Mbeki spreads ANC message in UDM heartland - The Mail & Guardian
    Feb 26, 2006 · President Thabo Mbeki took the African National Congress's local government campaign into the Transkei heartland of the United Democratic ...
  51. [51]
    LGE2016: SA Metros - the final results - Daily Maverick
    Aug 7, 2016 · UDM – 1.91% – 2 seats. AIC, UFEC, Cope, ACPD, PA – Less than 1% – 1 ... Art for South Africa: The Mimi Coertse Collection.
  52. [52]
    IEC Results Dashboard
    2021 Municipal Elections Leaderboard · National · Eastern Cape · Free State · Gauteng · KwaZulu-Natal · Mpumalanga · Northern Cape · Limpopo ...
  53. [53]
    [PDF] Election Report
    ... 2004 before the party was disbanded in 2005. In 1999, Bantu Holomisa's UDM gained 3,42% of the support, which then dwindled to 2,28% in 2004 and 0,85% in. 2009.
  54. [54]
    UDM hopes upcoming elections will mark return of party's good ...
    It has been in steady decline since 1999 when it held 14 seats in the National Assembly, now holding just two following the 2019 elections. Leader Bantu ...
  55. [55]
    UDM's Roelf Meyer quits politics - IOL
    "I am defecting from politics to do another job. This was a personal decision, not a political one." Meyer declined to elaborate on his personal ...Missing: leaves | Show results with:leaves
  56. [56]
    Bantu Holomisa, The UDM's Achilles heel - News24
    Aug 31, 2016 · That's the biggest problem in the UDM's history and its future. It is one of, if not the biggest weakness that has led to its regression as a ...
  57. [57]
    UDM Archives - United Democratic Movement
    Resignation of councillors from Benoni and the South East. Statement by National Deputy-Secretary To leave the political party that you have been part of ...<|separator|>
  58. [58]
    [PDF] THE DOMINANT-PARTY SYSTEM Challenges for South Africa's ...
    The existence of a dominant-party system in South Africa has raised growing concerns over its implications for the consolidation of democracy.
  59. [59]
    [PDF] Politics in a Stabilizing Democracy: South Africa's 2004 Elections
    The decline in registered voters between 1999 and 2004 reflects a variety of factors, including confusion about the registration process, inability to get ...
  60. [60]
    UDM prepares for comeback at national, provincial elections - South ...
    The UDM, however, has a lot of lost ground to cover. It has been in steady decline since 1999 when it held 14 seats in the National Assembly. 2004 saw it ...<|separator|>
  61. [61]
    [PDF] How the ANC Won the 2004 Elections: Perspectives on Voting ...
    South. Africa's political transition from apartheid to democracy is often regarded as a miracle because it was bloodless. The dawn of the new era brought with ...
  62. [62]
    South Africa: ANC loses majority in crucial vote – DW – 06/02/2024
    Jun 2, 2024 · The final results released by the country's Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) ... United Democratic Movement (UDM) and the Inkatha Freedom ...
  63. [63]
    2024 Election results: ANC left shell-shocked with 97% of votes ...
    Jun 1, 2024 · These are the latest verified results from South Africa's national election, released by the Electoral Commission of South Africa.
  64. [64]
    UDM officially joins Government of National Unity following meeting ...
    Jun 21, 2024 · JOHANNESBURG - The United Democratic Movement (UDM) has officially joined the Government of National Unity (GNU) following its meeting with the ...
  65. [65]
    UDM becomes the latest party to join ANC-led GNU - TimesLIVE
    Jun 21, 2024 · Bantu Holomisa's UDM has become the latest political party to join the ANC-led government of national unity (GNU).
  66. [66]
    UDM joins the GNU – Bantu Holomisa - POLITICS - Politicsweb
    Jun 21, 2024 · Party proposes a Technical Committee to scrutinise all the members' manifestos in order to formulate policy.
  67. [67]
    UDM agrees to be part of GNU - SABC News
    Jun 21, 2024 · UDM leader Bantu Holomisa says the party is accepting the invitation.
  68. [68]
    South Africa elections final results: What happens next? - Al Jazeera
    Jun 2, 2024 · The African National Congress (ANC) has lost parliamentary majority and will need coalition partners to surpass 50 percent votes and form a government.<|separator|>
  69. [69]
    Holomisa's battle to clean up defence – the general's one-year ...
    Jun 24, 2025 · Deputy Defence Minister Bantu Holomisa reflects on a turbulent first year in office and calls for stronger parliamentary accountability.
  70. [70]
    SA defence “political heads” working to resolve problems - Holomisa
    Oct 23, 2024 · Holomisa's 100 day review notes further work on a roadmap to “fix misclassification problems, improve transparency and restore financial ...
  71. [71]
    Year-in-review report on my role as Deputy Minister of Defence and ...
    Jun 13, 2025 · Despite acknowledgment from former President Mbeki, implementation remains weak. The UDM, through Parliamentary procedures must:Missing: organizational | Show results with:organizational
  72. [72]
    UDM supports ANC proposal to broaden coalition - SABC News
    Aug 12, 2025 · The UDM says it supports the ANC's proposal to expand the 10-party coalition in the GNU.
  73. [73]
    Clashes within GNU 'laced with silliness, says Holomisa - News24
    Nov 3, 2024 · Holomisa expressed concerns about financial accountability and transparency, particularly in the intelligence operations. He said it was vital ...
  74. [74]
    I don't lose sleep over political posturing from DA, ANC – UDM's ...
    Jun 30, 2025 · The UDM leader and Deputy Minister of Defence, Bantu Holomisa says the GNU is something the people of South Africa support, and it is better than the ...
  75. [75]
    ' Go to hell': Bantu Holomisa' s fiery exchange with a caller on ... - IOL
    Aug 22, 2025 · ... Bantu Holomisa, lost his temper during a live broadcast on Gagasi FM, clashing with both a listener and host Alex Mthiyane in a fiery ...
  76. [76]
    LISTEN | 'Go to hell': Bantu Holomisa clashes with radio callers over ...
    Aug 22, 2025 · LISTEN | 'Go to hell': Bantu Holomisa clashes with radio callers over age, arrogance and politics. August 22, 2025 at 09:36 am. Share current ...
  77. [77]
    Bantu Holomisa's 'go to hell' remarks sum up GNU'S agenda - IOL
    Sep 4, 2025 · Defence Deputy Minister Bantu Holomisa recently defended his remarks telling a listener to 'go to hell' during a radio interview.
  78. [78]
    READER LETTER | Politicians only look after their interests - Sowetan
    Apr 7, 2025 · When UDM leader Bantu Holomisa was on the opposition benches, he used to be a fierce critic of the ANC government.<|separator|>
  79. [79]
    'High-level gossip': UDM leader Bantu Holomisa dismisses rumours ...
    Mar 10, 2025 · UDM president Bantu Holomisa, who is also deputy minister of defence in the government of national unity (GNU), is considering stepping down as party leader.
  80. [80]
    The real power in the GNU might belong to the smallest parties
    Jun 19, 2025 · “Our contributions are impactful and transformative,” he said, underscoring their commitment to social cohesion, rural development, and ...
  81. [81]
    President of the Republic of South Africa v United Democratic ...
    President of the Republic of South Africa v United Democratic Movement · Case Number: CCT23/02C · Judge: The Court · Hearing Date: 6 - 8 August 2002 · Judgment Date ...
  82. [82]
    United Democratic Movement v President of the Republic of South ...
    SOUTH AFRICAN LOCAL GOVERNMENT. ASSOCIATION Sixth Intervening Party ... In October 2000, municipal (local government) elections were held. The DP ...
  83. [83]
    United Democratic Movement v Speaker of the National Assembly ...
    Jun 22, 2017 · It is declared that the Speaker of the National Assembly has the constitutional power to prescribe that voting in a motion of no confidence in ...Missing: organization | Show results with:organization
  84. [84]
    A Brief Synopsis of UDM v Speaker of the National Assembly 2017 5 ...
    The UDM decision ultimately deals with the National Assembly's obligation to hold the President and the Executive authority accountable in terms of section 102 ...Missing: organization | Show results with:organization
  85. [85]
    United Democratic Movement and Another v Lebashe Investment ...
    Sep 22, 2022 · The Court found that the ordinary meaning of the impugned statement was that the respondents are thieves, fraudsters, corrupt and dishonest.
  86. [86]
    United Democratic Movement and Another v Lebashe ... - SAFLII
    Sep 22, 2022 · The UDM says that its primary role as an opposition party is to strengthen democracy, highlight instances of maladministration and corruption ...
  87. [87]
    Lebashe Investment Group (Pty) Ltd and Others v United Democratic ...
    Mar 28, 2025 · This is an appeal against the dismissal of an exception raised by the appellants in response to the respondents' amended plea.
  88. [88]
    SCA sides with Holomisa in R2m defamation case - The Citizen
    Apr 1, 2025 · Bantu Holomisa and UDM have won the first legal round against Lebashe Investment Group in a defamation suit.
  89. [89]
    United Democratic Movement and Others v Eskom Holdings SOC ...
    Dec 1, 2023 · In particular, the UDM argued that loadshedding in hospitals, police stations and schools leads to violation of everyone's right to dignity, ...Missing: disputes | Show results with:disputes
  90. [90]
    United Democratic Movement (UDM) & Others v Eskom & Others
    Mar 20, 2023 · The Gauteng Division of the High Court, Pretoria will today hear PART A in the 3rd matter, United Democratic Movement (UDM) & Others v Eskom ...Missing: disputes | Show results with:disputes<|separator|>
  91. [91]
    Holomisa blames ANC for UDM failure | Scrolla.Africa
    Jun 7, 2023 · Holomisa, leader of the UDM, has claimed that the ANC used its money and floor-crossing legislation to kill his party by poaching prominent ...
  92. [92]
    Holomisa says UDM will not be 'an ice boy' in GNU - EWN
    Jun 24, 2024 · JOHANNESBURG - United Democratic Movement (UDM) leader Bantu Holomisa has denied being a mere extra in the Government of National Unity (GNU) ...
  93. [93]
    Bantu Holomisa: Why the general has stopped calling out 'amasela ...
    Sep 1, 2024 · In March this year, Holomisa called for an investigation into then-National Assembly speaker Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula over allegations of bribery ...