Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

User illusion

The user illusion is a in for the idea that conscious experience is a simplified, edited of , rather than a direct reflection of the objective world, allowing humans to make decisions efficiently. Borrowed from —where it describes the intuitive interface hiding a system's complexity—the term posits that receives only a tiny fraction of the processed subconsciously, creating an of seamless awareness. Danish author Tor Nørretranders popularized the concept in his 1991 book Mærk verden (translated as The User Illusion: Cutting Consciousness Down to Size in 1998), drawing on , , and to argue that filters vast sensory input—estimated at around 11 million bits per second from the senses, but only about 40–60 bits per second reach conscious —through processes like exformation (discarded information) to produce a coherent but limited "user-friendly" view. This framework, influenced by earlier HCI origins at PARC in the 1970s, suggests evolved as an adaptive interface for survival, prioritizing relevant signals over exhaustive detail, with implications for understanding self, , and .

Origins

Definition

The user illusion is a metaphor in and that likens human to a simplified on a computer, such as a , which conceals the underlying complexity of hardware and software processes to provide an intuitive and efficient interaction for the user. The term originates in human-computer interaction (HCI) but, as applied to human , this posits that the conscious mind receives only a highly filtered and abstracted representation of the vast sensory and neural data processed unconsciously, much like how a graphical hides intricate and computations behind familiar icons and menus. In this view, serves as a practical for and navigation through the world, prioritizing utility over exhaustive detail. The application of the user illusion metaphor to human consciousness originates from Danish science writer Tor Nørretranders' 1991 book Mærk Verden (translated into English as The User Illusion: Cutting Consciousness Down to Size in 1998), where he adapts the term from computer interface design to explain how the discards enormous amounts of sensory —termed "exformation"—to construct a coherent and manageable conscious experience. Nørretranders draws on empirical findings from and to argue that this filtering creates a streamlined , enabling humans to focus on relevant actions without being overwhelmed by the full scope of environmental data. At its core, the user illusion asserts that conscious experience does not provide direct access to objective but instead delivers a utility-oriented approximation shaped by evolutionary pressures and cognitive mechanisms, integrating insights from , , and . This filtered enhances adaptive behavior by emphasizing patterns and predictions essential for , rather than streams—such as the limited of conscious compared to unconscious processing. Unlike perceptual errors like optical illusions, which involve localized misinterpretations of sensory input, the user illusion describes a holistic, brain-wide simplification that operates across all modalities of experience to maintain psychological coherence and efficiency.

Etymology and Historical Development

The term "user illusion" originates from , where it was coined by and his colleagues at PARC in the late 1970s to describe the simplified, intuitive interface presented to users, concealing the underlying computational complexity, as in graphical desktops that mimic physical objects to facilitate interaction. Danish science writer Tor Nørretranders adapted this metaphor in 1991 for human in his book Mærk Verden (translated as The User Illusion: Cutting Down to Size in 1998), portraying consciousness as a streamlined "interface" that filters vast non-conscious processing into a coherent but limited experience. Nørretranders also introduced "exformation" as a to denote the immense information discarded during cognitive compression, essential to this illusion but absent from conscious awareness. Intellectual precursors to the user illusion concept trace back to 17th-century , particularly ' mind-body in (1641), which posited as a mediated realm distinct from mechanical bodily processes, influencing later views of the mind as an interpretive layer over raw sensory data. In the , pioneer Norbert Wiener's Cybernetics: Or Control and Communication in the Animal and the Machine (1948) provided foundational ideas on information processing in biological systems, emphasizing feedback loops and the brain's role in managing informational overload, which Nørretranders drew upon to frame as an adaptive filter. Similarly, ' The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind (1976) argued for the historical of introspective from earlier non-conscious mental states, a narrative Nørretranders expanded in a dedicated chapter to highlight the illusion's evolutionary roots. Nørretranders synthesized these strands in his 1991 work, integrating computer metaphors with cybernetic and psychological insights to formalize the user illusion as a model of . Philosopher independently echoed and amplified this in Consciousness Explained (1991), describing the as a "virtual machine" generating a user-like interface for self-perception, later explicitly adopting the "user illusion" term in his writings to underscore its role in explaining and . The concept gained traction post-1998 English publication, influencing discussions on non-conscious cognition. Prior to the , related ideas appeared scattered in , such as early information-processing models in the 1950s, but lacked unified terminology. After Nørretranders' popularization and Dennett's endorsement, the user illusion integrated into broader debates in by the early 2000s, informing illusionist theories of .

Core Concepts

Bandwidth of Consciousness

The receives an enormous influx of sensory , estimated at approximately 11 million bits per second, with the majority—around 10 million bits—originating from visual pathways via the , and the remaining 1 million bits from auditory, tactile, and other modalities. This high-bandwidth input reflects the raw data stream processed subconsciously, allowing the brain to handle complex environmental signals without conscious intervention. In contrast, conscious awareness operates at a severely restricted capacity of about 40 to 60 bits per second, functioning like a narrow that filters and summarizes the deluge of data to prevent overload. These estimates, popularized by Tor Nørretranders in The User Illusion, illustrate the "user illusion" as a for how provides a simplified to the brain's underlying , analogous to a in that hides complexity. This disparity underscores the user illusion in the context of human , where provides a simplified, low-resolution to the underlying neural . Drawing from , as formalized by in his seminal 1948 paper on communication , the mind can be viewed as an information-processing system where conscious access represents a compressed of total sensory to maintain efficiency. Shannon's framework quantifies in message transmission, and applied to , it illustrates how the brain discards vast amounts of redundant or irrelevant —termed exformation in related discussions—to deliver only the essential highlights to awareness, akin to a bottleneck in a . A practical example of this limitation is human reading, where conscious processes roughly 50 bits per second despite the eyes scanning millions of bits of raw visual each second. The achieves this by selectively extracting key features like word shapes and , ignoring peripheral details such as exact pixel-level textures, thereby creating a coherent from compressed input. This selective mechanism ensures that remains manageable, prioritizing relevance over exhaustive detail.

Exformation and Information Compression

Exformation, a term coined by Danish science writer Tor Nørretranders in his 1991 book The User Illusion (English translation published in 1998), denotes the extensive implicit and contextual assumptions shared between individuals that enable efficient communication without explicit . This discarded or unspoken , drawn from common cultural, experiential, or environmental backgrounds, allows communicators to convey complex ideas with minimal explicit content, as the recipient intuitively supplies the missing elements. In the brain's information processing, exformation plays a crucial role in compression, filtering the estimated 11 million bits of sensory entering the mind each second down to roughly 50 bits that enter conscious . This reduction occurs by leveraging shared exformation to omit redundant details, preventing overload while preserving essential meaning. For instance, a simple like "Pass the salt" during dinner relies on exformation—mutual understanding of the meal context, utensil locations, and social norms—to communicate intent without describing every action or element explicitly. Nørretranders relates exformation to semantics by drawing an analogy to Niels Bohr's principle of complementarity, first introduced in Bohr's 1927 address at the Como conference. In this analogy, meaning in language or thought arises not solely from explicit statements but from the complementary tension between what is expressed and what remains unsaid—much like wave and particle aspects in are mutually exclusive yet complementary. In poetry or everyday dialogue, this dynamic ensures that omissions enhance rather than obscure comprehension, as the brain reconstructs significance through implicit knowledge. Conceptually, the effective meaning in any exchange equals the transmitted information (I) plus the exformation (E), such that full explicit conveyance without E would exceed conscious and render communication impractical. This underscores how exformation sustains the user illusion by rendering vast informational manageable within limited conscious . Note that while the term "user illusion" originated in human-computer interaction at PARC in the 1970s, Nørretranders employs it metaphorically for the interface of to subconscious processes.

Applications

Information Processing

In the context of the user illusion, information processing in the prioritizes mechanisms to manage overwhelming sensory inputs and computational demands, presenting only a streamlined to conscious awareness. The integrates and analyzes vast data streams pre-consciously, with neural activity initiating actions well before subjective experience arises. Benjamin Libet's 1983 experiments demonstrated this through measurements of the readiness potential (RP), a slow-building electrical signal in the that onset approximately 550 milliseconds before voluntary finger movements, yet 350 to 500 milliseconds prior to the reported moment of conscious intent. This temporal gap highlights how processes drive decision initiation, aligning with the user illusion's role in concealing the brain's parallel, high-bandwidth operations to deliver a coherent, low-bandwidth conscious . The user illusion manifests in by backdating conscious to align with neural events, fostering a of immediacy and . In Libet's clock , participants observed a rapidly sweeping clock hand and reported the position at which they first felt the urge to act, but these reports consistently lagged behind the RP onset by hundreds of milliseconds, suggesting the retroactively timestamps to create a seamless perceptual . This ensures the conscious "user" perceives actions as originating from deliberate intent, masking the preceding unconscious of sensory and motivational cues. Sensory information undergoes hierarchical filtering before reaching , primarily via the , which acts as a relay and to cortical processing. Raw sensory data from peripheral receptors is routed through thalamic nuclei to layered cortical regions, where initial thalamic projections modulate early sensory gain and suppress irrelevant signals, allowing only abstracted, salient features—such as or threat assessment—to ascend to higher cortical areas and enter conscious . This multi-stage refinement reduces informational overload, preserving the user illusion of direct, unmediated access to the environment. Recent advances reinforce these dynamics through frameworks, where the brain anticipates outcomes based on prior models. Functional MRI studies replicating earlier work, such as Soon et al.'s demonstrations of frontoparietal activity forecasting choices up to 10 seconds before , confirm that unconscious predictive signals in decision circuits generate illusory feelings of spontaneity. These findings underscore how the user illusion optimizes processing efficiency by prioritizing foresight over exhaustive conscious deliberation.

Models of Self and Others

The user illusion plays a central role in constructing mental models of the , presenting a streamlined of personal amid the brain's distributed, modular operations. Philosopher described the not as a singular entity but as a "center of narrative gravity," an abstract point around which disparate cognitive processes and experiences cohere into a unified "I." This model hides internal conflicts and parallel activities, such as competing neural signals or subconscious influences, to deliver a coherent, user-friendly interface for and . By masking the brain's complexity—estimated to process around 11 million bits per second while consciousness handles only about 40 bits per second—the illusion fosters a sense of continuous selfhood essential for psychological stability. Dennett's further elucidates this self-representation, positing that consciousness emerges from numerous, concurrent "drafts" of neural content competing for dominance without a central theater or editor. In (1991), he argued that these drafts create the illusion of unity and immediacy, as the retroactively edits experiences into a seamless story, concealing the asynchronous, probabilistic nature of . For instance, phenomena like demonstrate how the self-model glosses over perceptual gaps to maintain narrative continuity. This framework underscores the user illusion's efficiency in prioritizing adaptive coherence over exhaustive accuracy. Extending to models of others, the user illusion underpins by enabling simplified attributions of intentions and beliefs to predict . Dennett's approach treats others as rational agents with desires and goals, a that approximates complex neural dynamics much like a interface abstracts hardware operations. This simplification aids social prediction but introduces errors, such as overattributing actions to stable traits rather than situational factors—a evident in everyday judgments of others' motives. Such models rely on shared exformation, like cultural assumptions, to compress vast interpersonal data into actionable insights. Dennett's ideas remain influential in contemporary discussions, particularly following his on April 19, 2024. Obituaries and analyses have highlighted his enduring on and .

Evolutionary Fitness

The user illusion, as conceptualized in interface theory of , posits that human perceptions, including conscious experience, evolved primarily to enhance and reproductive rather than to provide veridical representations of objective reality. Donald Hoffman argues that shapes perceptual interfaces—simplified, species-specific depictions akin to desktop icons on a computer—that prioritize fitness payoffs over truth, ensuring in complex environments. This Darwinian foundation is supported by evolutionary game theory simulations, which demonstrate that organisms perceiving reality accurately are consistently outcompeted by those relying on fitness-tuned illusions. In models simulating across territories, "truth" strategies, which estimate objective properties like exact quantities, incur higher informational costs and yield lower survival rates compared to "interface" strategies that encode only utility signals, such as color cues for high-fitness options. For instance, in a Gaussian where moderate resource levels maximize survival, interface perceivers using abstract icons dominate populations, driving veridical perceivers to within generations, regardless of environmental . Applied to consciousness, this low-bandwidth user illusion favors rapid, action-oriented processing over exhaustive accuracy, conserving cognitive resources for survival-critical decisions. A representative example is human , which evolved not to reveal spectral wavelengths but to detect fitness-relevant cues, such as the reddish hues of ripe fruit against green foliage, enabling efficient foraging for ancestors. Recent advancements in , as of 2024, further integrate theory with models of , proposing that perceptual systems function as interfaces that guide through simplified representations rather than veridical depictions. These perspectives align Hoffman's framework with theories where consciousness serves as an efficient interface for agent-environment interactions.

Criticisms

Introspection

Critics of the user illusion contend that introspection, through mechanisms like inner speech and metacognition, provides partial access to pre-conscious states, undermining the notion that consciousness serves as a wholly illusory or incomplete interface to subconscious processes. The Descriptive Experience Sampling (DES) method, developed by Russell T. Hurlburt, involves random beeps prompting participants to retrospectively describe their immediate inner experience with high fidelity, revealing instances of inner speech—unspoken verbalizations—and metacognitive reflections that capture thoughts just prior to full conscious awareness. This approach demonstrates that individuals can apprehend pristine inner experiences, including pre-conscious deliberations, suggesting that the boundary between subconscious and conscious realms is permeable rather than entirely deceptive. Phenomenological evidence further supports this partial accessibility, as reports of the "feeling of knowing"—a metacognitive of familiarity or rightness preceding explicit recall—indicate of subsurface cognitive traces before they enter full . Such feelings, distinct from mere familiarity, allow individuals to monitor and predict memory retrieval, challenging claims of total discard by highlighting reflective pathways to otherwise hidden processes. While Nørretranders posits that vast exformation is irretrievably filtered from , these introspective glimpses reveal that metacognitive access, though limited, enables critique and navigation of influences without rendering the conscious self illusory. Introspection remains filtered, as not all subconscious activity surfaces, yet it is not wholly opaque; for instance, practices enhance awareness of implicit biases by training sustained on automatic thought patterns. Recent bolsters this view, with 2023 functional MRI studies showing that interventions modulate the (DMN)—a for self-referential processing and —such as through reducing hyperconnectivity in affective contexts to enhance state , and DMN activation mediating in stress-related growth. These findings illustrate how introspective techniques can uncover and reframe subconscious layers, providing a more nuanced counter to the user illusion's emphasis on conscious limitation.

Social Behavior

Critics of the user illusion hypothesis argue that complex social cooperation can emerge in entirely non-conscious systems, thereby questioning the necessity of a conscious "user interface" for human sociality. For instance, ant colonies demonstrate sophisticated collective behaviors, such as foraging and nest-building, through decentralized interactions governed by simple local rules like pheromone trails, without any individual or collective consciousness. Similarly, bacterial communities achieve cooperative outcomes, including biofilm formation and virulence factor expression, via quorum sensing—a chemical signaling mechanism that coordinates group actions based on population density, operating purely at the subcellular level without awareness. These examples from swarm intelligence models developed in the 2000s illustrate how emergent sociality arises from implicit, non-conscious algorithms, suggesting that human cooperation might rely more on subconscious mechanisms than on illusory conscious models. In humans, evidence from supports the idea that social and prediction can occur through subconscious processes that bypass full conscious simulation. systems, discovered in the and extensively studied since, activate both when individuals perform an action and when they observe it in others, enabling automatic motor and emotional simulation that underpins without requiring deliberate conscious thought. This embodied simulation fosters interpersonal competence and emotional mirroring in social interactions, as shown in studies linking activity to of affective states between people. Such findings imply that while conscious models of others may aid higher-level prediction—as explored in related applications—much of human social bonding operates via these pre-conscious neural circuits, reducing the dependence on user illusions for basic cooperation. This critique extends to counterarguments against the purported applications of user illusions in social prediction, highlighting how decentralized norms can function through implicit rules without conscious mediation. In economic , social norms emerge as correlated equilibria in repeated interactions, where players conform to implicit expectations of reciprocity or fairness via decentralized signaling, rather than centralized conscious deliberation. For example, in scenarios modeled economically, cooperation sustains through norm-driven strategies that evolve from local incentives, demonstrating that social order can arise from non-conscious adherence to rules without invoking illusory self-models. These frameworks suggest that human , like that in non-conscious systems, leans heavily on automatic, rule-based processes, challenging the centrality of user illusions. A relatively underexplored area in this debate involves recent studies on swarms, which analogize non-conscious multi-agent systems to crowd and reveal illusion-like interfaces in emergent behaviors. In 2025 research on language-driven multi-agent simulations, agents modeled after bird flocking or ant foraging exhibit crowd-like navigation and cooperation through LLM-powered interactions, where emerges without individual "consciousness," yet interfaces mimic simplified user illusions to facilitate oversight. These experiments draw parallels to crowds, showing how decentralized swarms achieve and coordination via implicit protocols, further questioning the evolutionary need for conscious illusions in complex group settings.

Free Will

The user illusion, as a simplified conscious interface to complex subconscious processes, has profound implications for the nature of , prompting debates on whether our sense of volitional agency is genuine or merely a functional fiction. In this view, proponents argue that emerges as a biological that fosters and social cohesion, even if it operates within deterministic neural mechanisms. Philosopher , in his 2003 book Freedom Evolves, posits that is not an illusion in the pejorative sense but a valuable evolved capacity, akin to the user illusion of , which equips organisms with the ability to anticipate, avoid, and deliberate in ways that enhance survival and accountability. This compatibilist perspective reconciles determinism with agency by emphasizing that the conscious experience of choice—much like the —masks underlying computational processes, yet enables effective decision-making without requiring libertarian . Empirical support for this illusory aspect draws from Benjamin Libet's seminal 1983 experiments, which revealed that a readiness potential in the brain precedes conscious awareness of intent by approximately 350 milliseconds, suggesting that conscious decisions may serve as post-hoc rationalizations rather than causal initiators of action. Psychologist extended this in his 2002 analysis, interpreting such findings as evidence that the feeling of conscious will is an authorship illusion, where the mind infers causation after unconscious processes have already committed to the act. Libertarian philosophers counter that the user illusion does not preclude genuine , advocating for mechanisms that introduce true indeterminacy beyond deterministic neural models. Robert Kane, in his 1996 book The Significance of Free Will, defends a libertarian framework where quantum-level indeterminacy amplifies into macroscopic choices during "self-forming actions," allowing agents to originate decisions unconstrained by prior causes, thus transcending any reductive illusion of the conscious self. This view posits emergent properties in complex systems, such as the brain, that enable alternative possibilities without relying on the simplified for volition's reality. Recent challenges the deterministic interpretation underpinning illusionist claims, potentially bolstering libertarian or compatibilist alternatives. For instance, Aaron Schurger's 2023 study reinterprets the readiness potential not as evidence of predetermination but as stochastic neural noise accumulating until it crosses a decision threshold, implying that conscious intent could influence outcomes without being purely retrospective. If proves illusory under the user illusion paradigm, it carries significant ethical ramifications, particularly in diminishing retributive blame by highlighting how rationalizes predetermined actions. Compatibilists like Dennett maintain that this does not erode , as the illusion evolved to support societal norms of praise and punishment. However, critics question the coherence of such positions. Science writer , in a 2024 reflection following Dennett's death, critiques the "Dennett ": by insisting and are illusions, Dennett inadvertently underscores their profound, non-illusory role in human deliberation and ethics, urging a reevaluation of reductionist accounts in light of persistent subjective experience. This ongoing tension reflects broader 2023–2025 advancements in volition research, which increasingly emphasize hybrid models integrating timing—briefly, the neural precursors to —with illusions that confer adaptive benefits for evolutionary .

References

  1. [1]
    Magic and Software Design - AskTog
    ... user illusion" (Kay). We are designing interfaces for an interface system ... Don Norman calls it the "System Image," the physical embodiment of the ...
  2. [2]
    None
    ### Summary of "User Illusion" from https://hci-studies.org/lecture-and-exercises/lecture/02%20-%20Users.pdf
  3. [3]
    [PDF] Constructing the User - CumInCAD
    at Xerox PARC of the 1960s and early 1970s ... first graphical interfaces, to the extent that David Smith named the interface itself the “user illusion.
  4. [4]
    The “user illusion” method in multi-user interface design ...
    The “user illusion” method in multi-user interface design. Authors: George ... Human-centered computing · Human computer interaction (HCI) · Software and ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  5. [5]
    [PDF] Alan Kay – User Interface: A Personal View (1989)
    At. PARC we coined the phrase user illusion to describe what we were about when designing user interface. There are clear connotations to the stage ...
  6. [6]
    The User Illusion by Tor Norretranders - Penguin Random House
    In stock Rating 4.2 8 In this thought-provoking work, Norretranders argues that our perceptions are not direct representations of the world we experience, but instead, illusions our ...Missing: Mærker 1991
  7. [7]
    https://www.informationphilosopher.com/solutions/scientists/bohr/quantum_postulate.html
  8. [8]
    Daniel C. Dennett, The User-Illusion of Consciousness - PhilPapers
    Dennett, Daniel C. (2021). The User-Illusion of Consciousness. Journal of Consciousness Studies 28 (11-12):167-177.
  9. [9]
    How Much the Eye Tells the Brain - PMC - PubMed Central - NIH
    How Much the Eye Tells the Brain. Kristin Koch. Kristin Koch. 1 Department of ... Lower rates carry more bits per spike. Line is least squares fit: slope ...
  10. [10]
    [PDF] Bohr's way to defining complementarity(*) - arXiv
    We go through Bohr's talk about complementary features of quantum theory at the Volta. Conference in September 1927, by collating a manuscript that Bohr wrote ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  11. [11]
    Time of conscious intention to act in relation to onset of cerebral ...
    Time of conscious intention to act in relation to onset of cerebral activity (readiness-potential). The unconscious initiation of a freely voluntary act.
  12. [12]
    Thalamus modulates consciousness via layer-specific control of cortex
    We found that neurons in thalamus and deep cortical layers are most sensitive to changes in consciousness level, consistent across different anesthetic agents ...
  13. [13]
    https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/an-epitaph-for-daniel-dennett-philosopher-of-consciousness/
  14. [14]
    The Self as a Center of Narrative Gravity - ResearchGate
    The Self as a Center of Narrative Gravity. January 1992. DOI:10.5209/rev-ASEM.2013.v46.42862. Authors: Daniel Dennett at Tufts University. Daniel Dennett.
  15. [15]
    An Epitaph for Daniel Dennett, Philosopher of Consciousness
    Apr 23, 2024 · His belief that consciousness is an illusion is wackier than the belief that God is real. Science has real enemies—some in positions of great ...
  16. [16]
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3677335/
  17. [17]
    The Evolutionary Argument Against Reality | Quanta Magazine
    Apr 21, 2016 · The cognitive scientist Donald Hoffman uses evolutionary game theory to show that our perceptions of an independent reality must be illusions.
  18. [18]
    Spotting fruit versus picking fruit as the selective advantage of ...
    Feb 18, 2013 · We infer that in the evolution of human colour vision, spotting fruit from a distance was a more important selective advantage than picking fruit at arms' ...Missing: Hoffman | Show results with:Hoffman
  19. [19]
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5733077/
  20. [20]
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7350950/
  21. [21]
    Investigating Pristine Inner Experience
    You live your entire waking life immersed in your inner experiences (thoughts, feelings, sensations and so on) – private phenomena created by you, ...
  22. [22]
    Pristine Inner Experience and Descriptive Experience Sampling
    We argue that descriptive experience sampling (DES) can produce high fidelity descriptions of pristine inner experience.
  23. [23]
    The Phenomenology of Remembering Is an Epistemic Feeling - PMC
    We argue that the phenomenology of remembering consists of a metacognitive feeling of pastness (FOP).
  24. [24]
    (PDF) What Feeling Is the “Feeling of Knowing?” - ResearchGate
    Aug 9, 2025 · Rightness, not familiarity, is the feeling of knowing. Rightness and familiarity are distinct at both the functional and phenomenological ...
  25. [25]
    Meditation in the Workplace: Does Mindfulness Reduce Bias and ...
    Apr 10, 2022 · Mindfulness has been linked to reductions in implicit age bias, sunk-cost decision-making bias and increases in organisational citizenship behaviours (OCB).Missing: uncovering subconscious
  26. [26]
    Reducing default mode network connectivity with mindfulness ... - PMC
    We developed mindfulness-based fMRI neurofeedback (mbNF) for adolescents that aims to reduce default mode network (DMN) hyperconnectivity.Missing: introspection | Show results with:introspection
  27. [27]
    The mediating role of default mode network during meaning-making ...
    Jul 15, 2023 · Activation of the DMN during meaning-making could mediate the relationship between positive stressful events and stress-related growth.
  28. [28]
    (PDF) Swarm Intelligence: Concepts, Models and Applications
    This technical report provides a general introduction to SI, and offers a fundamental overview of two of the most popular SI paradigms: Ant Colony Optimization ...
  29. [29]
    Quorum Sensing Drives the Evolution of Cooperation in Bacteria
    Aug 17, 2009 · Many bacteria have evolved a simple chemical communication system called quorum sensing (QS), to “measure” the population density of clone-mates in their close ...
  30. [30]
    Mirror neurons: Enigma of the metaphysical modular brain - PMC
    Mirror neurons have been said to have the potential to provide a mechanism for action-understanding, imitation-learning, and the simulation of other people's ...Missing: subconscious bypassing
  31. [31]
    Empathy, mirror neurons and SYNC | Mind & Society
    Dec 14, 2014 · Mirror neurons provide an “embodied simulation” of the observed person's actions, leading to brain-to-brain coupling and synchronizing of ...Missing: bypassing | Show results with:bypassing
  32. [32]
    Mirroring others' emotions relates to empathy and interpersonal ...
    These findings suggest that simulation mechanisms and the MNS may indeed be relevant to social functioning in everyday life during typical human development.
  33. [33]
    Evolution of social norms and correlated equilibria - PNAS
    Apr 11, 2019 · Our work belongs to a body of game theory that has studied how correlated equilibria can emerge in a decentralized way through evolutionary or ...
  34. [34]
    (PDF) Game-Theoretic Accounts of Social Norms - ResearchGate
    Nov 3, 2017 · More precisely, we define social norms as behavioral regularities emerging in mixed-motive games, as a result of preferences for conformity ...Missing: decentralized | Show results with:decentralized
  35. [35]
    Emergent Crowds Dynamics from Language-Driven Multi-Agent ...
    Aug 20, 2025 · We observe that human navigation and movement in crowds are often influenced by complex social and environmental interactions, driven mainly by ...
  36. [36]
    Multi-agent systems powered by large language models
    We demonstrate our framework on two classical swarm intelligence scenarios–ant colony foraging and bird flocking–each involving different sensory inputs and ...Missing: consciousness | Show results with:consciousness<|separator|>
  37. [37]
    The Illusion of Conscious Will - MIT Press
    A new edition of Wegner's classic and controversial work, arguing that conscious will simply reminds of us the authorship of our actions.
  38. [38]
    The Significance of Free Will - Robert Kane - Oxford University Press
    Free delivery 25-day returnsRobert Kane provides a critical overview of debates about free will of the past half century, relating this recent inquiry to the broader history of the free ...
  39. [39]
    Probing for intentions: The early readiness potential does not reflect ...
    We conclude that the RP may be metacognitively accessible in response to external task demands but does not reflect the onset of a conscious intention.Missing: replication | Show results with:replication