_A New Social Contract_

Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

A New Social Contract (Dutch: Een nieuw sociaal contract) is a 2021 political manifesto by Pieter Omtzigt, a Dutch politician and Member of Parliament since 2003, with contributions from philosopher Welmoed Vlieger, critiquing the erosion of trust between the Dutch government and citizens due to systemic administrative failures and proposing a reformed framework for governance centered on rule of law and accountability.^[1]^[2] Published in February 2021 by Uitgeverij Prometheus, the book uses the childcare benefits scandal—where erroneous fraud accusations led to the wrongful financial ruin of thousands of families—as a primary example of bureaucratic overreach and institutional neglect of core governmental duties.^[1] Omtzigt argues that the existing social contract has broken down amid power imbalances and inadequate checks and balances, necessitating a bottom-up agreement involving citizens, government, large companies, and societal institutions to redefine rights, duties, and responsibilities with an emphasis on human dignity, empathy, and service-oriented politics.^[2]^[1] The manifesto's core proposals include overhauling legal and institutional mechanisms to repair the rule of law, fostering a mentality shift in both state apparatus and public to prioritize functionality over ideology, and rebuilding public confidence through transparent, citizen-focused administration.^[2]^[1] Omtzigt's work gained prominence amid his role in exposing governmental scandals, contributing to his departure from the Christian Democratic Appeal (CDA) party in 2021 and the subsequent founding of the Nieuw Sociaal Contract (NSC) party in 2023, which secured 20 seats in the Dutch House of Representatives that year and participated in the 2024 Schoof cabinet formation.^[2] While praised for highlighting empirical governance failures often downplayed by established institutions, the ideas have sparked debate over the feasibility of such reforms in a polarized political landscape resistant to accountability-driven change.^[2]

Background

Political Context in the Netherlands

The toeslagenaffaire, or childcare benefits scandal, represented a profound instance of bureaucratic overreach by Dutch authorities, eroding public trust in government institutions around 2019–2021. From 2012 onward, the tax authority (Belastingdienst) systematically misclassified up to 26,000 parents—disproportionately those from ethnic minority or lower-income backgrounds—as fraudulent claimants of childcare subsidies, using flawed risk-profiling algorithms that presumed guilt based on minimal evidence.^[3] ^[4] ^[5] This led to aggressive debt collection, with affected families facing repayment demands averaging €20,000–€50,000, resulting in bankruptcies, evictions, and over 1,000 children removed from homes into state custody; an independent review later confirmed the process violated principles of fairness and proportionality.^[6] ^[7] The scandal's exposure through parliamentary inquiries in 2020 highlighted entrenched administrative rigidity and a fraud-detection culture prioritizing efficiency over accuracy, with internal documents revealing ignored warnings about systemic errors since 2015.^[8] Public outrage peaked, manifesting in protests and polls showing trust in the tax authority plummeting to below 50% by late 2020.^[9] It directly precipitated the resignation of Prime Minister Mark Rutte's third cabinet on January 15, 2021, after a committee report condemned the government's failure to address grievances promptly, marking a rare collapse of executive stability in the Netherlands.^[10] ^[11] Compounding this were wider policy shortcomings signaling a breakdown in effective governance. A housing deficit of 279,000 units persisted into 2021, driven by regulatory bottlenecks and insufficient construction amid population growth, straining affordability in a nation with GDP per capita exceeding $55,000.^[12] Administrative burdens in education—such as teacher shortages affecting 20% of primary schools—and healthcare, where pre-COVID waiting lists for specialists averaged 6–7 weeks, further fueled complaints, with the National Ombudsman handling over 30,000 cases in 2019 alone, reflecting heightened scrutiny of state services.^[13] ^[14] These failures, amid a Gini coefficient for disposable income hovering at 0.26 (indicating moderate inequality by EU standards), underscored causal disconnects between economic prosperity and equitable public administration, prompting demands for systemic reform.^[15]^[16]

Pieter Omtzigt's Role and Motivations

Pieter Omtzigt entered the Dutch House of Representatives as a Christian Democratic Appeal (CDA) member in 2003, serving continuously for over 18 years until his departure from the party in 2021.^[17] Throughout his tenure, he established a reputation for rigorous, data-driven scrutiny of government actions, particularly in cases of institutional failure. In the investigation of Malaysia Airlines Flight MH17's downing on July 17, 2014, Omtzigt pressed for transparency on evidentiary gaps and potential external influences, including corruption allegations within Ukrainian intelligence that compromised probe integrity.^[18] ^[19] Omtzigt's most prominent exposure of systemic flaws came in the childcare benefits scandal (Toeslagenaffaire), where he repeatedly interrogated officials on the wrongful labeling of over 20,000 families as fraudulent, resulting in debt enforcement and widespread hardship between 2013 and 2019.^[20] Parliamentary inquiries he championed revealed administrative biases, with data showing tax authorities applied risk profiles unevenly, presuming guilt based on ethnicity or family status while favoring operational efficiency over due process safeguards.^[21] This culminated in leaked cabinet formation notes from June 2021, which included the directive "positie Omtzigt, functie elders" ("Omtzigt position, function elsewhere"), exposing efforts by party negotiators to sideline him amid his advocacy.^[17] Rooted in Christian democratic tenets, Omtzigt's drive for a restructured social framework emphasized subsidiarity—resolving issues at the most local competent level—and the inherent dignity of individuals against state overreach, viewing post-1945 welfare expansions as fostering unintended dependency without robust accountability mechanisms.^[22] His forensic approach, grounded in inquiry-derived evidence of implementation failures, positioned the push for renewal as a demand for institutional self-correction rather than partisan reinvention, highlighting how unchecked efficiency eroded trust in governance.^[23]

Publication

Authorship and Development

Een nieuw sociaal contract was written primarily by Pieter Omtzigt, a Member of Parliament for the Christian Democratic Appeal (CDA) at the time, drawing on his investigations into government failures such as the childcare benefits scandal (toeslagenaffaire). The work emerged in early 2021 amid ongoing revelations of administrative dysfunction and party-internal debates over renewal within the CDA, which had been tarnished by its involvement in the scandal's mishandling.^[24]^[25] Originally conceived as a contribution to reforming the CDA in response to these scandals, the manifesto evolved into a broader public critique of the Dutch political establishment upon its release. Omtzigt's marginalization within the party, exacerbated by leaked notes criticizing its leadership during cabinet formation negotiations in spring 2021, underscored the document's role in signaling his divergence from traditional party lines.^[26] The book was published on 23 February 2021 by Uitgeverij Prometheus in Amsterdam. It generated approximately €150,000 in royalties for Omtzigt, which he directed to food banks (voedselbanken) and clothing banks (kledingbanken) after taxes, reflecting his commitment to addressing social needs highlighted in the text.^[1]^[27]^[28]

Key Themes and Structure

The manifesto structures its analysis into two primary parts: a diagnostic examination of the shortcomings in the current Dutch social contract, including excessive bureaucracy and mechanisms perpetuating inequality, followed by prescriptive recommendations centered on fostering active citizenship through defined rights and obligations. This framework highlights how post-World War II arrangements, such as the consensus-driven polder model, have become inadequate in addressing contemporary challenges posed by globalization and technological advancements, leading to eroded trust between citizens and the state. At its core, the document advocates a transition from a system treating citizens as passive welfare beneficiaries to one empowering them as active participants, with governance oriented toward verifiable empirical results rather than ideological assumptions. For instance, it emphasizes reducing persistent poverty traps, where Statistics Netherlands (CBS) reported 221,000 children—equivalent to 6.9% of minors—living in low-income households in 2020, the lowest figure in 25 years but still indicative of intergenerational risks.^[29] Philosophically, the manifesto critiques expansive state paternalism, which it links to failures like the toeslagenaffaire—a childcare benefits scandal where tax authorities algorithmically targeted suspect groups, resulting in wrongful accusations and financial ruin for thousands of families between 2005 and 2019.^[5] In response, it proposes decentralized, strictly rule-bound administrative systems to mitigate such abuses and prioritize causal accountability in policy outcomes.^[30]

Core Proposals

Governance and Rule of Law Reforms

In "Een nieuw sociaal contract," Pieter Omtzigt critiques the erosion of the Dutch rule of law, exemplified by systemic failures in administrative processes that prioritize efficiency over individual rights, as seen in the toeslagenaffaire where the Belastingdienst erroneously flagged thousands of parents as fraudsters based on flawed risk indicators, resulting in demands for repayment of benefits, financial ruin, and personal tragedies for approximately 26,000 affected families between 2005 and 2019.^[31] This scandal, uncovered through parliamentary inquiry, highlighted a lack of proportionality checks and inadequate safeguards against bureaucratic overreach, contributing to the resignation of the Rutte III cabinet on January 15, 2021.^[31] Omtzigt argues for verifiable mechanisms to enforce causal accountability, ensuring state actions are predictable and contestable to rebuild trust in government-citizen interactions.^[32] Key reforms include establishing a constitutional court empowered to review laws against the Dutch Constitution, addressing the current prohibition under Article 120 on judicial testing of statutes' constitutionality, which Omtzigt views as a barrier to effective counterpower against legislative excess.^[32] This proposal, reiterated in his 2024 initiative note, encompasses ten measures such as distributed constitutional review by all courts on fundamental rights and enhanced parliamentary scrutiny tools to prevent recurrence of administrative arbitrariness.^[33] Complementary enhancements to legal protections aim to shield citizens from overwhelming government demands, including mandatory impact assessments for policies impacting vulnerable groups to evaluate disproportionate effects prior to implementation, drawing directly from the toeslagenaffaire's absence of such evaluations.^[32] Strengthening administrative courts and the ombudsman's role would enforce these, with binding powers to overturn decisions lacking evidence-based justification. To reduce agency discretion, Omtzigt advocates "citizen charters" outlining transparent, standardized decision-making protocols for bodies like the Belastingdienst, minimizing subjective interpretations that fueled error-prone processes in benefits administration.^[34] Empirical data from the Algemene Rekenkamer underscores the need: audits from 2005–2020 revealed persistent execution flaws in the toeslagen system, including inadequate risk assessments and recovery practices affecting over 60% of households with multiple demands, often exceeding €500 without sufficient appeal avenues.^[35] Integration of AI oversight committees for algorithmic tools in administration is proposed to detect and mitigate biases, as the toeslagenaffaire's fraud-detection software disproportionately targeted ethnic minorities without validation, amplifying causal harms.^[31] Further, Omtzigt calls for sunset clauses in legislation, requiring periodic evidence-based reviews and automatic expiration unless renewed with demonstrated efficacy, to combat regulatory accumulation that evades scrutiny—as evidenced by the Rekenkamer's findings of unaddressed design flaws persisting over 15 years in benefits frameworks.^[36] These reforms prioritize first-principles accountability, where policies must prove causal benefits outweigh costs, over unchecked expansion, fostering a rechtsstaat where state power serves rather than ensnares citizens.^[32] In Een nieuw sociaal contract, Pieter Omtzigt critiques the Dutch welfare system for fostering poverty traps through abrupt benefit phase-outs, which impose effective marginal tax rates of 60-100% on low-income earners transitioning to work, effectively penalizing additional earnings.^[37] A 2021 analysis by the Sociaal-Economische Raad (SER), drawing on CPB modeling, highlights how such dynamics in combined income taxes, social premiums, and subsidy reductions create disincentives, with some households facing net income losses from wage increases up to €5-10 per hour.^[37] Omtzigt proposes reforms including gradual benefit taper rates over wider income bands and introduction of earned income supplements akin to the U.S. Earned Income Tax Credit, calibrated to ensure positive work incentives without expanding overall welfare spending.^[38] On taxation, Omtzigt advocates broadening the income tax base by eliminating deductions and loopholes—such as the 30% ruling for expatriates, which he argues distorts labor markets and subsidizes high earners at public expense—while lowering statutory rates for middle-income brackets to reduce the overall tax burden on €30,000-€60,000 earners, who face combined pressures exceeding 50%.^[39] These changes aim to simplify the system, currently fragmented across multiple brackets and allowances, and align revenue neutrality with fiscal sustainability amid rising public debt, projected at 55% of GDP in 2025 by CPB estimates. He opposes fiscal expansions that ignore supply-side constraints, noting that unchecked net migration of over 100,000 annually since 2015 has inflated welfare costs by €2-3 billion yearly through heightened demand for income support and public services, per CPB migration impact assessments. For social welfare, Omtzigt favors universal provision of core services like education and basic healthcare over targeted cash transfers, arguing the latter exacerbate moral hazard and administrative errors, as evidenced by the 2019 childcare benefits scandal affecting 1.1 million families. Empirical data from Statistics Netherlands (CBS) underscores causal links between family structure and economic mobility: single-parent households face a 25-30% poverty risk in 2023, triple the 8-10% rate for two-parent families, due to reduced labor participation and higher childcare costs, supporting his emphasis on policies bolstering stable family units as a foundational mobility driver without relying on redistributive handouts. This approach prioritizes long-term self-reliance, with CPB simulations indicating that service-focused models yield 1-2% higher GDP growth over decades compared to cash-heavy systems prone to dependency cycles.

Citizenship, Family, and Housing

Omtzigt advocates for integrating citizenship education into school curricula that balances rights with duties, aiming to counteract what he describes as "rights inflation" stemming from cultural shifts since the 1960s, where emphasis on individual entitlements has eroded communal responsibilities. This approach seeks to foster personal responsibility as a foundation for societal stability, drawing on empirical observations that societies with stronger civic duty awareness exhibit lower rates of social fragmentation.^[40] In family policy, Omtzigt proposes expanding tax credits for dependent children to incentivize family formation and stability, alongside broadening paternity leave to encourage paternal involvement from birth, thereby reinforcing two-parent structures empirically linked to reduced state dependency. Data from Statistics Netherlands indicate that single-parent households, comprising 80% of native Dutch families receiving income support in 2016, face higher welfare reliance compared to intact families, underscoring causal connections between family intactness and lower public assistance needs.^[41] He critiques media portrayals that normalize single-parenthood without acknowledging these outcomes, prioritizing evidence over idealized narratives that may overlook elevated poverty risks—such as the 209,000 Dutch children at poverty risk in 2022, disproportionately from disrupted families.^[42] On housing, Omtzigt calls for mandating over 100,000 new units annually through zoning deregulation to curb speculative barriers, directly targeting the 390,000-unit shortage estimated in 2021 by ABF Research, which has exacerbated affordability crises and delayed family formation.^[43] These reforms emphasize supply-side realism over demand subsidies, linking accessible housing to broader social cohesion by enabling stable family environments that mitigate intergenerational dependency cycles observed in housing-constrained populations.^[44]

Reception and Influence

Initial Political Reactions

The publication of Een nieuw sociaal contract on February 23, 2021, elicited a range of immediate political responses in the Netherlands, reflecting Omtzigt's rising prominence amid ongoing scandals like the childcare benefits affair. The book quickly gained traction, selling 18,000 copies within its first two weeks and topping political bestseller lists, which amplified Omtzigt's critique of governance failures and bolstered his public profile as a reform advocate.^[45] Conservative-leaning commentators and politicians praised the work for its focus on restoring rule-of-law mechanisms and exposing executive overreach, viewing it as a pragmatic call to prioritize institutional accountability over ideological experimentation.^[46] Within the VVD and similar circles, it resonated as an endorsement of measured reforms to counter bureaucratic inefficiencies without radical restructuring. In contrast, left-leaning outlets and figures, including those associated with GroenLinks, dismissed it as inadequately progressive, faulting its limited emphasis on aggressive climate policies and wealth redistribution, and characterizing the proposals as preserving the existing power structures rather than challenging systemic inequalities.^[47]^[48] Reactions within Omtzigt's own CDA were particularly divided, with grassroots supporters hailing its reformist vision as a necessary reckoning with the party's complicity in governance lapses, while party leadership perceived it as a direct challenge to elite control, exacerbating tensions that led to Omtzigt's exclusion from the June 2021 leadership contest and his subsequent departure as an independent.^[49] This internal rift underscored the book's role in highlighting irreconcilable divides between Omtzigt's insistence on transparency and the party's preference for maintaining coalition stability.^[46]

Impact on Dutch Politics

The publication of A New Social Contract in June 2021 amplified public and parliamentary scrutiny of systemic governance failures exposed by the toeslagenaffaire child benefits scandal, in which Omtzigt had played a key role in uncovering wrongful fraud accusations against thousands of families, leading to the Rutte III cabinet's resignation on January 15, 2021.^[4]^[3] This contributed to a broader shift in political discourse toward demands for institutional accountability and rule-of-law reforms, as the manifesto's emphasis on rebuilding trust through transparent administration resonated amid revelations of bureaucratic overreach and political cover-ups.^[50] The scandal and subsequent manifesto fueled volatility in the March 17, 2021, general election, where voter disillusionment manifested in fragmented results: the ruling VVD retained the most seats at 34, but smaller parties gained ground, reflecting anti-establishment currents partly channeled by Omtzigt's independent stance after leaving the CDA.^[51] Public trust metrics deteriorated sharply pre- and post-election; surveys indicated a significant decline, with the Netherlands described as a "low-trust society" by September 2021 due to eroded confidence in government institutions handling citizen affairs.^[50] This erosion elevated discussions of administrative realism, with Omtzigt's proposals cited in debates on preventing future scandals through depoliticized civil service operations. In the caretaker period leading to the Fourth Rutte cabinet's formation in January 2022, the manifesto's critiques influenced targeted policy adjustments, including reforms to the benefits system to curb algorithmic biases and hasty fraud designations, as parliament—under pressure from cross-party inquiries—passed compensation schemes and oversight enhancements for the Tax and Customs Administration.^[52] Reactions spanned the spectrum: conservative voices commended the emphasis on welfare sustainability and legal limits to state intervention, while centrist figures incorporated elements of its citizenship-focused accountability into coalition negotiations; progressive critics, however, portrayed such reforms as insufficient diversions from deeper socioeconomic inequalities, prioritizing procedural fixes over redistributive measures.^[51] Overall, the work sustained momentum for evidence-based governance, evidenced by sustained parliamentary commissions into administrative ethics through 2022.^[53]

Criticisms and Controversies

Ideological Critiques

Right-leaning commentators have endorsed the manifesto's emphasis on curbing bureaucratic overreach, highlighting empirical evidence from administrative scandals like the toeslagenaffaire, where flawed algorithms and presumptions of fraud affected 25,000 to 35,000 families between 2012 and 2019, resulting in wrongful debt claims totaling billions of euros and widespread financial ruin.^[54]^[55] This case, which contributed to the Dutch government's resignation in January 2021, underscores the manifesto's argument that unchecked welfare administration often inflicts greater harm than the social risks it aims to mitigate, challenging assumptions of inherent state benevolence in redistribution.^[56] Left-leaning outlets have critiqued the manifesto for prioritizing procedural reforms over addressing structural power imbalances, such as socioeconomic disparities exacerbated by market dynamics, and for favoring incremental adjustments to existing institutions rather than pursuing expansive measures for economic equality.^[48] For instance, analyses argue that its focus on rule-bound governance neglects how entrenched hierarchies perpetuate inequality, opting instead for mild tweaks that preserve the status quo without redistributive ambition.^[48] From the right-wing fringe, the document has been faulted for insufficient rigor on migration and cultural assimilation, with critics contending that its rule-of-law emphasis dilutes demands for stricter border controls and integration mandates essential to preserving national cohesion.^[47] Such positions reflect broader ideological tensions, where the manifesto's moderation is seen as compromising on identity-preserving policies amid rising inflows—Netherlands net migration reached 140,000 in 2022—without commensurate cultural prerequisites.^[57] Counterarguments grounded in comparative evidence suggest that rule-focused administrative reforms can mitigate errors without state expansion; Denmark's digitalization strategy since 2016 has streamlined public services, reducing bureaucratic burdens by automating routine processes and achieving 99% citizen satisfaction with e-government while maintaining fiscal restraint.^[58]^[59] This model aligns with the manifesto's proposals, demonstrating that targeted digitization enhances accuracy—cutting processing errors in welfare claims—without necessitating broader ideological overhauls toward either radical equality or cultural retrenchment.^[60]

Practical and Implementation Challenges

The implementation of proposals outlined in A New Social Contract has encountered significant hurdles due to persistent Dutch political fragmentation and coalition instability following the 2021 elections. Despite the Nieuw Sociaal Contract (NSC) party's electoral success in November 2023, securing 20 seats, subsequent government formations repeatedly faltered, stalling reform agendas. For instance, NSC withdrew from coalition negotiations in February 2024 over unresolved issues like rule-of-law enhancements, contributing to delayed legislative progress. The Schoof cabinet, formed in July 2024, collapsed in June 2025 amid disputes over asylum policies, leaving a caretaker government unable to advance structural changes as of October 2025.^[61]^[62] Governance reforms, such as introducing "citizen charters" to formalize reciprocal obligations between state and individuals, have faced criticism for lacking precise, enforceable metrics. These charters aim to specify government service delivery timelines and citizen duties, but without binding judicial mechanisms or quantified benchmarks—unlike existing vague participation initiatives—experts argue they risk becoming symbolic rather than operational. Debates in parliamentary committees post-2023 highlighted enforceability gaps, with proposals for a national constitutional court to oversee compliance remaining unimplemented amid coalition vetoes from entrenched bureaucratic interests.^[63]^[64] Housing initiatives, emphasizing accelerated construction to address a shortage exceeding 400,000 units as of 2024, have been thwarted by localized Not-In-My-Backyard (NIMBY) opposition and regulatory barriers. Despite data underscoring urgency—average home prices surpassing €500,000 by mid-2025 and youth homeownership rates below 50%—municipal resistance to densification in greenbelt areas has delayed projects, as seen in stalled urban expansion plans in provinces like Noord-Holland. NSC's calls for streamlined permitting, including incentives for modular building, encountered pushback from environmental lobbies and homeowners prioritizing property values over supply increases.^[65]^[66]^[67] Efforts to overhaul bureaucracy, predicated on assuming cooperative civil service reforms, have been deemed naive amid recurrent scandals revealing systemic inertia. The 2022-2023 energy policy domain exemplified this: hasty transitions to renewables amid the Ukraine crisis led to grid overloads, soaring subsidies exceeding €20 billion, and blackouts in regions like Groningen, without adequate backups—issues Omtzigt had critiqued but which persisted due to departmental silos and union resistance to accountability measures. Critics, including fiscal watchdogs, contend that without deeper incentives like performance-based pay or depoliticization, entrenched interests perpetuate inefficiency, as evidenced by the childcare benefits scandal's lingering effects on trust.^[68]^[69]^[70] While these barriers have limited tangible outcomes, the manifesto's emphasis on causal accountability has empirically shifted discourse, prompting cross-party acknowledgments of veto-player dynamics in stalled agendas. However, the absence of aggressive fiscal retrenchment—such as mandatory spending caps tied to reform milestones—has fueled left-leaning narratives of inadequacy, allowing opponents to frame proposals as insufficiently transformative amid ballooning public debt ratios above 50% of GDP in 2024.^[71]^[72]

Legacy

Pieter Omtzigt, a former Christian Democratic Appeal (CDA) member known for exposing government scandals such as the childcare benefits affair, founded the Nieuw Sociaal Contract (NSC) party on August 20, 2023, drawing directly from principles outlined in his 2021 manifesto Een nieuw sociaal contract, which emphasized restoring trust in institutions through rule-of-law reforms and citizen-focused governance.^[73]^[74] The party's platform appealed to voters disillusioned with established parties, positioning NSC as an anti-elite alternative prioritizing administrative integrity over ideological extremes. In the snap general election of November 22, 2023, NSC secured 20 seats in the 150-seat House of Representatives, capturing approximately 15% of the vote amid widespread fragmentation following the collapse of the previous Rutte IV cabinet.^[75] This breakthrough reflected Omtzigt's personal popularity and the manifesto's resonance with demands for systemic accountability, enabling NSC to join negotiations for a new coalition. On July 2, 2024, NSC entered the Schoof I cabinet alongside the Party for Freedom (PVV), People's Party for Freedom and Democracy (VVD), and Farmer-Citizen Movement (BBB), with Omtzigt's party securing key portfolios in interior affairs and kingdom relations to advance governance transparency initiatives.^[76] ![Cover of "Een nieuw sociaal contract" manifesto][float-right] The party's early momentum stemmed from its critique of elite capture and promises of practical reforms, but coalition dynamics soon exposed execution challenges. By early 2025, persistent gridlock over migration, nitrogen emissions, and budget priorities eroded NSC's influence, with partial advances in governance legislation—such as enhanced parliamentary oversight mechanisms—contrasted by stalled progress on housing, where the cabinet's target of 100,000 annual new homes remained unmet due to regulatory hurdles and inter-party vetoes.^[77] Omtzigt's resignation as party leader on April 18, 2025, after 21 years in politics, was attributed to prolonged burnout from relentless advocacy against institutional opacity, further destabilizing NSC amid internal leadership vacuums.^[78]^[79] Subsequent events accelerated NSC's decline: the Schoof cabinet collapsed on June 3, 2025, primarily over PVV demands for stricter asylum policies, triggering a snap election for October 29, 2025.^[80] NSC ministers and state secretaries resigned en masse on August 23, 2025, leaving multiple portfolios vacant and underscoring the party's isolation in the fractured alliance.^[81] Polling by October 2025 showed NSC support below 5%, a sharp fall from its 2023 peak, as voters shifted toward PVV amid frustration with unfulfilled reform pledges and the manifesto's ideals clashing against realpolitik constraints like bureaucratic inertia and coalition compromises.^[82] This trajectory revealed gaps between NSC's causal emphasis on institutional fixes and the practical barriers of multipartisan governance, with limited delivery on core manifesto goals like accelerated housing amid ongoing shortages exceeding 400,000 units.^[83] Omtzigt's A New Social Contract extends classical social contract theory—rooted in thinkers like Hobbes and Locke, who emphasized consent for mutual protection—by incorporating empirical realities of contemporary bureaucratic states, where digital administration and welfare expansions have decoupled state actions from citizen oversight. The manifesto posits that reciprocity demands not only citizen compliance but verifiable state fulfillment of core duties, such as impartial rule enforcement and transparent decision-making, to counter detachment fostered by opaque algorithms and administrative overreach. This update critiques unchecked welfare growth, arguing it fosters "welfare cliffs" where incremental earnings trigger disproportionate benefit losses, yielding marginal effective tax rates over 70% in some Dutch cases and disincentivizing labor participation.^[84] Such distortions, Omtzigt contends, undermine the contract's legitimacy by prioritizing redistribution over productive incentives, as evidenced by stagnant workforce engagement amid rising entitlements.^[1] In practice, Dutch scandals like the 2013–2020 childcare benefits affair, involving algorithmic biases that wrongly labeled thousands of families as fraudulent, illustrate how state failures erode trust, with post-inquiry data showing institutional confidence hovering below 40% in key sectors.^[7] Omtzigt's framework insists on causal accountability—linking policy inputs to measurable outcomes like restored public faith—over virtue-oriented expansions that ignore precedent-based rule of law. This realism validates reciprocal duties as essential for modern legitimacy, contrasting with egalitarian ideals that expand entitlements without corresponding obligations, often amplified by media narratives downplaying incentive erosion. Post-COVID European discourse has paralleled this recalibration, with reports urging contracts attuned to trust deficits and technological disruptions rather than unchecked progressivism. In the Netherlands, sustained distrust—reflected in 2025 surveys where 59% viewed national direction negatively—affirms the manifesto's prescience, as unaddressed bureaucratic pathologies perpetuate cycles of grievance without empirical reforms.^[85] By foregrounding enforceable rights over symbolic policies, Omtzigt's contribution warns against contracts that neglect first-principles verification, potentially yielding fragile pacts vulnerable to populist backlash amid verifiable governance lapses.^[2]

References

[1]
Een Nieuw sociaal contract - Uitgeverij Prometheus
Omtzigt pleit vanuit zijn eigen ervaringen in de politiek voor een nieuw sociaal contract.
[2]
Waarom een 'Nieuw' Sociaal Contract? - Pieter Omtzigt
Sep 18, 2023 · Blokken om samen een nieuw sociaal contract mee op te bouwen. Dat contract gaat dus niet alleen over burgers en de overheid maar ook over grote ...
[3]
Dutch Rutte government resigns over child welfare fraud scandal
Jan 15, 2021 · The scandal began in 2012 and the number of parents involved could be as high as 26,000. Some openly called for the government to step down, ...
[4]
Dutch government resigns over child benefits scandal - The Guardian
Jan 15, 2021 · The Dutch government has resigned amid an escalating scandal over child benefits in which more than 20,000 families were wrongly accused of ...
[5]
Dutch scandal serves as a warning for Europe over risks of using ...
and critics say there is little stopping it ...
[6]
The Dutch childcare benefit scandal, institutional racism and ...
Jun 28, 2022 · So far, more than 1 000 children have been taken out of their homes and placed in state custody as a result of the accusations[2]. These numbers ...
[7]
Dutch childcare benefit scandal an urgent wake-up call to ban racist ...
Oct 25, 2021 · Tens of thousands of parents and caregivers from mostly low-income families were falsely accused of fraud by the Dutch tax authorities as a ...
[8]
https://www.borgenproject.org/the-childcare-benefits-scandal/
[9]
The Dutch government has been rocked by scandal. Why does its ...
Jan 22, 2021 · On 15 January, Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte was forced to resign after thousands of parents in the Netherlands were wrongly accused of benefit fraud.
[10]
Government in Netherlands Resigns After Benefit Scandal
Sep 30, 2021 · A parliamentary report concluded that tax authorities unfairly targeted poor families over child care benefits. Prime Minister Mark Rutte and ...<|separator|>
[11]
What the Dutch benefits scandal and policy's focus on 'fraud' can ...
Sep 28, 2024 · The benefits scandal led to the resignation of prime minister Mark Rutte's third cabinet in 2021. · Approximately 35,000 parents ( ...
[12]
Roof or real estate? An agent-based model of housing affordability ...
Dutch house prices increased sharply over 2015–2021. The official 2021 housing shortage of 279 thousand housing units (4 % of the housing stock) is double ...
[13]
Publish complaints about public services as open data (NL0051)
In the Netherlands, this led to a total of 30.775 complaints received by the Dutch National Ombudsman in 2019. ... With the complexity of bureaucracy continually ...Missing: 2015-2020 | Show results with:2015-2020
[14]
[PDF] Sustainable Governance in the Context of the COVID-19 Crisis
Due to the segregation of. Dutch education, in which children from lower socioeconomic and migration backgrounds are overrepresented in vocational education, ...
[15]
Gini Coefficient by Country 2025 - World Population Review
Netherlands Flag. Netherlands, 25.7, 2021. Ukraine Flag. Ukraine, 25.6, 2020 ... The Gini coefficient is essentially a measure of income inequality, with ...
[16]
Income inequality in the Netherlands is well below the EU average
Jul 3, 2024 · In 2022, income inequality according to the Gini coefficient was 0.285 in the Netherlands. Wealth inequality was much higher at 0.711, however. ...Missing: GDP | Show results with:GDP
[17]
Pieter Omtzigt quits the CDA after nearly 20 years as an MP
Jun 12, 2021 · Christian Democrat MP Pieter Omtzigt has resigned from the party, two days after a controversial document he wrote criticising the CDA was leaked to the media.Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[18]
Warning of corruption in Flight MH17 criminal case - The Irish Times
Dec 16, 2015 · Christian Democrat MP Pieter Omtzigt said: "There is very little actual evidence of who was responsible. Now we are finding that what there is ...<|separator|>
[19]
Corruption in Ukrainian secret service taints MH17 investigation
Dec 19, 2015 · “There is little actual evidence [in the investigation],” says Christian Democrat parliamentarian Pieter Omtzigt.
[20]
The Dutch Earthquake | Institute for New Economic Thinking
Nov 30, 2023 · The popularity of Pieter Omtzigt is largely due to his role in uncovering official wrongdoing in the childcare benefit scandal. Omzigt's new ...
[21]
Parliamentary committee of inquiry into Fraud Policy and Public ...
Feb 26, 2024 · The parliamentary committee of inquiry was mandated by the House of Representatives to investigate how the government combats fraud and what impact this has on ...Missing: Omtzigt biases<|separator|>
[22]
Christian Democracy: the Champion of Subsidiarity | Sphere of Politics
Subsidiarity is crucial to Christian Democracy, but under constant pressure. If the EU is to live up to the vision of its founders, Christian Democracy has ...
[23]
Een nieuw sociaal contract by Pieter Omtzigt - Goodreads
Feb 23, 2021 · Pieter Omtzigt laat zien dat er in Nederland grote problemen zijn met macht en tegenmacht. De mechanismen van de rechtsstaat functioneren niet ...Missing: motivations accountability
[24]
Pieter Omtzigt Een nieuw sociaal contract - Bibliotheek.nl
Pieter Omtzigt Een nieuw sociaal contract ... Bespreking door de CDA-politicus van verschillende politieke kwesties, waaronder de kinderopvangtoeslagenaffaire.
[25]
[PDF] BOOM 12379 parlementaire geschiedenis 2021 binnenwerk_BW.indd
Jan 17, 2025 · Renske Leijten (sp) en Pieter Omtzigt (cda) spreken met gedupeerden van de toeslagenaffaire ... 6 Pieter Omtzigt, Een nieuw sociaal contract. ( ...
[26]
Rousseau in vermomming - De Groene Amsterdammer
Nov 15, 2023 · Verschillende lokale afdelingen van het cda – de partij waar Omtzigt afscheid van nam – bepleitten een 'nieuw sociaal contract' voor hun stad.
[27]
Omtzigt schenkt opbrengst van zijn goedlopende boek aan de voedsel
Aug 15, 2023 · Uit het overzicht blijkt dat Omtzigt bijna 150.000 euro verdiende met de verkoop van zijn boek. Daarom werd hij maximaal gekort op zijn salaris.Missing: royalties | Show results with:royalties
[28]
Boek Pieter Omtzigt is na twee jaar plotseling weer een bestseller
Aug 30, 2023 · Eerder werd duidelijk dat Omtzigt bijna 150.000 euro heeft verdiend met de verkoop van het boek. Hij heeft dat bedrag opgegeven als ...Missing: royalties | Show results with:royalties
[29]
221 thousand children at risk of poverty, lowest number in 25 years
Dec 8, 2021 · 221 thousand minors in the Netherlands were living in low-income households, the lowest number in 25 years. This is equivalent to 6.9 percent of all children.Missing: persistent | Show results with:persistent
[30]
https://www.managementboek.nl/boek/9789044648058/een-nieuw-sociaal-contract-pieter-omtzigt
[31]
[PDF] Ongekend onrecht - Tweede Kamer
Dec 17, 2020 · Stel dat de. Belastingdienst bijvoorbeeld had gekozen voor 10%. De fout was €100 en de toeslag was €10.000, dan doen we er 10% van af. Je hebt ...
[32]
Een Nieuw Sociaal Contract
Pieter Omtzigt doet hiervoor vijf voorstellen: Een constitutioneel hof - met de bevoegdheid om wetten aan de Grondwet te toetsen (constitutionele toetsing) ...
[33]
Pieter Omtzigt dient initiatiefnota in voor constitutionele toetsing
Sep 9, 2024 · De initiatiefnota van Omtzigt omvat tien voorstellen ter verbetering van de constitutionele toetsing. Dit betreft het schrappen van artikel 120 ...
[34]
Nieuw sociaal contract - Pieter Omtzigt
Aug 19, 2021 · Het hele weefsel van de rechtsstaat moet worden onderzocht en gerepareerd. In dit boek doet Omtzigt een aantal voorstellen daartoe. Foto ...
[35]
Toeslagen terugbetalen | Rapport - Algemene Rekenkamer
Jun 13, 2019 · Voor het merendeel van de huishoudens (62%) die toeslagen moeten terugbetalen, gaat het om één terugvordering tegelijk. Maar daar tegenover ...Missing: 25% error rate
[36]
https://www.rekenkamer.nl/publicaties/kamerstukken/2020/02/13/toeslagen
[37]
[PDF] Werken zonder armoede - Sociaal-Economische Raad
Sep 10, 2021 · Gemiddelde marginale druk en 5- en 95-procentpercentielen in 2021 ... een hoge marginale belastingdruk voor mensen die zich opwerken van een mini-.
[38]
Bestaanszekerheid voor iedereen - Nieuw Sociaal Contract
Werken moet lonen, ouderen en jongeren moeten zekerheid hebben, en de menselijke maat moet terug in de overheid. ... Partijbureau Nieuw Sociaal Contract Grote ...
[39]
Dutch government plans new cut to expat tax break to collect €20 ...
Sep 4, 2025 · A plan to slash the tax break was pushed by Pieter Omtzigt, the politician who left the CDA to form his NSC party earlier that year. He ...
[40]
The Importance of a Natural Social Contract and Co-Evolutionary ...
Apr 22, 2025 · In the next section, such issues will be discussed further. 3. Quest for a New Social Contract. The duties and rights of citizens towards ...Missing: Pieter | Show results with:Pieter
[41]
Fewer welfare children for the first time since 2009 | Jeugdmonitor
Dec 3, 2018 · In 2016, 8 out of 10 native Dutch families on income support were single-parent families with a woman as the main breadwinner. This share was ...
[42]
CBS: Over 200.000 children in the Netherlands live at risk of poverty
Dec 2, 2022 · According to figures from the Dutch statistics office, 6,6 percent of children in the Netherlands are living at risk of poverty, ...Missing: cycles | Show results with:cycles
[43]
Excess demand set to drive eurozone house prices up, again | articles
Jul 2, 2024 · Nevertheless, according to ABF Research, it is estimated that the Dutch housing market is lacking some 390,000 homes to meet the number of home ...<|separator|>
[44]
[PDF] The Dutch Housing Crisis: increasing social unrest while the ...
The Netherlands faces a major shortage of housing, of 279,000 units in June 2021, which is expected to increase to 316,700 in 2024 (ABF Research, 2021). This ...
[45]
Pieter Omtzigt schreef het populairste politieke boek - NRC
Mar 8, 2021 · Het boek 'Een nieuw sociaal contract' van CDA-kamerlid Pieter Omtzigt is sinds zijn publicatie vorige maand achttienduizend keer verkocht, ...
[46]
https://www.boekenkrant.com/recensie/een-nieuw-sociaal-contract/
[47]
Waar blijft het inhoudelijke debat over 'Een nieuw sociaal contract ...
Sep 9, 2021 · Hier is Omtzigt, mijns inziens, niet concreet en scherp genoeg over in zijn boek. Burgerschapsvorming: Een nieuw sociaal contract tussen burgers ...
[48]
Het nieuwe sociaal contract van Pieter Omtzigt is vooral een wit ...
Jan 30, 2021 · Na het aftreden van het kabinet berichtte CDA-Kamerlid Pieter Omtzigt dat het tijd is voor een nieuw sociaal contract. In zijn beschouwing ...
[49]
CDA hoeft niet op terugkeer Omtzigt te rekenen: 'Boek is en blijft dicht'
Jul 29, 2023 · Pieter Omtzigt keert niet terug naar zijn oude partij, het CDA. Dat schrijft hij naar aanleiding van een bericht van het AD.
[50]
Declining trust in government: the low-trust society - Leiden University
Nov 1, 2021 · The Netherlands in September 2021 could be characterised as a low-trust society. Trust in the government has declined significantly in the ...Missing: opinion polls erosion Omtzigt<|control11|><|separator|>
[51]
Full article: The Dutch parliamentary elections of November 2023
Sep 11, 2024 · In the months prior to the elections, he was extremely popular: his 2021 book Een Nieuw Sociaal Contract (Omtzigt Citation2021) was number 1 on ...
[52]
[PDF] Dutch child benefit scandal: origin and latest developments
Trouw, Geen 30.000 euro voor bijna · helft gedupeerden in toeslagenaffaire. [No €30,000 for almost half of the victims in the allowance affair], 22-. 04-2021.Missing: explanation | Show results with:explanation
[53]
The Netherlands: Political Developments and Data in 2022 - OTJES
Apr 25, 2023 · The year 2022 was a period of contradictory developments in terms of political stability in the Netherlands.
[54]
In the Netherlands, a Discriminatory Algorithm has Impoverished ...
Dec 1, 2022 · Since 2012, 25,000 to 35,000 families could have been victims of this affair, product of a succession of failures of the state: presumption of ...
[55]
Childcare benefit report slams failings which ruined lives
Feb 26, 2024 · Some of the mistakes, it said, date back 20 years. MPs also failed because they voted in favour of bad laws and did not try to rectify problems.
[56]
Dutch benefits scandal - Museum of Failure
Oct 8, 2025 · The scandal, known as the Toeslagenaffaire, exposed a catastrophic failure of both technology and government. The scandal ultimately lead to ...Missing: administrative | Show results with:administrative
[57]
Recensie | Een nieuw sociaal contract - Public Affairs Academie
'Een nieuw sociaal contract' leest als een aanklacht tegen het systeem waar Omtzigt al bijna twintig jaar onderdeel is – en al twintig jaar ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary<|separator|>
[58]
[PDF] National Strategy for Digitalisation - together in the digital development
... digital solutions to reduce unnecessary bureaucracy and automate ... the Danish government is presenting its proposal for a new digital future for Denmark.
[59]
Denmark ranked as the world's top government for digitalisation
Sep 25, 2024 · Denmark has once again topped the United Nations E-Government Survey which assesses countries on the scope and quality of their online services.
[60]
How Denmark Became a Digital Government Global Leader - Queue-it
May 14, 2025 · It has the highest usage of digital services in the EU and some of the highest levels of citizen satisfaction with public services in the world.
[61]
Dutch elections: negotiations halted as Omtzigt's NSC pulls out
Feb 7, 2024 · Formation talks between election winner PVV, outgoing PM Rutte's VVD and newcomers BBB and NSC have stopped as Omtzigt's NSC pulls out.Missing: Nieuw Sociaal practical
[62]
Dutch gov't crisis deepens as NSC ministers step down - Xinhua
Aug 23, 2025 · The Dutch cabinet has been in a caretaker state since June 3, when the far-right Party for Freedom (PVV) withdrew over asylum policy. With NSC's ...Missing: stalled 2021
[63]
[PDF] The Netherlands Report - Sustainable Governance Indicators
Dec 17, 2024 · In 2022 and. 2023, ON! was formally accused by the NPO board of engaging in biased reporting and interviewing, thus violating rules of good ...
[64]
[PDF] Country Report: The Netherlands - Robert Bosch Stiftung
The outcome of the debate was that the government was called on 'to develop a charter for citizen participa- tion and to stimulate the use of citizens' forums ...Missing: enforceability | Show results with:enforceability
[65]
NSC wants to raise minimum wage, simplify taxes and build houses
Aug 18, 2025 · Centre-right party NSC has called for the minimum wage to be raised to €18 an hour and dental check-ups to be included in the basic health ...
[66]
How the Dutch created an Impossible Problem - YouTube
Jul 25, 2025 · The average price of a house, as of July 2025, is just over €500.000. The younger generations will likely never own a house in their own ...
[67]
NIMBYism vs Housing Shortage : r/Netherlands - Reddit
Dec 21, 2021 · Dutch redditors, if the government proposes to build skyscrapers in the area where you live, in order to alleviate the housing crisis, ...
[68]
Dutch parties vie for voters with no faith in government after string of ...
Nov 18, 2023 · A benefits fraud affair and claims of institutional racism are among issues that led to crisis of trust before this week's general election.Missing: bureaucracy reform
[69]
Gov't not "visibly solving Netherlands' core problems": Omtzigt as he ...
May 13, 2025 · Voters can't see that the government and others in national politics are focused on “solving the Netherlands' core problems,” former NSC ...Missing: 2022-2023 | Show results with:2022-2023
[70]
SGI 2022 | The Netherlands | Key Challenges
The SGI provide the most comprehensive survey of sustainable governance in 30 OECD and EU countries. Advocating the exchange of good practices, ...
[71]
The Netherlands: Political Developments and Data in 2024
Jun 4, 2025 · Following the 2023 national elections, the first half year of 2024 focused on negotiations between four parties from the centre-right to the ...
[72]
A new Dutch coalition: what are the policy plans? - Rabobank
May 31, 2024 · On 16 May the coalition parties PVV, VVD, NSC and BBB published their Outline Agreement ('Hoofdlijnenakkoord'). This document serves as the ...
[73]
Dutch Lawmaker Pieter Omtzigt Launches New Party - Bloomberg.com
Aug 20, 2023 · Independent Dutch lawmaker Pieter Omtzigt has launched his own political party but ruled out running for the prime minister post ahead of ...
[74]
Pieter Omtzigt launches new party, says he won't be PM
Aug 20, 2023 · Independent MP Pieter Omtzigt will take part in the November general election with his own party, the former CDA parliamentarian has announced.
[75]
Dutch election: Anti-Islam populist Geert Wilders wins dramatic victory
Nov 23, 2023 · The veteran politician says "we will govern" after his Freedom party doubles its seats in parliament.
[76]
Seasoned newcomers: the 16 ministers in Dick Schoof's cabinet
Jul 2, 2024 · The first new Dutch prime minister for almost 14 years takes office on Tuesday, heading a cabinet who are politically unknown quantities, ...
[77]
Short statement by Prime Minister Dick Schoof regarding the fall of ...
Jun 3, 2025 · Housing. Livelihood security. Public safety and national security. Migration. Nitrogen pollution. In the Framework Coalition Agreement 4 parties ...Missing: achievements failures 2024
[78]
NSC leader Pieter Omtzigt quits politics, citing toll on health
Apr 18, 2025 · Pieter Omtzigt has announced he is to quit national politics and step down as leader of the party he founded less than two years ago, Nieuw Sociaal Contract.
[79]
NSC leader Pieter Omtzigt quits national politics for good, citing ...
Apr 18, 2025 · NSC founder and party leader Pieter Omtzigt announced on Friday that he is resigning from national politics after having served in government for 21 years.
[80]
Dutch PM calls election after coalition collapse – DW – 06/03/2025
Jun 3, 2025 · The Netherlands is heading for a new election after far-right firebrand Geert Wilders' party quit the coalition over an immigration policy ...Missing: achievements failures housing
[81]
Resignation of New Social Contract (NSC) ministers and state ...
Aug 23, 2025 · Resignation of New Social Contract (NSC) ministers and state secretaries · Eddy van Hijum, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Social Affairs ...Missing: party stalled post- 2021
[82]
https://www.reuters.com/world/dutch-election-what-you-need-know-2025-10-23/
[83]
The fall of the Dutch government – that took longer than expected
Jun 19, 2025 · On 3 June, the Dutch government collapsed. Geert Wilders, leader of the far-right Party for Freedom (PVV), walked out of the four-party coalition over a ...Missing: achievements failures 2024 housing
[84]
Traditional income support policies: The "welfare cliff" - ResearchGate
Presenting contributions from Dutch and international researchers, this book provides scientific answers to the question of whether a UBI is desirable and ...
[85]
https://nltimes.nl/2025/10/20/survey-59-dutch-believe-country-going-wrong-direction

A New Social Contract