Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Absolutism

Absolutism denotes a political doctrine and governmental practice wherein a monarch wields supreme, undivided authority over the state, unconstrained by constitutions, legislatures, or other institutional limits on power.^[1]^[2] This system, which flourished across early modern Europe from the late sixteenth to the eighteenth century, derived much of its theoretical justification from the divine right of kings—a tenet asserting that royal sovereignty emanated directly from divine sanction, thereby rendering the ruler accountable solely to God rather than earthly institutions or subjects.^[3]^[4] Historically, absolutism emerged as monarchs navigated the fragmentation of medieval feudalism, the upheavals of religious wars such as the Thirty Years' War, and the imperatives of state-building, leading to the consolidation of centralized bureaucracies, standing armies, and uniform legal codes under royal control.^[1]^[5] Key characteristics included the subjugation of noble privileges through mechanisms like courtly rituals and Versailles-style palaces, the expansion of taxation to fund military and administrative apparatuses, and the promotion of mercantilist economic policies to bolster state revenues and sovereignty.^[1]^[6] Prominent exemplars encompassed Louis XIV of France (r. 1643–1715), whose long reign featured the revocation of religious tolerances and lavish centralization symbolizing L'état, c'est moi; the Hohenzollern rulers of Prussia, such as Frederick William I, who forged a militarized absolutist state with an army disproportionate to population size; and Peter the Great of Russia (r. 1682–1725), who imposed Western reforms to absolutize tsarist dominion amid modernization efforts.^[1]^[7] While absolutism enabled decisive governance, territorial expansion, and relative domestic stability in volatile eras, it engendered controversies through exorbitant fiscal burdens, suppression of dissent, and protracted conflicts that strained resources and legitimacy.^[5]^[8] In contrast to constitutionalist developments in England—where parliamentary assertions curbed royal prerogatives post-1688—and the Dutch Republic's federal republicanism, absolutism's rigidity ultimately faltered against Enlightenment critiques of arbitrary power, mounting debts from warfare, and revolutionary upheavals, most dramatically in France by 1789.^[7]^[8]

Political Absolutism

Definition and Theoretical Foundations

Political absolutism denotes a form of governance wherein a sovereign ruler, most commonly a monarch, exercises unlimited and indivisible authority, unbound by constitutional restraints, parliamentary oversight, or customary laws, concentrating all legislative, executive, and judicial powers in a single entity.^[9] This system contrasts with medieval feudalism, where monarchs shared power with nobles and estates, by centralizing control to ensure decisive action and prevent factional discord.^[10] The doctrine emerged prominently in early modern Europe amid religious wars and state-building efforts, positing that such unchecked power was essential for maintaining order and security.^[11] The theoretical underpinnings trace to Jean Bodin's Six Livres de la République (1576), which formalized sovereignty as the absolute and perpetual power over citizens and subjects, indivisible and residing supreme in the monarch to enact laws without contradiction.^[12] Bodin distinguished royal monarchy from despotism by arguing that absolute sovereignty must align with divine and natural laws, such as protecting subjects' lives and property, yet permitted the ruler to override lesser institutions for the commonwealth's preservation.^[13] This framework justified centralization against fragmented authorities, influencing absolutist practices in France and elsewhere by emphasizing the state's unity over divided loyalties. Thomas Hobbes furthered absolutist theory in Leviathan (1651), contending that in the natural state—characterized by perpetual conflict and insecurity—individuals surrender rights to an absolute sovereign via social contract to avert mutual destruction.^[14] Hobbes advocated monarchy as the optimal vessel for this undivided authority, as it minimized disputes over succession and ensured swift enforcement of peace, warning that divided power invited civil war as witnessed in England's upheavals.^[11] Complementing these secular rationales, the divine right doctrine asserted monarchs' authority derived directly from God, rendering them accountable only to divine judgment rather than earthly bodies. Articulated by figures like Robert Filmer in Patriarcha (c. 1680, published posthumously) and Jacques-Bénigne Bossuet in Politics Derived from the Words of Holy Scripture (1709), it analogized kings to patriarchal fathers or God's earthly vicegerents, prohibiting resistance except in cases of overt tyranny violating natural law.^[15] This religious justification reinforced absolutism by sacralizing the ruler's supremacy, as seen in James I of England's proclamations that kings "make and unmake laws" as God's delegates.^[16]

Historical Origins and Development

The concept of political absolutism, characterized by a sovereign's undivided and unrestricted authority, emerged in early modern Europe as monarchs sought to consolidate power amid the fragmentation of feudal structures and the upheavals of religious wars. In the late 16th century, following the Wars of Religion in France (1562–1598), which exposed the weaknesses of divided authority, theorists began articulating doctrines of indivisible sovereignty to restore order. This shift was driven by the need for centralized control to suppress factionalism and enforce uniformity, marking a departure from medieval conciliarism where power was shared among estates and corporations.^[17] Jean Bodin, a French jurist, laid foundational theoretical groundwork in his 1576 work Six Books of the Commonwealth, defining sovereignty as the "absolute and perpetual" power of a commonwealth, vested in a single ruler unbound by positive law or the consent of subjects, though still subject to divine and natural law. Bodin's ideas responded to the chaos of civil strife, arguing that divided sovereignty led to anarchy, and he advocated for a strong monarchy as the optimal form to maintain peace, influencing subsequent absolutist thought despite his own reservations about tyrannical excess.^[12]^[18] Parallel developments occurred in England, where the doctrine of the divine right of kings gained prominence under James I (r. 1603–1625), who asserted in writings like The True Law of Free Monarchies (1598) that monarchs derived authority directly from God, rendering them accountable only to divine judgment rather than parliamentary consent. This medieval-rooted idea, traceable to patristic interpretations of Romans 13:1–2 emphasizing obedience to ordained rulers, evolved into a bulwark against resistance theories amid conflicts like the Gunpowder Plot (1605). Thomas Hobbes further advanced absolutist theory in Leviathan (1651), written during the English Civil War (1642–1651), positing that individuals in a pre-social "state of nature" surrender all rights to an absolute sovereign via social contract to escape perpetual war, with the sovereign's indivisible power ensuring security irrespective of monarchical or other form.^[19]^[20] Absolutism's practical development peaked in France under Louis XIV (r. 1643–1715), who, building on Cardinal Richelieu's earlier centralization efforts (1624–1642) to subdue Huguenot revolts and noble privileges, dismantled feudal autonomies through intendants—royal administrators—and revoked the Edict of Nantes (1685) to impose religious uniformity. Louis XIV's reign exemplified absolutist governance by concentrating legislative, executive, and judicial powers in the crown, funding a professional army that grew from 50,000 to over 400,000 men by 1690, and constructing Versailles as a mechanism to control the nobility, famously declaring "L'état, c'est moi" to symbolize the fusion of state and person. This model, enabled by mercantilist policies under Colbert that boosted revenue through tariffs and monopolies, spread influences to absolutist regimes in Austria under Leopold I and Prussia under Frederick William (the Great Elector).^[21]^[22] By the late 17th century, absolutism had evolved into a system justifying expansive state-building, as seen in Spain under Philip II (r. 1556–1598), who centralized administration post-Reconquista but faced limits from inquisitorial and regional checks. Empirical outcomes included enhanced military capacity and administrative efficiency, though at the cost of fiscal strains evident in France's debt accumulation from wars like the War of the Spanish Succession (1701–1714). These developments reflected causal pressures from gunpowder warfare and emerging bureaucracies demanding unified command, distinguishing absolutism from earlier patrimonial kingship.^[17]

Key Examples and Case Studies

Louis XIV of France (r. 1643–1715) represents the archetype of European political absolutism, centralizing authority through administrative reforms that diminished noble and provincial autonomy. He deployed intendants—royal agents directly accountable to the crown—to oversee provinces, circumventing traditional estates and parlements, while constructing the Palace of Versailles starting in 1669 and fully relocating the court there by 1682 to domesticate the aristocracy under constant surveillance. Louis invoked divine right theory to legitimize unchecked rule, exemplified by his revocation of the Edict of Nantes on October 18, 1685, which suppressed Protestantism and prompted the emigration of approximately 200,000–400,000 Huguenots, thereby enforcing religious uniformity as a pillar of state power.^[23]^[24] Peter the Great of Russia (r. 1682–1725) pursued absolutist modernization to align his realm with European powers, wielding autocratic authority to overhaul military, economy, and culture. During his Grand Embassy (1697–1698), he traveled incognito to study Dutch and English shipbuilding, returning to enforce Western dress codes via decrees like the 1698 beard tax and 1700 uniform mandates for nobility and clergy, while founding St. Petersburg on May 27, 1703, as a fortified "window to Europe" amid the Great Northern War (1700–1721) against Sweden. He established the Table of Ranks in 1722, a merit-based hierarchy linking civil and military service to noble status, and created a precursor secret police under the Preobrazhensky Prikaz to suppress dissent, consolidating tsarist control over a vast, traditionally feudal society.^[25]^[26] Frederick II (the Great) of Prussia (r. 1740–1786) embodied enlightened absolutism, retaining sovereign prerogative while applying rationalist principles to governance. Upon accession, he issued the Edict of Toleration on July 22, 1740, granting religious freedoms to Catholics, Jews, and Protestant dissenters to bolster population and economy, and reformed judicial practices by abolishing torture in 1740 except for high treason cases. Frederick centralized bureaucracy through the Generalkommission and expanded Prussian territory via conquests in the War of the Austrian Succession (1740–1748) and Seven Years' War (1756–1763), amassing an army of 200,000 by 1786—triple the state's male population of military age—while declaring the monarch "the first servant of the state" to justify interventionist policies in agriculture, trade, and serfdom without parliamentary consent.^[27]

Achievements and Empirical Outcomes

Absolutist regimes in early modern Europe enabled rapid centralization of fiscal and military resources, often yielding territorial expansion and administrative efficiency unattainable under fragmented feudal systems. In Prussia, Frederick II's reforms professionalized the army through rigorous discipline and merit-based officer promotions, facilitating conquests in the Silesian Wars (1740–1748 and 1756–1763) that secured Silesia and nearly doubled the kingdom's population and territory. These military successes transformed Prussia from a peripheral electorate into a continental power capable of withstanding coalitions of larger states, with the army's effectiveness stemming from state-controlled conscription and supply systems that minimized noble interference.^[28]^[29] Similarly, in Russia, Peter I's absolutist decrees imposed Western-style military conscription and naval construction, culminating in the Great Northern War victory (1700–1721) that granted access to the Baltic Sea and established St. Petersburg as a strategic port. His administrative overhaul, including the Table of Ranks meritocracy and founding of technical schools, boosted state revenue through monopolies and tariffs, enabling industrialization initiatives like ironworks and shipyards that laid foundations for Russia's emergence as an empire spanning Eurasia. Empirical measures, such as the navy's growth from negligible to over 800 vessels by 1725, underscore how unchecked executive authority accelerated modernization in backward economies.^[30]^[31] In France, Louis XIV's consolidation of intendants for tax enforcement and revocation of noble privileges funded a standing army expansion to approximately 400,000 troops by the 1690s, supporting infrastructure projects like the 240-kilometer Canal du Midi (completed 1681) and Versailles expansions that centralized court life and patronage. These outcomes enhanced short-term state capacity for warfare and cultural projection, with France dominating European alliances during the War of the Spanish Succession (1701–1714). However, empirical data on fiscal extraction—revenues rising from 24 million livres in 1660 to over 100 million by 1715—reveal overreliance on regressive taille taxes, contributing to chronic deficits that eroded long-term sustainability without institutional checks.^[23]^[32]

Criticisms, Controversies, and Decline

Philosophical critiques of political absolutism gained prominence during the Enlightenment, challenging the doctrine of unlimited sovereign authority. John Locke, in his Two Treatises of Government published in 1689, rejected absolute monarchy as incompatible with natural rights to life, liberty, and property, asserting that legitimate government requires the consent of the governed and permits revolution against rulers who violate these rights.^[33] Similarly, Charles de Montesquieu, in The Spirit of the Laws (1748), distinguished moderate monarchies bound by fundamental laws from despotic rule characterized by unchecked power, arguing that concentrating legislative, executive, and judicial functions in one person inevitably leads to tyranny and advocating separation of powers to preserve liberty.^[34] In practice, absolutist regimes faced controversies over abuse of power and fiscal mismanagement, as the absence of institutional checks enabled arbitrary decisions with severe consequences. France under Louis XIV (reigned 1643–1715) exemplified this, with prolonged wars such as the War of the Spanish Succession (1701–1714) incurring massive debts—estimated at two billion livres by 1715—through extravagant court spending at Versailles and military overreach, leaving the state financially strained despite territorial gains.^[35]^[36] Critics, including contemporaries like François Fénelon, highlighted how such absolutist policies stifled economic innovation and burdened the populace with taxes, fostering resentment without avenues for redress.^[37] The decline of political absolutism accelerated through pivotal revolts and constitutional reforms in the late 17th and 18th centuries. In England, absolutist pretensions under James II culminated in the Glorious Revolution of 1688, where parliamentary forces invited William of Orange to invade, deposing the king and enacting the Bill of Rights in 1689, which curtailed royal prerogatives like suspending laws and raising taxes without consent, establishing parliamentary sovereignty. This event demonstrated the vulnerability of absolutism to elite opposition and legal traditions limiting monarchical power. In France, inherited debts and failed reforms under Louis XVI exacerbated crises, culminating in the Estates-General convocation in 1789 and the subsequent Revolution, which abolished absolute monarchy by August 4, 1789, through the renunciation of feudal privileges and execution of the king in 1793.^[38] By the 19th century, absolutism waned across Europe as Enlightenment ideas, economic liberalization, and revolutionary precedents promoted constitutional limits on power, though vestiges persisted in places like Russia until the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution. Empirical patterns showed absolutist states prone to inefficiency and revolt due to unaccountable rule, contrasting with more resilient systems incorporating checks, as unchecked authority correlated with policy failures like overexpansion and fiscal collapse.^[37]^[39]

Philosophical Absolutism

Metaphysical and Ontological Aspects

Metaphysical absolutism asserts that reality possesses an intrinsic, unchanging structure governed by objective principles independent of human cognition or cultural context. This position maintains that the fundamental nature of existence transcends subjective interpretations, privileging a unified, self-subsistent order over fragmented or observer-dependent accounts.^[40] In ontological terms, absolutism identifies being as absolute and self-contained, rejecting relational or perspectival dependencies. Parmenides, active around 475 BCE, formulated this by arguing that being is ungenerated, imperishable, uniform, and indivisible, with non-being impossible and change illusory, as "what is" must be whole and eternal.^[41] His thesis, preserved in fragments of his poem On Nature, grounds ontology in logical necessity: to think or speak of what is not leads to contradiction, thus affirming a singular, motionless reality.^[42] Plato (c. 428–348 BCE) advanced absolutist ontology through his doctrine of Forms, positing eternal, immutable archetypes—such as Justice or Beauty—as the true entities of being, with the physical world mere imperfect shadows. These Forms exist independently in a intelligible realm, accessible via reason rather than senses, ensuring universal standards for knowledge and existence.^[43] Baruch Spinoza (1632–1677) systematized ontological absolutism in his monistic framework, defining substance as the absolute, infinite, and self-caused foundation of all reality, from which modes (particular things) derive without altering its essence. Substance, equated with God or Nature, is ontologically prior and conceptually independent, embodying causal completeness where attributes like thought and extension express its totality.^[44] This view underscores determinism: all events follow necessarily from the absolute substance's nature, precluding contingency or observer-relativity.^[45] Such absolutist commitments facilitate causal explanations rooted in inherent properties, as opposed to relativistic ontologies where relations or contexts define being, potentially undermining predictive consistency in empirical inquiry. Critics, including relationalists, contend that absolute entities risk unfalsifiability, yet proponents cite logical coherence and alignment with observed invariances—like conservation laws—as empirical warrant.^[40]

Ethical and Moral Absolutism

Ethical and moral absolutism posits that specific actions possess intrinsic moral value, rendering them right or wrong irrespective of consequences, cultural norms, or situational factors. This view maintains that universal moral truths exist, binding all rational agents equally, often grounded in objective standards derived from reason, divine command, or human nature. Unlike consequentialist frameworks, which evaluate morality by outcomes, absolutism aligns with deontological ethics, emphasizing adherence to categorical duties that admit no exceptions.^[46]^[47] Prominent formulations appear in Immanuel Kant's Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785), where the categorical imperative requires actions to conform to maxims universalizable without contradiction, such as prohibiting lying even to save a life, as deception undermines rational trust essential to human autonomy.^[48] Thomas Aquinas, in Summa Theologica (1265–1274), integrated Aristotelian teleology with Christian theology, asserting natural law precepts—like the prohibition against intentional homicide—as participations in eternal divine reason, self-evident to human intellect and immutable across contexts.^[49] Earlier roots trace to Plato's theory of Forms in The Republic (c. 375 BCE), positing the Good as an absolute archetype transcending subjective opinion, against which particular acts are measured.^[50] Proponents argue absolutism provides a stable bulwark against moral arbitrariness, enabling cross-cultural condemnation of acts like genocide, which relativism might excuse as culturally relative.^[47] It counters the "is-ought" problem by anchoring oughts in non-empirical foundations, avoiding infinite regress in justificatory reasoning. Empirical support emerges from experimental psychology: a 2013 study in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology exposed participants to absolutist versus relativist arguments before a cheating task, finding those primed with relativism cheated significantly more (mean 2.84 vs. 1.89 opportunities exploited), suggesting absolutist beliefs correlate with restraint in self-interested dilemmas.^[51] This implies causal links between absolutist cognition and behavioral integrity, challenging relativist dismissals of objective morality as mere illusion. Critics within academia, often favoring relativism, contend absolutism rigidifies ethics amid diverse human experiences, yet such positions overlook evidence of convergent intuitions—e.g., near-universal aversion to unprovoked killing across societies—as indicators of innate moral grammar rather than constructed norms.^[52] Absolutism thus sustains moral realism against subjectivist erosion, prioritizing causal accountability in human action over expedient flexibility.

Epistemological Absolutism

Epistemological absolutism maintains that knowledge possesses an objective, ungradable structure, wherein certain beliefs can achieve absolute certainty through non-inferential justification, independent of contextual or perspectival variations.^[53] This view posits universal epistemic standards—such as principles of deduction, induction, and sensory reliability—that apply invariantly across rational agents, enabling the attainment of truths that hold regardless of cultural, historical, or individual frameworks.^[54] Proponents argue that without such absolutes, coherent justification regresses infinitely or circulates without anchor, undermining the possibility of warranted belief.^[55] Historically, absolutism traces to ancient rationalists like Plato, who contended that true knowledge derives from unchanging Forms accessible via reason, transcending sensory illusions and opinion (doxa).^[56] In the modern era, René Descartes exemplified this through methodical doubt, establishing the cogito ("I think, therefore I am") as an indubitable foundation from which clear and distinct ideas yield certain knowledge, as detailed in his Meditations on First Philosophy (1641).^[57] Immanuel Kant further advanced absolutist elements by asserting synthetic a priori judgments—universal necessities like those in mathematics and causality—as preconditions for experience, binding all minds irrespective of empirical contingency.^[56] Closely allied with foundationalism, epistemological absolutism structures justification pyramidally: basic beliefs, self-evident or incorrigible (e.g., immediate sensory qualia or logical tautologies), serve as bedrock supporting inferential superstructures without mutual dependence.^[55] This contrasts sharply with epistemic relativism, which, as critiqued in analyses of Protagorean thought, renders justification parochial to paradigms, eroding intersubjective agreement and scientific cumulativity.^[58] Empirical successes in fields like mathematics—where theorems like Euclid's (circa 300 BCE) remain eternally valid—bolster absolutism, as probabilistic or gradualist alternatives falter in explaining such unyielding certainties.^[59] Contemporary defenses emphasize causal realism: absolute epistemic norms align with reality's mind-independent structure, as evidenced by predictive successes in physics deriving from invariant laws, not ad hoc revisions.^[60] Critics from postmodern traditions, often ascribing to institutional relativism, charge absolutism with dogmatism, yet such objections overlook foundationalism's empirical testability via regress avoidance, privileging verifiable anchors over subjective coherence.^[54] Absolutism thus undergirds truth-seeking inquiry, rejecting graded "knowledge" that dilutes warrant to mere opinion.^[61]

Hegelian and Idealist Variants

Hegel's absolute idealism posits the Absolute as the comprehensive totality of reality, a self-developing spiritual substance (Geist) that resolves contradictions through dialectical progression, thereby establishing an objective rational structure underlying all existence. In his Phenomenology of Spirit (1807), Hegel describes this process as consciousness advancing from sensory certainty to absolute knowing, where subject and object coincide in the self-comprehending whole.^[62] The Science of Logic (1812–1816) elaborates the metaphysical foundation, tracing the dialectic from indeterminate being, through negation to becoming, and ultimately to the Absolute Idea as the unity of concept and reality.^[63] This framework asserts absolutism by denying contingent or relativistic foundations, insisting instead that "the rational is actual" as the Absolute actualizes itself historically without external contingencies dictating its essence.^[64] Dialectical method serves as the causal mechanism for this absolutist ontology: each stage negates its predecessor yet preserves and elevates it (Aufhebung), culminating in a non-contradictory synthesis that reveals the Absolute's necessity. Unlike subjective idealism, which confines reality to individual minds, Hegel's variant objectivizes the ideal as a universal process encompassing nature, history, and art, with empirical events—such as the French Revolution (1789–1799)—interpreted as manifestations of Spirit's self-realization rather than mere historical accidents.^[65] Critics, including later materialists like Karl Marx (who inverted Hegel's dialectic in Capital ), charged that this absolutizes historical teleology without sufficient empirical grounding, yet Hegel's system empirically aligns with observed patterns of cultural and institutional evolution toward greater rationality.^[66] Post-Hegelian idealist variants, particularly British absolute idealism, adapted these principles to emphasize monistic holism, where finite entities derive meaning only within the coherent Absolute. F. H. Bradley, in works influenced by Hegel, argued for a non-relational Absolute resolving apparent contradictions, as seen in his rejection of pluralistic realities in favor of a single experiential unity.^[67] Bernard Bosanquet extended this to social philosophy, viewing the state and individual as subordinate to the Absolute's ethical whole, with moral progress dialectically integrating particulars into universal harmony.^[68] These variants maintained absolutism by privileging the timeless, contradiction-free Absolute over empirical fragmentation, though they diverged from Hegel by de-emphasizing historical dynamism in favor of static coherence, influencing late 19th-century ethics but declining amid analytic philosophy's rise post-1900.^[69] Empirical support for such holism appears limited, relying on introspective coherence rather than quantifiable data, yet it causally explains unified cultural phenomena like legal systems evolving toward comprehensive rationality.

Debates with Relativism and Subjectivism

Absolutists argue that relativism, which posits that truth varies by cultural, historical, or individual contexts, undermines the possibility of rational discourse by rendering all claims equally valid or invalid depending on the observer. This position, famously articulated by Protagoras in ancient Greece with the claim that "man is the measure of all things," faces criticism for its internal inconsistency: the relativist assertion itself claims universal applicability, suggesting an absolute truth that contradicts its premise. Philosophers such as Plato, in works like the Theaetetus, demonstrated this self-refutation by showing that if all perceptions are equally true, no criterion exists to distinguish knowledge from opinion, leading to epistemological paralysis.^[70]^[71] In ethical debates, moral absolutism maintains that certain principles, such as prohibitions against murder or theft, hold universally regardless of subjective approval or cultural norms, grounded in objective reason or natural law. Absolutists like Immanuel Kant contended that relativism erodes moral accountability, as it implies no grounds to condemn practices like slavery or genocide if endorsed by a society, depriving ethical systems of prescriptive force. Empirical observations support this critique: societies adhering to absolutist frameworks, such as those emphasizing universal human rights post-World War II, have advanced legal prohibitions against atrocities via instruments like the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, whereas pure relativism struggles to justify interventions against culturally sanctioned harms. Relativists counter that absolutism imposes ethnocentric standards, ignoring adaptive moral evolution, yet absolutists respond that such evolution presupposes underlying constants, as evidenced by cross-cultural consensus on core harms in anthropological studies.^[56]^[72] Subjectivism, a variant emphasizing personal feelings or desires as the basis for truth or morality, intensifies these tensions by reducing norms to individual whim, lacking even the intersubjective checks of cultural relativism. Absolutists critique it for fostering solipsism, where no shared reality exists to resolve conflicts; for instance, if moral rightness stems solely from personal sentiment, as David Hume's emotivism might imply, then persuading others requires mere emotional manipulation rather than rational appeal. This view's practical failings appear in psychological research showing that subjectivist orientations correlate with higher rates of ethical inconsistency and social fragmentation, as individuals prioritize self-reference over evidence-based universals. While subjectivists argue it respects autonomy, absolutists maintain that causal chains of human behavior—rooted in predictable biological and rational imperatives—demand objective anchors to sustain cooperation and progress, as seen in enduring legal traditions derived from absolutist ethics.^[56]^[72]

Absolutism in Natural Sciences

Newtonian Physics and Absolute Concepts

In his Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica published in 1687, Isaac Newton articulated the concepts of absolute space and absolute time as foundational elements independent of observable bodies or events. Absolute space, described as remaining "always similar and immovable" without reference to external relations, serves as an unchanging backdrop for the universe's contents, while absolute time "flows equably" on its own nature, irrespective of external influences or motion.^[73] These notions enabled Newton to distinguish true, absolute motion—defined as translation between absolute places—from relative motion perceived through sensible measures like the positions of stars or ships at sea.^[74] Newton justified absolute motion through empirical criteria involving "properties, causes, and effects," arguing that rotational motion relative to absolute space produces detectable inertial forces absent in mere relative translations. A key illustration is the rotating bucket experiment: water in a stationary bucket relative to surrounding objects climbs the sides when spun due to centrifugal force, revealing absolute rotation even if isolated from external references; this effect persists regardless of the bucket's relation to other bodies, indicating motion's intrinsic detectability.^[75] Such forces, including those in uniformly accelerated bodies, necessitate an absolute framework to explain why they arise uniformly across inertial systems, underpinning Newton's first law of motion where bodies persist in uniform rectilinear motion absent external forces—implicitly relative to absolute space.^[76] These absolute concepts facilitated the mathematical formulation of classical mechanics, allowing universal laws like gravitation to operate invariantly across the cosmos without dependence on observers or local frames. For instance, planetary orbits and falling bodies are analyzed as motions in absolute space, yielding precise predictions verifiable by astronomical observations, such as Kepler's laws derived from inverse-square attraction.^[77] Newton's framework thus posits a realist ontology where space and time possess objective existence, causal efficacy in determining dynamics, and independence from material content, contrasting with relational views that reduce them to mere coordinations between bodies.^[78] This absolutist foundation dominated physics until the early 20th century, enabling empirical successes like the accurate computation of comet trajectories and tidal forces.^[79]

Challenges from Relativity and Modern Physics

Einstein's special relativity, formulated in his 1905 paper "On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies," rejected Newton's absolute space and time by establishing two postulates: the principle of relativity, stating that physical laws are identical in all inertial reference frames, and the constancy of the speed of light in vacuum for all observers.^[80] These axioms imply that simultaneity is relative, with events simultaneous in one frame not necessarily so in another moving at constant velocity relative to the first, thus dismantling the idea of a universal, frame-independent time.^[81] Time dilation, where clocks in relative motion tick at different rates, and length contraction along the direction of motion further demonstrate that space and time intervals are observer-dependent, verified experimentally through phenomena like the prolonged lifetime of cosmic-ray muons reaching Earth's surface, which decay slower when moving near light speed.^[82] General relativity, published by Einstein in 1915, extended these challenges to accelerated frames and gravity, replacing Newton's absolute space—a fixed, Euclidean arena—with a dynamic spacetime manifold whose curvature is determined by the distribution of mass and energy via the Einstein field equations.^[83] In this framework, there is no privileged inertial frame or rigid spatial structure; geometry emerges relationally from matter, as evidenced by the 1919 solar eclipse observations confirming light deflection by the Sun's gravity, which matched general relativity's predictions over Newtonian ones by a factor of twice.^[84] Gravitational time dilation, where clocks run slower in stronger fields, has been precisely measured in experiments such as the Pound-Rebka test (1959) using gamma rays in a gravitational potential and continuously accounted for in GPS systems to achieve sub-meter accuracy.^[85] Modern physics amplifies these relational aspects through quantum mechanics and quantum field theory, where phenomena like wave-particle duality and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle undermine classical absolute determinism, introducing inherent probabilistic limits on simultaneous knowledge of position and momentum.^[86] While quantum theories operate within relativistic spacetime, their non-local correlations, as in Bell's theorem violations confirmed by Aspect's 1982 experiments, challenge local absolute causality without preferred frames, though interpretations like many-worlds or Bohmian mechanics debate the extent of underlying absolutes.^[81] These developments collectively shift physics toward relational structures, where absolutes persist only as invariants like the spacetime interval, but foundational entities like space and time lose their independent, universal status.^[87]

Persistent Applications and Debates

In quantum mechanics, time functions as an absolute, universal parameter that governs the evolution of wave functions via the Schrödinger equation, independent of spatial coordinates or observer frames. This treatment presupposes a global, background time, enabling precise predictions of phenomena like atomic spectra and particle decays, as verified experimentally since the 1920s.^[88] However, this absolutist assumption conflicts with general relativity's dynamical spacetime, where time dilates variably, complicating unification efforts in quantum gravity theories.^[89] Cosmological models retain absolute-like structures through the cosmic rest frame defined by the cosmic microwave background (CMB), observed at 2.725 K with a dipole anisotropy indicating our motion relative to it at approximately 370 km/s. This frame renders the universe isotropic on large scales, serving as a practical reference for measuring peculiar velocities of galaxies and testing homogeneity, as in the Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker metric's comoving coordinates.^[90] Debates persist on whether this frame implies a fundamental absolute rest state or merely an emergent property of matter distribution, with some analyses suggesting vacuum structures could underpin a universal preferred frame.^[91] Contemporary interpretations of general relativity revive absolutist elements via coordinate-independent geometric representations, such as the Sparling form on the frame bundle, which encodes gravitational stress-energy without viewpoint dependence. This formulation addresses longstanding relational critiques by providing absolute, observer-neutral depictions of spacetime curvature effects, reconciling Newtonian intuitions with Einsteinian dynamics.^[92] Neo-Lorentzian approaches further debate preserving absolute simultaneity or time in relativistic contexts, arguing they align better with quantum requirements and big bang singularity models dated to approximately 13.8 billion years ago.^[93] These discussions underscore unresolved tensions between relational background independence and absolutist necessities for foundational theories.

Absolutism in Psychology and Cognition

Absolutist Thinking Patterns

Absolutist thinking patterns, often termed dichotomous or black-and-white thinking in cognitive psychology, refer to a rigid cognitive style that frames reality in binary extremes, excluding intermediate possibilities or shades of gray.^[94] Individuals employing this pattern evaluate situations, self, or others solely as wholly good or bad, successful or failed, without recognizing contextual nuances or probabilistic outcomes.^[95] This distortion manifests as an intolerance for ambiguity, where partial successes are dismissed as failures, fostering emotional volatility and decision-making paralysis.^[96] Key features include the pervasive use of absolutist language—words like "always," "never," "completely," or "totally"—which empirical linguistic analyses link to heightened psychological distress.^[97] For instance, studies analyzing speech and writing samples reveal that elevated absolutist word frequency correlates specifically with anxiety disorders, major depressive disorder, and suicidal ideation, distinguishing these from other conditions like schizophrenia.^[98] ^[99] Such patterns often emerge as adaptive responses to adverse early environments, where survival heuristics favor quick, categorical judgments over nuanced processing.^[100] In behavioral terms, absolutist thinkers exhibit perfectionistic tendencies, where any deviation from an ideal triggers self-criticism or interpersonal conflict, as seen in clinical observations of borderline personality disorder.^[95] Experimental interventions reducing dichotomous thinking—through prompts encouraging dialectical perspectives—have demonstrated improved emotion regulation and problem-solving in controlled settings.^[101] Neurocognitively, this style may stem from reduced prefrontal cortex flexibility, limiting the integration of probabilistic evidence, though longitudinal data on causality remain limited.^[102] Prevalence data indicate absolutist patterns are more pronounced in trauma-exposed populations, exacerbating depressive symptoms by amplifying perceived threats.^[103] Cross-cultural surveys confirm its maladaptive role across demographics, with therapeutic challenges in CBT focusing on evidence-based reframing to cultivate probabilistic reasoning.^[104] Despite its drawbacks, in high-stakes contexts like acute decision-making under uncertainty, mild absolutism can promote decisiveness, though overuse correlates with poorer long-term outcomes.^[105]

Empirical Studies and Behavioral Impacts

Empirical investigations into absolutist thinking, often operationalized as dichotomous or black-and-white cognition, have primarily linked it to adverse mental health outcomes. A 2018 study analyzing online forum posts found that users in anxiety, depression, and suicidal ideation communities employed absolutist language (e.g., words like "always," "never," "totally") at significantly higher rates than in neutral control forums, with large effect sizes (Cohen's d > 3.14), positioning it as a linguistic marker specific to these conditions rather than general negativity.^[98] This pattern was replicated in a 2022 analysis of Google search data, where elevated absolutist word frequency correlated with self-reported mental health declines, validating it as a behavioral proxy for distress based on psycholinguistic theory.^[99] Earlier therapeutic research from 1999 identified absolutist thinking as a cognitive style fostering emotional dysregulation, particularly anger, through rigid categorizations that amplify perceived threats.^[106] Behaviorally, absolutist thinking impairs adaptive functioning by promoting inflexibility in problem-solving and interpersonal dynamics. Individuals exhibiting high dichotomous thinking demonstrate reduced perspective-taking and openness to nuance, leading to strained relationships and heightened conflict, as evidenced in a 2021 scoping review synthesizing links to lower emotional intelligence and social adjustment.^[96] In decision-making contexts, it correlates with hasty judgments under uncertainty; a 2023 study posited evolutionary advantages in resource-scarce environments, where quick binary evaluations conserve cognitive resources and enhance survival odds, though modern settings often render this maladaptive, associating it with impulsivity and regret.^[100] Conversely, a 2021 investigation tied it to lower cognitive abilities and educational attainment, suggesting it hinders complex analytical tasks requiring gradations.^[107] In moral psychology, moral absolutism—viewing ethical principles as universal and exceptionless—exerts distinct behavioral effects, often amplifying intolerance toward norm violations. A 2024 experiment showed that priming moral absolutism increased deontological judgments and reduced utilitarian trade-offs in dilemmas, fostering perceptions of self-righteousness and resistance to compromise, mediated by rule adherence over outcomes.^[108] Empirical data from 2021 linked it to conservative moral foundations (e.g., loyalty, authority), mediating associations with sexist attitudes via unyielding standards that reject contextual relativism.^[109] However, forthcoming 2025 research indicates it uniquely drives conservative support for prohibitive policies (e.g., bans) more than liberal counterparts, who favor consequentialist absolutism, highlighting ideological divergences in how rigidity translates to policy endorsement.^[110] These patterns underscore causal pathways from absolutist cognition to polarized behaviors, though some findings, drawn from self-report scales, warrant caution due to potential response biases in politically charged domains.^[111]

Therapeutic and Ideological Implications

Absolutist thinking in psychology, characterized by dichotomous or black-and-white evaluations without intermediate shades, is classified as a core cognitive distortion in cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), where it contributes to heightened vulnerability for anxiety and depression by fostering perceptions of failure in non-perfect outcomes.^[112] ^[113] Therapeutically, CBT interventions target this pattern through techniques such as cognitive restructuring, which encourage clients to identify absolutist language (e.g., "always" or "never") and replace it with evidence-based probabilistic assessments, leading to reduced symptom severity in disorders like major depressive disorder.^[114] Empirical studies demonstrate that individuals with elevated dichotomous thinking exhibit stronger associations with negative perfectionism, which predicts maladaptive behaviors including self-criticism and avoidance, while therapeutic reduction of this style correlates with improved emotional regulation and lower relapse rates in treated cohorts.^[115] ^[116] From an ideological standpoint, absolutist cognition promotes rigid adherence to binary moral or political frameworks, diminishing cognitive flexibility and increasing susceptibility to dogmatic ideologies that reject compromise or empirical nuance.^[117] Research links this thinking style to personality traits such as low agreeableness and honesty-humility, which underpin antisocial tendencies and reduced openness to opposing views, thereby facilitating ideological polarization.^[118] In extremis, it manifests in heightened endorsement of radical attitudes, as cognitive inflexibility—closely aligned with dichotomous evaluations—predicts support for extremist positions across political spectra, with experimental interventions reducing such thinking shown to enhance intellectual humility and tolerance for ambiguity.^[101] ^[117] These patterns suggest causal pathways where absolutist cognition reinforces belief traps, insulating harmful ideologies from disconfirming evidence and amplifying group-based prejudices, as observed in longitudinal analyses of radicalization processes.^[116] ^[119]

References

[1]
Volume 2, Chapter 8: Absolutism - NOVA Open Publishing
Introduction. “Absolutism” is a concept of political authority created by historians to describe a shift in the governments of the major monarchies of Europe ...
[2]
What Is Absolutism? - ThoughtCo
Mar 29, 2022 · Absolutism is a political system in which a single sovereign ruler or leader holds complete and unrestrained power over a country.
[3]
A History of the 'Divine Right of Kings' Doctrine - Brewminate
Oct 4, 2020 · The Divine Right of Kings is a political and religious doctrine of royal absolutism. It asserts that a monarch is subject to no earthly authority.
[4]
Divine Right of Kings (AP Euro Lecture Notes) - TomRichey.net
Sep 1, 2018 · The Divine Right of Kings represents a “Top Down” approach to government, in contrast with the “Bottom Up” approach of social contract theory, ...
[5]
Causes and Effects of Absolute Monarchs - Students of History
An absolute monarchy is where an all-powerful king/queen rules with total control, believing in divine right, and power passed down through bloodlines.
[6]
Absolutism - (AP European History) - Vocab, Definition, Explanations
Absolutism is a political doctrine and practice in which a single ruler holds absolute power over the state and its people, often justified by divine right.
[7]
Absolutism and Constitutionalism - AP European History
While absolutism was implemented successfully in France, Prussia, Russia, and Austria, the English and the Dutch rejected this model in favor of ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[8]
AP European History Unit Three: Absolutism and Constitutionalism
Jan 24, 2023 · Absolutism, like Louis XIV's rule, limits nobility power, while constitutionalism, like in England, limits monarch power through parliament. ...
[9]
Absolutism - Oxford Constitutional Law
Absolutism is a government where a ruler has unlimited, undivided, and uncontrolled authority, not bound by law, and not obliged to let others participate.
[10]
Absolutism - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
Absolutism is a political system with absolute monarchy, where a monarch concentrates power, and is not encumbered by other institutions.
[11]
Absolutism and royalism (Chapter 12) - The Cambridge History of ...
The meaning of absolutism. The purpose of this chapter is to describe the main tenets of absolutist and royalist thinking in the seventeenth century.
[12]
Jean Bodin on Sovereignty | Stanford Humanities Center
Bodin, like Hobbes, is usually understood as a theorist of absolute monarchy. However, he thought a royal (as opposed to a despotic) monarchy consults the ...
[13]
Beyond the Legacy of Absolutism: Re-examining Jean Bodin's Idea ...
Jun 13, 2024 · Bodin believed tyrants violating fundamental laws of succession or natural laws could face resistance or just war, but not domestic resistance.
[14]
Two Conceptions of Sovereignty | The Structure of Pluralism
Early-modern political theorists, especially Jean Bodin and Thomas Hobbes, proposed a voluntarist account of sovereignty in which the sovereign's status is ...
[15]
Making Sense of the Divine Right of Kings - JSTOR Daily
Dec 18, 2020 · The theoreticians of divine right in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries “believed that the kings of England were answerable only to God.” ...
[16]
The Divine Right of James I and the English" by Nathan Greenhaw
This paper analyzes the development of James I's theory of divine right in England and how its application elevated the sovereignty of the monarch.
[17]
History of Europe - Absolutism, Monarchies, Dynasties | Britannica
Sep 10, 2025 · The authority of a sovereign was exercised in a society of orders and corporations, each having duties and privileges. St. Paul's image of the ...
[18]
Bodin, Jean | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Chapter Four is a comparison of the three forms of state; Bodin argues that royal, or hereditary, (as opposed to elective) monarchy is the best form of state.
[19]
Divine right of kings | Definition, History, & Facts - Britannica
Oct 11, 2025 · In its origins, the divine-right theory may be traced to the medieval conception of God's award of temporal power to the political ruler, while ...
[20]
Hobbes's Moral and Political Philosophy
Feb 12, 2002 · 11) This position reinforces absolutism by permitting Hobbes to maintain that subjects can obey even commands to perform actions they believe to ...Further Questions About the... · Absolutism · Responsibility and the Limits...
[21]
France - Absolutism, Louis XIV, Monarchy - Britannica
Louis revealed a desire to exercise a paternal control of affairs that might suggest a modern dictator rather than a 17th-century king.
[22]
Louis XIV's Absolutism in France | Overview & Impact - Study.com
Louis XIV established an absolute monarchy in 1643 when Cardinal Jules Mazarin died. Before that, Cardinal Richelieu had laid a foundation for absolutism ...What was Absolutism in France? · How Did Louis XIV Centralize...
[23]
The Reign of Louis XIV (1643-1715): An Overview - History
Louis XIV succeeded his father, Louis XIII, as king at the age of five. He ruled for 72 years, until his death in 1715, making his reign the longest of any ...
[24]
Louis XIV | Palace of Versailles
Coming to the throne at a tender age, tutored by Cardinal Mazarin, the Sun King embodied the principles of absolutism. In 1682 he moved the royal Court to the ...
[25]
HIST 202 - Lecture 4 - Peter the Great | Open Yale Courses
He tries not only to copy European absolutism, but to open up Russia to commerce, realizing that trade meant wealth and that wealth meant improvements in the ...
[26]
Peter the Great, Tsar of Russia - Renaissance and Reformation
Nov 26, 2019 · His reign is often portrayed as instrumental in dragging a “backward” Russia into the modern European world through profound cultural and military reform.
[27]
The “Enlightened Absolutism” of the Eighteenth Century
Mar 28, 2024 · If “enlightened absolutism,” also called “enlightened despotism,” sounds like a contradiction in terms, it is. At the time, though, it seemed ...
[28]
Prussia Under Frederick the Great | History of Western Civilization II
Frederick the Great significantly modernized Prussian economy, administration, judicial system, education, finance, and agriculture.Missing: empirical outcomes
[29]
Frederick the Great of Prussia | Biography & Accomplishments
His military victories made Prussia a dominant power in Europe, while his reforms transformed the kingdom into a modern state. Frederick died childless on ...
[30]
10 Major Accomplishments of Peter the Great | Learnodo Newtonic
May 14, 2016 · #9 HE MODERNIZED RUSSIAN ARMY AND BUILT A STRONG RUSSIAN NAVY. Before Peter the Great, Russia's army relied on militia of the nobility and ...
[31]
Peter the Great | Biography, Reign & Accomplishments - Study.com
He used a system of meritocracy to reform the Russian military and bureaucracy. He established secular schools for the education of noble children.
[32]
Chapter 8: Absolutism – Colorado Online
In short, more real power and money flowed to the central government of the monarch than ever before, something that underwrote the expansion of military and ...
[33]
Locke's Political Philosophy
Nov 9, 2005 · He argued that people have rights, such as the right to life, liberty, and property, that have a foundation independent of the laws of any particular society.Property · Consent, Political Obligation... · Locke and Punishment · Bibliography
[34]
Baron de Montesquieu, Charles-Louis de Secondat
Jul 18, 2003 · However, on Montesquieu's view it is generally a mistake to base civil laws on religious principles.
[35]
Imperial wars - Alpha History
According to a Compte Rendu drawn up by Desmaretz after the king's death, France was carrying a national debt of two billion livres. The annual interest ...<|separator|>
[36]
What We Learn from a Sovereign Debt Restructuring in France in 1721
The wars ended in 1714, leaving France in great financial difficulties. Louis XIV ... The unsecured debt left over from the war was converted into State bills.
[37]
Disadvantages of an Absolute Monarchy: Why It's a Risky System of ...
1. Lack of Accountability · 2. Potential for Abuse of Power · 3. Risk of Poor Decision Making · 4. Stifling of Innovation and Progress · 5. Human Rights Violations.
[38]
France's Fiscal Woes | History of Western Civilization II
Under Louis XIV, France witnessed successful reforms and growth as a global power, but financial strain imposed by multiple wars left the state bankrupt.
[39]
The End of Absolutism in Europe - 812 Words | 123 Help Me
These are some of the key reasons why absolutism failed in Europe. To begin with, there was a great loss of human lives. Beginning in 1643 England, the closest ...
[40]
[PDF] ABSOLUTISM VS. RELATIVISM IN CONTEMPORARY ONTOLOGY
v/z., Absolutism: the view that reality exists independently of our thinking. I conclude by defending Absolutism against. Sosa's objections. mJmest Sosa ...
[41]
Nestor-Luis Cordero, By being, it is: the thesis of Parmenides
At the end of the sixth century BCE, Parmenides wrote a poem to affirm his fundamental thesis upon which all philosophical systems should be based: that there ...
[42]
https://brill.com/display/book/9789004395848/BP000010.xml
[43]
Chapter 2: Classic Philosophy: Plato - Open UGA
These eternal Forms, according to Plato, exist independently of the empirical world. Therefore, they can only become knowable though metaphysical contemplation.
[44]
[PDF] 2 Spinoza's Metaphysics of Substance - PhilArchive
Jul 7, 2021 · Substance is both ontologically and conceptually independent. It is a thing that does not depend on anything else in order to be or be ...
[45]
[PDF] 3 Spinoza's Ontology - PhilPapers
In the opening definitions of the Ethics Spinoza mentions three kinds of basic entities, substance, mode, and attribute, after defining which he.
[46]
Moral Absolutism - Ethics Unwrapped - University of Texas at Austin
Moral absolutism asserts that there are certain universal moral principles by which all peoples' actions may be judged. It is a form of deontology.
[47]
Ethics Explainer: Moral Absolutism - The Ethics Centre
Apr 3, 2018 · Moral absolutism is the position that there are universal ethical standards that apply to actions regardless of context.Missing: metaphysics | Show results with:metaphysics
[48]
Kant's moral philosophy
Feb 23, 2004 · Immanuel Kant (1724–1804) argued that the supreme principle of morality is a principle of rationality that he dubbed the “Categorical ...
[49]
What is moral absolutism? | GotQuestions.org
Jan 4, 2022 · Moral absolutism is the philosophy that mankind is subject to absolute standards of conduct that do not change with circumstances.
[50]
https://philosophybasics.com/branch_moral_absolutism.html
[51]
Exposure to moral relativism compromises moral behavior
The philosophical position of moral absolutism holds that some moral beliefs are objectively true, and reflect facts that are independent of any social group's ...
[52]
[PDF] Exposure to moral relativism compromises moral behavior
Jul 10, 2013 · Across two studies we investigated the relationship between moral relativism versus absolutism and moral behavior. In Experiment 1, we found ...
[53]
Epistemic Gradualism Versus Epistemic Absolutism - Lai - 2022
Apr 25, 2021 · Epistemic absolutism holds that knowledge-that is ungradable, while epistemic gradualism argues the opposite. This paper purports to remodel ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[54]
Absolutism, Relativism and Metaepistemology | Erkenntnis
Aug 9, 2019 · This paper is about two topics: metaepistemological absolutism and the epistemic principles governing perceptual warrant.
[55]
Foundationalist Theories of Epistemic Justification
Feb 21, 2000 · According to foundationalism, any justified belief must either be foundational or depend for its justification, ultimately, on foundational ...Missing: absolute | Show results with:absolute
[56]
[PDF] CLASSIFICATION: ABSOLUTISM vs RELATIVISM
The entry on Relativism, by Bagharamian and Carter, clarifies the view of absolutism as a main contrast to relativism.
[57]
Descartes' Epistemology - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Dec 3, 1997 · The central insight of foundationalism is to organize knowledge in the manner of a well-structured, architectural edifice. Such an edifice owes ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[58]
Epistemology and Relativism - Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Epistemology is, roughly, the philosophical theory of knowledge, its nature and scope. What is the status of epistemological claims? Relativists regard the ...
[59]
Relativism - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Sep 11, 2015 · They are universal and not bound by historical or social conditions. Absolutism is often used as the key contrast idea to relativism.
[60]
Epistemic relativism, scepticism, pluralism - PMC - PubMed Central
Feb 6, 2016 · ... epistemic absolutism. Epistemic absolutism is a metaphysical doctrine, to wit, the view that there are absolutely correct epistemic standards.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[61]
The Isms Lectures--Skepticism, Dogmatism, Relativism, Absolutism
Let us clarify the meaning of "epistemological optimism." Epistemological optimism says that we can know, or have a great deal of certainty, about some things.
[62]
Hegel - Philosophy Pages
Nov 23, 2011 · Hegel's absolute idealism is evident even in the early Phänomenologie des Geistes Hegel ( Phenomenology of Mind ) (1807). There Hegel ...
[63]
Hegel's logic of absolute idealism and his political argument
Hegel's final argument in the Science of Logic is that there can be no actual object that is not “rational,” i.e., that is not constituted, in all of its ...
[64]
Hegel – Philosophy of Fine Art
Absolute Spirit is the ultimate form, the Ideal, or what Hegel would call Absolute Idealism. The dialectical system in his Logic is being, nothing (or ...
[65]
Hegel - Spirit and Absolute Truth
For Hegel and his two idealistic predecessors, a unified theory of reality is one which can systematically explain all forms of reality, starting from a single ...
[66]
Hegel Definition - Berkeley Learning Platform
Hegel's philosophy, often characterized as a form of absolute idealism, posits that reality is a unified whole, a synthesis of diverse and often contradictory ...
[67]
Jonathan Robinson, “Bradley and Bosanquet” - PhilPapers
Most accounts of British philosophy devote some space to what is variously called “British Idealism,” or “Neo-Hegelianism,” or “Absolute Idealism” of which ...
[68]
British absolute idealism: from Green to Bradley (Chapter 9)
These issues revolve around the twin constraints of holism and monism. Pursuing these, for instance, leads Bradley famously to deny the reality of relations, ...
[69]
British Idealism and the Political Philosophy of T. H. Green, Bernard ...
Jan 26, 2005 · Bradley Studies has devoted a Special Issue to exploring further the philosophies of Bradley and Bosanquet in a comparative perspective ( ...
[70]
[PDF] Global Relativism and Self-Refutation - UB
Self-refutation means a claim can be turned against itself, entailing its own falsity, or that making the claim entails its falsity.
[71]
Theories That Refute Themselves | Issue 106 - Philosophy Now
For not only are relativist positions committed to rejecting their own objective application in the self-refuting fashion that we have already seen; in ...
[72]
Why Relativism is the Worst Idea Ever | Blog of the APA
Jul 29, 2021 · Relativism is a major disruptor of our mental immune system. Objective standards of right and wrong are our main defences against bad ideas.
[73]
[PDF] Newton's Scholium on Time, Space, Place and Motion-I. The Text
The scholium following the eight opening definitions of the Principia sets out. Newton's views on absolute time, space, place and motion and proceeds to.
[74]
Newton's Scholium on Time, Space, Place and Motion |
In the Scholium to the Definitions at the beginning of the Principia, Newton distinguishes absolute time, space, place, and motion from their relative ...
[75]
By their properties, causes and Effects: Newton's Scholium on time ...
Recall that paragraph six of the scholium concludes: 'These are therefore absolute places, and only translations from these places are absolute motions.' The ...
[76]
[PDF] Absolute and relative motion - PhilArchive
Absolutism: true motion consists in change of place in. Absolute Space, at a rate set defined by Absolute Time. Relationism: true motion consists in kinematic ...
[77]
Newton's Principia / Relativity
Space, time and mass are the fundamental ideas, on which Newton developed his mechanics. All other physical quantities can be derived from these three.
[78]
[PDF] Kochiras.Newton's Absolute Time (in Time & Tense) - PhilArchive
There, since he has extended the domain of entities to include God, Newton argues that space and time are not absolute; for to be absolute is to be independent, ...
[79]
Newton's scholium on time, space, place and motion-I. The text
The first consists of paragraphs one to four in which Newton sets out his characterizations of absolute and relative time, space, place, and motion ...
[80]
Special relativity explained — Einstein's mind-bending theory of ...
May 12, 2025 · This groundbreaking theory explains how speed affects mass, time, and space, and introduced the world to the most famous equation in science: E ...
[81]
absolute and relational space and motion, post-Newtonian theories
Aug 11, 2006 · (Strict relationism denies that there is any such thing as an absolute motion; all motion is merely relative, i.e., is nothing more than changes ...
[82]
Relativity - University of Oregon
Special relativity destroyed classical physics view of absolute space and time, general relativity dismantles the idea that spacetime is described by ...Missing: challenges | Show results with:challenges
[83]
What is the theory of general relativity? Understanding Einstein's ...
Oct 29, 2024 · As he worked out the equations for his general theory of relativity, Einstein realized that massive objects caused a distortion in space-time.<|separator|>
[84]
GP-B — Einstein's Spacetime - Gravity Probe B
The theory does not make spacetime more relative than it was in special relativity. Just the opposite is true: the absolute space and time of Newton are ...
[85]
Newton's absolute time and space in general relativity - AIP Publishing
Apr 1, 2000 · In this sense, a theory of light can be related to absolute time and space of Newtonian gravitational theory. I illustrate the (R,t) methodology ...Missing: challenges | Show results with:challenges
[86]
Quantum Absolutism: Lee Smolin's Time Reborn
Jul 13, 2013 · “The apparently free, uncaused behavior of individual quantum systems presents a formidable challenge to [the principle of sufficient reason],” ...
[87]
Absolute space and Newton's theory of relativity - ScienceDirect.com
Philosophical discussions of absolute space and time, however, underemphasize Newton's concern with the relativity of motion.
[88]
Quantum Gravity's Time Problem | Quanta Magazine
Dec 1, 2016 · In quantum mechanics, time is universal and absolute; its steady ticks dictate the evolving entanglements between particles.
[89]
Flow of time in Quantum Mechanics vs General Relativity
Apr 13, 2021 · Quantum mechanics regards the flow of time as universal and absolute, whereas general relativity regards the flow of time as malleable and relative.
[90]
[PDF] Cosmology with the cosmic rest frame - arXiv
May 28, 2018 · The cosmic rest frame is a global frame for the universe, and the model assumes a one-to-one correspondence between comoving coordinates and ...<|separator|>
[91]
The seemingly preferred cosmic frame - IOPscience
... CMB frame might actually be an absolute universal frame, with some physically sustainable vacuum structure. But whether conceived within a legitimate ...
[92]
Absolute representations and modern physics
Mar 11, 2025 · This article overcomes this tension by demonstrating how, when formulated in the correct way, modern physics admits of an absolute representation of ...
[93]
Neo-Lorentzian Relativity and the Beginning of the Universe - arXiv
Sep 17, 2021 · Craig and co-author Sinclair have argued that physical cosmology supports the conclusion that physical reality began to exist at a finite time in the past.
[94]
Black & white thinking: A cognitive distortion - PMC - NIH
Black and white thinking, a cognitive distortion is often come across in persons with depression. The individuals tend to think dichotomously.
[95]
Dichotomous Thinking: Signs, Examples, and Treatments
Mar 11, 2024 · Dichotomous thinking, also known as "black or white thinking," is a symptom of many psychiatric conditions and personality disorders, including borderline ...
[96]
Seeing Things in Black‐and‐White: A Scoping Review on ...
Feb 8, 2021 · The objective of this study was to perform a mapping of evidence linking the dichotomous thinking style to other psychological variables.Abstract · Method · Results · Discussion
[97]
Elevated Use of Absolutist Words Is a Marker Specific to Anxiety ...
Absolutist thinking is considered a cognitive distortion by most cognitive therapies for anxiety and depression. Yet, there is little empirical evidence of its ...
[98]
Elevated Use of Absolutist Words Is a Marker Specific to Anxiety ...
Jan 5, 2018 · Absolutist thinking is considered a cognitive distortion by most cognitive therapies for anxiety and depression. Yet, there is little ...
[99]
Using absolutist word frequency from online searches to measure ...
Feb 16, 2022 · Accordingly, studies show that absolutist words (e.g. completely, totally, all) are more prevalent among depressed, suicidal patients and in ...
[100]
Association Between Individual Differences in Dichotomous ... - NIH
Dec 7, 2023 · Our research suggests that people's dichotomous thinking tendency may be a form of adaptation to the harshness of their childhood environment rather than their ...
[101]
Beyond black and white: Reducing dichotomous thinking to foster ...
We conducted an experiment to investigate whether increasing and/or decreasing dichotomous thinking (via black and white thinking and dialectical thinking ...
[102]
Autistic traits associated with dichotomic thinking mediated by ...
Aug 28, 2023 · ... black-and-white thinking in autism is that to circumvent the ... dichotomous thinking in both studies. This contradicts previous ...
[103]
How Trauma and Black-and-White Thinking Make Depression Worse
Jun 24, 2025 · Black-and-white thinking, also called polarized or dichotomous thinking, is a cognitive style where people see things in extremes—such as ...
[104]
The impact of absolute thinking on wellbeing - CentAUR
Oct 29, 2021 · We provide evidence that elevated use of absolutist words reflects absolutist thinking rather than psychological distress per se. We also ...
[105]
Black and White Thinking Can Affect Your Health | Psychology Today
Nov 10, 2020 · Often the end result of black and white, fixed mindset or dichotomous thinking is a lack of long term success. Black and white thinking can seem ...
[106]
Absolutist thinking and health - PubMed
Absolutist thinking has been identified in therapeutic studies as a style of thinking which is believed to promote emotional distress, particularly anger.
[107]
Dichotomous thinking and cognitive ability - ScienceDirect.com
Feb 1, 2021 · Previous studies imply that the dichotomous thinking is associated with low cognitive abilities and low level of education attainment.
[108]
Moral Believer or Moral Problem-Solver? Moral Pragmatism Fosters ...
Oct 23, 2024 · Prior research has established that when primed with moral absolutism, people tend to be intolerant toward dissidents yet refrain from ...
[109]
The Mediating Role of Moral Absolutism Between the “Binding Moral ...
Nov 24, 2021 · We show that the known relationship between the binding foundations and sexist attitudes is mediated by moral absolutism.
[110]
Moral absolutism drives support for bans: Unpacking ideological ...
Moral absolutism drives support for bans: Unpacking ideological differences in the moral philosophies of conservatives and liberals. Publication Date. Nov 2025 ...
[111]
[PDF] Its Relation to Political Conservatism and Epistemic Motivation
Jul 11, 2009 · Moral Absolutism This scale was designed to measure the degree to which participants think their own moral values are reflections of an ...
[112]
Cognitive Distortions: Unhelpful Thinking Habits - Psychology Tools
Mar 18, 2019 · Example of absolutistic dichotomous thinking: Tanya either did things perfectly or not at all. If she saw the slightest speck of dust at home ...
[113]
In an Absolute State: Elevated Use of Absolutist Words Is a Marker ...
Jan 5, 2018 · Absolutist thinking is considered a cognitive distortion by most cognitive therapies for anxiety and depression.
[114]
10 Cognitive Distortions That Can Cause Negative Thinking
Oct 17, 2025 · Cognitive distortions are negative or irrational patterns of thinking. These negative thought patterns can play a role in diminishing your motivation, lowering ...
[115]
The role of dichotomous thinking and rigidity in perfectionism
Dichotomous thinking emerged as the variable most predictive of negative perfectionism, and was less strongly related to positive perfectionism.Missing: empirical studies
[116]
Belief traps: Tackling the inertia of harmful beliefs - PubMed Central
Jul 18, 2022 · Black-and-white thinking is a major risk factor for the formation of resilient beliefs associated with psychiatric disorders as well as ...
[117]
Cognitive Inflexibility Predicts Extremist Attitudes - PMC - NIH
May 7, 2019 · Research into the roots of ideological extremism has traditionally focused on the social, economic, and demographic factors that make people ...
[118]
Dichotomous Thinking and Personality Traits: From the Viewpoints ...
Jul 17, 2020 · The present results indicate that dichotomous thinking is associated with antisocial tendencies, such as low Honesty–Humility and low Agreeableness.
[119]
Cognitive mechanisms in violent extremism - ScienceDirect.com
We conceptualize extremism as stemming from a motivational imbalance in which a given need “crowds out” other needs and liberates behavior from their ...Missing: absolutist | Show results with:absolutist