Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Beat frequency oscillator

A beat frequency oscillator (BFO) is an that produces a variable audio-frequency signal by mixing the outputs from two radio-frequency (RF) oscillators tuned to slightly different frequencies, resulting in a beat frequency equal to the absolute difference between the two RF signals, which is then filtered and amplified for audio output. Invented in 1901 by Canadian engineer Reginald Fessenden, the BFO operates on the heterodyne principle, where a fixed-frequency RF oscillator (typically at frequency f_1) and a variable-frequency RF oscillator (at frequency f_2, adjustable via a tuning capacitor) feed into a mixer stage that generates both sum (f_1 + f_2) and difference (|f_1 - f_2|) frequencies; an RF filter removes the higher sum frequency, leaving the audio-range difference as the output. Key components include stable RF oscillators (e.g., Colpitts or Hartley types), a nonlinear mixer (often a diode or transistor), RF bandpass filters to isolate the beat signal, and an audio amplifier for constant-amplitude output across a range from a few hertz to several kilohertz. Stability is critical to avoid frequency drift, requiring isolation between oscillators to prevent unwanted coupling or synchronization. Historically used for generating precise audio tones in early , BFOs have found prominent applications in radio receivers for demodulating () and single-sideband () suppressed-carrier signals, where the BFO injects a local RF tone to the incoming RF into an audible beat for detection. In metal detectors, a BFO employs one fixed reference oscillator and another whose varies with a search coil's —altered by nearby metals—producing a detectable change in the audio beat to indicate targets up to 80-90 mm deep. Though largely superseded by direct digital synthesis and other oscillators like the for general audio generation, BFOs remain relevant in niche RF and detection systems due to their simplicity and tunability.

Principles of Operation

Beat Phenomenon

The beat phenomenon occurs when two sinusoidal waves of slightly different frequencies superimpose, resulting in variations in the of the combined wave that resemble . These variations, known as beats, manifest as periodic increases and decreases in the intensity of the sound or signal, with the rate of these fluctuations determined by the difference in the frequencies of the two waves. This effect arises from the principle of wave superposition, where the individual waves interfere constructively and destructively over time. Mathematically, consider two waves of equal A and f_1 and f_2 (where |f_1 - f_2| is small compared to the ), expressed as A \cos(2\pi f_1 t) and A \cos(2\pi f_2 t). Their superposition is given by the trigonometric identity: A \cos(2\pi f_1 t) + A \cos(2\pi f_2 t) = 2A \cos\left(2\pi \frac{f_1 + f_2}{2} t\right) \cos\left(2\pi \frac{f_1 - f_2}{2} t\right). The term \cos\left(2\pi \frac{f_1 + f_2}{2} t\right) represents a high- at the (f_1 + f_2)/2, while the slowly varying \cos\left(2\pi \frac{f_1 - f_2}{2} t\right) acts as an that modulates the . The of this , or beat , is f_b = |f_1 - f_2|, corresponding to the rate at which the maxima and minima occur. An audible example of beats is observed when two tuning forks are struck simultaneously, one tuned to 440 Hz (the standard concert A) and the other to 442 Hz. The resulting sound produces a 2 Hz beat , perceived as a waxing and waning tone that pulses twice per second, illustrating how even small differences create perceptible interference patterns in . This acoustic effect forms the basis for heterodyning in , where beats are generated intentionally through signal mixing.

Heterodyning Process

Heterodyning is an electronic technique that combines two signals through nonlinear mixing to produce sum and difference . In the context of a beat frequency oscillator (BFO), the outputs of two RF oscillators—one fixed at frequency f_1 and the other variable at frequency f_2—are mixed, yielding output components at f_1 + f_2 and |f_1 - f_2|. This generates a beat frequency directly as the audio output. The key output of heterodyning in BFOs is the difference frequency, expressed as f_b = |f_1 - f_2|, where f_b is the beat . By tuning f_2 slightly offset from f_1, the resulting f_b falls within the audible range, enabling applications such as tone generation. Mixers perform this nonlinear operation using devices like diodes or transistors, which exploit their nonlinear current-voltage characteristics to multiply the input signals in the and produce the sum and difference products. For instance, diode-based mixers, such as those employing Schottky diodes, provide passive mixing with low noise, while transistor-based active mixers offer alongside translation. To extract the useful beat frequency, a follows the mixer, attenuating the higher sum frequency and unwanted harmonics while passing the difference component. This isolates an audio-range signal, which can be amplified for output in BFO systems.

Components and Design

Oscillator Configurations

Beat frequency oscillators (BFOs) typically employ two primary oscillators to generate the signals required for beat production: a fixed-frequency oscillator for stability and a for adjustability. The fixed-frequency oscillator maintains a constant output to serve as a , often operating at the (IF) of the system, while the variable-frequency oscillator introduces a slight offset to produce the desired audio beat tone through heterodyning. Fixed-frequency oscillators in BFO systems are commonly crystal-controlled to achieve high and minimize drift, which is critical for consistent beat output in applications like radio receivers. These oscillators use quartz crystals to lock the precisely, ensuring long-term accuracy within parts per million. For example, in superheterodyne receivers for or reception, the fixed BFO oscillator is often set at 455 kHz, the conventional IF frequency. Variable-frequency oscillators provide the tunable component, typically using LC-tuned circuits for adjustability in the radio frequency (RF) range from hundreds of kHz to several MHz. Common configurations include the Hartley and Colpitts oscillators, which are inductive-capacitive (LC) designs suitable for RF generation in analog BFOs due to their simplicity and ability to produce stable sine waves. The Hartley oscillator employs a tapped inductor for feedback, while the Colpitts uses a voltage divider of capacitors; both allow fine tuning via variable capacitors to offset the fixed frequency by 1-3 kHz, yielding an audible beat tone in the 800-1200 Hz range. In modern BFO implementations, (PLL) synthesizers and (DDS) offer enhanced precision and digital control over generation. PLL-based oscillators lock to a stable reference for low and fine resolution, while DDS uses digital techniques to produce arbitrary with high accuracy, often integrated in systems for variable offsets without mechanical tuning. These approaches operate in RF bands up to tens of MHz, with stability requirements ensuring beat frequency drift below 1 Hz to avoid audible artifacts.

Mixing and Filtering

In a beat frequency oscillator (BFO), the mixing stage combines the outputs from two oscillators operating at closely spaced , typically in the (RF) range, to generate both and components. The of this process illustrates the signal flow: the reference oscillator and variable oscillator outputs are fed into the , which produces the desired beat (the ) along with the undesired and potential harmonics; the subsequent then isolates the beat for further , often to an audio stage. Mixers in BFO circuits can be passive or active, selected based on design requirements for simplicity versus performance enhancement. Passive mixers, commonly diode-based, exploit the nonlinear current-voltage characteristics of diodes such as Schottky types to perform the frequency mixing without requiring external power, offering advantages in simplicity, wide bandwidth, and low intermodulation distortion, though they introduce conversion loss of approximately 4.5 to 9 dB. Active mixers, utilizing transistors in configurations like multipliers or Gilbert cells, provide conversion gain to compensate for losses, improved port isolation, and reduced local oscillator (LO) drive power needs, making them suitable for integrated designs where signal amplification is beneficial. Following mixing, low-pass or bandpass filters are employed to suppress the higher sum frequency and any harmonics while allowing the lower beat frequency—typically in the audible range of 20 Hz to 20 kHz—to pass to the audio . A configuration effectively attenuates frequencies above the beat tone, ensuring a clean output by removing products and the sum component, which could otherwise interfere with the desired signal. Practical considerations in BFO mixing and filtering include at mixer ports to minimize signal reflections and optimize power transfer, often achieved through matching networks tailored to the LO and RF input levels. Harmonic suppression is critical to prevent spurious signals from the nonlinear mixing process, addressed via careful frequency planning and to avoid overlap with the beat output. Additionally, phase noise from the oscillators can degrade the purity of the beat frequency, necessitating low-noise oscillator designs and mixer configurations that do not exacerbate contributions, such as those with good image rejection. A simple schematic for a passive diode mixer in a BFO involves the outputs of two oscillators capacitively coupled through series resistors to the of a , with the grounded; the beat frequency appears across a parallel acting as a basic , often augmented with an network for further audio extraction and suppression of RF components.

Applications

Radio Receivers

In superheterodyne radio receivers, the beat frequency oscillator (BFO) is integrated into the product detector stage to demodulate continuous wave (CW) and single-sideband (SSB) signals by mixing with the intermediate frequency (IF) output. For CW, this produces an audible beat tone typically in the 700-1000 Hz range for operator comfort; for SSB, it recovers the full baseband audio spectrum (typically 300-3000 Hz). This heterodyning process shifts the narrowband IF signal—often centered at 455 kHz in HF designs—to baseband audio frequencies, enabling the recovery of suppressed carrier information without requiring a full carrier transmission. The BFO serves as a local oscillator in the product detector, where the multiplication of IF and BFO signals yields sum and difference frequencies, with the low-frequency difference components forming the demodulated audio after low-pass filtering. For specific operating modes, the BFO is offset from the IF to align the suppressed at a suitable audio , such as 1 kHz, ensuring intelligible . In upper sideband (USB) mode, the BFO is set above the IF, for example at IF + 1 kHz, to restore the and shift the upper frequencies to positive audio without excessive . Conversely, for lower sideband (LSB) mode, the offset places the BFO below the IF by a similar amount, adapting to the 's frequency placement relative to the suppressed . In CW reception, the BFO offset is adjusted to produce a consistent beat tone when the receiver is tuned to the signal's , functioning similarly to the role in . The use of a BFO in superheterodyne receivers offers key advantages, particularly in and applications, by allowing narrow IF bandwidths (e.g., 2-3 kHz) that enhance selectivity and reject in crowded spectrum bands. Additionally, the adjustable BFO pitch control permits operators to customize the audio for personal preference, improving listening comfort during extended sessions without altering the receiver's overall .

Metal Detectors

In beat frequency oscillator (BFO) metal detectors, detection relies on the interaction between a stable reference oscillator and a variable search oscillator, where the search coil functions as the inductive component of an LC tank circuit. The reference oscillator maintains a fixed , typically around 100 kHz, while the search oscillator operates at a very similar . When conductive or magnetic metal approaches the search coil, it induces currents or alters the magnetic permeability, changing the coil's effective and thereby shifting the search oscillator's by a small amount, often in the range of tens to hundreds of hertz. This detuning produces a low-frequency beat signal through heterodyning, which falls within the audible range (usually 0 to 500 Hz) and serves as the detection indicator, with the beat tone's pitch or volume varying based on the metal's proximity, size, and . The core circuit of a BFO metal detector consists of the reference oscillator, the search oscillator incorporating the coil, a mixer stage to combine the two signals and extract the difference frequency, and a low-pass filter followed by an audio amplifier to convert the beat into an audible output. The search coil, often 8 to 12 inches in diameter for general use, pairs with a capacitor to set the oscillator frequency, while the reference uses a stable internal inductor to avoid environmental interference. In operation, the absence of metal yields a null or steady tone near zero beat, but metal detection causes a perceptible audio change, allowing users to interpret depth (via beat intensity) and rough type (ferrous metals typically increasing inductance, non-ferrous decreasing it via eddy currents). This setup emphasizes simplicity, with basic designs using transistor-based Colpitts or Hartley oscillators for both stages. Early BFO detectors, emerging in the , featured rudimentary circuits without metal , relying solely on presence for alerts, which made them effective for basic but prone to false signals from mineralization or coil height variations. Later variants introduced limited through phase-sensitive mixing or adjustable thresholds, though they remain inferior to (VLF) systems in selectivity. Key advantages include low component count for affordability and ease of construction, making BFO suitable for educational or entry-level applications, while disadvantages encompass high sensitivity to (causing erratic beats over mineralized ) and drift in oscillators, limiting depth to shallow targets (typically 6-12 inches for coins). Contemporary BFO implementations persist in inexpensive handheld units for hobbyist , such as compact models from brands like , where the audio output dynamically scales the beat frequency to modulate for proximity cues and for signal strength, facilitating casual or searches without complex setup. These devices, often under $100, prioritize portability over advanced features, detecting small and non-ferrous items like coins or relics in low-mineralization environments.

Signal Generators

Beat frequency oscillators (BFOs) are employed in (AF) signal generators to produce precise, low-distortion sinusoidal outputs across a wide range of frequencies, typically from 20 Hz to 20 kHz. In such instruments, a stable fixed-frequency , operating at around 190-210 kHz, is mixed with a tunable (VFO) spanning approximately 170-190 kHz, generating beat frequencies that correspond to the audio range through heterodyning. The difference between the two oscillator frequencies determines the output tone, allowing for continuous sweeps without the stability challenges associated with direct circuits. These BFO-based generators find applications in testing audio circuits, measuring harmonic distortion in amplifiers, and calibrating sound reproduction systems, where a clean output is essential. The mixed signal passes through a to suppress higher-frequency components, ensuring a pure audio suitable for precise measurements. A representative example is the General Radio Type 1304-B, a that delivers up to 1 watt into a 600-ohm load with below 0.25% across 100 Hz to 10 kHz, enabling reliable evaluations when paired with recording devices. Key advantages of BFO designs include exceptional stability—less than 7 Hz drift in the first hour of operation—and consistent over three decades of coverage, outperforming traditional audio oscillators in waveform purity and . Modern variants incorporate digital control for the VFO, such as direct digital synthesis (DDS) techniques, to achieve even greater precision and reduced in precision test equipment.

History

Invention

The beat frequency oscillator (BFO) originated from efforts to improve reception in the early . In 1901, Canadian engineer invented the principle, which forms the basis of the BFO, while developing a for (CW) transmissions. This innovation addressed a key limitation of early radio systems, where spark-gap transmitters produced damped waves detectable as audible clicks via simple detectors like coherers, but Fessenden's experimental CW signals—generated using high-frequency alternators—were pure tones inaudible to such devices. Fessenden demonstrated the in laboratory setups, mixing the incoming CW signal with a locally generated tone of slightly different frequency to produce audible beats via the beat phenomenon, where the interference of two close frequencies yields a low-frequency perceptible as . Fessenden's approach was detailed in his U.S. Patent 706,740, filed in 1901 and granted on August 12, 1902, which described a system for wireless signaling using beat-based detection to convert high-frequency electromagnetic waves into audible signals for telegraphy. The patent outlined the use of a local oscillator to heterodyne the received signal, enabling selective tuning and clearer reception in noisy environments, marking a foundational milestone in radio detection technology. Prior to the advent of oscillators in the , mechanical methods were employed to generate the local frequency for production. One such pre-electronic was the , invented around 1910 by German engineer Rudolph Goldschmidt and used in receivers during . For example, a 1917 implementation featured a motor-driven rotating at 4,000 RPM with spaced contacts to produce a square-wave signal near 40 kHz, which heterodyned with the incoming to yield an audible tone in the receiver's earpiece. These mechanical BFOs, though cumbersome and limited in frequency stability, bridged the gap until electronic oscillators became viable.

Development and Advancements

The development of beat frequency oscillators (BFOs) began transitioning in the from early mechanical and spark-based systems to implementations, which provided more reliable and tunable heterodyning for radio receivers. This shift was driven by advancements in technology, enabling stable local oscillation for beat frequency generation in heterodyne circuits. By the 1930s and 1940s, BFOs became integral to superheterodyne receivers, which saw widespread adoption during for due to their improved selectivity and sensitivity in noisy environments. In the 1960s and 1970s, the advent of solid-state transistors revolutionized BFO design, replacing bulky vacuum tubes with compact, low-power components that enhanced portability in amateur and portable radio equipment. Transistor-based BFOs facilitated integration with single-sideband (SSB) modulation techniques, which gained popularity in for efficient spectrum use, requiring precise beat frequency injection for . This era extended through the 1990s, with solid-state designs reducing power consumption and heat generation while maintaining functionality in handheld and mobile transceivers. Post-2000 advancements have shifted BFO functionality toward digital implementations using (DSP) and field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) in software-defined radios (SDRs), where heterodyning occurs in the digital domain for greater flexibility and precision. These digital BFOs minimize drift through software calibration and enable features like automatic upper/lower switching, addressing longstanding stability challenges. Enhanced stability in modern BFOs is further achieved via quartz crystal control, which provides accuracies on the order of parts per million over variations, a critical improvement over earlier LC-tuned designs.

References

  1. [1]
    Beat Frequency Oscillator (BFO)-Block Diagram,working
    Oct 16, 2009 · The beat frequency oscillator (BFO) is used to produce a variÂable frequency output in the audio-frequency (AF) range. BFO is used when the ...
  2. [2]
    Beat Frequency Oscillator (BFO) - Electronics Coach
    Beat Frequency Oscillator or BFO is an oscillator that produces a sinusoidal signal of the variable audio frequency range. It provides such a frequency that ...
  3. [3]
    Beat Frequency Oscillator- Principle and Applications - WellPCB
    Feb 25, 2022 · About beat frequency oscillator, An oscillator capable of producing a variable output frequency signal is essential in electronics.
  4. [4]
    Design of a Beat Frequency Oscillator Metal Detector - Academia.edu
    It uses the principle of electromagnetic induction and adopts a digital beat frequency technique. The system uses a search coil to detect metallic objects ...
  5. [5]
    48 Beats - The Feynman Lectures on Physics - Caltech
    In this chapter we shall discuss some of the phenomena which result from the interference of two sources which have different frequencies.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  6. [6]
    [PDF] 7. Beats - MIT Mathematics
    The result is a beat, and the beat frequency is the audible frequency. We'll make a mathematical study of this effect, using complex num- bers. We will ...
  7. [7]
    [PDF] Beats Phenomenon ( ) ( ) ( )
    When f1 = f2, the beat period becomes infinitely long, and no beats are heard. Page 3. UIUC Physics 406 Acoustical Physics of Music. ©Professor Steven Errede, ...
  8. [8]
    [PDF] FREQUENCY STABILITY
    Common Methods of Measuring Frequency Stability. 1.1 .l. Beat-Frequency Method. The first technique is called a heterodyne frequency-measuring method or beat ...
  9. [9]
    [PDF] BFO Theory - geotech1.com
    The BFO relies on two non-identical oscillators to generate a stable (in the absence of a target) beat frequency, therefore it is important that both ...
  10. [10]
    Heterodyne Receiver - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
    The mixing is done in a mixer stage, which uses the nonlinear characteristics of a transistor to produce the beat frequencies. To produce a beat frequency of ...
  11. [11]
    Basics of frequency mixing and mixers - Test & Measurement Tips
    Feb 26, 2016 · In its simplest form the double-balanced diode mixer consists of two unbalanced-to-balanced transformers and a diode ring. Double-balanced ...
  12. [12]
    [PDF] Receivers: From Spark to 16-Qam
    There are two basic types of oscillators: L-C tuned and crystal controlled. ... 3.2 Beat Frequency Oscillator (BFO) or second mixer. Even as the AM ...
  13. [13]
    Navy Electricity and Electronics Training Series (NEETS) - Module 17
    Beat-Frequency Oscillator. The beat-frequency oscillator (BFO) is necessary when you want to receive CW signals. CW signals are not modulated with an audio ...
  14. [14]
    Bipolar Transistor Cookbook — Part 5 | Nuts & Volts Magazine
    Figure 14, for example, shows the Figure 7 circuit modified to act as a 456 kHz beat-frequency oscillator (BFO) with an amplitude-modulation (AM) facility.C-R Oscillators · L-C Oscillators · Circuit Variations
  15. [15]
    Abstracts and references - IEEE Xplore
    The Colpitts oscillator is modulated by two reactance tubes and the ... when using a beat-frequency oscillator, and gives a detailed description of ...
  16. [16]
    Single-Chip Direct Digital Synthesis vs. the Analog PLL
    New integrated Complete-DDS products present an attractive alternative to analog PLLs for agile frequency synthesis applications.Missing: modern beat
  17. [17]
    [PDF] A Technical Tutorial on Digital Signal Synthesis - IEEE Long Island
    Direct digital synthesis (DDS) is a technique for using digital data processing blocks as a means to generate a frequency- and phase-tunable output signal ...
  18. [18]
    The Basics of Mixers | DigiKey
    Oct 20, 2011 · Generally, a passive mixer is made of passive devices, such as diodes. An active mixer is made of active devices, such as transistors.Missing: beat | Show results with:beat
  19. [19]
    Mixers - Microwaves101
    The nonlinear device within a mixer is most often a Schottky diode, but can also be a FET or other transistor. PIN diodes are never used for mixers, they switch ...
  20. [20]
    beat frequency oscillator - Electrical Engineering Stack Exchange
    Mar 6, 2019 · When there are 2 oscillation voltage at different frequency, they must be connected to the mixer circuit and filtered through the low pass ...
  21. [21]
    US2750508A - Transistor oscillator circuit - Google Patents
    Figure 5 is a schematic circuit diagram of a beat frequency oscillator ... beat frequency oscillator (B. F. 0.). Such an ... diode mixer 62 where they are ...
  22. [22]
    Ham Radio Glossary - ARRL
    Beat-frequency oscillator (BFO)--A receiver circuit that provides a signal to the detector. The BFO signal mixes with the incoming signal to produce an ...
  23. [23]
    None
    ### Summary of SSB Reception Using BFO in Receivers
  24. [24]
    SSB demodulation - Amateur Radio Stack Exchange
    Jul 5, 2014 · SSB demodulation involves mixing frequencies, using a Beat Frequency Oscillator (BFO) to convert the lower sideband back to baseband. The  ...
  25. [25]
    Superhet Radio Receiver: What it is & How it Works » Electronics Notes
    ### Summary of BFO and Product Detector for SSB/CW in Superheterodyne Receivers
  26. [26]
    Choosing a first IF for homebrew receiver - EEVblog
    Jul 16, 2024 · If the second IF is 455kHz, then one is in luck, as the suitable crystals for mixing 21.4MHz or 45MHz down to 455kHz are also widely available.
  27. [27]
    How Metal Detectors Work - Electronics | HowStuffWorks
    Mar 4, 2024 · The most basic way to detect metal uses a technology called beat-frequency oscillator (BFO). In a BFO system, there are two coils of wire ...Anatomy of a Metal Detector · VLF Technology · PI Technology · Detective Work
  28. [28]
    Metal Detectors - Theory and Practice - VLF, PI and BFO Schematics
    BFO designs are still used in cheap hand-held devices and in low quality, toy type detectors. The vintage BFO detector is more of a curiosity and collector's ...
  29. [29]
    Metal Detectors - Petra Blog
    May 16, 2022 · BFO or Beat Frequency Oscillator. Entry-level detectors typically contain a BFO. It has a large coil in the search head and a smaller one in ...Missing: modern | Show results with:modern
  30. [30]
    None
    ### Summary of GR 1304-B Beat-Frequency Audio Generator
  31. [31]
    The GR 1304-B Beat Frequency Audio Generator - Conrad Hoffman
    The 1304-B tunes from 20 to 20 kHz in a single sweep of it's 6" dial, and has a "plus 20" switch that adds 20 kHz to the range, giving a sweep from 20.020 kHz
  32. [32]
    An Almost Pure DDS Sine Wave Tone Generator - Analog Devices
    Dec 1, 2019 · A software-based direct digital synthesizer (DDS) can provide full flexibility with extremely fine frequency resolution and clock synchronization.Missing: beat | Show results with:beat<|control11|><|separator|>
  33. [33]
    Fessenden and the Early History of Radio Science
    Sep 3, 1994 · The first voice over radio was that of Reginald Aubrey Fessenden on 23 December 1900, and this is what he said: "Hello", he undoubtedly shouted ...
  34. [34]
    US706740A - Wireless signaling. - Google Patents
    FESSENDEN, OF MANTEO, NORTH CAROLINA. WIRELESS SIGNALING. ESPEGIFICATION forming part of Letters Patent NO. 706,740, dated August 12, 1909. Application filed ...
  35. [35]
    [PDF] Early radio wave detectors - Tube Electronics
    signal successively through three or more tone wheels connected in cascade ... The beat frequency produced at the diaphragm (27) by inter action of the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  36. [36]
    14. Expanded Audion and Vacuum-tube Development (1917-1930)
    SUPERHETERODYNE RECEIVER​​ Initially, receivers tuned directly to stations' transmitted frequencies, but, while during military work in France during World War ...
  37. [37]
    [PDF] VACUUM-TUBE OSCILLATORS - World Radio History
    In this book I have attempted to present a systematic and reason- ably complete treatment of the many factors which affect the behavior of vacuum-tube ...
  38. [38]
    WWII Communications Equipment Part2
    The BC-312, 314, 342 and 344 series of receivers were used extensively in ground applications from just before WWII up into the 1950s.
  39. [39]
    The Role of the Transistor in Amateur Radio - Ham Radio Academy
    Apr 15, 2024 · The introduction of transistors in the 1950s and 1960s led to a gradual transition from vacuum tube-based amateur radio equipment to solid-state ...
  40. [40]
    [PDF] A Software-Defined Radio for the Masses, Part 1 - ARRL
    The output frequency will vary according to the “beat” or difference frequency between the carrier and the switch-ro- tation frequency to provide an accu-.
  41. [41]
    [PDF] Oscillator metrology with software defined radio
    May 24, 2016 · Finally, we explore SDR's ability to compare oscillators at dissimilar frequencies and to scale to many- oscillator comparisons. One new SDR ...
  42. [42]
    [PDF] Stability of high quality quartz crystal oscillators
    Such oscillators can exhibit parts-in-1014 flicker floor stability in high precision quartz, frequency-source applications. Extensive details of measurement.