Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Beresheet

Beresheet was an unmanned mission developed by the Israeli non-profit organization , marking Israel's first attempt to reach the and the first lunar landing effort by a private company. Launched on February 22, 2019, aboard a rocket from , the 585-kilogram successfully entered after a circuitous journey involving multiple orbits to build up velocity. The mission aimed to achieve a in the region on April 11, 2019, but the attempt failed when the main engine shut down prematurely during descent, causing the lander to crash at high speed. Despite the crash, Beresheet demonstrated significant technological achievements, including a main hydrazine engine and eight attitude control thrusters for propulsion and a compact design roughly the size of a small car. The lander carried a suite of payloads, including a NASA-provided laser retroreflector array for precise distance measurements and a magnetometer to study the Moon's ancient magnetic fields, contributing data on lunar geological history even before the loss of contact. Notably, it also transported the Lunar Library—a nickel disc etched with 30 million pages of human knowledge, including the English Wikipedia, classic literature, and digital records—along with dehydrated tardigrades (water bears) as biological experiments and DNA from 25 individuals, consisting of over 100 cells, preserved in resin. These payloads scattered upon impact but are believed to have partially survived, with the tardigrades posing no risk of uncontrolled reproduction on the airless lunar surface. Originally conceived to compete in the Google Lunar X Prize, which offered $20 million for a private lunar landing but expired in 2018 without a winner, the mission proceeded with philanthropic funding and became a symbol of Israeli innovation in space exploration. The failure highlighted the challenges of lunar descent but provided valuable engineering lessons, inspiring a follow-on mission called Beresheet 2 that planned to deploy two landers and an orbiter for expanded scientific objectives. However, as of November 2025, Beresheet 2 development remains suspended due to funding shortfalls exacerbated by geopolitical events, including the October 2023 war, though SpaceIL continues educational outreach and seeks international partnerships for potential revival.

Background and Development

Origins and Planning

The Beresheet project originated as a response to the , a competition announced in 2007 by the X Prize Foundation in partnership with , offering $20 million to the first private team to land a robotic on the and traverse at least 500 meters by the end of 2012. The initial deadline was later extended multiple times, ultimately to March 31, 2018, due to challenges faced by entrants in securing funding and technology. This incentive spurred global interest in commercial lunar exploration, with the prize aiming to lower barriers for non-governmental space ventures. In 2011, was established as a non-profit organization in by three engineers—Yariv , Kfir Damari, and Yonatan Winetraub—who were inspired by the to develop an affordable . , an , initiated the effort through an online call for collaborators, drawing in Damari, a software developer, and Winetraub, a , to form the core team. Their goal was to demonstrate that a small, privately funded mission could achieve a soft lunar landing, fostering inspiration in Israel's tech community without relying on state resources initially. registered as a non-profit to crowdsource support and emphasize educational outreach. Funding proved a significant hurdle from the outset, as began with limited resources and no guaranteed prize payout. The team initially targeted under $10 million in costs but faced repeated setbacks in attracting investors, leading to a decade-long effort that ultimately raised approximately $100 million through private donations, including major contributions from philanthropists like and the Adelson Family Foundation. The Israeli government provided modest support, covering about 2.5% of the budget via the , alongside smaller grants and public campaigns that mobilized community donations. These funds were pieced together incrementally, with early reliance on the $20 million prize incentive shifting to diversified sources after the competition's extension. The planning phase spanned from 2011 to 2013, during which refined mission concepts, assembled a volunteer team, and conducted feasibility studies for a compact lander design. By 2015, the organization secured a launch , but the 2018 deadline passed without a winner, prompting to pivot and proceed independently with the Beresheet mission using accumulated funds. This decision marked a shift from competition-driven development to a standalone demonstration of private lunar capability, culminating in launch preparations by late 2018. partnered with for spacecraft construction to leverage industrial expertise.

Construction and Partnerships

The construction of the Beresheet lunar lander was initiated through a 2015 contract between SpaceIL and Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI), under which IAI served as the primary contractor responsible for the lander's structural framework and overall integration, enabling the project to leverage established Israeli aerospace capabilities for a cost-effective build. Major assembly of the lander took place from 2016 to 2018 at IAI's facilities, followed by integration and testing phases in 2018 and 2019, culminating in the spacecraft's completion on December 17, 2018. Key collaborations extended beyond IAI to include NASA, which provided a laser retroreflector array and communications support; the Weizmann Institute of Science, which contributed to a magnetic field experiment; RUAG Space, which supplied a 3D-printed engine mount; and the Swedish Space Corporation, which provided antenna network support for navigation. These partnerships were essential in pooling multidisciplinary expertise while maintaining the project's private-sector focus, originally inspired by the Google Lunar X Prize competition. Funding for the construction was predominantly private, with a total mission cost of approximately $100 million, including a major $40 million contribution from philanthropist , who served as SpaceIL's president. Additional support came from donors such as ($5 million) and , supplemented by a modest $2 million from the for technical assistance. This funding model emphasized philanthropic and corporate investments over substantial government subsidies, aligning with SpaceIL's nonprofit structure. A significant challenge during the build process involved adapting (COTS) components—such as processors and sensors—for the harsh space environment, a strategy adopted to minimize costs but which introduced vulnerabilities like sensitivity to interference and limited redundancy. Engineers addressed these issues through rigorous testing at IAI, including simulations and thermal vacuum chamber trials, to ensure reliability despite the constraints.

Spacecraft Design

Structure and Specifications

The Beresheet lander featured a compact boxy structure equipped with four reverse-tripod landing legs to ensure stability on the uneven lunar terrain. Developed by in collaboration with , the lander stood approximately 1.5 meters tall and measured 2.3 meters across with its legs deployed, achieving a launch of 585 . Its primary frame utilized aluminum for structural integrity, augmented by gold to mitigate thermal fluctuations in space. Power for the lander was supplied by solar panels affixed to the top deck, which generated electricity during exposure to sunlight, with lithium-ion batteries providing backup for shadowed periods and critical operations. The communication subsystem included an S-band for and command links to Earth, supported by ground stations from the and 's Deep Space Network. A compact laser retroreflector array, supplied by , was integrated to enable precise ranging and positioning measurements from Earth-based observatories. To endure the radiation-intensive lunar environment, the lander's electronics incorporated radiation-hardened components, such as the dual-core GR712RC processor, capable of withstanding high-energy particle exposure without failure. The overall design prioritized lightweight construction for the low-thrust trajectory, allowing for autonomous operations over a planned 2-3 day surface stay without dedicated thermal control systems.

Propulsion System

The propulsion system of the Beresheet lunar lander was centered on a bipropellant chemical configuration to perform orbit-raising maneuvers from geosynchronous transfer , insertion, and powered descent. The primary engine was a single LEROS 2b restartable liquid , developed by for apogee insertion applications in satellite missions, delivering a nominal of 420 N (95 lbf). This engine operated using (MMH) as fuel and (MON-3, a variant of nitrogen tetroxide) as oxidizer, a pair that ignites spontaneously upon mixing to ensure reliable multiple restarts without an external ignition source. The spacecraft carried approximately 435 of at launch, comprising the hypergolic MMH/MON mixture stored in integrated that fed both the main engine and attitude control thrusters, enabling the delta-v required for the mission phases. With a launch of 585 and of 150 , the system provided a total delta-v capability exceeding 4 km/s based on the engine's of 319.5 seconds, though the insertion burn alone achieved 324 m/s and the overall trans-lunar and descent maneuvers demanded roughly 1.5 km/s. Attitude control was handled by eight smaller reaction control system (RCS) thrusters, each producing lower thrust levels typical of satellite-derived designs (around 25 N), using the same hypergolic propellants for precise orientation during burns and non-propulsive phases. These thrusters maintained stability without dedicated cold-gas subsystems, aligning with the mission's emphasis on simplicity and heritage components from commercial satellite buses. This propulsion architecture was selected for its cost-effectiveness and proven reliability, adapting mature bipropellant technology from geostationary satellite apogee motors to enable efficient trajectory adjustments on a shared launch manifest with a rocket, avoiding the complexity and power demands of electric propulsion for the timeline-constrained private venture.

Avionics and Navigation

The avionics system of the Beresheet lunar lander centered on a main onboard computer powered by the GR712RC, a dual-core LEON3FT radiation-tolerant processor developed by Cobham Gaisler (now Frontgrade Technologies), which provided the core processing capabilities and interfaces to other subsystems for mission control and data handling. This processor enabled the execution of custom flight software tailored by to manage spacecraft operations, including command processing and . Additionally, Aitech Systems supplied a rugged I/O interface unit that facilitated power distribution and communications between the main computer and critical subsystems, ensuring reliable data flow in the harsh space environment. Navigation relied on a suite of sensors for precise attitude and position determination. Star trackers were employed to maintain orientation by identifying star patterns, though they encountered sun blinding shortly after launch, complicating initial trajectory adjustments. Inertial measurement units (IMUs) provided acceleration and angular rate data, with two redundant units installed for ; however, one IMU malfunctioned during the final descent, triggering a ground intervention that contributed to the mission outcome. The system incorporated a NASA-provided Laser Retroreflector Array (LRA) for post-landing precise ranging, consisting of eight corner-cube retroreflectors to enable laser altimetry measurements from Earth-based or orbital assets with centimeter-level accuracy. Autonomy features were integral to the , with onboard software designed for decision-making during critical phases like , including automatic ignition and corrections to handle anomalies without constant input. The fault-tolerant supported in key components, such as the dual , to maintain operational integrity, though a manual software command to restart the failed IMU inadvertently disabled the main during . Ground support integrated Beresheet's with tracking infrastructure, including SpaceIL's control center in for mission operations and the Swedish Space Corporation's global for uplink commands and . International collaboration extended to NASA's Deep for high-gain data relay during deep-space phases, ensuring continuous communication and health monitoring. To reduce development costs, the incorporated elements, such as the Imperx B3320C industrial-grade camera for perimeter imaging and visual navigation aids, which captured key mission selfies and surface views while supporting attitude verification. The also interfaced with the propulsion system for attitude control, using the hypergolic thrusters to execute fine pointing maneuvers based on inputs.

Scientific Objectives and Payload

Mission Goals

The Beresheet mission, developed by the Israeli nonprofit , aimed to achieve a historic on the as the first privately funded effort of its kind, demonstrating the feasibility of low-cost lunar exploration using off-the-shelf commercial components rather than bespoke space-grade hardware. This technological objective sought to validate a budget-constrained approach to , with the 585-kilogram lander built for approximately $100 million, far less than traditional national programs, by leveraging partnerships with companies like for integration and testing. Scientifically, the mission targeted mapping of lunar magnetic anomalies in the region to investigate ancient crustal s, providing ground-based measurements to complement orbital data and constrain models of the Moon's early and impact history. A key goal was to measure the vector at the surface during descent and operations, addressing gaps in understanding remnant magnetism formed billions of years ago. Additionally, Beresheet planned to capture high-resolution images of the lunar surface to support geological analysis, though these would rely on post-mission review by instruments like NASA's camera. Inspirational objectives focused on fostering education in , particularly among youth, by engaging over a million students through school programs, public tracking events, and the spacecraft's name—Beresheet, Hebrew for "In the Beginning" from the —to evoke national pride and curiosity about . The positioned itself as a catalyst for innovation, aiming to make Israel the fourth country after the , , and to achieve a controlled lunar landing, thereby elevating the nation's profile in global endeavors. Beyond science and technology, Beresheet included non-scientific tasks such as deploying a known as the Lunar Library, a durable archive consisting of 25 layered discs etched with 30 million pages of human knowledge including , texts, and cultural artifacts, intended as a long-term archive for future explorers, along with samples of human from 25 individuals preserved in over 100 cells. The payload also featured a experiment with thousands of dehydrated tardigrades (water bears) encased in resin within the capsule, designed to test their resilience to lunar conditions like vacuum and radiation for insights into survival.

Instruments and Equipment

The Beresheet lunar lander featured a compact of scientific instruments focused on measurements, surface imaging, and laser ranging experiments. The primary instrument was the SpaceIL (SILMAG), a fluxgate developed by the , in collaboration with researchers from the . This device was designed to detect lunar crustal s, providing data to investigate the Moon's magnetization history and remnant magnetism from ancient impacts or internal processes. The SILMAG offered high sensitivity with an accuracy of 0.1 nT, a digital resolution of 24 bits, and a of ±8 µT, supporting sample rates of 10 Hz for high-frequency observations or 0.625 Hz for extended . and testing were conducted at Ben-Gurion University prior to launch, though spacecraft-generated magnetic interference complicated full in-situ performance during the . supported the magnetometer's integration through a bilateral that facilitated and technical expertise, predating but aligning with the framework of the (CLPS) initiative. For imaging, Beresheet carried six (CCD) cameras, each with 8-megapixel resolution using Imperx Bobcat B3320C sensors and Ruda-Cardinal optics. Five of these were positioned to generate panoramic views of the lunar surface, enabling for topographic mapping and hazard detection during descent, while the sixth provided self-portraits of the lander. These cameras captured high-definition stills and video to document the approach to the landing site, contributing visual data for post-mission analysis of surface features. The payload also included a NASA-provided from the , a passive comprising eight engineered cube-corner mirrors arranged in a hemispherical aluminum housing (50 mm diameter, 16 mm height). This array was engineered to reflect laser pulses from ground- or orbit-based stations back to their source, supporting precise ranging experiments for lunar positioning with centimeter-level accuracy over long distances. The LRA required no power or active components, making it ideal for long-term surface operations, and underwent rigorous environmental testing for , extremes, and .

Mission Profile

Launch Sequence

The Beresheet lunar lander was integrated as a secondary on a rocket, stacked below the primary of the Indonesian Nusantara Satu and above the U.S. Air Force's S5 , utilizing a spring-loaded dispenser for separation. The stack lifted off on February 22, 2019, at 01:45 UTC from at Air Force Station in , with the generating 1.7 million pounds of thrust to propel the vehicle eastward over the Atlantic Ocean. During ascent, the rocket achieved initial orbit insertion into at approximately 215 km altitude before the second stage performed a burn to establish a highly elliptical with an apogee exceeding 60,000 km, optimized for the primary payload's geosynchronous transfer. Beresheet separated successfully from the 33 minutes after liftoff, marking the start of its independent trajectory. Following deployment, the lander confirmed nominal health through initial systems checks, deployed its solar panels for power generation, extended its landing legs, and established with ground controllers at the mission center in Yehud. Launch services were secured via a rideshare agreement with , enabling cost-effective access to space for the 585 kg lander.

Trajectory to the Moon

Following separation from the launch vehicle on February 22, 2019, the Beresheet lander began its journey from a with an initial perigee of approximately 215 km. To achieve a fuel-efficient path , the executed a series of four orbit-raising maneuvers using its main bipropellant engine, gradually increasing the apogee while maintaining a relatively low perigee. These burns occurred on February 24 (raising perigee to 650 km), February 28 (apogee to 133,000 km), March 7 (apogee to 270,000 km), and March 19 (apogee to 430,000 km), transforming the orbit into a series of phasing loops that synchronized arrival with the Moon's position. The final orbit-raising burn on March 19 effectively served as the , propelling Beresheet onto a that exploited gravitational perturbations for efficiency rather than a direct high-energy escape burn. This approach extended the total travel time to approximately 6.5 weeks but minimized consumption on the 585 kg . An out-of-plane followed on to refine the , ensuring alignment with the lunar . En route, Beresheet performed mid-course corrections to fine-tune its path, including a correction maneuver on April 1 that addressed energy and plane deviations accumulated during the phasing loops. These adjustments, executed via the spacecraft's thrusters, maintained the predicted lunar encounter parameters. On April 4, 2019, Beresheet approached the from the anti-Earth direction and executed its insertion burn at 14:18 UTC, firing the main engine for about six minutes to reduce velocity by over 1,000 km/h relative to the . This maneuver captured the lander into an initial elliptical with a periselene of 450 km and aposelene of 10,246 km (approximately 200 x 9,000 km at its closest alignment). The enabled this capture with reduced delta-v compared to direct trajectories. Over the subsequent week, Beresheet conducted a series of orbit-phasing maneuvers to circularize and lower its orbit for the planned landing. On April 7, a burn reduced the aposelene to 750 km; April 8 lowered the periselene to 210 km; and April 9 achieved a near-circular orbit of 200 x 210 km. This gradual process, spanning multiple periselene and aposelene adjustments, positioned the spacecraft for final descent preparations while allowing time for systems checks and data collection.

Planned Lunar Operations

Following lunar orbit insertion, Beresheet was scheduled to enter a and conduct a series of engine maneuvers over approximately one week to achieve a circular 200 km altitude orbit in preparation for descent. During this orbital phase, the primary scientific activity involved mapping regional magnetic field variations using the onboard SpaceIL (SILMAG), a dual fluxgate instrument developed by the in collaboration with , to investigate the Moon's ancient crustal magnetism. The spacecraft's dual cameras would also image the region to support landing site characterization, while the NASA-supplied Laser Retroreflector Array (LRA) would perform technology demonstrations for precision laser ranging and navigation, enabling future missions to measure distances from Earth-based observatories. Real-time data relay during the orbital phase was planned through the Swedish Space Corporation's ground antenna network for navigation and tracking, with scientific payloads transmitting observations to NASA's Deep Space Network (DSN) for global distribution and analysis. The planned soft landing targeted the northeastern portion of Mare Serenitatis, an ancient basaltic plain selected for its low hazard potential—including minimal craters, rocks, and slopes—and high scientific value due to underlying magnetic anomalies ideal for in-situ magnetometry. This primary site, within a 15 km diameter landing ellipse, was chosen based on orbital data from missions like Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter, with two backup sites in the same 140 km region of Mare Serenitatis to mitigate descent risks such as unexpected terrain features. Contingency procedures included autonomous abort capabilities during descent, allowing the spacecraft to return to orbit if hazards were detected by onboard sensors. After touchdown, Beresheet's surface operations were designed to last up to two days, constrained by the absence of active regulation, with all activities occurring during the lunar morning to maximize availability. The would perform stationary measurements of local to complement orbital data, providing insights into paleomagnetic at the site. Cameras would capture and transmit panoramic photographs and videos of the surrounding terrain, while the Lunar Library, a 25-layer nanofiche archive etched with digital records including Jewish texts and other cultural artifacts, would be deployed for long-term preservation on the lunar surface. Dehydrated tardigrades would also be exposed as part of biological experiments. All surface data transmission would occur via NASA's DSN antennas.

Landing Attempt and Failure

Descent and Landing Attempt

The descent phase of the Beresheet mission commenced on , 2019, at 19:07:55 UTC, when the lander initiated a powered descent burn from a with a perilune of 15 km using its main engine. This maneuver, part of the final braking sequence, aimed to gradually lower the spacecraft toward the lunar surface in the region. Early in the descent, the spacecraft successfully reduced its altitude, achieving a perilune of approximately 15 km without immediate issues reported in . As the descent progressed, onboard systems were activated to support navigation and documentation, including the laser altimeter for precise altitude measurements and the imaging camera to capture selfies and surface views. At around 13.3 km altitude, the altimeter began providing real-time distance data to the ground control team in Yehud, Israel. The initial phases appeared nominal, with the main engine firing as planned to control the descent trajectory. However, at approximately 14 km altitude and 19:19:05 UTC, an anomaly occurred when one of the —a critical —failed, leading to computer resets and a loss of . This failure disrupted the 's orientation, causing it to tumble and complicating engine performance. The chain of events from the IMU failure ultimately resulted in the main engine shutdown during final descent. Despite partial recovery efforts, the continued descending to about 200 meters with limited , as vertical velocity increased beyond safe thresholds.

Crash Sequence

The main engine shutdown, triggered by the chain of events from the earlier IMU failure, caused Beresheet to enter an unpowered free-fall phase beginning from lower altitudes during the final descent. The spacecraft reached a of 500 km/h by the time of impact, far exceeding the planned soft-landing speed of less than 10 km/h. The hard crash occurred on April 11, 2019, at 19:23 UTC, at coordinates 32.5956°N, 19.3496°E within . Telemetry signals were lost just 6 seconds prior to impact, confirming the spacecraft's destruction upon collision with the lunar terrain. Despite the , partial mission successes were achieved in the terminal phase, including the capture and transmission of several images during , providing valuable visual data of the lunar surface and the lander's approach.

Immediate Response

Upon of the loss of communications with Beresheet at approximately 489 feet (149 meters) above the lunar surface on April 11, 2019, the team at the mission control center in , declared the landing attempt a within minutes, citing an onboard engine malfunction that prevented a soft . Opher Doron, general manager of ' space division, addressed the team and public via an emotional livestream broadcast from the center, stating, "We had a in the ; we unfortunately have not managed to land successfully. It’s a tremendous up 'til now," reflecting a mix of disappointment and pride in the mission's orbital accomplishments. The atmosphere in shifted from tense anticipation to stunned silence as indicated the was traveling at over 310 miles per hour (500 km/h) toward impact, with groans from the assembled crowd turning to subdued applause for the overall effort. In the hours following the crash, the SpaceIL team prioritized the recovery and analysis of the final data and images transmitted by Beresheet just before signal loss, which revealed of events including the main engine shutdown and a subsequent failure. This data, including the last photograph captured approximately 9 miles (15 km) from the surface, was downloaded and reviewed to confirm the spacecraft's uncontrolled descent, providing initial insights into the anomaly without any post-impact signals received. Initial assessments relied on orbital trajectory predictions to pinpoint the probable impact site in the region, with the team concluding no further communications were possible due to the high-velocity collision. SpaceIL held an immediate on April 11, 2019, shortly after the event, where project leader Yonatan Weintraub acknowledged the crash but emphasized the mission's successes in reaching and inspiring global innovation, urging young viewers with the words, "We didn't reach the moon in the way we wanted to, but we did reach it. We orbited around it." , SpaceIL chairman, echoed this sentiment, noting, "We didn’t make it but we definitely tried. I think we can be proud," while announcing plans to pursue a follow-on mission. The crash garnered widespread global media coverage, highlighting Israel's pioneering private lunar effort as a milestone despite the outcome, with outlets from to detailing the dramatic final moments. Israeli President , hosting a watch party for children at his residence, praised the attempt in a public statement, reassuring the audience that the Beresheet project represented "a big and excellent achievement" for the nation and humanity, undimmed by the failure.

Investigation and Analysis

Failure Investigation

Following the crash of the Beresheet lunar lander on April 11, 2019, and (IAI) immediately established a joint investigation team comprising engineers from both organizations. The team, led by Opher Doron of IAI's Space Division and Ido Anteby of , was tasked with systematically examining the sequence of events leading to the failure, with the effort spanning several months. The investigation process centered on analyzing telemetry data transmitted from the lander during its , reviewing control room footage, and conducting simulations to model the software behavior under conditions. Hardware components, such as inertial measurement units and star trackers, underwent inspections using ground-based replicas to verify potential failure modes. Anomalies observed during the , including signal losses and resets, were probed through this data-driven approach. A preliminary detailing initial findings from the review was released on April 17, , marking the conclusion of the first phase of the probe. The full investigation wrapped up by late , though the comprehensive was not publicly issued, as the key insights had already been disseminated through interim updates and internal reviews. Significant challenges arose from the inability to recover physical wreckage from the remote lunar impact site, forcing the to depend almost entirely on digital logs, archived , and reconstructed simulations for evidence. Additionally, the mission's constrained $100 million budget limited redundancy in systems, complicating the of intermittent communication issues and component interactions.

Key Findings and Lessons

The investigation into the Beresheet mission's failure identified the primary cause as a malfunction in one of the lander's two (IMUs), which occurred approximately eight minutes into the descent phase on April 11, 2019. This IMU, responsible for acceleration and velocity, suddenly shut down without prior warning, despite functioning correctly during earlier maneuvers. The ground team responded by sending a command to switch to the redundant IMU and the computer, but this action initiated a cascade of failures: the caused critical software patches stored in temporary to be lost, leading to a boot loop where auxiliary software failed to load properly. As a result, the main engine automatically shut down to prevent potential damage, depriving the lander of the needed for a . Secondary issues compounded the problem, including inadequate fault tolerance in the navigation software, which lacked robust handling for such mid-descent anomalies, and untested edge cases arising from the vacuum and radiation environment of space. The lander's reliance on commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) components, such as the IMUs, had not undergone sufficiently rigorous vacuum and thermal testing, making them vulnerable to unexpected failures under operational stresses. Additionally, early mission anomalies—like the star trackers becoming inoperable due to dust contamination shortly after launch—had forced greater dependence on the IMUs for attitude determination, but these were not fully mitigated in the software architecture. Although the star tracker issue did not directly trigger the final descent failure, it highlighted broader weaknesses in sensor reliability. Key lessons from the failure emphasized the need for enhanced in systems to prevent single points of failure from cascading into mission-ending events. For instance, while Beresheet employed dual , the lack of automated without ground intervention proved insufficient; future designs must incorporate independent sensor suites with cross-verification algorithms. Rigorous vacuum and environmental testing of all COTS components, including prolonged simulations of lunar conditions, was identified as essential to uncover latent defects not evident in ground tests. Moreover, improvements to algorithms were recommended, shifting from reactive ground commands to onboard capable of handling dynamic faults during critical phases like , thereby reducing under time pressure. These findings directly informed the design of the follow-on mission, aiming to boost overall mission reliability through enhanced testing and software simulations. Overall, the Beresheet experience underscored the high-risk nature of low-cost lunar missions and the value of iterative learning in advancing private space endeavors.

Aftermath and Legacy

Wreckage and Impact Site

The impact site of Beresheet was precisely located by NASA's (LRO) through imaging conducted on April 22, 2019, eleven days after the crash, at coordinates 32.5956°N, 19.3496°E in the northeastern region of . This positioning, determined with a of 20 meters in and 8 meters in longitude, places the site on the rim of a small a few meters across, within an ancient volcanic plain visible from Earth. The terrain consists of a flat basaltic plain formed from long-ago lava flows, characterized by dark, low-reflectance mare material that has undergone minimal geological alteration over billions of years. No significant surface disruption beyond the immediate impact features was observed, preserving the site's original smooth texture. LRO's Narrow Angle Camera (NAC) captured a sequence of six images from an altitude of 90 kilometers, revealing a dark, elongated smudge approximately 10 meters wide—marking the primary impact point—surrounded by a white of increased reflectance extending 30 to 50 meters outward. This , likely resulting from the ejection of fine particles or , is accompanied by a faint ray of disturbed material stretching about 100 meters southward, indicative of a debris field scattered over roughly 100 meters from the crash dynamics. The lander struck the surface at a high exceeding 1 km/s, contributing to the localized roughening without forming a detectable larger than the pre-existing one. While specific components like engine fragments or solar panels are not distinctly resolved in the images due to resolution limits, the overall pattern confirms widespread dispersal of spacecraft remnants across the . The wreckage holds scientific value as one of the first spacecraft remnants on the , potentially enabling future sample return missions to analyze human-made artifacts, including payloads like the Arch Mission Foundation's Lunar Library with etched human knowledge and biological specimens such as tardigrades. Such studies could provide insights into the durability of terrestrial materials in the lunar environment and the effects of high-velocity impacts on non-indigenous contaminants. As of November 2025, LRO continues to monitor lunar sites including Beresheet's, with no observed changes or degradation reported, as the and low temperatures preserve the debris against significant erosion.

Beresheet 2 Follow-On Mission

In 2020, announced plans for the mission as a successor to the original Beresheet, featuring a mothership that would deploy one lunar orbiter and two small landers for surface operations, with an initial target launch in the first half of 2024. The mission was designed as a private initiative in collaboration with the (ISA) and , including a 2023 scientific cooperation agreement to support payload integration and data sharing, though not as a direct Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS) delivery. This partnership aimed to enable orbital and potential landing capabilities, building on the original mission's orbital insertion success. The spacecraft incorporated design upgrades informed by the original mission's , such as redundant and systems to mitigate single-point failures during descent. The overall mission mass was planned at approximately 1,000 kg, with the two landers each around 100 kg—significantly smaller than the original 585 kg Beresheet—to allow for dual-site landings while optimizing for commercial launch opportunities. Additional payloads included seismic sensors for moonquake detection, water-mapping instruments, and biological experiments like plant growth in sealed environments, selected to advance lunar science priorities. The launch timeline shifted from 2024 to 2025 amid development challenges, but in April 2025, suspended engineering work on due to funding shortfalls, resulting in layoffs of about 25 employees and consultants, as well as frozen supplier contracts. As of November 2025, the project remains on hold while seeks new investors to resume development. Potential revival efforts include leveraging ' (IAI) platform technologies, originally co-developed for Beresheet, though no firm commitments have been secured. Key partnerships extended beyond and , including a 2023 agreement with the () to integrate its Crater Navigation algorithm for precise landing site identification using lunar imagery. A January 2025 memorandum with the further supported scientific experiments on mapping and soil analysis. Despite these collaborations, persistent constraints have stalled progress, with prioritizing educational outreach in the interim.

Cultural and Scientific Impact

Despite its crash landing, the Beresheet mission yielded valuable scientific data during its orbital phase, particularly from its instrument, which measured lunar crustal magnetism and contributed to enhanced models of the Moon's variations. These measurements, taken before the descent, provided insights into ancient lunar magnetic anomalies, aiding global research on the Moon's geological history. Additionally, high-resolution images captured by Beresheet during its approach to the lunar surface supported refined mapping of the region, offering new visual data for planetary scientists studying lunar topography. The mission profoundly influenced Israeli society, igniting widespread enthusiasm for and fostering national pride even in the face of failure, often likened to an "Apollo effect" for inspiring future generations. As a national project, Beresheet engaged educational initiatives that reached over two million students through programs, curricula, and public outreach, promoting interest in and science across schools and universities. Intellectual property from the Beresheet design remains with (IAI), which has licensed elements of the technology for subsequent lunar missions, including the Israeli Lunar Lander (ILL) developed for planetary exploration. This licensing extends to international partnerships, such as an exclusive agreement with to commercialize the lander technology in the United States, demonstrating the mission's enduring technical value. In recognition of its significance, the named the (27050) Beresheet in 2019, honoring the spacecraft's pioneering role in private efforts. The payload's inclusion of dehydrated tardigrades, which survived the crash and scattered across the lunar surface, sparked international discussions in exobiology about the resilience of extremophiles and potential microbial contamination protocols for future missions. Globally, Beresheet pioneered private-sector lunar missions, serving as a model for cost-effective exploration and inspiring subsequent efforts like Japan's ispace Hakuto-R program, which attempted a commercial landing in 2023. The mission also generated economic spin-offs in Israel's technology sector by advancing domestic capabilities in , , and spacecraft manufacturing, bolstering the country's position in the burgeoning commercial .

References

  1. [1]
    Beresheet - NASA Science
    Feb 22, 2019 · Beresheet was Israel's first lunar mission and the first attempt by a private company to land on the Moon. The mission achieved lunar orbit, ...
  2. [2]
    Beresheet1, a private Israeli Moon mission - The Planetary Society
    Beresheet1 was a private mission to the Moon by Israeli non-profit SpaceIL. Built to win the now-defunct $20 million Google Lunar XPrize.
  3. [3]
    SpaceIL's Beresheet Lunar Lander: Israel's 1st Trip to the Moon
    Apr 15, 2019 · SpaceIL's lunar lander, Beresheet, launched from Cape Canaveral on a used SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket on Feb. 21, 2019, along with an Indonesian communications ...
  4. [4]
    Beresheet Lunar Lander - eoPortal
    Feb 13, 2019 · A privately funded Israeli lunar lander originally built for a prize competition is now complete and ready for launch in early 2019.
  5. [5]
    A Crashed Israeli Lunar Lander Spilled Tardigrades on the Moon
    Aug 5, 2019 · SpaceIL's Beresheet was the first privately funded lunar lander to attempt to touch down on the moon. It ended with a crash on April 11. Nasa.
  6. [6]
    From moonshot to funding freeze: SpaceIL halts Beresheet 2 lunar ...
    Apr 2, 2025 · SpaceIL has suspended the engineering development of the Beresheet 2 mission—the planned second Israeli lunar lander—after failing to secure the ...
  7. [7]
    Ex-Prize: Google's $30 Million Moon Race Ends with No Winner
    Jan 23, 2018 · The deadline was originally the end of 2012, but GLXP representatives pushed it back several times, finally to March 31 of this year. Google ...Missing: Beresheet | Show results with:Beresheet
  8. [8]
    How Israel's Moon Lander Got to the Launchpad
    Feb 21, 2019 · After several extensions, the deadline for the Google Lunar X Prize passed a year ago without a winner. Even without the $20 million prize, ...Missing: timeline | Show results with:timeline<|control11|><|separator|>
  9. [9]
    Israeli spacecraft aims for historic moon landing... within months
    Jul 10, 2018 · SpaceIL began in 2011 when engineers Yariv Bash, Kfir Damari and Yonatan Winetraub decided to compete in the Google Lunar XPRIZE, an ...
  10. [10]
    Israel is sending its first spacecraft to the moon. Meet the software ...
    Feb 22, 2019 · The team, named SpaceIL, initially estimated it would have to raise less than $10 million. A decade later, they've spent roughly $100 million.Missing: donations | Show results with:donations
  11. [11]
    SpaceIL's Beresheet, first privately funded moon lander, crash-lands
    Apr 12, 2019 · Much of the funding came from SpaceIL's Kahn, an Israeli-South African software entrepreneur, and the Adelson Family Foundation, a U.S.-based ...
  12. [12]
    SpaceIL receives $1m. grant to land Beresheet 2 on the moon
    Jan 15, 2020 · Moreover, most of the mission's budget was covered by private donors, with the Israeli government funding only 2.5% of the $100 million project.Missing: total donations
  13. [13]
    Israeli Spacecraft Fails to Make First Private Lunar Landing
    Apr 11, 2019 · The $100 million Beresheet spacecraft was not an Israeli government project but was instead funded, built and operated through SpaceIL's efforts ...
  14. [14]
    Here's (almost) everything you need to know about Israel's Moon ...
    Nov 8, 2018 · Google withdrew the cash prizes in April 2018 when no group was able to meet the contest deadline, which had already been extended from 2017. A ...
  15. [15]
    Beresheet fails in historic lunar landing attempt for SpaceIL
    Apr 11, 2019 · In October 2015, SpaceIL became the first Lunar X-Prize entrant to secure a launch contract, which kept the competition going with the new ...Missing: timeline | Show results with:timeline
  16. [16]
    SpaceIL completes lunar lander for February launch
    ### Summary of Beresheet Construction, Timeline, Partners, Funding, Challenges with COTS
  17. [17]
    Israeli company sends world's first privately funded mission to moon
    Feb 21, 2019 · Built by SpaceIL in partnership with the state-owned Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI), Beresheet cost about £70m, a fraction of the cost of ...Missing: construction timeline Rafael Technion
  18. [18]
    Beresheet - Wikipedia
    Beresheet was a demonstrator of a small robotic lunar lander and lunar probe operated by SpaceIL and Israel Aerospace Industries.
  19. [19]
    Beresheet (SpaceIL Lunar Lander) - Gunter's Space Page
    Jul 11, 2025 · Beresheet is a lunar lander by SpaceIL, with a propulsion system, instruments, and a time capsule. It crashed on the moon during landing ...
  20. [20]
    the first commercial lunar lander mission: beresheet - ResearchGate
    Sep 18, 2019 · On 4 April 2019, Beresheet successfully entered Lunar Orbit, and attempted to land on the Moon on 11 April 2019. In this paper the authors de- ...
  21. [21]
  22. [22]
    Frontgrade Processor on its Way to the Moon
    Feb 21, 2019 · The GR712RC, a dual-core LEON3FT processor, is employed in the Beresheet mission computer and will manage all aspects of the journey and landing.
  23. [23]
    LEROS 2b Apogee Engine - Nammo
    The engine successfully performed the orbit raising and lunar orbit insertion maneuvers. This is a cost-efficient, high performance bipropellant engine. The ...
  24. [24]
    Israel's Beresheet lander brakes into lunar orbit - Spaceflight Now
    Apr 4, 2019 · A series of main engine burns nudged Beresheet into longer orbits that took the spacecraft farther from Earth. Beresheet traveled more than ...Missing: type | Show results with:type
  25. [25]
    Israeli moon lander hitches ride on SpaceX launch with Indonesian ...
    Feb 22, 2019 · Formerly known as PSN 6, the satellite carries C-band and Ku-band transponders, along with a high-throughput payload for broadband services.
  26. [26]
    Israeli moon lander prepared for launch - Spaceflight Now
    Feb 21, 2019 · The robotic lander, made up of four legs, avionics, computers and thrusters, will take a circuitous route to the moon. Covered in gold ...Missing: specifications materials
  27. [27]
    Lunar Landing Facilitated by Aitech's Rugged I/O Interface System
    Modular, space-qualified I/O interface unit on unmanned Beresheet lunar lander; Manages power and communications between main computer and critical systems ...
  28. [28]
    As Beresheet heads to moon, Israeli team probes problem with ...
    Feb 22, 2019 · The Israeli team said glare from the sun on the spacecraft's sensors was making it more difficult than expected for the spacecraft to orient ...Missing: IMUs altimeters
  29. [29]
    SpaceIL reveals preliminary reasons behind Beresheet crash
    Apr 18, 2019 · Ido Anteby said Wednesday that the inertial measurement unit (IMU) malfunction during the landing maneuver was its first failure during the ...
  30. [30]
    SpaceIL says “chain of events” led to crash of lunar lander
    Apr 12, 2019 · ... total cost of about $100 million. Both SpaceIL and Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI), the company that built Beresheet for SpaceIL, received ...Missing: breakdown | Show results with:breakdown
  31. [31]
    Moon Mission “Beresheet” – Selfie Against the Backdrop of the Earth
    Mar 5, 2019 · Telemetry and camera data in the Beresheet project control center are obtained with the help of colleagues from Sweden and the equipment of ...
  32. [32]
    The science mission of SpaceIL's Beresheet lander: Plans and results
    Jan 31, 2020 · The mission included several science investigation goals ... This mission carries two scientific investigations: a magnetic fields investigation ...
  33. [33]
    Science, commerce, and the Moon - The Space Review
    Apr 8, 2019 · Besides the retroreflector and the lander's cameras, the main science instrument on Beresheet is a magnetometer. “The main science objective ...
  34. [34]
    The Lunar Library: Genesis - Arch Mission Foundation
    It is installed in the SpaceIL “Beresheet” lunar lander, which crashed on the Moon in April of 2019. The Lunar Library contains a 30 million page archive of ...
  35. [35]
  36. [36]
  37. [37]
    Israeli Lunar Lander Suffers Glitch on Way to the Moon | Space
    Feb 26, 2019 · Beresheet successfully deployed its landing legs shortly after launch and executed its first in-space maneuver on Sunday (Feb. 24) despite ...
  38. [38]
    Maneuver puts SpaceIL lander on course for the moon - SpaceNews
    Mar 19, 2019 · SpaceIL said its Beresheet lander performed a one-minute burn of its main thruster at 8:30 a.m. Eastern, extending the apogee of its orbit ...
  39. [39]
    Israeli Moon Lander Tweaks Orbit to Prep for Thursday Lunar Arrival
    Apr 1, 2019 · Israel's Beresheet moon lander fired its engine again today (April 1) to prepare for a planned capture into lunar orbit later this week.<|control11|><|separator|>
  40. [40]
    Beresheet lunar landing site revealed - Phys.org
    Mar 20, 2019 · Three optional landing sites (primary and two backups) were identified. The terrain in these locations is composed of material characteristic of ...Missing: contingencies | Show results with:contingencies
  41. [41]
    Beresheet Lunar Landing Site Revealed - Weizmann Wonder Wander
    Mar 17, 2019 · The chosen site is located in the northeastern part of Mare Serenitatis, a few hundreds of km east of the Apollo 15 landing site and a similar ...Missing: coordinates | Show results with:coordinates
  42. [42]
    Inside Israel's Crash-Landing on the Moon - Tablet Magazine
    May 21, 2019 · SpaceIL signed a launch contract with SpaceX in 2015. Beresheet would reach space atop one of the company's Falcon 9s, groundbreakingly ...
  43. [43]
    Israeli Moon Lander Suffered Engine Glitch Before Crash - Space
    Apr 12, 2019 · "A technical glitch in one of Beresheet's components triggered the chain of events yesterday that caused the main engine of the spacecraft to ...Missing: type | Show results with:type
  44. [44]
    Beresheet spacecraft: 'Technical glitch' led to Moon crash - BBC
    Apr 12, 2019 · Preliminary data from the Beresheet spacecraft suggests a technical glitch in one of its components caused the lander to crash on the Moon.Missing: avionics | Show results with:avionics
  45. [45]
    Israel's Beresheet Spacecraft Crashes Into Moon During Landing ...
    Apr 11, 2019 · Beresheet continued looping around our planet for the next six weeks, performing engine burns now and again to push its elliptical orbit closer ...
  46. [46]
    Israel's Beresheet spacecraft crashes on Moon - BBC
    Apr 11, 2019 · Israel's Beresheet spacecraft is believed to have smashed into the lunar surface after engine failure.Missing: report | Show results with:report
  47. [47]
    Beresheet Comes Close before Crashing on the Moon
    Apr 11, 2019 · Mission controllers announced Beresheet had a problem with its main engine, and the spacecraft stopped transmitting shortly thereafter.Missing: shutdown | Show results with:shutdown
  48. [48]
    Beresheet Impact Site Spotted - NASA
    May 15, 2019 · The photo above shows the landing site of the Israeli Beresheet spacecraft on a region of the Moon called Sea of Serenity, or Mare Serenitatis in Latin.Missing: aluminum frame composite<|separator|>
  49. [49]
    Israel's Beresheet spacecraft crashes into the moon during landing ...
    Apr 11, 2019 · The Beresheet spacecraft crashed into the moon's surface during its attempt to land on Earth's satellite on Thursday evening, dashing the hopes of hundreds of ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  50. [50]
    Moon Landing by Israel's Beresheet Spacecraft Ends in Crash
    Apr 11, 2019 · A small spacecraft that has captured the imagination and excitement of people in Israel and around the world appears to have crashed into the moon on Thursday.
  51. [51]
    Rivlin encourages children: This was a big accomplishment
    Apr 11, 2019 · President Reuven Rivlin is reassuring the children gathered at his residence that the Beresheet spacecraft project was a huge accomplishment ...
  52. [52]
    What Happened to Beresheet? | R&E | מכון דוידסון
    ### Summary of Beresheet Lunar Lander Failure Investigation
  53. [53]
    Investigation of Israeli lunar lander's crash points to human factor
    Apr 17, 2019 · A manually entered command apparently set off a chain reaction of events that led to last week's crash of an Israeli-built lunar lander.Missing: onboard | Show results with:onboard
  54. [54]
    5-6 attempts to restart Israeli moon lander's engine failed ...
    Apr 17, 2019 · According to the investigation, a malfunction was discovered in an acceleration sensor called IMU. A command sent to the sensor led to a ...
  55. [55]
    First findings issued on Beresheet's crash landing - Globes English
    Apr 17, 2019 · The spacecraft failed to successfully decelerate for a soft landing on the moon, hit the surface with full force, and disintegrated.
  56. [56]
  57. [57]
  58. [58]
    Software Command to Fix Faulty Sensor Doomed Beresheet
    Apr 17, 2019 · Landsman said an IMU failure on its own would not have caused Beresheet to crash, as the spacecraft has redundant units. The Post report, as ...
  59. [59]
    Past mistakes to avoid in our grand return to the Moon this decade
    Nov 11, 2022 · The investigation revealed that during the final descent phase, one of the lander's two Inertial Measurement Units (IMUs)—a sensor that tracks ...
  60. [60]
    What items will Israel's Beresheet 2 Moon mission bring for the ...
    Sep 27, 2022 · The Beresheet 2 mission will use vision-based landing sensor algorithms developed by Lulav Space and Ramon.Space's radiation-hardened computing ...
  61. [61]
    Beresheet Crash Site Spotted!
    May 15, 2019 · The coordinates of the darkest pixel (lowest reflectance) of the central "smudge" are 32.5956°N, 19.3496°E, with a 20-m (latitude) by 8-m ( ...
  62. [62]
    Beresheet Moon Impact Site - NASA Science
    As soon as its orbit placed NASA's Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO) over the landing site on April 22, 2019, LRO captured a six-image sequence of the area ...
  63. [63]
    Scientists Reveal Beresheet Spacecraft Lunar Landing Site
    Mar 19, 2019 · The terrain in these locations are composed of material characteristic of ancient mare surfaces – large, dark basalt plains resulting from long ...
  64. [64]
    Israeli spacecraft Beresheet crash site spotted on moon - Phys.org
    May 16, 2019 · While the spacecraft did land, it first touched the surface about 1000 meters per second faster than intended. The mishap occurred late in the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  65. [65]
    LRO Publications - NASA Science
    Jan 29, 2025 · Constraining the Structure under Lunar Impact Basins with Gravity. ... (2020), The science mission of SpaceIL's Beresheet lander, Planetary ...Missing: specifications | Show results with:specifications
  66. [66]
    Launching "Beresheet 2" Project - IAI
    Dec 9, 2020 · Beresheet will comprise three spacecraft – one orbiter and two landers – and will be launched in around four years. Along with scientific ...Missing: construction timeline
  67. [67]
    ISA and NASA sign SpaceIL Beresheet-2 Mission scientific ... - Gov.il
    Feb 1, 2023 · Beresheet2 is planned to launch by SpaceIL in 2025. MK Ofir Akunis, Israel's Minister of Innovation, Science and Technology: "The Beresheet ...
  68. [68]
    Beresheet 2 to include two landers and an orbiter - SpaceNews
    Oct 31, 2021 · IAI is handling the design of Beresheet 2 while SpaceIL works to bring in new partners for the mission. That includes a memorandum of ...
  69. [69]
    Beresheet 2 - Gunter's Space Page
    Jun 21, 2025 · Beresheet 2 is a lunar lander and orbiter mission by SpaceIL, with three spacecraft, but it is currently on hold due to lack of funding.<|control11|><|separator|>
  70. [70]
    Beresheet 2: A German-developed navigation algorithm will help the ...
    SpaceIL has signed a cooperation agreement with DLR, the German Aerospace Center. Construction of the spacecraft will be completed in summer 2025.
  71. [71]
    SpaceIL, Italian Space Agency to cooperate on Beresheet 2
    Jan 29, 2025 · The organization managed to attract Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) and billionaire investor Morris Kahn to the effort. The project amassed ...Missing: Authority | Show results with:Authority
  72. [72]
    Photos of the Moon by Israel's Beresheet Spacecraft
    Apr 12, 2019 · A self portrait taken during descent showed part of the spacecraft and the moon's surface about 14 miles away.
  73. [73]
    Israel's Beresheet spacecraft snaps stunning images of far side of ...
    Apr 5, 2019 · Israel's Beresheet spacecraft has captured its first images of the far side of the Moon ahead of the probe's historic lunar landing later ...
  74. [74]
    The Beresheet Effect - Weizmann Institute of Science
    Apr 14, 2019 · Israel's Beresheet spacecraft ended its eight-year journey to the Moon with a crash landing, but it succeeded in galvanizing Israelis—and fans ...
  75. [75]
    Israel Space Agency and NASA sign a statement of scientific ...
    Feb 1, 2023 · Beresheet1 has had an enormous educational impact on more than 2 million students ... Israeli Pride: Successful Launch of the "Dror 1" National ...
  76. [76]
    Moon Lander | Israel's Lunar Lander for Planetary Missions - IAI
    IAI's moon-lander (about 1.6 m height, 2.3 m in diameter and a launch mass of 600 Kg) is suitable for multiple payload housing options.Missing: specifications materials power
  77. [77]
    Firefly Aerospace and Israel Aerospace Industries Enter Exclusive ...
    Jul 9, 2019 · It has signed an Intellectual Property and Engineering Support Agreement with Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) for technology based on its Beresheet Lunar ...Missing: rights | Show results with:rights
  78. [78]
    Meanings of minor-planet names: 27001–28000 - Wikiwand
    27050 Beresheet, 1998 SW4, The Beresheet spacecraft was the first Israeli-built mission to go to the Moon. Beresheet entered Lunar Orbit on April 4, 2019, but ...
  79. [79]
    Private Japanese spacecraft crashes into moon in 'hard landing ...
    Jun 5, 2025 · Today's landing attempt was part of a wave of private lunar exploration, which kicked off with Israel's Beresheet lander mission in 2019.
  80. [80]
    History of IAI and the Security of Israel
    Beresheet, a co-development lunar lander of IAI and SpaceIL and the 1st commercial lunar mission, situated Israel as the 4th country to attempt landing and ...
  81. [81]
    Israel and the moon effect: From Beresheet to the Lunar Library
    Jun 7, 2022 · We also contributed with one million new shekels to fund the association's educational activities and 700,000 new shekels to fund the science ...