Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

CRIStin

CRIStin (Current Research Information System in Norway) was the national platform for registering and reporting research outputs in Norway from 2010 until its closure for new registrations on August 19, 2025, after which its data was migrated to the Norwegian Research Information Repository (NVA).^[1]^[2]^[3] Owned and managed by Norway's Ministry of Education and Research, it enabled researchers at universities, colleges, and other institutions to document scientific publications, projects, research groups, and personnel profiles in a standardized format, supporting national oversight of R&D activities.^[1]^[4]^[5] The system contributed to the Norwegian Scientific Index by aggregating verified publication data, which informed funding allocations, performance-based research funding, and institutional rankings, thereby promoting transparency and comparability in Norwegian academia.^[6]^[7]

Overview

Purpose and Scope

CRIStin, or the Current Research Information System in Norway, functions as a centralized national database designed to register, manage, and report research activities across publicly funded institutions. Its primary purpose is to provide research organizations with a unified tool for documenting scientific outputs, thereby facilitating efficient administrative reporting to government bodies and supporting performance evaluations for funding allocation. This system streamlines data collection on publications, projects, and personnel, reducing duplication of effort and enabling institutions to maintain comprehensive overviews of their research portfolios.^[8]^[9] The scope of CRIStin extends to the higher education, independent research institutes, and specialized health research sectors, encompassing all R&D activities funded by Norwegian public sources. It mandates registration of peer-reviewed scholarly publications for inclusion in the Norwegian Scientific Index, which underpins mechanisms like the performance-based funding model introduced in 2009, where publication points directly influence institutional budgets—approximately 2% of university funding derives from such indicators as of 2010 onward. Beyond publications, the system accommodates entries for research projects, including those in health sciences registered via integrations with national health registries, and researcher profiles to track collaborations and expertise.^[10]^[4]^[1] By prioritizing standardized metadata and quality controls, CRIStin seeks to enhance transparency and accessibility of Norwegian research data, aiding in national policy-making and international benchmarking while minimizing administrative overhead for users—goals articulated in its development to allocate more institutional time toward core research endeavors rather than fragmented reporting. Although operational until August 19, 2025, when registrations ceased for migration to the successor Norwegian Research Information Repository (NVA), CRIStin's framework continues to inform ongoing national efforts in research documentation.^[11]^[8]

Establishment and Governance

The Current Research Information System in Norway (CRIStin) was launched in 2004 to serve as a centralized national database for registering scholarly publications, research projects, and related activities conducted by Norwegian researchers and institutions.^[12] Initially developed as a project at the University of Oslo, it quickly expanded into a comprehensive shared infrastructure supporting over 160 public research organizations, including universities, colleges, and institutes, to facilitate standardized reporting and overview of national research output.^[13] The formal CRIStin organization was established in January 2011 to manage and sustain the system on a permanent basis.^[14] Ownership resides with the Ministry of Education and Research, in cooperation with the Ministry of Health and Care Services, reflecting its role in coordinating research documentation across education, health, and institute sectors.^[15] Governance emphasizes ministerial oversight for policy alignment, funding allocation, and integration with national research evaluation frameworks, such as the Norwegian Scientific Index. Operational development and maintenance were delegated to the Norwegian Directorate for ICT and Joint Services in Higher Education and Research (Unit), which handled technical implementation, data quality assurance, and system interoperability until CRIStin's phase-out in August 2025.^[16] This structure ensured CRIStin functioned as a government-mandated tool for performance-based funding distribution and research visibility, with mandatory registration requirements for affiliated researchers.^[4]

History

Origins and Development (Pre-2004)

The origins of CRIStin can be traced to the need for structured documentation of research activities in Norwegian higher education institutions during the 1990s, driven by increasing demands for accountability in public funding allocation and performance evaluation. Universities, facing fragmented manual reporting processes, began developing localized digital systems to catalog publications, projects, and researcher profiles. The University of Oslo led these efforts with FRIDA (Forskningsresultater, Informasjon og Dokumentasjon om vitenskapelig Aktivitet), an integrated research documentation platform initiated under the university's IT services division, USIT, to centralize data on scientific outputs and support institutional reporting to national agencies like the Research Council of Norway.^[17]^[18] FRIDA's architecture emphasized quality assurance in data entry, including verification of publication details against international standards, and enabled export functionalities for bibliometric analysis, laying foundational principles for scalable national use. By the early 2000s, similar but less advanced systems, such as ForskDok via Bibsys, operated at other institutions, highlighting inefficiencies in decentralized approaches and prompting inter-institutional collaboration. These pre-national prototypes addressed causal gaps in research oversight—such as inconsistent metrics for funding decisions—but were limited to individual universities, with FRIDA serving as the primary model due to its comprehensive integration of research, education, and administrative data at Oslo. Discussions for a unified system gained momentum around 2002–2003, influenced by European trends in current research information systems (CRIS) and Norway's policy shifts toward evidence-based resource distribution, though full implementation awaited post-2004 harmonization.^[19]^[20]

Launch and Early Implementation (2004–2010)

The system underlying CRIStin was established in 2004 through collaboration among Norwegian research institutions, initially focusing on standardizing the documentation of scholarly outputs such as publications, projects, and researcher affiliations.^[21] This foundation drew from prior local efforts, particularly at the University of Oslo, to create a shared platform that addressed fragmented data practices across universities and colleges. Early priorities included developing uniform registration routines and unique identifiers for researchers to ensure data consistency and interoperability, amid challenges like varying institutional workflows and the coexistence of competing databases such as BIBSYS ForskDok.^[22] By 2005, registrations had begun accumulating, with over 70,500 scholarly publications documented in the system by later evaluations, reflecting gradual adoption for national research monitoring.^[23] Implementation from 2004 to 2010 involved phased expansion, starting with pilot integrations at select universities like Oslo and Tromsø under the interim name Frida, before broadening to other higher education and research entities.^[24] This period emphasized building a comprehensive repository for research activities, complementing bibliographic systems like BIBSYS by prioritizing current information on outputs rather than archival storage. Key developments included protocols for verifying publication data and linking it to funding allocation models, such as publication points used in Norway's performance-based funding since the early 2000s.^[25] Institutions progressively shifted from disparate local tools to the joint system, though full unification lagged due to technical harmonization needs and resistance from ForskDok users. In October 2010, the Norwegian Ministry of Education and Research, in coordination with the Ministry of Health and Care Services, formalized CRIStin as a national entity, rebranding and restructuring it to encompass all public research sectors including higher education, health, and institutes.^[26] This transition marked the end of the early phase, enabling centralized governance and mandatory reporting for scholarly publications, with the system poised for broader data usage in policy evaluations by 2011.^[21] The effort supported empirical tracking of research productivity, registering outputs across disciplines without favoring specific fields, though initial coverage was uneven due to voluntary participation in non-mandated categories.^[22]

Evolution and Expansions (2011–2024)

Following its initial implementation, CRIStin expanded its core functionalities to encompass not only publication registration but also project documentation and linkages to funding sources, enabling institutions to track research activities more comprehensively. By 2011, the system had begun incorporating mandatory reporting of externally funded projects, including those from the Research Council of Norway (RCN), where users could assign six-digit RCN project codes to publications for better traceability and impact assessment.^[27] This development supported the Norwegian publication-based funding model, which allocates institutional resources based on weighted publication points derived from CRIStin data, with adjustments over time to include diverse output types such as monographs and book chapters prevalent in social sciences and humanities.^[25] The model's evolution emphasized balanced coverage across disciplines, avoiding over-reliance on journal metrics, and by the mid-2010s, CRIStin data informed annual funding distributions totaling approximately 2% of higher education and institute sector budgets.^[28] A significant expansion occurred in open access integration, aligning with national policy shifts. In 2014, a government report recommended full open access for publicly funded research by 2024, prompting CRIStin to enhance its role as a centralized repository for disseminating metadata and full-text links.^[29] By August 2017, formal national guidelines mandated immediate open access for articles, with CRIStin facilitating compliance through automated checks against the Norwegian Scientific Index (NVI) for peer-reviewed status and level classifications (Level 1 for standard academic outlets, Level 2 for top-tier).^[30] This included web services for data export to institutional systems, enabling reuse in grant applications and R&D statistics, while promoting green open access via self-archiving protocols.^[31] These features improved transparency, as evidenced by rising registration rates—over 44,000 publications annually by the late 2010s—while addressing coverage gaps in non-English outputs.^[32] Further refinements through 2024 focused on data quality, interoperability, and evaluation metrics. CRIStin incorporated advanced validation tools to ensure comprehensive reporting across sectors, including health and independent institutes, with expansions to capture international co-authorship indicators for policy analysis.^[33] By 2020, integrations with external databases like Web of Science enhanced bibliometric inputs for the NVI, supporting refined funding formulas that weighted collaborative and multidisciplinary outputs.^[34] Annual reporting deadlines, such as January 20 for publications, streamlined operations, while preparatory migrations underscored CRIStin's maturation into a robust national CRIS before its 2025 transition to the Norwegian Research Information Repository (NVA). These evolutions prioritized empirical tracking over narrative biases, fostering accountability in resource allocation without privileging politically favored fields.^[4]

Core Components

Norwegian Scientific Index

The Norwegian Scientific Index (NVI), integrated within the CRIStin system, serves as a bibliographic framework for identifying and classifying academic publications to support Norway's research evaluation and funding mechanisms.^[10] It operationalizes criteria for "academic" outputs by requiring publications to present verifiable new insights, undergo independent peer review prior to dissemination, and appear in approved channels accessible to the research community, aligning with international standards such as the Frascati Manual.^[10] This classification enables the quantification of scholarly production across higher education, research institutes, and health sectors for result-based budget redistribution.^[10] Publication channels—encompassing journals, series, and publishers—are evaluated and cataloged in the Norwegian Register for Scientific Journals, Series and Publishers, administered by the Norwegian Directorate for Higher Education and Skills.^[35] Channels meeting minimum scientific quality thresholds receive Level 1 status, denoting basic academic merit through relevance in national or international scholarly contexts, institutional endorsement, and adherence to peer-review processes.^[36] Level 2 designation applies to approximately the top 20% of channels, recognized as leading outlets in their fields based on enhanced criteria including international impact and editorial rigor, as determined by expert panels convened by the National Board of Scholarly Publishing.^[37] Level 0 indicates non-academic channels ineligible for evaluation, while Level X denotes channels under review or disputed.^[37] As of recent assessments, the register lists over 27,000 approved journals and series at Levels 1 and 2, alongside approximately 1,700 publishers.^[35] Within CRIStin, users register publications by linking them to NVI-approved channels, assigning metadata such as author affiliations and Health Research Classification System (HRCS) codes for interdisciplinary outputs like health research.^[10] Eligible entries contribute points to the Norwegian Publication Indicator (NPI), where Level 1 yields one point per publication (with multipliers for types like monographs) and Level 2 doubles the value, informing annual funding allocations—typically reported by April 1 for the prior year.^[10] This process, formalized around 2011, standardizes reporting across sectors to enhance transparency in resource distribution while incentivizing high-quality dissemination.^[38] Assessments occur periodically, with major reviews (e.g., completed by August 2023) ensuring ongoing validity amid evolving scholarly publishing landscapes.^[35]

Publication Registration System

The Publication Registration System in CRIStin served as the primary mechanism for Norwegian researchers to document scholarly outputs, enabling a centralized national database of research publications from higher education institutions and approved research institutes.^[8] Publications registered included peer-reviewed journal articles, monographs, book chapters, and conference proceedings that met criteria for academic merit, such as contributing original knowledge through systematic methods and rigorous scrutiny.^[39] Only outputs affiliated with Norwegian institutions qualified, with mandatory registration for eligibility in the Norwegian Publication Indicator (NVI), which allocated block funding based on weighted points.^[40] Registration required users to first search the database using identifiers like DOI, ISBN, or ISSN to avoid duplicates, followed by entry of detailed metadata including author affiliations, publication date, and the specific channel (journal, series, or publisher) from the Norwegian Scientific Index.^[41] For a publication to receive NVI points, the channel had to be approved at Level 1 (standard academic quality, yielding 1 point shared among authors) or Level 2 (top-tier, limited to 20-25% of channels, awarding up to 3 points for primary authorship).^[42] Non-academic outputs, such as popular science articles or reports, could be registered for completeness but did not accrue points.^[4] The process emphasized verification: academic status demanded peer review, relevance to the field, and publication in indexed channels, with institutional libraries often assisting to ensure compliance.^[43] Deadlines aligned with NVI cycles, typically requiring submission by February 1 of the year following publication to influence funding distributions.^[16] This system facilitated annual reporting of over 50,000 publications by the mid-2010s, promoting accountability while linking outputs to projects funded by bodies like the Research Council of Norway.^[44] Data integrity relied on user diligence and periodic audits, though challenges included inconsistent affiliation reporting and delays in channel approvals.^[10]

Functionality and Operations

User Registration and Data Entry

Users access the CRIStin system through institutional affiliation, as participation requires membership in a participating Norwegian research institution or organization connected to the national research infrastructure.^[45] To register as a user, individuals contact their institution's local superuser, who grants access after verifying eligibility, typically for researchers, faculty, or administrative staff involved in research documentation.^[45]^[16] Authentication occurs via FEIDE, Norway's federated electronic identity system, using an institutional username and password; upon first login, a user profile is often created automatically, though editing privileges for publications and projects demand confirmed institutional affiliation.^[16]^[44]^[46] Data entry begins after login, where users select their affiliated institution from the dashboard and navigate to the "Register results" section to initiate a new entry.^[47] Publications and other research outputs are categorized by type, such as journal articles, books, or conference papers, with mandatory registration required for scientific publications to qualify for national funding metrics like publication points.^[4] Users then input details including author lists (in the exact order as the original source), titles, publication dates (specifying "published" or "in press"), and metadata like journal names, which are verified against integrated databases via keyword searches.^[47]^[43] Prior to entry, users must search the existing CRIStin database to avoid duplicates, and authors bear responsibility for accuracy, often supported by institutional superusers who handle imports or quality checks.^[41]^[40] For non-publication outputs like projects or outreach activities, similar workflows apply, with categories aligned to national guidelines (e.g., KUF for artistic research), requiring linkage to the institution and adherence to rules like single-category listing per activity.^[48] Institutional protocols may mandate documentation, such as PDFs for point-eligible works, and superusers ensure compliance with data quality standards before finalization.^[41] This process emphasized manual verification to maintain data integrity for national reporting, though automation via imports from publisher APIs was available for some journals.^[40]

Integration with Other Systems

CRIStin facilitated integration with external systems primarily through the development of web services and APIs, enabling data exchange and reuse across the Norwegian research ecosystem. In 2012, initial web services were established to connect CRIStin with the Research Council of Norway's (RCN) reporting portal, allowing project leaders to report results by directly importing data from CRIStin rather than manual entry.^[49] This integration, expanded in 2013 to cover RCN-funded project outcomes, reduced redundancy and improved accuracy in funding evaluations.^[50] By 2016, additional government funding supported broader interoperability, including RESTful APIs that permitted institutions to query and retrieve CRIStin data for internal systems such as human resources or institutional repositories.^[51] These APIs transformed CRIStin from a siloed reporting tool into a central metadata hub, with even minor custom integrations yielding significant efficiency gains, as demonstrated in case studies of data synchronization for performance metrics.^[52] CRIStin also integrated with international identifiers like ORCID, incorporating ORCID iDs into researcher profiles to enable automated synchronization of publication records and affiliation data.^[53] This linkage extended to library systems via ISNI registries, facilitating bibliographic consistency and reducing duplicate entries in national databases.^[53] Overall, these connections emphasized CRIStin's role in streamlining workflows, though adoption varied by institution due to varying IT infrastructure compatibility.^[54]

Data Usage in Research Evaluation

CRIStin data on registered scholarly publications serve as the primary input for the Norwegian Publication Indicator (NPI), a national system that quantifies research output through weighted points to support performance-based funding allocation. Publications are categorized by type—such as journal articles, monographs, or conference papers—and assigned to channels in the Norwegian Scientific Index, which classifies outlets as Level 1 (standard) or Level 2 (highest international quality). For instance, a Level 1 journal article yields 1 point, divided among authors by affiliation share, while a Level 2 article yields 3 points under the same distribution; monographs receive 5 points at Level 1 or 8 at Level 2.^[55]^[56] These calculations, performed annually using CRIStin exports, ensure points reflect both productivity and quality, with non-Norwegian co-authors' shares proportionally reducing institutional credits.^[10] The aggregated NPI points directly influence resource distribution to higher education institutions, research institutes, and health sectors, comprising one of four key indicators in Norway's result-based funding model managed by the Ministry of Education and Research. Since its integration in 2011, publication performance has accounted for approximately 10-15% of the basic grant redistribution, incentivizing output while adjusting for institutional size and discipline variations.^[25]^[18] CRIStin facilitates this by validating data against the Norwegian Scientific Index and forwarding verified points to authorities, enabling formulaic funding decisions that prioritize peer-reviewed, high-impact work over raw volume.^[10] Beyond funding, CRIStin data underpin national and institutional research evaluations, including bibliometric analyses by the Research Council of Norway. For example, evaluations of specific fields, such as legal research, incorporate CRIStin-sourced publication and citation metrics modeled against Web of Science data to assess productivity trends and internationalization.^[57]^[58] Institutions leverage the system for internal performance reviews, grant applications to the Research Council, and compliance reporting, with data interoperability allowing reuse via web services for customized metrics like researcher-level output lists.^[45] This usage promotes transparency but relies on accurate self-reporting, as points are only awarded for verified, approved registrations.^[4]

Impact and Assessment

Contributions to Norwegian Research Policy

CRIStin facilitated the Norwegian performance-based research funding system by providing a centralized database for registering scholarly publications, which underpinned the Norwegian Publication Indicator (NPI) introduced in 2004 and operationalized for funding allocations starting in 2005.^[25] The NPI assigns weighted points to peer-reviewed outputs—such as 1 point for domestically oriented publications (level 1) and 3 points for internationally recruitable ones (level 2), adjusted for co-authorship—drawing directly from CRIStin-registered data to distribute approximately 2% of higher education institutions' basic funding, totaling around NOK 400 million annually by the mid-2010s.^[25] ^[57] This mechanism incentivized institutions to prioritize high-quality, international outputs while standardizing reporting across universities, colleges, and research institutes, thereby informing Ministry of Education and Research policies on resource allocation.^[59] By aggregating comprehensive publication metadata, including citations and journal classifications verified against sources like Web of Science, CRIStin enabled bibliometric evaluations that modeled publication rates and impacts for policy assessments, such as those conducted by the Research Council of Norway (RCN).^[57] This data infrastructure supported evidence-based adjustments to funding formulas, contributing to a reported increase in Norway's share of internationally co-authored papers from 25% in 2005 to over 40% by 2015, aligning with national goals for research internationalization and competitiveness.^[25] CRIStin's role extended to open access policy development; in 2014, it surveyed all Norwegian research institutions to map institutional APC funds, open access mandates, and contact points, aiding the government's progression toward a national open access strategy with targets for 100% OA by 2020 for certain funder outputs.^[14] CRIStin also enhanced policy transparency by mandating institutional registration of R&D activities, which fed into RCN grant evaluations and national reporting, reducing discrepancies in self-reported data and promoting accountability in public funding use.^[8] Evaluations of the system highlighted its contribution to consistent data quality for performance metrics, though later critiques noted potential overemphasis on quantity; nonetheless, it established a precedent for national CRIS systems influencing EU-level discussions on harmonized research assessment.

Achievements in Transparency and Accountability

CRIStin established a centralized national repository for scholarly publications, research projects, and other outputs from Norwegian public research institutions, enabling standardized verification and public accessibility of research activities that reduced reliance on disparate institutional reporting and minimized inconsistencies in data submission.^[8] This infrastructure supported transparent bibliometric analyses, as all registered outputs underwent quality checks against approved publication channels, fostering verifiable metrics for national research assessments.^[25] By serving as the primary data source for the Norwegian Publication Indicator, introduced in 2004, CRIStin linked institutional funding to documented outputs through a weighted points system—where one publication point equals 1,000 Norwegian kroner—reallocating approximately 2% of higher education sector funding based on peer-reviewed publications registered in the system.^[25] ^[14] This mechanism enhanced accountability, as institutions and researchers were incentivized to accurately report verifiable achievements, with points calculated transparently from level 1 (standard) and level 2 (high-impact) channels covering over 80% and 20% of outlets, respectively.^[60] CRIStin advanced open access compliance by mandating registration of accepted manuscripts for parallel publishing in institutional repositories, aligning with national policies such as the Research Council of Norway's 2006 open access guidelines and the 2017 goal of full open availability by 2024.^[30] ^[14] This integration facilitated tracking of open access dissemination, contributing to Norway's high rates of openly available research outputs and enabling funders to enforce transparency in publicly financed results without commercial dependencies.^[29]

Limitations and Criticisms

CRIStin has been criticized for its reliance on an outdated technological platform, which hampers efficiency and integration with modern tools. Developed on legacy systems, the database requires extensive manual data entry without sufficient automation, often referred to as a lack of "automagi" by researchers, leading to redundant work and limited reuse of metadata for purposes like CVs or funding applications.^[61] ^[62] This obsolescence contributed to repeated delays in upgrades, with a planned CRIStin 2.0 version postponed multiple times, including into 2017, exacerbating user frustration.^[63] Researchers have highlighted significant administrative burdens associated with CRIStin, including time-intensive registration processes that divert effort from core research activities. Surveys and reports indicate widespread dissatisfaction, particularly in fields like physiotherapy and humanities, where the system's rigidity fails to accommodate diverse outputs beyond peer-reviewed publications, such as reports or artistic works.^[64] Institutions have reported challenges in data verification and editing, compounded by periodic shutdowns for maintenance, as seen in the August 2025 closure for all registration activities.^[65] In the context of Norway's publication-based funding model, CRIStin data has faced scrutiny for enabling gaming behaviors by institutions, such as inflating publication counts through strategic classifications, and for inadequately filtering questionable or predatory journals. A 2016 evaluation identified flaws in indicator design reliant on CRIStin metrics, including overemphasis on quantity over quality, which distorted resource allocation.^[25] Additionally, the system's handling of retracted or erroneous entries, like those from the 2006 Sudbø scandal, has drawn criticism for merely marking rather than fully excluding problematic records, potentially perpetuating inaccuracies in evaluations.^[66] These issues underscore broader concerns about data integrity and the platform's fitness for high-stakes policy uses.

Transition and Legacy

Reasons for Replacement by NVA

The replacement of CRIStin by the Norwegian Research Information Repository (NVA) addressed longstanding inefficiencies in Norway's fragmented research information landscape, where publication registration occurred separately from open access archiving.^[67] Prior to the transition, CRIStin handled national registration of research activities, including publications and projects, but institutions maintained over 67 distinct local repositories (such as Brage, BORA, and HVL Open) for archiving and disseminating outputs, resulting in duplicated efforts, inconsistent data entry, and challenges in achieving comprehensive national oversight.^[67]^[68] This separation increased administrative burdens on researchers and institutions, as metadata had to be managed across multiple platforms, often leading to incomplete open access compliance and fragmented reporting for policy purposes.^[69]^[70] NVA was developed to consolidate these functions into a single, centralized national system, enabling simultaneous registration, archiving, and dissemination of research outputs to streamline workflows and reduce redundancy.^[3]^[68] By migrating CRIStin's data—closed to new registrations on August 19, 2025—and integrating content from institutional repositories, NVA eliminates the need for parallel systems, allowing researchers to register publications once for both national reporting and open access fulfillment.^[8]^[3] This unification supports Norway's open science mandates more effectively, providing a unified platform for metadata harvesting, persistent identifiers, and enhanced discoverability, which CRIStin alone could not achieve due to its narrower focus on registration without integrated archiving.^[67]^[70] Critics of CRIStin highlighted its outdated technical infrastructure and limited interoperability with international standards, which hampered efficient data sharing and evaluation in an era of increasing emphasis on open access metrics.^[71] NVA's adoption of modern repository standards, including better support for DOIs and API integrations, was intended to rectify these shortcomings, fostering a more scalable system aligned with EU-level open science initiatives while maintaining national control over research data.^[67] The transition, culminating in NVA's official launch on October 1, 2025, reflects a policy-driven push by the Norwegian Ministry of Education and Research to modernize infrastructure for long-term sustainability and reduced institutional costs.^[70]^[72]

Migration Process and Timeline

The migration process from CRIStin to the Norwegian Research Information Repository (NVA) entailed the automated transfer of research outputs, projects, and associated metadata from CRIStin and over 67 institutional repositories into a centralized national system managed by Sikt, the Norwegian Agency for Shared Services in Education and Research.^[67]^[71] This consolidation aimed to eliminate redundant data entry across fragmented systems while preserving historical records.^[72] Personal and institutional data linked to academic positions were automatically populated in NVA user profiles upon login via institutional credentials.^[44] Data migration commenced following the closure of new registrations in CRIStin, with full integration of content from local archives such as BORA, Brage, and NTNU Open occurring progressively to ensure continuity in research reporting and open access functions.^[73]^[74] Users were instructed to verify migrated entries in NVA for accuracy, as minor discrepancies—such as in student assignments—required targeted corrections by Sikt.^[75] Post-migration, CRIStin transitioned to read-only access for archival purposes, while NVA assumed all ongoing registration, reporting, and dissemination responsibilities.^[76] Key milestones included the development phase of NVA starting in fall 2019, with operational rollout accelerating in 2025.^[76] CRIStin halted new entries on August 19, 2025, triggering the bulk data transfer.^[8] Many institutions began adopting NVA in September 2025, with full availability from September 10 in some cases.^[74] The official launch occurred on October 1, 2025, marking the complete replacement of CRIStin nationwide.^[67] Ongoing refinements to the migrated dataset continued into late 2025 to address integration challenges.^[76]

Ongoing Influence Post-2025

Following the cessation of new registrations on August 19, 2025, CRIStin entered a read-only mode, preserving direct access to its historical database of Norwegian research outputs, projects, and personnel records spanning from its launch in 2010.^[77] This archival functionality supports ongoing scholarly inquiries into pre-2025 research trends, such as longitudinal analyses of publication volumes and citation impacts across disciplines.^[8] The bulk migration of CRIStin's data into the Norwegian Research Information Repository (NVA), completed by late September 2025, embeds its legacy records within the new national platform, ensuring continuity for research evaluations and funding allocations that reference historical metrics.^[72] NVA's integration of these datasets facilitates seamless querying of combined pre- and post-migration information, underpinning Norway's bibliometric assessments and compliance with European standards for current research information systems (CRIS).^[67] CRIStin's established protocols for data validation and the Norwegian Scientific Index—covering approved journals, series, and publishers—continue to inform NVA's quality controls, mitigating disruptions in institutional reporting to the Ministry of Education and Research.^[7] As of October 2025, this persistence enables researchers and policymakers to maintain accountability in performance-based funding models, with over 1.5 million registered publications from CRIStin forming a baseline for tracking national research productivity gains.^[68]

References

[1]
Cristin - NHH
Cristin (Current Research Information System in Norway) is the Norwegian system for registrating and reporting research activity. Cristin was introduced in ...
[2]
Cristin | University of Bergen Library | UiB
CRIStin is now replaced by the Norwegian Research Information Repository (NVA). Main content. Cristin is replaced by the Norwegian Research Information ...
[3]
Transition from Cristin to the National Research Archive (NVA)
May 8, 2025 · As of August 19, 2025, Cristin will be closed for new registrations. All data will be migrated to the new system: the National Research ...
[4]
Report research findings in Cristin - University of Inland Norway
Cristin is the system used for registration and reporting of research activities. Cristin is also used to submit data on scientific publications to the ...
[5]
CURRENT RESEARCH INFORMATION SYSTEM IN NORWAY/THE ...
Cristin is a national research information system for documenting the outputs of research (publications etc.). The national research archive (NVA) collects ...
[6]
Researcher pages - English - Cristin
Researcher pages. Upload a version of your article when you register the article in Cristin. Remember to register your academic publications for NVI.
[7]
Research information system Cristin | Nord.no
Info September 2025: The Norwegian Research Information Repository (Nasjonalt vitenarkiv, NVA) replaces Cristin and the institutional repositories.
[8]
Home - English - Cristin
Aug 19, 2025 · Register results and profiles, research groups. Log in to Results. Register projects and edit health research projects. Log in to Projects.
[9]
Publishing | Employee Pages | UiB
The purpose of CRIStin is to simplify and quality assure the reporting of research results and annual report data, and to help make the research and expertise ...
[10]
Reporting instructions (NVI) - English - Cristin
The Norwegian Scientific Index (NVI) in the research information system Cristin (hereafter called "the system") is used for registration of complete ...
[11]
[PDF] Cristin in the Norwegian research landscape - EuroCRIS
Cristin in the Norwegian research landscape. euroCRIS membership meeting. Espen ... Goals: More time for research & more efficient research administration.
[12]
Open Access in Norway - MDPI Blog
Mar 25, 2025 · CRISTIN, launched in 2004, documents all scholarly publications by Norwegian researchers. The platform will be integrating with the National ...Missing: scope | Show results with:scope<|separator|>
[13]
[PDF] CRIS 2012 Proceedings - EuroCRIS
CRIStin, (Current Research Information SysTem in Norway), is a national CRIS serving more than 160 institutions within the university/college sector, research ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[14]
[PDF] education, research and open access in norway
Nov 24, 2014 · The CRIStin organisation was established in January 2011 under the ownership of the Ministry of Education and Research in cooperation with the ...
[15]
[PDF] Current Research Information SysTem In Norway Visit to Iceland ...
To our knowledge, Norway is the first country to establish a truly national CRIS. Page 17. Benefits to researchers and institutions. Each publication is ...
[16]
Cristin registration - Kristiania
Cristin (Current Research Information SysTem in Norway) is a national register that is intended to provide a comprehensive overview of results from R&D/AD and ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[17]
[PDF] Vekt på forskning. Nytt system for dokumentasjon av vitenskapelig ...
inkluderer de fleste av institusjonene: ForskDok (Bibsys) og Frida (USIT ved. UiO). Men beslutninger og oppfølging må ligge innenfor de to organisasjonene ...
[18]
CRISTIN | Department of Philosophy | UiB
CRISTIN is a system for the documentation of research results, information and documentation of scientific activities.Missing: scope | Show results with:scope
[19]
[PDF] Samspillet mellom FS og andre systemer - Semantic Scholar
Current Research Information SysTem In Norway. Page 2. Topics. •Background ... predecessor FRIDA and CRIStin would not be that different as far as the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[20]
https://dspacecris.eurocris.org/handle/11366/330
[21]
[PDF] Superbrukeropplæring 7.2.2019 - Cristin
Selve systemet ble etablert i 2004, og er 15 år i år. Systemet fikk navnet Cristin i. 2010, da det ble gjort om til et nasjonalt system.
[22]
[PDF] Measuring scientific performance for improved policy making | ARMA
Apr 13, 2014 · research information system in Norway (CRIStin). Data on research ... CRIStin was launched in. 2010 and collects information on about ...
[23]
[PDF] R&D Evaluation Methodology and Funding Principles - ARIS
Jan 19, 2015 · Notes: Based on the registration of 70,500 scholarly publications in Norway's Cristin-system since 2005. Source: Sivertsen, G. (2014). 3.7.3 ...
[24]
Creating New Research Databases in Sweden and Norway - Ariadne
In 2011, a new system called CRIStin was implemented to replace Frida/Forskdok. In addition to the previous system it also includes publications that are not ...
[25]
Publication-Based Funding: The Norwegian Model - SpringerLink
Apr 20, 2016 · Cristin (The Current Research Information System in Norway; cristin.no) is a shared system for all research organizations in the public ...
[26]
[PDF] Cristin-10-040 22.10.2010 AS - Til: Institusjoner i helsesektoren
Oct 22, 2010 · Etablering av Cristin. Kunnskapsdepartementet har i samarbeid med Helse- og omsorgsdepartementet etablert organisasjonen Cristin. Cristin ...
[27]
[PDF] Registering a project code on an academic publication - Cristin
In order for this to work you will have to register the project code from the RCN on the publication registration in. CRIStin. It is recommended to add the ...
[28]
Publication-Based Funding: The Norwegian Model - ResearchGate
May 30, 2016 · This article describes the main components of the model and how it has been implemented, as well as the effects and experiences in three of the ...
[29]
National goals and guidelines for open access to research articles
Aug 22, 2017 · The goal of the government is to make all publicly funded Norwegian research articles openly available by 2024. Norway shall be a driving force ...
[30]
Open access to research - English - Cristin
The Norwegian government established national guidelines for open access to research articles on august 22nd 2017.
[31]
[PDF] how CRIStin is building a national infrastructure for Open Access
Researchers can generate publications lists to be used in application for grants from the NRC. • Institutions can reuse data from the CRIS via web services.
[32]
Generational differences in international research collaboration
The study is based on data for 5,600 Norwegian researchers and their publication output during a three-year period (44,000 publications). Two indicators for ...
[33]
Understanding and Evaluating Research and Scholarly Publishing ...
Jun 28, 2019 · CRISTIN (The Current Research Information System in Norway; cristin.no) is a shared system for all research organizations in the public ...Missing: pre- | Show results with:pre-
[34]
(PDF) The Norwegian Model in Norway - ResearchGate
The “Norwegian Model” attempts to comprehensively cover all the peer-reviewed scholarly literatures in all areas of research in one single weighted indicator.
[35]
Norwegian Register for Scientific Journals, Series and Publishers
In the Norwegian Register, you will find an overview over academic journals, series and publishers (publication channels), and you are welcome to suggest new.
[36]
Criteria for level 1 - Kanalregisteret
Aug 22, 2025 · Should be scientific relevant within its scientific field in Norwegian and/or international academic environments. · Must be suggested as an ...
[37]
Levels and changes in levels - Kanalregisteret
Level 1 and level 2 means that the publication channels are recognised as approved academic publication channels. Level 0 means that the publication channel is ...Missing: Index | Show results with:Index
[38]
Om NPI - Norsk publiseringsindikator - HK-dir
... Cristin og NVI (Norsk vitenskapsindeks) i 2011 fikk Norge felles rapportering av vitenskapelig publisering for UH-sektor, instituttsektor og helseforetak.
[39]
How to register academic publications for NVI - English - Cristin
To be classified as "academic", a publication has to meet all of the criteria below (see Reporting instructions paragraph 1).Missing: integration expansions
[40]
Registering procedures in Cristin - NHH
The main rule is that all publications and conference appearances shall be registered into Cristin. This includes: books; parts of books; journal articles ...Missing: process | Show results with:process
[41]
Registration - Biblioteket USN
Before registration, please search Cristin for the publication to check if it is already in the system. Log in to Cristin USN. Guides to registration in Cristin.
[42]
About the Norwegian Register - Kanalregisteret - HK-dir
Jul 4, 2025 · The Norwegian Register for Scientific Journals, Series and Publishers gives you an overview over approved academic publication channels and ...
[43]
Registration - For employees - University of Oslo - UiO
Nov 19, 2015 · Access to Cristin for UiO's employees · Work support > Research support > Publication > After publication > Cristin/NVA > Registration.Missing: details | Show results with:details
[44]
Register your research - NTNU
Registration deadline. Deadline for registering your research publications is 20 January.Missing: expansions | Show results with:expansions
[45]
FAQ - Frequently asked questions - English - Cristin
Oct 17, 2017 · To become a Cristin user, your institution must be in Cristin. Contact your local superuser for access. To log in, you must be registered and ...Missing: process | Show results with:process
[46]
Help and explanations | NHH
Log on to Cristin with your employee-number and usual NHH-password (FEIDE-logon). Faculty and administrative staff at NHH are registered as Cristin-users.
[47]
[PDF] GUIDE TO REGISTERING A PUBLICATION IN CRISTIN
You are now on your research profile page. Click on "Register results". 6. Select the main category of your publication, e.g. “Journal Publication”.
[48]
Registering public and user-oriented outreach in Cristin - Wikier
Additional listing guidelines: Each activity should be listed under only one category. (Example: an interview should be listed either under "Journal Article - ...
[49]
[PDF] Rapport og planer 2012-2013 - Cristin
Mar 15, 2013 · • Integrasjon med andre systemer via WebServices. Vi startet i 2012 med å etablere kobling til Forskningsrådets rapporteringsportal, slik at ...
[50]
[PDF] Even minor integrations can deliver great value – A case study
The implementation of a new API service has facilitated integrations with other systems, and is now changing the CRIStin system into the research information ...
[51]
[PDF] Årsrapport 2016 - Cristin
Mar 14, 2017 · Det ble gitt ekstra bevilgning i 2016 for å styrke integrasjon mellom Cristin og andre systemer, og dette er det nå lagt til rette for på ...
[52]
Even Minor Integrations Can Deliver Great Value – A Case Study
When CRIStin (Current research information system in Norway) was established, the system mainly served as a tool for reporting academic publishing activity ...
[53]
[PDF] Cristin - ORCID
The Norwegian ORCID-concortium. • The Norwegian concortium was established december 2017. • Founded by the Ministry of Education and Research. • Currently 95 ...
[54]
CRIStin in the Norwegian research landscape - EuroCRIS
May 28, 2019 · CRIStin as the national CRIS in Norway is an important hub for metadata in the research ecosystem. The presentation provides an overview of ...
[55]
Calculation of points for academic publications - English - Cristin
Nov 1, 2017 · Data from Cristin should be used to calculate points for academic publications in the three sectors. Points for academic articles are a weighted number.
[56]
Publication Channels and Publication Points - HVL
Oct 12, 2022 · Academic publication channels mean publishers that have been approved by the national publishing committee and been entered into the Norwegian register.
[57]
[PDF] Recent Research and Innovation Evaluations in Norway
The evaluation uses a formula for modelling the publication and citation rates, and is based on publication data from CRIStin and Web of science. The report is ...
[58]
Evaluation of legal research in Norway
The Research Council of Norway will evaluate research conducted by institutions whose main areas of activity include law. The evaluation will look at the ...
[59]
Resultat #1677799 - The effects of performance-based ... - Cristin
Renewed discussions on the relationship between productivity and citation impact in research. The effects of performance-based research funding systems are ...
[60]
Publication channels, levels and credits - Oslo - UiO
Nov 19, 2015 · When calculating points, the author's percentages must be weighted (multiplied) by a professionally determined number. The combinations of ...
[61]
Cristin forsvinner. Uklart hva som blir bedre i det nye systemet.
Oct 3, 2023 · «Cristin er bygget på et teknologisk system som er gammelt og utdatert. Derfor trenger systemet en fornyelse med dagens teknologiske muligheter ...
[62]
https://www.uniforum.uio.no/leserbrev/2020/pa-tide-a-fa-mer-ut-av-cristin.html
[63]
Skriftlig spørsmål fra Marianne Aasen (A) til kunnskapsministeren
Torbjørn Røe Isaksen: CRIStin 2.0 er forsinket, og skal etter planen ferdigstilles i løpet av 2017. Årsaken til forsinkelsen er at oppdraget med utvikling av ...
[64]
- Stor misnøye med CRIStin - Fysioterapeuten.no
Jan 19, 2016 · En del av misnøyen går ifølge Uniforum ut på at forskningsdatasystemet ennå ikke har blitt lastet inn på en ny teknologisk plattform, slik ...Missing: systemet | Show results with:systemet
[65]
I dag stengjer Cristin for registrering og redigering - Uniforum - UiO
Aug 19, 2025 · Det er Sikt Kunnskapssektorens tenesteleverandør som vil stengja Cristin for all bruk om under ein time. Det går fram av ein epost som ...
[66]
Ble trukket for 17 år siden, nå skal skandaleartiklene merkes - Khrono
Jan 19, 2023 · Sudbø-artiklene skal altså ikke fjernes fra Cristin-systemet, de skal merkes. Da Khrono før jul var i kontakt med Jens Petter Berg, som var ...
[67]
Norwegian National Research Information Repository (NVA) launched
Oct 4, 2025 · Norwegian National Research Information Repository (NVA) launched. Sat, 04/10/2025 - 20:15 euroCRIS Secret...Missing: establishment | Show results with:establishment
[68]
Norwegian Research Information Repository (NVA)
Sep 26, 2025 · NVA replaces Cristin (Current Research Information System in Norway) and the institutional repository Brage. In NVA, both the registration ...
[69]
New Norwegian knowledge archive (NVA) replaces Cristin - UiO
May 7, 2024 · Cristin has been in use since 2010 as a common national system for publicly funded research institutions.<|separator|>
[70]
Portal for publishing and Open Access | UiT
NVA was officially launched October 1st 2025. NVA replaces the old system, Cristin. NVA is a joint system for registering and reporting research activities for ...
[71]
NVA | University of Bergen Library | UiB
Norwegian Research Information Repository (NVA) is a national service for registration and reporting of research output, and access to research publications.
[72]
Today we start using the Norwegian Research Information ...
Sep 22, 2025 · The Norwegian Research Information Repository (NVA) is a national joint service for registering and reporting research results, and for making ...
[73]
Transition from CRISTIN and BORA to Nasjonal vitenarkiv (NVA)
May 16, 2025 · Content from Cristin and BORA will be migrated to NVA, and NVA will replace all functions currently performed in Cristin and BORA.
[74]
Publishing | NMBU
NVA: The Norwegian Research Information Repository will be available from September 10 2025, and replaces Cristin and Brage. Brage: NMBU's Open Research Archive ...
[75]
NVA – Norwegian Research Information Repository - Ansatt - OsloMet
Sep 19, 2016 · Deficiencies have been discovered in the migration of student assignments from ODA to NVA. Sikt is working on the issue. Access to NVA. Academic ...
[76]
[PDF] Norwegian National User Group Annual report 2025 - Sikt | IGeLU
The development of the National Knowledge Archive (NVA) began during the fall of 2019. ... NVA will fulfil the role as Norway's Current Research Information ...
[77]
NVA – Norwegian Research Information Repository - Oslo - UiO
Cristin is now closed for registration · Registration in NVA will become available at the end of August · There will be read-only access to Cristin for quite some ...Missing: system 1990s