Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Carnotaurus

Carnotaurus sastrei is a genus of large abelisaurid theropod dinosaur that inhabited South America during the Late Cretaceous epoch, approximately 72 to 69 million years ago, in what is now Patagonia, Argentina.^[1] Known from a single, exceptionally well-preserved nearly complete skeleton discovered in 1984 by Argentine paleontologist José F. Bonaparte in the Chubut Province, it represents one of the best-understood non-avian theropods from the Southern Hemisphere.^[2] This bipedal carnivore measured about 8 meters (26 feet) in length, stood roughly 2.5 meters (8 feet) tall at the hips, and weighed approximately 1.5 metric tons (1.7 short tons), making it a formidable predator adapted for agility rather than raw power.^[2]^[1] The dinosaur's most striking features include prominent, bull-like horns formed by thickened brow ridges above its eyes, likely covered in keratin sheaths and possibly used for intraspecific combat or display.^[2] Its skull was short and robust with blade-like teeth suited for slicing flesh, while its forelimbs were extraordinarily reduced—shorter than those of Tyrannosaurus rex—bearing four tiny fingers with claws, suggesting limited use in predation.^[1] The preserved skin impressions reveal a mosaic of small, pebbly scales interspersed with larger conical osteoderms along the body and tail, providing evidence of a textured, possibly armored integument unique among theropods.^[3] As a member of the Abelisauridae family within Ceratosauria, Carnotaurus exemplifies the evolutionary divergence of Southern Hemisphere theropods during the Cretaceous, coexisting with diverse fauna in a coastal floodplain environment of the La Colonia Formation.^[4] Its lightweight build, elongated hindlimbs, and high-arching tail indicate adaptations for speed, supporting inferences of it as an active hunter of medium-sized prey such as ornithopods and smaller dinosaurs.^[1] The genus name, derived from Latin for "meat-eating bull," aptly captures its carnivorous diet and horned morphology, while the species epithet honors the ranch Sastre where the holotype was found.^[1]

Discovery and research history

Discovery

The holotype specimen of Carnotaurus sastrei was discovered in 1984 during a paleontological expedition led by Argentine paleontologist José F. Bonaparte in the La Colonia Formation of Chubut Province, Patagonia, Argentina.^[5] The initial find was reported by a local landowner from the Sastre family, who spotted the exposed fossil in 1983 and alerted geologists from the state oil company YPF, prompting Bonaparte's team to investigate the site.^[6] The excavation was conducted under challenging conditions, as the skeleton was partially eroded and exposed to weathering on the surface of a remote ranch, necessitating meticulous techniques to extract the fragile bones without further damage.^[7] The process involved careful jacketing of the remains in plaster and burlap for protection, followed by arduous transport over rough terrain to Buenos Aires, where the specimen was housed at the Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales Bernardino Rivadavia under catalog number MACN-CH 894. This nearly complete skeleton, preserving the skull and much of the postcrania, represents one of the most intact abelisaurid finds to date.^[8] Bonaparte provided the first scientific description and illustrations of the specimen in his 1985 naming publication, highlighting its distinctive features and establishing it as a novel theropod taxon.^[9]

Naming and specimens

The genus Carnotaurus and the species C. sastrei were formally named and briefly described by Argentine paleontologist José F. Bonaparte in 1985, based on a well-preserved theropod skeleton from the Late Cretaceous La Colonia Formation in Chubut Province, Patagonia, Argentina.^[9] The generic name Carnotaurus combines the Latin words caro (flesh) and taurus (bull), alluding to the animal's carnivorous diet and the prominent bull-like horns on its skull.^[10] The specific epithet sastrei honors Ángel Sastre, the owner of the ranch (Estancia Pocho Sastre) where the fossils were discovered.^[11] A more detailed description followed in 1990 by Bonaparte, Fernando E. Novas, and Rodolfo A. Coria, published in Contributions in Science.^[12] The holotype specimen, MACN-CH 894, housed at the Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales Bernardino Rivadavia in Buenos Aires, consists of a nearly complete and articulated skeleton, including the full skull, much of the vertebral column, ribs, pectoral and pelvic girdles, forelimbs, hindlimbs, and extensive skin impressions.^[13] This exceptional preservation makes it one of the most complete abelisaurid skeletons known, allowing for detailed anatomical study.^[14] Beyond the holotype, Carnotaurus sastrei is known from a limited number of referred specimens, primarily isolated elements and partial remains from the same Patagonian region. These materials, recovered from sites in Chubut and Río Negro provinces, support the presence of C. sastrei in a coastal floodplain environment during the Maastrichtian stage.^[15] All known specimens of Carnotaurus sastrei are considered valid referrals to the type species, with no proposed synonyms or taxonomic revisions challenging the monotypic status of the genus; potential misattributions to other abelisaurids have been resolved through comparative analyses confirming unique traits such as the robust supraorbital horns and short forelimbs.^[14]

Subsequent studies

Following the initial description, subsequent research in the late 1990s focused on biomechanical analyses of the Carnotaurus holotype skull to infer its functional capabilities, revealing a relatively fast but not particularly strong bite force suited for agile predation rather than bone-crushing. Mazzetta et al. (1998) utilized comparative modeling to suggest that the horns likely served in intraspecific combat through low-impact butting or shoving, emphasizing the skull's lightweight construction for rapid head movements. These analyses, building directly on the holotype specimen, highlighted the dinosaur's adaptations for speed over raw power in feeding mechanics.^[16] In the 2000s and early 2010s, detailed examinations of the preserved skin impressions from the holotype advanced understanding of its integument, initially interpreted as featuring rows of osteoderms and patterned scalation indicative of armored protection. However, a comprehensive 2021 study revised these views, demonstrating that the skin consisted of a mosaic of small, irregular polygonal scales interspersed with larger, conical feature scales distributed randomly rather than in uniform rows, with no evidence of true osteoderms embedded in the dermis. This work clarified that the integument provided flexibility and possibly sensory functions over rigid armor, influencing reconstructions of abelisaurid soft tissue. Phylogenetic analyses in the 2010s incorporated newly described abelisaurid fossils from Madagascar (such as Majungasaurus) and India (such as Rajasaurus), refining Carnotaurus's position within Abelisauridae as a basal member of a South American clade while underscoring Gondwanan biogeographic connections. Carrano and Sampson (2008) established a foundational framework placing Carnotaurus as sister to more derived forms like Majungasaurus, based on shared cranial and postcranial traits. Subsequent revisions, including Tortosa et al. (2014), integrated European and Indo-Madagascan taxa to support a closer affinity between Indian-Madagascan lineages and some non-South American abelisaurids, though Carnotaurus remained firmly rooted in South American diversity.^[17] Post-2020 research has employed advanced imaging and modeling techniques on the holotype, such as CT scans for endocranial reconstruction and 3D digital simulations for assessing neck mobility and muscle attachments. Ongoing debates regarding growth rates draw from bone histology of referred abelisaurid materials from contemporaneous Patagonian deposits, suggesting rapid juvenile growth tapering to determinate adulthood, though direct sampling of Carnotaurus remains is lacking. A 2024 review further explored the functions of the horns, suggesting roles in species recognition and thermoregulation alongside combat.^[18]

Description

Skull

The skull of Carnotaurus sastrei measures approximately 60 cm in length from the premaxilla to the occipital condyle, presenting a robust and boxy overall shape with a shortened, deep profile typical of advanced abelisaurids.^[19] This compact cranium features a tall snout formed by deepened maxillae and a reduced antorbital region, while the premaxillae and nasals exhibit extensive ornamentation with rugose, pitted textures that extend across much of the dorsal surface.^[14] The nasal bones contribute to a prominent midline ridge, enhancing the skull's structural rigidity and contributing to its distinctive, horned appearance.^[20] One of the most striking features of the Carnotaurus skull is the pair of prominent supraorbital horns, which project obliquely upward and outward above the orbits. These horns, measuring up to 15 cm in length, are formed primarily by the fused frontal bones and are thick, conical structures that are internally solid and covered externally by a rough, vascularized texture suggestive of keratinous sheaths in life.^[21] The frontals bear deep excavations at their bases, integrating seamlessly with the surrounding orbital margins to form a reinforced bony framework.^[14] The dentition of Carnotaurus consists of 16 conical teeth per side in the upper jaw (four in the premaxilla and twelve in the maxilla) and approximately 15 in the dentary of the lower jaw, all characterized by low crowns that are recurved, laterally compressed, and finely serrated along their mesial and distal edges.^[22] These teeth decrease in size posteriorly and lack the robust, blade-like form seen in many other theropods, instead emphasizing a grasping function through their pointed apices and shallow enamel layers.^[14] The braincase of Carnotaurus is robustly constructed, with large supratemporal and posttemporal fenestrae that provided expansive attachment surfaces for the jaw adductor musculature, contributing to the skull's overall strength despite its relatively lightweight build. Additional features include a well-developed basisphenoid with prominent basipterygoid processes and a spacious cranial cavity, as revealed by CT analyses, underscoring adaptations for efficient sensory processing within a compact enclosure.

Postcranial skeleton

The postcranial skeleton of Carnotaurus sastrei is represented by a nearly complete holotype specimen (MACN-CH 894), providing insights into its bipedal, lightly built frame. The animal reached an estimated length of 7.5–8 meters and a body mass of 1.3–2.1 metric tons, derived from scaling the holotype skeleton and volumetric reconstructions.^[23] The axial skeleton comprises 10 short, robust cervical vertebrae forming a relatively rigid neck, 12 dorsal vertebrae contributing to a compact trunk, 6 fused sacral vertebrae, and approximately 42 caudal vertebrae forming a long tail.^[24] The cervical series features amphicoelous centra with low neural arches and prominent epipophyses, enhancing stability over flexibility.^[25] The dorsal vertebrae exhibit tall neural spines and robust transverse processes, supporting a deep ribcage, while the caudals transition from robust anterior forms with tall neural spines to slender posterior ones, enabling tail flexibility.^[26] The pectoral girdle is reduced, with a small scapula and coracoid articulating to form a narrow glenoid. The forelimbs are exceptionally diminutive, consisting of a short humerus (~28 cm long), very short and robust radius and ulna (~8 cm long, one-quarter the humerus length), terminating in a four-fingered hand. The manus features elongate metacarpal IV as the largest element (~8.4 cm), with phalanges bearing hoof-like unguals adapted for scratching rather than grasping.^[27]^[26]^[13] The pelvic girdle is robust, characterized by a tall, elongate ilium with a pronounced supraacetabular crest for muscle attachment. The hindlimbs are powerful and proportioned for bipedal support, with a left femur measuring 103 cm long (holotype), a slightly longer tibia, and fibula; the pes includes elongated metatarsals III and IV, indicative of a digitigrade stance with strong pedal claws.^[26]^[28] The tail is long and flexible, supported by haemal arches (chevrons) that extend posteriorly, housing large caudofemoralis musculature for hindlimb retraction. Skin impressions overlie parts of the axial and appendicular skeleton, revealing non-overlapping scales.

Skin impressions

The holotype specimen of Carnotaurus sastrei (MACN-CH 894) preserves extensive skin impressions across the neck, torso, and tail, representing the first such detailed preservation for a large-bodied theropod dinosaur.^[26] These impressions reveal a texture formed by a mosaic of small, rounded basement scales, typically 5–12 mm in diameter, interspersed with larger conical feature scales measuring 20–65 mm in diameter, resulting in an overall pebbly and knobby surface.^[29] The scales are densely distributed on the flanks and tail, providing comprehensive coverage in those regions, while being sparser on the neck; notably, no feathers or filamentous structures are evident in the preserved integument.^[30] This scale morphology bears resemblance to the scutes of modern crocodilians, indicating potential armored protection against injury or environmental factors.^[31] The close apposition of the skin to the underlying bones suggests a "shrink-wrapped" body outline, with minimal soft tissue padding between the integument and skeleton.

Classification

Placement within Theropoda

When José F. Bonaparte described Carnotaurus sastrei in 1986 based on a nearly complete skeleton from Patagonia, he classified it within Theropoda as the type genus of a new family, Carnotauridae, positioned among the carnosaurs (a then-broad group of advanced theropods including allosauroids and tyrannosauroids).^[26] This placement emphasized its large size, bipedal carnivorous form, and distinctive cranial ornamentation, though Bonaparte noted its unique combination of features that distinguished it from better-known North American theropods.^[26] By the 1990s, Carnotaurus was recognized as a ceratosaur based on primitive traits such as a reduced antorbital fenestra and other basal theropod characteristics shared with Ceratosaurus and early Gondwanan forms.^[32] This shift reflected growing evidence from South American discoveries that highlighted its affinities with non-tetanuran theropods, moving away from the carnosaur grouping that had briefly aligned it near tyrannosaurids due to superficial similarities in robust build and predatory adaptations.^[32] A pivotal reanalysis in 2004 by Diego Pol reinforced Carnotaurus's position within Abelisauroidea, a clade of ceratosaurs with strong Gondwanan ties, particularly in South America, based on shared derived features like an abbreviated maxilla and specialized cranial kinesis.^[32] Pol's phylogenetic framework underscored its evolutionary role in late Gondwanan ecosystems, linking it more firmly to other Patagonian theropods. The current consensus places Carnotaurus as a derived abelisaurid within Ceratosauria, specifically in the South American clade Brachyrostra, supported by synapomorphies including markedly shortened forelimbs with reduced manual digits and a deep, laterally compressed skull. This positioning is affirmed by comprehensive cladistic analyses that recover it within this derived subclade, emphasizing its role as an iconic representative of Late Cretaceous southern theropod diversity.^[33]^[34]

Relationships within Abelisauridae

Carnotaurus sastrei is positioned within the derived clade Abelisauridae, a group of Gondwanan ceratosaurian theropods characterized by robust skulls and reduced forelimbs. Phylogenetic analyses consistently recover it as a member of this family, often nested among late Cretaceous taxa from South America. In foundational studies, Carnotaurus forms a sister taxon relationship with Majungasaurus crenatissimus from Madagascar, with both sharing features such as a shortened snout and specialized cranial kinesis. More recent analyses from the 2020s place Carnotaurus within the South American subclade Brachyrostra (also encompassing Furileusauria), in a polytomy or sister relationship with taxa such as Aucasaurus, Koleken inakayali, and Niebla, based on shared synapomorphies like short maxillae, ≤12 maxillary teeth, and absence of certain vertebral grooves.^[33] These relationships highlight Carnotaurus's affinity with other Patagonian abelisaurids, while Majungasaurinae represents a separate Indo-African subclade including Majungasaurus and Rajasaurus narmadensis. Resolution varies across matrices due to fragmentary specimens, but Brachyrostra's monophyly is supported in recent phylogenies by shared short maxillae and robust quadrates.^[34] Distinctive autapomorphies of Carnotaurus include its elongated supraorbital horns formed by the postorbitals and extremely reduced forelimbs, with a humerus shorter than the radius and only four diminutive manual digits. These traits distinguish it from close relatives like Aucasaurus, which lacks such prominent horns and retains slightly longer arms. Within Abelisauridae, Carnotaurus exemplifies extreme morphological specialization, contributing to the recognition of subgroups such as Brachyrostra—a South American clade of short-snouted forms including Carnotaurus, Aucasaurus, and Ekrixinatosaurus. Brachyrostra is supported as monophyletic in several recent phylogenies by shared short maxillae and robust quadrates.^[33] The distribution of Carnotaurus and its relatives underscores the Gondwanan radiation of Abelisauridae during the Late Cretaceous, with taxa spanning South America (Carnotaurus), Africa (Majungasaurus, Rugops), and India (Rajasaurus, Indosaurus). This pattern reflects vicariance following the breakup of Gondwana, with abelisaurids diversifying as top predators in isolated landmasses. Evolutionary trends within the family show progressive cranial ornamentation, from subtle rugosities in basal forms to elaborate horns and bosses in derived taxa like Carnotaurus, potentially linked to display or intraspecific combat. Concurrently, forelimb reduction intensified over time, culminating in the vestigial arms of Carnotaurus, a trend paralleled in other theropod lineages but uniquely extreme in abelisaurids, possibly tied to shifts in locomotion or prey-handling strategies.^[35]

Paleobiology

Sensory systems and brain

The endocranial volume of Carnotaurus sastrei measures approximately 170 cm³, which is relatively small given its estimated body mass of 1,300–2,100 kg, yielding a reptile encephalization quotient (REQ) of roughly 0.4–0.5 based on brain-to-endocast ratios of 37–50%.^[36] This indicates a brain size typical for large non-coelurosaurian theropods, prioritizing basic sensory and motor functions over advanced cognitive processing seen in more derived groups.^[36] The olfactory bulbs and tracts are notably enlarged and elongated, occupying a significant portion of the forebrain and projecting anteroventrally, which suggests a well-developed sense of smell suited for detecting prey or carrion over distances, potentially aiding in hunting or scavenging in its forested paleoenvironment.^[36] In contrast, the optic lobes are moderately developed with limited expansion, implying competent but not exceptional visual acuity, likely sufficient for identifying movement in low-light conditions but without the heightened stereopsis of coelurosaurs.^[36] The inner ear features three well-defined semicircular canals, with the anterior canal forming a prominent ring and the flocculus projecting blade-like into it, configurations that indicate sensitivity to rapid head rotations and support agile head movements during pursuits or evasion maneuvers.^[36] Overall, the neuroanatomy of Carnotaurus reflects a more basal theropod condition compared to coelurosaurs, with greater relative investment in olfaction over vision and reduced emphasis on binocular overlap, as inferred from the subdued optic regions and skull morphology.^[36]

Locomotion and posture

Carnotaurus sastrei was a bipedal theropod dinosaur adapted for terrestrial locomotion, maintaining a horizontal body posture typical of large carnivorous dinosaurs. Its long, slender hindlimbs, which measured approximately 3.5 meters from hip to foot, provided the primary support and propulsion, enabling efficient bipedal gait while the short forelimbs, less than 1 meter in length, hung pendulous and contributed minimally to weight-bearing. This skeletal proportion, with hindlimbs comprising over 60% of the total body length, optimized balance and forward momentum during movement.^[12] Biomechanical models based on limb proportions and muscle reconstructions estimate that Carnotaurus could reach speeds of up to 48–56 km/h in short bursts, surpassing many contemporaneous large theropods and supporting its role as an agile predator. These estimates derive from analyses of femur length, stride dynamics, and the powerful retractor muscles in the hindlimbs, allowing for rapid acceleration over distances of 50–100 meters. The tail served as a critical counterbalance during such sprints, stiffened by ossified tendons along its length to prevent lateral swaying and enhance stability at high velocities.^[37] The forelimbs, with their reduced size and limited range of motion, were likely vestigial for manipulative tasks but may have functioned in maintaining balance or minor postural adjustments during turns or uneven terrain traversal. Muscle modeling indicates capabilities for shoulder protraction/retraction and elbow flexion/extension, though these movements were constrained and not suited for grasping. Carnotaurus's compact body, measuring about 8 meters in total length, combined with robust leg articulations, conferred high turning agility, facilitating quick directional changes essential for ambush-style predation.

Feeding adaptations and diet

The jaw mechanics of Carnotaurus sastrei featured a lightweight skull with reduced jaw adductor musculature, facilitating rapid closure speeds rather than high force exertion. Finite element analysis of the cranium indicates that the jaw-closing muscles effectively distributed biting stresses, minimizing deformation during prey engagement.^[38] Estimated bite force reached approximately 3,341 newtons at the posterior teeth, comparatively low relative to other theropods like Allosaurus fragilis, supporting a strategy emphasizing speed over power.^[38] The dentition consisted of thick, recurved, blade-like teeth with robust enamel, adapted for slashing flesh and securing struggling prey rather than bone-crushing.^[39] Wear patterns on preserved teeth suggest a high replacement rate, consistent with frequent predatory or scavenging activity. This configuration implies Carnotaurus targeted soft tissues, avoiding the energy-intensive processing of heavily armored or bony structures. Inferred diet included medium-sized ornithopods and juvenile titanosaurs, based on matching bite trace morphologies on titanosaur remains.^[40] Scavenging likely supplemented predation, given the weak bite unsuitable for tackling adult megaherbivores. Claims of piscivory have been dismissed due to lack of supporting evidence and incompatible cranial morphology. As an ambush predator, Carnotaurus probably relied on short bursts of speed to close distances on unsuspecting prey, using its slashing bite to inflict debilitating wounds. No direct gut contents or coprolites attributable to Carnotaurus have been identified, leaving dietary reconstructions dependent on biomechanical models and fossil trace evidence like bite marks.^[40] The supraorbital horns of Carnotaurus sastrei consist of paired, stout projections extending from the thickened frontal bones, curving slightly backward and measuring approximately 20 cm in length along the holotype skull. These structures feature a rugose, sculptured surface indicative of a keratinous sheath in life, which would have amplified their size and provided a reinforced tip for potential physical interactions.^[41] The underlying bone exhibits extensive vascular foramina, suggesting rapid growth through a well-supplied neurovascular network, similar to patterns observed in other abelisaurid cranial elements.^[42] Paleontological analyses propose that these horns primarily served functions in intraspecific interactions, such as combat or visual display for territorial or mating purposes. Finite element modeling of the C. sastrei cranium indicates that the structure could withstand significant lateral or dorsoventral stresses—equivalent to impacts at speeds up to 6 m/s—without fracturing, implying adaptation for side-to-side butting rather than direct frontal collisions.^[38] This mechanical resilience, combined with the horns' positioning and the robust neck musculature, supports hypotheses of their use in agonistic encounters among individuals, analogous to bovid horn clashes but differing from the dome-headed battering in pachycephalosaurs.^[16] Display roles are also inferred, where the prominent, keratin-sheathed horns could signal dominance, species identity, or mate quality during courtship, aligning with broader theropod patterns of exaggerated cranial features. Recent studies have expanded on these functions, suggesting additional roles in species recognition and thermoregulation.^[18] Regarding social behavior, the singular well-preserved holotype specimen suggests Carnotaurus operated primarily as a solitary predator, with horns facilitating occasional one-on-one confrontations for resource competition or reproduction rather than coordinated group dynamics.^[16] Ornamentation like the supraorbital horns likely played a role in signaling hierarchy or fitness in these isolated interactions, potentially deterring rivals without escalating to lethal combat. In the broader evolutionary context of Abelisauridae, such cranial projections represent an escalating trend of bony ornamentation—from subtle rugosities in basal forms to pronounced horns and bosses in derived taxa like Carnotaurus and Majungasaurus—possibly driven by sexual selection pressures that favored visually striking traits for mate attraction and rival assessment.^[35] This pattern underscores how abelisaurid skull evolution integrated functional robustness with socio-sexual signaling, contributing to the clade's diversification in the Late Cretaceous of Gondwana.^[43]

Geological context

Stratigraphy and dating

The primary locality of Carnotaurus sastrei is the La Colonia Formation in Chubut Province, central Patagonia, Argentina. The type specimen was discovered in the upper section of the La Colonia Formation, positioned above an underclay layer and below overlying volcanic deposits.^[44] The age of the strata bearing Carnotaurus fossils is estimated as early to late Maastrichtian, approximately 71–66 million years ago, based on U–Pb radiometric dating of detrital zircons from the underlying Puntudo Chico Formation (indicating a maximum age younger than ~71.7 Ma) and supporting palynological assemblages indicative of a Maastrichtian interval. Ammonite biostratigraphy from correlated marine sections in the region further constrains this timeframe to the Maastrichtian stage.^[45] Taphonomic analysis reveals that Carnotaurus fossils are preserved in fluvial sandstones, suggesting deposition in a riverine environment with moderate energy flow that facilitated the articulation and completeness of the nearly intact skeleton. These sandstones exhibit cross-bedding and contain disarticulated remains of other vertebrates, indicating rapid burial in channel or floodplain settings. In the broader context of South American Late Cretaceous geology, the La Colonia Formation correlates with the upper part of the Allen Formation sequence, sharing lithological and biostratigraphic features that reflect a regressive marine to continental transition across Patagonia. Fossils from the same stratigraphic levels include remains of titanosaurs and ornithopods, highlighting a diverse dinosaurian assemblage.

Paleoenvironment and fauna

The La Colonia Formation, dating to the Maastrichtian stage of the Late Cretaceous, records a dynamic coastal paleoenvironment characterized by estuarine and deltaic systems, with rivers emptying into shallow marine settings along the margins of the South Atlantic Ocean. This landscape featured floodplains subject to seasonal flooding, tidal influences, and periodic transgressions, supporting a mosaic of wetlands, lagoons, and low-lying coastal plains rather than arid interiors.^[44]^[45] The regional climate was warm-temperate to subtropical, with evidence of moderate seasonality in precipitation that sustained fluvial activity without extreme aridity.^[46] Palynological analyses of the formation reveal a diverse terrestrial flora dominated by gymnosperms, particularly araucarian conifers such as Araucariacites and other podocarps, alongside abundant ferns (e.g., trilete spores from Cyathidites) and cycad-like elements (e.g., Cycadopites pollen). These indicate nearby conifer-dominated forests and open woodlands adapted to the coastal setting. Aquatic and semi-aquatic vegetation was also prominent, including water ferns like Regnellidium and azollaceous plants such as Paleoazolla, thriving in the wetland habitats.^[46]^[47] The vertebrate fauna of the La Colonia Formation was rich and varied, reflecting a complex ecosystem where Carnotaurus served as the apex predator. Herbivorous dinosaurs included indeterminate ornithopods, likely basal iguanodontians given the absence of advanced hadrosaurs in this South American setting, and titanosaurian sauropods such as the recently described Titanomachya gimenezi.^[48] Other theropods coexisted, notably the abelisaurid Koleken inakayali, suggesting potential competition among large carnivores.^[49] Semi-aquatic and aquatic components were diverse, encompassing crocodylomorphs (including notosuchians), abundant turtles (e.g., bothremydids and chelids), plesiosaurs, and fish, while pterosaurs occupied aerial niches in the broader Patagonian landscape.^[44] Carnotaurus, as the largest known predator in this assemblage, likely targeted medium-sized herbivores like ornithopods and juvenile titanosaurs, filling the role of top carnivore in a sauropod-rich community.^[44] Strata of the La Colonia Formation preserve evidence of the Cretaceous-Paleogene (K-Pg) boundary, including an iridium anomaly, positioning the ecosystem perilously close to the mass extinction event approximately 66 million years ago; Carnotaurus and associated non-avian dinosaurs are restricted to pre-boundary levels, with no records extending into the Paleogene.^[45]

References

[1]
Carnotaurus | Natural History Museum
Length: 8.0m. Diet: carnivorous; When it lived: Late Cretaceous, 69–71 million years ago; Found in: Argentina. Carnotaurus was a meat-eating dinosaur with two ...Missing: sources | Show results with:sources
[2]
Carnotaurus sastrei | Western Australian Museum
Aug 25, 2022 · Facts ; Age, Approx. 70 million years old ; Diet, Carnivore ; Height, 2.5m at the hips ; Length, 8 metres ; Weight, 1.5 tonnes ...<|separator|>
[3]
The exquisitely preserved integument of Psittacosaurus and ... - Nature
Aug 12, 2022 · & Bell, P. R. The scaly skin of the abelisaurid Carnotaurus sastrei (Theropoda: Ceratosauria) from the Upper Cretaceous of Patagonia. Cretac ...
[4]
Ceratosaur palaeobiology: new insights on evolution and ecology of ...
Jun 28, 2018 · & López, V. The hand structure of Carnotaurus sastrei (Theropoda, Abelisauridae): Implications for hand diversity and evolution in abelisaurids.
[5]
The scaly skin of the abelisaurid Carnotaurus sastrei (Theropoda
Carnotaurus skin has medium to large conical feature scales (20-65mm) and small basement scales, the most completely preserved of any theropod.
[6]
Carnotaurus: "The Meat Eating Bull" - ZME Science
Feb 14, 2024 · Carnotaurus was undoubtedly carnivorous, as indicated by its sharp teeth and muscular build, suited for a predatory lifestyle. The debate among ...Missing: sources | Show results with:sources
[7]
[PDF] The scaly skin of the abelisaurid Carnotaurus sastrei (Theropoda
The integument of the theropod dinosaur Carnotaurus sastrei from the Upper Cretaceous of Argentina is here described in detail for the first time.
[8]
Carnotaurus Facts, Habitat, Diet, Fossils, Pictures - Extinct Animals
Mar 28, 2022 · In 1984, the first fossil of the Carnotaurus was discovered in Argentina's La Colonia Formation in the province of Chubut by Jose Bonaparte ...
[9]
Carnotaurus sastrei: The Short-Handed Sprinter - Darwin's Door
Sep 11, 2020 · Carnotaurus sastrei was first discovered in 1984, when a team of palaeontologists found a near-complete and fully articulated skeleton on an Argentinian farm.
[10]
(PDF) On the palaeobiology of the South American horned theropod ...
It is concluded that Car-notaurus was an agile theropod, with a somewhat fast rather than strong bite, and that it must have used the horns in intraspecific ...
[11]
The skull of Carnotaurus sastrei Bonaparte 1985 revisited - NASA ADS
Here we present a re-study of the skull of Carnotaurus including detailed osteological descriptions, CT scans analyses and comparisons with abelisaurid taxa.
[12]
Carnotaurus sastrei - iNaturalist
Carnotaurus sastrei is an extinct, large theropod dinosaur from South America, meaning 'meat-eating bull' due to its carnivorous diet and bull-like horns.Missing: size habitat
[13]
Carnotaurus etymology - Skye McDavid
Apr 5, 2023 · The specific epithet sastrei honors Angel Sastre, owner of the Pocho Sastre Ranch ('Estancia Pocho Sastre') where the holotype was discovered. ...
[14]
Carnotaurus sastrei Bonaparte, the Horned, Lightly Built Carnosaur ...
A further important event was the description of Carnotaurus sastrei by Bonaparte et al. (1990) , which provided information about the abelisaurid ...
[15]
[PDF] Carnotaurus sastrei Bonaparte, - the Horned, Lightly Built Carnosaur
HOLOTYPE. MACN-CH 894. Almost com- plete skeleton, with skin impressions ... complete. They were found close behind the cor- acoids. The right humerus ...<|separator|>
[16]
The skull of Carnotaurus sastrei Bonaparte 1985 revisited
Carnotaurus sastrei is an iconic theropod from Patagonia that was found in Chubut province in 1984 and originally described in a brief communication by José ...Missing: original | Show results with:original<|separator|>
[17]
First definitive record of Abelisauridae (Theropoda
Jun 8, 2022 · ... Carnotaurus sastrei, Viavenator exxoni and a generically ... Referred specimen—MUVP 477, an isolated caudal (tenth) cervical vertebra.
[18]
New giant carnivorous dinosaur reveals convergent evolutionary ...
Jul 25, 2022 · The degree of convergence is not as pronounced between Meraxes and the shortest armed abelisaurid in our sample, Carnotaurus ... Referred specimen ...
[19]
[PDF] ON THE PALAEOBIOLOGY OF THE SOUTH AMERICAN HORNED ...
Carnotaurus sastrei BONAPARTE, 1985, is a very interesting and unusual theropod from the Creta- ceous of South America.
[20]
A new abelisaurid dinosaur from the Late Cretaceous of southern ...
A phylogenetic analysis reveals that the new Abelisauridae from Provence is more closely related to taxa from India and Madagascar than to South American forms.Missing: revisions | Show results with:revisions
[21]
estimating body size from skull length in theropods - ResearchGate
Aug 10, 2025 · Least-square regressions reveal a tight correlation between skull length and body length ... Total length of the tail was estimated in 134 cm and ...<|separator|>
[22]
New information on the craniofacial anatomy of Carnotaurus sastrei ...
Jul 31, 2019 · They are featured by numerous derived skull traits, such as heavily ornamented bones, short and tall snout, and a strongly thickened cranial ...
[23]
Unveiling the Function and Evolutionary Significance of Carnotaurus ...
Jul 25, 2024 · This literature review investigates the morphological and behavioral significance of the horns of Carnotaurus sastrei, a theropod dinosaur ...
[24]
Taxonomic identification of isolated theropod teeth: The case of the ...
This number of teeth is shared with Carnotaurus, while Aucasaurus (14 or 15), Ekrixinatosaurus (16+), Majungasaurus (17) and Skorpiovenator (16+) have a ...
[25]
Body Size of Some Southern South American Cretaceous Dinosaurs
May 17, 2006 · Among theropods, the body mass of the strangely looking, horned Carnotaurus sastrei, was volumetrically estimated at 1.5 tonnes, while ...Missing: length | Show results with:length<|control11|><|separator|>
[26]
The Cervical Vertebrae of the Late Cretaceous Abelisaurid Dinosaur ...
Jun 27, 2012 · —The fourth cervical vertebra of Carnotaurus is a little larger than the preceding, with the neural arch almost twice as high and twice as wide ...
[27]
[PDF] The cervical vertebrae of the Late Cretaceous abelisaurid dinosaur ...
Méndez, A.H. 2014. The cervical vertebrae of the Late Cretaceous abelisaurid dinosaur Carnotaurus sastrei. Acta Pa- laeontologica Polonica 59 (3): 569–579.
[28]
Carnotaurus sastrei Bonaparte, the horned, lightly built carnosaur ...
Carnotaurus sastrei Bonaparte, the horned, lightly built carnosaur from the Middle Cretaceous of Patagonia. By Bonaparte, JF (José Fernando), 1928-2020.
[29]
The hand structure of Carnotaurus sastrei (Theropoda ...
Sep 19, 2011 · MACN-CH-894, holotype of Carnotaurus sastrei (Bonaparte, 1985), was collected from the Late Cretaceous (Campanian–Maastrichtian) La Colonia ...Missing: completeness | Show results with:completeness
[30]
Dinosaur Speed Demon: The Caudal Musculature of Carnotaurus ...
Oct 17, 2011 · When first described by Bonaparte et al. in 1990 [1], the holotype of Carnotaurus sastrei (MACN-CH 894) revealed many puzzling adaptations in ...Missing: transport | Show results with:transport
[31]
Carnotaurus does not have osteoderms - Incertae Sedis
May 30, 2021 · The large, circular indentations are impressions of the shield scales. Carnotaurus sastrei is fairly well-known as having extensive skin ...
[32]
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/230808674_The_Phylogeny_of_Ceratosauria_Dinosauria_Theropoda
[33]
[PDF] Morphology and distribution of scales, dermal ossifications, and ...
Scaly skin has been reported in the abelisaurid Carnotaurus (Bonaparte, Novas &. Coria, 1990; Czerkas & Czerkas, 1997), the allosauroids Allo- saurus (Pinegar ...
[34]
The Phylogeny of Ceratosauria (Dinosauria: Theropoda)
The results suggest that Elaphrosaurus and its relatives are the most basal ceratosaurs, followed by Ceratosaurus and Noasauridae + Abelisauridae (= ...
[35]
Bony cranial ornamentation linked to rapid evolution of gigantic ...
Sep 27, 2016 · We explore correlative evolution of osseous cranial ornaments with large body size in theropod dinosaurs using a phylogenetic comparative framework.
[36]
Novel information on the endocranial morphology of the abelisaurid ...
Carnotaurus sastrei (Bonaparte, 1985) is a derived brachyrostran abelisaurid from the Maastrichtian La Colonia Formation, Chubut province, Argentina (Novas, ...Missing: classification | Show results with:classification
[37]
The Caudal Musculature of Carnotaurus sastrei and Implications for ...
This large investment in the M. caudofemoralis suggests that Carnotaurus sastrei had the potential for great cursorial abilities, particularly short-burst ...
[38]
Cranial mechanics and functional interpretation of the horned ...
The analyses indicated that the jaw-closing musculature of C. sastrei would have played a key role in diminishing the stress level on the cranium during biting, ...Missing: diet | Show results with:diet
[39]
Jaw biomechanics and the evolution of biting performance in ... - NIH
Jun 9, 2010 · Theropod dinosaurs display a high degree of craniomandibular morphological diversity, which can lead one to infer equally diverse feeding ...
[40]
New Mammalian Remains from the Late Cretaceous La Colonia ...
Jun 1, 2009 · Here we describe new mammalian remains collected in outcrops of the La Colonia Formation (Campanian—Maastrichtian) exposed in Chubut Province, ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[41]
The Fossil Record of Predation in Dinosaurs
Jul 21, 2017 · Evidence of predatory behavior by carnivorous dinosaurs. ... Speculations about the diet and foraging behavior of large carnivorous dinosaurs.<|control11|><|separator|>
[42]
None
Nothing is retrieved...<|separator|>
[43]
An exceptional neurovascular system in abelisaurid theropod skull
Jun 22, 2020 · We compared this feature with CT scans of Carnotaurus and revealed that it also possess an internal system as in Skorpiovenator, but being ...
[44]
Unveiling the Function and Evolutionary Significance of Carnotaurus ...
Jul 25, 2024 · The horns of Carnotaurus are hypothesized to serve multiple roles, including species recognition, thermoregulation, and intraspecific combat.
[45]
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0195667121001361
[46]
Late Cretaceous reptilian biota of the La Colonia Formation, central ...
Late Cretaceous reptilian biota of the La Colonia Formation, central Patagonia, Argentina: Occurrences, preservation and paleoenvironments. Author links open ...
[47]
New South American record of the Cretaceous–Paleogene ...
The La Colonia Formation is an Upper Cretaceous to Paleogene shallow marine sedimentary unit in Chubut Province (Patagonia), Argentina that preserves important ...
[48]
Pollen from the K–Pg boundary of the La Colonia Formation ...
Among them, the La Colonia Formation represents coastal deposits dominated by tides with the development of barrier/lagoon complexes of Maastrichtian–Danian age ...
[49]
Late Cretaceous Aquatic Plant World in Patagonia, Argentina
Aug 22, 2014 · The La Colonia Formation is a geological unit deposited during a Maastrichtian-Danian transgressive episode of the South Atlantic Ocean. This ...
[50]
A new titanosaur from the La Colonia Formation (Campanian ...
Apr 10, 2024 · Here we report the associated remains of a new species of a titanosaurian sauropod from the La Colonia Formation found in northern Chubut Province.Missing: paleoenvironment | Show results with:paleoenvironment
[51]
A new abelisaurid dinosaur from the end Cretaceous of Patagonia ...
May 21, 2024 · A new abelisaurid dinosaur from the end Cretaceous of Patagonia and evolutionary rates among the Ceratosauria. Diego Pol,.Missing: thesis | Show results with:thesis