Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Howard Metzenbaum

Howard Morton Metzenbaum (June 4, 1917 – March 12, 2008) was an American attorney, businessman, and Democratic politician who served as a Senator from from 1977 to 1995, following an initial appointment to the seat in 1974 that ended after he lost a special election to . Born in to a family of modest means—his father operated a small business—Metzenbaum graduated from in 1939, earned a there in 1942, and built wealth through investments in and parking lots before turning to , including terms in the and State Senate in the and . A self-styled populist despite his personal fortune, Metzenbaum positioned himself as a defender of working-class interests against corporate power, authoring or co-sponsoring key legislation such as the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act of 1988, which mandates 60 days' notice for mass layoffs or plant closings, and advocating for nutrition labeling requirements on food products that became law in the early 1990s. His tenure, however, was marked by controversy over his procedural mastery and frequent filibusters—earning him the moniker "Senator No" from critics—who accused him of grandstanding and obstructing bills to benefit special interests, though he claimed such tactics saved billions in taxpayer funds by blocking pork-barrel spending; these efforts alienated many Republicans and even frustrated some Democratic allies and staff.

Early Life and Family Background

Childhood and Upbringing in Cleveland

Howard Metzenbaum was born on June 4, 1917, in , , to and Anna Metzenbaum, members of a Jewish family of modest means on the city's East Side. His father, a Hungarian-born immigrant, operated a that faced repeated financial setbacks, including , amid the economic volatility of the . His mother supplemented the household income by working in a department store for $13 per week, reflecting the precarious circumstances of many immigrant families in industrial . The onset of the in 1929 intensified these hardships, as Cleveland's economy, heavily reliant on manufacturing, suffered widespread unemployment and business failures. Metzenbaum began contributing to the family livelihood at age 10 by delivering groceries for tips, a task that required balancing physical labor with school obligations and instilled early lessons in and resourcefulness. This involvement in the family's grocery-related endeavors exposed him to the demands of small-scale in a competitive urban market. Growing up amid Cleveland's working-class neighborhoods, Metzenbaum witnessed the raw interplay of economic pressures, including the scramble for survival in a city dominated by and fluctuating labor markets, which shaped his pragmatic understanding of financial vulnerability without idealizing hardship.

Formal Education and Early Influences

Metzenbaum enrolled at following high school, earning a degree in 1939 and a from its Moritz College of Law in 1941. During law school, he financed his studies through part-time work, including drafting bills for state legislators. These academic achievements occurred amid the lingering effects of the , reflecting a merit-based progression driven by personal effort rather than familial resources. Upon admission to the Ohio bar shortly after graduation, Metzenbaum established a legal practice in , where he initially focused on representing labor unions in disputes during the . This work exposed him to the tensions between workers' rights and business operations, providing practical insights into workplace regulations and dynamics. Metzenbaum's early professional orientation was shaped by the era's economic context, including a Depression-forged emphasis on and the New Deal's model of federal intervention in recovery efforts, which he observed through direct involvement in labor advocacy rather than detached theory. These experiences steered him toward legal roles emphasizing protection for working-class interests, laying groundwork for later advocacy without reliance on ideological abstraction.

Pre-Political Career

Retail and Publishing Businesses

Metzenbaum accumulated significant wealth through entrepreneurial ventures in and prior to his sustained political career. In the , he owned 17 franchises in the area, capitalizing on postwar demand for automotive mobility and establishing a foothold in a competitive market that rewarded efficient operations and . In publishing, Metzenbaum co-owned the Sun Newspapers chain of suburban weekly publications serving the region, acquiring and consolidating established titles such as the Sun Post of and the West Side Sun News with partner David Skylar. This venture, initiated in the early 1970s following earlier business successes, involved strategic purchases that grew the group from individual community papers into a dominant suburban chain, with roots tracing to the Shaker Sun and emphasizing local coverage to build readership amid metropolitan expansion. The operation demonstrated his capacity for scaling media enterprises through acquisition and integration, navigating advertising revenues and distribution challenges in a fragmented market. These endeavors underscored Metzenbaum's pragmatic approach to growth, including negotiations with labor and adaptation to economic shifts, which preceded his later critiques of corporate practices despite his own reliance on market-driven profits.

Sports Franchise Ownership and Involvement

In January 1968, Howard Metzenbaum and partner Alva "Ted" Bonda purchased the professional soccer franchise from its original owners, Cleveland Indians executives and . The acquisition occurred amid the merger of the National Professional Soccer League and the into the (NASL), positioning the Stokers as a member in a league seeking to capitalize on growing but unproven interest in soccer within the . The Stokers, which had operated in 1967 under the by fielding the English club Stoke City rebranded as the Stokers, posted a competitive 14-11-7 record in the 1968 NASL season, capturing the Lakes Division title before losing in the to the Atlanta Chiefs. Despite this relative on-field success, the franchise struggled with low attendance and revenue challenges common to early soccer, where fan turnout often failed to sustain operations amid from established sports like and . The team folded on , , after just two seasons of independent operation, reflecting the broader instability of the sport's professional infrastructure in the U.S., including frequent league consolidations and team failures due to inadequate market demand rather than any significant government subsidies. This short-lived ownership underscored the high financial risks of investing in expansion sports leagues without established fan bases, a venture that contrasted with Metzenbaum's subsequent advocacy for regulatory measures in more mature industries.

State-Level Political Involvement

Service in the Ohio General Assembly

Howard Metzenbaum, a Democrat from Cuyahoga County, won election to the in 1942 and began serving in 1943, representing interests aligned with labor unions such as the and the International Association of Machinists, which he had previously represented in private practice. He held the seat through 1947, during a period of postwar economic adjustment in , where legislative efforts often addressed industrial recovery and urban challenges in areas like . In 1947, Metzenbaum advanced to the , serving until 1951. During this term, he sponsored a groundbreaking fair-employment act aimed at prohibiting discrimination in hiring practices, reflecting his early focus on labor protections amid Ohio's diverse industrial workforce. This initiative marked one of his notable contributions to state-level policy, though detailed records of its passage and impact remain limited in available historical accounts. Metzenbaum's state legislative tenure provided foundational experience in procedural navigation and debate, building on his legal background from . He departed the in 1951 to focus on private business ventures, including and , temporarily setting aside elective office.

Initial Gubernatorial and U.S. Senate Bids

Metzenbaum first demonstrated ambitions beyond through his role as for M. Young's successful 1958 U.S. Senate bid against incumbent , a former vice-presidential nominee and long-serving senator since 1940. Young's victory, with 57.4% of the vote to Bricker's 42.5%, capitalized on sentiments and critiques of , including Bricker's isolationist stances, in a year of Democratic gains amid economic concerns. Metzenbaum's grassroots organizing efforts mobilized urban and labor voters in and other industrial areas, emphasizing economic equity for working families hit by manufacturing slowdowns, while highlighting perceived and favoritism in governance. These tactics showcased Metzenbaum's strengths in building coalitions from his business and publishing networks but exposed early tensions with Ohio's business community wary of regulatory expansions. In 1964, Metzenbaum again managed Young's reelection against , son of the influential "Mr. Republican" and a of GOP power. Young eked out a narrow win, 50.4% to 49.6%, amid national Democratic momentum under President but local headwinds from economic anxieties in and sectors. The reiterated themes of challenging entrenched elites with promises of fairer labor protections and reforms, aligning with Metzenbaum's leanings forged in state-level for workers' rights. Voter responses underscored his organizing prowess in Democratic primaries and urban turnout but vulnerabilities to accusations of promoting overregulation, as opponents tied Democratic policies to burdensome rules on Ohio's factories and farms, contributing to the race's razor-thin margin. Throughout the , Metzenbaum explored personal bids for higher office, including U.S. opportunities, positioning himself as an outsider against dynastic figures like the Tafts amid Ohio's competitive two-party landscape. His publishing ventures, including ownership of suburban newspapers, amplified critiques of business practices and political insiders, fostering a profile centered on consumer protections and equity for blue-collar constituents. Yet, in a state reliant on , these efforts faced skepticism from voters and employers who viewed his —rooted in first-hand experience with and labor disputes—as potentially stifling through excessive . Such dynamics highlighted the challenges of translating energy into statewide viability without alienating moderate interests.

U.S. Senate Path and Elections

1970 Campaign, Appointment, and Special Election Loss

In the 1970 Democratic primary for the U.S. seat in , held on May 5, Metzenbaum defeated U.S. Representative Wayne , a powerful insider and chairman of the Democratic Campaign Committee, by leveraging aggressive television that portrayed Hays as out of touch with ordinary Ohioans. This victory positioned Metzenbaum as the nominee against Robert Taft Jr. in the general election on November 3, amid a national context of economic slowdown, inflation concerns, and fallout from the , which amplified voter skepticism toward liberal challengers. Taft, emphasizing his family's legacy of and business-friendly policies, prevailed with 1,565,682 votes (49.7%) to Metzenbaum's 1,471,504 (46.7%), a margin of 94,178 votes. The outcome reflected Ohio's preference for moderate Republicans seen as stabilizers for and , particularly in manufacturing-heavy regions wary of Metzenbaum's advocacy for stringent regulations on practices. On December 19, 1973, Democratic Governor appointed Metzenbaum to fill the vacancy left by Republican Senator , who resigned effective January 4, 1974, to serve as U.S. Attorney General under President . Metzenbaum was sworn in on January 4 and served until resigning on December 23, 1974, providing him a brief platform to critique corporate influence despite limited legislative impact during the interim period. To secure the seat in the accompanying election for the term beginning January 3, 1975, Metzenbaum entered the Democratic primary on May 7, 1974, facing former astronaut John Glenn in a contentious race featuring debates over personal wealth, tax records, and job experience—Metzenbaum accused Glenn of lacking substantive policy credentials beyond his NASA fame. Glenn won decisively, capturing over 53% of the vote to Metzenbaum's under 47%, as voters favored Glenn's national hero status and perceived moderation amid persistent economic unease and stagflation. This primary defeat, following Metzenbaum's resignation to allow Glenn early swearing-in on December 24, 1974, reinforced the 1970 lesson that Ohio's electorate prioritized candidates aligned with business stability and pragmatic conservatism over populist challenges to established economic interests.

1974 Election Victory and Reelections

Metzenbaum secured his initial full term in the U.S. Senate by defeating incumbent Robert Taft Jr. in the November 2, 1976, general election for Ohio's Class 1 seat, a contest influenced by residual national backlash against following the and President Gerald Ford's . The race was exceptionally close, with Metzenbaum prevailing by a slim margin of about 25,000 votes out of over 2.6 million cast, reflecting Ohio's status as a where outcomes often hinged on modest shifts in . This victory marked the culmination of Metzenbaum's persistence after prior setbacks, enabling him to serve from January 3, 1977, to January 3, 1983. In the 1982 reelection campaign for the term ending January 3, 1989, Metzenbaum faced Republican Paul Zuravleff, a -area businessman, and won decisively on November 2, 1982, capturing roughly 57% of the vote amid a Democratic midterm surge tied to economic recession under President . Opponents, backed by business interests critical of Metzenbaum's regulatory record, framed the contest as a on pro-labor policies, yet mobilization proved pivotal in sustaining his support in industrial regions like and Youngstown. The broader Democratic wave that year helped retain the seat, though Metzenbaum's margin underscored vulnerabilities in a state with fluctuating blue-collar allegiance. Metzenbaum's final reelection came in against Mayor George V. Voinovich, a with strong business and credentials, whom he defeated on November 8, , for the term from January 3, 1989, to January 3, 1995, again with about 57% of the vote despite a Republican presidential landslide for in . Voinovich's campaign emphasized Metzenbaum's perceived anti-business orientation, drawing funding from corporate donors wary of his advocacy, but labor endorsements and targeted appeals to working-class voters offset these challenges. While earlier wins aligned with national Democratic tides, the result highlighted Metzenbaum's personal resilience in a competitive environment, though it also signaled eroding margins among some traditional Democratic constituencies as economic shifts accelerated .

Senate Service (1974–1995)

Committee Assignments and Filibuster Strategies

Upon entering the in 1974, Metzenbaum secured assignments to the Committee on Labor and Human Resources, the Committee on the Judiciary, and the Select Committee on Intelligence, positions he retained through much of his tenure. These roles enabled rigorous oversight of regulatory frameworks, including labor standards, antitrust enforcement, and intelligence operations, where he chaired subcommittees such as Judiciary's Antitrust, and to scrutinize corporate consolidations and monopolistic practices. Metzenbaum employed tactics and procedural objections extensively to delay or amend legislation perceived as advancing corporate interests, often objecting to requests to prevent quick passage of " bills" laden with special-interest provisions. In 1977, he co-led a prolonged with Senator against deregulation, flooding the floor with amendments to extend debate over 13 days before , though the measure ultimately advanced. Similarly, in 1984, he joined efforts to nominee , contributing to repeated failed votes that stalled confirmation amid scrutiny of the nominee's . These strategies amplified minority positions by forcing extended deliberations and concessions, as seen in negotiations yielding modifications to anti-union riders or nomination vetting enhancements, yet they frequently provoked majority frustration in a body reliant on supermajorities for under Rule XXII. Colleagues dubbed him the "Senate's " for routinely invoking holds and threats of extended speeches, which prolonged sessions but underscored obstruction's constraints against determined majorities invoking votes requiring 60 senators. Despite occasional successes in extracting compromises, such as refined regulatory language, the approach highlighted filibustering's diminishing efficacy amid evolving norms favoring efficiency over exhaustive debate.

Major Legislative Efforts and Amendments

Metzenbaum sponsored S. 2527, the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act, in the 100th Congress, which President signed into law on August 4, 1988. The act requires employers with 100 or more employees to provide at least 60 days' written notice before a plant closing or mass layoff affecting 50 or more full-time workers, enabling affected employees to seek new jobs, retraining, or in advance; smaller employers (100-500 workers) may provide shorter notice proportional to size, with exceptions for unforeseeable events like . This bipartisan measure, co-sponsored by Senator (D-NJ), countered rising plant closures in manufacturing-heavy states like by imposing immediate notification obligations, though compliance costs led some firms to accelerate closures before enactment. He led efforts on the Workplace Fairness Act (S. 55), introduced in the 102nd and reintroduced in subsequent sessions, which sought to amend the National Labor Relations Act of 1935 by deeming it an to hire permanent replacements for economic strikers, aiming to restore bargaining leverage lost after rulings like NLRB v. Curtin Matheson Scientific, Inc. (1989). Despite securing majority support, the bill repeatedly stalled, failing votes in 1992 and 1994 amid Republican filibusters citing risks to employer flexibility during labor disputes; no core provisions passed, though it influenced narrower NLRB interpretations favoring strikers in select cases. Metzenbaum supported the 1986 amendments to the of 1967 (part of H.R. 4157, enacted October 16, 1986), which eliminated at age 70 for most private-sector workers effective January 1, 1987, extending protections previously capped at that age and applying immediately to non-federal executives, academics, and firefighters with exemptions until phased out. He sponsored S. 54 in the 101st (1989), the , which required judicial or EEOC oversight for valid waivers of ADEA rights in exchange for severance, codifying standards to prevent coerced releases and taking effect upon passage as part of broader 1990 reforms under the . In consumer protections, Metzenbaum secured enactment of disclosure requirements bearing his name, mandating carriers to clearly state frequent flier terms, including mileage accrual, expiration, and redemption rules, which took immediate effect to curb deceptive practices post- and informed passenger choices amid rising complaints in the 1980s. His pushes for fee transparency, such as mandatory late payment and over-limit disclosures, advanced through subcommittee but often diluted in full votes under Reagan-era resistance to regulatory burdens, yielding partial bipartisan wins in reporting standards rather than outright mandates. Overall, while facing frequent stalls from deregulation advocates, Metzenbaum's successes hinged on compromises preserving core notifications without expansive penalties.

Core Political Positions

Advocacy for Consumer Protections and Labor Rights

Metzenbaum, shaped by the economic hardships of the during his formative years in , consistently advocated for labor measures aimed at bolstering workers' bargaining leverage against employers, viewing such protections as essential to counter imbalances exacerbated by industrial shifts toward a service-oriented . He argued that without equitable tools, workers risked permanent displacement, drawing on historical precedents of struggles to justify interventions that preserved strike rights. A key effort was his sponsorship of S. 55 in the 103rd Congress (1993–1994), which sought to amend the National Labor Relations Act to prohibit permanent striker replacements, intending to restore balance by ensuring economic strikers could return to their positions post-dispute and thus enhance power. Metzenbaum contended this would deter employer tactics that rendered workers "disposable," citing rising use of replacements in the as evidence of eroded equity. While the bill's intent focused on protecting approximately 10–15% of strikes involving economic demands, analyses projected compliance would impose flexibility costs on employers, potentially elevating expenses by limiting hiring options and encouraging prolonged work stoppages, though the measure failed twice. Metzenbaum also supported minimum wage increases, such as the 1989 Fair Labor Standards Act amendments raising the rate to $4.55 per hour by 1991, opposing subminimum provisions for youth as insufficient for and arguing hikes would equitably redistribute income without broad disruption. He cosponsored precursors to the Family and Medical Leave Act, including S. 5 (1991 and 1993 versions), providing up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave for family or medical reasons to promote stability amid data showing millions of workers faced job loss for caregiving absences annually. The enacted FMLA's intent addressed family fragmentation, but empirical estimates pegged annual compliance costs at around $21 billion in lost and administrative burdens for employers, primarily through replacement staffing and record-keeping, though exemptions for small firms mitigated some impacts. In , Metzenbaum advanced bills like S. 865 (1989), the Consumer Protection Against Price-Fixing Act, targeting collusive practices to safeguard buyers from inflated costs, and contributed to nutrition labeling requirements under the Nutrition Labeling and Education Act, enabling informed choices based on empirical health data linking diet to outcomes. These efforts aimed to curb informational asymmetries, with compliance involving disclosure mandates that imposed verification costs on producers but yielded long-term market efficiencies through competition.

Stances on Economic Regulation and Business Practices

Metzenbaum consistently advocated for stringent economic regulations, opposing deregulation efforts in sectors such as natural gas and oil pricing throughout his Senate tenure. In 1977, he led a filibuster against partial deregulation of natural gas prices, arguing it would harm consumers by enabling price spikes, though subsequent events showed deregulation did not produce the feared explosions in costs as he had predicted. He similarly resisted Reagan administration proposals to ease antitrust rules in the 1980s, charging they would reverse progress in curbing corporate power. As chairman of the Senate Antitrust and Monopoly Subcommittee, Metzenbaum aggressively enforced antitrust laws, particularly against corporate mergers, which he viewed as threats to competition and consumer interests. He criticized oil industry consolidations in the early 1980s as "obscene," co-sponsoring a bill for a six-month moratorium on acquisitions by the largest oil firms to prevent market concentration. His efforts extended to opposing mergers in retail, media, and other sectors, such as urging scrutiny of the Federated Department Stores acquisition of Macy's in 1994 and decrying "merger mania" in 1987 hearings. While Metzenbaum emphasized monopoly risks, this approach overlooked potential efficiencies from mergers, such as enhanced competitiveness against foreign rivals, as evidenced in cases like the proposed GE-RCA deal where opponents argued consolidation could bolster innovation and global standing. Empirical analyses of merger effects indicate that blocking pro-competitive consolidations can hinder incentives for innovation by preserving fragmented structures less capable of R&D investment. On , Metzenbaum opposed federal reforms aimed at capping or limiting lawsuits, submitting amendments to block such measures during debates on the 1985-1986 Reform Act and fiercely resisting aviation-specific limits like the General Aviation Revitalization Act in 1994. He prioritized plaintiff rights, contending reforms unfairly shielded manufacturers, amid the liability crisis where lawsuit filings surged—product liability cases in federal courts rose over 26% from 1979 to 1980 alone—driving insurance premiums up dramatically, with general liability costs escalating due to expanded claims like and hazard warnings. This stance correlated with broader premium hikes that burdened manufacturers, potentially stifling product development as firms faced heightened litigation risks without corresponding safety gains. Metzenbaum's regulatory philosophy portrayed businesses as inherently adversarial to interests, justifying interventions to check corporate excesses, yet this contrasted with his own as a self-made in relatively unregulated markets. Prior to , he co-founded one of the first car-rental agencies, amassed Avis franchises, and built a -lot empire sold to for substantial gain, accumulating an estimated $5 million by the early 1980s. Such entrepreneurial achievements in low-regulation sectors like and rentals highlighted a selective application of , as he later channeled similar acumen into combating the very business practices that had enriched him.

Views on Foreign Policy, Gun Control, and National Security

Metzenbaum opposed military intervention in the Persian Gulf War, voting against the January 12, 1991, congressional authorization for the use of force against following its invasion of . He argued that sanctions should be given more time to compel Iraqi withdrawal, emphasizing diplomacy over immediate combat and rejecting claims that congressional support was a test of . This stance diverged from the bipartisan consensus, as the subsequent Operation Desert Storm achieved a swift coalition victory with minimal U.S. casualties—148 battle deaths—and liberated , though prolonged sanctions carried risks of Saddam Hussein's retention of chemical and biological weapons programs. On gun control, Metzenbaum was a leading proponent of stricter measures, co-sponsoring the introduced in the 100th Congress (1987–1988) and reintroduced in subsequent sessions. The bill mandated a five-day waiting period for purchases to allow background checks, aiming to block sales to felons and others prohibited under federal law; it passed the on November 20, 1993, as part of broader efforts following the 1981 assassination attempt on President Reagan. Metzenbaum's advocacy prioritized reducing through regulatory barriers, though empirical assessments of the law's causal impact on crime rates remain contested, with some analyses attributing post-1993 homicide declines to factors like improved policing rather than waiting periods alone, while Second Amendment advocates highlighted negligible effects on defensive uses estimated at 500,000 to 3 million annually. Regarding , Metzenbaum expressed skepticism toward unchecked intelligence expansions, pushing for greater and public disclosure of classified to enforce fiscal restraint. In debates over the Fiscal Intelligence Authorization Act, he contended that transparency on spending—estimated at around $28 billion total for national intelligence programs—would not compromise operations but align them with taxpayer accountability, criticizing the "" opacity as enabling inefficiency. His efforts, including amendments for revelations, faced resistance from hawks who argued such measures could undermine deterrence by signaling resource constraints to adversaries, particularly amid post-Cold War transitions where intelligence pivots to required agile funding. This oversight focus reflected a broader caution against executive overreach in , though it contrasted with Ohio's defense industry interests tied to agencies like the .

Controversies and Criticisms

Perceived Anti-Business Policies and Their Economic Consequences

Metzenbaum's sponsorship of legislation to prohibit employers from hiring permanent replacements for striking workers, introduced repeatedly during his Senate tenure including in 1991 and 1994, was criticized as tilting labor disputes in favor of unions by removing employers' leverage to resolve conflicts swiftly. Opponents, including economic analyses, argued that such bans would encourage more frequent and prolonged strikes by assuring strikers of job reinstatement, thereby elevating business operating risks and costs in labor-intensive industries like manufacturing. Empirical studies on similar replacement restrictions in other jurisdictions have linked them to adverse employment effects, including reduced hiring and investment deterrence, as firms face heightened uncertainty over labor stability. These policies formed part of a broader regulatory push, including stricter antitrust enforcement and mandates on businesses to maintain retiree benefits during financial distress, which critics contended imposed compliance burdens that accelerated from the . During Metzenbaum's from 1974 to 1995, Ohio's sector shed hundreds of thousands of jobs amid , with the state losing over 1.2 million positions across the industrial heartland from 1979 to 1983 alone. in spiked to an average of about 13% in 1982—exceeding the national rate of 9.7%—and remained persistently elevated through the , contrasting with faster national recovery trends as non-regulated sectors grew. Such outcomes fueled arguments that regulatory hurdles, rather than solely corporate decisions, causally contributed to plant relocations overseas by raising domestic production expenses and eroding competitiveness in global markets. Critics further noted an apparent inconsistency in Metzenbaum's stance, given his pre-political success as a self-made millionaire who built wealth through unregulated entrepreneurial ventures, such as developing a major airport parking franchise into the Airport Parking Company of America and real estate investments near Cleveland Hopkins International Airport. Having profited from free-market opportunities with minimal government interference, his later advocacy for stringent labor and business regulations was said to overlook how added compliance costs—often passed to consumers via higher prices—disadvantaged subsequent generations of Ohio workers and firms. This perspective challenges attributions of deindustrialization purely to corporate avarice, emphasizing instead how policy-induced rigidities in labor markets and operations incentivized offshoring to lower-cost venues.

Interpersonal and Procedural Conflicts in the Senate

Metzenbaum's confrontational tactics in the Senate, including frequent objections and procedural delays, frequently irritated fellow Democrats, most notably his Ohio colleague John Glenn. Their rivalry originated in intraparty contests, such as the 1970 Democratic primary where Metzenbaum defeated Glenn before losing the general election, and the 1974 primary where Glenn triumphed after delivering a rebuttal emphasizing his public service record against Metzenbaum's criticisms of his private-sector experience. This history of aggressive campaigning strained Senate collaboration, as Glenn and others viewed Metzenbaum's persistent challenges to party consensus as disruptive to unified Democratic efforts. Metzenbaum's use of filibusters and holds often postponed confirmations and , even alienating potential supporters. In December 1982, his extended against a bill incorporating numerous unrelated amendments provoked widespread frustration among senators eager to adjourn, highlighting how his procedural maneuvers could halt chamber business. He routinely placed holds on nominations and pet projects favored by colleagues across the aisle, blocking dozens of measures tied to regional interests and thereby impeding swift confirmations. Earned the moniker "Senator No" for his unyielding opposition, Metzenbaum's approach underscored his determination but undermined the cross-party relationships necessary for advancing broader initiatives. Colleagues reported the "groaning" at his routine objections, reflecting a that his obstruction, while principled in intent, curtailed overall legislative efficiency and fostered resentment even among ideological allies. This reputation, while amplifying his role, limited his capacity to build coalitions, as evidenced by complaints from peers who found his tactics exasperating despite shared partisan goals.

Electoral Backlash from Key Constituencies

Metzenbaum's 1976 Senate election victory against Republican Robert A. Taft Jr. was decided by a slim margin of roughly 2 percentage points, with Metzenbaum receiving 1,617,922 votes to Taft's 1,549,202 out of approximately 3.2 million cast, despite endorsements from major labor organizations like the that typically bolstered Democratic turnout in Ohio's industrial heartland. This underperformance relative to Jimmy Carter's statewide presidential win by over 10 percentage points highlighted emerging fissures among blue-collar Democrats, particularly in rural and manufacturing areas where Metzenbaum's advocacy for stringent measures—such as early pushes for federal restrictions on firearms—clashed with cultural attachments to and . His Senate record included support for bills expanding federal oversight on weapons, drawing opposition from advocates who argued such policies disregarded the practical concerns of working-class constituents reliant on firearms for sport and protection. Subsequent electoral dynamics revealed a deepening disconnect tied to Ohio's crisis, as steel mill closures and auto sector layoffs in the late 1970s and 1980s—exemplified by the Youngstown steel plant shutdowns displacing thousands—fostered resentment toward interventionist policies emphasizing regulation over market liberalization. While Metzenbaum retained union leadership backing, rank-and-file blue-collar voters increasingly defected to in 1980 and 1984, with Ohio's working-class precincts showing reduced Democratic margins amid frustration over perceived regulatory burdens on employers that exacerbated job flight. Primary turnout in Democratic contests during his tenure often lagged, signaling among erstwhile supporters who prioritized economic revival through and trade protections misaligned with Metzenbaum's focus on consumer and labor safeguards. Metzenbaum's 1993 announcement of ahead of the 1994 election, at age 76, came amid polling that favored a strong challenger in Mayor , buoying GOP prospects for flipping the seat in a state weary of prolonged incumbency. Post-retirement surveys and voting patterns underscored Ohio's rightward trajectory, with regulatory fatigue cited by business groups and analysts as a factor in voter realignment; compliance costs from Metzenbaum-era backed policies were blamed for hindering industrial recovery, contributing to gains in subsequent state and federal races as former Democratic strongholds embraced less interventionist approaches.

Post-Senate Period

Retirement Activities and Advocacy

Upon retiring from the U.S. Senate on January 3, 1995, following his decision not to seek re-election in at age 77, Howard Metzenbaum transitioned to leadership in advocacy organizations. He assumed the role of chairman of the Consumer Federation of America (CFA), a coalition representing over 300 nonprofit , labor, and groups focused on issues such as product safety, financial protections, and regulatory oversight. In this capacity, Metzenbaum continued to press for stronger antitrust enforcement and safeguards against corporate practices, drawing on his experience to advise on policy matters without the direct legislative authority he previously wielded. His involvement marked a shift from authoring amendments and filibustering bills to informal guidance and public commentary, particularly as majorities in after limited opportunities for Democratic-aligned initiatives on labor and economic regulation. Metzenbaum's post-Senate efforts emphasized sustaining pressure on business accountability, including critiques of mergers and deceptive marketing, though his influence operated through CFA's advocacy channels rather than binding votes. He participated in efforts to highlight risks in and supported campaigns for enhanced worker notifications in plant closures, echoing his earlier legislative pushes like the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act. These activities aligned with CFA's mission to amplify consumer voices in regulatory debates, but they yielded advisory impact amid a political less receptive to expansive interventions. By the late , as his health began to limit public engagements, Metzenbaum's role evolved toward mentorship within advocacy networks, fostering continuity in priorities without introducing novel legislative proposals.

Death and Immediate Tributes

Howard Metzenbaum died on March 12, 2008, at his home in , at the age of 90. No specific cause was reported in initial announcements, though he had been in declining health. Contemporary tributes from Democratic allies and advocacy groups emphasized his legislative battles on behalf of labor unions and consumer protections, crediting him with blocking numerous special-interest tax breaks and corporate exemptions during his tenure. Organizations like the Pension Rights Center and the described him as a dedicated champion for workers' pensions and , reflecting partisan admiration from progressive constituencies. Mainstream media coverage, such as in and , highlighted his tactics—earning him the nickname "Senator No"—as a tool to scrutinize business practices and force accountability, though these accounts often framed his record through a lens sympathetic to his regulatory interventions. His funeral service on March 16, 2008, at Anshe Chesed Fairmount Temple in , drew several hundred attendees, including Ohio political figures and family members, where speakers eulogized him as an anti-corruption watchdog and civil rights advocate who marched in Selma and opposed the . Coverage in outlets portrayed him as a liberal icon whose tenacity shaped Democratic priorities, particularly amid the 2008 presidential contest between and , though such depictions largely echoed endorsements from aligned politicians like former Vice President rather than detached analysis. He was interred at Mayfield Cemetery in Cleveland Heights.

Personal Life and Affiliations

Family Dynamics and Personal Relationships

Howard Metzenbaum married Shirley Turoff on August 8, 1946, in a union that lasted over 61 years until his death. The couple resided primarily in Shaker Heights, a suburb of , where they raised their four daughters: Barbara, Susan, Shelley, and Amy. This family structure provided a stable personal foundation amid Metzenbaum's frequent political campaigns and service, with no of marital discord or familial scandals emerging during his lifetime. The Metzenbaums' daughters occasionally participated in his electoral efforts, such as Susan signing the family register at a polling place during one campaign, reflecting a supportive home environment that reinforced his Cleveland-centric identity. Despite the demands of Washington duties, the family maintained deep roots in , frequently returning to their Shaker Heights home and leveraging local business networks built during Metzenbaum's earlier entrepreneurial phase for personal continuity. This balance allowed Metzenbaum to navigate political setbacks, including multiple races, with familial backing that emphasized resilience over publicity. Metzenbaum's personal relationships extended to close ties with and longtime associates, who described his home life as grounded and affectionate, contrasting his combative public persona. His daughters later recalled him as a devoted father and grandfather, prioritizing family gatherings and local traditions in , which sustained him through the volatility of national politics.

Jewish Heritage, Philanthropy, and Civic Engagements

Metzenbaum was born on June 4, 1917, in Cleveland to a Hungarian Jewish immigrant father whose business failures contributed to the family's poverty on the city's East Side. Early in his career, following his 1941 law degree from Ohio State University, he encountered employment discrimination due to anti-Semitism, as Jewish faith barred him from hires at major firms. This background informed his lifelong identification with Reform Judaism, where he served as national chairman of the Commission on Social Action in 1972, channeling faith-based advocacy toward civil rights and social justice issues like poverty alleviation and discrimination reform. His philanthropic efforts, while aligned with progressive causes, remained modest relative to his self-made millionaire status achieved through business ventures in and parking lots. Post-Senate, he donated proceeds from speaking engagements to unspecified charities, reflecting a pattern of targeted rather than large-scale giving. He also held the role of founding honorary chairman for the American Friends of , supporting initiatives in through this . No major family foundation bearing his name focused on broad or philanthropy; instead, his contributions emphasized advocacy-linked causes over expansive endowments. In civic circles before his senatorial career, Metzenbaum engaged through labor representation, filing tax returns and advocating for unions such as the and the International Association of Machinists, fostering worker via . He co-founded the Ohio School of Social Sciences, an organization aimed at on economic issues, and participated in the , prioritizing for underprivileged groups independent of federal programs. These roles underscored a pre-political rooted in local, empowerment rather than reliance on expansive government dependency structures.

Evaluations of Legacy

Praised Achievements in Progressive Reforms

Metzenbaum co-sponsored the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act, enacted in , which mandates that employers provide at least 60 days' advance notice to workers facing mass layoffs or plant closures affecting 50 or more employees, enabling better preparation for job transitions and retraining. Supporters credit the law with reducing the economic shock of sudden job losses, as evidenced by its adoption across industries and subsequent state-level expansions mirroring its provisions. In , Metzenbaum played a pivotal role in the Nutrition Labeling and Education Act of 1990, which required standardized facts panels on most packaged foods, enhancing and empowering informed purchasing decisions amid rising concerns. The legislation's implementation led to widespread compliance, with over 90% of packaged foods bearing labels by the mid-1990s, facilitating dietary improvements and accountability for misleading claims. Advocates praise Metzenbaum's frequent use of filibusters and procedural tactics to obstruct special-interest legislation, such as targeted tax breaks and exemptions benefiting corporations, thereby preserving broader taxpayer equity and curbing in policy-making. These efforts, including blocking provisions in omnibus spending bills during the , were estimated by contemporaries to avert billions in unnecessary federal expenditures, aligning with progressive aims to prioritize public over private gains.

Critiques of Policy Impacts and Partisan Legacy

Critics have contended that Metzenbaum's legislative emphasis on labor protections and regulatory mandates, such as the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) , imposed compliance burdens that eroded business confidence and contributed to from . The WARN required employers with 100 or more workers to provide 60 days' advance notice of plant closings or mass layoffs affecting 50 or more employees, a measure opponents labeled as overregulation stifling operational flexibility amid economic pressures. advocates argued such requirements increased uncertainty and costs, potentially accelerating or relocation to less regulated jurisdictions, though empirical assessments found limited direct evidence of widespread job displacement from the law itself. Ohio's sector, a of the state's , shed approximately 261,000 jobs during Metzenbaum's tenure from 1977 to 1995, with employment falling from 1,048,000 in 1979 to 787,000 in 1995. Realist analyses attribute part of this stagnation to the cumulative weight of federal and state regulations championed by figures like Metzenbaum, including heightened OSHA standards and union-favoring policies, which raised operational costs relative to right-to-work states such as , where employment held steadier before diversifying into energy-driven growth. These critiques portray Metzenbaum's anti-business posture—frequently cited by opponents as thriving on confrontation with —as emblematic of policies that prioritized short-term worker safeguards over long-term competitiveness, fostering an where job preservation efforts inadvertently hastened structural decline. Metzenbaum's procedural tactics in the , which earned him the nickname "Senator No," amplified perceptions of entrenchment by routinely deploying filibusters, holds, and voluminous amendments to derail opposing . He mastered these tools to block "Christmas tree bills" laden with special-interest provisions, offering over 1,000 amendments in some sessions to force extended debates and votes, often on nominations or appropriations. While effective against perceived corporate giveaways, such obstructionism drew rebukes for substituting adversarial delay for deliberative consensus, thereby intensifying inter-party distrust and laying groundwork for the era's rising , where minority vetoes supplanted . In retrospective evaluations, Metzenbaum's career symbolizes the pitfalls of unrestrained progressive liberalism, with its regulatory expansions and advocacy viewed as harbingers of inefficiency in and labor markets. Supporters of market-oriented reforms argue his pushes for measures like repeated increases and broadened social safety nets—enacted without offsetting fiscal disciplines—exacerbated dependency cycles and budgetary imbalances, prefiguring the debates where unchecked growth strained resources amid slowing revenue from deindustrialized regions. Conservative commentators, skeptical of mainstream media's tendency to lionize such figures without scrutinizing economic trade-offs, highlight how these policies correlated with persistent underperformance, underscoring a causal disconnect between interventionist intent and adaptive prosperity.

References

  1. [1]
    METZENBAUM, Howard Morton - Bioguide Search
    METZENBAUM, Howard Morton, a Senator from Ohio; born in Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, June 4, 1917; graduated, Ohio State University, Columbus 1939.
  2. [2]
    Senator Howard M. Metzenbaum - Congress.gov
    Howard M. Metzenbaum, the Senator from Ohio - in Congress from 1973 through 1975, 1977 through 1995.
  3. [3]
    METZENBAUM, HOWARD MORTON | Encyclopedia of Cleveland ...
    Howard Morton (4 June 1917 - 12 March 2008), a staunchly liberal US Senator during an era of conservative political ascendency associated with the presidency ...
  4. [4]
    Sen. Howard Metzenbaum: A Champion for the Public Interest
    Mar 14, 2008 · During his distinguished Senate career, he passed the landmark law that requires nutrition labels on food, fought for the rights of adoptive ...Missing: key | Show results with:key
  5. [5]
    'Senator No,' Howard Metzenbaum, dies - NBC News
    Mar 13, 2008 · 'Senator No,' Howard Metzenbaum, dies. Former Sen. Howard Metzenbaum ... Born June 4, 1917, Metzenbaum grew up a child of poverty and ...
  6. [6]
    Howard's End: Metzenbaum was true to form through his last days in ...
    Mar 13, 2008 · He won breakthrough federal funding for Alzheimer's research, watched out for migrant workers, and was always protective of America's children.
  7. [7]
    Ohio senator was a champion of labor and master of rules
    Mar 13, 2008 · Metzenbaum claimed to have single-handedly saved billions of tax dollars by blocking special tax breaks and pork-barrel programs. In 1982, the ...<|separator|>
  8. [8]
    Howard Metzenbaum | US news | The Guardian
    Mar 28, 2008 · He courted unpopularity by attacking the exemption from anti-trust legislation of major league baseball.
  9. [9]
    Howard M. Metzenbaum, Who Battled Big Business as Ohio Senator ...
    Mar 14, 2008 · Howard Morton Metzenbaum, grandson of an immigrant from Hungary, was born on June 4, 1917, in Cleveland. His father, Charles, eked out a living ...
  10. [10]
    Ohio's Metzenbaum was “conscience of Senate” for 19 years
    Mar 16, 2008 · Howard Metzenbaum, 90, the Ohio senator who battled big business, stood up for labor and consumers and blocked scores of special-interest bills, died Wednesday.Missing: controversies | Show results with:controversies
  11. [11]
    Howard Metzenbaum - Hero to Consumers (1917 - 2008)
    Mar 13, 2008 · A graduate of Ohio State University's school of law, he practiced law in Cleveland in the 1940s, mostly for labor unions; first the ...Missing: education | Show results with:education
  12. [12]
    Former Democratic U.S. Sen. Howard Metzenbaum of Ohio dies at 90
    Mar 13, 2008 · Howard Metzenbaum of Ohio dies at 90. ASSOCIATED PRESS. Mar 13, 2008. 5 ... Born June 4, 1917, Metzenbaum grew up a child of poverty and ...
  13. [13]
    Glenn And Metzenbaum: A Feud For The Ages (With A Happy Ending)
    Jan 5, 2019 · Howard Morton Metzenbaum, born in 1917 in Cleveland and who died in 2008 at the age of 90, was the grandson of a Jewish immigrant from Hungary.Missing: labor disputes
  14. [14]
    Howard Metzenbaum - Biography — JewAge
    In the early 1970s, Metzenbaum co-owned the Sun Newspapers chain of weeklies in the Cleveland suburbs. Bonda and Metzenbaum also started one of the ...Missing: history | Show results with:history<|control11|><|separator|>
  15. [15]
    SUN NEWSPAPERS | Encyclopedia of Cleveland History
    ... HOWARD METZENBAUM and David Skylar. Owners of the Sun Post of PARMA and the West Side Sun News, the new publishers continued purchasing established newspapers.
  16. [16]
    Anniversary brings musings about community newspapers
    when Howard Metzenbaum grouped the individual community newspapers into the ...
  17. [17]
    Cleveland Stokers - Fun While It Lasted
    May 8, 2013 · Meanwhile, in early 1968, Stouffer sold the Stokers to Howard Metzenbaum and Ted Bonda (future Indians owners themselves). The team improved ...
  18. [18]
    Howard Morton Metzenbaum (1917 - 2008) - Genealogy - Geni
    May 23, 2018 · In January 1968 Metzenbaum and Bonda purchased the Cleveland Stokers soccer club from Cleveland Indians executives Vernon Stouffer and Gabe Paul ...Missing: purchase | Show results with:purchase
  19. [19]
    Howard Metzenbaum 1917-2008 | BigSoccer Forum
    Former Ohio senator and co-owner of the NASL Cleveland Stokers Howard Metzenbaum died Wednesday night. He was preceded by fellow co-owner Alva "Ted" Bonda ...
  20. [20]
    Former Ohio senator Howard Metzenbaum dies in Florida
    Mar 13, 2008 · He surprised Democratic party regulars by winning a seat in the Ohio House (1943-46) and then the Ohio Senate (1947-50). From 1950 to 1970 ...
  21. [21]
    YOUNG, Stephen Marvin - Bioguide Search
    YOUNG, Stephen Marvin, a Representative and a Senator from Ohio; born on a farm near Norwalk, Huron County, Ohio, May 4, 1889; attended the public schools.
  22. [22]
    TV Helped a Winner in Ohio - The New York Times
    May 9, 1970 · This was one of the brief political commercials that saturated Ohio television screens in recent weeks. They helped Howard Metz enbaum, almost ...
  23. [23]
    1970 Senatorial General Election Results - Ohio
    May 17, 2019 · Senatorial Candidate, Political Party, Popular Vote. Robert Taft Jr. Republican, 1,565,682, 49.68%. Howard M. Metzenbaum, Democratic ...
  24. [24]
    Gov. Gilligan Picks Metzenbaum To Finish Saxbe's Senate Term
    Dec 20, 1973 · millionaire H M Metzenbaum, who is apptd on Dec 19 by Gov J J Gilligan to succeed US Atty Gen-designate W B Saxbe in US Sen, ...Missing: date | Show results with:date
  25. [25]
    Glenn Wins in Ohio Over Metzenbaum - The New York Times
    May 8, 1974 · John H Glenn Jr, former astronaut, scores stunning victory over US Sen Howard Metzenbaum on May 7 in Ohio primary for Dem nomination for US ...
  26. [26]
    States in the Senate | Ohio Senators
    Howard M. Metzenbaum (D), Jan. 4, 1974, Dec. 23, 1974, Appointed, then resigned. 93rd - 105th, John H. Glenn (D), Dec. 24, 1974, Jan. 3, 1999. 106th - 111th ...
  27. [27]
    Committees - U.S. Senate
    Congressional Action Senator Howard Metzenbaum, a Democrat from Ohio who chaired the Judiciary Committee's Subcommittee on Antitrust, Monopolies, and ...
  28. [28]
    Howard Metzenbaum -- The Senate's Dr. No The Senate groans ...
    Jan 2, 1983 · Howard Metzenbaum, the self-made millionaire lawyer and businessman from Cleveland about to start his second full term in the Senate, is proud ...
  29. [29]
    Senator James Abourezk's Thirteen-Day Filibuster
    Apr 8, 2025 · Abourezk and Sen. Howard Metzenbaum (D-Oh.) agreed to filibuster. They employed a less common filibuster technique by flooding the Senate ...
  30. [30]
    GAS FILIBUSTER ENDS AS BYRD OVERRIDES CUSTOMS OF ...
    Oct 4, 1977 · Senators Howard M. Metzenbaum, left, and James G. Abourezk, leaders filibuster against deregulation of natural gas, conferring after maneuver ...
  31. [31]
    Yearlong Dispute Stalls Meese Nomination - CQ Press
    ... filibuster against the nomination led by Sens. Edward M. Kennedy, D-Mass. and Howard M. Metzenbaum D-Ohio. (Votes 208, 209, p. 37-S). An earlier cloture vote ...
  32. [32]
    The Case Against the Filibuster | Brennan Center for Justice
    Oct 30, 2020 · At that time, the Senate chose not to adopt a strict majority rule, instead requiring two-thirds of the senators present to vote for cloture to ...Missing: strategies | Show results with:strategies
  33. [33]
    METZENBAUM FILIBUSTERS AS SENATORS BURN
    Dec 12, 1982 · ''For years, the filibuster or threat of filibuster was used against civil rights measures, proconsumer and protaxpayer measures,'' he said.Missing: strategies | Show results with:strategies
  34. [34]
    Ohio Sen. Howard M. Metzenbaum, 90; Fought Special-Interest Bills ...
    Mar 13, 2008 · Sen. Metzenbaum had some notable losses, including an unsuccessful two-week filibuster in 1977 against a bill that lifted price controls on ...Missing: Stokers financial
  35. [35]
    S.2527 - Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act 100th ...
    Summary of S.2527 - 100th Congress (1987-1988): Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act.
  36. [36]
    [PDF] legislative surveys striking down the workplace fairness act
    I. Introduction. On July 13, 1994 passage of the "Workplace Fairness Act" (the bill)' was blocked by a Republican-led filibuster in the United.
  37. [37]
    END OF FORCED RETIREMENT MEANS A LOT - TO A FEW
    Oct 26, 1986 · ''Abolishing age discrimination will offer new hope to older workers who are desperate to maintain their independence and dignity,'' declared ...Missing: Act | Show results with:Act
  38. [38]
    Congress Votes to End Mandatory Retirement Age
    Oct 17, 1986 · The legislation amends the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967, removing a provision that allows firms to mandate retirement at age 70.
  39. [39]
    Age Discrimination in Employment Waiver Protection Act of 1989 ...
    Summary of S.54 - 101st Congress (1989-1990): Age Discrimination in Employment Waiver Protection Act of 1989.
  40. [40]
    Surprisingly Busy Year for 100th Congress - CQ Press
    PL 100-583) that put new disclosure requirements on banks, department stores and other businesses that issued credit and charge ...
  41. [41]
    AIRLINES WARNED TO IMPROVE SERVICE - The Washington Post
    Apr 23, 1987 · Angry senators yesterday threatened airline executives with consumer protection legislation ... Howard M. Metzenbaum (D-Ohio) told ...Missing: credit card safety
  42. [42]
    Howard Metzenbaum: The Last Ferocious Liberal | The Nation
    Mar 14, 2008 · As a reporter and editor for The Toledo Blade and then for The Nation – one of his favorite publications – I interviewed Metzenbaum frequently ...Missing: newspapers publishing
  43. [43]
    Ban on Firing Strikers Blocked : Labor: Senate Republicans succeed ...
    Jul 13, 1994 · Metzenbaum (D-Ohio), who sponsored the legislation, argued that the current law “sends the unmistakable message that workers are disposable, ...
  44. [44]
    S.55 - 103rd Congress (1993-1994): A bill to amend the National ...
    Summary of S.55 - 103rd Congress (1993-1994): A bill to amend the National Labor Relations Act and the Railway Labor Act to prevent discrimination based on ...
  45. [45]
    Bill to protect jobs of strikers rejected by Senate - Baltimore Sun
    Jul 13, 1994 · Labor unions and their allies in Congress argue that the use of permanent replacements for striking workers sharply increased in the 1980s, ...Missing: arguments | Show results with:arguments<|separator|>
  46. [46]
    Striker Replacement Bill Blocked - CQ Almanac Online Edition
    But opponents argued that the bill would disrupt the delicate balance that gave workers and management roughly equal leverage in a dispute. “Current law is ...
  47. [47]
    How the Anti-Striker Replacement Bill Would Hurt American Workers
    The Clay- Metzenbaum Strike Bill would guarantee striking workers their old jobs. The Strike Bill thus would encourage workers to strike by taking considerable ...
  48. [48]
    Senate Panel, Defying Veto Threat, Backs Hike in Minimum Wage to ...
    Mar 9, 1989 · Sen. Howard M. Metzenbaum (D-Ohio) said Bush's proposal to pay those workers 80% of the minimum wage rate prevailing for most workers was “just ...
  49. [49]
    Minimum-Wage Impasse Finally Ended - CQ Almanac Online Edition
    HR 2710, the compromise measure approved by Congress, raises the minimum wage to $4.25 an hour by April 1, 1991. Under a provision that expires in 1993, ...
  50. [50]
    S.5 - 102nd Congress (1991-1992): Family and Medical Leave Act ...
    Cosponsors of S.5 - 102nd Congress (1991-1992): Family and Medical Leave Act of 1991. ... Metzenbaum, Howard M. [D-OH]*, 01/14/1991. Sen. D'Amato, Alfonse [R-NY]* ...
  51. [51]
    S. 5 (RS) - Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 - Content Details -
    Jan 27, 1993 · Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993. Full Title. To ... Mikulski (MD); Mark O. Hatfield (OR); Christopher S. Bond (MO); Howard M. Metzenbaum ...
  52. [52]
    Adding Up the Costs of the Family & Medical Leave Act – FMLA
    Jun 16, 2006 · Based on its survey, the Washington, D.C.-based Employment Policy Foundation (EPF) estimates that FMLA compliance cost employers $21 billion in ...
  53. [53]
    S.865 - Consumer Protection Against Price-Fixing Act of 1989
    Summary of S.865 - 101st Congress (1989-1990): Consumer Protection Against Price-Fixing Act of 1989. ... Metzenbaum, Howard M. [D-OH] (Introduced 04/19/1989).
  54. [54]
    The Ohio Citizen Action Howard M Metzenbaum Award
    Sen. Metzenbaum passed milestone consumer protection laws, including plant closing legislation, food labeling, and orphan drug legislation, and saved taxpayers ...
  55. [55]
    Natural Gas Deregulation Hits Snag in Senate - The Oklahoman
    Metzenbaum has long opposed measures that would lift controls on energy, whether it be oil, gas or both. As a freshman senator, he led a filibuster in 1977 for ...
  56. [56]
    Reagan faces a fight on his plan to ease antitrust law long-range
    Jan 29, 1986 · Senator Metzenbaum charges that the Reagan administration would like to ``turn the clock backwards'' by codifying permissive antitrust policy.
  57. [57]
    AN UNSETTLING SHIFT IN BIG OIL - The New York Times
    Mar 11, 1984 · ''These mergers are almost obscene,'' said Senator Howard M. Metzenbaum, Democrat of Ohio and one of the industry's leading critics. ''They ...
  58. [58]
    Misgivings About Big Mergers | TIME
    Mar 26, 1984 · ... Metzenbaum, a persistent industry critic, united behind a bill to impose a six-month moratorium on acquisitions by the 50 largest oil companies.
  59. [59]
    metzenbaum to ftc: macy merger not good for consumers, retailing
    Jul 18, 1994 · Howard Metzenbaum (D., Ohio) said Friday he is drafting a letter to Federal Trade Commission chairman Janet D. Steiger to convey his “major concerns” about the ...Missing: opposition | Show results with:opposition
  60. [60]
    Who Said Takeovers Were Dead? - Videos Index on TIME.com
    Mar 23, 1987 · Complained Democratic Senator Howard Metzenbaum of Ohio during hearings held last week by a Senate subcommittee: "Merger mania is rampant in ...Missing: ventures retail
  61. [61]
    Merger Seen Boosting U.S. Competitiveness - The Washington Post
    Dec 12, 1985 · A longtime foe of big mergers, Metzenbaum said, "On its face, the deal raises serious antitrust questions," and threatened to call hearings on ...Missing: opposition | Show results with:opposition
  62. [62]
    Prioritizing Innovation in Antitrust Merger Analysis - Mercatus Center
    Aug 15, 2024 · As a result, antitrust enforcement agencies have given greater consideration to the potential innovation effects of mergers in their analysis.
  63. [63]
    Studying Effects of Mergers on Innovation Using Evidence from R&D ...
    There is no evidence mergers are generally associated with reduced innovation, nor do the results indicate that supposedly lax antitrust enforcement over the ...
  64. [64]
    https://www.congress.gov/amendment/99th-congress/senate-amendment/3024/all-info
  65. [65]
    Remembering GARA : The Law that Changed the Trajectory of the ...
    Aug 1, 2024 · One of our major opponents was Howard Metzenbaum of Ohio [former Senate Democrat]. He was a really fierce opponent of product liability ...Missing: consumer | Show results with:consumer
  66. [66]
    Fighting at the Finish - Newsweek
    Jul 31, 1994 · Metzenbaum infuriated Ohio workers with his votes for gun control and against the gulf war. In the Senate, he drives even allies crazy, often ...Missing: controversies | Show results with:controversies
  67. [67]
    [PDF] Extent of 'Litigation Explosion' in Federal Courts Questioned - GAO
    Jan 28, 1988 · According to a 1980 Business Insurance article, the 26.4 percent increase from 1979 to 1980 in product liability cases filed in federal.
  68. [68]
    The American Consumer Pays Dearly for the Liability InsuranceCrisis
    The liability insurance crisis is now pinching the U.S consumer reflects the cost of insuring their manufacturers again st product liability lawsuits burden ...
  69. [69]
    [PDF] The Effect of 1980s Tort Reform Legislation on General Liability and ...
    The rise of asbestos litigation and hazard warnings cases accounted increase in general liability insurance costs, but there was also substa in the medical ...Missing: lawsuits | Show results with:lawsuits
  70. [70]
    Metzenbaum fought big business in Senate – The Denver Post
    Howard Metzenbaum co-founded a large parking- lot company and one of the first car-rental agencies.
  71. [71]
    CONFRONTATION IN THE GULF; War and Peace: A Sampling From ...
    Jan 11, 1991 · I urge the Senate to vote for peace, not war. Now is not the time for war. I reject the argument that says Congress must support the ...
  72. [72]
    [PDF] SENATE-Thursday, January 10, 1991 - Congress.gov
    Jan 10, 1991 · that the passage of this resolution is a vote for peace, not war; it is a vote to let sanctions work; it is a vote to take advantage of more ...
  73. [73]
    [PDF] The Battle Over the Brady Bill and the Future of Gun Control Advocacy
    Aug 11, 1993 · Representative Feighan and Senator Metzenbaum reintroduced the Brady measure in the 101st Congress, on January 4, 1989.19. The 1989 version of ...
  74. [74]
    President Signs 'Brady' Gun Control Law - CQ Almanac Online Edition
    The Senate on Nov. 24 cleared the so-called Brady bill (HR 1025) requiring a five-day waiting period for the purchase of a handgun.
  75. [75]
    Thirty Years On, How The Brady Bill Changed Gun Buying - The Trace
    Nov 30, 2023 · The Brady Bill requires all federally licensed gun dealers to run background checks on their customers through either the FBI or a state or local agency.
  76. [76]
    Fiscal 1992 Intelligence Authorization - CQ Almanac Online Edition
    Sen. Howard M. Metzenbaum, D-Ohio, argued that it would be impossible to impose fiscal discipline on the U.S. intelligence community so long as its budget ...
  77. [77]
    SHEDDING LIGHT ON BLACK BUDGET - The Washington Post
    Jul 29, 1991 · Howard M. Metzenbaum (D-Ohio), the measure would signal the end of a 15-year fight by proponents who say intelligence spending should comport ...
  78. [78]
    metzenbaum - intelligence budget
    Bush had set aside $19.0 billion for the C.I.A., the National Security Agency, the National Reconnaissance Office and other national intelligence programs.
  79. [79]
    Intelligence Oversight Steps Back from Public Accountability
    Jan 2, 2013 · ... intelligence oversight activities to the American public consistent with national security concerns. ... Howard Metzenbaum, Arlen Specter ...
  80. [80]
    Ban on Replacing Strikers Faces Veto Threat - The New York Times
    Prospects are less certain in the Senate, where Howard M. Metzenbaum, Democrat of Ohio, has introduced a similar measure. Advertisement. SKIP ADVERTISEMENT.
  81. [81]
    The effect of strike replacement legislation on employment
    A strike replacement ban that restricts the use of both permanent and temporary replacements is found to have adverse employment consequences.Missing: closures | Show results with:closures
  82. [82]
    [PDF] The Economic Effects of Banning Temporary Replacement Workers
    One serious adverse effect of such bans is on investment. Entrepreneurs and investors are discouraged from investing and doing business in a jurisdiction with a.Missing: closures | Show results with:closures
  83. [83]
    What's Gone Wrong (and Right) in the Industrial Heartland?
    Sep 22, 2017 · From 1979 to 1983, the industrial heartland was hit by its first major shock as manufacturing employment in the region declined by 1.2 million ...
  84. [84]
    Ohio - Unemployment 1982 - countryeconomy.com
    Ohio - Unemployment ; October 1982, 5,109.4, 13.6% ; September 1982, 5,112.6, 13.3% ; August 1982, 5,115.2, 12.9% ; July 1982, 5,117.6, 12.7% ...
  85. [85]
    Table V.B2--Additional Economic Factors, Historical Period
    Average annual percentage increase in--. Calendar year, Average annual unemployment rate ... 1980, 7.2, 1.9, 0.5, -0.2, 11.0. 1981, 7.6, 1.6, 1.1, 2.4, 13.3. 1982 ...
  86. [86]
    Howard M. Metzenbaum - The Columbus Dispatch
    Metzenbaum defeated Glenn in the 1970 Senate primary, only to lose the fall election to Republican Robert Taft Jr. He was appointed to the Senate by Gov.
  87. [87]
    John Glenn Debates Howard Metzenbaum Who Said He 'Never ...
    Dec 8, 2016 · Metzenbaum began calling him "Col. Glenn" to highlight his time in the Marine Corps, and later told him that he "had never met a payroll," which ...Missing: controversies | Show results with:controversies<|control11|><|separator|>
  88. [88]
    Washington at Work; Polite and Yet Dogged, An Ohio Senator Gives ...
    Oct 25, 1991 · Throughout his Senate career, Mr. Metzenbaum has so rankled with his blockage of bills on issues important to his colleagues' home states ...
  89. [89]
    The 1986 Plastic Gun Panic | GOA
    Aug 7, 2018 · Metzenbaum introduced legislation to outlaw all guns that contained less than 8.5 ounces of steel, because such guns could supposedly pass ...Missing: backlash blue- collar
  90. [90]
    IN OHIO, IT'S STILL A BALLGAME – Chicago Tribune
    In the 1980s, Ohio re-elected liberal Sen. Howard Metzenbaum but at the same time backed conservative President Ronald Reagan. More recently, the same Ohio ...
  91. [91]
    Why Ohio? - The American Interest
    Sep 8, 2016 · Ohio was “the entire ballgame,” explained an anchor. Although Obama was not quite at the requisite number of 270 electoral votes, any other ...Missing: challenges | Show results with:challenges
  92. [92]
    METZENBAUM WON'T SEEK FOURTH TERM - The Washington Post
    Jun 29, 1993 · Although Metzenbaum has had tough races, he was a survivor; his decision to retire buoyed GOP hopes of picking up a seat or possibly even taking ...Missing: 1994 pressure
  93. [93]
    Ohio's Political Transformation | City Journal
    Aug 2, 2022 · In the 2022 midterms, given strong chances for the GOP to pick up Democrat-held congressional seats, Ohio remains of towering electoral ...Missing: Metzenbaum regulatory
  94. [94]
    Senator Howard Metzenbaum Retirement | Video | C-SPAN.org
    Jun 29, 1993 · The Senate failed for a fifth time to garner the 60 votes needed to advance consideration of competing continuing resolutions to fund the ...Missing: 1994 reason pressure
  95. [95]
    Remembering Howard Metzenbaum (1917-2008)
    Mar 17, 2008 · Metzenbaum championed the rights of consumers and workers in Congress and was beloved by consumer and labor leaders alike. For example, to ...Missing: key achievements
  96. [96]
    Howard Metzenbaum Dies at 90; Ex-Ohio Senator
    Mar 13, 2008 · Howard Metzenbaum Dies at 90; Ex-Ohio Senator. Share full article. By ... Metzenbaum won re-election in 1988 from Ohio voters who chose ...
  97. [97]
    The Pension Rights Center Mourns the Death of Senator Howard ...
    “One of Senator Metzenbaum's last acts in the Senate was to introduce a 'Pension Bill of Rights,' a comprehensive reform measure that established basic ...
  98. [98]
    Human Rights Campaign Mourns the Death of Sen. Metzenbaum
    Mar 14, 2008 · Howard Metzenbaum of Ohio. Solmonese said: "With Sen. Metzenbaum's death, the GLBT community has lost a stalwart friend and dedicated ally.Missing: tributes | Show results with:tributes
  99. [99]
    Hundreds mourn Metzenbaum at funeral - The Columbus Dispatch
    Howard Metzenbaum was remembered as an anti-corruption watchdog and a fighter for civil rights at a funeral attended by several hundred people including ...
  100. [100]
    Metzenbaum mourned at funeral service today - cleveland.com
    Mar 16, 2008 · That truth led Metzenbaum, who died Wednesday at age 90, to march in Selma for civil rights and to oppose the Vietnam War, to block scores of ...Missing: tributes | Show results with:tributes
  101. [101]
    Remembering Howard Metzenbaum, Ohio's Jewish senator
    Mar 20, 2008 · Howard Metzenbaum, who died March 12 at age 90, was eulogized Sunday at Anshe Chesed Fairmount Temple.Missing: newspapers | Show results with:newspapers<|separator|>
  102. [102]
    Sen. Metzenbaum, fighter for civil rights, buried in Cleveland
    Mar 17, 2008 · Howard Metzenbaum was remembered as an anti-corruption watchdog and a fighter for civil rights at a funeral attended by several hundred family, ...
  103. [103]
    A look at Howard Metzenbaum's life - cleveland.com
    Mar 13, 2008 · June 4, 1917: Howard Morton Metzenbaum is born in Cleveland. After graduating from Glenville High School, he attends Ohio State University, ...Missing: United biography
  104. [104]
    Susan Metzenbaum to Be Wed To Joel Zylberberg of Yale Law
    Apr 13, 1975 · Mr. and Mrs. Howard M. Metzenbaum of Shaker Heights, Ohio, have announced the engagement of their daughter, Susan Lynn Metzenbaum, ...Missing: names | Show results with:names
  105. [105]
    "Senator Howard Metzenbaum"
    Senator Howard Metzenbaum watches daughter Suzi sign the register book at the family voting place in Malvern School. Also looking on are Shelley Metzenbaum ...Missing: names | Show results with:names
  106. [106]
    Metzenbaum family memories - cleveland.com
    Mar 14, 2008 · To the world, Howard Metzenbaum was a fighter. To us, his daughters and to our Mom, our husbands, and our children, he was much more.
  107. [107]
    Howard Metzenbaum Obituary (2008) - Cleveland, OH
    ... school and learn some new skills”. I returned to school in 1983 and completed the MBA program at Wright State University. Senator Metzenbaum ...Missing: education | Show results with:education<|separator|>
  108. [108]
    Devoted Senator, Reform Jewish Leader, Tireless Fighter for Social ...
    As an attorney, businessman and politician, Metzenbaum dedicated his life to protecting workers, guarding civil rights and advocating on behalf of consumers.
  109. [109]
    Howard Metzenbaum, former senator from Ohio | US & World News
    Mar 21, 2008 · ... elected to the U.S. Senate from Ohio. At the time I was in my early 20s, but already I'd been working in and around Ohio politics for seven ...
  110. [110]
    Two of the Senate's five new members are millionaires... - UPI
    May 19, 1983 · Howard Metzenbaum, D-Ohio, last year had income outside the Senate ... The small amount he made from giving speeches was donated to charity.Missing: philanthropy | Show results with:philanthropy
  111. [111]
    American Friends of Rabin Medical Center • News & Innovations
    Former Ohio Senator Howard Metzenbaum, founding Honorary Chairman of the American Friends of Rabin Medical Center (AFRMC), died at the age of 90 in March. read ...Missing: charitable | Show results with:charitable
  112. [112]
    SENATOR HOWARD METZENBAUM - GovInfo
    ... legislation that favored special interests, the Dayton Daily News called him ``Senator Can Do'' for his legislative accomplishments. The Cleveland Plain ...
  113. [113]
    SENATE DEMOCRATS DEFEAT EFFORTS TO WEAKEN PLANT ...
    Howard Metzenbaum. (D-Ohio) ... flexibility in dealing with short-term business slowdowns. "Mandatory notice of layoffs is overregulation," said Sen.
  114. [114]
    https://www.nytimes.com/1993/08/03/business/layoff-law-impact-is-almost-nil.html
  115. [115]
    [PDF] ----What's Happened to Ohio's Manufacturing Jobs?
    Nov 1, 1988 · In contrast, 39 percent more jobs were gained than lost by small businesses in the 1976-78 expansion. The current ratio of job gains to job.Missing: 1990s | Show results with:1990s