Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Migration Policy Institute


The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) is a Washington, D.C.-based founded in 2001 that conducts research, data analysis, and policy recommendations on global , trends, and strategies. Describing itself as independent and , MPI focuses on evidence-informed studies to influence policies, producing resources such as the Migration Data Hub for tracking immigrant populations, unauthorized estimates, and international comparisons.
MPI's work emphasizes pragmatic reforms, including pathways to for unauthorized immigrants and enhanced programs, which has positioned it as a key voice in U.S. and global policy discussions. However, independent assessments rate MPI as left-center biased due to its consistent advocacy for expansive policies and humane approaches over restrictionist measures. In 2011, it expanded internationally by establishing MPI in to address challenges. The institute's publications, including fact sheets and explainer articles, draw on authoritative data sources to highlight demographic shifts, such as the 13.7 million unauthorized immigrants in the U.S. as of mid-2023, reflecting diverse origins and labor contributions.

Founding and Early Development

Establishment in 2001

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) was founded in late 2001 as an independent, nonpartisan nonprofit think tank headquartered in Washington, D.C., dedicated to research and analysis on global migration movements, immigration policies, and integration outcomes. It emerged from the International Migration Policy Program previously housed at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, aiming to offer evidence-based insights to policymakers amid rising international migration flows and post-Cold War policy shifts. The organization was established just days before the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, which intensified scrutiny on immigration enforcement and border security in the ensuing years. MPI was co-founded by Demetrios G. Papademetriou, an economist with prior advisory roles to governments and international bodies, and Kathleen Newland, a specialist in and migration issues. Papademetriou assumed the role of founding president, leading the institute until 2014 and shaping its early focus on rigorous, data-driven examinations of migration's economic, social, and security dimensions rather than advocacy-driven narratives. Initial operations emphasized bridging academic research with practical recommendations, drawing on the founders' networks in think tanks and multilateral organizations to build credibility in a field often polarized by ideological debates. Early funding supported targeted studies on U.S. and systems, establishing MPI as a resource for empirical analysis independent of government influence.

Key Founders and Initial Mission

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) was co-founded in 2001 by Demetrios G. Papademetriou, a migration policy expert who served as its founding president and later president emeritus, and Kathleen Newland, a specialist in governance and refugee protection who became a senior fellow and board member. Papademetriou, with prior experience advising governments and international organizations on labor , sought to create a dedicated research entity amid debates on U.S. . Newland, drawing from her work on migration-development linkages, contributed to shaping MPI's emphasis on global policy analysis. From its inception, MPI's initial mission centered on conducting independent, nonpartisan research to analyze the movement of people worldwide and inform and integration policies with evidence-based insights. The founders aimed to address the growing complexities of large-scale by producing pragmatic, data-driven recommendations that promote orderly and fair systems, rather than ideological . This focus was positioned as a response to policy gaps in an era of increasing unauthorized flows and humanitarian crises, prioritizing analytical rigor over prescriptive outcomes.

Expansion in the 2000s

In the years immediately following its founding in late 2001 by Demetrios G. Papademetriou and Kathleen Newland, the Migration Policy Institute (MPI) underwent rapid organizational growth, transitioning from a nascent entity spun off from the Endowment for International Peace's International Migration Policy Program into an independent with expanded research capabilities. This period saw MPI build its core team of policy analysts, demographers, and economists, enabling broader coverage of migration dynamics beyond initial U.S.-focused efforts to include global flows and integration challenges. By mid-decade, the institute had established key partnerships with governments, NGOs, and academic institutions, facilitating data-driven analyses amid heightened scrutiny of systems. A hallmark of MPI's expansion was the launch of the Migration Information Source in 2003, an online platform delivering in-depth country profiles, thematic reports, and data visualizations on trends across more than 100 nations, which quickly became a resource for policymakers and researchers. This initiative reflected MPI's strategic shift toward comprehensive, evidence-based tools, including early precursors to its later data hubs, to address empirical gaps in understanding causal factors like labor market demands and security implications of cross-border movements. The institute's output surged, with dozens of publications annually by the late examining issues such as the record decade of 2000-2010, during which nearly 14 million immigrants entered the U.S., straining frameworks. Financially, MPI's growth was supported by diversified funding from and philanthropies, allowing for increased staffing—reaching over 50 personnel by —and programmatic depth without reliance on government contracts that might compromise independence. This expansion positioned MPI as a to ideologically driven narratives, emphasizing first-principles of migration's economic and social effects, though critics noted its outputs often aligned with perspectives favoring managed inflows over restrictionism, reflecting the think tank's origins in pro- circles. By decade's end, MPI had influenced debates on comprehensive , including worker programs and , through testimonies and advisory roles, underscoring its maturation into a pivotal voice.

Organizational Structure and Operations

Leadership and Governance

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) is led by its president, Andrew Selee, who succeeded co-founder Demetrios G. Papademetriou and Michael Fix in the role. Selee, who previously directed the Mexico Institute at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, oversees the institute's strategic direction, research agenda, and operations as a focused on and . Governance of MPI is vested in its Board of Trustees, which provides oversight, sets policy priorities, and ensures financial and operational accountability. The board is chaired by Roberta S. Jacobson, a former U.S. to and Under for Affairs, with Cecilia Malmström serving as vice chair; she previously held roles as for Trade and Home Affairs. Additional officers include Malcolm Brown and Lynden Melmed. Trustees hail from diverse sectors including , , and , such as Paul S. Dwyer Jr., Juan José Gómez-Camacho, and new appointees Paul Dwyer, Charles Kamasaki, and Elizabeth Espín Stern, who joined in July 2025 to broaden expertise in migration issues. As an nonprofit, MPI's structure emphasizes in , with the board approving major initiatives while the president manages day-to-day leadership and program directors handle specialized areas like U.S. immigration policy under Doris Meissner and immigrant integration under Margie McHugh. This framework supports MPI's self-described mission, though its outputs have drawn scrutiny for aligning with pro-immigration perspectives in policy debates.

Offices and Global Reach

The Migration Policy Institute maintains its headquarters in , at 1275 K Street NW, Suite 800. This location serves as the primary hub for its research, policy analysis, and administrative operations focused on North American immigration issues. In 2011, MPI established a European office, Migration Policy Institute Europe, in , , at Residence Palace, 155 Rue de la Loi. This outpost engages with , providing research and policy recommendations on migration and integration within , building on MPI's prior work. Official descriptions emphasize these two offices as the core physical presence, situated in and to align with the institute's prioritized research regions. MPI extends its influence globally beyond these bases through extensive international collaborations, data hubs tracking worldwide trends, and programs addressing partnerships, impacts, and policy frameworks in regions including , , and . While some secondary sources reference presences or historical offices in and , these are not corroborated in primary institutional documentation and appear tied to specific program leads or past initiatives rather than ongoing operational sites. The institute's nonpartisan analyses and engagements with governments, NGOs, and multilateral bodies, such as contributions to the , amplify its reach without requiring additional physical infrastructure.

Staff and Expertise

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) maintains a staff of approximately 75 individuals, including researchers, policy analysts, program directors, and support personnel, as reported in recent financial disclosures. This team composition supports MPI's focus on data-driven analysis of patterns, with roles distributed across U.S.-centric programs, initiatives, and efforts. Staff backgrounds typically include advanced degrees in fields such as , , , and , drawn from academic, governmental, and nonprofit sectors. Leadership and senior experts provide specialized knowledge in core migration domains. Andrew Selee, MPI's president since 2017, directs overall strategy with expertise in U.S.- border dynamics, resettlement, and reform, informed by his prior roles at the and academic positions. Doris Meissner, senior fellow and director of the U.S. Program, brings over 40 years of experience, including as commissioner of the () from 1993 to 1997, focusing on enforcement, border management, and bilateral migration agreements. Margie McHugh, director of the National Center on , specializes in and local strategies, development, and civic participation, based on her work with urban institutes and government task forces. Research staff emphasize empirical analysis of immigrant socioeconomic outcomes and policy impacts. Jeanne Batalova, a senior policy analyst, examines labor market effects, educational of immigrant youth, and demographic trends using and survey data. Gelatt, associate of the U.S. Policy Program, concentrates on legal pathways, family-based admissions, and processing inefficiencies. Meghan Benton, of programs, addresses , labor , and European Union policies, drawing from her at think tanks like the German Marshall Fund. These experts contribute to MPI's outputs through quantitative modeling, qualitative case studies, and stakeholder consultations, though the organization's emphasis on expansive legal pathways has drawn scrutiny for potentially underweighting enforcement data in favor of integration-focused narratives. MPI recruits for diversity in professional and personal backgrounds to mirror 's complexity, including multilingual capabilities and field experience in origin and destination countries. Expertise clusters around unauthorized (e.g., via residual methods from data), integration metrics like rates, and global flows, with tools like the relying on staff proficiency in datasets from sources such as the U.S. and . While MPI positions its work as nonpartisan, staff publications often highlight barriers to legalization over fiscal or security costs of high-volume inflows, reflecting institutional priorities rather than uniform empirical consensus.

Research Activities and Outputs

Core Research Areas

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) concentrates its research on key dimensions of migration, including , data-driven trends, and outcomes, with a primary emphasis on filling analytical gaps in systems worldwide. Its work spans U.S.-centric reforms, such as legal pathways, strategies, and unauthorized migration dynamics, often evaluating effectiveness through empirical assessments. Globally, MPI examines migration flows, labor mobility, and economic impacts, including remittances and linkages in origin countries. A central pillar involves immigrant , covering , employment, health access, and civic participation for newcomers in host societies. MPI's initiatives, such as the Integration Futures Working Group, explore long-term strategies for successful societal incorporation, drawing on comparative data from and . and addresses protection mechanisms, processing, and reintegration challenges, particularly in regions like the and , with analyses of outcomes and returnee support systems. Data tools form another core area, exemplified by the Migration Data Hub, which aggregates global statistics on stocks, flows, and demographics to inform evidence-based making. MPI also prioritizes management, transnational coordination, and health-related issues, such as pandemic-era restrictions and healthcare disparities. These efforts integrate quantitative modeling with qualitative case studies, often highlighting understudied intersections like climate-induced displacement and gender-specific patterns.

Publications and Data Tools

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) produces diverse outputs, including in-depth reports, concise fact sheets, policy briefs, and analytical published via its online platform, the Migration Information Source. Reports often examine trends, policy impacts, and global migration dynamics, drawing on quantitative analyses of official data sources such as U.S. Bureau American Community Surveys (ACS). For instance, a March 12, 2025, in the Migration Information Source compiles frequently requested statistics on immigrants and in the United States, tabulating data from ACS 2010–2023 alongside historical figures from 1970, 1990, and 2000 to track metrics like foreign-born population shares and origins. Fact sheets synthesize key data on topics like unauthorized immigrant populations at national, state, and county levels, emphasizing empirical profiles without prescriptive policy recommendations. MPI's Migration Information Source functions as a digital magazine offering factual overviews, data visualizations, and expert analyses on movements worldwide, with contributions from institute researchers and external specialists. Publications prioritize accessibility, compiling governmental and nongovernmental data sources into user guides, such as those on immigrant or flows, while attributing statistics to primary datasets like international statistics from the or U.S. Department of Homeland Security records. The institute also issues occasional books and working papers, though its core output remains periodic reports addressing timely issues, such as deferred action programs or labor patterns, updated with the latest available empirical evidence. Central to MPI's data outputs is the Migration Data Hub, an interactive online platform launched to visualize immigrant population characteristics and trends at U.S. national, state, and select county levels over time. The hub integrates tools for exploring metrics like net migration, asylum applications, citizenship acquisition, remittances, and unauthorized populations, sourcing data from entities including the U.S. Census Bureau, , and UNHCR. Key features include customizable maps, charts, and downloadable profiles; for example, State Immigration Data Profiles allow users to query foreign-born demographics by origin country, education, and employment, while Statistics tools track bilateral flows and policy-relevant indicators globally. Specialized subsets cover U.S.-specific topics, such as Unauthorized Immigrant Population Profiles estimating eligibility for programs like (DACA) using USCIS data as of December in recent years, and DACA recipient profiles at national and state scales. These tools emphasize empirical tabulations and visualizations to facilitate , with methodologies disclosed per dataset—such as residual estimation methods for unauthorized populations derived from ACS adjustments—and regular updates to reflect new releases like annual ACS . The hub's design supports cross-comparisons, enabling queries on topics from resettlement to skilled , though coverage varies by data availability, with stronger granularity for U.S. trends than some metrics.

Methodological Approach

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) primarily relies on quantitative demographic analysis and residual estimation techniques to derive insights into patterns, particularly for populations difficult to enumerate directly, such as unauthorized immigrants. A core method involves comparing total foreign-born populations from the U.S. Census Bureau's (ACS) against estimates of legal immigrants compiled from Department of Homeland Security (DHS) administrative data, historical Census records, and other official sources to calculate unauthorized populations via subtraction, known as the residual method. This three-stage process—first estimating unauthorized totals, then allocating legal statuses (e.g., lawful permanent residents, refugees, temporary visa holders) based on demographic characteristics like country of birth, entry year, age, and education, and finally assigning remaining noncitizens to categories such as —has been refined through collaborations with demographers and applied consistently in MPI's annual unauthorized population estimates, which pegged the U.S. figure at approximately 11.0 million as of mid-2022. In addition to census-based modeling, MPI incorporates projections that assume continuity in behavioral patterns, such as and migration rates among unauthorized groups, to forecast outcomes like birthright citizenship eligibility; for instance, their MPI-Penn State model projects future citizen births under varying scenarios while holding constant observed unauthorized demographics. For broader evaluation, the institute draws on migrant surveys, administrative inflows , and observational metrics to assess border enforcement efficacy, enabling estimates of irregular crossings and impacts without relying solely on government-reported apprehensions, which can undercount successful entries. These approaches are supplemented by qualitative analysis of legislative typologies and compilations in tools like the Migration Data Hub, which aggregates statistics from over 220 governmental and multilateral sources on topics including asylum claims and net migration flows. MPI's methods prioritize empirical rigor through cross-verification of sets—for example, mapping ACS characteristics to smaller surveys for validation—but depend on assumptions about completeness and respondent accuracy in self-reported surveys, potentially introducing undercounts for hidden populations. While positions its work as and evidence-based, critics note that selective emphasis on certain interpretations may align with pro-integration policy preferences, though factual sourcing from primary government records supports the reliability of baseline estimates.

Funding and Financial Transparency

Major Donors and Sources

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) obtains the majority of its funding through competitive research grants from private foundations, with additional support from multilateral organizations, U.S. and foreign government agencies, corporations, and individual philanthropists. This model emphasizes project-specific grants tied to migration research, , and data tools, rather than unrestricted endowments. Prominent foundation donors include the , , John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, , and , many of which prioritize progressive immigration and initiatives. For instance, the awarded MPI $930,442 for general support in December 2023. The also provided funding in 2023, reflecting contributions from high-net-worth individuals via donor-advised funds. Government and institutional funders encompass the U.S. Census Bureau for demographic data projects, the for Latin American migration studies, and various international agencies. Corporate supporters, such as , contribute through partnerships on policy consulting and analytics. MPI maintains that its diverse funding base supports analysis, though the predominance of left-leaning foundations has drawn scrutiny from conservative observers regarding potential agenda alignment. Detailed donor disclosures appear in MPI's IRS filings, available via public databases, but individual grant amounts beyond major awards are often aggregated for privacy. The Migration Policy Institute (MPI), as a 501(c)(3) , reports its financials annually via IRS filings, revealing a pattern of aligned with expanded and activities. Total increased from $4.13 million in fiscal year 2014 to $7.02 million in fiscal year 2023 and $8.59 million in fiscal year 2024 (ending June 2024). Expenses followed a similar upward trajectory, reaching $7.09 million in fiscal year 2024, yielding a of approximately $1.5 million for that year. This reflects broader trends in funding, where contributions—primarily from foundations and philanthropists—constituted 93.6% of in recent years, with program service and investments forming smaller shares.
Fiscal Year EndingTotal RevenueTotal Expenses
June 2014$4.13 millionNot specified in available filings
June 2017$7.71 million$6.00 million
June 2023$7.02 millionNot specified in available filings
June 2024$8.59 million$7.09 million
Net assets have accumulated steadily, standing at $12.2 million as of 2024, against liabilities of $6.0 million, indicating financial stability without reliance on debt for core operations. assigns MPI a perfect score for financial health and sustainability based on these metrics, highlighting efficient resource use with administrative costs below 20% of expenses in audited periods. The absence of significant deficits or volatility suggests donor confidence in MPI's framing, though growth correlates with heightened global debates post-2015, potentially amplifying grant inflows from international and philanthropic sources.

Potential Influences on Research

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) relies heavily on grants from private foundations for its research funding, with major donors including the , , , John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, and . These organizations have collectively provided millions in support; for instance, awarded $920,000 in 2021, $1.26 million in 2019, and $1.5 million in 2017, often for projects on integration and policy analysis. Similarly, the has issued 15 grants to MPI since 2006, focusing on labor market impacts of and related initiatives. The has contributed over $3 million since MPI's inception. These funders are characterized by philanthropic priorities emphasizing , , and expansive approaches to , which align with ideologies favoring increased and resettlement. Reliance on such sources—without a significant endowment or diversified conservative-leaning support—may incentivize MPI to prioritize research topics and methodologies that resonate with grantors' agendas, such as highlighting successes or economic benefits of , while underemphasizing fiscal costs, challenges, or enforcement needs. For example, grants have supported convenings on "pragmatic policy solutions" amid demographic shifts, potentially steering outputs toward accommodationist frameworks rather than restrictive alternatives. Government funding from U.S. and agencies adds another layer, comprising a portion of MPI's alongside foundations and corporations, but specifics on influences remain opaque in public disclosures. This mix could foster alignment with prevailing policy bureaucracies, which often promote managed over stringent controls, raising questions about in empirical analysis. Critics from restrictionist viewpoints contend that such dependencies contribute to systemic biases in , where outputs systematically downplay adverse impacts to sustain funding streams. MPI asserts its independence, but the pattern of donor selection—favoring institutions with track records in pro-immigration —suggests causal pressures toward ideologically congruent findings, as evidenced by the of MPI work critiquing high-volume inflows or advocating pauses.

Policy Influence and Engagements

Impact on U.S. Immigration Policy

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) exerts influence on U.S. immigration policy through its U.S. Immigration Policy Program, which produces analyses of demographic trends, enforcement outcomes, and reform proposals to inform lawmakers and executive agencies. Established as a nonpartisan think tank, MPI emphasizes evidence-based recommendations for modernizing legal pathways, enhancing integration, and addressing unauthorized migration, often highlighting economic contributions of immigrants and inefficiencies in restrictionist approaches. Its data tools, such as estimates of the unauthorized population, have been utilized in policy debates to quantify flows and origins, with recent analyses pegging the U.S. unauthorized immigrant population at approximately 11 million as of mid-2022. MPI experts frequently testify before , providing technical input that shapes legislative discussions. For example, Doris Meissner, director of MPI's U.S. Policy Program and former commissioner (1993–2001), has delivered to the Committee's Subcommittee on and the National Interest on topics including border management and reforms. Similarly, senior fellow Muzaffar Chishti has testified extensively before congressional committees since the early , addressing issues like employment-based s and enforcement priorities, with his insights cited in hearings on comprehensive reform efforts in 2006, 2007, and 2013. These appearances contribute to the evidentiary record for bills, though direct adoption of MPI-specific proposals remains indirect, often filtered through broader bipartisan negotiations. MPI's research has documented and critiqued major policy shifts, such as the administration's more than 500 immigration-related actions between 2017 and 2021, which included expanded interior enforcement and asylum restrictions; this tracking influenced subsequent Biden-era reversals and reform advocacy. Reports like the 2016 retrospective on the underscore gaps in temporary worker programs and family-based admissions, informing calls for recalibration in later proposals, while analyses of historical laws, such as the 1924 quota system, provide context for ongoing debates on numerical limits. Overall, MPI's output bolsters arguments for systemic overhaul favoring skilled migration and legalization pathways, impacting policy discourse by supplying policymakers with granular data amid polarized enforcement versus expansion tensions.

International Policy Contributions

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) extends its research beyond U.S. borders through its International Program, which develops solutions for global migration challenges, including irregular flows, strategies, and linkages. Established as a core pillar of MPI's work, the program conducts comparative analyses of migration systems in regions such as , , and , emphasizing politically feasible reforms informed by data from sources like the and national statistics. In 2011, MPI launched Migration Policy Institute Europe (MPI Europe) in to address () migration dynamics, producing over 100 reports and policy briefs by 2024 on topics including processing, labor mobility, and returns. MPI Europe's contributions include evaluations of the 's 2015-2016 migration crisis response, such as the 2017 report "After the Storm," which critiqued fragmented national approaches and advocated for coordinated burden-sharing mechanisms across member states, influencing discussions on the 's Pact on Migration and . The institute has also analyzed post-Brexit UK- cooperation, proposing frameworks for legal pathways and readmission agreements to manage crossings, as detailed in a 2021 explainer. MPI collaborates with international bodies on capacity-building, including the Athens Migration Policy Initiative (AMPI), launched in partnership with Greek authorities and the (IOM) to tackle Mediterranean routes, focusing on data-driven border management and smuggling disruptions since the early 2000s. Through its Migrants, Migration, and Development Program, MPI has shaped discourse on diaspora remittances and engagement policies, as in a 2013 report recommending destination-country incentives for origin-state investments, cited in and IOM strategies. Globally, MPI's Migration Data Hub compiles annual statistics on 281 million international migrants as of 2020, underpinning UN reports and informing bilateral agreements like those under the adopted in 2018. These efforts position MPI as a bridge between research and multilateral forums, though direct causal impacts on enacted policies remain mediated by national governments and organizations like the EU Commission, with MPI's analyses often favoring managed inflows over strict restrictions.

Collaborations and Advisory Roles

The Migration Policy Institute maintains the Transatlantic Council on Migration (TCM), an initiative launched in 2008 that convenes high-level experts, former policymakers, and stakeholders from North America and Europe to deliberate on migration challenges and produce advisory statements with policy recommendations. These statements, issued following plenary meetings, aim to guide decision-making in governments and international bodies, addressing topics such as migration governance, integration, and partnerships for managing flows. MPI collaborates with philanthropic organizations on targeted initiatives, including the Beyond Territorial Asylum Initiative, co-launched with the as a three-year project to reform the humanitarian protection system through an external advisory group of experts. This effort explores alternatives to traditional models and has influenced discussions on pathways, with outputs including reports on labor mobility for displaced persons. Additionally, through the Transatlantic Task Force on Immigration and , MPI has issued recommendations directed at U.S. Congress, Canadian Parliament, institutions, and governments to enhance integration frameworks. Institutionally, MPI extends technical assistance and evidence-based advice to governments, practitioners, and nongovernmental organizations seeking to address and issues, often via customized research, data tools, and policy consultations. Senior fellows such as Doris Meissner, former U.S. Commissioner of the , contribute to advisory engagements with U.S. policymakers, while the institute's reports inform bodies like the UK's Migration Advisory Committee. These roles position MPI as a bridge between research and practical policy application, though the institute emphasizes its independence in such interactions.

Criticisms and Controversies

Allegations of Ideological Bias

Critics have alleged that the Migration Policy Institute (MPI) exhibits a left-leaning ideological in its and recommendations, particularly through for expanded legal pathways for undocumented immigrants and of stricter enforcement measures. rates MPI as Left-Center biased, citing its positions favoring easier processes, humane policies prioritizing , and opposition to restrictive controls as evidence of a orientation on the issue, despite high factual accuracy in sourcing. Restrictionist organizations, such as the , have specifically accused MPI of producing misleading analyses that downplay the effectiveness of immigration enforcement. In January 2013, CIS described an MPI-promoted report on enforcement as offering a "deceptively misleading picture" by understating challenges in border and interior removals. Influence Watch, a project of the conservative , characterizes MPI's output as advocacy-oriented, including pushes for permanent legal residence for millions of undocumented individuals, rather than neutral scholarship. These allegations intensify around MPI's responses to policy shifts, such as its vocal opposition to Trump-era restrictions post-2017, which critics interpret as aligning with agendas over balanced analysis of immigration's fiscal and social costs. While MPI maintains its independence and status, detractors argue that its funding from pro-immigration philanthropies and staffing by former government officials with liberal leanings contribute to selective framing that privileges migrant perspectives.

Responses from Restrictionist Perspectives

Restrictionist organizations, including the , have criticized the Migration Policy Institute (MPI) for issuing reports that present a misleading portrayal of U.S. outcomes, arguing that such analyses obscure the systemic failures in and interior under lax policies. In a January 10, 2013, press release, described an MPI-promoted report as offering a "deceptive assessment" that minimizes the consequences of inadequate while advocating for expansions in immigration pathways. Executive Director Mark Krikorian has similarly faulted MPI for methodological approaches in evaluations that align with pro-immigration advocacy rather than objective scrutiny of policy effectiveness. The (FAIR) has echoed these concerns, contending that MPI's positions effectively endorse selective limited to extreme cases, such as ax murderers, while opposing comprehensive removal of unauthorized immigrants who pose broader fiscal and social burdens. In a May 16, 2014, analysis, FAIR highlighted MPI researcher arguments against prioritizing deportations beyond serious criminals, interpreting this as a deliberate effort to undermine enforcement mechanisms essential for . FAIR further asserts that MPI's advocacy for accelerated migrant processing and acceptance of large-scale and inflows disregards integration challenges, framing such policies as favoring demographic shifts over native-born workers' and cultural . From a restrictionist viewpoint, MPI's outputs consistently prioritize humanitarian and economic arguments for increased while underemphasizing empirical evidence of wage suppression, public service strains, and crime correlations linked to unrestricted inflows, as evidenced by fact-checks of MPI's resettlement data that reveal selective omissions of long-term costs. These critics maintain that MPI's self-description belies a structural alignment with open-borders interests, funded by foundations that support policy liberalization, thereby influencing lawmakers toward expansions rather than merit-based reforms grounded in national capacity limits.

MPI's Rebuttals and Self-Defense

The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) defends its research and policy positions by emphasizing its status as an independent, dedicated to evidence-based analysis of dynamics. Founded in , MPI asserts that its work avoids advocacy for any particular ideological agenda, instead aiming to equip policymakers with authoritative data on immigration's economic, social, and security implications to foster pragmatic reforms. This self-characterization serves as a primary bulwark against accusations of pro-open-borders , with the organization repeatedly highlighting its collaborations with governments and stakeholders from diverse political backgrounds. In addressing critiques from restrictionist perspectives, MPI often responds through publications that dissect policy outcomes with granular data, implicitly challenging oversimplified narratives. For example, a 2017 analysis of the Obama-era record refuted the "deporter in chief" label applied by immigrant-rights groups while also critiquing enforcement-first advocates for undercounting interior removals, presenting instead a fact-based showing over 3 million deportations from 2009 to 2016, predominantly of recent crossers. Similarly, MPI's examinations of resettlement under the Biden administration acknowledge fiscal and integration burdens raised by skeptics but counter with evidence of streamlined processes enabling over 100,000 admissions in 2024—the highest in three decades—while stressing vetting rigor to mitigate security risks. MPI leadership, including President Andrew Selee, reinforces this defense by framing the institute's role as promoting "humane and effective" systems that balance with legal migration channels, as evidenced in commentaries on measures like the U.S.- Safe Third Country Agreement revisions, which MPI credits with reducing irregular crossings without endorsing unrestricted flows. Though MPI has not published dedicated rebuttal pieces targeting specific critics, its methodology—drawing on government statistics, peer-reviewed studies, and longitudinal trends—positions its outputs as corrective to politicized claims, such as those exaggerating unauthorized populations or ignoring enforcement data. This approach aligns with MPI's foundational commitment to over partisan rhetoric, even amid broader debates on funding and influence.

References

  1. [1]
    migrationpolicy.org - About the Migration Policy Institute
    The Migration Policy Institute is an independent, nonpartisan think tank that seeks to improve immigration and integration policies.
  2. [2]
    About MPI | migrationpolicy.org
    The nonpartisan Migration Policy Institute seeks to improve immigration and integration policies through authoritative research and analysis.Missing: bias | Show results with:bias
  3. [3]
    Migration Data Hub | migrationpolicy.org
    These interactive data tools visualize changing patterns and characteristics of the immigrant population over time, at US, state, and sometimes county levels.International Migration Statistics · U.S. Immigration Trends · Unauthorized Immigrant
  4. [4]
    Frequently Requested Statistics on Immigr.. - Migration Policy Institute
    Mar 12, 2025 · Drawing from the most authoritative and current data available, this article offers an overview of present and past U.S. immigration trends ...
  5. [5]
    Migration Policy Institute - InfluenceWatch
    The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) is a think tank that produces research and policy analysis advocating for permanent legal residence for undocumented ...
  6. [6]
    Migration Policy Institute - Bias and Credibility - Media Bias/Fact Check
    In review, the Migration Policy Institute has a left leaning position regarding immigration. They are in favor of easier immigration and more humane policies ...
  7. [7]
    Migration Policy Institute - Bias Rating - AllSides
    On average, those who disagree with our rating think this source has a Center bias. Confidence Level. Confidence is determined by how many reviews have been ...Missing: tank | Show results with:tank
  8. [8]
    Migration Policy Institute | migrationpolicy.org
    The 13.7 million unauthorized immigrants living in the United States as of mid-2023 reflect increasingly diverse origins, socioeconomic and labor market ...About Us · Migration Data Hub · Work at MPI · Intern at MPI
  9. [9]
    Fact Sheets | migrationpolicy.org
    This fact sheet provides an overview of available pathways to the United States for migrants from Mexico, El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras, and data on ...
  10. [10]
    [PDF] MPI: A Decade of Accomplishments - Migration Policy Institute
    OUR HISTORY​​ Founded in late 2001 by Demetrios G. Papademetriou and Kathleen Newland, MPI grew out of the International Migration Policy Program at the Carnegie ...
  11. [11]
    Demetrios Papademetriou, Top Immigration Scholar, Dies at 75
    Feb 26, 2022 · Papademetriou served as president from 2001 to 2014. In 2011, he founded the institute's sister organization, Migration Policy Institute Europe, ...
  12. [12]
    [PDF] Annual Report 2004 - Migration Policy Institute
    most recently by taking the lead in drafting the EU's Common Basic. Principles ...
  13. [13]
    Demetrios G. Papademetriou | migrationpolicy.org
    Demetrios G. Papademetriou, who co-founded MPI and founded MPI Europe, was President Emeritus and a Distinguished Transatlantic Fellow at MPI.
  14. [14]
    Migration Policy Institute - MacArthur Foundation
    The Migration Policy Institute (MPI), founded in 2001, is the nation's leading independent think tank dedicated to analysis of the movement of people ...
  15. [15]
    MPI's 20th Anniversary | migrationpolicy.org
    Since its founding in 2001, the Migration Policy Institute has become a premier, authoritative source for evidence-based research and innovative policy ideas.
  16. [16]
    MPI - Migration Policy Institute
    Feb 21, 2023 · Founded in 2001 by Demetrios G. Papademetriou and Kathleen Newland ... In 2011, MPI established the Brussels-based Migration Policy Institute ...
  17. [17]
    Tributes to MPI President Emeritus Demetrios G. Papademetriou
    He wanted to provide practical and workable ideas that would bring order and fairness to immigration and migration policies. As a result, he was the driving ...Missing: initial | Show results with:initial
  18. [18]
    Kathleen Newland, Co-Founder, Migration Policy Institute
    Kathleen Newland is the Co-Founder of the Migration Policy Institute (MPI), Director of its Migrants, Migration, and Development Program, and leader of its ...<|separator|>
  19. [19]
    Rating for Migration Policy Institute - Charity Navigator
    Rating 4/4 · Review by Charity NavigatorFounded in 2001, the Migration Policy Institute (MPI) is an independent, nonpartisan think tank in Washington, D.C., dedicated to analysis of the movement ...
  20. [20]
    Migration policy institute - On Think Tanks
    Mar 19, 2025 · It aims to meet the rising demand for pragmatic and thoughtful responses to the challenges and opportunities that large-scale migration, whether ...
  21. [21]
    Two Decades after 9/11, National Security.. - Migration Policy Institute
    Sep 22, 2021 · ARTICLE: After the terror attacks of September 11, 2001 the U.S. immigration system was retooled to have a strong national security focus.
  22. [22]
  23. [23]
    A Record-Setting Decade of Immigration: 2000-2010
    Oct 5, 2011 · Nearly 14 million new immigrants (legal and illegal) settled in the country from 2000 to 2010, making it the highest decade of immigration in American history.Missing: Institute | Show results with:Institute
  24. [24]
    [PDF] THE MIGRATION POLICY INSTITUTE AND INTERNATIONAL ...
    It presents a history of the emergence of internal displacement as a major issue for the international community and addresses in detail the major concerns ...
  25. [25]
    Andrew Selee | migrationpolicy.org
    Andrew Selee is President of the Migration Policy Institute (MPI), a global nonpartisan institution that seeks to improve immigration and integration policies.
  26. [26]
    MPI Board of Trustees | migrationpolicy.org
    Roberta S. Jacobson, Chair · Cecilia Malmström, Vice Chair · Malcolm Brown, Treasurer · Lynden Melmed, Secretary · Paul S. Dwyer Jr. · Juan José Gómez-Camacho · Emily ...
  27. [27]
    MPI Board of Trustees Welcomes New Members with Di..
    Jul 10, 2025 · Three new members joined the Migration Policy Institute's Board of Trustees this month: Paul Dwyer, Charles Kamasaki and Elizabeth Espín Stern.Missing: leadership | Show results with:leadership
  28. [28]
    Experts & Staff | migrationpolicy.org
    Andrew Selee. President ; Doris Meissner. Senior Fellow and Director, U.S. Immigration Policy Program ; Margie McHugh. Director, National Center on Immigrant ...Sarah Pierce · Jeanne Batalova · Demetrios G. Papademetriou · Margie McHugh
  29. [29]
    Contact and Directions | migrationpolicy.org
    MPI's offices are located at 1275 K Street NW (between 13th and 12th Street NW). MPI's building will be on the left-hand side of the road. Take the Red Line ...
  30. [30]
    MPI Europe | migrationpolicy.org
    Dec 4, 2024 · The Migration Policy Institute Europe, established in Brussels in 2011, is a nonprofit, independent research institute that aims to provide ...Internships · Staff · Jobs
  31. [31]
    Migration Policy Institute Europe - LobbyFacts
    Address. Head Office. Residence Palace155 Rue de la Loi Brussels 1040. BELGIUM. EU Office. Residence Palace155 Rue de la Loi Brussels 1040. BELGIUM. Website.
  32. [32]
    Program: About Migration Policy Institute Europe | migrationpolicy.org
    Founded in Brussels in 2011, MPI Europe provides authoritative research and practical policy design to governmental and nongovernmental stakeholders who seek ...Missing: Manila New York
  33. [33]
    Global Skills and Talent Initiative | migrationpolicy.org
    MPI's Global Skills and Talent Initiative explores the role immigration can play in addressing current and future workforce needs in rapidly evolving labor ...Missing: reach | Show results with:reach
  34. [34]
    Towards a Global Compact for Migration: A Development Perspective
    This policy brief analyzes the benefits and risks of heightened cooperation between actors in these fields, and identifies areas where joint initiatives may ...
  35. [35]
    Migration Policy Institute | Devex
    Headquartered in Washington, DC, MPI has offices in Manila and New York, with a presence in the United Kingdom. In 2011, MPI established the Brussels-based ...
  36. [36]
    Reimagining Skilled Migration Partnerships to Support Development
    Sep 12, 2018 · This policy brief examines the new model of skill partnerships, as compared to more traditional ones.Missing: reach | Show results with:reach
  37. [37]
    migrationpolicy.org - Work at the Migration Policy Institute
    The Migration Policy Institute is an independent, nonpartisan think tank that seeks to improve immigration and integration policies through authoritative ...
  38. [38]
    Doris Meissner | migrationpolicy.org
    Her work and expertise also include immigration and politics, immigration enforcement, border control, cooperation with other countries, and immigration and ...
  39. [39]
    Margie McHugh | migrationpolicy.org
    Margie McHugh is Director of the Migration Policy Institute's National Center on Immigrant Integration Policy.
  40. [40]
    Jeanne Batalova | migrationpolicy.org
    Her areas of expertise include the impacts of immigrants on society and labor markets; social and economic mobility of first- and second-generation youth and ...
  41. [41]
    Julia Gelatt | migrationpolicy.org
    Julia Gelatt is Associate Director of the US Immigration Policy Program at the Migration Policy Institute. Her work focuses on the legal immigration system.
  42. [42]
    Meghan Benton | migrationpolicy.org
    Meghan Benton is Director of Global Programs at MPI, with responsibility for the strategic direction of the International Program and its flagship Transatlantic ...
  43. [43]
    Research & Initiatives | migrationpolicy.org
    Migrationpolicy.org has programs like U.S. Immigration Policy, initiatives like Migration Data Hub, and projects such as Integration Futures Working Group.Missing: core | Show results with:core
  44. [44]
    Migrants Deported from the United States.. | migrationpolicy.org
    His research areas include international migration in North and Central ... Copyright © 2001-2025 Migration Policy Institute. All rights reserved ...
  45. [45]
    Stopping the Revolving Door: Reception and Reintegration Services ...
    His research areas include international migration in North and Central ... Copyright © 2001-2025 Migration Policy Institute. All rights reserved ...
  46. [46]
    MPI-EUI Project | migrationpolicy.org
    The project was funded by the European Union and directed at the Migration Policy Institute ... Hide Project Research Areas. Employment · Economic Growth and ...
  47. [47]
    Research Publications | migrationpolicy.org
    This policy brief provides an account of how migration patterns and policy responses changed in recent years and the challenges ahead.Page 6 · Page 4 · Page 8Missing: core | Show results with:core
  48. [48]
    About the Migration Information Source | migrationpolicy.org
    A unique online magazine published by the Migration Policy Institute (MPI), the Source offers essential facts, tools, and analysis of the movement of people ...
  49. [49]
    Reports | migrationpolicy.org
    Migration Data Hub · Migration Information Source · Refugee and Forced ... Copyright © 2001-2025 Migration Policy Institute. All rights reserved ...
  50. [50]
    Program: U.S. Immigration Trends | migrationpolicy.org
    Program: These interactive data tools visualize changing patterns and characteristics of the immigrant population over time, at U.S., state, and sometimes ...
  51. [51]
    Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) Data Tools
    The two data tools offered here provide U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) data on active DACA recipients at U.S. and state levels as of December ...
  52. [52]
    Unauthorized Immigrant Population Profiles - Migration Policy Institute
    Use these data tools to learn about populations immediately and potentially eligible for the DACA program (as unveiled in 2012) nationally and for top states ...
  53. [53]
    MPI Methodology for Assigning Legal Status to Noncitizen ...
    MPI's three-stage method starts with estimating the number of unauthorized immigrants by comparing the number of all immigrants in the ACS with a count of ...
  54. [54]
    MPI Issues Latest Estimates of the Size and Origin..
    Jul 11, 2024 · The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) today released its latest estimates of the size of the unauthorized immigrant population in the United States, pegging the ...
  55. [55]
    MPI-Penn State Methodology for Projections of Birthright Citizenship ...
    The MPI-Penn State projections rest on the assumption that unauthorized immigrants will continue to behave as they do now.
  56. [56]
    [PDF] How to Effectively Measure Border Security and Immigration Control
    Jan 18, 2016 · The second methodology uses data points from migrant survey research to estimate inflows. The third methodology uses observational measures, or ...
  57. [57]
  58. [58]
    Funders | migrationpolicy.org
    MPI is funded primarily through research grants from foundations. We also receive funding from organizations, U.S. and international government agencies, ...Missing: annual | Show results with:annual
  59. [59]
    Migration Policy Institute - Annenberg Classroom
    The list of donors includes Booz Allen Hamilton, the Inter-American Development Bank, the Rockefeller Foundation and the U.S. Census Bureau, among many others.Missing: major | Show results with:major
  60. [60]
    Migration Policy Institute - Nonprofit Explorer - ProPublica
    Andrew Selee (Member, Board Of Trustees, & Mpi President), $254,712 ; Delia Pompa (Senior Fellow For Education Policy), $204,966 ; Margaret Mchugh (Director, ...Missing: leadership | Show results with:leadership
  61. [61]
    Migration Policy Institute Archives - Ford Foundation
    Migration Policy Institute has received 15 grants since 2006. Information displayed on this page may not represent the total grantmaking to a recipient.
  62. [62]
    Migration Policy Institute | Carnegie Corporation of New York
    2021, Migration Policy Institute, $920,000 ; 2019, Migration Policy Institute, $1,260,000 ; 2017, Migration Policy Institute, $1,500,000 ; 2015, Migration Policy ...
  63. [63]
    Carnegie Corporation of New York Board Approves 63 Grants ...
    Jun 12, 2025 · Migration Policy Institute (Washington, D.C.) 12-month grant of $500,000 for support of convenings to consider pragmatic policy solutions ...
  64. [64]
    U.S. Immigration Policy Program | Page 91 | migrationpolicy.org
    The U.S. Immigration Policy Program analyzes U.S. policies and their impacts, as well as the complex demographic, economic, political, foreign policy, and other ...
  65. [65]
    Testimony | migrationpolicy.org
    Testimony of Doris Meissner, Director of MPI's U.S. Immigration Policy Program, before the Senate Judiciary Committee's Subcommittee on Immigration and the ...
  66. [66]
    Muzaffar A. Chishti, Senior Fellow, Migration Policy Institute - USCIS
    Jan 14, 2025 · He has testified extensively on immigration policy issues before Congress and is frequently quoted in national and international media. In 1992, ...
  67. [67]
    Comprehensive Immigration Reform | migrationpolicy.org
    Debated in the U.S. Senate in 2006, 2007, and 2013, CIR would touch virtually every facet of the U.S. immigration system. The policies and many effects that ...
  68. [68]
    Immigration Has Been a Defining, Often Co.. | migrationpolicy.org
    Jan 6, 2022 · ARTICLE: As host to more immigrants than any other country, the United States has been shaped and reshaped by immigration over the centuries ...
  69. [69]
    U.S. Immigration Policy under Trump: Dee.. | migrationpolicy.org
    MPI's U.S. Immigration Policy Program analyzes U.S. policies and their impacts, as well as the complex demographic, economic, political, foreign policy, and ...
  70. [70]
    [PDF] The Immigration Act of 1990: Unfinished Business a Quarter-Century ...
    Jul 7, 2016 · The Immigration Act of 1990 was a significant milestone, representing the first major over- haul of the U.S. legal immigration system in a ...
  71. [71]
    A Century Later, Restrictive 1924 U.S. Immigration Law Has ...
    May 15, 2024 · A Brief History of U.S. Immigration Policy from the Colonial Period to the Present Day. ... Migration Policy Institute (MPI). 2013. Major U.S. ...
  72. [72]
    International Program | Page 55 | migrationpolicy.org
    MPI's International Program acts as a policy laboratory for developing innovative, evidence-based, and politically feasible solutions to worldwide migration ...Missing: contributions | Show results with:contributions
  73. [73]
    After the Storm: Learning from the EU Response to the Migration Crisis
    Migration Policy Institute Europe, established in Brussels in 2011, is a nonprofit, independent research institute that aims to provide a better understanding ...Missing: influence | Show results with:influence
  74. [74]
    The Door Opens for a New Chapter in European Cooperation on ...
    Migration Policy Institute Europe, established in Brussels in 2011, is a nonprofit, independent research institute that aims to provide a better understanding ...
  75. [75]
    Destination-Country Policies to Foster Diaspora Engagement in ...
    MPI's Migrants, Migration, and Development Program focuses on the intersection of migration and development policies and trends, moving beyond simple notions ...
  76. [76]
    Top Statistics on Global Migration and Migrants
    Aug 26, 2025 · In particular, this article uses data showcased in the International Migration Statistics section of the Migration Policy Institute's (MPI) ...
  77. [77]
    About the International Program | migrationpolicy.org
    MPI's International Program develops solutions to migration policy challenges, combining research with policy insights, and working in research, dialogue, and ...Missing: collaborations | Show results with:collaborations
  78. [78]
    Transatlantic Council on Migration | migrationpolicy.org
    Mar 28, 2022 · The Transatlantic Council on Migration is a unique deliberative body that examines vital policy issues and informs migration and immigrant ...
  79. [79]
    About the Transatlantic Council on Migration | migrationpolicy.org
    Launched in 2008, the Transatlantic Council is an MPI initiative that was first convened by founding President, Demetrios G. Papademetriou. The Council's ...Missing: initial | Show results with:initial
  80. [80]
    Beyond Territorial Asylum Initiative Advisory Group
    ... Migration Policy Institute. Full Bio >. Media Contact. Michelle Mittelstadt 202-266-1910 mmittelstadt@migrationpolicy.org · Research & Initiatives ...
  81. [81]
    Transatlantic Task Force on Immigration and Integration
    The Transatlantic Task Force on Immigration and Integration addressed its recommendations to European Union institutions and Member State governments, the ...Missing: collaborations | Show results with:collaborations
  82. [82]
    [PDF] Migration Governance in Unsettled Times: How Policymakers Can ...
    Apr 2, 2025 · Meghan Benton is Director of Global Programs at the Migration Policy Institute (MPI), with responsibility for the strategic direction of the ...
  83. [83]
    New Report Offers Deceptive Assessment of Immigration Enforcement
    Jan 10, 2013 · A new report being promoted by the MPI paints a deliberately misleading picture of the state of immigration law enforcement.Missing: criticism | Show results with:criticism
  84. [84]
    Migration Policy Institute (MPI) - Center for Immigration Studies
    The Center for Immigration Studies is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit research organization founded in 1985. It is the nation's only think tank devoted ...
  85. [85]
    Migration Policy Institute's Deportation Policy: Ax Murderers Only ...
    Migration Policy Institute's Deportation Policy: Ax Murderers Only? May 16, 2014 ... Migration Policy Institute (MPI), who “argues that understanding the ...
  86. [86]
    Immigration Enthusiasts: Forget Integration, We Need Disintegration
    Jan 16, 2020 · It stands to reason that a group called the Migration Policy Institute (MPI) would favor mass movements of refugees, asylum seekers and all ...
  87. [87]
    Migrant Lobby's Need for Speed Poses Problems for U.S.
    Dec 7, 2023 · “Antiquated U.S. Immigration System Ambles into the Digital World,” a recent essay from the Migration Policy Institute, summed up the ...
  88. [88]
    Fact-Checking a Fact Sheet on Refugee Resettlement
    Nov 5, 2015 · The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) released a fact sheet in which it covers key questions relating to the refugee resettlement program in ...<|separator|>
  89. [89]
    The Obama Record on Deportations: Deporter in Chief or Not?
    Jan 26, 2017 · Barack Obama was famously labeled “deporter in chief” by critics in the immigrant-rights community, even as enforcement-first advocates ...
  90. [90]
    How the Rebuilt U.S. System Resettled the Most Refugees in 30 Years
    Oct 30, 2024 · From FY 2017 to May 2020, 134 affiliate offices around the United States closed due to this restriction or because of insufficient funding, ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  91. [91]
    Migration Information Source - U.S. Policy Beat Articles
    The Migration Information Source provides fresh thought, authoritative data, and global analysis of international migration and refugee trends.<|separator|>
  92. [92]
    Donate Now - Support Essential Research & Pragmati..
    Since MPI's founding in 2001 as an independent, nonpartisan research organization dedicated to the evidence-informed study of international migration, ...