Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Optical comparator

An optical comparator is a precision measurement instrument that employs the principles of optics to project a magnified shadow or silhouette of a manufactured part onto a screen, enabling non-contact inspection and dimensional comparison against reference templates or standards.^[1] Patented in 1925, it facilitates the analysis of features such as lengths, widths, diameters, radii, and angles by aligning the projected image with overlays or crosshairs.^[2] This tool is widely used in quality control to verify part conformance without physical contact, reducing the risk of damage to delicate components.^[3] The core working principle involves placing the part on an adjustable XY stage beneath a light source, which casts a shadow through a telecentric lens system that magnifies the image—typically 5x to 100x—onto a vertical screen measuring 12 to 60 inches diagonally.^[2] In traditional manual models, operators visually compare the silhouette to mylar templates or etched glass overlays, while digital variants integrate cameras, software, and automated edge detection for faster, more repeatable measurements aligned with CAD models.^[3] Despite its longevity since the 1925 patent (U.S. Patent No. 1,703,933), the fundamental design has seen minimal evolution, with advancements primarily in digital enhancements for automation and 3D analysis capabilities.^[1]^[4] Optical comparators excel in applications requiring rapid 2D profiling, such as inspecting gears, threads, and contours in industries like automotive (e.g., seals and valves), aerospace (e.g., flanges and fasteners), and medical devices (e.g., stents and orthopedic screws).^[1] They offer advantages including simultaneous X- and Y-axis measurements and minimal setup time for small batches, but limitations include susceptibility to projection distortions from part height variations and reliance on operator skill in manual setups, which can introduce errors.^[2] In modern manufacturing, they are increasingly supplemented or replaced by vision systems for complex geometries, higher tolerances, and full automation, though they remain cost-effective for straightforward inspections.^[3]

History

Invention

The optical comparator was invented in 1919 by James Hartness, president of the Jones & Lamson Machine Company, in collaboration with engineer and astronomer Russell W. Porter.^[5]^[6] Hartness, a prolific inventor with numerous patents in mechanical engineering, conceived the device as a shadow graph to enable precise, non-contact inspection of machine parts, particularly screw threads and irregular shapes.^[7] Porter, hired by Hartness in late 1919, contributed his expertise in optics to refine the prototype into a practical tool for manufacturing gauging.^[6] This invention addressed the pressing need for accurate quality control in the production of complex machinery during the World War I era, when wartime demands accelerated advancements in precision metrology to ensure interchangeable parts without destructive testing.^[7]^[8] The first commercial model, known as the Hartness Screw-Thread Comparator, was introduced in 1922 by Jones & Lamson, marking the transition from prototype to industrial application.^[9] Initially designed for gauging irregular forms in machined components, it utilized a simple optical projection system to magnify and compare part profiles against templates, revolutionizing non-contact measurement in factories.^[5] This model quickly gained traction for its ability to inspect threads and contours at magnifications up to 50x, reducing reliance on manual micrometers and calipers.^[8] In 1925, Hartness filed U.S. Patent 1,703,933, which detailed the core optical projection setup, including the light source, lenses, and screen for shadow imaging of workpieces.^[4] The patent, issued in 1929 and co-credited to Porter, formalized the device's mechanism for detecting deviations in screw-threaded elements and other profiles, emphasizing its role in standardizing measurements for mass production.^[4] This legal protection solidified the optical comparator's foundation, paving the way for its broader adoption in precision engineering.

Development and Adoption

Following the initial invention of the optical comparator in the early 1920s by James Hartness and Russell W. Porter, significant refinements occurred in the 1930s and 1940s, driven by industrial and military needs. Companies such as Eastman Kodak advanced the technology, enhancing precision optics and projection capabilities to support complex manufacturing inspections.^[8] These improvements were particularly crucial for wartime production, where optical comparators were extensively used in fabricating components for the Norden bombsight, a key analog bombing device employed by Allied forces during World War II.^[10] After World War II, optical comparators saw widespread standardization and mass production in the 1950s, transitioning from specialized military tools to accessible benchtop models for routine quality control. This shift facilitated their integration into high-precision industries like automotive and aerospace, where they enabled efficient inspection of gears, threads, and machined parts to meet tightening tolerances.^[11] By the mid-1950s, innovations such as electronic edge detection systems, exemplified by the 1956 Projectron™ from Optical Gaging Products (OGP), further improved measurement accuracy and operator efficiency without altering the core optical design.^[10] Key milestones in the 1960s included the standardization of vertical and horizontal configurations, which expanded applicability for diverse part geometries—vertical for flat or small workpieces and horizontal for elongated components.^[12] Optical comparators also gained formal recognition in metrology standards, with calibration and usage aligned to ASME B89 series guidelines for dimensional inspection tools.^[13] Globally, adaptations emerged in the 1930s through European optical firms developing similar profile projectors for precision engineering, while in Japan, manufacturing integration accelerated in the 1950s following early prototypes like Nippon Kogaku's 1939 projection inspection machine, supporting postwar industrial growth.^[14]

Operating Principle

Basic Mechanism

An optical comparator operates by employing collimated light to generate a silhouette, or shadow profile, of a workpiece, which is subsequently magnified and projected onto a screen for comparative analysis against standardized templates or charts. The core process begins with a high-intensity light source directing parallel rays—achieved through a telecentric optical system—either through the transparent or translucent areas of the workpiece or reflecting off its surface. The edges of the workpiece occlude the light, forming a sharp contour outline that represents the object's profile without physical contact. This non-contact approach relies on edge detection via light occlusion, making it ideal for inspecting delicate, soft, or easily deformable materials that could be distorted by traditional probing methods.^[15]^[16] The underlying principle draws from shadowgraphy in geometric optics, where parallel light rays create an inverted, enlarged image of the object's silhouette, with the projected size determined by the fixed magnification of the optical system, remaining constant regardless of the separation between the workpiece and the projection screen due to the telecentric design.^[17] In this setup, the objective lens captures the shadow and projects it onto the screen, ensuring the image remains sharp and undistorted across the field of view. Magnification is a fixed attribute of the optical system, typically ranging from 5× to 100×, which allows for the visualization and measurement of minute features down to fractions of a millimeter. This magnification enables operators to overlay the projected profile with reference charts, grids, or digital overlays for direct visual comparison.^[18]^[15] This mechanism ensures high contrast at the edges due to the binary nature of light passage or blockage, facilitating accurate contour tracing without interference from surface textures or colors. By maintaining parallel illumination, variations in workpiece position along the optical axis have minimal impact on image fidelity, preserving measurement reliability in industrial settings.^[16]

Optical Projection

In optical comparators, the projection process begins with the formation of a silhouette from the workpiece, which is then magnified and displayed on a screen through a precisely engineered light path. A light source, such as an LED or halogen lamp, emits illumination that is collimated into parallel rays by a condenser lens, ensuring uniform lighting across the field of view. These rays pass through the workpiece positioned on the stage, creating a shadow profile or silhouette. The objective lens then captures this silhouette, inverting and magnifying it while focusing the image; mirrors or prisms subsequently direct the beam to the projection screen, where it forms a visible, enlarged shadowgraph for inspection.^[17]^[19]^[20] The projected image is typically inverted—appearing upside down and reversed left-to-right—due to the optics of the objective lens and mirrors, which necessitates the use of overlay charts or templates prepared in the same orientation to facilitate accurate comparisons. This inversion arises from the reversed optical path in standard configurations, though some advanced systems incorporate additional mirrors or relay lenses to produce an erect image that aligns vertically with the workpiece while retaining horizontal reversal. Horizontal projection systems, where light travels parallel to the stage before reflection, are common for versatile part handling, while vertical paths direct light upward through a glass stage for flat specimens.^[19]^[20]^[21] Telecentric optics play a critical role in projection types, particularly for contour measurements, by positioning the aperture at the focal point to produce parallel principal rays, thereby eliminating perspective distortion and ensuring edge measurements remain accurate regardless of slight focus variations or object depth. This setup maintains consistent magnification across the field of view, determined by the lens focal length; for instance, a 16-inch screen with 10x magnification accommodates parts up to approximately 1.6 inches in diameter. In surface illumination modes, coaxial or oblique lighting via half-reflecting mirrors enhances visibility of features, complementing the primary transmitted light path.^[15]^[17]^[22] To minimize optical aberrations in high-magnification setups, such as 20x or greater, achromatic lenses are employed within the objective system, combining elements of different glass types to correct chromatic and spherical distortions, resulting in sharper, color-fringe-free images with magnification accuracies as low as ±0.1% for contours. Telecentric designs further reduce barrel or pincushion distortion at the edges, preserving geometric fidelity essential for precise metrology. These corrections ensure the projected silhouette faithfully represents the workpiece without warping, supporting reliable inspections in industrial applications.^[17]^[23]^[21]

Components

Light Source and Projection System

The light source in an optical comparator provides the high-intensity illumination necessary to generate a sharp silhouette of the workpiece for projection. Traditionally, mercury vapor arc lamps have been employed for their ability to produce intense white light with high radiance, typically operating at 100 watts for optimal performance in precision metrology applications.^[24] These lamps excel in delivering uniform illumination but require careful handling due to their high operating temperatures and shorter lifespan compared to newer alternatives.^[20] In contemporary designs, halogen lamps or light-emitting diodes (LEDs) have largely replaced mercury vapor sources, offering greater stability, reduced heat output, and extended operational life. Halogen lamps provide consistent brightness with electronic dimming capabilities, while LEDs achieve lifespans of up to 50,000 hours under normal conditions, minimizing maintenance and downtime in industrial settings.^[25] Power requirements vary: halogen lamps typically 100-250 watts, while LEDs consume 20-100 watts or less, depending on the system size and illumination needs, with integrated cooling fans essential to dissipate heat and prevent thermal distortion in the optical components.^[26] The projection system begins with the condenser lens, which collects divergent rays from the light source and converts them into a parallel beam to evenly illuminate the object on the workstage. These condensers are constructed from multi-element glass assemblies with anti-reflective coatings to maximize light transmission and reduce flare, ensuring high-contrast images.^[27] Focal lengths for condenser and objective lenses typically vary from 50 mm to 200 mm, enabling adaptability across different magnification levels without compromising resolution.^[28] The objective lens, positioned after the workstage, captures and magnifies the shadowed profile of the workpiece, forming an inverted real image that maintains geometric fidelity.^[29] Projection optics route the magnified image toward the viewing area using prisms or mirrors to adjust the beam path efficiently. A common configuration employs a 45-degree mirror to redirect the vertical light path horizontally, facilitating compact benchtop designs while preserving image clarity.^[29] Alignment mechanisms, such as adjustable mounts and fine-focus controls, allow precise calibration to eliminate aberrations and ensure the light path remains coaxial throughout operation. This setup contributes to the overall optical projection by directing the collimated, magnified beam without introducing distortion.^[27]

Screen and Viewing

The screen in an optical comparator serves as the projection surface where the magnified silhouette of the workpiece is displayed for observation and measurement. It is typically constructed from ground glass or frosted glass to provide a diffuse, high-contrast image that scatters the projected light evenly, ensuring clarity without hotspots.^[30]^[31] Some models, particularly more affordable or portable variants, utilize translucent plastic screens for similar diffusion properties and lighter weight.^[32] These screens commonly range from 12 to 30 inches in diameter, with popular sizes including 14-inch and 16-inch options, allowing for sufficient viewing area while maintaining compactness.^[33]^[34] They are mounted vertically or at a slight angle, often at 90 degrees relative to the operator's line of sight, to facilitate comfortable overhead or direct viewing without straining the neck.^[35]^[36] Viewing aids integrated into the screen enhance measurement precision by providing reference scales directly on the projection surface. Built-in protractor scales, graduated from 0 to 360 degrees with vernier markings for 1-minute resolution, encircle the screen and rotate fully to align with the projected image for angular assessments.^[37] Linear rulers or etched scales, including cross-hairs and calibration reticles at 90-degree intervals, are also inscribed on the screen to enable direct linear measurements and alignment of overlay charts.^[30]^[38] Optional digital readouts, often coupled with encoders on the screen ring, provide precise angle measurements to 0.01 degrees, supplementing manual scales for higher accuracy in automated or CNC-equipped models.^[33] Illumination integration supports effective chart usage and image quality on the screen. Backlighting is provided through clips and holders for transparent overlay charts, allowing tolerances and dimensions to be superimposed on the projected profile for comparative inspection.^[39] Anti-glare coatings or protective glass layers are applied to the screen surface to minimize reflections from ambient light, thereby reducing parallax errors caused by off-axis viewing and improving contrast for accurate edge detection.^[40]^[41] The resolution achievable on the screen depends on its clarity and the system's magnification, typically enabling effective measurements to 0.001 inches at 10x magnification, as the ground glass diffusion maintains sharp edges without distortion.^[33]^[42] This level of detail supports precise silhouette comparisons, though it varies with screen quality and lighting uniformity.^[43]

Workstage and Fixtures

The workstage in an optical comparator serves as the precision platform for positioning and manipulating the workpiece during inspection, typically featuring a robust metal construction with a hard-anodized tooling plate for durability and smooth operation. Common designs include a rectangular table surface, such as 16 inches by 6 inches (407 mm by 153 mm), providing X-Y axis travel ranges of 8 inches by 4 inches (203 mm by 102 mm) or larger to accommodate precise alignment. These stages are often equipped with linear glass scales or encoders driven by micrometers, achieving resolutions as fine as 0.00005 inches (0.001 mm) for accurate positioning along the X and Y axes.^[44]^[45] Fixtures are essential for securely holding workpieces on the stage, with common types including V-blocks for cylindrical parts, staging centers for lathe-turned components, and rotary vises or tables for rotational inspection. V-blocks, often hardened and ground steel with 90-degree angles, can accommodate diameters from 0.5 inches to 3 inches (12 mm to 75 mm), while staging centers with carbide tips handle parts up to 5 inches (125 mm) in diameter and feature spring-loaded mechanisms for easy loading. Quick-release clamps and modular systems, such as magnetic V-blocks or rotary chucks, enable secure fixturing of irregular shapes without marring surfaces, often integrating with T-slots on the stage for repeatable setups.^[46]^[47] Movement controls on the workstage allow for fine adjustments, typically via handwheels or handles on the X and Y axes for manual traversal, supplemented by digital encoders in modern systems for readout precision. A dedicated Z-axis focus knob provides vertical adjustment, often with 2 inches (51 mm) of travel, to maintain sharp focus on the workpiece silhouette. These controls ensure minimal backlash and high repeatability, supporting inspections without disturbing the overall projection setup.^[44]^[45] The workstage capacity supports parts ranging from 0.1 inches to 10 inches in size, with load limits typically up to 100 pounds (45 kg) to prevent deflection during measurement, though smaller benchtop models may limit central loading to 15 pounds (7 kg) on glass inserts. This design accommodates a variety of industrial components, from small gears to larger forgings, while maintaining stability for accurate profiling.^[44]^[45]

Usage and Applications

Measurement Procedures

To perform measurements using an optical comparator, the initial setup involves securing the workpiece on the workstage using appropriate fixtures or clamps to ensure stability and precise positioning. The workpiece must be cleaned to remove any contaminants that could distort the projected image. Next, the light source is adjusted for optimal illumination, typically using transmitted light to create a clear silhouette of the part's edges against a contrasting background. A suitable magnification is selected based on the feature size, and the projection lens is focused to produce a sharp image on the screen. Calibration is performed using a certified reference standard, such as a gauge block or glass scale, to verify the system's accuracy before proceeding.^[48]^[49] Once setup is complete, the measurement procedure begins by overlaying a transparent Mylar or glass chart on the screen, which matches the part's nominal dimensions and includes lines for edges, angles, and radii derived from engineering drawings. The workstage is then adjusted in X and Y directions to align the projected silhouette of the workpiece edges with the corresponding lines on the chart. Deviations from nominal dimensions are measured by noting the stage travel distance required for alignment, scaled by the magnification factor, or by directly reading from screen protractors and scales for features like lengths, angles, and radii. For angular measurements, the stage is rotated if a rotary table is available, and the protractor on the screen is used to compare the projected angle against the chart.^[48]^[50] Common techniques include edge tracing, where the operator manually moves the stage to follow the contour of the projected silhouette along the chart lines, allowing for profile inspection and identification of deviations in complex shapes. Go/no-go gauging employs pre-made tolerance templates overlaid on the screen; the part passes if the silhouette fits within the go boundaries and does not exceed the no-go limits without further quantification. For thread pitch measurement, a rotary stage is used to rotate the threaded workpiece while aligning the thread profile with a specialized overlay chart; the pitch is determined by measuring the stage rotation or linear travel corresponding to one full thread turn, scaled appropriately.^[48]^[49] Potential error sources in these procedures primarily stem from operator parallax, which occurs when the viewer's eye is not aligned perpendicular to the screen crosshairs, leading to misalignment readings; this is mitigated by positioning the eye directly in line with the optical axis and using the system's built-in alignment aids. Other factors include environmental vibrations, improper focusing, or stage backlash, but typical system accuracy achieves resolutions of ±0.0005 inches (approximately ±0.013 mm) for most measurements when properly calibrated. Regular verification against standards, such as those outlined in JIS B 7184:1999, ensures reliable results.^[48]^[49]^[50]

Industrial Applications

Optical comparators play a vital role in quality control within the manufacturing sector, particularly in aerospace where they are used to inspect turbine blade profiles, fir trees, disks, slots, and cooling holes to ensure compliance with stringent dimensional tolerances.^[51]^[21] In the automotive industry, these devices facilitate the measurement of gear teeth, stampings, engine components, and seals, enabling rapid verification of part accuracy on production lines.^[1]^[52]^[48] In medical device manufacturing, optical comparators are essential for non-contact inspection of surgical tool edges and implant contours, such as orthopedic screws, knee implants, and stents, to meet precise tolerances that ensure patient safety and device functionality.^[51]^[1]^[21]^[48] For electronics production, optical comparators measure connector pins and circuit board outlines, detecting alignment issues and defects in small components to maintain assembly integrity.^[51]^[21] In tool and die making, these instruments verify punch profiles and die geometries to uphold tight tolerances in tooling production.^[51]^[21]^[53] Additionally, in plastics manufacturing, optical comparators assess dimensions of molded parts and extrusions, ensuring uniformity and adherence to design specifications.^[51]^[19]^[21]

Design Features

Magnification and Screen Size

Optical comparators typically employ fixed magnification lenses ranging from 5× to 100×, with common options including 5×, 10×, 20×, 50×, and 100×, allowing users to select based on the required resolution and field of view.^[54]^[37]^[55] Screen sizes in optical comparators generally range from 10 inches to 50 inches in diameter, with typical models featuring 14-inch to 30-inch screens to balance workspace and image clarity.^[54]^[56]^[19] Larger screens, such as 24-inch to 30-inch diameters, facilitate higher magnification without cropping the image of smaller parts, as they provide a broader projection area that accommodates the expanded silhouette.^[54] The effective field of view is calculated as the screen diameter divided by the magnification factor; for instance, a 16-inch screen with a 10× lens yields a 1.6-inch field of view.^[21]^[54] Magnification selection depends on part dimensions and feature tolerances, with lower magnifications like 5× or 10× suited for larger components, such as 6-inch parts requiring overall profile assessment, while higher levels like 50× or 100× are chosen for fine details, enabling resolution down to 0.00004 inches (0.001 mm).^[54]^[36] For example, a 5× lens on a 30-inch screen allows viewing up to 6 inches of a workpiece, ideal for industrial shafts or housings, whereas 100× is essential for measuring micro-features like 0.001-inch threads.^[54]^[48] Higher magnification amplifies potential distortions from misalignment or optical aberrations, necessitating precise workpiece positioning and calibration to maintain measurement accuracy, as even minor deviations are exaggerated on the screen.^[48]^[20] This trade-off reduces the field of view, limiting the visible area of larger parts and often requiring multiple setups or lens changes.^[54]^[36]

Image Orientation and Projection Types

Optical comparators are available in vertical and horizontal projection configurations, each suited to specific workpiece characteristics and handling requirements. In vertical projection systems, the workpiece is positioned below the projection screen with the optical axis parallel to the screen plane, allowing gravity to stabilize heavier or larger parts on the stage.^[57] This setup excels for flat or flexible components, such as gaskets or electronic parts, where the downward-pointing lens facilitates easy loading and minimizes distortion from part weight.^[1] Horizontal projection, by contrast, orients the optical axis perpendicular to the screen, projecting the image sideways, which is ideal for tall or elongated objects like shafts and cylindrical components that would be unstable or impractical in a vertical arrangement.^[58] Horizontal systems often feature side-access stages for convenient loading of heavy items, such as castings or gears, in industrial settings like aerospace manufacturing.^[57] The projected image in traditional optical comparators is typically inverted vertically and reversed horizontally due to the basic optical path, requiring operators to mentally adjust for accurate measurements.^[59] Corrected optics address this by incorporating one or more mirrors: a single mirror inverts the image vertically to make it erect (right-side up) but keeps it reversed horizontally, while fully corrected systems use additional mirrors or a relay lens to produce a non-inverted, non-reversed (positive) image.^[21] For instance, Mitutoyo profile projectors like the PH-3515F employ optics that yield an erect but horizontally inverted image, with vertical orientation matching the workpiece for straightforward displacement interpretation.^[17] In modern digital optical comparators, image orientation can be further refined through software-based correction, eliminating the need for physical mirrors and allowing real-time flipping or rotation on a digital display.^[60] Accessories such as rotatable screens or stages enhance multi-axis viewing; screens can rotate up to ±370° with digital counters for precise angular measurements, while motorized rotary stages enable automated orientation adjustments.^[17] Edge detectors, often integrated in advanced systems, automate boundary identification and orientation alignment, improving efficiency for complex profiles.^[57] Vertical configurations pair well with these features for inspecting flat parts in precision industries like watchmaking, whereas horizontal setups support them for cylindrical applications such as thread or cam inspection.^[1]

Advantages and Limitations

Benefits

Optical comparators provide non-contact measurement capabilities, making them ideal for inspecting soft, coated, or fragile parts without risking surface damage or deformation.^[61] This approach ensures the integrity of delicate components, such as those in electronics or medical devices, where physical probing could introduce errors or defects.^[62] The visual projection system enables rapid and intuitive full-profile inspections, often reducing setup and measurement time to just minutes compared to more complex methods.^[62] Operators can quickly overlay part silhouettes against templates or digital overlays, facilitating immediate visual assessment of tolerances and features without extensive data processing.^[63] These instruments offer high versatility for evaluating 2D profiles across diverse materials, including metals, plastics, and composites, with accuracies typically around 0.0005 inches (0.013 mm).^[61] Relatively minimal training is required for basic operation due to the straightforward optical interface, though operator experience is key for high-precision inspections.^[62] In terms of cost-effectiveness, optical comparators feature a lower initial investment than coordinate measuring machines (CMMs), while their robust mechanical designs ensure long-term durability and reduced maintenance needs.^[63] This combination makes them a practical choice for small to medium-scale manufacturing operations seeking precise metrology without prohibitive expenses.^[61]

Drawbacks and Modern Alternatives

Traditional optical comparators are limited to two-dimensional (2D) measurements, providing no capability for assessing height, depth, or three-dimensional features, which restricts their use for complex, multiplanar components.^[21] Additionally, measurements are highly operator-dependent, as accuracy depends on the skill in part alignment, edge identification, and interpretation of the projected silhouette, introducing subjective variability.^[21] They are also confined to line-of-sight profiles, unable to inspect obscured or internal geometries without repositioning.^[21] Accuracy can be compromised by parallax errors arising from misalignment between the part and the viewing angle, as well as sensitivity to external vibrations that distort the projected image and reduce measurement repeatability.^[21] Furthermore, these systems perform poorly on transparent materials, where light transmission blurs edges, or highly reflective surfaces, which cause glare and obscure feature definition.^[21] To address these shortcomings, modern digital optical comparators emerged in the 1990s, incorporating charge-coupled device (CCD) cameras to capture video images instead of relying on manual projection, enabling automated edge detection through software algorithms for more objective and repeatable results.^[64] These systems often include 3D capabilities via multi-angle imaging or structured light projection, allowing measurement of surface contours and depths beyond traditional 2D limits.^[21] As of 2025, recent models like Mitutoyo's Quick Vision-X (launched April 2024) and VisionX's Compact 500 Series (July 2025) incorporate advanced software for improved automation and precision.^[65]^[66] Contemporary alternatives include integration of optical comparators with computer numerical control (CNC) stages for automated part movement and data collection, minimizing operator intervention and enhancing throughput in high-volume inspections.^[67] Hybrid systems combining optical imaging with laser scanning further extend precision to sub-micron levels, enabling comprehensive 3D profiling of complex parts while overcoming visibility issues on challenging surfaces.^[68]

References

[1]
What Is an Optical Measurement Device | KEYENCE America
An optical comparator is a measuring instrument that uses a shadowed image to achieve non-contact measuring of parts.Missing: engineering | Show results with:engineering
[2]
All about optical comparators, and why avoid them - Hexagon
The basic concept of the comparator is that a part is affixed to a stage, a light source shines on it, and the resulting shadow image of the part is magnified ...
[3]
What Is A Digital Optical Comparator & How You Use It - VisionX Inc
Oct 21, 2020 · Comparators inspect, measure, and compare the dimensions of manufactured parts. These measurement tools function using the principles of optics ...Missing: engineering | Show results with:engineering
[4]
History - Optical Comparator
The first commercial comparator was a creation of James Hartness and Russell W. Porter in 1919. Mr. Hartness, the holder of many patents on mechanical ...
[5]
Stellafane Early History
This was the home of Russell W. Porter between late 1919, when he was hired by James Hartness to develop the optical comparator into a marketable product, and ...
[6]
Renaissance Tool Man - ASME Digital Collection
During the war, Hartness had advised the Bureau of Standards to use Porters talents on optical-related problems. Hartness recruited Porter back to Springfield ...
[7]
Shedding Light on Optical Comparators - Quality Digest
The optical comparator is invented by James Hartness, president of J&L Machine Co., in 1922. It projects the shadow of an object onto a screen a few feet away ...
[8]
[PDF] The Porter Garden Telescope - Stellafane
Jan 1, 2018 · JONES & LAMSON. MACHINE COMPANY. Springfield, Vermont. Porter obtained two patents for his telescope: - Patent No. 1468973, dated. September 25, ...
[9]
US1703933A - Optical comparator - Google Patents
J. HARTNESS ET'AL OPTI CAL COMPARATOR 3 Sheets-Shet Filed ma 21, 1925 Ewe/$1 6 comparator or thread-gaging Patented Mar. 5, 1929. JAMES EARTNESS Ann RUSSELL w.Missing: 1919 | Show results with:1919<|control11|><|separator|>
[10]
[PDF] ontour Projector Technologies
The optical comparator was invented in 1929 and was further developed by Eastman. Kodak and employed extensively in the production of the Norden bombsight used ...
[11]
Profile Projectors – All you need to know! - Sipcon - Vimmy Tech
The sales were around 300 units per year. 1940 – 1960 : A very strong boost to the sales of optical comparators was provided world war II as Profile Projectors ...
[12]
Optical Comparators Adapt and Grow - SME
Mar 1, 2018 · Optical comparators, sometimes called profile projectors, remain a fundamental tool for metrology even though the basics were invented in the 1920s.
[13]
American National Standards in Dimensional Metrology, ASME B89
The American Society of Mechanical Engineers, ASME, is the developer of American National Standards in dimensional metrology.
[14]
The profile projector: the unsung equipment supporting the precision ...
In 1939, Nippon Kogaku K.K. (now Nikon Corporation) created a prototype “projection inspection machine (the first profile projector)” that could inspect an ...Missing: Europe 1930s
[15]
Optical Comparator (Profile Projector) | KEYENCE America
This telecentric lens on KEYENCE's optical comparator allows you to capture the image of an object at the correct magnification without warping the image.
[16]
Mitutoyo
**Summary of Profile Projectors (Optical Comparators) Operating Principle:**
[17]
50 Years of Quality: The Pros and Cons of Optical Comparators
Jan 1, 2011 · Optical comparators were developed by James Hartness ... Russell Porter, architect, engineer and astronomer who worked closely with Hartness.Missing: 1919 | Show results with:1919
[18]
[PDF] Profile Projector - PH/PJ/PV Series - Mitutoyo
Each Mitutoyo profile projector is a measuring machine that performs measurements, inspections, and observations efficiently.Missing: principle | Show results with:principle
[19]
Optical Comparator - J&L Metrology Optical Comparator, Sales ...
This type of instrument is basically a simple reversed system with the addition of another mirror in the vertical optical plane. The second mirror flips the ...
[20]
Which Optical Comparator Should You Buy? - OGP
These digital systems combine the speed and accuracy of a video measurement system with the rugged capacity of a traditional optical comparator. The telecentric ...
[21]
Types, Applications and Considerations of Optical Comparators
The comparator promptly detects flaws such as defects, scratches, indentations, and dimensional errors by matching the workpiece to its standard specifications.Missing: ASME | Show results with:ASME
[22]
https://www.edmundoptics.com/knowledge-center/application-notes/imaging/advantages-of-telecentricity/
[23]
Why is Telecentricity So Important in Dimensional Metrology? - OGP
Telecentric optics are critically important for high accuracy measurement in today's video-based metrology systems. Find out why!
[24]
Mercury Arc Lamps - ZEISS Microscopy Online Campus
The most popular mercury lamp for optical microscopy is the HBO 100 (a 100-watt high-pressure mercury plasma arc-discharge lamp), which has the highest radiance ...
[25]
[PDF] LED Luminaire Lifetime: Recommendations for Testing and Reporting
LED sources emit light potentially for a very long time, and integrated lamps appear to be capable of at least 25,000 hours of operation. Such fundamental.Missing: comparator | Show results with:comparator
[26]
[PDF] Dorsey Metrology International 53 Oakley Street ... - MSI-Viking
▫ Quartz halogen light source fan cooled and electronically dimmed for long lamp life. ▫ Extra bright through lens surface illumination via LED. ▫ NIST ...
[27]
https://www.sipconinstrument.com/blog/optical-comparator-principle-diagram-types-and-uses/
[28]
24P Optical Comparator | Dorsey Metrology International
200mm. Focal Distance. 100mm. Lens Face Diameter. 68mm. Part Number. LENS-24-50X ... Focal Distance. 51mm. Lens Face Diameter. 50mm. Readouts. M2 display.
[29]
Objective Lenses - Optical Comparator
All J&L METROLOGY optical comparators feature true telecentric optical systems. Some manufacturers claim "telecentric illumination" but you owe it to yourself ...
[30]
16H / 16H CNC Optical Comparator | Dorsey Metrology International
High resolution ground glass screen with calibration reticle, 90 degree cross lines, and chart clips ... Used to mount flat parts on horizontal comparators ...
[31]
QL 20 Contour Projector | QL20 Optical Comparator - OGP
24” diameter ground glass screen, with 20″ viewing area, integral hood, 90 ... Optical Comparator Overlays · Optical Comparator Fixtures. Downloads ...
[32]
Cheap Profile Projectors - Precision and Portability - Alibaba.com
Projection Screen. Cheap profile projectors typically use frosted translucent plastic screens, which diffuse the projected image evenly and make the profile ...
[33]
https://www.mitutoyo.com/products/optical-comparators/
[34]
14HE Optical Comparator | Dorsey Metrology International
14" (350mm) angled high resolution glass screen for optimum viewing with 90 degree cross lines, calibration reticle and chart clips ... Used to mount flat parts ...
[35]
16VS Optical Comparator | Dorsey Metrology International
High resolution ground glass screen with calibration reticle, 90 degree cross lines, and chart clips ... Improves contrast on translucent plastic. Stages. Title.
[36]
None
### Summary of Optical Comparators from Dorsey_Comparators.pdf
[37]
[PDF] I-1 Optical Measuring Profile Projectors Microscopes INDEX - Mitutoyo
An optical system based on the principle that the primary ray is aligned parallel to the optical axis by placing a lens stop on the focal point on the image ...
[38]
Mitutoyo Optical Comparators, Optical Comparator from Component ...
Newly designed optical system with high NA lenses provide drastically brighter and clearer screen images during surface illumination. The three-lens mounting ...
[39]
Optical Comparator Charts | Dorsey Metrology International
Dorsey Metrology uses satin ground glass of superior quality for all our optical comparator glass charts. The charts are very durable and will last for many ...
[40]
How To Protect Any Sized Optical Comparator Glass Screen
How To Protect Any Sized Optical Comparator Glass Screen – A Case Study ... Anti-Glare · Blue Light Cut · Clear · Clear Abrasion Resistant Screen Protectors ...
[41]
https://www.ebay.com/itm/385471566220
[42]
Quality 101: Optical Comparator Basics
Jun 1, 2005 · For a 50X or 100X lens, the projector may need to be covered to eliminate light reflection for a clear view. Under higher magnification, the ...Missing: anti- glare
[43]
32P Optical Comparator | Dorsey Metrology International
Improves contrast on translucent plastic. Address. Dorsey Metrology Int 53 Oakley St Poughkeepsie, NY 12601. United States. Phone. 1-845-454-3111. Fax. 1-845 ...
[44]
[PDF] PH-A14 Profile Projector - Mitutoyo
The PH-A14 has linear glass scales, a bright image, 8"x4" workstage, 14" screen, 100lbs max load, and 10X standard magnification.
[45]
HB400 Horizontal Benchtop Optical Comparator | StarrettMetrology
In stockFeatures · 16" x 6" X-Y travel workstage (400mm x 150mm) · All metal construction with hard-anodized stage tooling plate · Single bayonet-style lens mounting ...
[46]
Optical Comparator Fixtures - OGP
3" v-blocks stage parts from 1/2" to 3" (12 to 75 mm) in diameter. The rotary staging vise provides quick, convenient staging for a variety of parts.
[47]
https://prymefix.com/home/prymefix_offerings/accessories/fixture-kits/comparator-fixture-kit/
[48]
How to Use an Optical Comparator: Working Principle, Accuracy ...
May 20, 2024 · Optical comparators can be used for reverse engineering applications, where they help recreate existing parts without original design ...
[49]
[PDF] Accuracy of Profile Projectors - Mitutoyo
Length accuracy (X & Y axis) impacts any measurements made using the measuring stage along either the X or Y axis. If the measuring stage is moved along both ...
[50]
[PDF] Fundamental Good Practice in Dimensional Metrology
... measurement procedure that described the measurements that were done and ... Optical comparator. An optical device that projects an enlarged shadow of.
[51]
Industries & Applications for Optical Comparators - VisionX Inc
Our systems are used by aerospace manufacturers worldwide to solve a wide range of challenging applications, including the inspection & measurement of: turbine ...
[52]
Optical Comparator - Definition & Examples - CrossCo
In aerospace, they are used to inspect turbine components while in automotive, they have similar uses such as examining seals and ensuring component quality.Missing: benchtop models 1950s
[53]
Optical Comparators: Ultimate Guide To Precision Measurement
Aug 14, 2024 · Optical comparators are essential in industries where precision is paramount, such as aerospace, automotive, and medical device manufacturing.
[54]
Optical Comparators Summary - Dorsey Metrology International
Calculations can be made by dividing the screen diameter by the lens magnification. For example, using a 10X lens on a 16" optical comparator would enable ...
[55]
Single or Multi-mag Optical Configurations - VisionX Inc
VisionGauge® Digital Optical Comparators are available in industry standard 5X, 10X, 20X, 50X and 100X optical configurations, in either single or multi-mag ...
[56]
High Accuracy Digital Optical Comparator - 3D Laser Vision
Rating 4.4 (12) Zoom objective(X), High Percision High Grade Optical Zoom Lens Program Control. Total video magnification(x), Optical Video Magnification:34X-220X(22-Inch ...
[57]
HF750 Horizontal Floor Standing Optical Comparator
In stockThe HF750 super capacity optical comparator delivers benefits from an even larger 30" (762mm) screen, setting a new standard for clarity and brightness.Missing: ground glass translucent protractor anti- glare
[58]
What are optical comparators? - Higher Precision Blog
### Summary of Optical Comparators from Higher Precision Blog
[59]
Advanced Optical Comparator – Profile Projector - Presto Group
Jun 23, 2025 · Optical Comparator, also known as a Profile Projector, is used for precise measurement and inspection of complex geometries in manufactured ...
[60]
Inspecting with Optical Comparators 351 - Tooling U
A type of lens that magnifies an illuminated image onto the optical comparator screen. Projection magnification lenses come in a variety of different ...
[61]
Fully Automated Digital Optical Comparators | VisionGauge®
With manual movement across three axes, the 400 Series is ideal for lower-volume applications that require precision measurements. Features of the 400 Series ...Missing: handwheels encoders
[62]
Achieving Precision with Mitutoyo's Profile Projectors
Profile projectors, also known as optical comparators, are essential tools used for inspecting and measuring the dimensions of various objects. They project an ...
[63]
Optical Measurement: When & Why? | 2015-04-01 | Quality Magazine
Apr 1, 2015 · The number one benefit of optical measurements is speed. Optical approaches can capture a great many high accuracy data points within a single field-of-view, ...
[64]
50 Years of Quality: Optical Comparators Go Digital
May 1, 2011 · Optical comparators are versatile and robust, and provide an easy-to-use and cost-effective measurement solution for many applications and ...
[65]
Digital Vs. Traditional Optical Comparators | VisionGauge®
Sep 18, 2023 · Digital optical comparators are fully automated devices used with intuitive tools, such as the VisionGauge® patented CAD Auto-Pass/Fail™ and CAD ...
[66]
OGP Optical Comparators | Profile Projectors
Benchtop and floor model optical comparators from OGP offer the industry's best value and performance for non-contact measurement. c-vision™ Video Contour ...Missing: 1950s control
[67]
ShapeGrabber Systems on the Forefront of Modern Metrology | OGP
ShapeGrabber Automated 3D Laser Scanners feature a new generation of metrology-class scanheads for high accuracy measurement. Find out more!