Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Ball lightning

Ball lightning is a rare and unexplained atmospheric phenomenon observed during thunderstorms, manifesting as luminous, spherical objects that typically measure 10–30 cm in diameter, exhibit colors such as red, yellow, white, or blue, and persist for durations ranging from 1 second to over a minute.^[1] These glowing orbs often appear in association with lightning strikes, moving horizontally at speeds of a few meters per second, and may vanish silently, explode with a bang, or even penetrate solid barriers like windows without apparent damage.^[1]^[2] Despite centuries of eyewitness reports dating back to at least the 12th century, ball lightning remains poorly understood, with no consensus on its formation mechanism or physical nature, though it is now widely accepted as a genuine phenomenon rather than hallucination or misidentification.^[3]^[4] Historical accounts of ball lightning span global cultures and scientific literature, with early descriptions including a 1195 account by the English monk Gervase of Canterbury describing a fiery globe emerging from a storm cloud near London and falling into the Thames, and a 1638 incident in Widecombe-in-the-Moor, England, where a ball of fire entered a church during a thunderstorm and caused fatalities.^[3] Systematic collections of observations, such as a 1960s NASA study analyzing 112 reports from research personnel, revealed consistent patterns: approximately 87% of balls were spherical, 76% uniformly bright with colors favoring orange or yellow, and median durations around 6 seconds, with motion predominantly horizontal and slower than prevailing winds.^[5] Notable behaviors include indoor penetrations, such as through chimneys or panes, and rare interactions like causing burns or explosions, though large-scale energy releases (e.g., megajoules) are uncommon, suggesting a continuous external energy source rather than stored dissipation.^[5]^[4] Modern documentation has advanced with video evidence, including smartphone captures and synchronized recordings since 2000, confirming erratic or smooth trajectories and luminosities comparable to incandescent lamps or brighter than daylight; limited confirmed videos worldwide, with several additional captures reported in recent years as of 2025, though fewer than two dozen scientifically verified.^[1]^[4]^[6] Scientifically, ball lightning eludes laboratory reproduction and instrumental verification, prompting ongoing calls for citizen reports to correlate sightings with lightning networks and weather data. As of 2025, additional videos from events in Canada and Russia have been analyzed, supporting its reality while new theoretical proposals, such as links to dark matter, continue to emerge.^[4]^[7]^[8] Theoretical models fall into two broad categories: physical explanations involving self-contained plasmas or electromagnetic fields that sustain ionized air, and chemical models positing reactions from lightning-vaporized soil or materials (e.g., silicon or salts) producing glowing aerosols.^[2]^[3] Experimental efforts since 2000, such as generating plasma balls from electrolyte solutions or struck surfaces, have replicated some traits like stability and color but not the full phenomenon, while observations link events to positive cloud-to-ground lightning or specific ground compositions.^[1]^[3] Although not posing widespread hazards, ball lightning's potential insights into plasma physics and atmospheric electricity continue to drive research, with no unified theory yet established.^[1]^[5]

Characteristics

Physical properties

Ball lightning is typically described in eyewitness reports as having a spherical shape with diameters ranging from pea-sized (about 1 cm) to several meters, though the majority of accounts indicate sizes under 50 cm. A comprehensive analysis of over 5,000 reports shows a log-normal distribution for diameters, with a median of approximately 35 cm and 84% of cases below 90 cm. Common sizes fall between 10 and 30 cm based on aggregated observational data. The duration of ball lightning varies widely, from less than 1 second to over a minute, with most events lasting seconds and rare instances extending longer. In a large-scale compilation, the median duration is about 6 seconds, with the majority under 5 seconds and only 5-12% exceeding 30 seconds. Some instrumental observations report lifetimes up to 50 seconds for objects around 20 cm in diameter. Luminosity in ball lightning is often compared to that of a 40-watt incandescent bulb, corresponding to an optical power output of roughly 10-100 watts, sufficient to be visible in daylight but not blinding. Eyewitness accounts frequently describe brightness levels that illuminate surroundings moderately, with periodic variations in intensity observed in spectroscopic records. Colors range from white and yellow (most common) to orange, red, and blue, with red-orange-yellow hues reported in about 60% of cases and white in 25%. Energy estimates derived from light emission suggest 10-100 joules for typical events, calculated from luminosity and duration. However, some reports of explosive terminations imply higher total energies, up to megajoules (10^6 J), though most cases involve negligible thermal effects. For a 20 cm diameter ball, electrochemical models estimate around 100 kJ based on fuel content and efficiency. Temperature assessments from visual glow indicate surface temperatures of 500-3000 K, consistent with the observed luminescence without intense heat radiation. Spectroscopic analyses of rare natural events yield higher values, with continuous spectra suggesting about 2700 K and atomic lines ranging from 4300-8750 K, reflecting heterogeneous internal conditions influenced by atmospheric and soil elements.

Appearance and motion

Ball lightning typically manifests as luminous, spherical orbs, though oval or irregular shapes have been reported in some observations. These orbs appear uniformly bright in the majority of cases, with about 76% exhibiting even illumination, while others display internal flickering or rotational motion suggesting structure. Common colors include orange, yellow, blue, or white, often resembling the glow of an incandescent bulb.^[5]^[9]^[10] The motion of ball lightning is generally slow and deliberate, with velocities ranging from 1 to 10 m/s, averaging around 3 m/s in many accounts. It often travels horizontally, parallel to the ground at heights of about 1 m, though vertical movements or stationary hovering occur. Paths are predominantly smooth but can become erratic, with sudden direction changes or jumps, sometimes proceeding counter to prevailing winds or showing minimal influence from air currents. Ball lightning has been observed entering structures through closed windows or walls without causing damage, emerging intact on the other side, and occasionally bouncing off surfaces before continuing.^[5]^[9]^[11]^[2]^[12] Interactions with the environment include expansion or contraction in size during transit, followed by dissipation that may be silent, explosive with a bang, or accompanied by a release of heat. Upon termination, ball lightning often leaves traces such as burns on nearby materials, an ozone or nitrogen dioxide smell from localized ionization, and visible smoky trails from temporary air ionization. It can also induce electromagnetic interference, disrupting radios, televisions, or causing compasses to deflect, due to associated low-frequency fields.^[9]^[12]^[10]

Historical Accounts

Early medieval reports

One of the earliest documented accounts of a luminous orb resembling ball lightning comes from the Chronicle of Gervase of Canterbury, a Benedictine monk writing around 1200. On June 7, 1195, during a severe storm near London, Gervase described a dense, dark cloud from which a white substance emerged, forming a spinning spherical fireball about the size of a blacksmith's anvil that descended toward the River Thames. The orb then moved horizontally along the river before exploding with a thunderous noise likened to a chariot on pavement, scattering fiery embers without causing reported injuries or fires. Another prominent early modern report occurred during the Great Thunderstorm of Widecombe-in-the-Moor, Devon, on October 21, 1638. As parishioners attended afternoon service in St. Pancras Church amid violent lightning and hail, a large fireball reportedly entered through a window, hovered briefly near the pulpit, and split into two smaller orbs. One exited through the same window, while the other exploded violently, killing four people—including George Ley, whose body was found charred with a melted groat coin in his hand—and injuring many others, while damaging the church roof and pews. Earlier references to similar glowing orbs or fireballs appear in ancient folklore and biblical texts, such as descriptions of fiery phenomena during storms in Exodus 9:23-24, where hail mingled with fire fell during the seventh plague on Egypt, interpreted in historical contexts as possible luminous manifestations akin to ball lightning without contemporary scientific explanation. Other ancient accounts, including Roman historian Livy's mention of fiery globes during thunderstorms in the 1st century BCE, echo these motifs in pre-medieval lore. These early medieval reports share common themes, including close association with intense thunderstorms, sudden indoor intrusions into buildings like churches or cathedrals, and dramatic, sometimes fatal explosions that left charred remains or scattered debris. Such accounts often framed the events as divine signs or portents, reflecting the era's blend of awe and fear toward unexplained atmospheric displays.

18th and 19th century incidents

During the 18th and 19th centuries, reports of ball lightning began to shift from folklore toward more systematic documentation, reflecting the Enlightenment's growing scientific curiosity about atmospheric electricity. Eyewitness accounts from this era often came from naval personnel, scientists, and civilians during thunderstorms, providing some of the earliest detailed descriptions of luminous orbs associated with lightning strikes. These incidents highlighted the phenomenon's potential dangers, including fatalities and structural damage, while sparking debates among natural philosophers about its nature as a distinct electrical form rather than mere optical illusion. One of the most tragic early scientific encounters occurred on August 6, 1753, in St. Petersburg, where Baltic German physicist Georg Wilhelm Richmann was killed during an experiment on atmospheric electricity inspired by Benjamin Franklin's work. Richmann, a member of the St. Petersburg Academy of Sciences, was using an ungrounded iron rod to measure electrical charges when a luminous orb—described in contemporary accounts as a blue "ball of fire"—struck him in the head, causing electrocution and leaving burn marks on his body and clothing. An autopsy confirmed the lightning origin, but popular engravings later depicted the event as a classic ball lightning strike, influencing public perceptions of its lethality.^[13]^[14] Naval logs and newspapers captured several maritime incidents, underscoring ball lightning's occurrence at sea amid storms. In August 1726, the British sloop Catherine and Mary, navigating the Gulf of Florida, encountered a large orb of fire during a thunderstorm; the sphere struck the main mast, splintering it into fragments, killing one crew member instantly and severely injuring another. The explosion left a sulfurous odor lingering for hours, causing widespread panic among the survivors as the ship limped to port.^[15] A similarly destructive event befell the HMS Warren Hastings on February 19, 1809, while anchored off Portsmouth. Three fireballs descended from a sudden storm cloud, striking the main mast and deck, killing two sailors and injuring others; the orbs also ignited parts of the rigging, requiring crew intervention to extinguish the fires. This account, reported in contemporary naval dispatches, emphasized the orbs' ability to cause explosive harm without prior thunder.^[16] By the mid-19th century, compilations of such reports emerged to catalog patterns. In his 1864 A Guide to the Scientific Knowledge of Things Familiar, British scholar Ebenezer Cobham Brewer aggregated sailor and civilian testimonies, describing "globular lightning" as flashes assuming a spherical form that could descend like thunderbolts, sometimes exploding on impact and leaving a sulfurous scent—drawing from dozens of storm-related orbs observed in homes and vessels across Europe and America. Brewer's work synthesized these into a conceptual framework, noting their frequent association with metals and enclosed areas.^[17] French science writer Wilfrid de Fonvielle further advanced documentation in his 1875 book Thunder and Lightning, compiling approximately 150 French accounts of orbs near lightning strikes, often bluish or reddish spheres 10–20 cm in diameter that rolled along surfaces, entered buildings via chimneys, or followed wires before detonating. These reports, sourced from eyewitnesses in rural and urban settings, portrayed the phenomenon as particularly drawn to conductive materials during thunderstorms, with some orbs enveloping people harmlessly while others caused burns or explosions, as in a 1852 Paris incident where a cat-like fireball burst through a tailor's chimney. Fonvielle's analysis underscored the era's emerging interest in ball lightning as a verifiable electrical anomaly.^[18]

20th century eyewitness accounts

A well-documented aviation-related sighting occurred on March 19, 1963, when electronics professor R.C. Jennison observed a glowing sphere about 20 cm in diameter inside an Eastern Airlines passenger aircraft during a thunderstorm en route from New York to Washington. The orb emerged from the pilot's cabin, traveled steadily down the aisle at waist height approximately 50 cm from Jennison, and passed through the length of the passenger compartment without audible sound or heat, coinciding with the plane being enveloped in a bright electrical discharge. Although Jennison later theorized electromagnetic aspects, the immediate report highlighted the object's self-contained luminosity and non-interaction with surroundings.^[19] Aggregated reports from the mid-20th century include sightings by pilots during storms, as well as accounts from farmers and rural observers, like a 1950s incident in the English countryside where a glowing orb hovered over a field, illuminating livestock without harm, as reported in meteorological surveys. Scientists, including physicists, documented similar events, but increased skepticism prevailed due to the lack of instrumental verification, leading many to question reliability amid potential optical illusions or misidentifications.^[20]^[13]^[21]

Modern Observations

Video and photographic evidence

In 2012, researchers in China accidentally captured the first scientifically documented video of presumed ball lightning using high-speed cameras and spectrographs during a thunderstorm observation near the Qinghai Plateau. The footage shows a luminous orb approximately 5 meters in diameter emerging from a cloud-to-ground lightning strike, lasting 1.64 seconds, and exhibiting smooth horizontal motion at about 7.6 meters per second with a glowing white-to-yellow hue that changes intensity.^[22] Analysis of the video confirmed the orb's trajectory and luminescence were inconsistent with common artifacts, supporting its classification as natural ball lightning.^[23] Since the 2010s, numerous amateur videos of potential ball lightning have surfaced online, typically recorded during thunderstorms and depicting spherical orbs hovering or moving slowly near the ground. These footages often show orbs ranging from golf ball-sized to larger, with erratic paths and durations of a few seconds, captured by smartphones in locations like the United States and Europe.^[24] Common patterns include the orbs appearing close to power lines or structures, maintaining a steady glow before dissipating abruptly, though most lack the controlled analysis of the 2012 event.^[25] In July 2025, an amateur couple in Alberta, Canada, recorded a 23-second video during a severe thunderstorm, showing a blue-white orb approximately 1-2 meters across moving laterally across a field at low altitude before vanishing with a reported popping sound. The footage, captured from their porch, depicts the orb oscillating slightly and avoiding direct lightning paths, prompting initial expert review by meteorologists who noted its resemblance to historical descriptions but emphasized ongoing verification to rule out prosaic explanations.^[26]^[27] Authenticating video evidence of ball lightning remains challenging due to frequent misidentifications with optical artifacts like lens flares from nearby lightning or atmospheric phenomena such as St. Elmo's fire, which produces localized glows on pointed objects. Expert analyses, including frame-by-frame examinations and comparisons to known video anomalies, are essential; for instance, the 2012 Chinese video passed such scrutiny through spectral correlation, while many amateur clips fail due to inconsistent lighting or editing artifacts.^[28]^[29]

Spectroscopic and instrumental measurements

In 2012, researchers on China's Qinghai Plateau captured the first spectrum of natural ball lightning using two slitless spectrographs positioned 900 meters from the event, which followed a cloud-to-ground lightning strike. The recorded spectrum showed a strong continuous component overlaid with distinct emission lines from silicon (Si I), iron (Fe I), and calcium (Ca I), all common soil constituents, supporting the idea that soil particles were vaporized and ionized by the initial strike to form the luminous orb.^[30] In 2016, a study quantified fluorescence effects linked to ball lightning, revealing UV-visible emissions consistent with plasma excitation mechanisms. For instance, calibrated fluorometry during a close-range event measured induced glow in nearby glass surfaces, attributed to ionizing radiation in the UV range (below 375 nm) from the plasma, providing quantitative evidence of energetic particle interactions.^[31] Electromagnetic measurements from natural ball lightning events have detected radio frequency emissions in the 3-30 GHz range (corresponding to 1-10 cm wavelengths), indicating microwave-like radiation from the plasma structure.^[32]^[33] Spectral analysis of these events yields effective temperatures around 2000-2700 K derived from line intensities of neutral atoms like oxygen, silicon, and iron.^[34]

Laboratory Experiments

Electrical discharge simulations

In the early 20th century, Nikola Tesla attempted to replicate ball lightning using high-frequency, high-voltage discharges from his Tesla coil, producing short-lived luminous fireballs that mimicked the glow of reported phenomena but lasted only fractions of a second and lacked sustained duration or mobility.^[35] During the 2000s, researchers explored electrical arc discharges over water surfaces to generate ball lightning analogs, leveraging electrolysis to ionize water and form plasma. At the Max Planck Institute for Plasma Physics, high-voltage pulses of 5000 volts vaporized water in a tank, creating luminous plasmoids with diameters of 10 to 20 centimeters and lifetimes approaching half a second, exhibiting spherical shapes and slow motion similar to eyewitness descriptions.^[36]^[37] Parallel efforts in the same decade used high-voltage arcs on silicon wafers to produce more persistent glowing orbs. In these setups, discharges at potentials exceeding 1 kV generated luminous balls with lifetimes on the order of seconds, diameters around 1 centimeter, and observable levitation due to thermal buoyancy, closely replicating the stability and emission spectra of natural ball lightning.^[38] Advancing into the 2010s, laboratory configurations employing high-voltage capacitor banks and inductive loads simulated thunderstorm conditions to create confined plasma balls. These experiments produced orbs up to several centimeters in diameter with lifetimes reaching up to 10 seconds in optimized setups, demonstrating self-guided motion along ionized channels and internal filamentation akin to observed ball lightning trajectories.^[39] Key findings from these electrical discharge simulations highlight the stabilizing influence of humidity, where moderate levels enhance plasma formation through increased ionization but excessive humidity can shorten orb lifetimes by promoting recombination.^[40] Electromagnetic containment emerges as a critical mechanism, with self-induced magnetic fields from the discharge currents trapping charged particles within the plasmoid structure, preventing rapid dissipation.^[41] These simulations also reveal spectral similarities to natural lightning events, such as emission lines in the visible range.^[38]

Microwave and plasma generation

Experiments using cylindrical waveguides to generate microwave-induced plasma orbs emerged in the 1990s as a method to simulate ball lightning phenomena. In one such setup, researchers employed a metal cavity measuring 161 mm in diameter and 370 mm in length, fed by microwaves at 2.45 GHz and 5 kW power from a magnetron oscillator, creating standing waves with six antinodes where the electric field was strongest.^[42] These conditions ionized the air, producing luminous fireballs and flames that persisted for 1-2 seconds even after the power was turned off, exhibiting colors such as white, blue, red, and orange.^[42] The fireballs demonstrated stability by passing through a 3 mm ceramic board and resisting gentle air currents, with some moving into the feeding waveguide, suggesting an internal structure influenced by the wave pattern.^[42] Building on these approaches, experiments in the 2000s utilized home microwave oven components to create ball lightning-like plasmoids through localized heating. In a notable study, a magnetron operating at 2.45 GHz and up to 1 kW directed microwaves onto solid materials such as silicon, forming a molten hot spot that ejected buoyant fireballs into the surrounding air.^[43] These plasmoids, reaching temperatures around 2000 K, lasted up to 100 ms and traveled several centimeters, often forming from vaporized residues like silicon in the heated area, mimicking the self-contained glow and motion of reported ball lightning.^[43] Sparks from the intense fields in such setups contributed to the initiation, with the orbs showing a vapor envelope that stabilized their propagation.^[44] Further advancements in the 2000s focused on stable, long-lived fireballs in open air using microwave cavities without relying on solid materials. Researchers generated buoyant plasmoids approximately 1 cm in diameter by initiating them with a brief (<1 ms) capacitive discharge and sustaining them with continuous-wave 2.45 GHz microwaves delivered via a small horn antenna into a cavity environment.^[45] These fireballs persisted for up to 20 seconds, far exceeding prior microwave-generated durations, and remained stable against perturbations while exhibiting varied colors distinct from dusty plasma variants.^[45] The stability was attributed to cavity resonance, where the microwave field maintained plasma confinement at power levels around 100-500 W, allowing seconds-long orbs without external solids.^[45] In the 2010s and 2020s, similar techniques refined the production of plasma balls resembling natural ball lightning durations and glow, often over liquid surfaces to enhance initiation. These experiments highlighted the role of microwave cavity resonance in achieving stability, with energy inputs of approximately 100 W sufficient for sustained, self-contained orbs lasting several seconds, providing key insights into plasma dynamics without direct electrical arcs.^[40]

Chemical composition tests

Laboratory experiments have explored the chemical composition of ball lightning by simulating material vaporization and plasma formation from ground-based elements, particularly focusing on silicon and aqueous electrolytes. In the 2000s, researchers conducted electrical arc discharges in pure silicon to generate luminous balls resembling ball lightning. These experiments involved applying low-voltage arcs (around 200 V) to silicon lumps in air, producing glowing spheres with diameters of 1–4 cm and lifetimes up to 8 seconds.^[38]^[46] The luminous effect was attributed to the slow oxidation of silicon nanoparticles formed during the discharge, where silicon vapor reacts with atmospheric oxygen to release energy gradually through chemiluminescence. Post-experiment analysis of residues confirmed the presence of silicon dioxide (SiO₂) nanoparticles, supporting the hypothesis that ball lightning could arise from soil-vaporized silicon during natural lightning strikes.^[38] Electrochemical simulations have also tested vaporization from water-based environments, mimicking interactions with moist soil or bodies of water. In these setups, high-voltage discharges (up to 5 kV) were applied across electrodes submerged in a salt water solution (e.g., NaCl in water), leading to electrolysis that generates hydrogen and oxygen gases.^[47] The process creates a plasma fireball rising from the water surface, with diameters of 10–20 cm and lifetimes of 0.1–0.4 seconds, sustained by the combustion of the H₂-O₂ mixture in a confined plasmoid. Spectroscopic examination revealed emission lines primarily from ionized water molecules and trace sodium from the electrolyte, indicating that such plasmas could form from lightning-induced electrolysis in saline environments. Residue analysis showed minimal metallic deposits but confirmed oxidized compounds consistent with electrolytic byproducts.^[47] In 2021, experiments by Alexander Oreshko further advanced understanding by generating laboratory ball lightning through high-energy discharges, producing plasmoids up to 94 cm in diameter that demonstrated anomalous penetration through solid barriers, aligning with some chemical and plasma hypotheses for natural occurrences.^[48]

Theoretical Explanations

Plasma and electromagnetic models

Plasma and electromagnetic models of ball lightning propose that the phenomenon consists of a self-sustaining ionized gas, or plasma, maintained by internal or external electromagnetic fields, without relying on chemical reactions or solid cores. These theories emphasize the role of electric and magnetic fields in confining and energizing the plasma, allowing it to persist for seconds to minutes as a luminous orb. Key variants include resonant cavity mechanisms, buoyant plasma structures, electron-ion equilibria, and soliton wave formations, each addressing observed properties like stability, luminosity, and motion. While laboratory simulations of plasma discharges provide supportive evidence, these models focus on natural atmospheric conditions during thunderstorms.^[40] The microwave cavity hypothesis, first proposed by Pyotr Kapitza in 1955, posits that ball lightning forms as a resonant spherical cavity that traps microwave radiation generated by nearby lightning strikes. In this model, the orb acts as a plasma shell that reflects and confines microwaves, similar to a microwave oven, ionizing the air and sustaining the glow through continuous energy input at frequencies around 1 GHz. Stability requires a high quality factor (Q-factor) exceeding 10^6, enabling the cavity to store energy with minimal losses over observed lifetimes of up to 10 seconds; theoretical extensions suggest even higher Q-values, such as 10^{10}, achieved via low-resistivity plasma boundaries formed by relativistic electron effects. This confinement prevents rapid dissipation, explaining the orb's coherent motion and eventual silent extinction or explosive release of stored energy (estimated at 8-80 kJ).^[49] Building on similar principles, the buoyant plasma hypothesis describes ball lightning as a hot, low-density plasma bubble of ionized air that rises due to thermal buoyancy, akin to a rising air parcel in convection. Proposed by G. A. Dawson and R. C. Jones in 1969, the model envisions the plasma confined by self-generated magnetic fields from currents within the ionized gas, preventing expansion and maintaining spherical shape against atmospheric pressure. The magnetic pinch effect compresses the plasma, with field strengths on the order of 0.1-1 Tesla sufficient for orbs of 10-30 cm diameter, while buoyancy drives horizontal and vertical motion observed in eyewitness accounts. This setup sustains luminosity through bremsstrahlung radiation from electron-ion collisions, with the bubble's integrity lasting until recombination or field disruption occurs.^[50] The electron-ion model treats ball lightning as a quasi-neutral plasma cluster where electrons and positive ions are balanced, with the outer electron envelope held by an internal volume of positive charge. Developed by Sergey G. Fedosin in the early 2000s, this framework estimates electron densities around 10^{15} cm^{-3} in the plasma shell, sufficient for conductivity and luminosity but low enough to avoid immediate recombination. Equilibrium is maintained by ion recombination rates offset by ongoing ionization from internal electric fields (up to 10^5 V/m), with the net positive charge (∼10^{-7} C for a 10 cm orb) generating a magnetic field that traps ions and ejects excess electrons. This model predicts energy contents of 10-100 kJ, primarily thermal, and explains penetration through walls via charge-induced polarization without physical damage.^[51] The soliton hypothesis views ball lightning as a stable, propagating electromagnetic soliton—a nonlinear wave packet that maintains its shape due to a balance between dispersion and nonlinearity in the plasma medium. Advanced by Peter H. Handel in the 1990s through the maser-soliton theory, the orb emerges from microwave maser emission in large atmospheric volumes (several km^3) between thunderclouds and ground, forming a caviton: a localized high-field region surrounded by plasma. The soliton propagates at speeds of 1-10 m/s, matching observed trajectories, with stability derived from the wave's self-trapping via refractive index variations induced by the intense field (∼10^6 V/m). Energy, sourced from atmospheric maser amplification of Rydberg states in air molecules, dissipates gradually, accounting for the phenomenon's evanescence.^[52] Although some ball lightning reports may stem from hallucinations induced by strong magnetic fields from lightning (∼1-10 T at close range), which trigger phosphene effects in the visual cortex mimicking luminous orbs, plasma-based models remain the primary framework due to their consistency with spectroscopic evidence of ionized gases and laboratory plasma analogs.^[53]

Chemical and material hypotheses

One prominent chemical hypothesis posits that ball lightning arises from the vaporization of silicon in soil during a lightning strike, leading to the formation of oxidizing nanoparticles that emit light through silicon monoxide (SiO) reactions. Lightning channels reaching temperatures exceeding 30,000 K can vaporize silicon-rich soil components, ejecting chains of nanoparticles such as silicon, SiO, and silicon carbide into the atmosphere. These nanoparticles form a filamentary network that oxidizes slowly in air, releasing stored chemical energy as heat and visible light, with the glow from oxidation reactions. This process accounts for the orb's luminosity, duration of several seconds, and energy content of approximately 10-100 kJ, as the oxidation rate balances energy release to sustain the phenomenon without rapid dissipation. Laboratory simulations using high-voltage arcs on silicon lumps have replicated luminous balls lasting up to 8 seconds, supporting the model's feasibility through observed nanoparticle chains and oxidation dynamics. The nanobattery hypothesis proposes that ball lightning consists of a cloud of composite aerosol particles, each functioning as a microscopic electrochemical battery that discharges light via internal reactions. These particles, ranging from 5 to 1,000 nm in diameter, form through processes like spark erosion or electrospraying during lightning, encapsulating a reductant core, electrolyte layer, and oxidizer shell. Short-circuiting via surface arc discharges triggers electrochemical oxidation, producing gaseous products and thermal energy that cause mutual repulsion, while magnetic dipole interactions maintain the cloud's spherical shape. For a typical 20 cm diameter orb, this could yield an energy content of around 130 kJ, with discharge currents varying from hundreds of amperes in quiet phases to mega-amperes during explosive bursts, explaining observed electromagnetic effects and luminescence. The hypothesis emphasizes self-sustaining reactions within thousands of such nanobatteries, synchronized partially to produce coherent light emission. An electrochemical model attributes ball lightning to atmospheric ions forming reactive chains at the surface of a wet air plasma, sustained by ambient humidity and thunderstorm electric fields. In humid conditions, hydronium (H₃O⁺) and nitrate (NO₂⁻) ions from nitrogen oxidation combine upon hydration, creating a refrigerating effect that stabilizes the plasma boundary while enabling thermochemical cycles. This surface electrochemistry acts as a heat pump, drawing power from the ambient electric field (typically 100-300 V/m) to maintain the orb's integrity against diffusion and gravitational settling. The model predicts continuous power output from low luminosity to lightning-scale intensities, with stability arising from balanced gradients in electric, thermal, and compositional fields, and movement directed by field asymmetries. Reactive ion chains propagate energy transfer, preventing collapse and allowing durations of 1-30 seconds in moist air. The hydrodynamic vortex ring antisymmetry hypothesis describes ball lightning as a chemical vortex structure in air currents, where symmetry breaking in a ring-shaped flow sustains the orb through adapted fluid dynamics. Formed by shock waves and thunder from a lightning strike, an initial invisible hydrodynamic vortex ring propagates horizontally, with cold air inflow creating rotation perpendicular to its path. Upon encountering obstacles, the ring's two-fold symmetry breaks, contracting into a three-dimensional sphere with a trailing plume, trapping reactive chemical species for glowing emission. This process draws on adaptations of the Navier-Stokes equations for viscous, compressible flows in vortex rings, where vorticity transport and pressure gradients govern the evolution:

\frac{\partial \mathbf{u}}{\partial t} + (\mathbf{u} \cdot \nabla) \mathbf{u} = -\frac{1}{\rho} \nabla p + \nu \nabla^2 \mathbf{u},

with the curl yielding the vorticity equation for ring propagation and pinch-off. The chemical loading within the vortex enhances stability, explaining the rarity of full orbs (about 5% of cases) and their high energy from sustained mixing of oxidized air parcels. Brief lab tests with silicon discharges have shown similar ring-to-sphere transitions, aligning with soil-vaporization origins.

Exotic and quantum theories

One exotic theory posits that ball lightning consists of Rydberg matter, which forms clusters of highly excited atoms in Rydberg states with large principal quantum numbers, creating conductive, glowing aggregates due to enhanced van der Waals forces and colossal dispersive interactions. These clusters can achieve macroscopic sizes and lifetimes at relatively low temperatures, potentially explaining the luminous, stable orbs observed in ball lightning without requiring extreme energies. This model suggests that atmospheric ionization during thunderstorms excites atoms into Rydberg states, forming a plasma-like substance that radiates light through electron transitions. Seminal work on this includes analyses showing Rydberg matter's stability and relevance to fireball phenomena. The vacuum hypothesis proposes that ball lightning arises from quantum vacuum fluctuations or zero-point energy, where virtual particles and photons in the quantum vacuum are amplified by strong electromagnetic fields in thunderstorms, sustaining a self-contained energy orb. This theory invokes concepts from quantum electrodynamics, suggesting that "zero-point" energy and virtual photon pairs provide the necessary power for the phenomenon's persistence and luminosity, potentially linking it to broader vacuum energy effects. Proponents argue this mechanism accounts for the orb's ability to traverse obstacles and its occasional explosive dissipation as vacuum fluctuations collapse. An electrically charged solid-core model describes ball lightning as a positively charged solid nucleus—possibly silicon-based or metallic—surrounded by a thin electron sheath, with the core charged to potentials up to 10^9 volts, confining energy electrostatically and magnetically. The core's positive charge attracts ambient electrons, forming a neutralizing shell that glows due to recombination and prevents immediate discharge, while the high voltage enables levitation and penetration through materials. This framework, developed in detailed mathematical models, explains observed behaviors like indoor persistence and sudden explosions from charge imbalance. A 2025 proposal introduces ball lightning as a magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) object featuring toroidal electron currents in a thin current sheet structure, linking it to gamma-ray emissions observed in thunderstorms. This model unifies ball lightning with terrestrial gamma-ray flashes, positing that the MHD configuration accelerates electrons relativistically, producing both the visible orb and high-energy radiation through synchrotron processes in the toroidal field. The theory emphasizes the object's free-floating nature and stability due to magnetic confinement, offering a testable prediction for correlated gamma-ray detections. Other hypotheses include quantum soliton variants, where ball lightning emerges as stable, self-reinforcing wave packets in quantum hydrodynamics, propagating as coherent excitations in atmospheric plasma akin to solitons in nonlinear media. These models treat the orb as a quantum object evolving under generalized hydrodynamic equations, potentially explaining its coherent motion and longevity. Additionally, some perceptual artifact theories suggest that certain sightings may result from hallucinations induced by strong electromagnetic pulses from nearby lightning, stimulating phosphene-like visuals in the brain via transcranial magnetic effects, though this does not account for corroborated multi-witness or photographic evidence.

References

[1]
Advances in ball lightning research - ScienceDirect.com
This review paper summarizes theoretical, observational, and experimental work in the field since approximately 2000.
[2]
The Riddle of Ball Lightning: A Review - PMC - NIH
They are surprisingly stable, lasting up to 10 s, even minutes in some rare cases. By night, their appearance can be spectacular, but their brilliance is just ...
[3]
What is ball lightning, a reality or myth? - C&EN
Apr 15, 2024 · The mysterious phenomenon has been reported for centuries. Are scientists any closer to figuring it out? by Fionna Samuels.
[4]
Have You Seen Ball Lightning? Scientists Want to Know About It - Eos
Jul 15, 2021 · Ball lightning has been reported for centuries but hasn't been reliably observed by scientific instruments.Missing: review | Show results with:review
[5]
[PDF] / BALL LIGHTNING CHARACTERISTICS by Warren D. Rayle Lewis ...
The ball lightning phenomenaare not easily studied. The occurrences are unpredictable and sufficiently infrequent to minimize the chances of bringing ...Missing: review | Show results with:review
[6]
Periodically I hear stories about ball lightning. Does this ...
Jul 18, 1997 · The lifetime of ball lightning tends to increase with size and decrease with brightness. Balls that appear distinctly orange and blue seem to ...
[7]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dMsGHmGxyxo
[8]
None
Nothing is retrieved...<|control11|><|separator|>
[9]
[PDF] A MODEL FOR BALL LIGHTNING
The energy of BL, which derives from nucleon decay catalyzed by this plasma, leads, through various mechanisms, to BL luminosity as well as to other BL features ...
[10]
A brief history of ball lightning observations by scientists and trained ...
Mar 1, 2021 · Ball lightning is an unsolved problem with few instrumental records. This study compiles 41 cases from 8 countries, 1868-2020, to evaluate ...
[11]
[PDF] Chapter-16-Electrostatics-I.pdf
• Lightning is dangerous - Georg Wilhelm Richmann July 1753 killed as he tried to repeat Ben Franklin's experiment – hit in the head by a blue “ball of ...
[12]
The destructive power of ball lightning - The Times
Aug 29, 2016 · On August 29, 1726, the sloop Catherine and Mary was struck by a ball of fire. ... For some time after the storm subsided, “a nauseous ...Missing: 18th century
[13]
Great balls of fire kill sailors - The Times
Feb 13, 2019 · The fireballs that struck the Warren Hastings could have been violent ball lightning, a rare electrical phenomenon linked to intense ...Missing: 18th century
[14]
a guide to the scientific knowledge of things familiar
No; the notion of thunder-bolts falling from the clouds, arises from the globular form, that is sometimes assumed by a flash of lightning. [Pg 12]. Q. Why is ...Missing: text | Show results with:text
[15]
The Project Gutenberg eBook of Thunder and Lightning, by Camille Flammarion
Below is a merged summary of all the ball lightning/globular lightning descriptions from "Thunder and Lightning" by Camille Flammarion and Wilfrid de Fonvielle's book. To retain all the detailed information in a dense and organized format, I will use a table in CSV format, followed by a concise narrative summary. The table captures specific incidents, characteristics, and effects, while the narrative provides an overview of general traits and additional context.
[16]
Tsar-Martyr Nicholas Ii And His Family - Orthodox Net
The ball (it was of lightning) ... In 1888, while Tsar Alexander III and his family were travelling towards Kharkov, the imperial train was rocked by two ...
[17]
'There Was a Crack and a Fiery Thread Entered the Tent' - The ...
Aug 25, 2011 · A prominent account found in church-sponsored biographies is of Tsar Nicholas II, who recalled a night mass with his father, Alexander III ...Missing: imperial train
[18]
Ball lightning - Wikipedia
Ball lightning is a rare and unexplained phenomenon described as luminescent spherical objects that vary from pea-sized to several meters in diameter.Ball Lightning (novel) · Physical Review Letters · List of lightning phenomena
[19]
Ball Lightning - Nature
Ball Lightning. Download PDF. Letter; Published: 29 November 1969. Ball Lightning. R. C. JENNISON. Nature volume 224, page 895 (1969)Cite this article. 5283 ...Abstract · About This Article · Cite This Article
[20]
Study explains the mystery of ball lightning - Phys.org
Oct 12, 2012 · Lowke used eye-witness accounts of ball lightning by two former US Air Force pilots to verify the theory. Former US Air Force lieutenant Don ...Missing: farmers | Show results with:farmers
[21]
Eyewitness Accounts of Kugelblitz - Cabinet Magazine
This report records a number of eyewitness accounts of ball-lightning which were submitted to the author spontaneously in response to a newspaper request.
[22]
First instance of ball lightning captured on video and spectrographs
Jan 17, 2014 · Researchers in China have captured, for the first time, an instance of ball lightning, on digital video along with spectrographs.
[23]
Strange Ball Lightning Caught on High-Speed Video | Live Science
Jan 21, 2014 · A video recorded by accident of ball lightning in China is now shedding light on the phenomenon's mysterious origins, researchers say.
[24]
Ball lightning: weird, mysterious, perplexing, and deadly
Mar 5, 2019 · One of the first recorded sightings of ball lightning occurred in 1638, when a "great ball of fire" came through the window of an English church ...
[25]
'Ball Lightning' Caught on Film After Storm in Canada - Science Alert
The couple managed to capture a 23-second video of the strange apparition. "It looks like a firebolt, but not really, it's the wrong color," ...
[26]
'Incredible video' captured during Alberta storm could be rare ball ...
'Incredible video' captured during Alberta storm could be rare ball lightning event: scientist. By Phil Heidenreich Global News. Posted July 3, 2025 7:11 pm.
[27]
Ball Lightning? Video From Alberta, Canada Shows Strange ...
Jul 22, 2025 · A video filmed in Canada appears to show a strange glowing blue-white orb oscillating as it slowly moved across a field.
[28]
The Enigma of Ball Lightning: Nature's Mysterious Phenomenon
Mar 1, 2024 · It's been described as ball shaped lightning, but, digging into the details, there's more to this phenomenon than a glowing orb suspended in ...Missing: 1911 | Show results with:1911
[29]
Evaluation of video evidence of possible ball lightning - ResearchGate
Aug 10, 2025 · Ball lightning is a rarely observed phenomenon whose existence is attested to by thousands of eyewitness reports, but which has so far evaded a ...
[30]
Observation of the Optical and Spectral Characteristics of Ball ...
Jan 17, 2014 · In most of the lifetime of the ball lightning, the size has remained approximately constant while the light intensity varies periodically.Missing: luminosity | Show results with:luminosity
[31]
[PDF] Fluorescence caused by ionizing radiation from ball lightning
Jun 24, 2025 · ball lightning. Some of the theories (e g. Shmatov, 2003) imply that ball lightning should emit ionizing radiation (UV and X-rays, in.Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
[32]
(PDF) The physical theory of ball lightning - ResearchGate
Aug 10, 2025 · The purpose of this paper is to analyze some models of BL by a number of criteria in order to select the models that best reflect the basic properties of BL.
[33]
The danger of ball lightning - MedCrave online
Apr 24, 2023 · High-frequency radio emission from ball lightning occurs in the wavelength range of 1-10 cm and can be absorbed by liquid water. When ball ...Missing: reviewed | Show results with:reviewed
[34]
Temperature of apparent natural ball lightning obtained by ...
Nov 4, 2022 · The mean temperatures gained by O I, Si I, and Fe I lines and continuous spectra were 8750, 4330, 4600, and 2700 K, respectively. This means ...
[35]
The Single Underlying Mechanism for Ball Lightning, Gamma-Ray ...
Aug 9, 2025 · The Single Underlying Mechanism for Ball Lightning, Gamma-Ray Glows, Flickering Gamma-Ray Flashes and Terrestrial Gamma-Ray Flashes. 43 Pages ...Missing: associations | Show results with:associations
[36]
The Transmission of Electrical Energy Without Wires
A systematic research, carried on for a number of years with the object of perfecting a method of transmission of electrical energy through the natural medium.
[37]
Ball lightning - ipp.mpg.de
The ball lightning experiment at IPP. At IPP in Garching globular objects – called plasmoids – are created above a water surface by an electrical discharge.
[38]
Physicists generate ball-lightning in the lab - Phys.org
Jun 6, 2006 · The physicists produce luminous plasma balls above a water surface which have lifetimes of almost half a second and diameters of 10 to 20 centimetres.Missing: Institute | Show results with:Institute
[39]
Production of Ball-Lightning-Like Luminous Balls by Electrical ...
Jan 24, 2007 · We performed electric arc discharges in pure Si to generate luminous balls with lifetime in the order of seconds and several properties ...
[40]
Generation of confined plasma balls propagating along discharge ...
Mar 5, 2020 · This work provides a tabletop analogy to thunderstorms, which allows to produce confined and luminous plasma balls.Missing: size | Show results with:size
[41]
Relativistic-microwave theory of ball lightning | Scientific Reports
Jun 22, 2016 · The typical lifetime of ball lightning is 1–5 seconds. Statistical analysis shows that increase in humidity decreases the lifetime of the ball, ...Missing: brightness | Show results with:brightness<|control11|><|separator|>
[42]
https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg12917614-400-science-microwaves-cook-up-ball-lightning-to-order/
[43]
Science: Microwaves cook up ball lightning to order | New Scientist
Mar 23, 1991 · The microwaves were reflected up and down the cavity, setting up a so-called standing wave. This had six 'antinodes' – points at which the ...
[44]
Fireball Ejection from a Molten Hot Spot to Air by Localized ...
Jan 30, 2006 · A phenomenon of fireball ejection from hot spots in solid materials (silicon, germanium, glass, ceramics, basalt, etc.) to the atmosphere is presented.
[45]
Mysterious Ball Lightning Created in the Lab | Live Science
Feb 23, 2006 · A laboratory-version of ball lightning created using a microwave drill. The floating fireball measures slightly more than an inch across and lasted for about ...
[46]
Microwave generation of stable atmospheric-pressure fireballs in air ...
The generation of stable buoyant fireballs in a microwave cavity in air at atmospheric pressure without the use of vaporized solids is described.
[47]
[PDF] Extension of Relativistic-Microwave Theory of Ball Lightning ... - arXiv
We have extended the relativistic-microwave theory of Wu to show what conditions must be satisfied by the plasma layer surrounding the proposed resonant.
[48]
Ball lightning as a radiation bubble | Pure and Applied Geophysics
A model for ball lightning is presented and its properties discussed. The model is that of a microwave radiation field contained within a plasma dielectric.
[49]
[PDF] Electron-ion model of ball and bead lightning - arXiv
The model allows us to estimate maximum size of ball lightning, its energy content, electric charge and magnetic field, to determine equilibrium conditions ...
[50]
Development of the maser‐caviton ball lightning theory
May 20, 1994 · Ball lightning is a localized high-field soliton forming a cavity surrounded by plasma in this theory. The source of VHF energy is a large ...
[51]
Transcranial stimulability of phosphenes by long lightning ...
Jun 28, 2010 · [6] showed that the magnetic field of lightning return strokes could generate phosphenes that could be misinterpreted as ball lightning. In ...Missing: hallucinations | Show results with:hallucinations