Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Bilocation

Bilocation is a reported supernatural or paranormal phenomenon in which a person or object is said to be present in two distinct locations simultaneously, often attributed to divine intervention or mystical ecstasy in religious contexts.^[1] Primarily documented within Christian hagiography, particularly Catholicism, it is viewed as a rare grace from God, rooted in divine omnipresence, and intended for spiritual edification rather than personal glory.^[1] The term gained prominence in the 19th century through Spiritualism, which described it as involving an "astral double" or ethereal projection of the body, though this interpretation diverges from traditional theological understandings.^[2] Historically, accounts of bilocation date back to early Christianity but proliferated during the 16th and 17th centuries amid the Catholic Counter-Reformation, when empirical science began challenging miraculous claims and prompting rigorous ecclesiastical scrutiny.^[3] Eyewitness testimonies, often from multiple reliable sources, served as the primary evidence, though verification was inherently difficult due to the phenomenon's transient nature and the physical distance between sites.^[4] The Catholic Church has approached such reports with caution, discerning between divine miracles, demonic deceptions, or human fraud, and has canonized saints partly on the basis of corroborated bilocation events.^[4] Notable examples include St. Ignatius of Loyola (1491–1556), who reportedly bilocated from Spain to the bedside of a dying disciple in Rome to offer consolation.^[2] In the 17th century, the Spanish nun María de Ágreda (1602–1665) was said to have bilocated over five hundred times to evangelize indigenous peoples in New Mexico, an account supported by Native American testimonies and her own writings, despite Inquisition investigations.^[5]^[3] Later figures encompass St. Alphonsus Liguori (1696–1787), an Italian bishop who bilocated to attend the deathbed of Pope Clement XIV in Rome while in ecstasy at home, and St. Pio of Pietrelcina (1887–1968), the Capuchin friar known for bilocating during Masses to aid penitents worldwide.^[1] These cases highlight bilocation's association with intense prayer and union with the divine, often occurring involuntarily.^[1] Beyond religious traditions, modern psychological and neurological studies have explored subjective experiences of bilocation, such as out-of-body sensations during trauma or meditation, suggesting it may involve disruptions in self-localization within the brain's temporoparietal junction, though these differ from the objective, witnessed events in hagiographic reports.^[6] Skeptics, including historians and scientists, emphasize the lack of empirical proof and potential for exaggeration or collective belief to influence perceptions, yet proponents argue that dismissing historical testimonies overlooks the cultural power of faith in shaping extraordinary phenomena.^[3]

Definition and Historical Origins

Definition and Phenomenon

Bilocation refers to the phenomenon where a person or object is reportedly present in two distinct locations at the same time. Historically, it has been described in religious, mystical, and philosophical contexts as a miraculous or supernatural ability, often linked to the soul's capacity to transcend physical limits.^[7]

Etymology and Early Concepts

The term bilocation derives from the Latin prefix bi- ("two") and locatio ("placement" or "location"), referring to the state or ability of being in two places simultaneously.^[8] The English noun first appeared in the mid-19th century, with the earliest recorded use in 1858 within a theological translation by Frederick William Faber, though discussions of the underlying phenomenon date to earlier Christian writings.^[9] In 17th-century Christian theology, the Latin form bilocatio emerged to describe miraculous duplications of presence among saints, possibly introduced by Jesuit scholars analyzing reports of apparitions and divided manifestations.^[7] Early conceptualizations of bilocation appear in ancient Greek philosophy through notions of "ubiquity" or the "multiplication of presence," where the soul's independence from the body enabled potential division or projection. Pythagorean ideas emphasized the soul's immortality and capacity for transmigration, implying a divisible essence that could transcend physical limits and manifest separately from the corporeal form.^[10] Roman accounts echoed these themes, adapting Greek philosophical speculations on soul projection into broader cultural narratives of spectral doubles. Such concepts relied on prerequisite ideas of soul-body dualism, as articulated by Plato—who viewed the soul as an eternal, non-physical entity separable from the body—and Aristotle, who described the soul as the form animating matter, allowing for theoretical extensions into multiplied presences.^[11] Over time, terminology for bilocation evolved from informal folklore descriptors like "doubles" or "fetch"—supernatural apparitions of living individuals, often portending death or significant events—to more formalized religious expressions. In Eastern traditions, analogous powers were categorized under siddhi, Sanskrit for spiritual accomplishments, encompassing abilities such as bilocation through yogic or meditative mastery that enabled the practitioner's presence in multiple loci.^[12] In medieval Christianity, terms like multiplicatio described the replication of a holy figure's presence, shifting from pagan or folkloric "doubles" to doctrinally sanctioned miracles rooted in divine intervention.^[7] This progression reflected a broader cultural move toward integrating philosophical dualism with religious frameworks, prioritizing the soul's transcendent potential over mere physical constraints.

Accounts in Ancient Greece and Rome

In ancient Greek tradition, one of the earliest accounts of bilocation is associated with Pythagoras, the 6th century BCE philosopher and founder of Pythagoreanism. According to Iamblichus in his On the Pythagorean Life, Pythagoras demonstrated this ability during a period of exile in Metapontum, where he had been residing after conflicts in Croton. A follower in Croton, facing a crisis, urgently sought Pythagoras's guidance, only to learn upon arrival that he had not left Metapontum. Witnesses reported seeing Pythagoras simultaneously in both cities, his golden thigh visible as a sign of his divine nature, resolving the crisis through his apparent dual presence. This anecdote, drawn from earlier sources like Aristoxenus, underscores Pythagoras's reputation as a semi-divine figure capable of transcending physical boundaries through the soul's power.^[13] A similar phenomenon is attributed to Apollonius of Tyana, a 1st century CE Neopythagorean philosopher, in Philostratus's Life of Apollonius of Tyana. Philostratus recounts instances of Apollonius's rapid disappearances and reappearances across distances, such as vanishing from a trial in Rome under Emperor Domitian and reappearing in Puteoli, Italy, to meet associates. These narratives, based on accounts from Apollonius's disciple Damis, portray his abilities as extensions of Pythagorean asceticism and divine communion, enabling feats that defied geographical limits, though they describe teleportation rather than strict simultaneity.^[14] Neoplatonic philosophy, particularly in Plotinus's 3rd century CE Enneads, provided a theoretical framework for the soul's multiplicity, akin to bilocation. Plotinus argued that the soul, as an immaterial hypostasis emanating from the Intellect, is not confined to one location but can be omnipresent, extending through the body and cosmos without division, allowing for simultaneous activities in multiple realms. This conception influenced later interpretations of ancient miracles, positing the soul's ubiquity as the mechanism behind apparent dual presences. Such accounts were embedded in the cultural milieu of mystery religions and oracles, where divine intervention enabled transcendent feats. In the Eleusinian Mysteries and Delphic Oracle, participants experienced ecstatic states that blurred physical boundaries, with gods like Apollo manifesting simultaneously in rituals and prophecies, suggesting bilocation as a hallmark of theurgic communion between human and divine realms.

Religious and Mystical Contexts

Hinduism and Buddhism

In Hinduism, the concept of bilocation is associated with siddhis (supernatural powers) described in the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali (circa 400 CE), particularly in the third chapter (Vibhuti Pada), where advanced yogic practices like samyama can lead to extraordinary abilities, including projections of consciousness or forms beyond physical limits, though not explicitly as one of the eight classical siddhis.^[15] This power, often termed bahuvigraha siddhi or the attainment of multiple embodiments, arises as a byproduct of advanced yogic discipline, including pranayama (breath control) and deep absorption (samadhi), enabling the practitioner to appear in diverse locations simultaneously for the purpose of teaching or guidance.^[16] Unlike illusory deceptions rooted in maya (cosmic illusion), this siddhi represents a genuine extension of consciousness beyond physical constraints, emphasizing its role in transcending dualistic perceptions toward ultimate non-dual realization.^[17] Prominent examples include the 20th-century sage Neem Karoli Baba, whose devotees reported instances of him appearing in multiple ashrams at the same time, such as being seen by separate groups in Kainchi and Vrindavan simultaneously during spiritual gatherings.^[18] Similarly, ancient figures like Adi Shankara (8th century CE) are depicted in traditional hagiographies as employing such siddhis to debate across distant regions, manifesting in various forms to propagate Advaita Vedanta teachings while maintaining his primary presence. In Buddhism, particularly within Tantric traditions, bilocation is viewed as a riddhi (supernatural accomplishment) manifesting from an enlightened mind, allowing advanced practitioners to project multiple forms to benefit sentient beings without attachment to the power itself.^[19] This ability emerges through profound samadhi states achieved via deity yoga and visualization practices, distinguishing it from mundane illusions by its basis in the non-dual nature of reality (dharmakaya). In Tibetan Buddhism, Padmasambhava (8th century CE), the lotus-born guru, exemplifies this through accounts of bilocating to various regions—such as subduing local deities in Tibet while simultaneously guiding disciples in India—to establish the Dharma, as detailed in his terma biographies.^[20] These manifestations underscore the bodhisattva ideal, where multiplicity serves compassionate activity rather than personal gain.

Christianity

In Christian theology, particularly within Catholicism, bilocation is regarded as a miraculous phenomenon where a person appears in two distinct locations simultaneously, often attributed to divine intervention rather than natural means.^[7] Early scriptural accounts, such as the ascension of the prophet Elijah in a whirlwind while Elisha witnesses it from afar (2 Kings 2:11-14), have been interpreted by some theologians as precursors to bilocation, suggesting a form of spiritual translocation or dual presence enabled by God's power.^[21] These Old Testament narratives emphasize prophetic authority and divine transport, laying a foundation for later hagiographic reports of saints manifesting in multiple places to fulfill spiritual duties.^[22] During the medieval period, bilocation claims became prominent in the lives of canonized saints, serving as signs of their holiness and intercessory role. Saint Anthony of Padua (1195–1231), a Portuguese Franciscan preacher who died in Italy, is one of the earliest documented cases; while residing in Padua, approximately 1,200 miles from Lisbon, he bilocated to his hometown to defend his father, Martin de Bulhões, who had been falsely accused of murder. Informed by God of the injustice, Anthony appeared in a Lisbon courtroom, commanded the victim's corpse to testify, revealing the true culprit and exonerating his father, before returning to Padua the next day.^[23] This event, recorded in contemporary Franciscan accounts, underscores bilocation as a tool for justice and familial protection within the Christian tradition.^[24] Another notable medieval-to-Enlightenment example involves Saint Alphonsus Liguori (1696–1787), the Italian bishop and founder of the Redemptorists, who experienced bilocation at age 86. On September 16, 1774, while in a trance in his diocese of Nocera dei Pagani (about 200 kilometers from Rome), Liguori appeared at the bedside of the dying Pope Clement XIV in the Vatican. The Pope later confirmed the saint's comforting presence and their discussion on Church matters, with witnesses verifying Liguori's physical immobility in Italy during the episode.^[25] This instance, investigated during Liguori's canonization process, highlights bilocation's role in pastoral care and papal support.^[7] Marian bilocation holds a unique place in Christian devotion, with the earliest recognized case occurring in A.D. 40. Our Lady of the Pillar refers to the Virgin Mary's appearance to Saint James the Greater in Zaragoza, Spain, while she remained physically in Jerusalem with the Apostle John. Accompanied by the Child Jesus and angels atop a jasper pillar, Mary encouraged James's faltering evangelization efforts among the Iberian tribes, instructing him to build the first church dedicated to her and promising ongoing miracles through her intercession.^[26] This bilocation, venerated through a 15-inch wooden statue still enshrined in Zaragoza's Basilica of Our Lady of the Pillar, is the sole documented instance of Mary manifesting dually during her earthly life, emphasizing her role as spiritual guide to the apostles.^[27] In the 20th century, Saint Pio of Pietrelcina (1887–1968), an Italian Capuchin friar known for his stigmata, reported numerous bilocations, often during Masses or crises, as verified by eyewitnesses and Church investigations. For instance, during World War II, Pio appeared in the sky over San Giovanni Rotondo, identified by an American pilot as the figure who deterred bombers from the town; the pilot later confirmed Pio's identity at the local friary.^[28] Other accounts include Pio simultaneously celebrating Mass at his convent while manifesting at Saint Anne's Church in Foggia on July 26, and attending spiritual meetings in distant locations, such as confirming his presence to a group in 1955 with the words, "Yes, of course I was there!"^[29] These events, documented in over 50 testimonies, aided conversions and protections, aligning with Pio's ministry of mercy.^[30] Theologically, Catholic doctrine views bilocation as metaphysically possible through God's omnipotence, which can suspend the natural law of local extension, though it remains physically impossible under ordinary conditions.^[7] Debates among theologians, such as St. Thomas Aquinas (who emphasized spiritual modes over physical duplication) and later figures like Duns Scotus and St. Robert Bellarmine (who affirmed potential physical bilocation via divine action), center on whether it involves true corporeal presence or visionary/phantasmal replications, possibly facilitated by angels transporting or multiplying the body.^[22] The Vatican scrutinizes such claims rigorously during canonization, requiring multiple eyewitness testimonies, exclusion of natural explanations, and alignment with Church teaching on miracles as signs of sanctity, as seen in the processes for saints like Liguori and Pio.^[31] This discernment ensures bilocation is understood not as a personal power but as a charism for edifying the faithful.^[1]

Islam and Judaism

In Islam, particularly within Sufi traditions, bilocation is linked to karamat (miraculous gifts bestowed on saints) and concepts like tay al-ard (the folding of the earth), enabling a person to traverse distances instantaneously or appear in multiple locations through divine intervention. This phenomenon is attributed to awliya (saints), such as Abdul Qadir Jilani (1077–1166), who is said to have manifested in distant places to guide followers or perform miracles, emphasizing submission to Allah's will. In Judaism, bilocation relates to kefitzat haderech (shortening of the path), a miraculous ability to cover great distances quickly or achieve dual presence, mentioned in Talmudic and Midrashic texts. For example, stories describe prophets like Elijah or rabbis appearing in multiple places, and Kabbalistic interpretations discuss spiritual projections. Modern discussions, such as in Chabad teachings, explore Talmudic "cloning" or bilocation as divine signs.^[32]

Indigenous and Other Traditions

In shamanic traditions, particularly among Siberian and Native American peoples, bilocation manifests through spirit journeys during healing rituals, where the shaman's physical body remains in one location while their soul travels to another realm or site to interact with spirits or retrieve lost souls. This practice, often induced by drumming, chanting, or ecstatic trance, enables the shaman to address communal needs such as curing illness or resolving disputes by appearing or acting in distant places through spiritual means. For instance, among the Iñupiat of northern Alaska, shamans employed these abilities to provide strength and healing, viewing the soul's dual presence as a natural extension of their role as intermediaries between worlds.^[33] Similarly, 19th-century ethnographic accounts of Inuit angakkuq (shamans) describe bilocation during séances, where the shaman and assisting spirits were perceived as present in multiple locations simultaneously to combat malevolent forces or guide the community. Native American shamans across various tribes, such as those in the Plains and Southwest, also attributed bilocation to their spiritual powers, allowing them to be physically present at rituals while their essence aided distant kin through visionary travel or shape-shifting. Scholarly analyses highlight this as part of a broader shamanistic repertoire, including teleportation and clairvoyance, rooted in heart-centered consciousness and ancestral wisdom traditions.^[34] These abilities were not for personal gain but served communal harmony, often invoked in ceremonies to protect against environmental threats or restore balance. In African traditions like those of the Yoruba, parallels to bilocation appear in concepts of spiritual multiplicity during Ifá divination, where priests (babalawo) channel orunmila's wisdom, enabling a perceived dual presence between the physical and spiritual realms to interpret fates and guide healing. This "double-going" involves the diviner's trance-like state, akin to shamanic ecstasy, facilitating communal resolution of crises through ancestral intervention. Oceanic folklore, particularly Polynesian tales, describes mana—a sacred force—as enabling multiplicity, where ancestral spirits or deities manifest simultaneously across islands or realms, aiding navigation, fertility rites, or protection during voyages. For example, figures like the god Maui embody this by appearing in multiple forms or locations to perform feats benefiting the community, tied to animistic beliefs in an interconnected cosmos. Celtic folklore features the "fetch" as an ominous bilocation, an apparition of a living person's double that appears to others as a harbinger of death or significant change, often during times of ritual or emotional intensity. Recorded in Irish and Scottish traditions, the fetch was not controlled like a shaman's journey but emerged spontaneously from the soul's detachment, serving as a communal warning tied to animistic views of the otherworld. Australian Aboriginal Dreamtime narratives portray ancestral beings as omnipresent across multiple sites, their essence embedded in sacred landscapes like rock formations and waterholes created during the eternal "everywhen." These beings continue to influence daily life through songlines, allowing their spiritual multiplicity to guide rituals for land stewardship and social cohesion, emphasizing ongoing communal ties to creation.^[35] Across these indigenous traditions, bilocation and related multiplicities are deeply rooted in animism, where all elements possess spirit, and ritual ecstasy—achieved via trance, song, or dance—facilitates the phenomenon for collective benefit, such as healing, prophecy, or environmental harmony, rather than individual prowess.^[36]

Occultism and Modern Reports

Witchcraft and Spectral Evidence

In the context of 17th-century European and colonial American witchcraft persecutions, bilocation was frequently invoked through the concept of spectral evidence, where the "shape" or apparition of an accused witch was reported to appear at a distant location to torment victims, serving as purported proof of their guilt. This evidentiary practice was central to trials such as the Bury St. Edmunds witch trials of 1645 in England, where witnesses testified that the spectral forms of suspects manifested elsewhere during interrogations, leading to confessions under torture and the execution of 18 individuals. Similarly, during the Salem witch trials of 1692 in Massachusetts, spectral evidence played a pivotal role, with accusers claiming that the invisible shapes of witches such as Bridget Bishop and Sarah Good bilocated to assault them, contributing to the conviction and hanging of 19 people and the death of one by pressing. The theological foundation for interpreting bilocation as evidence of witchcraft stemmed from Puritan beliefs that demonic pacts allowed witches to project their spirits or doubles across distances, a notion rooted in earlier demonological texts. The Malleus Maleficarum (1487), a influential treatise by Heinrich Kramer and Jacob Sprenger, described witches' abilities to fly or send forth spectral doubles through infernal alliances, framing such phenomena as signs of diabolical power rather than divine miracles. This contrasted briefly with Christian accounts of saintly bilocations viewed as holy manifestations, but in witchcraft contexts, it underscored accusations of malevolence. Puritans in New England and England expanded on these ideas, arguing that only Satan could enable such translocation, thereby justifying the use of spectral testimony in courts despite its reliance on unverifiable visions. Prominent witch-hunter Matthew Hopkins, active in England during the 1640s, frequently cited bilocative apparitions in his investigations, claiming that suspects' spectral shapes appeared to victims miles away, as in the cases around Manningtree and Chelmsford where over 100 people were accused and at least 23 executed. Hopkins' methods, detailed in his 1647 pamphlet The Discovery of Witches, emphasized these apparitions as corroborative evidence alongside pricking tests and swimming trials, amplifying fears of supernatural mobility among the populace. Such claims often led to swift legal outcomes, with juries accepting spectral bilocation as indicative of witchcraft pacts, resulting in widespread executions across East Anglia. By the late 1600s, the admissibility of spectral evidence began to wane amid growing skepticism and legal reforms, particularly after the Salem trials prompted reviews like Increase Mather's 1692 Cases of Conscience, which cautioned against relying solely on apparitions for convictions. Courts increasingly deemed spectral testimony insufficient without corroborating physical proof, marking a decline in bilocation-based prosecutions. This shift, culminating in the 1735 repeal of the Witchcraft Act and judicial rulings in cases like the 1712 Jane Wenham trial, contributed to the broader diminishment of witch hunts in Europe and the colonies by the early 18th century.

Occult Practices and Figures

In the 19th century, one of the most widely reported cases of bilocation in Western esoteric circles involved Émilie Sagée, a French teacher employed at a girls' boarding school in Livonia (present-day Latvia) in 1845. According to eyewitness accounts from 42 students and the headmistress, Sagée was observed appearing in two locations simultaneously on numerous occasions, such as teaching a class while her double was seen standing motionless outside a window or mimicking her actions in a classroom. These events, which lasted several months and caused distress among the students, were documented in detail by American spiritualist Robert Dale Owen in his 1860 book Footfalls on the Boundary of Another World with Narrative Illustrations, drawing from letters and testimonies provided by the headmistress and former pupils. Theosophy played a pivotal role in integrating bilocation into modern Western occultism by drawing on Eastern concepts of siddhis, or supernatural powers attained through yogic discipline. Helena Blavatsky, co-founder of the Theosophical Society in 1875, extensively discussed these abilities in her seminal works Isis Unveiled (1877) and The Secret Doctrine (1888), portraying bilocation as a manifestation of the astral double (mayavi-rupa) that could be projected consciously by advanced adepts, influenced by Hindu and Buddhist traditions of prapti (ubiquity) and kama-rupa projection. Blavatsky's writings emphasized that such powers were not miraculous but natural extensions of human potential, accessible through occult training, thereby bridging Eastern esotericism with Western hermeticism and inspiring later occultists to experiment with astral multiplicity. This framework influenced figures like the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn, where bilocation was viewed as a controlled psychic skill rather than a spontaneous anomaly. Early 20th-century occultist Aleister Crowley, founder of Thelema, claimed experiences of unconscious bilocation during ritual work, describing instances where his physical form remained stationary while his astral presence interacted in distant locales, often without his deliberate intent. In his Confessions (1929) and magical diaries, Crowley recounted such events as byproducts of invocations like the Bornless Ritual, aligning them with Thelemic principles of transcending dualistic space through "astral multiplicity" and the attainment of Knowledge and Conversation of the Holy Guardian Angel. Acquaintances, including fellow occultists, corroborated these claims, noting Crowley's apparent ability to manifest doubles during ceremonies, as referenced in Kenneth Grant's analysis of Crowley's Qliphothic workings in Nightside of Eden (1977). Crowley's accounts distinguished these from intentional projections, framing them as involuntary eruptions of the "True Will" amid intense magickal operations.^[37] Within esoteric Western traditions, practices aimed at inducing bilocation typically involve evocation—summoning spirits or energies to facilitate astral separation—and scrying, the use of reflective surfaces like black mirrors or crystals to observe and guide the double's projection. These methods, outlined in texts such as Franz Bardon's The Practice of Magical Evocation (1956), emphasize ritual preparation through meditation and visualization to achieve deliberate bilocation, contrasting with spontaneous occurrences reported in cases like Sagée's, where the phenomenon arose without ritual intent and was perceived as an uncontrollable etheric emanation. Evocation rituals often invoke planetary intelligences or elemental forces to stabilize the projection, while scrying serves to verify the double's remote activities, underscoring the distinction between volitional occult mastery and inadvertent psychic events in 19th- and 20th-century esotericism.

Contemporary Claims and New Religious Movements

In contemporary times, bilocation claims persist within New Religious Movements and New Age spirituality, often linked to channeled entities or extraterrestrial contact. For instance, in the 1970s, members of the Unarius Academy of Science reported bilocative experiences during psychic sessions, attributing them to interactions with "space brothers" from other dimensions.^[38] More recently, as of 2023, figures in modern shamanic practices, such as those in the ayahuasca retreats in South America, have described bilocation during visionary states, interpreted as soul flight or multidimensional travel. These accounts, documented in ethnographic studies, blend indigenous traditions with occult influences but lack empirical verification. Skeptics view them as subjective hallucinations, while proponents see them as evidence of expanded consciousness.^[39]

Explanations and Skepticism

Religious and Mystical Interpretations

In Christian theology, bilocation is often interpreted as a miraculous extension of divine omnipresence, whereby a saint's body or presence is enabled by God's power to occupy two locations simultaneously, either through angelic transport or a supernatural replication of form that defies natural physical laws. Catholic philosophers, such as those cited in early 20th-century theological treatises, argue that this is possible via distinct modes of location—circumscriptive (fully occupying space) in one place and definitive (spiritually present) in another—without contradicting divine sovereignty. This view underscores bilocation as evidence of the mystic's intimate union with God, where the individual's limitations are transcended by grace.^[7]^[1] Within Hinduism, bilocation aligns with the concept of siddhis, or supernatural powers attained through yogic mastery over maya, the illusory nature of material reality that veils ultimate truth. As described in Patanjali's Yoga Sutras, advanced practitioners can attain various extraordinary abilities through yoga, including powers related to perception and form that parallel bilocation, demonstrating control over the deceptive veil of maya to reveal the unity of consciousness. This theological framework positions bilocation not as mere physical duplication but as a sign of spiritual enlightenment, where the yogi operates beyond the constraints of space and time.^[40] Mystical psychology across traditions views bilocation as emerging from trance states that serve as gateways to higher realities, where the ego temporarily dissolves, allowing the spirit to project presence beyond the body. In Sufism, this parallels fana, the annihilation of the self in divine unity, enabling the mystic's ruh (spirit) to manifest in distant locations while the body remains stationary, as explored in Islamic spiritualist texts that link such phenomena to ascetic transcendence of physical boundaries. Symbolically, bilocation represents the profound unity of spirit and matter, affirming the mystic's or guru's elevated status and reinforcing communal faith in the interconnectedness of all existence.^[41]^[42] Theological debates, particularly within Christianity, center on whether bilocation constitutes a genuine physical event or a psychological manifestation in religious texts and hagiographies. Catholic traditions generally affirm its objective reality as a charism, supported by accounts of saints like Padre Pio, while Protestant perspectives often relegate it to subjective visionary experiences or symbolic allegory, emphasizing scriptural restraint against unverifiable miracles to avoid superstition. These discussions highlight tensions between empirical verification and faith-based acceptance, with Catholic theology prioritizing divine intervention over psychological explanations.^[2]^[43]

Scientific and Psychological Perspectives

Skeptical investigations into bilocation claims have consistently found no empirical evidence supporting the phenomenon as a physical reality, attributing reports to unreliable testimony and lack of verification. Joe Nickell, a prominent investigator affiliated with the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry (formerly CSICOP), has analyzed numerous historical cases of alleged bilocation among saints and mystics, concluding that they depend on hearsay, biased witnesses, and uncorroborated anecdotes rather than observable, repeatable events.^[44] In controlled settings, no bilocation has ever been demonstrated, with skeptics emphasizing the absence of physical traces or independent confirmation that would withstand scientific scrutiny.^[45] Psychological theories propose that bilocation perceptions arise from dissociative states, hallucinations, or suggestibility, particularly in trance-like conditions associated with intense emotional or religious fervor. For instance, individuals in altered states of consciousness may experience vivid mental imagery of their presence elsewhere, misinterpreted as literal duplication, while group sightings could stem from folie à deux, a shared delusional disorder where delusions transmit between closely related people.^[46] These explanations align with broader patterns in anomalous experiences, where cognitive biases and social reinforcement amplify subjective impressions into collective beliefs without objective basis.^[47] From a neurological viewpoint, sensations akin to bilocation may result from disruptions in brain regions processing body position and self-location, such as out-of-body experiences (OBEs) linked to temporal lobe activity. Olaf Blanke's research in the 2000s demonstrated that electrical stimulation of the temporoparietal junction can induce OBEs, where individuals feel detached from their body and perceive it from an external vantage, mimicking the dual presence described in bilocation accounts.^[48] Similarly, temporal lobe epilepsy has been associated with profound mystical visions and altered self-perception, potentially leading to interpretations of being in multiple locations during seizures.^[49] These findings suggest bilocation reports reflect neurobiological illusions rather than supernatural occurrences. Parapsychological efforts to validate bilocation through extrasensory perception (ESP) testing, including J.B. Rhine's card-guessing experiments in the 1930s, yielded initial positive results that failed to replicate under stricter controls, undermining claims of psi-mediated duplication.^[47] Contemporary attempts to invoke quantum mechanics—such as superposition or entanglement—to explain human bilocation have been widely critiqued as pseudoscientific misapplications, as quantum effects do not scale to macroscopic biological systems and lack experimental support for paranormal phenomena.^[50] Overall, these scientific and psychological perspectives frame bilocation as a product of human cognition and neurology, with no verifiable evidence for its literal occurrence.

Cultural Impact

In Literature and Art

Bilocation, the phenomenon of appearing in two places simultaneously, has long served as a motif in literature and art, often manifesting through doppelgängers or spectral doubles that evoke the supernatural and psychological tension between self and other. In classical works, this theme emerges implicitly in Dante Alighieri's Divine Comedy (completed around 1320), where the poet's soul undertakes a visionary journey through the afterlife while his physical body remains in exile on Earth. Similarly, Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's Faust (Part I, 1808; Part II, 1832) employs the doppelgänger through Mephistopheles, Faust's infernal double, who mirrors and tempts his host, embodying bilocation as a metaphysical division of the self in pursuit of forbidden knowledge.^[51] The 19th and 20th centuries amplified bilocation's exploration of fractured identity in prose fiction. Edgar Allan Poe's short story "William Wilson" (1839) exemplifies this through its protagonist's encounter with an identical yet morally opposing double, who appears at pivotal moments to thwart his vices, culminating in a duel that reveals the antagonist as his own suppressed conscience—a literary bilocation symbolizing inescapable self-confrontation. Franz Kafka's works, such as The Metamorphosis (1915), extend this fragmentation into existential alienation, where protagonists like Gregor Samsa experience a hallucinatory splitting of self, akin to bilocated doubles that underscore paranoia and identity dissolution in modern bureaucratic life.^[52] In visual art, bilocation motifs appear in depictions of mystical saints during the Renaissance, often to convey divine intervention. Spanish painter Francisco de Zurbarán's multiple portraits of St. Francis of Assisi, such as Saint Francis in Meditation (c. 1635–1639), portray the saint in rapt contemplation, rendered with stark chiaroscuro to heighten the ethereal duality.^[53] Surrealist René Magritte further abstracted this in the 20th century, using dual figures to probe perceptual ambiguity; in L'Imprudent (1936), a suited man steps from his own reflection in a mirror, creating a bilocated self that blurs reality and illusion, inviting viewers to question corporeal singularity.^[54] Thematically, bilocation in these works frequently symbolizes identity crisis and the uncanny, as theorized by Sigmund Freud in his 1919 essay "The 'Uncanny'," where the double represents a return of repressed infantile beliefs in omnipotence, transforming the familiar self into something estranged and terrifying.^[55] This motif underscores psychological duality, from Faustian ambition to Kafkaesque estrangement, often heightening narrative tension by externalizing internal conflict without resolving it.^[56]

In Film, Media, and Popular Culture

Bilocation, the concept of appearing or existing in two places simultaneously, has been explored in 20th- and 21st-century films as a motif of psychological fragmentation and identity crisis. In David Lynch's Lost Highway (1997), the protagonist Fred Madison undergoes a surreal transformation into mechanic Pete Dayton, embodying a doppelgänger dynamic that evokes bilocation through split identities and mirrored realities, as analyzed in scholarly examinations of Lynch's recurring twinning themes.^[57] Similarly, Christopher Nolan's The Prestige (2006) dramatizes bilocation via magical illusion and scientific duplication; rival magicians Alfred Borden employs a twin to achieve the "Transported Man" trick, appearing in two locations onstage, while Robert Angier uses a cloning machine invented by Nikola Tesla to create exact replicas, enabling literal multilocation at the cost of existential horror.^[58] In television adaptations of literary works, bilocation serves as a supernatural plot device blending crime procedural with horror. The HBO miniseries The Outsider (2020), based on Stephen King's 2018 novel, centers on an entity capable of bilocation that manifests as a shape-shifting duplicate, allowing it to commit murders in one location while providing an alibi elsewhere, as evidenced by eyewitness accounts and forensic contradictions that challenge rational investigation.^[59] Doctor Who episodes frequently incorporate time-based or technological duplicates resembling bilocation; in "Journey's End" (2008), the Tenth Doctor creates a half-human metacrisis duplicate via a biological transfer, resulting in two versions coexisting across timelines, while "The Rebel Flesh" (2011) and "The Almost People" (2011) feature acid-induced "gangers"—flesh avatars—that allow characters, including the Doctor, to operate in multiple hazardous environments simultaneously.^[60] Video games and comics have adapted bilocation into interactive and superhero narratives, emphasizing multiplicity and strategic presence. In the Portal series (2007–2011), the portal gun enables apparent bilocation by linking distant spaces, allowing players to manipulate momentum and visibility across locations as if occupying dual positions, a mechanic central to puzzle-solving in Aperture Science's test chambers.^[61] Marvel Comics' Jamie Madrox, known as Multiple Man, possesses the mutant ability to duplicate himself upon kinetic impact, creating autonomous copies that function independently in various locales, a power depicted in X-Factor Investigations storylines where dupes undertake parallel missions, reabsorbing later to share experiences.^[62] Over time, bilocation in media has evolved from a horror trope signifying omens of death or psychological dread—often tied to doppelgängers in early 20th-century films—to a sci-fi staple involving cloning or quantum tech, reflecting cultural shifts toward technological anxieties and identity fluidity in urban legends and speculative fiction.^[63] This transition mirrors broader genre hybridization, where supernatural bilocation yields to rationalized explanations like genetic engineering, influencing contemporary narratives in games and streaming media.^[64]

References

[1]
What is bilocation? - Aleteia
Jun 13, 2023 · Bilocation, within the context of Catholic theology, refers to a phenomenon in which an individual is believed to be present in two different locations ...Missing: history credible sources
[2]
Making Sense of Levitating Saints | Commonweal Magazine
Sep 6, 2023 · “Bilocation” was another quasi-scientific term favored by spiritualists, who believed that the human body had an “astral double,” a spiritual ...
[3]
Would you believe? A Yale historian reconsiders the seemingly ...
Mar 20, 2024 · At the conclusion of the book, you say that these many accounts of levitation and bilocation “reveal the power of belief to shape mentalities ...Missing: definition credible
[4]
The Trouble with Levitation and Bilocation | Church Life Journal
Oct 8, 2024 · Levitation and bilocation are but two of several physical phenomena that have been linked to mystical ecstasy in various cultures and religions ...
[5]
The bilocated mind: new perspectives on self-localization and ... - NIH
Evidence from neurology, cognitive neuroscience, and experimental psychology suggests that mental bilocation is a complex, but genuine experience, occurring ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
[6]
bilocation - Wiktionary, the free dictionary
English. English Wikipedia has an article on: bilocation · Wikipedia. Etymology. From bi- +‎ location. Pronunciation. IPA: /baɪləʊˈkeɪʃən/. Noun. bilocation ( ...
[7]
bilocation, n. meanings, etymology and more | Oxford English ...
The earliest known use of the noun bilocation is in the 1850s. OED's earliest evidence for bilocation is from 1858, in a translation by F. Faber.
[8]
CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Bilocation - New Advent
The question whether the same finite being (especially a body) can be at once in two (bilocation) or more (replication, multilocation) totally different placesMissing: medieval | Show results with:medieval
[9]
Pythagoreanism - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Mar 29, 2006 · Pythagoreanism is the philosophy of the ancient Greek philosopher Pythagoras (ca. 570–ca. 490 BCE), which prescribed a highly structured way of life.The Most Prominent... · Other Pythagoreans of the... · Neopythagoreanism
[10]
Dualism - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Aug 19, 2003 · Aristotle identifies the soul of a living creature with its form, and he argues, contra Plato, that forms cannot exist separately from the ...Missing: bilocation | Show results with:bilocation
[11]
Siddhi: 48 definitions - Wisdom Library
May 8, 2025 · Siddhi is positioned in the Eastern corner of the first circle of the kāśī-maṇḍala. ... Discover the meaning of siddhi in the context of India ...
[12]
iamblichus' life of pythagoras, or pythagoric life. - Project Gutenberg
But Pythagoras remained in one and the same unmoved state for two nights and three days, neither partaking of food, nor drink, nor sleep, unless perhaps as he ...Chap. XXVIII · Chap. XXXI · Chap. XXXV
[13]
The Life of Apollonius of Tyana : Philostratus - Internet Archive
Sep 18, 2023 · The Life of Apollonius of Tyana, translated from Greek by FC Conybeare (New York, 1912). The download contains both volumes of the Loeb Classical Library ...
[14]
Attaining the Siddhis: A Guide to the 25 Yogic Superpowers
The Yoga Sutras provide a taxonomy of supernormal mental powers and a means of obtaining them. Today we would classify most of the siddhis as various forms of ...
[15]
Yoga Sudhakara - English - Yoga Sutras Commentary
Feb 13, 2025 · ... Patanjali Yoga Sutras while offering unique perspectives, broadened my outlook. ... When a yogi creates multiple bodies simultaneously for ...
[16]
Siddhis in The Patanjali Yogasutra from the Perspective of Current ...
Nov 8, 2023 · In sutra 5, it is said that the result of samyama is universal knowledge (prajnaloka). Sutras 8, 9 and 10 refer to nirbija samadhi, the deeper ...
[17]
Rewriting the Sacred Geography of Advaita: Swami ... - Academia.edu
In the short treatise Śaṅkara the Missionary, the modern Vedāntin Swami Chinmayānanda famously appealed to the medieval hagiographies of Ādi Śaṅkarācārya as ...
[18]
Supernatural powers (siddhi): Significance and symbolism
Sep 22, 2024 · Supernatural powers, or Siddhis, in Tibetan Buddhism are defined as extraordinary spiritual abilities that individuals develop through their practices.
[19]
Introduction to Guru Padmasambhava - Lotsawa House
Once Guru Padmasambhava had firmly established Buddhism throughout greater Tibet, he journeyed to Cāmara (rnga yab gling) to prevent an invasion by rākṣasa ...
[20]
https://www.lotsawahouse.org/topics/guru-padmasambhava
[21]
Bilocation | Catholic Answers Encyclopedia
Bilocation is the presence of a finite being in two places at once. It is physically impossible, but a mixed mode of location is possible.
[22]
Saint Anthony's Miracles. A Dead Man Speaks - Santantonio.org
The distance from Padua to Lisbon is approximately 1,200 miles, but Anthony was there in a couple of hours through divine intervention. In the court room ...
[23]
The Spirituality of St. Anthony of Padua - EWTN
To the multiplicity of these virtues God in His goodness added, like to the gifted souls of the early Church, the charisms of prophecy, bilocation and miracles.
[24]
Saint Alphonsus de Liguori
Nov 2, 2008 · But, at the very moment he was with the Pope in Rome, the holy bishop was in his diocese 200 kilometers away. It was a case of bilocation, an ...
[25]
Meet Our Lady of the Pillar, the first apparition of the Virgin Mary in ...
Oct 12, 2021 · Although it was technically a bilocation of Our Lady, because she was living with John the Apostle in Jerusalem, it is still regarded as an ...
[26]
Did you know Mary's 1st apparition was an act of bilocation? - Aleteia
Oct 12, 2017 · The Blessed Virgin appeared to one of the apostles, St. James the Great, brother of St. John, in Spain. This apparition is known as Our Lady of the Pillar.
[27]
Padre Pio's Bilocation and the Odor of Sanctity | EWTN
Among the most remarkable of the documented cases of bilocation was the Padre's appearance in the air over San Giovanni Rotondo during World War II. While ...Missing: multiple | Show results with:multiple
[28]
3 Spiritual Gifts of Saint Padre Pio Explained - ChurchPOP
Sep 23, 2024 · The gift of bilocation enables a person to be in two places simultaneously. This phenomenon was reported multiple times by eyewitness accounts, ...<|separator|>
[29]
A Short Biography of the Saint from Pietrelcino - EWTN
the stigmata, a special fragrance, prophecy and bilocation — Padre Pio gave people hope as they began to rebuild their lives ...
[30]
State of the Departed Soul | EWTN
These cases, moreover, of bilocation do not entail, according to Catholic theology, the presence of the same body existing locally in two or more different ...
[31]
Expedition Magazine | Shamanism and Spirit - Penn Museum
Shamanism can oddly alter the weather; give a person physical strength that seems impossible; and curiously, give the power of bilocation, to be in two places ...
[32]
Native American Shamanism with William S. Lyon
He describes a number of shamanistic powers, including bilocation and teleportation. He emphasizes the importance of heart-centered consciousness. (Recorded ...
[33]
The Dreaming | Indigenous Beliefs, Creation Stories & Spirit Beings
In Aboriginal belief, they are spiritually as much alive today as they ever were. The places where the mythic beings performed some action or were “turned into” ...
[34]
https://newthinkingallowed.org/native-american-shamanism-with-william-s-lyon/
[35]
[PDF] LA SCIENZA DELL'ANIMA - Andrè Dumas - famiglia fideus
Gli esperimenti del professor Robert Hare. Robert Hare, medico e professore di chimica all'università di. Harward, in Pennylvania, inventore del cannello ...Missing: Émilie investigation
[36]
[PDF] Nightside of Eden
detractors of Aleister Crowley. Occultists, however, are aware that both the ... bilocation, here symbolized by the mummy (Osiris) and the risen youth ...
[37]
(PDF) Siddhis the miraculous yogic powers - ResearchGate
Apr 28, 2023 · The Sanskrit term siddhi in its plain everyday sense means “accomplishment, fulfilment, complete attainment (of any object)”.
[38]
(PDF) Beyond Time and Space: A Comparative Exploration of ...
Jun 21, 2024 · This study explores the notion of spatiotemporal phenomena, particularly bilocation within the religious and mystical traditions of Islam ...
[39]
Bilocation, Mystical - Encyclopedia.com
Bilocation is a mystical phenomenon where a body seems to be in two places at once, but it's always an apparent or seeming bilocation.
[40]
Does Protestant and Christian denominations have stories to tell ...
May 18, 2019 · Bilocation is a supernatutal gift of God that is somehow associated to people who had a pious character. Catholic Church had numerous stories to ...
[41]
Looking for a Miracle: Weeping Icons, Relics, Stigmata, Visions ...
Historical and paranormal investigator Joe Nickell confronts such strange events, powers, and objects as the Shroud of Turin, bleeding or weeping statues.
[42]
Secrets of 'The Flying Friar': Did St. Joseph of Copertino Really ...
... bilocation—that is, to be in two distinctly different places ... Joe Nickell. Joe Nickell, PhD, is senior research fellow of the Committee for ...
[43]
Shared Psychotic Disorder - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf - NIH
Aug 28, 2023 · Shared psychotic disorder (folie à deux) is a rare disorder characterized by sharing a specific delusion among two or more people in a close relationship.Missing: bilocation | Show results with:bilocation
[44]
[PDF] Investigating the Paranormal by David F. Marks - Skeptical Inquirer
While credence in extrasensory perception (ESP) and precognition is widespread, parapsychology has failed to produce a single repeatable demonstration. In the.
[45]
Out‐of‐body experience and autoscopy of neurological origin | Brain
We show that OBE and AS are frequently associated with pathological sensations of position, movement and perceived completeness of one's own body.Introduction · Methods · Results · Discussion
[46]
Ecstatic or Mystical Experience through Epilepsy - PMC - NIH
Ecstatic epilepsy is a rare form of focal epilepsy, so named because the seizures' first symptoms consist of an ecstatic/mystical experience.Missing: bilocation | Show results with:bilocation
[47]
[PDF] Quantum Theory and the Paranormal: The Misuse of Science
Psi promoters have picked up the jargon of quantum mechanics and in trying to apply it to the paranormal have confused vocabulary with substance. Steven N.
[48]
Dante Alighieri - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Jan 29, 2001 · It is generally accepted that Dante was born in 1265 in Florence. If it is true that he was born under the sign of Gemini—as reported in ...
[49]
Ambiguities in Goethe's Faust - jstor
It took precisely one hundred years after Goethe's death before the first serious and comprehensive attempt was made to interpret. Goethe's Faust, a Tragedy ...Missing: doppelganger bilocation
[50]
Kafka, paranoic doubles and the brain: hypnagogic vs. hyper ...
This paper discusses reasons (phenomenological and neurobiological) why the self projects an imaginary double (autoscopy) in its spontaneous hallucinations.Missing: bilocation | Show results with:bilocation
[51]
Saint Francis in Meditation, Zurbaran (1635-9) | Culture | The Guardian
Jul 21, 2001 · Zurbaran, in a portrait both realistic and revelatory, takes us into the thought- world of a Christian ascetic.
[52]
“L'Imprudent” and René Magritte's Use of Doubles and Doppelgängers
Apr 29, 2022 · The concepts of doubling and repetition at the core of “L'Imprudent” promulgate notions of the uncanny and mediate reality and representation in the artist's ...Missing: dual bilocation
[53]
[PDF] The “Uncanny”1 | MIT
It is only rarely that a psychoanalyst feels impelled to in- vestigate the subject of aesthetics even when aesthetics is understood to mean not merely the ...
[54]
Self as Other: The Doppelgänger - Double Dialogues
The central premise of the doppelgänger motif poses the paradox of encountering oneself as another; the logically impossible notion that the 'I' and the ...
[55]
"Altered States of Reality: The Theme of Twinning in David Lynch's ...
Lynch shows the audience that fantasy cannot subvert reality. It is only a temporary fix. Fred Madison's twinning is unsuccessful in the end.Missing: bilocation | Show results with:bilocation
[56]
Honesty: The Magic Trick at the Heart of The Prestige | Den of Geek
The Transported Man is nicked by Angier to become The New Transported Man; Borden steals it back as The Original Transported Man, before Angier trumps it with ...
[57]
Stephen King's latest novel wrestles with the question of how to be ...
Jun 5, 2018 · Curiously, bilocation – the phenomenon of one person being in two places at the same time – also featured prominently in one of the highest ...
[58]
BBC Latest News - Seeing double: Doctor Who doppelgängers - BBC
Aug 12, 2016 · We've seen double in the world of Doctor Who, so here's a selection of our favourite DW doppelgängers: Zygons, Gangers, androids and more.
[59]
Portal (Video Game) - TV Tropes
Portal is a First Person Puzzle Platformer video game series created by Valve that takes place in the same universe as the Half-Life series.
[60]
Multiple Man Powers, Enemies, History | Marvel
The mutant Multiple Man lives up to his name with the power to create duplicates of himself, and establishes the mutant detective agency, X-Factor ...Missing: bilocation | Show results with:bilocation
[61]
Sci-Fi Horror - TV Tropes
Sci-Fi Horror is a Sub-Genre of both Science Fiction and Horror that uses scientific advances or futuristic settings as a source of fear.
[62]
Be Afraid: What Horror Movies Say About America
Oct 23, 2024 · Dive into the history of horror cinema and its reflection of societal fears, from Cold War paranoia to contemporary terrors.<|control11|><|separator|>