Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Plotinus

Plotinus (c. 204/5–270 CE) was a Greco-Roman philosopher best known as the founder of Neoplatonism, a school of thought that synthesized Platonic ideas with elements of Aristotle, Stoicism, and mysticism to form a comprehensive metaphysical system emphasizing the soul's ascent to divine unity.^[1]^[2] Born in Lycopolis (modern Asyut) in Upper Egypt, Plotinus pursued philosophy from an early age but was dissatisfied with initial teachers until, at around age 28, he discovered Ammonius Saccas in Alexandria, under whom he studied for eleven years, absorbing a blend of Platonic and Eastern influences.^[3] In 244 CE, he joined the emperor Gordian III's ill-fated military expedition to Persia and Mesopotamia to engage with Persian and Indian sages, but after the emperor's death, Plotinus relocated to Rome, where he founded a flourishing philosophical school that attracted prominent Romans, including senators.^[2]^[4] He lectured orally, emphasizing practical ethics and contemplation, and lived ascetically, founding a community for orphaned children and engaging in public service.^[3] Little is known of his personal life, as he avoided self-disclosure, but his disciple Porphyry provides the primary biographical account in the Vita Plotini (Life of Plotinus), portraying him as a sage-like figure who experienced mystical unions with the divine four times in his life.^[5] Plotinus died in 270 CE at a retreat in Campania, Italy, reportedly from a lingering illness, after entrusting his unpublished writings to Porphyry.^[1] Plotinus's philosophical corpus consists of 54 treatises, compiled and edited posthumously by Porphyry into the Enneads (from Greek enneas, "group of nine"), organized into six books of nine tracts each, covering topics from ethics and psychology to cosmology and theology.^[3]^[5] These works, written in Greek, were not systematically composed but arose from lectures and discussions, reflecting Plotinus's interpretive engagement with Plato's dialogues, particularly the Timaeus, Parmenides, and Republic.^[2] At the heart of Plotinus's system is a hierarchical ontology derived through emanation (proodos), where all existence flows necessarily and timelessly from the One (to hen), an utterly simple, ineffable principle transcending being, multiplicity, and description—neither mind nor substance, yet the source of all.^[1]^[6] From the One emanates the Intellect (nous), a divine mind containing eternal Forms and engaged in eternal contemplation of its source, producing multiplicity through its self-reflection; the Intellect in turn generates the Soul (psyche), which mediates between the intelligible and sensible realms, animating the material world while striving to maintain unity.^[2]^[7] This emanative process, likened to light radiating from the sun or water overflowing from a spring, is not a creation ex nihilo but an eternal overflow of goodness, with the material universe as the farthest, shadowy reflection where matter represents privation and non-being.^[6] Human souls, fallen into embodiment, achieve salvation through epistrophe (return), via purification, virtue, dialectic, and mystical ecstasy (henosis), culminating in non-discursive union with the One.^[2] Plotinus thus integrates ethics, epistemology, and metaphysics, viewing philosophy as a therapeutic path to divine likeness.^[1] Plotinus's ideas exerted profound influence on subsequent philosophy, theology, and culture, shaping early Christian thinkers like Augustine, who drew on Neoplatonism for his doctrines of God and the soul; Islamic philosophers such as Avicenna and Averroes; and the Renaissance revival of Platonism through figures like Marsilio Ficino, who translated the Enneads into Latin.^[1]^[8] His emphasis on emanation and mystical ascent also impacted medieval mysticism, German Idealism, and modern esoteric traditions, establishing Neoplatonism as a enduring framework for understanding reality's unity.^[9]

Biography

Early life and education

Plotinus was born around 204 CE in Lycopolis (also known as Lyco), a city in Upper Egypt, to parents whose ethnic origins—possibly Roman or Greek—remain uncertain due to the scarcity of biographical records.^[1] His early life is shrouded in obscurity, as he himself showed little interest in personal history, viewing the body and individual circumstances as secondary to the soul's immaterial essence.^[10] According to accounts by his disciple Porphyry, Plotinus was notably reluctant to discuss his lineage, homeland, or upbringing, aligning with his philosophical emphasis on transcending material biography.^[11] At approximately age 28, around 232 CE, he relocated to Alexandria, the bustling intellectual hub of the Roman Empire, to pursue studies in literature, rhetoric, and philosophy.^[1] There, he sampled lectures from several prominent professors but found initial dissatisfaction until discovering a profound teacher.^[10] The pivotal influence in Plotinus's education was Ammonius Saccas (c. 175–242 CE), a self-taught philosopher from a humble background who did not commit his ideas to writing but synthesized elements of Platonism and Aristotelianism, potentially incorporating Oriental concepts.^[12] Plotinus studied under Ammonius for eleven years, a formative period that instilled the core principles guiding his later thought.^[1] He also engaged with Alexandria's vibrant scholarly milieu, attending lectures by contemporaries such as the pagan philosopher Origen (distinct from the Christian theologian Origen), whose eclectic approach reflected the city's diverse intellectual currents.^[2] By around age 39, in 243 CE, Plotinus's curiosity about Eastern wisdom—particularly Persian and Indian philosophies—led him to join Emperor Gordian III's military campaign against Persia, seeking direct exposure to these traditions.^[1]

Expedition to Persia and time in Alexandria

After spending eleven years studying under Ammonius Saccas in Alexandria, Plotinus joined the military expedition led by Roman Emperor Gordian III against the Sasanian Empire in 243 CE. His primary motivation was to encounter and learn from Persian philosophers and the wisdom traditions of India, reflecting his broad intellectual curiosity beyond Greek thought.^[1]^[2] The campaign, aimed at countering Sasanian expansion and securing Roman frontiers in the East, proved disastrous. Gordian III was assassinated by his own troops in 244 CE near the city of Zaitha in Mesopotamia, leading to the collapse of the expedition and widespread chaos among the Roman forces. Plotinus survived the turmoil and fled to the safety of Antioch, where he briefly resided amid the political instability following the emperor's death.^[1]^[2] From Antioch, Plotinus relocated to Rome around 244 CE, at the age of forty, marking the end of his time in the Eastern Mediterranean and the beginning of his later philosophical activities in Italy.^[1]^[2]

Later years in Rome

Plotinus arrived in Rome around 244 CE, following the collapse of the Roman military expedition to Persia, and quickly established a successful school of philosophy that drew students from the city's elite circles, including senators and prominent women such as Gemina and her daughter.^[1] His lectures, delivered in Greek, focused on close readings of Plato and Aristotle alongside his own interpretations, fostering lively discussions that integrated philosophical inquiry with practical aspects of Roman life.^[1] Among the notable attendees was the senator Rogatianus, who, inspired by Plotinus's teachings, renounced his wealth, dismissed his slaves, and declined the praetorship to pursue a life of philosophical simplicity—a commitment that Plotinus frequently praised as exemplary.^[13] The school attracted a diverse group of dedicated students, with Amelius joining early in 245/246 CE and remaining until 268/269 CE, contributing to the intellectual vitality through his own writings and debates.^[14] Porphyry arrived around 263 CE, becoming one of Plotinus's closest disciples and participating actively in the school's activities until 268/269 CE, when he left for Sicily due to health issues.^[1] Other pupils, such as Castricius Firmus and Eustochius, also formed part of this community, which emphasized communal living and ascetic practices, including vegetarianism, to align daily conduct with philosophical ideals.^[15] During this period, Plotinus did not produce formal writings for publication; instead, his ideas were captured in treatises based on lecture notes, later compiled posthumously.^[1] Porphyry's Vita Plotini portrays Plotinus as a sage-like figure who achieved mystical union with the divine on four occasions during his life.^[14] In a notable political endeavor, Plotinus briefly gained the ear of Emperor Gallienus around 260 CE, proposing to revive an abandoned city in Campania as a model Platonic polity governed by the principles of the Republic, complete with communal property and ascetic rules; however, the plan failed due to opposition from the empress Salonina and court intriguers.^[1] This utopian experiment reflected Plotinus's vision for applying philosophy to societal reform, though it remained unrealized.^[16] In his later years, Plotinus's health deteriorated from a painful, disfiguring skin ailment—described by his biographer Porphyry in terms suggestive of a leprosy-like condition—that compelled him to withdraw from public teaching around 269 CE.^[1] He relocated to a friend's estate in Campania, known as Campotinus, where he attempted a small-scale communal living arrangement with select students, emphasizing simplicity, vegetarianism, and spiritual discipline amid his worsening condition.^[14] Plotinus died there in 270 CE at the age of 66, refusing a portrait or image of himself to underscore the soul's primacy over the body; his final words, as recorded by Porphyry, urged his companions to "bring back the god in yourselves to the divine in the All."^[1] His will entrusted his affairs to close associates, with Porphyry providing the primary account of these events in his Life of Plotinus.^[14]

Works

Composition and style

Plotinus was a reluctant writer who produced his 54 treatises, later compiled as the Enneads, primarily in response to questions from students or debates within his school, composing them in Greek over approximately two decades from around 253 to 270 CE.^[1] According to his disciple Porphyry, Plotinus delayed writing for the first ten years after establishing his school in Rome, only beginning after persistent encouragement from associates like Amelius and Porphyry himself, who urged him to record his oral teachings for wider circulation.^[1] These works emerged not from a premeditated systematic plan but from the immediate needs of philosophical discourse, reflecting an improvisational approach rather than a polished authorial intent. The style of Plotinus's writing is characteristically dense and aphoristic, marked by a non-systematic structure that prioritizes depth of insight over linear organization or rhetorical flourish.^[1] Porphyry describes it as concise and rich in thought, where ideas abound more than words, often conveyed through terse phrases and apt metaphors drawn from nature—such as light radiating from a source or liquid overflowing a vessel—to evoke metaphysical processes intuitively rather than through exhaustive logical deduction.^[17] This approach blends elements of Platonic dialogue, mythic imagery, and argumentative exploration, resulting in texts that are more abstract and ecstatic than Plato's conversational mode, with frequent repetitions and digressions that mirror the exploratory nature of live seminars.^[1] Many treatises originated from oral lectures or discussions, transcribed from notes taken by students like Porphyry, with minimal revisions by Plotinus himself, leading to a repetitive and unfolding structure that invites readers to engage actively with the ideas.^[1] The works vary significantly in length, from brief essays to more extended compositions, and lack chronological ordering in their original production, emphasizing intuitive apprehension over technical terminology. Written in Attic Greek, the language is accessible yet profoundly layered, avoiding overly specialized jargon to foster a direct, almost mystical grasp of philosophical truths.^[17]

The Enneads and editorial role of Porphyry

After Plotinus's death in 270 CE, his disciple Porphyry undertook the task of compiling and organizing the philosopher's writings, which consisted of 54 treatises derived from lectures and discussions delivered over nearly two decades in Rome. Around 300 CE, Porphyry arranged these into six Enneads, each containing nine treatises, for a total of 54 works structured in a 6x9 grid that served as a checksum for manuscript transmission integrity.^[18]^[19] This organization was thematic rather than chronological, with Ennead I addressing ethical topics such as virtues and the soul's descent, Ennead II covering physics and cosmology, Ennead III exploring providence and fate, Ennead IV focusing on the soul, Ennead V treating intellect and the Platonic forms, and Ennead VI delving into metaphysical principles like the One and unity.^[18]^[3] Porphyry's editorial choices emphasized conceptual coherence, grouping related ideas to facilitate study and interpretation, though this imposed a retrospective order on Plotinus's evolving thought.^[20] Porphyry prefaced the Enneads with his Life of Plotinus (Vita Plotini), a biographical account that details the philosopher's background, teaching methods, and intellectual circle, while also justifying the collection's arrangement and lightly editing the texts for grammatical clarity without altering their philosophical content.^[21] He added descriptive titles to each treatise, such as "On the Good" or "Against the Gnostics," to aid accessibility, drawing from Plotinus's own indications or the discussions' themes.^[3] This biography, included in all major editions, portrays Plotinus as a humble Platonist ascetic and underscores Porphyry's role in preserving the corpus against potential loss.^[22] The original autographs of Plotinus's treatises have not survived, and early Greek manuscripts were scarce, leading to a complex history of transmission through intermediaries.^[23] Key medieval pathways included partial Arabic translations of Enneads IV–VI from the ninth century, which circulated under the misattributed title Theology of Aristotle and influenced Islamic philosophy before Latin renderings reached the West.^[24] In the Latin tradition, Marsilio Ficino's 1492 translation from Greek into Latin marked the first complete edition available in Europe, printed in Venice and accompanied by Ficino's extensive commentary, which revived Plotinus's ideas during the Renaissance.^[25] Surviving Greek codices, such as the ninth-century Parisinus Graecus 1801 and the fourteenth-century Laurentianus 87.3, form the basis for reconstructing the text, supplemented by these translations.^[23] Modern scholarly editions build on Ficino's foundational work and the rediscovery of Greek manuscripts in the fifteenth century, prioritizing philological accuracy.^[20] The definitive critical edition is Plotini Opera, edited by Paul Henry and Hans-Rudolf Schwyzer in three volumes (1951–1973), which collates primary manuscripts, emends corruptions, and provides apparatus criticus for textual variants.^[21] This edition established the standard Greek text used in subsequent translations and studies. Authenticity debates have centered on a handful of minor treatises occasionally attributed to Plotinus, such as fragments on demons or theurgy, but the core 54 works of the Enneads are universally accepted as genuine, with Porphyry's thematic grouping enduring as a cornerstone of their legacy.^[20]^[26]

Philosophy

The One as ultimate reality

Plotinus conceives of the One—also identified with the Good—as the supreme principle and ultimate reality, utterly simple and indivisible, transcending all categories of being, essence, or multiplicity.^[1] This principle is not a being among beings but the source from which all existence derives, described as "beyond being" and the "begetter of being" rather than a participant in it.^[2] Drawing from Plato's Republic (VI, 509b), Plotinus interprets the Form of the Good as epkeina ts ousias (beyond essence), positioning the One as the ineffable origin that illuminates all reality without itself being illuminated.^[2] The One's transcendence places it above the levels of intellect and soul, rendering it inaccessible to discursive reason, sensory perception, or intellectual contemplation.^[1] It is self-sufficient and possesses no parts, attributes, or distinctions, embodying perfect unity that precludes any need for action or relation to other entities.^[2] Plotinus emphasizes its ineffability, stating that "we speak of it as the One only by an abuse of the term," since no positive predicates can apply without introducing multiplicity.^[2] Knowledge of the One is approached indirectly through apophasis (negation), stripping away all concepts to affirm what it is not, or through analogies such as the sun, which radiates light without depletion or the light depending on the sun for its existence.^[2] As the causal ground of all things, the One functions not as a temporal creator but as an eternal, overflowing source from which reality emanates without any diminution of its own perfection, akin to light proceeding from the sun.^[1] This causation is non-relational and superabundant, maintaining the One's absolute simplicity while accounting for the multiplicity in the cosmos.^[2] Plotinus critiques anthropomorphic conceptions of divinity, rejecting views that attribute will, desire, or personality to the ultimate principle, as these imply deficiency or relationality.^[2] He also distances the One from Aristotle's unmoved mover, which he sees as overly intellectual and thus subordinate to a higher, super-intellectual reality.^[2] These ideas are elaborated primarily in Enneads V.1–6, where Plotinus systematically unfolds the One's primacy, as in V.2.1, which asserts its priority over being and intellect.^[2] In VI.9, he further explores its simplicity and the limits of language in describing it, underscoring that the One "neither gives out nor takes in" but remains the unchanging fount of all.^[2]

Emanation and the hypostases

Plotinus's metaphysics centers on the concept of emanation, or prohodos, as the eternal and necessary procession of all reality from the One, arising from its infinite superabundance rather than any deliberate act of creation. This process is analogous to the effortless radiance emanating from a light source, where the overflow diminishes neither the source nor involves temporal sequence or spatial division; instead, it unfolds timelessly and maintains the unity of the whole. Unlike creation ex nihilo, emanation preserves the continuity of being, with lower levels participating in the higher without independence or separation.^[1]^[2] The resulting ontological hierarchy consists of three primary hypostases, each representing a successive stage of procession from the One while aspiring to revert toward it. The first hypostasis is Nous, or Intellect, which emerges as the immediate product of the One's self-contemplation, constituting the realm of eternal, intelligible Forms in a state of perfect unity-in-multiplicity. In Nous, being and thought are identical, and it eternally contemplates the One, thereby sustaining its own existence through this intellectual activity; this hypostasis embodies the fullest participation in the One's simplicity yet introduces distinction through the plurality of Forms.^[1]^[2] The second hypostasis, Psyche or Soul, proceeds from Nous through a similar contemplative overflow, serving as the mediating principle between the intelligible and sensible realms. Psyche contemplates Nous, internalizing its Forms as logos (rational principles), and in turn generates the ordered cosmos by projecting these principles outward into multiplicity; this generative activity establishes the temporal and spatial structure of the material world without compromising the soul's unity. As the last truly active hypostasis, Psyche bridges the eternal and the changing, ensuring the harmony of the universe.^[1]^[2] At the base of the hierarchy lies matter (hylē), not as a positive substance or independent entity, but as the lowest level of reality—a formless potentiality, privation, and shadow of true being that receives but cannot retain the illuminations from higher hypostases. Matter represents the extreme of indefiniteness and non-being, arising as the indeterminate remainder in the procession, yet it is not inherently evil but merely deficient in form and goodness; this view rejects Gnostic dualism, which posits matter as an antagonistic force created by a malevolent demiurge, affirming instead that emanation integrates all levels within a unified, descending continuum of reality.^[1]^[2] Complementing procession is the complementary movement of epistrophe, or reversion, whereby each hypostasis and all derived entities turn back toward their source in a cyclical dynamic that restores unity. This aspiration ensures that nothing in the hierarchy is static or isolated; Nous reverts to the One through contemplation, Psyche to Nous via intellectual vision, and even matter indirectly participates by receiving form from the soul, preventing total alienation. Plotinus illustrates this hierarchical diminution using mathematical analogies, such as a geometric progression where reality decreases in intensity across levels, akin to numbers receding from unity (e.g., from 1 to 2, 4, etc., with increasing multiplicity and loss of perfection).^[1]^[2] These doctrines are elaborated in key treatises, notably Ennead V.1 ("On the Three Primary Hypostases"), which outlines the procession from the One through Intellect and Soul, and Ennead III.8 ("On Contemplation"), which details the contemplative mechanism driving both emanation and reversion across the hypostases.^[1]^[2]

The nature of the soul and intellect

Plotinus conceives of the human soul as consisting of a higher, undescended part that remains divine and intimately united with the Intellect (Nous) in the intelligible realm, while its lower aspects descend to animate the body through rational governance, sensation, and vegetative functions such as growth and nutrition.^[1] This undescended portion ensures the soul's essential continuity with the divine order, preventing complete immersion in corporeality, though there is debate among scholars regarding the extent of the soul's descent, with interpretations varying between full immersion and a mere projection of lower powers.^[1]^[27]^[28] Central to Plotinus's anthropology is the immortality of the soul, which he affirms as eternal and pre-existent to the body, drawing on Platonic precedents to argue against materialist views that would limit it to temporal existence.^[28] In Ennead IV.7, he systematically refutes Epicurean and Stoic doctrines positing the soul as corporeal or dissolvable, insisting instead that its incorporeal nature renders it impervious to generation and decay.^[29] The soul's descent into matter is not a punitive fall but a voluntary engagement for experiential purposes, allowing it to contemplate the sensible world as a shadow of the intelligible; reincarnation may occur as a means of purification, enabling progressive return toward its origin.^[30] The Intellect, or Nous, represents the divine mind as the second hypostasis emanating from the One, serving as the paradigmatic realm of eternal forms and the primary object of contemplative ascent for the soul.^[31] Human intellect participates in this divine Nous through a process of recollection (anamnesis), whereby the soul recovers innate knowledge of intelligible realities it once contemplated prior to embodiment, facilitating intellectual purification and alignment with the eternal.^[32] This participation underscores the soul's amphibious character, bridging the sensible and intelligible domains without fully severing its ties to the higher realm.^[31] Regarding the body-soul relation, Plotinus echoes Plato's Phaedo in portraying the body as a kind of prison or limitation for the soul, constraining its freedom through sensory distractions and passions, yet he mitigates stark dualism by emphasizing the soul's creative agency in shaping and informing the body as an image of intelligible principles.^[33] The body is not inherently evil but a necessary vehicle for the soul's descent and activity in the material order, with the soul imparting order and harmony to it through its immanent presence.^[33] In Ennead IV as a whole, particularly tracts 3–4 and 7–8, Plotinus elaborates these themes, countering materialist reductions of the soul to bodily functions while affirming its superior, incorporeal essence.^[30]

Ethics, happiness, and henosis

Plotinus conceives of happiness, or eudaimonia, not as residing in external goods, bodily pleasures, or even virtuous actions alone, but as the soul's assimilation to the divine (homoiosis theoi), a concept drawn from Plato's Theaetetus (176a–b).^[34] This assimilation involves the soul's return to its higher nature through intellectual contemplation and moral virtue, enabling it to participate in the eternal and unchanging realm of the Forms.^[35] In Ennead I.4, Plotinus argues that true well-being is located in the soul's alignment with the intelligible world, independent of contingent circumstances, thereby transcending the limitations of earthly existence.^[36] Central to Plotinus's ethical framework is a hierarchy of virtues that guides the soul's progression toward eudaimonia. The civic virtues, akin to those in Plato's Republic, focus on social harmony and the restraint of passions to maintain justice and moderation in communal life.^[35] These give way to purificatory virtues, which emphasize detachment from the body and material concerns, purifying the soul from irrational desires and attachments that bind it to the sensible world. At the highest level are the paradigmatic or theological virtues, which involve contemplative assimilation to the divine Intellect, where the soul contemplates the eternal Forms and achieves a godlike state of wisdom and unity.^[37] This progression marks a shift from the political life of civic duty to the contemplative life, where virtue becomes a means of intellectual ascent rather than mere practical restraint.^[38] The ultimate goal of this ethical ascent is henosis, the mystical union of the soul with the One, described as a temporary state of ecstatic transcendence beyond even the Intellect.^[39] Unlike intellectual contemplation, which remains within duality, henosis involves a dissolution of the soul's individuality into the ineffable unity of the One, often experienced as a flash of vision or rapture.^[40] Plotinus attains this through philosophical eros (love), which propels the soul upward as a longing for the divine source, combined with dialectic as a method of purifying thought and negating multiplicity.^[39] He advocates contemplative practices such as inward meditation and self-examination, eschewing ritual magic or theurgy, which later Neoplatonists like Iamblichus would emphasize.^[41] Beauty plays a pivotal role in facilitating this ascent, serving as a bridge from the sensible to the intelligible and ultimately to the One. In Ennead I.6, "On Beauty," Plotinus describes how the soul is initially drawn to physical beauty in bodies, arts, and nature, recognizing it as a reflection of higher, Form-like symmetry and harmony.^[42] This attraction prompts an inner turn, leading the soul to contemplate the intelligible beauties of virtue and the Forms, and finally to transcend even these toward the supreme Beauty of the Good. Thus, beauty functions not as an end but as a dynamic force (eros) guiding ethical and mystical progress.^[43] Plotinus critiques hedonism, particularly Epicurean variants, for reducing eudaimonia to pleasure, an absurdity that would equate the good life of humans with that of animals driven by mere sensation.^[44] He similarly challenges Stoic ethics for tying happiness too closely to rational autonomy and external indifferents, arguing that true freedom and well-being arise only through transcendence of the self toward divine union, not self-sufficiency within the material cosmos.^[36] In Ennead I.4, he reframes earlier eudaimonist traditions, including Stoicism, by insisting that virtue's reward lies in intellectual and mystical elevation, not in immanent control or absence of disturbance.^[35]

Relationship to other philosophies

Interpretation and development of Platonism

Plotinus positioned himself as a faithful interpreter of Plato, reviving and systematizing what he viewed as the core of Platonic philosophy, particularly its unwritten doctrines that emphasized a transcendent principle beyond being. He drew on Plato's allusions to the One in dialogues such as the Republic (509b) and Parmenides (137c–142a), interpreting it as the ultimate source of all reality, a concept rooted in Presocratic rationalism and Plato's esoteric teachings. This revival transformed Plato's scattered hints into a coherent metaphysical hierarchy, where the One stands above the Forms as the ineffable origin.^[1] In developing Platonism, Plotinus harmonized Plato's ideas with Aristotelian elements to address potential inconsistencies, notably identifying Plato's Intellect with Aristotle's unmoved mover from Metaphysics Lambda. This synthesis resolved tensions between Plato's theory of Forms and Aristotle's critique in Metaphysics M and N, portraying Intellect as the first emanation from the One that contemplates eternal truths. By incorporating Aristotle's emphasis on causality and potentiality, Plotinus created a unified system that preserved Platonic transcendence while engaging Peripatetic logic.^[1]^[45] Plotinus innovated upon Plato by introducing the doctrine of emanation to explain the procession of the Forms from the One, a process of necessary overflow rather than deliberate craftsmanship. Unlike Plato's Demiurge in the Timaeus, which fashions the cosmos from pre-existing matter, emanation depicts reality as a dynamic, timeless descent from unity to multiplicity, with the Forms residing in Intellect as objects of eternal contemplation. This shift emphasized interiority and mystical ascent (henosis), prioritizing personal philosophical experience over Plato's dialogical method, encouraging the soul's return to the One through contemplation rather than civic discourse.^[1]^[46] Influenced by Middle Platonists, Plotinus built on figures like Numenius of Apamea, who posited a triad of gods echoing Platonic principles, and Gaius, whose commentaries on the Timaeus shaped his cosmological views. Numenius's distinction between a transcendent first god and a secondary creator informed Plotinus's hypostases, while Gaius's interpretations of Plato's unwritten doctrines reinforced the esoteric nature of true philosophy. Plotinus's teaching style, delivered orally in seminars reminiscent of Plato's Academy, maintained this esotericism, reserving deeper insights for committed students and avoiding public written exposition until edited by Porphyry.^[47]^[48] Plotinus critiqued overly literal readings of Platonic myths, rejecting temporal creation in the Timaeus as a pedagogical device rather than historical fact, insisting the cosmos is eternal and its generation timeless. He prioritized metaphysics over politics, viewing Plato's Republic as an allegory for the soul's internal harmony rather than a blueprint for governance, thus elevating contemplative philosophy above practical affairs. This approach purified Platonism from materialist or anthropomorphic distortions, focusing on the soul's ascent to immaterial realities.^[46]^[1] Although modern scholars label Plotinus's philosophy "Neoplatonism"—a term coined in early 19th-century European scholarship to denote his synthesis of Plato with later developments—Plotinus himself claimed to expound pure Platonism without innovation. He saw his work as recovering Plato's authentic voice, unadulterated by later misinterpretations.^[49]

Critiques of Gnosticism and other contemporaries

Plotinus's treatise Ennead II.9, known as "Against the Gnostics," represents his most explicit polemical engagement with contemporary Gnostic thought, particularly the Sethian sect that had infiltrated his own philosophical circle in Rome. In this work, he systematically refutes the Gnostic dualistic cosmology, which posits matter as an inherently evil product of a flawed demiurge, a lesser deity responsible for a botched creation. Instead, Plotinus defends the Platonic tradition by asserting that the material world emerges through a necessary and benevolent emanation from the One, with matter serving as a receptive potential for intelligible forms rather than an ontological prison.^[50] Central to Plotinus's critique is the rejection of the Gnostic view of the soul's descent as an involuntary fall or cosmic error, which he counters by emphasizing the soul's voluntary involvement in embodiment as an act of providential care for the lower levels of reality. He portrays the universe not as a site of alienation or malice but as a harmonious structure where even matter contributes to the overall goodness of emanation, thereby preserving the optimism of his metaphysics against Gnostic pessimism. This polemic extended beyond Plotinus himself, as his student Amelius composed additional rebuttals to specific Gnostic texts circulating in the school, highlighting the intensity of these internal debates.^[51]^[52] Beyond Gnosticism, Plotinus directed sharp criticisms at other rival philosophies of his time, including Epicurean materialism, which he condemned for reducing reality to atoms moving by chance, thereby denying the purposeful order of emanation and the soul's higher aspirations. He likewise dismissed Skepticism's suspension of judgment (epochē) as a barrier to genuine truth-seeking, arguing that it abdicates the intellect's capacity for certain knowledge of the intelligible realm through dialectical ascent. While incorporating Pythagorean elements like numerical symbolism into his system, Plotinus critiqued excesses in Pythagorean esotericism that elevated secretive rituals and mystical interpretations over rational philosophical inquiry.^[53]^[54]^[55] Plotinus's opposition to astrology and magic, detailed in Enneads II.3–8, further illustrates his broader defense of free will against deterministic contemporaries. He reinterprets celestial bodies as ensouled entities participating in cosmic sympathy—a interconnected harmony—rather than as inexorable fates dictating human events, insisting that individual agency prevails over astral influences. Magic, in his view, exploits this sympathy through lower psychic manipulations but remains inferior to the contemplative ascent of philosophy, which aligns the soul with the divine without coercive arts. These treatises exemplify Plotinus's method of composing polemics in response to lively discussions within his Roman school, where diverse views from students and visitors prompted targeted refutations to safeguard his Neoplatonic synthesis.^[56]^[57]

Opposition to astrology and magic

Plotinus critiqued deterministic astrology, rejecting the notion that celestial bodies compel human fate through mechanical causation. In Ennead II.3 ["On Whether the Stars are Causes"], he argues that the stars and planets are ensouled living beings, animated by the World Soul, which operates through universal sympathy—a interconnected harmony pervading the cosmos—rather than rigid determinism.^[58] This sympathy allows for subtle influences on earthly events, such as climatic or temperamental tendencies, but does not override individual agency.^[59] Drawing from Plato's Timaeus, Plotinus portrays the heavens as part of a providential order where the stars signify rather than dictate outcomes, much like signs in nature indicate possibilities without enforcing them.^[60] Central to Plotinus's defense of free will is the hierarchical structure of the soul, where the higher aspect originates from the Intellect and remains immune to lower celestial influences. Horoscopes, he contends, may predict general dispositions or environmental alignments but cannot bind the rational soul's capacity for choice and ascent toward the divine.^[58] In Ennead IV.4 ["Problems of the Soul"], he extends this to emphasize that true freedom arises from aligning the soul with the One, transcending material causation altogether.^[59] This view aligns with Platonic ideas in the Laws on cosmic soul and providence, while diverging from Stoic fatalism by prioritizing intellectual transcendence over passive acceptance of cosmic necessity.^[60] Regarding magic, Plotinus dismissed it as a manipulative practice reliant on material sympathies, such as herbs, stones, or incantations, which exploit lower natural connections but fail to achieve genuine spiritual elevation. In Ennead IV.4, he describes magic as operating through the irrational parts of the soul and the body's affinities, potentially causing temporary effects like illusions or emotional disturbances, yet inherently limited and inferior to philosophical purification.^[56] Unlike prayer, which he sees as a contemplative alignment with the divine, magic seeks coercive control over sympathetic forces, inverting the proper ascent from matter to intellect.^[61] Plotinus's opposition reflects the cultural prevalence of Hellenistic magical practices, positioning his Neoplatonism as a transcendent alternative that safeguards human dignity against superstitious determinism.^[56]

Legacy and influence

In late antiquity and the ancient world

Plotinus's death in 270 CE marked not the end of his philosophical school but its institutionalization and expansion, with Neoplatonism emerging as the culminating phase of the Platonic Academy in late antiquity. His closest disciple, Porphyry (c. 234–305 CE), played a pivotal role by compiling and editing Plotinus's treatises into the organized collection known as the Enneads, which systematized his teachings on emanation, the soul, and the One for broader dissemination.^[62] Porphyry, a key member of Plotinus's school in Rome, relocated to Sicily in 268 CE due to health issues, where he continued his scholarly work, applying Plotinian metaphysics to critique contemporary ideologies, most notably in his work Against the Christians. This treatise drew directly on Plotinus's rationalist framework to challenge Christian doctrines, positioning Neoplatonism as a bulwark for pagan intellectual traditions amid Christianity's growing influence.^[63] Porphyry's student Iamblichus (c. 245–325 CE) further developed the tradition by founding a school in Apamea, Syria, where he integrated theurgy—ritual practices aimed at divine union—into Plotinus's contemplative philosophy, arguing that such rites complemented intellectual ascent to the divine.^[62] This synthesis of theory and practice influenced subsequent Neoplatonists, including Syrianus (d. 437 CE), who headed the Athenian Academy and emphasized hierarchical emanations in his commentaries on Aristotle and Plato. Under Syrianus's successor, Proclus (412–485 CE), Neoplatonism reached its most systematic form, with comprehensive treatises like the Elements of Theology that elaborated Plotinus's hypostases into a structured metaphysical system, viewing the Academy as the guardian of ancient wisdom.^[49] The school's final leaders, including Proclus's successors Ammonius (d. c. 517 CE) and Damascius (c. 458–538 CE), sustained Neoplatonic teaching in Athens until Emperor Justinian's edict closed the Academy in 529 CE, effectively ending organized pagan philosophy in the Roman world.^[49] Among the last pagan philosophers, Simplicius of Cilicia (c. 490–560 CE) exemplified Plotinus's enduring impact through his extensive commentaries on Aristotle, which harmonized Aristotelian logic with Plotinian metaphysics, such as the soul's immaterial nature, thereby preserving pagan synthesis for later Byzantine scholarship.^[64] During the 3rd to 6th centuries CE, Plotinus's texts faced losses in the West following the fall of Rome in 476 CE, with original manuscripts vulnerable to the era's upheavals, but they endured in the East through Byzantine copies and Arabic intermediaries like the 9th-century Theology of Aristotle, a paraphrase of parts of the Enneads that transmitted core ideas on the soul and intellect.^[65] Overall, Neoplatonism under these successors elevated philosophy as a counter to Christian dominance, fostering a pagan cultural renaissance that bridged classical antiquity to medieval learning.^[49]

On Christianity, Islam, and Judaism

Plotinus's philosophy exerted a profound indirect influence on Christian theology primarily through the works of Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite in the 5th–6th century CE, who adapted the Neoplatonic concept of emanation to articulate the Christian doctrine of the Trinity and the structure of the celestial hierarchy. In his Celestial Hierarchy, Pseudo-Dionysius describes a hierarchical order of angels mediating divine light from God to humanity, mirroring Plotinus's emanation from the One through Intellect and Soul, while integrating it with Christian notions of divine unity and procession.^[66] This framework influenced later Christian thinkers, including St. Augustine, who briefly referenced Plotinus's Enneads in his Confessions (Book VII) as a catalyst for his conversion, appreciating the philosopher's insights into the incorporeal nature of God and the soul's illumination, though Augustine critiqued and Christianized these ideas to align with scriptural revelation.^[67] Thomas Aquinas, in the 13th century, encountered Plotinian themes via Arabic intermediaries such as Avicenna, incorporating emanationist hierarchies into his synthesis of faith and reason in works like the Summa Theologica, where he adapted the notion of divine procession to explain the relations within the Trinity without endorsing pagan emanation as creation ex nihilo.^[68] In Islamic philosophy, Plotinus's ideas were transmitted through 9th-century Arabic translations and adaptations, notably the Theology of Aristotle, a paraphrase of Enneads IV–VI misattributed to Aristotle, which profoundly shaped early Muslim metaphysicians. Al-Kindi (d. c. 873), the first major Islamic philosopher, integrated the One as the simple, transcendent cause of all being into his On First Philosophy, viewing creation as an overflow from divine unity while harmonizing it with Quranic monotheism. Al-Farabi (d. 950) further developed emanation in his political and metaphysical treatises, positing a chain of intellects emanating from the First Cause (God) to govern the cosmos and human society, echoing Plotinus's hypostases but subordinating them to prophetic revelation.^[69] Avicenna (Ibn Sina, d. 1037) systematized these elements in his Metaphysics of the Healing, where the Necessary Existent (God) emanates the universe through intellect without diminishing itself, blending Plotinian overflow with Aristotelian causality to establish a foundational Islamic metaphysics. This influence extended to Sufi mysticism, as seen in Ibn Arabi (d. 1240), whose doctrine of wahdat al-wujud (unity of being) resonates with Plotinus's henosis—the soul's return to the One—depicting creation as manifestations of divine reality and mystical union as ecstatic absorption in the divine essence.^[70] Jewish thought absorbed Plotinian elements via Hellenistic precursors like Philo of Alexandria (1st century CE), who prefigured emanation in his allegorical interpretations of creation as divine logos proceeding from God, and through medieval Neoplatonic channels.^[71] In Kabbalah, the Zohar (late 13th century) incorporates emanation in its sefirot system, portraying a hierarchical overflow from the infinite Ein Sof (analogous to the One) through ten divine emanations structuring reality, influencing Jewish mystical cosmology to emphasize ascent toward divine unity.^[72] Maimonides (d. 1204), while critiquing emanation as incompatible with creation ex nihilo in his Guide for the Perplexed, nonetheless employed a Neoplatonic hierarchy of separate intellects mediating divine providence and prophecy, adapting Plotinian transcendence to affirm God's utter simplicity and ineffability within Jewish rationalism. The transmission of Plotinus's works to the Abrahamic world occurred largely via Arabic translations in 9th-century Baghdad under the Abbasid caliphate, where Greek texts were rendered into Arabic by scholars like those in al-Kindi's circle, facilitating the cross-pollination of ideas.^[73] Common themes include God (or the One) as beyond being and description, with creation as a necessary overflow rather than arbitrary act, fostering negative theology—describing divinity by what it is not—to preserve transcendence.^[74] These integrations sparked debates, with critics accusing Neoplatonism of pagan pantheism that diluted monotheism, yet proponents Christianized, Islamized, and Judaized core ideas, as in Pseudo-Dionysius's apophatic approach, which emphasized divine unknowability to reconcile Plotinus with orthodoxy.^[75]

In the Renaissance, Enlightenment, and modern West

The rediscovery of Plotinus in the Renaissance began with Marsilio Ficino's Latin translation of the Enneads, published in Florence in 1492, which made the philosopher's works accessible to Western scholars for the first time since antiquity.^[25] This translation not only revived Neoplatonism but also integrated Plotinus into the humanist curriculum, portraying him as a bridge between Plato and Christian theology.^[76] Ficino's commentary emphasized Plotinus's emanation theory as a metaphysical framework for divine love and cosmic harmony, influencing key figures like Giovanni Pico della Mirandola, who drew on these ideas in his syncretic philosophy to explore human dignity and the ascent of the soul.^[77] In art, Sandro Botticelli's Primavera (c. 1482) has been interpreted as an allegorical depiction of Plotinian emanation, with figures like Zephyrus and Chloris symbolizing the soul's descent into matter and its potential return to the divine through Venus as a mediator of intellectual beauty.^[78] In the 17th century, the Cambridge Platonists adapted Plotinus to counter emerging materialist philosophies. Benjamin Whichcote, often regarded as the movement's founder, invoked Plotinus's concepts of the soul and intellect to argue for an immaterial, divine order underlying reality, promoting a rational spirituality against mechanistic views.^[79] Ralph Cudworth, in his The True Intellectual System of the Universe (1678), extensively cited Plotinus to defend innate ideas and the eternity of the intellect, using emanation as evidence for a purposeful cosmos beyond atomic chance.^[80] These thinkers positioned Plotinus as a bulwark for religious tolerance and anti-materialism, blending his metaphysics with Christian ethics to influence English intellectual life. During the Enlightenment and Romantic eras, Plotinus's mystical elements resonated with German idealists seeking alternatives to rationalism. Johann Wolfgang von Goethe encountered Neoplatonism through translations and associates like Johann Gottfried Herder, incorporating Plotinian themes of emanation and the soul's striving toward unity in works like Faust, where the pursuit of the infinite echoes the philosopher's vision of divine overflow.^[81] Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Schelling studied Plotinus directly, viewing his hierarchy of being as a precursor to dynamic idealism, with the One as an absolute productivity akin to nature's self-unfolding.^[8] Arthur Schopenhauer, an avid reader of the Enneads, echoed Plotinus's emanation in his concept of the will as a blind, overflowing force manifesting the world, though he critiqued its optimism; this parallel framed the universe as an irrational drive toward representation, influencing his pessimism.^[82] In modern philosophy, Plotinus's ontology informed existential and process thinkers. Martin Heidegger engaged with Plotinus's notion of being as an infinitive process of presencing, seeing parallels to his own inquiry into Sein (Being) as withdrawal and emergence, though he rejected Neoplatonic hierarchies as metaphysical forgetfulness.^[83] Alfred North Whitehead's process philosophy drew indirectly on Plotinian emanation through a panentheistic view of creativity, where the divine lures the universe toward novel intensities, akin to the Intellect's eternal contemplation.^[84] In psychology, Carl Gustav Jung likened Plotinus's Nous (Intellect) to the collective unconscious's archetypes, interpreting them as primordial forms mediating the soul's integration and ascent to wholeness.^[85] The 20th century saw renewed scholarly engagement through A.H. Armstrong's definitive English translation of the Enneads in the Loeb Classical Library (1966–1988), which facilitated precise analysis and broadened access beyond earlier poetic renditions. In analytic philosophy, Plotinus faced critiques for his esoteric style and reliance on metaphor, often dismissed as obscurantist mysticism incompatible with empirical rigor.^[86] Conversely, continental philosophers revived him as a practitioner of philosophy as spiritual exercise; Pierre Hadot, in works like Plotinus or the Simplicity of Vision (1963), portrayed Plotinus's thought as transformative exercises in contemplation and detachment, influencing post-structuralists and phenomenologists to view metaphysics as lived ethics.^[87]

Cross-cultural impacts in India and beyond

In the 19th and 20th centuries, Theosophical thinkers, particularly Helena Blavatsky, drew parallels between Plotinus's Neoplatonism and Indian philosophies such as Vedanta and the Upanishads, positing a shared esoteric wisdom that bridged ancient traditions. Blavatsky interpreted Plotinus's concept of the One as akin to Brahman, the ultimate reality in Vedantic thought, and his doctrine of emanation as resonant with maya, the illusory manifestation of the divine in Hindu metaphysics.^[88] These linkages positioned Neoplatonism as a Western counterpart to Eastern non-dualism, influencing Theosophical efforts to synthesize global spiritualities during colonial encounters in India. Scholarly works have since explored these affinities, noting structural similarities in the hierarchical descent from unity to multiplicity, though direct historical transmission remains debated. Modern comparative philosophy has further highlighted resonances between Plotinus's emanative cosmology and Indian ontology, with essays examining shared motifs like the soul's ascent to the transcendent and the illusory nature of material plurality. For instance, R. Baine Harris's edited volume compiles analyses of how Plotinus's Intellect mirrors aspects of Upanishadic atman-brahman unity, emphasizing conceptual overlaps without positing causal influence.^[89] Such comparisons underscore Neoplatonism's role in fostering intercultural dialogues, as seen in 20th-century Indian scholarship that integrates Plotinian ideas into interpretations of Advaita Vedanta. In East Asia, Plotinus's ideas reached China and Japan indirectly through Jesuit translations of classical Western philosophy during the 16th to 18th centuries, which included Platonic and Neoplatonic texts alongside Confucian classics. These comparisons highlight how Neoplatonism informs contemporary East Asian philosophy's efforts to reconcile transcendence and immanence.^[90] In the Middle East and Africa, Plotinus's revival intersects with Islamic modernism and decolonial thought. Muhammad Iqbal, a key figure in 20th-century Islamic revivalism, critiqued Neoplatonic influences on medieval Islamic philosophy—such as emanationism in Avicenna—as deviations from dynamic Quranic selfhood, yet drew selectively on Plotinus to advocate a reconstructed metaphysics emphasizing action and ego (khudi) over static unity.^[91] Iqbal's engagement, evident in his analysis of Persian metaphysics, repurposed Neoplatonic elements to counter colonial rationalism, fostering a modernist Islam that integrates philosophical heritage with renewal. In African contexts, decolonial philosophers identify parallels between Plotinus's ontology of matter as non-being and indigenous ontologies, such as those of the Nso' people in Cameroon, where evil and materiality are seen as privations within a holistic spiritual framework.^[92] These affinities support decolonial projects reclaiming non-Western relational cosmologies against Eurocentric dualisms.^[92] Globally, Plotinus features in UNESCO initiatives promoting world philosophy, such as World Philosophy Day events that contextualize Neoplatonism within diverse traditions to foster intercultural understanding.^[93] Digital resources like the Perseus Project provide open-access Greek and English editions of the Enneads, enhancing accessibility, though translations into non-European languages remain limited—recent Chinese renditions of the Enneads mark progress, but Indian and African vernacular versions are scarce, hindering broader engagement. This incompleteness underscores ongoing challenges in globalizing Plotinian scholarship. Debates persist on whether these cross-cultural impacts stem from orientalist projections or genuine syncretism, particularly regarding Ammonius Saccas's possible exposure to Indian ideas during Plotinus's brief participation in Emperor Gordian's Persian expedition around 242 CE, aimed at studying Eastern philosophies.^[1] Some scholars speculate Ammonius's background—potentially non-Greek—facilitated such exchanges, as explored in analyses of Neoplatonic reception of yogic elements via the Indian Ocean trade.^[94] However, most evidence favors parallel developments over direct borrowing, emphasizing independent evolutions in mystical ontology.^[95]

References

[1]
Plotinus - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Sep 25, 2024 · Plotinus is generally regarded as the founder of Late Antique Platonism, sometimes termed “Neoplatonism”, a school of thought that,
[2]
Plotinus | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Plotinus is considered to be the founder of Neoplatonism. Taking his lead from his reading of Plato, Plotinus developed a complex spiritual cosmology.
[3]
Porphyry on Plotinus. Ennead I - Harvard University Press
Practically nothing is known of his early life, but at the age of 28 he went to Alexandria, and studied philosophy with Ammonius “Saccas” for eleven years.
[4]
Plotinus - Philosophy - Oxford Bibliographies
Oct 30, 2019 · Dillon 1988 and Henry 1991 provide helpful overviews of Plotinus's philosophy. O'Meara 1993 is a solid monograph-length introduction to the main ...
[5]
Porphyry on the Life of Plotinus. Ennead I - Loeb Classical Library
Plotinus (204/5–270 CE) was the first and greatest of Neoplatonic philosophers. His writings were edited by his disciple Porphyry.
[6]
The Derivation of All Things from the One (I) | Plotinus
Plotinus himself uses images of water or light 'emanating' (flowing) from a source in order to describe things coming from the One. However, he is well aware ...<|separator|>
[7]
(DOC) An Evaluation of Plotinus' Theory of Emanation - Academia.edu
Plotinus' theory of emanation proposes that the material universe originates from a transcendental first principle known as the One.
[8]
Plotinus' Legacy: The Transformation of Platonism from the ...
Jan 15, 2020 · Plotinus (204/5-270 CE) has an unusually complex profile, especially in the modern history of philosophy. He explicitly claimed to be nothing more than an ...
[9]
Plotinus (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy/Fall 2022 Edition)
Jun 30, 2003 · He is one of the most influential philosophers in antiquity after Plato and Aristotle. The term 'Neoplatonism' is an invention of early 19th ...
[10]
Plotinus | Ancient Philosopher & Mystic | Britannica
Plotinus (born 205 ce, Lyco, or Lycopolis, Egypt?—died 270, Campania) was an ancient philosopher, the centre of an influential circle of intellectuals and men ...
[11]
Porphyry: On the Life of Plotinus and the Arrangement of his Work
1. Plotinus, the philosopher our contemporary, seemed ashamed of being in the body. So deeply rooted was this feeling that he could never be induced to tell ...
[12]
Ammonius (2) Saccas | Oxford Classical Dictionary
Ammonius (2) Saccas, of Alexandria (1), Platonist philosopher, active in first half of 3rd cent. ce, famous as the teacher of Plotinus.Missing: early life education
[13]
[PDF] Remarks on the so-called Plotinus' Sarcophagus ('Vatican Museums ...
Rogatianus renounced all of his possessions, dismissed all of his slaves and even resigned his position as senator. When he became a praetor, and was to be ...
[14]
On the Life of Plotinus and the Order of His Books by Porphyry of Tyre
Dec 16, 2017 · Amelius went to Plotinus in the third year of Philip's reign [CE 245/6] and stayed until40 the first year of Claudius' [CE 268/9] so that he was ...
[15]
Plotinus - Classics - Oxford Bibliographies
Plotinus (205–270 CE) is considered to be the founder of Neoplatonism. Pupil of Ammonius Saccas, he taught in Rome from 244 to 269. Amelius and Porphyry are ...
[16]
Plotinus' Plan to Save the Roman Empire - Classical Wisdom
Sep 15, 2022 · Plotinus was not able to fully revive the Roman Empire and reverse the trend of decline, he had in the attempt a kind of accomplishment.Missing: arrived | Show results with:arrived
[17]
[PDF] Plotinus on Individuation: a Study of Ennead V. 7 [18]
Plotinus is increasingly seen as a valuable source for feminist research and work in philosophy, religion, and pedagogy. Cooper (2007: 78) has identified ...
[18]
Porphyry's Arrangement of the Enneads - Cambridge University Press
May 25, 2022 · Porphyry's Arrangement of the Enneads. Published online by Cambridge University Press: 25 May 2022. Edited by. Lloyd Gerson ...Missing: compilation scholarly
[19]
[PDF] Porphyry, Eusebius, and Late Ancient Tables of Contents
Hans-Rudolph Schwyzer, eds., Plotini ... translations of 54 treatises in (Porphyry's) chronological order. The recent English translation of Gerson et al., En-.
[20]
Plotinus and Modern Scholarship: From Ficino to the Twenty-First ...
Introduction. The history of modern scholarship on Plotinus has been to a large extent the history of the establishment of a reliable text and of ...
[21]
https://www.loebclassics.com/view/LCL440/1969/pb_LCL440.xxix.xml
[22]
Six Enneads - by Plotinus - Christian Classics Ethereal Library
The Enneads were compiled by Plotinus' student, Porphyry, who gathered together his teacher's essays and arranged and edited them himself. These writings ...
[23]
Some manuscript traditions of the Greek classics
Plotinus. The philosopher Plotinus composed his Enneads in the 3rd century AD. Manuscripts: A, Florence, Laurentianus 87, 3. E, Paris BNF graecus 1976. B ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[24]
https://brill.com/downloadpdf/book/edcoll/9789047419471/Bej.9789004156418.i-536_020.pdf
[25]
Florence, 1492: The Reappearance of Plotinus*
Nov 20, 2018 · In the western world, Plotinus was only a name until 1492. None of his treatises had been translated during the Middle Ages, ...Missing: Marsilius | Show results with:Marsilius
[26]
The Enneads Research Papers - Academia.edu
The Enneads is a collection of writings by the Neoplatonist philosopher Plotinus, compiled by his student Porphyry. It consists of six groups of nine ...
[27]
Plotinus on Individuation - Project MUSE
Feb 27, 2025 · A human being, according to Plotinus, consists of three phases of the soul: a higher soul that remains in the intelligible world, a lower soul ( ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[28]
Soul and Body | Plotinus: An Introduction to the Enneads
Discusses, in the context of the Platonic theory of two worlds, Plotinus' argument that soul is not body, does not depend on body, and is of a different nature ...Missing: tripartite | Show results with:tripartite
[29]
(L.) Ferroni, (D.P.) Taormina (edd.) Plotinus IV 7 (2) On the ...
Aug 22, 2024 · Plotinus' Ennead IV 7 (2), 'On the Immortality of the Soul', is the second treatise in the chronological order provided by Porphyry.
[30]
Plotinus. Ennead IV.8: On the Descent of the Soul into Bodies. The ...
Nov 23, 2012 · This is the first volume of a new series of translations and commentaries on the individual treatises of Plotinus' Enneads, edited by John Dillon and Andrew ...Missing: tripartite | Show results with:tripartite
[31]
Enneads of Plotinus - Georgetown University
There might be a complete coalescence: Soul might be interwoven through the body: or it might be an Ideal-Form detached or an Ideal-Form in governing contact ...
[32]
[PDF] Writing in the Soul. On some Aspects of Recollection in Plotinus - HAL
Oct 20, 2023 · In chapter 25 of Enneads (Enn.), IV.3 (27), Plotinus defines recollection as a very different kind of memory than ordinary memory.
[33]
The soul and the body (Chapter 8) - Plotinus on the Soul
Plotinus claims that nature is that which gives the trace of the soul to the body. Moreover, at Ennead IV 4, 28, 16f. we learn that the generative power gives ...Missing: tripartite scholarly
[34]
https://brill.com/display/book/9789004516014/BP000024.xml
[35]
Plotinus: Virtue Ethics | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Plotinus approaches the cardinal virtues from the following aspects: (P1) civic life (I 2.1.17-21), (P2) the purification of the soul in relation to the body ( ...Philosophical Background and... · The Cardinal Virtues · Virtue Ethics after Plotinus
[36]
PLOTINUS, ENNEAD 1. 4 AS CRITIQUE OF EARLIER EUDAIMONISM
Plotinus, aims, rather, to show other philosophers, especially Aristotelians and Stoics, that their many correct ideas are fully viable if and only if they give ...
[37]
Ethics and the Hierarchy of Virtues from Plotinus to Iamblichus
Jun 15, 2021 · In fact, Plotinus immediately opposes civic virtues to the higher ones, which entail purification and contemplation. Note, however, that ...
[38]
[PDF] Consciousness and agency in Plotinus - PhilArchive
are three levels of virtue: the civic, the purificatory and the intellectual. The civic virtues are those that impose limit and measure on our non-rational.
[39]
[PDF] Plotinus' Mystical Teaching of Henosis - ULB : Dok
Plotinis is known as both a philosopher and a mystic, and it is crucial to explain his mysticism of henosis in the light of his metaphysics of the One.
[40]
Plotinus' Philosophical Eros for the One: His Unio Mystica, Ethos ...
May 24, 2018 · Above all, this paper explores Plotinus' unparalleled philosophical eros for henosis (union) with the 'One', highlighting his legendary life ...
[41]
https://www.llewellyn.com/journal/article/2523
[42]
Plotinus, Ennead I.6: On Beauty. Translation with an Introduction ...
Jul 14, 2016 · Here Plotinus presents the theme of ascent from sensible beauty to its archetype in the intelligible world, an ascent made possible by the ...
[43]
[PDF] PLOTINUS Ennead I.6: On Beauty - dokumen.pub
Beauty but assigns to the One the role of cause of Beauty. The framework has now been established within which the individual must make his ascent (Chapter.
[44]
Chapter 10 - Plotinus and Epicurus on pleasure and happiness
If pleasure is the end and the good life is determined by pleasure, it is absurd of anyone to deny the good life to other living things; the same applies to ...
[45]
5 - Plotinus and the Theory of Forms - Cambridge University Press
May 25, 2022 · Plotinus' thesis actually paved the way to a new interpretation of Plato's Forms, the kernel for any Platonist system.
[46]
Historical Context (Part I) - The New Cambridge Companion to ...
May 25, 2022 · Plotinus, on the other hand, again follows Plato's Sophist in arguing that intelligible reality cannot be devoid of motion. In the Sophist ...<|separator|>
[47]
Numenius - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
May 4, 2009 · Numenius, a Platonist philosopher of the mid 2 nd century CE, had considerable impact on later Platonism, most notably on Plotinus (3 rd c.) and Porphyry (3 rd ...
[48]
3 The Concept of God in Middle Platonism - Oxford Academic
We know that Plotinus read–among these–Gaius, Numenius, and Atticus (Porphyry, V. Plot. 14.10–13). 16. Cf. Arthur Hilary Armstrong, 'Gnosis and Greek ...
[49]
Neoplatonism - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Jan 11, 2016 · By any standard of intellectual prowess, Plotinus is one of the intellectual giants of antiquity, on a par with the likes of Plato, Aristotle, ...
[50]
Plotinus. Ennead II.9: Against the Gnostics. Translation with an ...
Mar 27, 2018 · Plotinus refutes the Gnostics' multiplication of intelligible realties and clarifies the structure of the intelligible world, which has only three hypostases.
[51]
Plotinus and the Gnostics - jstor
PLOTINUS AND THE GNOSTICS. BY JOSEPH KATZ. Plotinus' essay against the Gnostics (Ennead II ix) 1 has often been commented upon. Due acknowledgment has been ...
[52]
Plotinus' Discussion with the Gnostics in Ennead II 9 ... - Academia.edu
This paper examines the dialectical engagement between Plotinus and his disciples identified as 'Gnostics' in Ennead II 9. It argues that while Porphyry's ...
[53]
Plotinus' criticism of Epicurean doctrines (Part III)
Aug 5, 2016 · In tr. 12 (Enn. II 4) 7.20–8 Plotinus criticises the notion that matter formed by atoms constitutes the substrate for the constitution of bodies ...
[54]
Plotinus and Scepticism. - Jan2 Opsomer - PhilPapers
Abstract. It is a well-known fact that Plotinus integrates skeptic arguments in order to prepare his own account of intellective knowledge.Missing: critique | Show results with:critique
[55]
Plotinus on Number - Bryn Mawr Classical Review
Feb 17, 2010 · By probing into the historical sources of Plotinus' understanding of number, this book offers a nice historical-philosophical approach to the ...
[56]
(PDF) Plotinus and Magic - ResearchGate
Aug 6, 2025 · Examination of key passages brings to light the context for discussion of magic, particularly issues of sympathy, prayer, astrology and divination.
[57]
Plotinus's treatise against the Gnostics - Academia.edu
Namely, these are: the Gnostics' betrayal of Platonic philosophy, their disdain for the cosmos, and the lack of ethic they show. In the opinion of Plotinus, the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[58]
On Whether the Stars Are Causes (2.3 (52)) - Plotinus: The Enneads
Plotinus is indeed very critical of astrological beliefs, both in this treatise and elsewhere in the Enneads, but he is far from rejecting astrology tout court ...
[59]
Plotinus On Astrology - Oxford Academic
Oct 31, 2023 · One of the first works he wrote, Enneads 3. 1 [6], is a treatise on fate which criticizes astrologers' claims alongside other deterministic ...
[60]
Psychic and Physical Treatises; comprising the Second and Third ...
This work gives Plotinus's accounts of the religions and cults of his age. He was interested in the occult but only in a detached and speculative way. He was ...
[61]
Plotinus (Chapter 3) - Defining Magic
Plotinus claims that there is no general difference between the effects of “magic” and those of “prayer” as he assumes a “natural drawing power in spells”.
[62]
Neo-Platonism - Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Neoplatonism is a modern term used to designate the period of Platonic philosophy beginning with the work of Plotinus and ending with the closing of the ...
[63]
Porphyry - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Feb 18, 2005 · On Plotinus' advice he left Rome for Sicily in order to recover from a bout of depression in 268 C.E. He must have stayed there for some time, ...Missing: arrival | Show results with:arrival
[64]
Simplicius - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Jun 3, 2020 · Simplicius of Cilicia (ca. 480–560 CE), roughly a contemporary of John Philoponus, is without doubt the most important Neoplatonic commentator on Aristotle.Life and Works · Simplicius as a Commentator... · Simplicius' Legacy · Bibliography
[65]
Greek Sources in Arabic and Islamic Philosophy
Feb 23, 2009 · Plotinus. Around AD 840 parts of Enneads IV–VI (devoted in the Porphyrian edition of Plotinus' writings to soul, the intelligible world and the ...
[66]
CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Dionysius the Pseudo-Areopagite
His thoughts, phrases, and expressions show a great familiarity with the works of the neo-Platonists, especially with Plotinus and Proclus. He is also ...
[67]
Augustine of Hippo - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Sep 25, 2019 · Augustine's life ended when the Vandals besieged Hippo; he is said to have died with a word of Plotinus on his lips (Possidius, Vita Augustini ...Life · Augustine and Philosophy · The Philosophical Tradition... · Ethics
[68]
influence of Arabic and Islamic Philosophy on the Latin West
Sep 19, 2008 · The impact of Arabic philosophers such as al-Fārābī, Avicenna and Averroes on Western philosophy was particularly strong in natural philosophy, psychology and ...
[69]
Arabic and Islamic Metaphysics - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Jul 5, 2012 · Metaphysics was of paramount importance, as its pivotal role in the overall history of the transmission of Greek thought into Arabic culture makes evident.
[70]
The Oneness of Being In Ibn 'Arabī and Plotinus - ResearchGate
Dec 23, 2022 · The primary aim of this book is to clarify the doctrine of the oneness of being in Ibn ʿArabī's Seals of Wisdom and Plotinus' Enneads.
[71]
From Philo to Plotinus: The Emergence of Mystical Union
Philo's reading of the imperative to cleave to God, his choice to invoke the term henōsis, suggests that a full union with the transcendent creator is not only ...
[72]
Video: List Lecture in Jewish Studies: Adam Afterman: Kabbalistic ...
Oct 13, 2023 · "At the very beginning of the new speculative kabbalah, En-Sof, which represents the God of Plotinus and his followers, was joined to a system ...
[73]
3 Emanationist Powers: Plotinus, Theology of Aristotle, and Ibn Gabirol
The Theology of Aristotle is an Arabic paraphrased edition of parts of books 4–6 of Plotinus's Enneads attributed to the circle of 9th-century Islamic ...
[74]
Plotinus' and Dionysius' Negative Theologies: Comparative Analysis ...
This article inquires into the specific differences between Plotinus' and Dionysius' negative theologies and their contemporary philosophical significance.
[75]
(PDF) The Dionysian negative theology between Neoplatonism and ...
The Dionysian negative theology between Neoplatonism and Christianity ... Plotinus; early Christianity https://addletonacademicpublishers.com/contents ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[76]
Marsilio Ficino (1433—1499) - Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
An edition of Plotinus was published in 1492. During this time Ficino completed his Three Books on Life, a medical and astrological treatise. After its 1489 ...Missing: Marsilius | Show results with:Marsilius
[77]
Giovanni Pico della Mirandola - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Jun 3, 2008 · The Platonism of late antiquity, from Plotinus through Proclus and his followers, dominated the other third of the book. Ficino had set a high ...Life · Works and Reputation · Conclusions and Oration · Bibliography
[78]
(PDF) The elements of ancient mistery cults and the neoplatonic ...
Jan 25, 2023 · PDF | The article introduces a new Neoplatonic interpretation of Botticelli's Primavera in the context of ancient mystery cults and the
[79]
The Cambridge Platonists (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
Oct 3, 2001 · Benjamin Whichcote. The oldest member of the group, Benjamin Whichcote, is usually considered to be the founding father of Cambridge Platonism.Benjamin Whichcote · Henry More · Ralph Cudworth · Bibliography
[80]
Ralph Cudworth (1617—1688) - Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
During this time, he also became a friend of Benjamin Whichcote, the founder of the philosophical and theological movement known as The Cambridge Platonists.
[81]
https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9781787443938-013/html
[82]
The Plotinian Influence in Schopenhauer's Doctrine of the Thing in ...
The most immediate association that comes when one thinks about Schopenhauer's thing in itself is Schopenhauer's identifying it with the will (Wille) . From ...
[83]
Remarks on Pierre Hadot's "Heidegger and Plotinus" - Academia.edu
We then examine Hadot's later article on "Being" as an infinitive in the Neoplatonic commentary on Plato's Parmenides, before turning to Hadot's reflections on ...
[84]
Process Neo-Platonism: The Platonic Side of Whitehead's Philosophy
He is, as it were, a process neo-Platonist whose organic outlook on life transcends simple dichotomies between process and permanence.Missing: Plotinus | Show results with:Plotinus
[85]
Jung and Swedenborg: modern Neoplatonists
The One of Plotinus and the 'unus mundus' of Jung both share the same ineffable unknowable realm. The Nous of Plotinus and the archetypes of Jung likewise ...
[86]
How Hermes Trismegistus Warped the History of Philosophy, Or ...
Dec 30, 2011 · The standard take on Plotinus is that he's an irrationalist mystic in Platonic clothing, and that he turns Plato's rigorous thought into little ...Missing: critique | Show results with:critique
[87]
Plotinus or the Simplicity of Vision - Amazon.com
What's it about? Pierre Hadot's philosophical examination of Plotinus's views on spirituality, existence, and virtue, exploring how he advocated spiritual ...
[88]
Neoplatonism | Theosophy World
A mystical school of philosophy that flourished from the 3rd to the 6th centuries identified primarily with Plotinus, and which had a significant influence ...
[89]
R. Baine Harris (ed.), Neoplatonism and Indian Thought - PhilPapers
The nineteen essays that form this pioneering volume of comparative philosophy represent an exchange of ideas among specialists in Neoplatonism and ...Missing: comparisons | Show results with:comparisons
[90]
[PDF] ZHU Xi, Plato, Aristotle, and Plotinus - University of Guelph
The crucial difference between Neo-Confucian and Plotinian cosmology involves the difference between the role of material force in Neo-Confucianism and the ...
[91]
Neo-Confucian Philosophy
“Neo-Confucianism” is the name commonly applied to the revival of the various strands of Confucian philosophy and political culture that began in the middle of ...Missing: Junyi | Show results with:Junyi
[92]
Reconstructing the Muslim Self: Muhammad Iqbal, Khudi, and ... - jstor
Iqbal argued that under the influence of Neoplatonism– the system of metaphysical speculation that had been inherited from Plato, through Plotinus ... Muhammad ...
[93]
Plotinus and African Concepts of Evil - Peter Lang Verlag
This book explores the concepts of evil in the world-views of Plotinus and the Nso' people of Cameroon. The author analyzes the theories of the natural ...Missing: decolonial | Show results with:decolonial
[94]
Philosophy, a school of freedom: teaching philosophy and learning ...
... not any such thing as non-Western philosophy, namely African, Chinese or Indian. Partisans of the 'classical' thesis – who, fol- lowing ...
[95]
https://www.academia.edu/125607343/Syncretism_and_the_Indian_Ocean_the_genesis_of_Hesychasm_by_the_Neoplatonic_reception_of_Yoga_in_Antiquity
[96]
(PDF) Syncretism and the Indian Ocean: the genesis of Hesychasm ...
This finds some support in the view that Plotinus teacher, Ammonius Saccas, may himself have been of Indian origin. The cognomen Saccas cannot be derived ...