Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Comminution

Comminution is the reduction of solid materials from one average particle size to a smaller average particle size through mechanical processes such as crushing, grinding, cutting, vibrating, or other forms of fracture.^[1] This fundamental operation applies mechanical energy to break down bulk materials into finer particles, often categorized into coarse (around 5 mm), fine (down to 63 μm), and ultrafine (<63 μm) regimes, depending on the desired output.^[1] In mineral processing and mining, comminution plays a critical role in liberating valuable minerals from surrounding gangue material, enabling efficient separation and extraction; it typically involves staged processes starting with primary crushing (reducing ore from over 1 m to P80 > 100 mm) and progressing to fine grinding (P80 < 30 μm) using equipment like jaw crushers, semi-autogenous mills, and ball mills.^[2] This step consumes significant energy—often 30-50% of total mining operations—but enhances mineral recovery, reduces chemical processing costs, and increases surface area for downstream treatments.^[2] Beyond mining, comminution is essential in the pharmaceutical industry, where size reduction (also known as micronization) improves drug dissolution rates, bioavailability, and uniformity by increasing particle surface area, facilitating better absorption and therapeutic efficacy in formulations like tablets, inhalers, and topical products.^[3] It also supports applications in food processing (e.g., grinding nuts or spices), cosmetics (producing fine powders for additives), and materials engineering (creating nanomaterials via atomization down to 20 nm), though challenges include low energy efficiency, potential contamination, and agglomeration at finer scales.^[1] Forces involved—such as impact, attrition, shear, and compression—dictate the method selection, with techniques like hammer milling or stirred media mills tailored to specific industries for optimal particle size distribution and minimal waste.^[1]

Definition and Fundamentals

Definition and Scope

Comminution is the mechanical process of reducing the size of solid materials, particularly ores and rocks, from larger particles to smaller ones through methods such as breaking, crushing, or grinding. This size reduction is essential in industries like mining and materials processing, where it facilitates the handling and further treatment of raw materials by creating more manageable particle sizes. The process involves applying external forces to fracture the material along natural weaknesses, resulting in a distribution of particle sizes that can range from coarse fragments to fine powders, depending on the desired outcome.^[1]^[2] The scope of comminution encompasses both dry and wet processes, with dry methods typically used for coarser reductions to avoid moisture-related complications, while wet processes, often involving water as a medium, are preferred for finer grinding to improve efficiency and control dust. It is distinct from fragmentation, which refers to the initial, often uncontrolled breaking of materials such as in blasting, and from pulverization, which denotes extreme size reduction to achieve very fine particles, usually below 100 micrometers, for applications requiring high reactivity. Comminution bridges these concepts by systematically progressing through stages: coarse reduction via crushing for particles typically larger than approximately 10 mm (with final crushing stages down to 5-10 mm), and finer reduction via grinding for sizes below that threshold. In ore processing, a primary goal is particle liberation, where valuable minerals are separated from surrounding gangue through targeted breakage, enhancing the efficiency of downstream separation techniques.^[4]^[5] Comminution's importance lies in its role in increasing the specific surface area of materials, which accelerates chemical reactions and improves reactivity in subsequent processing steps, such as leaching or flotation. However, it is highly energy-intensive, accounting for up to 50% of the total energy consumption in mineral processing operations, making efficiency improvements a critical focus for sustainability. This energy demand underscores the need for optimized processes that balance particle size reduction with minimal input, while avoiding over-grinding that could re-lock liberated minerals.^[2]^[6]^[7]

Historical Development

Comminution practices trace back to ancient civilizations, where manual and water-powered methods were employed for size reduction in both agriculture and mining. In agriculture, hand-operated querns—rotary stone mills—were widely used from prehistoric times to grind grains into flour, representing one of the earliest forms of mechanical comminution.^[8] In mining, the Romans advanced ore processing around the 1st century BCE to 1st century CE by adopting stamp mills, which utilized trip-hammers powered by waterwheels or animals to crush extracted ore prior to further refinement. These hydraulic stamp mills, inherited from earlier Greek designs dating to the 3rd century BCE, marked a significant step toward mechanized comminution in extractive industries.^[9]^[10] The 19th century brought industrialization to comminution through the integration of steam power and innovative crusher designs, driven by expanding mining operations during the Industrial Revolution. Steam engines powered early rock crushers, enabling more efficient ore handling in underground mines and boosting productivity in regions like Michigan's copper districts. A pivotal advancement occurred in 1858 when Eli Whitney Blake patented the jaw crusher, a double-toggle mechanism that used compressive force between a fixed and movable jaw to break stone, laying the foundation for modern primary crushing equipment.^[11]^[12] In the 20th century, comminution evolved toward finer grinding and greater automation, with key inventions enhancing capacity and uniformity. Ball mills emerged in the 1870s, initially for grinding flint in pottery production, but soon adapted for mineral processing through tumbling action with steel balls as media. Rod mills followed in the early 1900s, designed to produce more uniform particle sizes than ball mills by using elongated steel rods, addressing challenges in primary grinding stages after crushing. By the 1950s, autogenous grinding gained traction, particularly with the first commercial applications in the late 1950s, where ore itself served as the grinding medium, reducing reliance on external liners and media. Post-World War II, the focus shifted to energy-efficient designs amid rising operational costs and resource demands, incorporating optimized mill geometries and process controls to minimize power consumption in large-scale operations.^[13]^[14]^[15] Recent decades have emphasized sustainable and intelligent comminution, with high-pressure grinding rolls (HPGR) introduced in the 1980s as an energy-saving alternative to traditional mills. Developed by researchers like Klaus Schönert, HPGR technology compresses ore beds between counter-rotating rolls at high pressures, achieving up to 20-30% energy reductions compared to conventional methods and first commercialized around 1988 for diamond and iron ore processing. In the 2010s and continuing into the 2020s, artificial intelligence has been integrated for process control, using machine learning algorithms to optimize mill parameters in real-time, predict wear, and enhance throughput—evidenced by advanced sensor-based systems that have improved efficiency by 10-15% in modern circuits.^[16]^[17]^[18]

Physical Principles

Mechanisms of Size Reduction

Comminution involves several primary mechanisms of size reduction, each applying distinct types of stress to fracture materials. Compression applies gradual, sustained pressure that squeezes particles until they deform and break, commonly effective for brittle minerals by propagating cracks along stress lines. Impact delivers sudden, high-velocity force to shatter particles through shock waves, ideal for friable materials as it exploits internal flaws for rapid fragmentation. Attrition reduces size via shearing or rubbing forces between particles or against surfaces, producing finer particles through surface abrasion and edge chipping. Cutting, primarily for softer or fibrous materials, severs particles with sharp-edged tools, minimizing distortion while achieving precise size control.^[19] Fracture during comminution follows concepts rooted in material behavior under stress, distinguishing brittle failure—characterized by sudden crack propagation without significant plastic deformation—from ductile failure, where materials yield and deform plastically before breaking. In brittle fracture, prevalent in hard minerals, cracks initiate and grow rapidly due to stress concentrations at microscopic flaws, as described by Griffith's theory, which posits that fracture occurs when the energy release rate from crack extension equals the surface energy required to create new crack surfaces. This theory highlights how pre-existing microcracks amplify local stresses, lowering the overall fracture strength compared to theoretical cohesive limits, thus governing breakage in non-plastic regimes.^[20] Material properties profoundly influence the efficacy of these mechanisms, with hardness—measured on the Mohs scale from 1 (talc) to 10 (diamond)—indicating resistance to deformation and scratching, thereby dictating energy needs for breakage. Toughness, the ability to absorb energy before fracturing, and brittleness, the tendency for sudden failure, further modulate outcomes; brittle materials like quartz (Mohs hardness 7) fracture cleanly under impact or compression due to low toughness, yielding sharp-edged fragments, while more ductile materials such as coal (Mohs hardness ~2.5–3) exhibit higher toughness, resisting breakage and producing irregular, rounded particles through plastic flow. These properties interact, as higher hardness often correlates with brittleness in minerals, enhancing crack propagation but increasing wear on processing surfaces.^[21]^[22] Particle interactions during comminution vary between single-particle and bed modes, altering stress distribution and breakage patterns. In single-particle comminution, isolated particles experience direct, uniform stress, maximizing energy transfer for efficient fracture but risking over-crushing of fines. Bed comminution, involving layered particle assemblies, introduces inter-particle cushioning and multi-directional forces, promoting attrition alongside compression while reducing overall energy efficiency due to energy dissipation through particle rearrangements. Moisture content modulates these interactions, as low levels enhance brittle fracture by weakening inter-particle bonds, whereas high moisture (>2–3%) forms capillary bridges that increase cohesion, dampen impacts, and lower size reduction efficiency by promoting agglomeration over clean breaks.^[23]^[24]

Energy Laws and Requirements

The energy requirements in comminution are governed by several empirical laws that relate the input energy to the degree of size reduction achieved. These laws provide foundational models for estimating power consumption in crushing and grinding operations, though they differ in their assumptions about the underlying mechanisms of particle breakage. Kick's law, proposed in 1885, posits that the energy required for size reduction is proportional to the logarithm of the reduction ratio, making it suitable for coarse crushing where deformation and fracture dominate over surface creation. Mathematically, it is expressed as

E = K \log \left( \frac{D_1}{D_2} \right),

where E is the energy per unit mass, K is Kick's constant (dependent on material properties), D_1 is the initial particle size, and D_2 is the final particle size.^[25] Rittinger's law, developed in 1867, assumes that the energy is primarily used to create new surface area during fine grinding, where surface energy becomes significant. It states that energy consumption is directly proportional to the increase in specific surface area, given by

E = K_r \left( \frac{1}{D_2} - \frac{1}{D_1} \right),

with K_r as Rittinger's constant. This model holds best for brittle materials in fine size reduction processes, as it accounts for the energy absorbed in forming fracture surfaces.^[25] Bond's law, introduced in the 1950s, offers an intermediate empirical approach based on extensive mill data, linking energy to the square root of the size reduction ratio and incorporating a material-specific work index. The standard equation for the work input is

E = 10 W_i \left( \frac{1}{\sqrt{P}} - \frac{1}{\sqrt{F}} \right),

where E is in kWh per short ton, W_i is the Bond work index (a measure of ore grindability in kWh per short ton), P is the 80% passing size of the product in microns, and F is the 80% passing size of the feed in microns. This law is widely used for practical mill sizing and energy predictions across crushing and grinding stages.^[26] Actual energy efficiency in comminution is low, with only less than 1% to about 2% of the input energy contributing to particle breakage; the remainder is dissipated as heat, sound, and elastic deformation.^[27] Several factors influence the overall energy requirements beyond these laws. Feed size distribution affects efficiency, as coarser feeds demand higher initial energy for primary breakage, while finer feeds increase consumption in subsequent stages due to higher surface area demands. Moisture content in the feed can elevate energy use by up to 20-30% in certain circuits by altering particle cohesion and flow, particularly in high-pressure grinding rolls. Ore type, quantified through the work index, significantly impacts requirements, with harder ores like quartzites exhibiting W_i values of 15-20 kWh/ton compared to softer materials like limestones at 8-12 kWh/ton.^[24]^[26] In modern mineral processing, specific energy consumption (SEC) for grinding typically ranges from 20 to 50 kWh per ton, depending on the target fineness and ore characteristics, with fine grinding circuits often approaching the upper end to achieve particle sizes below 100 microns.^[28] These metrics underscore the need for optimized operations to mitigate the high energy intensity of comminution, which can account for 30-50% of total site electricity use.^[29]

Processes and Methods

Crushing

Crushing represents the initial stage of comminution, involving coarse size reduction of run-of-mine (ROM) ore to manageable sizes for subsequent processing.^[30] This process typically employs mechanical forces to break down large ore fragments, focusing on high-throughput operations that handle hundreds to thousands of tons per hour.^[30] Primary crushing reduces ROM ore, often exceeding 1 meter in size, to below 300 mm, preparing it for transport or further reduction.^[30] Secondary crushing then processes this material to under 100 mm, while tertiary crushing achieves products finer than 20 mm, enabling efficient downstream handling.^[30] These stages ensure progressive size reduction without excessive generation of fines early in the circuit.^[31] Crushing operations commonly occur in dry conditions, with moisture levels up to 8-10% tolerated to prevent material sticking.^[30] Size reduction relies primarily on compression in jaw and gyratory crushers for primary and secondary stages, and impact or attrition in cone and impact crushers for tertiary applications.^[31] Each stage achieves reduction ratios of 4:1 to 10:1, balancing efficiency with equipment limitations to avoid overloading.^[31] For instance, jaw crushers typically yield ratios of 3:1 to 5:1, while gyratory units reach 4:1 to 7:1.^[31] Circuits operate in open or closed configurations: open circuits pass material through once for simpler primary setups, whereas closed circuits recirculate oversize via screens to refine product size distribution, enhancing uniformity but increasing capacity demands by 40-50%.^[32] Key operational parameters include feed size, which dictates crusher selection—primary units handle up to 1.5 m—and product size, controlled by screen apertures to achieve targeted distributions.^[30] Throughput rates vary by stage, with primary crushers processing 160 to 13,000 tons per hour, tapering in later stages to maintain flow.^[30] Product sizing often targets 80% passing specific thresholds, such as 200 mm post-primary, to optimize liberation while minimizing energy input per the principles outlined in comminution energy laws.^[30] Challenges in crushing include significant wear on liners from abrasive ore, leading to frequent replacements and downtime in high-volume operations.^[33] Dust generation poses environmental and health risks, with concentrations of coarse particles (PM10) reaching over 20,000 μg/m³ near crushers in hard rock processing without controls, necessitating suppression systems.^[34] Over-crushing, particularly in high-ratio or choke-fed setups, produces excess fines that reduce efficiency and increase handling costs, requiring careful control of feed rates and settings.^[30]

Grinding

Grinding represents the final stage of comminution in mineral processing, where particle sizes are reduced to below 1 mm to enhance mineral liberation for subsequent beneficiation processes. This fine size reduction is typically achieved in wet environments, utilizing slurries with 30-50% solids content to facilitate material transport and reduce dust formation. The process employs tumbling mills charged with grinding media, which promote particle breakage through a combination of attrition—gradual surface abrasion via friction between particles and media—and impact, where particles shatter upon collision with falling media.^[35]^[36] Grinding operations are divided into intermediate and fine stages, following primary and secondary crushing to handle progressively smaller feed sizes. Intermediate grinding targets particles in the 1-10 mm range, while fine grinding further refines to sub-millimeter dimensions, often preparing material for flotation or leaching. These stages can operate in batch mode for smaller-scale or laboratory applications, allowing controlled cycles of loading, grinding, and discharge, or in continuous mode for industrial throughput, where slurry flows steadily through the mill to maintain consistent production rates.^[35]^[37] Key operational variables significantly influence grinding efficiency and product quality. Grinding media, such as steel balls (typically 10-80 mm in diameter) or rods, provide the necessary impact and attrition; larger media suit coarser feeds for efficient breakage, while smaller sizes enhance fine grinding but increase the risk of excessive wear. Mill speed is maintained at 60-80% of critical speed—the rotational velocity at which media would centrifuge—to optimize the cascading motion that drives breakage, with even a 1% speed increase potentially raising media consumption by 2%. Residence time, determined by slurry flow rate and mill filling (often 30-50% of volume), directly affects particle fineness; longer times promote smaller sizes but can lead to inefficiencies if overextended. Slurry solids concentration also plays a role, as higher percentages (up to 50%) thicken the rheology, impacting media movement and wear rates.^[35]^[37] The primary outcomes of grinding include a narrow particle size distribution, which improves separation efficiency in downstream processes by minimizing coarse fractions and optimizing surface area exposure. However, challenges such as over-grinding can arise, particularly with smaller media or prolonged residence times, resulting in the formation of excessive slimes—ultrafine particles below 10-20 µm that complicate handling, increase reagent consumption, and reduce overall recovery rates. Careful control of variables is thus essential to balance fineness with minimal slime generation.^[35]^[37]

Advanced Techniques

High-pressure grinding rolls (HPGR) represent a significant advancement in comminution technology, utilizing interparticle breakage mechanisms where ore particles are compressed between two counter-rotating rolls under pressures typically ranging from 3 to 8 MPa.^[38] This process generates a dense bed of material that fractures along natural weaknesses, producing finer products with micro-cracks that enhance downstream grinding efficiency. Introduced in the 1980s for cement production, HPGR technology gained widespread adoption in mineral processing circuits by the 2010s, particularly for hard rock ores, due to its ability to achieve energy savings of 20-30% compared to conventional ball milling while reducing overall operational costs.^[39] These savings stem from lower specific energy consumption and improved liberation, making HPGR a cornerstone for sustainable comminution in large-scale operations. Stirred mills, often configured vertically, excel in fine and ultrafine grinding applications, targeting particle sizes below 100 μm and extending to submicron levels for ultra-fines. In these devices, a rotating stirrer imparts high-intensity shear and impact forces to a bed of grinding media, enabling efficient size reduction through repeated stress events rather than bulk compression. This design is particularly suited for regrinding circuits in mineral processing, where it outperforms traditional ball mills in energy efficiency for fine products, often achieving target sizes with 20-50% less power input.^[40] The vertical orientation minimizes floor space and facilitates wet grinding, supporting high throughput for ores requiring liberation at scales below 10 μm. Microwave-assisted comminution serves as a pre-treatment method to weaken ore structures through selective thermal cracking, where microwave energy (typically 2.45 GHz) heats microwave-absorbent minerals differentially, inducing thermal stresses and fractures at grain boundaries. This approach reduces the hardness and energy required for subsequent mechanical grinding, with studies showing up to 50% decreases in comminution energy for treated ores like copper and iron sulfides. Pilot-scale investigations began in the 2000s, demonstrating feasibility in continuous systems, and as of 2025, while pilot-scale demonstrations show promise, full commercial adoption remains limited due to scale-up challenges, though integrated circuits enhance mineral recovery while lowering environmental impacts, such as dust generation and reagent use.^[41] Emerging techniques like ultrasonic and electrical disintegration further advance selective breakage, targeting mineral grains without excessive fines production. Ultrasonic comminution employs high-frequency vibrations (20-40 kHz) in a liquid medium to generate cavitation bubbles that implode, creating localized shock waves for precise fracturing along weaker interfaces, as evidenced in coal and sulfide ore processing where it improves liberation by 15-30%. Electrical pulse methods, using high-voltage discharges (50-200 kV) to initiate dielectric breakdown, promote intergranular cracks in immersed particles, enabling dry or low-water variants that reduce overall water consumption by up to 40% compared to wet milling and support eco-friendly circuits by minimizing slurry handling. These innovations prioritize sustainability, aligning with broader efforts to cut energy use in comminution by enhancing selectivity and reducing waste.

Equipment and Technology

Primary Crushers

Primary crushers are specialized equipment designed for the initial stage of comminution, reducing large run-of-mine (ROM) ore to a manageable size for subsequent processing. The two predominant types are jaw crushers and gyratory crushers, each suited to handle coarse feeds in high-volume operations. Jaw crushers employ a reciprocating jaw motion to apply compressive forces, while gyratory crushers use a continuous gyrating action for efficient size reduction. These machines typically achieve reduction ratios of 4:1 to 7:1, with capacities ranging from hundreds to thousands of tons per hour, depending on the model and feed characteristics.^[42]^[30] Jaw crushers, commonly used in primary applications, feature two rigid jaws forming a V-shaped crushing chamber, where material is compressed between a fixed jaw and a movable jaw. The Blake type, a double-toggle design, pivots the movable jaw at the upper end, providing maximum motion and crushing force at the bottom of the chamber, making it suitable for harder ores with compressive strengths up to 350 MPa. In contrast, the Dodge type, a single-toggle design, pivots at the lower end, delivering maximum motion at the top, which is better for softer materials up to 200 MPa but less common due to uneven wear. The reciprocating motion of the movable jaw, driven by an eccentric shaft, oscillates at rates typically between 200-400 cycles per minute, enabling effective breakage of large feed sizes up to 1.4 m. Modern jaw crushers, such as the Nordberg C Series, offer capacities from 100 to 1500 tons per hour (tph) and reduction ratios of 4:1 to 7:1, with robust non-welded frames to withstand high stresses.^[30]^[42]^[43] Gyratory crushers feature a cone-shaped mantle suspended within a flared crushing shell, where the mantle gyrates eccentrically to continuously compress material against the shell's concave surface. This design allows for a larger feed opening and higher throughput compared to jaw crushers, making it ideal for processing hard, abrasive ores in stationary installations. Feed sizes can reach up to 1.5 m, with the gyrating motion—typically 200-400 oscillations per minute—providing uniform reduction without the stop-start action of jaw crushers. The Superior MKIII series, for example, handles capacities up to 17,000 metric tons per hour (Mtph) and is optimized for hard rock applications through steep crushing chambers that enhance flow and reduce recirculation.^[44]^[30]^[43] In operation, primary crushers handle ROM ore directly from mining blasts, often requiring choke feeding to maintain a full chamber for optimal performance and energy efficiency. Power requirements typically range from 100 to 1000 kW, with jaw crushers on the lower end and gyratory models demanding more due to their scale. Maintenance focuses on wear parts, primarily manganese steel liners and jaws that work-harden under impact to resist abrasion, though regular inspections and replacements are necessary to minimize downtime—features like hydraulic adjustments in modern designs can reduce this by up to 70%. Selection of a primary crusher depends on ore abrasiveness, with both types performing well on abrasive materials like granite; throughput needs favor gyratory crushers for operations exceeding 1 million tons per year due to their higher capacity; and energy use is optimized through chamber profiling, potentially saving hundreds of MWh annually.^[43]^[44]^[42]^[45]

Secondary Mills and Grinders

Secondary mills and grinders are essential equipment in comminution circuits for achieving intermediate to fine particle sizes, typically reducing feed from primary crushers to products ranging from a few millimeters to microns, using media-assisted impact, attrition, and abrasion mechanisms. These devices operate after primary crushing to handle softer or more uniform ores, enabling higher throughput and finer liberation of valuable minerals compared to coarse reduction stages. Ball mills are cylindrical rotating drums filled with steel grinding balls as the media, where the cascading motion of the balls tumbles and impacts the ore charge to produce fine particles, often below 75 μm. They can operate in wet or dry modes, with wet milling being more common in mineral processing for improved efficiency and dust control, and typical power ratings range from 500 to 5000 kW depending on mill size. Ball mills are widely used in secondary and tertiary grinding stages due to their versatility in handling various ore types and achieving consistent size distributions. Rod mills differ from ball mills by using elongated steel rods as grinding media within a cylindrical shell, which provides a more uniform product size and reduces over-grinding of fines, making them suitable for feed preparation ahead of ball milling. Their design, with a length-to-diameter ratio of about 1.5:1 to 2:1, promotes end-to-end tumbling that breaks larger particles preferentially, often producing a product with 80% passing 1-2 mm. Rod mills are particularly effective in wet grinding applications for friable ores, minimizing slime production and improving downstream classification. Semi-autogenous grinding (SAG) mills and autogenous (AG) mills represent large-scale secondary grinding technologies that utilize the ore itself as the primary grinding media, supplemented in SAG mills by steel balls or pebbles for enhanced breakage. These mills feature diameters of 10 to 12 meters and lengths up to 7 meters, enabling high throughput capacities exceeding 1000 tons per hour in modern installations. AG mills rely solely on competent ore for autogenous breakage through abrasion and impact, while SAG mills incorporate 8-15% steel media to handle softer or less competent feeds, reducing the need for multiple stages. Common features across these mills include replaceable liners made of rubber or steel to protect the shell from wear and influence particle trajectories, with rubber liners offering longer life in corrosive environments. Large SAG and ball mills often employ gearless drives for reliable operation at high power levels up to 30 MW, eliminating mechanical gears and reducing maintenance. Integration with classification systems, such as hydrocyclones, allows closed-circuit operation to recycle oversize material, optimizing the grind size for downstream processes like flotation. While conventional tumbling mills dominate secondary grinding, brief mentions of advanced variants like stirred mills highlight their role in ultra-fine applications beyond standard secondary duties.

Applications and Industries

Mineral Processing

In mineral processing, comminution serves as the foundational step for liberating valuable minerals from their host ores, enabling efficient downstream separation techniques such as flotation and leaching. By fracturing ore particles, it exposes mineral grains, with liberation degrees often reaching 75-80% at grind sizes around 100 μm for gold-bearing sulfides, where finer particles enhance recovery by breaking down encapsulating pyrite or arsenopyrite.^[46] This size reduction is critical, as inadequate liberation leads to low recovery rates in subsequent hydrometallurgical or pyrometallurgical processes, while over-grinding increases energy costs without proportional benefits. Comminution circuits in mineral processing are designed as integrated loops of crushing, grinding, and classification to progressively reduce ore from run-of-mine sizes to the target fineness. For copper porphyry deposits, a typical setup involves primary jaw crushing to below 150-200 mm, followed by secondary semi-autogenous grinding (SAG) mills and tertiary ball mills, often with pebble crushing for recycle load management. At the Wushan porphyry copper mine, the SABC circuit—featuring an oversized SAG mill (8.8 m diameter) and ball mill (6.2 m diameter)—processes ore to a P80 of 170 μm, though optimizations targeted 115 μm for improved throughput and energy efficiency.^[47] These closed-circuit designs incorporate hydrocyclones for classification, ensuring consistent feed to flotation cells. Key challenges in mineral processing comminution arise from ore variability and resource constraints. Ore hardness, quantified by the Bond work index, typically ranges from 10 to 20 kWh/t across common deposits like porphyries and iron oxides, necessitating adjustments in mill loading and liners to handle fluctuations that can double energy demands.^[48] In arid regions, such as parts of Iran or Australia, water management is particularly acute, as wet grinding and classification consume millions of cubic meters annually—e.g., 6.14 million m³ for regional mining units—exacerbating groundwater depletion at rates of 55 cm per year and limiting circuit efficiency without advanced recycling technologies like thickeners.^[49] Case studies illustrate comminution's tailored application in mineral processing. For iron ore, circuits reduce run-of-mine material to pelletizing feed with over 90% passing 10 mm, followed by fine grinding to P80 sizes of 44-75 μm to optimize green pellet strength (1.64-2.01 kg/pellet) and yield (98-100% for +9 mm pellets), as demonstrated in beneficiated fines from Indian deposits.^[50] In gold processing, refractory ores require ultra-fine grinding to P80 of 10-12 μm prior to cyanidation, achieving 92-97% recovery by liberating submicron gold particles, as applied at sites like the KCGM operation where IsaMills expose inclusions otherwise locked in sulfides.^[51] These examples highlight P80 metrics as key indicators of circuit performance, balancing liberation against operational costs.

Pharmaceutical and Chemical Industries

In the pharmaceutical industry, comminution plays a critical role in reducing the particle size of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) to enhance bioavailability, particularly for poorly water-soluble drugs, by increasing surface area and dissolution rates. Techniques such as jet milling, also known as fluid energy milling, are commonly employed to achieve micronized particles typically below 10 μm, as seen in the processing of ibuprofen to improve its solubility. For heat-sensitive compounds, wet milling methods like media milling or high-pressure homogenization are preferred over dry processes to minimize thermal degradation, while dry milling suits stable APIs. These approaches ensure precise control over particle size distribution (PSD), which is essential for uniform drug release and efficacy.^[52] Contamination control is paramount in pharmaceutical comminution, with equipment often constructed from stainless steel to prevent metal impurities from affecting drug purity and safety. A narrow PSD is targeted to optimize dissolution kinetics, for instance, in aspirin tableting where particles are comminuted to a mean size of approximately 58 μm to facilitate consistent formulation and bioavailability. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) mandates particle size specifications in drug substance controls, generally expecting sizes below 1 mm with defined distributions to ensure blend homogeneity, prevent segregation, and support therapeutic efficacy, as outlined in guidelines for active pharmaceutical ingredients.^[53]^[54]^[55] In the chemical industry, comminution is utilized for producing fine powders of catalysts and pigments, where uniform particle sizes enhance reactivity and performance in applications like catalytic reforming or coloring agents. Attrition mills are frequently applied to achieve consistent size reduction through particle-on-particle rubbing, suitable for materials requiring high purity and narrow PSDs, often in the 1–10 μm range. Jet mills are also employed for dry comminution of these substances, enabling energy-efficient production on scales from grams to kilograms while maintaining sterility and precision distinct from bulk processing.^[56]^[57]

Modeling and Optimization

Mathematical Models

The population balance model (PBM) is a fundamental framework for describing the evolution of particle size distributions during comminution processes. It is expressed as the differential equation for the mass fraction M_i of particles in size interval i:

\frac{dM_i}{dt} = \sum_{j=1}^{i-1} B_{i,j} S_j M_j - S_i M_i

where the first term represents the birth of particles into size i from breakage of larger sizes j > i, and the second term accounts for the death of particles from size i due to further breakage.^[58] This model integrates two key functions: the selection function S_i, which quantifies the probability of breakage for particles of size i, and the breakage function B_{i,j}, which describes the distribution of daughter fragments from the breakage of parent particles of size j.^[59] The PBM enables prediction of transient and steady-state size distributions in batch or continuous systems, assuming independence of breakage events.^[60] The selection function S_i represents the specific rate of breakage for particles in size class i, typically measured in units of inverse time (s⁻¹). It is often empirically fitted to power-law forms such as S_i = a x_i^b, where x_i is the characteristic size of interval i, a is a scaling parameter dependent on material and operating conditions, and b is an exponent reflecting size dependency (commonly around 1-2 for many ores).^[61] This functional form arises from laboratory batch grinding experiments where particle disappearance rates are tracked over time, allowing parameter estimation via least-squares optimization.^[62] Variations in S_i account for influences like energy input and mill environment, with finer particles generally exhibiting lower breakage rates due to reduced stress exposure.^[63] Breakage distributions are characterized by the function B_{i,j}, which gives the cumulative mass fraction of primary daughter particles finer than size i produced from breakage of size j. A widely used representation is the t-family of curves, where the breakage outcome is parameterized by the mass fraction t_{10} passing a specific reference size (typically 1/10th of the parent size), generating a family of normalized cumulative undersize curves for different energy levels.^[64] The Austin model extends this for multi-stage comminution by assuming normalized breakage distributions that scale with specific energy, allowing cumulative breakage matrices to be constructed from single-particle tests and applied iteratively across process stages.^[61] These distributions emphasize the production of fines at higher energies, with the t-family providing a low-variance method to interpolate outcomes without exhaustive testing.^[65] The Bond work index serves as a material-specific parameter for estimating comminution energy requirements within these models, particularly as an input to selection functions. It is determined via a standard laboratory test in a Bond ball mill, starting with feed ground to 100% passing 6 mesh (3.35 mm) and closing on 100 mesh (150 μm), with the procedure cycled until the product achieves 80% passing 100 mesh (149 μm).^[66] The work index W_i is then calculated from the net energy consumed and the size reduction ratio, yielding values in kWh/t that quantify grindability.^[48] For high-pressure grinding rolls (HPGR), variations adapt the test to account for interparticle breakage, using smaller-scale batch methods with locked-cycle simulations to derive an effective HPGR work index, often 20-30% lower than conventional crushing due to enhanced microcracking.^[67]

Simulation and Efficiency Improvements

Simulation software plays a crucial role in modeling comminution circuits, enabling engineers to predict performance, optimize configurations, and evaluate operational changes without physical trials. JKSimMet, developed by JKTech, is a widely used steady-state simulator for analyzing comminution and classification processes, incorporating models for crushers, mills, and screens to perform mass balancing and flowsheet simulations.^[68] Similarly, HSC Sim, part of the HSC Chemistry suite from Metso, supports mineral processing simulations including comminution stages through its particles and minerals module, allowing users to model particle size distributions and circuit behavior based on thermodynamic and liberation data.^[69] For detailed analysis of internal mill dynamics, the discrete element method (DEM) simulates charge motion in tumbling mills by tracking individual particle interactions, providing insights into power draw, liner wear, and grinding efficiency.^[70] Optimization strategies leverage real-time data from advanced sensors to enhance comminution performance and reduce downtime. Positron emission particle tracking (PEPT) enables non-invasive monitoring of grinding media motion in stirred mills, offering high-resolution trajectories that inform adjustments to operational parameters like stirrer speed for improved energy utilization.^[71] Post-2020 implementations of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) have advanced predictive maintenance in mineral processing, using sensor data from vibrating screens and mills to forecast failures, with studies showing reductions in unplanned outages through anomaly detection models.^[72] These AI-driven approaches integrate with existing control systems to dynamically adjust feed rates and grinding parameters, drawing briefly on mathematical models for particle breakage to achieve more precise circuit optimization. Efficiency improvements in comminution circuits focus on targeted technologies that minimize energy and resource use. Variable speed drives (VSDs) applied to SAG and ball mills allow speed adjustments based on ore hardness, achieving energy reductions by optimizing torque and avoiding over-grinding.^[73] In wet grinding operations, water recycling systems treat and reuse process effluent, enhancing efficiency by reducing fresh water intake while maintaining slurry rheology for consistent throughput.^[74] Integration of high-pressure grinding rolls (HPGR) into circuits has demonstrated power savings of around 20% compared to conventional tumbling mills, primarily through interparticle breakage that generates more fines and lowers downstream energy demands.^[75] As of 2025, digital twins represent a transformative trend for comminution plants, creating virtual replicas that integrate real-time sensor data with simulation models to predict equipment behavior and test scenarios while minimizing risks.^[76] These systems, as implemented in projects like ABB's collaboration with Boliden for comminution optimization, enable proactive adjustments to reduce operational variability.^[77] Sustainability metrics, such as carbon footprint reduction, are increasingly embedded in these tools, with comminution optimizations like HPGR adoption and energy-efficient drives contributing to 30-50% lower CO2 emissions per ton of ore processed by curbing electricity-intensive grinding.^[78]

References

[1]
Comminution - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
Comminution is the reduction of solid material particle size by fracture through processes such as grinding or milling.
[2]
Comminution | Multotec
Comminution is the process of crushing and grinding materials to reduce them to smaller particles, making removal of minerals easier.
[3]
Pharmaceutical Size Reduction: Stability & Properties - Pion Inc
Sep 13, 2016 · The pharmaceutical size reduction process is also referred to as comminution, diminution or pulverization.
[4]
Comminution - NTNU
Comminution is size reduction, a fundamental process in mineral processing, done wet or dry, using crushers and mills, and can be done at different scales.Missing: engineering | Show results with:engineering
[5]
All About Particles: Modelling Ore Behaviour in Mineral Processing
Dec 1, 2023 · Comminution is the process of reducing the particle size of an ore to liberate the ore minerals from the gangue minerals. Thus, comminution ...
[6]
Comminution – Knowledge and References - Taylor & Francis
Comminution refers to the process of reducing the size of solid particles through the application of mechanical energy, primarily through crushing and grinding.
[7]
How to ensure energy efficiency in mining 1/4: Comminution circuit ...
Dec 4, 2018 · ... Energy Efficient Comminution, it accounts, on average, for more than 50% of a mine's energy consumption and 10% of total production costs.
[8]
From Quern to Computer: The history of flour milling – Page 5
Sep 6, 2016 · The earliest milling tools were worked by human effort, using specially selected stones or wooden artefacts to pound, crush and grind various raw materials.Missing: comminution stamp
[9]
Ancient Roman Mills - Vita Romae
Sep 17, 2018 · Roman mines used stamp mills which crushed the extracted ore before further processing. Stamp mills consisted of trip-hammers, powered by ...
[10]
Roman Mills - World History Encyclopedia
Jun 13, 2016 · The Romans constructed mills for use in agriculture, mining and construction. Around the 3rd century BCE, the first mills were used to grind grain.
[11]
Mining plants were dependent on steam to stay modern
and often overlooked — is the jaw crusher, patented in 1858 by a man named Ely Whitney Blake. Eli Whitney ...
[12]
The Blake Rock Crusher – Today in History: June 15
On June 15, 1858, Eli Whitney's nephew, Eli Whitney Blake of New Haven was granted US patent No. 20542 for a “machine for crushing stone.”
[13]
Ball Mill Crushing - 911Metallurgist
Mar 15, 2016 · Ball mill crushing by tube-mills were first introduced into the crushing departments of cyanide plants when it was found that for crushing finer than 30-mesh ...
[14]
[PDF] Rod Mill - 911 Metallurgist
Historically, rod mills have been used as the first grinding stage after crushing in mineral benefici- ation circuits. The rod mill product was further ground ...
[15]
AG Autogenous Grinding - 911Metallurgist
Aug 6, 2015 · Intermediate autogenous grinding can efficiently replace the rod mill and ball mill stage of a conventional grinding circuit. The need was shown ...
[16]
High pressure grinding rolls (HPGR) applications in the cement ...
Compressing a particle bed between two counter rotating rolls was achieved by the invention of the high pressure grinding rolls (HPGR) (Schönert and Knobloch, ...
[17]
[PDF] ThyssenKrupp Polysius - High Pressure Grinding Rolls for Minerals
High Pressure Grinding Rolls have been used for the grinding of diamond and iron ores since about 1988. There are now about 40 machines operating world-wide ...
[18]
Ways AI Optimization Improves Comminution Efficiency - Imubit
Oct 27, 2025 · Discover how AI optimization transforms comminution operations with real-time control, energy savings, and higher throughput in mining ...Missing: 2010s 2020s
[19]
Breakage process of mineral processing comminution machines
The attrition loading mechanism is one of the reasons that can cause abrasion. These terms have been widely used interchangeably in comminution studies.
[20]
Griffith Theory of Fracture | Request PDF - ResearchGate
Request PDF | Griffith Theory of Fracture | The theoretical strength of a solid is usually understood as the applied stress that fractures a perfect crystal ...
[21]
Quantifying the impact of mineral microstructure on the comminution ...
This paper investigates the influence of mineral mode, texture, and structure of various rocks on their comminution behavior. Significantly different ...
[22]
(PDF) Correlation between Material Properties and Breakage Rate ...
Apr 1, 2025 · The present study investigates four materials, namely quartz, marble, quartzite and metasandstone and aims to establish correlations, with the ...
[23]
Discrete element method simulation of bed comminution
The energy utilization in size reduction (to generate new surfaces) of a single particle is better than particles in a bed (Aziz and Schönert, 1980). This is ...
[24]
The effect of feed moisture on the comminution efficiency of HPGR ...
Feed moisture affects HPGR comminution efficiency parabolically, with both dry and very wet material having lower particle size reduction. Higher moisture ...
[25]
Comminution - 911Metallurgist
Nov 9, 2016 · The foregoing elementary discussion is relevant only to the crushing of a single particle but in practice a number of particles, often in a bed ...
[26]
Bond Work Index Formula-Equation - 911Metallurgist
Jul 15, 2013 · The work index Wi can be determined from plant operations and from laboratory ball mill grindability, rod mill grindability, and impact crushing ...
[27]
Mineral comminution: Energy efficiency considerations - ScienceDirect
Comminution has low energy efficiency, with actual values <1% to ~2%, but potential to improve by 2-3 times. The limiting efficiency is ~7.5 ± 2.5%.Missing: breakage | Show results with:breakage
[28]
Energy Use of Fine Grinding in Mineral Processing
Dec 18, 2013 · A wear rate of 7 g/kWh gives a contained energy consumption of 0.06 kWh contained per kWh of mechanical energy applied. Therefore, 6 to 20 pct ...
[29]
[PDF] Title: Benchmarking comminution energy consumption ... - UQ eSpace
On average, 36 per cent of the energy utilised by the mines was found to be consumed solely by comminution processes. 2. Comminution of gold and copper ores ...
[30]
AMIT 135: Lesson 5 Crushing - Mining Mill Operator Training
Explain the stages involved in crushing operation (Primary, Secondary and Tertiary); Recognize different types of crushing equipment used in Mineral industry ...
[31]
(PDF) SIZE REDUCTION BY CRUSHING METHODS
### Summary of Crushing Methods from ResearchGate PDF
[32]
Open or Closed Circuit Crushing - 911Metallurgist
Mar 1, 2016 · “Stage-crushing,” as we use the term here, applies to open-circuit reduction in a flow line comprising two or more crushing stages, with ...
[33]
Liner wear in jaw crushers - ScienceDirect.com
Wear in rock crushers causes great costs in the mining and aggregates industry. Change of the geometry of the crusher liners is a major reason for these ...
[34]
Grinding Media in Ball Mills-A Review[v1] - Preprints.org
Apr 23, 2023 · Grinding is the final stage of comminution, which reduces particle size to micron size level. The size reduction is achieved by attrition, ...
[35]
https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202304.0811/v1
[36]
A Review of the Grinding Media in Ball Mills for Mineral Processing
This work reviews the application of balls in mineral processing as a function of the materials used to manufacture them and the mass loss.<|control11|><|separator|>
[37]
Nordberg® C Series™ jaw crushers - Metso
### Summary of Nordberg® C Series™ Jaw Crushers
[38]
[PDF] Crushing and Screening Handbook - Metso
Feeders – a wide range of heavy-duty feeders designed to absorb impact, meter material to the crusher and scalp out fines. Primary gyratory crushers – ideally ...Missing: ROM | Show results with:ROM
[39]
Superior™ MKIII Series primary gyratory crushers - Metso
Superior™ MKIII crushers bring higher capacity making this crusher the most capex efficient primary gyratory crusher in the industry.Missing: hard | Show results with:hard
[40]
Choosing the right primary crusher for your aggregate application
Here is what a successful process of choosing a primary crusher looks like! Stages include defining crusher purpose, model refinement and installation.Missing: criteria throughput
[41]
[PDF] establishing the process mineralogy of gold ores | sgs
These results indicate that. ~75% recovery of locked gold can be expected by grinding the pyrite concentrate to below 100 µm. Figure 4: Size distribution of ...
[42]
Optimizing Performance of SABC Comminution Circuit of the ... - MDPI
Dec 2, 2016 · This research is focused on the Phase I SABC milling circuit of the Wushan porphyry copper mine. Improvements to the existing circuit were targeted.Missing: jaw tertiary
[43]
Bond Work Index - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
Bond's Work Index is defined as the specific energy expenditure in kilowatt-hours per ton required to grind a material, calculated using an empirical equation ...
[44]
Sustainable-circular water resources management in the mining ...
4.1. One of the major challenges of water-absorbing industries in arid regions is the growth of industries and the lack of use of up-to-date technologies that ...Missing: comminution | Show results with:comminution
[45]
(PDF) The effect of particle size on green pellet properties of iron ore ...
Aug 6, 2025 · This study deals with the beneficiation and agglomeration of the low grade iron ore; up to the extent such that it becomes an ideal blast furnace feed.
[46]
Ultrafine Grinding - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
The gold sulfide concentrate is grind with an IsaMill to a P80 of 10–12 μm. In the first 3 years of operation, high consumption of cyanide and high gold content ...
[47]
Overview of milling techniques for improving the solubility of poorly ...
Most drugs after crystallization may have to be comminuted and this physical transformation is required to various extents, often to enhance processability or ...Review · 4. Milling Adjuvants · 6. Milling Techniques For...
[48]
Strategies for preventing metal contamination in powders
Jul 3, 2024 · Metal contamination in pharmaceutical products is a huge problem. Detection and removal of these contaminants is critical during milling.
[49]
Investigation of the influence of mean HPMC particle size and ...
The drug, aspirin (USP grade, PR China) was comminuted using a pin mill (Retsch ZM 1000, Germany) to a mean particle size of 58 μm. Anhydrous lactose ( ...
[50]
[PDF] Guidance for Industry #292 - FDA
CVM generally expects that the drug substance will have a particle size less than 1 mm and that the drug substance specification can control the particle size ...
[51]
Attrition Grinding Mill Design - 911Metallurgist
Jun 9, 2017 · Studies also were made to determine the efficiency of the process in grinding a variety of industrial minerals, pigments, metals, and ceramics.
[52]
Novel production of ultrafine particles to meet environmental and ...
They are particularly useful for the production of pigments, catalysts, and fine chemicals. Jet mills can also be used for the size reduction of materials ...
[53]
[PDF] Optimization of Comminution Circuit Throughput and Product Size ...
The Population balance models are both systems of linear equations, and each use the same two basic functions: •. Breakage or Appearance function (B for the ...
[54]
Energy and population balances in comminution process modelling ...
The random functions, selection S(y) and breakage B(x,y), are present in the stochastic model of single comminution, which is based on the population balance.
[55]
Population Balance Modeling of Milling Processes - MDPI
Apr 3, 2024 · Population balance models (PBMs) enable engineers to simulate, design, control, and scale up various particulate processes and tailor product ...
[56]
Estimating the breakage and selection functions for a continuous mill
The usual approach for finding the breakage and selection functions has been first to use batch tests to determine the breakage function. Then the selection ...
[57]
Batch Grinding in Laboratory Ball Mills: Selection Function - 2009
Sep 25, 2009 · The selection functions and the breakage distribution functions are based on the experimentally-determined particle size distribution on the ...
[58]
[PDF] COMMINUTION MODELING OF PRIMARY BALL MILLS OF MIDUK ...
Where “si” is called selection function (S-1 as unit). By given selection function and assuming it remains constant during the grinding, the amount of ...Missing: S_i | Show results with:S_i
[59]
Evolution of impact breakage characterisation: Re-defining t-family ...
Accurate characterisation of ore competence through controlled single particle impact can enable improved modelling of comminution process response to ore ...
[60]
A new size distribution model by t-family curves for comminution of ...
In this study the breakage behaviour of three different limestones in an impact crusher was investigated. A new size distribution model was developed by t- ...
[61]
Bond Work Index Procedure and Method - 911Metallurgist
Jun 6, 2015 · This Grindability Test or Bond Ball Mill Work Index Procedure is used to determine the Bond Work Index of minus six mesh or finer feed ore samples.Missing: variable kWh/
[62]
[PDF] Work Index Determination for High Pressure Grinding Rolls - SGS
The set standard SPT pressure (55 MPa) appears to be in reasonable agreement with the actual pressure utilized between the rolls of a Labwal machine under.
[63]
Software - JKTech - University of Queensland
JKSimMet is an award-winning, general-purpose computer software package for the analysis and simulation of comminution and classification circuits in mineral ...
[64]
The energy needed to concentrate minerals from common rocks
Aug 15, 2019 · HSC Chemistry software was used to model the comminution and flotation processes. ... HSC Chemistry 9 and HSC Sim software [26]. The aim is to ...
[65]
Mechanics of media motion in tumbling mills with 3d discrete ...
The charge motion in a tumbling mill is analyzed in detail using a numerical simulation scheme known as the discrete element method (DEM).
[66]
Measurement of the motion of grinding media in a vertically stirred ...
Positron Emission Particle Tracking (PEPT) is a technique for measuring the flow trajectory of a radioactive particle in a granular or fluid system such as a ...
[67]
AI-Driven Predictive Maintenance in Mining: A Systematic Literature ...
This Systematic Literature Review analyzes 166 high-impact studies from Scopus and Web of Science, identifying key trends in fault detection algorithms.
[68]
[PDF] stepping forward: using variable speed drives for optimizing the
The whole variable speed drive system constitutes compact equipment that offers flexibility and higher efficiency to the grinding process.Missing: savings | Show results with:savings
[69]
Recycling of wet grinding industry effluent using effective ...
Bioremediation method is used in this work to recycle wet grinding industry effluents. •. Removal efficiency of EM consortium was compared to sludge activated ...
[70]
High Pressure Grinding Rolls - Energy → Sustainability Directory
Apr 5, 2025 · Water Efficiency → HPGR can operate in dry or semi-dry modes, significantly reducing water consumption compared to wet grinding processes like ...
[71]
Exploring digital twin systems in mining operations: A review
This study provides valuable insights into fully integrated digital twin mining systems, which will significantly improve mining efficiency and sustainability.
[72]
ABB & Boliden Use Digital Twins to Optimise Mining Processes
Jan 31, 2024 · A project between ABB and Boliden uses address digital twin technology to evaluate control strategies in the comminution process.
[73]
Slashing energy consumption and carbon emissions in comminution ...
Jul 31, 2024 · Notably, CPF reduces ball mill energy consumption alone by 30% to 50%. There is a growing consensus in the industry that miners need to reduce ...