Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Commissioner of Baseball

The Commissioner of Baseball is the highest-ranking executive of (MLB), responsible for upholding the sport's integrity, resolving disputes, and directing league operations to protect the game's best interests. The office was established in November 1920 amid the fallout from the 1919 , when team owners sought to restore public trust by appointing an independent authority outside their direct control, replacing the prior National Commission structure. Federal judge became the first commissioner in 1921, wielding broad, unilateral powers codified in a new governing agreement that granted him authority to act decisively against corruption, as demonstrated by his lifetime bans of eight players involved in the gambling scheme. Over the subsequent century, the role has evolved to encompass labor negotiations, broadcast rights deals, franchise relocations, and competitive balance measures, though retaining core oversight of umpiring, discipline, and rule enforcement. , elected in 2014 and assuming office in 2015 as the tenth commissioner, continues to address contemporary issues such as player health protocols, international expansion, and gambling integrity amid legalized . While early commissioners like Landis prioritized iron-fisted autonomy to combat gambling and maintain order, later figures navigated union conflicts and antitrust scrutiny, reflecting baseball's transition from a trust-based enterprise to a modern multibillion-dollar industry.

Establishment of the Office

The 1919 Black Sox Scandal

The between the heavily favored and the , played from October 1 to October 9, pitted a White Sox team with a league-best 88-52 regular-season record against the Reds, resulting in a 5-3 Reds victory amid suspicions of irregularities. Eight White Sox players—pitchers and Lefty Williams, infielders , , and , outfielder , third baseman , and outfielder —allegedly conspired with gamblers to intentionally lose games in exchange for payments totaling around $100,000 across the group, though not all received the full promised amounts and some games were still competitively played. The plot originated with , who leveraged prior gambling contacts to assemble the scheme during the season, drawing in professional bettors including Joseph "Sport" Sullivan, Billy Maharg, and figures linked to . Suspicion arose immediately, with betting odds shifting dramatically—such as a surge in wagers on before Game One—and observable lapses like Cicotte's errant pitches and Williams's uncharacteristic errors, though the White Sox won two games, complicating the fix's execution. The unraveled publicly in September 1920 when a Cook County investigation, prompted by sportswriter Hugh Fullerton's persistent reporting and confessions from Cicotte, Jackson, Felsch, and Williams on , exposed the players' admissions of accepting bribes to underperform. Indictments followed for the eight players and several gamblers on charges of to defraud, but the 1921 trial ended in acquittals after key confessions vanished—allegedly stolen from evidence—and jurors cited insufficient proof of intent to defraud the public specifically. Beneath the moral lapses, structural vulnerabilities in baseball's governance enabled the scandal: the , embedded in player contracts since , indefinitely bound athletes to their teams without free agency, suppressing salaries even for stars—Jackson earned $7,500 in 1919 while owner pocketed shares exceeding $50,000—and fostering resentment amid fines for minor infractions like wearing unapproved uniforms. Lax oversight by the National Commission, a tripartite body of league presidents and owners prone to conflicts of interest, failed to deter infiltration, as some owners had historical ties to betting syndicates and prioritized profits over integrity. This convergence of economic coercion and weak institutional checks eroded fan confidence, with attendance dipping in 1920 and widespread disillusionment framing baseball as corruptible rather than infallible, amplifying demands for an authoritative, independent overseer to restore legitimacy.

Creation of the Commissionership (1920)

Following the revelations of the 1919 Black Sox Scandal, which implicated players from the Chicago White Sox in conspiring with gamblers to fix the World Series, Major League Baseball owners confronted a crisis of public trust and governance failure. The National Commission, a three-member body comprising the American League president, National League president, and a National League club owner representative, proved ineffective in addressing the scandal due to internal divisions and perceived biases toward league interests over impartial enforcement. This structure, established in 1903 to oversee disputes between the leagues, lacked the centralized authority needed to decisively combat corruption and restore the sport's integrity. In early 1920, after National Commission chair Garry Herrmann resigned in amid the turmoil, owners initiated discussions to overhaul baseball's administration by creating a singular role with supreme authority over owners, players, and league presidents. The position was designed to function as an independent arbiter, empowered to act unilaterally in the "" of the game, replacing the Commission's fragmented oversight with decisive leadership to eliminate influences and prevent future scandals. Owners conceded substantial control, including veto power over their decisions, to signal robust self-regulation and avert potential antitrust prosecutions or congressional interventions that threatened the sport's exemption from federal oversight. Joint meetings of American and National League owners culminated on November 12, 1920, when they unanimously elected federal judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis to the newly created office, following negotiations in his Chicago courtroom that granted him absolute dispute-resolution powers without appeal. The agreement stipulated an annual salary of $50,000, supplemented by a $7,500 tax-free expense account, with Landis retaining his judgeship initially on a part-time basis; the formal contract was executed on January 12, 1921, for an indefinite term intended to ensure long-term stability. This establishment marked a pivotal shift from league-centric governance to an autocratic executive model, empirically justified by the Commission's paralysis and the urgent need to rebuild fan confidence eroded by empirical evidence of widespread betting irregularities.

Powers and Responsibilities

The Best Interests Clause and Disciplinary Powers

The Best Interests Clause, codified in the Agreement and , grants the of Baseball expansive authority to unilaterally investigate and discipline individuals or entities for conduct detrimental to the game's welfare. Originating from the framework establishing the office, the provision empowers the Commissioner to impose penalties including fines, temporary suspensions, or permanent ineligibility declarations, often without rights for grave violations. This discretionary stems from language allowing action against "any act, transaction, practice, or conduct not to be in the best interests of ," designed to enable swift and prioritize the causal preservation of competitive over procedural formalities. The clause's scope prominently encompasses gambling prohibitions under Rule 21, which mandates permanent ineligibility for players or personnel betting on games in which they have a direct duty or interest, and one-year suspensions for betting on unrelated contests. Additional gambling infractions, such as involvement with illegal bookmakers, permit penalties at the Commissioner's discretion, up to lifetime bans, reinforcing a zero-tolerance stance to avert corruption's spread. Rule 21 further authorizes discipline for failure to report solicitations to fix games, underscoring the provision's focus on proactive deterrence through severe, non-negotiable consequences. Beyond , the applies to performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs), where the Commissioner's office retains sole disciplinary jurisdiction under the Joint Drug Prevention and Treatment Program, permitting escalated suspensions if standard protocols insufficiently address threats to fair play. On-field misconduct, including violence or deliberate rule circumventions that compromise competition, likewise triggers fines, ejections, or longer-term ineligibility under Rule 21's provisions for acts endangering the game's standards. This breadth allows the Commissioner to address multifaceted integrity risks holistically, unbound by limits in core protective functions. The clause's effectiveness in upholding baseball's credibility derives from its capacity for immediate, binding resolutions, which empirical review of the sport's century-long record reveals as superior to slower or litigation paths in containing contagion—evidenced by the rarity of systemic fixes or betting rings post-establishment, despite persistent temptations in high-stakes athletics. The has recurrently challenged its scope via grievances, advocating to inject , yet judicial precedents affirm the Commissioner's latitude as a valid exercise of private governance, unyielding to external antitrust scrutiny due to baseball's unique exemption. Such resilience highlights the provision's causal realism: preempting erosion of fan trust through decisive enforcement outweighs union-preferred dilutions that risk dilatory outcomes.

Administrative and Business Roles

The of Baseball oversees core administrative functions through the Office of the , including the hiring, training, and performance evaluation of umpires who officiate games. This office also manages the annual scheduling of the 162-game regular season for all 30 teams, coordinating travel, , and conflict avoidance to ensure operational efficiency. expansion and relocation proposals require the 's approval, subject to owner votes, with evaluations focusing on market viability, stadium adequacy, and competitive balance. In business operations, the Commissioner serves as the league's chief negotiator for national media and sponsorship deals, centralizing among teams under the antitrust exemption established by the 1922 Major League Agreement. These responsibilities have driven expansion, with league-wide totals rising from roughly $1.5 billion in the early —primarily from gate receipts and nascent TV packages—to $12.1 billion in , fueled by multibillion-dollar contracts such as the current and agreements. The role further extends to , including oversight of events like the , to cultivate global markets and ancillary income streams. Operating as a CEO for the owner collective, the Commissioner prioritizes profitability within the league's structure, negotiating centralized licensing and to maximize shared while mitigating antitrust risks. This executive function has evolved with fragmentation, incorporating streaming partnerships and data analytics to sustain growth amid varying local market performances.

Evolution and Limitations of Authority

The office of Commissioner originated with expansive, near-absolute authority granted under the 1921 Major League Agreement, empowering the appointee to act unilaterally in the "best interests of baseball" without owner veto or judicial review, as exemplified by the lifetime tenure and disciplinary fiat initially afforded to its first holder. This structure prioritized centralized control to restore public trust post-scandal, insulating decisions from fragmented ownership interests and enabling swift enforcement against gambling or competitive integrity threats. Economic and legal pressures, particularly the rise of player collective bargaining following the 1966 formation of the Major League Baseball Players Association (MLBPA), progressively eroded this independence, compelling the Commissioner to negotiate labor terms via collective bargaining agreements (CBAs) rather than impose reforms unilaterally. Union militancy, culminating in strikes like 1972, 1981, and 1994–95, leveraged antitrust threats to extract concessions on free agency and salary arbitration, shifting power dynamics toward mutual agreement on revenue sharing, draft rules, and competitive balance measures that owners previously dictated. Owner self-interest in preserving league stability amid rising media revenues further incentivized collaborative governance, as unilateral commissioner actions risked labor disruptions or legal challenges under labor law exemptions carved out in CBAs. In response to the 1994–95 strike, owners amended the Major League Constitution's Section 5 on February 11, 1994, curtailing the Commissioner's "" clause by requiring owner approval for certain disciplinary and structural decisions, effectively subordinating the role to collective owner consensus and constraints. This revision reflected causal erosion from , which had demonstrated capacity to halt seasons, and owners' recognition that absolute commissioner power could conflict with their fiscal priorities, such as implementations needing MLBPA ratification. The preservation of MLB's judicially crafted antitrust exemption, upheld in cases like Toolson v. New York Yankees (1953) and (1972), imposes additional limitations, as substantive rule changes risk congressional scrutiny or exemption erosion without unanimous owner support, forcing negotiated compromises over edicts. This dynamic has fostered a more executive-like role, where the Commissioner facilitates owner-MLBPA alignments on issues like international drafts or expansion, prioritizing consensus to safeguard the exemption's economic shield against monopoly challenges.

Kenesaw Mountain Landis (1920–1944)

Banning the Black Sox and Anti-Gambling Stance

In response to the 1919 Black Sox Scandal, where eight Chicago White Sox players conspired with gamblers to fix the World Series, Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis imposed lifetime bans on all eight players—Chick Gandil, Eddie Cicotte, Shoeless Joe Jackson, Fred McMullin, Happy Felsch, Swede Risberg, Buck Weaver, and Lefty Williams—on August 3, 1921, one day after their acquittal in a Chicago court on conspiracy charges. Landis justified the bans by emphasizing the players' demonstrated associations with gamblers and evidence of intentional underperformance, including grand jury confessions from Cicotte and Jackson admitting to accepting bribes totaling around $70,000 to throw games, despite later trial inconsistencies due to missing documents and witness issues. His public statement underscored a zero-tolerance policy: "Regardless of the verdict of juries, no player who throws a ballgame, no player that undertakes or promises to throw a ballgame, no player that sits in conference with a bunch of crooked players and gamblers where the ways and means of throwing a ballgame are discussed and does not promptly tell his club about it, will ever play professional baseball." Landis extended this anti-gambling crusade beyond the Black Sox, conducting aggressive investigations into betting activities across baseball and issuing lifetime bans to at least 13 additional players and officials for associations or irregularities, such as New York Giants pitcher Rube Benton in 1922 for tipping off bets and Philadelphia Phillies shortstop for prior game-fixing involvement. These actions established a of exemplary to deter corruption, rooted in the causal reality that financial incentives from underpayment and gambling syndicates directly undermined game integrity, prioritizing long-term public trust over legal technicalities or sympathetic narratives about players' economic pressures. The bans' empirical impact validated Landis's approach: attendance, which had plummeted post-scandal amid eroded fan confidence, rebounded sharply, reaching over 10 million total by 1930 as decisive enforcement signaled baseball's commitment to honest competition. This restoration countered claims of procedural unfairness by highlighting the players' own admissions and the direct link between their actions and the sport's near-collapse in credibility, with no major fixing scandals recurring under Landis's tenure.

Enforcement of the Color Line

upheld Baseball's unwritten color line during his tenure as commissioner from 1920 to 1944, refraining from issuing any mandates to integrate Black players from the Negro Leagues despite occasional inquiries and public statements affirming the absence of formal barriers. In multiple instances, including a 1942 public declaration and a 1943 meeting with actor and club owners, Landis asserted that no league rule or agreement prohibited clubs from signing Negro players, emphasizing that such decisions rested with individual teams and managers. He stated, "any club was perfectly at liberty to hire one or twenty or twenty-five Negro players," reflecting deference to owners' autonomy rather than personal imposition of . This maintenance of segregation aligned with widespread resistance among club owners, who upheld a "gentleman's agreement" against integration, citing economic perils such as potential fan boycotts in southern markets and disruptions to team cohesion from white players' objections. Proposed tryouts for Black players by teams like the Pittsburgh Pirates and Cleveland Indians in 1942 were indefinitely postponed, underscoring owners' reluctance amid fears of alienating key demographics and sponsors. White players, particularly those from southern states, expressed mutual opposition, viewing integration as a threat to their professional environment, which further deterred action until broader societal shifts post-World War II altered the risk calculus. Landis's approach prioritized operational stability and unity over proactive reform, accepting the prevailing consensus without overriding it through his disciplinary authority, as the business imperatives of preserving attendance and avoiding internal strife dominated decision-making in an era when Negro Leagues operated successfully as separate enterprises. While some historians attribute perpetuation of the color line partly to his inaction, primary accounts indicate that causal drivers stemmed from owners' commercial judgments and player preferences, not unilateral fiat, as evidenced by the lack of even after his explicit non-objections.

Regulation of Minor League Systems

Landis prioritized the independence of clubs to maintain competitive balance and prevent monopolies over development. Upon assuming the commissionership in 1921, he demanded that all affiliate with the system, ensuring broader access to talent rather than exclusive control by affiliated teams. He also required clubs to disclose all farm system contracts and transactions, curbing attempts to conceal prospects and enforce through drafts over proprietary ownership. In February 1921, Landis ruled against Branch Rickey's Cardinals in a dispute over Phil Todt, affirming ' rights and signaling early resistance to expanding major-minor affiliations that favored collusion. Throughout the 1920s and into the 1930s, Landis clashed with owners seeking greater control via "chain-store" farm systems, which he viewed as undermining viability and player opportunity. During the 1930 winter meetings, he debated Rickey directly, insisting that players like George Toporcer could not be indefinitely warehoused in minors but must be sold or added to rosters, rejecting indefinite holding as antithetical to fair competition. He enforced this by granting free agency case-by-case, such as freeing infielder Fred Bennett from the ' Milwaukee Brewers farm club in April 1930. Violations drew fines; in 1938, he released 73 Cardinals farmhands from six teams, penalizing owners for undisclosed working agreements that evaded draft rules. These interventions slowed the erosion of independent by promoting draft-driven over concentrated ownership, though they highlighted persistent tensions between player development pipelines and preserving minor league autonomy as distinct business entities. Landis's actions freed hundreds of players by the late , forcing majors to compete more openly for talent, but owners' pushback— including rules attempting to override his Bennett decision—underscored limits to his authority amid rising farm system efficiencies.

Independence and Legacy

Landis embodied a model of autonomy through his lifetime , which insulated him from routine owner and allowed unilateral decision-making in safeguarding baseball's integrity. Elected unanimously on , , with an initial seven-year that evolved into indefinite tenure, he wielded expansive under the Agreement, prioritizing the sport's welfare over club interests. This structure rejected democratic dilution among owners, favoring decisive, judge-like enforcement to deter corruption, as demonstrated by his consistent exercise of disciplinary powers without contractual concessions to team demands. Landis died in office on November 25, 1944, at age 78 from a heart attack at St. Luke's Hospital in , having served nearly 24 years without major disruptions to his authority. In recognition of his tenure, he was elected to the National Baseball Hall of Fame by special committee vote in December 1944, affirming his role in restoring public trust post-1919 scandal. His legacy endures as the archetype of an independent guardian against graft, with in the absence of comparable betting or fixing incidents during his commissionership, crediting his zero-tolerance stance for fostering a , scandal-free . Despite critiques of authoritarian rigidity from owners seeking greater input, Landis's prioritized causal deterrence through unyielding oversight, influencing subsequent by embedding the principle of supremacy in baseball's operational ethos.

Happy Chandler (1945–1951)

Approval of Racial Integration

In October 1945, shortly after assuming office as commissioner on April 24, 1945, Albert "Happy" Chandler approved Branch Rickey's signing of Jackie Robinson to a contract with the Brooklyn Dodgers' minor league affiliate, the Montreal Royals, despite unanimous opposition from the other 15 major league clubs. Chandler instructed his contract chief to approve the transfer if it met standard requirements, overriding the owners' resistance rooted in longstanding segregation policies. Chandler's decision stemmed from a combination of moral convictions and pragmatic business considerations, emphasizing that denying based on contradicted both ethical principles and the need to expand the player pool for competitive balance. He later articulated a personal rationale, stating he could not justify to his barring a capable individual from playing due to skin color, while recognizing the market potential in tapping untapped amid post-World War II demographic shifts. This approval facilitated Robinson's promotion to the major leagues, where he debuted on April 15, 1947, against the at . The yielded measurable economic benefits, with the Dodgers experiencing a surge in attendance—drawing over 1.8 million fans at home in , an increase attributed partly to new African American spectators, alongside road game boosts for opponents. from integrated markets demonstrated revenue gains through broadened fan bases and enhanced talent access, offsetting initial player resistance, such as petitions from Dodgers teammates led by , and risks of boycotts in southern regions. Chandler's stance prioritized causal factors like competitive necessity over uniform owner consensus, proving prescient as integration correlated with league-wide attendance recovery from wartime lows.

Post-War Expansion and Conflicts with Owners

Following , experienced a surge in attendance, averaging over 21 million fans per season from 1946 to 1949, driven by returning servicemen and pent-up demand. Chandler prioritized initiatives to capitalize on this growth, including the negotiation of broadcast rights deals that generated new revenue streams. In , he secured $475,000 from radio rights to the , directing the funds toward establishing a player pension plan administered jointly by players and owners. By 1949, he expanded this model with a seven-year, $4.37 million contract for radio broadcasts of the and with Safety Razor and , further bolstering league finances and player benefits. Chandler also focused on protecting the system amid emerging threats from broadcasts, which reduced minor league attendance by drawing viewers away from live games. He endorsed uniform player contracts in 1946 that included safeguards for minor league development, such as standardized working conditions and limits on excessive bonuses to prevent talent hoarding by major league clubs. These measures aimed to sustain the farm system as a talent pipeline, though critics among owners argued they encroached on club autonomy in player procurement. Additionally, Chandler advocated for a $5,000 minimum for major leaguers in 1946, up from prior levels, to stabilize the workforce and attract post-war talent amid rising living costs. Tensions with owners escalated over Chandler's perceived favoritism toward and independent decision-making, including fines imposed on teams for violating signing rules and disputes over pay in the . He clashed particularly on salary escalations, defending player demands for higher compensation tied to attendance booms while owners sought to contain costs; for instance, his support for the and was viewed by some as inflating payrolls without corresponding productivity gains. These frictions highlighted early strains in the commissioner's authority, as owners resented Chandler's political-style interventions, such as relocating his office to against their preference for . Owners ultimately ousted Chandler in 1951, voting 9-7 against renewing his contract at the spring meetings, citing his overreach into business operations and alignment with player interests as undermining discipline. This decision, preceded by a similar rejection in the 1950 winter meetings, underscored power dynamics where the commissioner's "best interests of baseball" clause was subordinated to owner consensus, foreshadowing future limitations on the office. While Chandler's policies fostered short-term expansion through revenue innovation and player retention, detractors contended they sowed seeds of entitlement that burdened club finances without proportional oversight.

Ford Frick (1951–1965)

Introduction of TV and Revenue Growth

Under 's commissionership, formalized and expanded national television agreements in the , marking a pivotal shift toward leveraging broadcast media for financial expansion despite early concerns over attendance declines. Frick oversaw the refinement of contracts that built on experimental broadcasts from the , including a deal by the for and rights over six years, which evolved into regular national packages. By 1956, Frick negotiated a lucrative network contract that significantly boosted league-wide revenues, enabling contributions to players' pensions and infrastructure investments. These agreements featured national "Game of the Week" telecasts on networks like , increasing visibility to millions as television ownership surged from fewer than 10% of U.S. households in to over 85% by 1960. To mitigate risks to gate receipts, Frick enforced local blackouts of nationally televised games, prohibiting broadcasts within 75 miles of the home to preserve in-person , a policy rooted in data showing initial dips linked to proliferation. This approach, combined with rising ad s, drove a causal revenue boom: national rights escalated from modest sums in the early to $6 million annually by the mid-1960s (equivalent to $300,000 per team), funding new ballparks and support while broadening appeal to suburban audiences previously limited by urban access and travel constraints. However, these gains highlighted disparities, with large-market teams deriving disproportionate benefits from local TV deals—often 2-3 times higher than small-market counterparts—prompting Frick to advocate for revenue equalization among owners to sustain competitive balance, a precursor to formal sharing mechanisms. Critics, including affiliates, argued that unchecked TV expansion exacerbated financial strains in smaller venues, where attendance fell up to 50% in some regions by the late , underscoring the need for protective policies beyond blackouts. Despite such uneven impacts, Frick's stewardship positioned MLB for sustained growth, with TV revenues comprising a growing share of total income and fostering national fan engagement.

Handling of Traditions and Rule Changes

Ford Frick emphasized the preservation of baseball's statistical integrity during his tenure as commissioner, particularly in response to the 1961 schedule expansion from 154 to 162 games, which allowed to hit 61 home runs and surpass Ruth's 1927 mark of 60. Frick publicly stated that Maris's achievement would require a clarifying notation—often mythologized as an ""—in official records unless matched within the traditional 154-game framework, arguing that direct comparisons demanded equivalent conditions to honor historical benchmarks empirically. Although no such notation appeared in the commissioner's official ledger, Frick's midseason decree underscored his commitment to unaltered record-keeping amid structural changes, prioritizing causal consistency in performance metrics over unadjusted aggregates. Frick's approach extended to league expansion, where he opposed diluting talent pools in the established and Leagues by advocating instead for a third to accommodate growth without compromising competitive purity. Facing pressure from the proposed in the late , Frick engaged directly with its organizers, including , to explore parity admission rather than haphazard additions that could erode game quality through player dispersal. This stance reflected a conservative guardianship of traditions, as expansions to 10 teams per league in 1961–1962 proceeded under his oversight only after safeguards against overextension, though critics later argued it delayed necessary modernization and innovation in response to demographic shifts. In rule governance, Frick enforced uniformity to sustain the game's foundational elements, such as backing proposals for standardized franchise relocation criteria in to prevent arbitrary shifts that might undermine territorial stability and . His decisions, while defending empirical precedents like Ruth's unadjusted supremacy, drew criticism for rigidity, as evidenced by resistance to calls for broader interleague experimentation that some viewed as essential evolution.

William Eckert (1965–1968)

Expansion to New Cities

Under 's commissionership, undertook its third expansion wave of the , adding four franchises for the 1969 season to extend the sport's footprint into previously untapped markets. The incorporated the and , restoring a presence in Kansas City following the ' relocation to Oakland and introducing professional baseball to the via . Concurrently, the welcomed the , marking MLB's first venture into , and the San Diego Padres, further solidifying the West Coast presence beyond and . This growth increased the total number of teams from 20 to 24, with expansion drafts held on October 15, 1968, allowing existing clubs to protect 30 players each before allocating talent to the newcomers. The expansions were driven by efforts to balance league geography amid population shifts and competitive pressures, including the American League's unilateral push to preempt antitrust scrutiny after earlier relocations like the Senators to in 1961. Eckert facilitated negotiations with city officials, securing commitments for facilities such as Seattle's and Kansas City's Municipal Stadium, though these venues were temporary and modest compared to established parks. In and , Jarry Park and represented initial investments in new infrastructure. Empirical data from the inaugural 1969 season indicated attendance gains in expansion cities: the drew 836,971 fans, reflecting strong local support in a market eager for a return to big-league play, while the Expos attracted 1,170,176 in , buoyed by novelty and bilingual marketing. However, the talent dilution from rapid contributed to lower overall league quality, with the four new teams combining for a .429 and contributing to the "Year of the Pitcher" dynamics before rule changes.

Criticisms of Leadership Style

William Eckert's leadership as commissioner drew criticism for its perceived passivity and detachment from baseball operations, stemming from his outsider status as a retired general with minimal recent involvement in the sport—he had not attended a major league game in over ten years prior to his , , appointment. Sportswriters dubbed him the "Unknown Soldier," underscoring his obscurity and lack of acumen, such as his unawareness of the Dodgers' relocation to or mistakenly referring to the St. Louis Cardinals as the "Cincinnati Cardinals." Eckert's approach relied heavily on delegation to subordinates like executive director and committees, avoiding direct confrontation with controversies. Owners sidelined him in labor matters by hiring John Gaherin as chief negotiator in March 1966, reflecting doubts about his capacity to handle the emerging players' under , whom Eckert excluded from key discussions like a June 1966 television contract meeting. His tenure saw unintentional violations of union laws, positioning him as ineffective against the 's growing power. This hands-off style frustrated owners, who sought a more assertive "baseball man" amid incidents like the disorganized response to the April and June 1968 assassinations of and , which resulted in inconsistent game cancellations and public confusion. Baltimore Orioles owner Jerold Hoffberger criticized the lack of leadership, while Chicago Cubs owner Philip Wrigley deemed the selection of an outsider a mistake. Consequently, owners pressured Eckert into resigning on December 6, 1968, with three years left on his seven-year contract, leading to Bowie Kuhn's interim appointment on February 4, 1969. Despite presiding over a stable era of expansion and revenue growth, Eckert's reluctance to engage proactively with labor dynamics is argued by contemporaries to have exacerbated tensions that intensified under Kuhn, as the Major League Baseball Players Association solidified its influence.

Bowie Kuhn (1969–1984)

Battles Over Free Agency and Players' Union

In the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court's 1972 upholding of baseball's antitrust exemption in Flood v. Kuhn, which rejected outfielder Curt Flood's challenge to the reserve clause binding players to one team indefinitely, Commissioner Bowie Kuhn continued to defend the system's role in maintaining competitive balance and minor league viability. Kuhn had personally denied Flood's 1969 request for free agency, viewing the clause as essential to the sport's structure rather than an antitrust violation. This stance set the stage for intensified conflict with the Major League Baseball Players Association (MLBPA), led by executive director Marvin Miller, whose strategy exploited the clause's one-year renewal limit through grievances. The pivotal 1975 arbitration case of pitchers and tested this limit after both played the 1975 season without contracts following failed renewals. , who had pitched for the , and , formerly of the , filed grievances arguing the expired after one year, entitling them to free agency. Kuhn testified before the three-member panel, including independent arbitrator Peter Seitz, that the dispute belonged in , not impartial , and warned that dismantling the reserve system would jeopardize the ' survival by enabling talent concentration in wealthier clubs. On December 23, 1975, Seitz ruled in the players' favor, invalidating perpetual renewals and ushering in free agency, a decision Kuhn decried as "inconceivable" after nearly a century of precedent, arguing it upended the owner-player balance without negotiated safeguards. Kuhn immediately appealed to federal court, but the ruling stood, forcing owners to adopt free agency with limited protections like a re-entry draft in the 1976 agreement. Kuhn's resistance extended to salary arbitration, introduced in 1973 as a compromise to curb broader free agency demands, allowing eligible (typically after three years' service) to seek binding decisions based on comparable rather than team offers. He viewed this mechanism, alongside free agency, as distorting merit-based compensation by inflating pay through adversarial comparables untethered to individual performance or club revenues, contributing to unsustainable escalations—average rose from $45,000 in 1975 to over $180,000 by 1984. Kuhn prioritized owner rights to control costs and rosters, testifying that unchecked gains eroded the enabling player development and fan affordability, as evidenced by his predictions of rising ticket prices tied to salary spikes. Labor militancy peaked with the MLBPA's first work stoppage on April 1, 1972, a 13-day over owner contributions to the players' , halting exhibition games and delaying the season opener. Kuhn mediated the dispute, which resolved with owners increasing contributions by $500,000 annually and introducing , but he publicly lamented the action's harm to fans and the game, declaring "nobody won" while critiquing the 's leverage tactics as disruptive to baseball's traditions. The 1981 , lasting 50 days from June 12 to July 31 over free-agent compensation rules, canceled 713 games and split the season into halves for playoff purposes; Kuhn refused direct intervention to impose terms, instead ensuring the and proceeded via replacement considerations, but faulted the MLBPA's intransigence for prolonging economic damage estimated at $25 million in lost owner that year. Throughout, Kuhn framed these stoppages as causally linked to demands that prioritized short-term gains over long-term viability, arguing they compelled owners into concessions fostering beyond and merit, thus straining smaller-market franchises.

Anti-Drug Policies and Disciplinary Precedents

During Bowie Kuhn's tenure, implemented its first formal drug education program in 1971, aimed at educating players and clubs about the risks of . This initiative included distributing handbooks and resources, marking an early step toward proactive awareness rather than punitive measures alone. Kuhn also issued baseball's inaugural written at the start of the 1971 season, establishing guidelines for addressing violations. Kuhn escalated enforcement in response to rising cocaine use among players, particularly after arrests in the early 1980s. On December 15, 1983, he suspended four players—Kansas City Royals' , Jerry , and , plus pitcher —for one year without pay due to involvement in illegal drug use, primarily possession and related charges. , , and Aikens had pleaded guilty to misdemeanor charges following a 1983 World Series incident, while Howe's suspension stemmed from prior admissions of addiction. These actions set a for commissioner-imposed suspensions based on criminal convictions tied to drugs, though the players' union challenged them through ; arbitrator Richard Block reduced and 's penalties, highlighting tensions between league authority and rights. Kuhn reviewed and reinstated Aikens, , and on May 15, 1984, after they met conditions including treatment completion, but maintained stricter terms for repeat offenders like Howe. In June 1984, Kuhn formalized drug-related disciplinary rules, mandating a minimum one-year suspension for players convicted of drug crimes, with potential lifetime bans for recidivists, to deter future violations and safeguard the sport's image. pitcher faced a similar one-year suspension in July 1984 for cocaine-related issues, underscoring Kuhn's commitment to despite limited testing infrastructure at the time. These measures visibly reduced high-profile drug incidents during Kuhn's later years, as no major league-wide scandals erupted post-1983, though union resistance and outcomes constrained comprehensive testing until subsequent commissioners. Beyond drugs, Kuhn enforced precedents against gambling associations to preserve baseball's integrity, drawing from historical scandals like the 1919 Black Sox. In 1979, he revoked ' lifetime pass and barred him from official baseball activities for serving as a greeter at Bally's Park Place casino in Atlantic City, citing the conflict with the sport's anti-gambling stance. Similarly, in 1983, Kuhn suspended for promoting the Claridge Hotel and Casino, revoking his pass despite no evidence of personal gambling. These decisions emphasized symbolic disassociation from vice, even for Hall of Famers, though they faced criticism for overreach and were later reversed by in 1985. Such actions reinforced the commissioner's broad disciplinary authority under baseball's unique legal framework, prioritizing public trust over individual livelihoods.

Conflicts with Individual Owners

One of the most prominent conflicts during Bowie Kuhn's tenure arose with owner Charles O. Finley, whose aggressive cost-cutting and relocation attempts frequently clashed with Kuhn's interpretation of the commissioner's authority to protect the "best interests of baseball." Finley, known for his flamboyant management style and prior successes in building a dynasty that won three consecutive titles from 1972 to 1974, sought to dismantle the roster amid declining attendance and financial pressures following the team's sale of star pitcher in late 1974 due to a contract arbitration ruling. Kuhn's interventions emphasized league-wide competitive balance over individual owner prerogatives, leading to legal challenges that tested the scope of the commissioner's powers under the Agreement. The flashpoint occurred in mid-1976, when Finley attempted to sell three key players—reliever Rollie Fingers and outfielder Joe Rudi to the Boston Red Sox for $1 million each, and pitcher Vida Blue to the New York Yankees for $1.5 million—totaling $3.5 million in cash transactions framed as assignments of contracts. These moves, executed on June 15, 1976, were explicitly aimed at shedding salary obligations as Finley negotiated to relocate the franchise to New Orleans, where he had secured a lease but lacked league approval. On June 18, 1976, Kuhn voided the deals, invoking Article VII(G) of the Major League Agreement, which granted the commissioner discretion to disapprove player assignments detrimental to baseball's integrity or public confidence. Kuhn argued the sales constituted a "fire sale" that would erode fan interest by gutting a recent contender and undermine the competitive structure, especially amid growing scrutiny of labor dynamics post the 1975 Messersmith-McNally arbitration establishing free agency. Finley responded by suing Kuhn on June 26, 1976, in federal court in , seeking $10 million in and a declaration that the commissioner lacked authority to block the transactions, alleging arbitrary action and . The district court dismissed the suit, ruling that the Major League Agreement explicitly empowered Kuhn to act in baseball's , a decision upheld by the Seventh of Appeals in Charles O. Finley & Co. v. Kuhn (569 F.2d 527, 1978). The court deferred to baseball's unique antitrust exemption under federal , affirming that owners had contractually consented to such oversight when joining the league, thereby prioritizing collective stability over unilateral owner decisions. This precedent reinforced the commissioner's role in enforcing uniformity but drew criticism for potentially stifling owners' financial flexibility in distressed markets, as Finley's moves reflected genuine economic distress rather than malice, though they risked short-term gains at the expense of long-term league viability. Kuhn's stance extended to blocking Finley's repeated relocation bids, including a 1975 proposal to shift the A's to New Orleans, which required three-fourths owner approval under league rules—a threshold Finley failed to meet, prompting Kuhn to deny interim moves while enforcing contract obligations to maintain operations in Oakland. These disputes highlighted tensions between the commissioner's fiduciary duty to the sport's overall health and owners' rights to manage assets amid varying market conditions; proponents of Kuhn's approach credited it with preserving stability and , while detractors, including Finley, viewed it as overreach that hampered innovation and adaptability in a changing economic landscape. Ultimately, Finley sold the A's in 1977 to under league-supervised terms, exiting ownership after the 1976 interventions curtailed his autonomy.

Peter Ueberroth (1984–1989)

Financial Reforms and Drug Testing Initiatives

Upon assuming the role of commissioner in 1984, Peter Ueberroth confronted a league facing aggregate net losses exceeding $50 million across its 26 teams, with fewer than half reporting profits, prompting urgent measures to restore financial viability through operational efficiencies and revenue optimization. He centralized administrative functions such as purchasing and marketing, negotiating bulk deals for travel and supplies that yielded millions in savings, while advocating for owners to treat franchises as profit-oriented businesses rather than hobbies or tax shelters. In 1985, amid escalating player salaries following a lucrative $1 billion television contract that quadrupled broadcast revenue, Ueberroth convened owners to propose revenue sharing among clubs and explore salary arbitration reforms, though he publicly opposed a hard salary cap, arguing it undermined competitive balance without addressing root inefficiencies. These efforts contributed to a league-wide operating surplus by 1987, reversing prior deficits and enhancing short-term stability, as evidenced by improved attendance and sponsorship inflows from his Olympic-style commercialization tactics. Parallel to financial restructuring, Ueberroth prioritized combating substance abuse, particularly cocaine, after the 1985 Pittsburgh drug trials exposed widespread use among players, dealers, and even team personnel, implicating over 20 individuals in federal testimony. On February 28, 1986, he announced suspensions for 11 players—seven for one year and four for 60 days—based on admissions or trial evidence, marking the first commissioner-imposed penalties for off-field drug involvement absent positive tests. These were conditionally commuted to one year of probation, requiring offenders to donate 10 percent of their 1986 base salaries to community drug programs, perform 100 hours of anti-drug public service, and submit to random testing for the duration of their careers, with violations triggering full bans. The policy established mandatory counseling and testing protocols for implicated players, fostering a precedent for league-wide anti-substance measures that deterred usage through verifiable accountability rather than mere warnings.

1985-1986 Collusion Against Free Agents

Following the 1985 season, owners, prompted by Commissioner 's urging to treat teams as profit-driven businesses, reached an informal agreement to refrain from aggressively bidding for each other's free agents, aiming to curb rapidly escalating player salaries driven by free agency since 1976. This coordination stemmed from concerns over long-term contracts and salary inflation, with average player pay rising from approximately $44,000 in 1975 to over $370,000 by 1985, empowering the MLB Players Association (MLBPA) in negotiations. Ueberroth publicly criticized such deals as "dumb," advocating for cost controls to sustain league profitability amid union leverage that owners viewed as excessive. The strategy resulted in a depressed free-agent market: of 33 available players after the season, 29 re-signed with their original clubs, and overall free-agent salaries declined by about 5%, a stark deviation from prior offseasons. The MLBPA filed a alleging violation of the agreement's prohibition on owner , leading arbitrator Thomas Roberts to rule on September 22, , that owners had conspired to undermine free agency in breach of Article XVIII, Section H. This 1985-1986 collusion case, known as Collusion I, contributed to a broader settlement in November 1990, where owners agreed to pay $280 million across three related grievances (covering 1985-1988), with the MLBPA distributing funds to affected players without owners admitting liability. Ueberroth fined individual owners for their actions but framed the episode as a necessary market correction against unsustainable contract trends, though critics argued it compromised the commissioner's traditional neutrality by aligning with ownership interests over impartial enforcement of labor rules. The rulings underscored the owners' attempt to rebalance but affirmed the illegality of suppressing competition in violation of established agreements.

A. Bartlett Giamatti (1989)

Lifetime Ban of Pete Rose

In February 1989, initiated an investigation into allegations that , then manager of the , had engaged in on games, including those involving his own team. The probe, commissioned by Commissioner , was led by attorney , who compiled evidence including telephone records, bank transactions, witness testimonies from bookmakers and associates, and betting patterns spanning 1985 to 1987. This investigation uncovered that Rose placed bets totaling thousands of dollars daily, with specific documentation of wagers on 52 Reds games in 1987 alone, often through intermediaries like Tommy Bertolini, a convicted . The Dowd Report, delivered to Giamatti in May 1989, concluded with overwhelming evidence that had bet on , violating Rule 21 of MLB's regulations, which prohibits participants from wagering on games and imposes lifetime bans for such conduct. Despite 's repeated denials under oath and lack of direct proof that he intentionally influenced game outcomes to lose bets, the report emphasized the inherent causal risk: as manager, 's financial incentives from could compromise competitive integrity by subtly affecting lineup decisions, pitching choices, or motivational efforts, even absent overt fixing. Empirical patterns, such as 's documented debts exceeding $300,000 and consistent betting volumes correlating with ' performance, underscored this potential for outcome manipulation, prioritizing the game's foundational trust in unbiased results over 's on-field achievements. On August 24, 1989, Giamatti announced 's permanent placement on baseball's ineligible list via a negotiated agreement, in which Rose accepted the without formally admitting guilt but agreed not to challenge the findings further. This ruling upheld precedents like the 1920s bans under Commissioner , reinforcing that gambling's probabilistic threat to causal fairness—where self-interested wagers could erode empirical confidence in results—demanded absolute exclusion, irrespective of or unproven malice. Initially, the ban offered no reinstatement mechanism, embedding it as an irreversible safeguard against integrity erosion. The decision's legacy solidified MLB's zero-tolerance stance on , deterring similar risks amid rising legalized betting concerns, though critics later argued its punitiveness overlooked the absence of proven game-throwing, viewing it as disproportionate given Rose's 4,256 career hits. Nonetheless, the empirical weight of the Dowd —corroborated by multiple sources—affirmed the ban's necessity to preserve verifiable outcome legitimacy over individual .

Emphasis on Moral Integrity

Giamatti envisioned baseball not merely as a commercial enterprise but as a cultural institution embodying timeless ethical virtues, where the game's essence fosters communal bonds and moral reflection. In his 1989 book Take Time for Paradise: Americans and Their Games, he argued that , through its rituals and fair competition, sustains a sense of paradise amid modern life's transience, prioritizing honor and shared trust over . This perspective positioned the commissioner as a steward of the sport's soul, safeguarding its integrity against encroachments from business interests that could dilute its foundational principles of equity and professionalism. Central to Giamatti's philosophy was the causal linkage between moral and the game's enduring appeal: trust in unyielding standards of underpins fan engagement, which in turn drives economic sustainability through attendance and viewership. He asserted that " is an " for the commissioner's oversight of the institution's steady growth, rejecting that might compromise discipline for expediency. Publicly, he called for the game to "assert and aspire to the highest principles—of , of of , of within its rules," framing ethical as essential to preserving baseball's rule-bound moral framework against . Despite his brief tenure from April 1 to September 1, 1989, Giamatti's rhetoric established a precedent for prioritizing ethical guardianship, influencing successors like in maintaining vigilant standards amid ownership pressures. Concrete policy shifts were limited by his short time in office, yet his emphasis reinforced the commissioner's role in upholding absolute as the bedrock of baseball's cultural and financial viability, countering narratives that commercial success could supplant moral imperatives.

Fay Vincent (1989–1992)

Management of Labor Lockout and Expansion

In early 1990, Major League Baseball faced a labor impasse when owners locked out players after spring training camps opened on March 1 without a new Basic Agreement, primarily over arbitration eligibility, minimum salary increases, and revenue sharing. The 32-day lockout, the second-longest work stoppage in baseball history at the time, canceled all exhibition games and delayed the regular season's start. Commissioner Fay Vincent actively mediated between the Major League Baseball Players Association (MLBPA) and owners, proposing concessions such as lifting the lockout in exchange for a players' no-strike pledge, which the union rejected. Vincent's interventions, including direct negotiations, pressured both sides toward compromise, culminating in a new agreement on March 19, 1990, that raised the minimum salary to $100,000, shortened arbitration eligibility to two years of service (from three), and established a $10 million player development fund. The deal allowed the season to begin April 9 with a full 162-game schedule, averting further disruption, though owners criticized Vincent's role as overly interventionist and biased toward players. Vincent's handling of the lockout drew ire from owners, who viewed his —such as advocating for balanced concessions on —as undermining their leverage and favoring interests, contributing to long-term tensions. Despite this, the swift resolution preserved fan interest and revenue, with Vincent emphasizing the commissioner's duty to protect the game's public trust over unilateral owner positions. He also floated ideas like league realignment during talks to address structural imbalances exacerbating labor friction, though these were not immediately adopted. Under Vincent's oversight, MLB pursued to capitalize on growing interest and balance regional markets, announcing on June 10, 1991, franchises for , , and South Florida (Miami), both joining the for the 1993 season—the first additions since 1977. Each expansion fee was set at $95 million, split among existing teams, with selections prioritizing untapped markets: for its high-altitude potential and Rocky Mountain fan base, and for its large Hispanic population and tourism draw. This growth aimed at geographic equity, adding teams in underrepresented areas without immediate expansion to maintain competitive parity. Vincent's push ensured a structured draft process, requiring all teams to protect only 15 players, which facilitated competitive rosters for the and Marlins. While praised for broadening baseball's footprint, the process highlighted owner divisions, as Vincent mediated revenue disputes, including allocating $42 million of the 's expansion proceeds to the .

Ouster by Team Owners

Fay Vincent's tenure as commissioner increasingly strained relations with team owners, who viewed his disciplinary actions and unilateral decisions as overreaches that undermined their authority. In July 1990, Vincent enforced a suspension barring New York Yankees principal owner from day-to-day management of the team after Steinbrenner paid gambler Howie Spira $40,000 to uncover damaging information on Dave amid an ongoing contract dispute; this action, stemming from a plea agreement, effectively sidelined Steinbrenner for two years, with reinstatement conditioned on good behavior. Owners, including those sympathetic to Steinbrenner, resented Vincent's firm enforcement, perceiving it as an infringement on ownership prerogatives rather than impartial governance. Similarly, Vincent's repeated suspensions of pitcher Steve for —culminating in a lifetime ban attempt after Howe's seventh violation and guilty plea on June 8, 1992—drew criticism from clubs favoring more lenient handling of player discipline to maintain competitive rosters. These tensions escalated as Vincent vetoed owner-backed initiatives, including proposals for league realignment and the allocation of expansion franchise fees, which he sought to divide equitably between the and Leagues rather than allowing unilateral control by individual leagues. Owners, having faced financial penalties from arbitrator rulings on their 1985–1986 against free agents, prioritized reasserting collective control over an independent who they believed aligned too closely with players' interests and disrupted business operations. On September 4, , during a meeting near Chicago's O'Hare Airport, the 28 MLB owners voted 18–9, with one , to express no confidence in 's leadership and formally request his , citing his inability to foster on key issues. Vincent initially vowed to fight the resolution, threatening legal action, but resigned effective September 8, , after determining further resistance would exacerbate divisions. The ouster prompted owners to amend the Agreement, curtailing the commissioner's veto authority over ownership decisions and shifting toward a more collaborative, owner-aligned role—exemplified by the appointment of as acting commissioner—reflecting a deliberate pivot from the independent "best interests of " mandate established in 1920.

Bud Selig (1992–2015)

Oversight of Steroid Era and Testing Reforms

During Bud Selig's tenure as commissioner, experienced a marked increase in offensive production, particularly home runs, from the mid-1990s to the early , with league-wide home runs per game rising from approximately 0.88 in 1994 to a peak of 1.22 in 2000. This surge, exemplified by Mark McGwire's 70 home runs in 1998 and Barry Bonds's 73 in 2001, contributed to heightened fan interest and attendance following the 1994-1995 strike, aiding baseball's financial recovery. However, empirical correlations and player admissions later linked much of this power increase to widespread use of performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs), including anabolic steroids and , which enhance muscle mass, strength, and recovery, thereby enabling greater exit velocities and distances on batted balls. Although MLB had banned steroids since , no systematic testing occurred in the major leagues until , reflecting an initial tolerance amid the business benefits of elevated offense, as Selig later acknowledged the era's complexities but maintained ignorance of specifics until evidence mounted. Negotiations with the (MLBPA) yielded a agreement introducing anonymous survey testing in ; with over 5% positive results triggering mandatory unannounced testing starting in 2004, though penalties remained limited to education and treatment rather than suspensions. The MLBPA resisted stricter measures, prioritizing player privacy and employment protections, yet this delay perpetuated PED prevalence without solely excusing MLB's oversight in enforcement. The 2005 collective bargaining agreement marked a pivotal , establishing a Joint Drug Prevention and Treatment Program with 50-game suspensions for first offenses, 100 for second, and lifetime s for third, alongside blood testing for human in minors and expanded substances lists. Selig commissioned former U.S. Senator George Mitchell in 2006 to investigate PED use, resulting in the December 13, 2007, , a 409-page document detailing widespread steroid distribution networks and implicating 89 current or former players, including and , while criticizing both MLB and the union for a "collective failure" in addressing the issue. The report prompted heightened suspensions—such as Rafael Palmeiro's 50-game in 2005—and refinements to protocols, leading to a decline in rates to pre-surge levels by the early , validating reforms' efficacy in restoring competitive balance despite health risks like cardiovascular strain and long-term player injuries justifying intervention beyond mere popularity gains.

Business Expansions: Interleague Play and Revenue Sharing

Interleague play was introduced in in 1997 during Bud Selig's tenure as commissioner, allowing regular-season games between and teams for the first time since the leagues' separation in 1901. This innovation, alongside the 1995 addition of playoff berths and the 1994 restructuring of both leagues into three divisions each, aimed to enhance fan interest and attendance following the damage from the 1994–1995 players' strike. The inaugural interleague schedule produced a 42% attendance increase over teams' prior home averages during its opening weekend, with overall MLB attendance surging in subsequent years during these matchups, averaging higher per-game figures than intraleague games. Revenue sharing emerged as a key financial reform under Selig, formalized in the 1996 collective bargaining agreement after the 1994 strike exposed disparities between large- and small-market clubs. This system required high-revenue teams to distribute portions of their local income—initially around 14% of net local revenues—to lower-revenue clubs, supplemented by the introduction of a (luxury tax) in 1997 on payrolls exceeding league thresholds, intended to curb spending excesses without imposing a hard . The luxury tax rates escalated progressively, reaching 50% on portions above $236 million by later agreements, with funds partly allocated to to support competitive balance for small-market teams like the Milwaukee Brewers and . These measures contributed to MLB's revenue expansion from $1.2 billion in to over $8 billion by 2012, fostering greater financial stability and enabling investments in facilities and marketing that bolstered the league's global brand. Proponents, including Selig, argued that enhanced parity by aiding under-resourced franchises, as evidenced by increased playoff appearances from small-market teams post-implementation. However, critics contend diluted traditional intraleague rivalries and uneven scheduling advantaged some teams, potentially distorting competitive integrity despite attendance gains, while 's effectiveness remains debated given persistent payroll gaps between top and bottom quartiles.

1994 Strike and World Series Cancellation

The 1994 Major League Baseball strike commenced on August 12, 1994, when the (MLBPA) initiated a work stoppage following the expiration of the agreement on December 31, 1993. The primary contention centered on owners' demands for a and enhanced to address widening financial disparities among franchises and rapidly rising player compensation, which had increased from an average of $578,930 in to approximately $1.17 million by 1994. Owners argued that such measures were essential to curb payroll inflation, which threatened the viability of smaller-market teams amid stagnant local revenues in some areas, while the MLBPA rejected any cap as an infringement on free agency gains established since the . Acting Commissioner , who assumed the role in 1992 amid ongoing labor tensions, aligned with the owners' position, viewing the cap as a mechanism to impose fiscal discipline without directly colluding against free agents as in prior decades. Negotiations stalled as players walked out after 112 games into the season, halting all play and prompting the cancellation of the remaining regular-season contests, , and—on September 14, 1994—the , marking the first such forfeiture in MLB . This decision, announced by Selig, reflected the owners' impasse declaration and underscored the strike's severity, with 948 games ultimately lost and an estimated $1 billion in combined revenues forgone by teams, players, and affiliates. The 232-day disruption eroded public support, as fan attendance plummeted in subsequent seasons—dropping 20-30% in 1995—and fueled perceptions of player intransigence amid average salaries exceeding team revenues in low-market clubs. Owners unilaterally implemented salary caps and contract curbs in December 1994, prompting MLBPA decertification and a challenge that led to a federal injunction on March 31, 1995, mandating resumption of play. came via in July 1995, where owners prevailed on key impasse issues, paving the way for a new agreement that substituted a with a on high payrolls—phased in at rates up to 100% on amounts exceeding thresholds like $52 million initially—effectively curbing escalation indirectly while preserving arbitration and free agency. This outcome, ratified in 1996 after further talks, stabilized finances by linking player pay to league revenues at roughly 50%, though it drew criticism from players for conceding ground after prolonged fan alienation.

Rob Manfred (2015–present)

Handling of Sign-Stealing Scandals

Under 's leadership, confronted electronic sign-stealing scandals, most prominently involving the Houston Astros in 2017. The Astros employed a center-field camera to capture catchers' signs, relaying them via monitors and trash-can bangs to alert batters, aiding their victory. MLB's January 13, 2020, investigation, prompted by whistleblower , confirmed the scheme persisted into the playoffs despite a September 2017 league memo banning such electronics. Punishments included a $5 million fine—the maximum under MLB rules—loss of first- and second-round draft picks in 2020 and 2021, and one-year suspensions for manager and general manager , who were subsequently fired by the team. No players faced discipline, as Manfred granted immunity to encourage cooperation, citing deleted evidence and agreement (CBA) protections limiting commissioner authority over on-field personnel; he later expressed regret over this immunity decision in , acknowledging it constrained harsher measures. Similar violations drew responses from other teams. In 2017, the New York Yankees were fined $100,000 for using a dugout phone to decode and relay signs, with opting against draft forfeitures after internal review. The Boston Red Sox faced a $1 million fine and loss of $500,000 in international signing funds in April 2020 for 2018 video-room misuse to steal signs, alongside a one-year ban for replay operator J.T. Watkins and video coordinator Perez; manager , linked to both Astros and Red Sox schemes, received a year-long . These cases stemmed from an analytics-driven push exploiting video replay systems installed league-wide, blurring lines between permissible data use and cheating. To curb recurrence, enforced stricter technology protocols, including dedicated monitors in stadiums for umpires to detect violations and memos reiterating bans on electronic decoding. He defended the Astros penalties as a deterrent, arguing full player was infeasible without preservation, though critics, including and executives, contended the measures inadequately restored competitive , fostering lingering and boos for Astros personnel. Such leniency, tied to limits and immunity incentives, highlighted tensions between rapid investigation and punitive rigor, with some attributing scandals to unchecked technological arms races prioritizing edges over ethics.

Labor Disputes, Rule Innovations, and Pace-of-Play Changes

The (MLBPA) and team owners engaged in a 99-day lockout from December 2, 2021, to March 10, 2022, the longest in MLB history, which delayed and the start of the 2022 season by about a week. The dispute centered on , competitive balance, and player compensation, with owners proposing a salary floor to discourage low-spending teams from tanking and players pushing for higher thresholds to limit payroll disparities without a hard cap. The resulting five-year agreement (), effective through 2026, raised the minimum player salary from $570,500 to $700,000 in 2022 with annual $20,000 increases, but omitted a salary floor or cap, instead elevating thresholds starting at $230 million in 2022. A key rule innovation was the adoption of the universal (DH) in both leagues, eliminating the need for pitchers to bat in the and standardizing gameplay across MLB. To address declining fan interest in protracted games, MLB introduced a in the 2023 season, mandating pitchers to begin delivery within 15 seconds with bases empty or 18 seconds with runners on, following successful trials in the . This reform, combined with limits on pickoff attempts and larger bases, reduced the average nine-inning game time from 3 hours and 4 minutes in 2022 to 2 hours and 40 minutes in 2023—a decrease of approximately 24 minutes—while increasing action through more stolen bases and balls in play. Empirical data showed attendance rose 9.15% in 2023, the largest single-year league-wide increase in three decades, attributed in part to shorter, more dynamic games that appealed to younger audiences without diminishing competitive quality. These pace-of-play changes were implemented unilaterally by MLB after negotiations, reflecting Rob Manfred's emphasis on modernizing the sport amid stagnant television ratings. As of October 2025, MLB continued discussions on rule innovations tied to international expansion, with expressing optimism for top players' participation in the 2028 through an extended break from July 14 to 30, potentially accommodating baseball's tournament schedule. Negotiations with Olympic organizers and the MLBPA have progressed, focusing on logistical hurdles like player insurance and travel, though noted it might remain a one-off event rather than a recurring commitment. This initiative aligns with broader efforts to integrate MLB into global events, building on prior successes, but requires consensus amid the expiring 2026 .

Global Outreach, Media Deals, and Pete Rose Reinstatement

Under Rob 's leadership, has pursued expanded global outreach through initiatives like the (), which returned in 2023 after a six-year hiatus and demonstrated significant growth in international viewership and participation, with confirming its recurrence in 2026 as a centerpiece of the league's international strategy. The 2023 event featured top MLB talent from multiple nations, contributing to baseball's promotion in regions like and , where has emphasized sustaining growth via global events and overseas games. Additionally, MLB has expressed growing confidence in participating in the 2028 , with stating in October 2025 that big-league players are likely to compete, potentially via an extended All-Star break from July 15-20 at , marking a potential return to baseball after MLB's absence since 2008 due to prior scheduling conflicts. Manfred has overseen transformative media rights agreements to capitalize on streaming trends and broaden revenue streams, culminating in September 2025 announcements of three-year deals for 2026-2028 with , , and , which include national broadcasts, marquee events like the , and expanded digital access to out-of-market games. These pacts, valued at enhancing MLB's visibility amid , integrate 's streaming platform for select content, potentially preempting some games for NFL overlaps on , while retains core packages including local broadcasts for five MLB-controlled teams. The agreements reflect Manfred's push to unify fragmented rights, moving beyond the prior deal that expired after 2025, and aim to distribute content across traditional TV and platforms for sustained financial growth. A notable controversial decision in Manfred's tenure involved the reinstatement of Pete Rose, MLB's all-time hits leader banned in 1989 for gambling on games as Cincinnati Reds manager, whose permanent ineligibility was lifted on May 13, 2025, eight months after his death on September 30, 2024, as part of a broader policy change applying to 17 deceased individuals including "Shoeless" Joe Jackson. Manfred announced that permanent bans would henceforth expire upon death, rendering Rose eligible for Baseball Hall of Fame consideration and framing the move as aligning with the league's recognition of historical talent despite the integrity violations that prompted the original ban under Commissioner Bart Giamatti. Proponents, including Manfred who described it as "overdue," argue it honors Rose's on-field achievements—4,256 hits and three World Series titles—without retroactively endorsing gambling, which MLB maintains undermines competitive integrity. Critics contend the policy erodes precedent for lifelong accountability, potentially signaling leniency toward betting scandals in an era of legalized sports wagering partnerships with MLB, though the posthumous nature limits practical precedent for living players.

Challenges to the Commissioner's Office

Owners' Efforts to Curtail Independence

In response to Commissioner Fay Vincent's ouster on September 6, 1992, owners amended the Major League Agreement in February 1994 to restrict the commissioner's "" authority, confining it primarily to safeguarding public confidence and game integrity while excluding intervention in business matters such as , television contracts, franchise expansion, relocation, postseason play, and scheduling. These revisions mandated commissioner consultation with and approval from a three-quarters (21 of 28 owners at the time) for major disciplinary or operational actions, effectively subordinating unilateral powers established under Kenesaw Mountain Landis's 1921 agreement to owner supermajorities and recasting the commissioner as the owners' primary labor negotiator rather than an arbiter. During Bud Selig's tenure, formalized in 1998, owners further aligned the office with collective interests by eliminating the American and presidencies on September 16, 1999, thereby centralizing day-to-day operations under the commissioner while preserving veto thresholds that prevented decisive action without broad consensus. This post-1990s framework empirically diminished the commissioner's capacity for swift, independent enforcement, as owner majorities could delay or block responses to threats against league integrity, providing a structural against individual overreach—such as Vincent's suspensions of owners—but introducing risks of protracted inaction when owner-aligned interests conflicted with broader game standards.

Balancing Stakeholder Interests in a Unionized Era

The (MLBPA), established in 1966 and strengthened under leaders like , has wielded substantial influence through agreements (CBAs), compelling commissioners to mediate entrenched tensions among owners seeking cost controls and competitive parity, players demanding higher compensation and protections, and fans prioritizing game integrity and accessibility. CBAs codify player rights, often constraining the commissioner's disciplinary authority; for instance, suspensions exceeding 10 games trigger mandatory , where neutral arbitrators review proportionality and "just cause," limiting unilateral commissioner actions that might otherwise preserve league standards. This framework, while curbing potential abuses of power, has enabled the union to challenge penalties for on-field misconduct or off-field behavior deemed detrimental to the game, fostering perceptions of accountability gaps that undermine fan trust in enforcement consistency. Salary , introduced in the 1973 CBA and refined in subsequent agreements, exemplifies -driven mechanisms that escalate player pay, with empirical analyses showing arbitrated outcomes favoring players by aligning salaries more closely with performance metrics while exerting upward pressure on overall compensation. From 1974 to 2022, arbitration decisions accounted for approximately $1.64 billion in player salaries (in 2022 dollars), often resulting in settlements exceeding pre-arbitration figures and contributing to league-wide payroll inflation that strains smaller-market owners and distorts competitive balance. Critics argue this system incentivizes short-term individual gains over collective sustainability, as teams face compressed negotiation windows and higher financial commitments, indirectly burdening fans through elevated ticket prices and reduced roster flexibility. Such dynamics challenge commissioners to enforce fiscal restraint without alienating the , which has historically resisted caps or floors that might stabilize revenues but curb player earnings. Commercial imperatives, including the post-2018 expansion of legalized sports betting following the Supreme Court's PASPA repeal, have integrated gambling apps like DraftKings and FanDuel as official MLB partners, generating billions in league revenue through data deals and in-stadium promotions. Yet this shift heightens risks to game integrity, with monitoring firms like IC360 flagging anomalous wagering patterns—such as bets on specific pitches in 2025 Guardians games—and prompting lifetime bans for players involved in game-related betting, alongside one-year suspensions for peripheral violations. Addiction concerns persist, as expanded access correlates with rising problem gambling rates, potentially eroding fan engagement if scandals proliferate; empirical data from integrity monitors underscore the need for vigilant oversight over revenue pursuits, prioritizing causal safeguards like real-time bet tracking to avert fixes that could irreparably damage public perception. Efforts to address demographic representation through (DEI) initiatives, such as MLB's Diversity Pipeline Program launched in 2020, face scrutiny for conflating representational metrics with merit-based outcomes, with studies revealing persistent barriers to advancement for certain groups despite surface-level gains. Empirical examinations of MLB teams indicate no robust causal link between increased workforce and on-field , as measured by win-loss or metrics, suggesting such programs may divert resources from verifiable pipelines without enhancing competitive edges. In a ized context, where player selection emphasizes empirical skills over quotas, commissioners must navigate owner mandates for inclusive hiring against for protections, avoiding politicized frameworks that prioritize identity over integrity and risk alienating stakeholders invested in -driven success. This tension underscores the imperative to ground policies in on advancement rather than normalized narratives of systemic disadvantage, ensuring decisions align with causal realities of evaluation.

References

  1. [1]
    About MLB | Official Information
    Led by Commissioner ... role in society and permeating every facet of baseball's business, marketing, community relations and social responsibility endeavors.
  2. [2]
    Baseball's First Commissioner: The Hiring of Judge Kenesaw ...
    Jul 13, 2021 · Federal judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis was hired as baseball's first commissioner in November 1920. He served in that role for nearly a quarter-century until ...
  3. [3]
    Kenesaw Mountain Landis | Commissioners | About MLB
    Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis was elected baseball's first Commissioner on January 12, 1921. Born the sixth of seven children on November 20, 1866 in Milville, ...
  4. [4]
    Commissioner - BR Bullpen - Baseball-Reference.com
    The Commissioner of Baseball is the chief executive of Major League Baseball. The office was established in 1920. The current commissioner is Rob Manfred.
  5. [5]
    Kenesaw Landis - Baseball Hall of Fame
    In his first major act as commissioner, Landis banned eight White Sox players from baseball for life for their involvement with New York gambler Arnold ...
  6. [6]
    The Black Sox Scandal - Society for American Baseball Research
    Talented members of that White Sox club conspired with professional gamblers to rig the outcome of the 1919 World Series.
  7. [7]
    What Was the 1919 'Black Sox' Baseball Scandal? - History.com
    Oct 9, 2014 · In 1919, Chicago White Sox players, called "Black Sox," allegedly threw the World Series for money, and were later banned from baseball.<|separator|>
  8. [8]
    The Black Sox Scandal - The New York Times: This Day In Sports
    Seven star players for the Chicago White Sox and one former player were indicted late this afternoon, charged with complicity in a conspiracy with gamblers.<|separator|>
  9. [9]
    How Cheap was Charles Comiskey? Salaries and the Black Sox
    Dec 9, 2019 · So while Charlie was cheap, he was no cheaper than any of his contemporaries, all of whom routinely used the reserve clause to exploit player ...
  10. [10]
    Baseball's Reserve Clause | Federal Judicial Center
    By forbidding the voluntary movement of players to other teams, the reserve clause kept salaries artificially low and gave players no say over where they ...
  11. [11]
    Kenesaw Mountain Landis - Society for American Baseball Research
    Apr 16, 2020 · As baseball's first commissioner, Landis was the first and last court of recourse. Though standing only 5-feet-6 and weighing about 130 pounds, Landis was an ...
  12. [12]
    'Best interests of baseball' a wide-ranging power - MLB.com
    Aug 1, 2013 · The Commissioner has the power to take action against clubs or players if he believes they've done something that strikes at the integrity of the game or the ...
  13. [13]
    [PDF] The Authority of the Commissioner of Major League Baseball
    In November 1920, baseball owners announced that Landis was their choice as baseball's first commissioner. A committee of own- ers promptly was established ...
  14. [14]
    [PDF] Rule 21 - MLB.com
    (a) MISCONDUCT IN PLAYING BASEBALL. Any player or person connected with a Club who shall promise or agree to lose, or to attempt to lose, or to fail to give ...
  15. [15]
    [PDF] MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL'S JOINT DRUG PREVENTION AND ...
    The IPA shall have no authority to discipline Players for violations of the Program. All such authority shall repose in the. Commissioner's Office. The IPA ...
  16. [16]
    Forum: The Supreme Court (of Baseball) - The Yale Law Journal
    Sep 27, 2011 · ... best interests of baseball”—a power that its successor would be granted. Nevertheless, the National Commission oversaw baseball for almost ...
  17. [17]
    MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred on Rays' 2025 ballpark ...
    Nov 20, 2024 · Commissioner Manfred discusses Rays' ballpark situation, expansion timeline and more. November 20th, 2024. Mark Feinsand. @feinsand. Share ...
  18. [18]
    The Economic History of Major League Baseball – EH.net
    In 1913 Western Union paid each team $17,000 per year over five years for the rights to broadcast the games. The movie industry purchased the rights to film and ...<|separator|>
  19. [19]
    MLB Revenues Hit Record $12.1 Billion In 2024 - Forbes
    Jan 27, 2025 · The league reported $12.1 billion in gross revenues for last year; a record high. Forbes could not independently verify the figure.Missing: 1990s | Show results with:1990s
  20. [20]
    MLB revenues continue to rise despite decline in popularity, while ...
    Nov 9, 2022 · Thirty years ago the two leagues were almost equal in terms of gross revenue at around $1.5 billion. But now the MLB is over $10 billion while ...Missing: 1990s | Show results with:1990s
  21. [21]
    A commissioner's job description changes with the times - USA Today
    Aug 13, 2014 · The modern commissioner must have expertise in TV contracts, labor relations, player health, handling Congress, handling lawsuits, criminal law, ...
  22. [22]
    Major League Baseball Commissioners
    Since its inception, professional baseball has appointed one top executive, the Commissioner of Baseball, to oversee the entire operation and maintain the ...
  23. [23]
    https://www.espn.com/mlb/history/commissioners
  24. [24]
    [PDF] Professional Sports League Commissioners' Authority and ...
    See generally Reinsdorf, supra note 22 (detailing the various amendments to the Commissioner's power since the adoption of the Major League Agreement); Pachman, ...
  25. [25]
    [PDF] The Powers of the Commissioner in Baseball - CORE
    Prior to the 1994 amendment of Section 5, a Commissioner was authorized to take such action. Following the 1994 amendment to Section 5, the above situation.Missing: strike | Show results with:strike
  26. [26]
    The Exemption of Baseball from Federal Antitrust Laws: A Legal ...
    Baseball's continued exemption from federal antitrust laws next was upheld by the United States Supreme Court in 1953 in the case of Toolson v. New York Yankees ...
  27. [27]
    MLB sends letter to Congress to address antitrust claim
    Jul 29, 2022 · “The baseball exemption,” Manfred writes, “gives the Commissioner the ability to investigate and sanction misconduct without subjecting MLB's ...
  28. [28]
    Judge Landis and baseball's ban hammer - SABR.org
    Nov 19, 2024 · By 1921, after Landis was hired as commissioner to replace the National Commission, he had the ultimate authority to make his own judgment of “ ...
  29. [29]
    Ban Johnson and Exposure of the Black Sox Scandal
    Dec 27, 2023 · Although the honor is customarily accorded to Hugh Fullerton or Kenesaw Mountain Landis, the pivotal character in the Black Sox saga is Ban ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
  30. [30]
    13 Not So Famous Baseball Players Banned by Kenesaw Mountain ...
    Jun 7, 2015 · The banned “Black Sox” ( Shoeless Joe Jackson , Happy Felsch , Buck Weaver , Swede Risberg , Fred McMullin , Chick Gandil , Lefty Williams and ...
  31. [31]
    [PDF] Baseball at the Precipice of a Watershed Moment in the Production ...
    May 7, 2021 · Though baseball fans are quick to accept the triumph of baseball over its gambling past, the. Black Sox Scandal remains tied to the sport's ...
  32. [32]
    Saving Baseball after the 1919 Black Sox Scandal
    May 4, 2020 · Eight players from the Chicago White Sox conspired with gamblers to throw baseball games and lose the sport's penultimate event: the World Series.
  33. [33]
    Paul Robeson met Judge Landis to end baseball segregation
    Dec 19, 2024 · Landis could have broken the color bar in the 1920s, when he ruled the game with an iron fist and owners feared crossing him. His powers over ...
  34. [34]
    Does Baseball Deserve This Black Eye? Landis and Baseball ...
    Jul 18, 2009 · More than once Landis said, “If [anybody] wants to sign one or 25 Negro players, it is all right with me. That is the business of the manager ...
  35. [35]
    Can You Read, Judge Landis?
    Feb 18, 2021 · In spite of these facts, some researchers contend that Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis must be held blameless for extending the color line; ...
  36. [36]
    Landis, Baseball, and Racism — A Brief Comment - SABR.org
    Jul 18, 2009 · As the leader of a major public institution, Organized Baseball, Judge Landis resisted attempts to move that institution to desegregate. One can ...
  37. [37]
    1930 Winter Meetings: The Judge and the Mahatma Debate the ...
    ... farm systems to avoid draft expenses. Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis greatly disliked what he termed this “chain-store” model of ownership.7. Rumors ...
  38. [38]
    Commissioner Kenesaw Landis Biography - Baseball Almanac
    As an acting Federal Judge from 1905-1922, Landis was selected in 1920 to become the first Commissioner of Major League Baseball, serving until his death in ...
  39. [39]
    Albert Benjamin "Happy" Chandler | Commissioners | About MLB
    Although all 15 other clubs disapproved, Chandler welcomed the idea, and in October 1945, the Dodgers signed Jackie Robinson to a 1946 contract with their ...Missing: approval | Show results with:approval
  40. [40]
    Jackie Robinson in 1945: Signing with the Dodgers
    “Happy” Chandler was elected as his successor on April 24, 1945. There was ... So you bring him in and I'll approve the transfer.” Read more: “Happy ...
  41. [41]
    Happy Chandler Had to Approve Robinson's Dodger Contract
    May 10, 1987 · I told my chief contract man, George Dedman, that Jackie Robinson's contract would be submitted and if it was in order it was to be approved.
  42. [42]
    Happy Helping? Inside Commissioner Chandler's Role in Jackie ...
    Jan 11, 2022 · Rickey sought Chandler's approval and support before deciding to call up Robinson – which Chandler unequivocally granted. 3. Chandler lost ...
  43. [43]
    Robinson Breaks the Color Line in Major-League Baseball - EBSCO
    Later, Chandler would claim he had made his decision because he did not wish to explain to his Creator that he had denied a fellow human being a chance to play ...<|separator|>
  44. [44]
    https://journals.openedition.org/transatlantica/5462
  45. [45]
    MAILBOX; Happy Chandler's Stand On Integration Supported
    Mar 15, 1981 · In the summer of 1946, the major league owners voted, 15-1, to keep blacks out of major league baseball - with Rickey dissenting. He had signed ...
  46. [46]
    Reflections on African Americans in Baseball - PubMed Central - NIH
    But when Jackie Robinson hurdled baseball's racial divide, the Negro Leagues were sacrificed on integration's altar. Integration was a resounding success on the ...
  47. [47]
    Baseball's Most Colorful Commissioner: Happy Chandler - SABR.org
    In August 1946 they moved to protect baseball's reserve clause with a new uniform contract and to placate players with a $5,000 minimum salary, spring training ...Missing: post- expansion initiatives
  48. [48]
    https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/happy-chandler
  49. [49]
    Happy Chandler | Biography & Facts - Britannica
    American politician and baseball executive who served in the US Senate (1939–45) and as governor of Kentucky (1935–39, 1955–59)Missing: initiatives revenue<|separator|>
  50. [50]
    Chandler, Albert Benjamin ("Happy") | Encyclopedia.com
    Chandler feuded with the American League over umpire compensation, fined teams for violations of high school signing regulations, located his offices in ...Missing: conflicts | Show results with:conflicts
  51. [51]
    https://thisdayinbaseball.com/commissioner-happy-chandler-loses-his-bid-to-remain-in-office/
  52. [52]
    1950 Winter Meetings: The Happy Dagger
    By far the big moment of the meetings came when the 16 owners surprisingly voted against renewing Commissioner Happy Chandler's contract. ... Chandler's ouster ...Missing: salaries | Show results with:salaries
  53. [53]
    Major League Baseball on television in the 1950s - Wikipedia
    These were not "national" broadcast contracts since they were assembled through negotiations with individual teams to telecast games from their home parks.Missing: details | Show results with:details
  54. [54]
    Ford Frick - Society for American Baseball Research
    Oct 10, 2018 · He urged the owners to share local television revenue to balance the financial scales.50. Frick listed his proudest achievements as racial ...Missing: 1950s impact
  55. [55]
    Ford Frick - Baseball Hall of Fame
    Frick also negotiated television contracts that brought unprecedented revenue and visibility to the game. “Through 30 years as a baseball leader, he brought ...Missing: introducing 1950s
  56. [56]
    Sports on Television | Encyclopedia.com
    MLB commissioner Ford Frick (1894–1974) was so concerned about television's effect on attendance at baseball games that he took steps to limit the quality of ...
  57. [57]
    N.B.C. Will Pay $30.6 Million For Baseball TV in New Pact
    N.B.C. will pay each of the 20 big-league clubs $300,000 a year for a "game of the week" in 1966, 1967 and 1968. That will mean $6 million a year, or $18 ...Missing: 1951-1965 | Show results with:1951-1965<|separator|>
  58. [58]
    TV brought baseball to fans who had never seen a game
    On Aug. 26, 1939, NBC telecast a first professional game: Cincinnati at Brooklyn. "No monitor, only two cameras at Ebbets Field,” said Dodgers' ...Missing: contract | Show results with:contract
  59. [59]
    Roger Maris 61 Home Runs - Baseball Almanac
    Commissioner Ford Frick decided that Maris' record would not stand against Ruth's because it was not done during the same number of games. Maris could not take ...
  60. [60]
    Record Of Maris Has No Asterisk - The New York Times
    "Most home runs by player, season, 61, Roger Maris." The significant point is that there is no star, asterisk or footnote attached to the listing to show ...
  61. [61]
    Rickey's Folly: How the Continental League Forced Baseball ...
    “Probably no single program in baseball history,” Commissioner Ford Frick wrote, “created more controversy, aroused stronger fan feeling, or brought more ...
  62. [62]
    Frick Backs Proposal to Provide Uniformity in Franchise Shifting
    The measure, sponsored by the National League, aims to set up uniform rules for governing any shift in a major-league franchise. The transfer last spring, when ...
  63. [63]
    Expansion of 1969 - BR Bullpen - Baseball-Reference.com
    Jul 15, 2021 · On October 15, a draft was held for the Kansas City Royals and the Seattle Pilots of the American League. The Royals took pitcher Roger Nelson ...
  64. [64]
    Expansion, Round Two: How Charlie Finley Blew Up Baseball
    He refused to sign a new lease on the Kansas City ballpark and announced plans to move to Oakland. He had worn down his fellow owners. They approved the move at ...
  65. [65]
    April 8, 1969: Mike Hegan homers, sacrifices body for win in Seattle ...
    Aug 2, 2022 · Seattle and Kansas City were granted AL expansion franchises for the 1969 season. ... Earlier in the day, the Kansas City Royals, Montreal ...
  66. [66]
    Baseball History in 1969: The Amazin' Mets - This Great Game
    Three of the four new teams stretch baseball's geographic limits to extremes, with the Montreal Expos, San Diego Padres and Seattle Pilots joining the ranks.
  67. [67]
    The Major Leagues in 1968 and the Transition to a New Modern Era
    Apr 13, 2021 · Much maligned as feckless in his role as commissioner, William Eckert announced a set of rules changes about two weeks before his forced ...
  68. [68]
    William Eckert - Society for American Baseball Research
    Jan 8, 2012 · Retired Air Force Lieutenant General William Eckert was named commissioner of baseball in late 1965 from a list of candidates that included more than 150 names.
  69. [69]
    PROGRESS REPORT ON THE UNKNOWN SOLDIER | SI.com
    PROGRESS REPORT ON THE UNKNOWN SOLDIER. When Lieut. General William D. Eckert was named Commissioner of Baseball last fall his appointment was greeted with ...
  70. [70]
    Ranking the MLB COMMISSIONERS!! - Humm Baby Baseball
    Dec 30, 2022 · There have been 10 commissioners in the history of Major League Baseball, beginning with Kenasaw Mountain Landis in 1920. Of course, we all know ...Missing: evolution authority modern<|separator|>
  71. [71]
    Commissioner William “Spike” Eckert resigns under pressure from ...
    On December 6, 1968, Commissioner William “Spike” Eckert, sometimes referred to as the 'Unknown Solider', resigns under pressure from the major league ...Missing: reappointed | Show results with:reappointed
  72. [72]
    Flood v. Kuhn | 407 U.S. 258 (1972)
    In December, he complained to the Commissioner of Baseball and asked that he be made a free agent and be placed at liberty to strike his own bargain with any ...
  73. [73]
    Curt Flood's letter to Bowie Kuhn: 50 years later, a close look at the ...
    Dec 24, 2019 · Curt Flood sent the letter 50 years ago today, on Christmas Eve, to baseball commissioner Bowie Kuhn. It would change the sport forever.
  74. [74]
    [PDF] How Marvin Miller, Andy Messersmith and Dave McNally Brought ...
    Commissioner Bowie Kuhn had another option that would have allowed him to prevent Messersmith and McNally from having their grievances heard before a neutral.
  75. [75]
    [PDF] “Baseball Would Certainly Fail”: A History of Sports Leagues ...
    missioner Bowie Kuhn responded as follows: I am enormously disturbed by this arbitration decision. It is just incon- ceivable that after nearly 100 years of ...
  76. [76]
    [PDF] from flood to free agency: the messersmith-mcnally arbitration ...
    Indeed, Bowie Kuhn, as a witness at the hearing, stated that the issue before the Arbitration Board was one that should not be decided in arbitration but by ...
  77. [77]
    Fall 2000: The Messersmith Decision: A Look Back
    After the season, Bowie Kuhn insisted that the higher salaries resulting from free agency would inevitably lead to higher ticket prices. Marvin Miller disagrees ...
  78. [78]
    Baseball Strike Is Settled; Season to Open Tomorrow
    Apr 14, 1972 · “It's inevitable that there will be hard feelings,” said Bowie Kuhn, the commissioner of baseball. “My job is to hold them to a minimum. Who ...
  79. [79]
    Bowie Kent Kuhn | Commissioners | About MLB | Official Information
    Bowie K. Kuhn was elected baseball's fifth Commissioner by a unanimous vote of the 24 club owners on February 4, 1969.
  80. [80]
    Bowie Kuhn - Society for American Baseball Research
    and a stronger players' union — had come to the major ... Opposition was fierce, particularly from former commissioner Ford Frick ...
  81. [81]
    Major Leagues Establish a Program to Control Taking of Drugs by ...
    Feb 19, 1971 · Major league baseball has or ganized a drug education pro gram for its clubs, Commis sioner Bowie Kuhn announced yesterday.
  82. [82]
    The RULES, The LAW, The REALITY - Sports Illustrated Vault | SI.com
    Feb 16, 2009 · Baseball's first written drug policy was issued by commissioner Bowie Kuhn at the start of the '71 season.Missing: anti- | Show results with:anti-<|separator|>
  83. [83]
    KUHN BANS 4 PLAYERS FOR A YEAR FOR DRUG USE
    Dec 16, 1983 · Bowie Kuhn, the commissioner of baseball, imposed one-year suspensions without pay yesterday on four players involved with the use of illegal drugs.Missing: policies | Show results with:policies
  84. [84]
    Baseball commissioner Bowie Kuhn's one-year suspensions ... - UPI
    Under Kuhn's ruling, the suspensions of Wilson, Martin and Aikens can be reviewedon May 15 and those three players could then be reinstated. However, Howe's ...
  85. [85]
    12/15/83 Bowie Kuhn suspends Willie Wilson, Willie Aikens, Jerry ...
    Dec 15, 2024 · Vida Blue, along with Royals teammates Willie Aikens, Willie Wilson, and Jerry Martin were suspended for the entire 1984 season due to cocaine ...
  86. [86]
    A Brief History of MLB Drug-Suspension Arbitration (or, Don't Worry ...
    Aug 21, 2013 · In 1983, Richard Block overturned Commissioner Bowie Kuhn's one-year suspension of the Kansas City Royals' Willie Wilson and Jerry Martin for ...
  87. [87]
    Baseball Commissioner Bowie Kuhn today announced the ... - UPI
    May 15, 1984 · ... suspensions from baseball because of guilty pleas to charges of cocaine possession. Kuhn's decision means that Aikens, Martin and Wilson can ...
  88. [88]
    KUHN ANNOUNCES RULES ON DRUG CRIMES
    Jun 29, 1984 · Major league baseball players who are found guilty of drug-related crimes will face a minimum one-year suspension and could be barred for life.
  89. [89]
    BLUE SUSPENDED FOR THE YEAR - The New York Times
    Jul 27, 1984 · Commissioner Bowie Kuhn announced yesterday that he had suspended Vida Blue from playing for any team for the rest of this season because of ...
  90. [90]
    Baseball Commissioner Suspends Mickey Mantle and Willie Mays ...
    Motivated by a desire to distance Major League Baseball from any trace of gambling, Commissioner Bowie Kuhn banned retired superstars Willie Mays and Mickey ...
  91. [91]
    Today in Baseball History: When Mantle and Mays were banned ...
    Mar 18, 2020 · Major League Baseball actually banned two of the greatest players in its history for merely agreeing to shake hands with people at a casino.
  92. [92]
    MAYS, MANTLE REINSTATED BY BASEBALL COMMISSIONER
    Mar 19, 1985 · The new baseball commissioner, Peter Ueberroth, reversed the decision of his predecessor, Bowie Kuhn, by reinstating the two Hall of Fame members immediately.
  93. [93]
    12 Days That Shook MLB: Finley Sells Fingers, Rudi, Blue Only to ...
    Jun 15, 2020 · Finley refused to let the three players play, or even put on an Oakland uniform. The A's owners also said he was going to sue Kuhn over the ...
  94. [94]
    Finley v. Kuhn and the Power of the Commissioner
    Oct 4, 2016 · Neither is it an appellate judicial review of the wisdom of Bowie Kuhn's actions. The question before the court is not whether Bowie Kuhn was ...
  95. [95]
    When a $3.5-Million Sale of Oakland A's Stars Rocked Baseball
    Aug 2, 2021 · Three days after the sale, MLB commissioner Bowie Kuhn infuriated longtime nemesis Finley by voiding the transactions, citing his best-interests ...
  96. [96]
    Commissioner Bowie Kuhn voids the sales of Oakland A's stars Vida ...
    On June 18, 1976, Commissioner Bowie Kuhn voids the sales of Oakland A's stars Vida Blue, Rollie Fingers, and Joe Rudi.Missing: conflicts | Show results with:conflicts
  97. [97]
    Charles O. Finley & Co., Inc. v. Kuhn, 569 F.2d 527 (7th Cir. 1978)
    The complaint alleged that the "action of Kuhn was arbitrary, capricious, unreasonable, discriminatory, directly contrary to historical precedent, baseball ...Missing: disciplinary | Show results with:disciplinary<|control11|><|separator|>
  98. [98]
    Finley Files $10 Million Suit, Challenges Kuhn's Authority
    Jun 26, 1976 · Finley sued Commissioner Bowie Kuhn for $10 million in damages ... Kuhn lacked the authority to void the sales of the players. There ...Missing: voided | Show results with:voided
  99. [99]
    Bowie the K and Charlie O | The Hardball Times - FanGraphs
    Jun 15, 2016 · Finley hired sports attorney Neil Papiano to sue Kuhn for restraint of trade. So Finley filed suit in federal court in Chicago and asked for $10 ...Missing: conflicts | Show results with:conflicts
  100. [100]
    The Business of Baseball
    By 1990, average annual team revenues will jump to $40 million, primarily because major league baseball recently sold national broadcast rights for the 1990-93 ...<|separator|>
  101. [101]
    MLB collusion, explained | SB Nation
    Jan 18, 2018 · Ueberroth convinced the owners to run their teams like their other businesses to make money while emphasizing that profits were more important ...Missing: financial reforms
  102. [102]
    Peter Ueberroth - Society for American Baseball Research
    Sep 26, 2023 · In the summer of 1985, a potential work stoppage lay on the horizon. A 1983 TV deal worth $1 billion had quadrupled MLB's revenue, yet owners ...Missing: reforms | Show results with:reforms
  103. [103]
    The History of Sponsorship Part 2: Peter Ueberroth - SponsorCX
    By leaning on television rights, ticket sales, and a bold new sponsorship model, Ueberroth not only avoided financial collapse but produced a surplus.Missing: reduced | Show results with:reduced
  104. [104]
    This Is Your Sport on Cocaine: The Pittsburgh Trials of 1985
    Dec 14, 2021 · Ueberroth believed that Latin America was a key to the cocaine problem, and he tried to extend mandatory drug testing to the winter leagues in ...
  105. [105]
    MLB commissioner suspends players in drug scandal - History.com
    Dec 13, 2021 · Ueberroth's suspensions were much less severe because none of the players had failed drug tests and the abuse seemed to be a thing of the past.
  106. [106]
    BASEBALL ORDERS SUSPENSION OF 11 DRUG USERS
    Mar 1, 1986 · However, Mr. Ueberroth offered to lift the suspensions if the players agreed to certain conditions, including contributing 10 percent of their ...
  107. [107]
    Ueberroth Suspends Seven Players for Use of Drugs
    Mar 1, 1986 · --Each must donate 10% of his 1986 base salary to a drug program or facility in his club's home city.
  108. [108]
    Baseball Commissioner Peter Ueberroth Friday punished 21 players ...
    Feb 28, 1986 · Baseball Commissioner Peter Ueberroth Friday punished 21 players for their involvement with drugs. He also weighed the fate of three others.
  109. [109]
    The Empire Strikes Out: Collusion in Baseball in the 1980s
    It was an attempt by baseball owners to slow a dramatic rise in player salaries and to ratchet down their teams' liabilities for long-term contracts that were ...
  110. [110]
    Prospectus Feature: Assessing Barry Bonds' Collusion Case
    May 18, 2015 · Commissioner Peter Ueberroth took up the cause, calling long-term contracts “dumb.” Then, after a few more meetings, Leland MacPhail, the ...
  111. [111]
    1985 Winter Meetings: Free-Agent Freezeout: Collusion I
    Seven players were banned for a year and four for 60 days. 30 Ueberroth later removed the suspensions when each agreed to community service and to donate 5 to ...Missing: reforms | Show results with:reforms
  112. [112]
    Collusion, Tanking, Debt: Yes, Baseball Has A Dark Labor History ...
    Feb 12, 2018 · John Helyar, in his seminal book on baseball labor, Lords of the Realm, details an October 22, 1985, meeting between the owners and Ueberroth, ...
  113. [113]
    Arbitrator Rules Baseball Owners Guilty of Collusion
    Sep 22, 1987 · on Feb. 2, 1986, Roberts wrote that the owners conspired to “destroy” free agency after the 1985 season, violating Article XVIII, Section H, of ...
  114. [114]
    ARBITRATOR: BASEBALL OWNERS IN COLLUSION
    Sep 22, 1987 · The Major League Baseball Players Association won the first round of its 1985 collusion grievance Monday when arbitrator Thomas Roberts ruled ...
  115. [115]
    Agent: Baseball Owners Agree to Pay $280 Million
    Nov 4, 1990 · Baseball owners have agreed to pay players $280 million to settle the collusion cases, a player agent said Saturday.
  116. [116]
    HISTORY | MLBPA Players
    The players prevailed in that grievance, too, and, in November 1990, reached a final settlement to all three collusion cases in which $280 million in damages ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
  117. [117]
    THE PETE ROSE DECISION : Legal Opinion : THE GIAMATTI TEXT
    Aug 25, 1989 · “This sorry episode began last February when baseball received firm allegations that Mr. Rose bet on baseball games and on the Reds' games. Such ...
  118. [118]
    [PDF] office of the commissioner major league baseball - Dowd Report
    May 9, 1989 · payees. Rose denied placing bets with Bertolini and denied owing anyone money. Rose acknowledged sending eleven $8,000 checks to Bertolini made ...
  119. [119]
    The Case Against Pete Rose: The Dowd Report - Pitcher List
    Sep 2, 2021 · The Dowd Report was stunning. The report investigated claims of Pete Rose gambling during the 1985, 1986, and 1987 seasons.<|separator|>
  120. [120]
    Dowd Report - BR Bullpen - Baseball-Reference.com
    Aug 1, 2019 · The report concludes that there is significant evidence that Rose bet on baseball, based on the testimony of various Rose associates of less-than-stellar ...
  121. [121]
    Entries in long-hidden notebook show Pete Rose bet on baseball as ...
    Jun 22, 2015 · Dowd's investigation had established that Rose was hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt at the time he was banished from the game.
  122. [122]
    Pete Rose / A. Bartlett Giamatti Agreement - Baseball Almanac
    Baseball Almanac presents the complete text and detailed information about the Pete Rose / A. Bartlett Giamatti Agreement on banishment.
  123. [123]
    A. Bartlett Giamatti Press Release | Baseball Almanac
    AUGUST 24, 1989. STATEMENT OF COMMISSIONER A. BARTLETT GIAMATTI. The banishment for life of Pete Rose from baseball is the sad end of a sorry episode. One of ...
  124. [124]
    Banning of Pete Rose - BR Bullpen - Baseball-Reference.com
    May 14, 2025 · When presented with the Dowd Report, Giamatti decided to cut a deal with Rose to try to end the matter: Rose agreed to withdraw his suit and ...
  125. [125]
    https://books.google.com/books?id=C72sGT0cpwwC
  126. [126]
    https://vault.si.com/vault/1989/04/17/a-gentleman-and-a-scholer
  127. [127]
    A GENTLEMAN AND A SCHOLER - Sports Illustrated Vault | SI.com
    Apr 17, 1989 · The commissioner has the responsibility for the integrity and for the steady, sustainable growth of the whole institution. Integrity is an ...Missing: statements | Show results with:statements
  128. [128]
    Text of Giamatti's statement - UPI Archives
    Aug 24, 1989 · It must assert and aspire to the highest principles -- of integrity, of professionalism of performance, of fair play within its rules.
  129. [129]
    Baseball Czar Giamatti Dies of Heart Attack - Los Angeles Times
    Sep 2, 1989 · He loved the game of baseball and in a short time made a real contribution to the game, standing for the highest possible ethical standards.”.
  130. [130]
    [PDF] Baseball labor relations: the lockout of 1990
    Fay. Vincent, former deputy commissioner of baseball, became commissioner when A. Bartlett Giamatti, the former. Yale University and National League. President, ...
  131. [131]
    Baseball's Labor Dispute Settled With Compromise On Arbitration
    Mar 19, 1990 · The 32-day lockout was the second-longest shutdown of the seven work stoppages in baseball history, all having occurred in the last 18 years.
  132. [132]
    Commissioner tells union that training camp lockout would be lifted ...
    Mar 9, 1990 · Baseball Commissioner Fay Vincent offered to lift the spring training lockout Thursday, providing the Major League Players Assn. would ...
  133. [133]
    BASEBALL LOCKOUT WAS A JOKE - Deseret News
    Mar 20, 1990 · ... lockout that has delayed the 1990 baseball season has ended. According to Commissioner Fay Vincent, the season will begin on April 9 and at ...
  134. [134]
    Fay Vincent - Society for American Baseball Research
    Sep 26, 2023 · Suffice it to say that Vincent was instrumental in ending the lockout with his efforts to hammer out a compromise in forging a new Basic ...
  135. [135]
    Fay Vincent, baseball commissioner during three years of turmoil ...
    Feb 2, 2025 · Fay Vincent, who became baseball commissioner in 1989 and then was forced out three years later by owners intent on a labor confrontation ...
  136. [136]
    Fay Vincent, baseball commissioner during three years of turmoil ...
    ... realignment and negotiated a settlement that ended a 1990 spring training lockout. “I had the conviction that being commissioner was a public trust. I tried ...
  137. [137]
    Vincent to Pitch Expansion Plan - Los Angeles Times
    Mar 19, 1990 · Vincent played a major role in helping the owners and players reach a contract agreement late Sunday night, ending a 32-day lockout. The deal ...
  138. [138]
    Marlins celebrate 30th anniversary of team introduction - MLB.com
    Jun 9, 2021 · Thirty years ago to the day, then-MLB Commissioner Fay Vincent announced Denver and South Florida as the two areas chosen by the expansion ...
  139. [139]
    Francis T. Vincent, Jr. | Commissioners | About MLB
    In the first expansion since 1977, baseball announced that Denver, Colorado and Miami, Florida had been granted expansion teams that would begin play in 1993.
  140. [140]
    Fay Vincent, Who Helped Oversee Birth of Colorado Rockies and ...
    Feb 2, 2025 · Fay Vincent, Who Helped Oversee Birth of Colorado Rockies and Miami Marlins, Dies at 86. Fay Vincent, the former Commissioner of Baseball, ...
  141. [141]
    Former MLB commissioner Fay Vincent dies at 86 - ESPN
    Feb 2, 2025 · Under Vincent's watch, baseball expanded to 28 teams, with the Rockies and Marlins gaining approval from major league owners in 1991 and ...
  142. [142]
    The Making of the Marlins - Society for American Baseball Research
    This draft was unique among expansion drafts; all major-league teams had been required by Commissioner Fay Vincent to make players available to the two new ...
  143. [143]
    Fay Vincent, who tangled with owners as 8th MLB Commissioner ...
    Feb 3, 2025 · That July, Vincent permanently banned Steinbrenner from day-to-day management of the Yankees. Steinbrenner had been sued by star player Dave ...
  144. [144]
    Vincent, Bowing to Owners' Will, Resigns as Baseball Commissioner
    Sep 8, 1992 · Vincent's opponents wanted him out for a variety of reasons. They believed he had been too accommodating with the baseball player's union, and ...
  145. [145]
    BASEBALL; Owners, in an 18-9 Vote, Ask Vincent to Resign
    Sep 4, 1992 · Major league club owners, by a vote of 18 to 9, said today they did not have confidence in Fay Vincent as a commissioner who could move ...
  146. [146]
    Owners Want Vincent Out : Baseball: Resolution passes by 18-9-1 ...
    Sep 4, 1992 · Owners Want Vincent Out : Baseball: Resolution passes by 18-9-1 vote. Commissioner reiterates that he will not resign and threatens court action ...
  147. [147]
    Fay Vincent Gives Up Post as Baseball Commissioner : Sports
    Sep 8, 1992 · Vincent had vowed on Aug. 20, “I will not resign--ever.” But last Thursday the owners voted, 18-9 with one abstention, urging him to quit, ...
  148. [148]
    The Steroids Era - MLB Topics - ESPN
    Dec 5, 2012 · The MLB and MLBPA also agreed to keep players' names private until discipline could be imposed and agreed to apprise players of any allegations ...<|separator|>
  149. [149]
    In 'For The Good Of The Game,' Bud Selig Tells Of The MLB Steroid ...
    Jul 9, 2019 · The main thing people will most likely remember is that he presided over an era tainted by widespread steroid abuse.Missing: oversight | Show results with:oversight
  150. [150]
    Baseball strikes out - Reveal News
    Jul 17, 2021 · Baseball's home run surge in the late '90s and early 2000s was fueled by anabolic steroids. But fans didn't want to hear the difficult truth ...Missing: causal | Show results with:causal
  151. [151]
    Bud Selig: 'Maybe I should have said more' about steroids - ESPN
    Dec 5, 2016 · Bud Selig talks to Pedro Gomez about how difficult the steroid era was and the measures baseball took to combat it.Missing: oversight | Show results with:oversight
  152. [152]
    Bud Selig is still, laughably, pleading ignorance about the Steroid Era
    Dec 6, 2016 · Selig claims he knew nothing about PED use in 1998. That is simply not true. He knew McGwire was taking PEDs as early as 1993.Missing: oversight | Show results with:oversight
  153. [153]
    A timeline of MLB's drug-testing rules - USA Today
    Mar 28, 2014 · The deal calls for a survey urine test for banned steroids in 2003 and 2004, and if more than 5 percent of tests are positive in a year, for ...
  154. [154]
    Full Timeline of MLB's Failed Attempts to Rid the Game of PEDs
    May 31, 2018 · 2002-2004: Testing (with very light Penalties) Begins in the Majors! By the time the 2002 season rolled around, the suspicion over steroids in ...
  155. [155]
    Report Exposes Extent of Steroid Use in Baseball - NPR
    Dec 13, 2007 · Major League Baseball has "a serious drug culture" in which steroid use is "widespread," says former Senate Majority Leader George Mitchell.
  156. [156]
    It's time to end Interleague Play | Athletics Nation
    Jun 2, 2017 · Interleague play was part of Bud Selig's plan to bring the fans back after the 1994 strike and cancelled world series, one that severely ...
  157. [157]
    https://www.sportsbusinessjournal.com/Daily/Issues/1997/06/16/Leagues-Governing-Bodies/MLB-INTERLEAGUE-PLAY-LEADS-TO-JUMP-IN-ATTENDANCE/
  158. [158]
    MLB INTERLEAGUE PLAY LEADS TO JUMP IN ATTENDANCE
    Jun 15, 1997 · MLB's first weekend of interleague play saw over a 42% increase in attendance compared to the home team's average attendance through Sunday, ...
  159. [159]
    Attendance surges during Interleague Play - MLB.com
    MLB entered the week with an overall attendance of 33,486,813 after a banner Interleague Play schedule, averaging 31,064 total fans per game across 1,078 dates.
  160. [160]
    The 1994 MLB players' strike: Why it is still helping baseball today
    Aug 12, 2014 · But the owners, led by acting commissioner Bud Selig, insisted on tying their revenue-sharing proposals to a cap on player salaries, and it was ...
  161. [161]
    How the MLBPA won the battle behind the 1994 players' strike
    Aug 11, 2019 · But the fact is the agreement we ultimately reached put in revenue sharing and a (luxury tax) for the first time in the history of baseball.
  162. [162]
    Baseball's prosperity at the center of Selig's legacy | MLB.com
    Jan 4, 2015 · Selig, who will retire as Commissioner of Baseball later this month, instituted vast increases in revenue sharing -- along with a luxury tax -- ...
  163. [163]
    [PDF] Revenue Sharing in Major League Baseball
    the luxury tax, but noting the league's failed attempts at implementing a salary cap in 1994, arguably the cause of the players' strike that year); see also ...
  164. [164]
    Growth of MLB under Selig as Commissioner
    Sep 26, 2013 · In 1992, when Selig assumed leadership of the game, total industry revenues were at $1.2 billion; by 2012, revenues had grown more than 600 ...Missing: expansions effects<|control11|><|separator|>
  165. [165]
    Gray areas of revenue sharing face scrutiny - Sports Business Journal
    Apr 4, 2011 · MLB Commissioner Bud Selig often likes to trumpet baseball's revenue sharing and its importance in improving the game's on-field competitive ...
  166. [166]
    Does MLB Interleague Play Really Boost Attendance? - WSJ
    Jul 8, 2009 · One of the top justifications for Major League Baseball's interleague play, now in its 13th season, is that it increases attendance.
  167. [167]
    Is Revenue Sharing Working for Major League Baseball? A ...
    Apr 24, 2009 · Since the introduction of revenue sharing, however, average annual growth for Quartile 1 teams has been only 0.72%, compared to 8.02% for ...
  168. [168]
    'You People Have Double-Crossed Us': Bud Selig's Run-In With Al ...
    Aug 16, 2019 · On Aug. 12, 1994, Major League Baseball players walked off the job after months of failed labor negotiations. A month later, acting Commissioner Bud Selig ...
  169. [169]
    Study shows MLB average salary up 11% YOY to $4.9 million - ESPN
    Apr 4, 2023 · MLB Average Salaries ; 1990, $578,930, +12.9% ; 1991, $891,188, +53.9% ; 1992, $1,084,408, +21.7% ; 1993, $1,120,254, +3.3%.Missing: escalating costs
  170. [170]
    Average Baseball Salary - AP News
    Jan 29, 2025 · Average Baseball Salary ; 1993, 109,000, 1,076,089 ; 1994, 109,000, 1,168,263 ; 1995, 109,000, 1,110,766 ; 1996, 122,667, 1,119,981.Missing: escalating | Show results with:escalating
  171. [171]
    Marginal Payroll/Marginal Wins: 1990-1994 - Baseball Prospectus
    Apr 12, 2004 · Instead MLB was demanding that the players accept a salary cap that would have reduced player salaries by an average of 15%. The players refused ...
  172. [172]
    [PDF] The baseball strike of 1994-95 - Bureau of Labor Statistics
    The owners proposed a. 7-year contract that would split their total revenue with the players, 50-50, while phasing in a salary cap over 4 years. Provided that ...
  173. [173]
    The Senate and the 1994-95 Baseball Strike
    Sep 5, 2024 · The 1994 baseball strike led to a cancelled World Series, millions of heartbroken fans, and a series of bipartisan efforts by United States senators to save ...
  174. [174]
    MLB cancels playoffs, World Series | September 14, 1994 | HISTORY
    Aug 24, 2021 · Years afterward, the impact of the 1994 strike and cancelled World Series cut deeply with many former players. In 2014, former Oakland A's ...
  175. [175]
    What happened to the 1994 Postseason? - MLB.com
    The MLB Players Association went on strike after play on Aug. 11, 1994, ending the season and resulting in the cancellation of the Postseason.
  176. [176]
    MLB's Last Work Stoppage In 1994-95 Proved Costly
    Mar 2, 2022 · MLB canceled games due to a labor dispute for the first time in 27 years. That stoppage sacrificed a World Series and affected future attendance ...
  177. [177]
    CBA History | Cot's Baseball Contracts
    November, 1990 – Owners settle all three collusion cases for a total of $280 million, with the union determining how to distribute the money to the players who ...Missing: details | Show results with:details<|separator|>
  178. [178]
    Owners Offer Luxury Tax Alternative to Salary Cap
    Feb 2, 1995 · Phased in over four years, the owners' new proposal would place a 75% tax on payrolls between $35 million and $42 million, and 100% on payrolls ...
  179. [179]
    The history of the Competitive Balance Tax - Pinstripe Alley
    Jan 13, 2022 · A compromise between the league's insistence on a salary cap and the union's resistance to one, the initial luxury tax penalized the teams with ...
  180. [180]
    Owners Abandon Bid to Impose Salary Cap : Baseball: Luxury tax ...
    Feb 2, 1995 · The new offer, made as talks resumed after a 40-day break, moved the owners off their central demand to reduce player salaries to 50 percent of ...
  181. [181]
    MLB commissioner Rob Manfred defends punishment of Astros
    Feb 16, 2020 · In a wide-ranging interview with ESPN's Karl Ravech, Manfred explained why he didn't punish any Astros players for their roles in the scandal, ...
  182. [182]
    Rob Manfred says granting Astros immunity 'not my best decision'
    Jun 22, 2023 · MLB did not punish any Houston players after a league investigation confirmed the Astros had cheated by using a camera-based sign-stealing ...
  183. [183]
    Drellich: Rob Manfred second-guesses giving Astros players ...
    Jun 22, 2023 · Nearly four years later, MLB commissioner Rob Manfred thinks that perhaps he should have tried to suspend Houston Astros players after all.<|separator|>
  184. [184]
    Red Sox, Yankees fined separately as part of MLB investigation into ...
    Sep 15, 2017 · Manfred decided on the punishment -- and elected not to levy harsher penalties, such as the forfeiture of draft picks or even wins -- after ...
  185. [185]
    Commissioner decision on Red Sox investigation - MLB.com
    Apr 22, 2020 · Commissioner Rob Manfred handed down discipline regarding the investigation into the Red Sox sign-stealing investigation on Wednesday.
  186. [186]
    Rob Manfred discusses 2017 Astros in press conference - MLB.com
    Feb 16, 2020 · Manfred discusses Astros' illegal sign-stealing · Whether the Astros punishment had been serious enough to deter others: “ · On players ...
  187. [187]
    MLB players, execs on sign-stealing scandal: Astros' tarnished rep ...
    Jan 15, 2020 · The longtime exec called those draft picks "a liquidated cost," and a veteran scout said the organization "should have been hammered" ...
  188. [188]
    With MLB Lockout Over, Here Are All The Details Of New 2022-26 ...
    Mar 10, 2022 · The 22.7% increase in the minimum salary is the biggest single-year percentage increase since 2003. From $700,00 it will increase $20,000 each ...
  189. [189]
    MLB labor: How fight over salary cap will shape negotiations - ESPN
    Sep 18, 2025 · There are two words MLB and the MLBPA simply cannot agree on. Here's how it got this way and what it means for the next CBA.Missing: limitations | Show results with:limitations
  190. [190]
    MLB lockout: Details of new, 2022 collective bargaining agreement
    Mar 10, 2022 · ... salary cap more than originally intended. Here are the first thresholds for each year of the CBA: 2022: $230 million 2023: $233 million 2024 ...
  191. [191]
    MLB Rule Changes: Takeaways on pitch clock, bigger bases, more
    Sep 29, 2023 · On top of that, average attendance is up 9.15%, the biggest one-year increase across the league in 30 years, according to MLB.
  192. [192]
    SBJ Unpacks: MLB's pitch clock is 2023's best innovation in sports
    Dec 18, 2023 · The average time of a nine-inning MLB game dropped to two hours, 40 minutes, a 24-minute decrease from the 2022 season.<|separator|>
  193. [193]
    6 reasons MLB games are hottest ticket in town
    Aug 8, 2023 · 6 reasons MLB games are hottest ticket in town · 1. THE PITCH TIMER. Because of the pitch timer, games are shorter. · 2. MORE ACTION · 3. THE ...Missing: clock | Show results with:clock
  194. [194]
    https://www.reuters.com/sports/manfred-optimistic-about-mlb-participation-2028-olympics-hurdles-remain-2025-10-25/
  195. [195]
    https://www.mlb.com/news/mlb-players-2028-olympics-discussions
  196. [196]
    MLB discussing logistics of players participating in 2028 LA Olympics
    Jul 15, 2025 · Manfred said Olympic organizers are also meeting with the MLB Players Association to discuss the possibility of big league players participating ...Missing: talks | Show results with:talks
  197. [197]
    World Baseball Classic will return in 2026 - MLB.com
    Mar 21, 2023 · Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred announced on Tuesday prior to the 2023 championship game between Team Japan and Team USA that<|separator|>
  198. [198]
    Rob Manfred | MLB Executives | About MLB | Official Information
    Manfred has prioritized sustaining the game's international growth, including through global events like the 2023 World Baseball Classic. In 2016, MLB ...
  199. [199]
    https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6750516/2025/10/26/mlb-los-angeles-2028-olympics-major-leaguers/
  200. [200]
    https://www.dailybreeze.com/2025/10/25/rob-manfred-confident-mlb-players-will-play-in-2028-l-a-olympics/
  201. [201]
    https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/46285653/commissioner-says-mlb-nearing-broadcast-deals-2026-28-seasons
  202. [202]
    Commissioner says MLB nearing broadcast deals for 2026 ... - ESPN
    Sep 16, 2025 · Commissioner Rob Manfred on Tuesday confirmed that MLB is nearing broadcast agreements with three media companies for the 2026 through 2028 ...Missing: responsibilities umpires expansion
  203. [203]
    MLB closes in on new media rights deals with ESPN, NBC and Netflix
    Aug 22, 2025 · Major League Baseball is nearing a finalized agreement with Disney's ESPN, Comcast's NBC Sports and Netflix on new three-year media rights ...
  204. [204]
    MLB's new media deal could see games pre-empted by NFL ...
    Sep 17, 2025 · Major League Baseball's new three-year media rights agreements with ESPN, NBC, and Netflix will change how fans access marquee games and events, ...
  205. [205]
    New details on how MLB might split expiring ESPN package
    MLB is in active negotiations with ESPN, Comcast-owned NBCUniversal, Apple and Netflix on the expiring ESPN rights package, and it is possible that other ...
  206. [206]
    Rob Manfred says MLB nears deals with ESPN, NBC and Netflix
    Sep 17, 2025 · MLB commissioner Rob Manfred confirmed media reports that MLB is nearing agreements for 2026-28 with ESPN, NBC and Netflix.Missing: 2026-2028 | Show results with:2026-2028
  207. [207]
    MLB negotiating with Netflix, ESPN, NBC, Apple for possible ...
    Aug 14, 2025 · Major League Baseball executives are in negotiations that could result in new broadcast packages and relationships with Netflix, ESPN, NBC ...<|separator|>
  208. [208]
    Decision on ineligibility status after death impacts Rose, others
    May 13, 2025 · Major League Baseball removed Pete Rose and 16 other deceased individuals from the permanently ineligible list on Tuesday, Commissioner Rob Manfred announced.
  209. [209]
    Pete Rose, 'Shoeless' Joe Jackson among players reinstated by MLB
    May 13, 2025 · Baseball commissioner Rob Manfred on Tuesday removed Pete Rose, "Shoeless" Joe Jackson and other deceased players from Major League Baseball's permanently ...
  210. [210]
    Pete Rose, "Shoeless" Joe Jackson and others reinstated by MLB ...
    May 13, 2025 · Rose and Jackson were among 17 total players reinstated Tuesday. Rose's permanent ban was lifted eight months after his death and came a day ...
  211. [211]
    Rob Manfred calls MLB's decision to reinstate Pete Rose 'overdue'
    May 30, 2025 · Rob Manfred defended his choice to reinstate Pete Rose, "Shoeless" Joe Jackson and other deceased banned players.
  212. [212]
    Pete Rose reinstated by Major League Baseball - WVXU
    May 13, 2025 · MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred issued a statement Tuesday saying permanent bans end upon the death of the individual.
  213. [213]
    Pete Rose reinstated by MLB and is eligible for Baseball Hall of Fame
    May 14, 2025 · The decision makes Rose, who died at 83 last September, eligible to be inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.<|control11|><|separator|>
  214. [214]
    OWNERS LIMIT POWERS OF THE COMMISSIONER - The ...
    Baseball's next commissioner will not have the same broad powers to act in the "best interests" of the game -- an ability possessed by his or her ...Missing: amendments | Show results with:amendments
  215. [215]
    BASEBALL; Commissioner's Powers Are Diluted by Owners
    Feb 12, 1994 · The owners removed the best-interest authority from collective bargaining even while giving the commissioner "exclusive responsibility for ...Missing: limit | Show results with:limit
  216. [216]
    BASEBALL; League Presidents Out As Baseball Centralizes
    Sep 16, 1999 · Major league club owners voted unanimously today to abandon the traditional arrangement and consolidate all operating functions in the commissioner's office.
  217. [217]
    Baseball's Labor Wars - Dissent Magazine
    Mar 28, 2022 · MLB owners' recent lockout was an effort to reverse the gains that players had won over decades of labor struggle. The owners failed.Missing: era challenges
  218. [218]
    MLB Commissioner Legal Advantages
    Jan 24, 2012 · The most recent CBA also presents specific limits to the commissioner's power, including the possibility of arbitration for suspensions over 10 ...Missing: constraints | Show results with:constraints
  219. [219]
    [PDF] Negotiated Settlement under MLB Final-Offer Salary Arbitration ...
    The conclusion by Burgess and Marburger (1993) that arbitrated salaries won by players were higher and those won by management were lower in the baseball FOSA ...
  220. [220]
    [PDF] Team Versus Player? A Study of Baseball Salary Arbitration and the ...
    Jun 4, 2023 · Since 1974 and through 2022, based on my data, arbitrator decisions have determined $1.64 billion in player salaries (in 2022 constant dollars).
  221. [221]
    An Empirical Analysis of Major League Baseball's Salary Negotiati
    This paper uses data from Major League Baseball's (MLB) binding FOA framework to explore whether arbitrated set- tlements resemble privately negotiated ...
  222. [222]
    How MLB is trying to embrace legalized gambling without ...
    May 26, 2023 · In addition to game fixing and similar scandals, there are concerns with related issues like gambling addiction or exposing children to problem ...
  223. [223]
    Leagues Are Struggling to Deal With a Certain Type of Sports Bet
    Aug 8, 2025 · ESPN reported that gambling integrity monitor IC360 had flagged unusual betting activity on those two pitches. The wagers in question, it said, ...Missing: integration addiction
  224. [224]
    MLB's Growing Gambling Problem - Bleacher Report
    Jul 30, 2025 · For players, umpires and employees who bet on games they aren't involved in, it's a one-year ban. For games they are involved in, it's permanent ...
  225. [225]
    Sports gambling scandals raise concerns over game integrity - Axios
    Jul 31, 2025 · The major sports leagues are confronting a potentially costly reality in sports gambling: If you embrace it, problems will come.
  226. [226]
    The illusion of inclusion: examining the limitations of diversity ... - NIH
    Mar 26, 2025 · In the current work we examine Major League Baseball (MLB) as a case study of how the most common DEI metric, the representation of historically ...Missing: critiques impact
  227. [227]
    [PDF] The Relationship Between Diversity and Performance in Major ...
    The current study examines surface and deep-level diversity, conflict, and performance through a study of Major League Baseball (MLB) teams. Thus, the unit of ...Missing: DEI initiatives
  228. [228]
    examining the limitations of diversity metrics in baseball - PubMed
    Mar 26, 2025 · We find evidence that, despite the high diversity, some baseball players and coaches in the lower levels seem to have less ability to advance than others.Missing: critiques performance impact empirical