Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Critical frequency

Critical frequency refers to the highest frequency of a radio wave that is totally reflected back to Earth by an ionospheric layer when incident normally (vertically), beyond which the wave penetrates the layer and escapes into space.^[1] This phenomenon arises because the refractive index of the ionosphere becomes zero at the point where the wave frequency equals the plasma frequency of the local electron density, leading to reflection for lower frequencies.^[2] The value of the critical frequency, denoted as f_c or f_o, is directly related to the maximum electron density N_m in the layer and is approximated by the formula f_c \approx 9 \times 10^{-3} \sqrt{N_m} MHz, where N_m is in electrons per cubic centimeter.^[2] Different ionospheric layers exhibit distinct critical frequencies, labeled as f_oE for the E layer (typically 3–5 MHz), f_oF1 for the lower F1 layer (around 5–7 MHz during daytime), and f_oF2 for the dominant F2 layer (often 8–15 MHz or higher, varying widely).^[3] These frequencies fluctuate diurnally, seasonally, and with solar activity; for instance, they peak around local noon or early afternoon and increase during periods of high sunspot activity due to enhanced ionization from solar ultraviolet radiation.^[1] The F2 layer's critical frequency is particularly significant, as it governs long-distance high-frequency (HF) skywave propagation for communications, broadcasting, and navigation over thousands of kilometers.^[4] In practice, the critical frequency measured vertically informs the calculation of the maximum usable frequency (MUF) for oblique paths, where MUF = f_oF2 / \cos \theta (or more precisely, using the secant of the effective angle), enabling reliable prediction of propagation conditions.^[3] Ionosondes, ground-based radar-like instruments, routinely measure these frequencies by transmitting swept-frequency signals and analyzing echo returns, providing real-time data for global ionospheric models.^[1] While primarily associated with the ionosphere in radio physics, the term "critical frequency" also appears in other fields, such as acoustics (the frequency above which sound transmission through panels increases) and vibration engineering (natural frequencies causing resonance), but the ionospheric context remains the most established and impactful application.^[5]

Fundamentals

Definition

The critical frequency, denoted as f_c or f_o, is defined as the highest frequency of an electromagnetic wave that can be transmitted vertically and totally reflected back to Earth by an ionized layer in the atmosphere, such as the ionosphere, due to the refractive index of the medium becoming zero at that point.^[6] This threshold determines the boundary between reflection and penetration for radio waves, playing a central role in plasma physics and radio communications where ionized media act as natural waveguides for long-distance signal propagation.^[7] The concept of critical frequency emerged in the early 20th century amid efforts to understand radio wave propagation beyond line-of-sight distances, with the term coined by British physicist Edward Appleton during his ionospheric research in the 1920s and formalized in 1930 as a method to quantify upper-atmospheric ionization.^[6] Appleton's experiments, building on earlier theories of a conducting atmospheric layer proposed by Kennelly and Heaviside in 1902, demonstrated that varying the transmitted frequency could reveal the reflective properties of ionized regions, earning him the 1947 Nobel Prize in Physics for these foundational contributions.^[6] At its core, the critical frequency arises from the interaction between radio waves and the ionosphere, a region ionized by solar ultraviolet radiation and X-rays that strips electrons from neutral atoms, creating a partially ionized plasma of free electrons and positive ions.^[7] These free electrons, being much smaller than radio wavelengths, respond collectively to the oscillating electric field of the wave, altering its propagation path through refraction; below the critical frequency, this interaction causes total reflection, while above it, the wave penetrates the layer with reduced refractive index.^[7] This plasma-wave coupling underpins applications in high-frequency radio communications, where the critical frequency sets practical limits on usable spectrum bands.^[7]

Physical basis

The critical frequency arises from the interaction between electromagnetic radio waves and the ionized plasma in the upper atmosphere, where free electrons dominate the response to the wave's electric field. As a radio wave propagates into a region of increasing ionization, it encounters free electrons that are set into oscillatory motion by the oscillating electric field of the wave. These electrons, being much lighter than ions, accelerate rapidly and reradiate electromagnetic fields that interfere with the incident wave, leading to a phase shift in the overall propagation. This interference causes the wave to refract, bending its path according to the local electron density, with higher densities resulting in greater bending toward the normal of the density gradient.^[8]^[9] In regions of sufficiently high electron density, the refractive index of the plasma decreases progressively, altering the wave's velocity and direction. For frequencies below the critical value, the cumulative refraction becomes so pronounced that the wave reaches a turning point where it is totally reflected back toward the Earth, preventing further penetration into the denser plasma layers. This reflection occurs without significant absorption under typical conditions, as the electrons' motion remains largely in phase with the driving field, though minor absorption can happen due to collisions. The process is analogous to total internal reflection at an optical boundary but driven by the plasma's collective electron response rather than a discrete interface.^[10]^[11] The threshold for this total reflection corresponds to the point where the plasma's effective refractive index approaches zero, marking the boundary beyond which the refractive index becomes imaginary and the wave propagates evanescently, decaying without further penetration. At this critical condition, the wave's frequency matches the natural oscillation frequency of the plasma electrons, leading to resonant behavior that fully redirects the energy. Electron density serves as the primary parameter governing this threshold, with variations determining the exact location and sharpness of the reflection point within the ionized medium.^[8]^[9]

Mathematical Relations

Dependence on electron density

The critical frequency f_c of an ionospheric layer is fundamentally determined by the maximum electron density N_e at its peak, as this density governs the plasma's response to incident radio waves. For vertical incidence in the absence of geomagnetic influences, f_c equals the plasma frequency f_p, which scales directly with the square root of N_e. This relationship arises because radio waves below f_c are reflected due to the plasma's inability to support propagation at those frequencies, while higher frequencies penetrate through.^[12] The primary equation linking f_c to N_e is derived from the Appleton-Hartree equation, which describes the refractive index n of a magnetoionic medium. In its simplified form without collisions or magnetic field effects, the Appleton-Hartree equation reduces to n^2 = 1 - \frac{\omega_p^2}{\omega^2}, where \omega_p = \sqrt{\frac{N_e e^2}{\epsilon_0 m_e}} is the angular plasma frequency, \omega = 2\pi f is the angular wave frequency, e is the elementary charge, \epsilon_0 is the permittivity of free space, and m_e is the electron mass. Reflection occurs when n = 0, implying \omega = \omega_p or f = f_p, so f_c = f_p = \frac{1}{2\pi} \sqrt{\frac{N_e e^2}{\epsilon_0 m_e}}. With geomagnetic effects present but small for vertical ordinary-ray propagation, f_c approximates this form closely.^[12] (Note: Ratcliffe's 1959 book provides the foundational derivation; URL links to publisher page.) A practical numerical approximation for ionospheric applications is f_c \approx 9 \sqrt{N_e} Hz, where N_e is in electrons per cubic meter; this stems from evaluating the constants in the fundamental equation, yielding f_c^2 \approx 80.5 N_e in Hz^2. For typical F-layer peak densities of $10^{11} to $10^{12} electrons/m^3, f_c ranges from approximately 3 to 9 MHz during moderate solar activity, though daytime values can reach 10–15 MHz under higher densities. These values establish the scale for HF radio reflection, with higher N_e enabling support for greater frequencies before penetration.^[5]^[12]

Connection to maximum usable frequency

The maximum usable frequency (MUF) represents the highest radio frequency that enables reliable communication between two points on Earth through reflection from the ionosphere via oblique propagation paths.^[7].pdf) This frequency exceeds the critical frequency for vertical incidence due to the geometry of the oblique ray path, allowing signals to reach greater distances, typically beyond 1000 km in high-frequency (HF) bands.^[13]^[7] The relationship between MUF and the critical frequency f_c is approximated by the secant law for shallow angles of incidence:

\text{MUF} = \frac{f_c}{\cos \theta}

where \theta is the angle of incidence measured from the normal to the ionospheric layer.^[7].pdf)^[13] This formulation assumes a flat, horizontally stratified ionosphere and provides a first-order estimate for path planning.^[7] This approximation derives from Snell's law of refraction, which states that n \sin i = \sin i_0 (constant along the ray path), where n is the refractive index, i the angle of refraction, and i_0 the initial angle.^[13] In the ionosphere, n \approx \sqrt{1 - \frac{81 N}{f^2}}, with N as electron density and f as frequency (in the Appleton-Hartree formula's quasi-longitudinal approximation).^[13].pdf) For oblique incidence, the ray penetrates to a region of higher electron density before total reflection occurs (where n = 0), effectively scaling the vertical critical frequency by the secant of the incidence angle to account for the extended path length through varying density.^[7]^[13] Corrections for ionospheric curvature introduce a factor k (typically 1.0–1.2), yielding \text{MUF} = k f_c \sec \theta.^[7] In practical HF radio applications, MUF predictions inform frequency selection for long-distance links, with operators typically using 80–90% of the predicted MUF (known as the optimum working frequency or FOT) to ensure reliability under varying conditions.^[7].pdf) MUF charts, derived from ionosonde data and models like those incorporating sunspot number and seasonal variations, map expected values for specific distances (e.g., MUF(4000)F2 for 4000 km paths) to aid circuit planning.^[7] However, accuracy is influenced by factors such as ionospheric layer tilt, which can distort ray paths and alter the effective incidence angle, leading to 5–10 dB signal variations or asymmetric propagation.^[7].pdf)

Theoretical Connections

Link to plasma frequency

The plasma frequency, denoted as f_p, represents the natural oscillation frequency of electrons in a plasma and is given by the formula

f_p = \frac{1}{2\pi} \sqrt{ \frac{N_e e^2 }{\epsilon_0 m_e } },

where N_e is the electron density, e is the elementary charge, \epsilon_0 is the vacuum permittivity, and m_e is the electron mass. This frequency arises from the collective motion of electrons responding to electrostatic perturbations in a charge-neutral plasma. In the context of collisionless plasmas without magnetic fields, the critical frequency f_c for vertically incident electromagnetic waves is identical to the plasma frequency f_p, as reflection occurs precisely where the wave frequency matches the local plasma oscillation frequency.^[14] This equivalence holds because waves below f_p cannot propagate, being evanescent in the plasma medium. For ionospheric conditions, minor adjustments account for weak collisions and the geomagnetic field, which slightly modify the cutoff but preserve the close approximation to f_p for high-frequency vertical sounding.^[11] While the plasma frequency characterizes general electron plasma oscillations in any plasma, the critical frequency specifically denotes the propagation cutoff for electromagnetic waves in the ionosphere, highlighting their shared physical origin but distinct observational contexts. This plasma frequency concept was first introduced by Irving Langmuir in 1928 for laboratory discharges, with its application to ionospheric wave reflection developing in the following decade through radio propagation studies.

Influence on index of refraction

The refractive index n of a radio wave propagating through an ionized plasma, such as the ionosphere, is fundamentally influenced by the critical frequency, which marks the transition between reflection and transmission. In the absence of collisions and magnetic field effects, the refractive index is given by the equation

n = \sqrt{1 - \left( \frac{f_p}{f} \right)^2},

where f_p is the plasma frequency and f is the wave frequency.^[9] At the critical frequency f_c = f_p, the refractive index reaches zero, causing the wave to turn back at the point of incidence for vertical propagation.^[9] This equation arises from the plasma's dielectric response, where free electrons oscillate in response to the electromagnetic field, effectively reducing the phase velocity of the wave.^[15] In a stratified ionospheric layer, the electron density typically varies with height, and a common approximation assumes a parabolic profile for the electron density near the layer's peak. This variation leads to a corresponding profile in the refractive index, where n decreases gradually from near unity at lower altitudes to zero at the reflection height, the point where the local plasma frequency equals the wave frequency.^[16] The parabolic form simplifies calculations of ray paths, resulting in curved trajectories that bend the wave back toward Earth, enabling skywave propagation.^[16] For frequencies below the critical frequency, the term inside the square root becomes negative, rendering n imaginary and the wave evanescent; this non-propagating behavior causes total reflection without significant penetration into the layer.^[9] Conversely, above f_c, n is real but less than 1, allowing the wave to propagate through the plasma with reduced phase velocity and potential refraction.^[9] The presence of the Earth's magnetic field introduces complexity via the Appleton-Hartree magneto-ionic theory, which splits the wave into two characteristic modes: the ordinary mode, largely unaffected by the field, and the extraordinary mode, influenced by the geomagnetic components.^[15] This splitting modifies the effective critical frequency for each mode, with cutoffs at f_c = f_p for the ordinary mode and shifted values involving the electron gyrofrequency for the extraordinary mode, altering reflection conditions based on propagation direction relative to the field.^[15]

Ionospheric Applications

Interaction with the F layer

The F layer represents the highest region of the ionosphere, spanning altitudes from approximately 150 to 500 km, where the F2 sublayer hosts the peak electron density, denoted as N_mF_2, which governs the critical frequency f_oF_2.^[17] This peak density arises primarily from the ionization of atomic oxygen by solar extreme ultraviolet radiation, making the F2 layer the dominant reflector for high-frequency radio signals.^[18] The critical frequency f_oF_2 exhibits pronounced diurnal variations, typically peaking in the early afternoon due to maximum photoionization rates and declining sharply at night from electron-ion recombination in the absence of solar input.^[19] Seasonal patterns further modulate these changes, with f_oF_2 often elevated during equinoxes or winter months in mid-latitudes owing to favorable neutral wind dynamics and chemistry, while solar activity exerts a overarching influence—values are substantially higher during solar maximum periods compared to minima.^[20]^[21] Measurement of f_oF_2 relies on ionosondes, ground-based radars that perform vertical incidence sounding by transmitting swept-frequency pulses (typically 1–30 MHz) and recording echo delays to produce ionograms—trace plots of frequency against virtual height.^[14] The critical frequency is identified on the ionogram as the apex frequency of the F2 trace, where signals transition from reflection to penetration.^[22] Observed f_oF_2 values generally range from 5 to 15 MHz, with daytime mid-latitude maxima around 10–12 MHz during moderate solar activity and nighttime minima near 4–6 MHz.^[17] The International Reference Ionosphere (IRI) model integrates global observational data to predict these parameters, accounting for latitudinal, seasonal, and solar dependencies with median accuracies within 0.5–1 MHz.^[23]^[24]

Effects on radio wave propagation

The critical frequency plays a pivotal role in skywave propagation, where high-frequency (HF) radio signals in the 3–30 MHz band are refracted or reflected by ionospheric layers, enabling communication beyond the line-of-sight horizon by "skipping" signals over thousands of kilometers.^[25] This mechanism relies on the ionosphere's electron density, which determines the highest frequency (f_c) that can be reflected vertically; signals at or below f_c undergo total reflection for shorter skips, while those above f_c but below the maximum usable frequency (MUF) support multi-hop paths involving multiple ionospheric and ground reflections.^[26] For instance, on paths exceeding 4,000 km, three-hop (3F) modes at frequencies around 13 MHz can maintain reliable coverage, as the focusing effect per hop preserves signal strength.^[26] Propagation characteristics vary significantly with frequency relative to f_c: below f_c, waves experience total reflection suitable for short-skip distances (typically under 2,000 km), but increased absorption near f_c—known as deviative absorption—can attenuate lower HF bands, particularly during daytime.^[26] Above f_c yet below the MUF, oblique incidence allows multi-hop skywave paths for long-distance links, with the MUF serving as the upper propagation limit influenced by f_c and path geometry.^[25] These bands are essential for global HF networks, where diurnal variations in f_c (e.g., higher daytime values due to solar illumination) dictate usable frequencies, such as 3–6.6 MHz at night and over 13 MHz during the day for aviation routes.^[25] Disturbances like solar flares and auroral activity impose significant limitations on propagation tied to f_c. Solar flares enhance D-region ionization primarily through increased X-ray radiation, temporarily elevating absorption and leading to radio blackouts lasting minutes to hours and disrupting HF signals in the 3–30 MHz range, while foF2 may increase due to additional extreme ultraviolet ionization in the F region.^[27]^[28] For example, X-class flares can cause near-complete daytime signal loss on 7 MHz and 14 MHz bands, with recovery times extending to hours amid ongoing geomagnetic activity.^[29] Auroral activity, often linked to geomagnetic storms, scatters HF waves through enhanced electron precipitation in polar regions, altering skip distances and introducing phase fluctuations that degrade signal quality.^[29] In modern applications, the critical frequency underpins reliable HF communications in amateur radio, aviation, and military sectors, where forecasting tools predict propagation based on real-time f_c data. Services like VOACAP, developed by the U.S. National Telecommunications and Information Administration, integrate ionospheric parameters including f_c to forecast optimal frequencies for circuits up to 20,000 km, supporting amateur operators on bands from 3.5–28 MHz and aviation networks like the South Pacific's MWARA-SP system.^[30] Military and aviation users rely on such predictions to select frequencies avoiding blackout risks, ensuring robust long-range links during variable solar conditions.^[25]

References

[1]
[PDF] Characteristics of the ionosphere and their application to radio ...
The properties considered are absorption, virtual height, and critical frequency. It is pointed out that the long-time increase of critical frequencies ...
[2]
The Ionosphere - The Radio JOVE Project
The lowest frequency detectable, known as the critical frequency, is related to the density of electrons by the equation: f = 9x10^-3 x sqrt(N) MHz. In this ...
[3]
Module 2_3: HF Radiation - Choosing the Right Frequency
This critical frequency may be referred to using the symbol foF2. The F1 and E layers also have critical frequencies associated with the maximum plasma ...
[4]
STORM Time Empirical Ionospheric Correction
The storm-time correction of the F-region critical frequency is primarily of benefit for high frequency (HF; 3-30 MHz) communication users.
[5]
Critical Frequency - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
Critical frequency is defined as the natural frequency of a system at which it can respond significantly to external forcing functions, particularly in systems ...
[6]
[PDF] Edward V. Appleton - Nobel Lecture
In this lecture I wish to draw your attention to certain features of the elec- trical state of the higher reaches of the earth's atmosphere.
[7]
[PDF] Ionospheric radio propagation - NIST Technical Series Publications
... Appleton Formula. 63. 2.3.3. Some Properties of the Appleton Formula. 71. 2.3.3.1. No Magnetic Field, No Collisions. 71. 2.3.3.2. Magnetic Field, No Collisions.
[8]
Ionospheric Physics of Radio Wave Propagation - ecjones.org
Nov 27, 2011 · A basic physical and mathematical description of the ionospheric propagation of radio waves.<|control11|><|separator|>
[9]
[PDF] Ionospheric Propagation
Ionospheric propagation involves radio waves being reflected or refracted by the ionosphere, depending on frequency and if it's below or above the plasma ...
[10]
https://faculty.nps.edu/jenn/EC3630/Ionosphere(v1.6.5).pdf
[11]
49 Propagation in the Ionosphere, Whistlers - Galileo and Einstein
Radio waves sent upwards with frequency ω less than this will be reflected at the height where the local plasma frequency matches the wave frequency ω=ωpl, so ...
[12]
[PDF] School on the Physics of Equatorial Atmosphere - ICTP
Oct 5, 2001 · refractive index becomes zero. This condition is expressed, using ... when the critical frequency is much higher than///. On the basis ...
[13]
[PDF] Sky Wave Propagation - Index of /
Mar 20, 2010 · Equation (6) is known as secant law. It indicates that fMUF is greater than fc by a factor sec φi. It gives the maximum frequency which can be ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[14]
[PDF] Optimal Estimation Inversion of Ionospheric Electron Density from ...
Aug 16, 2023 · ... ionosphere, the energy is reflected at the level where the plasma frequency is equal to the probing wave frequency (i.e., critical frequency).
[15]
[PDF] Physics of the Ionosphere - Indico [Home]
n2 2 = 1 – X/(1-iZ) = 1 + X Z/(1+Z2) - iX Z/(1+Z2) where the refractive index is now divided in a real part, μ, and an imaginary part, χ.
[16]
Ionospheric Radio Wave Propagation
110). Here, $N=N(z)$ is the density of free electrons in the ionosphere, and $z$ is a coordinate that measures height above the surface of the Earth. (The ...
[17]
A new global empirical NmF2 model for operational use in radio ...
Dec 28, 2011 · The maximum/peak electron density of the F2 layer NmF2 may range from about 1012 to 1013 m−3 [Dolukhanov, 1971] during day time and during ...
[18]
Long-term relationships of ionospheric electron density with solar ...
Aug 30, 2024 · Because NmF2 corresponds to the F2 layer peak height hmF2 and the center of mass of TEC refers to an altitude range of about 350–400 km, it ...
[19]
[PDF] Ionospheric foF2 morphology and response of F2 layer height over ...
Figure 1(a–f) represents the average diurnal varia- tion of the critical frequency (foF2) over Jicamarca for all seasons during low solar activity (LSA) years ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[20]
Seasonal and diurnal variations in foF2 trends - AGU Journals - Wiley
Apr 10, 2015 · A detailed analysis of diurnal and seasonal variations in the trends in the F2 layer critical frequency on the basis of monthly medians of foF2 ...
[21]
[PDF] Solar activity variations of the ionospheric peak electron density
The slope of NmF2 with P in the linear segment further shows similar annual variations as the background electron densities at moderate solar activity.
[22]
Accuracy assessment of the quiet-time ionospheric F2 peak ...
The electron density Ne is measured directly (NmF2 = (1/80.6). (foF2)2), and the height of the layer is obtained throughout the true height inversion procedure.
[23]
International Reference Ionosphere
F2-peak plasmafrequency (foF2/MHz) or electron density (NmF2/m-3) Bottomside ... HEIGHT RANGE: Electron density: daytime: 65 - 30,000 km, nighttime: 80 ...
[24]
Statistical modeling of ionospheric foF2 over Wuhan - AGU Journals
Apr 8, 2004 · In contrast, the IRI model has a lower accuracy with standard deviations of about 0.5 to 1 MHz and tends to overestimate foF2 over Wuhan. [32] ...Missing: typical | Show results with:typical
[25]
[PDF] HF Frequency Management Guidance Material
Mar 15, 2009 · 1.8 Sky wave propagation in the HF band (3 to 30 MHz) is complicated, because there are many variable factors, which decide whether or not ...
[26]
[PDF] Ionospheric radio propagation - GovInfo
... Ionosphere. 3.1. Worldwide Soundings. 101. 3.2. Experimental Techniques. „. 103 ... Reflection Method. 108. 3.2.2.2. Continuous-Wave Field-Intensity ...
[27]
Solar Flares (Radio Blackouts) - Space Weather Prediction Center
Solar flares are large eruptions of electromagnetic radiation from the Sun lasting from minutes to hours. The sudden outburst of electromagnetic energy ...Missing: critical | Show results with:critical
[28]
High‐Frequency Communications Response to Solar Activity in ...
Jan 11, 2019 · This paper presents the response of HF amateur radio propagation as observed by the Reverse Beacon Network and the Weak Signal Propagation ...
[29]
VOACAP Voice of America Coverage Analysis Program
VOACAP is free professional high-frequency (3-30 MHz) propagation prediction software from NTIA / ITS , originally developed for Voice of America (VOA).VOACAP Online for Ham Radio · VOACAP DX Charts · VOACAP Online for 11MMissing: critical | Show results with:critical