Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Erez


Kibbutz Erez is a secular communal settlement in the northwestern Negev region of southern Israel, situated approximately 1 kilometer from the Gaza Strip border within the Sha'ar HaNegev Regional Council. Founded in 1949 by a group of Palmach veterans who had participated in the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, the kibbutz derives its name from the Hebrew word for cedar tree and initially comprised a few dozen members focused on agricultural development. Relocated to its permanent site in 1950, it has sustained a population of around 600 residents as of recent estimates, emphasizing collective living principles amid ongoing security challenges due to its proximity to Gaza.
The kibbutz's economy centers on agriculture, including field crops, orchards, citrus groves, animal husbandry, and beekeeping that yields 30 tons of honey annually, supplemented by manufacturing such as thermoplastics production. On October 7, 2023, during a large-scale Hamas incursion, the kibbutz's civilian emergency response team, aided by volunteers from nearby Kibbutz Or HaNer, engaged and neutralized multiple terrorists attempting to breach the perimeter, averting a potential massacre despite delays in military intervention. This defense effort resulted in the deaths of several squad members but preserved the community from widespread infiltration, highlighting resident resilience in a region marked by persistent border threats. Following the attack, like many Gaza-border communities, Erez faced temporary evacuation, though efforts to repopulate and fortify such settlements continue amid government initiatives to bolster frontier demographics.

History

Founding and Early Settlement

Kibbutz was founded in 1949 by a group of veterans who had fought in the War of Independence for Israel's . The settlers, numbering a few dozen, belonged to a pioneering named "Erez" affiliated with the . Among the founders were individuals who participated in operations to liberate areas in the during the conflict. The initial settlement occurred on sand dunes adjacent to the Gaza Strip in the northwestern Negev, reflecting post-war efforts to populate and secure frontier regions. This location positioned Erez as one of the early communal farms aimed at agricultural development in challenging arid terrain while contributing to border defense. By 1950, the community had relocated to its current , where foundational infrastructure for was established, marking the transition from provisional to permanent settlement. Early activities focused on and crop cultivation, typical of pioneers adapting to environmental constraints through cooperative labor. A on the grounds commemorates the founders' contributions.

Role in the 1948 Arab-Israeli War

The site of present-day Kibbutz Erez was occupied by the Palestinian village of Dimra prior to and during the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, with Dimra's population recorded at 520 inhabitants in a 1945 survey. On October 31, 1948, amid Israeli military operations on the southern front, Dimra's residents—primarily women and children—evacuated the village, with male inhabitants departing around the same period as part of broader depopulation patterns during the conflict's final months. This occurred in the context of , an Israeli offensive launched on October 15, 1948, aimed at breaking Egyptian supply lines and securing the region, which led to the capture or flight from multiple villages in the Gaza subdistrict, including Dimra. No major battles were recorded directly at Dimra, but the village's depopulation aligned with forces' advances that neutralized Arab irregulars and positions in the area, facilitating territorial control south of . Earlier, on May 31, 1948, residents expelled from the nearby village of Huj were temporarily directed to Dimra by forces, though subsequent military actions prevented their return, contributing to movements. historian documents these expulsions as part of systematic efforts to clear strategic zones during the war's chaos, where fear of combat, orders to depart, and direct expulsions caused over 70% of Palestinian village abandonments in the region. Kibbutz Erez itself was not established until January 1949, but its founding group—veterans of the strike force from the United Kibbutz Movement—had actively participated in combat operations during the war, including efforts to liberate southern territories from control. These fighters' experiences in securing the area post-truce enabled the kibbutz's placement on the depopulated Dimra lands in 1950, as part of Israel's post-war settlement policy to consolidate borders and agricultural frontiers. The war's outcome, including armistice lines that placed the site within Israeli territory, directly paved the way for Erez's development as a .

Post-War Development and Expansion

Following its establishment in 1949 by veterans from the , initially comprised a few dozen settlers focused on basic agricultural reclamation in the northwestern , near the border. The community expanded its cultivated land through the development of field crops, orchards, and groves, supplemented by , with support from the (KKL-JNF) for infrastructure such as facilities and fish ponds. Economic diversification accelerated in subsequent decades, incorporating industrial activities like the Erez Thermoplastics Products factory for manufacturing plastic goods and an producing 30 tons of annually from regional flora. Protective by KKL-JNF enhanced both agricultural viability and border security, reflecting the kibbutz's strategic location 1.61 km from . Demographic expansion efforts intensified from around , with deliberate policies to absorb new residents amid broader challenges, growing the population to 558 by mid-2023. This growth paralleled regional council initiatives in Sha'ar HaNegev to bolster peripheral settlements through family-oriented programs and economic incentives.

Geography and Demographics

Location and Physical Setting


Erez is a kibbutz located in southwestern Israel at the northwestern tip of the Negev Desert, under the jurisdiction of the Sha'ar HaNegev Regional Council. It sits approximately 1 kilometer north of the Gaza Strip border, adjacent to the Erez Crossing, the main passage between Israel and northern Gaza near the Palestinian city of Beit Hanoun. The site's coordinates are 31.55984° N, 34.564889° E.
The physical setting encompasses flat, sandy terrain typical of the southern transitioning into the , enabling agriculture through extensive irrigation despite the semi-arid environment. The region experiences a with hot, dry summers and mild, rainy winters, recording an annual average of 271 mm of precipitation across 72.1 rainy days. Proximity to the , about 4 kilometers west, moderates temperatures, while the nearby influences aridity and necessitates water management for settlement viability.

Population Composition and Community Structure

Erez, a , had a pre-October 7, 2023, of 558 residents. Estimates from 2021 place the figure at 608, reflecting gradual growth typical of established kibbutzim in Israel's southern periphery. The residents are overwhelmingly Jewish , comprising multi-generational families including children, working adults, and retirees, with no significant non-Jewish minority presence as is common in exclusively Jewish communal settlements. Following the attack on , 2023, which prompted a temporary evacuation, most residents had returned by mid-2025, aligning with broader trends in Gaza-border communities where approximately 90% of displaced individuals resettled amid enhanced security measures. The community's demographic stability supports its agricultural and entrepreneurial activities, with a focus on family-oriented living that has sustained population levels despite proximity to conflict zones. Structurally, Erez operates as a traditional affiliated with the United Kibbutz Movement, emphasizing of land, production facilities, and resources. occurs through democratic processes, including a of full members for major decisions and elected committees for operational management, such as , , and . A civilian defense squad plays a central role in community protection, as demonstrated by its successful repulsion of the infiltration attempt with assistance from neighboring Or HaNer. Communal institutions like shared dining halls and welfare systems foster social cohesion, though privatization trends in Israeli kibbutzim have introduced individual housing and income options while preserving core egalitarian principles.

Economy

Agricultural Foundations

Kibbutz Erez was founded in 1949 by veterans affiliated with the United Kibbutz Movement, with agriculture serving as the core economic and communal foundation from its inception. The settlement's early efforts centered on transforming the sandy soils of the northwestern into productive farmland, emphasizing collective labor to cultivate field crops such as grains and vegetables, alongside the planting of orchards and groves to support self-sufficiency and export potential. These activities aligned with the broader model, where members shared ownership of land and equipment to maximize yields in arid conditions through and techniques adapted to the region's . Animal husbandry complemented crop production, incorporating livestock rearing for dairy, meat, and possibly poultry, which provided essential protein sources and manure for soil enrichment in the kibbutz's integrated farming system. By the mid-20th century, the kibbutz had developed specialized apiculture, harvesting approximately 30 tons of honey annually from bees foraging on wildflowers, citrus blossoms, tamarisk, avocado, and eucalyptus, establishing honey as a branded agricultural product. This diversification within agriculture underscored Erez's adaptation to local flora, contributing to its role in regional food security despite proximity to the Gaza border, where orchards extended mere hundreds of meters from the fence. Prior to the October 7, 2023, events, agriculture remained the primary income source, encompassing field cultivation, fruit tree management, and citrus operations that yielded high-value exports amid Israel's water-scarce environment. The kibbutz's agricultural infrastructure, including greenhouses and drip irrigation—technologies pioneered in Israeli collectives—enabled resilient production of perishable goods, though vulnerability to border threats periodically disrupted operations. These foundations not only sustained the community of around 558 residents by 2019 but also integrated with national efforts to reclaim and develop peripheral lands for intensive farming.

Industrial Activities and Regional Integration

Kibbutz Erez maintains a sector centered on plastics and textiles, comprising three primary facilities that generate significant income for the community. , established in 1982, produces high-performance coated , including reinforced membranes for applications in roofing, , and fabrics, with annual emphasizing and global standards. The company operates a wholly owned subsidiary in and holds partial ownership in a facility in , facilitating and . Complementing this, the runs a plastics plant that processes materials into reusable resins and a producing plastic containers, contributing to a localized industrial focused on synthetic materials and nonvulcanizable elastomers. These operations, owned collectively by the , emphasize practices such as full and minimization, aligning with broader Israeli efforts in resource-efficient . In terms of regional integration, Erez's industries support the economy of the by providing skilled employment and fostering supply chain linkages within southern Israel's agro- corridor, though operations have faced disruptions from proximity to the border. The facilities export products regionally and internationally, integrating production into Israel's high-tech manufacturing sector while historically benefiting from national incentives for development. Adjacent to the defunct Erez Industrial Zone in —once a hub for joint ventures employing thousands of before its closure—the 's enterprises represent a unilateral foothold amid limited cross-border economic cooperation post-disengagement.

Employment Dynamics Including Palestinian Labor

Kibbutz Erez, primarily engaged in agriculture including avocado cultivation, has historically relied on Palestinian laborers from for manual farm work, with these workers accessing the site via the adjacent under Israeli-issued permits. This arrangement mirrored broader patterns in border kibbutzim, where Palestinian labor supplemented local efforts in labor-intensive sectors like fruit harvesting, often on a daily or seasonal basis. Prior to , 2023, the enabled roughly 18,000 to 20,000 Gazan workers to enter annually for employment, many directed to agricultural roles in southern communities including those near Erez, where wages—typically 20-30% higher than Gaza averages—drove participation despite permit quotas and security screenings. Permit issuance fluctuated with security policies; for instance, in 2017, temporarily eased restrictions during the holiday to allow additional Palestinian agricultural workers into Erez and similar sites, reflecting economic pressures on farms amid labor shortages. By 2023, daily crossings peaked at around 1,000-2,000 workers via Erez, supporting 's agricultural output while providing with remittance inflows estimated at hundreds of millions of dollars yearly, though critics noted vulnerabilities like permit revocations for minor infractions and limited labor protections. Industrial activities in Erez, such as light manufacturing tied to , occasionally incorporated Palestinian labor under similar permit regimes, but dominated, with workers handling tasks Israelis increasingly avoided due to low pay and physical demands. The October 7, 2023, attack, which infiltrated and killed or abducted residents while exploiting familiarity with local layouts—prompting investigations into whether some workers shared —led to an immediate and sustained halt in Palestinian labor access. services interrogated thousands of former Gazan workers post-attack, concluding no widespread but confirming isolated leaks, which reinforced policy shifts toward barring Gazan entrants entirely. As of 2025, Erez remains partially evacuated and under reconstruction, with its agricultural and industrial bases disrupted; labor needs are met through volunteers, foreign guest workers from , or temporary domestic hires, amid debates over resuming permits given persistent threats. This transition underscores a pre-attack now severed by imperatives, with surging above 40% in the absence of cross-border jobs.

Security and Border Infrastructure

Evolution of Defensive Measures

Following its establishment in 1949 as a frontier settlement near the , implemented basic perimeter fencing and relied on armed resident patrols for defense, reflecting the kibbutz movement's historical role in securing Israel's borders against infiltration attempts. These measures evolved from ad hoc communal vigilance into formalized security squads by the late , with volunteers receiving training in firearms, , and threat response to counter cross-border raids. In response to escalating Palestinian rocket fire from starting in the early 2000s, Erez augmented human defenses with hardened infrastructure, including communal bomb shelters and mandatory mamad (protected residential spaces) in new constructions, mandated under Israel's 1991 Civil Defense Law to withstand and blast effects within 15 seconds of alert sirens. Older structures received retrofitted bunkers, often artistically designed to integrate with communal areas like dining halls, providing rapid shelter for residents during barrages that intensified after Hamas's 2007 takeover of . The Gaza-Israel border barrier adjacent to Erez underwent successive upgrades beginning in the , with constructing an electronic and segments in 1994 to deter militant incursions and smuggling. Post-2005 and amid rising tunnel threats—highlighted by a 2013 Hamas infiltration attempt—defenses shifted to include seismic sensors and detection systems. By 2016, initiated a multi-billion-shekel "smart " , featuring 65 kilometers of above-ground anti-climb s, cameras, radars, and AI-monitored intrusion alerts, complemented by a 70-kilometer-deep barrier completed in to block tunneling. These fortifications, integrated with rapid-response units, aimed to create a multi-layered "iron " against ground breaches, though vulnerabilities to coordinated assaults persisted.

The Erez Crossing and Its Operations

The , situated in the northern adjacent to 's border near Kibbutz Erez, functions as the sole pedestrian terminal for movement between and . Controlled and operated by the (IDF), it enables limited crossings primarily for holding approved permits, including those for employment in , medical treatment, trade, and family visits to the . The crossing's infrastructure includes a secure Israeli terminal with inspection facilities, separated from the Palestinian side by a militarized , reflecting Israel's emphasis on preventing unauthorized entries amid ongoing threats from Gaza-based militant groups. Operations are coordinated by the Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT), Israel's liaison body for civilian affairs in and the , which processes permit applications and facilitates humanitarian cases. Since 1991, following the end of general exit permissions after the , require individualized magnetic or exit permits, vetted for security risks by Israel's General Security Service (). Categories eligible include daily laborers (up to 17,000 permits issued by September 2022), merchants (88,000 crossings recorded in 2021, a 43% increase from prior years), medical patients (with approval rates fluctuating, e.g., 54% in late 2017), and urgent cases like traders or aid workers. Permits are typically valid for short durations, requiring renewal, and denials often cite intelligence-based security concerns rather than blanket policies. Security protocols at Erez are multilayered to counter infiltration risks, involving pre-approval screening, on-site physical searches, metal detectors, baggage scans, and interrogations focused on potential ties. Crossers proceed through a Palestinian pre-screening area before entering the zone, where delays can extend hours due to these checks, designed to thwart attacks—such as the multiple attempted bombings and shootings documented at the site since the . The terminal operates Sunday through during daylight (approximately 7:00 AM to 4:00 PM local time), with limited access for emergencies or foreigners, averaging thousands of daily transits pre-2023 for workers alone, though exact figures vary with permit quotas and threat levels. COGAT reports highlight facilitation efforts, like expedited exits, but operations remain suspended since the crossing's damage during the [October 7](/page/October 7), 2023, assault.

Pre-2023 Threat Assessments and Policies

Prior to October 2023, Israeli policies governing the Erez Crossing emphasized facilitating controlled Palestinian movement to alleviate economic pressures in Gaza and sustain relative calm along the border. This approach involved issuing work permits allowing Gazan laborers to enter Israel for employment, with numbers expanding significantly in the years leading up to the attack; by early 2023, around 18,000 such permits were active, enabling daily crossings for jobs in construction and agriculture. In August 2022, the Israeli Defense Ministry approved an additional 1,500 permits explicitly to encourage border quiet by tying economic opportunity to reduced violence. These measures reflected a broader strategy of economic palliation, where permit access and indirect funding flows—such as Qatari transfers—were leveraged to deter Hamas from escalation, predicated on the assumption that governance burdens would constrain the group's military ambitions. Security protocols at Erez incorporated multi-layered vetting, including permit-based approvals by authorities, biometric scans, automated barriers, and patrols to screen for potential threats among crossers. Operations were limited to hours, with rigorous checks on vehicles and individuals, though the volume of workers strained resources and occasionally prompted temporary closures amid border disturbances, such as riots in September 2023 that led to a two-week shutdown before resumption. Despite periodic incidents of near the crossing, including Hamas-orchestrated protests from 2018 onward, policies maintained openness for approved traders and laborers under the rationale that blanket restrictions would heighten desperation and rocket fire without eliminating underlying risks. Threat assessments by the (IDF) and intelligence agencies like prior to 2023 characterized as operationally deterred from major offensives, citing Israel's demonstrated retaliatory capacity—evident in operations like Protective Edge in 2014—and 's investment in civilian administration amid Gaza's humanitarian challenges. This view underestimated 's covert buildup of assault capabilities, including training exercises mimicking border breaches that were observed but dismissed as non-imminent by analysts prioritizing northern threats from and Iranian proxies. For Erez specifically, evaluations focused on low-probability infiltration via permitted channels rather than mass coordinated attacks, aligning with a deterrence model that tolerated simmering tensions in favor of containment through economic levers, though internal warnings about 's intent were not escalated to alter crossing operations.

The October 7, 2023 Hamas Attack

Infiltration Tactics and Initial Breach

Hamas militants initiated their assault on the Erez area by launching a massive rocket barrage starting at approximately 6:30 a.m. on , 2023, followed by coordinated breaches of the Gaza-Israel border fence using explosives, bulldozers, and fire to disable surveillance and barriers. Near the adjacent , a key entry point for Palestinian workers, terrorists exploited the chaos to cross into Israeli territory, destroying infrastructure at the crossing itself as part of broader efforts to overwhelm border defenses. These tactics mirrored operations elsewhere along the border, where employed vehicles, motorcycles, and paragliders to rapidly advance toward nearby communities after neutralizing electronic fencing and observation towers. In the case of Kibbutz Erez, located about 1 kilometer from the border, an estimated group of terrorists approached the perimeter shortly after the fence breaches, aiming to infiltrate the community via roads and open fields. The kibbutz's security coordinator detected the incursion early through alerts and visual confirmation, mobilizing the standby defense squad—comprising armed civilian volunteers—to establish defensive positions at key access points. Reinforced by members of the neighboring kibbutz's security team, the defenders engaged the approaching militants with small arms fire, preventing any penetration into the residential areas or homes. The initial breach attempts were further disrupted by an tank dispatched to the border vicinity, which fired on terrorist concentrations, and subsequent strikes that targeted advancing groups before they could consolidate. This rapid response contrasted with delays in other border communities, where achieved deeper infiltrations; at Erez, the coordinated civilian-military action resulted in the neutralization of several terrorists without a successful entry into the core. One member of the Erez standby squad was killed during the exchanges, marking the kibbutz's sole fatality from the ground assault. An investigation later credited the security squad's preparedness and execution for thwarting 's operational plans against Erez, highlighting effective use of terrain and pre-positioned weapons caches.

Local Response and Armed Resistance

On the morning of October 7, 2023, members of Erez's civilian security detected militants breaching the perimeter fence and responded immediately by engaging the intruders with small arms fire from defensive positions near the kibbutz entrance. The , consisting of volunteers trained for defense, positioned themselves to block advances toward residential areas, preventing deeper infiltration into the community. Reinforced by volunteers from the neighboring Kibbutz Or HaNer security team, the Erez defenders conducted a coordinated counteraction, including suppressing fire on approximately 10-15 terrorists attempting to advance on motorcycles and foot. This joint effort pinned down the attackers, with fighting intensifying around 7:45 a.m. near a backyard entrance, where squad member Amir Naim was fatally wounded while providing covering fire. Despite being outnumbered and facing sustained assaults, the teams subdued the threat without allowing hostages to be taken or widespread entry into homes. An IDF investigation later credited the security squads' rapid mobilization and effective tactics with averting a massacre, noting that their actions contained the breach until a tank from the Golani Brigade arrived around 10:30 a.m. to neutralize remaining militants. No kibbutz residents were killed or abducted during the incident, underscoring the success of the localized armed resistance amid broader IDF delays in responding to the multi-front assault.

Casualties, Hostages, and Immediate Aftermath

During the attack on Erez on October 7, 2023, one resident was killed: Amir Manzhor Naim, a 27-year-old student and member of the kibbutz's local security team (also known as the rapid response squad), who was fatally shot while engaging terrorists in a residential yard around 7:45 a.m. Several other civilians, including squad members, sustained injuries during the clashes but were evacuated for treatment. No residents of were taken , as the attackers—estimated at dozens attempting to the perimeter—were repelled before achieving significant infiltration into the community. In the immediate aftermath, the kibbutz's coordinator, Chava Edry, coordinated with reinforcements from neighboring Kibbutz Or HaNer, whose team arrived around 8:00 a.m. to bolster the defense; an tank was deployed to the border fence, and strikes targeted terrorist concentrations, collectively thwarting further incursions and preventing a larger-scale . Residents were ordered to during the fighting, after which the kibbutz—home to around 600 people—was fully evacuated by authorities for reasons, with the site converted into a temporary outpost in the following week to secure the area and conduct sweeps for remaining threats.

Investigations and Security Reforms

IDF Probes into Failures

The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) released an internal probe on June 10, 2025, examining its performance during the Hamas attack on Kibbutz Erez on October 7, 2023, concluding that the military "failed in its mission to protect the residents of Kibbutz Erez and the civilians present in the area." The investigation highlighted delays in IDF reinforcement, with regular forces arriving only hours after the initial breach, leaving the kibbutz reliant on its local security team for defense against approximately 20-30 Hamas terrorists who infiltrated via nearby breaches in the border fence. A separate IDF investigation into the adjacent Erez Crossing, published in March 2025, revealed that around 120 terrorists overran the facility and nearby base, exploiting intelligence and operational shortcomings that resulted in the site's complete destruction and a loss of for hours. The probe identified failures in border defense protocols, including inadequate for a multi-front and insufficient numbers, leading to nine soldiers killed and three kidnapped before aerial support could intervene effectively. Both probes underscored broader conceptual errors in threat assessment, such as underestimating Hamas's capacity for coordinated ground incursions despite prior warnings of vulnerabilities, contributing to the ease of infiltration near Erez. These findings align with IDF's wider accountability reports, which admitted a "complete " in preventing the due to misprioritization of threats and overreliance on technological barriers like the fence, which terrorists neutralized using basic tools and explosives. No disciplinary actions were detailed specifically for Erez personnel in the public summaries, though the investigations informed subsequent reforms in unit training and rapid-response doctrines.

Heroism of Kibbutz Security Teams

The emergency standby squad of Kibbutz Erez, consisting of civilians trained in local defense, mobilized by 6:40 a.m. on October 7, 2023, shortly after detecting unusual activity near the kibbutz perimeter amid the broader Hamas incursion from Gaza. With 12 of its 16 members accessing personal weapons, the squad positioned itself at the "Blue Gate"—a rear entry point—and opened fire on 15-20 terrorists arriving in pickup trucks around 7:05 a.m., initiating fierce exchanges involving grenades and small-arms fire. Under the leadership of former security coordinator Ben Sadan, the team conducted ground operations that eliminated at least two terrorists within the boundaries and supported the neutralization of six more north of the Shikma Stream bridge, utilizing personal firearms and even drones for reconnaissance and targeting. Reinforcements from the neighboring 's security team, numbering about 12 members and led by Yaniv Kastenbaum, arrived around 8:00 a.m., bolstering the defense by counterattacking at breach points like Point 29 along the border fence and aiding in rescues of trapped families despite ammunition shortages and injuries among responders. These actions, characterized by the IDF's subsequent probe as demonstrating "courage and determination," effectively repelled the main infiltration wave, preventing the kibbutz from being overrun and averting a potential comparable to those in less-defended communities. The fighting subsided by 10:30 a.m., with IDF paratroopers arriving shortly after to clear remaining threats, though the kibbutz had already been partially infiltrated without full conquest. The squad suffered one fatality—Amir Manzhor Naim, a 27-year-old reserve and student —along with several wounded civilians, underscoring the personal risks undertaken amid delayed military intervention. This localized resistance highlighted the critical role of prepared civilian volunteers in mitigating Hamas's ground assault, as affirmed in the , which contrasted their efficacy with systemic command failures.

Policy Shifts and Lessons on Threat Prioritization

Following the October 7, 2023, Hamas attack, Israeli investigations, including those by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), identified fundamental flaws in pre-attack threat assessments that prioritized distant threats like Iran and Hezbollah over Hamas's immediate capabilities and ideological commitment to large-scale invasion. Analysts had assumed Hamas sought only "limited deterrence" through sporadic rocket fire or border raids, underestimating its multi-year preparation for a coordinated ground assault involving thousands of fighters, as evidenced by ignored intelligence indicators like Hamas training exercises simulating kibbutz infiltrations. This misprioritization stemmed from a "conflict management" doctrine that emphasized economic concessions to Gaza—such as work permits for 18,000 Gazans in Israel pre-attack—to maintain calm, while diverting resources to high-tech barriers that proved insufficient against low-tech breaches like bulldozers and paragliders. Policy shifts post-attack marked a pivot to "military maximalism," abandoning containment for the explicit goal of dismantling Hamas's military and governance structures in , as articulated by Benjamin Netanyahu's on October 7, 2023. The IDF's doctrinal reforms included reallocating forces southward, enhancing rapid-response units for border communities like Erez—where initial breaches exposed delays in military intervention—and integrating with technological surveillance to better gauge enemy intent beyond observable capabilities. By mid-2024, this manifested in operations targeting leadership and infrastructure, with over 17,000 militants reported killed, reflecting a recognition that ideological foes undeterred by incentives demand preemptive degradation rather than reactive defense. Key lessons emphasized recalibrating threat models to weigh ideological drivers—Hamas's charter-mandated goal of Israel's destruction—equally with material power, countering prior biases that dismissed warnings as "aspirational" rather than operational. Investigations highlighted systemic underinvestment in southern command readiness, where IDF brigades were reduced by 2023, leaving gaps exploited on when forces overran positions near and adjacent kibbutzim. Reforms now mandate annual war games simulating multi-front invasions, prioritizing as the "gravest proximate threat" in strategies updated in 2024. This approach underscores causal realism: passive deterrence fails against actors whose core tenets reject coexistence, necessitating sustained offensive posture to restore security equilibria.

Controversies and Alternative Perspectives

Critiques of Coexistence Initiatives

Critics of coexistence initiatives in communities like Kibbutz Erez argue that programs fostering economic ties, such as employing Palestinian workers from , created a false sense of security and inadvertently aided Hamas's intelligence gathering for the , 2023, attack. Prior to the assault, approximately 20,000 Gazan laborers crossed into Israel daily through the nearby , many working in border kibbutzim including agricultural roles that familiarized them with community layouts, security routines, and resident habits. While Israel's has stated that systematic spying by workers was not widespread, detractors contend the policy reflected naivety, prioritizing over verifiable threats like Hamas's charter advocating Israel's destruction and repeated rocket barrages, which totaled over 20,000 since 2005. These initiatives, often rooted in dialogue groups and shared projects emblematic of left-leaning kibbutz culture, are faulted for downplaying causal factors such as Hamas's ideological commitment to and in Gaza's education and media, evidenced by polls showing majority Palestinian support for the atrocities. In Erez and similar enclaves, such optimism contributed to lax perimeter defenses; for instance, the kibbutz's security team, though effective in repelling infiltrators on with volunteer aid, operated in a context where pre-attack warnings were dismissed amid coexistence . Post-attack testimonies from kibbutzim highlight this shift, with residents like those in nearby renouncing prior beliefs, one stating, "We thought (Gazans) were like us. And it turned out, no, they’re not," underscoring regrets over assuming mutual goodwill despite empirical indicators of enmity. Further critiques target the ideological underpinnings, noting that Hamas deliberately struck peacenik strongholds like these kibbutzim, exploiting their advocacy for gestures like the 2005 Gaza disengagement, which empowered the group without reciprocal moderation—Hamas fired over 4,000 rockets in the year preceding alone. Analysts attribute this vulnerability to a in and sources promoting coexistence narratives, often sidelining data on Palestinian rejectionism, such as consistent poll majorities favoring armed struggle over . Residents' post-trauma pivot toward hawkish stances, including calls for zones over renewed worker programs, reflects a reckoning with these oversights, prioritizing deterrence grounded in Hamas's unchanged objectives.

Debates on Gaza Disengagement Impacts

The 2005 Gaza Disengagement, implemented under Prime Minister from August to September 2005, involved the evacuation of approximately 8,000 Israeli settlers from 21 settlements and the withdrawal of (IDF) from inside territory. Proponents argued it would enhance Israel's by reducing direct exposure to Palestinian , minimizing IDF casualties from low-level clashes, and allowing external border control to prevent smuggling and infiltration. Critics, including opponents within Sharon's party, contended that unilateral without a negotiated agreement would empower terrorist groups, as evidenced by the subsequent electoral victory in January 2006 and its violent takeover of in June 2007. Security debates center on whether disengagement mitigated or exacerbated . Rocket and mortar attacks from on communities, including those near Erez, intensified post-withdrawal: from 2005 to 2006, incidents rose 42% to 1,777 launches, with interpreting the pullout as a that justified escalated operations, including for cross-border raids. While some analyses note a short-term drop in casualties inside due to the absence of settlements, overall cross-border threats grew, culminating in major conflicts in 2008–2009, 2012, 2014, and 2021, and contributing to the strategic vulnerabilities exposed on , 2023. 's militarization, funded partly by international aid diverted from civilian use, transformed into a launchpad for attacks rather than a , undermining claims of reduced friction. Economically, advocates anticipated "peace dividends" through Palestinian and development, with receiving billions in aid post-2005, leading to initial GDP growth and infrastructure projects. However, empirical outcomes revealed systemic diversion of resources to 's military buildup, resulting in persistent , rates exceeding 40% by 2010, and negligible spillover benefits for areas like Erez, where costs rose due to fortified defenses against incursions. Assessments from institutes highlight that without mechanisms to enforce demilitarization—absent in the unilateral plan—economic incentives failed to deter terrorism, as prioritized ideological confrontation over prosperity. Long-term evaluations, particularly after , 2023, frame disengagement as a cautionary precedent for unilateral concessions, with data showing over 20,000 rockets fired from since 2005, correlating with heightened risks to proximate communities. While a minority of analysts, including some in Sharon's circle, maintain it preserved demographic majorities and freed resources for other threats, the consensus in peer-reviewed security studies emphasizes its role in enabling Hamas's entrenchment, absent Palestinian Authority reforms or international guarantees against terror infrastructure. This underscores tensions between territorial and the causal link between and adversary , informing post-2023 reassessments.

Ideological Influences on Vulnerability

Residents of Kibbutz Erez and neighboring Gaza-border communities, rooted in the socialist-collectivist ethos of the , historically prioritized communal ideals and agricultural pioneering over militarized defense, a legacy that evolved into dovish orientations favoring Palestinian-Israeli reconciliation. This ideological framework, influenced by , emphasized coexistence and economic interdependence, such as employing Gazan laborers in kibbutz fields and industrial zones near Erez, despite persistent hostilities including over 20,000 rockets fired from Gaza since 2005. The 2005 Gaza disengagement, supported by many leaders as a step toward peace, exemplified this vulnerability: withdrawal of Israeli settlements and military presence handed control to elements, enabling Hamas's 2007 takeover and subsequent militarization, yet border kibbutzim like Erez maintained minimal fortifications, viewing enhanced barriers as antithetical to trust-building. Hamas's charter, explicitly calling for Israel's elimination through , contradicted assumptions of mutual goodwill, but ideological commitment to two-state solutions and opposition to settlement expansions led to underinvestment in perimeter security, with some communities resisting IDF-proposed upgrades pre-2023. On October 7, 2023, this mindset manifested in delayed responses and intelligence gaps; kibbutz security teams, often volunteer-based and under-equipped due to budget priorities favoring social programs, faced infiltrators who exploited familiarity from prior worker interactions for . Critics argue that systemic downplaying of Hamas's ideological rigidity—rooted in Islamist rejectionism rather than negotiable grievances—fostered complacency, as evidenced by post-attack surveys showing 70-80% of survivors in affected kibbutzim shifting toward hawkish views on deterrence. While not the sole factor amid broader lapses, this ideological lens prioritized aspirational peace over empirical threat assessment, contributing to Erez's exposure during the assault that killed three residents and threatened broader breach.

Community Resilience and Future Outlook

Post-Attack Relocation and Recovery

Following the attack on October 7, 2023, residents of Erez were evacuated from the community as a precautionary measure due to its proximity to the and the ongoing security threats, with the Israeli government directing thousands from border communities to temporary in hotels and other facilities, primarily in areas like and the Dead Sea region. This relocation affected approximately 200,000 people from southern , including Erez's roughly 700 residents, who were housed in state-provided accommodations for an initial period of up to 18 months, supplemented by community support and government stipends. By mid-2024, the began a gradual return process, with initial trickle-back of residents amid ongoing military operations in and heightened border vigilance; as of May 2024, most had not yet returned, citing and unresolved security concerns, though the kibbutz's defense squad's successful repulsion of the incursion—resulting in no resident fatalities—facilitated earlier deliberations on repopulation compared to more devastated communities like . Individual returns accelerated in late 2024, exemplified by residents like Orna, who resettled in December 2024 after over a year in evacuation. As of August 2025, a significant portion of Erez residents had returned home, aligning with broader trends among Gaza-border communities where enhanced fortifications, including expanded buffer zones and surveillance, enabled phased repopulation; community leaders emphasized collective decision-making, with over 60% back in some analogous kibbutzim by early 2025, though full recovery involved ongoing therapy programs for post-traumatic stress and economic rebuilding of agricultural operations. Recovery efforts included international aid, such as UJA-Federation's , which disbursed funds for repairs and support in Erez, focusing on reintegrating families while addressing debates over long-term viability near . Despite progress, some families opted for permanent relocation to central , reflecting persistent fears of renewed threats absent comprehensive demilitarization of .

Reconstruction and Demographic Changes

Following the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023, which included an attempted infiltration into Kibbutz Erez, residents were evacuated due to security concerns and damage to homes and infrastructure. The kibbutz's civilian defense squad, aided by volunteers from neighboring Kibbutz Or HaNer, repelled the incursion, averting a larger-scale massacre and limiting physical destruction compared to harder-hit communities like or . Reconstruction has focused on repairing damaged structures, fences, and public spaces, with volunteer efforts including playground renovations organized by groups like Jewish National Fund-USA in late 2023 and 2024. International Jewish organizations have provided targeted support; UJA-Federation of New York's , launched in 2024 with $17 million in funding, assists Erez in rehabilitating infrastructure, bolstering community resilience, and facilitating resident recovery through grants for repairs and psychosocial services. As of mid-2024, evacuees remained in temporary accommodations, including 77 renovated apartments in arranged by Atalef for Erez families. By October 2025, broader reconstruction has progressed, with five severely affected communities still in temporary housing, but Erez's relatively contained damage has supported phased returns. Demographically, pre-attack population stood at approximately 240 residents, with no reported fatalities from the itself during the incursion. Post-evacuation has led to some permanent departures, particularly among elderly members facing challenges in kibbutz-supported aging infrastructure disrupted by the relocation. However, regional trends indicate high , with about 90% of Gaza-border evacuees—totaling 62,000 people—returning by September 2025, supplemented by over 2,500 newcomers drawn to fortified border communities. For Erez, return efforts align with this pattern, though exact figures remain undisclosed; the influx of younger families and ideological settlers has offset losses, shifting demographics toward more security-conscious profiles amid enhanced presence and barriers.

Long-Term Security and Ideological Reassessment

Following the October 7, 2023, attack, Kibbutz Erez implemented enhanced long-term security protocols, building on the proven effectiveness of its civilian defense squad. An investigation released on June 10, 2025, credited the kibbutz's security team, augmented by volunteers from neighboring Kibbutz Or HaNer, with repelling the incursion and averting a larger , despite initial delays in response. This event underscored the limitations of relying solely on external forces, prompting investments in fortified infrastructure, including expanded protected spaces and advanced surveillance systems adjacent to communal areas like the dining room. Broader regional initiatives have supported Erez's security upgrades, with NGOs providing tactical firearms training to Gaza-border volunteers to deter future infiltrations. By September 2025, approximately 90% of pre-attack residents in the area, including Erez, had returned, joined by over 2,500 newcomers, reflecting renewed confidence in multi-layered defenses comprising reinforced perimeter fences, drone monitoring, and permanent outposts. These measures address systemic vulnerabilities exposed on , such as inadequate border barriers that facilitated the breach. Ideologically, the attack prompted a reassessment among Erez residents and the , shifting from traditional emphases on coexistence and economic cooperation with toward prioritizing deterrence and self-reliance. Pre-attack kibbutz ideologies, often aligned with left-leaning visions of dividends from the 2005 disengagement, faced scrutiny for underestimating Hamas's existential threats, as evidenced by the group's subsequent of . Post-attack, kibbutzim like Erez have attracted "real Zionists" committed to fortified , with kibbutz leaders advocating detachment from progressive politics in favor of pragmatic security partnerships. This evolution reflects causal lessons from : ideological optimism about Palestinian moderation failed to account for Hamas's charter-mandated hostility, necessitating a recalibration toward active over passive borders. While some analyses downplay disengagement's role, empirical data on escalated rocket fire and tunnel networks post-2005 substantiate critiques of policies that relinquished territorial buffers without robust enforcement mechanisms. Residents' return signals ideological resilience, tempered by demands for verifiable threat neutralization before full reconstruction.

References

  1. [1]
    | Erez - KKL
    Kibbutz Erez, established in 1949, is a secular kibbutz near the Gaza border, named after the founders, and named 'Erez' meaning 'cedar tree'. It has a ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
  2. [2]
    This isn't the “Wild West”, this is Kibbutz Erez – Inspiration from Zion
    Jul 22, 2024 · The Kibbutz is located just one kilometer (approx. half a mile) from the border with the Gaza Strip but their orchards are just 500 meters away.Missing: founding | Show results with:founding
  3. [3]
    ABOUT EREZ | Erez Camondo
    The Story of Erez ... The kibbutz was founded in 1949 by a group of Palmach members who fought for the establishment of the state of Israel. A few dozen people ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
  4. [4]
    Erez (Ashqelon, Southern District, Israel) - City Population
    Contents: Rural Locality (kibbutz) ; 608 Population [2021] – Estimate ; 0.5500 km² Area ; 1,105/km² Population Density [2021].
  5. [5]
    Heroes of Or HaNer and Erez: A united front against terror
    Oct 20, 2023 · On October 7, the people of the south were confronted with a harrowing reality. Thousands of terrorists breached the fence and launched a ...
  6. [6]
    Kibbutz Civilian Security Team Fought Off Hamas in Fierce Battle ...
    Jun 10, 2025 · The brave actions of Kibbutz Erez's civilian defense squad, reinforced by volunteers from neighboring Kibbutz Or Ha'Ner, prevented a potential massacre.Missing: achievements controversies
  7. [7]
    Kibbutz Erez emergency response team prevented 'massacre' on ...
    Jun 9, 2025 · Two were killed inside the kibbutz and six more were gunned down north of the Shikma Stream bridge, likely during their retreat. As fighting ...<|separator|>
  8. [8]
    IDF probe: Failures and heroism at Kibbutz Erez, October 7 Massacre
    Jun 10, 2025 · The probe said that the military “failed in its mission to protect the residents of Kibbutz Erez and the civilians present in the area.”
  9. [9]
    The Story of Kibbutz Erez on October 7th - כאן 7.10.360
    Oct 7, 2024 · On the morning of October 7th, the security squad of the kibbutz near the Erez crossing stopped Hamas terrorists on the fences and prevented ...
  10. [10]
    Kibbutz Erez - Jewish Independent
    May 24, 2024 · Of the 1,000-plus residents, 97 kibbutz members were killed, 11 people were abducted and one-third of the houses were severely damaged. Kibbutz ...
  11. [11]
    Government unveils plans to double population of Israeli ...
    Jul 10, 2025 · The government outlined plans on Thursday to double the rural population of Israeli communities in the Gaza border area.
  12. [12]
    Erez Crossing - Bein Harim
    In Hebrew the word 'Erez' means 'cedar tree' and just 1 km away sits a kibbutz with the same name, founded in 1949 on sand dunes close to the Gaza Strip.Missing: date | Show results with:date
  13. [13]
    palquest | dimra - interactive encyclopedia of the palestine question
    Village Before 1948. The village stood on the southern coastal plain, on a site that had distinctive, red-brown soil. It was linked by a short secondary road ...Missing: War | Show results with:War
  14. [14]
    [PDF] kibbutz erez - Uri Davis
    The Palestinian Arab society was interwoven with the developing settler Jewish society throughout the years of the British Mandate administration (1922-1948).
  15. [15]
    1948 - Yale University Press
    Benny Morris demolishes misconceptions and provides a comprehensive history of the Israeli-Arab war of 1948. This history of the foundational war in the ...Missing: Dimra | Show results with:Dimra
  16. [16]
    How October 7 Exposed the History of Gaza's Perimeter - SarimBlog
    Apr 6, 2025 · ... 1948.[9]. To the north, Kibbutz Erez was established on the site of Dimra, part of the Gazan subdistrict where 520 villagers were removed in ...
  17. [17]
    The Gaza Strip: History of Jewish Settlement
    Some Jews returned, however, and, in 1946, kibbutz Kfar Darom was established to prevent the British from separating the Negev from the Jewish state. The United ...
  18. [18]
    [PDF] Head of the Sha'ar HaNegev Regional Council
    Aug 28, 2015 · For the last seven years Kibbutz Erez has been working to stimulate its demographic growth. The kibbutz insisted on absorbing new residents ...
  19. [19]
    Kibbutz Erez
    Kibbutz Erez is in southwestern Israel, currently evacuated, near the Gaza border. It was named after the Erez Crossing and had a 2023 attack attempt.Missing: history | Show results with:history
  20. [20]
    Erez on the map of Israel, location on the map, exact time
    31.55984, 34.564889. Erez is located in the time zone Israel Standard Time. Official currency — ILS ...
  21. [21]
    Yearly & Monthly weather - Erez, Israel
    Jan 27, 2024 · Throughout the year, in Erez, there are 72.1 rainfall days, and 271mm (10.67") of precipitation is accumulated.
  22. [22]
    THE LAND: Geography and Climate Ministry of Foreign Affairs - Gov.il
    Nov 4, 2021 · Israel's climate ranges from temperate to tropical, with plenty of sunshine. Two distinct seasons predominate: a rainy winter period from November to May; and ...Missing: Erez | Show results with:Erez
  23. [23]
    How American Jews Are Helping Israel's Communities Near Gaza ...
    Aug 20, 2025 · For months afterward, the kibbutz was empty, its residents internally displaced and sheltering elsewhere amid the war between Hamas and Israel.Missing: population | Show results with:population
  24. [24]
    Rebuilding Gaza border Kibbutzim: UJA's Project Horizon Aid
    Aug 5, 2025 · Before the war, Dor Zohar, a lifelong resident of Erez, helped manage a Tel Aviv high-tech firm. “Even though there were no hostages from Erez ...
  25. [25]
    Kibbutz Erez defense squad, with help from nearby kibbutz, repelled ...
    Jun 10, 2025 · Members of Kibbutz Erez's civil defense squad, with help from the security team of the nearby kibbutz of Or Haner, repelled Hamas's attempted invasion of the ...Missing: composition | Show results with:composition
  26. [26]
    Federation Partnering With Israeli Kibbutz Impacted by 10/7
    May 1, 2024 · As one of the largest communities in the western Negev, it has a current population that is 36 percent young adults and 34 percent children ...
  27. [27]
    Erez - Wikipedia
    Economy. The kibbutz has three main industries: agriculture (arable and fruit farming as well as animal husbandry), manufacturing (Erez Thermoplastics Products ...History · 1948 Arab-Israeli war · 2023 Hamas attack · Economy
  28. [28]
    EREZ Technical Textiles - Technical Textile for the Modern World
    EREZ Technical Textiles manufactures high-performance, long-lasting coated technical textiles for various industrial applications worldwide.Missing: kibbutz | Show results with:kibbutz
  29. [29]
    How a company in rural Israel became a global leader in technical ...
    Mar 2, 2020 · One of the two companies that formed E² is a technical fabric manufacturer in southern Israel called Erez Thermoplastic Products.
  30. [30]
    Erez Thermoplastic Products - Startup Nation Finder
    Jun 27, 2019 · The company is owned by Kibbutz Erez and has a wholly owned marketing subsidiary in the United States, as well as part ownership of a ...
  31. [31]
    Erez Thermoplastic - Crunchbase Company Profile & Funding
    Kibbutz Erez owns it that has a wholly owned marketing subsidiary in the United States as well as part ownership of a manufacturing facility in South Africa.
  32. [32]
    Jewish sightseeing in Erez, Israel - San Diego Jewish World
    Aug 1, 2003 · At a spot a bit to the northwest of the Gaza Strip¹s northeast corner, they founded Kibbutz 'Erez,' meaning cedar trees. ... kibbutz fields, ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
  33. [33]
    Sustainability - EREZ Technical Textiles
    EREZ focuses on sustainability by reusing materials, selling 100% of scraps, and aiming to reduce environmental impact and waste.
  34. [34]
    Kibbutz Erez - Company Profile and News - Bloomberg Markets
    Kibbutz Erez was founded in 1949. The Company's line of business includes the manufacturing of synthetic resins, plastics materials, and nonvulcanizable ...
  35. [35]
    [PDF] The Erez and Gaza Industrial Estates: Catalysts for Development
    Apr 25, 2005 · Positive developments in the Erez Industrial Estate, for instance, could demonstrate ways for economic coop- eration and practical support for ...
  36. [36]
    Beit Hanoun "Erez" Industrial Zone and Palestinian Workers - WAFA
    The Erez industrial zone will be shut down as part of Israel's plan to withdraw from the Gaza Strip.Missing: kibbutz | Show results with:kibbutz
  37. [37]
    Israel to Permit Entry of Palestinian Workers During Sukkot Holiday
    Oct 6, 2017 · Palestinian agricultural workers on kibbutz Erez ...
  38. [38]
    An Israeli volunteer takes part in the avocado fruit harvest at a ...
    An Israeli volunteer takes part in the avocado fruit harvest at a plantation near Kibbutz Erez close to the border with the Gaza Strip in southern Israel on ...
  39. [39]
    Israel reopens the main Gaza crossing for Palestinian laborers after ...
    Sep 28, 2023 · The Erez crossing is the sole pedestrian passageway out of the coastal enclave into Israel for the roughly 18,000 Palestinians from Gaza who ...
  40. [40]
    Israel-Gaza, anatomy of a border at war: 'We can't live like this ...
    May 1, 2024 · Until October 7, Erez was the main link between Gaza and Israel, mainly because of some 20,000 Palestinian workers from the enclave who were ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  41. [41]
    Exits by Palestinians from Gaza via Erez Crossing - Gisha
    Dec 26, 2023 · The numbers of exits from Gaza via Erez Crossing between March 2020 and late 2021, when the “coronavirus closure” at Erez was gradually removed, ...
  42. [42]
    How Israel's Work Permit Policy for Palestinians Helps Maintain the ...
    May 26, 2023 · There are an estimated 150,000 Palestinians currently working in Israel, but is Israel using economic relations as a tool to retain control over ...
  43. [43]
    Report: Shin Bet debunks idea that Gazan workers spied en masse ...
    Mar 7, 2024 · The Shin Bet security service concluded that there was no broad effort by Palestinians who entered Israel from Gaza for work prior to the October 7 massacre.
  44. [44]
    Palestinian Workers in Israel Gave Detailed Information to Hamas ...
    Mar 10, 2024 · Palestinian workers in Israel provided detailed information to Hamas that helped the terrorist group plan the murderous attacks of Oct. 7.
  45. [45]
    Shin Bet rejects suspicion Gaza workers gathered intel for Oct. 7 killers
    Mar 7, 2024 · The Shin Bet ruled out the possibility after interrogating about 3,000 Gazan laborers, Channel 12 reported on Thursday. Arabs from Gaza entered ...
  46. [46]
    Foreign Workers Now Teach Jews How To Farm — on the Kibbutz
    Sep 26, 2014 · In fact, according to the Ministry of Agriculture, the vast majority of farm workers on all 270 of Israel's kibbutzim are foreign guest workers.
  47. [47]
    'It's like another planet': crossing the frontier from Gaza to work in Israel
    Jan 1, 2023 · Built in the 2000s at a cost of $60m (£50m), Erez was designed to facilitate about 45,000 Palestinians a day who used to leave the strip to go ...Missing: kibbutz | Show results with:kibbutz
  48. [48]
    From border defence to 'vulnerable' communities, Israel's kibbutzim ...
    Nov 5, 2023 · The kibbutzim were first formed in the early 1910s to stake out the borders of the future state of Israel and the Palestinian Territories.
  49. [49]
    Kibbutz Under Fire: Back to the Days of Sickle and Bayonet - jstor
    From its inception the kibbutz took on the dual roles of security and settlement that were deeply anchored in Zionist ideology and the socialist doctrines at ...
  50. [50]
    PHOTO ESSAY: The beautiful bomb shelters of the Gaza Envelope
    Nov 24, 2023 · The painted concrete blocks reflect the Jews' resilience in settling the land - even now, when they are stained with Jewish blood.
  51. [51]
    Bomb shelter upgrades provide security to Israeli community - ICEJ
    Jun 26, 2023 · The kibbutz has two underground bomb shelters which over the years became totally unusable. But thanks to the Christian Embassy's generous ...
  52. [52]
    The Long, Bloody History of the Israel-Gaza “Border” | The Nation
    Nov 29, 2023 · From 1991, Palestinians needed an Israeli permit to exit Gaza (or the occupied West Bank); in 1994, Israel built a fence around the Strip for ...
  53. [53]
    Gaza's Subterranean Warfare: Palestinian Resistance Tunnels vs ...
    May 5, 2024 · However, Israel only realized the real threat posed by the tunnels when a combat group consisting of 13 members from the Qassam Brigades ...
  54. [54]
    Israel announces completion of underground Gaza border barrier
    Dec 7, 2021 · Israel on Tuesday announced the completion of a sensor-equipped underground wall on its side of the Gaza border, a counter-measure developed after Hamas ...
  55. [55]
    Israel Completes Vast, Billion-dollar Gaza Barrier
    Dec 7, 2021 · The barrier is 65 kilometers long, and cost an estimated 3.5 billion shekels ($1.11 billion) to build. Its development was announced in 2016, ...Missing: crossing | Show results with:crossing
  56. [56]
    The 'Iron Wall': What is the Gaza-Israel fence? - Al Arabiya
    Oct 11, 2023 · Tel Aviv announced in 2021 the completion of an enhanced security barrier around the Gaza Strip designed to prevent militants from sneaking into ...
  57. [57]
    The seven border crossings of Gaza | Israel-Palestine conflict
    Jun 15, 2022 · The Gaza Strip had seven main border crossings giving it access to the outside world. Only three remain open.
  58. [58]
    COGAT summary of activities 2021 Ministry of Foreign Affairs - Gov.il
    Feb 2, 2022 · In 2021, 13.5 million individual crossings were registered of Palestinians who entered Israel from Judea and Samaria for work, commerce, medical treatment, and ...
  59. [59]
    Israel okays 1500 more entry permits for Gaza workers, bringing ...
    Sep 22, 2022 · Israel will raise the quota of work permits for Gazan Palestinians to 17,000 next week, expanding a policy that defense officials view as a ...Missing: procedures | Show results with:procedures
  60. [60]
    Palestinian access from Gaza Strip declined sharply in 2017
    Jan 15, 2018 · By the end of November 2017, the approval rate for permit applications by Palestinian patients to travel via Erez was 54 per cent, down from 62 ...Missing: procedures | Show results with:procedures
  61. [61]
    [PDF] Movement in and out of Gaza in 2022 - UN.org.
    Feb 23, 2023 · Information on the status of Erez crossings and the number of people entering or exiting is based on data provided by the General Authority of ...
  62. [62]
    120 terrorists invaded Erez Crossing, adjacent base on Oct. 7, as ...
    Mar 30, 2025 · Before the war, some 18,000 Gazans had work permits to enter Israel via the Erez Crossing. ... into the Erez Crossing on October 7, 2023. (Defense ...
  63. [63]
    Eyeing Quiet, Israel Expands Work Permits for Gazans
    Aug 19, 2022 · The Israeli Defense Ministry announced on Friday that it has approved 1,500 additional work permits for Palestinians in Gaza, following a ...
  64. [64]
    How Israel Secretly Propped Up Hamas - The New York Times
    Dec 10, 2023 · Multiple Israeli governments enabled money to go to Gaza for humanitarian reasons, not to strengthen Hamas, an official in Mr. Netanyahu's ...
  65. [65]
    Crossing Erez in March 2023 - This Week in Palestine
    All the measures my vulnerability has invoked amazed me: the security gadgets, the modern technology, the automated steel grid floors, the heavily armed and ...
  66. [66]
    Israel reopens Gaza border crossing, despite ongoing riots
    Sep 28, 2023 · Erez Crossing again allows thousands of Gazans into Israel for work after being closed 2 weeks ago due to violent protests.
  67. [67]
    Hamas-directed Gaza border violence a major security threat
    Sep 26, 2023 · Hamas-directed Gaza border violence a major security threat · Hamas is channeling Palestinian frustration toward Israel rather than toward the ...Missing: pre- | Show results with:pre-
  68. [68]
    “Hamas is deterred” as wishful thinking: An analysis of how Israel ...
    Oct 7, 2025 · In 1967, Israel was again surprised by the sudden threat from Egypt, as Israeli intelligence had assessed that Egypt was deeply involved in a ...
  69. [69]
    The October 7 Attack: An Assessment of the Intelligence Failings
    Oct 7, 2024 · At the same time, it would be wrong to conclude that Israel was completely unaware of the potential threat of Hamas. The IDF's new operational ...
  70. [70]
    Israel's army admits failures on Oct. 7 and says it underestimated ...
    Oct 7, 2025 · Israel's military has determined that Hamas was able to carry out the Oct. 7 attack because the much more powerful Israeli army misjudged ...
  71. [71]
    Israel's Oct. 7 Early Warning Failure: Who Is to Blame?
    Oct 4, 2024 · Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his intelligence chiefs appear locked in a blame game, with each side offering conflicting accounts of whether warnings ...
  72. [72]
    A detailed look at how Hamas secretly crossed into Israel - ABC News
    Oct 12, 2023 · Hamas militants broke through Israel's complex border security systems with the morning of Oct. 7, attacking the neighboring towns, killing hundreds of people.Missing: history | Show results with:history
  73. [73]
    Hamas destroyed the Erez Crossing on October 7. Despite this, we ...
    Jun 5, 2024 · 20K likes, 7304 comments - idf on June 5, 2024: "Hamas destroyed the Erez Crossing on October 7. Despite this, we have continued our efforts ...
  74. [74]
    Failure at the Fence | FRONTLINE | Official Site | Documentary Series
    Dec 19, 2023 · Watch FRONTLINE and The Washington Post's documentary on how Hamas was able to breach Israel's vaunted security barrier on Oct. 7 and carry ...
  75. [75]
    IDF Probe: Kibbutz Erez Security Chief Got Help From Neighboring ...
    Jun 10, 2025 · The military investigation found that the conduct of the security squad and its coordinator thwarted Hamas plans to attack the kibbutz on October 7.
  76. [76]
    The Times of Israel - Facebook
    Jun 10, 2025 · Every Kibbutz should have self-defense civilian militia unit attached to IDF as first to respond in case of terrorist attack. 4 mos. 1.
  77. [77]
    'They Saved Us': Kibbutz Civilian Security Team Fought Off
    Jun 10, 2025 · At 7:45 a.m., Naim was fatally wounded while fighting from a home's yard near the back entrance. As the Erez defenders found themselves pinned ...
  78. [78]
    Amir Naim, 27: Engineering student was eagerly awaiting son's birth
    Oct 1, 2024 · Amir Manzhor Naim, 27, from Kibbutz Erez, was killed battling the Hamas attack on the kibbutz on October 7. A member of the kibbutz's local ...
  79. [79]
    IDF failed to protect border kibbutz on Oct. 7, probe finds - WNG.org
    Jun 10, 2025 · The Israeli military failed to protect the Kibbutz Erez community near the Gaza Strip during the Oct. 7, 2023 terror attacks, the Israel Defense Forces ...
  80. [80]
    October 7 probe: Hamas destroyed Erez Crossing, brought loss of ...
    Mar 30, 2025 · IDF probe reveals IDF failures in defending against Hamas attack on Erez Crossing • Nine soldiers killed, three hostages taken.
  81. [81]
    IDF Probe Into October 7 Attack On Erez Crossing Reveals Army ...
    Mar 30, 2025 · The Israel Defense Forces released its conclusions on sunday after investigating the October 7 battle at the Erez crossing, with some damning ...
  82. [82]
    Israel's military publishes first report on 7 October 2023 failures - BBC
    Feb 27, 2025 · Israel's military has published its first official account of the mistakes that led to its failures during Hamas's 7 October 2023 attack, which ...
  83. [83]
    'IDF Failed in its Mission to Protect Civilians': Report Into IDF's ... - FDD
    Feb 28, 2025 · ... IDF's October 7 Failures Released. Latest Developments. Not Prepared for Surprise Attack: The IDF on February 27 released its first internal ...
  84. [84]
    IDF's Oct. 7 probes show it misread Hamas for years, left southern ...
    Feb 27, 2025 · ... threat to Israel, that it was uninterested in a large-scale war ... The battles investigation found that the IDF failed to protect ...
  85. [85]
    Years of Israeli Misconceptions, Intelligence Blunders Led to ...
    Feb 28, 2025 · ... Failures That Resulted in the October 7 Massacre. ... The Israel Defense Forces' inquiry into the approach to the threat ...
  86. [86]
    [PDF] Israeli Intelligence Failures Prior to Hamas's October 7 Attack
    on the threat from tunnels, concluding that Hamas would again launch any attack through tunnels rather than through an assault above ground.143 Similarly ...<|separator|>
  87. [87]
    Israeli Security After October 7
    Feb 21, 2024 · Hamas's attack tested the core tenets of Israel's security outlook ... Hamas attacks and the threat of cross-border action. Neither ...
  88. [88]
    Redefining vigilance: reevaluating the meaning of early warning in ...
    This issue stems from Israel's failure to adapt to the changing threat landscape and change accordingly its early warning concept to modern threats posed by ...
  89. [89]
    Post-Oct. 7 divergent paths: Israel's military maximalism and Saudi ...
    Aug 7, 2025 · The Hamas attack on Oct. 7, 2023, shattered Israel's long-standing security paradigm, replacing limited deterrence with an ambitious ...
  90. [90]
    Israel Applying Lessons Learned from October 7
    Mar 13, 2025 · Among the findings: the concept of deterrence (originating in Cold War interstate realism theory) and the practice of holding off on attacks to ...
  91. [91]
    The State of Israel's National Security - INSS
    ... Hamas surprise attack on the western Negev on October 7, 2023. This ... Israel is undeniably under threat from countries and organizations that refuse ...
  92. [92]
    Learning from mistakes: the impact of the October 7 surprise attack ...
    In the American case, for example, Sims argues that marked failures and high-risk situations lead to intelligence overreach and the use of aggressive collection ...
  93. [93]
    How Changes in the Israeli Military Led to the Failure of October 7
    May 20, 2024 · The Hamas attack of Oct. 7 exposed severe shortages of transport ... To counter this threat, Hamas established a counterintelligence wing, known ...
  94. [94]
    These kibbutzniks used to believe in peace with Palestinians. Their ...
    May 3, 2025 · Before October 7, kibbutzniks living near the Gaza border often advocated for peace with Palestinians. For many, those views have changed ...<|separator|>
  95. [95]
    October 7: When Hamas targeted Israel's peaceniks on kibbutzim
    Aug 25, 2024 · View of the destruction caused by Hamas terrorists on October 7, 2023, in Kibbutz Kfar Aza, near the Israeli-Gaza border, in southern Israel, ...<|separator|>
  96. [96]
    Their dovish hopes clipped, some Gaza border residents make ...
    Mar 4, 2024 · Civilians who followed Hamas into Israel to loot and vandalize communities on October 7 showed their true faces, says one Nir Oz survivor.
  97. [97]
    Israel's 2005 Disengagement from Gaza: a multilateral move under ...
    Mar 11, 2025 · ... terror attacks against Israel during the period leading to the Gaza ... security, particularly concerning smuggling and terrorist infiltration.
  98. [98]
    Security, Terrorism, and Territorial Withdrawal: Critically ...
    Oct 18, 2022 · Instead, Israel withdrew to mitigate its casualties, yield foreign policy gains, deter and deny terrorist groups, and avert a perceived ...
  99. [99]
    The Disengagement: The Unanswered Question
    The failure of this plan became evident when Hamas took over Gaza. Its operational capabilities improved considerably and it built a small terror army ...
  100. [100]
    Why the Likud Voted No to Sharon's Disengagement Plan
    Furthermore, the polls published in the newspapers on the Gaza disengagement plan failed to separate likely voters from all Likud members. In a poll ...Missing: critiques | Show results with:critiques
  101. [101]
    Lessons from Gaza disengagement remain relevant 20 years later
    Aug 5, 2025 · From 2005 to 2006, the number of rocket and mortar attacks from Gaza on Israel rose 42% to 1,777. Hamas also began building tunnels into ...<|separator|>
  102. [102]
    Israel's War to Halt Palestinian Rocket Attacks
    Mar 3, 2008 · The 2005 Gaza disengagement provided Hamas with a sense of empowerment and self-confidence that led to a clear-cut escalation in the employment of the rocket ...
  103. [103]
    Military Consequences of a Gaza Ceasefire Collapse
    Nov 20, 2008 · Hamas's military capabilities have grown since 2005 as a consequence of four major developments: Israel's August 2005 disengagement from Gaza, ...Missing: outcomes | Show results with:outcomes
  104. [104]
    [PDF] Ten Years since the Disengagement from the Gaza Strip - INSS
    Palestinians in the Gaza Strip would be integrated as Israeli citizens and vote for its institutions. 31 Nir Yahav, “Peres Hints: Disengagement Was a Failure,” ...
  105. [105]
    Benny Gantz's Dangerous Ambiguity on West Bank Disengagement
    Feb 18, 2019 · Even the terror groups of Hezbollah and Hamas pose a far greater threat to Israel's national security than they did a decade ago. Under ...<|separator|>
  106. [106]
    What is a kibbutz? The roots of Israel's communal villages ... - NPR
    Oct 12, 2023 · The first kibbutz was established in 1910, and over the decades that followed, dozens were formed across the territory that would become Israel.Missing: Erez | Show results with:Erez<|separator|>
  107. [107]
    Scenes from a Kibbutz – Rebecca Burgess - Law & Liberty
    Nov 15, 2023 · Thus, it's not surprising to learn that among Israelis, the kibbutz residents on the Gaza border are actually more likely to have supported the ...Missing: criticism pacifism<|control11|><|separator|>
  108. [108]
    'Settlers are right': The kibbutz movement should break away from ...
    Feb 16, 2024 · Meir produces a page featuring statistics about the composition of the senior officer corps in the Israel Defense Forces. "There are 12 ...
  109. [109]
    The Left's October 7 Revisionism - Tablet Magazine
    Aug 20, 2025 · These officials were so confident that no danger from Gaza was imminent that, even after the signs of an impending invasion were accumulating ...Missing: kibbutzim | Show results with:kibbutzim
  110. [110]
    Israelis return to rebuild kibbutzim after October 7 | The Jerusalem Post
    Oct 6, 2025 · Minister Zeev Elkin, who is overseeing the recovery, said the plan was to double the population to 120,000 in the coming years. The remains of ...
  111. [111]
    Oct. 7 evacuees from Kibbutz Re'im are fleeing back home amid ...
    Jun 17, 2025 · During the first night of missile attacks, they went to a supposedly protected space on the moshav that wasn't really protected. On the second ...
  112. [112]
    ATUFOT - Myisrael
    Established at Kibbutz Erez—just miles from the Gaza border—this holistic ... Forced to evacuate for over a year, Orna returned home in December 2024 ...
  113. [113]
    How American Jews are helping Israeli communities near Gaza
    Aug 5, 2025 · Launched in March 2024, Project Horizon began by awarding $8 million to the eight communities that suffered most in the Hamas attack: Be'eri ...
  114. [114]
    Find Your Voice In Israel - JNF.org
    Meanwhile, other volunteers painted playgrounds and repaired fences in badly harmed Kibbutz Erez ... Many of these families have lost loved ones on October 7 or ...
  115. [115]
    2024 Impact Report - AFINS
    Atalef in the Community - Renovation of 77 apartments in Kiryat Gat for Kibbutz Erez evacuees as a temporary housing solution. ... October 7 in Kfar Aza; ...
  116. [116]
    Residents Return To Israel's Gaza Border Communities ... - i24 News
    Sep 16, 2025 · In Nahal Oz, only a third of residents have returned so far after the kibbutz reopened to families on Sept. 1. Five communities – Be'eri ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  117. [117]
    After October 7, These Elderly Kibbutzniks Struggle With an ...
    Aug 29, 2024 · The evacuation of kibbutzim after October 7 left their older members in a quandary. The support and infrastructure that enabled them to live independently ...Missing: population | Show results with:population<|control11|><|separator|>
  118. [118]
    Gaza border residents return as rebuilding progresses
    Sep 22, 2025 · Some 62,000 residents have returned to Gaza border communities. Reconstruction continues, with five key areas still in temporary housing.
  119. [119]
    2 years after Oct. 7 shattered them, Israel's border kibbutzes are ...
    Oct 5, 2025 · Roughly 100 of about 260 Israeli kibbutzim sit on the borders, a design Shotan said was meant to anchor the edges through civilian life rather ...
  120. [120]
    Israeli NGO transforms Gaza border security volunteers into defence ...
    May 11, 2025 · Volunteer security team members from Gaza-border communities train in tactical firearm use, honing skills to prevent a repeat of the October 7, 2023, Hamas-led ...
  121. [121]
    90% of pre-Oct. 7 residents have returned to Gaza border area ...
    Sep 17, 2025 · 90% of pre-Oct. 7 residents have returned to Gaza border area, joined by 2,500 others. Government agency tasked with rehabilitating region says ...
  122. [122]
    The Untold Story of How Israel Failed on October 7
    May 15, 2025 · Nine soldiers were killed and three kidnapped before air force drone strikes on Hamas vehicles prompted the terrorists to leave for Gaza or ...
  123. [123]
    Why did self-righteous opponents of Gaza disengagement ignore ...
    Aug 5, 2025 · Why Did the Self-righteous Opponents of Israel's Gaza Disengagement Ignore Security Warnings Before October 7? · Thousands of Israelis marched to ...
  124. [124]
    'You have to be a real Zionist': Two years after Oct. 7, new dreamers ...
    Oct 6, 2025 · 90% of displaced Gaza border residents have returned, joined by more than 2500 newcomers. Some say it's idealism, others just want to 'get ...
  125. [125]
    2 years after Oct. 7 shattered them, Israel's border kibbutzes are ...
    Oct 6, 2025 · The scale of the damage remains stark. The movement counts 56 kibbutzim evacuated after Oct. 7 and says kibbutz communities lost 318 people in ...Missing: peace impact