Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Gender debates

Gender debates refer to a range of philosophical, scientific, and policy disputes over the distinction between biological sex—defined as a binary reproductive category in humans based on the production of small gametes (sperm) or large gametes (ova)—and gender as a social or psychological construct, particularly intensified by claims of gender identity fluidity and demands for affirmation in law, medicine, and public spaces.^[1]^[2] These debates challenge traditional understandings rooted in evolutionary biology, where sex dimorphism confers average physical advantages to males in strength, speed, and endurance, even after hormone therapy, leading to conflicts in sex-segregated domains like athletics and prisons.^[3]^[4] Central controversies include the medical treatment of gender dysphoria, especially in minors, where systematic reviews have identified low-quality evidence supporting interventions like puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones, prompting restrictions in jurisdictions prioritizing empirical caution over ideological affirmation.^[5] Proponents of gender identity models argue for self-identification overriding biological criteria, citing personal autonomy and minority rights, yet this framework often clashes with protections for sex-based categories, such as female-only shelters or competitive sports, where empirical data affirm persistent male physiological edges post-transition.^[6]^[7] Critics, drawing from first-principles biology and causal analyses of development, highlight risks of over-medicalization amid rising youth referrals—predominantly adolescent females in recent cohorts—and question the validity of social contagion hypotheses, given institutional biases in research favoring affirmative approaches despite methodological flaws in supportive studies.^[8] Defining characteristics include legal battles over pronouns, bathroom access, and detransition narratives, underscoring tensions between individual expression and collective sex-based realities, with policy shifts in places like the UK and parts of the US reflecting growing emphasis on evidence over consensus in academia and media, where left-leaning skews have historically amplified unverified claims of fluidity.^[9]

Foundational Concepts

Biological Sex and Dimorphism

Biological sex in humans refers to the binary classification of organisms based on the type of gametes they produce or are developmentally organized to produce: males produce small, motile gametes (sperm), while females produce large, non-motile gametes (ova).^[10] This definition stems from anisogamy, the evolutionary distinction between gamete sizes that underpins sexual reproduction in species like humans, with no third gamete type observed.^[11] ^[12] Sex determination in humans is primarily genetic and occurs at fertilization. The presence of a Y chromosome typically triggers the expression of the SRY gene, a key transcription factor located on the Y chromosome that initiates the differentiation of bipotential gonads into testes around the 6th to 7th week of embryonic development.^[13] In the absence of SRY (as in XX individuals), the default developmental pathway leads to ovarian formation.^[14] Testes produce testosterone and anti-Müllerian hormone, promoting male internal and external genitalia, while ovaries facilitate female structures via estrogen and other hormones. Chromosomal anomalies, such as XXY (Klinefelter syndrome) or X0 (Turner syndrome), occur but do not alter the binary gametic framework; affected individuals remain organized toward one sex or the other. Human sexual dimorphism manifests in pronounced physical differences arising from these developmental pathways, reflecting evolutionary pressures like reproductive roles and mate competition. Males exhibit greater average stature (approximately 8-10% taller globally), higher muscle mass (up to 40% more upper-body strength), broader shoulders, narrower hips, and denser bones, while females show wider pelvic girdles adapted for childbirth, higher body fat percentages (for energy reserves during gestation and lactation), and larger average breast size post-puberty.^[15] ^[16] Secondary traits include denser facial and body hair, deeper voice pitch (due to larger larynx), and prominent brow ridges in males, contrasting with smoother skin and higher voice pitch in females.^[17] These differences emerge early: body size dimorphism is detectable by 1 month of age, peaks around 3 months, and stabilizes by adulthood, with males' larger brains (about 11% by volume) correlating to overall body size scaling.^[18] Disorders of sex development (DSDs), formerly termed intersex conditions, represent rare deviations from typical binary development, affecting chromosomal, gonadal, or anatomical structures. True ambiguity in external genitalia occurs in approximately 0.018% of births (1 in 5,500), far lower than inflated estimates of 1.7% that include non-reproductive traits like Klinefelter syndrome; most DSD cases resolve to male or female based on gonadal tissue or gametic potential, with no evidence of a third sex category.^[19] For instance, congenital adrenal hyperplasia in XX females may masculinize genitalia but does not produce sperm, confirming female sex organization. Such conditions highlight the robustness of binary sex pathways rather than undermining them, as fertility and gamete production remain aligned with one of the two types in viable cases.^[20]

Gender as Construct vs. Innate Traits

The debate centers on whether gender—encompassing behavioral tendencies, preferences, and identities—arises primarily from social conditioning and cultural norms, as posited by social construct theorists, or from innate biological factors linked to sex, as supported by empirical research in genetics, endocrinology, and evolutionary psychology. Proponents of the construct view, such as philosopher Judith Butler, argue that gender is performative and iteratively produced through repeated social acts, detached from biological sex, with roles varying arbitrarily across societies. However, this perspective has faced criticism for underemphasizing consistent cross-cultural patterns and biological mechanisms, which behavioral genetic studies indicate play a substantial role in shaping sex-differentiated traits.^[21] Twin studies provide robust evidence for genetic contributions to sex differences in behavior and personality. For instance, analyses of over 6,800 adult twins reveal that heritability accounts for 40-50% of variance in Big Five personality traits, with sex-specific genetic influences evident in domains like neuroticism and agreeableness, where females consistently score higher across samples.^[22] ^[23] These findings persist even after controlling for shared environments, suggesting that individual differences in gender-typical behaviors, such as masculinity-femininity in personality, stem partly from direct genetic effects rather than solely postnatal socialization.^[24] Prenatal hormone exposure further underscores innateness: girls with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH), who experience elevated prenatal androgens, exhibit increased male-typical play preferences, such as choosing trucks over dolls, independent of rearing influences.^[25] Meta-analyses confirm that such androgen effects masculinize and defeminize play behavior in humans, with similar patterns in typical populations via digit ratio proxies for fetal testosterone.^[26] ^[27] Cross-cultural universality reinforces biological underpinnings over pure constructivism. Sex differences in mate preferences—men prioritizing physical attractiveness and youth, women financial prospects and status—hold across 45 countries, replicating earlier findings in 37 nations and indicating evolutionary adaptations rather than cultural artifacts.^[28] ^[29] Similarly, personality gaps, like greater female extraversion facets in enthusiasm but male edges in assertiveness, appear in 55 cultures, with effect sizes stable despite varying gender equality levels, challenging socialization-only models.^[30] While some variability exists, the consistency of these patterns, including in isolated societies, aligns with first-principles causal chains from sex chromosomes and hormones to brain dimorphism and adaptive behaviors, rather than top-down cultural imposition. Critics of construct theory note that institutional biases in academia, often favoring interpretive over quantitative paradigms, may inflate cultural explanations despite contradictory data from large-scale genetic and observational studies.^[31]

Historical Evolution

Pre-Modern and Traditional Perspectives

In ancient civilizations, gender roles were inextricably tied to biological dimorphism and reproductive imperatives, positing men and women as complementary yet hierarchically ordered sexes essential for societal stability and lineage continuity. Men, endowed with greater physical strength and deemed more rational or assertive, assumed roles in warfare, governance, and provision, while women, bearing the burdens of gestation and child-rearing, were oriented toward domestic management and familial harmony. This division reflected empirical observations of sex-linked traits and the necessities of survival in agrarian or tribal contexts, where deviation from such norms risked communal disruption.^[32] Greek philosophers like Aristotle formalized these distinctions in the 4th century BCE, arguing that women represented a developmental deficiency in human form, with matter dominated by the male principle of form; consequently, females lacked full deliberative capacity and were naturally suited to subordination under male authority.^[33]^[34] In the Judeo-Christian tradition, Genesis 1:27 (circa 6th-5th century BCE compilation) delineates humanity as created male and female in God's image, with subsequent texts like Ephesians 5:22-33 (1st century CE) prescribing wifely submission to husbands as analogous to the church's relation to Christ, underscoring male headship rooted in creation order and protective responsibility.^[35]^[36] Eastern traditions echoed this binary complementarity. Confucian doctrine, codified by thinkers like Confucius (551-479 BCE) and elaborated in texts such as the Book of Rites, enforced "male superior, female subordinate" (nan zun nü bei) hierarchies, confining women to virtues of chastity, obedience, and household diligence to preserve patrilineal order.^[37]^[38] In Hinduism, Vedic texts from around 1500-500 BCE outlined dharma for women as devoted spousal support and progeny-bearing, with epics like the Mahabharata portraying ideal femininity in protective domesticity, though divine feminine archetypes like Shakti affirmed women's spiritual potency within sex-specific bounds.^[39]^[40] These perspectives uniformly rejected fluid or self-determined gender identities, viewing them as antithetical to natural teleology and cosmic balance.

20th-Century Feminist and Psychological Shifts

In the early 20th century, first-wave feminism primarily targeted legal barriers to women's participation, such as suffrage, achieved in the United States via the 19th Amendment in 1920, while largely accepting traditional gender dimorphism in roles.^[41] However, post-World War II developments spurred a second wave that interrogated gender as a product of socialization rather than biology. Simone de Beauvoir's The Second Sex (1949) posited that "one is not born, but rather becomes, a woman," framing femininity as an imposed construct perpetuated by patriarchal structures, which profoundly shaped subsequent debates by prioritizing existential and social factors over innate traits.^[42] ^[43] This perspective gained traction amid broader cultural critiques, including Betty Friedan's The Feminine Mystique (1963), which highlighted the psychological dissatisfaction of middle-class housewives, attributing it to restrictive norms rather than biological predispositions, though empirical studies later indicated persistent sex-based variances in occupational preferences.^[44] Parallel shifts occurred in psychology, where early 20th-century Freudian theories emphasized innate psychosexual stages and concepts like penis envy to explain gender development, often reinforcing biological determinism.^[45] By the mid-century, however, environmentalist models predominated. Psychologist John Money, in 1955, differentiated "gender role" from biological sex, arguing through intersex case studies that gender identity forms via early rearing and socialization, independent of chromosomes or anatomy, a view that influenced clinical practices like neonatal surgeries for ambiguous genitalia.^[46] ^[47] This framework, echoed in social learning theories from the 1960s onward, suggested behaviors were acquired through observation and reinforcement, diminishing emphasis on genetic or hormonal causalities despite mounting evidence from twin studies showing heritability in traits like aggression and spatial ability.^[48] ^[44] These feminist and psychological reconceptualizations converged in the late 1960s and 1970s, fostering a paradigm where gender disparities were ascribed to nurture over nature, informing policies on education and family. Yet, Money's theories faced empirical refutation, as seen in the 1965 David Reimer case, where a biologically male child reassigned female after a botched circumcision exhibited distress and eventual reversion, underscoring limits to malleability.^[49] Feminist psychology further critiqued prior models for bias, advocating research paradigms that highlighted socialization's role, though reviews of behavioral journals through the century revealed consistent, non-trivial sex differences in traits like verbal fluency and mechanical interest, challenging purely constructivist accounts.^[50] ^[51] This era's shifts, while advancing scrutiny of norms, often downplayed biological substrates, a tendency attributable in part to ideological priorities in academic institutions.^[52]

Late 20th- to 21st-Century Postmodern Influences

In the late 20th century, postmodern philosophy reshaped gender debates by emphasizing the constructed nature of categories like sex and gender, drawing from critiques of structuralism and Enlightenment rationality. Michel Foucault's The History of Sexuality (Volume 1 published in 1976) argued that modern discourses on sexuality function as mechanisms of power, producing identities through normalization rather than reflecting innate truths, thereby framing gender norms as products of historical and institutional forces rather than biological imperatives.^[53] This perspective influenced subsequent theorists by shifting focus from material realities to discursive formations, positing that power relations fabricate the very subjects they regulate.^[54] Judith Butler extended these ideas in Gender Trouble (1990), introducing gender performativity as a theory where gender emerges through iterative, citational practices that cite and reinforce regulatory norms, rather than originating from a prediscursive biological core.^[55] Butler contended that distinctions between sex, gender, and sexuality are not foundational but artificially stabilized fictions sustained by heteronormative regimes, challenging feminist essentialism and advocating subversion through parody or drag to expose their contingency.^[56] This framework, rooted in Foucault's genealogy and Jacques Derrida's deconstruction (as in Of Grammatology, 1967), underpinned queer theory's emergence in the 1990s, which deconstructed binary oppositions and promoted gender as fluid and performative, influencing academic fields like cultural studies and literature.^[57] Extending into the 21st century, these postmodern tenets informed transgender and non-binary identity discourses, evident in Butler's later works like Undoing Gender (2004), which linked recognition of self-identified genders to broader critiques of biopolitical norms.^[58] They contributed to policy shifts, such as self-identification laws in countries like Argentina (2012) and Canada (2017), prioritizing subjective experience over chromosomal or anatomical markers.^[59] However, such approaches have faced scrutiny for sidelining biological evidence, including genetic dimorphism and reproductive anisogamy, which empirical data affirm as causal foundations of sex differences predating cultural overlays.^[60] Critics, including gender-critical feminists, contend that performativity theory abstracts from material constraints, fostering policies that conflate identity with sex-based protections and erode category-specific rights, often amplified in institutionally biased academic environments favoring deconstructive paradigms over reductionist biology.^[61]^[55]

Empirical Evidence of Sex Differences

Psychological and Cognitive Variations

Empirical studies consistently indicate negligible average differences between males and females in general intelligence (g-factor), with effect sizes near zero, though males exhibit greater variability, leading to higher proportions at both extremes of the distribution.^[62] Specific cognitive domains show reliable sex differences: males tend to outperform females in visuospatial tasks, such as mental rotation and spatial navigation, with moderate to large effect sizes (d ≈ 0.5–0.9), while females excel in verbal fluency, episodic memory, and perceptual speed, also with moderate effects (d ≈ 0.2–0.6).^[63] ^[64] These patterns persist across the lifespan, including into advanced age, where sex differences in memory and executive function remain detectable among octogenarians.^[65] In personality traits, meta-analyses of the Big Five model reveal consistent sex differences: females score higher on average in neuroticism (d ≈ 0.4), reflecting greater emotional sensitivity and proneness to anxiety; agreeableness (d ≈ 0.5), indicating higher empathy and compliance; and conscientiousness (d ≈ 0.2), associated with greater orderliness and industriousness.^[66] ^[67] Males, conversely, show advantages in assertiveness and sensation-seeking facets of extraversion, as well as openness to ideas, though overall extraversion differences are smaller.^[66] These traits exhibit moderate heritability and cross-cultural stability, suggesting biological underpinnings beyond socialization alone.^[68] Vocational and leisure interests display pronounced sex differences, with males preferentially orienting toward "things" (e.g., mechanical, abstract systems) and females toward "people" (e.g., social, interpersonal roles), yielding one of the largest observed effect sizes in psychology (d = 0.93).^[69] This dichotomy manifests universally across cultures and predicts occupational choices, such as higher male representation in engineering and higher female in healthcare, and is partly attributable to prenatal androgen exposure influencing brain organization.^[70] ^[71] Psychological variations extend to mental health outcomes, where females experience higher rates of internalizing disorders like depression and anxiety—women are approximately twice as likely to be diagnosed with major depressive disorder—while males predominate in externalizing issues and completed suicides, with global male suicide rates 1.8–4 times higher than females despite comparable or higher female attempt rates.^[72] ^[73] ^[74] These disparities, evident in large-scale epidemiological data, underscore causal factors including biological vulnerabilities (e.g., hormonal influences on mood regulation) and behavioral differences in help-seeking and lethality of methods.^[75]^[76]

Neurological and Physiological Data

Males exhibit approximately 11% greater overall brain volume than females on average, even after adjusting for body size differences.^[77] A 2014 meta-analysis of structural neuroimaging studies identified statistically significant sex differences in 67% of 620 cerebral measures, including larger volumes in male-specific regions such as the amygdala and hypothalamus, and female-specific expansions in areas like the planum temporale.^[78] These structural dimorphisms persist across the lifespan, with prenatal testosterone exposure playing a key role in masculinizing brain regions responsible for spatial processing and aggression-related behaviors.^[27] Functional connectivity patterns also diverge by sex, with males showing stronger inter-network connections facilitating global integration, while females demonstrate more intra-network efficiency linked to verbal and social processing.^[79] Prenatal androgen surges, peaking between weeks 8-24 of gestation, drive sexual differentiation of neural circuits, as evidenced by studies on congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) where elevated fetal testosterone correlates with atypical female-typical brain organization and behaviors like increased rough-and-tumble play.^[80] Postnatally, circulating gonadal hormones modulate synaptic plasticity; for instance, testosterone enhances excitatory neurotransmission in male brains, contributing to observed sex differences in risk-taking and motor skills.^[81] Physiologically, sex dimorphisms manifest in gonadal hormone profiles that underpin neurological outcomes, with males maintaining higher lifetime testosterone levels (averaging 300-1000 ng/dL versus 15-70 ng/dL in females), influencing muscle mass, bone density, and cardiovascular responses that indirectly affect brain perfusion and resilience.^[82] These hormonal gradients, originating from XX/XY chromosomal differences, yield measurable physiological variances such as 40-50% greater male upper-body strength and higher male red blood cell counts, which support evolutionary adaptations in energy allocation and neural demands.^[78] Single-cell transcriptomic analyses confirm sex-biased gene expression in prenatal brains, with thousands of differentially expressed genes tied to both hormonal and chromosomal factors, underscoring causal mechanisms beyond environmental influences alone.^[83]

Evolutionary and Genetic Underpinnings

Sex determination in humans is genetically governed by the XX/XY chromosomal system, where the SRY gene on the Y chromosome triggers the differentiation of bipotential gonads into testes around the seventh week of embryonic development, leading to testosterone production and male phenotypic traits.^[24] This binary mechanism establishes foundational dimorphism, with subsequent genetic effects influencing brain organization and behavioral tendencies; for instance, genome-wide analyses reveal sex-biased gene expression in over 6,500 human genes, contributing to differences in neural pathways associated with aggression, spatial cognition, and mating behaviors.^[24] Twin studies further demonstrate moderate to high heritability for sex-differentiated traits, such as childhood play preferences (e.g., boys' preference for rough-and-tumble play, h² ≈ 0.5-0.8) and adult personality dimensions like empathy and systemizing, independent of shared environment.^[24] Evolutionary frameworks attribute these patterns to sexual selection and anisogamy, where the asymmetric costs of gamete production—ova being far larger and more resource-intensive than sperm—imposed greater obligatory parental investment on females, favoring male strategies of mate competition and quantity over quality, and female selectivity for provisioning partners.^[84] This dynamic, rooted in Darwinian principles and elaborated by Bateman's experiments on fruit flies showing higher variance in male reproductive success, manifests in human sexual dimorphism, including men's 10-15% greater average height and upper-body strength, adaptations linked to intra-sexual contest competition. Cross-cultural data from 37 societies confirm universal sex differences in mate preferences, with women prioritizing cues to resource acquisition (e.g., financial prospects rated 1.5-2 standard deviations higher by females) and men emphasizing reproductive value indicators like youth and physical attractiveness, patterns persisting even in resource-equalized or matrilineal cultures.^[85] Prenatal hormones, particularly androgens, mediate genetic instructions into dimorphic neural development, with higher testosterone exposure in utero correlating with masculinized traits such as enhanced spatial abilities and reduced verbal fluency in both sexes, as proxied by the 2D:4D digit ratio (a biomarker of fetal androgen levels).^[86] Studies of individuals with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH), who experience elevated prenatal androgens regardless of genetic sex, show females exhibiting increased male-typical behaviors, including toy preferences and rough play, underscoring organizational effects over activational ones post-puberty.^[86] Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) reveal sex-specific genetic architectures for behavioral traits, with polygenic scores explaining up to 10-25% of variance in sex-differentiated outcomes like risk-taking and educational attainment, where male polygenic influences amplify extremes in variance.^[87] These findings counter purely socialization-based explanations by highlighting causal pathways from genotype to phenotype via evolutionary pressures, though environmental interactions modulate expression.^[78]

Core Debates

Distinction Between Sex and Gender Identity

Biological sex in humans is defined by the type of gametes an organism is organized to produce: males produce small gametes (sperm), while females produce large gametes (ova or eggs).^[88] This dimorphic classification arises from anisogamy, the evolutionary divergence in gamete size for reproduction, resulting in a binary structure across sexually reproducing species, including humans, with no third gamete type observed.^[89] ^[90] Disorders of sexual development (DSDs), such as intersex conditions, represent developmental anomalies or variations within the binary sexes rather than intermediate or additional categories, as affected individuals are still organized around either male or female reproductive pathways, albeit imperfectly.^[1] ^[91] Gender identity, by contrast, refers to an individual's subjective, internal sense of being male, female, or something else, which may or may not align with their biological sex.^[92] This concept, formalized in psychological and medical literature since the mid-20th century, posits gender as influenced by social, cultural, and potentially neurobiological factors, distinct from the immutable biological markers of sex.^[93] ^[94] Proponents of the distinction argue it accounts for cases of gender dysphoria, where an incongruence between sex and identity leads to distress, estimated to affect approximately 0.005% to 0.014% of natal males and 0.002% to 0.003% of natal females in clinical referral rates, though self-reported transgender identification has risen to around 0.6% in recent U.S. surveys among adults.^[92] However, empirical support for gender identity as an innate, sex-independent trait remains contested, with studies showing high comorbidity with autism spectrum disorders (up to 20% overlap in some youth clinics), mental health issues, and social influences, suggesting environmental and psychological factors may contribute significantly beyond biological causation.^[95] The proposed separation between objective sex and subjective gender identity underpins much of contemporary gender debate, yet critics from biology and philosophy contend it conflates verifiable reproductive dimorphism with unmeasurable self-perception, potentially undermining sex-based categories in law, medicine, and sports.^[1] ^[95] Longitudinal data indicate that most childhood gender nonconformity desists by adolescence, with over 80% of referred youth aligning with their natal sex by adulthood, challenging claims of fixed, cross-sex identities emerging early.^[96] Neuroimaging studies purporting "brain sex" mismatches have failed replication or shown overlaps too broad to diagnostically distinguish transgender individuals from cisgender controls, highlighting the distinction's reliance on self-report over causal mechanisms.^[95] While institutions like the American Psychological Association endorse the framework, methodological critiques note selection biases in samples and conflation of correlation with causation, underscoring the need for rigorous, pre-treatment controls in research.^[93] ^[95]

Transgender Phenomena and Dysphoria

Transgender phenomena encompass experiences in which individuals persistently identify with a gender different from their biological sex, often leading to gender dysphoria, defined in the DSM-5 as clinically significant distress or impairment resulting from this incongruence.^[97] Gender dysphoria typically manifests as discomfort with one's primary or secondary sex characteristics, desires for opposite-sex traits, or conviction of having been born in the wrong body.^[97] These experiences have been documented across cultures and eras, though modern clinical recognition surged in the late 20th century with formalized diagnoses like gender identity disorder, later revised to gender dysphoria to emphasize distress over identity alone.^[97] Prevalence estimates for gender dysphoria vary widely due to methodological differences, with childhood rates historically around 0.005-0.014% for boys and 0.002-0.003% for girls based on clinical referrals, but self-reported adult rates reaching 0.6-1.7% in some surveys.^[98] Recorded diagnoses in children and youth increased substantially from 2011 to 2021, particularly among adolescent females, with UK data showing a 4,000-fold rise in referrals to gender clinics dominated by natal females over recent decades.^[99] This temporal shift raises questions about potential social influences, as traditional patterns favored natal males, though empirical data on causation remain inconclusive.^[99] The etiology of gender dysphoria involves a complex interplay of biological, psychological, and social factors, with no single cause identified.^[97] Twin studies indicate moderate heritability, with estimates ranging from 11% to 62% depending on age and sex, suggesting genetic influences but low concordance rates even in monozygotic pairs, implying significant non-shared environmental roles.^[100] Prenatal hormonal exposures and neurodevelopmental differences have been hypothesized, yet evidence is inconsistent, with brain imaging studies failing to show reliable "female-typical" patterns in trans-identifying males or vice versa.^[101] Comorbidities complicate attribution: up to 70-80% of individuals with gender dysphoria exhibit co-occurring psychiatric conditions like depression, anxiety, or autism spectrum disorder (ASD), with ASD prevalence in gender clinic samples 3-6 times higher than in the general population.^[102]^[103] These overlaps suggest possible misattribution of distress sources, as untreated mental health issues often precede dysphoria onset.^[104] Debates center on whether dysphoria primarily reflects innate cross-sex identity or secondary responses to trauma, autism-related social challenges, or peer influences, particularly in the "rapid-onset gender dysphoria" subtype observed in adolescent clusters.^[105] Longitudinal data indicate high desistance rates (60-90%) in pre-pubertal children with dysphoria if not medically transitioned, though adult persistence is higher post-puberty.^[106] Treatment outcomes are contentious: the 2024 Cass Review, commissioned by the UK's NHS, found "remarkably weak" evidence for puberty blockers and hormones alleviating dysphoria long-term, citing low-quality studies, risks like bone density loss, and unknown fertility impacts, leading to restrictions on youth interventions outside trials.^[5] Detransition rates, where individuals revert to natal sex identification, are understudied but range from 1-13% in available cohorts, often linked to unresolved comorbidities or regret over irreversible changes, with loss to follow-up inflating underreporting.^[107]^[108] Empirical scrutiny underscores the need for comprehensive psychological evaluation before affirmation, as social transition may entrench dysphoria without addressing root causes.^[109]

Gender Roles, Norms, and Equality Claims

Gender roles denote the socially expected behaviors, responsibilities, and attributes associated with biological males and females, often manifesting as men in provider and protector functions and women in nurturing and domestic roles across hunter-gatherer and agrarian societies. These patterns appear in anthropological records from diverse cultures, including the division of labor in foraging groups where males hunted large game and females gathered and cared for offspring, supported by ethnographic data from over 170 societies showing near-universal sex specialization in subsistence tasks. Equality claims in gender debates frequently assert that such roles are arbitrary social constructs, detachable from biology, and that achieving substantive equality necessitates their deconstruction to enable identical participation across domains like workforce distribution and family structures.^[110] Empirical evidence, however, indicates persistent biological underpinnings influencing role preferences, challenging blanket equality assertions that presume interchangeability. Meta-analyses of vocational interests reveal large sex differences, with males favoring "things-oriented" fields (e.g., mechanics, engineering) and females "people-oriented" ones (e.g., teaching, nursing), yielding an effect size of d = 0.93 across 492,000 participants from 97 studies spanning multiple countries and decades.^[69] These disparities hold independently of socialization, as evidenced by longitudinal studies tracking interests from childhood, where genetic factors account for 30-50% of variance in occupational choices, with prenatal testosterone exposure correlating to male-typical preferences in systemizing tasks.^[111]^[112] The gender-equality paradox further underscores this, observing that in nations with high gender equality indices—like Sweden, Norway, and Finland—occupational and educational segregation by sex intensifies rather than diminishes. For instance, in 2018 data from the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), Scandinavian countries showed the widest gaps in male enrollment in physics and female in reading, despite policies promoting equal access; women comprised 80-90% of health and education graduates but under 20% in engineering.^[113]^[114] This pattern aligns with evolutionary accounts positing adaptive specialization: males evolved risk-taking and spatial skills for hunting/navigation, females empathy and verbal skills for kin care, yielding heritable traits that surface under minimal constraint.^[115]^[32] Personality differences reinforce these tendencies, with meta-analyses of Big Five traits finding females higher in agreeableness (d ≈ 0.5) and neuroticism (d ≈ 0.4), traits linked to relational roles, while males score higher in assertiveness and sensation-seeking, suiting competitive domains; these gaps persist across 50+ cultures and are 20-40% heritable.^[116]^[117] Critics of equality claims argue that overlooking such averages—focusing instead on outliers or variance equality—promotes outcome-based metrics that misattribute voluntary choices to oppression, as seen in Nordic labor markets where women opt for part-time work at rates 3-5 times higher than men post-parenthood, correlating with family priorities over career maximization.^[118]^[119] Policies enforcing role parity, such as gender quotas, have yielded mixed results, with Norway's 2003 board quotas increasing female representation to 40% but reducing firm performance by 2-3% in return on assets due to mismatched expertise pools.^[118] Norms enforcing traditional roles, while culturally variable, often reflect these empirical realities rather than pure imposition, as deviations incur fitness costs in ancestral environments; modern claims equating norms with inequality ignore how sex-dimorphic traits yield complementary rather than competitive outcomes in pair-bonding and reproduction. For example, cross-national surveys show women prioritizing partner resources (earning potential) at twice the rate of men, who emphasize physical attractiveness, patterns stable since David Buss's 37-culture study in 1989 and replicated in 2020s data.^[115] Equality advocates' emphasis on sameness, per some analyses, risks eroding these complementarities, contributing to fertility declines below replacement in high-equality states (e.g., Sweden's 1.7 births per woman in 2023).^[120] Thus, truth-seeking approaches prioritize opportunity equality acknowledging average differences over enforced uniformity.^[110]

Controversies and Criticisms

Fairness in Sports and Single-Sex Categories

Biological males typically outperform biological females in athletic events reliant on speed, strength, power, and endurance by 10-30%, attributable to higher testosterone levels driving greater muscle mass, bone density, hemoglobin concentration, and skeletal structure differences that emerge post-puberty.^[121]^[122]^[123] These disparities underpin the establishment of single-sex categories in competitive sports since the early 20th century, aimed at ensuring equitable competition and opportunities for females, as male advantages persist across elite, recreational, and youth levels, with even high-school boys often surpassing world-class female records.^[124]^[125] Transgender women—biological males who transition after puberty—retain significant performance advantages over biological females even after 1-3 years of gender-affirming hormone therapy (GAHT), including testosterone suppression.^[126]^[127] Studies indicate that prior to GAHT, transgender women exhibit 15-31% superior performance in push-ups, sit-ups, and endurance runs compared to female peers; post-GAHT, advantages diminish but persist at 9-12% in strength and speed metrics, with incomplete reversal of male-typical physiological traits like larger hearts, lungs, and VO2 max capacity.^[128]^[129]^[4] This retention challenges the fairness of allowing transgender women in female categories, as empirical data contradicts claims of full equalization through hormone therapy alone, with some analyses estimating lifelong edges of 10% or more in power-based sports.^[130]^[131] High-profile cases illustrate these disparities. In 2022, Lia Thomas, a transgender woman and former collegiate male swimmer ranked 462nd nationally in men's events, won the NCAA Division I women's 500-yard freestyle title after transitioning and competing in the female category, outperforming biological female competitors by margins reflecting retained male advantages.^[132] In response to ensuing controversies over fairness, the University of Pennsylvania vacated and modified Thomas's records in July 2025, aligning with updated eligibility rules barring transgender women from women's events.^[133] Such outcomes have fueled debates, with critics arguing that transgender inclusion displaces biological females from podiums, scholarships, and records, undermining the purpose of sex-segregated sports.^[134] Sports governing bodies have increasingly prioritized fairness by restricting transgender women from female categories. World Athletics implemented regulations in March 2023 prohibiting athletes who experienced male puberty from competing in women's events, citing irremediable biological advantages post-testosterone exposure.^[135] Similar bans followed from World Rugby (2020), International Cycling Union, and in 2025, the U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Committee, which excluded transgender women from women's Olympic-eligible competitions to protect female integrity.^[136]^[137] The International Olympic Committee's 2021 Framework on Fairness, Inclusion, and Non-Discrimination deferred to sport-specific evidence, rejecting blanket testosterone thresholds in favor of data-driven policies that avoid presuming against inclusion without proof of harm—yet subsequent research has prompted stricter measures in multiple disciplines.^[138]^[139] In contact and combat sports, safety risks compound fairness issues, with reports of injuries to biological females from transgender opponents' greater force generation. Incidents include a 2023 field hockey match where a transgender player fractured a female opponent's skull and nose, and multiple volleyball cases of concussions and dislocations inflicted by transgender women, leading to team forfeits.^[140]^[141] While some reviews claim insufficient systematic evidence of elevated risk, biomechanical analyses and case documentation indicate transgender women's preserved strength (e.g., higher handgrip and punch force) elevates injury potential in high-impact scenarios, prompting bans in rugby, boxing, and similar sports.^[142]^[143] Proponents of open categories cite inclusion, but causal evidence from physiology favors sex-based segregation to mitigate both competitive inequity and physical harm, with alternatives like open or third categories proposed to accommodate transgender athletes without compromising female protections.^[144]^[145]

Impacts on Women and Children

In women's sports, transgender women who have undergone male puberty retain significant physical advantages over biological females, even after hormone therapy. A 2021 study found that after 12 months of testosterone suppression, transgender women remained 48% stronger in push-ups and had 35% larger quadriceps muscle mass compared to cisgender women.^[146] Similarly, a review of biomechanical data indicated that transgender women maintain superior strength, speed, and power outputs, with advantages persisting beyond two years of suppression in metrics like running and throwing.^[147] These disparities have led to displaced opportunities for female athletes, as seen in cases like swimmer Lia Thomas, who won NCAA titles in 2022 after competing as a male previously, prompting policy reversals by organizations such as World Athletics in 2023 to exclude transgender women from elite female categories. Policies allowing self-identification into women's single-sex spaces have compromised female safety and privacy. In UK prisons, the 2018 case of Karen White, a transgender woman with prior convictions for sexual offenses against women, assaulted four female inmates after transfer to a women's facility, highlighting risks under earlier self-ID guidance.^[148] Similar incidents occurred in the US, including a 2020 rape allegation by a biological female inmate against a transgender inmate at Logan Correctional Center in Illinois, and a 2024 lawsuit at Rikers Island where a man posing as transgender raped a female prisoner.^[149]^[150] In response, Scotland revised policies in 2023 to house transgender women convicted of violence against women in male facilities, acknowledging heightened victimization risks for female prisoners.^[151] Proposed self-ID reforms in Scotland, blocked by the UK government in 2023, raised concerns that they would erode sex-based protections in shelters and refuges, potentially increasing male access without safeguards.^[152] For children, the rise in youth gender dysphoria referrals, particularly among adolescent girls, correlates with social influences rather than innate identity in many cases. Lisa Littman's 2018 study on rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD), based on parental reports, identified clusters of sudden onset linked to peer groups and online communities, with a 2023 follow-up analysis of 1,655 cases supporting social contagion patterns, especially in females without childhood dysphoria.^[153] Critics, often from pro-affirmation circles, challenged the methodology for relying on skeptical parents, but subsequent data from UK clinics showed a 4,000% increase in female referrals from 2009 to 2018, aligning with ROGD timelines.^[154] Medical interventions for minors carry uncertain benefits and documented risks, with evidence deemed low-quality by independent reviews. The 2024 Cass Review, commissioned by England's NHS, concluded that studies on puberty blockers and hormones for gender dysphoria lack rigor, showing no clear improvements in mental health and potential harms like bone density loss and fertility issues; it prompted a 2024 ban on routine blocker prescriptions for under-18s.^[109]^[155] Detransition rates remain underreported due to poor long-term follow-up, but a 2021 US survey found 13.1% of gender-diverse individuals had detransitioned, often citing resolution of dysphoria without medical needs or external pressures like family expectations.^[108] Claims of near-zero regret overlook high desistance rates in pre-pubertal cohorts (up to 80-90% without intervention) and emerging adult regret patterns amid rising youth caseloads.^[107] These trends suggest over-medicalization driven by ideological affirmation over exploratory therapy, exacerbating lifelong consequences for children.

Cultural and Ideological Critiques

Gender ideology has been critiqued for subordinating biological sex—a verifiable dimorphism observed in over 99.98% of humans through chromosomes, gametes, and reproductive anatomy—to subjective self-identification, thereby eroding objective categories essential for social organization. Critics argue this shift prioritizes ideological assertions over empirical reality, leading to policy changes that redefine sex-based protections without evidence of improved outcomes for those claiming transgender identities. For instance, the doctrine that "trans women are women" based on internal feelings ignores measurable sex differences in strength, bone density, and disease susceptibility, which persist post-hormone treatments.^[156]^[157] Ideologically, gender theory traces to postmodern influences, including queer theory's deconstruction of fixed identities as oppressive constructs, reframing sex and gender as fluid spectra to challenge heteronormativity. James Lindsay contends this constitutes "gender Marxism," an extension of cultural hegemony critiques where traditional sex roles are recast as power imbalances akin to class oppression, aiming to dismantle binary norms through institutional activism rather than evidence-based reform. This parallels historical Marxist adaptations, substituting identity categories for economic ones, yet lacks causal mechanisms explaining dysphoria beyond social influences or comorbidities like autism, which affect up to 20-30% of youth referrals in some clinics. Mainstream academic endorsement of these ideas often reflects institutional pressures, with dissenters facing professional repercussions, as documented in cases of canceled researchers since 2018.^[158]^[159] From a cultural standpoint, gender-critical feminists, such as those aligned with second-wave principles, argue the ideology undermines women's hard-won sex-based rights by allowing male-bodied individuals access to female spaces, citing incidents of voyeurism or assault in prisons and shelters post-self-ID policies, as in Canada's 2017-2021 prison transfers where 40% involved sex offenders. Helen Joyce describes this as "institutional capture," where corporations and governments adopt affirming language to signal virtue, suppressing debate and fostering a climate where questioning transitions invites accusations of bigotry, evidenced by the UK's 2020 Cass Review interim findings of weak evidence for youth interventions amid rising referrals from 1,500 in 2009 to 5,000 by 2018. These critiques emphasize that affirming unverified identities culturally normalizes detachment from biology, potentially amplifying social contagion in adolescents, with detransitioner testimonies rising 4,000% in online forums from 2015-2020.^[160]^[161]^[162] Broader ideological opposition highlights how gender ideology intersects with neoliberal individualism, commodifying identity through medical markets projected to reach $1.6 billion annually by 2026, while sidelining family structures; data from Sweden's long-term studies show regret rates up to 10% for surgeries, with suicide risks persisting post-transition at 19 times the general population rate. Critics like Joyce attribute this persistence to unresolved underlying issues rather than mismatched bodies, urging a return to causal realism over affirmation. Such views, though marginalized in left-leaning institutions, draw on first-principles recognition of sex as a material prerequisite for reproduction and safety, warning of societal costs including blurred parental roles and increased youth mental health crises, with U.S. teen female depression doubling from 2010-2020 alongside gender clinic expansions.^[163]^[157]

Recent Developments and Policy

Legal Battles and Legislation (2020-2025)

In the United States, the Supreme Court's 2020 decision in Bostock v. Clayton County extended Title VII protections against employment discrimination to include transgender individuals, interpreting "sex" discrimination to encompass actions based on gender identity incongruence with biological sex. This ruling, limited to workplace contexts, prompted subsequent legislative pushback in states concerned with broader implications for sex-based rights, leading to over 500 bills introduced by 2025 targeting transgender policies in education, healthcare, and sports.^[164] By mid-2025, 27 states had enacted laws restricting gender-affirming medical interventions for minors, including bans on puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones, citing insufficient long-term evidence of benefits and risks of irreversibility.^[165] A pivotal 2025 Supreme Court case, United States v. Skrmetti, upheld Tennessee's 2023 ban on puberty blockers, hormone therapy, and surgeries for transgender minors under the 14th Amendment, rejecting equal protection challenges and affirming states' authority to regulate experimental treatments lacking robust pediatric consensus.^[166] The 6-3 decision emphasized that such care does not equate to discrimination based on sex or transgender status, distinguishing it from Bostock's employment scope and noting Tennessee's evidence-based rationale tied to developmental harms.^[167] Federal responses intensified under the second Trump administration, with Executive Order 14168 on January 20, 2025, mandating recognition of only biological male and female sexes in federal policy, prohibiting funding for youth transitions, and directing agencies to prioritize sex-based distinctions in prisons, sports, and bathrooms.^[168] A follow-up order on January 28 banned federal support for chemical or surgical interventions on children, framing them as mutilation unsupported by causal evidence of improved outcomes.^[169] In sports, state laws in at least 24 jurisdictions by 2025 barred males identifying as female from female categories, driven by fairness concerns over physiological advantages like muscle mass and bone density persisting post-puberty.^[170] The Supreme Court granted certiorari in July 2025 for Little v. Hecox and a West Virginia case, challenging bans under Title IX and equal protection as discriminatory, with arguments scheduled for the 2025-26 term; lower courts had mixed rulings, some upholding bans where plaintiffs failed to show irreparable harm.^[171]^[172] Separately, a Texas federal court in May 2025 vacated EEOC guidance extending harassment protections to gender identity, citing overreach beyond statutory text and procedural flaws.^[173] In the United Kingdom, the Supreme Court's April 16, 2025, ruling in For Women Scotland Ltd v. Scottish Ministers clarified that "sex" and "woman" under the Equality Act 2010 denote biological criteria, unaltered by a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC), thereby preserving single-sex spaces and services for natal females despite self-identification claims.^[174]^[175] This decision rejected expansive interpretations favoring gender identity, affirming Parliament's intent to protect sex-based rights amid evidence of risks like voyeurism in women's facilities. Efforts to reform the Gender Recognition Act 2004 for easier self-ID stalled, with a May 2025 petition for diagnosis-free changes garnering insufficient support and highlighting evidential gaps in transition efficacy.^[176] An October 2025 High Court case, W v. Gender Recognition Panel, further defined "mother" as the biological female parent, excluding post-transition individuals regardless of GRC.^[177] European trends mirrored restrictions, with countries like Sweden and Finland curtailing youth transitions by 2022-2024 based on systematic reviews deeming evidence low-quality and risks high, influencing UK Cass Review implementation that paused puberty blockers outside trials.^[178] These developments reflected growing judicial and legislative emphasis on biological immutability and empirical scrutiny over ideological assertions, though advocacy groups challenged them as rights erosions without addressing causal data on dysphoria persistence or desistance rates exceeding 80% pre-puberty in untreated cases.^[179]

Global and Institutional Responses

In response to growing concerns over the evidence base for youth gender transitions, several European health authorities have restricted access to puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones for minors. Finland's Council for Choices in Health Care in 2020 recommended non-medical interventions as first-line treatment for gender-dysphoric youth, citing insufficient evidence of benefits outweighing risks..pdf) Sweden's National Board of Health and Welfare in 2022 similarly curtailed hormonal interventions to research settings only, following systematic reviews finding low-quality evidence and potential harms like infertility and bone density loss. Norway's Healthcare Investigation Board in 2023 endorsed restrictions, emphasizing psychotherapy over medicalization absent robust long-term data. Denmark followed in 2023, halting routine puberty suppression for those under 18 outside trials, based on assessments of uncertain efficacy and risks. By late 2024, Italy's National Bioethics Committee advised psychotherapy as primary treatment and limited blockers to controlled studies, aligning with empirical critiques of affirmative models. The United Kingdom's 2024 Cass Review, an independent appraisal of gender services for youth, concluded that the evidence for medical interventions was "remarkably weak," prompting NHS England to ban routine puberty blockers outside clinical trials and make the restriction indefinite in December 2024 on expert advice.^[109]^[155] These shifts reflect a pattern in Europe where systematic evidence reviews prioritized causal risks—such as desistance rates in untreated dysphoria and iatrogenic effects—over ideological affirmation, contrasting with earlier uncritical adoption of protocols from bodies like WPATH, which have faced scrutiny for lacking rigorous trials.^[180] The World Health Organization (WHO) has maintained a framework supportive of gender-affirming approaches, reclassifying gender incongruence in ICD-11 (effective 2022) as a sexual health condition rather than a mental disorder to reduce stigma, while endorsing access to interventions like hormones for those meeting criteria.^[181] However, WHO's forthcoming guidelines on transgender health, anticipated post-2024 consultations, have drawn criticism for potential overreliance on low-quality studies amid European restrictions, with no explicit endorsement of youth blockers as standard care by 2025.^[182] The United Nations, through entities like UN Women, has framed gender-critical perspectives—emphasizing biological sex distinctions—as part of an "extremist anti-rights movement" undermining LGBTQ+ inclusion, as stated in 2024 reports on backlash against gender equality advances.^[183] UN initiatives continue to integrate gender identity into human rights frameworks, prioritizing self-identification and decriminalization of transitions, though without addressing empirical data on desistance or comorbidities in youth dysphoria prevalent in reviews like Cass.^[184] In the United States, institutional responses remain polarized, with 25 states enacting bans on gender-affirming care for minors by mid-2025, often citing European evidence gaps, while bodies like the American College of Physicians opposed such measures as contrary to patient autonomy.^[178]^[185] Federal actions under the Trump administration in 2025 rescinded prior guidance affirming coverage for such care, restricting it for federal employees and emphasizing biological sex in policy.^[186] Globally, while some NGOs like Human Rights Watch decried restrictions as rights violations, the European trend underscores institutional prioritization of precautionary principles in medicine, driven by meta-analyses showing puberty blockers' off-label use lacked randomized controlled trials demonstrating net benefits for gender dysphoria resolution.^[178]^[187]

References

[1]
In Humans, Sex is Binary and Immutable by Georgi K. Marinov | NAS
The author argues that sex in humans is strictly binary and immutable, and that denying this attacks the foundations of biological sciences.
[2]
Understanding the Sex Binary | City Journal
Mar 20, 2023 · The “sex binary” refers to the biological reality that there are only two sexes—male and female—and that these categories refer to ...Missing: peer | Show results with:peer
[3]
Biology and Management of Male‐Bodied Athletes in Elite Female ...
Feb 27, 2025 · The male physical advantages in sports recognize that, on average, men are taller, stronger, and faster with greater endurance than women.ABSTRACT · Male Physical Advantages in... · Identifying Male-Bodied...<|separator|>
[4]
Strength, power and aerobic capacity of transgender athletes
The primary objective of this cross-sectional study was to compare standard laboratory performance metrics of transgender athletes to cisgender athletes.
[5]
The Final Cass Review and the NHS England Response - SEGM
Apr 11, 2024 · The review recognizes that the evidence base for psychotherapeutic approaches to the management of gender dysphoria in youth is very low quality ...
[6]
Sport and Transgender People: A Systematic Review of the ... - NIH
Transgender men are not thought to possess an athletic advantage, despite being injected with testosterone if they chose to medically transition with cross-sex ...
[7]
Why Male Athletes Who Identify as Transgender Should Not ...
Sep 23, 2022 · Research confirms what common sense knows: males have significant athletic advantages over females. Is it fair for males to compete in women's ...
[8]
Denying biological sex is anthropocentric and promotes species ...
The paper argues biological sex is binary, not a spectrum, and that denying it is based on a lack of knowledge and promotes species chauvinism.Missing: mammals | Show results with:mammals
[9]
Sexual selection drives sex difference in adult life expectancy across ...
Oct 1, 2025 · Like humans, 72% of mammals exhibited a female life expectancy advantage, while 68% of birds showed a male advantage, as expected from the ...Sexual Selection Drives Sex... · Results · Sex Differences In Ale
[10]
Gamete competition, gamete limitation, and the evolution of the two ...
Oct 16, 2014 · Biologically, males are defined as the sex that produces the smaller gametes (e.g. sperm), implying that the male and female sexes only exist ...
[11]
[PDF] There Are Only Two Sexes and There Can Never Be More
Aug 11, 2025 · In biological science, sex is defined by the gamete morph an organism produces: females produce large gametes (eggs/ova); males produce small ...
[12]
8.4 Sex: It's About the Gametes – The Evolution and Biology of Sex
Scientists have created a definition of female that includes all the individuals that produce large gametes (eggs), those that produce small gametes (sperm) ...
[13]
SRY: Sex determination - Genes and Disease - NCBI Bookshelf - NIH
SRY (which stands for sex-determining region Y gene) is found on the Y chromosome. In the cell, it binds to other DNA and in doing so distorts it dramatically ...
[14]
Sry: the master switch in mammalian sex determination | Development
Dec 1, 2010 · SRY, the mammalian Y-chromosomal testis-determining gene, induces male sex determination. Recent studies in mice reveal that the major role of SRY is to ...Introduction · An overview of the mammalian... · Sry expression and its regulation
[15]
A meta-analysis of the association between male dimorphism ... - eLife
Feb 18, 2022 · Humans are sexually dimorphic: men and women differ in body build and composition, craniofacial structure, and voice pitch, likely mediated ...
[16]
Sexual Dimorphism in the Musculoskeletal System: Sex Hormones ...
Sep 1, 2024 · Studies have shown higher muscle mass, cancellous bone mass, and long bone width in males compared with females as well as different traits in ...
[17]
Sexual Dimorphism of Size Ontogeny and Life History - PMC - NIH
Jul 24, 2020 · Results: We found that sexual dimorphism in body size starts at age 1 month, peaks at age 3 months, and diminishes by age 24 months. During ...
[18]
Dump the “dimorphism”: Comprehensive synthesis of human brain ...
Males' brains are larger than females' from birth, stabilizing around 11 % in adults. This size difference accounts for other reproducible findings.
[19]
How common is intersex? a response to Anne Fausto-Sterling
Applying this more precise definition, the true prevalence of intersex is seen to be about 0.018%, almost 100 times lower than Fausto-Sterling s estimate of 1.7 ...
[20]
Differences/Disorder of Sex Development
Prevalence and Course DSD occur in approximately 1 in 4,500-5,500 births, although prevalence rates vary widely depending upon the specific condition. Many DSD ...
[21]
Gender as Biological Fact vs Gender as Social Construction
The first view says that biological sex largely defines gender, the other that society or culture largely defines it. I will call this opposing pair of views ...
[22]
Sex differences in the genetic and environmental influences on the ...
The present study uses a population-based sample of 6.806 adult twins from same-sex and opposite-sex twin pairs to examine sex differences in the underlying ...
[23]
Sex differences in the Big Five model personality traits: A behavior ...
Across several twin studies, research estimates that approximately 40–50% of the variation in the BFM domains is due to genetic variation (meta-analytic ...<|separator|>
[24]
The Genetics of Sex Differences in Brain and Behavior - PMC
This paper reviews the evidence for direct genetic effects in behavioral and brain sex differences. We highlight the `four core genotypes' model and sex ...
[25]
How Early Hormones Shape Gender Development - PMC - NIH
Increasing evidence confirms that prenatal androgens have facilitative effects on male-typed activity interests and engagement (including child toy preferences ...
[26]
Prenatal androgen exposure and sex-typical play behaviour
These meta-analytic findings suggest that prenatal androgen exposure masculinises and defeminises play behaviour in humans.
[27]
Early androgen exposure and human gender development
Feb 26, 2015 · Thus, several lines of evidence converge on the conclusion that prenatal exposure to androgenic hormones increases male-typical play behavior in ...
[28]
Sex Differences in Mate Preferences Across 45 Countries
Mar 20, 2020 · Support for universal sex differences in preferences remains robust: Men, more than women, prefer attractive, young mates, and women, more than men, prefer ...Missing: universality | Show results with:universality
[29]
[PDF] Sex Differences in Mate Preferences Across 45 Countries
universal sex differences in preferences remains robust: Men, more than women, prefer attractive, young mates, and women, more than men, prefer older mates ...Missing: universality | Show results with:universality
[30]
"Why Can't a Man Be More Like a Woman? Sex Differences in Big ...
In our study, females scored higher than males on neuroticism, and to a lesser extent, agreeableness. This aligns with previous findings that ...
[31]
Gender Differences in Personality across the Ten Aspects of the Big ...
This paper investigates gender differences in personality traits, both at the level of the Big Five and at the sublevel of two aspects within each Big Five ...
[32]
Evolved but Not Fixed: A Life History Account of Gender Roles and ...
Jul 23, 2019 · The current account provides novel interpretations of phenomena ranging from sex differences in mate preference, sociosexuality, and sexism to ...
[33]
Aristotle on Woman - Theopolis Institute
Apr 26, 2018 · Aristotle taught that women are defective men, with rational and moral capacities inferior to men. This is evident in generation.
[34]
Aristotle's Account of the Place of Women within the Polis - LSE Blogs
Jan 28, 2022 · Through this natural hierarchy, Aristotle concludes that women are inferior beings who cannot participate in political activity because of their ...
[35]
The Biblical Role of Men and Women - BJU Today
Feb 19, 2019 · The Bible clearly states men and women were created with equal value, standing, blessing and participation in the promises of God to Abraham.The Central Question · ``submission''--1 Peter 3:1... · ``head''--Ephesians 5:23; 1...
[36]
How Are Men and Women Different? - 9Marks
Dec 11, 2019 · The Bible, however, suggests that gender carries with it its own ought-ness. Our actions should correspond to divinely created identity. Our ...Body · Appearance · Character
[37]
gender in Confucian philosophy
Feb 27, 2023 · Men and women in Confucian philosophy are properly “gendered” when they are ritualized to embody a series of familial/social roles; their ...Patrilineage and Gender... · Confucian Feminism: A Hybrid...
[38]
How does Traditional Confucian Culture Influence Adolescents ...
The guiding principle of gender relations in Confucianism is “male as superior and women as subordinate” (nan zun nv bei). Sons are more valued than daughters, ...
[39]
Women's Dharma – Heart Of Hinduism
According to tradition, women, more delicate than men, require and deserve protection. Hindu texts extol the virtues of womanhood and of the essential role ...
[40]
Hinduism 101: Women and Hinduism - Hindu American Foundation
Dec 6, 2017 · Hinduism has always worshipped divinity in female form as Shakti. Women have played prominent roles in Hindu society from ancient time till now.
[41]
Women's Suffrage in the Progressive Era - The Library of Congress
During the late 1800s and early 1900s, women and women's organizations not only worked to gain the right to vote, they also worked for broad-based economic and ...Missing: 1900-1999 | Show results with:1900-1999
[42]
The Second Sex | Issue 69 - Philosophy Now
Her book The Second Sex radically challenged political and existential theory, but its most enduring impact is on how women understand themselves, their ...
[43]
One is not born, but becomes a woman | TORCH
Mar 22, 2021 · De Beauvoir argues that historical events have led to women being subjected as weaker by the stronger, a role taken on by men which can be ...
[44]
Gender Development Research in Sex Roles: Historical Trends and ...
The late 1960s through the 1970s marked an important turning point in the field of gender research, including theory and research in gender development.Missing: pre- modern
[45]
Theoretical Perspectives on Gender - Sage Publishing
In this chapter we will examine some major psychological theories that have been formulated to explain differences between women and men and how they develop.
[46]
The Birth of Gender: Social Control, Hermaphroditism, and the New ...
This chapter shows that pioneering sexologist John Money coined and developed the terms “gender” and “gender role” in the 1950s and 1960s in the United States.
[47]
John Money, 84; Doctor Pioneered Study of Gender Identity in 1950s
Jul 13, 2006 · Money's theories also challenged taboos of 1950s-era sexuality, establishing the notion of gender roles and gender identity -- terms that ...Missing: impact | Show results with:impact
[48]
https://oxfordre.com/psychology/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780190236557.001.0001/acrefore-9780190236557-e-513
[49]
David Reimer and John Money Gender Reassignment Controversy
Nov 15, 2017 · In the mid-1960s, psychologist John Money encouraged the gender reassignment of David Reimer, who was born a biological male but suffered ...Missing: 1950s | Show results with:1950s
[50]
Feminism and psychology: Analysis of a half-century of research on ...
Journal; Peer Reviewed Journal. Document Type. Journal Article. Digital Object ... A review of gender comparisons in three behavioral journals through the 20th ...
[51]
The Evolution of Gender Psychology: Tracing the Discipline's Growth
Feb 21, 2024 · The psychology of gender has evolved significantly over the years, reflecting a fascinating journey through historical biases, academic struggles, feminist ...
[52]
Gender Studies: Foundations and Key Concepts - JSTOR Daily
Nov 29, 2018 · We publish articles grounded in peer-reviewed research and provide free access to that research for all of our readers. About JSTOR Daily ...Missing: 20th | Show results with:20th
[53]
Playing with Butler and Foucault: Bisexuality and Queer Theory
Nov 25, 2009 · This article will take on two of queer theories most cited works, Foucault's The History of Sexuality (1978) and Butler's Gender Trouble (1990/2006).
[54]
[PDF] Michel Foucault and Judith Butler - WRAP: Warwick
One of the main influences on Judith Butler's thinking has been the work of. Michel Foucault. Although this relationship is often commented on, it is rarely.
[55]
Postmodern Feminism Theory in Sociology - Simply Psychology
Feb 13, 2024 · Judith Butler is an American philosopher and gender theorist whose work has been extremely influential within the field of postmodern feminism.
[56]
Gender Performativity | LGBTQ+ Studies: An Open Textbook
Judith Butler's Gender Trouble, originally published in 1990, introduces the term performativity to suggest gender identity is not natural.
[57]
Postmodern Queer Theory - (Intro to Comparative Literature) | Fiveable
Judith Butler's work has been instrumental in shaping postmodern queer theory, particularly her concept of gender performativity, which posits that gender is ...
[58]
[PDF] Butler, Subjectivity, Sex/Gender, and a Postmodern Theory of ... - MIT
Apr 2, 2002 · In The Psychic Life of Power (1997a), Butler writes about gender not only to deconstruct other modern theories of gender, subjectivity and the ...
[59]
Gender: A Postmodern Idea Developed in Association with ... - MDPI
This review examines the foundations of modern and postmodern thought, then focuses on sex and gender with respect to their history within these modes of ...
[60]
Biological Sex, Gender Criticism and Feminist Criminology
From a gender critical perspective, the argument runs that as biological sex has a material reality and is immutable, individuals' sense of identity cannot (and ...
[61]
The Absurdity of Gender Theory | The Russell Kirk Center
Jan 19, 2015 · Gender theory follows the modern ideal: society is supposed to consist of self-sufficient subjects, without any engagement or mutual attachment.<|separator|>
[62]
Sex/gender differences in general cognitive abilities - NIH
May 15, 2024 · Research has shown that differences between males and females are not in general intelligence, but only in some specific factors and tasks.Missing: 2020-2025 | Show results with:2020-2025
[63]
Sex/gender differences in cognitive abilities - ScienceDirect.com
Women tend to display higher verbal abilities, including verbal memory, whereas men exhibit higher spatial and arithmetical skills8–10; a similar pattern has ...
[64]
Effect of gender differences on cognitive ability | Research Starters
Women generally excel in verbal skills, while men often perform better on spatial tasks. These differences are often minimal and can vary based on context.Introduction · Educational Settings · Testing Differences
[65]
Sex differences in cognitive performance persist into your 80s
Mar 17, 2025 · Our study confirms enduring sex differences in memory and executive function, even among individuals aged 80 and above.
[66]
Why Can't a Man Be More Like a Woman? Sex Differences in Big ...
Women generally report higher levels of neuroticism, extraversion, agreeableness, and conscientiousness than men. Men are more assertive and risk-taking, while ...
[67]
(PDF) Sex Differences in the Big Five: A View Through the Lens of ...
Aug 13, 2025 · Sex differences in personality traits within the Big Five model are consistently reproduced across. studies conducted in different cultures.
[68]
[PDF] Sex differences in the Big Five model personality traits - MIDUS
Mar 22, 2018 · In a recent meta- analysis, Vukasovic and Bratko (2015) concluded that gender was not a significant moderator of the heritability of personality ...
[69]
(PDF) Men and Things, Women and People: A Meta-Analysis of Sex ...
Results showed that men prefer working with things and women prefer working with people, producing a large effect size (d = 0.93) on the Things–People dimension ...
[70]
Gendered Occupational Interests: Prenatal Androgen Effects on ...
The results support the hypothesis that sex differences in occupational interests are due, in part, to prenatal androgen influences on differential orientation ...
[71]
Sex Differences in Adolescents' Occupational Desires Are Universal
Jan 31, 2022 · In every country (without exception), more girls than boys aspired to a people-oriented occupation, and more boys than girls aspired to a things-oriented or ...Missing: orientation | Show results with:orientation
[72]
Men and women: statistics | Mental Health Foundation
Today, women are three times more likely than men to experience common mental health problems. · Rates of self-harm among young women have tripled since 1993 ...
[73]
Gender differences in the predictive effect of depression and ...
Apr 14, 2023 · Global prevalence estimates show that the suicide rate among men is 1.8 times higher than among women. Moreover, the rate in developed ...
[74]
Differences in Suicide Among Men and Women - Verywell Mind
Nov 12, 2024 · Suicide statistics reveal that women are roughly three times more likely to attempt suicide, 3 though, as of 2022, men are four times more likely to die by ...Suicide Attempts & Risk of Death · Suicide Methods · Prior Suicide Attempts
[75]
Men Are More Likely to Die by Suicide, but Less Likely To Have ...
Nov 17, 2022 · In 2020, the suicide rate among men was four times higher than the rate among women. Another way of looking at this is that men make up 49% of ...
[76]
Gender differences in mental health | Research Starters - EBSCO
Almost four times as many men as women die by suicide, even though women attempt suicide at about three times the rate at which men do. Most successful ...<|separator|>
[77]
Neuroscience and Sex/Gender: Looking Back and Forward
Jan 2, 2020 · Perhaps the most obvious sex difference in the human brain involves its size. Men's brains are ∼11% larger, on average, than women's brains ( ...<|separator|>
[78]
Sex differences in the human brain: a roadmap for more careful ...
Jul 26, 2022 · We review observations that motivate research on sex differences in human neuroanatomy, including potential causes (evolutionary, genetic, and environmental) ...
[79]
Sex differences and age-related changes of large-scale brain ...
Jul 6, 2025 · The study explores how age and sex influence large-scale brain functional connectivity (FC). It finds that males typically exhibit stronger inter-network ...<|separator|>
[80]
Sexual differentiation of the human brain: Relation to gender identity ...
▻ Testosterone in the fetal stage determines sexual differentiation of the human brain. ▻ The degree of genital masculinization does not necessarily ...
[81]
His and Hers: Sex Differences in the Brain - PMC - NIH
Jan 1, 2021 · The group that studied males found that estrogens strengthen excitatory synapses by increasing neurotransmitter sensitivity, whereas our group ...
[82]
A meta-analysis of sex differences in human brain structure - PMC
This is the first meta-analysis of sex differences in the typical human brain. Regional sex differences overlap with areas implicated in psychiatric conditions.
[83]
Article Early establishment and life course stability of sex biases in ...
Jul 9, 2025 · We find an abundance of sex differences in expression (sex-DEs) in the prenatal brain, driven by both hormonal and sex-chromosomal factors.
[84]
Understanding the evolution of ecological sex differences
Sex differences in selection arise for at least two possible reasons: (1) differences originating from anisogamy—the Darwin-Bateman paradigm—and (2) competition ...Missing: peer- | Show results with:peer-
[85]
Sex differences in human mate preferences: Evolutionary ...
Feb 4, 2010 · Sex differences in human mate preferences: Evolutionary hypotheses tested in 37 cultures - Volume 12 Issue 1.<|separator|>
[86]
The effects of prenatal sex steroid hormones on sexual ...
Some studies have shown that sex differences in the central nervous system appear before the onset of the release gonadal hormones during embryonic development.
[87]
Sexual differences in genetic architecture in UK Biobank - bioRxiv
Jul 21, 2020 · We found small yet widespread differences in genetic architecture across traits through the calculation of sex-specific heritability, genetic correlations,Results · Phenotype Prediction With... · Gwas With Randomized Sex<|separator|>
[88]
Considering Sex as a Biological Variable in Basic and Clinical Studies
The classical biological definition of the 2 sexes is that females have ovaries and make larger female gametes (eggs), whereas males have testes and make ...
[89]
[PDF] What are biological sexes? - PhilPapers
Oct 27, 2021 · Biological sexes (male, female, hermaphrodite) are defined by different gametic strategies for reproduction. Sexes are regions of phenotypic ...<|separator|>
[90]
Ideology versus Biology - Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study
Apr 16, 2025 · Biological sex and gender have become a point of political and ideological debate, particularly around the rights of transgender individuals.What Is Biological Sex? · What Is Gender? · Toward A More Inclusive...
[91]
Biological sex is binary, even though there is a rainbow of sex roles
Dec 21, 2022 · Biomedical and social scientists are increasingly calling the biological sex into question, arguing that sex is a graded spectrum rather than a binary trait.
[92]
Neurobiology of gender identity and sexual orientation - PMC
The present review discusses the relationship of sexual identity and sexual orientation to prenatal factors that act to shape the development of the brain.2 |. Hormones, Genes And... · 4 |. Sexual Orientation · 4.2 |. Human Studies
[93]
Understanding transgender people, gender identity and gender ...
Mar 9, 2023 · Gender identity refers to a person's internal sense of being male, female or something else; gender expression refers to the way a person ...
[94]
Differentiating sex and gender in health research to achieve ... - NIH
Sex usually refers to a person's biological characteristics, whereas gender refers to socially constructed roles and norms.
[95]
Sex, gender and gender identity: a re-evaluation of the evidence
In this article we reappraise the phenomenology of gender identity, contrast 'treatments' for homosexuality with those for gender non-conformity.
[96]
Stability and Change in Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation ...
Jul 15, 2025 · In this monograph, we provide a detailed quantitative description of gender identity and sexual orientation across childhood and adolescence in ...<|separator|>
[97]
Gender Dysphoria - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf
The etiology of gender dysphoria (GD) remains unclear, but it is thought to originate from a complex biopsychosocial link. Individuals born with congenital ...Introduction · Etiology · History and Physical · Treatment / Management
[98]
A narrative review of gender dysphoria in childhood and adolescence
Reported estimates of the prevalence of gender dysphoria (0.6–1.7%) are highly variable and irreproducible due to variability of the data source, study ...
[99]
Epidemiology of gender dysphoria and gender incongruence in ...
Jan 24, 2025 · Conclusions Recorded prevalence of gender dysphoria/incongruence increased substantially in children and young people between 2011 and 2021, ...
[100]
Gender dysphoria in twins: a register-based population study - Nature
Aug 4, 2022 · estimated heritability at 62%, while Sasaki et al. found a heritability of 41% for adolescent assigned females (aF) and 11% for adult aF, and no ...
[101]
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0283011
[102]
Psychiatric Axis I Comorbidities among Patients with Gender ... - NIH
Conclusion. Consistent with most earlier researches, the majority of patients with gender dysphoria had psychiatric Axis I comorbidity.
[103]
Autism Spectrum Disorder and Gender Dysphoria/Incongruence. A ...
May 20, 2022 · This review showed a relationship between ASD traits and GD feelings in the general population and a high prevalence of GD/GI in ASD.
[104]
A systematic review on gender dysphoria in adolescents and young ...
Sep 21, 2023 · A systematic review on gender dysphoria in adolescents and young adults: focus on suicidal and self-harming ideation and behaviours.
[105]
Gender Dysphoria, Its Causes and Symptoms: A Review
The cause of GD can be attributed to a variety of biological, hormonal, psychological, social, family, and childhood abuse factors that are characterized by ...
[106]
A PRISMA systematic review of adolescent gender dysphoria literature
Aug 8, 2023 · Our over-arching aim was to establish what the literature tells us about gender dysphoria in adolescence.
[107]
Accurate transition regret and detransition rates are unknown - SEGM
Sep 11, 2023 · Accurate transition regret and detransition rates are unknown · Like all medical interventions, “gender-affirming” interventions are associated ...
[108]
Factors Leading to “Detransition” Among Transgender and Gender ...
In this national study, 13.1% of TGD respondents who had ever pursued gender affirmation reported a history of detransition. To our knowledge, this is the first ...
[109]
Cass Review Final Report
No information is available for this page. · Learn why
[110]
Sex Equality's Irreconcilable Differences - The Yale Law Journal
Feb 4, 2023 · This Feature argues that sex equality's continued embrace of real differences should not survive what LGBTQ equality shows.
[111]
Gender-related academic and occupational interests and goals.
This chapter reviews the theories and empirical evidence concerning whether gender differences in academic and occupational goals and interests exist, ...
[112]
Things versus People: Gender Differences in Vocational Interests ...
Female apprentices tend to choose occupations that are oriented towards working with people, while male apprentices tend to favor occupations that involve ...
[113]
The Gender Scandal: Part One (Scandinavia) and Part Two (Canada)
Dec 7, 2018 · In Stockholm, I concentrated more on what has come to be known as the “gender paradox.” Here is the paradox in a nutshell: as societies become ...
[114]
The 'paradox' of working in the world's most equal countries - BBC
Sep 4, 2019 · While Nordic fathers do take more parental leave than anywhere else in the world, the gender split of parenting labour remains far from equal.
[115]
Evolved gender differences in mate preferences - ScienceDirect.com
Evolutionary theorists have posited that contemporary men and women may differ in their specific psychological mechanisms having to do with mate selection ...
[116]
Gender differences in personality: a meta-analysis - PubMed
Males were found to be more assertive and had slightly higher self-esteem than females. Females were higher than males in extraversion, anxiety, trust, and, ...
[117]
International comparison of gender differences in the five-factor ...
We investigated the presence of gender differences in FFM personality dimensions across nearly half of all countries in the world.
[118]
The Nordic Glass Ceiling | Cato Institute
Mar 8, 2018 · This analysis argues that gender quotas have been ineffective and that several aspects of Nordic social policies have negatively affected women's career ...Nordic Public-Sector... · Nordic Tax Policy · Norwegian Gender Quotas<|separator|>
[119]
Sex differences and occupational choice Theorizing for policy ...
Longstanding empirical findings document real world differences in occupational preferences between men and women. Women are more likely to prefer occupations ...
[120]
The Nordic Gender Equality Paradox
It can seem as a paradox why Nordic societies – which are the most gender equal in the world in many regards – have few women on top of the business world.
[121]
The Biological Basis of Sex Differences in Athletic Performance
Dec 1, 2023 · Thus, for athletic events and sports relying on endurance, muscle strength, speed, and power, males typically outperform females by 10%-30% ...
[122]
Evidence on sex differences in sports performance
The profound sex differences in sports performance are primarily attributable to the direct and indirect effects of sex-steroid hormones and provide a ...
[123]
Sex Differences in Athletic Performance | ACSM Consensus Statement
Males' higher testosterone leads to greater speed, strength, and power, resulting in 10-30% better performance in aerobic and muscle power events.
[124]
[PDF] Comparing Athletic Performances - The Best Elite Women to Boys ...
Jun 14, 2018 · There is a 10-12% performance gap between elite males and females. In 2017, men and boys outperformed elite women thousands of times.
[125]
Expanding the Gap: An Updated Look Into Sex Differences in ...
Males consistently outperform females in athletic endeavors, including running events of standard Olympic distances (100 m to Marathon).Introduction · Explanations · Practical Applications · Conclusion
[126]
Effect of gender affirming hormones on athletic performance in ...
Transwomen retain an advantage in endurance (1.5 mile run) over female controls for over 2 years after starting gender affirming hormones. Transwomen are ...
[127]
How does hormone transition in transgender women change body ...
Mar 1, 2021 · It is possible that transwomen competing in sports may retain strength advantages over cisgender women, even after 3 years of hormone therapy.
[128]
Effect of gender affirming hormones on athletic performance in ...
Prior to gender affirming hormones, transwomen performed 31% more push-ups and 15% more sit-ups in 1 min and ran 1.5 miles 21% faster than their female ...
[129]
Trans women retain athletic edge after a year of hormone therapy ...
Jan 5, 2021 · A new study suggests transgender women maintain an athletic advantage over their cisgender peers even after a year on hormone therapy.
[130]
Sex differences and athletic performance. Where do trans ... - Frontiers
Oct 26, 2023 · As described above, following 2 years of gender affirming hormone therapy, trans women completed their 1.5 mile run slower than cis men, but ...
[131]
Two new scientific reviews agree that transwomen athletes retain ...
Mar 7, 2021 · The two studies arrive at the same conclusion: male athletes suppressing testosterone in order to transition lose little in the way of muscle mass and strength.
[132]
Trans swimmer Lia Thomas loses legal battle, Olympics hopes dashed
Jun 12, 2024 · Thomas made history in 2022, becoming the first transgender woman to win an NCAA swimming championship.
[133]
Penn to ban trans athletes, ending Thomas case - ESPN
Jul 1, 2025 · The University of Pennsylvania on Tuesday modified a trio of school records set by transgender swimmer Lia Thomas and said it would apologize to female ...Missing: facts | Show results with:facts
[134]
Yes, Lia Thomas's Body Is the Problem | The Heritage Foundation
Feb 9, 2024 · Susan Shaw, a women's and gender studies professor at Oregon State, penned a recent op-ed in Forbes titled “Transgender Swimmer Lia Thomas' ...
[135]
[PDF] ELIGIBILITY REGULATIONS FOR TRANSGENDER ATHLETES
Mar 23, 2023 · World Athletics regulations aim to allow transgender athletes to participate in their gender identity, while maintaining separate male and ...
[136]
A list of sports organizations that have begun transgender ...
Jul 23, 2025 · A list of sports organizations that have begun transgender competition bans · U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Committee · International Cycling Union.
[137]
US Olympic and Paralympic officials bar transgender women from ...
Jul 23, 2025 · Transgender women will no longer be eligible to compete for the United States in the Olympic or Paralympic Games in women's categories.
[138]
Fairness, Inclusion and Non-Discrimination in Olympic Sport
In November 2021, the IOC released the Framework on Fairness, Inclusion and Non-Discrimination on the Basis of Gender Identity and Sex Variations.
[139]
Position statement: IOC framework on fairness, inclusion and non ...
The IOC framework supports policies for trans athletes, aiming for inclusion, fairness, and non-discrimination, and guides sport-specific policies.
[140]
Trans Athlete Injures Multiple Girls, Forcing Team To Forfeit. Wither ...
Mar 5, 2024 · Injuries sustained by girls and women during athletic contests with transgender athletes are not the stuff of mere speculation.
[141]
[PDF] Trans Athlete Injures Multiple Girls, Forcing Team To Forfeit. Wither ...
Apr 10, 2024 · Last year, a female athlete was injured by a trans-identified male opponent during a field hockey game in. Massachusetts when a ball he threw at ...
[142]
Trans Women in Sport: What Does the Science Say?
Oct 16, 2025 · Safety concerns are mostly hypothetical. To date, there is no solid evidence that trans women pose a greater injury risk to cis women in sport.
[143]
Professor: 'Trans Athletes Causing Life-Altering Injuries'
Apr 17, 2025 · Professor Banzhaf has also documented how M2F transgender athletes have seriously injured girls and women in many sports. BOXING. USA Boxing, ...
[144]
Sports Medicine Considerations When Caring for the Transgender ...
TW athletes have demonstrated increased risk of insufficiency fractures, and exogenous estrogen carries an increased risk of venous thromboembolism. Certain sex ...
[145]
[PDF] Expert Declaration Concerning Injury Risks Associated with ...
current evidence, testosterone suppression is unlikely to guarantee fairness between transgender women and natal females in gender-affected sports.” (UK Sports.
[146]
Trans Inclusion & Women's Sport
After 12 months of testosterone suppression, transgender women remained 48% stronger, with 35% larger quadriceps mass compared with the control population of ...
[147]
Sex differences and athletic performance. Where do trans ... - NIH
Oct 27, 2023 · This review seeks to offer considerations for whether trans individuals should be excluded from sports and athletics, and how future research should proceed.
[148]
Sexual assaults in women's prison reignite debate over transgender ...
Sep 9, 2018 · A leading prison reformer has said prisoners who have committed violent offences against women should not be able to transfer to women's prisons.
[149]
Lawsuit: Female Prisoner Says She Was Raped by Transgender ...
Feb 19, 2020 · An inmate at Illinois' largest women's prison says she was raped by a transgender inmate who was transferred into her housing unit last year.
[150]
Man posing as transgender woman raped female prisoner at Rikers ...
Jan 24, 2024 · A former prisoner in the Rose M. Singer women's jail on Rikers Island is suing New York City, alleging jail staff ignored her warnings in ...
[151]
Trans women inmates who hurt females to go to male prisons - BBC
Dec 5, 2023 · Under previous guidance drawn up in 2014, the prison service allowed all prisoners to be placed in facilities matching their gender identity ...
[152]
Scotland's gender recognition bill would have harmed women
Feb 3, 2023 · In short, if coded into law, this bill would effectively render null and void women's hard-earned sex-based rights and protections.
[153]
Study of 1,655 Cases Supports the "Rapid-Onset Gender Dysphoria ...
Mar 30, 2023 · A new study examining 1,655 parental reports lends further credibility to the rapid onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) hypothesis, first posited by ...
[154]
More Sloppy Scholarship on Trans Identity - City Journal
Jan 11, 2024 · Critics alleged that Littman's method of surveying parents was unreliable, but Littman showed that her method was consistent with other papers ...
[155]
Ban on puberty blockers to be made indefinite on experts' advice
Dec 11, 2024 · The NHS stopped the routine prescription of puberty blocker treatments to under 18s in March 2024, following the Cass Review into gender ...Missing: findings | Show results with:findings
[156]
What Is Gender Ideology? - The Heritage Foundation
Jul 7, 2023 · Gender ideology is the theory that the sex binary doesn't capture the complexity of the human species, and that human individuals are properly ...
[157]
The Incoherence of Gender Ideology - Quillette
Aug 4, 2021 · They reject the idea that women must necessarily have any particular feeling, or thought, or taste, or preference. If “gender” is an artificial ...
[158]
Queer Theory is Gender Marxism, Et Cetera - New Discourses
Mar 30, 2022 · Gender ideology and Queer Theory are Sex, Gender, and Sexuality Marxism, or just Gender Marxism or Sexual Marxism to be more concise.
[159]
[PDF] The Corrosive Impact of Transgender Ideology - Civitas
As Davies-Arai argues,. 'It's a political idea that we have a sense of gender identity which exists independent of both our biological sex and our gendered ...
[160]
Holly Lawford-Smith: What is Gender-Critical Feminism? (And why is ...
Gender critical feminism is not 'about' trans. It is about sex. But because it is about sex, it clashes with gender identity ideology, which is at the heart of ...
[161]
Trans: When Ideology Meets Reality by Helen Joyce | Goodreads
Rating 4.3 (3,211) Sep 7, 2021 · People are being shamed and silenced for attempting to understand the consequences of redefining 'man' and 'woman'. While compassion for ...
[162]
What do feminists say about gender ideology?
Apr 3, 2024 · Critiquing gender ideology is not hatred towards any individual or group, just as critiquing sexism and gender ideology is not hatred of men ...
[163]
Transgender Ideology Is Riddled With Contradictions. Here Are the ...
Feb 9, 2018 · D., researches and writes about marriage, bioethics, religious liberty, and political philosophy. Now, activists claim that gender identity is ...
[164]
Trans Legislation Tracker: 2025 Anti-Trans Bills
We track legislation that seeks to block trans people from receiving basic healthcare, education, legal recognition, and the right to publicly exist.Missing: battles | Show results with:battles
[165]
Policy Tracker: Youth Access to Gender Affirming Care and State ...
Also bans hormone and puberty blocking GAC Rx for those <19 unless the individual, family, and provider are able to meet specific criteria outlined by the State ...Missing: 2020-2025 | Show results with:2020-2025
[166]
[PDF] 23-477 United States v. Skrmetti (06/18/2025) - Supreme Court
Jun 18, 2025 · that discrimination against transgender employees neces- sarily “penalizes a person identified as male at birth for traits or actions that ...Missing: battles | Show results with:battles
[167]
Supreme Court delivers major blow to transgender rights, upholding ...
Jun 18, 2025 · The Supreme Court on Wednesday upheld Tennessee's ban on gender-affirming care for transgender minors, a stunning setback to transgender rights.
[168]
Defending Women From Gender Ideology Extremism And Restoring ...
Jan 20, 2025 · It is the policy of the United States to recognize two sexes, male and female. These sexes are not changeable and are grounded in fundamental ...
[169]
Protecting Children from Chemical and Surgical Mutilation
Jan 28, 2025 · It is the policy of the United States that it will not fund, sponsor, promote, assist, or support the so-called “transition” of a child from one sex to another.Missing: 2020-2025 | Show results with:2020-2025
[170]
Where anti-trans state bills stand in 2025 - The 19th News
May 28, 2025 · Those newly passed laws include restrictions on trans students' ability to use school restrooms or play school sports, Pride flag bans on ...
[171]
Supreme Court takes up cases on transgender athletes - SCOTUSblog
Jul 3, 2025 · The Supreme Court on Thursday added two cases on transgender athletes to its docket for the 2025-26 term. In Little v. Hecox and West Virginia ...Missing: 2020-2025 | Show results with:2020-2025
[172]
Supreme Court Agrees to Hear Cases Involving Transgender Athletes
Jul 3, 2025 · The court announced it would hear challenges to state laws barring transgender youth from girls' and women's sports.
[173]
Federal Court Vacated Gender Identity Portions of EEOC ...
May 29, 2025 · A federal district court in Texas on May 15, 2025, vacated the gender identity parts of the 2024 Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) Enforcement ...Missing: battles | Show results with:battles
[174]
[PDF] JUDGMENT For Women Scotland Ltd (Appellant) v The Scottish ...
Apr 16, 2025 · 54. The common law of England and Wales did not recognise the possibility of a person becoming a different gender from their gender at birth.
[175]
UK Supreme Court ruling on the meaning of sex in the Equality Act
According to the ruling, obtaining a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC) does not change your legal sex for Equality Act purposes. Two solid blocks of ...Missing: reform | Show results with:reform
[176]
E-petition: transgender people self-identifying their legal gender
May 15, 2025 · The petition calls on the government to change the law so that trans people can change their legal gender without an official diagnosis of gender dysphoria.
[177]
[PDF] W -v- Gender Recognition Panel - Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Oct 17, 2025 · Para 1 of the judgment articulates it thus: “In this case the court is required to define the term 'mother' under the law of England and Wales.Missing: reform | Show results with:reform
[178]
“They're Ruining People's Lives”: Bans on Gender-Affirming Care for ...
Jun 3, 2025 · The remaining 25 state laws, referred to in this report as "bans" or "blanket bans," prohibit nearly all forms of gender-affirming medical care ...
[179]
Prohibiting Gender-Affirming Medical Care for Youth
Several bans proposed in 2023 would limit access to care for older youth up to age 26. Since 2020, 36 states have attempted to restrict access to gender- ...Missing: puberty blockers
[180]
The Future of Gender-Affirming Care — A Law and Policy ...
Jan 15, 2025 · The Cass Review on gender-affirming care, which has been used to justify bans in U.S. states, transgresses medical law, policy, and practice ...
[181]
Gender incongruence and transgender health in the ICD
ICD-11 has redefined gender identity-related health, replacing outdated diagnostic categories like ICD-10's “transsexualism” and “gender identity disorder of ...
[182]
The World Health Organization Clarifies its Plans to Issue ... - SEGM
Feb 1, 2024 · The World Health Organization issued an update on its plan to develop guidelines for "trans and gender diverse people.<|separator|>
[183]
UN Women Calls Gender-Criticals An Extremist Anti-rights Movement
Jun 17, 2024 · UN Women explicitly calls out the "gender-critical" movement, which has infamous adherents such as JK Rowling, as being an extremist "anti-rights" movement.
[184]
Gender Equality | United Nations
Gender equality, besides being a fundamental human right, is essential to achieve peaceful societies, with full human potential and sustainable development.
[185]
Attacks on Gender-Affirming and Transgender Health Care
Aug 29, 2025 · Published: 8/29/25 A growing number of states are banning gender-affirming health care and pursuing anti-LGBTQ+ legislation, contrary to ACP ...
[186]
[PDF] Recission of “HHS Notice and Guidance on Gender Affirming Care ...
Feb 20, 2025 · The. 2022 OCR Notice and Guidance outlined the application of federal civil rights and patient privacy laws to such medical treatments for ...
[187]
Cass review: how has report affected care for transgender young ...
Jul 2, 2025 · Review led to profound changes, some of which made young people feel unsupported, yet new clinics are opening.