Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Liniment

A liniment is a or semi-liquid medicinal preparation designed for external application to , typically consisting of active ingredients dissolved in an oily, alcoholic, or aqueous , and intended to be rubbed into the affected area for therapeutic effect. These preparations are commonly used as analgesics or counterirritants to provide temporary relief from minor musculoskeletal pains, such as those associated with , sprains, strains, backaches, and bruises. Liniments work through local mechanisms, including the stimulation of blood flow ( action) or cooling/warming sensations that distract from underlying , often without significant systemic absorption when applied to unbroken . Common active ingredients include , , , and , which are formulated in bases like for quick and or oils like linseed for prolonged . Examples of well-known liniments include those containing compound for joint and muscle relief, as well as traditional formulations like mustard or liniments that promote circulation and reduce . Historically, liniments have been employed since ancient times for their emollient and soothing properties, with modern over-the-counter products like Icy Hot and continuing this legacy by incorporating similar botanicals and synthetics for everyday . While generally safe for topical use, they require caution to avoid or allergic reactions, and are not recommended for open wounds or prolonged application without medical advice.

Definition and Etymology

Definition

A liniment is a medicated topical preparation in the form of a or designed for external application to , primarily to provide relief from , , or muscle soreness. It typically consists of active ingredients dissolved or suspended in a vehicle such as , , or , facilitating its use through rubbing or to enhance penetration. Key characteristics of liniments include their rubefacient properties, which cause localized redness and warmth by dilating skin blood vessels, counterirritant effects that distract from deeper pain through superficial irritation, and analgesic actions that directly alleviate discomfort. These preparations are usually alcohol- or oil-based to promote rapid absorption into the skin without requiring occlusion, distinguishing them from other topical forms. Common ingredients like menthol or camphor often contribute to the cooling or warming sensations that support these therapeutic effects. In contrast to ointments, which are thicker, semi-solid greasier bases that form a protective barrier on the skin, or lotions, which are thinner, aqueous suspensions intended for soothing or moisturizing without vigorous rubbing, liniments are specifically formulated for massage-like application to stimulate circulation and to underlying tissues. Their basic mechanism involves penetration to target muscles, joints, or nerves locally, with minimal systemic absorption in most cases, thereby reducing the risk of widespread side effects.

Etymology

The term "liniment" derives from the linīmentum, meaning "a soft ointment," which itself stems from the verb linīre (a collateral form of linere), signifying "to anoint," "to smear," or "to daub." This Latin root traces back to the Proto-Indo-European (s)lei-, denoting something "slimy," "sticky," or "smeared," evoking the action of spreading a viscous substance. The word entered around 1420, initially borrowed directly from Latin linīmentum as a medical term for preparations. By the , it was established in English usage, appearing in texts like Palladius on Husbondrie. Over time, the meaning evolved from a broad reference to soft ointments or general substances for to a more specific designation by the for liquid or semi-liquid medicinal preparations intended for rubbing into to relieve or . This shift reflects advancements in pharmaceutical terminology, emphasizing friction-based application.

History

Ancient and Traditional Uses

Liniments, topical preparations typically consisting of oils or solvents infused with herbs and resins, have been employed since ancient times for alleviating muscular and joint ailments. In around 1500 BCE, such remedies were commonly used to provide relief for laborers suffering from muscle strains and pains incurred during heavy work. The , a comprehensive medical text from this era, documents numerous recipes for ointments made from oils like and combined with resins such as and , applied externally to soothe inflammation and promote healing in overworked tissues. These formulations were integral to therapeutic practices, blending practical with ritual elements to address occupational injuries prevalent among pyramid builders and agricultural workers. In and , liniment-like rubs evolved into systematic treatments for joint pain and injuries, emphasizing friction and herbal infusions. , around 400 BCE, advocated for oil-based massages incorporating herbs to treat conditions like and sprains, recommending vigorous rubbing with mixed with aromatic plants to improve circulation and reduce stiffness in affected joints. He viewed such applications as essential for restoring bodily balance, particularly for athletes and those with , laying foundational principles for . Building on this, the Roman physician in the 2nd century formalized the concept of counterirritation, theorizing that mild surface irritation from liniments could draw away deeper pains and inflammation. Galen's writings prescribed - or oil-based preparations with irritants like or herbs to stimulate blood flow and relieve internal discomfort, influencing medical practices across the and beyond. Traditional Chinese medicine incorporated herbal liniments from approximately 200 BCE, utilizing alcohol or vinegar as solvents to extract active compounds from plants for external application. Ginger ( officinale), valued for its warming properties, was a key ingredient in these formulations, often infused in to create rubs for and joint swelling, aiming to dispel "cold-damp" pathogens according to classical texts like the . Such remedies were applied through to meridians, enhancing flow and reducing pain in conditions exacerbated by weather or exertion, reflecting a holistic integration of herbalism and acupuncture principles. Indigenous peoples of the Americas developed liniment analogs using animal fats as bases for plant mixtures well before European contact in the late . Native tribes, including those in the Northeast and , crafted salves from rendered bear or deer fat blended with pulverized herbs like willow bark or to treat sprains and bruises, providing emollient and effects through topical application. These pre-Columbian preparations were prepared by healers during communal rituals, emphasizing natural fats for their ability to penetrate skin and deliver plant essences directly to injured areas, sustaining community health amid nomadic or agrarian lifestyles. During the medieval period in , folk remedies featured liniments derived from wine or steeped with herbs to address bruises and injuries, as recorded in 12th-century manuscripts. Texts such as the , a of and general remedies from around 1150 CE, describe mixtures of with comfrey or rue applied as compresses to reduce swelling and promote resorption, drawing on humoral theory to balance excess "hot" humors. These accessible household preparations were widespread among peasants and clergy, often self-administered to hasten recovery from falls or blows, and preserved oral traditions that bridged ancient Greco-Roman knowledge with emerging scholastic medicine.

Modern Developments

In the 19th century, liniment formulations advanced significantly with the introduction of as a primary , enhancing the penetration of active ingredients through for better therapeutic . Pharmacists in Victorian England and the commonly utilized alcoholic bases, such as , to dissolve essential oils and resins, marking a shift from purely oleaginous preparations to more effective rubefacients and analgesics. This period also saw the patenting of the first major commercial liniments, including Sloan's Liniment in the 1880s, which capitalized on the growing industry and made topical pain relief accessible to broader consumer markets. The early 20th century brought standardization efforts through pharmacopeial regulations, with the (USP) Ninth Revision in 1910 establishing official standards for drug strength, quality, and purity, including preparations like liniments, cerates, and ointments. The 1906 further enforced these standards by prohibiting misbranded or adulterated drugs, laying the groundwork for consistent manufacturing practices. Following , liniments increasingly incorporated synthetic ingredients, such as analogs of natural counterirritants, to ensure batch-to-batch consistency and scalability in production amid rising pharmaceutical industrialization. Liniments also gained prominence in during the 1920s, with menthol-based products recommended for muscle strains and recovery among athletes, including those preparing for events like the Olympics. The Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act of 1938 expanded oversight by requiring proof of safety and accurate labeling for topical products, curbing unsubstantiated claims in the liniment market. In the , modern liniments have integrated evidence-based active ingredients like , derived from chili peppers, which clinical trials have shown to provide moderate relief for chronic when applied topically at concentrations of 0.025% to 8%. These advancements reflect a focus on scientifically validated mechanisms, such as capsaicin's depletion of to reduce signaling. The global market for liniments and rubs was valued at US$2.75 billion in 2021 and projected to reach US$3.65 billion by 2025, driven by an aging population seeking non-opioid management options for conditions like .

Composition and Formulation

Common Ingredients

Liniments typically incorporate a range of active ingredients that provide therapeutic effects such as analgesia, counterirritation, and action. , derived from or other oils, is a common active component that induces a cooling sensation by activating the receptors on sensory neurons, thereby distracting from underlying pain. Typical concentrations of menthol in liniment formulations range from 1% to 5%. , a waxy, crystalline substance obtained from the wood of the camphor tree, acts as a counterirritant by stimulating endings to produce a warming effect through mild and increased local blood flow. Pharmacopeial and regulatory limits allow camphor concentrations up to 11% in topical preparations like liniments. , often sourced from oil, functions as an agent similar to aspirin by inhibiting enzymes, which reduces synthesis and alleviates musculoskeletal pain. Base solvents form the vehicle for these active ingredients, facilitating application and absorption. , such as isopropyl alcohol, serves as a primary solvent in many liniments due to its rapid evaporation, which enhances skin penetration of the actives while providing a cooling effect upon application. In contrast, oils like or are used as emollient bases in oil-based liniments, offering moisturizing properties that soothe the and prolong contact time for sustained relief. Other additives enhance the sensory or therapeutic profile of liniments. , extracted from chili peppers, generates a heat sensation by initially stimulating receptors and subsequently depleting , a involved in pain signaling, leading to prolonged analgesia. Essential oils, such as , contribute aromatic distraction through their invigorating scent and mild counterirritant properties, which help mask discomfort during application. Inert components ensure formulation stability and safety. Water and emulsifiers are included in emulsion-type liniments to create a homogeneous of oil and aqueous phases, preventing separation. Preservatives like parabens are added to inhibit microbial growth, particularly in water-containing formulations, maintaining product integrity over time.

Preparation Methods

Liniments can be prepared through various methods depending on the scale and formulation type, ranging from simple homemade infusions to complex industrial processes. The basic homemade method involves infusing dried or fresh , such as or , in an or base to extract active compounds. Typically, a is filled about one-third full with the material by volume, then covered with a like (70% ) or at a ratio of approximately 1 part to 5 parts solvent by weight to volume, allowing for efficient without excessive dilution. The mixture is sealed and left to infuse for 1 to 2 weeks in a cool, dark place, shaken daily to agitate, and then strained through or a fine mesh to remove solids, yielding a clear liniment suitable for immediate use. For emulsion-based liniments, which combine oil and aqueous phases for improved spreadability and absorption, preparation starts by creating separate phases: an oil phase incorporating ingredients like dissolved in a carrier such as or , and an aqueous phase using water or . Emulsifiers such as or are added to stabilize the mixture, typically at 1-2% of the total volume, to prevent . The phases are then combined under high-shear mixing or homogenization—often using a for small batches—to form a stable , with the process ensuring droplet sizes remain small (under 10 microns) for uniformity and efficacy. This method is particularly useful for liniments requiring both hydrophobic and hydrophilic components, as seen in traditional soap-emulsified formulations. On an industrial scale, liniment begins with solvent of active ingredients from raw materials, such as essential oils or herbal extracts, using or supercritical CO2 to isolate potent compounds efficiently while minimizing impurities. The extracted actives are then blended with bases, preservatives, and other excipients in large vats under controlled (typically 20-30°C) and to ensure homogeneity, often following good manufacturing practices (GMP) for consistency. involves (HPLC) testing to verify potency levels of key actives, such as or salicylates, ensuring concentrations meet specified tolerances (e.g., ±5% of target). This scalable process allows for high-volume output while maintaining batch-to-batch . Storage is critical to maintain liniment stability, with amber glass bottles recommended to shield contents from UV light, which can degrade volatile components and reduce efficacy over time. These bottles, often with airtight caps, help extend to typically 2-3 years when stored in a cool, dry place below 25°C, preventing oxidation and microbial growth without the need for additional stabilizers in alcohol-based formulations. Variations in preparation techniques include hot and cold s, tailored to the desired preservation of compounds. Cold , performed at over 1-4 weeks, best preserves heat-sensitive volatile compounds like by avoiding evaporation or degradation, making it ideal for aromatic . In contrast, hot involves gentle heating (e.g., in a double at 40-50°C for 2-4 hours) to accelerate but risks losing some volatiles, suitable for tougher materials where speed is prioritized over full retention of essential oils.

Types

Topical Liniments

Topical liniments are external preparations applied directly to the to provide localized relief from musculoskeletal discomfort, primarily through counterirritant, , or mechanisms. These formulations are typically liquid or semi-liquid, often alcohol-based for enhanced , and are distinguished by their sensory effects and active ingredients, which target specific types of such as muscle soreness or . Unlike oral medications, topical liniments minimize systemic , reducing the risk of gastrointestinal side effects while delivering therapeutic agents to the site of application. Cooling liniments are formulated with ingredients like or oil to produce a refreshing sensation that soothes post-exercise muscle relief by activating receptors on , which create a cooling effect and temporarily desensitize pain pathways. These are commonly applied to large areas such as the legs or back after to alleviate soreness and reduce perceived . For instance, products containing 5-10% provide rapid onset relief lasting 1-2 hours, making them popular among athletes for recovery. Heating liniments, in contrast, incorporate from peppers or ginger extracts to stimulate blood flow and promote , which helps alleviate by counteracting and enhancing nutrient delivery to affected tissues. The warming arises from capsaicin's activation of receptors, leading to an initial mild followed by prolonged analgesia; the warming has an immediate onset, with counterirritant effects providing temporary shortly after application, though prolonged analgesia may develop with repeated use and can endure for several hours. Ginger-based variants further support circulation through compounds, offering a milder suitable for ongoing conditions. Analgesic liniments often feature salicylates, such as , which inhibit synthesis locally to mimic the effects of oral nonsteroidal drugs (NSAIDs) for arthritis-related without significant systemic exposure. Applied to inflamed joints, these provide benefits by reducing swelling and tenderness, with significant local absorption through the skin. Many are developed as gel-emulsion hybrids to improve stability and controlled release, allowing for targeted application over bony prominences like knees or elbows. Specialized variants cater to distinct needs, such as sports rubs for athletes, which use quick-absorbing alcohol bases to facilitate rapid evaporation and penetration during or after training, often combining with essential oils for multifunctional relief. In comparison, arthritis formulas employ thicker consistencies, like gels or ointments, to ensure prolonged contact and precise targeting of joints, minimizing runoff and enhancing efficacy on irregular surfaces. The market for topical liniments predominantly serves human applications, with industry analyses indicating that human-use formulations account for the majority of sales due to widespread demand for over-the-counter pain management.

Veterinary Liniments

Veterinary liniments are specialized topical preparations designed for animal use, tailored to the physiological differences of various species, with a strong focus on equine and livestock applications. In horses, formulations like Absorbine Veterinary Liniment, containing an iodine complex alongside menthol and herbal extracts, are widely employed to alleviate leg swelling, muscular soreness, and joint stiffness resulting from exertion or injury. These products provide fast-acting relief by stimulating blood flow and reducing inflammation when rubbed into affected areas. Formulations for horses include menthol concentrations up to 4%, suitable for their thicker skin. Adaptations for companion animals emphasize milder compositions to suit smaller sizes and sensitivities. For , menthol-based liniments, such as Absorbine Veterinary Liniment (), target joint issues like and minor strains, offering soothing relief without overwhelming potency; however, prevent access to treated areas to avoid licking and potential . In cats, veterinary liniments strictly avoid toxic essential oils—including tea tree, , , and —which can lead to severe poisoning through absorption or , manifesting as , tremors, or respiratory distress; instead, hypoallergenic bases prioritize safety. Livestock applications, particularly for in farming settings, often incorporate -based liniments to treat bruises, sprains, and inflammatory conditions from handling or environmental factors. variants, such as ointments formulated with natural extracts like and , are favored to minimize drying or irritation on sensitive , promoting faster of traumatized tissues. Dosing protocols account for body size and risks, with larger applications for —typically a generous rub covering the affected area multiple times daily—contrasted against smaller, precise amounts for pets to prevent accidental licking and subsequent . Non-ingestible formulations underscore , as many liniments contain compounds that could cause gastrointestinal upset if consumed. The prominence of veterinary liniments traces back to sports in the late 1800s, with innovations like Absorbine Veterinary Liniment developed in 1892 to support working and competitive .

Medical and Therapeutic Uses

Human Applications

Liniments, topical preparations often containing counterirritants such as or , or nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) like , are applied to to alleviate various musculoskeletal conditions through mechanisms including counterirritation and local effects. For acute musculoskeletal pain, such as strains and sprains, liniments provide effective relief by distracting from deeper pain via sensory stimulation from counterirritants, with meta-analyses showing that topical NSAIDs achieve at least 50% pain reduction in 40-80% of users (depending on formulation) compared to 15-35% with , while counterirritants provide moderate relief with response rates around 40% vs. 20%. In arthritis management, particularly knee osteoarthritis, liniments incorporating topical NSAIDs demonstrate superiority over in reducing symptoms like and , with randomized controlled trials (RCTs) from 2020 showing equivalent efficacy to oral NSAIDs in achieving clinically meaningful relief, such as a 50% or greater reduction on visual analog scales after 4-12 weeks of use. For sports-related injuries, including (DOMS) following intense exercise, pre- and post-application of NSAID-based liniments has been shown in pilot RCTs to significantly decrease soreness intensity and improve recovery, with scores reduced by up to 30% within 48 hours compared to . Liniments are also utilized for minor ailments like and bruises, offering temporary relief when applied as needed for short-term use, typically up to 7 days, in line with FDA guidance for over-the-counter topical analgesics to avoid prolonged exposure. However, their can vary by individual type, with sensitive or potentially experiencing reduced or , and they are contraindicated for application on open wounds to prevent or adverse reactions.

Animal Applications

Liniments play a significant role in for treating musculoskeletal conditions in , particularly tendonitis and splints commonly seen in racehorses due to high-impact activities. These topical preparations provide symptomatic relief by reducing , stiffness, and minor swelling through improved circulation and counterirritant effects. For instance, a 2022 randomized study involving 18 mature stock horses with chronic demonstrated that daily application of a liniment (Sore No More Performance Ultra) significantly lowered scores and inflammation markers, as measured by pressure algometry and , with treated horses showing sustained improvements over 44 days compared to controls. Such applications are often integrated into post-exercise routines for performance to support recovery without interfering with training. In small animals like dogs, liniments incorporating are employed to alleviate symptoms of musculoskeletal conditions, offering benefits to soothe sore muscles and reduce tenderness when applied topically. Veterinary recommendations emphasize gentle rubbing into the affected area to minimize , often following a to ensure tolerance, with applications limited to 2-3 times daily on . This approach aids in managing chronic discomfort while complementing other therapies like exercise modification. Veterinary protocols for liniment application across species typically involve thorough cleaning of the site, followed by to enhance absorption, and containment via bandaging or wraps to maximize therapeutic effects—such as leaving a leg wrap on for 12-24 hours in . is essential, especially in sensitive breeds, with for allergic reactions like redness or over 24 hours post-application; if reactions occur, immediate rinsing and veterinary consultation are advised. Historically, liniment use on traces back to 18th-century practices, where topical remedies evolved alongside advancements in veterinary to address the demands of elite equine performance.

Application and Safety

Methods of Application

Liniments are typically applied to , to ensure optimal absorption and minimize the risk of . Begin by washing the affected area with mild and , then pat thoroughly. A thin layer of liniment should be applied directly to the targeted , using or a soft applicator such as a ball to avoid direct contact if sensitivity is a concern. To enhance penetration, gently the liniment into the skin for 1-2 minutes. For areas, use circular motions to promote circulation around the without excessive , while linear stroking along the of muscles is suitable for broader applications. Warming the liniment slightly by rubbing it between the palms before application can facilitate easier spreading, particularly for thicker formulations. This process is generally recommended 3-4 times daily for adults, depending on the product's instructions and the severity of symptoms. Avoid applying liniment near the eyes, mucous membranes, or on broken to prevent or systemic . Initial effects may onset within 5-10 minutes, though full relief can take longer; for improved penetration with certain warming liniments, a heat pack can be applied after , but only if specified by the product to avoid excessive heating. Best practices include performing a on a small area of unaffected 24 hours prior to full use to check for allergic reactions, and thoroughly washing hands after application to prevent accidental transfer to sensitive areas.

Precautions and Side Effects

Liniments, as topical preparations, require careful use to minimize risks of adverse reactions. Common side effects include localized , redness, and a burning or stinging at the application site, particularly with formulations containing , which may intensify with heat, humidity, or sweating. These effects are typically transient but can be more pronounced in sensitive individuals. Rare allergic reactions, such as , itching, swelling, or , may occur, necessitating immediate discontinuation of use. For liniments with , additional topical reactions like or blistering have been reported. Certain populations face heightened contraindications. Liniments containing salicylates, such as , should be avoided during , especially from the third trimester onward, due to risks of fetal harm, including premature closure of the and complications during labor. They are also contraindicated for children under 2 years of age, as well as those with to ingredients or conditions like eczema, where skin barrier disruption may exacerbate irritation. Severe renal impairment further warrants avoidance to prevent potential complications from absorption. Overuse poses significant risks, including chemical burns from excessive application or covering treated areas, which can lead to severe skin damage such as blistering or necrosis. Prolonged or widespread use may result in systemic absorption, particularly of salicylates, potentially causing salicylate poisoning with symptoms like tinnitus, nausea, or metabolic acidosis. In the United States, liniments are classified as over-the-counter (OTC) external drug products under FDA Monograph M017, which specifies safe concentrations—such as up to 30% for and 0.025% to 0.25% for —and mandates labeling with warnings against use on broken or large areas. In the , liniments are distinguished as either under Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009—if intended for cleansing or beautifying without therapeutic claims—or medicinal products under Directive 2001/83/EC if making health-related claims, affecting registration, safety assessments, and ingredient restrictions. For emergencies, discontinue use immediately if a , severe , or allergic symptoms develop, and wash the area thoroughly. In cases of , which can cause from alcohol, salicylates, or leading to seizures, , or respiratory distress, seek urgent medical attention and contact a without inducing .

Notable Examples

Commercial Products

Bengay is a prominent commercial liniment brand featuring a blend of and designed to provide temporary relief from minor muscle and joint pain associated with , bruises, and strains. Introduced in 1898 by French pharmacist Dr. Jules Bengué as "Baume Analgesique," it was the first product to incorporate and as topical analgesics in the United States. The Ultra Strength variant contains 30% , 10% , and 4% , offering a non-greasy cream formulation for enhanced penetration and pain relief. Icy Hot represents another leading liniment option, utilizing a dual-action that delivers an initial cooling sensation followed by warming relief through and to alleviate muscle aches, joint pain, and sprains. Launched approximately 50 years ago in the , the brand has evolved to include convenient formats such as roll-on applicators, which allow for mess-free, targeted application on larger areas. The Original Cream variant features 10% and 30% , emphasizing contrast for effective . Absorbine, initially developed as an equine liniment in 1892, has been widely adapted for human use, with estimates indicating that 40% to 50% of sales as of the late involve applications for human muscle and joint soreness. Its formula includes 1.27% , 0.50% , and 0.02% iodine, providing properties alongside relief for temporary muscular stiffness and arthritis-related swelling. Available in and liquid forms, the product is valued for its invigorating scent and ability to stimulate circulation in affected areas. Tiger Balm stands out as a herbal liniment with roots in traditional Asian medicine, originating in the 1870s when Chinese herbalist Aw Chu Kin developed the formula as a natural remedy for pain. Named by his son and launched commercially in , it has achieved global distribution for relieving headaches, muscle strains, and discomfort through penetrating warmth. The liniment version incorporates , , cajuput oil, and oil, offering a concentrated, non-staining application suitable for larger body areas.

Historical Formulations

One notable early liniment was Elliman's Embrocation, introduced in 1847 in the as a topical rub primarily for horses to alleviate muscle strains and joint pain. Formulated by James Elliman Senior, it consisted of a mixture of eggs, , and , which provided a warming effect through the volatile properties of turpentine. By 1850, a variant known as Universal Embrocation was adapted for human use, targeting rheumatic aches and sprains, reflecting the era's common practice of repurposing veterinary remedies for personal application. The of 1864 formalized Linimentum Saponis, a compound liniment designed for general external rubs to soothe local and pain. This preparation combined hard (cut small, 2½ ounces), (1½ ounces), (18 fluid ounces), (2 fluid ounces), and oil of (3 fluid drachms), creating an emulsified liquid that could be easily applied and absorbed for its mild counterirritant and qualities. The inclusion of enhanced the liniment's ability to produce a sensation of warmth, making it suitable for conditions like bruises and sore throats. Indigenous peoples in , prior to the 1800s, used willow bark—a natural source of —for pain relief and to reduce , often by chewing the bark or making a ; animal fats such as bear grease served as bases for other topical salves. These preparations predated European colonization and influenced later herbal remedies. In the , American patent medicines included various liniments marketed as cure-alls, some containing derivatives for enhanced pain-numbing effects, though formulations varied widely without regulation. Products like certain proprietary rubs promised relief from and but often relied on undisclosed narcotics, leading to widespread abuse until the mandated labeling and curtailed such unchecked sales. Dr. Kilmer's remedies, while prominent in this era, notably avoided opium in their compositions, distinguishing them from many competitors. These historical formulations collectively established foundational counterirritant principles in liniment design, where ingredients like , , and herbal analgesics created localized irritation to distract from deeper pain, a that persists in modern topical therapies.