Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Necklacing

Necklacing is an extrajudicial method of execution and torture originating in South African townships in 1985, whereby a rubber tire filled with gasoline is forced around a victim's chest or neck and set ablaze, causing prolonged burning and death.^[1]^[2] The practice drew from earlier rural burnings of suspected witches but adapted to urban political violence during the anti-apartheid era, often following makeshift "trials" by crowds or youth groups affiliated with organizations like the United Democratic Front (UDF).^[1] Perpetrators, typically black township residents including "comrades" enforcing community discipline, targeted individuals accused of collaboration with the apartheid regime, such as black local councillors, police informants, or boycott violators, though it also claimed victims in intra-community factional clashes between groups like UDF supporters and rivals.^[2] Estimates of fatalities vary, with the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) documenting at least 400 deaths in the mid-1980s, while other records indicate around 428 necklacings from 1985 onward and over 300 burnings (many necklacings) between 1984 and 1987.^[3]^[1] The act symbolized the escalation of township unrest into ritualistic mob justice, blending political retribution with cultural purification motifs involving fire, yet it drew condemnation for its brutality and was later acknowledged by anti-apartheid leaders as a product of desperation under oppression, though with initial denials of endorsement.^[1]^[2] Instances persisted sporadically post-apartheid as vigilante punishment for crime, underscoring unresolved patterns of communal violence.^[4]

Definition and Method

Description of the Practice

Necklacing constitutes a form of extrajudicial summary execution wherein a rubber tire, saturated with gasoline or petrol, is forcibly placed around the victim's neck and upper torso, after which it is ignited, resulting in the victim being burned alive.^[5]^[6]^[7] The tire's design encircles the chest and arms, restricting movement and ensuring the flames envelop the body in a sustained manner.^[8] This practice is typically enforced by mobs, who overpower and restrain the victim prior to applying the tire, often by binding the hands or forcing the individual to the ground to prevent evasion during the setup and ignition.^[9]^[10] The immobilization techniques, combined with the weight and constriction of the tire, render escape improbable once the fire is lit.^[11] As a mob-orchestrated punishment, necklacing targets individuals suspected of offenses such as criminality or betrayal, with the public nature of the act serving to amplify its deterrent effect through visible terror and communal participation.^[12]^[13]^[7]

Mechanics and Lethality

The practice of necklacing begins with restraining the victim, often by binding the hands behind the back with wire or other materials to prevent interference, followed by forcing a rubber tire over the head, neck, and shoulders down to the waist or chest.^[14] The tire is then filled with gasoline (petrol), which serves as an accelerant due to its low flash point and rapid vaporization, enabling quick ignition upon application of a flame.^[14] Once lit, the gasoline ignites fiercely, producing flames that can reach heights of up to 20 feet, while the tire's rubber composition—primarily synthetic polymers—melts at temperatures around 200–300°C, adhering to the skin like tar and intensifying thermal damage through prolonged contact and secondary combustion.^[15] This setup constricts the victim's mobility via the tire's weight (typically 10–20 kg for a standard car tire) and positioning, rendering escape impossible without external aid, and the fire's radiant and convective heat rapidly escalates to cause full-thickness (third-degree) burns across the exposed upper body, including the head, neck, torso, and arms, often encompassing a significant portion of the total body surface area.^[14] Lethality stems primarily from the synergistic effects of extreme thermal injury, hypovolemic shock from massive fluid loss through damaged skin, and acute respiratory compromise. The intense heat denatures proteins in tissues, leading to coagulation necrosis and systemic inflammatory response; concurrently, inhalation of superheated gases and smoke causes edema and charring of the airways, precipitating asphyxia or respiratory failure.^[16] Pain-induced catecholamine surge can trigger cardiac arrhythmias or cardiogenic shock, while untreated burn shock from capillary permeability exacerbates organ failure. Death typically occurs within 10–20 minutes, though some accounts describe the process extending to around 20 minutes as the victim convulses before succumbing, with survival exceedingly rare absent immediate extinguishment and advanced medical care such as fluid resuscitation and airway management.^[14] ^[17] Forensic examinations of necklacing victims reveal characteristic patterns, including remnants of charred tire rubber fused to the neck and torso, extensive carbonization of soft tissues rendering identification difficult, and evidence of perimortem burns with soot deposition in the trachea indicating ante-mortem inhalation injury. Autopsies document hyperaemia and blistering in uncharred areas, confirming the fire's progression from superficial to deep dermal destruction, while toxicology may detect elevated carbon monoxide levels from incomplete combustion contributing to hypoxia.^[18] ^[16] These findings distinguish necklacing from other incendiary deaths by the ligature-like tire imprint and localized melt patterns, underscoring the method's design for inescapable, rapid incineration.^[18]

Origins and Historical Context in South Africa

Emergence in the Early 1980s

Necklacing first emerged as a method of mob execution in South African townships during the mid-1980s, amid intensifying anti-apartheid unrest that began escalating in 1984 with events such as the Vaal uprising.^[1] The practice evolved from earlier forms of communal punishment, including stonings, beatings, and sporadic burnings of suspected collaborators or witches, as township residents sought more decisive and symbolically potent means to enforce collective discipline when formal authority structures collapsed.^[1] Initial documented instances included a case in KwaNobuhle, Eastern Cape, in March 1985, where a town councilor accused of corruption was targeted, marking the method's transition to a politically charged vigilante tool.^[1] By mid-1985, necklacing had appeared in the East Rand townships, with the killing of Maki Skosana in Duduza on July 20, 1985—on suspicion of involvement in a grenade attack—as one of the earliest high-profile cases, broadcast and sparking national attention.^[19] This incident directly preceded President P.W. Botha's declaration of a nationwide state of emergency on July 21, 1985, which, while expanding police powers, coincided with deepened community distrust of state forces and restricted their effective penetration into townships due to heightened resistance and logistical challenges.^[1] The emergency's media blackout and curfews inadvertently amplified reliance on informal, self-administered justice, as residents bypassed perceived complicit or absent policing to target individuals viewed as aiding the apartheid regime.^[2] The method was primarily adopted by young township militants, often termed comtsotsis—politicized youth blending comrade ideology with street toughness—operating within ANC-aligned structures such as the Congress of South African Students (COSAS).^[1] These groups organized "kangaroo courts" or street committees to adjudicate accusations of collaboration, using necklacing to assert control and deter perceived traitors in areas where state influence waned.^[1] This grassroots enforcement reflected broader dynamics of township self-governance amid the breakdown of black local councils boycotted since 1983-1984.^[1]

Apartheid-Era Township Dynamics

Apartheid's influx control laws, enforced through passbooks and the Native Urban Areas Act amendments, restricted black South Africans' permanent urban residence, compelling millions to live as temporary migrant laborers in peripheral townships while designating rural bantustans as nominal homelands.^[20] This system, culminating in the Bantu Homelands Citizenship Act of 1970, stripped black citizens of South African nationality and funneled labor to white urban economies, resulting in severe overcrowding as illegal urban influxes evaded controls.^[21] By the late 1970s, township populations had swelled due to forced relocations under the Group Areas Act—displacing over 3 million people between 1960 and 1983 into underserviced areas with inadequate housing and infrastructure, fostering chronic unemployment rates exceeding 30% in places like Soweto.^[22] These policies engendered weak municipal governance, as state-appointed councils lacked legitimacy and resources, leaving communities reliant on informal self-policing amid resource scarcity and police absenteeism from routine enforcement. The resultant social fragmentation amplified intra-community suspicions, particularly toward impimpis—informants collaborating with apartheid security forces to suppress dissent—which eroded trust in a context of pervasive surveillance and raids.^[23] Township administrations, undermined by boycotts and corruption, failed to mediate disputes, allowing vigilante groups to fill governance voids and target perceived collaborators as existential threats to collective resistance.^[24] Rapid, unplanned urbanization from 1970s relocations correlated with escalating violence, as evidenced by the Vaal Triangle uprisings from 1984, where population pressures and service breakdowns precipitated cycles of retribution against informants and rivals.^[25] Forced urbanization disrupted traditional rural authorities, transplanting heterogeneous groups into townships without established hierarchies, which compounded youth disenfranchisement amid high school dropout rates and exclusion from formal economies.^[26] Underground ANC networks, operating via clandestine cells since the 1976 Soweto uprising, radicalized township youth through student organizations like COSAS, channeling grievances into militant structures that prioritized purging internal threats over institutional mediation.^[27] This dynamic, while rooted in apartheid's engineered instability, intensified factional enforcement, as youth cadres assumed de facto control in the absence of viable alternatives, heightening the resort to extrajudicial measures against suspected disloyalty.^[28]

Necklacing During the Apartheid Struggle

Targets and Perpetrators

The primary targets of necklacing during the apartheid struggle were black South Africans accused of collaborating with security forces, including police informants derogatorily termed impimpis or individuals suspected of betraying anti-apartheid activists by providing information to authorities. These victims, often ordinary township residents, faced summary accusations in informal settings lacking evidentiary standards or due process, as part of efforts to purge perceived internal threats amid escalating township unrest.^[15]^[29] Perpetrators consisted mainly of young black militants, known as "comrades," who formed vigilante groups in townships and operated extrajudicial "people's courts" to adjudicate alleged betrayals. These actors were typically affiliated with the United Democratic Front (UDF), a broad anti-apartheid coalition aligned with the African National Congress (ANC), and drew from youth cadres radicalized by school boycotts, consumer campaigns, and resistance to state-imposed structures like black local councils.^[1]^[30]^[31] The dynamics highlighted intra-community enforcement, with necklacing serving as a tool for youth-led factions to assert control and deter collaboration during periods of intense state repression that disrupted traditional authority and policing in black townships. This resulted in predominantly black-on-black executions, framing the practice as an instrument of internal discipline rather than exclusively anti-state resistance.^[14]^[29]

Scale and Notable Cases

Necklacing reached its height between 1985 and 1987 amid intensifying township unrest and successive states of emergency imposed by the apartheid regime, with the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) estimating at least 400 victims during the mid-1980s.^[3] TRC data indicate approximately 700 deaths from necklacing or related burnings occurred nationwide between 1984 and 1989, peaking in 1986 with 306 such fatalities.^[29] These figures reflect underreporting, as the TRC's database captured only 191 confirmed necklacing cases, underscoring the practice's role in vigilante enforcement against perceived collaborators.^[29] Notable incidents in 1986 highlighted the frequency in areas like the East Rand and Nelspruit (in the Highveld region), where multiple daily occurrences were reported during unrest peaks.^[32] On 3 July, student activist Lucky Mnisi was burned after being coerced into police collaboration, followed by Frank Mlotshwa's similar fate in September, both labeled informants by crowds.^[3] An earlier emblematic case involved Maki Skhosana's necklacing in July 1985 on the East Rand, where she was accused of complicity in the deaths of COSAS activists.^[3] Although primarily directed at adult males suspected of informing or council affiliations, women and children faced targeting in familial reprisals, such as sons of community councillors killed alongside fathers or mothers accused of witchcraft aiding security forces.^[29] These patterns emerged from community paranoia, exacerbated by state infiltration tactics.^[3] By the late 1980s, necklacing waned due to external pressures from ANC leadership urging restraint, including official condemnations by figures like Oliver Tambo, though public messaging remained ambivalent toward mass actions.^[3]^[31] This shift aligned with broader efforts to curb internal violence as negotiations loomed.^[29]

Political Endorsements and Internal Debates

Winnie Madikizela-Mandela publicly endorsed necklacing as a tool of liberation during a rally in Munsieville on April 13, 1986, declaring, "Together hand in hand, with our boxes of matches and our necklaces we shall liberate this country," framing it as a necessary act in the struggle against apartheid.^[33]^[34] This statement aligned with broader militant rhetoric within segments of the anti-apartheid movement, where such tactics were viewed by proponents as deterrents against perceived collaborators and enforcers of township "ungovernability" to undermine state authority.^[31] In contrast, Anglican Archbishop Desmond Tutu condemned necklacing explicitly, intervening in at least one instance to prevent its execution and speaking against it at a mass funeral in July 1985 following the state of emergency, arguing it contradicted the moral imperatives of the liberation struggle.^[35]^[36] ANC President Oliver Tambo and other leaders expressed reservations, discouraging the practice in public statements while avoiding outright bans, as Tambo noted in 1987 that the organization had not formally condemned it due to its grassroots origins but urged restraint to preserve unity.^[37]^[31] Internal debates within the ANC and United Democratic Front (UDF) centered on necklacing's tactical efficacy versus its risks, with some activists defending it as a spontaneous response that intimidated informants and advanced the goal of rendering townships ungovernable, as echoed in ANC directives from 1985.^[38] Critics within these groups, including UDF officials who issued multiple condemnations, contended it exacerbated black-on-black violence, eroded the movement's ethical standing, and provided propaganda fodder for the apartheid regime to portray the struggle as anarchic.^[30]^[31] This ambivalence persisted without formal resolution, reflecting tensions between immediate revolutionary imperatives and long-term political legitimacy.^[31]

Post-Apartheid Developments in South Africa

Decline After 1994

Following the transition to democracy in 1994, necklacing incidents in South Africa plummeted, becoming exceedingly rare by the mid-1990s as the practice effectively faded from township violence.^[6]^[39] This sharp decline coincided with the reassertion of centralized state policing, which supplanted the vacuum of authority that had enabled unchecked mob executions during apartheid's final years.^[40] The establishment of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) in 1995 further eroded the political justifications for vigilante acts like necklacing by providing formal mechanisms for addressing grievances through public hearings and amnesty applications, thereby diminishing the appeal of extrajudicial retribution.^[41] Democratization shifted township power dynamics, as elected governance and restored institutional legitimacy reduced the perceived necessity for community-led deterrence against suspected informants or criminals, redirecting intra-community conflicts toward less ritualized violence such as stabbings and assaults.^[42] Official crime data from the South African Police Service reflect this trend: while overall murder rates remained elevated—peaking at over 26,000 annually around 1995 before stabilizing—specific reports of tire-based burnings vanished from records, indicating necklacing's obsolescence amid broader vigilantism.^[39] By 2005, analyses confirmed that such apartheid-era tactics "no longer exist," supplanted by conventional weaponry in persistent disputes.^[39]

Sporadic Revivals and Modern Instances

In the post-apartheid era, necklacing persisted in isolated instances tied to vigilante responses against perceived criminals, rather than organized political violence. During the May 2008 xenophobic riots, which displaced over 50,000 people and killed 62, some attacks involved burning victims in ways evocative of necklacing, though not always using tires specifically, amid broader mob actions against foreign nationals accused of economic competition.^[43]^[44] A cluster of cases occurred in July 2011 in New Brighton township, Port Elizabeth, Eastern Cape, where residents executed four suspected thieves via necklacing over one month, forcing tires around victims' necks, dousing them with petrol, and igniting them in response to house robberies and murders.^[6]^[45] Media reports questioned if this signaled a "return," but records indicated only one prior case in the preceding decade, underscoring the events' sporadic nature rather than revival.^[6] These incidents aligned with broader vigilantism amid frustrations over crime and policing inefficacy, including during service delivery protests, but did not escalate into widespread practice.^[46] South African Police Service reports through 2019 noted mob justice killings, including occasional necklacing on streets to humiliate suspects, yet without evidence of systemic resurgence.^[46] From 2012 onward, documented cases remained infrequent, such as a 2012 necklacing of an alleged criminal in the Western Cape, contrasting with persistent high violent crime rates—over 20,000 murders annually—but a evident shift from apartheid-era ritualistic executions to ad hoc vigilantism in townships.^[47] Official crime statistics up to 2024 show no major upticks in necklacing, embedded instead in general homicide trends exceeding 27,000 yearly, linked to ongoing social stressors like inequality and service failures without reverting to the method's former prevalence.^[48]

Necklacing in Other Regions

Haiti

Necklacing, known locally as Père Lebrun after a prominent Haitian tire retailer whose advertisements depicted him emerging from a tire, emerged in Haiti following the February 7, 1986, flight of dictator Jean-Claude Duvalier.^[49] In the ensuing chaos, mobs across Port-au-Prince and provincial towns targeted remnants of the Tonton Macoute paramilitary force and other perceived collaborators with the Duvalier regime, employing lynching methods including the placement of gasoline-soaked automobile tires around victims' necks before ignition.^[50] On February 9, 1986, for instance, one such execution involved stripping and burning a suspect alive using gasoline and tires amid widespread revenge killings that claimed dozens of lives in the capital alone.^[51]^[50] These post-Duvalier lynchings reflected popular retribution against the Macoutes' decades-long reign of terror under François and Jean-Claude Duvalier, during which the militia enforced repression through arbitrary arrests, torture, and extrajudicial killings.^[52] Waves of mob violence in 1986 and into the late 1980s focused on suspected regime loyalists, with Père Lebrun becoming a favored extrajudicial punishment symbolizing communal justice in the absence of functioning state institutions.^[53] The practice persisted amid political instability, including during the transitional period leading to Jean-Bertrand Aristide's 1990 election, where it served as a tool for settling scores against Duvalier-era figures rather than racial or township conflicts seen elsewhere.^[53] Under Aristide's brief initial presidency (February to September 1991), necklacing continued, with at least 25 documented mob lynchings reported, some involving tires.^[54] Aristide himself referenced Père Lebrun positively in a September 27, 1991, speech, describing burning-tire execution as an "elegant" and "beautiful instrument" for addressing injustice, which critics argued inflamed vigilantism.^[55]^[56] Following the 1991 coup against Aristide and his 1994 restoration, the practice declined in frequency as formal governance partially stabilized, though it reemerged sporadically in contexts of gang-related violence, such as mob killings of suspected criminals using tire burnings in Port-au-Prince as recently as April 2023.^[57]^[58]

South Asia (Sri Lanka and India)

In Sri Lanka, necklacing emerged as a method of extrajudicial execution amid the ethnic tensions of the 1983 Black July riots, where Sinhalese mobs targeted Tamil civilians, businesses, and properties, pioneering the practice by dousing tires with gasoline and igniting them around victims' necks to ensure prolonged suffering and public terror.^[59] ^[60] This occurred against the backdrop of the escalating Tamil insurgency led by the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), though primary attribution in 1983 was to Sinhalese perpetrators responding to LTTE attacks that killed 13 soldiers on July 23.^[59] The practice intensified during the 1987–1989 Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna (JVP) insurrection, a Marxist-Leninist uprising by Sinhalese youth against the government and Indian Peace Keeping Force (IPKF), reaching its peak with numerous cases of suspected JVP supporters being killed via necklacing on streets and after arrests by security forces or vigilantes.^[61] For instance, in August 1989, following the detention of 200 alleged JVP activists in Panadura, four bodies were discovered necklaced shortly after, highlighting its role in counterinsurgent reprisals amid the parallel LTTE conflict.^[61] Human Rights Watch documented ongoing reports of necklacing as part of broader atrocities, including against perceived informers, in the late 1980s chaos enveloping both ethnic and ideological insurgencies.^[62] The method's appeal in these rural and semi-urban settings stemmed from readily available vehicle tires and kerosene, enabling low-logistics executions suited to insurgent-state skirmishes without firearms.^[63] In India, necklacing has not been verifiably documented as a systematic tactic in Northeast ethnic insurgencies, such as those in Assam during the 1990s United Liberation Front of Asom (ULFA) campaigns, or in Naxalite-Maoist areas, where executions more commonly involved beheadings, shootings, or IEDs against suspected informers and state collaborators.^[64] ^[65] Sporadic insurgent violence in jungle terrains of the Northeast and central India favored resource-efficient methods, but no peer-reviewed or governmental reports confirm widespread tire-based burnings, distinguishing these conflicts from Sri Lanka's documented cases.^[66] ^[65]

West Africa (Ivory Coast and Nigeria)

In Ivory Coast, necklacing emerged during the 2010-2011 post-election crisis, amid ethnic tensions between southern supporters of incumbent Laurent Gbagbo and northern-backed opposition leader Alassane Ouattara. Pro-Gbagbo militias, including the Young Patriots led by Charles Blé Goudé, employed the method against individuals perceived as northern collaborators or foreign immigrants sympathetic to Ouattara, often at makeshift roadblocks in Abidjan and other urban areas. Human Rights Watch documented such executions as part of broader atrocities by Gbagbo forces, which fueled the short civil war and subsequent International Criminal Court prosecutions.^[67] In Nigeria, necklacing has been reported primarily in the Niger Delta region since the 1990s, within the context of oil-related militancy and resource disputes involving ethnic minorities like the Ijaw and Ogoni against state forces and multinational companies. Vigilante groups and local mobs used it to punish suspected thieves, collaborators with oil firms, or informants in ungoverned rural and creekside areas lacking effective policing. U.S. State Department human rights reports from the early 2000s noted its persistence, particularly as a form of extrajudicial enforcement amid escalating kidnappings and pipeline sabotage by militants such as those under Ken Saro-Wiwa's successors or later Movement for the Emancipation of the Niger Delta factions. Human Rights Watch observed its role in inter-communal vigilantism, where tires soaked in gasoline were ignited around victims' necks to deter perceived betrayals in resource conflicts.^[68]^[69]

Brazil

In Brazil, the practice analogous to necklacing is known as the "microwave oven" (forno de micro-ondas), whereby victims are forced into a stack of tires doused with gasoline or other accelerants and set ablaze, leading to rapid carbonization and death. This method has been documented primarily in urban slums (favelas) of cities like Rio de Janeiro, where it served as a brutal tool of informal justice administered by drug trafficking organizations or community-aligned militias against suspected thieves, rivals, or police informants during heightened violence in the 1990s and 2000s.^[70]^[71] Forensic analyses describe it as a deliberate execution technique favored by narcotraffickers to eliminate perceived betrayers, with the enclosed tire structure intensifying burns and complicating body identification.^[72] In Rio de Janeiro's favelas, such executions occurred amid territorial disputes between factions like Comando Vermelho and emerging militias, often targeting individuals accused of aiding authorities or engaging in intra-community crimes that undermined gang-enforced order. These acts exemplified vigilante anti-crime measures in state-absent zones, where perpetrators viewed informants or opportunistic criminals as existential threats warranting exemplary punishment to deter collaboration and maintain territorial control. Cases highlighted the method's gruesome efficiency, with victims suffering lethal thermal injuries before potential asphyxiation, as evidenced in medico-legal examinations of charred remains.^[73] The rollout of Pacifying Police Units (UPP) beginning in 2008 in Rio's favelas curtailed overt instances by reasserting state presence and disrupting criminal autonomy, reducing overall extrajudicial killings through sustained occupation and community policing.^[74] Despite this, the practice lingers in peripheral or reconquered areas reliant on parallel justice systems, with forensic reports confirming sporadic use into the 2010s and beyond as a vestige of favela governance vacuums.^[75]

Additional Global Occurrences

Isolated reports of necklacing have occasionally surfaced in contexts of political upheaval or tribal conflict outside primary regions, but these lack corroboration from reputable sources and do not indicate systemic adoption. For example, during Zimbabwe's fast-track land reform program from 2000 onward, farm invasions and extrajudicial killings occurred amid economic collapse and political violence, yet no verified instances of tire-based executions were recorded in contemporary analyses or human rights reports.^[76] Similarly, Papua New Guinea's highlands have seen escalating tribal warfare since the 1990s, intensified by firearms and resulting in hundreds of deaths annually, but necklacing has not been documented as a prevalent method in conflict accounts.^[77] These unconfirmed mentions highlight the practice's failure to institutionalize globally, remaining tied to unique socio-political conditions rather than diffusing as a standardized vigilante tactic. No evidence supports widespread or recurrent use elsewhere, underscoring its rarity beyond entrenched conflict zones.

Sociological and Causal Factors

Motivations from Perpetrators' Perspectives

Perpetrators and their supporters in South African townships during the 1980s justified necklacing primarily as a form of immediate retribution against suspected informers, or impimpi, who were perceived as betraying anti-apartheid resistance by collaborating with security forces.^[31] In environments marked by profound distrust of state institutions and limited access to formal justice, it was framed as "defensive violence" to enforce community loyalty and disrupt apartheid intelligence networks.^[31] Chris Hani of the African National Congress (ANC) described it as a "mass weapon" wielded by communities against collaborators, emphasizing its role in countering regime informants amid asymmetric conflict.^[31] This rationale extended to deterrence through public terror, with perpetrators asserting that the spectacle instilled fear, reducing spying: one community member noted, "It works, after this you won’t find too many people spying for the police."^[1] Advocates highlighted practical advantages, including its low cost—relying on ubiquitous tires and gasoline—and participatory nature, enabling collective enforcement in townships where ANC-aligned "comrades" operated informal courts absent state alternatives.^[38] Alfred Nzo of the ANC endorsed it as a popular mechanism to "eliminate enemy elements," while perpetrators in cases like the 1985 Colesberg incident cited retaliation for specific betrayals, such as reporting boycott violations, to safeguard group solidarity.^[31]^[38] Some defended necklacing as a "necessary evil" in the context of apartheid's overwhelming military superiority, where communities lacked firearms and viewed it as proportionate resistance to state killings and provocations.^[38] Oliver Tambo linked such "excesses" to oppression-induced desperation, and Winnie Mandela invoked it symbolically for liberation.^[31] However, even from perpetrators' accounts, its application often extended beyond verified traitors to those accused on flimsy evidence, as in Truth and Reconciliation Commission testimonies where informants later expressed regret over targeting perceived threats like walkie-talkie users without confirmation.^[38] Empirically, claims of deterrence proved limited, as necklacing—while resulting in 400-700 deaths from 1985 onward—failed to halt regime infiltration or statewide unrest, instead escalating cycles of retaliation without dismantling informant networks.^[31]^[38] Perpetrator reflections, such as those in Colesberg, revealed internal recognition of misapplications harming innocents and eroding moral cohesion, underscoring its inefficacy as precise justice in low-trust settings.^[38]

Cultural and Psychological Underpinnings

Necklacing reflects entrenched cultural motifs in Bantu-speaking African communities, where witchcraft accusations historically triggered punitive burnings to purge malevolent forces believed to undermine social cohesion.^[1] Anthropological examinations trace these practices to traditional justice systems that equated sorcerers or traitors with existential threats, employing fire as a purifying agent to destroy evil essences and disrupt harmful spiritual linkages.^[1] The tire's encircling form evokes ritualistic containment of deviance, channeling communal rituals into spectacles that reaffirm group boundaries amid uncertainty.^[1] From a psychological vantage, necklacing manifests deindividuation in crowd contexts, eroding personal restraint as participants merge into an anonymous collective, heightening impulsivity and aggression through diffused responsibility.^[78] ^[38] Obedience to informal hierarchies, such as those led by assertive youth enforcers, further entrenches this dynamic, compelling conformity to escalating norms where individual moral inhibitions yield to perceived group imperatives for purification.^[38] These mechanisms parallel recurrent burnings of accused witches across pre-colonial African societies, where supernatural dreads prompted vigilante expulsions of "evil" independent of centralized governance.^[1] Empirical patterns in anthropological records show such violence surging during social disruptions, not as artifacts of external oppression alone, but as amplifications of indigenous beliefs in the absence of institutional deterrence.^[1]

Controversies and Long-Term Impact

Ethical and Legal Critiques

Necklacing constitutes a form of torture and extrajudicial execution prohibited under international human rights law, including the United Nations Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, which defines torture as any act inflicting severe physical pain or suffering intentionally, a description fitting the prolonged burning inflicted on victims.^[79]^[80] South Africa ratified the convention in 1998, binding it to criminalize such acts and prevent their recurrence, yet the practice's persistence in vigilante contexts post-apartheid highlights enforcement gaps. Domestically, it violates the South African Constitution's protections against cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment under section 12 and the right to life under section 11, with the Truth and Reconciliation Commission documenting approximately 70 cases of necklacing or similar burnings between 1985 and 1989 as gross human rights violations.^[2] Prosecutions after 1994 have been rare, amid ongoing challenges with mob justice in townships, where state authority struggles against community-driven retribution.^[6] Ethically, necklacing has drawn condemnation for its barbarity, even from anti-apartheid leaders, who argued it eroded the moral authority of liberation movements by mirroring the regime's brutality rather than transcending it.^[30] Figures within the United Democratic Front and African National Congress publicly rejected the practice, emphasizing its incompatibility with humane resistance, though internal discourses revealed ambivalence as killings escalated from mid-1985 onward.^[31] Critics, including analysts from the Institute of Race Relations, contend that such violence inflicted self-damage on black communities by fostering cycles of intra-group terror, undermining claims to ethical superiority in the anti-apartheid struggle.^[81] Some defenses framed necklacing as an act of desperate resistance against apartheid informants, but this is rebutted by evidence of its predominant intra-racial application, with victims overwhelmingly black township residents accused of collaboration rather than direct agents of the white regime.^[2] Truth and Reconciliation Commission records confirm the targeting focused on internal purges, with black-on-black killings comprising the bulk of documented cases, thus prioritizing community control over broader anti-oppression aims and negating justifications rooted in existential threat from the state.^[32] This pattern, acknowledged in ANC submissions to the commission, highlights how the practice devolved into vigilante excess, damaging long-term prospects for reconciliation and rule of law.^[82]

Legacy in Post-Colonial Violence Narratives

Necklacing's association with African National Congress (ANC)-aligned township militants against suspected collaborators significantly tarnished the organization's moral standing in liberation narratives, as its brutality—often involving public immolation—contrasted with claims of principled resistance. Official ANC statements post-1985 escalation condemned the practice, yet lingering ambivalence in discourse, including endorsements like Winnie Madikizela-Mandela's 1986 description of it as a revolutionary tool, persisted in post-apartheid reflections, complicating the party's self-presentation as a victim of state oppression rather than perpetrator of intra-community terror.^[31]^[83] The Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), established in 1995, classified necklacing killings as gross human rights violations, with amnesty granted to over 800 applicants linked to such acts upon confession, a process critics argue entrenched impunity by prioritizing political reconciliation over accountability for civilian deaths estimated in the thousands during 1984–1990. This framework, while averting retribution, normalized extrajudicial enforcement in post-colonial South Africa, fostering governance failures where state institutions failed to supplant vigilante logics, as seen in enduring township distrust of police efficacy.^[82]^[84] In post-colonial analyses, mainstream media and academic narratives—often institutionally left-leaning—tend to contextualize necklacing as reactive "defensive violence" amid apartheid desperation, downplaying its agency-independent savagery to preserve movement legitimacy, whereas right-leaning perspectives highlight it as endogenous barbarism that alienated international allies and provided causal pretext for apartheid's security escalations, thereby extending the regime's lifespan.^[31]^[38] Recent 2025 scholarship on democratic fragility frames necklacing's impunity legacy as a causal factor in South Africa's stalled transition, where pre-1994 intra-black violence legacies intersect with inequality to erode institutional trust, perpetuating cycles of private retribution over rule-of-law adherence and explaining persistent state capture vulnerabilities.^[85]^[86]

References

[1]
[PDF] The Ritual of the Necklace | CSVR
In the upheavals of the last two decades South Africa has witnessed the establishment of burning as a means of extra-legal punishment. A widely renowned form of ...
[2]
TRC Final Report - Truth Commission - South African History Archive
Killing of 'collaborators': stabbings, necklacings and burnings. 282 Around seventy cases of necklacing or burning were reported between 1985 and 198938, mostly ...
[3]
TRC Final Report - Truth Commission - South African History Archive
The necklace became a terrible symbol of the brutalisation of political conflict in South Africa during the mid-1980s and claimed at least 400 lives.
[4]
New Situations Demand Old Magic: Necklacing in South Africa, Past ...
Nicholas Rush Smith's chapter explores collective violence in postapartheid South Africa, where vigilante violence involving an attempt to necklace alleged ...
[5]
Post-Apartheid Hopes Stained by Bloodletting - The New York Times
Jul 3, 1992 · Necklacing, an execution ritual in which a gasoline-soaked tire hung around the offender's neck is set afire, has claimed over 110 victims ...Missing: method | Show results with:method
[6]
Is necklacing returning to South Africa? - BBC News
Oct 12, 2011 · South African townships were rocked by incidents of necklacing - mob-justice punishment in which tyres are forced over victims' shoulders and set alight.
[7]
Mob justice in South Africa | Features - Al Jazeera
May 13, 2012 · Necklacing, a brutal apartheid-era murder method, is making a ... After decades of apartheid, when violence was used against the ...
[8]
[PDF] Towards constructing restorative justice: A view of crime
... necklacing‖ (the practice of execution carried out by forcing a rubber tire, filled with petrol/gasoline around a victim's chest and arms, and setting it on ...
[9]
Impact of Media Violence on Children - Senate Commerce Committee
Jun 26, 2007 · ... necklacing” him – placing tires around him so that he is immobilized, then dousing him with gasoline and setting him on fire. Vic brutally ...Missing: techniques | Show results with:techniques
[10]
Mob Justice in Burundi: Official Complicity and Impunity | HRW
Mar 26, 2010 · ... necklacing,” a gruesome form of public killing in which tires were placed around the victim's neck and set aflame.[110] Eric Niyonzima, a ...
[11]
[PDF] Liminagraphy - EUR Research Information Portal
Dec 13, 2021 · 38 During apartheid necklacing (torture and execution where a rubber tire is filled with fuel forced over the victims chest and shoulders ...Missing: gasoline techniques
[12]
Winnie Madikizela-Mandela Is Dead at 81; Fought Apartheid
Apr 2, 2018 · She was referring to “necklacing,” a form of sometimes arbitrary execution by fire using a gas-soaked tire around a supposed traitor's neck, ...Missing: method | Show results with:method
[13]
Apartheid ended 20 years ago, so why is Cape Town still 'a paradise ...
Apr 30, 2014 · “The mobs punish suspected criminals with 'necklacing',” says Swartbooi. ... execution, lawyer says. 2h ago. Baseball. Blue Jays batter Dodgers ...Missing: method | Show results with:method
[14]
South Africa The War of Blacks Against Blacks | TIME - Time Magazine
Jan 26, 1987 · This is how it happens. In the townships of South Africa, militant black youths first capture a victim. Next they chop off his hands or tie them ...
[15]
FIERY 'NECKLACE' BECOMES EMBLEM OF DEEPENING SOUTH ...
Jun 29, 1986 · South Africa's unrest over the last 21 months has acquired its own harsh emblem, it is the form of fiery execution called ''the necklace''.
[16]
Forensic Pathology of Thermal Injuries - Medscape Reference
Jul 2, 2025 · Burns of skin or other tissue are caused by fire, radiant heat, radiation, chemical, or electrical contact. Thermal burns result from any ...<|separator|>
[17]
Necklacing | Historica Wiki - Fandom
Necklacing was a form of summary execution that involved putting a tire around a victim's neck, dousing it in oil, and burning them to death over 20 minutes.Missing: time | Show results with:time
[18]
Illustrated forensic pathology : necklacing - UPSpace
In July 2024, we examined the charred remains of an unidentified adult male. Remnants of a burned tire were found to be wrapped around the neck and torso.
[19]
TRUTH COMMISSION LOOKS AT FIRST "NECKLACE" MURDER
Feb 4, 1997 · The callous murder of South Africa's first "necklace" victim, Maki Skosana, in the East Rand township of Duduza in July 1985 was examined by the Truth and ...Missing: incidents 1980s<|separator|>
[20]
[PDF] The Paradox of Apartheid - Digital Georgetown
May 9, 2011 · These „influx controls,‟ unique to Apartheid South Africa and keystone of separate development, inhibited. Black social and economic mobility.
[21]
The Homelands - South African History Online
The Bantustans were a major administrative mechanism for the removal of Blacks from the South African political system under the many laws and policies created ...
[22]
[PDF] INFLUX CONTROLS AND THEIR ABOLITION
This act was intended to bring about the separate development of whites and blacks in South. Africa and represented the completion of the apartheid system. It ...
[23]
[PDF] Vigilante violence during South Africa's period of transition - CSVR
extent of violence during South Africa's transition from apartheid rule to democracy. ... When you summarise it, [Guguletu] is a very violent township.
[24]
PATTERNS OF VIOLENCE IN THE AFRICAN TOWNSHIPS OF THE ...
May 29, 2025 · This shaped counterviolence against impimpis, the police, the hated community ... Understanding South African political violence: a new ...
[25]
[PDF] The apartheid city : construction, decline and reconstruction
Violence in the 1980's emerged in the context of the crumbling of territorial apartheid, rapid unplanned urbanisation, the ban- kruptcy of township ...
[26]
Urban violence in South Africa - IFRA-Nigeria - OpenEdition Books
This ascendancy of the youth is believed to have intensified the violence in the 1970s and 1980s, as the older members may in all probability have been less ...Missing: correlation | Show results with:correlation
[27]
Youth and the National Liberation Struggle | South African History ...
Mar 21, 2011 · This meant the youth in townships were increasingly being concentrated at schools and youth networks were beginning to have a wider reach. In ...Missing: radicalization | Show results with:radicalization
[28]
Underground operatives in the 1980s - South African History Archive
In the 1980s the ANC (and to a lesser extent the PAC) had underground activists operating inside the country. These played an important role in politicizing ...Missing: radicalization | Show results with:radicalization
[29]
TRC Final Report - Truth Commission - South African History Archive
Burning and the 'necklace'. 271 In general, the violations perpetrated by supporters of the mass opposition movement in South Africa involved the attacking of ...
[30]
NECKLACING WAS CONDEMNED, UDF LEADERS TELL TRC
May 6, 1998 · The UDF, however, had very little direct control over the development of the necklacing phenomenon. The organisation's capacity and ability to ...Missing: cadres people's
[31]
A prose of ambivalence: liberation struggle discourse on necklacing
In the November 2007 issue of ANC Today, former African National Congress (ANC) and South African State President Thabo Mbeki provided a summary of the book ...Missing: execution | Show results with:execution
[32]
'Necklacing' Deadly Sign Of Violence - The Washington Post
Jul 17, 1986 · 'Necklacing' Deadly Sign Of Violence. July 17, 1986More than ... The apartheid system puts such a terrible anger into the people it hurts.
[33]
Winnie Mandela in six quotes - BBC
Apr 3, 2018 · "With our boxes of matches and our necklaces we will liberate this country." The comment, at a rally in Johannesburg, signalled that Mrs ...Missing: 1986 | Show results with:1986
[34]
How the necklace was hung around Winnie's neck - OPINION
Apr 17, 2018 · The necklace in this context involved placing a petrol or diesel filled tire around the neck of an individual and then burning them to death.
[35]
Bishop Desmond Tutu speaking against 'necklacing' at mass funeral ...
Jul 24, 1985 · Bishop Desmond Tutu speaking against 'necklacing' at mass funeral held shortly after the 21st July 1985 State of Emergency and the recent ...
[36]
Desmond Tutu's laugh was contagious. His fight for freedom ... - NPR
Dec 26, 2021 · Perhaps the most dramatic episode was his intervention to save a young Black South African from being "necklaced," a gruesome practice in the ...
[37]
Conservative protesters staged a 'mock necklacing' outside the ... - UPI
Tambo, president of African National Congress, told reporters earlier his organization is discouraging the gruesome practice. 'We have not condemned it because ...<|separator|>
[38]
[PDF] Political Violence in South Africa: A Case Study of "Necklacing" in ...
Roger Brooke, a fellow South African, for your support while also challenging me. From the beginning, you encouraged me to start the dialogue between ubuntu and ...
[39]
[PDF] Crime and Crime Prevention in South Africa: 10 Years After
ordinary South Africans while feelings of safety continue to decline. Page ... acts such as “necklacing” no longer exists. Now, the gratuitous nature.
[40]
Land Scarcity and Urban Violence in South Africa 1990-1994
Jan 1, 1994 · The intensity of armed political violence in South Africa has generally decreased since 1994. ... justice and vigilantism still exist in ...
[41]
[PDF] Truth Commissions and Gender: Principles, Policies, and Procedures
In order to promote justice, peace, and reconciliation, government officials and nongovernmental advocates are likely to consider a variety of transitional ...
[42]
Introduction | Contradictions of Democracy: Vigilantism and Rights in ...
Put differently, opponents of vigilantism put faith in state violence as the solution to citizen violence—an irony in a place familiar with the horrible ...
[43]
[PDF] MAY 2008 VIOLENCE AGAINST FOREIGN NATIONALS IN SOUTH ...
'necklacing' were a particularly visible form of vigilantism and were often enacted against people ... 2008 Xenophobic Violence in South Africa and Its ...
[44]
Xenophobic Violence in South Africa: Rays of Hope in Terrible Times
May 22, 2008 · Xenophobic Violence in South Africa: Rays of Hope in Terrible Times ... necklacing” not seen since some of the worst days of the anti ...<|separator|>
[45]
Necklacing re-ignites in SA vigilantism - IOL
Jul 27, 2011 · Residents in New Brighton, Port Elizabeth have resorted to finding thieves, put tyres around their necks, douse them with petrol and set them ablaze.
[46]
[PDF] ANNUAL CRImE REPORT 2018/2019 - SAPS
Aug 31, 2019 · with necklacing e.g. mostly occurring on the streets rather than inside residences. The main purpose of mob justice is to humiliate and ...
[47]
[PDF] March/April 2019 Volume 63 | Number 2 - Western Cape Government
Peter and her husband who was accused in 2012 of necklacing a young albino man, Rowan du Preez, who she had been trying to rehabilitate from a life of crime ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[48]
[PDF] Victims of Crime report - Statistics South Africa
Aug 27, 2024 · • To provide complementary data on the level of crime within South Africa in addition to the statistics ... policing forums (50,3%) was most ...Missing: necklacing | Show results with:necklacing
[49]
[PDF] HAITI - Human Rights Watch
Nov 1, 1991 · The Aristide government allowed unprecedented access by the Haitian press to Haiti's prisons and thus focused considerable attention on the ...
[50]
HAITIANS TAKE OUT 28 YEARS OF ANGER ON CRYPT
Feb 9, 1986 · Most were beaten to death, but one was reportedly stripped and burned alive with gasoline and automobile tires. Advertisement. SKIP ...
[51]
ANGRY MOBS IN HAITI SAID TO TAKE REVENGE ON DUVALIER'S ...
Feb 9, 1986 · A day after the fall of the Duvalier Government that ruled Haiti for nearly three decades, sporadic violence erupted in the capital today, with many acts of ...
[52]
Tontons Macoutes | Haitian paramilitary organization - Britannica
Sep 3, 2025 · Other articles where Tontons Macoutes is discussed: François Duvalier: …aide, Clément Barbot, organized the Tontons Macoutes (“Bogeymen”), ...<|separator|>
[53]
Haiti: The Shadows of Terror | Kenneth Roth
Mar 26, 1992 · Most recently, the preferred method of lynching has been the lighting of a gasoline-soaked tire around the victim's neck—a practice called Père ...
[54]
MR. ARISTIDE'S ROLE IN MOB VIOLENCE - The Washington Post
Sep 21, 1994 · ... necklacing" during the tenure of Haitian President Jean-Bertrand Aristide. In fact, we reported 25 instances of people lynched by mobs during Mr ...Missing: 1980s | Show results with:1980s
[55]
Haiti: Shifting on Aristide? - Time Magazine
Oct 21, 1991 · ... Haiti. Most disturbing: a Sept. 27 speech in which Aristide seemed to condone Pere Lebrun, a Haitian form of lynching in which a gasoline ...
[56]
Haiti: Why The Coup Matters - Newsweek
Oct 13, 1991 · Upon his return from a U.S. tour, the president had called execution by burning tire a "beautiful instrument." Aristide escaped to Caracas only ...Missing: post- | Show results with:post-
[57]
Mob kills 13 suspected Haiti gangsters with gas-soaked tires
Apr 24, 2023 · Police and witnesses say a mob in the Haitian capital has beaten and burned 13 suspected gang members to death with gasoline-soaked tires ...Missing: Duvalier | Show results with:Duvalier
[58]
Haitians fight back against gangs, drawing support — and worry
May 15, 2023 · In one incident, a mob pulled suspected gang members from police custody, hung gasoline-soaked tires around their necks and beat and burned ...Missing: executions | Show results with:executions
[59]
This Divided Island: Stories from the Sri Lankan War review
Mar 9, 2015 · ... Tamil riots, leaving Hindu homes and restaurants smouldering across the island. It was at this time that Sinhala rioters pioneered “necklacing ...
[60]
The War To End All Wars - Esquire Middle East
Dec 20, 2014 · Tamils in mixed areas were hunted down by mobs, and their shops and homes gutted. During this time necklacing – the placing of a tyre doused in ...
[61]
Sri Lankan security forces, JVP rebels wage a bitter war - India Today
Aug 15, 1989 · Last week, an army patrol hauled in 200 suspected JVP activists in the town of Panadura. Two days later, four bodies were found "neck laced" at ...
[62]
[PDF] Human Rights in Sri Lanka
Mar 12, 1991 · horrible mutilation of young family members by Sri Lankan soldiers. Reports of disappearances, necklacing (burning live victims in tires) as ...<|separator|>
[63]
Sri Lanka slides into anarchy as trigger-happy militants run amok ...
Nov 6, 2013 · ... Sri Lanka are not done mercifully with rifles but through "necklacing": tie the arms, put a tyre round the neck, throw a tin of kerosene and ...
[64]
Insurgency in India's Northeast Cross-border Links and Strategic ...
The rebels' entry into the Himalayan Kingdom followed the first organized counter-insurgency operations that the Indian Army launched against the ULFA in Assam ...
[65]
Government, Vigilante, and Naxalite Abuses in India's Chhattisgarh ...
The armed movement by Maoist groups often called Naxalites spans four decades and 13 states in India. They purport to defend the rights of the poor, especially ...
[66]
Ethnic Insurgencies and the Crime-Insurgency Nexus in India's ...
Moreover, the partition of Assam heightened anti-Indian sentiment in Assam. This ultimately drove the outbreak of anti-Indian insurgency in Assam in the 1980s, ...
[67]
Is Ivory Coast zeal to prosecute former bad guys setting up war in ...
Mar 12, 2013 · ... Ivory Coast toward western Ivory's Coast border with Liberia, June 2011. ... Methods included the infamous “necklacing,” burning victims to death ...
[68]
Nigeria - State.gov
... Niger Delta region. Freelance security forces and former security forces ... The practice of "necklacing" criminals (placing a gasoline-soaked tire ...
[69]
Human Rights in Nigeria
Aug 22, 2000 · ... necklacing" - being burned alive by a burning tire placed around their neck. ... Nigeria: Crackdown In The Niger Delta. Reports. August 18, 2025 ...
[70]
The “microwave oven” practice in Brazil - PMC - NIH
Feb 12, 2023 · This article presents a forensic case of an unusual illegal cremation of a person using a process colloquially known as the “microwave oven” practice in Brazil.
[71]
Death in the “microwave oven”: A form of execution by carbonization
Death in the “microwave oven” has nothing to do with microwaves energy. It is the jargon name given to a criminal form of execution by carbonization.
[72]
Death in the "microwave oven": A form of execution by carbonization
Death in the "microwave oven" has nothing to do with microwaves energy. It is the jargon name given to a criminal form of execution by carbonization that ...
[73]
The Challenge of Burnt Remains from the Brazilian "Microwave Oven"
Jun 3, 2023 · The term commonly known in Brazil as the “microwave oven” death refers to the criminal act of execution, especially practiced amongst narcotraffickers.
[74]
The pacification of Brazil's urban margins: how police and traffickers ...
Oct 3, 2019 · Beginning in 2008, the Pacifying Police Units (UPP) programme was rolled out across many of the city's favelas, with the aim of establishing a ...Missing: necklacing | Show results with:necklacing
[75]
The "microwave oven" practice in Brazil - ResearchGate
Aug 6, 2025 · This report presents a case of microwave oven cremation of a body found in a rural area of Minas Gerais, Brazil. The forensic work helped ...
[76]
Why Mugabe's Land Reforms Were so Disastrous | Cato Institute
Aug 30, 2018 · In the early 2000s, Zimbabwe's former dictator Robert Mugabe gave the green light to his paramilitary supporters to invade commercial farms, ...Missing: necklacing | Show results with:necklacing
[77]
Tribal fighting in PNG's highlands has escalated into guerilla warfare ...
Sep 11, 2023 · Police have swarmed Enga Province in a desperate bid to bring a long-running tribal conflict under control.Missing: necklacing | Show results with:necklacing
[78]
Deindividuation and criminal responsibility - SciELO South Africa
This contribution assesses the social-psychological concept of deindividuation in the particular context of its use in instances of crowd violence in South ...
[79]
Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading ...
Each State Party shall ensure that all acts of torture are offences under its criminal law. The same shall apply to an attempt to commit torture and to an act ...Missing: necklacing | Show results with:necklacing
[80]
Party Led By Mandela Now Owns Up To Atrocities
May 13, 1997 · South Africa's governing party admitted today that it used torture ... necklacing'' people suspected of cooperating with the South African ...
[81]
[PDF] REviEw: People's war: New Light on the Struggle for South Africa
Necklacing is a terrifying form of extra-judicial killing, in which a motor vehicle tyre filled with petrol is hung around the victim's neck and set alight,.Missing: Jeffrey critique
[82]
ANC Second Submission to the TRC
Further submissions and responses by the African National Congress to questions raised by the Commission for Truth and Reconciliation.<|control11|><|separator|>
[83]
Why Winnie Madikizela Mandela's Legacy Is Being Debated After ...
Apr 12, 2018 · Winnie Madikizela-Mandela was an anti-apartheid activist in her own right, in addition to being married to icon and South Africa's first black president, ...Missing: condemn | Show results with:condemn<|separator|>
[84]
https://brill.com/downloadpdf/book/edcoll/9789004491311/B9789004491311_s007.pdf
[85]
South Africa's flawed transition and its implications for social justice ...
Aug 26, 2025 · As a result, the legacy of apartheid continues to shape collective memory, where mass violence and socioeconomic inequality intersect to ...
[86]
2024-05 - A violent freedom - Wits University
May 27, 2024 · A violent freedom ... Despite the knife-edge upon which South Africans live, the country is not, in fact, a failed state – but a new form of ...Missing: legacies | Show results with:legacies