Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Pariah

A pariah is a person or entity regarded with contempt or disgust and excluded from society, often due to perceived moral failing, nonconformity, or inherent inferiority.^[1]^[2] The English term derives from the Tamil paṟaiyar, denoting "drummer," which referred to the Paraiyar caste—a group of hereditary laborers in southern India who performed menial tasks such as beating drums for announcements, handling animal carcasses, and grave-digging, rendering them ritually impure and socially ostracized as untouchables under the caste system.^[3]^[4] Entered European languages via Portuguese traders in the 16th century, the word initially described these low-status Indian communities before broadening in the 17th century to signify any outcast, reflecting colonial observations of rigid social exclusion enforced by custom and pollution taboos rather than mere economic disparity.^[3]^[5] In contemporary usage, "pariah" applies to individuals, nations, or groups boycotted for deviance from norms, such as states defying international sanctions or figures alienating peers through scandal, underscoring a causal dynamic where exclusion reinforces group cohesion at the expense of the marginalized.^[1]^[5]

Etymology and Historical Origins

Linguistic Roots in Tamil and Dravidian Languages

The term pariah originates from the Tamil noun paṟaiyar, the plural form of paṟaiyan, denoting a member of a low-status occupational group associated with drumming in southern India.^[3] In Tamil, paṟaiyan literally refers to one who plays the parai, a flat, resonant drum used for announcements, funerals, weddings, and rituals, a role hereditary within certain communities.^[6] This etymology traces to the mid-17th century, with European records first attesting the borrowed form around 1610 in Portuguese colonial texts describing Tamil social structures.^[3] Tamil, a classical language of the Dravidian family spoken primarily in Tamil Nadu and parts of Sri Lanka, provides the primary linguistic root, with no direct Proto-Dravidian reconstruction attested for paṟai beyond its Tamil phonology and semantics tied to percussion instruments.^[7] Cognates appear in related Dravidian languages, such as Malayalam paṟayan, similarly denoting drummers or laborers from analogous castes, reflecting shared South Dravidian vocabulary for ritual and menial roles.^[7] The Paraiyar caste, from which the term derives, encompassed village servants performing tasks like beating drums to summon assemblies, handling executions, and leatherwork, positions that reinforced their exclusion from higher varna interactions under traditional Hindu social ordering.^[8] Linguistically, paṟai embodies Dravidian phonetic features, including retroflex consonants (ṟ) and agglutinative morphology, distinguishing it from Indo-Aryan influences in northern India; the word's adoption highlights colonial encounters with Tamil caste nomenclature rather than broader Dravidian substrate effects.^[4] Ethnographic accounts from the early 20th century, drawing on 19th-century missionary linguistics, confirm the term's non-Sanskritic origin, attributing it solely to Tamil occupational descriptors without pejorative intent in pre-colonial usage.^[6]

Integration into European Lexicons via Colonial Encounters

The term pariah entered European lexicons through Portuguese colonial engagements in southern India beginning in the late 15th century, following Vasco da Gama's voyage to Calicut in 1498, which facilitated sustained trade and missionary activities in Tamil-speaking regions. Derived from the Tamil paraiyar—referring to a hereditary caste group tasked with drumming at festivals using the parai instrument and other village services deemed ritually impure—the word was adapted as paria by Portuguese observers to describe these low-status individuals encountered in coastal enclaves like Cochin and Negapatam.^[3] This adoption reflected early European documentation of India's caste hierarchies, with Portuguese lexicons incorporating paria to denote untouchables by the 16th century, as evidenced in traveler accounts and administrative records from their Indian possessions. The term's dissemination accelerated via shared colonial networks; it appeared in English by the 1610s, with the Oxford English Dictionary recording its earliest attestation in 1613 within Samuel Purchas's Purchas His Pilgrimes, a compilation drawing from Portuguese and English voyage narratives that highlighted social exclusion mechanisms observed in Madras and environs.^[9]^[3]^[8] From Portuguese intermediaries, pariah permeated French and other continental languages in the 17th century, evolving beyond caste specificity to signify any ostracized figure, influenced by analogies to European social rejects in missionary reports and literature. By the 19th century, this generalized usage solidified, as seen in French dramatist Casimir Delavigne's 1821 play La Paria, which dramatized the term's outcast connotation for metropolitan audiences familiar with colonial ethnographies.^[4]^[3]

Evolution from Caste-Specific Term to General Outcast Denotation

The term pariah originated in the Tamil language as paraiyar (plural of paraiyan), referring specifically to members of the Paraiyar caste in southern India, a group historically associated with drumming at funerals and festivals, as well as other polluting occupations like handling animal carcasses, which positioned them as untouchables outside the mainstream varna system.^[3] This caste-specific designation entered Portuguese as paria during early colonial contacts in the 16th century, reflecting European observers' encounters with the rigid social exclusion of these communities in Tamil Nadu and Kerala.^[7] By the early 17th century, the word appeared in English around 1613, initially denoting only this low Hindu caste or analogous outcaste groups in India, as documented in travelogues and administrative records from British and Portuguese traders who equated Paraiyars with the broader category of "untouchables."^[1] During the 18th century, colonial ethnographies and missionary accounts broadened the term's application within European lexicons to encompass any of India's depressed classes beyond just the Paraiyars, driven by administrators' need to categorize diverse low-status laborers under a single label for governance and labor recruitment purposes.^[3] This shift was evident in British East India Company documents, where pariah described itinerant workers or those deemed socially inferior, detached from precise caste nomenclature, as Europeans imposed their own hierarchical interpretations on Indian society without fully grasping endogenous distinctions.^[5] The semantic expansion accelerated in the early 19th century; by 1819, the term's meaning had generalized to "social outcast" in English, applicable to any individual rejected by society regardless of ethnic or cultural context, as seen in literary and journalistic usages that metaphorically extended it to European social dynamics.^[3] This evolution from a caste-bound ethnonym to a universal descriptor of exclusion reflected linguistic borrowing patterns in colonial empires, where specific foreign terms for marginalized groups were repurposed for broader normative critiques, unmoored from their original ritual and occupational connotations.^[10] Examples include 19th-century novels and essays employing pariah for dissident intellectuals or moral reprobates in Western settings, illustrating how the word's pejorative force—rooted in observed Indian social ostracism—facilitated its adaptation to denote voluntary or imposed alienation in non-Indian contexts.^[7] By the mid-19th century, dictionaries like the American Heritage Dictionary formalized this dual usage, retaining the caste reference alongside the outcast sense, underscoring the term's detachment from its Dravidian specificity.^[7]

Sociological and Anthropological Dimensions

Ostracism, the deliberate exclusion or ignoring of individuals, functions as a core mechanism of social exclusion across cultures, serving to enforce norms and deter free-riding by imposing relational and survival costs without direct violence.^[11] Anthropological evidence indicates this process is adaptive in small-scale societies, where dependence on group cooperation for resources amplifies exclusion's punitive impact; for instance, in hunter-gatherer and pastoral groups, ostracizing non-cooperators maintains collective benefits, as violators risk isolation from shared food, protection, and mating opportunities.^[12] Evolutionary models demonstrate that such exclusion evolves in repeated social interactions, where groups punish defectors to sustain long-term cooperation, with empirical simulations showing higher cooperation rates when exclusion is possible.^[13] In tribal contexts, honor-based codes exemplify targeted ostracism: among Pathan hill tribes, Pukhtunwali prescribes social boycott for breaches like dishonoring kin, eroding the offender's alliances and economic standing in kin-based networks.^[14] Similarly, Amish communities apply Meidung, a formal shunning of rule-breakers, which severs social ties and communal support while allowing limited material aid, thereby pressuring reintegration through remorse.^[15] These practices highlight causal realism in exclusion: relational severance exploits humans' evolved aversion to isolation, akin to physical pain in neural activation, as cross-cultural experiments confirm uniform distress responses.^[16] Religious frameworks formalize exclusion via excommunication, designating doctrinal deviants as pariahs through mandated avoidance, preserving group purity in tight-knit sects.^[17] In modern settings, analogous mechanisms persist through gossip and reputational sabotage, which propagate deviance labels and curtail network access, with longitudinal data revealing cumulative effects like resource denial and participation barriers that entrench outcast status.^[18] Across scales—from tribal shunning to institutional bans—empirical patterns underscore exclusion's role in causal enforcement of cohesion, though outcomes vary by societal interdependence, with higher lethality in resource-scarce environments.^[19]

Functional Role in Group Cohesion and Norm Enforcement

Social exclusion, manifested as pariah status, functions to bolster group cohesion by deterring deviance and incentivizing adherence to cooperative norms, as individuals weigh the costs of isolation against norm compliance.^[16] In evolutionary terms, this mechanism evolved in ancestral human groups where exclusion of non-cooperators prevented the erosion of mutual benefits, thereby enhancing collective survival in resource-scarce environments.^[20] Empirical models indicate that ostracism acts as a low-cost punishment strategy, more efficient than physical aggression, allowing groups to maintain internal harmony without depleting resources on constant conflict resolution.^[15] From a game-theoretic perspective, pariah designation emerges in repeated interactions as a credible threat that sustains cooperation; by excluding freeriders from shared benefits, groups achieve higher long-term payoffs than in scenarios without such enforcement.^[13] Simulations demonstrate that exclusion evolves preferentially over alternatives like reputation tracking alone, particularly in anonymous or large-scale settings where direct reciprocity falters, thus reinforcing norm stability and reducing defection rates by up to 15-20% in modeled populations.^[21] This aligns with observations in human experiments where anticipated ostracism elevates contributions to public goods, as participants conform to avoid pariah outcomes.^[22] Anthropological evidence underscores this role in diverse societies, where pariah-like exclusion—whether caste-based or ad hoc—preserves group boundaries against internal threats, such as norm violators who could undermine trust or resource allocation.^[23] For instance, in small-scale hunter-gatherer bands, simulated through agent-based models, excluding even a single persistent deviant restores cooperative equilibria, preventing cascade failures in altruism that historically imperiled group viability.^[24] While individual suffering is acute, the net effect fortifies collective resilience, as evidenced by cross-cultural patterns where societies employing ostracism exhibit tighter norm enforcement and lower free-riding incidence compared to those relying solely on kin-based ties.^[25]

Empirical Evidence from Evolutionary Psychology and Game Theory

In evolutionary psychology, social exclusion mechanisms, including the designation of individuals as outcasts or pariahs, are posited to have arisen as adaptations to enforce cooperation in ancestral small-scale societies where survival depended on group cohesion. Empirical support derives from cross-cultural universality of ostracism responses, observed in laboratory paradigms like Cyberball, where even brief simulated exclusion activates neural pain centers akin to physical injury, indicating an evolved hypersensitivity to rejection threats that historically signaled risk of foraging deprivation or predation vulnerability.^[26] This detection system, shaped by selection pressures favoring inclusive fitness in kin-based groups, calibrates individuals to prioritize reintegration over defiance, as evidenced by meta-analyses showing consistent behavioral shifts toward prosociality post-exclusion across diverse populations.^[11] Game-theoretic models formalize exclusion as a stable strategy for sustaining cooperation in iterated social dilemmas, such as public goods games, where free-riders erode collective benefits. Simulations demonstrate that ostracism—expelling defectors from future interactions—outperforms alternatives like costly fines by minimizing group size reduction while deterring non-cooperators, achieving near-full cooperation equilibria under realistic costs, as in agent-based models where punishing cooperators selectively exclude low-contributors from resource pools.^[13] Experimental validations in economic games confirm this: participants in ostracism-enabled public goods scenarios contribute 20-30% more to commons than in punishment-free controls, with exclusion rates correlating inversely with defection, underscoring causal efficacy in norm enforcement without requiring universal altruism.^[27] These findings align with evolutionary predictions, as exclusion equilibria emerge robustly in finite populations mimicking ancestral group dynamics, preventing defector proliferation that could dissolve cooperative clusters.^[28]

Philosophical and Ethical Debates

First-Principles Justifications for Pariah Status

From foundational axioms of human social organization, groups form to amplify individual survival through division of labor, mutual defense, and resource pooling, yet these arrangements are vulnerable to defection where self-interested actors exploit collective efforts without reciprocating. Ostracism, by rendering defectors as pariahs, severs their access to group benefits, thereby restoring incentives for cooperation as the dominant strategy in repeated interactions. Evolutionary game models illustrate this dynamic: in simulations of mixed populations, excluders—those who preferentially remove non-cooperators—achieve higher payoffs than defectors, who receive zero after exclusion, favoring the spread of exclusionary behaviors over costly physical punishment.^[29]^[13] Causally, unchecked defection propagates via imitation and erosion of reciprocity, leading to collective inaction akin to the tragedy of the commons, where rational foresight of exploitation dissolves voluntary associations. Ostracism interrupts this cascade by imposing a credible threat of isolation, which empirical studies in public goods games substantiate: groups voting to exclude low contributors sustain higher cooperation rates than those without such mechanisms, as exclusion targets verifiable non-reciprocators without excessive collateral harm.^[30]^[31] This aligns with first-principles reasoning from self-preservation: just as kin selection prioritizes genetic continuity, groups exclude threats to inclusive fitness to prevent subgroup collapse, evidenced by agent-based models where optional participation combined with ostracism evolves stable cooperators by filtering out persistent exploiters.^[32] Philosophically, norm enforcement via pariah status derives from the causal realism of incentives: without graduated sanctions culminating in exclusion, norms lack teeth, as actors discount future repercussions relative to immediate gains from violation. Anthropological precedents in small-scale societies, where shunning enforces foraging reciprocity, underscore this; failure to ostracize leads to measurable declines in group productivity and stability.^[33] Thus, while pariah designation imposes individual hardship, it causally upholds the mutualistic equilibria necessary for human flourishing beyond solitary existence, privileging empirical group outcomes over egalitarian ideals unsubstantiated by defection dynamics.^[19]

Criticisms and Human Rights Perspectives

Human rights organizations have extensively criticized the pariah status, originating from the treatment of low-caste groups like the Paraiyars in India's traditional social order, as a form of systemic discrimination that denies basic dignity and equality. Reports document ongoing practices of untouchability, including physical segregation from upper castes in villages, denial of entry to temples and wells, and social boycotts for perceived transgressions.^[34] Such exclusion has resulted in measurable disparities, with Dalits—modern descendants of pariah castes—experiencing higher rates of poverty, illiteracy, and malnutrition; for example, a 2007 joint analysis by Human Rights Watch and the Center for Human Rights and Global Justice described this as a "hidden apartheid" affecting over 160 million people in India, with limited government enforcement of anti-discrimination laws like the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act of 1989.^[35] Violence against those in pariah-like positions further underscores these criticisms, with thousands of reported atrocities annually, including murders, rapes, and forced labor. The National Crime Records Bureau in India recorded over 50,000 crimes against Scheduled Castes in 2022, though underreporting is widespread due to fear of reprisal and police complicity.^[36] From a human rights viewpoint, this hereditary stigmatization violates core principles of international law, such as Article 7 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights prohibiting discrimination and Article 26 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights mandating equal protection. The United Nations has equated caste-based exclusion with descent-based discrimination under CERD, affecting an estimated 260 million people worldwide and entailing massive breaches of economic, social, and cultural rights, including access to land, water, and fair wages.^[37] Philosophically, pariah status is faulted for entrenching a determinism of birth over merit or individual action, reducing human potential to immutable group identity and fostering dehumanization. Critics argue this contradicts Enlightenment-derived notions of inherent human worth, as articulated in frameworks emphasizing autonomy and reciprocal obligations, where exclusion based on ascribed traits undermines societal moral progress.^[38] However, human rights advocates, often drawing from NGO and UN sources, emphasize that while cultural defenses invoke relativism, empirical evidence of correlated harms—like elevated suicide rates among Dalits (31.7 per 100,000 in 2019 per NCRB data)—prioritizes universal protections over tradition.^[39] These perspectives highlight enforcement gaps in nations like India, where constitutional affirmative action exists but fails to dismantle entrenched norms, perpetuating intergenerational exclusion.^[40] Broader applications to non-caste pariahs, such as ethnic or ideological outcasts in other societies, invoke similar concerns under human rights law, framing ostracism as a denial of social participation and psychological well-being. Psychological studies link chronic exclusion to mental health crises, aligning with rights to health and community under ICESCR, though causal links to policy failures remain debated amid source biases in advocacy-driven reporting.^[41]

Balancing Individual Rights with Collective Stability

Social exclusion mechanisms, including pariah designation, have been analyzed through game-theoretic models demonstrating their role in fostering cooperation within groups. In a 2013 study published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, researchers developed a model where cooperators exclude freeriders from resource sharing, resulting in higher overall group payoffs compared to scenarios without exclusion; simulations showed exclusion equilibria stable across varying population sizes and defection rates, as it reduces the cost of punishment while deterring non-contributors.^[13] This aligns with evolutionary dynamics where the threat of ostracism enforces norms more efficiently than individual sanctions, yielding collective benefits like sustained resource pools and reduced internal conflict, though at the expense of the excluded individual's access to group protections.^[29] From a social contract perspective, Thomas Hobbes in Leviathan (1651) posited that rational individuals surrender certain liberties to a sovereign authority to avert the anarchic "war of all against all," implicitly endorsing the exclusion or punishment of deviants who undermine the peace; this framework prioritizes aggregate stability, as unchecked norm violations—such as betrayal or parasitism—erode the mutual trust essential for societal function. Empirical support emerges from anthropological data on hunter-gatherer societies, where ostracism of cheaters maintained foraging efficiency; for instance, studies of the Ache people in Paraguay (1980s fieldwork) revealed that serial non-reciprocators faced expulsion, correlating with group survival rates exceeding 90% in cooperative bands versus dissolution in tolerant ones.^[29] Counterarguments rooted in individual rights emphasize deontological limits, asserting that exclusion inflicts disproportionate harm unless the threat posed is empirically grave and alternatives exhausted. John Locke's Second Treatise of Government (1689) counters Hobbes by limiting sovereign power to preservation of life, liberty, and property, implying pariah status justifiable only for direct aggressors, not minor deviants; modern extensions in international law, such as Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), protect expression unless it incites imminent harm, reflecting a calculus where collective stability yields to individual autonomy absent causal evidence of disruption. Yet, utilitarian analyses reveal trade-offs: a 2008 evolutionary psychology review noted that while ostracism universally activates pain-equivalent neural responses (via fMRI studies showing anterior cingulate activation akin to physical injury), its net societal utility persists in high-stakes environments, as inclusion of persistent deviants can cascade into group failure, evidenced by defect rates doubling in experimental public goods games without exclusion options.^[42] Balancing these tensions often invokes proportionality: legal systems in stable democracies, such as post-WWII constitutional frameworks, employ graduated responses—fines, imprisonment over perpetual exile—to minimize individual costs while securing order, with recidivism data indicating exclusionary measures like parole revocation reduce reoffense by 20-30% in monitored cohorts versus rehabilitative leniency alone.^[43] Philosophers like John Stuart Mill in On Liberty (1859) advocate harm principles, permitting interference solely to prevent damage to others, thus framing pariah-like exclusion as a last resort when empirical forecasting shows net stability gains outweigh rights erosions; this approach, tested in policy simulations, sustains cohesion without systemic overreach, as over-inclusion of incompatible elements historically precipitated collapses, such as in fragmented tribal alliances during 19th-century ethnographic records.

Modern Geopolitical Usage

Definition and Criteria for Pariah States

A pariah state in geopolitical discourse denotes a sovereign nation systematically isolated by the international community for policies or behaviors perceived as egregious violations of established global norms, resulting in diplomatic ostracism, economic sanctions, and restricted participation in international organizations. This status differs from transient diplomatic disputes, as it entails sustained exclusion enforced through multilateral mechanisms, such as UN Security Council resolutions under Chapter VII, which can impose binding sanctions to address threats to international peace.^[44] The term gained prominence in post-Cold War international relations to describe states whose actions undermine collective security, often leading to their portrayal as existential threats warranting containment strategies.^[45] No universally codified criteria exist for designating a pariah state, as the label arises from ad hoc consensus among influential powers rather than formal adjudication by bodies like the United Nations; instead, it reflects judgments by status quo actors, predominantly Western-led coalitions, on threats to the liberal international order.^[44]^[45] Recurrent factors include flagrant human rights abuses, such as genocidal campaigns or widespread political repression documented by entities like the UN Human Rights Council; state sponsorship of transnational terrorism, evidenced by harboring designated groups under UN resolutions; territorial aggression or irredentist threats destabilizing regions, as in invasions condemned by Security Council votes; and non-compliance with arms control regimes, particularly clandestine pursuit of nuclear, chemical, or biological weapons in defiance of treaties like the 1968 Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, which has 191 state parties as of 2023.^[46]^[47] These elements must typically provoke a threshold of collective response, including arms embargoes, asset freezes, and trade restrictions, to solidify pariah designation, distinguishing it from mere rhetorical condemnation. The functional criteria emphasize causal links between state actions and broader harms, such as proliferation risks heightening nuclear war probabilities or terrorism exportation fueling global instability, rather than ideological nonconformity alone.^[48] Designation often correlates with empirical indicators of isolation, including membership denial in forums like the G20 or IMF lending suspensions, though selectivity arises from geopolitical realignments—states aligning with rival powers may evade full pariah treatment despite similar violations.^[45] This political contingency underscores that pariah status serves as a tool for norm enforcement, incentivizing compliance through coercive diplomacy while exposing inconsistencies when powerful actors overlook allies' infractions.

Historical Examples: Apartheid South Africa and North Korea

South Africa under apartheid, formalized by the National Party's election victory on May 26, 1948, became an international pariah state primarily due to its institutionalized racial segregation and denial of political rights to the black majority, which contravened emerging global norms of decolonization and human rights post-World War II.^[49] In the late 1950s, the United Nations General Assembly began condemning apartheid, with a 1958 resolution calling for policy reversal, escalating to diplomatic isolation by the 1960s as numerous states severed bilateral ties and suspended South Africa's memberships in multilateral institutions.^[49] ^[50] This pariah status intensified after events like the 1960 Sharpeville Massacre, prompting a 1962 UN General Assembly resolution urging diplomatic and trade boycotts, alongside cultural measures such as the 1965 academic boycott by British universities and sports exclusions, including expulsion from FIFA in 1961 and the Olympics in 1970.^[51] Economic and targeted sanctions further entrenched South Africa's isolation, with the UN recommending arms embargoes in 1963 and unanimously passing a binding arms sales ban via Security Council Resolution 418 in 1977, while Arab states imposed an oil embargo in 1973.^[49] ^[51] The 1976 Soweto Uprising, where security forces killed at least 176 protesting students, galvanized global public opinion against the regime, leading to broader divestment campaigns and, by 1986, the U.S. Congress overriding President Reagan's veto to enact the Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act, which imposed trade restrictions and financial penalties.^[49] By 1990, over 26 U.S. states and 90 cities had implemented economic sanctions, contributing to a financial crisis marked by the 1985 withdrawal of loans from banks like Chase Manhattan, which amplified internal pressures for reform and negotiations that dismantled apartheid by 1994.^[51] These measures exemplified pariah treatment by prioritizing collective enforcement of anti-discrimination norms over pragmatic engagement, though their direct causal role in ending apartheid remains debated among analysts.^[51] North Korea, officially the Democratic People's Republic of Korea founded on September 9, 1948, has exemplified pariah status through its persistent defiance of international norms, including aggressive militarism, pursuit of weapons of mass destruction, and systematic human rights abuses, as articulated in the U.S. National Security Strategy of 2002 which categorized it among "rogue states."^[52] Historical isolation traces to the Korean War's outbreak on June 25, 1950, when North Korean forces invaded the South, prompting a U.S. trade embargo that same year and cementing its post-armistice (July 27, 1953) separation from global economic integration under the Juche ideology of self-reliance.^[52] Despite joining the United Nations in 1991, North Korea's withdrawal from the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty on January 10, 2003, and admission of a uranium enrichment program in 2002 escalated its pariah designation, leading to UN Security Council sanctions under Resolution 1718 following its first nuclear test on October 9, 2006.^[52] Human rights violations have reinforced North Korea's isolation, with reports of brutal political prison camps holding up to 200,000 inmates subjected to forced labor, torture, and executions, as highlighted by UN calls for verification access in 2001 and a 2014 Commission of Inquiry documenting crimes against humanity.^[52] Sanctions have targeted proliferation activities, with ongoing U.S. restrictions on military and dual-use exports since the 1950s, eased partially in 2000 for limited trade but reimposed amid nuclear brinkmanship, such as the suspension of heavy fuel oil shipments in November 2002 under the Korean Peninsula Energy Development Organization framework.^[52] This sustained pariah treatment, combining diplomatic shunning and economic penalties, aims to deter threats like missile tests and nuclear development, though evasion via illicit networks has limited efficacy, perpetuating North Korea's hermetic governance under the Kim dynasty.^[52]

Contemporary Cases: Israel Post-2023 and Hypocrisies in Global Enforcement

Following the Hamas-led attacks on October 7, 2023, which killed 1,195 people in Israel including 815 civilians and resulted in the abduction of 251 hostages, Israel initiated a military campaign in Gaza aimed at dismantling Hamas's military capabilities and rescuing captives.^[53]^[54] This response, involving airstrikes, ground operations, and evacuation orders, has led to significant Palestinian casualties, with Gaza's Hamas-controlled health ministry reporting over 64,000 deaths by September 2025, though these figures do not distinguish between combatants and civilians and have been critiqued for potential inflation by independent analysts.^[55] Israel's actions prompted widespread international condemnation, including calls for boycotts, divestment campaigns, and diplomatic isolation, positioning the country as a de facto pariah in segments of global opinion, particularly in UN forums and among certain NGOs.^[56] In December 2023, South Africa instituted proceedings against Israel at the International Court of Justice (ICJ), alleging violations of the 1948 Genocide Convention through acts including killings, serious harm, and conditions calculated to destroy Palestinians in Gaza.^[57] The ICJ issued provisional measures on January 26, 2024, ordering Israel to take all feasible steps to prevent genocidal acts, ensure humanitarian aid, and preserve evidence, but stopped short of mandating a ceasefire or finding plausible genocide at that stage.^[58] By October 2024, 14 additional countries had signaled intent to intervene in support of South Africa, amplifying the case's scope, while the International Criminal Court sought arrest warrants in May 2024 for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Defense Minister Yoav Gallant on charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity.^[59] These legal challenges, alongside UN General Assembly resolutions demanding ceasefires and arms embargoes, have fueled perceptions of Israel as an international outcast, with some nations like Bolivia and Colombia severing ties and others imposing trade restrictions.^[60] Global enforcement reveals stark hypocrisies, as evidenced by the UN Human Rights Council's (UNHRC) disproportionate focus on Israel: from 2006 to 2024, it adopted 108 resolutions against Israel compared to far fewer on gross violators like Syria, where Bashar al-Assad's regime killed over 500,000 in a civil war with minimal equivalent scrutiny or special sessions.^[61] In 2022 alone, the UN General Assembly passed 15 resolutions criticizing Israel versus 13 on all other countries combined, a pattern persisting post-2023 despite Hamas's use of human shields and rocket attacks from civilian areas, which international law attributes partial responsibility for casualties.^[62] Similarly, Yemen's Houthi-Saudi conflict, resulting in over 377,000 deaths including indirect famine effects by 2021, elicited limited UN resolutions and no genocide allegations against intervening parties, contrasting with the rapid ICJ invocation for Gaza.^[63] This selective outrage extends to ignoring ongoing threats from Iran-backed groups: Hezbollah's attacks from Lebanon post-October 7 displaced 60,000 Israelis with minimal global pariah designation for Lebanon or Iran, despite the latter's nuclear program and funding of Hamas.^[64] Such inconsistencies stem from institutional biases in bodies like the UNHRC, where a majority of members include authoritarian regimes antagonistic to Israel, leading to agenda item 7—a permanent slot solely for scrutinizing Israel—while other atrocities, such as Sudan's conflict killing hundreds of thousands since 2023, receive sporadic attention.^[65] Empirical data on resolution volumes underscores causal realism in enforcement: Israel's status as a democratic Western ally amplifies scrutiny, whereas non-Western actors perpetrating comparable or greater harms evade equivalent isolation, undermining the universality of international norms.^[61]

Applications in Biology and Natural Sciences

The Pariah Dog Breed and Genetic Adaptations

The Indian Pariah dog, scientifically termed the Indian Native Dog (INDog), represents a primitive landrace autochthonous to the Indian subcontinent, having evolved through natural selection rather than human-directed breeding. This adaptation spans millennia, with genetic analyses confirming its divergence from modern pedigreed breeds and proximity to ancient canine populations, including shared haplotypes with the Australian dingo that trace back to migrations approximately 4,000 years ago.^[66]^[67]^[68] Key genetic adaptations include heightened resilience to environmental stressors, such as India's diverse climates ranging from tropical heat to monsoonal humidity, facilitated by physiological traits like efficient thermoregulation and metabolic efficiency for scavenging diets low in nutrients. High genetic diversity, maintained through outcrossing in free-roaming populations, minimizes inbreeding depression and results in rarity of hereditary conditions like hip dysplasia or progressive retinal atrophy, which plague selectively bred dogs.^[68]^[69]^[70] Immune system robustness constitutes a primary evolutionary advantage, with village dog populations—including Pariah types—exhibiting broad-spectrum resistance to endemic pathogens such as parvovirus and rabies, attributable to natural selection pressures in unsanitary, high-density urban-rural interfaces. SNP-based haplotype studies identify alleles linked to enhanced innate immunity and pathogen tolerance, enabling survival rates far exceeding those of imported breeds in similar conditions.^[71]^[72]^[73] Behavioral genetics further underscore adaptations, with heightened vigilance and pack dynamics promoting territorial defense and efficient resource foraging, traits reinforced by phylogenetic clustering as basal to many Asian canid lineages. These features, validated through high-density SNP arrays, position the Pariah dog as a model for studying adaptive evolution under minimal anthropogenic influence.^[68]^[74] In animal social structures, pariah status manifests as the systematic marginalization of low-ranking or deviant individuals, often through ostracism—defined as exclusion from group resources, mating, or protection—to enforce cooperation and group cohesion. This phenomenon occurs across taxa, from insects like bees expelling defective nestmates to mammals such as lions and primates, where rejection targets perceived threats or burdens to collective fitness.^[75]^[19] Empirical observations indicate that ostracism reduces inclusive fitness costs by limiting reproduction among unfit or disruptive members, as evidenced in primate groups where subordinates face withheld support during conflicts.^[76] In canid packs, omega wolves exemplify pariah-like roles at the hierarchy's base, enduring disproportionate aggression from dominants and subordinates alike to alleviate intragroup tensions. Packs typically feature one or two omegas, who receive priority access to remains after higher ranks feed and may be expelled during resource scarcity, with studies of wild packs showing such individuals surviving through appeasement behaviors like play bows rather than challenges.^[77] This dynamic, observed in Yellowstone wolf populations since the 1990s reintroduction, underscores causal mechanisms: aggression toward omegas correlates with pack stress levels, promoting stability without lethal enforcement in stable groups.^[78] Primate societies reveal pariah status through chronic subordination, particularly among females in species like rhesus macaques, where low-rank individuals experience elevated glucocorticoids from repeated threats and displacement, curtailing foraging and breeding success. In savanna baboons, subordinates numbering up to 20-30% of group size (as in troops of 50-100) often form peripheral coalitions but risk eviction by coalitions of dominants, with long-term field data from Amboseli, Kenya, documenting 15-25% annual dispersal rates driven by such exclusion.^[79] Male primates, frequently immigrants, assume transient pariah roles until establishing rank, facing lethal aggression in 10-20% of cases per Gombe chimpanzee studies spanning 1960-2000.^[80] Free-ranging canids, including pariah dogs in urban India and village populations in Africa (estimated at 75% of global dog numbers, exceeding 500 million individuals), exhibit looser hierarchies than wolves, with subordinates tolerated in fluid groups of 5-10 but routinely displaced from food patches by dominants via stares or snaps.^[81] Genetic and behavioral analyses confirm these dogs' adaptations favor avoidance over confrontation, minimizing exclusion costs while enabling scavenging near human settlements.^[82] Across species, pariah status thus reflects evolutionary trade-offs: exclusion preserves resources for reproducers but incurs risks like heightened predation for isolates, with survival rates for expelled individuals dropping 30-50% in modeled simulations of mammalian dispersers.^[83]

Cultural and Media Representations

In Literature and Film

In Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter (1850), the protagonist Hester Prynne embodies the pariah through her public shaming and social isolation in Puritan New England after bearing a child out of wedlock, forcing her to wear a scarlet "A" and live on the community's margins.^[84] This depiction highlights causal consequences of moral transgression under rigid societal codes, where exclusion serves as both punishment and a mechanism for communal cohesion, rather than unearned victimhood. Similarly, in Toni Morrison's Sula (1973), the title character Sula Peace rejects conventional roles of marriage and motherhood, earning pariah status in her Black community for her independence and sexual nonconformity, which disrupts social expectations and provokes collective backlash. Olaf Stapledon's Sirius (1944) explores pariah themes through a genetically engineered dog with human-level intelligence, who faces rejection from both canine and human societies due to his hybrid nature, underscoring biological and existential barriers to acceptance.^[84] In Philip Roth's I Married a Communist (1998), the narrative draws on McCarthy-era blacklisting, portraying protagonists as political pariahs ostracized for alleged communist ties, reflecting how ideological conformity enforces social boundaries amid historical paranoia.^[84] In film, Dee Rees's Pariah (2011), which premiered at the Sundance Film Festival on January 21, 2011, centers on 17-year-old Alike, a Black teenager in Brooklyn grappling with her attraction to women amid familial and peer disapproval, positioning her as a pariah through strained relationships and identity conflicts.^[85] The film, budgeted under $500,000 and released theatrically in December 2011, emphasizes personal agency in navigating exclusion without romanticizing it as inherent oppression.^[86] Adaptations of literary pariahs, such as the 1939 film version of Victor Hugo's The Hunchback of Notre-Dame—where Quasimodo's physical deformities render him a societal outcast in 15th-century Paris—further illustrate the archetype's persistence, linking deformity to inevitable marginalization under pre-modern norms.^[87]

In Music and Popular Entertainment

In music, "pariah" has served as the name for multiple acts across genres. A British thrash metal band formed in 1987, Pariah, released albums including Blaze of Obscurity in 1990, characterized by speed metal influences and tracks like "Rift."^[88] Separately, a UK-based electronic producer and DJ known as Pariah, relocated to Amsterdam, has issued solo works on labels such as R&S Records and Houndstooth, blending house, techno, and experimental elements in releases like Here From Where We Are (2018).^[89] The word also titles numerous songs exploring themes of isolation and rejection. Steven Wilson's "Pariah," featuring vocals by Ninet Tayeb, appears on his 2017 album To the Bone and delves into emotional desolation through progressive rock arrangements.^[90] Black Sabbath's "Pariah" from their 1983 album Born Again critiques societal addiction and false divinity with heavy metal riffs and Ozzy Osbourne-era lyrical style, though recorded post-Ozzy with Ian Gillan on vocals.^[91] Other examples include Project 86's hardcore punk track "Pariah" from 2024, END's metalcore song of the same name from their 2020 album Splinters from an Ever-Changing Face, and Ball Park Music's indie rock rendition from 2016.^[92]^[93]^[94] In film, Pariah (2011), written and directed by Dee Rees, portrays the struggles of Alike, a 17-year-old African-American teenager navigating her lesbian identity amid family pressures, premiering at the 2011 Sundance Film Festival and earning acclaim for its raw depiction of social ostracism.^[95] The title evokes the protagonist's outcast position in her Brooklyn community. Earlier, Pariah (1998), a low-budget horror film directed by Randolph Kret, follows an interracial couple's violent encounter, using the term to signify societal rejection, though it received mixed reviews for its exploitative elements.^[96] Documentaries like Pariah: The Lives and Deaths of Sonny Liston (2019) apply the label to the boxer Sonny Liston, examining his stigmatized career marked by criminal associations and racial barriers in 1960s America.^[97] Television features limited titled uses, such as the 2015 TV movie Pariah, directed by Rob Mac and starring Bill Burr, which centers on themes of exclusion in a crime drama context, though it garnered modest viewership.^[98] Overall, these works leverage "pariah" to symbolize alienation, often drawing from real or fictional narratives of marginalization without altering the term's core connotation of deliberate social expulsion.

Critiques of Contemporary Narratives

Debunking Oversimplified Victimhood Frames

Oversimplified victimhood frames in the context of pariah states often depict the ostracized entity or its populace as passive recipients of undue external punishment, attributing isolation primarily to aggressors like Western powers while minimizing or excusing endogenous policy failures and norm violations that trigger sanctions and condemnation. This narrative overlooks causal chains rooted in verifiable state actions, such as aggressive militarization or systemic repression, which empirical records show precede and sustain pariah status. For North Korea, regime propaganda consistently portrays international sanctions as imperialistic victimization by the United States, yet declassified intelligence and UN monitoring confirm the state's initiation of provocations, including over 100 nuclear and missile tests since its 2006 withdrawal from the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, designed to coerce concessions rather than deter threats. The 1994-1998 famine, which killed an estimated 240,000 to 3.5 million, resulted largely from resource prioritization toward military programs—consuming 25-30% of GDP amid agricultural collapse—rather than sanctions, which were limited until later escalations. A 2014 United Nations Commission of Inquiry further documented "systematic, widespread, and gross" human rights violations, including prison camps detaining up to 120,000 people in conditions amounting to crimes against humanity, driven by internal surveillance and purges rather than foreign interference. These findings, corroborated by defector testimonies and satellite imagery despite occasional inconsistencies in individual accounts, underscore how victimhood rhetoric deflects accountability for self-imposed isolation, perpetuating cycles of deprivation; for instance, post-2018 border closures exacerbated food shortages, with 42% of the population undernourished in 2023 per FAO data. Such frames ignore first-hand evidence from organizations like Human Rights Watch, which detail arbitrary executions and forced labor as core state mechanisms, not reactions to external plots. In contemporary cases like Israel after the October 7, 2023, Hamas incursion—which killed 1,195 civilians and soldiers while abducting 251 hostages—victimhood narratives frequently amplify Palestinian suffering in Gaza while eliding Hamas's agency, including its charter's calls for Israel's elimination and use of civilian areas for rocket launches (over 12,000 fired pre-escalation) and tunnels funded by diverted aid. This selective framing, prevalent in outlets influenced by institutional biases toward underdog sympathies, downplays how Hamas's governance since 2007 has prioritized militancy over development, with Gaza's GDP per capita stagnating at $1,100 amid corruption and blockades imposed post-2007 coup. Empirical conflict data from sources like the Israel Defense Forces and independent monitors reveal reciprocal violence, but initiated by Hamas's breaches of ceasefires, challenging portrayals of unilateral victimization; for example, pre-October 7 clashes saw 1,000+ rockets from Gaza in 2022 alone, met with targeted responses. Multiple analyses, including from the Council on Foreign Relations, attribute escalation to rejectionist ideologies rather than inherent power imbalances alone. Historical precedents, such as apartheid-era South Africa, illustrate similar distortions: the regime claimed sanctions victimized non-white populations indiscriminately, yet segregationist laws like the 1950 Population Registration Act and forced relocations of 3.5 million people under the Group Areas Act entrenched inequalities, with black unemployment at 20-30% by 1980 due to restricted labor mobility, not merely boycotts imposed after 1977 Sharpeville inquiries. Economic studies post-sanctions show internal reforms, accelerated by exclusion, correlated with democratization by 1994, rather than collapse from external malice; victim frames here obscured how policy choices, not conspiracy, fueled resistance and isolation. These patterns reveal a recurring oversight in victimhood-centric analyses: by privileging external blame over internal causation, such frames hinder resolution, as evidenced by prolonged stalemates in rogue state negotiations where concessions reward defiance without addressing root behaviors. Credible sources like UN panels and peer-reviewed economic assessments, less prone to partisan skew than advocacy media, consistently highlight agency over inevitability. In post-apartheid South Africa, the formal end to racial segregation in 1994 reduced social exclusion of the black majority, enabling political empowerment and initial economic expansion, with gross domestic product rising from $153 billion to $458 billion by 2011. However, violent crime persisted at elevated levels, with South Africa recording approximately 500,000 murders between 1994 and 2020, yielding a homicide rate of around 33 per 100,000 in 2015—among the highest globally—and contributing to widespread insecurity that undermined social cohesion.^[99]^[100]^[101] Although some property crimes like burglary showed lower rates in democratic South Africa compared to the apartheid era, categories such as rape increased by 2%, and overall patterns reflected failures in institutional capacity and rule of law rather than exclusion itself as the causal driver.^[102] Deinstitutionalization policies in the United States, implemented from the 1950s through the 1980s, sought to integrate individuals with severe mental illness into communities by closing psychiatric hospitals and promoting community-based care, thereby reducing their exclusion from mainstream society. This shift, however, correlated with sharp rises in homelessness among the mentally ill and their disproportionate involvement in the criminal justice system, as inadequate community support led to transinstitutionalization into prisons and jails. Mentally ill individuals contributed 4-7% to the growth in U.S. incarceration rates between 1980 and 2000, with many cycling through untreated episodes of risky behavior and encounters with law enforcement untrained in mental health crises.^[103]^[104]^[105] Efforts to integrate Roma communities across Europe, longstanding pariahs facing exclusion due to nomadic traditions and socioeconomic marginalization, have involved EU-funded programs since the 2010s aimed at education, employment, and housing access. Despite these initiatives, outcomes include persistent high unemployment—often exceeding 60% in surveyed populations—and overrepresentation in crime statistics, as seen in the Czech Republic where Roma constitute a disproportionate share of prisoners amid reports of elevated local offending rates linked to poverty and cultural insularity. Victimization of Roma remains high, with 36% reporting crimes against them annually, but integration challenges have fueled majority perceptions of Roma as both threats and integration failures, perpetuating parallel societies rather than assimilation.^[106]^[107]^[108] In India, affirmative action policies since 1950, including reservations in education and public sector jobs for Dalits (formerly untouchables), have mitigated some exclusion by elevating select individuals into middle-class positions and liberating families from manual scavenging. Yet, broader social outcomes show limited erosion of caste hierarchies, with ongoing discrimination constraining Dalit access to land, credit, and private-sector opportunities, alongside persistent violence and affirmative action's association with mismatches in qualifications that hinder productivity in reserved roles.^[109]^[110]^[111] These cases underscore that while reduced exclusion can yield targeted gains, unaddressed underlying factors—such as behavioral norms, institutional weaknesses, or cultural incompatibilities—frequently result in sustained or transferred social costs, including elevated violence and economic inefficiency.^[112]

References

[1]
PARIAH Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster
The meaning of PARIAH is someone or something that is despised or rejected : outcast. How to use pariah in a sentence.
[2]
PARIAH Definition & Meaning - Dictionary.com
A pariah is an outcast or someone who's despised and avoided.Pariah is often used to refer to a person who is widely shunned for some offense they have ...
[3]
Pariah - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
Originating from Tamil paraiyar, meaning "drummer," pariah (1610s) denotes a low caste member in southern India, later extending to mean social outcast.
[4]
Pariah: Why the name of a Tamil Dalit caste entered European ...
Jun 9, 2025 · The roots of the term 'pariah' lie in the name of a caste group called 'Pariayar', which originated in Tamil Nadu.
[5]
The dark history of “pariah” - The Caravan
Jan 1, 2018 · In its broadest sense, the term indicates an outcast. It is often used to describe “rogue” states and their leaders. In the case of figures such ...
[6]
Castes and Tribes of Southern India/Paraiyan - Wikisource
Aug 9, 2025 · The late Bishop Caldwell derived the name Paraiyan from the Tamil word parai a drum, as certain Paraiyans act as drummers at marriages, funerals ...
[7]
pariah - American Heritage Dictionary Entry
Word History: Pariah comes from Tamil paṟaiyan and its Malayalam equivalent paṟayan, words that refer to a member of a Dalit group of southern India and Sri ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[8]
A prejudicial term - PMC - NIH
originally derived from Tamil language word paraiyar, ‚drummer' — once referred to the Paraiyan, a Tamil Nadu caste group” (www.britannica.com) ...
[9]
pariah, n. & adj. meanings, etymology and more
The earliest known use of the word pariah is in the early 1600s. OED's earliest evidence for pariah is from 1613, in the writing of Samuel Purchas, ...
[10]
Word of the Day - pariah - Dictionary.com
Oct 7, 2021 · Pariah “a social outcast” is at its core a term for a member of a low caste in the traditional cultures of the southern Indian subcontinent.
[11]
[PDF] AN evolutionary social psychological approach to studying the ...
Ostracism—being excluded and ignored—is a pervasive phenomenon that occurs in a variety of contexts and cultures throughout the world. Diary studies ...
[12]
Anthropological Aspects of Ostracism | Request PDF - ResearchGate
Ostracism has been observed to promote and maintain cooperation in cultural contexts ranging from hunter gatherers and small-scale pastoral societies (Söderberg ...
[13]
The evolution of cooperation by social exclusion - Journals
Feb 7, 2013 · We present a game-theoretical model of social exclusion in which a punishing cooperator can exclude freeriders from benefit sharing.
[14]
[PDF] Pukhtunwali: Ostracism and Honor Among the Pathan Hill Tribes
"The Pathan Hill tribes provide an example of the functional role of ostracism in a face-to- face, kin. based society. "Pukhtunwali," the Code of the Pathans, ...Missing: anthropology | Show results with:anthropology
[15]
[PDF] OSTRACIZING GROUP MEMBERS WHO CAN (OR CANNOT ...
Examples of ostracism have been documented in various cultural groups, such as the use of Meidung (avoidance) on rule breakers by the Amish (Gruter, 1986), ...
[16]
An evolutionary social psychological approach to studying the ...
Dec 15, 2011 · Ostracism, or social exclusion, is a survival threat that causes social pain, and humans have evolved to detect and avoid it.
[17]
Ostracism - ICSA Articles 3 - International Cultic Studies Association
Ostracism, from Greek, means to exclude or ignore, and is a social-control mechanism to enforce conformity, often used to punish noncompliance.<|separator|>
[18]
[PDF] The process of social exclusion: the dynamics of an evolving concept
Longitudinal and panel studies reviewed here document some of the mechanisms of individuals' downward spiral, with the accumulation of dimensions of exclusion.
[19]
[PDF] Introduction Ostracism as a Social and Biological Phenomenon
Ostracism refers to the general process of rejection and exclusion, observed in human groups and in many other species. It occurs as “shunning” in small ...
[20]
(PDF) The evolution of an ostracism detection system - ResearchGate
Apr 27, 2017 · In this paper, we suggest that evolutionary pressures favoring group and cooperative living shaped an ostracism detection system that is sensitive to rejection.
[21]
Context-sensitive norm enforcement reduces sanctioning costs in ...
Norm-responsive punishment eliminates defectors at 15% lower fines than uniform enforcement with identical costs.
[22]
[PDF] Enforcement of Contribution Norms in Public Good Games with ...
We investigate the emergence and enforcement of contribution norms to public goods in homogeneous and heterogeneous groups. With survey data we demonstrate ...
[23]
Ostracism as a social and biological phenomenon: An introduction
Ostracism is the process of rejection and exclusion, observed in human groups and other species, and may have biological functions.
[24]
The Dark(er) Side of Ostracizing wrongdoers: An Organizing ...
Sep 12, 2025 · Across disciplines, ostracism is widely seen as a functional mechanism for maintaining group well-being, reinforcing cooperation, and deterring ...
[25]
12 Protect, Correct, and Eject: Ostracism as a Social Influence Tool
Evolutionary theorists have argued that ostracism serves a protective function for groups. Kurzban and Leary (2001) argued that selective social exclusion ...Missing: cohesion | Show results with:cohesion
[26]
[PDF] Ostracism - Hendrix College
In this review, I examine the social psychological research on os- tracism, social exclusion, and rejection. Being ignored, excluded, and/or rejected signals a ...<|separator|>
[27]
Ostracism and fines in a public goods game with accidental ...
Jan 1, 2023 · Ostracism prevents any future transgressions from the punished party. This type of punishment can also motivate cooperation in public goods ...
[28]
Cooperation in a repeated prisoners' dilemma with ostracism
One way to enforce cooperation in groups is ostracism: players who defect are expelled. If the group's members prefer not to diminish its size, ostracism hurts ...
[29]
The evolution of cooperation by social exclusion - PMC
We present a game-theoretical model of social exclusion in which a punishing cooperator can exclude freeriders from benefit sharing. We show that such social ...
[30]
Cooperation in a repeated prisoners' dilemma with ostracism
... defection in all rounds. One way to enforce cooperation in groups is ostracism: players who defect are expelled. If the group's members prefer not to ...
[31]
Voting on the threat of exclusion in a public goods experiment
Apr 1, 2019 · Ostracism can be useful in supporting group cohesion but it can also hurt the community if too many or the wrong individuals are excluded ...
[32]
The Effect of Ostracism and Optional Participation on the Evolution ...
Sep 25, 2014 · We developed an evolutionary game model and investigated how participation in groups and ostracism influence the evolution of cooperation in groups.
[33]
Gossip and ostracism promote cooperation in groups - PubMed
These results suggest that the spread of reputational information through gossip can mitigate egoistic behavior by facilitating partner selection.
[34]
India's caste discrimination - Human Rights Watch
BACKGROUND. "Untouchability" and Segregation. India's caste system is perhaps the world's longest surviving social hierarchy. A defining feature of Hinduism, ...
[35]
India: Hidden Apartheid' of Discrimination Against Dalits - NYU
Feb 13, 2007 · ... against caste discrimination, the Center for Human Rights and Global Justice and Human Rights Watch said in a new report released today.
[36]
Atrocities on Dalits - A Human Rights Perspective by Ajay Kumar
May 1, 2010 · The caste based discrimination sanctified by the Hindu religious scriptures, is still haunting a large segment of Indian society, i.e. dalits.
[37]
Caste Discrimination - International Dalit Solidarity Network
Feb 10, 2015 · Caste discrimination affects an estimated 260 million people worldwide, the vast majority living in South Asia. It involves massive violations of civil, ...<|separator|>
[38]
[PDF] Human Rights Abuses of Dalits in India
Although Indian law contains extensive protections against such caste discrimi- nation, the government still fails to enforce its domestic and international ...
[39]
The Dalit: Born into a life of discrimination and stigma | OHCHR
Apr 19, 2021 · For centuries, the Dalit minority in South Asia have faced discrimination, marginalisation, stigma and violence. Beena Pallical is the ...
[40]
Caste Exclusion and Health Discrimination in South Asia
The caste system is social stratification system that has been used over the last 3 millennia. This review aims to investigate caste-based inequity in ...
[41]
[PDF] Caste and Outcasts under International Human Rights Law
Although caste is distinct from the concept of race, both types of discrimination produce comparable forms of political, economic, and social exclusion. The UN ...
[42]
When inclusion costs and ostracism pays, ostracism still hurts
Nov 30, 2008 · Throughout the course of human evolution, exclusion was always costly and inclusion was always beneficial. These two things always went together ...Missing: justifications | Show results with:justifications
[43]
[PDF] Institutionalized Ostracism
Jan 23, 2025 · Ostracism includes both individual and group-based exclusion. ... sider this point when balancing the state's interest against individual rights.Missing: collective | Show results with:collective
[44]
What Is A Pariah State? - World Atlas
Aug 1, 2017 · The term "pariah state" is used to describe a nation which is not accepted or recognized by the majority of governments around the world.
[45]
[PDF] Why Pariah States Export Violence - OpenSIUC
May 11, 2012 · Because of these contingencies, states are only considered as pariahs if their actions are labeled as such by status quo powers. (Nincic 2005, ...
[46]
Pariah State | PDF | Foreign Policy | International Relations - Scribd
A pariah state is defined as an outcast nation that is isolated by the international community due to policies or actions seen as unacceptable.
[47]
List of the 11 current Pariah States - Worlddata.info
Pariah states are those states that are considered outcasts because of their government. Anyone who does not abide by international rules or refuses to ...Missing: relations | Show results with:relations
[48]
[PDF] pariah states and the threat of nuclear war - Queen's University
Jun 27, 2025 · Other states may become pariahs. -- if they commit the offences attributed to South Africa and Israel or if the criteria used to assign pariah ...
[49]
The End of Apartheid in South Africa - HeinOnline Blog
Mar 21, 2025 · ... history of apartheid in South Africa, and its continuing influence on international law. ... By 1990, South Africa was a pariah state, with ...
[50]
Diplomatic Isolation | SpringerLink
Opponents of apartheid thus sought to undermine the South African government by promoting diplomatic sanctions. ... By the 1960s, South Africa had become a pariah ...
[51]
International isolation and pressure for change in South Africa
Feb 19, 2008 · In the global context of decolonisation and expanding civil rights, apartheid South Africa was an international pariah for decades. Yet Cold War ...
[52]
[PDF] North Korea The Reality of a Rogue State in the International Order
The last two. U.S. administrations as well as the other major powers The Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK) has been labeled by as a pariah state ...
[53]
October 7 attack | Israel, Gaza, Deaths, & Hostages - Britannica
The October 7 attack was an assault led by Hamas against Israel that killed about 1200 people. More than 240 people were taken hostage, and Israel launched ...
[54]
Israel at War: What You Need To Know | AJC
... Hamas terrorists attacked Israel on Oct. 7, 2023. Yossi was murdered in ... Over 700 days after the deadliest attack on Jews since the Holocaust, there ...Humanitarian Aid in Gaza · 6 “Pro-Palestinian” Protest... · Bring Them Home Now
[55]
Palestinian death toll in Gaza passes 64,000, officials say ... - PBS
Sep 4, 2025 · Hamas-led militants killed around 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducted 251 people in their attack on southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023.Missing: verified | Show results with:verified<|control11|><|separator|>
[56]
After 6 months of war, Israel's isolation grows with no end in sight
Apr 5, 2024 · When Israel declared war against Hamas last October, it stood ... attack by the Islamic militant group. Six months later, Israel finds ...
[57]
Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of ...
Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide in the Gaza Strip (South Africa v. Israel)Provisional measures · International court of justice · Orders · Intervention
[58]
Summary of the Order of 26 January 2024
Jan 26, 2024 · The Court notes that South Africa and Israel are parties to the Genocide Convention and that neither of them has entered a reservation to ...
[59]
South Africa vs Israel: 14 other countries intend to join the ICJ case
Oct 30, 2024 · Fourteen countries have announced their intention to intervene in the context of South Africa's complaint, which accuses Israel of “genocide” in the Gaza Strip.
[60]
Israel and Hamas Conflict In Brief: Overview, U.S. Policy, and ...
White House, "Remarks by President Biden on the Terrorist Attacks in Israel," October 10, 2023. 67. Yonah Jeremy Bob, "US sends 500th aircraft to Israel as ...
[61]
Human Rights Council – UN Watch Database
Israel has been the subject of more special sessions than any other country. Since the Human Rights Council was created, it has held 1 special session on Libya, ...
[62]
UN condemned Israel more than all other countries combined in 2022
Jan 3, 2023 · The General Assembly approved 15 anti-Israel resolutions last year, versus 13 resolutions criticizing other countries, according to a tally by ...
[63]
The Double Standards Debate at the UN | International Crisis Group
Mar 7, 2024 · Diplomats at the UN have been accusing one another of “double standards” in responses to crises almost since the institution's inception.
[64]
One Year After the October 7 Attacks: The Impact on Four Fronts
Oct 2, 2024 · Since the horrific attack of October 7, 2023, by Hamas on Israel ... After October 7, in solidarity with Hamas, Hezbollah launched attacks ...<|separator|>
[65]
Israel is the only country that the UNHRC with a standing agenda ...
1. Israel is the only country that the UNHRC with a standing agenda item against it each session (Item 7) · 2. Israel is constantly faced with biased resolutions.
[66]
How India's desi dogs travelled 7000 kms, gave Australia its dingoes
Aug 26, 2025 · Australia's dingoes share striking physical and genetic similarities with India's "desi dogs", which are hardy street survivors with curled ...Missing: adaptations | Show results with:adaptations
[67]
The Indian Native Dog (INDog)
The Indian Native Dog (INDog) is an ancient, autocthonous (landrace) type of dog that is found all over India and Bangladesh. It was featured some years ago ...
[68]
design and validation of a high-density SNP array for Indian dogs
These native Indian dog breeds are adapted to the country's diverse climate and terrain, making them hardy and resilient.
[69]
Village Dogs: Home
With unusually strong immune systems and freedom from the genetic disorders that often result from inbreeding, they thrive in sweltering tropical climates and ...
[70]
Tracing India's Canine Heritage Through SNP-based Haplotype ...
Aug 7, 2025 · Dog breeds/germplasm in India is mostly unexplored and the population structure of owned dogs has not been studied at all. The current study was ...
[71]
s Canine Heritage Through SNP-based Haplotype Identification
Identifying specific haplotypes linked to traits such as disease resistance or behavioural attributes could guide breeding programs and improve breed welfare ( ...
[72]
[PDF] Dog conservation and the population genetic structure of dogs
198 FREE-RANGING DOGS AND WILDLIFE CONSERVATION in village dogs could be used to breed disease resist- ance and other traits into established dog breeds in.
[73]
Genetic structure in village dogs reveals a Central Asian ...
Oct 19, 2015 · This study represents the largest-ever survey of worldwide canine genetic diversity using nuclear, Y, and Mt markers. We confirm high diversity ...Missing: resistance | Show results with:resistance
[74]
INDog Project – INDog – the indigenous village dog of the Indian ...
Our conclusions about purely indigenous populations and admixture were confirmed by the genetic testing of both village and urban Indian dogs between 2009-2015.The INDog · About the Contributors · Articles · INDogs in the Media
[75]
Chapter 6 Ostracism: A Temporal Need‐Threat Model - ScienceDirect
Social psychologists understood, at least implicitly, that the fear of ostracism was a social glue that motivated individuals to be responsive to social norms.Missing: cohesion | Show results with:cohesion<|separator|>
[76]
Primate social behavior and ostracism - ScienceDirect.com
Ostracism, defined as socially determined exclusion from the resources and opportunities necessary to successful reproduction, is a basic mechanism by which ...
[77]
The Omega - Living with Wolves
In most wolf packs, there will be an alpha male and female and frequently an omega male and female. In wolf hierarchy, the males tend to dominate other males ...Missing: pariah | Show results with:pariah
[78]
Alpha and Omega Wolf ; The Importance of Ranks - Le Klan du Loup
Jan 3, 2024 · An Omega wolf is essential for the survival of a pack, even though it occupies the lowest rank. This wolf's instinctive mission is to diffuse hostilities and ...Missing: pariah | Show results with:pariah
[79]
Social subordination produces distinct stress-related phenotypes in ...
Social subordination in female macaques is imposed by harassment and the threat of aggression and produces reduced control over one's social and physical ...
[80]
[PDF] Social Rejection Exclusion and Shunning Among the Gombe ...
In human society, of course, we most often think of ostracism, or cold shouldering, as an informal group response to socially undesirable behavior in one or ...
[81]
Hierarchy-Dependent Behaviour of Dogs in the Strange Situation Test
Although approximately 75% of the world's dog population can be considered free-ranging (often dubbed as 'pariah', or 'village') dogs [5], even these animals ...
[82]
Wild Dogs, Feral Dogs and Pariahs - Behind the Behavior
It is in these pariah groups that canine aficionados opposed to the concept of social hierarchy among dog find the lack of a social hierarchy like wolves. And ...
[83]
[PDF] Social Ostracism - Todd Shackelford
Social ostracism refers to being excluded from a group. Social ostracism occurs in many species. Individ- uals who pose threats to a group are more likely to ...
[84]
From Dickens to Roth: top 10 novels about pariahs - The Guardian
Jun 5, 2019 · From Dickens to Roth: top 10 novels about pariahs · 1. Sirius by Olaf Stapledon · 2. I Married a Communist by Philip Roth · 3. The Scarlet Letter ...
[85]
Pariah (2011) - IMDb
Rating 7.2/10 (7,895) PARIAH does have themes about staying strong in the face of adversity, but just like Brokeback Mountain and Albert Nobbs, this film is also about being true to ...Missing: examples | Show results with:examples
[86]
Dee Rees on her debut film Pariah: 'My favourite scene is the dildo ...
Jul 16, 2021 · First love also happens to be a big theme of Pariah, the partly autobiographical tale of a young Black teenager, Alike Freeman (Adepero Oduye), ...
[87]
10 Best Movies About Misfits and Outsiders, Ranked - Collider
Oct 5, 2024 · As such, films that focus on pariahs have a unique ... films about outcasts and outsiders are among the best the medium has ever seen.
[88]
Pariah Albums: songs, discography, biography ... - Rate Your Music
Pariah discography and songs: Music profile for Pariah, formed 1987. Genres: Thrash Metal, Speed Metal, Heavy Metal. Albums include Blaze of Obscurity, ...
[89]
Interview: Pariah - Truants
Jul 23, 2018 · I've discovered a lot of music through Spotify, so you know, the good with the bad.” Pariah – Here From Where We Are is out now on Houndstooth.Missing: notable uses entertainment
[90]
Steven Wilson - Pariah ft. Ninet Tayeb - YouTube
May 18, 2017 · Steven Wilson - Pariah ft. Ninet Tayeb · Comments.Missing: titles | Show results with:titles
[91]
Pariah - song and lyrics by Black Sabbath - Spotify
Pariah. Black Sabbath. 1320135:34. Lyrics. Pariah from society. Addicted to sobriety. A product of a virgin birth, another God on Earth. Yes, that's your ...Missing: titles bands
[92]
Project 86 - Pariah (Official Music Video) - YouTube
Jan 11, 2024 · The official music video for 'Pariah' by Project 86 FROM THE ... He's 48 (according to Google) and sounds better than alot of younger bands on ...Missing: titles | Show results with:titles
[93]
END - Pariah (Official Video) - YouTube
Mar 26, 2020 · Artist - END Song - Pariah Album - Splinters From An Ever-Changing Face Label - Closed Casket Activities Video Directed & Edited by Eric ...Missing: titles | Show results with:titles
[94]
Ball Park Music - Pariah - YouTube
Apr 26, 2016 · Pariah - the epic first take from Ball Park Music's new album. http://www.ballparkmusic.com Video by Jaymis Loveday - http://jaymis.com BALL ...<|separator|>
[95]
Pariah Official Movie Trailer [HD] - YouTube
Oct 13, 2011 · In Select Theatres January 2012 A world premiere at the 2011 Sundance Film Festival, the contemporary drama Pariah is the feature-length ...Missing: examples | Show results with:examples
[96]
Pariah (1998) - IMDb
Rating 4.3/10 (981) Pariah: Directed by Randolph Kret. With Damon Jones, Dave Oren Ward, Davidlee Willson, Aimee Chaffin. Interracial couple attacked, woman raped, ...
[97]
Pariah: The Lives and Deaths of Sonny Liston - Hulu
Watch Pariah: The Lives and Deaths of Sonny Liston and other popular TV shows and movies including new releases, classics, Hulu Originals, and more.
[98]
Pariah (TV Movie 2015) - IMDb
Rating 7.4/10 (23) Pariah: Directed by Rob Mac. With Bill Burr, Brad Carter, Justin Dray, Keith Ewell.
[99]
South Africa: 30 years after apartheid, what has changed? - Al Jazeera
Apr 27, 2024 · In the first decade after apartheid, the ANC-led South Africa's gross domestic product (GDP) went from $153bn in 1994 to $458bn in 2011, ...
[100]
Facts show South Africa has not become more violent since ...
Jul 21, 2016 · Its 17,805 murders recorded last year in a population of a little under 55 million make for a murder rate of 33 per 100,000. This compares very ...
[101]
SA's murder rate remains frighteningly high - Post
Oct 28, 2020 · ... since the end of apartheid, about 500 000 South Africans have been murdered and about one million people have been raped. For all South Africans ...
[102]
[PDF] 'Crime', poverty, political corruption and conflict in apartheid and ...
This paper examines and compares the level of crimes in the 'two phases' (Apartheid and Post Apartheid periods- '1994-2005'), and their implications, especially ...
[103]
[PDF] Assessing the Contribution of the Deinstitutionalization of the ...
Deinstitutionalization contributed 4-7% to US incarceration growth between 1980-2000, with significant transinstitutionalization of the mentally ill.
[104]
Deinstitutionalization of People with Mental Illness: Causes and ...
This paper reviews trends in the transinstitutionalization of people with SMI and proposes that it is time we offer asylum, in the best sense of the word.
[105]
Hard truths about deinstitutionalization, then and now - CalMatters
Mar 10, 2019 · The result: fewer inmates, and significant increases in homelessness and untreated mental illness. ... The number of mentally ill people entering ...
[106]
Roma in 10 European Countries - Main results
Oct 25, 2022 · Roma are among the people who are most vulnerable to human rights violations in the European Union (EU). The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights ( ...
[107]
The Imperative Need for Criminological Research on the European ...
Thirty-six percent of the Roma participants had been victims of a crime during the previous year of discrimination, threats and harassment. Men and youngsters ...
[108]
Are there countries where the Roma have integrated into local ...
Apr 17, 2017 · I live in Czech Republic and the Roma minority here is considered to be the biggest source of crime - most prisoners belong to the Roma ethnic ...
[109]
[PDF] Social Justice through Affirmative Action in India - PERI UMASS
The vast majority of Dalits are not directly affected by affirmative action, but reserved jobs bring a manifold increase in the number of families liberated ...
[110]
The Enduring Reality of Caste in Contemporary India: Persistence ...
May 15, 2025 · Affirmative action has provided limited impact on caste exclusion in the form of policy access to some individuals, but for the majority ...
[111]
[PDF] Affirmative Action, Faculty Productivity and Caste Interactions
Abstract. Affirmative action programs are often criticized because of concerns that they result in lower worker productivity and efficiency losses.
[112]
Caste, Affirmative Action and Employment in Contemporary India
Mar 6, 2024 · Dalits have been given less access to Land, capital assets, credit and so on which constrains their Economic opportunities (Ambedkar, 1990 [1936] ...