Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Pinnacle Point

Pinnacle Point Site Complex is an archaeological locality comprising over 30 caves, rockshelters, and open-air sites on a rocky promontory south of Mossel Bay in the Western Cape Province, South Africa, directly along the Indian Ocean coast.^[1] It preserves a rich record of Middle Stone Age human occupations dating from approximately 164,000 to 50,000 years ago, offering critical insights into the origins of modern human behavior through evidence of technological innovation, symbolic practices, and coastal adaptations.^[2] In 2024, the complex was inscribed as a component of the UNESCO World Heritage Site "The Emergence of Modern Human Behaviour: The Pleistocene Occupation Sites of South Africa," highlighting its exceptional testimony to early Homo sapiens' cognitive and ecological advancements.^[1] Excavations, particularly at Pinnacle Point Cave 13B (PP13B), have uncovered the earliest systematic exploitation of marine shellfish around 162,000 years ago, demonstrating that early humans foraged coastal resources during Marine Isotope Stage 6, a period of glacial aridity when terrestrial game was scarce.^[2] This adaptation is evidenced by dense shell middens and associated tools, indicating planned resource use in a nutrient-rich environment influenced by the Agulhas Current and Cape Floral Region.^[2] The site's faunal and floral remains further reveal a broad diet incorporating geophytes, small mammals, and tortoises, underscoring dietary flexibility amid environmental instability.^[2] Pinnacle Point is also notable for pioneering technologies, including the heat treatment of silcrete stone—dating to about 164,000 years ago—to improve tool flaking, the production of bladelets, and the modification of ochre pigments for possible symbolic or functional purposes.^[2] High-resolution chronologies from sites like PP5-6, established through optically stimulated luminescence dating of 197 samples, span Marine Isotope Stages 5 to 3 (approximately 110,000 to 50,000 years ago) and link these behaviors to sea-level changes and climatic oscillations.^[3] Artifacts from the Howiesons Poort industry, such as backed pieces and microliths, reflect advanced hunting strategies and raw material selection, contributing to broader understandings of behavioral modernity in Africa.^[3] The complex's stratigraphic integrity and proximity to paleo-coastlines enable precise reconstructions of human-environment interactions, positioning Pinnacle Point as a cornerstone for studying the evolutionary pressures that shaped modern humanity.^[1] Ongoing research emphasizes its role in demonstrating that key behavioral traits emerged in southern Africa before global dispersals.^[2]

Geography and Location

Coastal Setting

Pinnacle Point is situated on a small rocky promontory along the southern coast of South Africa in the Western Cape Province, approximately 10 km west of Mossel Bay, at coordinates roughly 34°12′S 22°05′E.^[4] This headland forms part of the cliffed coastline, protruding into the Indian Ocean and providing a strategic vantage point over the surrounding seascape. The promontory is composed primarily of quartzitic sandstone from the Skurweberg Formation within the Table Mountain Group, contributing to the rugged terrain and natural cave formations along its cliffs.^[4] The site overlooks the Indian Ocean, where prevailing southwesterly winds and swells shape the dynamic coastal environment, interacting with tides that reach highs of up to 3 meters above mean sea level.^[4] It lies within the Cape Floristic Region, a biodiversity hotspot characterized by fynbos vegetation adapted to the Mediterranean-like climate of mild, wet winters and dry summers.^[5] Seasonal upwelling along the Agulhas Bank, particularly during summer and autumn, brings nutrient-rich waters to the surface, enhancing marine productivity and influencing the coastal ecosystem.^[6] These oceanic and atmospheric conditions, combined with exposure to coastal winds and tidal fluctuations, created a resource-rich interface that shaped the paleoenvironmental context for human settlement. In the modern era, Pinnacle Point is integrated into the Pinnacle Point Estate, a residential and golf resort development that occupies the area above the cliffs, with archaeological zones designated as a Provincial Heritage Site under South Africa's National Heritage Resources Act of 1999, ensuring restricted public access to preserve the site's integrity.^[7] This location forms the eastern edge of the broader Palaeo-Agulhas Plain, a now-submerged coastal shelf that extended during glacial periods.^[8]

Geological Context

The Pinnacle Point site complex is situated within coastal cliffs composed primarily of coarse quartzitic sandstones from the Skurweberg Formation of the Paleozoic Table Mountain Sandstone Group, overlain by Cenozoic deposits of the Bredasdorp Group, which include Miocene to Pliocene limestones and calcretes.^[9]^[10] The sea caves themselves formed through mechanical erosion by waves during Pleistocene sea-level highstands, with elevated positions at 3–7 m and 12–15 m above modern sea level reflecting tectonic stability and repeated exposure to marine processes during interglacial periods.^[4] These fluctuations, driven by global climate cycles, sculpted shear zones and faulted bedrock into cavities that later accumulated sediments, preserving archaeological records.^[11] During glacial periods of the Pleistocene, lowered sea levels exposed the Palaeo-Agulhas Plain (PAP), a vast continental shelf extending up to 100 km offshore from the modern southern Cape coast, serving as a critical refugium for diverse ecosystems amid broader aridification.^[12] This nutrient-rich shelf, influenced by the Agulhas Current's upwelling, supported productive grasslands, wetlands, and coastal foraging grounds, contrasting with the surrounding hyper-arid interiors.^[13] Particularly during Marine Isotope Stage 6 (MIS 6, approximately 191,000–130,000 years ago), the region experienced extreme aridity and cold conditions, with sea levels dropping over 120 m, compressing human populations toward the coast and enhancing the PAP's role as a habitable corridor.^[11]^[5] Sedimentary sequences at Pinnacle Point include aeolian dunes and beach deposits from the Waenhuiskrans and Strandveld Formations within the Bredasdorp Group, which capped and intermittently sealed cave entrances during regressive phases.^[4] These unlithified to cemented sands, derived from coastal erosion and wind transport, overlay older marine-influenced layers like boulder-strewn beach facies from highstands such as MIS 11 (>349,000 years ago).^[14] Guano accumulations from avian and bat activity further contributed to sealing and phosphatization of deposits, creating laminated silts and facilitating the exceptional preservation of organic materials by stabilizing sediments against post-depositional erosion.^[15]

Site Complex

Overview of Caves

The Pinnacle Point Site Complex consists of at least 28 archaeological sites, including caves and rock shelters situated along approximately 2 km of the southern Cape coastline, south of Mossel Bay in the Western Cape Province of South Africa.^[16] These sites are clustered into distinct groups, including PP5-6 to the north and the PP13 series (encompassing PP13A, PP13B, and PP13C) further south, forming a dense concentration of paleoanthropological localities within a narrow coastal zone.^[8] The complex's proximity to the modern shoreline underscores its role in documenting early human coastal adaptations, with Pinnacle Point 13B (PP13B) standing out for its well-preserved Middle Stone Age sequences.^[17] The caves and shelters display diverse morphologies, primarily as wave-cut sea caves incised into quartzitic sandstone cliffs of the Table Mountain Group, alongside more sheltered inland overhangs.^[18] These features vary in depth up to 30 meters and in elevation from near sea level to around 15 meters above present-day sea level, reflecting formation during Pleistocene sea-level fluctuations that exposed and eroded the coastal bedrock.^[19] Many contain stratified sedimentary fills reaching up to 7 meters in thickness, comprising aeolian, colluvial, and anthropogenic deposits that accumulated over marine isotope stages 6 and 5.^[20] Exceptional preservation within the complex is attributed to natural protective mechanisms, including sealing by overlying dune sands around 90 ka, which shielded interiors from wind erosion and post-depositional mixing.^[4] Accumulations of bat guano further contributed by stabilizing sediments and reducing bioturbation from burrowing animals, thereby maintaining stratigraphic integrity across multiple sites.^[15]

Pinnacle Point 13B

Pinnacle Point 13B (PP13B) is a large sea cave situated on the southern coast of South Africa near Mossel Bay in the Western Cape Province, featuring a roughly circular east-facing mouth at approximately 15 meters above modern sea level and extending about 30 meters in depth from the entrance, with a width of around 8 meters and a roof height of up to 7 meters at the mouth, narrowing toward the rear.^[4] The cave's sedimentary sequence comprises seven major units—layers 1 through 6 in the upper deposits and a distinct lower unit—spanning roughly 60,000 to 160,000 years ago and reflecting episodic human occupations interspersed with natural sedimentation processes influenced by sea-level fluctuations and coastal dune incursions.^[4]^[21] These units contain numerous hearths and ash deposits indicative of repeated fire use, as well as shell middens composed primarily of marine mollusk remains accumulated from human foraging activities.^[4] Excavations at PP13B, initiated in 2000, have focused on three main areas (northeastern, western, and eastern) totaling approximately 20 square meters, employing precise total station mapping and three-dimensional plotting to document artifacts and features in situ.^[4] The site's stratigraphic integrity is generally well-preserved, with many artifacts remaining in primary context due to limited post-depositional disturbances such as root penetration or minor subsidence, as evidenced by fabric analyses of clast orientations showing low levels of reworking in key occupational horizons.^[22]^[4] Among the key stratigraphic layers, Layer 10, part of the upper Middle Stone Age sequence and dated to between 90,000 and 120,000 years ago via optically stimulated luminescence (OSL), stands out for its association with heat-treated silcrete tools, where controlled heating improved stone flaking properties for tool production.^[21] The Lower Cave unit, representing the basal sedimentary deposit and dated to approximately 160,000 years ago, marks the earliest intensive human occupation at the site and includes dense concentrations of shellfish remains from deliberate coastal foraging.^[21]^[17]

Other Key Sites

Pinnacle Point Site 5-6 (PP5-6), an inland rock shelter located approximately 1 km from the coastal caves, features a stratigraphic sequence of deposits spanning approximately 110,000 to 50,000 years ago, providing a continuous record of Middle Stone Age (MSA) occupation over a 60,000-year interval.^[23] The site consists of multiple layers formed through alternating anthropogenic and geogenic processes, linked to regional climate fluctuations and sea-level changes during glacial cycles.^[8] Key assemblages from PP5-6 include advanced microlithic stone tools, such as small segmented blades and backed pieces, indicative of specialized lithic production techniques.^[24] Additionally, the site yields evidence of ochre processing, with 35 mineral pigment artifacts analyzed for sourcing, revealing procurement from local iron-rich outcrops and modification through grinding and possible mixing for use in symbolic or functional activities.^[25] Adjacent to the primary cave of PP13B, smaller sites PP13A and PP13C contain thinner MSA stratigraphic layers dating to the Middle Pleistocene, contributing supplementary data on early human activities within the coastal complex. PP13A, a dune deposit beneath an overhanging cliff, preserves low densities of shellfish alongside lithic materials and worked ochre fragments, suggesting intermittent use for resource processing.^[26] PP13C, a large lower cave directly below PP13B, exhibits similar MSA horizons with evidence of pigment modification, including red ochre pieces showing use-wear from scraping or abrasion, as well as bladelet production debris comparable to that in neighboring sites.^[26] These smaller caves, excavated to limited depths, highlight localized depositional environments influenced by erosion and sediment input from the adjacent PP13B.^[27] Collectively, the sites at Pinnacle Point illustrate patterns of human mobility and resource exploitation across a heterogeneous landscape, with PP5-6's inland position complementing the coastal focus of PP13A, PP13B, and PP13C by evidencing forays into interior zones for raw materials like ochre and silcrete for tool-making.^[28] This inter-site variability underscores adaptive strategies during periods of environmental stress, such as Marine Isotope Stage 6, where occupants alternated between marine shellfish gathering at coastal caves and terrestrial pursuits at inland shelters.^[28]

Archaeological Findings

Early Human Occupation

The Pinnacle Point site complex provides evidence of early modern human occupation dating back to approximately 164,000 years ago during Marine Isotope Stage (MIS) 6, representing one of the earliest dated coastal occupations in South Africa.^[2] This initial phase at Pinnacle Point Cave 13B (PP13B) includes Middle Stone Age (MSA) layers with lithic artifacts, pigments, and shellfish remains, indicating sustained human activity in a refugial coastal environment during a period of global glaciation. Occupation continued into the Last Interglacial (MIS 5e, around 125,000 years ago), with multiple layers at PP13B documenting repeated human visits as sea levels rose and coastal resources became more accessible.^[2] However, stratigraphic and geochronological data reveal gaps in occupation, spanning about 37,000 years between the upper MIS 6 layers (~162,000–152,000 years ago) and the lower MIS 5 layers (~130,000–120,000 years ago), likely corresponding to hyper-arid intervals that restricted inland access to the southern Cape coast. Subsequent phases within the site complex extend the record of human presence, incorporating the Still Bay techno-complex (~92,000–87,000 years ago) and Howiesons Poort techno-complex (~70,000–59,000 years ago), marked by specialized bladelet and backed tool production associated with these occupations.^[3] At sites like Pinnacle Point 5-6 (PP5-6), a high-resolution optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) chronology based on 197 samples confirms continuous occupation from approximately 110,000 to 50,000 years ago (MIS 5 to 3), with these later MSA phases showing continuity in coastal adaptation through fluctuating climatic conditions.^[3] Overall, the chronology reflects punctuated but recurrent human engagement with the landscape, spanning from MIS 6 through MIS 4, underscoring Pinnacle Point's role as a persistent coastal refuge. Habitation patterns at Pinnacle Point suggest repeated seasonal returns by foraging groups, inferred from the accumulation of discrete stratigraphic units with varying intensities of anthropogenic input, particularly during periods of close coastal proximity in MIS 5.^[29] Artifact densities in key layers, such as the Shelly Brown Sand and Upper Roof Spall at PP13B, reach up to 4,165 lithic artifacts per cubic meter, reflecting episodes of concentrated activity amid otherwise sparse deposits. These patterns indicate short-term occupations rather than permanent settlements, with evidence of structured discard around hearths pointing to organized use of space.^[29] Demographic insights from the sites imply small group sizes of 10–20 individuals, based on the clustering of hearths and limited spatial extent of discard patterns in MIS 5 layers at PP5-6, consistent with mobile hunter-gatherer strategies in a resource-variable coastal setting.^[29] Such inferences align with low to moderate overall site densities, suggesting that groups returned opportunistically to exploit seasonal marine and terrestrial resources without large-scale aggregation.

Tool Technologies

The stone tool technologies at Pinnacle Point represent significant advancements in Middle Stone Age (MSA) lithic production, characterized by diverse assemblages that reflect adaptive manufacturing strategies. The sites yield a range of MSA tools, including points for piercing or cutting, scrapers for processing hides and plants, and blades for versatile tasks such as slicing. These tools demonstrate a shift toward more standardized and efficient production methods compared to earlier Acheulean traditions.^[24] A hallmark innovation at Pinnacle Point is the controlled heat treatment of silcrete, providing the earliest known evidence of this technique dating to approximately 164,000 years ago at PP13B.^[30] This process involved heating silcrete rocks to temperatures of 300–400°C, which altered their mineral structure by dehydrating silanol groups and forming stronger silica bonds, thereby improving flaking predictability and reducing fracture toughness to mimic higher-quality materials like chert. Experimental replications have confirmed these effects, showing that heat-treated silcrete requires up to 50% less cutting force for tool edges, enhancing overall efficiency in producing sharper implements with fewer errors during knapping. Up to 70% of silcrete artifacts from Howiesons Poort layers (~70,000–59,000 years ago) at PP5-6 exhibit signs of intentional heating, indicating systematic application across the production chain.^[30]^[3]^[31] In the Howiesons Poort layers, tool assemblages feature small, backed segments—thin blades with one retouched edge—designed for hafting into composite weapons like spears or arrows, enabling more precise and projectile-based hunting. These backed tools, often made on heat-treated silcrete, mark a technological leap in miniaturization and hafting technology. Raw materials were primarily sourced locally within 10–20 km of the sites, including silcrete for fine-grained blades, quartzite for robust scrapers and cores, and occasional marine shells modified into edged tools for scraping or cutting soft materials. Evidence of on-site knapping workshops is apparent from abundant debitage, cores, and production waste in occupation layers, suggesting intensive, localized manufacturing activities.^[32]^[33]^[24]

Dietary and Environmental Evidence

Excavations at Pinnacle Point Site 13B have yielded substantial evidence of shellfish exploitation as a primary subsistence strategy, marking the earliest documented systematic marine foraging by early modern humans around 164,000 years ago during Marine Isotope Stage 6. This activity involved the collection of over 20 shellfish species from intertidal zones, including prominent taxa such as the brown mussel (Perna perna), the turban shell (Turbo sarmaticus), limpets (Scutellastra argenvillei), and sand mussels (Donax serra).^[34] The diversity and volume of these remains, concentrated in shell middens, indicate a reliable, nutrient-rich resource that supported human survival amid arid glacial conditions when terrestrial vegetation was sparse.^[34] Midden analyses further reveal seasonal patterns in shellfish procurement, with shifts in dominant species reflecting tidal cycles and resource availability; for instance, brown mussels predominated during low-tide exposures, while sand mussels were targeted in beach strandings associated with winter storms.^[35] Oxygen isotope profiling of Turbo sarmaticus shells confirms collections occurred year-round, particularly in autumn and winter, underscoring a strategic adaptation to coastal rhythms that buffered against environmental variability.^[35] This sustained marine reliance, evidenced by stable carbon isotope ratios in human dental remains showing consistent shellfish intake, highlights the role of coastal foraging in enabling persistent occupation of the region.^[34] Complementing marine resources, the faunal assemblage at Pinnacle Point includes remains of small game, such as angulate tortoises (Chersina angulata) and geometric tortoises (Psammobates geometricus), alongside Cape fur seals (Arctocephalus pusillus), which were opportunistically hunted or scavenged for meat and fat.^[34] Taphonomic studies of cut marks and burning on these bones confirm direct hominin exploitation, with tortoises comprising a significant but secondary dietary component due to their accessibility in fynbos habitats. Large mammal remains, primarily from bovids and equids in size classes 2–5, are present but limited in density, suggesting infrequent and selective hunting rather than intensive terrestrial predation, likely constrained by low population densities and mobility needs. Paleoenvironmental proxies from pollen and phytolith records at the site illuminate vegetation dynamics, with dominant C3 fynbos elements like restios and evergreen shrubs indicating a winter-rainfall regime during early occupations around 160,000–120,000 years ago.^[34] Phytolith assemblages show low grass representation initially, reflecting open fynbos shrublands on a narrow coastal plain, followed by shifts toward increased C4 grasses and riparian thicket during Marine Isotope Stage 5 (~115,000–90,000 years ago), possibly linked to wetter interglacial pulses.^[36] These changes in floral composition suggest fluctuating resource availability that influenced foraging breadth, with humans gathering geophytes and seeds from the Cape Floral Kingdom's diverse biota.^[36] Among non-dietary materials, over 380 ochre pieces, primarily red iron oxide, date from 164,000 to 91,000 years ago, with notable concentrations around 100,000 years ago exhibiting microscopic striations from grinding and scraping.^[37] These modifications, concentrated on the reddest and most saturated portions, point to processing for pigment production, likely used in body painting for social or ritual purposes rather than utilitarian hafting, as hafting residues are absent.^[37] The preferential selection of vibrant hues aligns with symbolic behaviors observed in later Middle Stone Age contexts, providing early evidence of aesthetic or communicative practices.^[37]

Research History

Discovery and Initial Excavations

The archaeological significance of the Pinnacle Point site complex was first recognized in 1997 during a heritage impact assessment conducted ahead of proposed development for a golf estate on the coastal cliffs south of Mossel Bay, Western Cape Province, South Africa. Archaeologists Jonathan Kaplan and Peter Nilssen led the survey, which identified 28 archaeological localities spanning a 2 km stretch of coastline, including a series of caves and rock shelters with visible Middle Stone Age (MSA) deposits rich in stone tools, shellfish remains, and faunal bones.^[16]^[38] The 1997 survey highlighted the site's vulnerability to impending construction activities, which posed immediate threats to the unexcavated deposits through potential bulldozing and site destruction. This prompted urgent documentation efforts, including surface collections and preliminary mapping of exposed sections in caves such as PP13A and PP13B, where MSA layers were evident but partially eroded by natural coastal processes. Limited salvage recording was undertaken to mitigate data loss, though full-scale excavation was deferred due to logistical constraints and the need for further funding.^[16] In response to these risks, a follow-up survey in 1999 by Peter Nilssen and Curtis Marean confirmed the high potential of four key caves (PP13A, PP13B, PP5-6, and PP9C) and advocated for systematic research to preserve the record before further environmental or human-induced damage. Ongoing coastal erosion, driven by wave action and wind, had already exposed and partially disturbed the deposits, underscoring the urgency for intervention in the late 1990s. These early efforts established Pinnacle Point as a critical MSA locality but were constrained by the site's precarious location and the broader challenges of heritage protection amid regional development pressures.^[4]

Key Researchers and Projects

Curtis Marean, a paleoanthropologist at Arizona State University, has been the principal investigator leading excavations at Pinnacle Point since 2000 through the Pinnacle Point Site Project, with a primary focus on Cave 13B (PP13B) to explore early modern human behaviors.^[39] His extensive background in African paleoanthropology, including prior work on faunal assemblages and human evolution, has driven interdisciplinary investigations into coastal adaptations and technological innovations at the site.^[40] Marean's efforts have coordinated a multinational team of archaeologists, geologists, and paleoenvironmental scientists, establishing Pinnacle Point as a cornerstone for understanding Middle Stone Age human origins.^[41] Pioneering surveys in the southern Cape region during the 1990s by Hilary Deacon, a prominent South African archaeologist, provided essential contextual groundwork for later work at Pinnacle Point by mapping Stone Age sites and paleoecological patterns along the coast.^[42] The project has benefited from an international collaborative team, including specialists like Kyle Brown, whose expertise in lithic heat treatment revealed early evidence of this advanced technique at PP13B dating back over 160,000 years.^[43] Other contributors, such as Erella Hovers, have supported comparative analyses of site formation processes and artifact taphonomy, enhancing interpretations of the archaeological record.^[44] The Pinnacle Point research integrates with the Palaeo-Agulhas Plain Project (PAPP), initiated in the 2010s, which examines landscape-scale paleoenvironments and human mobility across the now-submerged continental shelf adjacent to the sites.^[13] This collaborative initiative, involving modelers, geomorphologists, and ecologists, reconstructs the rich ecosystems that supported early human populations during glacial periods. Funding for these efforts has come from major sources, including the U.S. National Science Foundation, which supported initial excavations and ongoing fieldwork, and the Leakey Foundation, which has backed specialized studies on human behavioral evolution at the site.^[45]^[46]

Recent Studies and Dating Methods

Recent studies at Pinnacle Point since 2010 have advanced the precision of chronological frameworks through refined dating techniques, particularly single-grain optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) and electron spin resonance (ESR) methods, which target individual quartz grains and tooth enamel samples to minimize averaging errors in heterogeneous sediments. Single-grain OSL measures the time since last sunlight exposure for each grain, allowing detection of post-depositional mixing and achieving resolutions down to centuries in some layers, while ESR provides independent verification for organic materials like teeth by assessing trapped electrons from radiation exposure. These approaches have been applied across sites like PP13B and PP5-6 to resolve stratigraphic complexities previously obscured by multi-grain averaging.^[47]^[48] A landmark 2025 study by Arizona State University researchers utilized single-grain OSL on 169 samples from Pinnacle Point Site 5-6 (PP5-6), integrated with Bayesian stratigraphic modeling in OxCal software, to produce a high-resolution chronology spanning approximately 110,000 to 50,000 years ago. This analysis confirmed near-continuous human occupation during Marine Isotope Stages (MIS) 5 through early MIS 3, with episodic interruptions tied to sea-level fluctuations and erosion events, such as gaps at 103.9–98.5 ka and 81.1–78.6 ka, supported by archaeological evidence of persistent shellfish exploitation and tool use. The Bayesian framework incorporated prior stratigraphic information to refine age estimates, yielding uncertainties as low as ±1,000 years for key layers and linking deposition patterns to global climate records.^[8]^[23] Paleoenvironmental reconstructions have benefited from stable isotope analyses of speleothems in Pinnacle Point caves, providing a continuous record from 90,000 to 53,000 years ago that reveals shifts in rainfall and aridity linked to MIS 4 cooling. Oxygen (δ¹⁸O) and carbon (δ¹³C) isotope ratios indicate wetter conditions during interstadials and drier, grass-dominated landscapes during glacial phases, correlating with fluctuations in human site use intensity. These data, derived from high-resolution sampling along stalagmite growth axes, complement OSL chronologies by contextualizing environmental drivers of occupation without relying on sparse faunal remains.^[9] Methodological innovations in artifact analysis include 3D optical microscopy combined with Bayesian probabilistic modeling to non-destructively assess tool surfaces, as demonstrated in a 2020 investigation of silcrete artifacts near Pinnacle Point. By quantifying surface roughness parameters from experimental and archaeological samples via silicon peels, the model classified heat-treated pieces—indicative of early pyrotechnology—with 84% accuracy on average, enabling precise identification of thermal alterations dating to around 164,000 years ago at PP13B. This approach integrates stratigraphic priors similar to OxCal applications in dating, enhancing interpretations of Middle Stone Age technological adaptations.^[49]

Implications for Human Evolution

Origins of Modern Behavior

The archaeological record at Pinnacle Point Cave 13B (PP13B) offers pivotal insights into the emergence of behavioral modernity among early Homo sapiens, characterized by innovative foraging strategies and technological advancements during the Middle Stone Age. In layers dated to approximately 164,000 years ago, evidence of complex foraging is apparent through the targeted collection and processing of marine shellfish, which demanded seasonal planning, risk assessment, and coordinated group efforts to access intertidal zones. This systematic resource exploitation represents an early manifestation of flexible problem-solving and ecological adaptability, foundational to modern human behavior.^[34] Technological sophistication at PP13B further underscores these origins, with silcrete stone tools showing heat treatment—a pyrotechnological process involving controlled heating to enhance flaking properties—as early as 164,000 years ago, though it became predominant around 71,000–72,000 years ago. This innovation, which improved tool sharpness and efficiency for tasks like hafting into composite implements, demonstrates foresight, experimentation, and cumulative cultural knowledge, predating analogous Upper Paleolithic technologies in Europe by more than 50,000 years. By 71,000 years ago, heat-treated silcrete facilitated the production of microlithic bladelets, likely used as components of projectile weaponry, marking an enduring advanced lithic tradition in southern Africa. Cognitive dimensions of modern behavior are illuminated by the processing and use of red ochre at PP13B, with dozens of pieces recovered from layers spanning 164,000 to 60,000 years ago, many showing grinding and mixing suggestive of non-utilitarian, symbolic applications such as body adornment or ritual.^[37] This abstract engagement with pigments implies symbolic thinking and social complexity, contrasting with the more limited evidence of such practices among contemporaneous Neanderthals, whose ochre use appears sporadic and functional rather than systematically processed.^[50] The tool-making prowess, including brief references to bladelet production for versatile applications, further highlights enhanced planning and innovation not widely attested in Neanderthal assemblages until later periods. Collectively, PP13B's findings support the coastal dispersal model for Homo sapiens origins, wherein early adaptations to resource-rich coastal niches in southern Africa enabled population expansions and the refinement of modern behaviors, facilitating eventual migrations out of the continent. Recent high-resolution chronologies from optically stimulated luminescence dating confirm these behaviors span Marine Isotope Stages 5 to 3 (approximately 110,000 to 50,000 years ago), linking them to sea-level changes and climatic oscillations.^[3]^[34] These developments challenge Eurocentric timelines for behavioral modernity, affirming Africa's role as the cradle of key human cognitive and technological milestones.

Adaptations to Coastal Environments

During Marine Isotope Stage 6 (MIS 6), approximately 195,000 to 123,000 years ago, early modern humans at Pinnacle Point adapted to arid and fluctuating coastal climates by exploiting marine refugia, where the proximity of the sea to the shore—reaching within 4–5 kilometers of the site—provided access to nutrient-rich intertidal zones.^[34] This strategy was crucial during periods of terrestrial resource scarcity, as the Cape Floral Region's productivity diminished under glacial conditions. Shellfish, particularly species like Turbo sarmaticus and Perna perna, served as a reliable protein buffer, offering year-round availability and high caloric returns that complemented limited plant and animal foods from the hinterland.^[51] These resources underscored how coastal adaptations mitigated famine risks amid environmental stress. Mobility patterns among these populations involved seasonal movements along the southern Cape coast, inferred from the distribution of sites like Pinnacle Point 13B and nearby caves, which align with the patchy availability of intertidal resources.^[34] Resource seasonality, driven by tidal cycles and minor fluctuations in shellfish abundance (higher during spring tides), prompted short-distance migrations of a few kilometers to optimize foraging efficiency, rather than long inland treks.^[17] This coastal-oriented mobility reduced energy expenditure and enhanced foraging success, as evidenced by dense shell middens and lithic scatters concentrated near paleo-shorelines during favorable interstadials within MIS 6.^[51] These adaptations played a pivotal role in population persistence, enabling small groups of early modern humans to endure the harsh conditions of MIS 6 in southern African refugia, thereby maintaining genetic continuity.^[34] The sustained exploitation of marine resources fostered demographic stability, which contributed to the expansion and eventual out-of-Africa migrations around 60,000 years ago, as coastal foragers carried these behavioral innovations northward along the African shoreline.^[51]

Heritage and Conservation

Provincial Heritage Designation

In 2012, the Pinnacle Point Site Complex was declared a Grade I Provincial Heritage Site by Heritage Western Cape, the provincial heritage resources authority, under section 27 of the National Heritage Resources Act (No. 25 of 1999).^[52] This designation, gazetted on 14 December 2012, recognizes the site's national significance for preserving Africa's densest concentration of well-preserved archaeological deposits related to the origins of anatomically modern humans (Homo sapiens), including evidence of early coastal foraging, pigment use, and heat treatment of silcrete for tool-making dating back 170,000 years.^[52] The Grade I status elevates the site to the highest protection level under provincial law, equivalent to national importance, encompassing the cave complex on Erf 15387 and portions of Erf 2001 in Mossel Bay, Western Cape.^[53] The legal protections afforded by the designation prohibit any alteration, damage, excavation, or development that could impact the heritage resources without prior authorization from Heritage Western Cape, as stipulated in sections 34, 35, and 36 of the National Heritage Resources Act.^[52] To further safeguard the site, Mossel Bay Municipality established the Pinnacle Point Heritage Buffer Zone in 2015, approved by Heritage Western Cape on 9 June 2015, which overlays adjacent properties including parts of the Pinnacle Point Golf Estate.^[54] This buffer zone imposes zoning restrictions such as maximum building coverage of 40%, height limits of 8.5 meters (two storeys), and defined building lines (e.g., 5 meters from streets), while requiring archaeological monitoring for any earthworks to prevent physical damage, looting, or erosion of the caves and surrounding deposits.^[55] All new land-use applications within the zone must undergo evaluation under the Act to ensure compatibility with the site's archaeological and palaeoenvironmental integrity.^[55] Local management of the designated site is facilitated through close collaboration between Heritage Western Cape and the Pinnacle Point Estate Homeowners Association (HOA), initiated in 2011 with the development of an Archaeological Conservation Management Plan (ACMP).^[56] Under this framework, the HOA oversees daily security and monitoring, including 24-hour patrols by estate guards to restrict unauthorized access to the caves and heritage areas, thereby mitigating risks of looting and environmental degradation.^[56] The estate's involvement ensures compliance with the ACMP, with any potential disturbances—such as construction or land alterations—requiring on-site archaeological supervision and Heritage Western Cape approval to maintain the site's condition for ongoing research.^[56]

World Heritage Status

In 2024, the Pinnacle Point Site Complex was inscribed as part of the UNESCO World Heritage Site titled "The Emergence of Modern Human Behaviour: The Pleistocene Occupation Sites of South Africa," alongside Diepkloof Rock Shelter and Sibhudu Cave. This cultural property was officially added to the World Heritage List on July 26, 2024, during the 46th session of the UNESCO World Heritage Committee in New Delhi, India.^[1]^[57] The inscription recognizes the site's outstanding universal value under criteria (iii), (iv), and (v), highlighting its exceptional testimony to cultural traditions of the Middle Stone Age, well-preserved records of ancient human life from 162,000 to 38,000 years ago, and evidence of human interaction with coastal environments through resource exploitation.^[1] Spanning dispersed locations along approximately 600 km of South Africa's southern and eastern coastal zones, the serial property underscores Pinnacle Point's role in documenting the origins of behaviorally modern humans, including innovations in toolmaking, symbolic thought, and adaptation to climatic changes.^[1]^[27] This World Heritage status elevates Pinnacle Point's significance in global narratives of human evolution, complementing nearby sites like Blombos Cave in illustrating early modern behaviors such as ochre processing and engraving.^[1] The designation imposes international obligations on South Africa under the UNESCO World Heritage Convention, including enhanced funding and technical support for ongoing research, site management, and conservation to ensure the preservation of these irreplaceable archaeological resources.

Preservation Efforts and Tourism

The Pinnacle Point Site Complex faces significant threats from climate change, including rising sea levels and intensified coastal erosion, which jeopardize the preservation of its stratigraphic sequences and archaeological records dating back over 160,000 years.^[1] These environmental pressures are compounded by potential human-induced risks, such as increased visitation and development activities that could uncover or disturb artifacts.^[54] To address erosion, integrated conservation management plans, including the 2017–2022 framework developed by Square One Landscape Architects, outline strategies for site stabilization and monitoring, with ongoing efforts to resolve water seepage and flow issues affecting the coastal caves.^[54]^[27] Local communities play a key role in protection, actively safeguarding the sites against destructive activities like unauthorized access and looting through collaborative heritage agreements and patrols coordinated with provincial authorities.^[58] Additionally, digital archiving of excavated artifacts—using total station mapping and data loggers for precise provenience records—ensures long-term documentation and accessibility for research while minimizing physical handling.^[59] Tourism at Pinnacle Point is carefully managed to balance public access with site integrity, primarily through guided cave tours operated by Point of Human Origins since the early 2010s.^[60] These tours, limited to small groups of up to 12 visitors per session to reduce foot traffic and environmental impact, provide on-site interpretations of early modern human behaviors, including hands-on demonstrations with replica tools and contextual talks by expert guides.^[61] Educational programs extend beyond the caves, incorporating presentations on human origins and sustainable heritage practices, often linked to exhibits at nearby Mossel Bay institutions like the Bartolomeu Dias Museum Complex, fostering greater public understanding of the site's global significance.^[60] Access is by appointment only, with seasonal adjustments to protect sensitive areas, ensuring that tourism supports conservation funding without compromising the fragile deposits.^[62] Ongoing efforts build on the site's provincial and World Heritage designations to integrate local stakeholders in protection initiatives, including climate-resilient monitoring and community involvement.^[1] Organizations such as the Pinnacle Conservation Trust promote ecotourism and awareness programs that engage residents in flora and fauna preservation, aiming to sustain the site's integrity amid evolving environmental challenges.^[63] These plans include advanced surveying techniques and joint management committees to address emerging threats, ensuring Pinnacle Point remains a vital resource for understanding human evolution.^[27]

References

[1]
The Emergence of Modern Human Behaviour: The Pleistocene ...
Aug 1, 2024 · ... Pinnacle Point Site Complex is located directly on the coast. These sites provide the most varied and best-preserved record known of the ...
[2]
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2010.07.003
[3]
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quascirev.2025.109263
[4]
[PDF] The stratigraphy of the Middle Stone Age sediments at Pinnacle ...
South Africa, approximately 10 km west of the Mossel Bay point. (Fig. 1). Pinnacle Point is a formal geographic location and is now the location of a large ...
[5]
Pinnacle Point Cave 13B (Western Cape Province, South Africa) in ...
A model is developed that suggests that the combined richness of the Cape Floral Region on the south coast of Africa, with its high diversity and density of ...Missing: Indian upwelling
[6]
Atmospheric and advective forcing of upwelling on South Africa's ...
An important feature of the central Agulhas Bank thermal structure is the seasonal (summer–autumn) occurrence of a mid-shelf upwelling ridge positioned roughly ...
[7]
Caves - Pinnacle Point Estate
“This is a significant step towards having Pinnacle Point declared a World Heritage Site,” said Professor Curtis Marean, who heads the South African Coastal ...Missing: UNESCO | Show results with:UNESCO<|control11|><|separator|>
[8]
A high-resolution chronology for the archaeological deposits at ...
Apr 15, 2025 · Pinnacle Point is a rocky headland where a series of caves, rockshelters and open-air localities are situated at the eastern edge of a half- ...
[9]
Late Pleistocene records of speleothem stable isotopic compositions ...
Oct 11, 2018 · We present new speleothem stable oxygen and carbon isotope ratios (δ18Oc and δ13C) from two caves at Pinnacle Point, South Africa, covering the ...
[10]
[PDF] GEOLOGY AND GEOMORPHOLOGY The Pinnacle Point caves are ...
The limestone and calcrete rocks that are exposed on site are part of the Bredasdorp formation. The cliffs at Pinnacle Point show evidence of breccia talus ...Missing: Miocene | Show results with:Miocene
[11]
Technological Trends in the Middle Stone Age of South Africa ...
Deacon, Hilary J., Janette Deacon, Anton Scholtz, J. ... Frequency and distribution of edge damage on Middle Stone Age lithic points, Pinnacle Point 13B, South ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[12]
The Palaeo-Agulhas Plain: A lost world and extinct ecosystem
This palaeoscape comprised the extensive Palaeo-Agulhas Plain (PAP), which was exposed at lower sea levels during glacial periods. Our model predicts that ...
[13]
A lost world and extinct ecosystem - ASU News
May 15, 2020 · However, through most of the last 200,000 years, lowered sea levels during glacial phases, when the ice sucks up the water, exposed a vast plain ...Missing: refugium nutrient- rich shelf
[14]
[PDF] The stratigraphy and sedimentology of the Bredasdorp group ...
The next cycle, reaching a transgressive maximum of c. 180m, started in the Miocene and terminated in the Early Pliocene. Again no evidence of marine deposits ...
[15]
Site formation processes at Pinnacle Point Cave 13B (Mossel Bay ...
The cave is associated with a fluctuating coastal environment, frequent changes in sea level and climate controlled patterns of sedimentation, and the presence ...Missing: wave | Show results with:wave
[16]
(PDF) Pinnacle Point at Mossel Bay, South Africa - ResearchGate
Aug 6, 2025 · Our survey to date has covered a 2 km section of 8km of coastal cliffs, penetrated 1 km inland, and resulted in the discovery of 28 archaeological sites.
[17]
[PDF] Pinnacle Point Cave 13B (Western Cape Province, South Africa) in ...
Pinnacle Point is the only locality in coastal South Africa with archaeological sediments that are shown with geochrono- logical techniques to sample this ...
[18]
Pinnacle Point geology – why early humans could live there
These ancient rocks have been repeatedly eroded by past high sea levels and evidence of these processes remains clear, expressed as erosional notches and wave- ...
[19]
(PDF) Middle and Late Pleistocene paleoscape modeling along the ...
Aug 6, 2025 · Pinnacle Point is directly exposed to the sea. The coastal cliffs are highly folded and faulted exposures of the. Skurweberg Formation of the ...Missing: Miocene | Show results with:Miocene
[20]
The Influence of the Geoarchaeological Career of Paul Goldberg
A series of sea caves and rock shelters with strong anthropogenic contributions are found at Pinnacle Point ... Up to 7 meters of stratified deposits, with ...
[21]
[PDF] An OSL chronology for the sedimentary deposits from Pinnacle Point ...
Sediment micromorphology suggests that the sands are predominantly breakdown products of the roof rock rather than aeolian or marine sands transported in from ...
[22]
Taphonomic implications of orientation of plotted finds from Pinnacle ...
This study evaluates the level of disturbance at Pinnacle Point 13B (PP13B) in Mossel Bay, South Africa using several techniques developed for analyzing clast ...
[23]
Archaeologists use sediment and sunlight to date important site on ...
May 28, 2025 · The archaeological site, Pinnacle Point, is a designated World Heritage Site and contains the earliest evidence of humans eating seafood, using paint, ...
[24]
Lithic technological responses to Late Pleistocene glacial cycling at ...
PP5-6 is a rockshelter and cave site at Pinnacle Point on the south coast of South Africa near Mossel Bay. The rockshelter and cave formed in the quartzitic ...
[25]
Middle Stone Age mineral pigment procurement at Pinnacle Point 5 ...
May 25, 2021 · We report on a multi-method sourcing study of 35 mineral pigment artefacts from the Middle Stone Age site of Pinnacle Point 5–6 North (PP5–6 N),Missing: microlithic processing
[26]
Middle and late Pleistocene faunas of Pinnacle Point and their ...
Sites PP5–6, PP9, PP13A, and PP13B have yielded MSA assemblages, including collections of lithic materials, fauna, worked ochre, and hominin remains (Marean ...
[27]
[PDF] Pleistocene Occupation Sites of South Africa (South Africa) No 1723
Mar 13, 2024 · The archaeological assemblage from Pinnacle Point Site Complex is permanently curated at the Iziko South African Museum in. Cape Town. Sibhudu ...
[28]
Pinnacle Point Cave 13B (Western Cape Province, South Africa) in ...
Aug 9, 2025 · This evidence directs our focus to Marine Isotope Stage (MIS) 6, when from 195-123ka the world was in a fluctuating but predominantly glacial ...Missing: 140000-190000 | Show results with:140000-190000
[29]
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2015.04.006
[30]
Early Evidence for the Extensive Heat Treatment of Silcrete in the ...
Oct 19, 2016 · Silcrete forms a significant component of the raw materials used for tool production in some of the Howiesons Poort and Still Bay sites located ...
[31]
Why Was Silcrete Heat-Treated in the Middle Stone Age? An Early ...
In this paper we present data on heat treatment of silcrete through the Howiesons Poort and post-Howiesons Poort of the rock shelter site Mertenhof.
[32]
Heat treatment significantly increases the sharpness of silcrete stone ...
Oct 6, 2020 · Results show that heat-treated silcrete can be significantly sharper than unheated alternatives, with cutting forces halving and energy requirements reducing.
[33]
Howiesons Poort backed artifacts provide evidence for social ...
Jun 9, 2022 · They suggest the Howiesons Poort lasted for closer to 50,000 years, starting approximately 105/109 ka and not vanishing until after 52 ka (see ...Missing: occupation | Show results with:occupation
[34]
Lithic technological responses to Late Pleistocene glacial cycling at ...
The Pinnacle Point caves occur in Skurweberg quartzitic sandstone; however most of this material is coarse-grained and does not fracture conchoidally. The ...
[35]
Pinnacle Point Cave 13B (Western Cape Province, South Africa) in ...
Pinnacle Point is the only locality in coastal South Africa with archaeological sediments that are shown with geochronological techniques to sample this ...
[36]
Seasonal scheduling of shellfish collection in the Middle and Later ...
Results from two Middle Stone Age sites, Klasies River and Pinnacle Point 5–6, show distinct seasonal patterns that likely reflect the seasonal availability of ...
[37]
The Exploitation of Plant Resources by Early Homo sapiens: The ...
Jun 12, 2012 · Pinnacle Point 13B (PP13B) is one of several South African Middle ... In some areas of the site, there is excellent preservation of ...
[38]
The pigments from Pinnacle Point Cave 13B, Western Cape, South ...
Earth pigments from the three excavations at Pinnacle Point Cave 13B (Western Cape Province, South Africa), spanning the terminal middle Pleistocene and ...Missing: PP13A PP13C
[39]
A talk by Dr Peter Nilssen on the discovery and findings of the Point ...
Peter initiated the ongoing research at Pinnacle Point with Curtis Marean after discovering the cave sites in 1997 with Jonathan Kaplan. This talk will be ...
[40]
ASU research site given UNESCO World Heritage designation
the Olympic gold medal of ...Missing: complex | Show results with:complex
[41]
Curtis Marean - ASU Search
Curtis Marean's research interests focus on the origins of modern humans ... study of sedimentary microfacies at site Pinnacle Point 5-6, South Africa.
[42]
Curtis MAREAN | Arizona State University, Tempe | Research profile
The earliest evidence for this is the heat treatment of silcrete ~164 ka at the Middle Stone Age site, Pinnacle Point 13B in South Africa. Heating stone prior ...
[43]
Hilary John Deacon: Archaeologist (1936-2010) - SciELO South Africa
Hilary Deacon's career was based on a broad and solid grounding in both ... Pinnacle Point, freeing them in some respects from constraints of ...
[44]
An early and enduring advanced technology originating ... - PubMed
Nov 22, 2012 · Here we describe a previously unrecognized advanced stone tool technology from Pinnacle Point Site 5-6 on the south coast of South Africa, ...Missing: deposits 110000– 30000 ochre processing
[45]
Taphonomic implications of orientation of plotted finds from Pinnacle ...
Aug 9, 2025 · The fabric analysis performed by Bernatchez [121] illustrates that most artifacts at PP13B are subjected to disturbance intensity less than that ...
[46]
Excavations at Cave 13B, Pinnacle Point at Mossel Bay, South ...
With National Science Foundation support, Dr. Curtis Marean conducted exploratory archaeological investigations in July of 2000 of three caves near Mossel ...
[47]
Grantee Spotlight: Naomi Cleghorn - The Leakey Foundation
Feb 4, 2015 · Graduate student Christopher Shelton (L) and Naomi Cleghorn working at Pinnacle Point site 5/6. They found KEH-1 in 2012 during a survey.Missing: NSF | Show results with:NSF
[48]
An OSL chronology for the sedimentary deposits from Pinnacle Point ...
This study also used the same systematic approach as that used for the dating of the Howieson's Poort and Still Bay in South Africa. This single-grain ...
[49]
An OSL chronology for the sedimentary deposits from Pinnacle Point ...
Ages have been obtained for 30 samples from the Middle Stone Age and from ... dating of the Howieson's Poort and Still Bay in South Africa. This single ...Missing: Howiesons | Show results with:Howiesons
[50]
A new approach to identify heat treated silcrete near Pinnacle Point ...
Silicon peels precisely replicate the surface roughness of silcrete flakes. •. Our Bayesian model predicts heat treatment with an average accuracy of 84%. •.
[51]
Use of red ochre by early Neandertals - PNAS
Jan 23, 2012 · I Watts, The pigments from Pinnacle Point cave 13B, Western Cape, South Africa. J Hum Evol 59, 392–411 (2010). Crossref · PubMed · Google ...
[52]
Early human use of marine resources and pigment in South Africa ...
Oct 18, 2007 · Here we show that by ∼164 kyr ago (±12 kyr) at Pinnacle Point (on the south coast of South Africa) humans expanded their diet to include marine resources.
[53]
Early, intensive marine resource exploitation by Middle Stone Age ...
Apr 12, 2021 · At Pinnacle Point, layers with marine shells are dated to ∼162 ± 12 ka, 125 ± 10 ka, and 126 ± 10 ka (14, 57), but none of these are considered ...
[54]
[PDF] Provincial Gazette Provinsiale Koerant - SAFLII
Dec 14, 2012 · ... ........................................ 2695. Heritage Western Cape: Declaration of heritage resources as provincial heritage sites ...
[55]
New Heritage Site Declared at Pinnacle Point - d7.westerncape.gov.za
Jan 24, 2013 · Tourism and job opportunities are expected to flow to Mossel Bay with the declaration in December 2012 of caves at Pinnacle Point as a provincial heritage site.Missing: designation | Show results with:designation
[56]
None
### Summary of Pinnacle Point Heritage Buffer Zone
[57]
[PDF] Zoning Scheme By-law - Mossel Bay Municipality
Jul 30, 2015 · The Buffer Zone will be established on the following ... Pinnacle Point Golf Estate, on arrangement with the Pinnacle Point Golf Estate.
[58]
Managing heritage resources: Pinnacle Point Estate
The caves were declared a provincial heritage site in 2012, and the HOA continues to monitor and protect them under the auspices of HWC, and in terms of the ...Missing: collaboration security<|control11|><|separator|>
[59]
History & World Heritage Site - Point of Human Origins
Allow us to introduce you to the Pinnacle Point Site Complex - the place that's revealed among the earliest evidence for modern human behaviour. This short, ...Missing: pre- | Show results with:pre-
[60]
Exciting times ahead as the internationally acclaimed Pinnacle Point ...
Jul 23, 2024 · There is also proof of early stone-age, middle stone-age ... Pinnacle Point assemblage is not Howiesons Poort, but shares some technological ...
[61]
Pinnacle Point: Excavation and Survey Methods | Request PDF
We used a digital archive comprising the location data for all finds previously excavated from the site (fauna, flora, lithic artifacts, and geological ...
[62]
Point of Human Origins: Archaeological Tours, South Africa
Visit archaeological cave site at the Pinnacle Point Site Complex, a World Heritage Site with early evidence for the emergence of modern human behaviour.Cave Tours · Tours · Point to Point · History & World Heritage Site
[63]
Point of Human Origins Experience - Garden Route - SA-Venues.com
The Human Origins Experience is a tour that explores these beginnings of modern human behaviour, making it available to anyone who wants to know more.<|separator|>
[64]
Point of Human Origins (2025) - All You Need to Know ... - Tripadvisor
Our tour is a dual journey - one in space and time, and one within. Our main goals are to create awareness of the original human design, to awaken the human ...
[65]
Introducing... Pinnacle Conservation | Mossel Bay Advertiser
Sep 27, 2013 · Our mission is to teach the community that, through preservation of local fauna and flora, they will be able to sustainably exploit ecotourism ...