Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Prince of Nothing

The Prince of Nothing is a trilogy of epic fantasy novels by Canadian author R. Scott Bakker, published between 2003 and 2006, set in the richly detailed world of Eärwa on the continent of the Three Seas.^[1] The series centers on a massive Holy War called by the Thousand Temples, launched by the Inrithi kingdoms of the North against the Fanim heretics of the desert south, blending elements of historical crusades with philosophical inquiry into faith, power, and human cognition.^[1] Key characters include the manipulative warrior-priest Anasûrimbor Kellhus, a hyper-intelligent figure from the mysterious Thousand Temples monastery; Drusas Achamian, a sorcerer haunted by prophetic dreams; and Esmenet, a former prostitute entangled in the escalating conflict.^[1] The trilogy comprises The Darkness That Comes Before (first published April 2003), which introduces the converging plotlines and the impending apocalypse; The Warrior-Prophet (first published 2004), focusing on the Holy War's march and Kellhus's rise as a messianic leader; and The Thousandfold Thought (first published 2006), culminating in the siege of Shimeh and revelations about ancient threats.^[2]^[3]^[4] Published initially by Penguin Books Canada, Overlook Press in the US, and Orbit in the UK, the books feature intricate world-building, including non-human races like the Cûnuroi and Sranc, and explore themes of religious fanaticism, collective delusion, and the limits of reason amid supernatural horrors.^[1] As the opening arc of Bakker's broader Second Apocalypse series—which continues with the Aspect-Emperor quadrilogy (2009–2017)—The Prince of Nothing depicts events twenty years prior to a prophesied cataclysmic return of ancient Consult forces, drawing inspiration from J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth and Frank Herbert's Dune while emphasizing gritty realism and psychological depth.^[1] The narrative employs an omniscient style to capture the epic scale of battles and intrigues, earning praise for its ambitious scope and intellectual rigor, though noted for its dark tone and complex prose.^[1]

Overview

Publication History

The Prince of Nothing trilogy was developed by R. Scott Bakker, a Canadian author who pursued a PhD in philosophy at Vanderbilt University, whose academic background in literature, history, and ancient languages profoundly shaped the series' intricate world-building and thematic exploration of belief, violence, and human cognition. Bakker began constructing the world of Eärwa in the mid-1980s as a hobby inspired by role-playing games and epic fantasy, but the narrative core of the trilogy emerged around 1986 during his university years; he spent approximately 15 years refining the manuscripts before securing publication, drawing on his philosophical studies to infuse the work with intellectual depth.^[5]^[1] The first novel, The Darkness That Comes Before, was initially published in Canada by Penguin Canada in March 2003, marking Bakker's debut in professional fiction after years of personal development; it was released in the United States by Overlook Press and in the United Kingdom by Simon & Schuster in 2004 (trade paperback) and by Orbit Books in 2005 (paperback).^[2] The second volume, The Warrior-Prophet, followed with a Canadian edition from Penguin Canada in 2004, a US release from Overlook Press in 2005, and a UK edition from Orbit in 2006. The trilogy concluded with The Thousandfold Thought, published in Canada and the US by Penguin Canada and Overlook Press, respectively, in 2006, and in the UK by Orbit in 2007. These releases transitioned Bakker from regional recognition to international availability through established genre publishers, without reliance on smaller presses.^[6]^[7]^[5] Each book appeared first in hardcover, followed by paperback editions within one to two years, with ebook versions becoming available starting in the late 2000s through platforms like Amazon Kindle; no significant revisions or alternate editions have been issued as of 2025. The series' initial sales were modest, reflecting its dense, philosophical style, but it gradually built a dedicated cult following among readers of epic fantasy. Prince of Nothing serves as the foundational trilogy of Bakker's larger Second Apocalypse series.^[8]^[1]

Series Premise

The Prince of Nothing trilogy by R. Scott Bakker is set in the richly detailed world of Eärwa, a medieval-inspired realm scarred by a cataclysmic apocalypse thousands of years prior, where ancient non-human threats linger in the shadows, poised to unleash further devastation. The central conflict revolves around a prophesied Holy War, a massive crusade marshaled by the dominant Inrithi religion against the Fanim heathens to reclaim the holy city of Shimeh in the distant south. At the heart of this narrative is Anasûrimbor Kellhus, a prodigious warrior-monk trained in a remote monastic order, whose unparalleled intellect and manipulative prowess allow him to infiltrate and influence the war's fractious leaders, drawing them into his enigmatic designs.^[9]^[10]^[11] The trilogy unfolds across three volumes—The Darkness That Comes Before (2003), The Warrior-Prophet (2004), and The Thousandfold Thought (2006)—building from the intricate political and religious machinations that ignite the crusade to escalating revelations about destiny, hidden manipulations, and the interplay between mortal ambitions and existential perils. Interwoven throughout are the rivalries of sorcerous schools, whose practitioners wield reality-warping powers but face damnation from pious factions, heightening the stakes amid a backdrop of fanaticism and betrayal. This structure transforms the initial intrigue of a faith-driven expedition into a profound exploration of power's corrupting influence and the fragility of human will.^[10]^[9] Bakker employs a dense, introspective prose style that emphasizes psychological depth, drawing on his philosophical background to dissect character motivations and the illusions shaping belief and action, resulting in an epic fantasy infused with grimdark elements of unrelenting violence, moral ambiguity, and existential dread. The series stands out for its avoidance of traditional heroic tropes, instead presenting a tapestry of flawed individuals ensnared by larger forces, where the Holy War serves as both a literal march and a metaphor for humanity's confrontation with its own darkness.^[10]^[11]

World and Setting

Eärwa and Its Races

Eärwa is the central world of R. Scott Bakker's Second Apocalypse series, depicted as a vast continent shaped by divine creation and ancient cataclysms, where the fabric of reality intersects with metaphysical forces. Created by a pantheon of gods, Eärwa serves as a battleground between mortal inhabitants and extradimensional threats, with its cosmology structured around the material world and the transcendent Outside—a realm of infinite possibility and damnation that lies beyond sensory perception. The Inchoroi, an alien race of biomechanical invaders originating from the Outside, arrived millennia ago seeking to seal Eärwa from divine judgment by eradicating sentient life, thereby preventing souls from achieving salvation and perpetuating their own exile from the gods' mercy.^[12]^[13]^[1] The inhabitants of Eärwa encompass diverse races, each marked by profound historical conflicts. Humans form the dominant species, comprising varied ethnic groups such as the fair-skinned, light-eyed Scylvendi nomads of the eastern steppes and other tribes scattered across the continent, whose ancestors were once enslaved by elder races. The Nonmen, known as the Cûnuroi in their ancient tongue, are immortal, elf-like beings who predated human arrival by tens of thousands of years; they established sophisticated underground mansions and wielded powerful sorcery, but suffered catastrophic losses during the Inchoroi wars, leading to subtypes like the noble Cûnuroi and the memory-afflicted Erratics, who wander as tormented exiles. In contrast, the Sranc represent a perversion of life, engineered by the Inchoroi as swarming, bestial hordes driven by insatiable lust and violence, serving as disposable shock troops in apocalyptic conflicts.^[12]^[13]^[1] Geographically, Eärwa features harsh, expansive terrains that echo its turbulent past, including the frozen northern wildernesses of the Ancient North—once thriving human kingdoms now reduced to haunted ruins from the First Apocalypse, a cataclysmic war against the Inchoroi and their Consult allies around 2,000 years prior. To the east lie the arid Jiünati Steppes, home to the nomadic Scylvendi tribes, whose grasslands support a warrior culture amid constant threats from Sranc incursions. Scattered throughout are ancient Nonman ruins, such as the subterranean Mansions like Siol, testaments to pre-human grandeur now infested by horrors from the Outside.^[12]^[1] Sorcery in Eärwa draws power from the ontos, the underlying reality, but is viewed as an abomination by the gods, marking practitioners with the "Mark" that signals their damnation in the afterlife. The primary schools include the Gnosis, a rigorous, logic-based tradition inherited from the Nonmen Quya and preserved by human sects like the Mandate, enabling precise manipulations of causality at great metaphysical cost. The Anagogis employs metaphorical invocations tied to cultural and emotional significances, widely practiced despite its illusions of meaning. The Daimos, or Psûkhe, manipulates souls directly without traditional sorcery, accessible to those with innate sensitivity but still incurring divine wrath. All forms risk eternal torment, reinforcing the world's eschatological tension.^[12]^[13]

The Three Seas and Societies

The Three Seas refers to the densely populated human heartland in south-central Eärwa, comprising the interconnected regions surrounding the inland bodies of water known as the Seas of Meneanor, Nyranisas, and Oncis. This area serves as the primary stage for the series' exploration of human civilization, marked by a mix of imperial decadence, desert theocracies, and northern feudal kingdoms recovering from ancient cataclysms. The geography features the fertile lowlands and bustling ports of the Nansur Empire in the east, the arid expanses of the Kianene lands to the south, and the rugged hills and plains of northern realms such as Galeoth and High Ainon.^[14]^[15] Societies within the Three Seas are characterized by stratified feudal hierarchies, where noble houses, warrior castes, and merchant classes dominate, often sustained by extensive slave economies particularly prevalent in the Nansur Empire. Patriarchal norms prevail across most regions, with women largely excluded from positions of political or military power, though cultural variations exist—northern societies like those in Galeoth emphasize martial honor and tribal loyalties, while the Kianene maintain a more rigid, piety-driven social order. Economic life revolves around trade routes linking the seas, agriculture in the river valleys, and resource extraction from surrounding frontiers, fostering both prosperity and internecine rivalries.^[14]^[15] The dominant religion in the Three Seas is Inrithism, a monotheistic faith governed by the Thousand Temples and centered in the holy city of Sumna, drawing from the ancient scriptures of the Tusk—a collection of tribal laws and myths—and the revelations of Inri Sejenus, the Latter Prophet, who was executed on the Circumfix symbol. Inrithism condemns sorcery as an abomination, viewing it as a mark of damnation, yet tolerates certain schools of magic under strict oversight, integrating polytheistic elements from pre-Revelation traditions into its worship of the divine God. The faith exerts significant theocratic influence, uniting disparate nations under its spiritual authority while fueling ambitions for expansion.^[14]^[15] In contrast, Fanimry holds sway exclusively in the Kianene theocracy, representing a puritanical monotheistic rival to Inrithism that emerged from the teachings of the desert prophet Fane. Kian's society under Fanimry is organized as a militant theocracy, with padirajahs ruling as both temporal and spiritual leaders, and its warrior Cishaurim—mystics who wield a unique, non-sorcerous form of magic—enforcing doctrinal purity. This faith's control over the sacred city of Shimeh intensifies longstanding religious tensions with Inrithic powers.^[14]^[15]^[16] Politically, the Nansur Empire stands as the preeminent power in the Three Seas, a sprawling, bureaucratic state ruled from the opulent capital of Momemn, where Emperor Xerius III pursues imperial revival through military campaigns and diplomatic maneuvering against neighboring threats. To the north, kingdoms like High Ainon and Galeoth operate as confederations of feudal lords, with High Ain's scholarly traditions contrasting Galeoth's hardy, Tusk-worshipping warrior ethos. The Thousand Temples wield overarching theocratic control across Inrithic lands, coordinating religious edicts and levies, while tribal groups such as the Conriots provide fierce, nomadic warrior contingents allied to various crowns. In Kian, the Padishah's theocratic rule enforces unity amid desert harshness, positioning it as a formidable southern bulwark.^[14]^[15] Underlying these structures is the pervasive influence of sorcerous institutions, such as the Mandate, an ancient order of wizards dedicated to vigilance against non-human threats from the north, operating on the fringes of Inrithic society despite widespread condemnation of their arts. This interplay of imperial ambitions, theocratic mandates, and arcane undercurrents defines the precarious balance of power in the Three Seas.^[14]

Plot Summary

The Holy War and Key Events

The Holy War, a massive crusade convened by the Inrithi faiths against the Fanim heathens in the south, forms the central narrative thread of the Prince of Nothing trilogy. In The Darkness That Comes Before, the story opens with the political machinations surrounding the convocation of the Holy War in the imperial capital of Momemn, where Emperor Ikurei Xerius III seeks to exploit the crusade for territorial gains while the Shriah Maithanet mobilizes the faithful.^[17] Thousands of Men of the Tusk—knights, barbarians, and pilgrims from across the Three Seas—gather amid tensions between sorcerous Schools vying for influence and the parallel Fanim jihad led by the Cishaurim. The Holy War departs Momemn and marches southward, encountering initial skirmishes and logistical hardships, including a decisive battle at the River Sempis where Nansur forces under General Ikurei Conphas clash with Kianene armies, setting the stage for deeper intrigues and betrayals within the crusade's ranks.^[18] As detailed in The Warrior-Prophet, the Holy War presses deeper into Fanim territory, facing escalating hardships from desert terrain, supply shortages, and ambushes that exacerbate internal divisions among the Inrithi leaders. A pivotal event is the prolonged siege of Caraskand, a fortified Kianene city, where the crusaders suffer heavy losses but ultimately breach its walls through a combination of sorcery, betrayal, and sheer ferocity, claiming a pyrrhic victory that fractures alliances further.^[19] Prophetic visions and rumors of divine intervention intensify, leading to the emergence of a figure hailed as the Warrior-Prophet who unites disparate factions amid growing suspicions of treachery from within, including infernal pacts struck by key participants. The march continues toward the sacred city of Shimeh, with the crusade teetering on the brink of collapse as external threats from the Cishaurim and internal schisms threaten to unravel the entire endeavor.^[20] The Thousandfold Thought culminates the trilogy's arc with the Holy War's final push to Shimeh, the holy city of the Inrithi faith, where the crusaders confront not only the entrenched Fanim forces but also profound revelations about ancient threats. Climactic battles erupt around Shimeh, involving sorcerous duels between the Scarlet Spires and the Cishaurim, as well as ground assaults that decimate the Inrithi host.^[21] The resolution unfolds through confrontations with hidden manipulators and disclosures regarding the Consult's machinations, transforming the crusade from a war of conquest into an apocalyptic struggle, though the Holy War achieves its nominal goal at immense cost, leaving the Three Seas forever altered.^[22] Throughout the trilogy, the Holy War evolves from a politically driven expedition marked by imperial scheming and factional rivalries into a transformative odyssey fraught with prophetic escalations and existential perils, ultimately reshaping the geopolitical landscape of Eärwa.

Role of Prophecy and the Consult

The Consult represents the primary antagonistic force in the Prince of Nothing series, an ancient and secretive cabal comprising human sorcerers, Nonmen, and the alien Inchoroi, driven by a nihilistic quest to eradicate all existence as a means of escaping eternal damnation.^[23] This alliance formed in the distant past when members of the Mangaecca school of sorcery uncovered the Inverse Fire, a metaphysical artifact revealing the torment awaiting souls in the "Outside"—a hellish realm beyond the world of Eärwa—prompting them to pursue universal oblivion as salvation.^[23] Their motivations stem from a profound horror of this damnation, leading them to employ forbidden sorcery and the alien Tekne, a biotechnological science, in their efforts to silence all souls and prevent any further suffering.^[23] The history of the Consult is inextricably linked to the First Apocalypse, a cataclysmic war that scarred Eärwa millennia ago, when the Inchoroi arrived from the void aboard their massive Ark, intent on conquering the world to achieve their own redemption by ending all life.^[23] The Inchoroi, grotesque and technologically advanced extraterrestrials, allied with treacherous Nonmen and human sorcerers to wage this apocalyptic conflict against the Nonman kingdoms and early human civilizations, nearly succeeding in their genocidal aims.^[23] Central to their arsenal was the No-God, known as Mog-Pharau^[24], a colossal weapon forged through the Tekne to "unworld" existence by severing the connection between souls and the divine, effectively dooming the world to a voiceless void; though defeated, its creation marked the Consult's emergence as an enduring threat.^[23] In the present era of the series, the Consult's machinations foreshadow the Second Apocalypse, a prophesied recurrence of the ancient cataclysm, where they command vast hordes of Sranc—ferocious, rape-obsessed homunculi bred as shock troops—and deploy insidious Tekne creations to undermine human societies.^[25] Key among these artifacts are the Skin-Spies, grotesque infiltrators crafted from Nonman flesh and Inchoroi biotechnology, designed to mimic humans undetected and sow chaos from within, advancing the Consult's goal of resurrecting the No-God to consummate their vision of non-existence.^[25] This looming threat mirrors the First Apocalypse's devastation, blending metaphysical horror with technological abomination to imperil the fragile civilizations of the Three Seas. Prophecy plays a pivotal role in countering the Consult's designs, most notably through the Celmomian prophecies, the dying utterances of Anasûrimbor Celmomas II during the First Apocalypse, which foretell the return of an heir from his bloodline after two millennia to lead the fight against the resurgent darkness of the Second Apocalypse.^[26] These visions, preserved through the dream-sorcery of the Mandate school, intertwine with the Dûnyain breeding programs, an isolated monastic order's millennia-long effort to engineer superhuman intellect and emotional transcendence via selective breeding and rigorous conditioning, producing individuals capable of mastering causality itself.^[26] The prophesied "Prince of Nothing"—a figure devoid of worldly ties yet wielding absolute dominion—emerges from this lineage, embodying the prophecies' promise of a savior against the Consult's apocalyptic machinery, though the fulfillment raises profound questions about predestination and free will in Eärwa's metaphysics.^[26] The Holy War, a massive crusade central to the series, unwittingly intersects with these prophetic currents and the Consult's hidden manipulations, drawing disparate forces toward a confrontation with the ancient evil.^[25]

Characters

Protagonists and Central Figures

Anasûrimbor Kellhus is a central protagonist in the Prince of Nothing trilogy, portrayed as a Dûnyain monk trained from birth in an isolated monastery near Golgotterath to achieve absolute control over mind and body through rigorous discipline in logic, rhetoric, and physical prowess.^[27] Bred for perfection by the Dûnyain order, Kellhus possesses superhuman perceptual abilities, allowing him to read subtle facial expressions, tones, and intentions to manipulate others with near-infallible precision, often bending wills without overt force.^[28] His primary role drives the narrative as he leaves the monastery on a quest to find his father, Anasûrimbor Moënghus, whose disappearance decades earlier shattered the Dûnyain's isolationist doctrines, propelling Kellhus into the chaos of the Holy War where his skills enable him to influence leaders and events profoundly.^[27] Drusas Achamian, commonly known as Akka, serves as another key viewpoint character, a sorcerer of the Mandate school whose members are haunted nightly by prophetic dreams of the First Apocalypse, a cataclysmic event two millennia prior that nearly ended humanity.^[29] As a wizard-spy, Achamian grapples with his duties to investigate signs of the Consult—a secretive cabal plotting a Second Apocalypse—while navigating personal conflicts, including a forbidden romance that challenges the Mandate's ascetic vows and his own doubts about the reliability of his visions.^[30] His role in the story centers on teaching and allying with Kellhus during the Holy War, providing intellectual and magical insight that underscores themes of doubt and redemption amid escalating threats.^[31] Esmenet emerges as a complex figure of intellect and resilience, beginning as a literate prostitute in the city of Sumna where she supplements her income by tutoring and forms a deep emotional bond with Achamian, offering him solace from his tormented existence.^[32] Her background in a patriarchal society limits her agency, yet her sharp mind and empathy allow her to rise through alliances formed during the Holy War, evolving from marginalization to positions of influence that explore her struggle for autonomy and self-worth.^[33] Esmenet's interactions with the protagonists highlight her role in humanizing their philosophical pursuits, as she navigates love, loss, and power in a world that commodifies women. Cnaiür urs Skiötha, chieftain of the Scylvendi tribes—fierce nomadic warriors of the eastern steppes—embodies raw physical might and unyielding cultural pride, renowned as the most violent of men for his brutal combat skills and unorthodox tactics that have earned him the moniker "the Mad Scylvendi."^[34] Driven by a consuming vengeance against Moënghus for betraying his father and leading to the massacre of his people, Cnaiür joins the Holy War under false pretenses, his psychological turmoil manifesting in fits of rage and introspection that contrast the calculated natures of other protagonists.^[35] His alliance with Kellhus, forged through shared enmity, propels key events, showcasing his prowess as a warrior while revealing deep internal conflicts rooted in shame and tribal honor.^[36]

Antagonists and Supporting Roles

Anasûrimbor Moënghus serves as a pivotal antagonistic figure in the series, functioning as the exiled father of Anasûrimbor Kellhus and a former Dûnyain monk who has integrated into the societies of the Three Seas after fleeing his monastic origins.^[37] His manipulations from afar orchestrate broader geopolitical and prophetic events, drawing his son into a quest that intersects with the Holy War.^[15] Moënghus's decision to "go native" in Shimeh, the holy city, represents a betrayal of Dûnyain principles, positioning him as a shadowy architect of conflict who influences alliances and betrayals among human factions.^[15] Ikurei Conphas embodies ambitious military opposition within the Nansur Empire, as the nephew of Emperor Ikurei Xerius III and a strategically brilliant general leading imperial forces in the Holy War.^[15] His moral ambiguity and conceited pursuit of control over the crusade's outcomes create tensions with other leaders, often prioritizing imperial dominance over religious zeal.^[1] Conphas's tactical genius drives key confrontations, underscoring themes of power and betrayal as he navigates the political undercurrents of the campaign.^[15] Sërwe functions as a supporting character entangled in the power dynamics of the Holy War, initially appearing as a vulnerable slave concubine captured as a battle-prize by a tribal leader.^[37] Her role highlights the exploitation and agency of women in the series' harsh world, becoming a concubine whose personal entanglements influence interpersonal conflicts and loyalties.^[11] Despite her apparent fragility, Sërwe's interactions reveal moments of unexpected resilience amid the surrounding brutality.^[11] Agents of the Consult, particularly the Skin-Spies, represent a insidious antagonistic force infiltrating human society during the Holy War, created through ancient Inchoroi technology to mimic and undermine their targets.^[15] These non-human spies, part of the Consult's broader cabal of sorcerers and generals responsible for awakening the No-God in the First Apocalypse, operate covertly to advance their apocalyptic agenda after centuries of dormancy.^[37] Their presence introduces existential threats, challenging perceptions of identity and loyalty within the crusading ranks.^[15] Among supporting roles, Maithanet stands out as the high prelate of the Thousand Temples and leader of the Inrithi faith, whose issuance of the Holy War decree against the Fanim propels the central conflict.^[37] His religious authority shapes the moral and political landscape, fostering alliances while concealing deeper motives tied to ancient threats.^[1] Proyas, a noble prince and key ally in the crusade, provides strategic and ideological support, his devout perspective influencing group dynamics and decisions.^[1] Various tribal leaders, such as those from the Scylvendi and other nomadic groups, contribute to the narrative through their fierce independence and rivalries, complicating the Holy War's progress with cultural clashes and opportunistic maneuvers.^[15]

Themes and Influences

Historical and Cultural Inspirations

The Prince of Nothing trilogy draws heavily from the historical dynamics of the Crusades, particularly the First Crusade of 1096–1099, in structuring its central Holy War narrative. The Inrithi crusade against the Fanim to reclaim the holy city of Shimeh mirrors the Christian campaigns to capture Jerusalem, including the mobilization of disparate northern European kingdoms under a religious banner, the logistical challenges of a massive host marching through hostile territories, and the ensuing atrocities upon reaching the objective.^[38] This parallel extends to the political machinations among crusade leaders, evoking the rivalries and betrayals during the historical event.^[39] The Nansur Empire serves as a primary analogue to the Byzantine Empire, particularly during the Komnenian era of the late 11th and early 12th centuries, reflecting a sophisticated, intrigue-laden imperial court besieged by external threats. Elements such as the emperor's strategic use of mercenaries, the opulent yet decaying capital of Momemn, and the empire's role as a cultural crossroads between northern "barbarian" kingdoms and southern heathens echo Byzantium's position amid the Seljuk Turks and Latin crusaders.^[40] Additionally, the philosophical schools and academies within Nansur society evoke Hellenistic Greek traditions, with their emphasis on rhetoric, metaphysics, and intellectual debate reminiscent of the Platonic Academy or Stoic schools in ancient Athens and Alexandria.^[15] The Scylvendi tribes embody nomadic warrior cultures akin to the Scythians of the Eurasian steppes (circa 7th–3rd centuries BCE), characterized by their horse-archer prowess, ritualistic scalping practices, and fierce independence from settled empires. Their tribal confederation and disdain for agrarian societies parallel Scythian raids on Greek colonies and Persian territories, while their shamanistic elements draw from steppe nomadic spiritualities.^[41] In contrast, the Fanim religion and Kianene culture are inspired by medieval Islam, particularly the Fatimid and Seljuk caliphates, with their monotheistic fervor, desert warfare tactics, and theocratic governance mirroring the resistance to crusader incursions in the Levant and Anatolia.^[15] Beyond these socio-historical borrowings, the Nonmen race incorporates motifs from elven myths in European folklore and literature, portraying them as ancient, ethereal beings with near-immortal lifespans, profound sorrow from lost glories, and an otherworldly beauty that borders on the uncanny.^[42] The Inchoroi, meanwhile, represent Lovecraftian cosmic horror influences, depicted as grotesque alien entities driven by hedonistic and existential dread, whose technology and philosophy evoke H.P. Lovecraft's Great Old Ones as intrusive, reality-warping outsiders indifferent to mortal concerns.^[15]

Philosophical and Metaphysical Elements

The Prince of Nothing trilogy deeply integrates philosophical inquiry, reflecting author R. Scott Bakker's academic background in philosophy to examine human cognition, causality, and the illusions of selfhood. Central to this exploration is the Dûnyain order's adherence to the Logos, a principle emphasizing rational dominion over emotion and the inexorable chains of cause and effect, which they pursue to forge an "absolute will" unbound by worldly contingencies.^[1] The Dûnyain train relentlessly to predict and manipulate outcomes with precision, viewing history and passion as veils that obscure true agency, ultimately striving for the Absolute—a state of self-moving thought where the soul operates independently of external determinants.^[43] Anasûrimbor Kellhus, the series' pivotal figure, incarnates this philosophy as a near-superhuman intellect capable of dissecting social interactions and human frailties in advance, rendering him an embodiment of unyielding rational control.^[13] Metaphysically, the narrative probes the tension between free will and determinism, positing a universe governed by rigid causal laws that undermine subjective notions of choice, a theme Bakker attributes to humanity's hardwired predisposition toward illusionary beliefs.^[43] Sorcery serves as a stark metaphysical emblem in this debate, functioning as an irrefutable mark of objective damnation that contradicts the world's purported divine harmony and reinforces a deterministic ontology where actions indelibly stain the soul, independent of intent or perception.^[23] This portrayal underscores Bakker's view that no frame of reference is absolute, urging continual revision of assumptions about agency and consequence to counter cognitive blind spots.^[43] The series critiques religion through the lenses of Inrithism and Fanimry, depicting them as mechanisms of social control that exploit humanity's innate credulity and thirst for certainty, paralleling Bakker's agnostic stance that traditional faiths masquerade doubt as absolute knowledge.^[13] Bakker contrasts two forms of faith: one open to doubt and the "superunknown," embracing revision, and the other rigidly certain, blind to its own limitations, with the former aligning more closely to philosophical inquiry than institutionalized dogma.^[43] In Eärwa, these religions enforce objective values in a pre-scientific milieu, mirroring ancestral worldviews where belief coordinated communities but stifled critical awareness.^[1] Recurring themes of blindness highlight human ignorance to higher truths, drawing from Bakker's work on cognition and the "Blind Brain Theory," which posits that consciousness neglects its own mechanistic underpinnings, fostering delusions of autonomy and meaning.^[44] This motif permeates the trilogy as characters grapple with unseen causal forces, echoing Bakker's contention that our perspectives are inherently limited, compelling perpetual questioning to approximate deeper realities.^[43]

Legacy and Continuation

Critical Reception

The Prince of Nothing trilogy received widespread critical acclaim for its intellectual depth, intricate world-building, and subversion of traditional fantasy tropes, establishing R. Scott Bakker as a significant voice in the genre.^[45] Reviewers praised the series' dense, philosophical prose and exploration of themes like faith, manipulation, and apocalypse, often comparing it to the gritty complexity of Steven Erikson's Malazan Book of the Fallen series.^[46] The trilogy's blend of historical inspiration from the Crusades with metaphysical elements was highlighted as a refreshing departure from formulaic epic fantasy, appealing to readers seeking challenging narratives.^[47] Publications such as Publishers Weekly described the debut novel, The Darkness That Comes Before, as a "challenging debut" in the Tolkien tradition, deserving of a broader audience beyond those fatigued by conventional tropes.^[47] Publishers Weekly, as quoted in Locus Magazine, lauded the concluding volume, The Thousandfold Thought, as the shattering climax to a "magnificent fantasy saga" and a "work of unforgettable power," while Locus emphasized its detailed and complex epic scope.^[48] The Guardian praised the third book for improving upon the philosophizing of the second while maintaining apocalyptic intensity with clashing civilizations and monstrous elements.^[45] Criticisms centered on the trilogy's dense writing style and slow pacing, which some found alienating for casual readers, with excessive philosophizing occasionally overshadowing plot progression. The inclusion of lengthy glossaries and recaps was viewed by some as indicative of overly complex narrative demands.^[45] Despite these, the series has achieved cult status within the grimdark subgenre for its unflinching brutality and moral ambiguity, influencing the evolution of dark fantasy literature through its emphasis on psychological depth and subversion.^[11] By 2025, ongoing fan discussions have sustained interest in Bakker's unfinished Second Apocalypse series, underscoring the trilogy's enduring impact.

The Aspect-Emperor Series

The Aspect-Emperor is a tetralogy of epic fantasy novels by Canadian author R. Scott Bakker, serving as the second phase of his larger Second Apocalypse series and directly continuing the narrative established in the Prince of Nothing trilogy. The books in the series are The Judging Eye (2009), The White-Luck Warrior (2011), The Great Ordeal (2016), and The Unholy Consult (2017). These volumes expand the scope of the world of Eärwa, delving deeper into its metaphysical and cosmological underpinnings while advancing the central conflict against the Consult.^[49] Set approximately twenty years after the events of The Thousandfold Thought, the concluding novel of Prince of Nothing, The Aspect-Emperor follows Anasûrimbor Kellhus in his role as the Aspect-Emperor of the Three Seas, where he unites the fractured human kingdoms under his rule and launches the Great Ordeal—a massive crusade aimed at destroying the Consult's stronghold at Golgotterath to avert the Second Apocalypse. The series introduces significant new characters, such as Mimara, the estranged daughter of Drusas Achamian and Esmenet, whose perspective adds layers to the exploration of faith, sorcery, and divine judgment. Continuing figures from the prior trilogy, including Kellhus, Esmenet, and Achamian, provide narrative continuity while highlighting the long-term consequences of the Holy War's outcome.^[50]^[51] Throughout the tetralogy, unresolved elements from Prince of Nothing intensify, particularly the escalating threat of the Second Apocalypse, the uncertain fates of ancient artifacts like the Gnosis and the Skin-Spies, and the fulfillment of prophecies surrounding the No-God and the world's end. These threads culminate in revelations about the nature of reality, damnation, and the limits of human agency, leaving broader questions about redemption and cosmic balance open-ended. As of November 2025, no additional books in the Second Apocalypse have been published, and while Bakker has discussed plans for a third series subtitled The No-God—envisioned as a duology to conclude the overarching saga—the project remains unconfirmed and without a release timeline.^[50]

References

[1]
A Conversation With R. Scott Bakker - The SF Site
R. Scott Bakker is a student of literature, history, philosophy, and ancient languages and is a member of the American Philosophical Association (APA)
[2]
The Darkness That Comes Before - Title
Title: The Darkness That Comes Before Title Record # 151698. Author: R. Scott Bakker Date: 2003-04-00. Type: NOVEL Series: The Prince of Nothing
[3]
https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?151699
[4]
https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?151700
[5]
Interview with R. Scott Bakker - SFFWorld
Jul 18, 2004 · I had discovered philosophy, and the endorphins were coursing through my veins. I was hellbent on becoming a professional academic. As strange ...
[6]
The Darkness That Comes Before - Quill and Quire
Publisher: Penguin Books Canada. DETAILS. Price: $24. Page Count: 600 pp. Format: Paper. ISBN: 0-14-301374-2. Issue Date: 2003-3. Categories: Fiction: Novels ...
[7]
The Darkness That Comes Before (Paperback) - Abrams Books
Free delivery over $49.95 30-day returnsThe Prince of Nothing, Book One · ISBN: 9781590201183 · Publication Date: September 2, 2008 ...
[8]
The Prince of Nothing (3 book series) Kindle Edition - Amazon.com
30-day returnsScott Bakker's Prince of Nothing series introduces readers to a strikingly original and engrossingly vivid new world. With its language and classes of people, ...
[9]
The Darkness That Comes Before (Prince of Nothing Series #1)
In stock Free deliveryThe first book in R. Scott Bakker's Prince of Nothing series introduces readers to a strikingly original and engrossingly vivid new world. With its language ...
[10]
THE DARKNESS THAT COMES BEFORE: The Prince of Nothing Book One by R. Scott Bakker
### Summary of Review for *The Darkness That Comes Before: The Prince of Nothing Book One* by R. Scott Bakker
[11]
REVIEW: The Darkness That Comes Before by R. Scott Bakker
Feb 9, 2022 · The first book in The Prince of Nothing Trilogy, The Darkness That Comes Before, lays the groundwork for a world remade by an apocalyptic event.
[12]
The Four Revelations of Cinial'jin | Three Pound Brain
I assumed that in Eärwa, men, Nonmen and Inchoroi all have souls, as a soul is required to perceive the ontus, work sorcery and be damned. Aurang can ...
[13]
Interview with R. Scott Bakker - SFFWorld
Mar 31, 2008 · – Were there any perceived conventions of the fantasy genre which you wanted to twist or break when you set out to write The Prince of Nothing?
[14]
The Prince of Nothing Trilogy - R. Scott Bakker - Roland's Codex
Jul 3, 2010 · Civilization now thrives in the southern Three Seas - a multitude of nations, sharing Inrithism, the religion of the Thousand Temples... but ...Missing: geography | Show results with:geography
[15]
The Prince of Nothing & The Aspect-Emperor by R. Scott Bakker
Apr 17, 2016 · The Darkness That Comes Before (2003, ****) is published by Orbit in the UK, Overlook in the US and Penguin in Canada. The Warrior-Prophet ...Missing: exact | Show results with:exact
[16]
The Darkness That Comes Before by R. Scott Bakker - Goodreads
Rating 3.8 (23,390) The first novel in this new series is due for publication in 2009. Whilst working on the Prince of Nothing series, Bakker was given a challenge by his wife ...
[17]
The Darkness That Comes Before by R. Scott Bakker - Hachette UK
The Darkness That Comes Before. by R. Scott Bakker. The Darkness That Comes ... Books by R Scott Baker: Prince of Nothing Trilogy The Darkness That Comes ...
[18]
The Warrior Prophet (The Prince of Nothing, #2) - Goodreads
Rating 4.0 (15,542) R. Scott Bakker. 3.99. 15,542 ratings566 reviews. Want to Read ... The first novel in this new series is due for publication in 2009. Whilst working on the ...
[19]
The Warrior-Prophet by R. Scott Bakker | Hachette UK
But who is the Warrior-Prophet: a dangerous heretic, who turns brother against brother? Or the only man who can avert the Second Apocalypse? The Holy War stands ...Missing: synopsis | Show results with:synopsis
[20]
The Thousandfold Thought by R. Scott Bakker - Goodreads
Rating 4.0 (12,962) The Darkness That Comes Before, R. Scott Bakker's magnificent debut, drew thunderous acclaim from reviewers and fellow fantasy authors.
[21]
The Thousandfold Thought by R. Scott Bakker - Hachette UK
The epic conclusion to the acclaimed Prince of Nothing trilogy. Books by R Scott Baker: Prince of Nothing Trilogy The Darkness That Comes Before The Warrior ...
[22]
The False Sun
### Summary of Lore: Consult, Inchoroi, First Apocalypse, No-God
[23]
Viva Golgotterath | Three Pound Brain - WordPress.com
Jan 9, 2012 · “The False Sun” is a story about the origins of the Consult, and so brings together the historical and metaphysical dimensions of the greater ...
[24]
The Unholy Consult | Three Pound Brain
Jan 13, 2017 · The Unholy Consult, the penultimate book of The Aspect-Emperor, is set to be released this July, ending a story arc that has been my obsession ...
[25]
Excerpt: The Unholy Consult by R. Scott Bakker - Grimdark Magazine
Jul 23, 2017 · A man like a god. Anasûrimbor Kellhus. Far to the north, in the very shadow of Golgotterath, a group of ascetics called the Dûnyain had ...
[26]
Review - THE DARKNESS THAT COMES BEFORE by R. Scott Bakker
Jul 15, 2022 · The Darkness That Comes Before by Author R. Scott Bakker is ambitious, engrossing, and overall, exceptional.Missing: blurb | Show results with:blurb
[27]
The Darkness That Comes Before by R Scott Bakker book review
Rating 9.3/10 (2) The central figure of the book is Drusas Achamian, a spy/sorcerer of questionable value to his school of Sorcery, The Mandate. While being the smallest school, ...
[28]
The Darkness That Comes Before by R. Scott Bakker - Fantasy Faction
Jun 4, 2015 · ... Bakker wisely opens up his story with an intensely intriguing prologue before pulling us into the life and times of Drusas Achamian.
[29]
Dragonmount Fantasy Review: R. Scott Bakker
May 4, 2011 · The Prince of Nothing is a story on three levels. The uppermost level deals with the growing Holy War between two major religions, the Inrithi ...
[30]
The Darkness That Comes Before – R. Scott Bakker - Bookworm Blues
Jul 23, 2010 · In the book's most harrowing scene, which fans of gentler fantasy will find too graphic, Esmenet is raped by a creature who, despite its ...
[31]
https://dragonmount.com/news/fantasyreview/R.ScottBakker/
[32]
R. Scott Bakker: Anasûrimbor Kellhus and Cnaiür urs Skiötha
Feb 15, 2023 · Anasûrimbor Kellhus is tall and strong, with blonde hair and blue eyes. He has a long, heavy-featured and aquiline face. He wears his hair long, with a close- ...
[33]
Thousandfold Thought synopsis. R Scott Bakker - SFF Chronicles
Jul 10, 2005 · And Anasûrimbor Kellhus will at last confront his father and the dread revelation of the Thousandfold Thought. Due January 2006 in Canada ...
[34]
Book Reviews -- THE PRINCE OF NOTHING TRILOGY, Books Two ...
Sep 17, 2010 · Bakker reveals the rich history and culture of Eärwa through the actions and words of the characters. He makes very little use of the sinister, ...
[35]
The Darkness That Comes Before - The SF Site Featured Review
The Darkness That Comes Before: Book 1 of The Prince of Nothing. R. Scott ... The Darkness That Comes Before features an extremely complex cultural background, a ...Missing: analysis | Show results with:analysis
[36]
Wertzone Classics: The Prince of Nothing Trilogy by R. Scott Bakker
Apr 15, 2007 · Bakker is interested in philosophy (indeed, his masters' degree in the field was put on hold whilst he worked on this trilogy) and this ...
[37]
Book Review of The Darkness That Comes Before (The Prince of ...
Yet, what truly sets this series apart is Bakker's unique world-building. Drawing inspiration from the Mediterranean during the First Crusade, he crafts a ...
[38]
Book Review -- THE DARKNESS THAT COMES BEFORE
Jul 26, 2010 · Scott Bakker's The Darkness that Comes Before, the first book of ... Bakker's Dunyain monk, Anasûrimbor Kellhus, is the lens through ...
[39]
The Darkness That Comes Before- R. Scott Bakker
Sep 4, 2013 · The Three Seas are now ruled by factions of wizards, warriors and priests who fight among themselves in wars covert, barbaric and Holy.Missing: interview | Show results with:interview
[40]
Second Apocalypse - All The Tropes
Indeed, the Sranc are genetically engineered to be cheap and disposable soldiers, even to the point of throwing themselves at the enemy's spears to deprive them ...
[41]
The wotmania Files: A Conversation with R. Scott Bakker (11/1/2005)
Feb 12, 2009 · Scott Bakker is one of only a handful of authors that I have interviewed more than once. Since I posted the 2004 interview on Tuesday, I thought I would go ...
[42]
Phrenomenology: Zahavi, Dennett and the End of Being
Oct 22, 2014 · It would be like saying we could never know that free will ... I'm almost 3/4 way finished with your first Prince of Nothing tale and was going to ...
[43]
The end of Britain as we know it | Books | The Guardian
May 13, 2006 · And few fantasies come more apocalyptic than R Scott Bakker's Prince of Nothing sequence, with its clashing civilisations, squabbling gods and ...<|separator|>
[44]
Roundtable: While GRRM Fans Wait for Book Six… – Locus Online
Scott Bakker's Prince of Nothing series is excellent, and Steven Erikson's Malazan books may not be everyone's cup of tea, but they are gritty, rigorously ...
[45]
Overlooked Books - Publishers Weekly
Dec 6, 2004 · ... Prince of Nothing Book One R. Scott Bakker (Overlook). Bakker's challenging debut, the first in a new trilogy in the Tolkien tradition ...
[46]
New Books, 2nd week February 2006 - Locus Online
7-day returnsFeb 17, 2006 · "The Prince of Nothing trilogy is a work of unforgettable power." • Lisa Goldstein reviewed the book in the January issue of Locus Magazine ...
[47]
https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/print/20041206/30282-overlooked-books.html
[48]
R Scott Bakker's Aspect-Emperor books in order - Fantastic Fiction
A series by R Scott Bakker · 1 The Judging Eye (2008) · 2 The White Luck Warrior (2011) · 3 The Great Ordeal (2016) · 4 The Unholy Consult (2017).
[49]
New R. Scott Bakker interview - Pat's Fantasy Hotlist
Jun 10, 2016 · - Now that you have reached the end of the second series and looking back at the story that was the Prince of Nothing, how well do they fit ...
[50]
The Aspect-Emperor Series by R. Scott Bakker - Goodreads
Book 1 · Shelve The Judging Eye · Book 2 · Shelve The White Luck Warrior · Book 3 · Shelve The Great Ordeal · Book 4 · Shelve The Unholy Consult.