Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Cabal

A cabal is a secretive clique of individuals united by a shared agenda, typically involving political machinations or subversive plotting to advance private interests at the expense of broader transparency.^[1]^[2] The word entered English in the 17th century from French cabale, tracing to Medieval Latin cabbala, a transliteration of Hebrew qabbālāh denoting esoteric scriptural interpretation, which metaphorically connoted hidden knowledge and thus covert scheming.^[1]^[3] The term's historical salience emerged with the Cabal Ministry under King Charles II of England (1668–1674), an informal advisory cabal of five privy councilors—Clifford, Arlington, Buckingham, Ashley, and Lauderdale—whose surnames' initials acronymically spelled "CABAL," influencing policies like the secret Treaty of Dover with France, which allied England against the Dutch Republic and promised religious toleration for Catholics in exchange for subsidies.^[4]^[5] This episode exemplified cabals as real, albeit factional, instruments of royal prerogative, often fracturing due to internal rivalries rather than monolithic cohesion.^[4] In modern parlance, "cabal" frequently labels alleged shadowy networks in conspiracy narratives, such as purported elite cabals engineering globalist agendas, though empirical scrutiny reveals these as largely unsubstantiated extrapolations from disparate power concentrations, lacking direct causal linkages and prone to confirmation bias amid observable institutional influences like interlocking directorates in finance and policy.^[6]^[7] Such invocations persist despite historical precedents showing cabals as ephemeral, self-undermining alliances rather than omnipotent entities.^[8]

Origins and Etymology

Linguistic and Cultural Roots

The term "cabal" traces its linguistic origins to the Hebrew qabbālāh (קַבָּלָה), denoting "received tradition," "esoteric lore," or "mystical doctrine," derived from the root qabal meaning "to receive" or "to accept."^[1] ^[2] This referred specifically to Kabbalah, the Jewish tradition of interpreting the Hebrew Bible through symbolic and hidden meanings, emphasizing orally transmitted secrets among initiates.^[1] The concept entered European scholarship via Medieval Latin cabbala around the 16th century, where it signified occult or mystical exegesis of sacred texts, often evoking notions of concealed knowledge accessible only to a select few.^[1] ^[9] From Latin, the word evolved into Old French cabale by the mid-16th century, shifting toward connotations of intrigue or factional scheming, influenced by associations with secretive doctrinal disputes in religious and philosophical circles.^[1] This French form entered English usage in the 1590s, initially as a noun for "mystical interpretation," but rapidly acquiring pejorative senses of a "secret plot" or "clandestine group" by the early 17th century, reflecting cultural anxieties over hidden influences in politics and religion.^[1] Culturally, these roots embed the term in traditions of guarded esotericism, paralleling other Indo-European concepts of arcane wisdom—such as Greek mysteria or Latin arcana—but uniquely tied to the structured, initiatory transmission of Kabbalistic thought, which prioritized causal chains of symbolic revelation over overt doctrine.^[1] ^[9] Early non-English attestations, such as in Italian cabalare (to intrigue), further illustrate its adaptation into Romance languages for denoting covert alliances, underscoring a broader cultural archetype of small, opaque networks wielding disproportionate influence through shared, unspoken lore.^[10] This evolution highlights how linguistic borrowing preserved the core idea of "reception" as a metaphor for exclusive, tradition-bound collusion, distinct from mere conspiracy by its emphasis on inherited, quasi-mystical bonds.^[1]

Popularization in English via the Cabal Ministry

The term "cabal," denoting a small group engaged in secret scheming, entered English usage in the mid-17th century from French cabale, itself derived from Medieval Latin cabbala referring to esoteric traditions, but its political connotation was vividly popularized through association with the Cabal Ministry under King Charles II.^[2] This informal inner council operated from roughly 1668 to 1674, succeeding the dismissed Earl of Clarendon and advising the king on foreign policy amid tensions with the Dutch Republic and France.^[11]^[12] The ministry comprised five prominent privy councillors whose surnames' initials coincidentally spelled "CABAL": Sir Thomas Clifford (Treasurer of the Household), Anthony Ashley-Cooper (later Earl of Shaftesbury), George Villiers (2nd Duke of Buckingham), Henry Bennet (Earl of Arlington), and John Maitland (Duke of Lauderdale).^[11]^[4] This mnemonic device, noted in contemporary discourse, amplified the term's resonance, transforming it from a general reference to intrigue into a shorthand for opaque royal advisory cliques evading parliamentary scrutiny.^[13] Though not the word's etymological origin—the Hebrew qabbālāh (tradition) predates it by centuries—the Cabal's notoriety embedded the acronym in public memory, as satirists and opponents lampooned the group for its perceived conspiratorial unity.^[2] The Cabal's secretive operations, including the 1670 Treaty of Dover—a clandestine pact with Louis XIV of France for military alliance against the Netherlands, funded by French subsidies in exchange for Charles's eventual Catholic conversion—fueled perceptions of underhanded plotting.^[5]^[12] Despite lacking formal cohesion and often fracturing into rival factions (e.g., Arlington versus Buckingham), the ministry's role in escalating the Third Anglo-Dutch War (1672–1674) and suppressing domestic dissent, such as through the 1673 Test Act debates, solidified "cabal" as a pejorative for factional intrigue in English politics.^[11] By the ministry's dissolution around 1674, amid scandals like Clifford's resignation over the Test Act and public backlash against pro-French policies, the term had permeated political rhetoric, influencing later usages in critiques of court favoritism.^[4] This episode marked a pivotal shift, embedding "cabal" in English lexicon as synonymous with small-scale, self-serving political machinations rather than mere mysticism.^[13]

Historical Instances

English Political Context

The Cabal Ministry emerged in English politics during the Restoration era as an informal advisory group to King Charles II, formed in the summer of 1667 after the fall of Edward Hyde, 1st Earl of Clarendon, from the chancellorship amid scandals including the Dutch naval defeat in the Second Anglo-Dutch War.^[14] This inner circle, drawn from the Privy Council, handled state affairs with minimal oversight from the larger body, reflecting Charles's preference for trusted confidants over broader consultation to consolidate royal prerogative against parliamentary constraints.^[11] The group's five core members—Sir Thomas Clifford (Treasurer of the Navy, later Lord Treasurer in 1672), Henry Bennet (1st Earl of Arlington, Secretary of State for the Northern Department), George Villiers (2nd Duke of Buckingham, royal favorite), Anthony Ashley Cooper (Baron Ashley, later 1st Earl of Shaftesbury, Chancellor of the Exchequer), and John Maitland (1st Duke of Lauderdale, Secretary of State for Scotland)—had surnames whose initials acronymically spelled "CABAL," a coincidence that amplified public perceptions of clandestine scheming.^[11]^[14] The Cabal pursued policies favoring absolutist tendencies and French alignment, exemplified by the Treaty of Dover signed on 1 June 1670, which committed England to join France in war against the Dutch Republic while securing annual subsidies of £225,000 (equivalent to 3 million livres) for Charles.^[14] Secret articles, unknown to Arlington and Buckingham, obligated Charles to declare his conversion to Roman Catholicism at a propitious moment and suspend penal laws against Catholics, with Louis XIV providing 6,000 troops if domestic resistance arose.^[15]^[16] These provisions aligned with Charles's personal inclinations but risked alienating Protestant England, as evidenced by later parliamentary backlash and the fabricated Popish Plot hysteria of 1678. Lauderdale dominated Scottish policy, enforcing conformity that suppressed Presbyterian dissent, while the group navigated domestic issues like the Conventicle Act of 1670 to curb nonconformist gatherings.^[11] Internal fractures eroded the Cabal's cohesion; Shaftesbury, initially supportive, turned oppositional upon suspecting the Catholic undertones, allying with parliamentary critics against perceived absolutism.^[11] By 1673, Arlington's dismissal and Clifford's resignation over anti-Catholic Test Acts marked its decline, with full dissolution around 1674 as Charles reoriented toward a more compliant ministry amid the Third Anglo-Dutch War's costs and subsidy disputes.^[14] This episode entrenched "cabal" in English lexicon as denoting a self-interested, opaque political clique, distinct from formal cabinets, and foreshadowed partisan divides culminating in the Exclusion Crisis of 1679–1681.^[11] Earlier 17th-century usages referenced ad hoc royal councils for foreign affairs, but the Cabal Ministry's visibility and fallout provided the archetype for intrigue in parliamentary monarchy.^[17]

Dutch and Continental European Usage

In the Netherlands, particularly during the Dutch Republic's stadtholderate periods in the 17th and 18th centuries, the term kabaal (or kabale) described secretive alliances of nobles or officials pursuing partisan agendas through covert influence, often in opposition to republican checks on executive power. This usage emerged amid factional struggles between pro-Orange partisans favoring hereditary stadtholder authority and States Party advocates of decentralized provincial governance, where accusations of kabaal highlighted perceived manipulations undermining public deliberation.^[18] A key instance was the Friesche Kabaal, denoting the influential Frisian pro-Orange nobility who supported Stadtholder William III (1650–1702, stadtholder from 1672) and extended their reach into Holland's ridderschap (knightly assembly). Led by figures like Willem Bentinck van Rhoon, this group advocated pro-British policies and military reforms, but critics, including anti-Orange elements, portrayed them as a shadowy clique eroding provincial autonomy, especially during tensions leading to the 1780s Patriot Revolt. Historical accounts from the Patriot era document the term's pejorative application against this faction, associating it with orchestrated resistance to ducal advisors like the Duke of Brunswick and broader Orange restoration efforts post-1787 Prussian intervention.^[19] Such rhetoric intensified around 1786–1787, when the Friesche Kabaal faced backlash for allegedly prioritizing Orange interests over federal consensus, contributing to William V's temporary ousting before his reinstatement. Across continental Europe, cognate terms like German Kabale or French cabale similarly connoted clandestine political maneuvering in absolutist courts, though less tied to republican contexts than in the Netherlands. In German principalities, Kabale evoked factional plotting among advisors or electors, as seen in 18th-century Prussian and Austrian diplomatic histories where it described intrigue networks challenging monarchical prerogative—often without the ethnic-regional dimension of the Dutch example. This broader application underscored a shared causal dynamic: cabals as emergent from information asymmetries and patronage systems, enabling small groups to amplify leverage amid opaque decision-making, though empirical instances remain more anecdotal than systematically verified compared to Dutch records.

Other Verified Historical Examples

The Conway Cabal of 1777–1778 represented an attempted intrigue within the Continental Army and Congress to supplant George Washington as commander-in-chief amid military setbacks. Following American defeats at the Battles of Brandywine (September 11, 1777) and Germantown (October 4, 1777), dissatisfaction grew among some officers and legislators, who viewed Washington's leadership as inadequate for sustaining the Revolution.^[20] ^[21] Key figures included Brigadier General Thomas Conway, who on October 1777 wrote a letter to General Horatio Gates asserting that "a certain great man [Washington] is most damnably deficient" and proposing Gates as a superior alternative, though the letter was intercepted and forwarded to Washington by November 4, 1777.^[22] ^[23] The effort coalesced around the Board of War, reorganized in late 1777 under Gates's influence, which Conway joined as inspector general on December 14, 1777, granting him oversight of army reforms and amplifying factional maneuvering.^[20] Congressional allies, including members frustrated by Valley Forge encampment hardships, discussed replacing Washington, with proposals circulating in early 1778 to elevate Gates or others.^[24] However, Washington's allies, such as Alexander Hamilton and Henry Laurens, countered through correspondence exposing the plot, while public loyalty to Washington—bolstered by his personal oversight at Valley Forge—eroded support.^[25] Conway resigned on March 28, 1778, after a duel with General John Cadwalader over insults related to the intrigue, and the cabal dissolved without achieving its aim, reinforcing Washington's command.^[22] ^[20] This episode exemplifies a cabal as a clandestine faction pursuing self-interested subversion within a larger institution, distinct from open political debate, and its failure highlighted the risks of internal division during existential conflict.^[24] Primary evidence derives from intercepted letters, congressional records, and participant accounts, confirming the coordinated intent despite loose organization.^[21]

Definition and Distinctions

Core Characteristics of a Cabal

A cabal is fundamentally defined as a small group of individuals secretly united to pursue shared objectives, often involving the promotion of private interests or the acquisition of power through clandestine coordination.^[10] This limited scale—typically involving few members—enables tight control, rapid decision-making, and minimized risk of betrayal or detection, as larger groups would inherently increase exposure to leaks or infiltration.^[2] The secretive nature extends to both membership and activities, with operations shielded from public view to evade opposition or legal repercussions.^[26] Central to a cabal's function is the orchestration of intrigues or plots, which may include subversive tactics such as misinformation, alliances with sympathetic actors, or manipulation of official processes to achieve ends like policy shifts or leadership changes.^[27] These schemes are contrived and purposeful, directed toward specific gains rather than generalized disruption, and frequently target established authorities or rivals in political, economic, or institutional spheres.^[3] While not always malevolent in intent, cabals prioritize self-advancement over transparency or collective welfare, often employing deception to mask motives and maintain plausible deniability.^[2] Empirical analysis of historical cabals reveals a pattern of informal structure, lacking formal hierarchies or public charters, which allows flexibility but also fosters internal rivalries if objectives diverge.^[28] Cohesion arises from mutual benefit or ideological alignment, yet sustainability depends on perceived reciprocity, as evidenced by documented breakdowns when trust erodes.^[29] This dynamic underscores cabals as causal agents of influence, where causal realism highlights how small, insulated networks can disproportionately shape outcomes by exploiting informational asymmetries.^[10]

Differentiation from Broader Conspiracies or Factions

The term cabal specifically refers to a small, secretive group of individuals united for clandestine intrigue, typically to manipulate power structures from within, distinguishing it from broader conspiracies that often invoke expansive, multi-layered networks spanning institutions or nations.^[2]^[10] While conspiracies in general denote any hidden agreement to commit unlawful or subversive acts, potentially involving dozens or hundreds across hierarchies—as seen in documented cases like the Watergate scandal's operatives—a cabal's scale remains intimate, often limited to 3–10 key figures coordinating via personal ties rather than formalized chains of command.^[27] This granularity underscores cabals as tactical subsets rather than systemic overhauls, with empirical examples like the 1670s English Cabal Ministry involving just five privy councilors leveraging opacity for policy sway, not mass mobilization.^[26] In contrast to factions, which manifest as visible subgroups within larger entities—such as ideological blocs in legislative bodies openly vying for influence through debates and alliances—cabals eschew publicity, embedding deception to subvert rather than compete transparently.^[6] Factions, per political analyses, thrive on declared loyalties and bargaining, as in U.S. congressional caucuses formed post-1789 with explicit platforms; cabals, however, prioritize exclusivity and deniability, their plots unraveling only through leaks or betrayals, like the 1970s Lockheed bribery scandal's core executive clique bribing foreign officials without broader corporate endorsement.^[10] This covert operational mode renders cabals more vulnerable to internal fracture but potent for short-term gains, unlike factions' durability via public scrutiny. Such distinctions highlight cabals' reliance on interpersonal trust and minimal footprints, empirically verifiable in declassified records of intrigues like the 1940s British Cliveden Set's informal lobbying circle of six aristocrats pushing appeasement, versus expansive conspiracy narratives lacking proportional evidence of coordination.^[30] Broader theories, often critiqued for overattributing causality to unproven cabals writ large, dilute this precision by conflating elite influence with omnipotent control, ignoring cabals' historical tendency toward self-limitation by ambition or exposure.^[2]

Verified Real-World Cabals

Political and Governmental Examples

The Conway Cabal emerged during the American Revolutionary War in late 1777, involving a faction of Continental Army officers and members of Congress who sought to replace General George Washington as commander-in-chief with Major General Horatio Gates.^[22] Key figures included Brigadier General Thomas Conway, who criticized Washington's leadership after defeats at Brandywine and Germantown, and Gates, whose victory at Saratoga bolstered his reputation; correspondence revealed their intrigue, such as Conway's letter to Gates stating Washington's removal was necessary for success.^[24] The plot gained traction amid congressional frustrations over military setbacks and the British occupation of Philadelphia on September 26, 1777, with efforts to promote Conway to inspector general on December 14, 1777, against Washington's advice.^[21] Washington learned of the scheme on November 4, 1777, via intercepted letters, prompting him to rally support and expose the disloyalty, leading to Conway's resignation on January 28, 1778, and the cabal's dissolution without altering command.^[31] In the Watergate scandal, the White House Plumbers—a covert unit formed on July 24, 1971, under President Richard Nixon—operated as a small group tasked with stopping leaks of classified information, such as the Pentagon Papers, but expanded into illegal political sabotage.^[32] Led by E. Howard Hunt and G. Gordon Liddy, both former CIA and FBI operatives, the five-to-ten-member team included figures like Egil Krogh and engaged in operations like the September 1971 break-in at Daniel Ellsberg's psychiatrist's office to discredit him.^[33] Their activities culminated in the June 17, 1972, burglary of the Democratic National Committee headquarters at the Watergate complex, approved by higher aides including John Ehrlichman, to install wiretaps and photograph documents for Nixon's reelection advantage.^[34] Investigations by the FBI and Congress uncovered the unit's ties to the Committee for the Re-Election of the President, resulting in convictions of seven operatives on January 30, 1973, and contributing to Nixon's resignation on August 9, 1974, after evidence of cover-up emerged.^[35] The Iran-Contra affair exemplified a modern governmental cabal within the Reagan administration from 1985 to 1986, where National Security Council staff bypassed congressional bans on aid to Nicaraguan Contras by secretly facilitating arms sales to Iran.^[36] Core members, including Rear Admiral John Poindexter, Lieutenant Colonel Oliver North, and National Security Advisor Robert McFarlane, directed the "Enterprise"—a network of private operatives and foreign entities—that diverted approximately $3.8 million from over $48 million in Iranian arms profits to the Contras, violating the Boland Amendment of 1984.^[37] The operation began with Israel's shipment of U.S.-made TOW missiles to Iran in 1985 to secure hostage releases, escalating to direct U.S. involvement despite an arms embargo, as detailed in Reagan's finding of January 17, 1986.^[38] Exposed by a Lebanese magazine on November 3, 1986, the scandal prompted the Tower Commission report on February 26, 1987, confirming unauthorized actions by a "small group" operating outside oversight, leading to eleven convictions (many later overturned or pardoned) and Reagan's public acknowledgment of responsibility on March 4, 1987, without admitting direct knowledge.^[39]

Economic and Corporate Intrigues

In the realm of economics and corporations, cabals manifest as secretive agreements among executives or firms to manipulate markets, fix prices, or allocate territories, often evading antitrust laws to maximize profits at consumers' expense.^[40] Such intrigues differ from open competition by relying on covert coordination, as evidenced in historical and contemporary cases prosecuted by regulators.^[41] One prominent early example is the Phoebus cartel, formed in 1924 by major incandescent light bulb manufacturers including General Electric, Osram, Associated Electrical Industries, and Philips.^[42] The group, operating from Geneva, standardized bulb lifespans at 1,000 hours—down from prior averages exceeding 2,500 hours—to accelerate replacement sales, imposing fines on members producing longer-lasting bulbs.^[42] This planned obsolescence scheme divided global markets into exclusive territories and controlled production quotas, persisting until World War II disruptions in 1939, though antitrust scrutiny had begun eroding it earlier.^[42] A more recent corporate cabal involved the manipulation of the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR), a benchmark for over $300 trillion in financial contracts, from approximately 2005 to 2012.^[43] Traders at banks including Barclays, UBS, Deutsche Bank, Royal Bank of Scotland, and JPMorgan Chase colluded via electronic chats and requests to submit false rates, artificially inflating or deflating LIBOR to profit from derivatives positions or mask financial distress during the 2008 crisis.^[43] Regulators imposed fines exceeding $9 billion across institutions; for instance, Barclays paid $450 million in 2012, while Deutsche Bank faced $2.5 billion in 2015.^[44]^[43] These cases illustrate cabals' reliance on trust among participants to sustain secrecy, often uncovered through whistleblowers or investigations revealing documented communications.^[45] Similar patterns appear in other verified price-fixing schemes, such as the 1990s lysine cartel involving Archer Daniels Midland and foreign competitors, which rigged feed additive prices and resulted in $100 million in U.S. fines.^[40] Despite enforcement, such intrigues persist due to high barriers to detection and the economic incentives for short-term gains.^[40]

Alleged Contemporary Cabals

Accusations in Global Politics and Elites

Accusations of a secretive cabal operating among global political and economic elites often center on claims of coordinated manipulation of international policies, elections, and crises to consolidate power and erode national sovereignty. These allegations, frequently voiced by populist figures and movements, portray elites from forums like the World Economic Forum (WEF) and the Bilderberg Group as plotting dystopian agendas, such as the WEF's "Great Reset" initiative launched in June 2020 as a COVID-19 recovery plan, which critics interpret as a blueprint for centralized control over economies and societies.^[46] Similarly, the annual Bilderberg Meetings, held since 1954 to foster transatlantic dialogue among approximately 120-150 political leaders, business executives, and academics under Chatham House rules, have drawn charges of serving as a venue for elites to orchestrate global events away from public scrutiny.^[7] In the United States, former President Donald Trump popularized accusations against a "deep state"—described as entrenched bureaucrats and intelligence officials undermining his administration through leaks, investigations, and policy sabotage—mentioning the need to "destroy" or "demolish" it at least 56 times on Truth Social by August 2024.^[47] These claims gained traction amid events like the FBI's 2016 investigation into Hillary Clinton's emails and the subsequent Russia probe, which Trump allies framed as evidence of institutional bias against outsiders. The QAnon movement, originating from anonymous 4chan posts in October 2017, escalated such narratives by alleging a satanic global cabal of elites—including Democratic politicians, Hollywood figures, and financiers—engaged in child trafficking and ritual abuse, with Trump positioned as their chief opponent in a covert war.^[48] QAnon adherents cited unverified "drops" from the pseudonymous "Q" as proof, influencing events like the January 6, 2021, Capitol riot, where participants invoked anti-cabal rhetoric.^[49] Broader "New World Order" theories accuse a transnational elite cabal of engineering crises, such as pandemics or economic downturns, to impose supranational governance, with roots in post-Cold War anxieties but amplified in contemporary politics by figures skeptical of multilateral institutions.^[50] In Europe, similar charges target Davos summits as hubs for an "elite cabal" detached from public concerns, with accusations peaking during the WEF's 2023 meeting amid inflation and energy debates.^[51] Proponents, including some conservative commentators, point to overlapping attendance at these gatherings by policymakers and billionaires as circumstantial evidence of undue influence, though mainstream analyses attribute the persistence of such claims to distrust in opaque global networks rather than substantiated plots.^[52] These accusations have entered electoral discourse, as seen in QAnon's indirect endorsement by Trump in 2020, where he characterized followers as opposing "radical left" threats without fully disavowing the cabal framework.^[48]

Intelligence and Covert Network Claims

Claims of cabals within intelligence agencies typically involve allegations of small, secretive groups of officials coordinating covertly to subvert elected governments or manipulate policy, often framed as part of a broader "deep state" apparatus. In the United States, such accusations gained prominence during the Trump administration, with critics asserting that elements within the FBI and CIA operated as a unified network to undermine the president through fabricated investigations. For instance, former FBI Director James Comey and former CIA Director John Brennan faced scrutiny for their roles in promoting intelligence assessments on Russian election interference, which some reports described as overstated or politically motivated.^[53]^[54] A key focal point has been the FBI's Crossfire Hurricane investigation into alleged Trump-Russia ties, launched on July 31, 2016, based partly on tips from foreign intelligence and the Steele dossier—a collection of unverified memos compiled by former MI6 officer Christopher Steele alleging compromising ties between Trump associates and Russia. Special Counsel John Durham's May 2023 report criticized the FBI for opening the full investigation with "raw, unanalyzed, and uncorroborated intelligence," noting 17 significant errors or omissions in FISA applications to surveil Trump aide Carter Page, and concluding that the bureau failed to treat the Steele information with appropriate skepticism despite known biases in its sourcing. While Durham did not prove a criminal conspiracy or explicit cabal, his findings highlighted procedural lapses and confirmation bias within the FBI, fueling claims of an insular network prioritizing institutional agendas over evidence.^[53]^[54] Further allegations emerged from leaked communications and whistleblower accounts suggesting coordination between intelligence officials and media outlets to amplify anti-Trump narratives. The 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment on Russian interference, briefed to President-elect Trump on January 6, 2017, has been cited as an example, with Durham probing Brennan's involvement in its rushed production, which included input from unvetted sources. Critics, including Trump allies, labeled senior FBI and CIA figures a "criminal cabal" resistant to oversight, pointing to anonymous leaks to the press—such as the January 2017 BuzzFeed publication of the Steele dossier—as evidence of deliberate information warfare.^[55]^[54]^[53] Internationally, similar claims have targeted covert networks like alleged Mossad-CIA collaborations in operations such as the use of front companies for espionage, as revealed in 2015 South African Spy Cables documenting Israeli airline El Al's role in intelligence activities. However, these often blend verified covert practices with unsubstantiated conspiracy, lacking direct evidence of rogue cabals independent of official directives. In Europe, accusations against MI6 and GCHQ have included covert surveillance programs like Tempora, exposed by Edward Snowden in 2013, interpreted by some as tools of an elite intelligence cabal influencing Brexit and elections, though official inquiries attributed them to standard signals intelligence rather than illicit plotting. Overall, while documented misconduct in cases like the FBI's FISA abuses provides empirical basis for skepticism toward intelligence impartiality, comprehensive proof of tightly knit, self-directed cabals remains elusive, with investigations revealing more systemic flaws than orchestrated intrigue.^[56]^[53]

Role in Conspiratorial Narratives

Prominent Theories Involving Cabals

The New World Order theory posits that a secretive cabal comprising global elites, including bankers, politicians, and corporate leaders, orchestrates events to establish a totalitarian one-world government, eroding national sovereignty through mechanisms like international organizations and economic crises. Proponents, drawing from statements by figures such as George H.W. Bush in a 1990 speech referencing a "new world order," interpret such rhetoric as evidence of coordinated elite planning, often linking it to groups like the Trilateral Commission founded in 1973. This narrative gained traction in the 1990s amid globalization debates, with adherents citing declassified documents and public admissions of elite networking as indicators of hidden influence.^[50]^[52] In QAnon lore, a satanic cabal of high-level Democrats, Hollywood figures, and global financiers engages in child trafficking and ritual abuse to maintain control, countered by former President Donald Trump in a purported secret war that would culminate in mass arrests known as "The Storm." Originating from anonymous 4chan posts in October 2017 under the pseudonym "Q," the theory expanded via social media, incorporating elements like adrenochrome harvesting from children, and by 2020 had influenced events such as the January 6 Capitol riot where believers sought to expose the cabal. Surveys indicate that by November 2020, 17% of Americans had heard of QAnon, with belief correlating to distrust in mainstream institutions.^[57]^[58]^[49] The Deep State concept describes an entrenched network of unelected bureaucrats, intelligence officials, and career civil servants operating as a shadow government to subvert elected leaders, particularly evident in claims of surveillance and leaks against Trump starting in 2016. Articulated by figures like Steve Bannon in 2017, it references historical precedents such as the FBI's COINTELPRO program exposed in 1971, which targeted domestic groups, as proof of institutionalized power beyond democratic oversight. By 2024, Trump referenced destroying the Deep State over 56 times on Truth Social, framing it as a cabal resisting policy reforms like those in Schedule F executive orders.^[59]^[47] Illuminati theories allege a surviving remnant of the Bavarian Illuminati, disbanded in 1785, persists as a cabal infiltrating Freemasonry and modern institutions to manipulate wars, economies, and media for global domination. Popularized in works like John Robison's 1797 Proofs of a Conspiracy, contemporary variants point to symbols in currency and entertainment as signals, with belief persisting due to opaque elite gatherings like the Bohemian Grove encampments since 1872. Adherents often overlap this with NWO claims, estimating membership in thousands among influencers.^[60] Other theories invoke cabals around forums like the Bilderberg Meetings, annual private gatherings since 1954 of approximately 120-150 political and business leaders, accused of plotting policy without public scrutiny, as evidenced by attendee lists including figures like Henry Kissinger since the 1950s.^[7] These narratives frequently intersect, portraying interconnected elite factions advancing agendas through coordinated secrecy rather than overt action.

Assessments of Evidence and Verifiability

The verifiability of cabals hinges on primary evidence such as declassified documents, court records, and corroborated whistleblower accounts, which have substantiated select historical instances while leaving many contemporary allegations unsubstantiated. For example, the U.S. government's Tuskegee Syphilis Study (1932–1972) was exposed through investigative reporting and official inquiries, revealing a deliberate conspiracy by public health officials to withhold penicillin from African American participants despite its availability as a cure, confirmed by Centers for Disease Control records and a subsequent presidential apology in 1997.^[61] Similarly, the CIA's MKUltra program (1953–1973), involving non-consensual mind-control experiments with LSD and other substances, was verified via over 20,000 declassified pages released under Freedom of Information Act requests in the 1970s, including Senate hearings that documented ethical violations and participant harms.^[61] These cases demonstrate that verifiable cabals typically emerge from institutional leaks or legal scrutiny, yielding falsifiable chains of custody for actions and motives. Corporate and economic cabals have likewise been proven through antitrust prosecutions and internal memos. The 1990s price-fixing scandal involving lysine producers, including Archer Daniels Midland executives, resulted in guilty pleas and fines exceeding $100 million after FBI sting operations uncovered taped admissions of coordinated global surcharges, as detailed in U.S. Department of Justice filings. Such evidence contrasts sharply with unverified claims, where reliance on pattern recognition or anonymous sources predominates without documentary corroboration. Alleged modern cabals, such as those posited in narratives of elite pedophile networks or "deep state" manipulations, often falter under evidentiary scrutiny despite high-profile triggers like the Jeffrey Epstein case. While Epstein's 2008 plea deal and 2019 death involved documented associations with figures like Bill Clinton and Prince Andrew—evidenced by flight logs and victim testimonies released in court unsealed in 2024—no comprehensive proof has emerged of a singular controlling cabal orchestrating global events, with investigations attributing activities to individual exploitation rather than institutionalized conspiracy.^[62]^[63] Claims amplified in movements like QAnon, which allege a satanic elite cabal, have prompted actions like the 2016 Pizzagate shooting but lack primary documents linking purported symbols (e.g., coded emails) to coordinated plots, as federal probes found no substantiation beyond speculation.^[64] Assessing source credibility is essential: declassified archives and judicial outcomes provide high-verifiability anchors, whereas partisan media or academic analyses—often exhibiting institutional biases toward dismissing structured dissent—may overgeneralize failures of grand theories to discredit narrower, evidence-based inquiries into malfeasance. Empirical standards demand replication across independent verifiers; theories persisting on circumstantial inference alone remain unverified, underscoring the distinction between plausible intrigue and unsubstantiated cabal assertions.^[65]

Psychological and Sociological Critiques

Belief in secret cabals often arises from psychological motives including the epistemic need to impose order on uncertain environments and the existential drive for a sense of control and safety amid perceived threats.^[66] Individuals prone to such beliefs exhibit heightened pattern recognition, interpreting ambiguous or coincidental events as evidence of coordinated malice, a phenomenon linked to apophenia and illusory correlations rather than verifiable causal links.^[67]^[68] Experimental studies demonstrate that exposure to anxiety-inducing stressors, such as personal uncertainty or global crises, correlates with increased endorsement of conspiratorial explanations attributing events to hidden groups, as these narratives reduce cognitive dissonance by positing intentional agency over stochastic processes.^[69]^[70] Critiques from cognitive psychology highlight that while not all conspiracy adherents display impaired reasoning—recent meta-analyses show weak or inconsistent ties to overall cognitive deficits—belief in expansive cabals frequently aligns with intuitive rather than analytical processing styles, favoring holistic narratives over evidence-based scrutiny.^[71]^[72] Personality factors, including narcissism and a need for uniqueness, further predict susceptibility, as cabal theories affirm believers' perceived insight into "hidden truths" inaccessible to others.^[73] These mechanisms, evolved for detecting genuine threats in ancestral environments, can misfire in modern contexts, generating false positives for coordinated plots where decentralized incentives or incompetence suffice as explanations.^[68] Sociologically, endorsement of cabal narratives intensifies in contexts of institutional distrust and social fragmentation, where they serve as identity-affirming responses to perceived threats against ingroup status, such as economic displacement or cultural shifts.^[74]^[75] In low-trust societies, these beliefs correlate with intergroup antagonism, framing outgroups as omnipotent schemers and justifying exclusionary actions, though empirical reviews indicate they rarely mobilize effective collective resistance and instead perpetuate cycles of alienation.^[76]^[77] Critiques emphasize that while real factional intrigues occur, sociological overreliance on cabal frameworks overlooks emergent social dynamics driven by visible incentives, such as regulatory capture or elite capture, favoring simplistic monocausal attributions over multifaceted analyses of power structures.^[78] Longitudinal data from 2022 surveys across multiple nations reveal stable or declining overall conspiracy adherence over time, suggesting such beliefs thrive episodically during acute disruptions rather than as enduring sociological fixtures.^[79]

Cultural and Societal Impact

Representations in Literature and Media

In literature, cabals are often depicted as clandestine groups wielding hidden influence through deception, murder, or ideological subversion. In Agatha Christie's The Seven Dials Mystery (1929), a hooded secret society bearing clock-face emblems engages in assassination and intelligence gathering, with its members infiltrating high society to eliminate threats.^[80] Similarly, Dan Brown's Angels & Demons (2000) portrays the Illuminati as a centuries-old cabal of scientists plotting the destruction of the Vatican, marked by ambigrams and orchestrated murders to revive their order.^[80] Umberto Eco's Foucault's Pendulum (1988) satirizes such groups through the fictional "Tres" (Templi Resurgentes Equites Synarchici), a fabricated Templar-derived cabal invented by editors that spirals into real paranoia and violence, highlighting the self-fulfilling dangers of conspiratorial invention.^[80] Restoration-era English literature frequently satirized political cabals inspired by the Cabal Ministry of 1667–1673, portraying ministers like the Earl of Arlington and Duke of Buckingham as scheming factions undermining royal policy through backroom deals and factional rivalries.^[81] In Clive Barker's novella Cabal (1988), a monstrous underground society in Midian contrasts with a human psychiatric cabal framing protagonist Aaron Boone for serial killings, emphasizing themes of persecution and hidden otherness.^[82] G.K. Chesterton's The Man Who Was Thursday (1908) features the Central Council of Anarchists, a seven-member cabal named after days of the week, plotting societal overthrow until revealed as an elaborate counter-conspiracy.^[80] Film adaptations and original screenplays extend these motifs, often amplifying cabals as global threats. In The Da Vinci Code (2006), directed by Ron Howard from Brown's novel, the Priory of Sion operates as a protective cabal safeguarding Jesus's bloodline secrets against the Catholic Church's Opus Dei enforcers.^[83] Rosemary's Baby (1968), based on Ira Levin's novel, depicts a Satanic cabal of New York elites ritually impregnating the protagonist to birth the Antichrist, using everyday social networks for coercion.^[83] Eyes Wide Shut (1999) by Stanley Kubrick portrays an elite masked cabal conducting orgiastic rituals and issuing veiled death threats to intruders, symbolizing upper-class exclusivity and menace.^[84] In broader media, cabals symbolize unchecked power, as in Lara Croft: Tomb Raider (2001), where the Illuminati cabal seeks Illuminati artifacts to manipulate time and consolidate control.^[83] Such representations typically frame cabals as antagonists thwarted by protagonists uncovering their plots, reinforcing narratives of hidden elites versus individual agency, though children's literature like Enid Blyton's Secret Seven series (1949–1963) inverts this with benign child cabals solving petty crimes.^[80] These depictions draw from historical intrigue but prioritize dramatic escalation over empirical fidelity.

Influence on Public Discourse and Policy

Beliefs in secret cabals, often framed as shadowy networks of elites or bureaucrats controlling governance, have shaped political rhetoric and voter mobilization, particularly in populist movements challenging institutional authority. In the United States, the "deep state" narrative—depicting unelected officials as a cabal thwarting democratic mandates—gained prominence during Donald Trump's presidency, with Trump citing it in over 140 executive orders issued in his first 100 days to restructure federal agencies and curb perceived insider resistance.^[85] This framing influenced policy debates on civil service reforms, as seen in proposals to reclassify thousands of federal positions for easier dismissal, justified as dismantling entrenched power structures.^[86] Such theories amplified public skepticism toward expertise-driven governance, correlating with reduced trust in institutions like the FBI and intelligence community, where approval ratings among Republicans fell below 50% by 2018 amid claims of cabal-orchestrated investigations.^[87] QAnon adherents, who envision a satanic pedophile cabal of global elites opposing figures like Trump, have impacted electoral dynamics and legislative priorities. In the 2020 U.S. congressional primaries, over 80 candidates expressed sympathy for QAnon tenets, securing nominations in several races and elevating issues like child sex trafficking into Republican platforms, which prompted federal task forces and hearings despite limited evidence tying claims to verifiable cabals.^[88] This influence extended to public opinion, with QAnon exposure correlating with heightened support for anti-trafficking policies but also broader resistance to mainstream narratives on elections and public health; surveys indicated that 20-30% of Republicans encountered QAnon content, associating it with diminished faith in electoral integrity post-2020.^[89]^[90] Empirical studies link cabal-centric conspiracy beliefs to policy noncompliance and democratic erosion, including lower vaccine uptake during the COVID-19 pandemic—where endorsement of elite-plot theories reduced compliance by up to 25% in affected cohorts—and increased support for autocratic measures amid perceived institutional conspiracies.^[91]^[92] These dynamics foster polarized discourse, as evidenced by the January 6, 2021, Capitol events, where deep state and election-cabal rhetoric motivated participants, per FBI assessments tying over 20% of cases to conspiracy-driven ideologies.^[79] While academic analyses often attribute such impacts to psychological factors like powerlessness, real-world elite networks—such as documented Epstein associations—lend partial credence to coordination concerns, though exaggerated cabal claims typically lack causal evidence for policy subversion.^[93]^[94]

References

[1]
Cabal - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
Originating from French cabal and Medieval Latin cabbala, the word means a mystical Old Testament interpretation and a secretive private group.
[2]
CABAL Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster
The term traces back to cabbala, the Medieval Latin name for the Kabbalah, a traditional system of esoteric Jewish mysticism. Latin borrowed Cabbala from the ...
[3]
CABAL Definition & Meaning - Dictionary.com
Word History and Origins Origin of cabal1. C17: from French cabale, from Medieval Latin cabala; see cabbala. Origin of cabal2. see kabbalah ; by a coincidence, ...
[4]
The Cabal Facts & Worksheets - School History
The Cabal Ministry was a private group of high councilors of Charles II of England between 1667 and 1674. Formed following the dismissal of Edward Hyde, 1st ...Download The Cabal... · Resource Examples · Key Facts And Information
[5]
The Cabal Ministry of Charles II - Hoydens & Firebrands
May 23, 2009 · King Charles II gathered five staunch supporters and peers of the realm around him to promote his own policies.
[6]
Cabal - Definition, Meaning & Synonyms - Vocabulary.com
Cabal comes from the word cabbala (also spelled kabbala), which refers to a Jewish tradition of interpreting texts. Cabbala is often regarded as a secret and ...
[7]
Bilderberg mystery: Why do people believe in cabals? - BBC News
Jun 8, 2011 · Conspiracy theories abound as to what is discussed and who is there. Why, asks Tom de Castella? The belief in secret cabals running the world is ...
[8]
CABAL: The Curious History of a Word
Jan 7, 2022 · A prominent member of the CABAL ministry who did not know of the secret treaty eventually turned against Charles II. In the 1670s, Lord ...
[9]
The Origin of Cabal: From Past to Present - Wordpandit
The word “cabal” originates from the Hebrew term qabbālāh (קַבָּלָה), meaning “received tradition” or “mystical doctrine.” This term was later adapted into Medieval ...
[10]
cabal, n.¹ meanings, etymology and more | Oxford English Dictionary
A secret intrigue, esp. with the aim of gaining political control or influence; a plot. Now somewhat archaic. 1614. Howsoever there may ...
[11]
The Cabal | A History of Britain
The name of the Cabal has become permanently associated with the group who formed this inner council after the fall of Clarendon.
[12]
How did the Cabal Ministry influence political developments?
The Cabal Ministry, active from 1668 to 1674 during the reign of King Charles II, was a group of five ministers whose initials formed the acronym "CABAL.
[13]
CABAL (TREATY OF ALLIANCE) - EUdesign
The word "cabal" (meaning "a secret association of intriguers") was popularly applied to Charles II's ministry as a nickname because of the initials of those ...
[14]
A timeline of the Restoration period - HistoryExtra
Apr 17, 2023 · Summer 1667 Charles forms the Cabal ministry, a private group of high councillors who help him extend his power. The first letters of the names ...
[15]
HIST 251 - An Unsettled Settlement: The Restoration Era, 1660-1688
First of all, Charles had agreed secretly that at an appropriate moment he would suspend the penal laws against Roman Catholics.
[16]
[PDF] The Events of 1688/89 - Dordt Digital Collections
Sep 3, 2023 · In 1670, Charles II signed the Treaty of Dover with France. It provided for a joint attack on the Dutch and for French subsidies to the ...
[17]
Cabal - Oxford Reference
A group or association of political intriguers. In England in the 17th century it was a precursor of the English cabinet.<|separator|>
[18]
Geschiedenis van het Nederlandsche volk. Deel 3, P.J. Blok - DBNL
... William Pitt regeerde thans Engeland met groote bekwaamheid en omzich- ... friesche kabaal' - terwijl Zeeland talmde met een antwoord en de overige ...
[19]
Register., De patriottentijd. Deel 3: 1786-1787, H.T. Colenbrander
Grenville (William Wyndham), engelsch onderhandelaar te Parijs in 1782, I ... friesche kabaal tegen den hertog van Brunswijk, 65; zijn val, 66. Haren ...
[20]
Conway Cabal | George Washington's Mount Vernon
The Conway Cabal refers to a loosely organized attempt by a group of military officers and members of Congress to remove General George Washington from command.
[21]
George Washington learns of effort to discredit him | HISTORY
In a letter that General George Washington receives on November 4, 1777, he is informed that a conspiracy is afoot to discredit him with Congress.
[22]
Conway Cabal | American Battlefield Trust
Oct 1, 2021 · Brigadier General Thomas Conway, serving in the main Continental Army under General George Washington sat down one evening in Pennsylvania and penned a letter.Missing: examples | Show results with:examples
[23]
https://www.ushistory.org/march/other/cabal.htm
[24]
The Conway Cabal - AMERICAN HERITAGE
Beyond the factual truth or shifting historical meaning, what is the lasting importance of the Conway Cabal? For students of Washington, it is a rare peek ...
[25]
Conway Cabal | Facts, Events, Information & History
Feb 14, 2020 · The Conway Cabal was an attempt by several generals and members of Congress to replace General Washington as leader of the Continental Army.
[26]
Cabal - Political Dictionary
A “cabal” is a group of people involved in a secret plot or conspiracy. The term can also refer to the plot itself, or to the secret organization of the ...
[27]
CABAL definition in American English - Collins Dictionary
1. a small group of intriguers, esp one formed for political purposes · 2. a secret plot, esp a political one; conspiracy; intrigue · 3. a secret or exclusive set ...
[28]
Hobbes, Empire, and the Politics of the Cabal
Dec 19, 2022 · The dynamic and unstable politics of the Cabal also generated a rich political discourse. In this period, Thomas Hobbes penned several ...Missing: excluding | Show results with:excluding
[29]
[PDF] Hobbes, empire and the politics of the cabal
Feb 2, 2023 · The context of Cabal era politics explains the debates in which Pax seems most invested: not just whether colonies were economically beneficial, ...Missing: excluding | Show results with:excluding
[30]
https://politicaldictionary.com/words/cabal
[31]
Cabal! The Plot Against General Washington
Apr 8, 2020 · A story full of political maneuvering, Cabal! sheds new light on the contentious relationship between the Continental Congress and the Continental Army.
[32]
From Plumbers to Prisoners: The Watergate Scandal's Most Inept ...
A crack team of ex-CIA and FBI operatives nicknamed the White House 'plumbers' were supposed to stop intelligence leaks that could damage Richard Nixon.Missing: cabal | Show results with:cabal
[33]
Meet the White House Plumbers - The History Reader
The Plumbers are best remembered for the politically motivated Watergate Hotel break-in, but dirty tricks in dark hotels weren't why they were brought together.Missing: cabal | Show results with:cabal
[34]
The Real Story Of The White House Plumbers Who Plotted Watergate
Apr 22, 2022 · A team of former FBI and CIA operatives, the “White House plumbers” were tasked with stopping information leaks that made the president look bad and fighting ...Missing: cabal | Show results with:cabal
[35]
Fixing the White House's Leaks — Nixon's 'Plumbers' | Coffee or Die
Aug 29, 2021 · Ultimately, the plumbers were arrested after breaking into the headquarters of the Democratic National Committee at the Watergate Office ...Missing: cabal | Show results with:cabal
[36]
Report of Congressional Committees Investigating the Iran-Contra ...
The Secretaries of State and Defense repeatedly opposed such sales to a Government designated by the United States as a supporter of international terrorism.
[37]
The Iran-Contra Affair - Levin Center for Oversight and Democracy
The Enterprise made at least $48 million from weapons sales to Iran, at least $3.8 million of which was diverted to the Contras. · President Reagan signed a CIA ...<|separator|>
[38]
The Iran-Contra Affair | American Experience | Official Site - PBS
In 1985, while Iran and Iraq were at war, Iran made a secret request to buy weapons from the United States. McFarlane sought Reagan's approval, in spite of the ...Missing: example | Show results with:example
[39]
President Reagan's Role in the Iran-Contra Scandal | Brookings
That incident revealed a covert U.S. government operation to sell arms to the Iranians and ultimately divert the profits to Nicaragua's Contra forces. These ...Missing: example | Show results with:example
[40]
Illegal Corporate Price-Fixing Conspiracies are Widespread in U.S. ...
Apr 18, 2023 · Illegal Corporate Price-Fixing Conspiracies are Widespread in U.S. Economy · electronic components ($8.6 billion in penalties) · automotive parts ...
[41]
Five Major Banks Agree to Parent-Level Guilty Pleas
May 20, 2015 · JPMorgan, which was involved from at least as early as July 2010 until January 2013, has agreed to pay a fine of $550 million; and. RBS, which ...
[42]
The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy - IEEE Spectrum
The Phoebus cartel engineered a shorter-lived lightbulb and gave birth to planned obsolescence.
[43]
Understanding the Libor Scandal | Council on Foreign Relations
Regulators in the United States, the UK, and the European Union have fined banks more than $9 billion for rigging Libor, which underpins over $300 trillion ...
[44]
Libor-rigging fines: a timeline - The Guardian
Apr 23, 2015 · Deutsche Bank has been fined a record $2.5bn for rigging Libor - here's a list of other banks fined for rigging Libor rates.
[45]
Five global banks to pay $5.7 billion in fines over rate rigging | Reuters
May 20, 2015 · Five of the world's largest banks, including JPMorgan Chase & Co and Citigroup Inc, were fined roughly $5.7 billion, and four of them ...
[46]
What is the Great Reset - and how did it get hijacked by conspiracy ...
Jun 23, 2021 · A global Covid recovery plan by the World Economic Forum has inspired false rumours about the creation of a tyrannical world government.
[47]
Trump has said he wants to destroy the “deep state” 56 times on ...
Aug 1, 2024 · Donald Trump has set the scene for a potential second term as president by laying out a multi-step plan on Truth Social to “demolish the ...
[48]
How the QAnon movement entered mainstream politics
Jul 19, 2025 · The foundational belief of many of the QAnon followers is that Donald Trump is the heroic figure fighting the elite pedophile ring.
[49]
QAnon: What is it and where did it come from? - BBC
Jan 6, 2021 · President Trump - viewed as a hero by the movement - has stopped short of endorsing the conspiracy theory but has described QAnon activists as " ...
[50]
The New World Order: The Historical Origins of a Dangerous ...
May 30, 2022 · The New World Order (NWO) is a conspiracy theory in which adherents believe that a cabal of powerful elites is secretly implementing a dystopian international ...
[51]
Elite Davos forum 'sitting target' of conspiracy theorists - France 24
Jan 20, 2023 · The World Economic Forum in Davos is an ideal target for conspiracy theorists pushing the idea of an elite cabal running the world.
[52]
The 'New World Order' - ISD
Sep 20, 2022 · The 'New World Order' conspiracy theory argues that a shadowy elite force is trying to implement a totalitarian world government.
[53]
The Deep State Is Real - POLITICO Magazine
Sep 5, 2017 · Michael Crowley is senior foreign affairs correspondent for Politico. At a conference in mid-July, Barack Obama's CIA director, John Brennan, ...
[54]
Durham Is Scrutinizing Ex-C.I.A. Director's Role in Russian ...
Dec 23, 2019 · The federal prosecutor investigating the origins of the Russia inquiry is examining testimony by the former C.I.A. director John Brennan and ...<|separator|>
[55]
'Criminal Cabal'? FBI Fears Political Attacks May Imperil Work ... - NPR
Jan 22, 2018 · It has been called a "criminal cabal" rife with corruption. It's been said that its leaders need to be taken out in "handcuffs.
[56]
Spy cables: Israel airline used as intelligence 'front' - Al Jazeera
Feb 24, 2015 · South Africa's spy agencies concurred with allegations that Israel uses its flag-carrier, El Al Airlines, as cover for its intelligence agencies.Missing: cabals | Show results with:cabals
[57]
QAnon | ADL
Oct 28, 2022 · QAnon is a decentralized, far-right political movement rooted in a baseless conspiracy theory that former President Donald Trump is waging a secret war against ...
[58]
5 facts about the QAnon conspiracy theories - Pew Research Center
Nov 16, 2020 · Here are five facts about how much Americans have heard about the QAnon conspiracy theories and their views about them.<|separator|>
[59]
State Secrecy Explains the Origins of the 'Deep State' Conspiracy ...
Feb 6, 2024 · Lost in today's misinformation fights is the recognition that modern conspiracy theories spring from excesses of state secrecy.Missing: proven | Show results with:proven<|control11|><|separator|>
[60]
Who are the Illuminati? | The Week
Sep 17, 2025 · Belief that a 'corrupt elite is secretly running the world' is one of the longest-running and most widespread conspiracy theories of our ...
[61]
5 times the U.S. government revealed secrets it tried to keep hidden
Dec 19, 2024 · Here are five instances when the US government eventually owned up to programs and incidents that it initially kept secret.Missing: cabals plots<|separator|>
[62]
Understanding the Epstein Saga - The New York Times
Jul 22, 2025 · In the swirl of conspiracy theories, it's hard to tell what's real. ... A tight frame of Jeffrey Epstein at court. ... Jeffrey Epstein, the rich sex ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[63]
What do we know about the Jeffrey Epstein files? - BBC
Aug 19, 2025 · The clamour is growing for the Trump administration to put documents related to the Epstein investigations before the public.Missing: examples | Show results with:examples
[64]
The QAnon Conspiracy Theory: A Security Threat in the Making?
Jul 4, 2020 · A survey of cases of individuals who have allegedly or apparently been radicalized to criminal acts with a nexus to violence by QAnon, including ...
[65]
Conspiracy Theories - PMC - PubMed Central - NIH
A conspiracy theory is an explanation of an event which cites a conspiracy as a salient cause. Psychological approaches explain belief in conspiracy theories.
[66]
The Psychology of Conspiracy Theories - PMC - NIH
Belief in conspiracy theories appears to be driven by motives that can be characterized as epistemic (understanding one's environment), existential (being safe ...
[67]
[PDF] A Meta-Analytic Review of Motivational and Personological Correlates
A drive to understand the everyday world is one reason why people may be drawn to conspiracy theories. Identifying intuitive explanations for ambiguous events, ...
[68]
Conspiracy Theories: Evolved Functions and Psychological ... - jstor
We review evidence pertaining to two competing evolutionary hypotheses: (a) conspiracy beliefs are a by-product of a suite of psychological mechanisms (e.g., ...
[69]
Belief in conspiracy theories: Basic principles of an emerging ...
The negative emotions that constitute the psychological origins of belief in conspiracy theories include anxiety, uncertainty, or the feeling that one lacks ...
[70]
[PDF] Do stress and anxiety lead to belief in conspiracy theories?
Sep 5, 2023 · A variety of causes of (or motives for) belief in conspir- acy theories have been proposed in the psychological literature. (see Douglas et al., ...
[71]
Are conspiracy beliefs a sign of flawed cognition? Reexamining the ...
Dec 12, 2024 · Belief in implausible conspiracy theories has been associated with suboptimal information processing.
[72]
[PDF] Reasoning ability predicts irrational worldview but not conspiracy ...
Previous research showed that individual tendency to believe in conspiracy theories is related to numerous social, personality, and cognitive variables.<|separator|>
[73]
[PDF] Psychological Predictors of Belief in Conspiracy Theories
Research supports a range of explanations for conspiracy beliefs that point to dispositional causes, such as personality traits, and situational ones, such as ...
[74]
How social identity shapes conspiratorial belief - ScienceDirect.com
We argue that conspiracy theories often develop in response to threats to people's social identities, whether those identities are racial, political, or ...Missing: cabals | Show results with:cabals
[75]
The Plot Thickens: A Sociology of Conspiracy Theories
Feb 5, 2024 · At the intergroup level, belief in conspiracy theories has been described as maladaptive us- versus-them reasoning (Van Prooijen & Van Lange ...
[76]
Understanding Conspiracy Theories - Douglas - Wiley Online Library
Mar 20, 2019 · Our review of the literature shows that conspiracy beliefs result from a range of psychological, political, and social factors. Next, how are ...Missing: cabals | Show results with:cabals
[77]
Conspiracy Movements: A Definitional Introduction and Theoretical ...
Apr 20, 2022 · Conspiracy theories have been used to mobilize and justify collective action in many political and social movements around the world.
[78]
Why Believe Conspiracy Theories? - Meggan M. Jordan, Jennifer M ...
May 15, 2024 · Beliefs, even conspiratorial ones, do not occur in a vacuum: they reflect social conditions and fulfill important identity needs, including ...<|separator|>
[79]
Have beliefs in conspiracy theories increased over time? | PLOS One
Jul 20, 2022 · Psychological, Political, and Situational Factors Combine to Boost COVID-19 Conspiracy Theory Beliefs. Canadian Journal of Political Science.
[80]
Ten of the best secret societies in literature | Culture | The Guardian
Oct 9, 2009 · The Secret Seven Children's fiction is full of secret societies, of which Enid Blyton's band of do-gooding children is the most benign.Missing: cabal | Show results with:cabal
[81]
[PDF] ABSTRACT Title of Dissertation: CABALAS AND CABALS IN ...
expands the definition of cabal as only secret political plottings to include personal intrigues as well. In the two worlds, the caballists' writings ...
[82]
Cabal by Clive Barker (1988): Stand Me Up at the Gates of Hell
Jan 7, 2015 · Cabal is the story of Aaron Boone, a young man on the run from his psychiatrist Dr. Decker, a secret madman who plans to blame Boone for his own serial killer ...
[83]
Films About Secret Societies - Moria Reviews
Of existing secret societies, The Illuminati appear in Razor Blade Smile (1998), Lara Croft, Tomb Raider (2001) and Trump vs The Illuminati (2020), are ...
[84]
Movies about Secret Societies - IMDb
Movies about Secret Societies ; 1. Eyes Wide Shut. 19992h 39m ; 2. They Live. 19881h 34m ; 3. Rosemary's Baby. 19682h 17m ; 4. Fight Club. 19992h 19m ; 5. National ...Missing: cabal fiction
[85]
Deeper Than the “Deep State”: Follow the Money | Origins
Jul 10, 2025 · During his first hundred days in office, President Donald J. Trump issued over 140 Executive Orders. His Department of Government Efficiency ...Missing: accusations | Show results with:accusations
[86]
Musk and Ramaswamy, meet the real deep state | Brookings
Nov 18, 2024 · Now, with Republicans poised to lead both chambers of Congress, President-elect Trump is preparing to deliver on his promise to “dismantle ...
[87]
Gov Exec: Deconstructing the Deep State
Donald Trump isn't the first president to be deeply skeptical of the institutions and people he now leads. A month after President Trump took the oath of office ...
[88]
Who Supports QAnon? A Case Study in Political Extremism
The QAnon conspiracy theory has garnered increasing attention as more than 80 pro-QAnon congressional candidates vied for nominations in 2020 primary races.Missing: influence policy
[89]
Understanding QAnon's Connection to American Politics, Religion ...
May 27, 2021 · QAnon's core theory revolves around Satan-worshipping pedophiles plotting against Trump and a coming “storm” that would clear out those evil forces.Missing: policy opinion
[90]
Most Americans who have heard of QAnon conspiracy theories say ...
Sep 16, 2020 · Republicans who rely on Trump and his campaign as a major election news source are somewhat more likely to see the QAnon conspiracies as ...
[91]
COVID-19 Conspiracies, Trust in Authorities, and Duty to Comply ...
Jan 11, 2022 · Conspiracy theories can undermine public trust in authorities, reduce public engagement in pro-social behaviours, and increase the incidence of ...
[92]
Is democracy under threat? Why belief in conspiracy theories ...
Mar 13, 2023 · Results revealed that the perceived presence of conspiracies increased support for autocracy, partly due to feelings of political powerlessness.
[93]
Shining a spotlight on the dangerous consequences of conspiracy ...
This review shines a spotlight on how conspiracy beliefs could impact public and personal health (eg, vaccine uptake), democratic citizenship (eg, political ...Missing: discourse | Show results with:discourse
[94]
Conspiracy theories and their believers in an era of misinformation
Dec 12, 2024 · Conspiracy theories have transitioned from fringe phenomena to central forces shaping public opinion and political discourse worldwide.Missing: cabal | Show results with:cabal