Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Quark model

The quark model is a foundational framework in that describes hadrons—strongly interacting composite particles such as protons, neutrons, and —as bound states composed of more fundamental constituents called quarks. Introduced independently in 1964 by and , the model posits that baryons consist of three quarks (qqq) while are quark-antiquark pairs (q̄q), with quarks carrying fractional electric charges of ±1/3 or ±2/3 times the and obeying the for quantum numbers like , , and . Initially featuring three quark flavors—up (u, charge +2/3), down (d, -1/3), and strange (s, -1/3)—the model was later expanded to include three heavier flavors: (c, +2/3), (b, -1/3), and top (t, +2/3), accommodating discoveries like the J/ψ in 1974. Building on the SU(3) flavor symmetry of the "eightfold way" developed by Gell-Mann and in 1961, the quark model successfully organized the proliferation of known s into multiplets and predicted the existence of new particles, most notably the Ω⁻ (sss, mass ≈1.67 GeV), which was experimentally confirmed shortly after the model's . It explains key properties, including spin-parity assignments, magnetic moments (e.g., the proton-to-neutron ratio μ_p/μ_n ≈ -3/2), and decay patterns, by treating quarks as non-relativistic fermions in a potential akin to the Cornell form V(r) = -α/r + βr. The model's predictive power was bolstered by the incorporation of (QCD) in the , which introduced the concept of (red, green, blue) to ensure confinement—quarks cannot exist in isolation but form color-neutral s via exchange. Despite its triumphs, the quark model has limitations, such as the missing resonances problem, where only about 20 established N* states are observed despite dozens predicted, and struggling to describe exotic hadrons like tetraquarks (qq̄q̄q) and pentaquarks (qqqq̄), which challenge the simple q̄q and qqq paradigm. Extensions, including relativistic corrections, , and simulations, have refined its accuracy for light spectra, while ongoing experiments at facilities like the LHC continue to test its validity in heavy-quark sectors. Today, the quark model remains integral to the , providing an intuitive bridge between phenomenological spectroscopy and the perturbative regime of QCD.

Basic Principles

Quark Flavors and Generations

Quarks are particles classified as fermions, possessing intrinsic of 1/2 and exhibiting half-integer statistics, with electric charges that are fractions of the e. For instance, the carries a charge of +2/3 e, while the has -1/3 e. These particles are categorized into six distinct flavors: up (u), down (d), (c), strange (s), (t), and (b). The flavors are organized into three generations, reflecting a pattern of increasing mass: the first generation consists of the light up and down quarks; the second includes the somewhat heavier and strange quarks; and the third comprises the heavy and quarks. This generational structure arises from the of , where each generation forms doublets, with the up-type quarks (u, c, t) having +2/3 e charge and the down-type (d, s, b) having -1/3 e. Among the lighter quarks—up, down, and strange—an approximate SU(3) flavor symmetry governs their strong interactions, treating them as transforming under the fundamental representation of the SU(3) group. This symmetry incorporates the strangeness quantum number, assigned as S = -1 to the strange quark to account for its distinct behavior in weak decays and conservation in strong processes. Antiquarks, the antiparticles of quarks, serve as their charge conjugates, carrying opposite electric charges, baryon numbers of -1/3, and inverted flavor quantum numbers such as .

Hadrons as Quark Composites

Hadrons represent the fundamental building blocks of atomic nuclei and are understood within the quark model as bound states of quarks, held together by the mediated through the exchange of gluons. This binding arises from the of the strong interaction, ensuring that quarks cannot exist in due to confinement. The model posits that all observed hadrons, such as protons, neutrons, and pions, emerge from specific combinations of these fundamental constituents, providing a unified description of their properties like mass and spin. Mesons form one class of hadrons, composed of a single quark and its corresponding antiquark, denoted as q \bar{q}. These pairs exhibit integer total spin (0 or 1), classifying mesons as bosons that obey Bose-Einstein statistics. Examples include the neutral pion (\pi^0), which consists of a mixture of up and down quark-antiquark states, and the rho meson (\rho), both pivotal in mediating short-range nuclear forces. The quark-antiquark structure accounts for their zero baryon number and relatively lighter masses compared to baryons. Baryons constitute the other primary category, built from three quarks (qqq), which combine to yield half-integer spin (typically \frac{1}{2} or \frac{3}{2}), rendering them fermions subject to Fermi-Dirac statistics. Antibaryons, their antiparticles, are analogously formed from three antiquarks (\bar{q} \bar{q} \bar{q}), such as the antiproton. The proton itself exemplifies this, comprising two up quarks and one down quark (uud), while the neutron is udd. Since quarks are spin-\frac{1}{2} fermions, the Pauli exclusion principle mandates that any identical quarks within a baryon must occupy antisymmetric wave functions, ensuring distinct quantum states to avoid violation—this is evident in states like the \Delta^{++} baryon with three up quarks, where spatial, spin, and flavor symmetries balance the overall antisymmetry./University_Physics_III_-Optics_and_Modern_Physics(OpenStax)/11%3A_Particle_Physics_and_Cosmology/11.04%3A_Quarks) A key quantum number distinguishing these composites is the B, conserved in strong and electromagnetic interactions, defined by the equation B = \frac{1}{3} (N_q - N_{\bar{q}}) where N_q is the number of quarks and N_{\bar{q}} is the number of antiquarks. This assigns B = +1 to baryons, B = -1 to antibaryons, and B = 0 to mesons, underpinning the stability of matter and prohibiting processes like in the .

Color Charge and Confinement

In the quark model, quarks possess an additional known as , which comes in three varieties conventionally labeled , , and . This property was introduced to ensure that the wave functions of baryons, composed of three identical , remain antisymmetric under particle exchange in accordance with the . The color charges transform according to the fundamental representation of the non-Abelian gauge group SU(3)c, providing a threefold degeneracy for each and enabling the construction of color-neutral hadronic states.90625-4) The strong interaction between quarks is mediated by gluons, which are massless bosons belonging to the (color-octet) representation of SU(3)c. Unlike photons in , gluons carry both color and anticolor charges, allowing them to interact with each other and leading to a non-linear dynamics of the strong force.90625-4) This self-interaction is a key feature that distinguishes (QCD) from . A central consequence of the is the phenomenon of quark confinement, which posits that and gluons are perpetually bound within hadrons and cannot be observed in isolation. This arises because the between quarks grows linearly with separation distance, approximated as
V(r) \approx kr
where k \approx 1 GeV/fm is the string tension parameter, reflecting the formation of a flux tube of gluonic fields between the quarks. As a result, the energy required to separate quarks diverges, favoring the creation of new quark-antiquark pairs instead, which hadronize into observable particles. Hadrons manifest as color singlets, ensuring overall color neutrality under the SU(3)c symmetry. For mesons, this is achieved through a quark-antiquark pair (q\bar{q}) in a color-singlet state, where the anticolor of the antiquark neutralizes the color of the quark. Baryons, conversely, consist of three quarks (qqq) combined in a fully antisymmetric color-singlet configuration, corresponding to the invariant singlet in the decomposition of the $3 \otimes 3 \otimes 3 representation.90625-4) Complementing confinement is the property of asymptotic freedom, whereby the strong coupling constant decreases at short interquark distances (high momentum transfers), making the interaction perturbative in that regime. This behavior, arising from the negative beta function of non-Abelian gauge theories, allows for reliable QCD calculations of high-energy processes while confinement dominates at larger scales.

Historical Development

Symmetry Groups and Pre-Quark Models

In the early development of particle physics, isospin symmetry, based on the SU(2) group, emerged as a key concept to describe the approximate degeneracy in masses and strong interaction properties among certain hadrons. Introduced by Werner Heisenberg in 1932, this symmetry treated the proton and neutron as the two components of an isospin doublet (I=1/2), reflecting their nearly identical masses and the charge independence of the strong force. This SU(2) framework was later extended to mesons like pions, forming isospin triplets (I=1), and provided a successful classification for non-strange hadrons before the inclusion of strange particles. In retrospect, this symmetry corresponds to treating the up (u) and down (d) quark flavors as a doublet with similar masses, though pre-quark models viewed it purely as an internal quantum number without substructure. The discovery of particles with unusual production and decay properties in cosmic rays during the late prompted the introduction of a new , strangeness (S), to resolve inconsistencies in selection rules. Proposed by T. Nakano and Kazuhiko Nishijima in 1953, and independently by in 1953, strangeness assigned integer values to hadrons, with non-strange particles (like nucleons and pions) having S=0 and strange particles (like K mesons and Λ s) having S=±1, explaining their associated production in strong interactions while decaying weakly. This led to the formulation of SU(3) flavor symmetry in the 1950s, extending SU(2) to a larger group incorporating strangeness, treating the u, d, and strange (s) flavors on equal footing despite mass differences that made the symmetry approximate. Early SU(3) models, such as the Sakata model, posited fundamental triplets of particles (proton, , and a hyperon like Λ) to build hadrons, but these were phenomenological without deeper dynamical insight. A major advancement came with the "eightfold way," proposed by and in 1961, which systematically classified hadrons into irreducible representations of SU(3). Baryons were organized into an octet (dimension 8) including the doublet (p, n with S=0), the Σ triplet (S=-1), the Λ singlet (S=-1), and the Ξ doublet (S=-2), while mesons formed a similar octet with (π, K, η) and (ρ, K*, ω/φ) members. Decuplets (dimension 10) were also predicted for spin-3/2 baryons, forming symmetric representations with equal spacing in mass due to an assumed linear strangeness dependence, as seen in the Δ (S=0), Σ* (S=-1), and Ξ* (S=-2) resonances. This scheme elegantly unified the growing "" and highlighted patterns in , though it remained a classification tool without explaining underlying dynamics. In 1962, Gell-Mann applied the eightfold way to predict the existence of a new in the decuplet: the Ω⁻ with S=-3, composed conceptually as an state, having spin 3/2, Y=0, I=0, and a mass around 1680 MeV. This particle completed the decuplet and served as a crucial test of SU(3) , as its properties followed directly from without adjustable parameters. The prediction underscored the of the model, distinguishing it from earlier schemes like the Sakata model, which could not accommodate an S=-3 state. Despite these successes, pre-quark symmetry models faced significant challenges, particularly in explaining electromagnetic properties such as magnetic moments. For instance, the Sakata model yielded incorrect predictions for magnetic moments, failing to match experimental values like the proton's μ_p ≈ 2.79 magnetons, which suggested a need for internal structure beyond simple fundamental particles. Additionally, the absence of free fundamental constituents in experiments contradicted expectations from these models, as no isolated "building blocks" like those in the Sakata triplet were observed, hinting at confinement or composite nature without direct evidence. These discrepancies motivated deeper theoretical refinements leading toward subconstituent ideas.

Proposal and Early Evidence

In 1964, and independently proposed the quark model as a framework to classify the growing number of observed hadrons using SU(3) . introduced the term "quarks" in his seminal paper, drawing inspiration from the phrase "Three quarks for Muster Mark!" in James Joyce's novel . Zweig, working at , referred to the same entities as "aces" in his detailed but described an identical structure of triplets. The model posited three types of quarks—up (u), down (d), and strange (s)—each transforming under the (3) representation of SU(3), with hadrons composed of integer combinations of these quarks to form the observed octet and decuplet representations. This proposal provided a mathematical realization of that had been empirically successful but lacked a physical basis, predicting masses and decay patterns with remarkable accuracy for the time. However, quarks were initially viewed by many as mathematical conveniences rather than physical particles, given the failure to observe free quarks and challenges with integer charges in early formulations. Initial experimental support emerged from deep inelastic electron-proton scattering experiments at the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) starting in 1968, conducted by Jerome Friedman, Henry Kendall, and Richard Taylor. These experiments probed the proton's interior at short distances, revealing a structure function that scaled with the Bjorken variable x, indicating scattering off point-like constituents carrying fractions of the proton's momentum and charge. The observed scaling behavior and the inferred fractional charges (approximately +2/3 and -1/3) aligned closely with the quark model's predictions, providing the first compelling evidence for quarks as real, dynamical entities within hadrons. Contemporaneous searches in experiments at accelerators sought direct signatures of free quarks through tracks with anomalous or momentum consistent with fractional , yielding some controversial reports that fueled debate but lacked confirmation. These efforts highlighted the tension between the model's implications and the absence of isolated quarks, later attributed to confinement. A key theoretical refinement strengthening the model came in 1970, when , John Iliopoulos, and Luciano Maiani proposed a fourth "" quark to suppress flavor-changing neutral currents in weak interactions via the . This prediction extended the quark framework to resolve discrepancies between theory and observations in decays, paving the way for the discovery of charmed particles in 1974.

Acceptance and Refinements

The discovery of the J/ψ meson in 1974 provided crucial experimental confirmation of the charm quark, a fourth quark flavor predicted by the model to resolve issues with symmetries. Independent experiments at the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC), led by , and at , led by Samuel Ting, observed the narrow resonance in electron-positron annihilation and proton-beryllium collisions, respectively, with a of approximately 3.1 GeV/c². This finding, which earned Richter and Ting the 1976 , elevated the quark model from a theoretical construct to a cornerstone of , as the J/ψ's properties aligned precisely with a charm-anticharm . The subsequent "November Revolution" marked a period of rapid experimental breakthroughs that solidified the model's predictions for higher generations. Shortly after the J/ψ announcement, the ψ' resonance was identified at SLAC in December 1974, confirming excited charmonium states. By 1977, the discovery of the Υ meson at by Lederman's group revealed the bottom quark through the observation of the Υ meson resonance at around 9.5 GeV/c². These discoveries, occurring in quick succession, demonstrated the quark model's predictive power for heavy flavors and spurred global accelerator programs to probe deeper into the standard model's structure. Theoretical refinements addressed early discrepancies, notably through the introduction of . In 1964, O. W. Greenberg proposed color as an additional for quarks to explain the statistics of identical particles in s, allowing three quarks in a without violating Pauli exclusion. This concept was revived in 1973 amid the development of (QCD), where quarks carry one of three colors (red, green, blue) and gluons mediate the strong force as color-octet bosons, ensuring color neutrality in s. The incorporation of gluons resolved issues with the naive quark model, such as the overcounting of states, and provided a dynamical basis for confinement. The model's completeness was affirmed in 1995 with the discovery of the top quark at Fermilab's collider by the CDF and DØ collaborations. Analyzing proton-antiproton collisions at √s = 1.8 TeV, both teams reported evidence for top-antitop pairs decaying leptonically, with a mass of about 176 GeV/c², fulfilling the six-flavor structure and validating the third generation. Further refinements emerged from (DIS) experiments, which revealed that nucleons contain not only quarks but also a "" of virtual quark-antiquark pairs and s contributing to structure functions. Data from SLAC and in the showed deviations from pure valence quark predictions in the scaling behavior of F₂(x,Q²), necessitating the inclusion of sea quarks (especially strange and heavier flavors) and gluon distributions to account for momentum fractions and evolution under QCD. These insights, quantified through parton distribution functions, enhanced the model's description of nucleon interiors without altering its foundational composite nature.

Mesons

Classification by Quantum Numbers

In the quark model, mesons are classified as bound states of a and an antiquark, with their properties determined by key quantum numbers. The total spin angular momentum S arises from the spins of the quark and antiquark, which are each \frac{1}{2}, yielding S = 0 ( with antiparallel spins) or S = 1 ( with parallel spins). The orbital angular momentum L describes the relative motion between the quark and antiquark, taking non-negative values. The total J then results from vector addition: \mathbf{J} = \mathbf{L} + \mathbf{S}, so J ranges from |L - S| to L + S in steps. Flavor quantum numbers further organize mesons based on the up (u), down (d), and strange () quark content, assuming approximate SU(3) flavor symmetry for the light quarks. Isovector mesons, with isospin I = 1, include charged states like the pion triplet \pi^+ = u\bar{d}, \pi^0 = \frac{u\bar{u} - d\bar{d}}{\sqrt{2}}, and \pi^- = d\bar{u}. Isoscalar mesons have I = 0, such as the eta \eta \approx \frac{u\bar{u} + d\bar{d}}{\sqrt{2}} (with strange admixture). Strange mesons involve the s quark, forming isodoublets like the kaons K^+ = u\bar{s}, K^0 = d\bar{s}, and their antiparticles. Under SU(3) flavor symmetry, the quark-antiquark combinations decompose as $3 \otimes \bar{3} = 8 \oplus 1, leading to nonets (octet plus singlet) for ground-state mesons with L = 0. These include pseudoscalar nonets (J^{PC} = 0^{-+}) comprising \pi, K, and \eta states, and vector nonets (J^{PC} = 1^{--}) with \rho, K^*, and \phi states. Additional quantum numbers include P and C. For quark-antiquark mesons, is given by P = (-1)^{L+1}, reflecting the intrinsic parities of the quark (+1) and antiquark (-1) combined with the orbital factor (-1)^L. Thus, S-wave (L=0) mesons are pseudoscalars (P = -1), while P-wave (L=1) mesons are scalars (P = +1). C applies to neutral mesons composed of a quark and its antiquark, defined as C = (-1)^{L+S}, which determines allowed decay modes; for example, C = -1 for vector mesons like the \rho^0. For non-identical quark flavors, a generalized G-parity G = [C](/page/C) (-1)^I is used, incorporating . Selection rules for meson decays enforce conservation of these quantum numbers under strong, electromagnetic, or weak interactions. Strong decays, dominant for hadrons, conserve J^{PC}, (SU(3) approximately), , and charge conjugation, restricting transitions like J=1 vectors to two pseudoscalars ($0^- + 0^-) via L=1 orbital change. Electromagnetic decays conserve C and (up to small violations), while weak decays allow flavor changes but are suppressed. These rules predict allowed and forbidden channels, such as the electromagnetic decay of \eta \to \gamma\gamma permitted by C = +1.

Spectroscopy and Examples

The quark model successfully predicts the spectrum of ground-state pseudoscalar mesons, which form an SU(3) flavor nonet consisting of the light up (u), down (d), and strange (s) quarks. The isovector pions (π⁺, π⁰, π⁻) have masses around 140 MeV, while the isodoublet kaons (K⁺, K⁰ and their antiparticles) are heavier at approximately 495 MeV due to the larger strange quark mass. The isoscalar states η and η' exhibit mixing between the SU(3) octet and singlet configurations, with masses of 548 MeV and 958 MeV, respectively; this mixing arises from SU(3) flavor symmetry breaking and is significantly influenced by the QCD axial U(1) anomaly, which breaks the U(1)_A symmetry and generates the large η' mass through topological effects. In the vector meson sector (J^{PC} = 1^{--}), the quark model also aligns well with observations, forming another nonet. The ρ meson, composed of u\bar{d} or similar light quark pairs, has a mass of 770 MeV, while the nearly degenerate ω (782 MeV) is primarily (u\bar{u} + d\bar{d})/√2. The φ (1020 MeV) shows ideal mixing close to pure s\bar{s}, with the ω-φ mixing angle θ_V ≈ 36.5° deviating slightly from the ideal value of 35.3° due to small admixtures of light quarks in φ and strange quarks in ω; this pattern validates the quark model's flavor SU(3) assignments and the dominance of the strange quark mass in heavier states. Radial and orbital excitations provide further tests of the model, particularly for higher (L) states. For L=1 (P-wave) excitations, the scalar mesons include the a_0(980) at 980 MeV, interpreted as a nonstrange q\bar{q} state, while the tensor meson f_2(1270) at 1270 MeV fits as an isoscalar with mixed light and strange content; these masses follow the expected increase from spin-orbit and tensor interactions in the quark potential. Heavy quarkonia spectra offer a particularly clean validation, resembling hydrogen-like systems due to the heavy quark masses allowing nonrelativistic approximations. The charmonium J/ψ (c\bar{c}, 1^3S_1 state) has a mass of 3097 MeV, with its partner η_c (1^1S_0) at 2980 MeV; radial excitations like ψ(2S) at 3686 MeV follow the predicted from Coulombic and linear confining potentials. Similarly, bottomonium features the Υ (b\bar{b}, 1^3S_1) at 9460 MeV and η_b (1^1S_0) at 9400 MeV, with the Υ(2S) at 10,023 MeV exhibiting analogous scaling, confirming the quark model's success for bound heavy quark-antiquark pairs where relativistic effects are minimal. The quark model demonstrates strong predictive power through Regge trajectories, where meson masses satisfy linear relations like M^2 ∝ J for excitations, as seen in the ρ trajectory (ρ at J=1, ρ(1450) at J=2, ρ(1700) at J=3) with a universal slope parameter α' ≈ 0.9 GeV^{-2}, reflecting the string-like confinement in QCD. However, deviations occur in the light scalar sector below 1 GeV, where states like f_0(500) (500 MeV), a_0(980), and f_0(980) exhibit masses and broad widths inconsistent with simple q\bar{q} predictions, suggesting contributions from exotic configurations such as tetraquarks or two- molecules rather than pure quark-antiquark bindings.

Baryons

Ground-State Multiplets

In the quark model, the ground-state baryons, which are the lightest three-quark states with total J = 1/2 or $3/2, are organized into irreducible representations of the SU(3) based on the up (u), down (d), and strange (s) s. This classification arises from the decomposition of three quark flavors: $3 \otimes 3 \otimes 3 = 10 \oplus 8 \oplus 8 \oplus 1, where the physical states correspond to the symmetric decuplet (10), two mixed-symmetry octets (8), and an antisymmetric singlet (1), though the singlet is not observed in the . The octet and decuplet multiplets account for all known low-lying baryons with zero orbital (L = 0), providing a successful framework for understanding their quantum numbers and mass patterns prior to the full development of . The spin-$1/2 baryon octet consists of the nucleon doublet (proton p = uud with mass 938 MeV and neutron n = udd with mass 940 MeV), the \Sigma triplet (\Sigma^+ = uus at 1189 MeV, \Sigma^0 = uds at 1193 MeV, \Sigma^- = dds at 1197 MeV), the isosinglet \Lambda (uds at 1116 MeV), and the \Xi doublet (\Xi^0 = uss at 1315 MeV, \Xi^- = dss at 1321 MeV). These particles fit the SU(3) octet representation, characterized by isospin I ranging from 0 to 1 and hypercharge Y = B + S (baryon number B = 1, strangeness S = 0 to -2). The masses satisfy the Gell-Mann–Okubo relation, derived from first-order SU(3) breaking due to the strange quark mass, given by $3M_\Lambda + M_\Sigma = 2(M_N + M_\Xi), which holds to within about 2% using average isomultiplet masses (M_\Sigma \approx 1193 MeV, M_N \approx 939 MeV, M_\Xi \approx 1318 MeV). The octet wave functions exhibit mixed symmetry under quark exchange: for example, the \Lambda flavor state is antisymmetric in the u-d pair to ensure overall antisymmetry when combined with spin and color degrees of freedom, distinguishing it from the symmetric \Sigma^0. The spin-$3/2 decuplet includes the \Delta (\Delta^{++} = uuu at 1232 MeV, \Delta^+ = uud, \Delta^0 = udd, \Delta^- = ddd), the \Sigma^* triplet (\Sigma^{*+} = uus at 1383 MeV, \Sigma^{*0} = uds, \Sigma^{*-} = dds), the \Xi^* doublet (\Xi^{*0} = uss at 1533 MeV, \Xi^{*-} = dss), and the \Omega^- (sss at 1672 MeV). These form the fully symmetric 10 representation, with I = 0 to $3/2 and Y = 1 to -1. The decuplet particles are short-lived resonances that decay strongly, such as \Delta \to N\pi, with widths decreasing from \sim 115 MeV for the \Delta to \sim 1.3 MeV for the \Omega^- due to reduced in heavier states. Their wave functions are totally symmetric, such as the \Delta^{++} being purely uuu. A key success of the model is the prediction of equal mass spacings along the axis, approximately 150 MeV per added , as seen in the progression \Delta to \Sigma^* (151 MeV), \Sigma^* to \Xi^* (150 MeV), and \Xi^* to \Omega^- (139 MeV), which anticipated the discovery of the \Omega^-. These multiplets are visualized in the isospin-hypercharge (I_3-Y) plane, standard for SU(3) representations. The octet appears as a with the nucleon doublet at Y=1, I=1/2; the triplet and at Y=0, I=1 and I=0; and the doublet at Y=-1, I=1/2. The decuplet forms an equilateral triangle with vertices at the I=3/2 (Y=1), I=1/2 \Xi^* (Y=-1), and I=0 \Omega^- (Y=-1), connected by lines of constant .

Excited States and Color Discovery

Baryon resonances represent excited states of baryons, extending the quark model beyond ground states to higher energy levels where quarks exhibit . Notable examples include the N*(1535), classified as S_{11} with quantum numbers J^P = \frac{1}{2}^-, and the Δ*(1600) with J^P = \frac{3}{2}^+. These resonances arise from configurations involving excited quark orbitals, such as the first radial or orbital excitations in the and families. A notable challenge is the "missing resonances" problem, where the quark model predicts more excited states than observed experimentally, with only about half the expected N* and Δ* resonances confirmed. In the quark model, their mass spectra and decay patterns follow Regge trajectories, linear relations between squared mass and spin, akin to those observed in spectroscopy, supporting a string-like quark confinement picture. A key challenge in the early quark model emerged from the Δ^{++} baryon, composed of three identical up quarks (uuu) in a symmetric spin-flavor ground state. Without additional degrees of freedom, this would violate the for identical fermions, as the total wavefunction must be antisymmetric. To resolve this discrepancy, Oscar W. Greenberg proposed in the introduction of a hidden "color" degree of freedom for s, assigning each one of three colors (, , blue) to ensure the total wavefunction remains antisymmetric. For baryons, this allows a fully antisymmetric color described by the wavefunction \frac{1}{\sqrt{6}} \epsilon_{ijk} q^i q^j q^k, where \epsilon_{ijk} is the and q^i denotes quarks of color i, enabling the observed spin-flavor symmetries without Pauli violation. This color concept was further developed in 1973 by Harald Fritzsch, , and Heinrich Leutwyler, who integrated it into a non-Abelian gauge theory based on SU(3)_c, introducing color-octet gluons as mediators of the strong interaction between colored . This framework laid the foundation for (QCD), predicting and . Experimental confirmation of three colors came from electron-positron annihilation data, where the ratio R = \sigma(e^+ e^- \to \mathrm{hadrons}) / \sigma(e^+ e^- \to \mu^+ \mu^-) measured approximately 3 above quark production thresholds, consistent with the sum of squared charges for three colored quark flavors (u, d, s).

Extensions and Predictions

Exotic Hadrons

Exotic hadrons are hadronic states that cannot be accommodated within the conventional quark model framework of mesons as quark-antiquark pairs or baryons as three-quark combinations, instead requiring additional quarks, antiquarks, or gluons. These particles challenge the simple quark model by suggesting more complex binding mechanisms, such as multi-quark clusters or gluonic excitations, and have been increasingly observed since the early 2000s through high-precision experiments at facilities like Belle, , and LHCb. Their study provides insights into the non-perturbative dynamics of beyond the standard quark model predictions. Tetraquarks, composed of four s (e.g., two quarks and two antiquarks), represent one class of exotic mesons, with the X(3872) serving as the archetypal example discovered in 2003 by the Belle Collaboration in the decay B^\pm \to K^\pm J/\psi \pi^+ \pi^-. This state has a mass of approximately 3872 MeV and quantum numbers J^{PC} = 1^{++}, and it is interpreted either as a loosely bound molecule of D^0 \bar{D}^{*0} or a compact c \bar{c} q \bar{q} tetraquark configuration, where c denotes the quark and q a light quark. Subsequent observations by , CDF, D0, and LHCb confirmed its existence, with LHCb measurements refining its width to about 1.2 MeV, supporting its exotic nature through isospin-violating decays. In the 2020s, LHCb has expanded the spectrum of charmed tetraquarks, including the doubly charmed T_{cc}^+(3875) observed in 2021 as a D D \pi with a binding energy near threshold, indicating molecular-like binding, and additional states like Z_c(3900) and Z_c(4020) with charged quantum numbers incompatible with pure q \bar{q}. Pentaquarks, containing four quarks and one antiquark (e.g., qqqq \bar{q}), faced early with the claimed observation of the \Theta^+ (uudd \bar{s}) at 1540 MeV by the LEPS Collaboration in 2003 via the reaction \gamma n \to K^- \Theta^+, but subsequent high-statistics experiments by CLAS, HERMES, and others in 2005–2006 failed to confirm it, leading to its classification as a statistical fluctuation or background artifact by the Particle Data Group. Genuine pentaquarks emerged in 2015 with LHCb's discovery of two hidden-charm states, P_c(4380)^+ and P_c(4450)^+, in \Lambda_b^0 \to J/\psi p K^- decays, with masses around 4380 MeV and 4450 MeV, respectively, and widths of 205 MeV and 39 MeV; these are interpreted as J/\psi p bound states or compact c c u u d pentaquarks with spin-parity assignments J^P = 3/2^- and $5/2^+. LHCb's 2019 update with larger datasets resolved these into three narrower states—P_c(4312)^+, P_c(4440)^+, and P_c(4457)^+—all with significance exceeding 5σ, further supporting molecular or diquark models for their structure. Hybrid mesons, incorporating a quark-antiquark pair excited by gluonic degrees of freedom (q \bar{q} g), exhibit exotic quantum numbers forbidden for conventional mesons, such as J^{PC} = 1^{-+}. The \pi_1(1600) is a prominent light hybrid candidate, observed by the E852 Collaboration at Brookhaven in the 1990s–2000s through diffractive production in \pi^- p \to \eta \pi^- p and f_1(1285) \pi^- p reactions, with a mass of about 1593 MeV, width of 168 MeV, and dominant decay to \eta \pi. Its exotic J^{PC} = 1^{-+} assignment, confirmed by partial-wave analysis, aligns with flux-tube model predictions for gluonic excitations in the quark model, distinguishing it from q \bar{q} states. In the heavy sector, LHCb reported evidence for hybrid states h_c(4000) (mass ~4000 MeV) and h_c(4300) (mass ~4307 MeV) in June 2024, exhibiting quantum numbers suggestive of gluonic excitations in charmonium. Dibaryons, potential six-quark (qqqqqq) states akin to deuteron-like bound systems of two baryons, were theoretically predicted in the within bag model extensions of the quark model. The H-dibaryon, a flavor-singlet (uuddss) state with -2, was proposed by Jaffe in 1977 as potentially stable with a mass below 2Λ (2230 MeV), arising from attractive color-magnetic interactions among the quarks. Despite extensive searches at Brookhaven and yielding no , recent candidates include a Λnn bound state (~3060 MeV) suggested by HypHI analyses of ^6_ΛH decays (e.g., to ^3He p π⁻ and t π⁻) in 2013, with ~2 MeV relative to Λ + d, though debated and not confirmed in later experiments; ongoing analyses in the continue to explore. Lattice QCD simulations suggest the H is unbound by 10–20 MeV at physical quark masses. These developments, combined with RHIC data on strangelet-like correlations, highlight the persistence of dibaryon searches in probing multi-quark clustering. Additionally, in April 2025, discovered the tetraquark T_{c\bar{c}c\bar{c}}(7100) with mass 7173 ± 16 MeV, the first fully charmed tetraquark, challenging models of compact multi-quark states.

Static Properties

The quark model provides successful predictions for the magnetic moments of baryons, particularly through the non-relativistic constituent framework combined with SU(6) spin-flavor symmetry. In this approach, the proton magnetic moment is given by \mu_p = \frac{4\mu_u - \mu_d}{3}, where \mu_u and \mu_d are the quark magnetic moments, respectively, with \mu_q = \frac{e_q}{2m_q} in (nuclear magnetons \mu_N are implicit via the proton mass scale). Assuming equal constituent masses m_u = m_d \approx M_p / 3, the naive prediction yields \mu_p \approx 3 \mu_N, while incorporating small mass differences m_u \neq m_d refines it to approximately $1.87 \mu_N; the observed value is \mu_p \approx 2.79 \mu_N, with further improvement from SU(6) wave functions accounting for spin-flavor correlations that reduce the discrepancy to within 5-10%. Similar predictions hold for the (\mu_n \approx -2 \mu_N) and the \Sigma^0 \to \Lambda transition moment, validating the model's description of and flavor contributions to baryon . Charge radii and electromagnetic form factors of hadrons, probed via electron scattering, align well with quark model distributions of constituent quarks. The proton charge radius, extracted from the dipole form factor G_E(Q^2) \approx (1 + Q^2 / (6 \langle r^2 \rangle))^{-2}, matches model expectations of \langle r^2 \rangle_p^{1/2} \approx 0.84 fm when assuming a spatial wave function with quark separations scaled by the confinement size; neutron data, despite zero net charge, reveal a non-zero \langle r^2 \rangle_n^{1/2} \approx 0.34 fm from the magnetic form factor slope, consistent with the model's up-down quark charge asymmetry. For mesons like the pion, the model predicts a charge radius \langle r^2 \rangle_\pi^{1/2} \approx 0.66 fm from quark-antiquark overlap, reproducing electron scattering cross sections at low Q^2. These agreements confirm the quark model's validity for static charge distributions without invoking relativistic effects for light hadrons. Mass formulas in the additive quark model treat hadron masses as sums of constituent quark masses plus a constant binding term, with refinements for flavor symmetry breaking. For mesons, the relation M \approx 2m_q + \mathrm{const.} holds approximately, as seen in the pseudoscalar octet where m_\pi \approx 2m_u + c and m_K \approx m_u + m_s + c, capturing the mass m_s \approx 150 MeV above the up/down value; vector mesons follow similarly, with deviations under 10%. Baryon masses incorporate pairwise interactions, but the Coleman-Glashow relations for electromagnetic mass differences—m_n - m_p = m_{\Sigma^-} - m_{\Sigma^0} = m_{\Xi^-} - m_{\Xi^0}—emerge naturally in the SU(3) limit with m_u = m_d, predicting shifts of order 5 MeV that match observations to within 1 MeV after QCD spin-spin corrections. These formulas succeed for heavy-light systems but require adjustments for light hadrons. Hyperfine splittings between spin-singlet and triplet states provide key tests of the model's chromomagnetic interactions. For charmonium, the ground-state splitting is \Delta M = M_{J/\psi} - M_{\eta_c} = \frac{8}{3} \frac{\alpha_s}{m_c^2} |\psi(0)|^2, where \alpha_s is the strong coupling and |\psi(0)|^2 is the wave function at the origin; using m_c \approx 1.5 GeV and perturbative \alpha_s \approx 0.3, this yields \Delta M \approx 117 MeV, closely matching the observed 113 MeV and validating the non-relativistic potential for heavy quarks. In light baryons, analogous chromomagnetic terms explain the \Delta - N splitting of 294 MeV via \Delta M \propto \langle \vec{\sigma}_i \cdot \vec{\sigma}_j \rangle / m_q^2, though with larger corrections from confinement. Overall, the additive quark model excels in predicting these static properties for ordinary hadrons, with successes in scaling behaviors and symmetry relations, but incorporates tweaks like relativistic corrections and color factors for light systems where binding effects amplify deviations up to 20%.

Relation to Quantum Chromodynamics

From Model to Theory

The quark model serves as an effective theory that approximates (QCD) at low energies, particularly on the scale of hadronic bound states around 1 GeV, where quark and antiquark interactions dominate the structure of mesons and baryons. In this regime, the model captures phenomenological aspects of hadron spectroscopy and symmetries without requiring the full non-perturbative dynamics of QCD, treating quarks as constituents bound by an effective potential that mimics confinement. The underlying theory, QCD, is described by its Lagrangian density, which governs the interactions of quarks and gluons through the strong force: \mathcal{L}_\text{QCD} = \bar{q} (i \gamma^\mu D_\mu - m) q - \frac{1}{4} G^a_{\mu\nu} G^{a \mu\nu}, where q represents the quark fields, m is the , D_\mu = \partial_\mu - i g_s (\lambda^a / 2) A^a_\mu is the incorporating the strong coupling g_s and gluon fields A^a_\mu (with \lambda^a as the ), and G^a_{\mu\nu} is the . This gauge-invariant formulation based on SU(3) color symmetry provides a perturbative framework at high energies but necessitates methods at low energies to connect to the quark model's predictions. Lattice QCD simulations, which discretize spacetime to compute QCD path integrals non-perturbatively, have confirmed key patterns from the model, such as the ordering and splittings in mass spectra for light . For instance, these computations reproduce the masses of ground-state mesons and baryons with accuracies approaching experimental values when including dynamical effects, validating the model's success in describing color-neutral bound states without free . Intermediate models like the Nambu–Jona-Lasinio (NJL) model and the bag model act as bridges between the phenomenological quark model and full QCD by incorporating essential non-perturbative features such as and confinement. The NJL model, an effective four-fermion interaction theory, dynamically generates constituent quark masses from QCD-like interactions, aligning with the quark model's mass hierarchies while respecting global symmetries. Similarly, the bag model confines quarks within a finite spherical enforced by conditions, effectively introducing a linear confinement potential that rises with interquark separation, thereby explaining hadron sizes and stability in a relativistic . The validity of the quark model aligns with the flow of the strong \alpha_s, which is of order 1 at quark mass scales relevant to hadrons (around 300–500 MeV for light ), where effects prevail and the model provides a good approximation. At higher energies, \alpha_s decreases asymptotically due to the , transitioning to perturbative QCD where and degrees of freedom become explicit, and the model gives way to more fundamental descriptions.

Limitations and Validity

The naive quark model encounters significant breakdowns in describing certain light scalar mesons, such as the f₀(500) (also known as the σ), which exhibits a broad width and decay patterns inconsistent with a simple quark-antiquark (q\bar{q}) . This , with a around 500 MeV, fails to fit into expected SU(3) flavor multiplets for conventional mesons and requires alternative interpretations, including tetraquark states or mixtures involving glueballs—pure gluonic excitations without valence quarks. Similar issues arise for other low-mass scalars like the f₀(980) and a₀(980), where four-quark or molecular structures better account for their proximity to kaon-antikaon thresholds and enhanced couplings. Chiral symmetry breaking in quantum chromodynamics (QCD) further highlights limitations of the naive model, as it cannot fully capture the emergence of nearly massless Goldstone bosons like the pions without incorporating non-perturbative vacuum effects. In the chiral limit of massless quarks, spontaneous breaking of the approximate SU(2)_L × SU(2)_R symmetry generates a quark-antiquark condensate ⟨\bar{q}q⟩ in the QCD vacuum, which serves as the order parameter and endows pions with their pseudo-Goldstone nature. The pion mass arises primarily from explicit symmetry breaking by small current quark masses, as quantified by the Gell-Mann–Oakes–Renner relation: m_π² f_π² = -(m_u + m_d) ⟨\bar{q}q⟩, where f_π ≈ 93 MeV is the pion decay constant. This condensate, with magnitude around (250 MeV)^3, reflects strong non-perturbative dynamics absent in the basic quark model. For heavier quarks, the model's validity improves through extensions like heavy quark effective theory (HQET), which treats charm (c) and bottom (b) quarks as nearly static sources due to their large masses (m_c ≈ 1.3 GeV, m_b ≈ 4.2 GeV). In the infinite heavy-quark-mass limit, HQET reveals an emergent spin-flavor symmetry, predicting mass degeneracies within doublets of mesons sharing the same light-quark angular momentum but differing in total spin—for instance, equal masses for the pseudoscalar D (J^P = 0^-) and vector D^* (1^-) states, up to 1/m_Q corrections, with observed splittings of about 140 MeV for both D and B doublets. This symmetry enhances predictive power for heavy-light spectroscopy, where the naive model alone underperforms due to relativistic effects on lighter constituents. The quark model remains a reliable phenomenological tool for hadron spectroscopy in the regime above approximately 1 GeV, where perturbative QCD contributions dominate and excited-state patterns align well with constituent quark assignments, as seen in charmonium and bottomonium spectra. However, it falters for low-lying states below this threshold, where effects like confinement and multi-quark admixtures distort simple q\bar{q} or qqq pictures, leading to deviations in masses and widths for scalars and some resonances. Recent advances in during the 2020s have refined this scope by providing ab initio calculations of masses and resonances with sub-percent precision, confirming quark-model successes for higher excitations while quantifying corrections for lighter states through methods like the Lüscher formalism for and HAL QCD potentials. Tensions in precision tests, such as the muon's anomalous (g-2)_μ, underscore the model's approximate nature by revealing sensitivities to QCD effects beyond its framework. The final experimental value from the experiment, as of June 2025, is a_μ^exp = 1165920705(147) × 10^{-11}, which agrees with the updated prediction within approximately 0.3σ. This resolution of the previous ~4.2σ tension relied on refined non-perturbative QCD calculations, particularly for the dominant hadronic (HVP) contribution, highlighting the need for accurate inputs that the quark model approximates but does not fully capture. These developments affirm the importance of full QCD for electroweak precision observables, limiting the model's standalone applicability.

References

  1. [1]
    [PDF] 15. Quark Model - Particle Data Group
    Aug 11, 2022 · The quark model exists on many levels: at the simplest level, it is an almost dynamics-free picture of strongly interacting particles as bound ...
  2. [2]
    [PDF] Gell-Mann.pdf
    Complete symmetry among the members of the triplet gives the exact eightfold way, while a mass difference, for example, between the isotopic dou- blet and ...
  3. [3]
    [PDF] An introduction to the quark model arXiv:1205.4326v2 [hep-ph] 24 ...
    May 24, 2012 · Abstract. This document contains a review on the quark model, prepared for lectures at the. Niccolò Cabeo School at Ferrara in May 2012.
  4. [4]
    [PDF] 15. Quark Model - Particle Data Group
    May 31, 2024 · Quarks come in six flavors. We describe the properties of mesons as ¯qq systems and baryons as qqq systems. Along the way we discuss hadronic ...
  5. [5]
    [PDF] On the history of the strong interaction - arXiv
    Nov 28, 2012 · Immediately thereafter,. Heisenberg introduced the notion of isospin as a symmetry of the strong in- teraction, in order to explain why proton ...Missing: pre- | Show results with:pre-
  6. [6]
    [PDF] arXiv:1309.0517v2 [hep-ph] 14 Jan 2014
    Jan 14, 2014 · Iz and SU(3) weight diagrams for the light baryon multiplets. The quark model explained Iz in terms of the u and d quarks [Eq. (9)], and S in ...
  7. [7]
    [PDF] Eightfold Way, Discovery of Ω- Quark Model - UF Physics
    However, the model was giving completely wrong magnetic moments and not allowed for a baryon with S=-3. The latter was in dramatic difference with the Eightfold ...Missing: pre- | Show results with:pre-
  8. [8]
    A Schematic Model of Baryons and Mesons - Inspire HEP
    A Schematic Model of Baryons and Mesons. Murray Gell-Mann(. Caltech. ) 1964.
  9. [9]
    https://cds.cern.ch/record/570209
  10. [10]
    Nineteen sixty-four - CERN Courier
    Sep 9, 2025 · ... Gell-Mann's SU(3) symmetry scheme, dubbed “the Eightfold Way”. But Gell-Mann summarily dismissed his suggestion, showing him on a napkin how ...Missing: flavor original
  11. [11]
    [PDF] The Discovery of Quarks* - SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory
    First proposed in 1964 by Gell-Mann (1) and Zweig (2), these p$'fticles had to have electrical charges equal to l/3 or 2/3 that of an electron or proton.
  12. [12]
    50 years of the GIM mechanism - CERN Courier
    Jan 24, 2020 · The GIM mechanism was the solution to a problem arising in the simplest weak interaction theory with one charged vector boson coupled to the Cabibbo currents.
  13. [13]
    https://pdg.lbl.gov/2024/listings/rpp2024-list-upsilon.pdf
  14. [14]
    [hep-ex/9503003] Observation of the Top Quark - arXiv
    Mar 3, 1995 · Abstract: The DO collaboration reports on a search for the Standard Model top quark in pbar-p collisions at Sqrt(s)=1.8TeV at the Fermilab ...Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
  15. [15]
    [PDF] 18. Structure Functions - Particle Data Group
    Dec 1, 2023 · 18.1 Deep inelastic scattering​​ High-energy lepton-nucleon scattering plays a key role in determining the partonic structure of the proton. The ...
  16. [16]
    [PDF] CERN-TH-412.pdf
    unitary symmetry breaking is universal, it is the same for mesons as baryons, it is identical for octets and decuplets. This accounts for roughly the same mass ...
  17. [17]
    [PDF] 63. Spectroscopy of Light Meson Resonances - Particle Data Group
    Dec 1, 2023 · In the present text we describe the experimental spectrum of light mesons and their classifications within the constituent quark model, with ...
  18. [18]
    [PDF] The $\eta - arXiv
    Jun 16, 2025 · It has long been realized that the η-η′ mixing is caused by the axial U(1)A anomaly [13], i.e. the SU(3) break- ing effects that are sizable and ...
  19. [19]
    Bottomonium spectrum revisited | Phys. Rev. D
    Apr 20, 2016 · We revisit the bottomonium spectrum motivated by the recently exciting experimental progress in the observation of new bottomonium states, both conventional ...Missing: paper | Show results with:paper
  20. [20]
    Mass spectra and Regge trajectories of light mesons in the ...
    Jun 24, 2009 · Here we investigate the Regge trajectories both in the ( M 2 , J ) and ( M 2 , n r ) planes ( M is the mass, J is the spin, and n r ...
  21. [21]
    [PDF] Symmetries of Baryons and Mesons - ufrgs
    FEBRUARY 1, 1962. Symmetries of Baryons and Mesons*. MURRAY GELL—MANN ... and by Gell-Mann and I evy in reference 17 for the "a meson. " Page 17. SYM ...
  22. [22]
    [PDF] Note on Unitary Symmetry in Strong Interactions - SciSpace
    The purpose cif this note is to investigate consequences of the three-dimen- sional unitary group (denoted as U3 hereafter), which is a certain ...
  23. [23]
    [PDF] 81. N and ∆ Resonances - Particle Data Group
    Dec 1, 2023 · Only resonances with an overall status of ∗∗∗ or ∗∗∗∗ are included in the main Baryon Summary Table.<|separator|>
  24. [24]
    [1707.05650] Regge trajectories of Excited Baryons, quark-diquark ...
    Jul 18, 2017 · We analyze the radial (n) and angular-momentum (J) Regge trajectories for all light-quark states with baryon number one listed in the 2016 ...
  25. [25]
    [PDF] The Delta: The First Pion Nucleon Resonance - OSTI.gov
    constituent particles, or quarks. Our friend, the delta, posed a puzzle for the scheme, in that the. A* particle was to be made of three u quarks, all with ...
  26. [26]
    [PDF] 9. QUANTUM CHROMODYNAMICS - Particle Data Group
    Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), the gauge field theory that describes the strong interactions of colored quarks and gluons, is the SU(3) component of the. SU(3)× ...
  27. [27]
    [PDF] 79. Heavy Non-qq Mesons - Particle Data Group
    May 31, 2024 · The review is split into 3 parts, discussing separately heavy–light systems, heavy–heavy sys- tems, as well as systems with more than two heavy ...
  28. [28]
    [1606.08593] Exotic hadrons: review and perspectives - arXiv
    Jun 28, 2016 · This paper reviews the physics of exotic hadrons, focusing on uninvestigated flavor configurations and the constituent quark model of ...
  29. [29]
    https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-non-qqbar-mesons.pdf
  30. [30]
    https://arxiv.org/abs/1606.08593
  31. [31]
    https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.91.262001
  32. [32]
    https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.102.092005
  33. [33]
    [PDF] 15. Quark Model - Particle Data Group
    Dec 1, 2021 · These ingredients provide the basic mechanisms that determine the hadron spectrum in the stan- dard quark model. 15.8 Lattice Calculations of ...
  34. [34]
    Systematics of strong interaction radii for hadrons - ScienceDirect.com
    A quark model with constituent quarks accounts for the absolute values as well as the flavour dependence of the radii if one attributes a mean squared radius ...
  35. [35]
    Effective quark models in QCD at low and intermediate energies
    The effective quark models are employed to describe the hadronization of QCD in the quark sector. They reveal a different structure depending on how the ...Missing: GeV | Show results with:GeV
  36. [36]
    [PDF] 9. Quantum Chromodynamics - Particle Data Group
    Dec 1, 2021 · It is sensitive to the relative fractions of quark and gluon jets in an inclusive jet sample and receives contributions from soft-gluon initial- ...
  37. [37]
    Remnants of quark model in lattice QCD simulation in the Coulomb ...
    Jul 27, 2022 · The paper studies the relation between QCD and quark model using lattice QCD simulations, finding that static quark-antiquark potential is ...
  38. [38]
    [PDF] 15. QUARK MODEL - Particle Data Group
    Feb 8, 2016 · More recently, a lattice QCD simulation, Ref. 6, has successfully reproduced the masses of the η and η′, and as a byproduct find a mixing angle ...
  39. [39]
    The Nambu-Jona-Lasinio model of quantum chromodynamics
    The Nambu—Jona-Lasinio model is reviewed in its flavor SU(2) and SU(3) versions applied to quarks. The dynamical generation of quark masses is demonstrated ...
  40. [40]
    [PDF] αs(2019) – Precision measurements of the QCD coupling
    renormalization because the explicit factors of the quark mass. The ... renormalization group (RG) improvement to αV (q), i.e., we use the next-to ...
  41. [41]
    [PDF] 78. Non-qq Mesons - Particle Data Group
    Jun 1, 2020 · with a model in which the f0(500) and f0(980) are tetraquarks. They also extract an upper limit for the mixing angle of 17o between the f0 ...Missing: bar | Show results with:bar
  42. [42]
    https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.13299
  43. [43]
    [PDF] 5. Chiral Symmetry Breaking - DAMTP
    This, of course, is the pattern of chiral symmetry breaking (5.5) that arises from the quark condensate. ... pion is a Goldstone boson for broken chiral symmetry.
  44. [44]
    None
    ### Summary on HQET for Heavy Quarks c, b, and Prediction of Equal Masses for D and B Doublets
  45. [45]
    https://indico.cern.ch/event/746380/attachments/1776946/3080776/alphas_2019_proceeds_July_1st.pdf
  46. [46]
    [PDF] 15. Quark Model - Particle Data Group
    Dec 1, 2023 · The very short lifetime of the t quark (→ W+b) makes it likely that bound-state hadrons containing t quarks and/or antiquarks do not exist.
  47. [47]
    [2505.10002] Lattice QCD calculations of hadron spectroscopy - arXiv
    May 15, 2025 · This chapter provides a pedagogical introduction to theoretical studies of hadrons based on the fundamental theory of strong interactions - Quantum ...Missing: improvements 2020s
  48. [48]
    https://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/tong/gaugetheory/5chisb.pdf
  49. [49]
    https://pdg.lbl.gov/2023/reviews/rpp2023-rev-heavy-quark-eff-th.pdf