Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Al-Qalam

Al-Qalam (Arabic: القلم, al-qalam, lit. "The Pen") is the sixty-eighth chapter (sūrah) of the Quran, comprising 52 verses (āyāt) divided into two sections (rukūʿ). Revealed primarily in Mecca during the early phase of Muhammad's prophethood, it is traditionally regarded as the second surah disclosed after Sūrat al-ʿAlaq, addressing initial opposition to the prophetic message. The opens with an oath by and what it inscribes, a reference interpreted as affirming the sanctity of and divine , followed by a direct to accusations labeling as possessed or mad, instead praising his exemplary moral character (maʿmūn). It transitions to admonitions against disbelievers, employing the of a prosperous whose arrogant owners neglected and , resulting in its destruction as a cautionary exemplar of divine for and denial of truth. Central themes include exhortations to patience for the amid , critiques of materialistic denial, and assurances of ultimate accountability on the Day of Judgment, underscoring causal consequences of human actions in Islamic theology. While some exegetes debate minor portions (verses 17–33 and 48–50) as potentially Medinan due to contextual allusions, the surah's core Meccan orientation emphasizes monotheistic proclamation and moral integrity over political consolidation.

Overview and Placement

Summary of Content


Al-Qalam (Arabic: القلم, "The Pen") is the 68th surah of the Quran, consisting of 52 verses revealed in Mecca during a phase of heightened opposition to Muhammad. The chapter addresses accusations of insanity against the Prophet, validates his prophethood through divine affirmation, and delivers moral admonitions via a parable of divine retribution for ingratitude. It employs rhetorical oaths, contrasts between the righteous and wicked, and eschatological warnings to underscore accountability.
The commences with the disjointed letter "Nun" and an oath "By the pen and what they inscribe" (68:1), followed by declarations exonerating the from madness, promising him an enduring reward, and attesting to his morals (68:2-4). Verses 5-16 defend Muhammad's against detractors, portraying the latter as misguided and destined for , while urging the to disregard their slander and remain patient. A central in verses 17-33 recounts owners of a fertile who vowed to harvest its fruits secretly at dawn to exclude the needy; their plot was divinely thwarted by overnight destruction, serving as a cautionary exemplar akin to past punished nations. Verses 34-52 delineate rewards of paradise for the God-fearing versus chains and humiliation for criminals on , rejecting notions that disbelievers escape consequence merely by worldly respite. The surah reassures the of 's knowledge of truth-concealers, depicts mockers as poet-inspired deviants, and concludes by affirming that only discerns the misguided from guided, emphasizing amid rejection. This progression from personal vindication to communal and universal judgment forms a cohesive exhortation against arrogance and disbelief.

Position and Structure in the Quran

Al-Qalam is the 68th in the standard compilation of the , positioned immediately after and before Surah Al-Haqqah. It consists of 52 verses (ayat), making it a relatively short chapter within the Quranic corpus. Classified as a Makki surah, Al-Qalam was revealed in during the early phase of Muhammad's prophethood, prior to the in 622 CE. Scholarly traditions, including those attributed to , rank it as the second in chronological order of revelation, underscoring its primacy among the initial Meccan disclosures. The surah's structure features an opening with the muqatta'at letter "Nūn" (ن), followed by an oath invoking and what is inscribed, which sets a thematic foundation for subsequent affirmations of prophetic integrity and moral exhortations. In traditional Quranic recitation, Al-Qalam divides into two (sections), facilitating its liturgical use: the first encompassing the oath, defense of the , and critique of disbelievers' character; the second presenting the of the garden owners and concluding with warnings of . This bipartite form aligns with broader patterns in Makki surahs, emphasizing rhetorical oaths and narrative parables to address Meccan opposition.

Revelation Context

Period of Revelation

Surah Al-Qalam (Quran 68) is classified as a , revealed during the initial years of Muhammad's prophethood in , prior to the in 622 CE. Traditional Islamic scholarship, including reports attributed to , positions it as one of the earliest revelations, potentially the second surah after (Quran 96), following the commencement of revelation around 610 CE. This early timing aligns with the surah's focus on defending the Prophet's character against nascent accusations of madness and poetry, reflecting the onset of opposition rather than later organized persecution. The surah's content provides internal evidence for its Meccan origin, emphasizing monotheistic proclamation, refutation of polytheistic mockery, and warnings of —hallmarks of pre-Hijrah revelations aimed at converting Meccan elites amid growing hostility but before mass emigration to (circa 615 ). Sayyid Abul Ala Maududi, in his Tafhim al-Qur'an, notes that while it ranks among the earliest Makkan surahs, the intensity of described opposition suggests when antagonism had escalated to tyrannical levels, likely within the first three to five years of the mission (610–615 ). A minority scholarly view, based on (occasions of revelation) traditions, posits that verses 17–33 (the of the garden owners) and 48–50 may have been revealed in , as they reference events or themes more resonant with later Madinan contexts, such as agricultural metaphors tied to settled communities. However, the predominant consensus among exegetes, including those compiling chronological orders like those in documentation, affirms the surah's core as Meccan, with any Medinan interpolations not altering its primary early Makkan attribution. This classification underscores the surah's role in the foundational phase of Quranic disclosure, prioritizing moral admonition over legal codification typical of Madinan surahs.

Asbab al-Nuzul and Historical Events

Surah Al-Qalam was revealed during the early Meccan period of the Muhammad's mission, roughly 610–613 CE, shortly after the initial private preaching phase when public proclamation began and faced immediate hostility from leaders. This timing aligns with the surah's defensive tone against emerging slanders, as opposition intensified without yet reaching the organized boycotts or tortures of later years. The opening verses (68:1–7) address accusations that the was majnun (mad or possessed by ), a common pagan retort to his monotheistic message disrupting Meccan and commerce. Classical exegeses, drawing from prophetic traditions, link this to figures like al-Walid ibn al-Mughira and (), who publicly mocked Muhammad's revelations as poetic madness or sorcery to discredit him among tribes. No single pins the entire to one incident, but the rebuttal reflects causal pressures: disbelievers' refusal to heed warnings stemmed from economic stakes in the and fear of social upheaval, prompting divine affirmation of the 's integrity to sustain his resolve. Verses 8–16 depict an archetypal slanderer—"one who habitually swears, is abusive, and transgressive"—traditionally identified in tafsirs like Ibn Kathir's as al-Walid ibn al-Mughira, a wealthy Qurayshite with influential sons who swore oaths to vilify the while boasting his lineage and riches. Al-Walid's historical role involved initial ambivalence toward —he once praised the Quran's eloquence but yielded to tribal pressure—before aligning with persecutors, exemplifying how elite self-interest fueled rejection. This portrayal warns of divine reversal for such figures, grounded in reports of al-Walid's eventual death in the (624 CE), though the verses predate that event. The of the owners (68:17–33) lacks a corroborated specific occasion in authentic narrations, functioning as a general admonition against miserly arrogance akin to Quraysh hoarding. Some exegetes speculate ties to Ta'if's orchards or Meccan incidents of denied , but these remain interpretive without strong chains, emphasizing instead timeless causality: ingratitude invites calamity, as seen in pre-Islamic famines or the later destruction of Quraysh power. Closing verses (68:48–52) urge patience amid plots to "drive him away" through whispers and diversions, reflecting documented Meccan tactics like assigning guards to monitor and provoke the during circumambulations, countered by his protected status. This historical friction—Quraysh's incremental escalation from ridicule to isolation—underscores the surah's role in bolstering early believers against despair.

Textual Breakdown

Opening Oath: Nun and the Pen

Surah Al-Qalam opens with the disjointed letter Nūn (ن), followed by a divine oath: "By the pen and what they inscribe" (Arabic: ن ۚ وَالْقَلَمِ وَمَا يَسْطُرُونَ). This verse, the first of the surah, belongs to the category of ḥurūf muqaṭṭaʿāt (disjointed letters), mysterious alphabetic symbols appearing at the beginning of 29 Quranic surahs, whose full significance is considered known only to Allah according to classical exegetes like Ibn Kathir. Alternative interpretations in some early traditions propose Nūn as referring to a cosmic whale supporting the earth or an inkwell, but these are not emphasized in mainstream tafsir, which aligns it with letters like Sād or Qāf as divine mysteries defying human comprehension. The oath "by " (al-qalam) symbolizes the primordial instrument of divine and , evoking the recording of human destinies by angelic scribes as described elsewhere in the Quran (e.g., Al-Infitar 82:10-12). Ibn Kathir interprets this swearing as affirming the Prophet Muhammad's greatness, countering Meccan accusations of by highlighting the pen's role in inscribing truth and . The phrase "and what they inscribe" extends the oath to the written records of deeds, emphasizing accountability and the permanence of in Islamic theology. Subsequent verses (2-4) directly rebut claims of prophetic madness: "You are not, by the favor of your Lord, a madman. And indeed, for you is a reward uninterrupted. And indeed, you are of a great moral character" (translations adapted from Sahih International). This sequence links the oath to a defense of Muhammad's sanity and integrity, revealed amid early Makkan persecution around 615 CE, when opponents like Al-Walid ibn al-Mughira dismissed revelations as poetic frenzy. The "uninterrupted reward" (ajr ghayr mamnūn) denotes an eternal, ungrudging recompense in the afterlife, underscoring divine favor independent of human gratitude. The affirmation of "great moral character" (ḥusn al-khuluq) aligns with hadith narrations praising the Prophet's pre-Islamic virtues, positioning the oath as both epistemological (knowledge via writing) and ethical validation.

Defense of Prophethood and Character

The opening verses following the oath by Nun and the pen explicitly rebut accusations leveled against Muhammad by the Quraysh disbelievers, who dismissed him as majnun (mad or possessed) due to his delivery of revelations. Quran 68:2 declares, "You are not, [O Muhammad], by the favor of your Lord, a madman," emphasizing that his prophethood stems from divine grace rather than insanity or fabrication. This affirmation counters claims that his utterances were symptoms of possession or poetic frenzy, a common Meccan objection during the early phase of revelation around 610-615 CE. Verse 68:4 further bolsters this defense by attesting to Muhammad's exemplary character: "And indeed, you are of a great moral character" (wa-innaka la-'ala khuluqin 'azim). Traditional exegeses interpret this as divine endorsement of his integrity, honesty, and ethical conduct, qualities observed even by pre-Islamic adversaries who nicknamed him al-Amin (the trustworthy) prior to prophethood. Ibn Kathir's tafsir links this to the Prophet's lifelong reputation for truthfulness, arguing it serves as empirical proof against charges of deceit, as no individual of such established probity would invent revelations under scrutiny. The verse underscores that moral excellence is inseparable from authentic prophethood, distinguishing Muhammad from false claimants whose personal flaws often undermine their assertions. This character defense extends implicitly to prophethood's veracity in verses 3 and 5-7, promising Muhammad an "uninterrupted reward" (68:3) for his steadfastness and warning against yielding to deniers, as God discerns the misguided from the guided. Such assurances reinforce causal realism in divine selection: prophets are chosen for their alignment with truth, not human flaws, with historical accounts noting Muhammad's pre-revelation life free of vices like idolatry or usury, further evidencing the claim. Exegetes like those in Tafsir al-Tabari view these verses as a holistic rebuttal, integrating sanity, ethics, and eschatological accountability to affirm prophethood amid opposition.

Parable of the Garden Owners

The Parable of the Garden Owners, spanning verses 17–33 of Surah Al-Qalam, illustrates against ingratitude and avarice through the account of prosperous individuals who owned a lush, fruit-bearing but conspired to harvest it covertly to evade sharing with the destitute. The narrative begins with stating that the Meccan disbelievers were tested similarly to these garden owners, who swore an to gather the 's at dawn without exception, omitting to mention in their scheme—a lapse signaling their and disregard for . This plot stemmed from habitual stinginess, as their late father had customarily allocated a portion of the harvest for , but his heirs neglected this practice after his death. A calamity befell the garden overnight, divinely ordained as a : a storm of ruinous winds and fire encircled and scorched it, reducing the abundant fruits to barren remains by morning. Upon arrival, the owners initially mistook the devastation for an enhanced bloom, only to confront the total destruction, lamenting their failure to heed God's command for and . One among them urged reflection on their omission of invoking 's name and their resolve to deny the needy their due, prompting collective remorse and an appeal for , though the underscores the irreversibility of such willful . The episode culminates in a affirming that does not treat the righteous equivalently to the wicked, reinforcing the of amid prosperity. Classical exegeses, such as those by , interpret the garden as a real historical incident, possibly located in regions like or among pre-Islamic , where the owners' avarice mirrored the Quraysh's rejection of prophetic warnings despite evident blessings. The father's prior generosity—diverting yields for the poor while reinvesting in the garden—contrasts sharply with the sons' plot, highlighting how inherited without ethical restraint invites perdition. Maududi's analysis frames it as an for the Meccans' peril: just as the garden's destruction nullified their self-sufficient scheming, Mecca's eventual would expose the futility of opposing . The parable emphasizes causal consequences of neglecting and , portraying deprivation not as arbitrary but as a direct outcome of defying divine ordinances on distribution. Narrations in traditions, while varying in specifics like the garden's exact locale, consistently stress the lesson's universality: prosperity demands recognition of its Giver, lest it turn to ruin.

Verse of the Evil Eye

Quran 68:51 states: Wa-in yakādu alladhīna kafarū la-yuz'likūnaka bi-absārihim lammā samiʿū al-dhik'ra wa yaqūlūna innahu la-maj'nūnun, translated as "And indeed, those who disbelieve would almost make you slip with their eyes when they hear , and they say, 'Indeed, he is mad.'" This verse concludes the surah's rebuke of Meccan opponents, highlighting their visceral toward Muhammad's message, manifested through intense glares that nearly destabilize him spiritually or physically. Classical exegeses, such as , interpret "make you slip with their eyes" (yuzliqūnaka bi-absārihim) as evidence of the 's (al-'ayn) tangible effects, where envy-driven gazes inflict harm by Allah's permission. cites hadiths, including the Muhammad's statement, "The is real and if anything were to overtake the divine decree, it would be the ," to affirm its reality, drawing from pre-Islamic Arab beliefs validated by . The disbelievers' stares, fueled by over the 's success and divine favor, exemplify hasad () leading to al-'ayn, potentially causing misfortune without physical contact. In prophetic traditions, this verse is invoked for ruqyah (exorcism-like recitation) against affliction, with scholars recommending its recitation alongside surahs like and An-Nas for protection. For instance, a hadith in narrates the instructing the afflicted to seek washing from the envier, underscoring causal links between gaze, intent, and harm, though always subordinate to divine will. elaborates that the polytheists' eyes conveyed murderous intent, nearly "throwing down" the , but divine safeguarding prevailed, reinforcing the verse's role in affirming prophethood amid . The verse's emphasis on auditory reception of "the reminder" (al-dhikr, the ) ties hostility to truth-rejection, with the accusation of (majnun) reflecting psychological denial rather than empirical assessment. While Islamic sources uniformly uphold the evil eye's veracity based on this and supporting narrations, empirical validation remains within faith-based frameworks, as no modern corroborates gaze-induced harm independent of psychological or effects. Nonetheless, its persists in Muslim practice for spiritual fortification, as evidenced by traditions from companions like , who linked it to specific Meccan incidents of toward early converts.

Core Themes and Messages

Rebuttal of Disbeliever Objections

The directly counters the primary objection from Meccan disbelievers that Muhammad was majnun (insane or possessed), a charge rooted in their rejection of revelations perceived as disruptive to social norms. Verse 2 declares, "You are not, by the grace of your Lord, a madman," framing the as unfounded and divinely refuted, with the preceding by the pen (verse 1) invoked as evidence of coherent, inscribed divine wisdom rather than erratic delusion. Classical exegeses attribute this slur to figures like Al-Walid ibn al-Mughirah, who mocked the Prophet's warnings as symptoms of madness to discredit his message among tribes. Verses 3–4 extend the rebuttal by affirming an "uninterrupted reward" and the Prophet's "great moral character," directly challenging insinuations of moral defect or self-interest in his proclamation. This attestation, drawn from divine knowledge, contrasts sharply with disbeliever portrayals of him as a fabricator or opportunist, emphasizing instead his pre-revelation reputation for trustworthiness (al-Amin) among Meccans, which they could not substantively dispute. Ibn Kathir notes that such verses serve to bolster the Prophet's resolve while exposing the accusers' envy-driven motives, as no empirical evidence of insanity—such as incoherent speech or erratic behavior—was ever documented in his 23-year mission. The of the arrogant garden owners (verses 17–33) implicitly rebuts disbeliever complacency and denial of , portraying their worldly self-sufficiency as illusory akin to the owners' fateful decision to exclude the needy and harvest prematurely. Exegetes interpret this as a targeted admonition to elites like Abu Jahl, whose economic dominance fostered and mockery of , warning that ingratitude invites sudden reversal, as evidenced by the garden's overnight destruction. The narrative's causal logic—arrogance begetting vulnerability—undermines their objection that prophetic warnings lack consequence, paralleling historical precedents of punished nations without invoking unverifiable . Verse 51 addresses physical intimidation tactics, stating that disbelievers "would have almost made you stumble with their eyes" upon hearing the , explained in as envious glares or literal attempts to harm or deter the Prophet, reflecting rather than rational critique. This rebuts their non-verbal rejection by highlighting its futility against divine protection, with reports from companions like confirming instances of such hostility during recitations in . Overall, these responses prioritize evidentiary affirmation of the Prophet's and mission integrity over polemical retaliation, grounding rebuttals in observable traits and logical consequences observable to contemporaries.

Moral and Ethical Admonitions

The Surah Al-Qalam presents moral admonitions centered on exemplary character, urging believers to emulate the Muhammad's elevated ethical conduct, described as possessing "a great " that withstands accusations of or from detractors. This portrayal serves as a model for , emphasizing , under , and steadfast propagation of divine guidance despite opposition, as the 's actions yield enduring spiritual results rather than fleeting material gains associated with insincere motives. Such character counters the ethical lapses of disbelievers, who are depicted as hasty in judgment and dismissive of moral restraint. A central ethical in verses 17–33 illustrates the perils of arrogance, ingratitude, and stinginess, recounting owners of a fertile garden who conspire to harvest its yield at dawn without allocating any portion for the poor as customary (), driven by avarice and self-delusion about their prosperity's permanence. Their subsequent —a devastating strike leaving the garden barren—highlights the causal link between ethical neglect, such as withholding alms and failing to express to the divine provider, and material ruin, reinforcing the imperative of and as safeguards against . The narrative culminates in partial , but underscores that ethical must precede calamity, not follow it, to avert irreversible loss. Further admonitions caution against moral compromise through association with the wicked or yielding to societal pressure, commanding the —and by extension believers—not to obey those given to or futile pursuits, as such alliances erode personal and invite collective downfall. () is extolled as an ethical , exemplified by historical figures of endurance, urging restraint from impulsive responses to and reliance on divine over . This fosters a about human frailty and the transient nature of worldly , promoting ethical rooted in awareness of in the hereafter rather than transient majoritarian approval.

Eschatological Warnings

In Surah Al-Qalam, eschatological warnings emphasize the inevitability of the Day of Judgment and the severe consequences for disbelievers, contrasting temporary worldly afflictions with eternal hereafter punishment. Verse 33 explicitly states that the destruction exemplified in the of the garden owners—where arrogant owners face ruin for neglecting and —represents only a provisional worldly penalty, while "the punishment of the Hereafter is certainly far worse, if only they knew." This underscores a core Islamic doctrine of escalating accountability, where denial of divine signs leads to and reckoning beyond earthly comprehension. Verses 42–52 provide vivid imagery of Judgment Day's terrors, beginning with the "dreadful " when Allah's "" is uncovered, symbolizing an overwhelming event of divine manifestation that humbles . On this day, disbelievers summoned to prostrate will find their backs stiffened, unable to bow due to prior rejection of truth, with eyes downcast and a encompassing them. Classical , such as Ibn Kathir's, interprets this as the moment of ultimate exposure, where physical and spiritual incapacity reflects lifelong arrogance, leading to inescapable divine scrutiny. The details the process: deeds from the "clear " are presented, forcing criminals to confess sins in full awareness, without excuses from devils or false gods. They will beg for relief, offering bribes like children's ransom or doubled worldly goods, but find no escape from chains binding wrongdoers. In despair, they wish to revert to dust rather than face the , highlighting regret's futility post-resurrection. These depictions warn of causal —unrepentant disbelief culminating in from —urging on prophetic messages as reminders before the inexorable hour. notes this as a direct to Meccan opponents, paralleling biblical motifs of final while rooted in Quranic of realities.

Exegetical Traditions

Classical Tafsir Interpretations

Classical tafsirs of Surah Al-Qalam emphasize its role in defending the Prophet 's prophethood against Meccan disbelievers' claims of insanity, while highlighting divine oaths attesting to revelation's veracity and moral exhortations. The opening disjointed letter "" (68:1) receives cosmological interpretations in early exegeses; Abu Ja'far al-Tabari (d. 923 CE) in Jami' al-Bayan identifies it as a whale (al-hut) carrying the seven earths, based on narrations from companions like , symbolizing the foundational stability of creation under divine command. Ismail (d. 1373 CE) echoes this in his tafsir, reporting traditions where Nun is an immense in primordial waters, supporting a , , and earths steadied by mountains, while also allowing views of it as an inkwell or the Preserved Tablet to underscore Allah's pre-eternal knowledge. al-Qurtubi (d. 1273 CE) similarly attributes the whale interpretation to , linking it to the lowest earth in a multi-layered cosmos. The subsequent oath "by the pen and what they inscribe" (68:1) is explained by as referring to the angelic pen recording human actions or the primordial pen inscribing divine decree on the Guarded Tablet, drawing from such as that of Al-Walid bin Ubaydah emphasizing writing's primacy in creation. connects "what they inscribe" to scribes' documentation, refuting claims of prophetic delusion by invoking instruments of eternal truth. Verses 2-4 directly counter accusations of madness, with citing Aisha's narration that the Prophet's character constituted the itself, manifested in traits like patience and kindness reported by . and others frame this as divine reassurance, privileging empirical observation of the Prophet's over detractors' slanders. The of the garden owners (68:17-33) is interpreted as a of avarice and ingratitude; views the destruction—attributed to their failure to invoke "if wills" and neglect of the poor's share—as mirroring disbelievers' fate, possibly alluding to a historical event near Ta'if per some athar. elaborates it as admonition against self-sufficiency without , emphasizing causal links between ethical lapses and material loss. Closing verses on the (68:51-52) affirm its tangible effects under divine permission; Ibn Kathir substantiates this with hadiths from and Abu Umamah, noting the disbelievers' envy nearly swayed the but was thwarted by Quranic protection, underscoring revelation's safeguarding role. These exegeses, grounded in prophetic traditions, portray the as integrating prophethood validation with eschatological warnings.

Associated Hadith and Narrations

Several narrations elucidate the opening oath in Surah Al-Qalam by "Nun" and "," emphasizing the Pen's primordial role in divine decree. A prophetic tradition states that the first entity created by was , which He commanded to inscribe the destinies of all until the Day of Judgment. This narration, reported by from the Prophet Muhammad, underscores the Pen as an instrument of predetermination, aligning with the surah's of writing as a cosmic to truth and . Similar accounts in collections like Sunan at-Tirmidhi affirm this sequence, grading the chain as hasan sahih, though some variants specify the command occurring 50,000 years before the of the heavens and earth. Regarding the eschatological imagery in verse 42, where the "" is uncovered amid judgment, authentic provide detailed prophetic exposition. In , Abu Sa'id al-Khudri narrated that the Prophet described the Day of Resurrection: will command to intercede, and upon of His shin, all believers will prostrate in and , while hypocrites, unable to prostrate despite prior habit, will be exposed. This narration, corroborated in , interprets the "uncovering" as a manifestation of divine majesty eliciting involuntary submission from the faithful, contrasting with the disbelievers' incapacity, thus reinforcing the surah's warning of inescapable reckoning. Interpretations of "" as a cosmic , such as a supporting the reported via , appear in early traditions but lack direct prophetic attribution, deriving instead from companion exegesis rather than sahih chains. These are not classified as prophetic narrations and reflect interpretive diversity rather than core doctrinal . No sahih explicitly link the surah's parable of the garden or moral admonitions to specific prophetic events, though general traditions on the Prophet's exemplary echo verse 4's affirmation of his "great moral ."

Intertextual and Comparative Analysis

Coherence with Adjacent Surahs

Surah Al-Qalam exhibits thematic continuity with the preceding Surah (67), both being early Makki revelations that emphasize divine authority and human accountability. Al-Mulk underscores God's sovereignty over creation, including the heavens and earth, as evidence against denial of resurrection and judgment, while Al-Qalam extends this by defending the Prophet Muhammad's mission against accusations of , portraying it as divinely inspired akin to the protected scriptures of prior prophets. This progression shifts from cosmic signs of God's dominion to the integrity of prophetic guidance, reinforcing belief in through trust in His messenger. In relation to the following Surah Al-Haqqah (69), Al-Qalam foreshadows eschatological inevitability by warning disbelievers of an inescapable reckoning, using parables like the garden owners to illustrate consequences of arrogance and ingratitude. Al-Haqqah elaborates this motif, vividly depicting the Day of Judgment's terrors and the fates of past nations, thus providing detailed substantiation to Al-Qalam's introductory allusions to divine torment and reward. The shared focus on respite granted to transgressors—allowing them to exhaust their rebellion before inevitable downfall—links the surahs, portraying judgment as the culmination of unchecked disbelief. Collectively, Surahs 67–69 form a cohesive in the Quranic arrangement, transitioning from affirmation of God's kingship (), through validation of prophethood and moral admonition (Al-Qalam), to graphic portrayal of accountability (Al-Haqqah), underscoring interconnected themes of , risalah, and without rigid chronological ordering but evident structural .

Parallels with Pre-Islamic and Judeo-Christian Texts

The opening verses of Surah Al-Qalam defend the Prophet Muhammad against charges of being majnun (possessed or mad), a motif recurrent in prophetic narratives where messengers face similar derision. For instance, the records the priest Shephatiah accusing the prophet of madness for his warnings (Jeremiah 29:26), while the depicts critics claiming was demon-possessed rather than divinely inspired (Matthew 11:18; Luke 7:33). These parallels highlight a shared in Abrahamic traditions: opposition to prophets framed as psychological or spiritual aberration, often as a pretext for rejecting monotheistic exhortations. The central in verses 17–33, recounting wealthy owners who swear an to harvest prematurely, exclude the needy, and suffer total destruction as retribution, thematically aligns with Biblical parables emphasizing abrupt on material arrogance. Comparable narratives include the , where a prosperous man hoards his abundant harvest only to face untimely death and loss (Luke 12:16–21), and the Parable of the Wicked Tenants, involving stewards who defy the owner, mistreat envoys, and invite ruin (Matthew 21:33–41; 12:1–9; Luke 20:9–16). Scholar Angelika Neuwirth observes these affinities in the motif of wealth-induced leading to eschatological reversal, situating the Quranic account within a Late Antique milieu of moral didacticism shared across scriptures. Unlike the tenant-focused , the Quranic version centers on owners' ingratitude and denial of , underscoring causal links between ethical neglect and , but both employ agricultural to convey inevitable . Verses 48–50 reference the "Companion of the Fish" (sahib al-hut), widely interpreted in Islamic as Jonah, evoking his ordeal of submersion and deliverance after repentance—a narrative directly paralleled in the (Jonah 1:1–17; 2:1–10). This episode reinforces themes of mercy following contrition, echoed in Syriac Christian hymns like those of on Jonah's mission to . Such intertextual echoes suggest the Quran presupposes familiarity with these stories among its audience, positioning itself as a corrective or confirmation of prior revelations (cf. 5:48), though textual variants in transmission and oral circulation complicate claims of direct dependence. In pre-Islamic Arabian contexts, the surah's oath structures (e.g., "By the Pen and what they inscribe," verse 1) and vivid eschatological imagery resonate with the hyperbolic oaths and ethical laments in Jahiliyyah poetry, such as those decrying tribal excess or invoking natural forces for emphasis (e.g., motifs in works by Zuhayr ibn Abi Sulma). However, scholars note the Quran's transformation of these rhetorical devices into a distinct, non-metrical saj' prose, purportedly inimitable, diverging from poetry's pagan undertones while repurposing shared causal realism about divine oversight of human folly. No verbatim borrowings are attested, reflecting instead a continuum of Semitic expressive traditions adapted for monotheistic critique.

Scholarly Debates and Criticisms

Claims of Linguistic and Structural Miracles

Muslim scholars assert that exemplifies Quranic inimitability through its opening oath by the disjointed letter "" and "," which they interpret as a divine challenge to produce comparable , emphasizing the precision of written . This structure transitions into a defense of the Prophet Muhammad's sanity and character using emphatic negations and affirmations, such as "You are not, by the grace of your , a madman" (68:2), crafted with rhythmic parallelism to refute contemporary accusations. Proponents highlight the surah's rhetorical devices, including vivid in the of the companions of the (68:17-33), where destruction is depicted through concise, evocative language like branding on the "" (68:16), combining admonition with phonetic . The narrative employs repetition of interrogatives to provoke reflection on consequences, underscoring causal links between arrogance and in a balanced syntactic framework. schemes, as in "fa sa tubSiru wa yuBsiroon" (68:5), enhance memorability and auditory impact, features deemed inimitable in pre-Islamic . Structurally, the surah is paired with , mirroring themes of but with a sharper tone of warning, comprising 52 verses that shift from prophetic vindication to eschatological and conclude with universal reminder, forming a cohesive argumentative arc. Analyses describe proportional linking verses through negation-affirmation patterns and verb tenses denoting persistent opposition, contributing to claims of . These elements, while subjective in their miraculous attribution, are presented by exegetes as evidence of linguistic superiority beyond human capability.

Textual Transmission and Authenticity Questions

Al-Qalam was revealed in during the early phase of Muhammad's prophethood, prior to the in 622 , and thus forms part of the initial corpus memorized by companions and inscribed on available materials such as leather, bones, and palm stalks. Following the Battle of Yamama in 633 , which resulted in the death of numerous memorizers, Caliph (r. 632–634 ) commissioned to compile scattered writings into a unified collection under the supervision of key huffaz (memorizers). This suhuf (sheets) served as the basis for Caliph Uthman's around 650 , wherein a committee standardized the consonantal text () to the Qurayshi dialect, producing multiple codices distributed to provincial capitals, including the text of Al-Qalam in its canonical order. The Uthmanic codex's transmission for Surah Al-Qalam is attested in surviving early manuscripts, such as the Topkapi Codex in , which contains verses 68:8–52 in a script consistent with 8th-century style, aligning closely with the standardized despite minor orthographic differences attributable to pre-vocalization practices. Other Hijazi-script fragments from the first century (7th–8th ) exhibit similar fidelity, with radiocarbon analyses of comparable Quranic folios dating to 568–645 confirming the antiquity and uniformity of the skeletal text across surahs. Authenticity debates arise primarily from historical-critical approaches questioning the seamlessness of oral-to-written transition in , with some scholars positing potential interpolations or regional variants suppressed during Uthmanic standardization, as referenced in reports of companions like Ibn Mas'ud possessing differing codices. However, empirical evidence counters significant alteration: the ten canonical (recitations), including variants in Al-Qalam such as subtle vowel shifts in verses like 68:1 (Nun wal-qalam), trace matn (content) and isnad (chain) to via mutawatir (mass-transmitted) paths, preserving semantic integrity without doctrinal variance. Paleographic and codicological studies, including those of the Corpus Coranicum project, demonstrate that early manuscripts evince a fixed by the late , with deviations limited to permissible recitational flexibility rather than substantive edits, underscoring causal mechanisms of communal over individual authorship that ensured textual stability superior to many contemporaneous scriptures. No surah-specific authenticity challenges to Al-Qalam have gained traction in peer-reviewed literature, as its Meccan and brevity mitigate opportunities for later accretion alleged in longer Medinan texts.

Non-Muslim Critiques and Polemical Views

Orientalist scholars have frequently challenged the Islamic doctrine of the Quran's (inimitability), including in early Meccan surahs such as Al-Qalam, asserting that its rhetorical style exhibits ambiguities, inconsistencies, and structural deficiencies rather than unparalleled eloquence. , in his analysis of Quranic composition, contended that narratives in surahs like Al-Qalam lack uniform progression and logical , attributing this to the oral improvisational of the text rather than divine . Similarly, Richard Bell described the Quran's arrangement as characterized by dispersion and rare instances of sustained , viewing passages in Al-Qalam—such as the abrupt shift from the prophetic to the garden —as exemplifying disjointed elaboration over masterful unity. Critics like Reynolds Nicholson labeled the Quran a "farrago of long-winded narratives," a applicable to Al-Qalam's exhortatory warnings and moral allegory, which they saw as tedious and repetitive rather than rhetorically innovative. Ignaz Goldziher further argued for textual instability in the 's literary form, suggesting that elements in Al-Qalam, including its response to accusations of prophetic (verses 2-4), reflect human inconsistencies rather than inimitable . These views contrast sharply with Muslim claims of the surah's stylistic superiority, positing instead that its mirrors 7th-century Arabian conventions without transcending them. The surah's opening huruf muqatta'at—"" (verse 1)—has drawn particular scrutiny as an opaque device lacking evident purpose, with some non-Muslim analysts interpreting such disjointed letters across 29 surahs as possible abbreviations, musical cues, or vestiges of pre-Islamic incantatory formulas rather than symbolic oaths attesting to divine authorship. Polemicists, including those emphasizing the Quran's human origins, regard Al-Qalam's self-vindication of the Prophet's and character (verses 2-4) as circular , tailored to counter contemporary Meccan derision rather than conveying universal truth, thereby undermining claims of prescience.) The of the garden owners (verses 17-33), while framed as a caution against avarice, has been critiqued in polemical literature as a derivative folk motif akin to agrarian fables in Near Eastern traditions, lacking the ethical depth or originality attributed to it in Islamic . Such interpretations portray the surah's warnings of eschatological retribution as psychologically manipulative, aimed at coercing compliance among early opponents, rather than evidencing causal in divine . Overall, these non-Muslim perspectives prioritize empirical of the text's historical and literary context over theological assertions, often highlighting perceived —such as the unyielding condemnation of disbelievers—as reflective of tribal rather than transcendent .

References

  1. [1]
    Surah Al-Qalam [68] - Translation and Transliteration - القلم‎ - My Islam
    Surah Al-Qalam (Arabic text: القلم) is the 68th chapter of the Qur'an. The surah titled in English means “The Pen” and it consists of 52 verses...Surah Qalam ayat 17 · Surah Qalam, ayat 48-50 · Surah Qalam Ayat 12 in Arabic...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  2. [2]
    Surah Al Qalam Summary - The Last Dialogue
    Mar 7, 2019 · This Surah has 52 verses divided into 2 Rukus/Sections. It takes its name from verse 1: ” ن ۚ وَالْقَلَمِ وَمَا يَسْطُرُونَ” ( Nun. By the pen and what they ...
  3. [3]
    Quran Structure - Islamicstudies.info
    Revealed No. Revealed, Rukuh. 96, Al-Alaq, 19, 1, Mecca 1, 1. 68, Al-Qalam, 52, 2, Mecca 2, 2.<|separator|>
  4. [4]
    About Surah Al-Qalam | Quran – Amrayn
    Surah Al-Qalam is the 68th surah (chapter) of The Glorious Quran. Name of ... In this Meccan sûrah, the Prophet's heart is reassured and his character is highly ...
  5. [5]
    Surah Al-Qalam 68:1-33 - Towards Understanding the Quran
    It means that this Quran which is being inscribed by the hands of the writers of revelation, is by itself enough to refute the slander of the disbelievers.<|control11|><|separator|>
  6. [6]
    Surah al-Qalam, Chapter 68
    The Chapter, revealed in Mecca, has 52 Verses. Some Qur'an exegetes have entertained doubts about the Revelation of all the blessed Verses of the Chapter in ...
  7. [7]
    Surat al Qalam - What lessons are there in the second revelation?
    Mar 6, 2021 · The main theme​​ Surat al Qalam was revealed in Makkah, and bears the hallmarks of Makkan surahs, as it challenges the status quo and disbelief. ...
  8. [8]
    Al-Itqān: Meccan and Medinan Chapters - Iqra Online
    Nov 6, 2017 · 68, Al-Qalam, Mecca, 17-33, Medina. 48-50, Medina. 73, Al-Muzzammil, Mecca, 10-11, Medina. 20, Medina. 76, Al-Insān, Mecca, 24, Medina. 77, Al- ...
  9. [9]
    Surah Al-Qalam - 1-52 - Quran.com
    ### Summary of Surah Al-Qalam (Quran 68)
  10. [10]
    Surah Al-Qalam - 1-52 - Quran.com
    Surah Al-Qalam, also called Nun, was revealed when opposition to the Prophet was harsh. Its themes include replies to opponents, warnings, and exhortation to ...
  11. [11]
  12. [12]
  13. [13]
    (PDF) The letter Noon in Surah Al Qalam - ResearchGate
    Aug 7, 2017 · This article undertakes stylistic study of the Qur'anic chapter 68; Al Qalam (The Pen), which begins with a single letter N?n.
  14. [14]
    Overview - Surah 68: al-Qalam (The Pen )
    Overview ; Total Words *, 300 ; Root Words *, 130 ; Unique Root Words *, 5 ; Makki / Madani, Makki ; Chronological Order*, 2nd (according to Ibn Abbas).
  15. [15]
    [PDF] ینید يرگنشور و نآرق - Quran and Religious Enlightenment
    Surah al-Qalam is the 68th surah in the Muṣḥaf arrangement, comprising 52 verses. All tables of chronological order of revelation place it as the second Surah ...Missing: breakdown | Show results with:breakdown
  16. [16]
    Surah Al-Qalam - 1-52 - Quran.com
    Period of Revelation​​ This too is one of the earliest surahs to be revealed at Makkah, but its subject matter shows that it was sent down at the time when ...
  17. [17]
    68. Surah Al Qalam (The Pen) - The Meaning of the Qur'an
    Period of Revelation. This too is one of the earliest surahs to be revealed at Makkah, but its subject matter shows that it was sent down at the time when ...
  18. [18]
    Revelation Order - Tanzil Documents
    Al-Qalam, 68, Meccan, Except 17-33 and 48-50, from Medina. 3, Al-Muzzammil, 73 ... Except 68-70, from Medina. 43, Faatir, 35, Meccan. 44, Maryam, 19, Meccan ...
  19. [19]
    Surah 68. Al-Qalam - Alim.org
    Surah Al-Qalam was revealed when opposition was harsh. It includes warnings to disbelievers, and the Prophet is exhorted to bear with patience.<|control11|><|separator|>
  20. [20]
    Tafsir Surah Al-Qalam - 2 - Quran.com
    The present Surah deals with the truth of the Holy Prophet's ﷺ claim, and gives sound and solid proof of it. Thus it rebuts the criticisms and taunts of the ...Missing: Tabari occasions
  21. [21]
    Surah Qalam ayat 1 Tafsir Ibn Kathir | Nun. By the pen and what they
    Allah swears by the Nun, which is the whale that carries the earths on its back while in Water, and beneath which is the Bull and under the Bull is the Rock.Missing: Asbab Nuzul
  22. [22]
    Tafsir of Surah Al-Qalam Ayat 1-52 (end) - honey for the heart
    Tafsir of Surah Al-Qalam · (The Pen) · Chapter 68 · {1. Nun. By the pen and by what they Yastur. · 2. You, by the grace of your Lord, are not insane. · 3. And verily ...
  23. [23]
    Al-Qalam 68:1 - Nun. By the Pen and What They Write
    However, some early tafsir (exegesis) traditions present fascinating interpretations. One view suggests 'Nun' refers to a colossal whale that supports the earth ...
  24. [24]
    Surah Al-Qalam Ayat 4 (68:4 Quran) With Tafsir - My Islam
    Read Surah Qalam Ayat 4 (68:4) with translation. Included verse by verse commentary with tafsir for those looking to learn about this ayah in detail.<|separator|>
  25. [25]
    Surah al-Qalam and the sanity of prophets
    Jun 26, 2020 · The death of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Sahib of Qadian is not something from which one may not draw any lesson and just consign it to the ever-receding ...
  26. [26]
  27. [27]
    Surah Qalam ayat 17 Tafsir Quran 68:17 - القرآن الكريم
    *12) Here, one should also keep Al-Kahf: 32-44 in view, in which the parable of the owners of two gardens has been cited for teaching a lesson. Tafsir Maarif-ul ...
  28. [28]
    Surah Al-Qalam Ayat 17 (68:17 Quran) With Tafsir - My Islam
    Read Surah Qalam Ayat 17 (68:17) with translation. Included verse by verse commentary with tafsir for those looking to learn about this ayah in detail.
  29. [29]
    Surah Al-Qalam 68:1-33 - Tafsir Maariful Quran - Islamicstudies.info
    This incident took place after the migration. The Story of the Owners of a Garden ... [ Ibn Kathir ]. They were from amongst the People of the Book. This ...
  30. [30]
  31. [31]
    Surah Qalam ayat 51 Tafsir Ibn Kathir - القرآن الكريم
    Quran 68:51 Tafsir Al-Jalalayn. Indeed those who disbelieve would almost throw you down to the ground read la-yuzliqūnaka or la-yazliqūnaka with their looks ...Missing: Ayn | Show results with:Ayn
  32. [32]
    Tafsir Surah Al-Qalam - 51 - Quran.com
    The evil eye is a reality which causes loss, illness and destruction. Authentic Traditions report that it is a reality. The Arabs also believed that an evil eye ...
  33. [33]
  34. [34]
  35. [35]
    Tafsir Surah Al-Qalam - 17 - Quran.com
    However, they were called the owners of the garden on account of the popularity of the garden. The incident is reported according to the narration of Muhammad ...
  36. [36]
    Surah Al-Qalam - 33 - Quran.com
    That is the ˹way of Our˺ punishment ˹in this world˺. But the punishment of the Hereafter is certainly far worse, if only they knew. 1. Read full surah.
  37. [37]
    Surah Qalam ayat 42 Tafsir Ibn Kathir | The Day the shin will be ...
    Quran 68:42 Tafsir Ibn Kathir ... The Terror of the Day of Judgement After Allah mentions that those who have Taqwa, will have Gardens of Delight with their Lord, ...Missing: 68:42-52 eschatological
  38. [38]
    Surah Qalam ayat 52 Tafsir Ibn Kathir | But it is not except a reminder
    The Command to be Patient and to refrain from being Hasty like Yunus was Allah says, فَاصْبِرْ ( So wait with patience ) `O Muhammad, persevere against the harm ...Missing: 68:42-52 eschatological<|separator|>
  39. [39]
  40. [40]
    The Letter Nun in Qur'an 68:1: Early Tafsir Interpretations and Cross ...
    Jun 23, 2025 · It explores the tafsir tradition surrounding Surah 68:1, the etymological roots of the word nun, and any potential (or coincidental) connections ...
  41. [41]
    Tafseer Ibn Katheer Surah Al-Qalam Verse 48-52 - Word of Allah
    Surah Al Qalam Tafsir Ibn Kathir. Here you can read complete English Tafsir of Surah Al Qalam from Tafsir Ibn Kathir with English translation of Al Qalam.Missing: Asbab Nuzul
  42. [42]
    Sahih al-Bukhari 7439 - Oneness, Uniqueness of Allah (Tawheed)
    'The Shin,' and so Allah will then uncover His Shin whereupon every believer will prostrate before Him and there will remain those who used to prostrate ...
  43. [43]
    تفسير Tanwîr al-Miqbâs min Tafsîr Ibn 'Abbâs - Al Tafsir
    Allah swears by the Nun, which is the whale that carries the earths on its back while in Water, and beneath which is the Bull and under the Bull is the Rock.
  44. [44]
    Tafsir Surah Al-Qalam - 1 - Quran.com
    The present Surah deals with the truth of the Holy Prophet's ﷺ claim, and gives sound and solid proof of it. Thus it rebuts the criticisms and taunts of the ...Missing: Asbab Nuzul<|separator|>
  45. [45]
    Surah al Qalam – the Pen (68) | Linguistic Miracle Blog
    Surah al Qalam tells us to believe in Prophet Muhammad, and if you don't – here are the consequences (hellfire.) This is why the surah begins with Qalam (the ...
  46. [46]
    Introduction to chapters of the Holy Quran: Surah al-Talaq, al-Tahrim ...
    Apr 8, 2022 · The subject-matter in Surah al-Qalam was that the philosophy behind giving respite to the enemies of the Prophets is that they may reach the ...Missing: coherence | Show results with:coherence
  47. [47]
    The Noble Quran English Translation and Tafsir of Surah Al-Haqqah
    Jan 14, 2023 · Surah Al-Qalam comes before surah Al-Haqqah according to the written copy of the Quran, al-Mushf. It briefly refers to the Day of Judgment. 68: ...
  48. [48]
    [PDF] The Qurʾān and the Bible | Almuslih
    Published with assistance from the foundation established in memory of Amasa Stone Mather of the Class of 1907, Yale College. Copyright © 2018 by Yale ...
  49. [49]
    Rhetorical Transformation in the Qurʾān and Pre-Islamic Poetry
    This study examines how selected place names, animal figures, and natural elements are used rhetorically in the Qurʾān and pre-Islamic Arabic poetry.
  50. [50]
    The stylistic study in Surat Al-Qalam
    The stylistic study in Surat Al-Qalam. Document Type : Original Article ... verses of this surah indicates the causal relationship between the meanings of the ...Missing: breakdown | Show results with:breakdown
  51. [51]
    Surah Al-Qalam - 1-52 - Quran.com
    Read and listen to Surah Al-Qalam. The Surah was revealed in Mecca, ordered 68 in the Quran. The Surah title means "The Pen" in English and consists o...Missing: authentic narration
  52. [52]
    The ʿUthmānic Codex: Understanding how the Qur'an was Preserved
    Jun 22, 2022 · An overview of the history behind the Uthmanic codex and how it was compiled to preserve the Quran as it was revealed to the Prophet Muhammad ...
  53. [53]
    The "Qur'an Of Uthman" At The Topkapi Museum, Istanbul, Turkey ...
    Jul 31, 2008 · A display of what is widely held to be the 'Uthmanic manuscript of the Qur'an in the Topkapi Museum, Istanbul, Turkey.
  54. [54]
    Concise List Of Arabic Manuscripts Of The Qur'an Attributable To ...
    The use of coloured inks in early Qur'anic manuscripts can be traced to the 1st century of hijra. Before the emergence of Islam, red ink was used for ...
  55. [55]
    [PDF] Variant Readings of the Qur'an
    in presenting this new edition of a scholarly work originally published by the Institute in 1998 on: Variant Readings of the Qur'an, A Critical Study of ...
  56. [56]
    The Qur'ān, Textual Criticism, and the New Testament
    Sep 30, 2024 · Muslims believe that the Qur'ān they have today is the exact same text that Muhammad received from Gabriel and that Allah has perfectly preserved it verbatim.
  57. [57]
    [PDF] An Evaluation of Claims by Non-Muslim Scholars about the ...
    The skepticism concerning eloquence and rhetoric of Quranic verses is one of the most basic and most serious doubts raised by some non-Muslims. What follows are ...