Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Emanuel Derman


Emanuel Derman (born 1945) is a South African-born American physicist-turned-quantitative analyst, academic, and author renowned for bridging with . After earning a in from in 1973 and conducting postdoctoral research in the field, Derman shifted to in the , joining before moving to in 1985, where he rose to managing director and co-developed the Black-Derman-Toy (BDT) model—a foundational short-rate framework for pricing that calibrates to the and structure.
As head of quantitative strategies at until 2002, Derman advanced local models, including the Derman-Kani tree approach for . He later served as Professor of Professional Practice in at , directing its master's program from 2003 to 2023, while authoring influential works like My Life as a Quant: Reflections on Physics and Finance (2004), which chronicles his career transition, and Models.Behaving.Badly: Why Confusing Illusion with Reality Can Lead to Disaster, Wall Street, and the Subprime Debacle (2011), which applies first-principles scrutiny to expose the flawed metaphysics and overconfidence in financial models' predictive power. Derman's writings emphasize the irreducible gap between robust scientific theories and pragmatic, error-prone financial metaphors, advocating in quantitative .

Early Life and Education

Childhood and Family Background

Emanuel Derman was born in , , to parents who had immigrated from in the mid-1930s to escape . His family originated from a Polish-Jewish background, with many extended relatives, including his maternal grandparents, perishing during . Derman's upbringing took place within a protective, first-generation immigrant Jewish community in , characterized by close-knit Polish-Jewish networks that maintained traditional values amid a British-influenced colonial society. The family environment emphasized core principles instilled by his mother, including devotion to family, in adversity, and eidelkeit—a Yiddish concept denoting personal refinement, decency, and propriety. This occurred against the backdrop of South Africa's intensifying regime in the through , which imposed and coercive policies, though the insular Jewish enclave provided some insulation from broader societal tensions. Derman attended Herzlia High School, matriculating in 1961, reflecting the structured educational path typical of the community's aspirations for intellectual and professional advancement. Derman departed at age 21 to pursue graduate studies abroad, marking the end of his formative years in this immigrant enclave. His early life, as detailed in personal memoirs, highlights the interplay of Holocaust-era displacement, communal solidarity, and adaptation to a segregated postcolonial context.

Undergraduate and Graduate Studies

Derman completed his undergraduate education at the in , earning a B.Sc. (Hons) degree in and . He began university studies at age 16 and finished the four-year program, specializing in physics and during this period. Following his undergraduate degree, Derman relocated to the at age 21 to pursue graduate studies in at . There, he obtained an M.A. and a Ph.D., completing the doctorate in with a focused on tests for a weak in . His doctoral research contributed to early work in physics, reflecting the era's emphasis on developing the of particle interactions.

Physics Career

Doctoral Research in Particle Physics

Derman received his PhD in theoretical particle physics from Columbia University in 1973 after approximately seven years of graduate study. His doctoral thesis examined the production of muons in high-energy proton collisions, addressing experimental observations of dimuon events from cosmic rays and early particle accelerators. This research applied the quark-parton model, a developing framework positing protons as composites of quarks and gluons, to interpret processes. In a key 1973 paper co-authored with John N. Ng while affiliated with the , Derman modeled dimuon production as arising from quark-antiquark annihilations or decays involving charm quarks, aligning theoretical predictions with observed cross-sections. The work contributed to validating the parton picture amid debates over scaling violations and higher-order effects, though direct thesis details remain unpublished in accessible archives. Derman's graduate efforts occurred during a pivotal era in , following the November Revolution of that confirmed the charmed , which retroactively contextualized models of heavy flavor production in his thesis domain. These investigations emphasized perturbative calculations and inclusive cross-section estimates, laying groundwork for his subsequent postdoctoral explorations of heavy fragmentation and electroweak asymmetries.

Postdoctoral and Research Positions

Following receipt of his PhD in theoretical particle physics from Columbia University in 1973, Derman undertook a series of postdoctoral fellowships in the field. He first held a two-year postdoctoral position at the University of Pennsylvania, conducting research on theoretical particle physics. This was followed by a two-year postdoctoral fellowship at the University of Oxford in England, where he continued studies in theoretical physics. Derman then spent two additional years as a at The Rockefeller University in , completing a six-year sequence of such appointments spanning 1973 to 1979 across these institutions. His work during this period centered on unified theories of elementary particle interactions, contributing to articles published in the domain of . In 1979, Derman transitioned to a faculty role as of physics at the at Boulder, where he remained until 1980 and extended his research in . This position marked the culmination of his academic research phase in the field amid a competitive job market for permanent roles in . By 1980, facing limited prospects for tenure-track advancement, he shifted toward applied computational work, though his physics research effectively concluded around this time.

Transition to Finance

Motivations for Career Shift

After completing his doctoral research in and holding postdoctoral and assistant professorship positions, Derman faced constrained academic opportunities in the late and early , characterized by a scarcity of permanent faculty roles and an abundance of temporary postdoctoral appointments. Compounding this, his family circumstances—wife and young son residing in while he was based in —prompted a departure from physics in for a position at Bell Laboratories' Systems Center near , where he shifted toward applied computing and . At from 1980 to 1985, Derman engaged in software development and quantitative analysis, gaining proficiency in programming languages like UNIX but growing restless with the environment's constraints after five years of deliberation. In late 1985, specifically November, he transitioned to ' fixed-income research group, drawn by the prospect of applying physical sciences' modeling techniques to financial instruments, amid a broader influx of physicists to seeking intellectually demanding roles with practical impact and superior compensation unavailable in shrinking physics job markets. Derman anticipated intellectual diminishment upon entering after nearly two decades in physics' pursuit of theories, yet he discovered unexpected depth in , particularly options, whose mathematical frameworks—such as the Black-Scholes model—echoed physics' elegance and empirical applicability. This resonance, combining rigorous modeling with real-world testing against market data, sustained his engagement, transforming what he initially viewed as a pragmatic into a fulfilling domain where financial models offered tangible, iterative refinements akin to scientific experimentation.

Early Roles in Quantitative Analysis

In 1985, following a decade at AT&T Bell Laboratories developing programming languages for business modeling, Emanuel Derman transitioned to by joining ' fixed income research group. There, he applied his background to of derivatives, extending the Black-Scholes-Merton replication methodology to instruments amid the nascent growth of quantitative trading. Derman's initial role involved collaborating closely with bond options traders in a small team environment, focusing on model development for pricing and hedging fixed income securities such as treasury bills and corporate bonds. Over his first four years (1985–1989), he contributed to quantitative strategies in fixed income, leveraging computational skills from UNIX systems honed at Bell Labs to build practical financial models in an era when many quants lacked strong programming expertise. This period marked Derman as one of the pioneering physicists in quantitative finance, helping to professionalize derivative pricing in fixed income divisions where empirical of models to was becoming essential. His work emphasized bridging theoretical constructs with trader needs, fostering innovations that later influenced industry standards, though early efforts were constrained by limited data and computing power compared to subsequent decades.

Financial Innovations and Models

Development of the Black-Derman-Toy Model

In the mid-1980s, amid growing demand for pricing interest rate derivatives at , , Emanuel Derman, and William Toy collaborated to develop a pioneering no-arbitrage model for short-term interest rates. , renowned for his work on the Black-Scholes model, sought a framework that could calibrate precisely to observed bond yields and volatilities, addressing limitations in earlier approaches like the constant-rate assumptions of Black-Scholes for fixed-income options. Derman, leveraging his physics background in particle theory and numerical methods, contributed to constructing the model's binomial lattice , which modeled the evolution of instantaneous short rates as lognormally distributed to match empirical volatility smiles and term structures. The model innovated by using a one-factor recombining tree to simulate future short-rate paths, ensuring no-arbitrage consistency with the current through forward induction calibration. This approach allowed for pricing options on s or rates, incorporating time-dependent drift and volatility parameters derived from market data on cap prices or volatilities. Initially implemented internally at for valuing mortgage-backed securities and options, the model provided a practical alternative to simulation-heavy methods, emphasizing empirical fit over theoretical purity. The model was formalized and published in the January-February issue of the Financial Analysts Journal as "A One-Factor Model of Interest Rates and Its Application to Treasury Bond Options," detailing its application to European options on Treasury bonds with numerical examples using 1989 market data. This publication marked its broader dissemination, influencing subsequent term-structure models like Hull-White, though Derman later critiqued such frameworks for over-relying on Gaussian assumptions that mismatched real-world lognormal rate behaviors.

Contributions to Volatility and Derivatives Pricing

Derman, in collaboration with Iraj Kani, developed the implied tree model to reconcile the Black-Scholes-Merton framework with observed smiles in option prices. Published in 1994, this approach constructs a recombining where the price and its associated transition probabilities are calibrated to match the market-implied volatilities across a range of strikes and maturities for European index options. By fitting the to liquid vanilla option prices, the model enables the pricing and hedging of illiquid exotic derivatives, such as barriers and binaries, in a manner consistent with the prevailing smile, addressing the Black-Scholes assumption of constant which fails to capture the observed post-1987 . Extending this, Derman contributed to local volatility models, where instantaneous is a deterministic of the underlying asset and time, σ(S, t), rather than . In a 1996 Goldman Sachs research note, he outlined the local volatility surface derived from Dupire's formula, relating it to implied volatilities via rules: local volatility exceeds implied for at-the-money options, skews propagate forward, and smiles flatten over time under no-arbitrage constraints. This framework allows numerical implementation via trees or finite differences to path-dependent derivatives while reproducing the entire volatility surface, improving upon models by ensuring calibration to vanillas without additional parameters. Derman's work emphasized practical applications in trading, including the of like variance swaps, where realized is hedged against implied levels. He critiqued the limitations of smile-consistent models, noting that forward skew dynamics in local can lead to unrealistic hedging demands during market stress, as local vols amplify in low-probability regions. These contributions, grounded in empirical option data from indices like the , facilitated risk-neutral extensions beyond bonds—building on his earlier Black-Derman-Toy interest rate model—and influenced subsequent and jump-diffusion hybrids.

Professional Career in Finance

Tenure at Goldman Sachs

Derman joined in 1985, recruited from Bell Laboratories to apply his physics background to quantitative , initially focusing on modeling. During his tenure, which spanned from 1985 to 2002 with a brief stint at in between, he advanced through roles in quantitative strategies, leading research groups in , equities, and eventually firmwide . By the 1990s, as head of the Quantitative Strategies group in , Derman oversaw model development and trading strategies that integrated empirical data with theoretical frameworks, emphasizing practical applicability over abstract ideals. In 2000, Derman transitioned to managing director in ' firmwide risk division, heading the Quantitative Risk Strategies group, where he directed efforts to quantify portfolio risks using probabilistic methods grounded in historical market behaviors rather than untested assumptions. His leadership contributed to Goldman's reputation for robust , earning him the SunGard/IAFE Financial Engineer of the Year award in 2000 for innovations in quantitative risk tools. Derman's approach prioritized causal links between market events and model outputs, critiquing overly deterministic financial physics analogies in internal strategies. Derman departed in 2002 to pursue academia full-time at , leaving as a recognized pioneer in quant risk, later inducted into the Risk Hall of Fame that year for his firm's advancements under his guidance. His 17-year tenure exemplified the integration of scientific rigor into banking operations, though he later reflected on the inherent limits of models in capturing real-world financial turbulence.

Risk Management and Leadership Roles

In the 1990s at , Derman headed the Quantitative Strategies Group within the equities division, overseeing the development of models for pricing and . Later in his tenure, he served as head of in the firm's firm-wide risk department, focusing on quantitative approaches to evaluate and mitigate portfolio exposures across . These roles involved leading teams that integrated physics-inspired modeling techniques into practical risk frameworks, emphasizing in risk measurement over mere control or prediction. Derman was appointed a managing director at & Co. in 1997, a position that reflected his influence in steering quantitative risk strategies amid growing market complexity. Under his leadership, the Quantitative Strategies group advanced contributions in areas such as equity derivatives and volatility modeling, which supported broader firm-wide practices. After retiring from Goldman Sachs in 2002, Derman joined Prisma Capital Partners as Head of Risk and a partner, where he directed for the fund-of-funds operation, applying quantitative methods to oversee allocations and systemic exposures. In this capacity, he emphasized model limitations in capturing real-world uncertainties, drawing from his prior experience to advocate for robust, non-overreliant risk protocols. He held this role into the 2010s, contributing to the firm's navigation of post-financial crisis regulatory scrutiny on alternative investments.

Academic Contributions

Professorship at Columbia University

Emanuel Derman joined in 2003 as Professor of Professional Practice in the Department of and (IEOR). In this capacity, he bridged his expertise in and quantitative finance to educate students on the application of mathematical models to financial markets. His appointment leveraged his prior industry experience at firms like , where he developed key models such as the Black-Derman-Toy model, to inform academic instruction on derivatives pricing and . Throughout his two-decade tenure until 2023, Derman supervised student research projects and contributed to coursework in , including topics on term-structure modeling and credit derivatives. He emphasized the limitations of financial models, drawing from first-hand Wall Street observations to caution against over-reliance on mathematical abstractions in predicting market behavior. This perspective, informed by his critique of models as metaphors rather than theories, shaped classroom discussions on volatility smiles and behavioral aspects of . Upon retirement in 2023, Derman was honored with a dedicated event at Columbia's Davis Auditorium recognizing his impact on quantitative education. He transitioned to Professor of Professional Practice Emeritus, continuing to influence the field through publications and lectures while maintaining an affiliation with the university. His academic role underscored a practitioner-oriented approach, prioritizing empirical validation over idealized assumptions in .

Direction of Financial Engineering Program

Derman served as director of Columbia University's in (MSFE) program, housed in the Department of and , from 2003 until his retirement in 2023. In this capacity, as Professor of Professional Practice, he oversaw the program's , which emphasizes quantitative methods in finance, including derivatives pricing, , and stochastic modeling, integrating theoretical physics-inspired approaches with practical industry applications derived from his prior roles at and . Under Derman's leadership, the program prioritized instruction by active financial practitioners alongside academics, ensuring relevance to real-world market dynamics such as surfaces and term structure modeling. He fostered connections between the academic environment and Wall Street, exemplified by regular seminars featuring industry experts, which exposed students to current challenges in quantitative . This practitioner-oriented focus reflected Derman's view, articulated in his publications, that financial models must account for behavioral and empirical realities beyond . The MSFE program, during Derman's tenure, maintained its status as a selective graduate offering, admitting cohorts trained for roles in , hedge funds, and risk advisory, with coursework incorporating computational tools like for simulation and calibration of models such as the Black-Derman-Toy interest rate framework he co-developed. Upon his departure, Columbia Engineering recognized his contributions with a on May 3, 2023, honoring his impact on quantitative . Derman's status post-2023 allows continued affiliation, underscoring the program's enduring emphasis on rigorous, empirically grounded training.

Writings and Publications

Autobiographical Memoir: My Life as a Quant

"My Life as a Quant: Reflections on and " is Emanuel Derman's 2004 autobiographical , published by John Wiley & Sons, detailing his transition from to quantitative . The book spans Derman's early experiences, academic struggles, and professional evolution, emphasizing the cultural and intellectual contrasts between pure science and Wall Street's pragmatic demands. Derman recounts arriving in from , , in 1966 to pursue a PhD in physics at , a process that took seven years until completion in 1973 amid personal isolation and cultural adjustment. During this period, he met his future wife, Eva, while grappling with the rigidities of academic physics and growing disillusionment with reductionist approaches under funding pressures. The memoir's middle sections explore Derman's postdoctoral years, including a stint at Oxford University that shifted his perspectives on scientific inquiry, followed by the uncertainties of postdoc life marked by temporary positions and intellectual highs alongside financial lows. Facing limited prospects in academia, Derman pivoted to finance in the early 1980s, joining as one of the pioneering physicists applying mathematical modeling to markets. He describes developing key tools like the Black-Derman-Toy interest rate model, which calibrated term structures using short-rate dynamics, and reflects on collaborating with figures such as . These chapters highlight the memoir's core tension: physics' pursuit of universal truths versus finance's episodic, human-driven volatility, where models serve as approximations rather than immutable laws. Later portions delve into Derman's rise to head of quantitative strategies at , interweaving technical anecdotes with philosophical musings on the perils of over-relying on mathematical abstractions in unpredictable markets. The book critiques the hubris in equating financial models with physical theories, arguing that finance demands humility toward emergent behaviors absent in controlled experiments. Reception has been positive among quants and academics for its candid portrayal of interdisciplinary migration, though some reviewers note its technical depth may alienate non-specialists. Named one of BusinessWeek's top business books of 2004, it underscores Derman's role in bridging scientific rigor with .

Critique of Modeling: Models.Behaving.Badly

In Models.Behaving.Badly: Why Confusing Illusion with Reality Can Lead to Disaster, on and in Life, published in , Emanuel Derman critiques the pervasive misuse of quantitative financial models by drawing on his experience as a physicist-turned-quant. He contends that these models, often imported from physics, function as imperfect analogies or metaphors rather than robust theories, yet practitioners and regulators treat them as infallible predictors of market behavior, fostering overconfidence and systemic risks. Derman delineates a fundamental distinction between scientific theories and financial models: theories, such as in or Dirac's equation in , provide standalone, essential descriptions of natural laws that hold independently of human interpretation. In contrast, financial models—like the Black-Scholes option pricing formula—are provisional fictions that analogize complex human-driven phenomena (e.g., proxying with ) to simpler physical processes, remaining contingent on subjective assumptions about investor psychology and . This relativism renders them prone to "behaving badly" when markets deviate from modeled equilibria, as human value judgments shift unpredictably unlike inanimate physical systems. Specific targets of Derman's critique include the (CAPM) and the Efficient Market Model (EMM), which he dismantles as non-theories masquerading as axiomatic truths; CAPM fails to reliably dictate expected returns because it overlooks variable human risk tolerances, while EMM's assumption of perpetual market efficiency ignores behavioral anomalies and contributed to the complacency preceding the 2007–2008 financial crisis. He argues that even "riskless" assets like long-term bonds carry unmodeled interest rate risks, and abstract frameworks like the so-called Fundamental Theorem of Finance mislead by implying universality absent in human-centric economics. Overreliance on such models, Derman asserts, amplified the crisis by providing illusory precision in pricing illiquid securities and underestimating tail risks. To mitigate these pitfalls, Derman advocates a "Modeler's Hippocratic Oath," urging practitioners to eschew mathematical intimidation, explicitly disclose assumptions, avoid axiomatizing models as eternal truths, and deploy them judiciously—for instance, as tools for interpolating prices of liquid assets to illiquid ones or ranking securities relative to intuition, rather than as oracles for absolute valuation. He emphasizes integrating models with human intuition, recognizing their role in transforming vague sentiments (e.g., via ) into actionable insights, while maintaining humility about their metaphorical limits to prevent conflating with .

Technical Works: The Volatility Smile

In the early 1990s, Emanuel Derman, while at , co-authored influential research addressing the , a pattern in options markets where implied volatilities derived from Black-Scholes-Merton (BSM) prices vary non-monotonically with strike prices, forming a U-shaped curve that contradicts the BSM model's constant volatility assumption. This phenomenon, observed prominently in equity index options following the 1987 crash, implied higher volatilities for deep in-the-money and out-of-the-money strikes, reflecting market expectations of fat-tailed return distributions and . Derman and Iraj Kani's 1994 paper, "The Volatility Smile and Its Implied Tree," introduced a binomial lattice model—termed the implied binomial tree—that calibrates to observed option prices to infer a state-dependent local function consistent with the . The approach constructs a recombining tree where transition probabilities and local volatilities are iteratively adjusted to match market-implied volatilities across strikes and maturities, enabling arbitrage-free pricing of exotic derivatives like barriers and Asians without assuming processes. This local volatility framework, σ(S,t), posits volatility as a deterministic function of underlying price S and time t, derived via Dupire's relating local to implied volatilities: ∂C/∂T = (1/2) σ²(K,T) K² ∂²C/∂K², where C is price. The implied tree method gained practical adoption in quantitative finance for its computational tractability and market consistency, influencing subsequent models like stochastic volatility extensions (e.g., ) while highlighting limitations such as forward-skew inconsistencies in short-term smiles. Derman's work emphasized empirical over theoretical purity, arguing that models should replicate observed prices rather than impose unrealistic constancy. In 2016, Derman co-authored The Volatility Smile with Michael B. Miller, a comprehensive synthesizing these ideas with BSM foundations and extensions. Spanning 528 pages, the book devotes its first half to BSM derivations, including the analogy and risk-neutral valuation, before advancing to smile-consistent models like and jump-diffusions. It provides pedagogical tools, such as numerical examples and code for tree construction, aimed at students and practitioners, while critiquing over-reliance on BSM by demonstrating how smiles reveal regime shifts in market dynamics, such as post-crash leverage effects. The text underscores valuation principles like no-arbitrage and completeness, positioning the smile as a diagnostic for model inadequacy rather than mere .

Personal Reflections: Brief Hours and Weeks

Brief Hours and Weeks: My Life as a Capetonian is a memoir published by Emanuel Derman on March 1, 2025, chronicling his upbringing in , , within a close-knit, first-generation Polish-Jewish immigrant community during the 1940s, 1950s, and 1960s. The narrative spans Derman's first 21 years, from his birth on July 3, 1945, until his emigration to the in 1966 to pursue a PhD in physics at . In the book, Derman reflects on familial resilience amid historical traumas, particularly his mother's immigration from in the 1930s and the subsequent annihilation of her extended family in the Brześć Ghetto by 1942 during . His mother emerges as a central figure, embodying , devotion to family, and a cultural ideal of eidelkeit—a Yiddish-inflected notion of refinement and moral decency prized by Eastern European Jewish immigrants. Derman contemplates her endurance, including her support for surviving relatives like siblings in , while raising him and his sisters, Shulamit and Ruth, and later facing her own diagnosis of (ALS) in 1970, which she bore for nine years. The memoir weaves personal anecdotes with observations of community life, such as neighbors seeking solace from his mother over tea and cupcakes, and vignettes of figures like the lonely Mrs. Gold, whose chapter Nobel laureate praised as a "triumph" for evocatively capturing mid-20th-century . These reflections underscore themes of quiet fortitude against loss and the immigrant pursuit of cultural continuity in a distant colonial outpost, evoking shared memories of the city's pre-apartheid social fabric for contemporaries like Coetzee. Derman questions the enduring value of eidelkeit in such transplanted lives, framing his early experiences as formative to his later transitions into physics and .

Philosophical Views on Financial Modeling

Limitations of Mathematical Models in Finance

Derman argues that mathematical models in finance function as provisional approximations or metaphors rather than absolute theories akin to those in physics, leading to inherent limitations when they are misconstrued as depictions of reality. Unlike physical theories, which derive from repeatable experiments and fundamental laws, financial models calibrate historical data to interpolate prices or rank securities but cannot reliably predict outcomes in human-driven markets subject to shifting expectations and behaviors. This distinction underscores their shallowness: models simplify complex realities, such as investor psychology, into explicit but temporary assumptions, like the in the Black-Scholes framework, which assumes constant volatility and fails during market panics when actual volatility spikes. A core limitation is the inability to verify models through controlled testing, as involves coupled systems influenced by collective human actions rather than isolated, law-governed phenomena. Derman highlights how overreliance on statistical parameters, such as correlations in (CDO) models, reduces profound uncertainty to quantifiable risk, masking tail events and fostering complacency. For instance, pre-2008 models priced mortgage-backed securities by extrapolating benign historical correlations, ignoring endogenous loops where rising s amplified systemic stress, thus contributing to widespread mispricing. These tools excel in stable regimes for pricing similar assets but "behave badly" when markets deviate from calibrated conditions, as human greed, fear, and defy the ergodic assumptions embedded in many quantitative frameworks. Derman emphasizes that progress in modeling is fleeting, with markets continually evolving and rendering prior formulations obsolete, necessitating ongoing recalibration rather than static reliance. Simple, transparent models with clear assumptions—such as early versions of Black-Scholes—are preferable to opaque, complex ones, yet even these demand supplementation with intuition and common sense to mitigate risks of illusionary precision. He critiques the tendency in finance to elevate models to theoretical status, akin to confusing a map with the territory, which erodes judgment and amplifies crises by encouraging leverage on flawed probabilities. While not the sole cause of events like the , this exacerbates vulnerabilities, as models break down amid that transcends probabilistic .

Distinction Between Models, Theories, and Reality

Derman delineates theories as absolute descriptions that reveal the intrinsic nature of phenomena, providing deep, non-metaphorical insights into reality itself. In physics, for instance, or exemplify theories by unifying observable behaviors with underlying principles, effectively becoming indistinguishable from the truths they describe. In contrast, models function as relative analogies or metaphors, approximating what something is "partially like" rather than what it fundamentally is, often by reducing complexity and focusing on selective aspects. Derman describes models as simplifications that "sweep dirt under the rug," such as the Black-Scholes option pricing model, which analogizes stock price movements to but ignores broader market dynamics like human or regime shifts. These constructs require ongoing calibration and defense, lacking the self-evident depth of theories. Reality, for Derman, transcends both, as models inevitably distort it through their partiality, leading to peril when practitioners—particularly in —mistake them for comprehensive truths. He argues that 's reliance on such models, unlike physics' theoretical foundations, fosters illusions of precision, as seen in the where oversimplified risk models failed amid unmodeled correlations and liquidity evaporation. This confusion arises because models interpolate and predict within narrow bounds but crumble when extrapolated to unprecedented events, underscoring the need for in their application.

Implications for Financial Crises and Risk

Derman contends that the overreliance on quantitative financial models exacerbates crises by promoting a false sense of precision in risk assessment, as these models assume stationary market behaviors akin to physical laws, which unravel amid human-driven shifts in expectations and liquidity during stress events. In the 2007–2008 subprime mortgage collapse, for instance, models pricing collateralized debt obligations (CDOs) simplified complex default correlations into optimistic parameters, masking contagion risks and leading to trillions in losses when illiquidity and panic deviated from calibrated assumptions. This failure stems from finance's dependence on probabilistic approximations rather than verifiable experiments, unlike physics, where repeatable tests refine theories to high accuracy. For , Derman's framework underscores the peril of conflating quantifiable risk—measurable via standard deviations or Value-at-Risk—with deeper uncertainty arising from non-stationary human actions, which models inherently undervalue in tail events. He advocates treating models as pragmatic tools for interpolation within familiar regimes, supplemented by qualitative overlays like scenario analysis and common-sense judgment, rather than as oracles that invite complacency. Crises amplify this when models "behave badly," as behavioral changes invalidate inputs, prompting cascading failures; Derman notes that allowing failures without bailouts could instill greater caution than regulatory tweaks alone. Broader implications include reforming incentives to counter , such as reinstating personal liability for executives or imposing trading frictions, over enhancing model sophistication, since greed and short-termism in public firms often override mathematical safeguards. Derman warns that unlearned lessons from persist, with larger banks posing amplified systemic threats if model illusions continue to obscure reality. Ultimately, his views urge humility in quantitative finance: models mitigate routine risks but cannot engineer crisis-proof systems, demanding vigilance against their metaphorical limits to avert recurring disasters.

Legacy and Influence

Impact on Quantitative Finance

Emanuel Derman's development of the Derman-Kani binomial tree model in 1994 introduced a framework for constructing implied trees that reconcile market-observed option prices with no-arbitrage constraints, enabling the extraction of local volatility surfaces directly from implied volatilities. This local volatility approach, which posits that volatility is a deterministic of both time and asset price, provided quants with a practical tool for pricing exotic options and hedging derivatives portfolios more accurately than constant-volatility assumptions in the Black-Scholes model. The model's influence persists, as it forms the basis for calibrating volatility dynamics in equity and index derivatives trading, with implementations still used in desks for forecasting. In collaboration with and William Toy, Derman co-authored the Black-Derman-Toy model in 1987, a that generalized the Ho-Lee framework by incorporating time-dependent volatility and mean reversion, allowing for the fitting of the entire term structure to observed bond prices. This model advanced pricing at institutions like , where Derman applied it to value mortgage-backed securities and swaptions, influencing practices during the 1990s fixed-income boom. Its assumption for short rates addressed limitations in earlier models, promoting widespread adoption in quantitative strategies for term structure modeling. Derman's 1996 paper "Model Risk" quantified the uncertainties inherent in financial models by demonstrating how small parameter perturbations could lead to significant valuation discrepancies, prompting quants to incorporate model risk into Value-at-Risk calculations and stress testing. This work, grounded in empirical analysis of equity and fixed-income models, shifted industry practices toward ensemble modeling and sensitivity analysis, evidenced by its integration into regulatory frameworks like Basel II's model validation requirements. His contributions overall bridged physics-inspired stochastic processes with market realities, training generations of practitioners through Columbia's financial engineering program and fostering a more rigorous approach to volatility and risk quantification in quantitative finance.

Reception and Criticisms of Derman's Work

Derman's memoir My Life as a Quant: Reflections on Physics and Finance, published in 2004, received generally positive reviews for its candid depiction of a physicist's transition to Wall Street and the intellectual challenges of applying scientific methods to finance. Critics praised its authenticity and insights into the pioneering era of quantitative roles at firms like Goldman Sachs, with one reviewer noting Derman's "mature curiosity" as a hallmark of his scientific approach to markets. However, some readers found it underwhelming in fulfilling promises of deep quantitative revelations, rating it lower for lacking excitement in finance sections compared to physics anecdotes. His 2011 book Models.Behaving.Badly: Why Confusing Illusion with Reality Can Lead to Disaster, on and in Life earned acclaim for its philosophical distinction between pragmatic financial models—as relative analogies rather than absolute theories—and its call for modeler humility via a proposed "." Reviewers highlighted its prescience in critiquing overreliance on models like the and , which contributed to the 2008 crisis by fostering undue confidence in predictability. The work's elegant prose and warnings against "mathematical idolatry" resonated in post-crisis debates on model risk. Yet, some faulted Derman for excessive harshness toward the efficient market model, arguing he mischaracterizes it as asserting constant efficiency rather than efficiency under specified assumptions, thereby downplaying its descriptive utility. Derman's technical contributions, including co-development of the Black-Derman-Toy model in 1987 and the Derman-Kani local volatility framework in the early 1990s, have profoundly influenced and remain integral to quantitative finance practices. His analyses of the —documenting patterns contradicting Black-Scholes constant assumptions post-1987 crash—gained wide adoption, enabling better hedging in options markets across equities, currencies, and rates. These innovations addressed empirical anomalies but faced implicit criticism in their failure to fully anticipate tail risks during crises, underscoring Derman's own later emphasis on models' human-dependent limitations. Broader critiques of Derman's oeuvre center on perceived undue pessimism about quantitative methods' scientific aspirations, with some arguing his views risk eroding in tools that have enabled trillions in efficient transfer despite inherent flaws. Proponents counter that his advocacy for viewing models as "useful fictions" has enhanced awareness, influencing regulatory scrutiny and training without rejecting modeling outright.

References

  1. [1]
    Emanuel Derman | Columbia Engineering
    Emanuel Derman is Professor of Practice Emeritus at Columbia University ... Goldman Sachs & Co. in 1997. The financial models he developed there, the ...
  2. [2]
    Black-Derman-Toy Model Developed by Team at Goldman Sachs
    At his desk at Goldman Sachs, Fischer Black worked with Emanuel Derman and Bill Toy to create a remarkably simple model to value most fixed income derivatives.
  3. [3]
    About Me - Emanuel Derman
    Emanuel Derman is Professor of Practice Emeritus at Columbia University, where he directed their program in financial engineering from 2003 – 2023.
  4. [4]
    Books by Emanuel Derman
    Books by Emanuel Derman · Brief Hours and Weeks: My Life as a Capetonian · Models. Behaving. Badly · My Life as a Quant · The Volatility Smile.
  5. [5]
    A Book Review: Models.Behaving.Badly. By Emanuel Derman
    Nov 21, 2011 · An extensive biographical sketch of his childhood and youth in Cape Town, son of Jews who fled Poland in the mid-30's ahead of the Holocaust, ...Missing: background | Show results with:background
  6. [6]
    Brief Hours and Weeks: My LIfe as a Capetonian - Emanuel Derman
    Feb 28, 2025 · Derman was born in South Africa but has spent most of his professional years in Manhattan in New York City, where he has made contributions to ...
  7. [7]
    An Excerpt from Emanuel Derman's Brief Hours and Weeks: My Life ...
    Feb 28, 2025 · Friend of WITI and contributor Emanuel Derman wrote the excellent memoir, My Life as a Quant. Now, he winds back the clock from the world of ...
  8. [8]
    Herzlia Foundation & Alumni Association - Robynne Esther
    Jul 10, 2019 · A few months back I had the great privilege of meeting one of my students grandfathers Emanuel Derman, a Herzlia matriculant of 1961. Emanuel ...
  9. [9]
    Financial Engineer of the Year - Emanuel Derman
    Sep 7, 2000 · Dr. Derman was born in South Africa. He obtained a B.Sc. (Hons) in Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics at the University of Cape Town, ...Missing: childhood family background
  10. [10]
    The Worlds of Yesterday - Emanuel Derman
    Sep 6, 2013 · I began by studying physics, chemistry, pure and applied math. I liked theory, was bad at lab work. In my second year I dropped chemistry and ...
  11. [11]
    [PDF] Theories, Models and Metaphors in Science & Finance - SOA
    Mar 22, 2010 · ♢ Emanuel Derman, PhD. Emanuel is the Head of Risk Management at ... Professor Derman holds a BS degree from the University of Cape ...
  12. [12]
    Short Bio - Emanuel Derman
    Dec 1, 2007 · Emanuel Derman is a professor at Columbia University and director of their program in financial engineering. His book, My Life as A Quant: ...
  13. [13]
    Emanuel DERMAN | Faculty Member | Doctor of Philosophy
    Emanuel Derman currently works at the Department of Industrial Engineering and Operations Research, Columbia University, where he is cohead of the financial ...Missing: education background
  14. [14]
    [PDF] A Calculus of Risk - Emanuel Derman
    Derman, a native of Cape Town, South Africa, received his doctorate from Columbia University in 1973 for a thesis ... and charmed quark production at the ...Missing: PhD | Show results with:PhD
  15. [15]
    My Life as a Quant: Reflections on Physics and Finance
    My Life as a Quant recounts the evolution of Derman's life, from his youth in Cape Town, South Africa to the Wall Street firm Goldman Sachs where Derman spent ...
  16. [16]
    Dimuon Production in a Quark-Parton Model - INSPIRE
    ... particle physics* 250-256. •. DOI: 10.1016/0370-2693(73)90702-8. edit ... Emanuel Derman(. Pennsylvania U. ) ,. John N. Ng(. Pennsylvania U. ) Phys.Rev.Lett ...
  17. [17]
    Emanuel Derman - Inspire HEP
    Nov 19, 2022 · Emanuel Derman · L.N. Chang(. Pennsylvania U. ) , · E. Derman(. Pennsylvania U. ) , · J.N. Ng(. Pennsylvania U. ) (1975). Published ...
  18. [18]
    Emanuel Derman - Columbia Engineering Magazine
    Six years in postdoctoral positions in theoretical particle physics at U. of Pennsylvania, Oxford University and The Rockefeller University. · Assistant ...
  19. [19]
    Emanuel Derman on Theories, Models, and Science - Econlib
    Mar 12, 2012 · Derman, a former physicist and Goldman Sachs quant [quantitative analyst], contrasts the search for truth in the sciences with the search for ...
  20. [20]
    The great escape to Wall Street - Physics World
    May 31, 2005 · His opinions on the elusive unified theory of financial economics are required reading for physicists who are contemplating a career change but ...
  21. [21]
    They Tried to Outsmart Wall Street - The New York Times
    Mar 9, 2009 · After spending 20 years in the study of physics, Emanuel Derman applied his thinking to stock options.
  22. [22]
  23. [23]
    CFM Talks To: Emanuel Derman - Capital Fund Management
    Aug 28, 2019 · ... Black and Bill Toy, what was to become known as the BDT, or Black-Derman-Toy model, a popular model used for pricing interest rate derivatives.
  24. [24]
    Odd Lots: How a Former Physicist Helped Revolutionize Wall Street
    Jul 11, 2016 · Derman went from studying physics to Goldman Sachs in 1985 near the dawn of a revolution in how markets traded and assets were valued. In ...
  25. [25]
    [PDF] A One-Factor Model Of Interest Rates And Its Application To
    A One-Factor Model Of Interest Rates And Its Application To. Black, Fischer; Derman, Emanuel; Toy, William. Financial Analysts Journal; Jan/Feb 1990; 46, 1; ...
  26. [26]
    One on One Interview with Emanuel Derman (Financial Engineering ...
    Jan 1, 2003 · He received his Ph.D. in theoretical particle physics from Columbia University in 1973 and taught at a few universities, before landing at AT&T ...
  27. [27]
    A One-Factor Model of Interest Rates and Its Application to Treasury ...
    Dec 31, 2018 · A One-Factor Model of Interest Rates and Its Application to Treasury Bond Options. Fischer Black. ,. Emanuel Derman. &. William Toy.
  28. [28]
    Excerpt of My Life as a Quant in Financial Engineering News
    Sep 2, 2004 · Financial Engineering News is pleased to publish this excerpt from the new book by Dr. Emanuel Derman “My Life As A Quant: Reflections on ...Missing: transition | Show results with:transition
  29. [29]
    [PDF] The Volatility Smile and Its Implied Tree
    Jan 31, 1994 · You can use this implied tree to value other derivatives whose prices are not readily available from the market – standard but illiquid.
  30. [30]
    The Volatility Smile and Its Implied Tree - Emanuel Derman
    Feb 1, 1994 · In this paper we show how you can use the smile – the prices of known, liquid, European-style index options of all available strikes and ...
  31. [31]
    Trading Volatility by Emanuel Derman :: SSRN
    Aug 13, 2019 · It is a social-science model, an attempt to describe the unpredictable behavior of a stock price and the value of options that depends on that price.Missing: contributions | Show results with:contributions
  32. [32]
    [PDF] The Local Volatility Surface | Emanuel Derman
    In this report we explain the local volatility surface, give examples of its applications, and propose sev- eral heuristic rules of thumb for understanding the.
  33. [33]
    (PDF) The Local Volatility Surface: Unlocking the Information in ...
    This article explains the concept of local volatility and its use. It also presents three heuristic rules that relate local and implied volatilities.
  34. [34]
    Local Volatility Models - The Volatility Smile - Wiley Online Library
    In a local volatility model, the instantaneous stock volatility σ(S, t) is a function of stock price and future time. How to build and use a binomial tree ...
  35. [35]
    (PDF) More Than You Ever Wanted to Know About Volatility Swaps
    1997 Is the Volatility Skew Fair? Emanuel Derman, Michael Kamal, Iraj Kani ... pricing derivative products whose valuation depends on volatility surfaces.
  36. [36]
    Trading Volatility | Emanuel Derman - Inference Review
    The Black–Scholes equation takes the idea of Brownian motion from physics and uses it to explain volatility in stock options markets. Emanuel Derman reviews ...
  37. [37]
    ‪Emanuel Derman‬ - ‪Google Scholar‬
    Emanuel Derman. Professor, Columbia University. Verified email at ... Goldman Sachs Quantitative Strategies Research Notes 2, 45-60, 1994. 340, 1994.
  38. [38]
    [PDF] Beyond Mont Pèlerin: South African Physicist Bankers in a World ...
    Jan 21, 2025 · ... Goldman. Sachs was Emanuel Derman who had been headhunted from Bell labs in 1985. The importance of Derman's role at Goldman Sachs ... tenure ...<|separator|>
  39. [39]
    Goldman?s Head Quant Derman to Retire (Risk Magazine, 22 May ...
    Sep 6, 2013 · 22 May – Emanuel Derman, head of Goldman Sachs' quantitative risk strategies group in firmwide risk, will retire from the firm in June.
  40. [40]
    Announcement by Risk Magazine Top 50 Hall of Fame
    Sep 6, 2013 · Derman was a physicist before making the leap to Wall Street. In 1973, he earned a PhD in particle physics at Columbia, and went on to teach ...
  41. [41]
    Emanuel Derman - Isenberg School of Management : UMass Amherst
    Emanuel Derman. Professor of Practice Emeritus, Financial Engineering ... Goldman Sachs & Co. in 1997. The financial models he developed there, the ...
  42. [42]
    The Purpose of Risk Management - Emanuel Derman
    Mar 13, 2007 · One of the things he said is that the purpose of risk management is neither to control nor measure risk, but rather to make risk transparent.Missing: career positions
  43. [43]
    Events - A day to honor Emanuel Derman's accomplishments ... - CFE
    Under Emanuel Derman's leadership, the Quantitative Strategies group at Goldman Sachs made important contributions in these areas, focusing on equity ...
  44. [44]
    Emanuel Derman - Big Think
    He has a PhD in theoretical physics from Columbia University and is the author of numerous articles in elementary particle physics, computer science, and ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  45. [45]
    Can Risk Managers Manage Risk? - Harvard Business Review
    Veteran quant Emanuel Derman, trained as a physicist, used to be head of quantitative strategies at Goldman Sachs. He says such blind spots are inherent in any ...
  46. [46]
    Emanuel Derman | The Guardian
    Jun 29, 2014 · Emanuel Derman is co-head of risk at Prisma Capital Partners and a professor at Columbia University, where he directs their program in financial engineering.
  47. [47]
    [PDF] Certified Portfolio Manager (CPM®) Program
    Emanuel Derman. Professor Emanuel Derman joined Columbia University's Industrial Engineering and Operations Research. Department in 2003 where he is the ...
  48. [48]
    Term-Structure and Credit Derivatives - Coursera
    Offered by Columbia University. This course will focus on capturing the evolution of interest rates and providing deep insight into credit .
  49. [49]
    [PDF] FINANCIAL ENGINEERING
    The core curriculum includes courses in stochastic processes, optimization, numerical techniques, Monte Carlo simulation, and data analysis. Students also study ...
  50. [50]
    Emanuel Derman - MathWorks
    Emanuel Derman is a professor at Columbia University, where he directs their program in financial engineering. He started out as a theoretical physicist, doing ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  51. [51]
    My Life as a Quant: Reflections on Physics and Finance | Wiley
    Free delivery 30-day returnsIn My Life as a Quant, Emanuel Derman relives his exciting journey as one of the first high-energy particle physicists to migrate to Wall Street.Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  52. [52]
    My Life as a Quant Summary of Key Ideas and Review - Blinkist
    Rating 4.0 (16) My Life as a Quant (2004) tells the unique story of what happens when a theoretical physicist swaps particle accelerators for Wall Street trading floors. It ...
  53. [53]
    My Life as a Quant: Reflections on Physics and Finance - Amazon.com
    30-day returnsIn My Life as a Quant, Emanuel Derman relives his exciting journey as one of the first high-energy particle physicists to migrate to Wall Street.
  54. [54]
    My Life as a Quant - Emanuel Derman
    My Life as a Quant Reviewed in the Financial Times by Stefan Stern · Excerpt of My Life as a Quant in Financial Engineering News. Other Books by Emanuel Derman.
  55. [55]
    Interview with Emanuel Derman - QuantNet
    Sep 21, 2009 · Emanuel Derman is best known as a quantitative analyst, and author of the book My Life as a Quant: Reflections on Physics and Finance.Missing: childhood | Show results with:childhood
  56. [56]
    Models.Behaving.Badly. | Book by Emanuel Derman
    The truth is somewhere in between. In this book I will argue that there are three distinct ways of understanding the world: theories, models, and intuition.
  57. [57]
    Emanuel Derman's Models.Behaving.Badly. - Mathbabe
    Oct 25, 2011 · This morning I want to talk about Emanuel Derman's beautifully written and wise new book “Models. Behaving. Badly.”, available in some book ...Missing: summary critique
  58. [58]
    Models Behaving Badly : Summary | Book Reviews
    Oct 30, 2011 · Emanuel Derman's book, “Models.Behaving.Badly”, gives a physicist and quant's perspective of models Vs theories, their nature, ...Missing: critique | Show results with:critique
  59. [59]
    Models.Behaving.Badly.: Why Confusing Illusion with Reality Can ...
    Sep 7, 2017 · Models.Behaving.Badly.: Why Confusing Illusion with Reality Can Lead to Disaster, on Wall Street and in Life (a review) · Share on Facebook ...Missing: critique | Show results with:critique
  60. [60]
  61. [61]
    [PDF] TRADING VOLATILITY AS AN ASSET CLASS - Emanuel Derman
    WHY TRADE VOLATILITY? Volatility is the simplest measure of a stock's riskiness or uncertainty. Different types: realized volatility, implied volatility, local ...
  62. [62]
    The Volatility Smile - Emanuel Derman, Michael B. Miller
    The Volatility Smile presents a unified treatment of the Black-Scholes-Merton model and the more advanced models that have replaced it. It is also a book about ...
  63. [63]
    The Volatility Smile (Wiley Finance) - Amazon.com
    The Volatility Smile presents a unified treatment of the Black-Scholes-Merton model and the more advanced models that have replaced it.
  64. [64]
    The Volatility Smile | Wiley Online Books
    The Volatility Smile ; Author(s):. Emanuel Derman, Michael B. Miller, ; First published:26 August 2016 ; Print ISBN:9781118959169 | ; Online ISBN: ...
  65. [65]
    Emanuel Derman Brief Hours and Weeks (Hardback) | eBay
    Author: Emanuel Derman. Format: Hardback. Title: Brief Hours and Weeks. Release Year: 2025. Release Date: 03/01/2025. Subtitle: My Life as a Capetonian.
  66. [66]
    Brief Hours and Weeks by Emanuel Derman on Apple Books
    Brief Hours and Weeks is the author's account of growing up in a small, tightly knit, first-generation Polish-Jewish community in Cape Town in the 1940s, ...
  67. [67]
    Emanuel Derman - Prabook
    Derman, Emanuel was born on July 3, 1945 in Cape Town, South Africa. Came to the United States, 1966. Son of Chaim and Sonia Derman. Education.
  68. [68]
    J M Coetzee on my new book, Brief Hours and Weeks
    Feb 6, 2025 · “Brief Hours and Weeks awakes many memories of Cape Town, the city of Emanuel Derman's youth and mine, as it was half a century ago.
  69. [69]
    The Financial Modelers' Manifesto - Emanuel Derman
    Jan 8, 2009 · Progress in financial modeling is fleeting and temporary. Markets change and newer models become necessary. Simple clear models with explicit ...
  70. [70]
    [PDF] Models Behaving Badly - QWAFAFEW Boston
    Economists don't understand the difference between theorems and laws. ▫ Economists have fallen in love with mathematics, rigor and formalism for their own ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  71. [71]
    METAPHORS, MODELS & THEORIES - Edge.org
    Nov 30, 2010 · Theories tell you what something is. Models tell you merely what something is partially like. Emanuel Derman is physicist and a former managing ...
  72. [72]
    [PDF] The Financial Modelers' Manifesto - SOA
    It's a different story with finance and economics, which are concerned with the mental world of monetary value. The Financial Modelers' Manifesto. By Emanuel ...
  73. [73]
    BREAKING THE CYCLE: A Conversation With Emanuel Derman
    May 27, 2010 · ... Rockefeller University and president of The New York Academy of Sciences. ... EMANUEL DERMAN, a former managing director and head of the ...
  74. [74]
    [PDF] STOCHASTIC IMPLIED TREES: ARBITRAGE PRICING WITH ...
    In this paper we present an arbitrage pricing framework for valuing and hedging contingent equity index claims in the presence of a stochastic term and ...
  75. [75]
    New QuantSpeak Episode with Emanuel Derman - Wilmott
    Jun 26, 2024 · He received his Ph.D. in theoretical physics in 1973 and initially struggled to find jobs and gain tenure in academic roles, despite his passion ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  76. [76]
    Financial Engineers Behaving Boldly: Emanuel Derman
    Jun 19, 2012 · Nobody personifies a “quant” like Emanuel Derman. First, there is his educational pedigree: After earning a PhD in theoretical particle physics ...
  77. [77]
    Review of “My Life as a Quant” and “The Quants” by Wight Martindale
    Jan 18, 2024 · Derman, a South African native who received his Ph.D. in theoretical physics from Columbia in 1973 and then migrated to the Quantitative ...<|separator|>
  78. [78]
    October | 2006 - This Blog Needs No Name
    Oct 7, 2006 · Given the numerous 5-star reviews the book got, I was sorely disappointed with it. The book really does not live up to any of the promises of ...
  79. [79]
    None
    Nothing is retrieved...<|separator|>
  80. [80]
    [PDF] Laughter in the Dark - The Problem of the Volatility Smile
    The smile phenomenon has spread to stock options, interest-rate options, currency options, and almost ever other volatility mar- ket. Since the ...
  81. [81]
    Q&A: Emanuel Derman on model risks, why quantitative finance is ...
    Oct 3, 2011 · The use of advanced mathematics and techniques from physics helped give credibility to the financial models that proved inadequate in the ...