Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Feedback Hub

Feedback Hub is a free universal Windows application developed by , pre-installed on and devices, that enables users to report problems, submit suggestions, and provide feedback on Windows operating system features, apps, and related Microsoft products to help improve and software quality. Launched on May 13, 2016, as part of Microsoft's efforts to enhance user involvement in product development, particularly through the Windows Insider Program, Feedback Hub replaced earlier feedback mechanisms and integrated directly into the Windows ecosystem to streamline the collection of actionable insights from millions of users worldwide. The app's core functionality allows users to categorize submissions as either problems (e.g., bugs or crashes) or suggestions (e.g., feature requests), with options to search for existing similar feedback, upvote others' submissions, attach screenshots, files, or diagnostic data, and track the status of their input through community interactions. For Windows Insider participants, additional sections include Announcements for official updates, Quests for guided testing tasks that earn badges, and Achievements to recognize active contributors, fostering a gamified approach to beta testing and iterative improvements. Accessible via the search, the + F shortcut, or the , Feedback Hub requires a sign-in for full features like submission tracking and , ensuring is tied to specific devices and user profiles for targeted resolutions by engineers. Over time, updates have expanded its capabilities, such as advanced diagnostics for detailed error reporting and integration with broader services, making it a central hub for continuous in the evolving Windows platform.

History

Windows Feedback

The Windows Feedback tool was introduced as part of the Windows 7 beta program in early 2009, enabling participants to submit comments, bug reports, and suggestions directly to during pre-release testing phases. Users accessed the tool through a prominent "Send Feedback" link integrated into the interface and applications, which required enrollment in Microsoft's Connect program to enable submissions. This mechanism facilitated real-time input from beta testers, helping refine the operating system before its general release. As part of the broader Windows Feedback Program launched in 2012, encouraged active customer involvement by streamlining the process of sharing insights on system performance and usability during development. The dedicated Windows Feedback app was introduced with the Windows 10 Technical Preview in October 2014, available via the Windows Store and serving as a platform for users to report bugs and offer feature suggestions beyond beta testing. Key features of the Windows Feedback tool and app included diagnostic data collection, such as automatic screenshots, system configuration details, and crash logs, allowing users to attach relevant evidence to their submissions for more effective analysis by engineers. These elements enabled direct, contextual transmission during pre-release evaluations, contributing to iterative improvements in Windows development. Microsoft announced the deprecation of the Windows Feedback app in 2016, coinciding with the Anniversary Update, as it was succeeded by more advanced feedback mechanisms. This shift briefly referenced a transition to the Insider Hub as a specialized tool for beta users.

Insider Hub

The Insider Hub app was launched on November 12, 2014, as part of Build 9879 for the Fast ring of the Program, coinciding with the early preview phases of Windows 10. This release marked the app's debut alongside the broader initiative, which had been announced in September 2014 to gather beta tester input for refining the upcoming operating system. Designed exclusively for participants, it served as a dedicated companion tool to the existing Windows Feedback app used by non-Insider users for general suggestions. The app's primary functions centered on providing tailored resources for testers, including access to detailed build notes that outlined changes in preview releases and flight information detailing rollout schedules across rings like Fast and Slow. It also facilitated feedback submission by integrating directly with the Windows Feedback app, allowing Insiders to report issues encountered during testing. These features enabled users to stay informed about ongoing developments without navigating external sites, streamlining the testing process for previews. Insider Hub played a key role in fostering two-way communication between and the Insider community, featuring news feeds that delivered program announcements, quests for targeted input, and notifications for critical updates. It supported diagnostic uploads through its linkage to the , where users could attach logs and reports to help engineers diagnose beta-specific . This bidirectional exchange was essential for iterative improvements, as engineers reviewed submissions to prioritize fixes and enhancements. During the early Windows 10 development phases from 2014 to 2016, Insider Hub saw widespread adoption, with the Program reaching over 1 million participants by October 2014 and more than 7 million by September 2015. Insiders submitted over 200,000 pieces of feedback by late 2014, escalating to more than 1 million by March 2015, underscoring the app's importance in shaping the final release in July 2015 and subsequent updates. By mid-2016, the collective input via the app had contributed to delivering to over 300 million devices, highlighting its pivotal role in the operating system's evolution.

Merger and Launch

In early 2016, Microsoft announced the merger of the Windows Feedback and Insider Hub apps into a unified application called Feedback Hub, aiming to create a centralized platform for both general user feedback and Windows Insider program updates. The merger was announced in mobile build 14283 on March 10, 2016, with the full Feedback Hub app rolling out to Windows Insiders in build 14291 on March 17, 2016, for PC and mobile, where the app combined the core functionalities of its predecessors while introducing enhancements like improved feedback organization and direct Microsoft responses. This merger addressed the need to streamline the feedback process, allowing Insiders to access program news alongside general users submitting suggestions and bug reports in one universal Windows app. Feedback Hub launched officially as a universal app for Windows Insiders on March 17, 2016, with general availability extended to all users on May 20, 2016, via the . The app's design emphasized ease of use across devices, enabling users to file feedback quickly and engage with community-voted items, motivated by Microsoft's goal to foster broader participation in improving Windows without separate tools for different user groups. With the release of the Anniversary Update (version 1607) on August 2, 2016, Feedback Hub became preinstalled as a default on new installations and upgrades, ensuring seamless integration for all users. This integration solidified its role as the primary feedback mechanism, reflecting Microsoft's commitment to a cohesive experience that bridged casual reporting and Insider contributions.

Features and Functionality

Submitting Feedback

Feedback Hub provides users with a streamlined interface for reporting bugs or submitting suggestions directly to Microsoft, enabling the collection of detailed input to improve Windows and related applications. The process begins with launching the app, either by searching for "Feedback Hub" in the Start menu or using the keyboard shortcut Windows key + F, which simultaneously captures a screenshot and opens the app for quick reporting. To submit new feedback, users first search the app's database for similar existing items to avoid duplication; if none match, they select "Give new feedback." The process involves entering a concise and optional , followed by selecting a category—either "Problem" for or "Suggestion" for requests—and refining it with a subcategory, such as specific apps or system components. For problem reports, users can indicate if the issue is blocking (preventing normal use) and provide step-by-step reproduction instructions. Attachments enhance submissions, including screenshots (captured via + PrtScn and attached from the Screenshots folder), screen recordings via the "Recreate my problem" or "Record my suggestion" tools to demonstrate issues in action, or other files like logs. Diagnostic data collection is integrated to aid troubleshooting, with options to include system logs, app crash dumps, and device performance metrics upon submission; crash dumps, which capture memory states from failures, are part of optional diagnostic data and may contain fragments of affected files. Privacy settings for these diagnostics are managed in Windows Settings under Privacy & security > Diagnostics & feedback, where users choose between required (basic device info) and optional (detailed error reports) levels, and can review data using the Diagnostic Data Viewer tool before it is sent. Submissions can be made anonymously without a Microsoft account, but signing in is required to search for existing feedback, upvote submissions, track status updates, and access community features. After finalizing details, users review the submission, optionally save a local copy, agree to diagnostic sharing if applicable, and select Submit to send it to Microsoft for review.

Community Engagement

Community engagement in Feedback Hub centers on mechanisms that allow users to interact with and prioritize feedback submitted by the community, fostering collective input on Windows improvements. After submitting new feedback items, users can discover and support existing ones through upvoting, which highlights popular requests by increasing their visibility based on vote counts. This feature encourages users to search for similar issues before creating duplicates, promoting efficiency in the feedback process. The app's search functionality enables users to browse and filter feedback effectively, using tools to query by keywords, categories (such as apps or settings), status (e.g., new, in progress, or completed), and popularity indicated by upvotes. help narrow down thousands of items, with visual aids like category icons and colors aiding quick identification during . Users can also on feedback items to provide additional context, share experiences, or express support, enriching discussions without requiring new submissions. To incentivize participation, Feedback Hub includes an achievement system where active users earn badges for actions like submitting , upvoting items, and completing quests related to the Program. These badges, such as those for top posters or consistent contributors, are tied to a user's and sync across devices, allowing seamless access to progress on multiple Windows machines. This gamification element rewards engagement while maintaining focus on quality contributions.

System Integration

Feedback Hub integrates seamlessly with the Windows ecosystem through authentication, enabling cross-device synchronization of user data. When signed in with a , the app syncs history in the "My " section, including submitted items, their statuses, and associated upvotes, allowing users to track contributions across multiple Windows devices. Drafts of unfinished submissions are also preserved and accessible on other signed-in devices, facilitating in reporting issues or suggestions. Achievements earned through participation, such as completing quests or consistent submission, are tied to the and sync accordingly for Windows Insiders, promoting ongoing engagement without data loss during device switches. The app maintains deep integration with the Program, routing feedback based on the user's enrolled flight to ensure submissions reach relevant development teams. Upon signing in with the Insider Program account, Feedback Hub automatically detects the current build and flight details, tagging submissions with precise version information to streamline and for preview features. This connectivity extends to Insider-specific elements like Announcements, which pull from official flight blog updates, and Quests, which guide users through targeted testing with progress tracked via synced achievements. Such routing enhances the program's iterative development process by channeling build-specific input directly to engineers. Accessibility is embedded in Feedback Hub's design, supporting screen readers such as Narrator, , and NVDA to ensure inclusive use within the Windows environment. Users can navigate the app entirely via keyboard, employing to move between elements, for selections in lists or filters, and Enter or Spacebar for actions like upvoting or posting comments. compatibility extends to core functions, including searching feedback, submitting new items, and reviewing drafts, with verbal announcements for interactive controls to aid low-vision users. Keyboard shortcuts, such as + F for quick access, further integrate with Windows-wide navigation standards. Feedback Hub connects to related Windows tools, notably , by automatically capturing build and upgrade-related diagnostics during submissions. For instance, when reporting upgrade errors, the app collects relevant log files and system details tied to the installed build, providing contextual data without manual intervention. This linkage supports of update issues, where users can attach screenshots or recordings directly, ensuring feedback includes precise environmental information for support teams.

Development and Updates

Version History

Feedback Hub was first made available to Windows Insiders in March 2016, merging the Windows Feedback and Insider Hub apps into a unified platform for user input. This initial version was made available to all Windows 10 users in May 2016, expanding beyond the Windows Insider Program. The app was integrated into the Anniversary Update (version 1607) in August 2016, allowing seamless access via the Win + F keyboard shortcut and embedding it as a core system component for feedback collection. Feedback Hub was updated to support following its release in October 2021. Recent developments as of October 2025 have included fixes, refinements for faster , enhanced compatibility with the latest Windows builds, resolutions for synchronization issues with cloud-based storage, and optimizations for performance on ARM-based devices. The merger of the original apps streamlined the process into a single interface. New capabilities have been added, including support for richer media attachments like videos and screen recordings to provide more detailed reports. All updates to Feedback Hub are delivered through the , with automatic servicing enabled by default to ensure users receive the latest versions without manual intervention.

Platform Support

Feedback Hub is natively available on starting from version 1607 (Anniversary Update, build 14393) and all subsequent versions, including , where it is preinstalled on consumer editions such as and . The app is bundled as a (UWP) application, automatically installed via on supported systems without requiring separate download from the . As a UWP app, Feedback Hub supports multiple processor architectures, including x86, x64, and (including ARM64), enabling it to run on a wide range of devices from desktops and laptops to tablets and ARM-based systems like those powered by processors. This multi-architecture compatibility extends to both traditional /AMD-based PCs and emerging ARM devices, supporting form factors that include mobile (historically via ) and modern hybrid devices like 2-in-1 convertibles. Access to Feedback Hub is limited to Windows ecosystems, with no native web-based or cross-platform versions available outside of the for UWP deployment. Users on non-Windows platforms cannot directly interact with the app, though feedback submission is confined to Windows environments. Following the end of support for on October 14, 2025, Feedback Hub on affected devices will no longer receive security updates or compatibility improvements, potentially limiting its functionality for submitting or viewing feedback on older installations. However, the app remains fully compatible with and ongoing Program previews, ensuring continued support for future Windows iterations.

Reception

Impact

Feedback Hub has significantly influenced Microsoft product development by enabling the implementation of user-suggested improvements across various applications and features. For instance, early user on the discoverability of full-screen mode in modern desktop apps, such as the and apps, prompted to relocate the full-screen button from the charms menu to the title bar in Build 9926, with further adjustments to its position in Build 10041 for better visibility. In , Insider suggestions have led to refinements like improved filtering for recommended websites on the and updates to the for easier sign-out access. These changes demonstrate how targeted translates into tangible enhancements, improving overall . Early mechanisms collected over 3 million pieces in their first eight months, laying groundwork for tools like Feedback Hub. The platform plays a crucial role in accelerating bug fixes, particularly during Windows Insider previews, where detailed submissions with attached diagnostics allow engineering teams to quickly identify and resolve issues. Since its inception, Feedback Hub has collected millions of feedback items, providing with actionable data to prioritize fixes and features based on upvoting. Submission and voting mechanisms further amplify this impact by surfacing high-priority concerns for rapid iteration. This process has been instrumental in refining previews, ensuring more stable releases for broader adoption. Feedback Hub also contributes to shaping long-term product roadmaps by incorporating user input into decision-making, including clear explanations for declined requests that help align expectations. Following its launch in , the app's status updates and responses have boosted transparency, fostering greater user trust and encouraging sustained participation in beta testing programs, which grew to over 10 million Insiders by 2017. This increased engagement has created a virtuous cycle, where informed users contribute more effectively to evolving ecosystems like Windows 11.

Controversies

In 2021, a by Neowin highlighted allegations that Feedback Hub operates as a "rigged system," with accused of silently deleting upvotes on user-submitted ideas, thereby undermining the platform's integrity. Specific examples included popular requests, such as enabling placement on the top or sides, which saw its upvote count drop from 25,732 to 16,098 overnight—a 37% decrease—while other requests like Start menu groups and folders fell from 11,115 to 6,694 upvotes (40% decrease) and drag-and-drop functionality declined from 10,855 to 7,137 (34% decrease). These fluctuations, lacking any downvote mechanism, fueled user , with commentators noting that upvoting, a core engagement , appeared manipulated to alter visibility and prioritization of . User complaints from 2020 to 2023 frequently cited unresponsive submission processes, where attempts to issues resulted in endless loading or failed uploads, often requiring app resets or reinstalls to function. Additionally, the generated excessive notification , including unsolicited prompts for ratings and updates that cluttered inboxes and disrupted workflows. Reports also emerged of high CPU and disk usage by Feedback Hub's background processes, leading to system slowdowns without clear justification from . As of mid-2025, concerns about Feedback Hub's maintenance persisted among some users, who perceived the platform as stagnant, as reflected in an August 2025 discussion questioning if it had become a "has-been" following an announcement dated August 1, 2025. However, clarified that the app remains maintained, with updates increasingly communicated through other channels, and a subsequent app update was released on October 23, 2025. Recent analyses, such as in October 2024, have called for evolving Feedback Hub's feedback processing to improve clarity on issues across Insider channels, while June 2025 reports highlighted ongoing user backlash against Windows features amid feedback mechanisms. A persistent involves the lack of in how prioritizes feedback and tracks resolutions, leaving users uncertain if high-voted suggestions are reviewed or implemented, which erodes confidence in the system's purpose. For instance, analyses of top requests across Microsoft products revealed that unresolved items accumulate without explanation, prompting accusations that the platform serves more as a tool than a genuine influence on product decisions.

References

  1. [1]
    Send feedback to Microsoft with the Feedback Hub app
    The Feedback Hub app lets you tell Microsoft about any problems you run into while using Windows devices. You can also send suggestions to help us improve ...
  2. [2]
    Feedback Hub - Free download and install on Windows
    Rating 3.3 (17,188) · Free · WindowsOct 23, 2025 · Help us make Windows better! Provide feedback about Windows and apps by sharing your suggestions or problems. If you want to be even more ...
  3. [3]
    Explore the Feedback Hub - Windows Insider Program
    Mar 2, 2023 · The Feedback Hub is an app available on Windows devices. You can search for it, press Win + F to open it, or find it in your Start menu to get started.
  4. [4]
    Remove the Ugly "Send Feedback" Link in Windows 7 Beta
    Jan 22, 2009 · The first thing you'll want to do is open up regedit.exe through the start menu search box, and then browse down to the following key ...
  5. [5]
    Give feedback on Windows 7 Beta - Tim Heuer
    Jan 12, 2009 · Basically, you need to sign up for the Connect program for the Windows 7 beta and then your feedback link will work. Record your Feedback. The ...
  6. [6]
    Windows 7 Release Candidate Is Available From Microsoft - Source
    Apr 30, 2009 · Available soon, Windows 7 Upgrade Advisor will be a downloadable tool that will help people determine their ability to upgrade from their ...
  7. [7]
    The Windows Feedback Program | Windows Experience Blog
    Apr 13, 2012 · The Windows Feedback Program was created for us to enlist the help of customers who want to be more actively involved providing direct feedback ...
  8. [8]
    Microsoft's Feedback Hub app is now available for all Windows 10 ...
    May 20, 2016 · Microsoft has made the Feedback Hub app, previously exclusive to Windows Insiders, available to all Windows 10 users.
  9. [9]
    New build available to the Windows Insider Program
    Nov 12, 2014 · We're rolling out our next build update to the “Fast” ring of the Windows Insider Program – Build 9879! Once again this build has a ton of changes.Missing: launch | Show results with:launch
  10. [10]
    1 million people have signed up to test the next version of Windows
    Oct 13, 2014 · So far, the program has generated 200,000 pieces of user-initiated feedback from its users, which will be put to use in refining Windows 10.
  11. [11]
    Windows 10 problem? Now everyone can gripe to Microsoft via ...
    May 23, 2016 · Feedback Hub is an amalgamation of a previously released Windows Feedback app and the Insider Hub for Windows Insiders, which Microsoft released ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  12. [12]
    Windows Insider - Wikipedia
    Windows Insider is an open software testing program by Microsoft that allows users globally who own a valid license of Windows 11, Windows 10,
  13. [13]
    More than 1 million bits of feedback have been submitted by ...
    Mar 14, 2015 · More than 1 million bits of feedback have been submitted by Windows Insiders. News. By Derek Kessler published March 14, 2015. Microsoft ...
  14. [14]
    A change in leadership for the Windows Insider Program
    Jun 1, 2016 · Since we first started the Windows Insider Program back in September 2014, Windows Insiders have helped us ship Windows 10 to over 300 million ...Missing: statistics | Show results with:statistics
  15. [15]
    Announcing Windows 10 Mobile Insider Preview Build 14283
    Mar 10, 2016 · Coming Soon – the Feedback Hub: When you open Insider Hub on this build, you will see a new welcome dialog for Feedback Hub. Coming in the next ...
  16. [16]
  17. [17]
    What's new in Windows 10 version 1607 Anniversary Update
    Aug 20, 2020 · The Feedback Hub will now show Microsoft responses; You can now make a screenshot and open Feedback Hub directly with Win + F. Option now ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  18. [18]
    Diagnostics, feedback, and privacy in Windows - Microsoft Support
    By running Diagnostic Data Viewer, you can see an icon which indicates whether your device is part of a sample and also which specific data is collected from ...
  19. [19]
    Feedback Hub gets new achievement page, makes sorting feedback ...
    Aug 19, 2019 · Each category will now have a clear icon and color when you're sorting through feedback, helping to sort them out visually. You can see and ...
  20. [20]
    Basic tasks using a screen reader with the Feedback Hub
    Press the Up or Down arrow key or the SR key+Right or Left arrow key until you hear the filter option you want and press Spacebar to select. You can select more ...
  21. [21]
    Submit Windows upgrade errors using Feedback Hub
    Apr 8, 2025 · This article describes how to submit problems with a Windows upgrade to Microsoft using the Windows Feedback Hub.
  22. [22]
    Feedback Hub now available for anyone running Windows 10 PC or ...
    May 20, 2016 · The Feedback Hub app for Windows 10 is now available for everyone to try, expanding from its previous Insider-only status.
  23. [23]
    Launch Feedback Hub from your app - UWP applications
    Feb 27, 2025 · Feedback Hub is available only on devices that run version 10.0.14271 or later of a Windows 10 OS that is based on the desktop and mobile device ...
  24. [24]
    Release notes - May 2016 - Enthusiast Guide - Microsoft Learn
    Jan 19, 2021 · We've converged Feedback App and Inside Hub into a single app Feedback Hub, which is the go-to tool for giving us feedback on features you love ...
  25. [25]
    Get updates for apps and games in Microsoft Store
    To update apps and games, open the Microsoft Store and select 'Get Updates'. Some apps manage their own updates.
  26. [26]
    Use Feedback Hub to report an Azure VPN Client problem
    Oct 9, 2024 · The Feedback Hub app is automatically a part of Windows 10 and Windows 11. You don't need to download it separately. The screenshots shown in ...Missing: platforms | Show results with:platforms
  27. [27]
    The-Windows-10-Feedback-Hub - LENOVO COMMUNITY
    Mar 11, 2018 · Feedback Hub for all users of Windows 10 is a communication tool included in the Windows 10 operating system as of the 2016 Anniversary Update.
  28. [28]
    App package architectures - MSIX - Microsoft Learn
    Dec 29, 2021 · Learn more about which processor architecture(s) you should use when building your UWP app package.
  29. [29]
    Feedback Hub App on Windows 11 24H2 Arm64 says Tented ...
    Nov 25, 2024 · I signed in (Windows 11 24H2 Arm64) with my Microsoft Personal account. When the Feedback Hub App is invoked using windows-key + F this ...How to install Feedback Hub in the following context? See below.I'm on a pre-installed windows 11 computer. Is it possible, without a ...More results from learn.microsoft.com
  30. [30]
  31. [31]
    How to prepare for Windows 10 end of support by moving to ...
    Oct 31, 2024 · This blog post is intended to help you prepare for Windows 10 end of support by outlining considerations for moving to Windows 11 today.
  32. [32]
    Announcing Windows 11 Insider Preview Build 26120.6682 (Beta ...
    Sep 12, 2025 · Launch app updates provided from publishers directly on the product page. FEEDBACK: Please file feedback in Feedback Hub (WIN + F) under ...
  33. [33]
    How Windows Insider Feedback Influences Windows 10 Development
    Jun 12, 2015 · The Modern Desktop Apps (MDA) team is another example of how our teams are using Windows Insider feedback. In early builds, Windows Insiders ...
  34. [34]
    Announcing Windows 11 Insider Preview Build 26120.2702 (Dev ...
    Dec 13, 2024 · We are improving the filtering for recommended websites on the Start menu based on feedback from Windows Insiders so that we show the highest ...
  35. [35]
    Announcing Windows 11 Insider Preview Build 26120.1843 (Dev ...
    Sep 20, 2024 · Based on feedback, we've made some updates to the new account manager on the Start menu making the sign out option directly visible, and ...
  36. [36]
    Announcing Windows 10 Insider Preview Build 14352
    May 26, 2016 · Feedback Hub will now show Microsoft responses: You'll now see short status tags on feedback to let you know what we're doing with it. The ...
  37. [37]
    Windows 10 has more than 10 million beta testers now - Ghacks
    Mar 28, 2017 · Windows 10 has more than 10 million beta testers now. windows feedback hub ... Users may report issues to Microsoft, and give feedback on ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  38. [38]
    Hey Microsoft, fix the upvote counts in your Feedback Hub - Neowin
    Dec 24, 2021 · It's important to note that you cannot downvote items in the Feedback Hub, so the decrease in upvotes is definitely not a user-triggered event.
  39. [39]
    Feedback Hub Using to much CPU and Disk - Microsoft Learn
    May 21, 2020 · So, Problem that i'm having is : Feedback Hub starts on itself while i'm running High Power usage programs such as games.This is normal? - Microsoft Q&Afeedback hub using cpu - Microsoft Q&AMore results from learn.microsoft.com
  40. [40]
    Windows 10's Feedback Hub: A forum for political trolls, spammers
    Jul 13, 2020 · When Microsoft made the Feedback Hub universal app available to Windows 10 Insiders in March 2016 and generally available two months later ...
  41. [41]
    Feedback Hub Complaint - Windows 11 Forum
    Nov 25, 2023 · I just tried to use the Feedback Hub and I have to admit that MS now has me totally lost on how to use it. If MS truly wants feedback then ...Missing: 2020-2023 | Show results with:2020-2023
  42. [42]
    Is Feedback Hub now a "has been"? - Microsoft Q&A
    Aug 25, 2025 · I'd like to reassure you that the Feedback Hub is still actively maintained. While it may appear inactive due to fewer announcements, Microsoft ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
  43. [43]
    Here are the top 10 features people want in Microsoft Word - Neowin
    Apr 3, 2022 · In a way, this lack of transparency destroys the purpose of a feedback hub as customers begin to lose faith that their complaints are even being ...