Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Future Commando Force

The Future Commando Force (FCF) is a modernization and transformation programme of the United Kingdom's , reorienting them from traditional amphibious infantry to a forward-deployed, special operations-capable force specializing in , high-intensity raiding, and persistent presence operations in contested environments. Announced in the 2021 of Security, Defence, Development and Foreign Policy, the FCF aims to enhance agility, lethality, and integration with advanced technologies such as uncrewed systems, networked communications, and precision munitions, enabling small, versatile teams to conduct disaggregated infiltration and targeted strikes. Central to the FCF is the establishment of the UK Commando Force, comprising approximately 4,000 personnel organized into scalable units like the Littoral Response Groups (LRGs), which support intelligence gathering, crisis intervention, and battlespace shaping for larger allied forces. Key structural changes include reducing the number of main commando units to two infantry battalions (40 and 45 Commando), with repurposed for maritime operations, alongside the formation of experimental groups such as the Vanguard Strike Company to trial new tactics and equipment, including Crye Precision uniforms and drone-enabled resupply. The programme has driven deployments in diverse theaters, such as leading operations, demonstrating enhanced technological integration and interoperability. Despite its innovations, the FCF has faced internal and external controversies, including debates over the abandonment of large-scale amphibious assault capabilities, persistent funding shortfalls estimated at £0.7 billion for enabling platforms, and challenges in and retention amid personnel shortages. Critics argue that while the emphasis on elite, small-team raiding aligns with peer-competitor threats like those from and , potential tactical deficiencies in training and organizational silos may limit operational effectiveness in sustained high-intensity conflicts.

Concept and Objectives

Strategic Rationale

The Future Commando Force (FCF) emerged as a core component of the United Kingdom's response to an increasingly contested global security environment, as outlined in the March 2021 Integrated Review of Security, Defence, Development and Foreign Policy and the accompanying Defence Command Paper, Defence in a Competitive Age. This transformation addresses the limitations of legacy amphibious capabilities in the face of peer competitors employing advanced anti-access/area denial (A2/AD) systems, such as those deployed by Russia in the Euro-Atlantic and China in the Indo-Pacific, which render traditional large-scale landings vulnerable and resource-intensive. The rationale emphasizes shifting from massed infantry assaults to persistent, forward-deployed operations in littoral zones—coastal and near-shore areas critical for power projection—enabling the Royal Marines to conduct sub-threshold activities like intelligence gathering, partner training, and deterrence without escalating to full conflict. Central to the FCF's strategic purpose is the creation of a "littoral strike" capability, reorienting the Royal Marines as a special operations-capable integrated across domains (, , , and cyber) to operate ahead of main forces, shape battlespaces, and relieve pressure on (UKSF) for high-end tasks. This aligns with the UK's "Integrated Operating Concept" for 2030, prioritizing agility, lethality, and technological enablers like uncrewed systems and networked teams over sheer manpower, amid fiscal constraints that reduced personnel from three battalions to two (40 and ) plus specialist elements. By embedding the FCF within Littoral Response Groups (LRGs)—one for the Euro-Atlantic operationalized in 2021 and another for the Indo-Pacific by 2023—the supports commitments, global partnerships, and the "Global Britain" vision of persistent engagement to counter state threats below the warfighting threshold. The initiative received targeted funding, including £40 million over four years for development, to modernize and , ensuring resilience against evolving threats like and grey-zone aggression. This forward-leaning posture positions the FCF as the "landward extension of the fleet," enhancing interoperability for scalable responses from to escalation dominance, while adapting to wargaming insights that highlight the need for distributed, survivable units in A2/AD environments.

Core Principles and Littoral Focus

The Future Commando Force (FCF) embodies core principles of distributed operations, precision, adaptability, and survivability, designed to enable small, agile teams—typically 12-person strike units—to conduct disruptive raids and enable naval fires in high-threat environments rather than sustain traditional ground-holding roles. This shift prioritizes lethality through long-range precision weapons, such as high-mobility artillery rocket systems (HIMARS), over massed infantry maneuvers, with forces dispersed across areas up to 40 by 30 kilometers to minimize vulnerability. Integration as a "landward extension of the fleet" underpins these tenets, fostering multi-domain synergy where enhance naval sea control via land-based and strikes, supported by intermittent maritime logistics and deception tactics like signature management. The littoral focus of FCF centers on persistent forward presence in coastal zones to counter peer-adversary (A2/AD) capabilities, projecting from sea-based platforms into contested littorals for shaping and crisis response. Littoral Response Groups (LRGs), comprising vanguard strike companies and specialized enablers, operationalize this through sea-basing and operational maneuver, enabling rapid interdiction, contributions, and deterrence by denial—imposing friction on adversaries via asymmetric effects and scalable dispersal. Exercises like Green Dagger have validated these concepts, demonstrating how distributed elements can disrupt larger formations, such as a U.S. brigade, across littoral maneuvers with enhanced connectivity and power-to-weight ratios. This approach aligns with broader emphasizing a "distributed protean " for relative superiority in sub-threshold competition and warfighting, though challenges persist in and communications under .

Organizational Structure

Force Composition and Units

The Future Commando Force (FCF) restructures the into a leaner, more deployable formation centered on two persistent (LRG North and LRG South), each comprising around 400-500 personnel focused on high-threat littoral operations. LRG North typically draws its core infantry from elements of , embarked on amphibious assets like Albion and or , with integrated aviation from including and helicopters. LRG South similarly utilizes personnel from , supported by Bulwark and equivalent landing platforms, enabling distributed raiding and strike operations. These groups incorporate specialized sub-units such as Vanguard Strike Companies, experimental formations testing FCF concepts with enhanced mobility and sensor integration, rotating from 40 and 45 Commandos' four command companies each. Supporting the LRGs are multi-service elements under the , including for maritime operations and interdiction, for cyber and electronic warfare, and for precision fires. Protective and sustainment roles are fulfilled by and , ensuring operational resilience across the nine battalion-sized units of the broader Commando Force. Integration extends to commando-qualified personnel from the Royal Navy, , and , forming joint teams for tasks like NATO Level 2 as outlined in the 2025 Strategic Defence Review. This composition prioritizes agility over mass, with units trained for persistent presence and scalable reinforcement rather than traditional brigade deployments.

Integration with Royal Navy and Allies

The Future Commando Force (FCF) integrates units directly into Littoral Response Groups (LRGs), enabling persistent forward deployment and maritime strike capabilities from amphibious platforms. Two LRGs—North and South—are maintained, with LRG(N) typically centered on HMS Albion and carrying elements of , while LRG(S) operates similarly with rotations from other units, forming self-contained task groups that include ships, aviation assets, logistics, and commando forces for rapid response in contested littoral environments. This naval integration positions FCF commandos as a landward extension of the fleet, emphasizing strike operations from the sea rather than traditional amphibious landings, with providing , targeting support for naval fires, and raids in support of carrier strike groups or independent operations. FCF enhances interoperability with allies through joint exercises and task force contributions, such as LRG(N) operations in the High North alongside partners to counter threats in regions. In 2023, the and agreed to co-develop a future littoral strike platform to bolster amphibious capabilities for both nations' commando forces, focusing on shared logistics and operational concepts. Recent integrations include and Army Rangers joining special operations task forces, testing FCF models in multinational environments like Norway's Project Heimdall for high-intensity warfare scenarios.

Development History

Background Prior to 2019

The , established in their modern form during the Second World War, have historically served as the United Kingdom's premier amphibious force, specializing in raiding, , and from the sea. Their role emphasized rapid deployment via amphibious shipping to secure beachheads or conduct disruptive operations, as demonstrated in operations like the 1982 Falklands Campaign, where logistical vulnerabilities in contested littorals were exposed due to concentrated forces and enemy fire. Post-Cold War, the Corps shifted toward expeditionary interventions in and , contributing significantly to with 40-50% of UK personnel drawn from backgrounds by 2018, underscoring their elite training and adaptability. Strategic Defence and Security Reviews in 2010 and 2015 reshaped the force amid budget constraints and evolving threats. The 2010 review reduced strength from approximately 7,140 to 6,500 personnel while retaining key amphibious assets like HMS Albion and HMS Bulwark, prioritizing carrier strike over large-scale landings in peer conflicts. The 2015 review restored some funding, committing to F-35 integration and enhanced maritime task groups, but highlighted the need for greater agility against (A2/AD) capabilities proliferating among adversaries like and , rendering traditional amphibious assaults increasingly untenable in urbanized coastal zones. The Modernising Defence Programme (MDP), initiated in January 2018, marked the immediate precursor to formalized transformation efforts by addressing these gaps through innovation and lethality enhancements. In December 2018, the MDP allocated £20 million from the Defence Innovation Fund for projects including advanced digital communications tailored to the emerging Future Commando Force concept, alongside training to boost readiness. This funding reflected early recognition of the need for distributed, networked teams capable of operating in contested littorals, informed by wargaming and exercises testing small-unit strikes, such as pre-2019 iterations of distributed operations that validated the disruptive potential of 12-person teams against larger conventional forces. These initiatives aimed to evolve the Royal Marines from ground-holding toward a scalable, maritime-integrated force focused on deterrence, deception, and precision effects amid rising great-power competition.

2019-2020 Inception and Planning

The inception of the Future Commando Force (FCF) stemmed from early 2019 assessments within the to reorient the Royal toward high-readiness, forward-deployed operations in contested littoral environments amid rising peer-state threats from actors like and . In February 2019, then-Defence Secretary announced initial plans for two Littoral Strike Groups, comprising multi-role support ships and specialized vessels to enable commando forces to conduct strikes from the sea, marking a shift from traditional amphibious assault toward persistent presence and raiding. This built on broader defence strategy emphasizing technological integration and special operations-like capabilities for the , with early conceptualization driven by the need to counter anti-access/area-denial (A2/AD) challenges in and theaters. Planning accelerated through 2019 with targeted experimentation and exercises to validate concepts. In April 2019, Exercise Commando Warrior tested autonomous unmanned ground vehicles in tactical maneuvers, representing the first operational integration of such systems by units to enhance in dispersed operations. By September 2019, at the Defence and Security Equipment International () exhibition, leaders detailed the Littoral Strike framework, projecting a future commando force operating from sea bases with blended human-technology teams for , , and precision strikes. November 2019 saw lead FCF trials during simulations in , focusing on the Marines as the "lethal tip of the spear" in multi-domain scenarios involving rapid insertion and extraction. These activities involved collaboration with UK industry and allies to prototype equipment, such as low-signature raiding craft and sensor networks, prioritizing empirical testing over doctrinal assumptions. Into 2020, planning emphasized materiel and doctrinal refinement amid the disruptions, with June trials introducing a new Crye Precision optimized for maritime special operations, featuring multi-terrain and modular load-bearing for extended littoral patrols. Official documents like the September 2020 "How Defence Works" primer referenced ongoing FCF development, including specialist troops leveraging cutting-edge uncrewed systems for strike effects from distributed naval platforms. This phase consolidated lessons from 2019 trials into force design principles, such as scalable troops (around 60 personnel) for persistent engagement, setting the stage for the 2021 Defence Command Paper's formal endorsement while addressing capability gaps identified in peer-reviewed analyses of amphibious vulnerabilities.

2021-2022 Implementation Phases

The implementation of the Future Commando Force (FCF) commenced in 2021 following the and Defence Command Paper, with the UK announcing the transformation of the Royal Marines from a traditional amphibious force into a globally deployable, special operations-capable unit focused on littoral strike operations. This shift emphasized persistent forward presence, deterrence against sub-threshold threats, and integration with allies, supported by an initial investment exceeding £200 million over the subsequent decade for equipment, training, and structural changes. Specifically, £40 million was allocated over four years starting in 2021 to develop FCF capabilities, including enhanced multi-domain integration and littoral response groups (LRGs). In March 2021, the first (LRG) (North) was deployed to the Euro-Atlantic region under and frameworks, marking the initial operational rollout of FCF concepts with a focus on rapid crisis response and partner capacity building. Concurrently, Vanguard Strike Companies (VSCs)—specialized units of approximately 150 personnel each, comprising and integrated army commandos—entered service to pioneer FCF tactics, with one stationed in for operations and another embedded with Norwegian forces in ; rotations occurred every six months to maintain readiness. New lightweight commando uniforms were introduced to support dispersed, high-mobility operations, alongside training adaptations for smaller four-man teams equipped with advanced communications and navigation systems, replacing larger traditional sections for greater agility in contested environments. HMS Trent began forward operations from later in 2021, conducting maritime security and counter-piracy missions in the while testing FCF-enabled persistent presence. The 2022 phase built on these foundations with expanded training and exercises to embed FCF doctrine across the force. In February , a troop of Royal Marine recruits completed initial training incorporating novel FCF tactics, such as distributed lethality and technology-enabled strikes, representing the first full integration of the program into the recruitment pipeline. By May , FCF elements led multinational operations, demonstrating enhanced cold-weather littoral capabilities and with allies in high-threat scenarios. Over £50 million was invested to convert a for dedicated littoral strike support, enabling more flexible insertions and extractions in denied areas, as part of broader £6.6 billion in research, development, and experimentation prioritized from onward to adapt to peer adversaries. These efforts aligned with the Ministry of Defence's 2021-2022 Outcome Delivery Plan, which outlined FCF as a core priority for naval transformation amid evolving global threats.

2023-2025 Recent Developments

In September 2023, the UK Ministry of Defence adopted the Knight's Stoner 1 (KS-1), designated L403A1, as a new for in lead strike teams, improving stealth and lethality for counter-terrorism and specialist missions within the Commando Force. The National Audit Office's review of the Equipment Plan 2023–2033 allocated funds for modernisation but highlighted a £0.7 billion shortfall, excluding capabilities for sea-based operations in high-threat maritime environments and thereby constraining the force's contested littoral deployment. This gap reflected broader equipment prioritization challenges, with the plan forecasting affordability risks rising to 74% of projects by 2024–25 due to cost pressures. Commando units advanced amphibious enablers, initiating industry engagement for the Commando Insertion Craft in June 2023 to replace aging for covert insertions, alongside early discussions for Multi-Role Support Ships to bolster littoral lift capacity. joined NATO's BALTOPS 2023 exercise in the , testing strike-from-sea tactics amid limited surface escort availability, underscoring persistent integration hurdles with the Littoral Response Groups. In October 2024, UK Commando Force personnel conducted training in with partners, refining tactics for dispersed, high-mobility operations in complex terrain. The Commando Force integrated the CF Strike Network for enhanced command, control, and uncrewed systems coordination, aligning with the shift to smaller, agile raiding groups over traditional battalion-scale maneuvers. The July 2024 Labour government launched a Strategic Defence Review, culminating in 2025 findings that endorsed the Commando Force's evolution into a Level 2 contributor, equipped with forces-specific gear for deterrence and rapid response. This included integration of Rangers into task forces alongside Commandos, as noted in parliamentary responses tied to the review. Issuance of the to operational units proceeded in March 2025, with field testing during exercises validating its performance in extreme conditions. Persistent challenges included personnel shortfalls and vessel inadequacies, limiting full readiness despite doctrinal progress toward drone-supported, data-driven raiding.

Operational Capabilities

Doctrine and Tactics

The doctrine of the Future Commando Force (FCF) revolves around the Littoral Strike concept, which positions the as a special operations-capable amphibious advanced force focused on (FIND) and strikes (STRIKE) to shape the against peer adversaries in contested littorals. This approach treats amphibious units as a landward extension of naval strike and sea control capabilities, emphasizing distributed operations to counter (A2/AD) systems rather than traditional massed assaults. Core principles include persistent forward presence via Littoral Response Groups (LRGs), scalable force projection from company-sized elements, and multi-domain integration with uncrewed systems and allied fires to enable rapid disruption of high-value targets. Tactics prioritize small, agile teams—typically 12-person strike companies—conducting dispersed raiding to exploit adversary vulnerabilities, forcing enemy concentration that exposes them to offshore precision fires. These teams leverage low-signature insertion methods, such as Insertion Craft and uncrewed surface vessels, combined with deception tactics like decoys and multispectral concealment to maintain surprise in archipelagic or urban coastal environments. Integration of technologies like loitering munitions, UAVs for intelligence, surveillance, and (ISR), and the CF Strike Network facilitates real-time data sharing for targeting, as demonstrated in exercises such as Green Dagger, where teams disrupted larger U.S. Marine forces using raiding and joint fires. Every company incorporates specialized operators and joint terminal attack controllers (JTACs) for all-weather dismounted operations and scalable escalation to company groups with attached enablers. Operational tactics avoid force concentration, instead employing networked multiple points of presence to generate dilemmas for adversaries, supported by man-portable effectors like and for enhanced lethality. In practice, LRGs enable crisis response and shaping, as seen in the 2023 Sudan evacuation and Asia-Pacific deployments aboard vessels like , where conducted persistent surveillance and strike preparation. This doctrine, informed by wargaming and trials since 2019, aligns with Level 2 support, equipping units with SOF-specific gear for littoral manoeuvre in high-threat scenarios.

Equipment and Technologies

The Future Commando Force (FCF) integrates advanced equipment and technologies to enable rapid, technology-enabled operations in littoral environments, prioritizing mobility, surveillance, and networked lethality over traditional heavy armor. Central to this is a new multi-terrain , introduced in 2020, featuring enhanced durability, suppression, and modular attachments for sensors and communications gear, designed to support operations across , , and air interfaces. Personal protective and communication systems include over 1,000 MPU5 handheld networking radios, deployed since 2023, which provide resilient, mobile ad-hoc networking for integrating helmet-mounted cameras, hand-thrown unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), and rotary-wing drones used for , and resupply missions. These systems facilitate real-time data sharing in contested environments, enhancing for small, distributed units. Unmanned systems form a core capability, with investments in long-range UAVs, throwable drones, and drone swarms to deliver precision strikes and persistent without risking personnel. In , the acquisition of 60 Viking all-terrain tracked vehicles under a agreement bolstered mobility, offering amphibious and snow-capable transport suited to high-north operations. Supporting technologies encompass enhanced digital communications and virtual reality training systems, funded through the Modernising Defence Programme with £50 million allocated by 2019 for FCF-specific innovations like directed energy integration prototypes. The Multi-Role Support Ship (MRSS) program, advancing as of 2024, will further enable deployment of these assets via aviation-capable platforms for sustained littoral presence.

Training and Personnel

Selection and Recruitment Processes

The selection and recruitment processes for the Future Commando Force (FCF) align with those of the Royal Marines Corps, emphasizing physical endurance, mental resilience, and adaptability to produce multi-skilled personnel capable of operating in high-threat littoral environments. Applicants must meet stringent eligibility criteria, including or citizenship, age between 16 and 32, and no serious criminal convictions, before proceeding through a multi-stage assessment designed to identify candidates suited for the FCF's specialized, technology-integrated roles. The process begins with an online application followed by the Defence Aptitude (DAA), a computer-based test evaluating verbal, numerical, spatial, electrical, and mechanical reasoning to gauge cognitive suitability for tasks. Successful candidates then undergo a selection via video , assessing , , and leadership potential, alongside a Pre-Joining (PJFA) that includes tests such as press-ups, sit-ups, and a 1.5-mile run to ensure baseline physical readiness. These initial filters aim to prepare recruits for the demands of FCF operations, which require versatility beyond traditional amphibious assault. Further evaluation occurs at the 4-day Candidate Preparation Course (RM CPC), a pass/fail event incorporating fitness circuits, swimming assessments, and medical screenings, succeeded by the 2-week Recruit Orientation Phase (ROP) at the Commando Training Centre (CTCRM) in Lympstone, featuring a 3-day field exercise and the Royal Marines Fitness Assessment (RMFA). Only those passing advance to the 32-week initial training, divided into phases focusing on weapon handling, tactics, and the grueling 30-mile Commando , maintaining standards unchanged despite the FCF's shift toward agile, special operations-capable units. Women have been eligible since policy changes in 2018, with recent calls for "super fit" female applicants underscoring that physical benchmarks—such as completing the endurance course in under 73 minutes for recruits—remain arduous to preserve . Recruitment challenges have persisted amid the FCF transition, with the Royal Marines facing a shortfall of approximately 600 personnel as of early , attributed to broader armed forces intake issues rather than FCF-specific reforms. This gap has strained implementation of the FCF's multi-domain warfare focus, prompting efforts to attract talent for roles emphasizing , , and autonomous systems integration, though critics argue systemic delays in processing and perceived lowering of standards—despite official denials—have exacerbated shortfalls without enhancing selectivity for FCF needs.

Specialized Training Reforms

The specialized training reforms for the Future Commando Force (FCF) focus on evolving capabilities toward distributed, technology-enabled small-team operations in contested littoral environments, moving beyond conventional training. Announced as part of the UK's 2019-2020 defence modernization, these changes integrate advanced tactics, unmanned systems, and virtual augmentation to prepare commandos for raiding, , and missions with minimal logistical footprints. Key reforms emphasize small raiding teams of 4-12 personnel, trained to operate autonomously over wide areas using real-time drone feeds for and battle damage assessment, as trialed in exercises like Green Dagger in October 2021 and Arctic fight phases in March 2021. Training incorporates lightweight vehicles such as MRZRs equipped with precision munitions, shifting focus from patrolling to enabling partner fires like HIMARS systems. Individual and unit-level pipelines have been adjusted to prioritize sea-based boarding, high-speed raiding, and dispersed sustainment, with intensified scrutiny in desert and mountain terrains to validate FCF concepts, including evaluations in December 2020. tools were introduced in March 2021 to simulate complex scenarios, supplementing rather than supplanting live drills for cost-effective skill rehearsal. By August 2025, reforms blended enduring proficiencies with FCF innovations, as seen in mountain exercises testing new communications suites and kit limits in extreme conditions, ensuring with allied forces. These adaptations address force generation challenges by fostering niche competencies in and autonomous platforms, though they demand ongoing validation amid evolving threats.

Evaluations and Challenges

Achievements and Operational Tests

The Future Commando Force (FCF) has undergone several operational tests demonstrating enhanced littoral maneuverability and integration of unmanned systems. In May 2019, during Exercise Commando Warrior Two, trialed autonomous technologies and small-unit tactics to inform FCF development, focusing on rapid deployment from naval platforms in contested environments. These experiments validated initial concepts for distributed operations, emphasizing precision strikes over traditional amphibious assaults. Subsequent tests in 2020 advanced equipment integration and team structures. At Bovington Training Area in September, evaluated new team configurations and sensor systems, achieving successful simulations of hit-and-run raids that highlighted improved through networked data sharing. Exercise Serpent Rock in during November involved practicing cliff assaults, tunnel , and deployment of throwbots and drones, confirming the operational utility of these tools for no-notice maritime interdiction tasks. In operations around the same period, under the Littoral Response Group Experimentation (LRG(X)), units from 42 and 47 Commando tested drones for intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR) from HMS Albion—the first such warship deployment—alongside jet skis for small-team insertions and maritime sniper overwatch, resulting in refined procedures for agile, forward-deployed strikes. A notable multinational validation occurred during Exercise Green Dagger in October 2021, where integrated FCF tactics with U.S. Marine Corps forces in , employing small teams to disrupt larger opposing formations in scenario-based maneuvers across and terrain. This exercise underscored the effectiveness of FCF's emphasis on persistent presence and precision effects, with UK elements demonstrating rapid dominance in simulated high-threat environments through integration. Overall, these tests have contributed to milestones such as the technology trials, which successfully incorporated crewless systems into workflows, paving the way for scalable FCF capabilities. ![Royal Marines conducting operations during Exercise Serpent Rock][float-right]

Criticisms and Funding Constraints

The Future Commando Force (FCF) has encountered significant funding constraints that restrict its planned capabilities. The National Audit Office's Equipment Plan 2023-2033, published in December 2023, identified a £0.7 billion shortfall required to equip the force for operations in high-threat maritime environments, which remains unallocated within the Royal Navy's budget. This gap forms part of a wider £17 billion affordability deficit in the Ministry of Defence's overall equipment programme, prompting NAO chief executive Gareth Davies to warn of risks to value for money and programme delivery if such shortfalls persist. As a result, the Commando Force is currently resourced only for lower-threat scenarios, limiting its role in contested littorals without additional investment in protective assets like enhanced air defense and unmanned systems. These budgetary limitations have drawn criticism for undermining the FCF's doctrinal emphasis on distributed, persistent operations from the sea. Defence analysts have noted that without the funding for multi-role support ships and advanced insertion craft—such as replacements for the —the force lacks the organic enablers needed for independent deployment, increasing reliance on allied support like U.S. assets. Personnel constraints compound this, with facing acute shortages that have reduced the deployability of the ; for instance, no suitable warships or auxiliaries were available for NATO's 2024 exercise, highlighting gaps in ship availability tied to broader resource pressures. Broader critiques question the FCF's strategic viability amid these fiscal realities, arguing that the shift to a leaner, special operations-oriented structure—reducing unit sizes and prioritizing raiding over sustained amphibious assaults—may render the force ineffective against peer competitors lacking mass and logistics for holding captured ground. Recruitment and retention crises within the armed forces further erode capabilities, as producing qualified non-commissioned officers for specialized roles takes up to a , and small military occupational specialties (10-15 personnel) suffer disproportionately from outflows. Some commentators view the transformation as a defensive measure to preserve the Royal Marines' identity rather than a robust adaptation, potentially sidelining it in high-end warfighting scenarios where lift and firepower deficits persist.

Debates on Long-Term Viability

The Future Commando Force's long-term viability has been questioned due to persistent funding shortfalls, with the National Audit Office reporting in December 2023 that an additional £700 million is required to equip the force for operations in high-threat maritime environments, a sum that remains unallocated amid broader defence budget pressures. This gap arises from the transformation's reliance on advanced technologies like unmanned systems and precision strike capabilities, which demand sustained investment beyond initial allocations of £200-£400 million outlined in the for the force's development over a decade. Critics, including defence analysts, contend that without ring-fenced funding, the force risks becoming under-equipped for peer-level threats from adversaries like or , where distributed littoral operations require robust enablers that current budgets may not deliver. Strategic debates further highlight vulnerabilities in scalability and integration, as the force's emphasis on small-scale raiding and persistent presence in contested areas—envisioned under the 2021 Defence Command Paper—may falter in prolonged peer conflicts lacking adequate aviation lift and sealift capacity. The planned retirement of the Albion-class landing platform dock ships by the mid-2030s exacerbates this, potentially relegating Royal Marines to reliance on multi-role support ships or allied assets, which analysts argue undermines the force's independent amphibious role and exposes it to contested logistics chains. Proponents counter that the model's agility aligns with hybrid warfare trends, but sceptics, drawing from RUSI assessments, warn that unproven dependencies on autonomous systems and joint all-domain operations could prove illusory if technological maturation lags or adversaries develop effective counters, as evidenced by ongoing equipment procurement delays. Personnel sustainability adds another layer of contention, with Royal Marines facing recruitment shortfalls—intake targets missed by up to 20% in recent years—and high training attrition rates exceeding 50% for commandos, potentially straining the force's elite manpower model amid the transformation's demands for multi-skilled operators proficient in cyber, drones, and special operations. While Ministry of Defence officials maintain standards remain unchanged, as affirmed by a minister in April 2025, external reviews of UK armed forces readiness underscore broader retention challenges driven by pay stagnation and operational tempo, which could erode the force's qualitative edge over time without reforms to address demographic shifts and competing civilian opportunities. These factors, compounded by political volatility in defence spending—as seen in post-2024 election reviews—fuel arguments that the FCF's viability hinges on improbable fiscal discipline and strategic continuity in an era of competing priorities like nuclear deterrence and cyber defence.

References

  1. [1]
    Armed Forces to be more active around the world to combat threats ...
    Mar 23, 2021 · The Royal Navy will transform the Royal Marines into the Future Commando Force (FCF), marking an evolution from amphibious infantry held at ...
  2. [2]
    Royal Marines Commando unit created to shape the Future ...
    Jul 20, 2020 · A select group of commandos will form a new Vanguard Strike Company to shape how the Royal Marines Commandos of the future will operate around the globe.<|control11|><|separator|>
  3. [3]
    Strike from the sea – developing the UK Commando Force
    Jun 14, 2024 · The Royal Marines have been undergoing a rapid transformation in the last 5 years. Here we take an overview of their new operating concepts and the enablers.
  4. [4]
    Watch: What is the Future Commando Force? - Forces News
    Mar 23, 2021 · The Future Commando Force (FCF) is designed to modernise the way Royal Marines operate. It has been described by the Royal Navy as the most significant ...
  5. [5]
    New commando force leads Britain's military in Arctic operations
    May 13, 2022 · WASHINGTON ― The new Future Commando Force program, made up of about 4,000 personnel with the British Royal Marines, is leading the way in ...
  6. [6]
    Full article: The Future Commando Force - Taylor & Francis Online
    Jun 20, 2023 · The new Future Commando Force (FCF) concept shapes the Royal Marines into an expeditionary raiding force. It is designed to fight high intensity warfare.
  7. [7]
    [PDF] Defence in a competitive age - GOV.UK
    Future Commando Force (FCF). UK's new littoral strike fighting capability, centred around the Royal Marines. Global Response Force. Army's very-high-readiness ...
  8. [8]
    [PDF] Amphibious Futures: The Royal Marines in Contested New ... - RUSI
    Commando forces are a subset of amphibious forces typically optimised for tasks such as light infantry functions and raiding. In practice, this distinction has ...
  9. [9]
    [PDF] MARITIME OPERATING CONCEPT MarOpC - GOV.UK
    Sep 5, 2022 · Littoral Strike: A persistently engaged and technologically enabled Commando Force capable of strike and Special Operations, whilst ...Missing: rationale | Show results with:rationale
  10. [10]
    Understanding the Royal Navy's littoral response group concept
    Aug 17, 2021 · The LRG(N) was centred on HMS Albion and RFA Mounts Bay carrying 45 commando Royal Marines. To some extent, the LRG is just a re-branding ...
  11. [11]
    UK Littoral Response Group: the shape of things to come?
    Jun 25, 2021 · It consists of the amphibious assault ship or landing platform dock (LPD) HMS Albion and the auxiliary landing ship (LSD) RFA Mounts Bay, a ...
  12. [12]
    Royal Marines at the tip of the NATO spear on major Arctic exercise
    Mar 14, 2024 · The Littoral Response Group (North) is centred on 400 Royal Marines, Army and Navy Commandos and the amphibious ship RFA Mounts Bay. Nordic ...
  13. [13]
    Defence in microcosm: the future of the Royal Marines - The Ideas Lab
    Nov 21, 2024 · This concept was set out in the Defence Command Paper Defence in a competitive age, published in March 2021 as the military element of the wider ...
  14. [14]
    The evolving role of the Royal Marines Commandos
    Apr 3, 2025 · Today, they are reinventing themselves as a high-tech, forward-deployed force, ready to confront the grey zone challenges of great power ...
  15. [15]
    The United Kingdom Commando Force: An Introduction
    Jan 9, 2024 · The Littoral Strike concept of employment, which is the guiding idea behind the 'Future Commando Force' transformation, calls for a littoral ...
  16. [16]
    The Royal Marines & SBS: Locations, Commando Units, Personnel
    Nov 24, 2024 · Future and Innovation​​ The Royal Marines are undergoing significant transformation through the Future Commando Force (FCF) initiative, focusing ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  17. [17]
    How the UK is changing its special forces for a modern world
    Sep 10, 2025 · These include defense and protection of the UK and its dependencies; deterrence and defense in the Euro-Atlantic; and shaping the global ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  18. [18]
    Commando fliers complete year-long task group mission - Royal Navy
    Oct 26, 2024 · Two Response Groups lie at the heart of the commandos' future operating model, a self-contained force (ships, air power, commandos and kit) ...
  19. [19]
    UK and Netherlands confirm future amphibious relationship
    Jun 30, 2023 · The UK and Netherlands agree to explore opportunities to develop a future littoral strike platform, providing future capability to both nations' Commando ...
  20. [20]
    https://ukdefencejournal.org.uk/rangers-and-commandos-join-nato-special-ops-taskforce/
  21. [21]
    THE ROYAL MARINES IN NORWAY: Project Heimdall - Luftled
    The ultimate goal is for future exercise design to accommodate and test the Future Commando Force operating model, fully integrating with allied partners.
  22. [22]
    4The Royal Marines - Parliament UK
    Feb 1, 2018 · The evidence indicates that somewhere between 40 and 50% of UKSF personnel have a Royal Marines background—yet another indication of the ...
  23. [23]
    Modernising Defence Programme update - GOV.UK
    Dec 18, 2018 · We will improve the readiness and availability of a range of key Defence platforms: major warships, attack submarines, helicopters and a range ...
  24. [24]
    Commando Force - Navy Lookout
    In February 2019, the then Defence Minister, Gavin Williamson, announced the plan to rapidly procure vessels around which two 'Littoral Strike Groups' would be ...
  25. [25]
    DSEI: Royal Marines Embrace Littoral Strike and Prepare to Forward ...
    Sep 11, 2019 · At the heart of the proposed shake-up is the concept of Littoral Strike, which will see a future commando force projected onto land from specialist shipping.Missing: principles | Show results with:principles
  26. [26]
    Royal Marines take big step with new technology
    Apr 25, 2019 · ... Future Commando Force and Littoral Strike development. “This has been a ground-breaking exercise.” The equipment used in the exercise was ...
  27. [27]
    Commandos are the lethal tip of the spear on desert war games
    Nov 11, 2019 · Royal Marines have been developing the Future Commando Force concept as the lethal tip of the spear on war games in the California desert.Missing: initial planning
  28. [28]
    40 Commando | Royal Navy
    The unit of 40 Commando are at the forefront of innovation as commandos go back to their roots as raiders from the sea and embrace new technologies to help ...
  29. [29]
    New Commando Uniform for UK's Royal Marines | SOF News
    Jun 27, 2020 · Under the Future Commando Force programme more Royal Marines will operate from the sea, utilising new and innovative technology as high- ...Missing: inception planning<|separator|>
  30. [30]
    [PDF] How Defence Works (September 2020) - GOV.UK
    Sep 22, 2020 · • developing a Future Commando Force, returning to commando roots, with specialist troops using cutting-edge technology to deliver ...
  31. [31]
    Special Operations: British Future Commando Force - StrategyPage
    Mar 19, 2021 · Britain is implementing a lot of their Future Commando Force modernization measures in 2021 These include new combat equipment, weapons, ...
  32. [32]
    Future Commando Force - Military Wiki - Fandom
    The Future Commando Force (FCF) is an in-progress modernisation programme and model of the future role and operations of the Royal Marines.
  33. [33]
    Ministry of Defence Outcome Delivery Plan: 2021 to 2022 - GOV.UK
    Jul 15, 2021 · This Outcome Delivery Plan sets out our priorities: understanding the threats we face, defending the Homeland, contributing to a secure international community.Missing: phases | Show results with:phases
  34. [34]
    Britain's Commandos to get new assault rifles - Royal Navy
    Sep 6, 2023 · The Knight's Stoner 1 (KS-1) rifle (designated L403A1) headlines a host of new kit additions for the UK Commando Forces in 'lead strike teams'.Missing: developments | Show results with:developments
  35. [35]
    https://www.nao.org.uk/reports/equipment-plan-2023-to-2033/
  36. [36]
    Royal Marines complete Arctic training with intensive combat missions
    Mar 12, 2021 · 10 October 2024. UK Commando Force hone expertise in complex mountain warfare in Slovenia alongside NATO allies. Royal Marines have honed ...
  37. [37]
    Royal Navy procures new rifle for specialist commando operations
    Mar 8, 2025 · Royal Marines from the UK Commando Force have been issued a new rifle for specialist operations, including counter-terrorism.<|separator|>
  38. [38]
    Head to toe: Royal Marines Future Commando Force | Issue 120
    Feb 10, 2021 · The Royal Marines unveiled a new uniform as part of their transition into a Future Commando Force equipped with long-range uncrewed aerial vehicles, throwable ...
  39. [39]
    UK Royal Marines field over 1000 Persistent Systems MPU5 ...
    Jun 6, 2023 · This gear includes new helmet cameras, hand-thrown unmanned aircraft and ground systems, rotary-wing drones for ISR and resupply, and MPU5s to ...
  40. [40]
    Defence Secretary oral statement on the Defence Command Paper
    Mar 22, 2021 · Defence Secretary Ben Wallace describes Defence's contribution to the Integrated Review of Security, Defence, Development and Foreign Policy.
  41. [41]
    British military to receive 60 All-Terrain Vehicles under international ...
    Dec 16, 2022 · The vehicle boasts a number of characteristics that make it perfect for the Future Commando Force: it is adept over snow, has amphibious ...
  42. [42]
    First Sea Lord's Sea Power conference 2024 - Defence Secretary's ...
    May 14, 2024 · The MRSS programme is an important milestone in our Future Commando Force modernisation programme. And it takes the number of Royal Navy ...
  43. [43]
    Royal Marines | Joining Process
    How to join · Submit your application · Defence Aptitude Assessment (DAA) · Selection Interview · Pre joining Fitness Assessment (PJFA) · Attend the Royal Marine ...
  44. [44]
    [PDF] ROYAL MARINES CAREER HANDBOOK - Charlton School
    Under a Littoral Strike programme, we are transitioning into a Future Commando Force that will be structured, trained and equipped to meet the emerging ...
  45. [45]
    Royal Marines Commando 2025 | How2become.com
    The Royal Marines Commando Selection Process · Stage 1 – ONLINE REGISTRATION & APPLICATION · Stage 2 – The Naval Service Defence Aptitude Assessment · Stage 3 – ...
  46. [46]
    Royal Marines Recruitment & Selection Overview
    Aug 8, 2016 · Table 1, below, provides an outline of the current Royal Marines recruitment and selection process.Royal Marines Pre Joining... · Tests And Interviews · The Royal Marines Vision
  47. [47]
    Females welcomed to Commando selection – but standards remain ...
    Oct 10, 2025 · Females welcomed to Commando selection – but standards remain as arduous as ever · Trial planned to change Royal Marines recruit training course ...
  48. [48]
    Royal Marines have shortfall of 600 troops amid recruitment crisis
    Jan 9, 2024 · ... Future Commando Force programme and oversaw a period of transformation. keywords. Topics. UK Foreign and Security Policy · Sea Power. Regions ...
  49. [49]
    Royal Marines have shortfall of 600 troops amid recruitment crisis
    Jan 9, 2024 · However, they said the Future Commando Force (FCF) envisaged marines being a more agile force, rather than carrying out mass amphibious assault.<|control11|><|separator|>
  50. [50]
    https://nationalsecuritynews.com/2025/10/royal-marine-chief-urges-super-fit-women-to-join-the-commandos/
  51. [51]
    Commandos prepare for operations on Mojave Desert training ...
    Oct 26, 2021 · ... Future Commando Force. This includes keeping small teams of ... Littoral Response Group (South) early next year.” Related articles. 10 ...
  52. [52]
    Royal Marines scrutinise new tactics in the Mojave Desert
    Dec 21, 2020 · “Overall a great deal was learnt as best practice for Future Commando Force teams.” This main exercise followed intensive training 7,000ft ...
  53. [53]
    Royal Marines raiders take on high speed exercises with HMS ...
    Jun 19, 2020 · More emphasis will be placed on these boarding and raiding skills as Royal Marines forge ahead with Future Commando Force development. The ...
  54. [54]
    Royal Marines trial virtual reality kit - Royal Navy
    Mar 4, 2021 · The use of the software is to support real-life training, not replace it. It's all part of Future Commando Force development and allows ...<|separator|>
  55. [55]
    Royal Marines test new kit and commando skills during intensive ...
    Aug 29, 2025 · Exercise Green Dagger sharpened distinct mountain skills – vertical assaults and abseiling, river crossings and reconnaissance – and brought ...
  56. [56]
    Royal Marines test new technology for UK future commando force
    May 31, 2019 · The central theme of the UK future commando force is to experiment with how Royal Marines will operate on the battlefields of the future, while ...Missing: rationale | Show results with:rationale
  57. [57]
    Royal Marines test future tech on commando raids
    May 29, 2019 · Royal Marines have looked back to their commando roots as they experiment with how they will operate on the battlefields of the future.Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  58. [58]
    Future Commando Force: Royal Marines Trial New Concepts
    Sep 2, 2020 · Royal Marines have been testing new concepts for the Future Commando Force at Bovington Training Area in Dorset.Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  59. [59]
    Royal Marines add new kit to daring exercises in Gibraltar
    Nov 13, 2020 · More than 80 marines from Scotland-based 43 Commando Fleet Protection Group spent two weeks on Exercise Serpent Rock, honing the skills ...
  60. [60]
    Royal Marines Test Future Commando Force Concepts In Cyprus
    Nov 30, 2020 · Royal Marines Test Future Commando Force Concepts In Cyprus. Briohny Williams. 30th November 2020 at 11:34am. Video Player is loading. Play ...
  61. [61]
    Royal Navy looks to future following successful technology trials in ...
    Jan 5, 2021 · Norway was the first real test of Project EVE, the infrastructure that is underpinning Future Commando Force, and Cyprus further put the system ...<|separator|>
  62. [62]
    Commando Force not funded to 'operate in high-threat' areas
    Dec 4, 2023 · The report points out a stark funding gap, indicating that the Commando Force is currently not funded to operate from the sea in high-threat maritime ...
  63. [63]
    Thoughts on the Future Commando Force - UK Defence Journal
    Feb 1, 2021 · To sum up, the FCF concept assures the future of the Royal Marines. It will provide a capability of great value in both low intensity and high ...
  64. [64]
    Defence outlines 2030 vision for the Armed Forces
    The Royal Marines will also benefit from a £200-million investment over the next ten years to form the Future Command Force, a Commando force that is ...Missing: funding | Show results with:funding<|control11|><|separator|>
  65. [65]
    The Commando Force's Focus on Raiding is Distorting Future ...
    Feb 15, 2023 · Future-Commando-Force-Hero. Royal Marines in Offshore Raiding Craft in 2019. (Credit: Royal Navy. Open Government ...
  66. [66]
    Ready for War? - Defence Committee - Parliament UK
    Feb 4, 2024 · We started this inquiry with the intention of assessing the Readiness of the UK Armed Forces, and reporting our findings to the House and to the public.
  67. [67]
    Minister rejects claims Royal Marines standards are changing
    Apr 30, 2025 · Alistair Carns has rejected online speculation that the standards required to earn the Royal Marines Green Beret are being lowered.