Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

iOS 13

iOS 13 is the thirteenth major release of the iOS mobile operating system developed by . exclusively for iPhone devices. Announced at the on June 3, 2019, and publicly released on September 19, 2019, it succeeded and introduced substantial enhancements in , protections, and system performance. Key features included a system-wide Dark Mode that reduced and extended display battery life by dynamically adjusting interface colors to darker tones, alongside a redesigned app with advanced editing tools for non-destructive modifications to images and videos. iOS 13 also debuted Sign in with Apple, a privacy-focused method that allowed users to create accounts without sharing with third-party apps, hiding addresses via relays. Performance optimizations reduced app download sizes by up to 50 percent and app updates by up to 60 percent, while enabling app launches up to twice as fast compared to iOS 12. The update supported iPhones from the onward, requiring a minimum of 2 GB and discontinuing compatibility with 32-bit apps, which prompted developers to migrate to 64-bit architectures. Concurrently, Apple bifurcated iPad functionality into the separate , allowing iOS 13 to focus on iPhone-specific refinements like swipe-to-type input and improved Maps with "Look Around" street-level imagery akin to . While initial rollout encountered typical launch bugs such as battery drain and connectivity issues—addressed in subsequent point releases like iOS 13.1—iOS 13 laid foundational improvements in privacy and efficiency that influenced future iterations.

Development and Announcement

Announcement at WWDC 2019

iOS 13 was publicly unveiled on June 3, 2019, during the keynote presentation at Apple's (WWDC) in , as the direct successor to iOS 12. The announcement highlighted a redesigned and strengthened measures as core priorities, with Apple describing the update as delivering a "dramatic new look" for through system-wide theming options and tools to limit data sharing with apps. Key demonstrations during the keynote included Dark Mode, which applies dark backgrounds across the system and compatible apps to reduce eye strain and potentially extend display battery life; Sign in with Apple, a privacy-centric system that hides email addresses from third-party services and generates unique relays; and significant overhauls to native apps such as for enhanced editing and organization, and Maps for improved navigation and Look Around imagery. These features were positioned to modernize the experience on existing hardware, addressing long-standing user requests for visual and functional updates without requiring new devices. Apple also showcased performance optimizations, claiming app launches up to twice as fast, authentication 30% quicker, app downloads 50% smaller on average, and update sizes reduced by 60%, attributing these gains to system-wide efficiencies rather than hardware changes. enhancements were a recurring theme, including options for one-time location sharing and on-device processing for suggestions to minimize data transmission to servers. The beta version for developers was made available immediately following the keynote, with public release planned for the fall.

Development Focus and Goals

Apple's engineering efforts for iOS 13 prioritized revitalizing dynamism after iOS 12's primary emphasis on backend stability and bug fixes, which had deferred major visual overhauls. The core objectives centered on implementing system-wide Dark Mode for reduced and improved low-light usability, alongside refined gesture navigation to streamline app switching and minimize reliance on on-screen buttons. These changes stemmed from internal assessments of fatigue, aiming to foster greater customization and efficiency without compromising the platform's core simplicity. A pivotal goal involved forking iPad optimizations into the distinct variant, freeing iOS 13 to incorporate iPhone-tailored advancements like QuickPath swipe typing on the , which leveraged touch input patterns unsuitable for larger iPad screens. This separation acknowledged hardware divergences—such as iPhone's compact versus iPad's expansive display—and usage disparities, enabling parallel development tracks to avoid feature conflicts and enhance device-specific responsiveness. Performance targets were informed by telemetry from iOS 12 deployments, which highlighted inefficiencies in app suspension and leading to crashes and drain. Engineers optimized for up to 2x faster app resume times via streamlined background handling and code execution efficiencies, alongside 50% reductions in initial download sizes through modular asset delivery. unlocks were engineered for 30% quicker processing, collectively addressing empirical reports of sluggishness on older devices while preserving battery longevity.

Release History

Initial Release and Major Updates

iOS 13 entered developer beta testing on June 3, 2019, immediately following its unveiling at Apple's (WWDC), with public betas available shortly thereafter to allow broader testing ahead of the stable release. The initial public version, iOS 13.0, launched on September 19, 2019, marking the first major update to Apple's since , introducing core features such as system-wide Dark Mode and a redesigned app. Just five days later, on September 24, 2019, Apple expedited the release of to address stability issues reported in the initial rollout, including battery drain and app crashes, while adding new capabilities like mouse support through AssistiveTouch for purposes and enhancements to such as Look Around functionality. Subsequent feature-bearing updates followed rapidly; arrived on October 28, 2019, enabling Deep —a technique that merges multiple exposures for improved detail in low-light photos—alongside new sets and shortcut analysis options. Further refinements continued into 2020, with iOS 13.4 releasing on March 24 amid the early , incorporating Drive folder sharing to permit collaborative access and permissions management directly from the Files app, as well as new Memoji stickers and trackpad gestures for compatibility that extended usability benefits. The sequence of major updates concluded with iOS 13.6.1 on August 12, 2020, which included final feature tweaks such as improvements to the TV app for better content sharing and playback alongside a fix for excessive storage accumulation from system data files, paving the way for the transition to iOS 14's public debut the following month.

Security and Bug-Fix Patches

iOS 13 received multiple point releases after its major feature updates, concentrating on remediation of security vulnerabilities and stability improvements. These patches targeted critical issues, including kernel-level memory corruption that could enable arbitrary code execution and escapes from app sandboxes, as detailed in Apple's security advisories for sub-versions like iOS 13.1 through 13.7. For example, iOS 13.4, released March 24, 2020, patched 30 vulnerabilities across components such as the kernel, WebKit, and Foundation framework, addressing risks like out-of-bounds memory access and input validation failures. Subsequent updates, such as iOS 13.5 on May 20, 2020, and iOS 13.5.1 on June 1, 2020, fixed additional privileges escalation flaws that allowed malicious apps to execute with elevated , including one exploited by jailbreak tools. These releases documented fixes for over 20 distinct CVEs in some cases, with cumulative efforts across the iOS 13 series addressing dozens of such causal defects through improved memory handling and validation. iOS 13.5 also incorporated the for , paired with security enhancements to prevent related abuse vectors. Support for iOS 13 concluded with version 13.7 in September 2020, after which no further patches were issued for the branch, rendering un-updated installations susceptible to unpatched exploits. Compatible hardware transitioned to iOS 14 and beyond for ongoing vulnerability remediation, though devices remaining on iOS 13 faced elevated risks compared to ecosystems with prolonged branch support; this contrasts with Android's fragmentation, where many devices receive no equivalent timely fixes due to manufacturer delays. Apple's approach prioritized unified patching during active support, evidenced by rapid deployment of kernel and sandbox remedies that curtailed known exploit chains.

System-Wide Features

User Interface Redesign

iOS 13 introduced an optional Dark Mode that inverted the system's light theme to a predominantly dark color scheme, applying it consistently across native apps and supported third-party interfaces. This change aimed to reduce during prolonged use in dim lighting by lowering overall screen and ratios that could exacerbate visual fatigue. Independent tests verified its benefits for displays, where black pixels consume no power; for instance, enabling Dark Mode on an Max extended battery life by up to 30% during indoor at low brightness levels (100 nits), and by 12% in brighter conditions (300 nits). The volume heads-up display (HUD) was repositioned to a compact overlay in the screen's upper-left corner, shrinking dynamically after initial adjustment to reduce visual obstruction compared to the prior centered, persistent indicator. This redesign improved by allowing users to maintain focus on content, such as videos, without the large blocking key areas. System-wide contextual menus, triggered by long-press gestures, expanded to provide quick-action previews and options directly on interactive elements, streamlining workflows previously requiring multiple taps or menu navigation. These menus replaced some 3D Touch dependencies, broadening accessibility across devices without pressure-sensitive screens. The Control Center underwent refinement with support for multiple swipeable pages, allowing users to group and customize toggles for frequently accessed settings like , , and flashlight, thereby facilitating faster one-handed operation without cluttering a single view.

Performance and Battery Optimizations

iOS 13 implemented system-level optimizations to enhance responsiveness, primarily through revisions to app resource loading and process scheduling that enabled apps to launch up to twice as fast on devices such as the and 2018 when compared to the same hardware running iOS 12.3. These gains stemmed from an improved scheduler, reduced overall usage, and more efficient high-priority allocation for foreground tasks, allowing quicker initialization without preloading unnecessary assets. Battery efficiency benefited from more aggressive throttling of app refresh and ancillary processes, which minimized idle power draw while prioritizing active usage. A key addition in iOS 13.1 was Optimized Battery Charging, which uses to analyze daily routines and hold charging at 80% until the typical departure time, thereby reducing the chemical stress of prolonged full-charge states and extending long-term capacity retention. Low Power Mode received complementary adjustments to further limit activities and when activated, though core functionality remained consistent with prior versions. On supported older hardware like the , these changes occasionally led to trade-offs, including reported animation stuttering during home screen transitions, attributable to the increased demands of refined process management on constrained and CPU resources. Independent benchmarks confirmed smoother real-world task execution on newer models but highlighted variability on entry-level devices, underscoring the causal role of limits in optimization outcomes.

Privacy and Security Enhancements

iOS 13 introduced Sign in with Apple, a mechanism enabling users to log into third-party apps and websites via their without disclosing personal details like addresses or numbers to the service providers. Launched in September 2019 alongside the initial iOS 13 release, this feature utilizes a private that assigns a unique, app-specific proxy address, forwarding messages to the user's true while concealing it from developers and mitigating data aggregation practices prevalent in alternatives like or sign-ins. Developers were mandated to offer Sign in with Apple alongside any third-party login options, promoting broader adoption and reducing reliance on data-intensive social logins. Location Services received substantial refinements, including a new permission model with "Allow Once" prompts for one-time access, replacing immediate "Always Allow" options to curb persistent tracking, alongside background access indicators notifying users of ongoing usage. Significant Locations data—historical records aiding personalized suggestions—was encrypted on-device with access restricted to essential system functions. To thwart network-level surveillance, iOS 13 implemented randomization for connections, assigning temporary, unique identifiers per network to prevent cross-location device fingerprinting by carriers or hotspots, complemented by limits on apps' ability to scan nearby devices for location inference. These measures prioritized limiting third-party access over Apple's internal practices, where diagnostic analytics and iCloud syncing collect usage unless users navigate complex paths across multiple settings menus. Unlike Android's contemporaneous permissions, which offered finer-grained toggles for individual sensors, 13's controls emphasized prompted consents but provided fewer per-app granularities for ancillary data like or precise repeat access, potentially leaving residual ecosystem tracking vectors. Empirical reviews post-release confirmed reduced app-requested but highlighted that relayed communications in Sign in with Apple still route through Apple's servers, introducing a centralized intermediary not present in decentralized alternatives.

Siri and Machine Learning Improvements

iOS 13 introduced enhancements to via neural text-to-speech (TTS) technology, enabling a more natural-sounding voice synthesized entirely by software rather than concatenated audio clips, which improved prosody including stress, intonation, and rhythm patterns. This shift supported better handling of varied speech outputs while maintaining computational efficiency on device hardware. The Shortcuts app became native to iOS 13, expanding automation capabilities with triggers for creating and executing multi-step routines, such as contextual actions based on user habits detected via on-device . On-device processing for suggestions reduced cloud dependency, enabling faster response times for routine queries by leveraging local neural networks, though specific reductions varied by without quantified averages like 30% across all tasks. These improvements prioritized privacy-preserving inference but highlighted limitations in , where often failed to infer multi-step cause-effect relationships in complex scenarios compared to data-intensive models. In response to the July scandal where contractors reviewed anonymized Siri audio for quality improvement—revealing inadvertent recordings of private conversations—Apple implemented for voice data storage and made human review opt-in only, applying these changes in iOS 13 to limit unauthorized access. Empirical benchmarks from showed Siri achieving higher accuracy in basic query handling due to refined on-device models, yet it underperformed in navigation and contextual tasks, succeeding in only about 80-90% of complex prompts versus Google's near-98% in similar evaluations. Offline support in iOS 13 allowed to process rudimentary commands like setting alarms or timers without internet connectivity, relying on pre-downloaded on-device models, but advanced features remained cloud-bound, underscoring Apple's deliberate lag in adoption relative to ecosystems that aggregated anonymized data for broader training without central storage. This on-device emphasis enhanced latency for supported tasks and mitigated data transmission risks but constrained 's adaptability in dynamic, reasoning-heavy interactions, where competitors' approaches yielded superior empirical outcomes in real-world accuracy tests.

Accessibility and Input Changes

iOS 13 introduced QuickPath, a swipe-to-type feature for that allows users to slide a finger across keys to input words, with the system predicting the intended term based on gesture path and providing autocorrect suggestions that adapt from user corrections. This method, enabled by default upon iOS 13 installation on September 19, 2019, supports continuous typing without lifting the finger, enhancing input speed for able-bodied users while offering an alternative to precise tapping for those with motor challenges. Text selection and editing gestures were refined for efficiency, including double-tapping to select a word, triple-tapping for a , and quadruple-tapping for a , alongside three-finger actions such as pinching to or cut and swiping to . These updates, available across -compatible devices, reduce reliance on contextual menus and improve precision in text manipulation, particularly benefiting users with limited dexterity by minimizing multi-step interactions. Voice Control debuted as a comprehensive hands-free input system, enabling spoken commands to navigate interfaces, dictate text, edit content, and control apps without physical input, with support for custom vocabulary and grid overlays for precise targeting. Introduced at and rolled out in the initial release, this feature processes on-device commands for privacy and allows overlay numbering for element selection, providing motor-impaired users an alternative to touch-based navigation. The Files app expanded to support direct access to external USB drives and SD cards via or adapters, facilitating file input and management from removable storage without importing to internal memory. This capability, new in iOS 13, aids users dependent on external media for data transfer, such as those with accessibility needs for bulk input or compatibility with specialized hardware. Haptic feedback integration via Haptic Touch provided tactile confirmation for long-press inputs and actions, configurable in settings for customized .

Application-Specific Updates

Photos and Media Management

The Photos app in iOS 13 introduced a redesigned tabbed interface at the bottom of the screen, featuring Library for chronological viewing of all media, For You for machine-curated suggestions like memories and shared activity highlights, Search with enhanced queries and , and Albums for organized collections including smart albums based on such as , places, and dates. This structure improved navigation by prioritizing contextual discovery over linear scrolling, leveraging on-device to surface relevant content without requiring manual sorting. Video editing tools received updates for more intuitive manipulation, including drag handles on the to clips precisely by adjusting start and end points, alongside options to add filters, text, and slow-motion effects directly in the Photos app. These changes enabled basic non-destructive edits on-device, reducing reliance on third-party apps for simple tasks like shortening footage or stabilizing shaky videos via built-in stabilization algorithms that analyze motion data from the device's sensors. With iOS 13.2, Deep Fusion was added exclusively for iPhone 11 series devices, employing the A13 Bionic's Neural Engine to perform pixel-level fusion of multiple exposures: a primary short-exposure image for sharpness, supplemented by a burst of longer exposures to capture fine textures and reduce noise in medium-lighting conditions (e.g., indoor settings with ambient light). This computational photography technique processes nine images in a single shot—merging them via machine learning models trained to preserve natural details like fabric weaves or hair strands—resulting in higher fidelity outputs compared to single-exposure captures, though it can introduce artifacts such as unnatural edge sharpening or color inconsistencies in complex scenes, which some reviewers noted as less customizable than raw processing pipelines in certain Android camera applications that allow user-selected fusion parameters. Shared Albums capacity supported up to 5,000 photos and videos per album, facilitating group syncing for family or events without consuming personal storage quotas, as content in shared libraries is hosted separately and only downloads for participants. This limit encouraged efficient media distribution by prompting deletions or new albums upon reaching capacity, mitigating storage bloat while maintaining causal access control through subscriber invitations and contributor restrictions.

Messages, Memoji, and Communication

iOS 13 expanded expressive options in the Messages app through Memoji stickers, enabling users to generate and share static avatar-based images featuring customizable poses, expressions, and accessories such as new hats, piercings, teeth options, and hair styles. These stickers integrate directly into conversations via the keyboard or app drawer, allowing drag-and-drop attachment similar to third-party packs. Animoji characters gained three additional options—an , cow, and —enhancing animated messaging with broader animal representations tracked via the device's . Group messaging received refinements, including per-thread notification muting to reduce interruptions without leaving conversations, and synchronized display of effects like bubble animations across participants with compatible devices. These updates prioritized intra-Apple , where full feature parity relies on all users operating within the ecosystem. maintained its protocol for Apple-to-Apple exchanges, ensuring messages remain inaccessible to intermediaries including Apple itself under normal operation. Cross-platform communication with devices defaults to unencrypted or , stripping advanced features and security, which perpetuates distinct "blue bubble" () and "green bubble" () visuals signaling reduced functionality. Apple's refusal to extend to , as internal documents reveal, stems from a deliberate strategy to leverage feature exclusivity for user retention and ecosystem loyalty, effectively raising switching costs for owners. This approach has drawn antitrust scrutiny, with the U.S. Department of Justice contending that withholding and rich media support from non-Apple platforms erects barriers that hinder competition in mobile operating systems. Post-release data indicated sustained growth in engagement, with usage contributing to higher interaction rates in personal communications, though precise metrics tied to 's additions remain sparse in public reports. User feedback highlighted drawbacks, including visual clutter from proliferated s overwhelming conversation threads and elevated storage demands from accumulated media, prompting complaints about interface usability and device space management.

Maps and Location Services

iOS 13 introduced several enhancements to , focusing on improved navigation interfaces and user personalization features. The app received a redesigned search and direction interface with simplified controls for entering destinations and selecting transport modes, aiming to streamline route planning. Look Around, a street-level imagery feature akin to , became available in select U.S. cities including , , and at launch, allowing users to explore panoramic views by tapping a dedicated button in search results. This imagery was captured via Apple's own vehicles, providing interactive 360-degree perspectives without reliance on third-party street view data. Favorites functionality enabled users to save frequently visited locations like home or work, with automatic syncing across iCloud-connected Apple devices for seamless access. Guides offered curated collections of recommendations for categories such as dining or shopping, drawn from partnerships with providers like , allowing users to follow pre-built lists or create custom ones for trip planning. Navigation updates included real-time transit schedules for buses and trains in supported areas, with arrival predictions and connection details integrated into directions. However, cycling directions were not available at iOS 13's September 19, 2019 release, trailing on which had supported bike routes since 2010, limiting options for urban cyclists. Apple Maps in iOS 13 processed certain route calculations on-device to minimize data transmission to servers, reducing the risk of location history linkage to user identities beyond basic navigation requests. Map data sourcing continued to depend on partnerships, notably with for base cartography and routing information, supplemented by Apple's growing in-house collections. Critics noted incomplete coverage and lower empirical accuracy compared to , which benefited from extensive crowdsourced data from billions of Android queries and user contributions; independent reviews from the era highlighted frequent routing errors in , such as outdated road details or missed turns, attributing this to Google's superior scale over Apple's licensed sources.

Reminders and Productivity Tools

The Reminders app in iOS 13 underwent a major redesign, introducing features aimed at enhancing task organization and management. Smart Lists automatically categorized reminders into predefined groups such as Scheduled, Today, Flagged, and All, dynamically populating based on attributes like due dates, priorities, and flags without manual sorting. Users could create custom Smart Lists filtered by tags, dates, locations, or priorities, providing a more intuitive overview of tasks. Additional capabilities included support for sub-tasks via nested checklists within individual reminders, enabling of complex projects. Tags were implemented through input, such as appending "#work" or "#urgent" to a reminder, which allowed searching and filtering across lists. Enhanced permitted quick creation of reminders via phrases like "remind me tomorrow at 3 PM to ," integrating seamlessly with for voice or text entry. These updates positioned Reminders as a more robust , comparable to competitors like in feature depth, though confined to the without cross-platform flexibility akin to Google Keep's access. iCloud syncing saw backend improvements to support the new , requiring users to lists via for access to advanced features like templates and shared lists. However, this rendered Reminders incompatible with pre-iOS 13 devices and older macOS versions, leading to sync failures for mixed-device households. Reports highlighted occasional desynchronization issues, such as delayed updates or incomplete propagation across devices, often resolved by manual interventions but exposing reliability gaps. While preview analyses noted productivity enhancements from streamlined organization—such as faster task capture and reduced in beta testing—these were tempered by ecosystem limitations, including the absence of native third-party integration for quick access from the . The app's protocol support was discontinued, disrupting synchronization with non-Apple third-party services and reinforcing dependency on . This design prioritized intra-Apple cohesion over broader , potentially hindering users reliant on diverse toolchains.

Music and Entertainment Apps

iOS 13 introduced time-synced lyrics in the Apple Music app, enabling users to follow along with songs displaying lyrics that advance in real-time with the beat, available for select tracks in Apple Music's catalog. The app also featured an improved Up Next queue interface, presented as a dedicated view for managing upcoming playback, adding songs dynamically, and reviewing recent history without excessive scrolling. These updates aimed to enhance user control over playback sequences, though some observers noted the changes prioritized visual polish over deeper customization options found in competitors. The in iOS 13 expanded integration with third-party streaming channels, such as and Showtime, allowing users to access subscription-based content directly within the app alongside purchased or rented media, with unified authentication via TV providers. This consolidation facilitated a single interface for entertainment services, reducing the need to switch between standalone apps, but required linking credentials that some users found cumbersome for multi-provider setups. Unlike later iOS versions, iOS 13 did not support lossless audio playback in , which relies on compressed formats like , limiting fidelity compared to uncompressed alternatives available on platforms like via third-party apps supporting open codecs such as . Apple's emphasis on subscription tiers in Music drew criticism for ecosystem lock-in, as seamless integration favored over rivals, potentially discouraging use of open-format libraries that permitted more flexibly without premium barriers. User reports highlighted battery drain issues during Apple Music playback in iOS 13, particularly from background activity, contradicting broader claims of playback efficiency gains and prompting workarounds like disabling refresh or data access. Interface critiques positioned as less intuitive than Spotify's, with the Now Playing sheet and navigation described as clunky and visually heavy, prioritizing aesthetics over streamlined access to libraries and playlists.

Hardware Compatibility

Supported Devices

iOS 13 supported the and Plus, , and 7 Plus, and 8 Plus, , , and XS Max, and , 11 Pro, and 11 Pro Max; it was also compatible with the seventh-generation . Apple ended support for the , , and Plus, as their A7 and A8 chips lacked the processing capabilities to handle iOS 13's expanded features and optimizations without significant performance degradation. On the with its A9 chip, iOS 13 delivered functional performance comparable to iOS 12 in everyday tasks, though with slight slowdowns in animations and multitasking; devices with A12 Bionic or later chips, such as the and series, fully utilized neural engine improvements for faster on-device processing in features like photo editing and enhancements. This compatibility cutoff aligned with Apple's pattern of maintaining roughly five years of major OS updates per device, incentivizing upgrades to access peak efficiency and new hardware-specific capabilities. Adoption reached 55% of iPhones from the prior four years by October 2019 and exceeded 80% on compatible devices by mid-2020, reflecting strong uptake among eligible users despite initial bugs. Critics, including analysts, contended that the exclusions exemplified to boost sales, particularly when contrasted with select Android manufacturers offering seven or more years of updates on flagship models by the early .

Device-Specific Limitations

iOS 13 introduced features constrained by device hardware, resulting in incomplete parity across supported iPhones. For instance, Deep Fusion, a technology leveraging for enhanced image detail in medium-light conditions, was exclusive to the , , and iPhone 11 Pro Max due to their A13 Bionic processors' neural engine capabilities; older models like the , with the A9 chip, lacked the requisite processing power for real-time fusion of multiple image frames. Dark Mode, while universally available on iOS 13-compatible devices, offered limited battery efficiency gains on LCD-equipped iPhones such as the 6s, 7, and 8 series, where black pixels still required backlight illumination; benchmarks confirmed negligible power savings compared to displays on the , , XR, and 11 models, which could achieve up to 30% reduction in display energy draw by deactivating pixels for true blacks. The platform entirely omitted iPad compatibility, with Apple redirecting tablet enhancements to the separate release to accommodate larger screens and multitasking demands, thereby stranding pre-2015 iPads on without access to iOS 13's UI refinements or app updates. This hardware-software interdependence, a hallmark of Apple's philosophy, enabled iOS 13's tailored optimizations but enforced upgrade cycles for full functionality, differing from Android's broader , which supported diverse devices through layers at the cost of potential performance variances and delayed feature rollouts.

Issues and Criticisms

Launch Bugs and Stability Problems

Upon its release on September 19, 2019, iOS 13.0 exhibited numerous stability issues, including frequent app crashes, system freezes, and excessive drain reported by users across multiple devices. Specific complaints highlighted crashes in third-party apps upon launch and erratic in built-in applications, with battery consumption accelerating due to background processes and unoptimized code. User forums documented these problems affecting a significant portion of early adopters, with threads on platforms like and Apple Communities indicating widespread disruption shortly after rollout. Apple's subsequent updates underscored the severity, as iOS 13 required eight patches within the first two months—more than any prior iOS version in a comparable period—targeting core stability flaws. iOS 13.1, released on September 24, 2019, incorporated extensive bug fixes, including remedies for drain and restore failures from backups, though it introduced some new inconsistencies. Further iterations like iOS 13.1.1 addressed lingering crash triggers and Siri-related hangs, reflecting reactive stabilization efforts. Contributing factors traced to the development cycle included persistent bugs from the initial betas unveiled at WWDC in June 2019, where testers encountered unresolved edge cases in features like Dark Mode and app switching. The compressed timeline between beta phases and general availability amplified these, as evidenced by developer reports of sync failures and glitches persisting into production. This pattern of elevated post-launch volatility contrasted with iOS 12's more refined rollout, prioritizing rapid feature delivery over exhaustive pre-release hardening.

Performance Inconsistencies Across Devices

Independent benchmarks revealed that iOS 13's performance optimizations yielded uneven results across hardware generations, with older A9-powered devices like the experiencing marginally slower overall responsiveness compared to , though the difference was described as nearly imperceptible in everyday tasks and occasionally faster in specific operations such as app launches. Newer models with and later chips generally realized Apple's promised gains, including up to twice as fast app resuming on the , but sustained workloads could trigger dynamic CPU throttling if battery health degraded, reducing peak speeds by up to 20-30% in affected scenarios to avert shutdowns. The introduction of Optimized Battery Charging in iOS 13, which pauses charging at 80% until predicted usage time to minimize chemical on lithium-ion cells, showed variable real-world efficacy; while designed to extend by reducing time spent at full charge, early user tests and reviews indicated inconsistent pattern learning, leading to frequent overrides to 100% and limited measurable lifespan benefits amid initial software bugs. Critics noted discrepancies between Apple's internal metrics—claiming broad efficiency uplifts—and third-party benchmarks like , where multi-core scores on devices such as the remained largely stable or showed minor regressions in threaded tasks post-update, suggesting that headline gains masked variances in management and under load. This opacity in Apple's testing methodology fueled skepticism, as independent data emphasized hardware-tier dependencies over uniform improvements.

Controversies Around Ecosystem Lock-In

Sign in with Apple, introduced at the on June 3, 2019, and rolled out with on September 19, 2019, required developers of apps offering third-party social logins—such as those from or —to also implement Apple's alternative as a privacy-focused option. Proponents viewed it as a counter to data-tracking practices by giants, particularly amid post-Cambridge Analytica scrutiny, but antitrust watchdogs and developers criticized it for entrenching dependency on Apple IDs and the ecosystem, potentially stifling competition by favoring Apple's proprietary system over rivals' login methods. The U.S. Department of Justice launched an investigation into the feature in early 2021 as part of broader antitrust scrutiny of Apple, highlighting complaints that the mandate disadvantaged competing authentication services while binding users more tightly to Apple's services. iMessage's enhancements in iOS 13, including Animoji and Memoji expansions, reinforced its role as a proprietary messaging protocol exclusive to Apple devices, exacerbating interoperability issues with via the continued absence of (RCS) support. This exclusivity manifested in visual distinctions like bubbles for iMessage versus green for SMS/MMS from non-iOS users, fostering a that empirically drives network effects and iPhone adoption, with surveys from the era indicating iMessage as a key factor in U.S. teen preferences—up to 80% citing seamless group chats as influential. executives, including Sameer Samat, publicly rebuked Apple's refusal to adopt RCS standards by 2022, attributing it to deliberate strategies that prioritize ecosystem retention over cross-platform parity, a stance Apple maintained until announcing partial RCS implementation in late 2023 for iOS 18. The UK's later described iMessage as contributing to "serious lock-in" effects in 2021 testimony, underscoring how such features create switching costs that favor Apple's market share stability. iOS 13's privacy enhancements, such as randomized MAC addresses for scanning and for aggregated in features like suggestions and improvements, were promoted as bolstering the "walled garden" model's superiority over Android's more . However, —a adding statistical to datasets—permits Apple to collect and analyze behavioral centrally for product refinement, drawing for enabling surveillance-like aggregation under the guise of , as noted in analyses questioning whether it truly prevents inferential breaches at scale. Detractors argue this undermines Apple's narrative of inherent advantages, since the closed concentrates risks in Apple's hands while marketing features obscure that still occurs internally, contrasting with decentralized Android vulnerabilities but not eliminating centralized control's causal potential for abuse. Empirical comparisons, including lower incidence on (under 0.5% vs. Android's higher rates per security reports), support some efficacy claims, yet antitrust discussions frame these as tools reinforcing lock-in by portraying alternatives as riskier without addressing Apple's own dependencies.

Reception and Legacy

Critical and User Reception

Critics generally praised iOS 13 for its visual and functional updates, including a refreshed with Dark Mode, enhanced controls via Sign in with Apple, and redesigned apps like and Reminders. described it as a "worthy upgrade" that overhauled the UI significantly since , emphasizing system-wide Dark Mode and contextual improvements, though it noted persistent limitations. The Verge awarded it 7.5 out of 10, highlighting Dark Mode's aesthetic appeal and automatic toggling, alongside robust photo editing tools, but criticized the rushed launch feel. Tom's Guide gave 4 out of 5 stars for innovations like Dark Mode and the revamped app, while rated it 4.5 out of 5 for improved efficiency and features. User reception was mixed initially due to launch-day stability issues, including app crashes, cellular connectivity drops, and Camera app slowdowns, prompting Apple to release just five days after the September 19, 2019 debut to address bugs. Despite these, adoption was brisk, reaching 20% of compatible devices within one week and 50% within 26 days, indicating broad acceptance of new features like swipe-based QuickPath typing and privacy enhancements. Dark Mode, a flagship addition, garnered strong user interest, with iOS adoption rates estimated at 55-70% among Apple users, reflecting satisfaction with its eye-strain reduction and battery savings on displays, though some third-party app inconsistencies persisted early on. Overall, while innovations met expectations for and , empirical feedback underscored stability shortfalls that tempered post-launch enthusiasm until patches stabilized the system.

Comparative Analysis with Competitors

iOS 13's unified update mechanism enabled rapid adoption across Apple's ecosystem, reaching 50% of active iPhones within 26 days of its September 19, 2019 release, compared to 's slower rollout hampered by manufacturer dependencies. , released on September 3, 2019, achieved only about 16% adoption after 10 months, reflecting persistent fragmentation where, by late 2019, the majority of devices ran versions older than (Android 9), with less than 10% typically on the latest release due to varying OEM support timelines. This disparity stems from iOS's centralized control, ensuring consistent updates for supported spanning six years of , versus 's decentralized model, which prioritizes broad compatibility but delays patches and features for many users. In privacy features, iOS 13 introduced granular controls like location privacy enhancements and "Sign in with Apple" to reduce third-party tracking, appearing more robust on paper than 10's scoped , which limited app access to external files to curb unauthorized data scanning. However, empirical data underscores iOS's lower incidence, attributable to Apple's stringent review process and absence of , with mobile threats in Q3 2019 predominantly targeting due to its open ecosystem and fragmentation enabling exploits on unpatched devices. 's higher vulnerability—evidenced by rapid evolution focused on its platform—arose from easier app distribution outside , though scoped mitigated some tracking risks without the closed-gatekeeper model of iOS. Feature-wise, both systems debuted system-wide Dark Mode in 2019, but iOS 13's implementation offered deeper integration with higher contrast and refinement, arriving later than Android's beta previews yet avoiding the visual inconsistencies seen in some skins. iOS 13 emphasized streamlined enhancements like faster app downloads (up to 60% smaller) and gesture navigation refinements, eschewing bloat in favor of core usability, while prioritized gesture overhauls and live captioning but inherited ecosystem variability. On AI, critiques highlighted Apple's lagging Google's Assistant, which leveraged deeper integration for contextual responses, reflecting iOS's deliberate restraint against Android's more expansive but sometimes intrusive AI features tied to Google's data-driven services. Android's openness afforded greater customization, such as themeable interfaces and , contrasting 13's ecosystem lock-in that enforced uniformity but restricted user modifications to maintain and . This trade-off favored Android for users seeking flexibility and , yet iOS's controlled environment yielded fewer compatibility issues, underscoring a causal link between closure and reliability over Android's innovation breadth amid fragmentation risks.

Long-Term Impact on iOS Ecosystem

iOS 13's introduction of system-wide Dark Mode established a foundational interface paradigm that persisted across subsequent releases, including through iOS 18, where it evolved with features like adaptive scheduling and third-party app compliance mandates, thereby standardizing reduced eye strain and battery efficiency as ecosystem norms. Privacy enhancements, such as Sign in with Apple, prioritized user data minimization by offering email relay and hiding, influencing later iOS iterations' emphasis on on-device processing and app tracking transparency, though empirical adoption remained constrained by implementation friction and preference for incumbents like sign-in. The update's exclusion of legacy devices including the , , and necessitated hardware upgrades for continued access to new features, aligning with Apple's release of the series in September 2019 and contributing to sustained premium device sales cycles. This strategy leveraged iOS's modular codebase, enabling compatible devices to average 5-6 years of major version support—exceeding contemporary medians of 3 years—thus extending ecosystem utility and user retention beyond typical competitor timelines. By reinforcing seamless hardware-software integration, iOS 13 solidified Apple's closed dynamics, which empirically maintained global market share stability at approximately 18-20% through 2020 and beyond, underwriting amid commoditized alternatives. However, this lock-in has drawn scrutiny for prioritizing proprietary cohesion over , potentially curtailing third-party in areas like cross-platform services while empirically bolstering internal advancements in and consistency.

References

  1. [1]
    Apple previews iOS 13
    Jun 3, 2019 · Apple today previewed iOS 13, introducing a dramatic new look for iPhone with Dark Mode and new ways to browse and edit photos, sign in to apps and websites.
  2. [2]
    Apple announces iOS 13 release date of September 19 - 9to5Mac
    Sep 10, 2019 · After its iPhone event, Apple announced that iOS 13 and watchOS 6 will all be officially released on Thursday, September 19. iOS 13 was unveiled ...
  3. [3]
    iOS 13: Complete Guide and Feature List - MacRumors
    Sep 1, 2020 · Apple's list of compatible devices confirms that iOS 13 is compatible with all of these iPhones and iPods: iPhone 11. iPhone 11 Pro. iPhone 11 ...
  4. [4]
    About iOS 13 Updates - Apple Support
    iOS 13 introduces a dramatic new look for iPhone with Dark Mode, new ways to browse and edit photos, and a private new way to sign in to apps and websites ...
  5. [5]
    Apple iOS 13: the biggest new features coming to the iPhone
    Jun 3, 2019 · Improved performance · Related · Dark mode · New swiping keyboard · Reminders · Updates to Apple Mail, Notes, and Safari · Apple Maps · Privacy.Chaim Gartenberg · Reminders · Imessage Profile Pictures<|separator|>
  6. [6]
    Apple officially unveils iOS 13 for iPhone at WWDC 2019 with Dark ...
    Jun 3, 2019 · Apple today previewed iOS 13, introducing a dramatic new look for iPhone with Dark Mode and new ways to browse and edit photos, sign in to apps and websites.
  7. [7]
    All the highlights from Apple's WWDC 2019 keynote - WIRED
    Jun 3, 2019 · When iOS 13 arrives (in beta later in June, otherwise this autumn), iPhone users will get dark mode, performance boosts and upgrades to Siri, ...
  8. [8]
    All the Big iOS 13 Changes Apple Announced at WWDC 19
    Jun 4, 2019 · Apps should launch twice as fast. “Smaller apps” should download in half the time, and update 60 percent more quickly. Face ID should take 30 ...
  9. [9]
    iTunes, iOS 13 updates announced at developers conference keynote
    Jun 3, 2019 · Among the features of iOS 13 are unlocking Face ID 30% faster; app downloads are now 50% smaller in terms of memory, and updates are 60% ...Tim Cook Unveils New Mac Pro... · Ios 13 Showcases New Photo... · New Ipad Operating System
  10. [10]
    Apple WWDC 2019 Announcements: iOS 13, iPadOS, a New Mac ...
    Jun 3, 2019 · Privacy was a big focus for Apple at this year's WWDC.​​ A new login feature called "Sign in With Apple" lets you log in to apps without having ...
  11. [11]
    iOS 13: The Ars Technica review
    Sep 20, 2019 · Last year, Apple set users' expectations with iOS 12, saying it would be focused on improving performance and fixing bugs and stability ...
  12. [12]
    iOS 13 focuses on speed and embraces the darkness - Engadget
    Jun 3, 2019 · Face ID unlocks will be 30 percent faster. Apple is also changing how it packages apps -- downloads will be 50 percent smaller, while updates ...
  13. [13]
    iOS 13 review: The iPhone goes dark - Mashable
    By breaking iPadOS away from iOS, Apple is showing it's prepared to finally treat the iPad as a separate product with very different capabilities. iOS 13 is ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  14. [14]
    Apple pushes up iOS 13.1 and iPadOS to September 24th - The Verge
    Sep 19, 2019 · Both iOS 13.1 and iPadOS will now be released on September 24th instead of the originally announced September 30th release date.
  15. [15]
    Apple releases iOS 13.2 with Deep Fusion - TechCrunch
    Oct 28, 2019 · If you have an iPhone 11 or iPhone 11 Pro, iOS 13.2 enables Deep Fusion, an image-processing feature that should make your photos look better ...
  16. [16]
    When will Apple release iOS 13.4 to the public? - 9to5Mac
    Feb 12, 2020 · Currently, evidence suggests that iOS 13.4, iPadOS 13.4, macOS 10.15.4, watchOS 6.2, and tvOS 13.4 will be released to the public sometime in March.
  17. [17]
    Apple Releases iOS and iPadOS 13.6.1 With Fix for Storage Issue ...
    Aug 12, 2020 · Apple today released iOS and iPadOS 13.6.1, minor updates that come a month after the release of the iOS 13.6 update with Car Keys and Audio ...
  18. [18]
    About the security content of iOS 13 - Apple Support
    Recent releases are listed on the Apple security updates page. Apple security documents reference vulnerabilities by CVE-ID when possible. For more information ...
  19. [19]
    Apple iOS 13.4 offers fixes for 30 vulnerabilities - Sophos News
    Mar 26, 2020 · The attention grabber is iOS/iPad 13.4, which fixes 30 CVEs. Apple doesn't rate the severity of vulnerabilities in its advisories, but we can pick out a few ...Missing: patches | Show results with:patches
  20. [20]
    Apple confirms iOS 13.5.1 security update patches vulnerability ...
    Jun 1, 2020 · iOS 13.5.1 and iPadOS 13.5.1 fixes a vulnerability that allowed applications “to execute arbitrary code with kernel privileges.”
  21. [21]
    Apple Releases iPadOS and iOS 13.5 With Exposure Notification ...
    May 20, 2020 · iOS 13.5 speeds up access to the passcode field on devices with Face ID when you are wearing a face mask and introduces the Exposure ...
  22. [22]
    iOS 13 Latest Version, Updates, Problems, Fixes & New Features
    Aug 24, 2020 · The latest version of iOS 13 is iOS 13.6.1. That update focus exclusively on bug fixes and arrived in mid August 2020.<|control11|><|separator|>
  23. [23]
    Apple iPhone - endoflife.date
    Sep 22, 2025 · 13 Pro, 15 - 26, 4 years ago. (24 Sep 2021) ; 13 Pro Max, 15 - 26, 4 years ago. (24 Sep 2021) ; 12 Mini, 14 - 26, 4 years and 11 months ago. (13 ...
  24. [24]
    iOS 13's Dark Mode Extends OLED iPhone Battery Life, Test Confirms
    Oct 21, 2019 · The same test performed at 300 nits, which is closer to outdoors use, saw ‌Dark Mode‌ save 12 percent battery. How to Enable Dark Mode in iOS 13.Missing: empirical | Show results with:empirical
  25. [25]
    Test shows dark mode really can save battery life on OLED iPhones
    Oct 20, 2019 · Test shows dark mode really can save battery life on OLED iPhones. At the end of a robotic test, the difference was considerable. Steve Dent.
  26. [26]
    Here's the New iOS 13 Volume Indicator - MacRumors
    Jun 3, 2019 · The new iOS 13 update (and the new iPadOS update) feature an updated volume HUD, which is less obtrusive than the previous volume control option.Missing: usability | Show results with:usability
  27. [27]
    10 usability improvements in iOS 13 - The Mobile Spoon
    Aug 26, 2019 · 1. Pads vs. Phones · 2. 3D touch is (almost) a goner · 3. A new Volume HUD · 4. Let's have a toast! · 5. A much better typing experience · 6.
  28. [28]
    Context menus | Apple Developer Documentation
    iPadOS lets you reveal a context menu when people perform a long press on the touchscreen or use a secondary click with an attached trackpad or keyboard. For ...
  29. [29]
    Speed and performance are at the heart of iOS 13 - iDownloadBlog
    Jun 4, 2019 · Faster app launch: Two times faster app launches on the iPhone XS and 2018 iPad Pro series vs. launching the same apps on the same devices ...
  30. [30]
    iOS 13 on the iPhone 6S and SE: New software runs fine on ... - Reddit
    Sep 21, 2019 · 386 votes, 155 comments. I have a 6s and I've only noticed some animation stutters while in the home screen that weren't there before.My iPhone 6S (iOS 13) suddenly got slower. Only I noticed it? - RedditiPhone 13 Pro - Choppy/Stuttery/Laggy all the time : r/ios - RedditMore results from www.reddit.com
  31. [31]
    iOS 13 vs iOS 12 performance | MacRumors Forums
    Jun 3, 2019 · Hello, is iOS 13 faster and more fluid than iOS 12? Apple said: "Apps will launch up to 2x faster than before" Speed Test videos: iOS 13 ...
  32. [32]
    Privacy - Features - Apple
    End-to-end encryption protects your iMessage and FaceTime conversations across all your devices. With watchOS, iOS, and iPadOS, your messages are encrypted on ...Security · Privacy · Features · Applebot model training and...
  33. [33]
    Sign in with Apple | Apple Developer Documentation
    Sign in with Apple provides a fast, private way to sign into apps and websites, giving people a consistent experience they can trust.Sign in with Apple JS · REST API · Authentication Services
  34. [34]
    The iOS 13 Privacy and Security Features You Should Know - WIRED
    Sep 22, 2019 · Block Bluetooth Access · Stay Safe From Wi-Fi Tracking · Share Photos Without Locations · Silence Unknown Callers · Find Devices Anywhere.
  35. [35]
    About privacy and Location Services in iOS, iPadOS, and watchOS
    Privacy settings in iOS and iPadOS help give you control over which apps have access to information stored on your device. For example, you can allow a social- ...Location Services & Privacy · iPhone or iPad app switcher · SIM pinMissing: features | Show results with:features
  36. [36]
    Apple's collection of user data hard to stop says report - AppleInsider
    Apr 10, 2024 · The instructions to restrict data access were deemed "very complex and confusing" by the report, with steps scattered in various online ...
  37. [37]
    iOS 13: Here are the new security and privacy features you need to ...
    Sep 19, 2019 · iOS 13: Here are the new security and privacy features you need to know · You'll start to see reminders about apps that track your location · You ...
  38. [38]
    "Sign in with Apple" is a great new privacy feature—and a weapon
    Jun 3, 2019 · The new Sign in with Apple button provides a secure log in to participating apps and sites, verified by Face ID or Touch ID. It's available for ...<|separator|>
  39. [39]
    The Best New Siri Features & Commands in iOS 13 for iPhone
    Sep 19, 2019 · Apple's neural TTS system improves prosody (patterns of stress, intonation, tone, and rhythm), and that means a less artificial, stitched- ...
  40. [40]
    Apple iOS 13 Siri improvements for iPhone, iPad, Watch and AirPods
    Jun 4, 2019 · Apple said Siri will soon have a new voice that's entirely generated by software, which will allow it to sound more accurate. I heard it and I ...
  41. [41]
    Siri Shortcuts comes built-in on iOS 13, allows for more powerful ...
    Jun 3, 2019 · Apple announced the new app Siri Shortcuts, which allows iOS users to create custom voice commands for their apps.
  42. [42]
    How Apple is improving Siri Shortcuts in iOS, iPadOS - Computerworld
    Jul 19, 2019 · Apple in iOS 13 has made it much easier and clearer to build Shortcuts than before. Commands are now described in natural language, rather than ...
  43. [43]
    iOS and iPadOS 13: The MacStories Review - Page 14 of 30
    An example of a conversational shortcut in Siri. You can go back and forth with the assistant using natural language input.Missing: enhancements | Show results with:enhancements
  44. [44]
    Confirmed: Apple Caught In Siri Privacy Scandal, Let Contractors ...
    Jul 30, 2019 · The Silicon Valley company is sending “a small proportion of Siri recordings are passed on to contractors working for the company around the world.”
  45. [45]
    https://www.statista.com/statistics/1040539/digital-assistant-performance-comparison/
  46. [46]
    How To Use Siri Offline On iPhone And iPad - Macworld
    Jan 5, 2022 · What can Siri do offline? · Opening apps · Creating new alarms · Creating timers (but, weirdly, not using the stopwatch) · Controlling some system ...
  47. [47]
    an exploratory comparison of Alexa, Google Assistant and Siri - NIH
    Nov 24, 2019 · Out of a total of 6 possible points, Siri averaged 5.16 points, Google Assistant averaged 5.10 points and Alexa averaged 0.98 points. Google ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  48. [48]
    How to use the iPhone's new Slide to Type keyboard feature in iOS 13
    Sep 19, 2019 · QuickPath is enabled by default after installing iOS 13. You don't have to do anything other than place a finger on the keyboard and swipe.
  49. [49]
    Type with the onscreen keyboard on iPhone - Apple Support
    Open the onscreen keyboard by tapping a text field. Tap individual keys to type, or use QuickPath to type a word by sliding from one letter to the next without ...
  50. [50]
    13 Features of iOS 13: QuickPath keyboard - Six Colors
    Sep 16, 2019 · Instead of tapping on keys, you put your finger on the first letter and then slide it to the next letter and so on. Based on your finger ...
  51. [51]
    Augmented Text Editing on Mobile: The New iOS 13 Gestures - Stories
    Oct 14, 2019 · Text Selection · Double-tap to select a word. · Double-tap two times to select a sentence. · Double-tap three times to select a paragraph.
  52. [52]
    How to use the text editing gestures on iPhone and iPad
    Apr 11, 2024 · Select a word: Double-tap with one finger. · Select a sentence: Tap it three times. · Select a paragraph: Tap it three (or four) times. · Select ...
  53. [53]
    iOS 13 Makes Editing Text Easier - MacLife Boise
    Oct 1, 2019 · Copy: To copy selected text, pinch in with three fingers, or, more likely, your thumb, index finger, and middle finger. · Cut: To cut (copy and ...
  54. [54]
    Use Voice Control on your iPhone, iPad, or iPod touch - Apple Support
    Go to Settings and select Accessibility. · Select Voice Control, then select Set up Voice Control. A download will begin in the background.
  55. [55]
    Using Voice Control in iOS 13 to Operate an iPhone Hands-Free
    Dec 12, 2019 · How to Enable Voice Control · Open up the Settings app. · Scroll down to Accessibility and tap it. · Select the Voice Control option. · Tap on ...
  56. [56]
    24 Voice Control Features in iOS 13 That Let You Use Your iPhone ...
    Dec 16, 2019 · The new Voice Control setting is a far-reaching, dedicated option that enables you to control your iPhone completely hands-free.
  57. [57]
    Connect external storage devices to iPhone - Apple Support
    You can use the Files app and other supported apps to access files stored on external devices, such as USB drives and SD cards, connected to your iPhone.
  58. [58]
    USB Storage with iOS 13: The FAQ - TidBITS
    Oct 16, 2019 · iOS 13 can read any standard USB storage device as long as it has been formatted with a compatible file system and has sufficient power provided.
  59. [59]
    The Best External Storage Options for iPhone That Work with iOS ...
    Sep 24, 2019 · The Best External Storage Options for iPhone That Work with iOS 13's Files App · 1. Lightning Flash Drives · 2. USB Flash Drives · 3. SD Card ...
  60. [60]
    Disable Haptic Touch on IOS 13 (keeping 3D Touch) - Ask Different
    Oct 28, 2019 · You can adjust the sensitivity and duration by going to Settings -> Accessibility -> Touch -> 3D & Haptic Touch . You can turn 3D Touch on and ...
  61. [61]
    How to enable haptic feedback on your iPhone - Android Police
    Jan 11, 2024 · Open your iPhone Settings. · Tap Sound & Haptics. Screenshot of the iPhone settings · Scroll down and tap Keyboard Feedback under System Sounds & ...<|separator|>
  62. [62]
    iOS 13's Photos prettifies your library, brings sliders everywhere ...
    Jun 4, 2019 · The iOS 13 software update includes rich updates for the Photos app that make it easy and fun to browse your photos with intelligently curated albums.
  63. [63]
    How to Edit Videos Using Photos App in iOS 13 and iPadOS 13
    Jul 17, 2019 · 1. Open the Photos app on your iPhone or iPad and head over to the video you want to edit. You can also capture a video and start editing it ...<|separator|>
  64. [64]
    13 Features of iOS 13: Video editing - Six Colors
    Sep 19, 2019 · Tap the rotate button and you're done—or, if you prefer, use the manual Straighten tool to adjust it to any angle, not just 90° increments.
  65. [65]
    Deep Fusion in iOS 13.2 makes the iPhone 11 Pro's camera even ...
    Oct 28, 2019 · iOS 13.2 introduces Deep Fusion, an advanced image processing system that uses the A13 Bionic Neural Engine to capture images with ...
  66. [66]
    Everything new in iOS 13.2 beta 1: Deep Fusion, new AirPods, more
    Oct 2, 2019 · The headlining feature of iOS 13.2 is the initial debut of Deep Fusion, Apple's computational photography feature coming to the iPhone 11 line.
  67. [67]
    iOS 13.2 now available with Deep Fusion, new emoji, Siri privacy ...
    Oct 28, 2019 · iOS 13.2 includes the new Deep Fusion camera technology for iPhone 11 and iPhone 11 Pro, new emoji, and more. tvOS 13.2 is also now available.
  68. [68]
    How to Create Shared Photo Albums on iPhone & iPad - OS X Daily
    Oct 3, 2020 · A shared album can hold up to 5000 photos and videos, which is a lot, but if you've reached the limit, you'll need to delete some of the ...
  69. [69]
    Family Sharing Photos Limit - Apple Support Community
    Dec 31, 2021 · If you reach your Shared Album limit, you need to delete some photos or videos before adding new ones. The photos and videos in your Shared ...how to get round the crazy 5000 shared album limit with my 2TB plan?Why is there a limit of 5000 photos and videos for a shared album?More results from discussions.apple.com
  70. [70]
    Hands on with Apple's new Memoji stickers in iOS 13
    Jun 7, 2019 · Users will be able to customize their Memoji with additional hats, teeth options, new hair and makeup colors, ear piercings, facial piercings ...<|separator|>
  71. [71]
    How to Use Animoji and Memoji Stickers in iOS - MacRumors
    Jul 3, 2020 · Animoji/Memoji stickers let you express yourself using an existing character or a custom-made character that looks like you, using classic emoji-like poses and ...
  72. [72]
    iOS 13 features three new Animoji and Memoji Stickers - 9to5Mac
    Jun 3, 2019 · Apple has added various new configuration options for Memoji and three new Animoji characters: you can now animate an octopus, a cow and a mouse.
  73. [73]
    Everything new with Messages in iOS 13 | AppleInsider
    Jun 27, 2019 · Once done, Messages in iOS 13 will automatically create a series of stickers based on that character that can easily be dragged into ...Profiles · Animoji And Memoji · Helpful FeaturesMissing: statistics complaints
  74. [74]
    How secure is iMessage? The Truth Behind Your Private Chats
    Mar 27, 2024 · iMessage can be used across all your Apple devices and employs robust end-to-end encryption to ensure the utmost privacy and security when messaging.
  75. [75]
    Yes, FBI Announced Texting Between iPhone and Android Is Not ...
    Dec 5, 2024 · The FBI's guidelines recommended that users not send texts from iPhone to Android or vice versa because they were not securely encrypted.
  76. [76]
    Apple Didn't Bring iMessage to Android Because of its Lock-In Strategy
    Apr 9, 2021 · But as early as 2013, the company's executives decided not to do so because it would lower the bar for users leaving the platform and could ...
  77. [77]
    The DOJ Puts Apple's iMessage Encryption in the Antitrust Crosshairs
    Mar 21, 2024 · The DOJ argues that by refusing to allow users of other smartphone platforms like Android to use its end-to-end encryption iMessage protocol, it ...
  78. [78]
    iOS and iPadOS 13: The MacStories Review - Page 26 of 30
    Messages' iOS 13 update largely focuses on expanding Memoji adoption across the system, with a handful of other enhancements to Animoji and message search.
  79. [79]
    Messages is taking up too much space. - Apple Support Communities
    Oct 9, 2023 · I see that my Messages app is taking up 63GB of storage, so I check to see what's taking up the space in specific. It says Auto Delete Old Conversations 1GB.Sticker issue resolved in Messages on iPhone 15 Pro MaxHelp! iPhone 11 Adding Rude Sticker Text - Apple Support CommunityMore results from discussions.apple.comMissing: statistics complaints
  80. [80]
    Apple Maps: Complete Guide to iOS 13 - MacRumors
    Feb 21, 2020 · All of the new features introduced in the Maps app in iOS 13, such as Favorites, Collections, and Junction View have been added to CarPlay. The ...
  81. [81]
    iOS 13 brings detailed street view imagery to Apple Maps - 9to5Mac
    Jun 4, 2019 · When you first press the Look Around button, a small rectangular overlay appears over the top of the map cartography. This Look Around window ...
  82. [82]
    13 Features of iOS 13: Maps improvements - Six Colors
    Sep 18, 2019 · As of iOS 13, however, if you tap on a bus stop or subway station in Apple Maps, you'll get a list of when you can expect the next bus or train ...
  83. [83]
    How secure is the iPhone in iOS 13? Apple explains privacy - 9to5Mac
    Nov 6, 2019 · Maps data isn't associated with your Apple ID for identifying travel patterns; Photos relies on the power of on-device processing to recognize ...
  84. [84]
    The Biggest Apple Maps Change Is One You Can't See - WIRED
    Jan 31, 2020 · With this latest update, Apple is no longer licensing TomTom data for the US, the company confirmed. Apple Maps now relies on the company's own ...
  85. [85]
    Apple Maps vs. Google Maps on iOS - GeeksforGeeks
    Jul 23, 2025 · Google's Extensive data sources mean that directions are generally more accurate and over-to-date than those of Apple Maps. ... 13 min read ...
  86. [86]
    Use Smart Lists in Reminders on iPhone - Apple Support
    You can create custom Smart Lists to automatically include items filtered by tags, dates, times, locations, flags, and priority.Missing: sub- natural
  87. [87]
    A Closer Look at the Updated Reminders App - The Sweet Setup
    Jun 5, 2019 · The main Reminders screen has been redesigned to include 4 boxes in a grid-style view. These show your reminders by category.
  88. [88]
    Reminders: How To Create Subtasks in iOS 13 - YouTube
    Oct 17, 2019 · Check out my gear on Kit: https://kit.co/mikemurphyco #ios13 #reminders #subtasks Reminders: How To Create Subtasks in iOS 13 This tutorial ...Missing: smart tags natural language<|separator|>
  89. [89]
    New reminders VS things 3 | MacRumors Forums
    Jun 12, 2019 · Reminders may not have tags, but you can always add #tag and look for them via search. Although you can flag items and prioritize items too by 3 ...
  90. [90]
    Reminders: Complete Guide to iOS 13 - MacRumors
    May 26, 2020 · Reminders features enhanced Siri intelligence in iOS 13, which means you can type longer, more descriptive sentences that Reminders will ...
  91. [91]
    Reminders v Google Tasks : r/gtd - Reddit
    Aug 20, 2024 · I've been using Google Tasks for years for project and action lists, and I'm considering switching to Apple Reminders due to Apple Reminders having tags and ...Apple notes vs Google keep : r/iPhone13ProMax - RedditHow are people using Google Keep? Or is or dead/discontinuedMore results from www.reddit.com
  92. [92]
    Update the Reminders app in iOS 13 or later - Apple Support
    grocery lists, templates, and more — you need to upgrade the reminders in iCloud.
  93. [93]
    Apple Reveals Serious Reminders Sync Problem In iOS 13 - Forbes
    Oct 1, 2019 · The problem stems from the fact Apple has, bizarrely, made Reminders in iOS 13 incompatible with “earlier versions of iOS and macOS.” For ...
  94. [94]
    Solution for iCloud sync issues after iOS 13 update! - GoodTask Forum
    Dec 20, 2019 · The Solution: Go to icloud.com, log in, and open reminders there. Select a list and then click "1,234 Completed" under the list name in the ...Missing: improvements | Show results with:improvements
  95. [95]
    Reminders will not Upgrade - Solution FYI - Apple Support Community
    Dec 21, 2024 · My Reminders would not upgrade across multiple devices. After a LOT of frustration, I finally got it, I am sharing my solution.Reminders App (iOS 13) really seems to have problemsios 13 reminders not syncing with icloud accountMore results from discussions.apple.comMissing: improvements | Show results with:improvements
  96. [96]
    Say goodbye to procrastination and hello to productivity with iOS ...
    Jun 10, 2019 · The Reminders app in iOS 13 and iPadOS has received a substantial facelift along with meaningful functional improvements and productivity boosts.
  97. [97]
    10 ways iOS 13's Reminders app can turn you into a productivity beast
    Sep 8, 2019 · Lists may have been in Reminders for a while, but here's a cool new feature: You can now share lists with other iOS 13 users, and they'll see ...
  98. [98]
    iOS 13 Reminders does no longer support CalDAV #17190 - GitHub
    Sep 17, 2019 · The new Reminders app will no longer sync over CalDAV as this would mean you have to choose between Reminders and anything else.
  99. [99]
    Reminders app no longer supports CalDAV - BusyCal
    Jul 28, 2024 · Starting with iOS 13 and macOS Catalina, the new Reminders app no longer supports CalDAV. NEW: Direct syncing with Reminders​. You can now sync ...
  100. [100]
    View Moving, Time-Synced Lyrics in Apple Music to Sing Along to ...
    Jul 10, 2019 · In iOS 13, open up the Music app, then choose a song with lyrics from Apple's massive library of tracks. Next, tap the Lyrics button.
  101. [101]
    Follow along with time-synced lyrics and see a better Up Next view ...
    Jun 13, 2019 · A new feature that will allow Apple Music listeners follow along with a song's lyrics, and see a better view of what's coming next with a revamped Up Next view.
  102. [102]
    What's new with Apple Music on iOS 13 aside dark mode and cool ...
    Jul 28, 2019 · What's new with Apple Music on iOS 13 aside dark mode and cool lyrics features? ... The queue is literally why I stopped using Spotify ...
  103. [103]
    Add your TV provider to the Apple TV app on iPhone
    Go to the Settings app on your iPhone. Tap General, then tap TV Provider. Choose your TV provider, then sign in with your provider credentials.
  104. [104]
    Connect apps and add your TV provider to the ... - Apple Support
    Connect apps and add your TV provider to the Apple TV app on iPod touch. With the Apple TV app , you can watch shows and movies from streaming services and ...
  105. [105]
    Apple Music announces Spatial Audio and Lossless Audio
    May 17, 2021 · To start listening to Lossless Audio, subscribers using the latest version of Apple Music can turn it on in Settings > Music > Audio Quality.
  106. [106]
    Behold: iOS 13's Music App Sucks - Sam Stevens
    Spotify overall has a better interface, except for the lack of a Library, which makes me irrationally unhappy. Perhaps it comes from my carefully curating my ...
  107. [107]
    Apple Music battery drain issues reported by iOS 13.5.1 users
    Jul 8, 2020 · Among the steps people have tried are force-quitting the app, restarting the phone, disabling background refresh, turning off mobile data access ...
  108. [108]
    Apple Music vs Spotify: which is better? - What Hi-Fi?
    Aug 1, 2025 · Apple Music vs Spotify &amp;ndash; which is best? Apple Music's launch interface was visually heavy and clunky to use. Both Spotify and Apple ...The State Of Play · Subscription Plans · Sound Quality
  109. [109]
    iOS 13 adoption tops 20% across iPhone and iPad devices one ...
    Sep 26, 2019 · According to data from Mixpanel, iOS 13 today crossed the 20% adoption mark. This is slightly ahead of where iOS 12 was at the same point in ...
  110. [110]
    iOS 13 Now Installed on 55% of iPhones Introduced in Last Four Years
    Oct 16, 2019 · Apple reports that iOS 13 is installed on 55% of all iPhones introduced in the past four years, and 50% of all ‌iPhone‌ devices, as measured by ...
  111. [111]
    iOS 13 on the iPhone 6S and SE: New software runs fine on a ...
    Sep 20, 2019 · In general, iOS 13 running on these phones is almost imperceptibly slower than the same phones running iOS 12, though in many cases performance ...
  112. [112]
    Tested: iPhone 6s & iOS 13 update - Dedoimedo
    Nov 30, 2019 · The iOS 13 update was smooth, with no major performance issues, and the new OS is consistent and fast, though the battery charge drops rapidly ...
  113. [113]
    Will the 13 and 14 lose support from Apple on the same year?
    Nov 30, 2023 · Dropping support has nothing/very little to do with the chip and everything to do with encouraging people to upgrade.
  114. [114]
    iOS 13 now installed on 81% of all compatible iPhones
    Jun 19, 2020 · Like iOS 12, iOS 13 has seen a fairly rapid adoption rate. By October 2019, iOS 13 was running on 50% of all compatible devices and 55% of ...
  115. [115]
    Apple's Deep Fusion camera feature will be available soon ... - iMore
    Oct 2, 2019 · The feature only works with the iPhone 11, iPhone 11 Pro and iPhone 11 Pro Max. UPDATE: While initial reports indicated the iOS 13.2 developer ...
  116. [116]
    How to use Deep Fusion on iPhone cameras - 9to5Mac
    Mar 22, 2022 · Keep in mind that Deep Fusion is only available on iPhone 11, 12, 13, and SE 3. Head to the Settings app then swipe down and tap Camera; Make ...
  117. [117]
    The Facts About Dark Mode And Battery Life: LCD Vs OLED, iOS 13 ...
    Jun 16, 2019 · Dark mode has no impact on battery life. And note that dark mode has nothing to do with turning down the brightness on the display, which does affect (increase ...
  118. [118]
    iPadOS 13 Supported iPad Models (iOS 13) - EveryMac.com
    Nov 15, 2021 · The iPadOS does drop support for some older iPad models. Specifically, Apple's press release notes that iPadOS supports "iPad Air 2 and ...
  119. [119]
    iPhone vs Android: 15 Reasons iPhones Are Better | SMASHED IT
    Seamless Hardware-Software Integration. The most significant advantage of iPhone over Android lies in Apple's complete control over both hardware and software.
  120. [120]
    Android Vs iOS: Differences, Similarities, Best Option And ... - Intelivita
    Sep 8, 2025 · Software updates and device longevity differ significantly between Android and iOS. Apple maintains full control over its hardware and software ...
  121. [121]
    Common iOS 13 problems and how to fix them (iOS 13.7 update)
    Jan 31, 2022 · New iOS 13.6 issues. The problem: Performance lag, various app problems, battery drain, Touch ID, and Face ID problems. Even as late as iOS ...
  122. [122]
    iOS 13 Battery Life Bad? Tips to Fix Battery Drain in iOS 13
    Sep 23, 2019 · Sometimes just forcing the iPhone or iPad to reboot can resolve battery issues, particularly if there's some errant background app behavior or ...
  123. [123]
    Apple Releases iOS 13.1 and iPadOS 13.1; Bringing Many Bug ...
    Sep 21, 2019 · Update on the apps crashing upon launch I previously reported. By ... I have noticed the battery drain in iOS 13 but just downloaded 13.1.
  124. [124]
    Crazy high battery drain on iOS 13.1.3 - Reddit
    Oct 22, 2019 · Try restart your phone. It sounds stupid, but i had some apps doing crazy stuff in background and a simple restart solved the problem. Check ...iOS 13.5.1 suffers from a horrible battery drain issue : r/apple - RedditiOS 26.0.1 is out with important bug fixes - RedditMore results from www.reddit.comMissing: launch Maps
  125. [125]
    https://www.statista.com/chart/20118/apple-ios-updates-bug-fixes/
  126. [126]
    Apple releases iOS 13.1.1 with fixes for battery drain, Siri, iPhone ...
    Sep 27, 2019 · iOS 13.1.1 includes bug fixes and improvements for your iPhone. This update: Fixes issues that could prevent iPhone restoring from backup ...
  127. [127]
    iOS 13.1 - Bug Fixes, Changes, and Improvements
    Sep 24, 2019 · iOS 13.1 includes bug fixes and improvements, including AirDrop with Ultra Wideband technology on iPhone 11, iPhone 11 Pro, and iPhone 11 Pro ...
  128. [128]
    Six Reasons Why iOS 13 and Catalina Are So Buggy - TidBITS
    Oct 21, 2019 · iOS 13 and macOS 10.15 Catalina have been unusually buggy releases for Apple. The betas started out buggy at WWDC in June, which is not unexpected.
  129. [129]
    Developers encounter major iCloud issues in iOS 13 beta - iMore
    Sep 5, 2019 · There have been numerous reports from developers about the buggy beta cycle of iOS 13, from Springboard issues to app crashes.
  130. [130]
    A Tariff Theory About Apple's iOS 13 Surprise - OneZero - Medium
    Sep 3, 2019 · “Earlier betas of 13.0 were unreliable compared to those of 12.0, so Apple just took out some of the features promised at WWDC for 13.0, and ...
  131. [131]
    iOS 13.1 brings controversial CPU throttling feature to 2018 iPhones
    Sep 24, 2019 · With the latest iOS update Apple will gain the ability to reduce the CPU performance of all 2018 iPhone models if the software detects that ...
  132. [132]
    iOS 13.1 to bring CPU throttling feature to iPhone XR and XS
    Sep 20, 2019 · iOS 13.1 is expected to arrive on September 24 and will add Apple's CPU throttling feature to iPhone XR and iPhone XS users.
  133. [133]
    iOS 13 Introduces New 'Optimized Battery Charging' Feature
    Jun 5, 2019 · Apple in iOS 13 introduced a new "Optimized Battery Charging" feature, which is designed to extend the total battery life of your iOS device.
  134. [134]
    Apple iOS 13 will improve battery life with optimized battery charging
    Jun 12, 2019 · The new feature, called "optimized battery charging," will launch for iPhones this fall in the iOS 13 update but is already available for developer testing.
  135. [135]
    iPhone XS Benchmarks - Geekbench
    Benchmark results for the iPhone XS can be found below. The data on this chart is gathered from user-submitted Geekbench 6 results from the Geekbench Browser.
  136. [136]
    Feds probing Sign In with Apple for antitrust violations - Tom's Guide
    Feb 26, 2021 · Apple's time-saving Sign In with Apple feature is being investigated by the U.S. Department of Justice as part of an antitrust probe, ...
  137. [137]
    Apple now facing an antitrust investigation over 'Sign in with Apple'
    Jun 24, 2024 · Now, the U.S. DOJ is investigating those complaints. Some developers are unhappy with the rules associated with “Sign in with Apple”. Now, ...Missing: controversies | Show results with:controversies
  138. [138]
    Android exec rebukes iMessage lock-in with RCS push - 9to5Google
    Jan 8, 2022 · Lockheimer believes that Apple's decision to not support the Rich Communication Services standard is meant to protect iMessage's vendor lock-in ...
  139. [139]
    [PDF] Differential Privacy - Apple
    Users can examine the information being shared with Apple for the categories of data that are protected using Differential Privacy. In iOS, the information is ...
  140. [140]
    Apple's 'Differential Privacy' Is About Collecting Your Data - WIRED
    Jun 13, 2016 · Differential privacy, translated from Apple-speak, is the statistical science of trying to learn as much as possible about a group while ...
  141. [141]
    [PDF] How Apple Has Abused Its Mobile Platform Dominance
    Apple's practices violate antitrust law as they damage competition and consumer welfare, the promotion of which are key objectives of the Sherman. Act.23 ...
  142. [142]
    iOS 13 review: dark mode, a new Photos app, and bugs | The Verge
    Rating 7.5/10 · Review by Chaim GartenbergSep 19, 2019 · iOS 13 is big and flashy. It's looking to wow users with a slick dark mode; striking updates to apps like Apple Maps, Photos, and even Reminders.Missing: satisfaction | Show results with:satisfaction
  143. [143]
    iOS 13 review: The biggest update in years | Tom's Guide
    Rating 4.0 · Review by Philip MichaelsOct 9, 2019 · Dark Mode, Sign in with Apple and revamped Photos app make it well worth the update.
  144. [144]
    Apple iOS 13 Review - PCMag
    Rating 4.5 Sep 2, 2020 · Apple's stellar iOS 13 mobile OS updates visuals and adds new privacy features to iPhones, with Dark Mode, improved efficiency, and a healthy dollop of machine ...Missing: critical | Show results with:critical
  145. [145]
    iOS 13 Adoption Rate Ablaze: Half of All iPhones Already Upgraded
    Oct 20, 2019 · It took only 26 days for iOS 13 to be installed in 50% of all iPhones, slower than iOS 12 but still at an impressive pace.
  146. [146]
    35+ Dark mode statistics you need to know (2025) - forms.app
    Feb 5, 2024 · Among Apple iOS users, dark mode adoption rates range from 55% to 70% (Earthweb). 19. 82.7% of respondents to a Medium survey stated they ...
  147. [147]
    Apple's iOS 13 is running on 50 percent of all iPhones after three ...
    Oct 16, 2019 · According to the company, more than 50 percent of all iPhones were running iOS 13 just 26 days after launch.
  148. [148]
    Android 10 has the fastest update rate ever, hits 16% of users in 10 ...
    Jul 9, 2020 · At the end of the chart, Android 10 hits 400 million users at the 300-day mark (Android 10 is 310 days old), which sounds like a pretty big ...
  149. [149]
    https://www.statista.com/chart/19303/mobile-android-operating-system/
  150. [150]
    iOS 13 vs. Android 10: How Apple and Google compare - CNET
    Sep 15, 2019 · iOS 13 includes a systemwide dark mode, more control over privacy settings and a bushel of improvements designed to make the iPhone more secure and easier to ...
  151. [151]
    IT threat evolution Q3 2019. Statistics - Securelist
    Nov 29, 2019 · Among all the mobile threats detected in Q3 2019, the lion's share went to potentially unsolicited RiskTool-class programs (32.1%), which ...Mobile Threats · Mobile Banking Trojans · Vulnerable Applications Used...
  152. [152]
    Comparative analysis of Android and iOS from security viewpoint
    From 2019 onwards, Android has been the most dangerous OS [5,135,136]. Malware for Android continues to evolve at a rapid rate, continuing a four-year trend.Review Article · Introduction · Vulnerability Trends In...
  153. [153]
    Android Q Dark Mode vs iOS 13 Dark Mode: What's The Difference
    Jun 26, 2019 · iOS 13 dark mode is much better than dark mode in Android Q as it offers a more detailed design, and overall app-support.
  154. [154]
    iOS 13 VS Android 10 - Agicent
    Sep 17, 2024 · Performance: The Face Id features is now around 30% faster. Also, the apps have been made significantly small even after the update thus ...
  155. [155]
    Comparison: iOS13 vs Android 10 - Clove Technology
    Jan 28, 2020 · In iOS13 the trusty assistant has been updated and now features a new, less robotic voice, the ability to stream radio stations, search for ...
  156. [156]
    Apple announces iOS 13 with dark mode, updated Apple apps and ...
    Jun 3, 2019 · Apple is adding system-wide dark mode for iOS 13. With a simple button in Control Center, you'll be able to switch from a light interface to a dark interface.
  157. [157]
    Dark Mode iOS 13 Can Save Battery Life, Especially for OLED ...
    Nov 11, 2019 · Phones with OLED screens completely turn off pixels for black displays, which leads to battery savings if you phone is in dark mode.
  158. [158]
    How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? - Hacker News
    Jan 28, 2020 · 73% use Sign in with Apple and the rest using their phone number. If it was a privacy issue, wouldn't people rather trust Apple than an indie ...
  159. [159]
    Apple iOS 13 Release News Delivers iPhone Update Warning
    May 11, 2019 · iPhonesoft.fr states iOS 13 will drop support for the iPhone 5s, iPhone SE, iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus as well as the iPad mini 2 and iPad Air.
  160. [160]
    iPhone vs. Android: Which actually offers longer support?
    Dec 2, 2023 · Apple generally supports iOS upgrades for up to six years. And at the launch of the Pixel 8, Google announced that the phone would receive seven ...
  161. [161]
    Android vs iOS: The state of software support - PhoneArena
    Aug 2, 2021 · The median software support is now upwards of three years, while select devices can enjoy even four years of continued support.
  162. [162]
    iPhone Users and Sales Stats for 2025 - Backlinko
    Sep 25, 2025 · Apple's iPhone claims an 18.7% market share of the global smartphone market, ranking as one of the leading smartphone brands worldwide.
  163. [163]
    Does Apple Stifle or Promote Innovation? - ProMarket
    Apr 2, 2024 · The answer is both. How so? The recent antitrust complaint against Apple heralds a pivotal shift in understanding the influence of tech giants on innovation.
  164. [164]
    Case Study: Apple's Ecosystem Strategy - Building Loyalty and ...
    Nov 21, 2024 · Closed Ecosystem: Critics argue that Apple's walled garden restricts consumer choice and stifles innovation from third-party developers (source) ...