Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Open-loop gain

Open-loop gain, often denoted as A_{VOL} or simply A, refers to the inherent voltage of an (op-amp) or similar amplifier circuit when no is applied, meaning the feedback loop is "open" and the output does not influence the input. This represents the amplifier's intrinsic capability from the input voltage to the output voltage, typically measured under conditions or at low frequencies. In practical op-amps, the open-loop gain is extraordinarily high, often ranging from $10^5 to $10^8 (or 100 to 160 ), though it is usually specified as a typical value rather than minimum or maximum due to variations with factors like , load, and output voltage. This high is fundamental to amplifier designs, where closing the loop with external resistors allows the closed-loop to be precisely set by those components, approximating the ideal case when A_{VOL} is much larger than the desired —following the G \approx \frac{1}{\beta}, where \beta is the factor, provided A_{VOL} \beta \gg 1. The open-loop 's is characterized by a flat response at low frequencies, followed by a at approximately 20 per (6 per ) after the dominant , with the product remaining constant in this region, which directly influences the op-amp's unity-gain and in closed-loop applications. Beyond electronics, open-loop gain extends to control systems, where it describes the forward-path gain in a system without , determining the overall response before any corrective loops are introduced; high values here similarly enable robust closed-loop performance but require careful analysis to avoid , often via Bode plots assessing and margins. In both domains, the concept underscores the trade-offs between , , and , making it a parameter in and system design.

Fundamentals

Definition

Open-loop gain is the intrinsic factor of a or when no path connects the output to the input, quantified as the of the output signal to the input signal . In , it is often denoted as A and represents the voltage, current, or power transfer characteristic in isolation, while in control s, it is commonly symbolized as G and describes the forward path without loop closure. This definition assumes a basic understanding of as signal but specifies the open to exclude any stabilizing or corrective influences. Unlike closed-loop gain, which adjusts the overall response through feedback to achieve desired performance such as reduced distortion or increased bandwidth, open-loop gain solely captures the system's native behavior, serving as a baseline for analyzing effects. It highlights the uncompensated dynamics, where output directly scales with input without correction for errors or disturbances. The notion of open-loop gain originated in the early amid advancements in design and , particularly during the vacuum tube era from the 1920s to 1940s, when engineers sought to characterize stages independently of networks. A pivotal early analysis came in 1928 from Karl Küpfmüller, who examined open-loop characteristics in circuits to understand dynamics. In development, vacuum tube prototypes in the 1940s further formalized the term, enabling high-gain applications in analog computing and . Open-loop gain is expressed as a dimensionless for or in decibels (dB) as $20 \log_{10} |A| for , facilitating logarithmic assessments in plots. Typical values in operational amplifiers range from 100 dB to 130 dB at , equating to of 100,000 to over 1,000,000, underscoring the high inherent that circuits then tame for practical use.

Mathematical Representation

The open-loop gain A of a linear is fundamentally defined as the of the output voltage V_{\text{out}} to the input voltage V_{\text{in}} in the absence of , applicable to (DC) or low-frequency scenarios where the system behaves as a constant multiplier. This relationship is expressed mathematically as A = \frac{V_{\text{out}}}{V_{\text{in}}}, where V_{\text{in}} typically represents the differential input voltage for devices like operational amplifiers. In the , the open-loop gain is represented as a complex-valued A(j\omega), where j is the and \omega is the , capturing both the |A(j\omega)| and \angle A(j\omega) of the system's response to sinusoidal inputs. For dynamic analysis, the Laplace domain form A(s) is used, with s = \sigma + j\omega, enabling the study of transient and steady-state behaviors through pole-zero configurations. The |A(j\omega)| quantifies at each , while the indicates any shift in the output signal relative to the input. For plotting and comparative analysis, the open-loop gain is often expressed on a logarithmic scale as $20 \log_{10} |A| in decibels (dB), which linearizes multiplicative effects and facilitates visualization of gain variations across frequencies. This dB representation highlights the typically high values of open-loop gain, often exceeding 100 dB at low frequencies, emphasizing its role in feedback design. These representations assume ideal linear behavior of the system, where the gain operates proportionally without introducing nonlinear distortions or noise, and the input-output relationship remains time-invariant. In complex notation, the open-loop gain A(j\omega) can be decomposed into real and imaginary components as A(j\omega) = \operatorname{Re}\{A\} + j \operatorname{Im}\{A\}, where the magnitude is |A(j\omega)| = \sqrt{[\operatorname{Re}\{A\}]^2 + [\operatorname{Im}\{A\}]^2} and the phase is \angle A(j\omega) = \tan^{-1} \left( \frac{\operatorname{Im}\{A\}}{\operatorname{Re}\{A\}} \right). This vector form aids in understanding the gain's contribution to system dynamics, such as in Nyquist or Bode analyses.

Feedback Systems

Closed-Loop Gain Derivation

In feedback systems, the feedback factor β represents the fraction of the output signal that is fed back to the input, typically through a passive or that scales the output voltage or current. This factor is dimensionless and assumes a value between 0 and 1 for attenuating networks in configurations. For a basic , consider an open-loop A that amplifies the input signal (input minus ). The input to the becomes e = x - β y, where x is the external input and y is the output. The output is then y = A e = A (x - β y), leading to the exact closed-loop after solving for y/x: A_{cl} = \frac{A}{1 + A \beta} This expression shows how the closed-loop gain depends on both the open-loop gain and the factor. When the open-loop gain |A| is very large compared to 1/β, the term A β >> 1, simplifying the closed-loop gain to the high-gain approximation: A_{cl} \approx \frac{1}{\beta} This approximation explains the behavior of ideal high-gain amplifiers, such as operational amplifiers in non-inverting configurations, where the closed-loop gain is determined solely by the , independent of variations in the open-loop gain. In , the formula becomes A_{cl} = A / (1 - A β), which can lead to if A β ≥ 1, as the denominator approaches zero or becomes negative; however, the derivation here focuses on the stable case. The finite open-loop gain introduces an output error relative to the case, quantified as the relative error ε = (A_{cl, ideal} - A_{cl}) / A_{cl, ideal} = 1 / (1 + A β), which approaches zero for high A β and highlights the precision gained from strong .

Stability and Bandwidth Effects

In systems, the of the open-loop gain A(j\omega) typically exhibits a due to inherent in the . For single-pole dominant systems, this occurs at a rate of 20 per beyond the dominant , leading to a gradual decrease in magnitude as increases. In applications, the unity-gain f_t, also known as the gain-bandwidth product, is the point where the magnitude of the amplifier's open-loop gain |A(j\omega)| = 1 (0 ), serving as a key parameter that limits the operational range of the loop. Stability analysis uses the L(j\omega) = A(j\omega) \beta(j\omega). analysis provides a graphical tool to evaluate these effects, plotting the |L(j\omega)| in decibels and the \angle L(j\omega) against the logarithmic \omega. The gain crossover frequency is identified where |L(j\omega)| = 1, and the —defined as the difference between the phase angle at this frequency and -180°—indicates relative . Similarly, the phase crossover frequency occurs where \angle L(j\omega) = -180^\circ, with the being the of the at that point. Stability in closed-loop systems is assessed using criteria such as the Nyquist theorem, which requires that the Nyquist plot of the open-loop L(j\omega) does not encircle the -1 point on the to avoid . The Barkhausen criterion highlights conditions for : the magnitude equals unity and the phase shift is a multiple of 360°; to avoid , these conditions should not be met simultaneously. A greater than 45° is generally recommended to ensure robust against perturbations, providing damping to prevent oscillations. The open-loop gain influences trade-offs in feedback configurations, where extends the closed-loop toward the unity-gain f_t but at the of reduced low- . This extension arises because the closed-loop approximates the gain crossover of the , allowing higher response speeds for a given open-loop , though it trades off the high DC advantage of open-loop operation. At high frequencies near or beyond the unity-gain point, the system's sensitivity to and increases, as the open-loop gain provides less of input disturbances and nonlinear effects. loops amplify measurement in these regimes, potentially degrading unless compensated by characteristics that suppress high-frequency components.

Electronics Applications

Operational Amplifiers

Operational amplifiers (op-amps) are high-gain electronic voltage amplifiers with a input , where the open-loop gain is defined as the ratio of the output voltage to the differential input voltage. This gain, denoted as A_{OL}, typically ranges from $10^5 to $10^7 (equivalent to 100 to 140 ) in modern devices, enabling the op-amp to amplify small input differences significantly while operating in open-loop mode without . The differential input rejects common-mode signals, focusing amplification on the difference between the inverting and non-inverting inputs, which is fundamental to their use in precision analog circuits. The internal structure of an op-amp contributes to its high open-loop gain through a multi-stage design, typically comprising a differential input stage followed by one or more high-gain voltage amplification stages and an output stage. The differential stage, often implemented with a pair of matched transistors (e.g., bipolar or CMOS), provides initial amplification and common-mode rejection, while subsequent gain stages, such as common-emitter or common-source amplifiers, multiply the signal to achieve the overall high A_{OL}. For instance, classic designs like the μA741 feature two gain stages, with the first being a differential amplifier biased by a current mirror. This cascaded architecture ensures the cumulative gain reaches the specified levels but also introduces frequency-dependent roll-off due to parasitic capacitances. In practice, the finite open-loop gain of real op-amps leads to non-ideal effects, including input offset voltage errors and limitations in slew rate. The finite A_{OL} causes the differential input voltage to be non-zero even when the output is at the desired level, amplifying any inherent input offset (typically in the μV to mV range) and degrading precision in low-gain closed-loop configurations. Additionally, this gain limitation interacts with slew rate—the maximum rate of output voltage change, often 0.5 V/μs in general-purpose op-amps like the μA741—constraining the amplifier's ability to respond quickly to large signal swings without distortion. These effects are particularly evident in high-frequency or high-precision applications, where the op-amp's gain-bandwidth product (typically 1 MHz for the μA741) further bounds performance. The historical evolution of op-amps traces back to vacuum-tube designs in the , initially developed for analog and featuring open-loop gains around ( dB), such as the K2-W model released commercially in 1953. The transition to integrated circuits in the mid-1960s marked a significant advancement, with the μA741, introduced by in 1968, achieving a typical open-loop gain of 200,000 (106 dB) through its monolithic , including internal compensation for . This popularized op-amps in , offering improved reliability and integration over tube-based predecessors. In , the open-loop gain plays a in selecting op-amps for applications, such as integrators, where high A_{OL} minimizes errors from finite gain and offset drift. For integrator circuits, which accumulate input signals over time via a feedback , op-amps with A_{OL} exceeding 10^6 ensure the at the inverting input remains accurate, reducing output errors to fractions of a percent even for low-frequency signals. Designers prioritize devices like bipolar or chopper-stabilized op-amps for such uses, as their elevated gain suppresses variations in under changing output conditions, enhancing long-term accuracy in applications like and . This selection criterion balances gain with other factors, such as margins, to avoid oscillations in loops.

Measurement and Characterization

Measuring the open-loop gain of operational amplifiers at involves applying a small input voltage using precise voltage sources while operating the device in a configuration that nulls to prevent . A common approach employs a servo loop to maintain the input voltage near zero by adjusting the output, allowing direct measurement of the resulting output voltage to compute the gain as the ratio of output to the nulled input . This ensures the amplifier remains in its linear region at low frequencies, typically below 10 Hz, where gain is highest. For AC characterization, network analyzers are widely used to capture the of open-loop gain by injecting a small signal into the path of a closed-loop , such as an inverting with high , to avoid direct open-loop operation that could induce oscillations. The analyzer measures the return signal to derive the open-loop , providing and data across frequencies from to the unity-gain , often up to 100 MHz or more for high-speed devices. Precautions include selecting resistors that ensure , typically with a of 1 to 10, to isolate the open-loop response without altering the device's intrinsic behavior. Among established methods, the servo-loop stabilization technique integrates an auxiliary to dynamically balance the inputs, enabling precise gain extraction at both and low frequencies by minimizing errors. Blackman's impedance technique, based on return-ratio analysis, indirectly assesses open-loop gain by measuring changes in input or under conditions, where the is inferred from the ratio of impedances with and without the active element. These approaches are particularly useful for high-gain s, providing accuracy within 0.1 at low frequencies when implemented with low-noise . Key error sources in these measurements include loading effects from test fixtures that reduce effective by shunting the output, limitations that obscure low-level signals at high frequencies, and parasitic capacitances introducing unintended poles that distort the response. To mitigate loading, high-impedance probes and buffer amplifiers are employed, while is addressed through averaging multiple sweeps and shielding; parasitics are minimized via short traces and guard rings, ensuring measurement fidelity within 1% for gains above 100 . Industry practices for testing, informed by guidelines in IEEE papers on , emphasize calibrated setups for , as seen in datasheets. For instance, the AD797 op-amp specifies a minimum open-loop of 120 dB at 10 Hz, dropping to unity at 110 MHz, measured under controlled conditions to account for temperature and supply variations.

Control Systems Applications

Open-Loop Transfer Functions

In control systems, the open-loop transfer function G(s) describes the dynamic relationship between the system's input and output in the Laplace domain, defined as the ratio of the Laplace transform of the output to the Laplace transform of the input under zero initial conditions. This representation enables prediction of system behavior for design purposes without incorporating feedback mechanisms. A common form for second-order open-loop systems is G(s) = \frac{K}{s(s + a)}, where K is the constant and a represents a related to system or . In block diagram notation, the open-loop is depicted as a single forward-path block G(s) connecting the input signal directly to the output, excluding any return path. The time-domain response of an open-loop system, such as its , exhibits characteristics like determined solely by the inherent poles of G(s), without any corrective action to adjust for deviations from the desired trajectory. For instance, in motor speed control within process applications, a simple proportional may model the relationship between applied voltage and rotational speed, often approximated as a form G(s) = \frac{K}{\tau s + 1} to capture acceleration dynamics. Open-loop transfer functions are particularly useful in preliminary modeling for systems like basic process , but they exhibit significant limitations, including high to external disturbances and variations, as there is no inherent mechanism to compensate for these effects.

Comparison to Closed-Loop Systems

In systems, open-loop gain refers to the direct amplification or from input to output without mechanisms, whereas closed-loop systems incorporate to compare the actual output with a desired reference, enabling error correction and adjustment of the control signal. This fundamental difference results in open-loop systems being simpler in , as they do not require sensors or comparators for , but they are inherently less robust to external disturbances or variations since there is no mechanism to compensate for deviations. In contrast, closed-loop configurations achieve greater accuracy by continuously monitoring and correcting errors, though at the expense of increased system complexity. A key performance distinction lies in steady-state error, where open-loop systems typically exhibit nonzero persistent errors due to the absence of , leading to offsets in output under constant disturbances or model inaccuracies. For instance, in an open-loop system, timing is preset without sensing vehicle density, resulting in potential inefficiencies during varying traffic conditions and a steady-state error in flow optimization if demand changes. Closed-loop systems, however, can minimize or eliminate steady-state error through integral control actions, as seen in a that senses and adjusts heating to maintain the setpoint precisely, rejecting ambient disturbances like open windows. Open-loop gain finds applications in repetitive, predictable tasks where environmental variations are minimal, such as the fixed-cycle operation of a that follows predetermined soak, wash, and rinse durations without monitoring load or water levels. Closed-loop approaches are preferred in dynamic environments requiring adaptability, like automotive systems that adjust based on speed to counter road inclines. From a practical standpoint, open-loop systems offer lower implementation costs and reduced complexity, avoiding the need for hardware, but they suffer from higher inaccuracy in non-ideal conditions. Closed-loop designs, while more expensive due to added components like sensors and controllers, provide superior reliability and performance in uncertain settings. Hybrid systems often leverage open-loop gain as a for initial actions, such as terms that provide rapid response based on anticipated inputs, which are then refined by closed-loop for precision and disturbance rejection, as in locomotion where open-loop trajectories are stabilized via sensory corrections. This combination balances the simplicity of open-loop operation with the robustness of closed-loop tuning, particularly in real-time applications like .

References

  1. [1]
    [PDF] MT-033: Voltage Feedback Op Amp Gain and Bandwidth
    The open-loop dc gain (usually referred to as AVOL) is the gain of the amplifier without the feedback loop being closed, hence the name “open-loop.” For a ...
  2. [2]
    [PDF] Operational Amplifiers
    Some op-amps have open loop gain values as high as 108 Vo/Vi. The graph that relates the output voltage to the input voltage is called the voltage transfer.
  3. [3]
    Control System Basics — FIRST Robotics Competition documentation
    Jun 21, 2025 · The open-loop gain is the total gain from the sum node at the input (the circle) to the output branch. this would be the system's gain if ...
  4. [4]
    The operational amplifier
    The open loop gain, A, of the amplifier is ranges from 105 to 107 at very low frequency, but drops rapidly with increasing frequency.
  5. [5]
    [PDF] Operational Amplifiers: Chapter 1 - MIT OpenCourseWare
    The quantity a in this equation is the open-loop gain or open-loop transfer function of the amplifier. (Note that a gain of a is assumed, even if it is not.Missing: representation | Show results with:representation
  6. [6]
    [PDF] Lecture 13 Dynamic analysis of feedback
    A(s) = 10. 5. 1 + s/100. ,. F = 0.01. • open-loop gain is large at DC (10. 5. ) • open-loop bandwidth is around 100 rad/sec. • open-loop settling time is around ...
  7. [7]
    [PDF] 1. January 1934: Stabilized Feedback Amplifiers. (Black, H.S.)
    This paper describes and explains the theory of the feedback principle and then demonstrates how stability of amplification and reduction of.
  8. [8]
    [PDF] CHAPTER 1: OP AMP BASICS - Analog Devices
    An ideal op amp has infinite gain for differential input signals. In practice, real devices will have quite high gain (also called open-loop gain) but this ...
  9. [9]
    [PDF] MT-033: Voltage Feedback Op Amp Gain and Bandwidth
    The open-loop dc gain (usually referred to as AVOL) is the gain of the amplifier without the feedback loop being closed, hence the name “open-loop.” For a ...
  10. [10]
    [PDF] Control System Design Based on Frequency Response Analysis
    1. It provides a necessary and sufficient condition for closed- loop stability based on the properties of the open-loop transfer function.
  11. [11]
    [PDF] Feedback Systems - Stanford University
    But, as we'll see in a moment, negative feedback extends bandwidth by selectively throwing away gain at lower frequencies. We will demonstrate that one may ...
  12. [12]
    [PDF] Feedback Fundamentals
    The high open loop gain of the amplifier is traded off for high bandwidth and low sensitivity. This is some times expressed by saying that gain is the hard ...
  13. [13]
    [PDF] Understanding Operational Amplifier Specifications (Rev. B)
    A is called the close loop gain of the op amp circuit, whereas a is the open loop gain. The product ab is called the loop gain. This is the gain a signal ...
  14. [14]
    [PDF] IC Op-Amps Through the Ages - Stanford University
    Perhaps the most famous op-amp of the vacuum tube era was the Philbrick. K2-W, whose particularly elegant design served as the inspiration for transistorized ...
  15. [15]
    [PDF] Basic OpAmp Design and Compensation
    The first stage is a pMOS differential pair with nMOS current mirrors. Second stage is a common-source amplifier. Shown in the diagram are reasonable widths in ...
  16. [16]
    [PDF] Op Amp Offset Voltage and Bias Current Limitations
    For a practical op amp, however, the differential input is the input offset voltage (VOS) and the open loop gain is typically on the order of 1 MV/V or 120 dB.
  17. [17]
    [PDF] µA741 General-Purpose Operational Amplifiers datasheet (Rev. G)
    Typical open loop gain is 106 dB while driving a 2000-Ω load. Short circuit tolerance, offset voltage trimming, and unity-gain stability makes the. μA741 ...
  18. [18]
    [PDF] H Op Amp History - Analog Devices
    Op amp history began in the early 20th century with vacuum tubes, named in 1947, and the first IC op amp in the mid-1960s.
  19. [19]
    1964: The First Widely-Used Analog Integrated Circuit is Introduced
    Then in 1968 Dave Fullagar of Fairchild one-upped the LM101 by adding an internal compensating capacitor to deliver the µA741, the most popular op-amp of all ...
  20. [20]
    [PDF] CHAPTER 1: THE OP AMP - Analog Devices
    The open-loop gain of the amplifier will attempt to force the differential voltage to zero. As long as the input and output stays in the operational range of ...Missing: multi- | Show results with:multi-
  21. [21]
    [PDF] Applying a New Precision Op Amp AN-242 - Texas Instruments
    These inverters have bias current and offset voltage of LM11 along with speed of the FET op amps. Open loop gain is about 140 dB and settling time to 1 mV about ...
  22. [22]
    Simple Op Amp Measurements - Analog Devices
    The open-loop dc gain of an op amp can be very high; gains greater than 107 are not unknown, but values between 250,000 and 2,000,000 are more usual.
  23. [23]
    Better, Faster Open-Loop Gain Measurement - Analog Devices
    The goal of such measurements is to characterize the frequency response of the network rapidly and with minimal effort, using available tools and a small amount ...
  24. [24]
    Measuring the Open Loop Gain of an Operational Amplifier
    Apr 8, 2021 · The typical gain of an op amp ranges from 104 to 105 or higher. Because the gain is so high, the input signal for an op amp must be very ...
  25. [25]
    Op-Amp complex impedance - Electrical Engineering Stack Exchange
    Jun 5, 2022 · Let's use the Blackman formula to find the input impedance. where Zd is the input impedance with the system dead, i.e. op amp gain = 0, Tsc is ...How to understand the open-loop gain of a op-amp?What is the best way to simulate the open-loop gain of an op-amp in ...More results from electronics.stackexchange.com
  26. [26]
    [PDF] Stabilizing Current-Feedback Op Amps While Optimizing Circuit ...
    This report discusses stability analysis, the effects of parasitic components due to printed circuit boards (PCBs), optimization of noise components, and ...
  27. [27]
  28. [28]
  29. [29]
    [PDF] Chapter Eight - Transfer Functions
    The parameter k is called the open loop gain, and the product ak is called the gain-.
  30. [30]
    [PDF] ECE 380: Control Systems - Purdue Engineering
    Recall that the gain margin is defined as the factor by which K can be increased before the closed loop system becomes unstable (we will define the gain margin.
  31. [31]
    Design PID Control for DC Motor Using Classical Control Theory
    The variable to control is the output speed. Compute the open-loop transfer function G from the state-space representation matrices A , B , C , and D. G ...
  32. [32]
    [PDF] Introduction to Control Engineering - LSU Scholarly Repository
    Jan 12, 2023 · where AOL is the open-loop gain of the amplifier. Additionally, the amplifier gain is very large. However, the magnitude of AOL is not well ...
  33. [33]
    [PDF] CENG 5131
    a control system without feedback is called an open-loop control system. ... Timed traffic lights. Thermostatic control. Washing ... % PROCNTL1.M Proportional ...
  34. [34]
    [PDF] Algorithmic Robotics: Enabling Autonomy in Challenging ...
    Closed loop control. 10/23/2021. CSCE274 - I. REKLEITIS. 9. • Example: – Thermostat. Thermostat – Source: wikipedia.com. Page 10. Closed loop control. 10/23/ ...
  35. [35]
    [PDF] An Open-Loop Baseline for Reinforcement Learning Locomotion ...
    A hybrid approach that integrates the strengths of feedforward (open-loop) and feedback (closed-loop) control offers a middle ground, as seen in various ...