Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Teach For America


Teach For America (TFA) is a founded in 1990 by that recruits recent college graduates from top universities to commit two years of in low-income public schools, providing them with accelerated training and alternative certification to address educational disparities. The program's model emphasizes selecting high-achieving corps members, intensive summer training, ongoing support, and a focus on data-driven instruction to close achievement gaps, with often advancing to leadership roles in education and policy.
Over three decades, TFA has placed more than 60,000 corps members in classrooms across the , primarily in and rural high-poverty , contributing to a network of alumni who influence systemic reforms. Empirical evaluations, including a 2024 of 23 studies covering over 5 million , indicate that TFA teachers produce statistically significant positive effects on math (0.05 standard deviations) and especially (0.16 standard deviations) compared to other novice teachers, though impacts on reading and nontested outcomes like are inconsistent or negligible. Randomized and quasi-experimental studies from like Miami-Dade and corroborate higher effectiveness in math and for TFA teachers, attributing gains to rigorous selection and instructional focus rather than extensive pedagogical training. Despite these measurable student gains, TFA has drawn for its short-term commitment, which results in high turnover rates—over 80% of corps members leave classrooms after two years—potentially undermining long-term stability and exacerbating inequities by assigning inexperienced teachers disproportionately to students. Critics, including educators and policy analysts, argue the model prioritizes elite recruitment over sustainable , fostering a "churn and burn" dynamic that benefits career trajectories more than persistent student needs, with program enrollment declining amid broader teacher shortages. Longitudinal analyses suggest that while initial high performance occurs, the transient nature limits enduring impacts on student trajectories.

History

Founding and Early Development (1989–2000)

Teach For America was founded in 1989 by , a senior who proposed the organization in her undergraduate thesis advocating for a national teacher corps to address educational inequities in low-income communities. The initiative drew inspiration from programs like the , aiming to recruit top recent college graduates for two-year teaching commitments in under-resourced public schools. Kopp's grassroots recruitment effort in 1989 attracted 2,500 applicants from elite campuses, enabling the launch of the inaugural corps the following year. The first corps consisted of 489 members who began in across six low-income urban and rural communities, including areas in , , , , , and . Corps members underwent an intensive five-week summer training institute focused on and instructional strategies before assuming full teaching responsibilities, often without prior experience. Early operations emphasized selectivity, with applicants evaluated on leadership potential and commitment to equity, though the program faced logistical hurdles such as securing placements and alternative certification pathways amid varying state regulations. By 1991, Teach For America expanded to 12 regions and recruited 1,068 corps members, reflecting growing interest and organizational maturation. The corps size reached approximately 1,500 by 1992, with cumulative applicants exceeding 30,000 by 2000 as recruitment scaled nationally. Over the decade, roughly 5,000 individuals served, with recent cohorts achieving a 90% two-year completion rate despite challenges like high-poverty school environments and resource shortages. This period solidified the model's emphasis on developing teacher-leaders to confront systemic gaps, though scalability required ongoing adaptations in training and partnerships with school districts.

Expansion and Maturation (2000–Present)

In the early , Teach For America experienced accelerated fueled by increased philanthropic and governmental , enabling the of approximately 1,600 new members annually by 2000. This growth built on earlier foundations, with member numbers rising from around 900 in 1995 to over 10,000 by the 2012–13 school year, alongside from five initial sites to 48 regions nationwide. By , the supported more than 8,000 active members and 20,000 across 39 regions, reflecting a scaling of operations that emphasized placement in high-need urban and rural schools. This period also marked maturation through alumni-driven initiatives, such as the founding of by two TFA in 2000, which expanded to 79 schools serving 27,000 students by the , primarily in regions. Organizational refinements included enhanced training protocols and a shift toward leveraging for systems-level , with over 1,000 and members recognized as Teachers of the Year at state, district, or school levels over the years. By 2013–14, size peaked at 11,100 members across 48 regions, but subsequent adjustments reduced active to around 4,000 by the mid-, amid broader recruitment challenges and a strategic pivot to deepen impact through a exceeding 70,000 , members, and fellows influencing over 9,000 schools. Further maturation involved data-informed evolutions, such as intensified focus on student feedback mechanisms like the Cultivate System introduced in the 2020s to address engagement by incorporating direct input on classroom relevance. The organization set ambitious targets, aiming by 2030 for twice as many children in its communities to achieve key educational milestones linked to economic mobility. Recent evaluations, including a 2025 principal survey, indicated strong support for TFA educators' effectiveness, with widespread endorsement of their contributions to underserved classrooms. These developments underscored a transition from rapid scaling to sustainable leadership cultivation, with corps members teaching over 290,000 students annually in more than 2,000 schools by the mid-2020s.

Program Model

Recruitment and Selection

Teach For America primarily recruits recent college graduates and career changers from diverse academic majors and backgrounds, targeting individuals with demonstrated leadership experience and a commitment to addressing educational disparities. The organization casts a wide net through campus visits, virtual events, and partnerships with universities, aiming to build the largest and most diverse applicant pool possible to identify candidates positioned for impact in low-income . Applications open annually from through for the subsequent school year's , with multiple deadlines such as September 15 and October 20, 2025, for the 2026 cohort. Eligibility requires a from an accredited institution by the start of summer training (typically ), a minimum cumulative GPA of 2.5, and U.S. , , or valid ; no prior teaching experience or specific major is mandated, reflecting the program's alternative certification model. The process begins with a concise online application including background questions, a resume upload, and two short-answer responses, which undergoes review within approximately one week to determine eligibility. Promising applicants advance to interviews—often or in-person—conducted by trained TFA or staff, incorporating elements like group discussions, sample teaching activities, and one-on-one assessments to evaluate traits such as perseverance, , interpersonal skills, respect for differences, and an unwavering belief in the potential of all students. TFA's evaluation employs a research-based framework with standardized rubrics and statistical validation, overseen by senior committees for consistency, prioritizing and growth mindset over traditional pedagogical credentials. This rigorous multi-stage approach yields high selectivity, with historical acceptance rates ranging from 12 to 15 percent; for instance, in 2013, approximately 14 percent of 57,000 applicants were admitted. More recent data indicate rates as low as 12 percent, underscoring the program's emphasis on admitting only those deemed capable of driving student outcomes comparable to or exceeding veteran educators. Post-interview decisions on admission and placement (region and subject) follow within days, with offers requiring acceptance within 10 days.

Training and Certification

Teach For America corps members participate in a multi-week summer institute, typically lasting five weeks and commencing in late May or early June depending on the region, to acquire essential competencies prior to entering classrooms. This pre-service training encompasses onboarding for certification testing and equity-focused strategies, a one-week kick-off for integration, and intensive phases of lesson planning, collaborative practice in simulated or paired settings, and sessions on , , and instructional delivery. The program emphasizes hands-on application, with corps members delivering lessons to students in partner summer programs or mock environments while receiving feedback from mentors and peers, aiming to build skills in creating rigorous, inclusive learning experiences. begins upon offer acceptance and integrates with ; applicants without prior credentials obtain an initial or provisional teaching license by passing state-mandated exams in and subject areas, facilitated by TFA's partnerships with regional education authorities that accommodate routes. Full , required in most regions, is pursued during the two-year commitment through university-affiliated programs, TFA-supported coursework, or state pathways, generally requiring 1-2 years of combined , , and evaluations. Ongoing development extends beyond summer institute via in-year coaching, professional learning communities, and access to resources like the Teaching as Leadership framework, which structures support around mindsets for instructional planning, cultural competency, and achievement outcomes, though requirements vary by state reciprocity rules and policies.

Placement and Corps Responsibilities

Teach For America places accepted corps members in public or public charter serving low-income communities across more than 40 regions in the United States, encompassing urban, rural, and suburban areas in over 50 states and the District of Columbia. Applicants select up to three preferred regions during the application process, which they finalize after their , with placement ultimately determined by a combination of these preferences, the availability of teaching positions, the subject and grade-level needs of partnering and , and specific hiring requirements such as relevant undergraduate and regional standards. Corps members typically receive confirmation of their specific region, school, and subject assignment approximately two weeks after finalizing their preferences, following which they undergo summer institute training before commencing full-time in August or September. As full-time teachers, corps members commit to a minimum two-year tenure, during which they assume primary responsibility for planning and delivering instruction in their assigned classrooms, typically for grades K-12 in under-resourced where student demographics reflect high concentrations of and educational disadvantage. Their core duties include setting ambitious academic goals for students, implementing data-driven instructional strategies to achieve measurable outcomes, and fostering an equitable learning environment that addresses systemic barriers to achievement. members receive the same and benefits as other first-year teachers in their , ranging from $32,000 to $72,000 annually depending on location, supplemented by Teach For America stipends of $3,000 to $6,500 for certification or relocation support. In addition to classroom teaching, corps members engage in continuous professional development through individualized coaching, peer collaboration, and mentorship from experienced educators, participating in an iterative cycle of planning lessons, teaching, assessing student progress, and reflecting on practices to refine their effectiveness. They must obtain state teaching certification, beginning with passing subject-specific exams for provisional licensure upon entry and pursuing full certification within the two-year term, often through partnerships with universities or alternative pathways facilitated by Teach For America. This structure emphasizes rapid skill acquisition and leadership growth, with expectations that corps members demonstrate initiative, adaptability to feedback, and a commitment to long-term impact on educational equity beyond their tenure.

Key Frameworks and Resources

Teach For America's primary instructional framework is Teaching as Leadership (), which underpins the organization's approach to developing corps members into effective educators capable of driving student achievement in high-need schools. Derived from analyses of high-performing teachers within the , TAL integrates a mindset of relentless pursuit of and excellence with practical strategies for classroom leadership. This framework posits that transformative teaching requires corps members to adopt beliefs in their students' potential and to apply structured practices throughout their tenure. The TAL framework comprises five interconnected elements of practice: Set Big Goals, where teachers establish ambitious, measurable student outcomes aligned with long-term success; Invest Students and Families, focusing on building relationships and engaging families to foster a supportive learning ecosystem; Plan Purposefully, involving data-driven tailored to student needs; Execute Effectively, emphasizing rigorous, adaptive delivery of lessons; and Engage Reflectively, through ongoing and adjustment of teaching methods based on of impact. These elements are reinforced by a foundational in , asserting that all students can achieve at high levels regardless of background. In addition to TAL, corps members utilize a range of resources to implement the framework, including content-specific curricula developed in partnership with experts, instructional coaching from program managers and mentors, and access to an ecosystem of on-demand digital tools for lesson planning and student data analysis. During the initial five-week summer training institute, participants receive certification-aligned instruction and equity-centered modules, followed by year-long support encompassing professional development workshops and wellness programs to address burnout risks. External collaborations, such as with BetterLesson since 2023, supply customized coaching and instructional materials to approximately 3,500 educators annually. TAL principles are disseminated through key publications, notably the 2010 book Teaching As Leadership: The Highly Effective Teacher's Guide to Closing the Achievement Gap, authored by TFA's former chief knowledge officer Steven Farr, which details the framework's origins from observing over 25,000 trained teachers and provides case studies for application. This resource, along with internal rubrics used for performance evaluation, ensures consistency across TFA's diverse regions.

Operations and Scale

Geographical and Demographic Reach

Teach For America operates exclusively within the , placing corps members in more than 40 regions that encompass urban, suburban, and rural communities across dozens of states. These regions include high-need areas such as the , Appalachian , and Native communities in , alongside major cities like , , and . As of April 2025, the organization supports placements in over 9,000 schools nationwide, adapting to local district needs while prioritizing locations with persistent teacher shortages and high student poverty rates. The program's demographic focus targets public schools serving predominantly low-income students, where at least 75% typically qualify for free or reduced-price meals, reflecting economic disadvantage. Students reached are disproportionately from racial and ethnic minority groups, with historical data indicating that around 90% are American, , or Native American in high-poverty settings, though contemporary placements continue to emphasize underserved and rural districts with similar profiles. Corps members themselves, drawn largely from recent graduates of selective colleges, show increasing : approximately 60% identify as , , or people of color, contrasting with the national workforce where such groups comprise about 20%. This composition aims to align with the demographics of the students served, though corps members often enter with limited prior classroom experience.

Organizational Growth Metrics

Teach For America commenced operations with an inaugural of nearly 500 members in 1990. The organization expanded rapidly over the subsequent decades, reaching more than 8,000 active members and 20,000 by 2010 across 39 regions. This growth accelerated further, with size surpassing 10,500 active members by 2014 and cumulative exceeding 37,000. Corps expansion peaked in the early at approximately 6,000 incoming members annually around 2013, reflecting a broader scaling that included placements in over 48 communities by 2013. Post-peak, however, the active corps contracted sharply, declining by nearly two-thirds from its height by the early amid broader challenges in and retention. As of 2024, the active corps stands at approximately 4,000 members, serving more than 290,000 students in over 2,000 schools. This represents a partial stabilization following the downturn, with operations spanning over 40 regions and 60 placement communities. The cumulative alumni network has continued to expand, surpassing 66,000 individuals, contributing to a total organizational force of over 70,000 including current corps members and Ignite fellows active in more than 9,000 schools nationwide.

Acceptance and Selectivity Rates

Teach For America maintains a rigorous selection process for its corps members, drawing from a large pool of applicants to identify candidates with strong potential, , and to . The organization evaluates applicants through multiple stages, including application review, phone interviews, and in-person or virtual assessments focusing on teaching simulations, experiences, and perseverance. This process results in acceptance rates that have historically positioned TFA as one of the most selective educational nonprofits, often comparable to admissions at graduate programs. In the 2010 application cycle, TFA received over 46,000 applications and accepted approximately 4,500 candidates, yielding an acceptance rate of 9.7 percent. Between 2008 and 2013, rates fluctuated between 11 and 15 percent amid growing applicant volumes and corps expansion. More recent data indicate continued selectivity, with annual rates as low as 12 percent reported in analyses of the program's recruitment model, reflecting a focus on mission-driven individuals likely to succeed in high-needs classrooms. Selectivity has persisted despite fluctuations in corps size; for instance, projections for the 2023-2024 cohort suggested rates around 10 percent, even as the incoming class stabilized at about 2,200 members following pandemic-related declines. This competitiveness underscores TFA's emphasis on quality over quantity, with accepted corps members typically holding above-average GPAs (e.g., around 3.6 in earlier cohorts) and diverse professional backgrounds. However, as the organization has contracted from peak placements of nearly 6,000 in the mid-2010s, some reports note slightly elevated rates in specific subgroups, though overall standards remain stringent to ensure alignment with performance predictors derived from prior corps outcomes.

Educational Impact and Evaluation

Student Achievement Outcomes

A meta-analysis of 23 studies encompassing over 5 million students found that Teach For America (TFA) teachers produce small but statistically significant positive effects on achievement (effect size of 0.05 standard deviations) and larger effects on science (0.16 standard deviations), while showing negligible impacts on arts (ELA) reading (effect size less than 0.01). These effects are generally stronger for TFA compared to first- and second-year members, with alumni yielding 0.09 standard deviations in math and 0.10 in ELA, versus near-zero for corps members alone. Randomized controlled trials within the meta-analysis, which mitigate selection biases, similarly indicate positive effects, particularly in (0.05 standard deviations). Effects vary by grade level and subject, with notable gains in pre-K through (0.18 standard deviations in math, 0.14 in ELA) and high school (0.15 in math, 0.08 in ELA), but limited data for secondary and post-pandemic periods, where math effects turned slightly negative (-0.13 standard deviations, though based on fewer studies). A separate of four studies confirmed a moderate positive effect on (0.12 standard deviations, p < 0.001) for TFA teachers versus non-TFA peers, but no significant impact on elementary reading (0.04 standard deviations, p = 0.30). Earlier randomized experiments, such as those in secondary across multiple districts, reported gains equivalent to 2-3 months of additional learning, outperforming comparison teachers with similar experience. Some studies highlight context-specific limitations, including negative effects for uncertified TFA teachers in certain districts prior to (significant declines in five of six achievement tests) and null or diminished impacts in elementary settings relative to novices. Overall, TFA members and tend to exceed novice non-TFA s in high-need subjects like math, but evidence bases remain thin for ELA and non-test outcomes, with heterogeneity driven by regional placement, status, and evaluation methods.

Teacher Effectiveness and Retention Dynamics

Teach For America (TFA) members demonstrate above-average effectiveness in raising , particularly in and , relative to novice or comparison teachers in similar high-need schools, according to multiple quasi-experimental and randomized studies. A 2024 meta-analysis by the , synthesizing data from 22 evaluations across 16 sites, found TFA teachers produced statistically significant gains of 0.05 standard deviations in math and 0.16 in , with null effects in arts, effects that persisted when controlling for experience and school context. In a 2023 evaluation of TFA , members increased by an average of 0.07 standard deviations more than non-TFA peers, with stronger effects (up to 0.15 standard deviations) in high-poverty elementary and schools. These gains stem from intensive pre-service emphasizing data-driven and high expectations, though critics note that under-certification may limit broader pedagogical depth compared to fully prepared educators. Retention among TFA corps members remains low, with most departing after the two-year commitment, contributing to high turnover in placement schools. National data indicate that approximately 50-60% of corps members exit their initial school post-commitment, and only about 15% remain in the same classroom long-term, compared to 40-50% retention rates for non-TFA novice teachers in urban districts. A 2022 analysis of New York City schools found five-year retention at 25% for TFA teachers versus over 50% for comparable non-TFA educators, attributing exits to burnout from challenging environments and TFA's ethos of leadership beyond classroom teaching. In Indianapolis, non-TFA teachers were 27 percentage points more likely to stay through the 2021-22 school year, exacerbating staffing instability in TFA-heavy schools. These dynamics reveal a : short tenures limit sustained relationships and institutional , potentially undermining long-term school improvement, yet extended-stay corps members exhibit heightened effectiveness. A 2016 study of TFA found that those retained beyond two years boosted math achievement by 0.10-0.15 standard deviations more than short-term peers, suggesting self-selection of more resilient, adaptable teachers. indicates this pattern holds across cohorts, with driven less by performance deficits than by systemic factors like inadequate administrative support and policy emphasis on temporary high-impact service over career . Overall, while TFA enhances immediate instructional quality in underserved areas, its model prioritizes catalytic influence over enduring presence, prompting debates on whether high-turnover efficacy justifies scalability amid persistent educator shortages.

Long-Term Systemic and Alumni Effects

Teach For America alumni, numbering over 60,000 as of 2023, predominantly pursue careers in and related fields, with approximately 80% engaged full-time in roles impacting low-income communities, including over 1,000 positions as school system leaders. These often ascend to influential roles in and administration, aligning with TFA's explicit that emphasizes leveraging participant experiences to foster in systemic efforts. For instance, TFA have held or sought elected office, with 27 serving in public positions and over 700 expressing interest in political as of 2012 data, contributing to for measures like evaluation reforms and expansions. Despite high initial effectiveness, TFA's low teacher retention rates—around 50% departing placement schools after the two-year commitment and only 15% remaining long-term—limit direct classroom-based systemic transformations, potentially exacerbating turnover costs in under-resourced districts. However, who persist in teaching demonstrate accelerated professional growth, outperforming non-TFA peers by more than double in student achievement gains over five years, suggesting selective retention of high-performers could yield sustained instructional improvements. Longitudinal student outcome studies indicate persistent TFA effects, with exposed students showing elevated test scores and non-test academic measures years later, though these benefits accrue primarily from short-term high-impact teaching rather than enduring personnel stability. Critics argue that TFA's model, by prioritizing temporary placements and alumni redirection toward policy advocacy, may obscure underlying structural deficiencies in teacher preparation and district funding, thereby hindering broader systemic overhauls like enhanced traditional recruitment or poverty alleviation. Empirical evidence on alumni-driven policy influence remains mixed; while TFA networks have advanced accountability-oriented reforms in select regions, alumni surveys reveal heightened attribution of achievement gaps to societal inequities over school-level factors, potentially steering efforts toward external interventions rather than operational efficiencies. Overall, TFA's alumni effects manifest more through networked leadership than persistent teaching cadres, with community-level progress in some areas linked to this dispersion, though causal attribution to program design versus individual selection effects requires further disaggregation.

Funding and Sustainability

Revenue Sources and Financial Model

Teach For America, a 501(c)(3) , derives the majority of its revenue from contributions, which include private philanthropic gifts, from foundations and corporations, and government . The organization does not bill schools or districts for corps member placements; employing entities hire participants as regular teachers, providing standard salaries and benefits, while TFA funds , the five-week summer institute, ongoing , and alumni support through external contributions. In 2023 (ending May 31, 2023), TFA reported of $275.6 million, with contributions comprising $253.4 million or 92% of the total; program service , such as fees from regional partnerships or affiliated services, contributed $15.5 million (5.6%); and added $7.2 million (2.6%). Within contributions, sources—including individuals, , and corporations—accounted for roughly 71% of operating contributions, while public sources, such as federal grants and state education funding, provided the remaining 29%. Government support specifically totaled about $53 million, reflecting TFA's participation in programs that partially offset training and placement costs. TFA's financial model emphasizes diversified, multi-level , with national campaigns targeting major donors and regional efforts securing local grants and contributions to align with community-specific needs across its operational footprint. This approach sustains a decentralized structure serving 25 regions but exposes the organization to volatility, as evidenced by a drop to $221.4 million in for 2024 (ending May 31, 2024), where contributions fell to $198 million (89.4%), program services rose slightly to $16.6 million (7.5%), and investment income increased to $7.5 million (3.4%). Expenses consistently outpaced in recent years, yielding net operating losses of $22.6 million in 2023 and $23.9 million in 2024, underscoring reliance on reserves or donor commitments for long-term viability.

Major Donors and Philanthropic Support

Teach For America has received substantial philanthropic support from foundations, corporations, and individuals, which forms the largest portion of its revenue, accounting for approximately $201 million of its $276 million total revenue in recent years. This funding model emphasizes private contributions over government grants, enabling operational flexibility in recruiting, training, and placing corps members in low-income schools. The Walton Family Foundation stands out as one of TFA's most significant long-term donors, providing grants since 1993 and totaling tens of millions over time, including a $49 million investment announced in 2011 to expand size and a $50 million commitment over three years in 2015 to support teacher recruitment and placement. Additional grants, such as $20 million in 2013, have targeted expansion in high-need regions like the . Other foundations contributing multimillion-dollar sums include the , which awarded $12 million in 2015 for teacher preparation initiatives, and the Broad Foundation, which co-invested in TFA's endowment alongside the and John Arnold Foundation, the Robertson Foundation, and philanthropists Steve and Sue Mandel in 2011. Individual philanthropists have also played key roles, with donating $25 million in 2022 to bolster TFA's national operations and alumni networks. More recently, contributed $10 million in May 2025 to expand programs, labs, and financial aid for corps members. Corporate foundations such as the Charitable Foundation, the Foundation, Foundation, and have provided annual support exceeding $500,000 each in various years, often tied to specific or efforts. Early philanthropic backing was instrumental in TFA's founding and growth, including a $500,000 seed gift from and investments from Don Fisher of in the , which helped scale the program from a pilot to a national organization. These contributions underscore a reliance on donors aligned with priorities, such as teacher pipeline development in underserved areas, though total philanthropic inflows have fluctuated with economic conditions and donor priorities.

Criticisms and Controversies

Effectiveness and Equity Debates

Teach For America (TFA) corps members have demonstrated varying effectiveness in improving student achievement, with empirical evidence from randomized controlled trials indicating stronger impacts in than in English language arts. A 2006 multisite found that TFA teachers produced greater gains in math scores (effect size of 0.15 standard deviations) compared to other novice teachers, though effects were negligible in reading. Similarly, a Campbell of four studies reported positive effects on math outcomes but inconsistent results for reading and . However, a 2010 review of peer-reviewed studies highlighted mixed findings, with TFA teachers often outperforming peers in math but not uniformly across subjects or regions. Critics argue that TFA's reliance on under-certified teachers undermines long-term effectiveness, as students of such teachers exhibit approximately 20% less annual academic growth than those taught by fully certified educators. Nonexperimental analyses, such as a 2024 study in , detected no significant TFA effects on subsequent-year test scores or nontest outcomes like , though persistent benefits appeared in some subgroups. Retention challenges further complicate effectiveness claims; only about one-third of corps members continue beyond the two-year commitment, contributing to higher turnover in high-poverty schools where stability is crucial for sustained progress. Those who remain, however, show accelerated improvement, gaining skills at double the rate of non-TFA teachers over five years. Equity debates center on whether TFA's model exacerbates disparities despite its stated goal of addressing educational inequities in low-income communities. Proponents cite evidence that TFA placements in underserved areas yield distributional benefits, with one showing gains across the achievement spectrum in elementary math, potentially narrowing gaps for lower-performing students. Yet, the program's short-term structure is criticized for perpetuating instability; high turnover rates—exacerbated by corps members' limited and frequent departure after two years—disrupt continuity in schools serving predominantly minority and low-income students, where retention is already low at around 70% annually. Furthermore, TFA's recruitment of predominantly elite-college graduates from outside affected communities has fueled accusations of cultural disconnect and "white savior" dynamics, with critics contending that this approach prioritizes temporary interventions over building local capacity. Empirical data on impacts remain sparse, but suggest that while initial student outcomes may improve, the model's pipeline into and charters—rather than classroom retention—may divert focus from to broader agendas perceived as market-oriented. A Brookings noted that declining TFA enrollment correlates with broader scrutiny of its claims, as high-poverty districts grapple with persistent staffing shortages.

Ideological and Political Dimensions

Teach For America (TFA) has encountered ideological scrutiny from progressive critics who view it as emblematic of neoliberal , emphasizing market-driven solutions like schools over structural changes to public education and . By 2018, approximately 40% of TFA's 6,736 corps members were placed in schools, up from 13% in 2008, with higher concentrations in cities such as (54%) and (70%). This placement pattern stems from partnerships with networks founded by TFA alumni, including and , and funding incentives from donors like the Foundation, which provided $6,000 per corps member in charters versus $4,000 in traditional public schools during 2013-2015 grants. observers, including leaders, argue that such alignments deprofessionalize teaching, exacerbate turnover in under-resourced schools, and facilitate the displacement of experienced unionized educators to accommodate lower-cost TFA recruits. Conservative commentators contend that TFA has shifted from its founding emphasis on closing achievement gaps through high standards and accountability toward advancing left-leaning social priorities, diluting its educational focus. Under CEO Elisa Villanueva Beard, the organization has prioritized issues like and identity-based protections, including a dedicated DACA director and over 31 statements on the topic since 2013. Following Donald Trump's victory, TFA demanded DACA continuity, "culturally responsive teaching," and safe classrooms for LGBTQ youth, Muslim students, and teachers. It also issued 11 demands to Secretary , critiquing her despite prior TFA support for policies like that aligned with DeVos's agenda. Events such as the 25th-anniversary summit featured sessions on "#StayWoke" racial literacy and resistance to perceived systemic inequities in policing, which critics attribute to a broader embrace of over curricular rigor. This evolution correlates with declining applicant numbers, from 57,000 in 2013 to 37,000 by , amid perceptions of ideological overreach. TFA maintains political neutrality in its core mission but engages in advocacy that spans debates, often reflecting the predominantly liberal demographics of its recruits from . Such involvement has fueled accusations of reinforcing elite-driven narratives that blend rhetoric with market reforms, as articulated in analyses framing TFA as "progressive neoliberalism." These dimensions highlight TFA's positioning at the intersection of and broader cultural conflicts, with sources from both ideological flanks questioning its fidelity to apolitical, evidence-based teaching.

Certification, Union, and Labor Concerns

Teach For America corps members enter classrooms without prior , relying instead on state-specific pathways such as provisional or emergency credentials that allow them to teach while pursuing full licensure. Corps members must hold a from an accredited institution and typically achieve a minimum GPA of 2.5, passing required subject-area exams and tests before or during their summer institute training, which spans five weeks. Most regions mandate ongoing coursework—often evenings and weekends—toward full within the two-year commitment, though requirements vary by , with some like emphasizing passing assessments for eligibility. Critics, including advocates, contend this model prioritizes rapid placement over rigorous preparation, potentially compromising instructional quality in high-needs schools where experienced teachers are scarce, as uncertified novices may lack the pedagogical depth to address complex student challenges effectively. Teachers' unions have frequently opposed Teach For America, viewing its deployment of short-term, alternatively certified instructors as a threat to professional standards and job security for unionized educators. Organizations like the and local affiliates argue that TFA corps members, with their two-year commitment, serve as temporary replacements that undermine tenure protections and agreements, enabling districts to sidestep hiring fully credentialed, career teachers amid shortages. In 2019, amid strikes in Oakland and , unions highlighted tensions, accusing TFA of anti-union leanings by advising corps members against participation and threatening to withhold post-service awards—potentially thousands of dollars—for striking, which could deter involvement in labor actions. Such stances reflect unions' broader self-interest in preserving membership rolls and salary scales, though TFA maintains it does not displace veteran teachers and has formed partnerships with some unions. In , Democratic lawmakers proposed banning TFA placements in 2019, citing its role in charter-heavy districts amid strike waves, though the measure did not pass. Labor concerns for corps members center on compensation, workload, and retention amid demanding conditions in under-resourced schools. Corps members are employed directly by districts, receiving salaries comparable to other novice s—averaging approximately $44,000 annually nationwide in recent estimates—plus standard benefits, though TFA itself provides only a pre-service without direct responsibility. The two-year model fosters high attrition, with many exiting after fulfilling their term due to from extended hours, administrative burdens, and insufficient support, exacerbating teacher shortages rather than alleviating them long-term. Union disputes have included cases, such as a 2015 ruling affirming TFA teachers' rights to unionize in charter schools, challenging contracts that restricted organizing. These dynamics underscore TFA's reliance on motivated but transient labor, which critics argue exploits for systemic gaps while districts benefit from lower-cost staffing without investing in sustained .

References

  1. [1]
    About - Teach for America
    Our Mission. Teach For America finds, develops and supports extraordinary leaders to transform education and expand opportunity for all children. Our Why. We ...
  2. [2]
  3. [3]
    Our Approach | Teach For America
    TFA's approach involves leaders, those impacted by unequal outcomes, and a coalition. It has four stages: find leaders, support educators, develop leaders, and ...
  4. [4]
    Our Impact | Teach For America
    In the last 10 years, AP/Dual Credit course completion has grown from 23% to 43%, and the percentage of students in the Rio Grande Valley who enroll into higher ...
  5. [5]
    A Meta-analysis of Teach For America Teacher Impacts
    Effects were statistically significant and positive for science, with the average effect for science 0.16 standard deviations higher for students of TFA ...
  6. [6]
    [PDF] A Meta-analysis of Teach For America Teacher Impacts
    The average statistically significant effects were 0.05 for math and 0.16 for science, indicating positive impacts of TFA on both math and science achievement.<|control11|><|separator|>
  7. [7]
    National Evaluation of Teach For America - Mathematica
    Findings. The study found that TFA teachers had a positive impact on students' math achievement. Average math scores were higher in classes taught by TFA ...
  8. [8]
    Teaching and Leading: Impacts of Teach For America Indianapolis
    Jul 20, 2023 · TFA Indy teachers were, on average, more effective at increasing student achievement than non-TFA teachers. One year of instruction by a TFA ...
  9. [9]
    Teach For America is shrinking—Is this cause for celebration?
    Jan 31, 2023 · TFA has clearly had a positive impact on students, but its diminished stature creates space for less-rigorous and less-tested alternative ...
  10. [10]
    Teach For America's Fast Path to the Classroom Accelerates ...
    Feb 28, 2024 · The program remains controversial, however. TFA teachers are usually new to education, and critics worry that the program provides students who ...
  11. [11]
    How Teach for America Lost Its Way - Commentary Magazine
    Nov 15, 2017 · Teach for America, or TFA, the national corps of recent graduates who commit two years to teaching in underserved classrooms across the country.
  12. [12]
    The Effects of High-performing, High-turnover Teachers on Long-run ...
    Nov 22, 2022 · A fundamental question is what effect these programs have on student achievement over the long run. To address this question, I study Teach For ...Missing: empirical | Show results with:empirical<|separator|>
  13. [13]
    Estimates of Teach for America Effects on Student Test and Nontest ...
    Mar 6, 2024 · This article examines the impact of Teach for America (TFA) on following-year student test and nontest outcomes in Miami-Dade County Public Schools.
  14. [14]
    Milestones in TFA's 25-Year History - Education Week
    The interactive timeline below highlights key turning points in the organization's development.
  15. [15]
    Ten Years of Teach For America (Opinion) - Education Week
    Jun 21, 2000 · As Teach For America gears up to enter its second decade, founder Wendy Kopp reports on what has been learned and what comes next.
  16. [16]
    How Teach for America Evolved Into an Arm of the Charter School ...
    Jun 18, 2019 · In 2000, it raised $25 million from private donors, government grants and foundations, which supported about 1,600 new corps members a year. By ...
  17. [17]
    [PDF] LETTER - Teach for America
    our teaching corps has grown from 900 corps members in 1995 to more than 10,000 in 2012. corps groWTh. In the 2012–13 school year, more than 10,000 first- and ...
  18. [18]
    [PDF] Teach for America and Teacher Quality: Increasing Achievement ...
    TFA underwent a period of expansion in the early 2000s, expanding from five original sites, including one in Eastern North Carolina, to 48 regional sites ...
  19. [19]
    [PDF] 2010 Annual Report - Teach For America
    Today, more than 8,000 corps members and 20,000 alumni are working across 39 regions, and there is growing evidence of their impact and influence at all levels.
  20. [20]
    [PDF] Company description - Teach for America
    Teach For America. 2013-14 school year includes 11,100 corps members teaching in 48 regions across the country ... Corps members are full-time teachers employed ...
  21. [21]
    70K+ Education Leaders | Teach For America Leadership
    Teach For America is a force of over 70,000 alumni, corps members, and Ignite Fellows working in over 9,000 schools nationwide. As a collective—educators ...
  22. [22]
    Belonging in the Classroom: How Student Feedback Can Address ...
    Dec 16, 2024 · The Cultivate System is helping TFA educators gather feedback directly from their students about what they are experiencing in terms of relevance of classwork.
  23. [23]
    Survey Finds Widespread Principal Support for Teach For America ...
    Oct 1, 2025 · Founded in 1990, Teach For America finds, develops, and supports a growing network of leaders who expand opportunity for children from ...
  24. [24]
    Teacher Application Process & Requirements - Teach for America
    What is the Hiring Timeline? ; Learn if you're invited to an interview, Sept. 22, Oct. 27 ; Attend your interview, Sept. 29 - Oct. 1, Nov. 03 - 06 ; Learn your ...
  25. [25]
    [PDF] GettinG the RiGht PeoPle in the ClassRoom - Teach for America
    the largest, most diverse and highly-qualified applicant pool in our history.
  26. [26]
    Teach For America | Company Profile - Vault
    Teach For America recruits primarily high-achieving college seniors; applicants undergo a thorough selection process, with an acceptance rate of roughly 12 ...Missing: selectivity | Show results with:selectivity<|separator|>
  27. [27]
    Teach for Prestige | Opinion - The Harvard Crimson
    Oct 13, 2023 · ... TFA was able to produce acceptance rates averaging between 11 and 15 percent. ... Corps members produce student outcomes equal to or better ...
  28. [28]
    Initial Training - Teach for America
    Regions are grouped into two waves of training start dates: Monday, May 20, and Monday, June 10. You can view training start dates for each region using our ...
  29. [29]
    WWC | Teach for America (TFA) - Institute of Education Sciences
    Teach For America (TFA) is a highly selective route to teacher certification ... TFA teachers receive 5–7 weeks of in-person training over the summer ...
  30. [30]
    Do I need to earn a teaching certification to teach as a corps member?
    Most regions also require corps members to work toward full teaching certification during their two-year commitment.
  31. [31]
    Teacher Development & Certification Program | Teach For America
    Commit to teaching full-time for 2 years in an underserved school. Get hired by a local school or district. Receive salary and benefits directly from your ...
  32. [32]
    Teach For America Corps Locations & Regions
    We currently place corps members in over 40 regions with over 60 placement communities. ... 1990, 1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001 ...
  33. [33]
    How does Teach For America determine an applicant's region and ...
    Teach For America determines placement based on region and subject preferences, availability of teaching positions, and other hiring requirements.
  34. [34]
    Teach For America Corps Program
    Teach For America corps members teach full time for at least two years in underserved schools. Learn more about our teaching program, reasons to join Teach ...Preparing to Teach with Teach... · Info Sessions · Salary and BenefitsMissing: timeline | Show results with:timeline<|control11|><|separator|>
  35. [35]
    Teach For America Family & Friends FAQs
    We place teachers in nearly 40 regions across the country. Depending on the region, first-year TFA teachers make between $33,000 - $68,000 per school year.Missing: 1990s | Show results with:1990s
  36. [36]
    [PDF] never smooth. never dull. change lives. - Teach for America
    Corps members who can put their students on a different life path must also be great leaders. This philosophy is the basis for the Teaching As Leadership ...
  37. [37]
    [PDF] The Effectiveness of Secondary Math Teachers from Teach ... - ERIC
    Teach For America's Teaching as Leadership Rubric ... lists TFA's Teaching As Leadership rubric, which includes six principles of leadership, each.<|separator|>
  38. [38]
    What kind of training and support do corps members receive?
    As a TFA corps member, you will engage in a pre-service model with corps members from across the country, the goal of which is to develop you as a teacher ...Missing: responsibilities | Show results with:responsibilities
  39. [39]
    TFA Partners with BetterLesson for 2023-24 School Year
    Nov 29, 2023 · BetterLesson extends support to 3500 TFA educators delivering coaching and instructional resources to teachers in the TFA program.
  40. [40]
    Choosing a Teach For America Location
    Select up to three regions: You are open to teaching in multiple locations and would be excited to accept an offer from any of the locations you've selected.Missing: 1990s | Show results with:1990s
  41. [41]
    Teach For America Priority Regions
    First-year teachers in San Antonio earn one of the highest starting salaries of all Teach For America locations, coming in at $54,000 per year. Even though the ...
  42. [42]
    Teach For America's Outgoing CEO Reflects on Her Tenure (Opinion)
    Apr 8, 2025 · Teach For America alumni serve in elected offices ranging from local school boards to Congress. ... We reach more than 40 regions with our ...
  43. [43]
    [PDF] 1.3 months 2.6 months Each of the eight cities featured in a third ...
    Since 1990, Teach For America has placed almost 67,000 teachers in more than 50 urban and rural communities across the. United States. Studies show that its ...
  44. [44]
    [PDF] A Racio-economic Analysis of Teach for America
    Moreover, although 90% of the students served by TFA are African America, Latino, or Native American, and live in high-poverty communities, 14% of recruits are ...Missing: reach | Show results with:reach
  45. [45]
    Teach for America and Teacher Ed: Heads You Win, Tails We Lose
    Oct 2, 2025 · The website lists the colleges that contribute the most graduates to the TFA corps, and it reads like a Who's Who of American higher education.
  46. [46]
    Teach For America At 25: With Maturity, New Pressure To Change
    Dec 1, 2014 · Within a few years, TFA had became a top recruiter at elite schools around the country. Enlarge this image. TFA corps of 1990, the first year.
  47. [47]
    How competitive is Teach for America? - College Confidential Forums
    Aug 25, 2010 · Teach For America is very competitive! The 2010 Corps acceptance rate was 9.7% for more than 46,000 applicants. Also the average gpa was a ...
  48. [48]
    No surprise here: TFA, TNTP applications surge
    If the TFA trajectory continues through the end of hiring season, it will be the organization's most selective year, with an acceptance rate hovering around 10 ...Missing: statistics | Show results with:statistics
  49. [49]
    Once a Big Player, Teach For America Tries to Regain Its Footing
    Aug 3, 2023 · This year, TFA is welcoming an incoming class of about 2,200. That's up from last year's low of 1,616—but still a far cry from the nearly 6,000 ...
  50. [50]
    [PDF] teach for america: recruiting, selecting, and training the next
    Our model includes a rigorous selection process that allows us to identify talented candidates who are strong leaders in their communities and best positioned ...
  51. [51]
    What are the effects of Teach For America on Math, English ...
    Thus, from a meta‐analytic perspective, we conclude that TFA corps members and alumni together have a positive and statistically significant effect on math ...
  52. [52]
    The Impacts of Teach for America on Student Achievement and ...
    Aug 10, 2025 · This paper reports on a randomized experiment to study the impact of an alternative teacher preparation program, Teach for America (TFA), ...<|separator|>
  53. [53]
    [PDF] Teach For America: A Review of the Evidence
    Jun 2, 2010 · Uncertified TFA teachers had significant negative effects on student achievement for five of the six. Page 11. 7 of 17 tests. (The sixth was ...
  54. [54]
    (PDF) The Effectiveness of "Teach for America" and Other Under ...
    Aug 7, 2025 · Students of under-certified teachers make about 20% less academic growth per year than do students of teachers with regular certification.
  55. [55]
    [PDF] The Effects of High-performing, High-turnover Teachers on Long-run ...
    First, I document five-year cumulative retention rates and find that, as expected, retention is lower for TFA teachers (25%) than for other NYC teachers working ...
  56. [56]
    Teacher Attrition and Mobility During the Teach for America ...
    Jul 7, 2016 · We also find that TFA corps members eventually retained beyond the 2-year commitment performed substantially better in mathematics during their ...
  57. [57]
    [PDF] Teacher Attrition and Mobility During the Teach For America ...
    below the 37% retention rate of the 2011 cohort of TFA corps members observed in the administrative data. Based on these estimates, we conclude that the ...
  58. [58]
    [PDF] How does Teach For America engage its alumni politically? A case ...
    Feb 22, 2021 · Part of TFA's theory of change relies on moving alumni of its program into policy and leadership positions, not only for the expansion of its ...
  59. [59]
    Looking Past the Spin: Teach for America - Rethinking Schools
    (TFA has sent recruits to Houston since 1991, and this year has more than 450 corps members teaching there.)<|separator|>
  60. [60]
    The Role of Teach For America Alumni in Education Policy
    May 5, 2016 · This study also examines the ways in which TFA and its alumni are engaged in matters of charter schools and school choice, teacher evaluation ...
  61. [61]
    [PDF] Persistent Teach For America Effects on Student Test and Non-Test ...
    Jan 2, 2024 · Several prior studies have found that teacher effects on test scores persist, to some extent, to test scores in future grades (Jacob et al., ...
  62. [62]
    [PDF] Teach For America Influence on Non-TFA Teachers in TFA-Hiring ...
    Jul 12, 2022 · This paper is grounded theoretically in sociocultural policy studies and related anthropological and sociological research that examines ...
  63. [63]
    TFA Analysis Fails to Consider Systemic Costs of Teacher Turnover
    Mar 14, 2023 · The study finds that, after six years of teaching, TFA teachers continue to improve their contributions to students' standardized test scores at ...Missing: term studies
  64. [64]
    Here's What Teach For America Alumni Believe About Charters ...
    Oct 8, 2019 · Teach For America alumni are more likely to attribute differences in student outcomes to societal inequities and less likely to support ...<|separator|>
  65. [65]
    How Teach for America Affects Beliefs about Education
    Oct 8, 2019 · TFA participants are more likely to believe larger societal inequities perpetuate income-based differences in educational outcomes.
  66. [66]
    Research - Teach For All
    Teach For All is a learning network working to generate evidence-based insights about how to develop collective leadership that leads to the systemic change.<|separator|>
  67. [67]
    Teach For America Inc - Nonprofit Explorer - ProPublica
    Teach For America Inc. is a 501(c)(3) educational nonprofit. In 2024, it had $221M revenue, $245M expenses, and a net loss of $23.9M. In 2023, it had $275M  ...
  68. [68]
    Supporting TFA - Teach for America
    How is TFA funded? Teach For America raises money nationally and locally from a diverse set of donors, including businesses, foundations, government ...
  69. [69]
    How is TFA funded? | Teach For America
    Teach For America raises money nationally and locally from a diverse set of ... For more details, view our most recent Annual Report. Popular questions.
  70. [70]
    Teach for America | Company Overview & News - Forbes
    Teach for America ; Total Revenue: $276M · Government Support$53M · Private Donations$201M · Other Income$22M ; Total Expenses: $302M · Charitable Services$217M.
  71. [71]
    Walton Family Foundation Invests $49 million in Teach For America
    Jul 27, 2011 · Since 1993 and prior to today's announcement, the Walton Family Foundation has contributed more than $22 million to Teach For America. This ...<|separator|>
  72. [72]
    Walton Family Foundation to Invest $50 Million in Teach For America
    Nov 4, 2015 · The Walton Family Foundation today announced that it is investing $50 million over three years in Teach For America (TFA), which this year is turning 25 years ...
  73. [73]
    Walton Family Foundation Awards $20 Million to Teach for America
    The Walton Family Foundation has announced a two-year, $20 million grant to Teach For America in support of TFA's efforts to recruit and train more teachers ...
  74. [74]
    Gates Foundation put millions of dollars into new education focus
    Nov 23, 2015 · Gates Foundation put millions of dollars into new education focus: Teacher preparation ; October 2015 · $12,000,000 ; Teach for America Inc.
  75. [75]
    Teach For America Announces Endowment With Investments From ...
    Jan 27, 2011 · Three additional philanthropic donors—the Laura and John Arnold Foundation, the Robertson Foundation, and Steve and Sue Mandel—stepped up and ...Missing: largest | Show results with:largest
  76. [76]
    Teach For America Receives $25 Million Investment from ...
    Nov 14, 2022 · Teach For America Receives $25 Million Investment from Philanthropist MacKenzie Scott. The substantial gift affirms the importance of Teach For ...
  77. [77]
    Ripple Donates $10M to Teach For America to Boost Innovation ...
    May 5, 2025 · The $10 million donation will expand the Ignite Tutoring Fellows program, drive innovation in our Reinvention Lab, and provide crucial financial assistance.
  78. [78]
    [PDF] SUPPORTERS AND FINANCIALS - Teach for America
    Teach For America's 2014 total revenue was $72,671,191, with 27% from foundations, 27% from individuals/events, and 11% from federal funding. 35% of revenue ...
  79. [79]
    Teach For America - Philanthropy Roundtable
    The philanthropic support that has powered TFA from the beginning has soared along with its enrollments. Don Fisher recognized in the early 1990s that a ...
  80. [80]
    Alternative routes to teaching: The impacts of Teach for America on ...
    Nov 23, 2005 · This paper reports on a randomized experiment to study the impact of an alternative teacher preparation program, Teach for America (TFA), on student ...Missing: trials | Show results with:trials
  81. [81]
    [PDF] Teach For America: A Review of the Evidence
    Jun 2, 2010 · However, only a handful of peer-reviewed studies of TFA's impact exist—and the findings are mixed. These studies analyze different samples, ...
  82. [82]
    Teaching for All? Teach For America's Effects across the Distribution ...
    The majority of the quasi-experimental evidence found that TFA teachers had a positive effect on math and science on average, and little to no impact on ...Missing: empirical | Show results with:empirical
  83. [83]
    A Bourdieusian analysis of why Teach For America teachers quit early
    One of the criticisms levied most frequently against TFA, however, is that its corps members (CMs) rarely stay beyond their two-year commitment; indeed, most ...
  84. [84]
  85. [85]
    Teach for America - InfluenceWatch
    TFA received $45 million in government grants in 2017, according to tax records. The following organizations have made contributions of greater than $5 million ...Missing: breakdown | Show results with:breakdown<|control11|><|separator|>
  86. [86]
    Teach for America and the Politics of Progressive Neoliberalism
    The purpose of this article is to problematize TFA's intentions by situating its political philosophy in the larger context of neoliberal educational reform.
  87. [87]
    Teach For America's Defenders and Detractors Are Both Wrong
    Jun 25, 2019 · Teach For America's Defenders and Detractors Are Both Wrong ... They see the TFA legacy as complicated, mixed, and legitimately open to critique.Missing: controversies | Show results with:controversies
  88. [88]
    Life as a Corps Member | Teach For America
    Training: During training, corps members will spend about two weeks on centralized learning experiences, primarily done synchronously with some asynchronous ...
  89. [89]
    Teach for America (TFA) - South Carolina Department of Education
    Potential candidates for Teach for America must have a bachelor's degree from a regionally accredited institution and have a passing score on the appropriate ...
  90. [90]
    Public school strikes revive clash with Teach for America | AP News
    Feb 13, 2019 · But the program also has produced a number of “traditionalist” career teachers who have become its chief critics as well as union leaders.
  91. [91]
  92. [92]
    Teach For America draws fire over school strike guidance - K-12 Dive
    Feb 19, 2019 · TFA has also had a reputation for opposing teachers' unions in the past, though it has refuted those allegations. And last week's events have ...
  93. [93]
    Are Teach For America Members Allowed to Go on Strike?
    Feb 22, 2019 · Teach For America has said corps members who go on strike would lose thousands of dollars in award money.
  94. [94]
    Teach For America — except for California - POLITICO
    Apr 6, 2019 · Democrats are pushing to ban Teach For America from California amid a wave of teacher's strikes and a heated debate over charter schools.Missing: disputes conflicts
  95. [95]
    Corps Member Salaries in the United States for Teach For America
    Rating 3.8 (496) Average Teach For America Corps Member yearly pay in the United States is approximately $44,021, which is 32% above the national average. Salary estimated from ...
  96. [96]
    Yes, 'Teach for America' Workers Are Employees and Can Join ...
    Aug 7, 2015 · A National Labor Relations Board hearing officer has ruled that Teach for America teachers should be included in the union at a Detroit ...Missing: disputes | Show results with:disputes