Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Stipend

A stipend is a fixed sum of paid at regular intervals, either for services rendered without regard to hours worked or to offset living expenses during , , or periods. The term derives from the Latin stipendium, originally referring to a soldier's pay or contribution, combining stips (a small or ) with pendere (to weigh out or pay). In contrast to salaries or wages, which compensate for labor performed and must comply with requirements, stipends function as allowances untethered to productivity metrics, often provided to students, interns, fellows, or to enable participation in non-commercial activities. While not classified as in many educational contexts, stipends are generally taxable as ordinary under rules unless qualifying as tax-exempt scholarships restricted to tuition or required fees.

Definition and Etymology

Core Definition

A stipend is a fixed, periodic of provided to an individual, typically to support living expenses, defray costs associated with or , or serve as subsistence during non-commercial activities such as internships, fellowships, or apprenticeships. This form of support differs from wages or salaries, which constitute compensation for labor performed and are subject to federal and state laws, overtime requirements, and payroll withholding; stipends, by contrast, are not linked to hours worked or productivity and thus evade such labor regulations. Under U.S. tax rules, stipends are generally treated as , akin to other earnings, unless they qualify for specific exemptions—such as portions of scholarships or fellowships not requiring services like or , which may be excluded from . Organizations issuing stipends often classify them as allowances rather than remuneration to avoid employer obligations under employment law, though misclassification can lead to legal recharacterization as wages if the effectively compensates for work.

Linguistic Origins

The English word stipend traces its origins to the Latin stipendium, a term denoting a , impost, , or—particularly in contexts—soldier's pay or . This derives from the combination of stips (or stip-, referring to a small , , , or contribution) and pendere (meaning "to weigh," "to hang," or "to pay out," as in weighing out on scales). The root stips likely evokes the idea of modest, piecemeal offerings, akin to contributions pooled for or , while pendere underscores the act of disbursing value by weight, a common ancient practice for or commodities. The word entered around the early 15th century, appearing in forms such as stipendie or stipendy, borrowed via stipende or directly from usage in medieval texts. Its earliest recorded applications in English pertained to fixed periodical payments, often for clerical or , reflecting the Latin sense of compensated rather than profit-driven wage labor. By the 15th century, it had solidified in legal and administrative documents, such as those outlining ecclesiastical benefices, where it distinguished modest sustenance allowances from full salaries. This linguistic evolution preserved the connotation of a non-commercial, duty-bound provision, differentiating it from terms like salarium (derived from sal, , implying an allowance for essentials).

Historical Development

Ancient and Roman Roots

The practice of providing a stipend originated in the Roman Republic as a form of military compensation known as stipendium, introduced around 406 BCE during the extended siege of Veii to support citizen-soldiers absent from their farms for prolonged campaigns. This marked an evolution from earlier unpaid levies of property-owning citizens, funded initially through a tributum tax on Roman citizens to cover basic living expenses rather than as full wages. The stipendium was structured as a fixed annual sum, disbursed in three installments—typically in January, May, and September—reflecting its role as a periodic allowance rather than hourly or task-based pay. Etymologically, stipendium derives from Latin stips (a small coin or voluntary contribution) and pendere (to weigh out or pay), underscoring its basis in pooled public funds rather than individual contracts. By the late , a standard legionary's stipendium amounted to approximately 225 denarii annually, with deductions for , equipment, and clothing, though higher ranks like centurions received multiples thereof. Emperors such as later increased it to 300 denarii around 84 CE by adjusting payment frequency to monthly installments, effectively raising effective compensation without altering the base rate. Pre-Roman antecedents appear in ancient Greek practices, where city-states like began paying misthos (wages) to citizen-soldiers and rowers during the (431–404 BCE) to enable broader participation beyond the wealthy class, though this was often campaign-specific rather than a standardized annual stipend. Mercenaries, termed misthophoroi, received fixed payments as early as the 5th century BCE, paralleling the model's emphasis on reliability for professional service. These Greco-Roman systems prioritized fixed allowances to sustain military readiness, influencing later stipend concepts by decoupling pay from direct productivity metrics.

Medieval and Early Modern Contexts

In the , the term "stipend," adapted from Latin stipendium (originally denoting pay), emerged in English usage to describe fixed remuneration for services, distinct from variable tithes or incomes derived from church lands. priests typically subsisted on tithes—ten percent of parishioners' produce or income—but auxiliary , such as priests tasked with perpetual masses for benefactors' souls, received dedicated annual stipends. Records from 1412 indicate these payments averaged £5 per year in , sufficient for basic sustenance amid prevailing wage levels where unskilled laborers earned around 2 pence daily. Hospitals and monastic institutions supplemented clerical support through periodic stipends to resident chaplains, ensuring dedicated spiritual services. A 15th-century English ordinance mandated payments of 2 shillings to its at , , , , and midsummer, totaling 10 shillings annually—modest but reliable amid economic fluctuations like the post-Black Death labor shortages that elevated general wages. These arrangements reflected principles prioritizing clerical independence from secular employment, though enforcement varied, with some priests supplementing income via informal fees despite prohibitions on . By the (c. 1500–1800), stipends extended to academic and administrative roles amid institutional growth, particularly in universities where college fellows received fixed allowances for teaching and governance, evolving from medieval self-funded student models reliant on family remittances or . In , and fellows' stipends, often £10–20 annually by the , covered living costs while enabling scholarly focus, though supplemented by tutoring fees. Clerical stipends persisted post-Reformation, with curates in under-endowed parishes drawing £30–80 yearly by the late , underscoring the form's adaptability to professionalizing services amid shifting from feudal benefices to salaried equivalents. This usage highlighted stipends' core function as non-proprietary payments for specialized duties, contrasting with wages tied to manual labor or land grants.

19th to 20th Century Evolution

During the , stipends in ecclesiastical roles underwent significant reforms in , driven by disparities in parish endowments and the challenges of . The Ecclesiastical Commissioners, established by in 1836, centralized church finances to redistribute resources from wealthy benefices to underfunded ones, thereby augmenting stipends for and incumbents in poor rural and expanding urban areas. By the 1870s, voluntary organizations such as the Church Pastoral Aid Society (CPAS) and Additional Curates Society supported stipends for over 500 in cities, addressing shortages in industrial parishes where traditional tithes proved insufficient. Typical curate stipends rose modestly from £70–£80 annually in the early 1800s to around £100 by mid-century, reflecting incremental efforts to attract educated personnel amid . In parallel, the prompted changes in arrangements, where stipends or fixed allowances began supplementing or replacing unpaid terms, particularly as gained influence. In , pre-1800 apprenticeships often involved premiums paid by families to masters, with minimal to the apprentice; however, by the late , economic pressures and labor led to more structured payments, evolving into progressive allowances in trades. In the United States, apprenticeship shifted from employer control in the 1880s to union dominance by the 1930s, incorporating stipends or entry-level fixed sums to cover living costs during , distinct from full wages tied to . The National Apprenticeship Act of 1937 formalized standards, often including modest stipends for initial phases to incentivize skill acquisition without immediate full compensation. Academic fellowships marked a key expansion of stipends into education, transitioning from largely unpaid positions in the to compensated ones by the early 20th. Early 19th-century university fellows, such as at or emerging American institutions, typically received endowments covering board but not reliable cash allowances, prioritizing prestige over financial support. The , endowed in 1902, represented a pivotal model, providing recipients with a fixed stipend—initially £250 annually, equivalent to covering tuition, travel, and living expenses—to study at , fostering international academic exchange without obligations. This influenced 20th-century proliferation, as research universities and governments adopted stipends for graduate fellows and interns to promote specialized training; for instance, U.S. programs post-1940s, like awards, standardized stipends around $1,000–$2,000 yearly initially, emphasizing subsistence over profit. By mid-century, such mechanisms distinguished stipends from salaries, enabling focus on intellectual pursuits amid rising enrollment.

Types and Applications

Educational and Fellowship Stipends

Educational stipends provide fixed financial support to students engaged in programs or , primarily to offset living expenses without constituting compensation for labor performed. Unlike salaries, which require defined work duties and confer status, stipends in this lack a scope of work and are tied to educational activities such as or . This structure incentivizes focus on learning over productivity metrics, though recipients may still undertake incidental tasks like assisting in labs. Fellowship stipends extend this model to non-degree or advanced pursuits, often funding independent projects with a living allowance alongside tuition remission. Programs like the offer such stipends for international scholars, covering expenses to facilitate cross-cultural academic exchange. In U.S. graduate education, (NSF) Graduate Research Fellowships provide annual stipends of approximately $37,000 as of 2024, enabling recipients to pursue doctoral without teaching obligations. These payments prioritize talent development over market-wage equivalence, with amounts calibrated to basic subsistence rather than regional living costs. Tax treatment varies by jurisdiction and use. In the United States, stipends qualifying as scholarships—used for tuition, fees, books, or required supplies at eligible institutions—are generally nontaxable for candidates. However, portions allocated to , board, or personal expenses are taxable as , per IRS Publication 970, with post-2019 rules mandating taxation for non-W-2 reported non-tuition fellowship payments. Internationally, stipends average $20,000–$45,000 annually in the U.S., €40,000–€50,000 in , and lower in developing economies, reflecting national funding priorities and cost-of-living adjustments. Recipients must track expenditures to claim exclusions, underscoring stipends' role as conditional aid rather than unrestricted grants. Critics note that modest stipend levels—often below entry-level professional wages—can deter diverse applicants or force supplemental employment, potentially undermining the intended focus on scholarship. Empirical data from U.S. institutions show field-specific variances, with disciplines averaging higher ($30,000–$40,000) than ($20,000–$30,000), driven by availability rather than considerations. Despite this, stipends remain a of merit-based academic progression, fostering through subsidized risk-taking in .

Internship and Apprenticeship Stipends

Internship stipends consist of fixed payments provided to participants in short-term, programs, typically lasting from a few weeks to several months, intended to offset living or incidental expenses rather than compensate for labor performed. Under the U.S. Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), for-profit employers may offer unpaid internships or stipends below if the intern qualifies as the primary beneficiary of the arrangement, determined by a seven-factor test including whether the experience provides training akin to an educational environment, integrates classroom learning, does not displace regular employees, and confers no immediate advantage to the employer over unpaid labor. Paid internship stipends, when structured as compensation for work, require classification as W-2 employees entitled to at least federal or state for all hours worked, plus if applicable, with average hourly rates around $15.54 in the U.S. as of October 2025, though high-end and roles can reach $9,000 monthly. Apprenticeship compensation more frequently takes the form of progressive wages rather than fixed stipends, particularly in registered programs overseen by the U.S. Department of Labor, where participants earn entry-level pay starting at 40-60% of a journeyperson's rate—often above —and receive structured increases tied to milestones over 1-6 years, culminating in industry-recognized credentials. In non-registered or educational apprenticeships, stipends may supplement or replace wages to support trainees during intensive combined with classroom instruction, but these must still comply with FLSA if deemed , distinguishing them from pure support payments by requiring accountability for productive work. Unlike internships, emphasize long-term mastery and , with compensation designed to reflect advancing and reduce turnover, though initial rates can resemble stipends in low-skill entry phases. The core distinction lies in purpose and duration: internship stipends facilitate temporary exposure to professional environments without guaranteed skill or job entitlement, potentially limiting access due to financial barriers for unpaid variants, whereas apprenticeship payments prioritize measurable competency development and labor market integration, often with legal exemptions from certain rules but mandates for progression to align with economic value created. Stipends in both contexts are taxable as if exceeding reimbursements, per IRS guidelines, underscoring their role as fiscal mechanisms that enable investments while navigating laws, though critics argue low or absent stipends in internships can perpetuate by favoring affluent participants.

Clergy and Religious Stipends

In religious traditions, stipends refer to fixed monetary or material provisions intended to support ministers in their vocational duties without implying contractual for services. This distinction arises from theological principles emphasizing that sacred roles, such as administering sacraments or leading , are not commodities for sale but acts of divine service; stipends thus serve as maintenance allowances to free from secular labor. Historically, these provisions evolved from communal offerings of goods—such as or land grants in early Christian communities—to standardized cash payments by the medieval period, as increasingly relied on institutional support amid feudal economies. Within Catholicism, Mass stipends represent a specific application: a from the faithful to a for offering the according to an intended purpose, such as for the deceased or a special , with the funds contributing to the 's sustenance. Canon 945 of the Code of Canon Law mandates that priests accept only one such offering per to prevent accumulation, while Canon 948 requires separate Masses for each accepted , even if small, ensuring equitable application. The practice traces to patristic eras when offerings supported celebrants' daily needs, formalizing in the under papal decrees like those of Benedict XIV, which reduced obligations for stipend-free Masses in wealthy parishes. In the United States, the customary stipend amount is $10 per as of 2024, though diocesan variations exist. This system avoids —the illicit sale of spiritual goods—by framing the offering as voluntary support rather than payment for efficacy. In and some Protestant denominations, such as the , stipends denote the primary remuneration for ordained , funded largely through congregational giving and diocesan common funds, enabling full-time without external employment. As of 2025, full-time stipends in the average around £28,000 annually, with proposals in 2023 seeking increases to £30,000 amid inflation, marking the first formal pay rise request in history. The term "stipend" underscores a non-market ethic: unlike wages tied to hours or output, it critiques commodified labor by prioritizing vocational freedom, as articulated in Reformed theological reflections. Protestant traditions vary; many, including Lutheran and Baptist bodies, use "" interchangeably, with median full-time compensation around $63,000-86,000 in U.S. synods as of 2019, often including housing allowances. However, the stipend model persists where it aligns with views of ministry as a calling detached from economic bargaining. Beyond Christianity, analogous provisions appear in other faiths, though less uniformly termed "stipends." In Islam, imams receive salaries or stipends from endowments () or community funds, deemed permissible by scholars like Ibn Taymiyyah, who endorsed suitable payments from surplus resources to sustain leaders without overburdening the poor. U.S. imams average $30,000 annually as of recent surveys, often supplemented by teaching or secondary roles due to modest budgets. In , rabbis historically earned fees for lifecycle events like weddings alongside congregational salaries, with modern and Conservative rabbis averaging $174,525 in total compensation in 2021 per Rabbinical Assembly data, reflecting larger scales but rooted in communal support rather than fee-for-service alone. These structures universally prioritize sustainability for religious leadership while guarding against perceptions of spiritual .

Distinctions from Compensation Forms

Comparison to Salary and Wages

A stipend is a fixed periodic intended to cover living or specific expenses, such as during , , or fellowship periods, without constituting compensation for services rendered. In contrast, and wages represent for work performed, typically tied to contracts and subject to hourly, output-based, or fixed periodic calculations reflecting labor value. This distinction arises from the absence of a direct in stipends, where no formal scope of work or productivity expectations are imposed, unlike salaries which imply ongoing obligations. Under U.S. labor law, stipends often exempt recipients from classification as employees under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), particularly for interns or trainees where the primary is the individual gaining experience rather than the provider deriving immediate advantage. For instance, unpaid or stipended internships in the must satisfy the DOL's seven-factor "primary beneficiary test," focusing on whether the arrangement displaces regular workers or provides educational benefit; failure to meet this can reclassify stipends as wages requiring and compliance. Salaries and wages, however, trigger FLSA protections, including (e.g., $7.25 per hour federally as of 2025) and overtime at 1.5 times the regular rate for hours over 40 weekly. Tax treatment further delineates the two: the IRS views stipends for non-employment purposes, such as fellowships or allowances, as potentially non-wage not subject to employer withholding for FICA taxes or , though recipients must report them on if exceeding exclusions like qualified education expenses. , conversely, mandate employer withholding of federal , Social Security (6.2% employee share), and (1.45% employee share) under IRC Section 3101, with employers matching contributions. This framework incentivizes stipends for non-labor support but risks recharacterization as wages if tied to productive work, as determined by behavioral and financial control factors in IRS common-law tests. Economically, stipends decouple payment from market-valued labor output, functioning more as subsistence grants that may undervalue recipient contributions compared to salaries calibrated by supply-demand dynamics in competitive markets. Empirical data from U.S. indicates median weekly earnings for salaried workers exceeded $1,000 in 2024, far surpassing typical stipends averaging $500–$800 monthly, highlighting stipends' role in enabling access to low- or no-productivity roles like academic research rather than full economic compensation.

Relation to Grants and Allowances

Stipends share functional similarities with allowances in that both provide fixed or periodic payments to cover living or incidental expenses without constituting wages for labor performed. Unlike allowances, which are often reimbursements tied to verifiable costs such as or (e.g., rates set by government policies), stipends are predetermined sums not requiring expense documentation, typically aimed at subsistence support during or educational pursuits. In contrast to grants, which are generally lump-sum awards allocated for discrete projects or organizational objectives—such as research initiatives funded competitively by entities like the —stipends represent individualized, recurring disbursements embedded within certain grant structures, particularly fellowships or training programs. For instance, under U.S. federal regulations, stipends may be authorized within training grants to defray participants' living expenses but are explicitly distinguished from project-specific grant funds, which cannot support stipends as allowable costs on research grants. This relational framework underscores stipends' hybrid nature: they align with allowances in purpose (expense offset) but diverge from grants in delivery (personal vs. programmatic) and accountability (fixed vs. outcome-oriented). Policy distinctions ensure stipends avoid wage-like implications, preserving their role in non-employment contexts, as evidenced in educational and training statutes like 34 CFR § 270.31, which permits stipends for personnel in assistance without classifying them as compensation.

Taxation and Reporting Requirements

In the United States, stipends are generally includible in as compensation for services or as taxable portions of and fellowships, unless specific exclusions apply under Section 117. Qualified or fellowship amounts covering tuition, fees, books, supplies, and equipment required for enrollment or attendance at an eligible are excluded from , but stipends allocated for non-qualified expenses such as room, board, travel, or personal living costs are taxable. For stipends tied to services—like those in internships, apprenticeships, or assistantships—the payments constitute akin to wages, subject to , though often exempt from FICA taxes if the recipient qualifies as a under IRS rules. Clergy stipends follow a distinct framework: base salary or stipend amounts are includible in income for federal tax purposes, but a designated housing allowance (parsonage or rental allowance) is excludable from to the extent it covers actual expenses or the fair rental value of furnished provided, provided the minister is duly ordained and performing ministerial duties. Ministers remain employees for withholding but self-employed for Security and (SECA) taxes on earnings from ministerial services, requiring Schedule SE filing even if church-elected opt-outs apply for SECA. Reporting obligations vary by payer and recipient status. Payers typically do not withhold federal on stipends unless classified as wages, leaving self-reporting to recipients on as "other income" or via /fellowship lines (e.g., line 1 of Schedule 1 for taxable portions). For non-employee compensation exceeding $600 annually, payers must issue (Box 3 for other income or Box 7 pre-2020 equivalents), while scholarships over thresholds may trigger or W-2 reporting if wages are involved; nonresident aliens receive Form 1042-S for withholdings at 14% (for students/scholars) or 30%, potentially reduced by tax treaties via Form W-8BEN. Failure to report taxable stipends risks IRS penalties, as no form issuance does not exempt inclusion in . Internationally, taxation hinges on domestic laws and bilateral treaties, with no unified or standard for stipends; they are often treated as taxable unless exempted as non-compensatory grants (e.g., for pure research in some member states), subject to progressive rates and potential relief under Model conventions allocating rights based on residency and source. In cross-border contexts, withholding may apply to nonresidents, mirroring U.S. 1042-S mechanics, while mobility directives facilitate treaty claims to avoid dual taxation on stipend-derived .

Labor Law Applicability and Exemptions

Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), stipends are subject to labor law requirements only if the recipient qualifies as an "employee," which triggers obligations for , , and recordkeeping. Recipients of stipends in educational, , or fellowship contexts are frequently exempt if the arrangement lacks an employment relationship, as determined by the "primary beneficiary test" established by the Department of Labor in 2018. This test assesses seven non-exhaustive factors, such as whether the parties understand no compensation beyond any stipend equates to wages, the provided mirrors educational environments, the work complements formal education or accommodates academic schedules, it does not displace regular employees or provide immediate employer advantage, and there is no expectation of compensated employment upon completion. If the recipient (e.g., an intern) derives primary benefit from the experience, no employment status arises, exempting the stipend from FLSA wage provisions. For stipends in , such as those for graduate or assistants, applicability varies by the nature of duties performed. Pure fellowships providing financial support without required services are typically not wages and exempt from FLSA, as no exists. However, stipends tied to substantial labor, like graded or supervised displacing paid staff, often classify recipients as employees, subjecting payments to and if non-exempt. Exemptions may apply under FLSA 13(a)(1) for professional roles in , requiring primary duties in or and compensation at least equal to the salary threshold (e.g., $844 per week as of July 1, 2024, under updated rules), but student-specific arrangements prioritize educational benefit over employer gain to avoid reclassification. State labor laws can impose stricter standards than federal FLSA, potentially treating stipends as wages regardless of primary beneficiary analysis; for instance, requires payment for all hours worked by interns unless strictly educational and non-displacing. Non-profits and religious organizations offering stipends to volunteers or trainees may invoke additional exemptions, provided no economic dependence or occurs, though courts scrutinize for disguised . Internationally, exemptions differ markedly. In the , directives like the 2022 internship framework emphasize fair remuneration for work performed, with stipends qualifying as wages under national laws unless under regulated trainee schemes limiting hours and ensuring pedagogical value; pure grants without labor remain exempt from social security contributions in many member states. Countries like distinguish "minijobs" or apprenticeships, where stipends below thresholds avoid full labor protections, but empirical data from indicates frequent misclassification risks due to varying enforcement.

Economic Incentives and Market Role

Stipends function as economic incentives by providing recipients with fixed payments to offset living or opportunity costs, thereby encouraging participation in roles emphasizing skill development over immediate productivity. This structure lowers the financial barrier to entry for programs, apprenticeships, or fellowships, where full market wages might deter involvement due to short-term earnings forgone. Empirical data from training initiatives demonstrate that stipends enhance persistence and outcomes; for example, in Per Scholas's skills programs, $1,000 stipends raised completion rates by 18 percentage points, certification rates by 14 points, and employment placement by improving learner retention amid economic pressures. Such incentives align individual behavior with investments in , yielding long-term labor market benefits through elevated skills and reduced dropout risks. For organizations, stipends offer cost efficiencies by securing services or talent at rates below standard wages, enabling scaled provision of developmental opportunities without proportional labor expense escalation. In internship settings, stipended arrangements allow firms to evaluate candidates' fit while containing payroll variability, as fixed sums avoid overtime or benefit mandates under frameworks like the U.S. Fair Labor Standards Act's primary beneficiary test for unpaid or low-paid roles. This incentivizes employers to expand entry pipelines, particularly in sectors like or nonprofits, where stipends fund graduate assistants or fellows contributing to innovation at subsidized rates—such as PhD stipends averaging $20,000–$30,000 annually, often tied to grant-funded projects. Providers thus leverage stipends to internalize training externalities, fostering talent pipelines that enhance competitive positioning. In the labor , stipends bridge education-to-employment transitions by augmenting skilled labor supply without distorting core equilibria, as they typically apply to non-permanent, learning-focused positions. Studies affirm that compensated internships, including stipended ones, correlate with higher post-graduation job offers and starting salaries compared to unpaid equivalents, mitigating in access to networks and experience. By subsidizing specific formation—evident in elevated workforce productivity from fellowship-enhanced —stipends support macroeconomic growth, though their fixed nature limits inflationary pressures on entry wages. Overall, they complement mechanisms, incentivizing voluntary upgrades that causal chains link to broader economic dynamism.

Criticisms and Counterarguments

Allegations of Exploitation

Critics of stipend programs, particularly in internships and apprenticeships, contend that they facilitate the extraction of labor value from participants at rates insufficient to reflect the economic contribution or costs involved. Under the U.S. Fair Labor Standards Act, stipends below —or none at all—are permissible only if the internship primarily benefits the trainee rather than the employer, yet numerous cases reveal interns performing production-level tasks like or administrative duties without commensurate pay, effectively displacing paid workers. A 2021 survey indicated that over 40% of internships remained unpaid, with stipendiary ones often providing nominal amounts—averaging $1,000–$2,000 for summer programs—that fail to offset relocation, , or foregone earnings, thereby subsidizing employer operations. Legal challenges underscore these allegations: in Glatt v. Fox Searchlight Pictures (2013), a U.S. District Court ruled that unpaid interns were employees entitled to back wages, as their roles generated profit for the company without providing educational equivalence to academic training. Similar suits against entities like Hearst Magazines and resulted in multimillion-dollar settlements by 2015, highlighting systemic underpayment where stipends masked what courts deemed wage violations. Labor advocates argue this structure disproportionately burdens lower-income participants, who cannot afford to work for exposure alone, perpetuating class-based access to career networks while employers capture gains without full labor costs. In academic and stipends, claims focus on students or postdocs receiving fixed payments—often $20,000–$30,000 annually in U.S. programs—that undervalue skilled outputs like or , akin to underpaid under the guise of . Reports from organizations like the National Association of Colleges and Employers note that such stipends rarely adjust for or regional living costs, leading to net financial losses for recipients and enabling institutions to externalize expenses. These critiques, frequently advanced by labor-focused outlets and unions, emphasize causal links to reduced for early-career workers, though empirical wage recovery data shows enforcement gaps, with the U.S. Department of Labor investigating few cases relative to prevalence.

Empirical Benefits and Defenses

Empirical studies indicate that stipends for internships and training programs enhance participants' career trajectories by facilitating skill acquisition and networking opportunities that exceed the immediate financial outlay. For instance, recipients of stipends in tech skills training programs demonstrate higher graduation rates, certification attainment, and subsequent employment compared to non-stipended cohorts, as evidenced by a 2022 analysis of Per Scholas initiatives where stipends correlated with improved program completion and job placement. Similarly, National Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE) data from the Class of 2023 reveals that paid interns, often receiving stipends rather than full salaries, averaged 1.4 job offers versus 0.9 for unpaid interns, underscoring the role of modest fixed payments in bridging to professional roles. In and contexts, stipends support unfettered focus on developmental activities, yielding long-term gains. guidelines distinguish stipends from wages by emphasizing their purpose in offsetting living costs during non-compensatory , enabling broader access to expertise-building experiences that elevate future earning potential. A 2017 study on perceptions found that both students and employers viewed paid arrangements, including stipends, as advancing career preparation through practical exposure, with participants reporting enhanced independent of wage levels. Defenses of stipends counter exploitation allegations by highlighting the primary beneficiary test, where the recipient gains disproportionate value from over . U.S. Department of Labor criteria affirm that stipends are permissible when the internship's educational benefits predominate, as in cases where trainees work under without displacing employees, fostering mutual gains without coercive underpayment. Longitudinal outcomes refute net harm claims: a 2016 Economic Policy Institute analysis, drawing on graduate surveys, showed paid participants (including stipended) achieving 72% job offer rates versus 44% for unpaid, indicating voluntary participation yields tangible advancement rather than systemic abuse. For and religious roles, stipends provide fiscal flexibility, allowing congregations to sustain ministerial training without full labor market wage burdens, as supported by 68% satisfaction rates among recipients in a 2018 denominational survey who viewed them as adequate for service-oriented vocations. This structure aligns with causal incentives for non-profit entities, where fixed payments prioritize mission alignment over hourly productivity, empirically linked to stable tenures without evidence of widespread undercompensation relative to vocational outputs.

References

  1. [1]
    STIPEND Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster
    The meaning of STIPEND is a fixed sum of money paid periodically for services or to defray expenses. How to use stipend in a sentence.
  2. [2]
    STIPEND | definition in the Cambridge English Dictionary
    an amount of money that is paid regularly to someone, especially for work or training that is usually unpaid: An $80-a-month stipend covers each ...
  3. [3]
    Stipend - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
    Early 15c. origin from Latin stipendium, meaning tax or pay, from stips (gift) + pendere (to weigh/pay); meaning includes wage, salary, especially military ...
  4. [4]
    Distinguishing Between Stipends for Training and Salaries/Wages ...
    A stipend is a periodic payment other than wages paid to a student in connection with educationally related activities undertaken by the student.<|separator|>
  5. [5]
    Stipend Versus Salary: Key Differences - BetterUp
    Jul 25, 2023 · Salaries and wages are subject to minimum wage requirements at the federal and state levels, while there are no minimum amounts for stipends.What's a salary? · What's a stipend? · Salaries versus stipends: Key...
  6. [6]
    Topic no. 421, Scholarships, fellowship grants, and other grants - IRS
    Sep 22, 2025 · Tax-free. If you receive a scholarship, a fellowship grant, or other grant, all or part of the amounts you receive may be tax-free. · Taxable.
  7. [7]
    Publication 970 (2024), Tax Benefits for Education - IRS
    A scholarship or fellowship grant is generally taxable compensation only if it is shown in box 1 of your Form W-2, Wage and Tax Statement. However, for tax ...
  8. [8]
    Stipend: Definition, Rules and Who Typically Receives It | Indeed.com
    Jun 6, 2025 · A stipend is a fixed amount of money an organization pays to people who complete unpaid work. Stipends usually replace salaries and help trainees, students, ...
  9. [9]
    What Is a Stipend? | Chase
    Apr 15, 2025 · A stipend is a fixed amount of money that's often in place of a salary or wage. Let's explore how stipends work and whether they're taxable.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  10. [10]
    Stipend vs. Salary: Key Differences for Employers - Rippling
    Jan 9, 2025 · Salaries are most commonly paid to regular, full-time employees. Stipends can be offered to a broader range of workers, including part-time ...What is a stipend? · Stipend vs. salary: 6 key... · Stipend vs salary: Which one...
  11. [11]
    Are Stipends Taxable? A Complete Guide for 2024 | Benepass
    Stipends are considered taxable income by the IRS if they don't belong in the pre-tax or non-taxable categories.
  12. [12]
    Stipend: Understanding Its Legal Definition and Implications
    A stipend is a fixed payment for services or expenses. It is governed by the policies of the entity providing it. Stipends may not be subject to the same taxes ...
  13. [13]
  14. [14]
    stipend, n. meanings, etymology and more - Oxford English Dictionary
    OED's earliest evidence for stipend is from before 1475, in R. Higden's Polychronicon. stipend is a borrowing from French. Etymons: French stipende. See ...
  15. [15]
    Stipendium | Oxford Classical Dictionary
    Around 400 bce during the war with Veii a payment was first made to Roman soldiers while on long campaigns to assist with their living expenses. In the 2nd cent ...
  16. [16]
    How the Roman Army Was Paid (Smith's Dictionary, 1875)
    Jan 26, 2020 · This sum then was considered as an unit, and called stipendium, being paid three times a year. Hence Suetonius says of Domitian (Dom. 7): " ...
  17. [17]
    Pay of Roman legionary - IMPERIUM ROMANUM
    Wage (stipendium) appeared as a salary at the turn of the 5th and 4th centuries BCE. probably during the battles between Rome and the city of Veii. The Romans ...Missing: meaning | Show results with:meaning
  18. [18]
    Roman Soldiers Pay - Vindolanda
    Oct 31, 2022 · Soldiers' pay was made in three instalments of 75 denarii in January, May and September. Domitian changed the intervals to three monthly and thus increased pay ...<|separator|>
  19. [19]
    Ancient Greek mercenaries - Wikipedia
    The term misthophoros originally applied to someone who worked in return for payment by salary. That included hired labour and the word was very soon applied to ...
  20. [20]
    Parish Priests and Their People in the Middle Ages in England, by ...
    ... priests to celebrate for a year. So that it is abundantly evident that £5 a year was the usual stipend for a chantry priest. Elizabeth Davy, 1412, leaves cc ...
  21. [21]
    Medieval Prices and Wages - The History of England
    A labourer for example, earned £2 a year in 1300, which means 40 shillings, or 480 pence a year – or 2 pence a day.
  22. [22]
    Medieval Tithes | A Writer's Perspective - WordPress.com
    Feb 13, 2022 · What it says is that a 'stipend' was paid to the priest of the hospital five times a year: 2 shillings at Michaelmas, 2 at Christmas, 2 at ...
  23. [23]
    CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Stipend - New Advent
    A stipend is a fixed pay, salary; retribution for work done; the income of an ecclesiastical living. In canon law stipend is a general designation of means of ...Missing: medieval | Show results with:medieval
  24. [24]
    Fortunes of the Clergy
    Indeed, it has sometimes been said that a stipend was paid so that a priest 'did not have to work' (in secular employment) and could concentrate on parochial ...Missing: medieval | Show results with:medieval<|separator|>
  25. [25]
    Ecclesiastical Commissioners for England - Archives Hub - Jisc
    ... New Bishoprics Act, 1875 (38 & 39 Vic Cap 34) and the Commissioner's growing responsibility for the stipends of the Cathedral clergy during the 19th century.<|control11|><|separator|>
  26. [26]
    Nineteenth century urbanisation and the Church of England, an ...
    Oct 19, 2022 · By 1870's CPAS was paying the stipends of over 500 clergy mainly in the cities and the Additional Curates Society supported a comparable number.
  27. [27]
    Flexible Supply of Apprenticeship in the British Industrial Revolution
    Feb 21, 2017 · We use annual information on apprenticeships in England between 1710–1805 to estimate the dynamic supply-responsiveness in this market.
  28. [28]
    The Transformation of Industrial Apprenticeship in the United States
    Between the 1880s and 1930s, apprenticeship was transformed from an institution dominated by employers to one dominated by unions.
  29. [29]
    The History of the National Apprenticeship Act - myOneFlow
    Domestic apprenticeships began to disappear, and more apprentices were paid for their labor. However, as factory work became the norm, working conditions ...<|separator|>
  30. [30]
    [Solved] How did internships and fellowships from the 19th century ...
    19th Century: Interns and fellows were often not paid, as the focus was on learning and gaining experience. Today: While unpaid internships still exist, many ...
  31. [31]
    Rhodes Scholarship | Honors College | Kent State University
    The Rhodes Scholarship, created by Cecil Rhodes, is a prestigious program enabling study at Oxford, covering fees, airfare, and a stipend.
  32. [32]
    History of College Scholarships
    Jul 14, 2020 · The provision of financial aid in the form of grants and scholarships has a storied history reaching back to ancient Greece.
  33. [33]
    Stipend: Definition, Types, Benefits, and Tax Implications
    A stipend is a fixed monetary amount offered as support during periods of training or employment for roles that might otherwise not provide compensation.
  34. [34]
    Stipend Definition & Purpose - Study.com
    The word "stipend" comes from the Latin word stipendium, originally referring to military service payment.
  35. [35]
    15 Fellowships That Offer Full Tuition and Stipends
    **Fulbright Program**: Offers funding for international educational exchange for students, scholars, and professionals. 3. **National Science Foundation ...
  36. [36]
    7.2.1 Fellowships and Other Stipend Support: Policy
    Feb 27, 2023 · Fellowships, typically including a full or partial tuition payment and a stipend for living expenses, are awarded as a form of financial support ...
  37. [37]
    How Much Is A PhD Stipend? - ResearchDeep
    Jul 24, 2025 · Countries Offering the Highest Stipends ; Switzerland, €40,000 – €50,000, High stipends help offset the high cost of living. ; United States ...
  38. [38]
    PhD Stipend Survey Results
    PhD stipends vary; for example, Purdue Chemical Engineering is $40,000, Yale Physics is $50,777, and Princeton Chemistry is $58,216. Some, like Columbia ...
  39. [39]
    Fact Sheet #71: Internship Programs Under The Fair Labor ...
    This fact sheet provides general information to help determine whether interns and students working for “for-profit” employers are entitled to minimum wages ...
  40. [40]
    Unpaid Internships-The Federal Labor Code Requirements
    Unpaid internships offered by for-profit companies are subject to the US Department of Labor's Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), which establishes minimum wage ...
  41. [41]
    A Guide to Paying Interns and Internship Stipends - Justworks
    As mentioned above, paid interns are W-2 employees and are entitled to be paid at least the applicable minimum wage for all hours worked.
  42. [42]
    Internship Salary: Hourly Rate October 2025 United States
    How much do Internship jobs pay per hour? The average hourly pay for a Internship job in the US is $15.54. Hourly salary range is $8.65 to $21.88.
  43. [43]
    Glassdoor report: These are the 10 highest-paying internships of 2023
    Apr 25, 2023 · Stripe will compensate interns the most this year, with an average monthly internship salary of over $9000, according to a new Glassdoor study ...Missing: stipends amounts
  44. [44]
    Internship vs Apprenticeship: What's the Difference? - AJAC
    Registered apprenticeships pay you to learn a skill in the work environment. Internships give you the chance to learn before you earn.
  45. [45]
    Apprenticeship vs. Internship: Understanding the Difference - Indeed
    Jun 6, 2025 · In this article, we discuss the differences between an apprenticeship vs. an internship so you can explore your training options.
  46. [46]
    The Difference: Internship and Apprenticeship - CareerWise Colorado
    The longer duration of an apprenticeship is an important distinction from an internship; it ensures that the training received prepares the apprentice to step ...
  47. [47]
    Rite Questions: Mass Stipend FAQs - Adoremus Bulletin
    Jul 12, 2023 · Later, it became a sum of money, the object being to contribute to the proper support of the clergy. The Catholic Encyclopedia comments: “The ...
  48. [48]
    Catholic stipend, byzantine stiped
    Initially, these were goods or services, which over time, transitioned into monetary form to support clergy who could not sustain themselves through other means ...
  49. [49]
    Decree On Mass Stipends | EWTN
    According to canon 948, "separate Masses are to be applied for the intentions for which an individual offering, even if small, has been made and accepted." ...
  50. [50]
    Mass Stipends and Simony | Catholic Answers Magazine
    Oct 3, 2023 · It is a gift of God and a calling to the service of others. That fits with the definition of simony as the buying of spiritual things. But ...<|separator|>
  51. [51]
    Clergy pay and expenses - The Church of England
    The majority of clergy receive a stipend which is funded by the giving of congregations. It is paid in order to enable the clergy person to exercise their ...
  52. [52]
    Church of England clergy asks for pay raise for first time in history
    Jun 21, 2023 · Unite said it proposed increasing the national minimum stipend to around $37,000 and the national benchmark stipend to about $40,000. Since late ...<|separator|>
  53. [53]
    Stipend: A Theological Challenge to the Marketplace
    Nov 16, 2005 · Stipend gives the church space to articulate principles that critique the market-driven approaches used to determine what clergy should be paid.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  54. [54]
    Is it OK for an Imam to have a salary? - joebradford.net
    Ibn Taymiyah, Majmu al-Fatawa 17/31: It is permitted to give the Imam and Muadhin from the like of the excess of the endowment mentioned a stipend, suitable ...
  55. [55]
    [PDF] 2023-2024 Salary Survey - The Rabbinical Assembly
    In 2021, the mean compensation for respondents serving as either co-, solo, or senior rabbi was $174,525. The average increase across congregation sizes was 9. ...
  56. [56]
    Stipend Law and Legal Definition | USLegal, Inc.
    A stipend is a fixed sum of money paid periodically for services or to defray expenses. The fact that remuneration is termed a "fee" or "stipend" rather ...
  57. [57]
    Topic no. 401, Wages and salaries | Internal Revenue Service
    Aug 29, 2025 · All wages, salaries and tips you received for performing services as an employee of an employer must be included in your gross income.
  58. [58]
    Wages and the Fair Labor Standards Act
    The Overtime Security Advisor helps determine which employees are exempt from the FLSA minimum wage and overtime pay requirements under the Part 541 overtime ...
  59. [59]
    Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee? - IRS
    Aug 7, 2025 · It is critical that business owners correctly determine whether the individuals providing services are employees or independent contractors.Forms and associated taxes · Defined · Common Law · About Form SS-8<|separator|>
  60. [60]
    Stipend vs salary: What's the difference? | Blog posts - Forma
    Unlike salaries, which serve as regular payments for work performed, stipends are specific allowances provided by employers to cover designated expenses such as ...
  61. [61]
    11.2.9 Allowable and Unallowable Costs - NIH Grants & Funding
    A stipend A payment made to an individual under a fellowship or training grant in accordance with pre-established levels to provide for the individual's living ...
  62. [62]
    11.3.8 Allowable and Unallowable Costs - NIH Grants & Funding
    A stipend is not considered compensation for the services expected of an employee. as a subsistence allowance to help defray living expenses during the research ...
  63. [63]
    34 CFR § 270.31 - What stipends and related reimbursements are ...
    (a) The recipient of an award under this program may pay: (1) Stipends to public school personnel who participate in technical assistance or training ...<|separator|>
  64. [64]
    11.3.10 Stipend Supplementation, Compensation, and Other Income
    Mar 11, 2010 · A stipend is not considered compensation for the services expected of an employee. supplementation; they are allowable charges to Federal grants ...
  65. [65]
    How Internship Income Is Taxed and When To Expect a Refund
    Jul 15, 2022 · On the federal level, wage and salary income is subject to three federal taxes: Income tax, Social Security tax and the Medicare tax. You ...
  66. [66]
    Ministers' Compensation & Housing Allowance - IRS
    A minister's housing allowance (sometimes called a parsonage allowance or a rental allowance) is excludable from gross income for income tax purposes.Ministers' compensation... · About IRS Publication 517 · Tax Topic 417
  67. [67]
    Members of the clergy | Internal Revenue Service
    Jun 30, 2025 · Members of the clergy and other religious workers should file Form 1040 (Schedule SE) and review Publication 517 to pay Social Security and ...
  68. [68]
    Publication 517 (2024), Social Security and Other Information ... - IRS
    Jan 23, 2025 · If you are a minister of a church, your earnings for the services you perform in your capacity as a minister are subject to SE tax, even if you ...
  69. [69]
    Stipend - How to Report - TaxAct
    If you receive a Form 1099-MISC, enter it as a Form 1099-MISC. If you receive a Form 1098-T, with a Box 5 stipend as a scholarship or fellowship, enter it ...
  70. [70]
    Reporting Stipend Income On Your Tax Return - Financial Services
    Stipends reported to you on a stipend letter are treated for tax purposes as taxable scholarships. Per IRS Publication 970, taxable scholarships and fellowships ...
  71. [71]
    Withholding federal income tax on scholarships, fellowships ... - IRS
    The withholding tax rate is 30%. However, the withholding tax rate may be reduced to 14% (or a lower treaty rate) if a nonresident alien is a student, ...
  72. [72]
    Are Stipends Taxed by the IRS? How Do They Work? | NSKT Global
    Oct 22, 2024 · The IRS requires stipend recipients to report these payments as income on their tax returns, even if they don't receive a 1099-MISC or W-2 form.W-2 Reporting · Academic/Fellowship Stipends · Training/Internship Stipends
  73. [73]
    Double taxation - Your Europe - European Union
    There is a risk that your income may be taxed twice if two countries have the right to tax your income.
  74. [74]
    Claiming treaty exemption for a scholarship or fellowship grant - IRS
    Mar 14, 2025 · Eligible individual may claim a tax treaty withholding exemption for scholarship or fellowship grants by submitting Form W-8 BEN, Certificate of Foreign Status ...
  75. [75]
    Fact Sheet #17S: Higher Education Institutions and Overtime Pay ...
    This fact sheet provides information on the exemption from minimum wage and overtime pay provided by Section 13(a)(1) of the FLSA as defined by Regulations, 29 ...
  76. [76]
    Fact Sheet #17D: Exemption for Professional Employees Under the ...
    Teachers are exempt if their primary duty is teaching, tutoring, instructing or lecturing in the activity of imparting knowledge, and if they are employed and ...
  77. [77]
  78. [78]
    Per Scholas Research Finds Stipends Drive Better Outcomes in ...
    Dec 6, 2022 · Research shows stipends improve graduation, certification, and employment rates. $1000 stipends increased course completion by 18%, ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  79. [79]
    [PDF] Stipends and Skills Training: A Winning Combination | Per Scholas
    The Per Scholas research clearly shows that stipends can help investments in workforce development yield higher returns by increasing learner persistence ...Missing: empirical | Show results with:empirical
  80. [80]
    How PhD Students Get Paid - SMU
    Jan 15, 2025 · How much you get as a stipend depends on your university, but a range for the average PhD stipend is usually between $20,000 - $30,000 per year.Missing: incentives | Show results with:incentives
  81. [81]
    Unpaid Internships And The Need For Federal Action - NACE
    NACE research has found that students who take part in paid internships receive more job offers and garner higher starting salaries than those who participate ...
  82. [82]
    Unpaid interns fare worse in the job market - Economic Policy Institute
    Jul 6, 2016 · Unpaid internships are associated with less success in the job market after graduation, both in terms of job offers and salary offers.Missing: stipends | Show results with:stipends
  83. [83]
    [PDF] Workforce Development: Increased Earnings from Fellowships1
    Based on labor economics theory, more school or work experience improves an early-career professional's ability to be hired at an increased salary. This ...Missing: studies | Show results with:studies
  84. [84]
    How the Labor Department Has Let Companies Off the Hook for ...
    Apr 9, 2014 · Four years after warning for-profit companies about unpaid internships, the agency has investigated relatively few employers for wage ...Missing: allegations | Show results with:allegations<|separator|>
  85. [85]
    More than 40% of interns are still unpaid—why that's legal - CNBC
    Aug 17, 2021 · Some argue unpaid internships provide valuable opportunities, while others critique the practice as an excuse to exploit free labor.Missing: stipend | Show results with:stipend
  86. [86]
    How Unpaid Interns Are Exploited, Fighting Back and Winning - PBS
    Sep 27, 2013 · Glatt realized that what his “employer” was doing (not paying him) was illegal. He wasn't receiving training and there was no guarantee of a ...Missing: allegations | Show results with:allegations
  87. [87]
    Privilege and Exploitation in Intern Nation - Dissent Magazine
    The biggest scandal that Perlin exposes, however, is the simple fact that most unpaid internships are flatly illegal under the Fair Labor Standards Act, which ...Missing: allegations | Show results with:allegations
  88. [88]
    The Rightful Resentment of Uncompensated Student Labor
    Uncompensated labor puts unbearable financial stress on many students, often forcing them to choose between their long-term professional ambitions and near- ...Missing: allegations | Show results with:allegations
  89. [89]
    The Class of 2023: Inequity Continues to Underpin Internship ...
    Aug 8, 2023 · NACE research has consistently found that students who take part in paid internships receive more job offers and garner higher starting salaries.Missing: stipends | Show results with:stipends
  90. [90]
    [PDF] Paid versus Unpaid Internships: Perspectives of Students and ...
    Oct 4, 2017 · Internships for students provide many benefits including work experience and “...enhanced career development and preparation”. (Rogers, 2013 ...
  91. [91]
    Q. "Are we required to pay summer interns?" - HR Ministry Solutions
    May 1, 2024 · Generally, yes, though it depends on who benefits most from their work. The US Department of Labor (DOL) has adopted the “primary beneficiary test."
  92. [92]
    [PDF] Summary of Research and Changes to Clergy Benefit ... - FLUMC
    Over 68% of clergy felt the stipend was satisfactory. Those who felt the stipend was inadequate were mostly in the 50-65 age group. e. Over 28% of clergy ...