Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Transition-edge sensor

A transition-edge sensor (TES) is a highly sensitive cryogenic detector that utilizes the sharp transition from superconducting to normal resistive states in a thin superconducting film, operated at or near its critical temperature (T_c), to measure minute temperature changes induced by absorbed energy from photons, particles, or other sources.^[1] This device functions as a calorimeter or thermometer, converting incident energy into thermal signals with exceptional precision, typically requiring cooling to millikelvin temperatures using dilution refrigerators.^[2] TESs operate on the principle of negative electrothermal feedback (NETF), where the sensor is voltage-biased in its resistive transition region, causing a small temperature rise from energy deposition to sharply increase resistance, which in turn reduces Joule heating and stabilizes the temperature.^[1] Common materials include bilayers such as molybdenum/gold (Mo/Au) or aluminum/titanium (Al/Ti), engineered via the proximity effect to tune T_c to values around 100 mK, with transition widths as narrow as 1 mK for optimal sensitivity.^[2] The key figure of merit is the parameter α = (T/R)(dR/dT), which quantifies the sharpness of the resistance-temperature curve and enables energy resolutions scaling as ΔE ≈ √(n k_B T² C / α), where C is the heat capacity and n is the number of degrees of freedom.^[1] These sensors offer unparalleled performance, including energy resolutions down to 1–5 eV for X-ray photons in the 0.1–10 keV range—far superior to semiconductor detectors like CCDs—and noise-equivalent powers (NEP) as low as 10⁻²⁰ W/√Hz for millimeter-wave detection.^[2] They support single-photon or single-particle counting with near-unity quantum efficiency and can be arrayed in thousands of pixels using superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) readout and multiplexing techniques, such as frequency-domain multiplexing (FDM) with ratios up to 2000:1.^[1] Applications of TESs span astrophysics, where they enable high-resolution X-ray spectroscopy in missions like the Athena X-ray Integral Field Unit (with 3840 pixels achieving 2.5 eV resolution at 6 keV) and cosmic microwave background (CMB) polarization measurements in experiments like the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT); particle physics, including neutrino mass determinations in projects like HOLMES and dark matter searches in CRESST; and emerging fields such as quantum optics for photon-number-resolving detection and biophysics for high-efficiency imaging.^[1] Ongoing advancements focus on larger arrays (e.g., 32,000+ pixels), reduced noise, and integration with space-based observatories to push detection limits for fundamental physics and cosmology.^[1]

Introduction

Definition and Principle

A transition-edge sensor (TES) is a highly sensitive cryogenic thermometer that exploits the sharp increase in electrical resistance near the superconducting-to-normal transition temperature of a thin superconducting film biased at its transition edge.^[3] This device functions as a calorimetric detector, converting absorbed energy from incident particles or photons directly into a measurable electrical signal through temperature-dependent resistance changes.^[4] The superconducting transition provides an inherently steep resistance-temperature curve, enabling detection of minute energy depositions on the order of electronvolts.^[2] In operation, an absorbed energy packet raises the temperature of the TES slightly above its bias point, causing a rapid increase in resistance within the narrow transition region, typically spanning a few millikelvins.^[4] The TES is electrically biased, and the resulting modulation in current or voltage reflects the temperature excursion proportional to the input energy. The fundamental power balance at steady state equates the electrical Joule heating (bias power) to the thermal power flow to the heat bath, given by P = I^2 R(T), where P is the bias power, I is the bias current, and R(T) is the strongly temperature-dependent resistance.^[3] This relation underpins the device's response, as any energy input perturbs the equilibrium, altering R(T) and thus the current for a fixed bias.^[5] A key feature stabilizing TES performance is negative electrothermal feedback, which arises when the device is voltage-biased through a shunt resistor.^[3] Upon energy absorption and temperature rise, the increased resistance reduces the current, thereby decreasing the Joule heating power and counteracting further temperature changes to maintain operation near the transition edge.^[4] This intrinsic feedback linearizes the sensor's response over a wide dynamic range, suppresses thermal fluctuations, and shortens the recovery time compared to non-feedback designs.^[3] Compared to semiconductor-based sensors, such as silicon or germanium diodes, TES devices achieve vastly superior energy resolution—often exceeding 1000 for X-ray photons—due to their near-ideal calorimetric efficiency and the sharpness of the superconducting transition, which amplifies small temperature signals without the bandgap limitations of semiconductors.^[2] This makes TESs particularly advantageous for applications demanding sub-electronvolt precision, where semiconductor detectors typically resolve energies only to tens of electronvolts.

Operating Conditions

Transition-edge sensors (TESs) require operation at millikelvin temperatures to position the superconducting transition edge at the boundary between the superconducting and normal states, typically in the range of 50–500 mK depending on the material and application.^[4] This low-temperature regime ensures the sharp resistance change near the critical temperature T_c, enabling high sensitivity to energy deposition.^[7] Achieving and maintaining these temperatures necessitates advanced cryogenic systems, such as dilution refrigerators or adiabatic demagnetization refrigerators, which provide the required cooling power below 1 K.^[4] These setups are essential for stabilizing the TES environment and supporting large detector arrays in applications like astrophysics and particle physics.^[8] High vacuum conditions, on the order of $10^{-4} mbar or better, are critical to minimize convective heat transfer and reduce thermal noise from residual gas interactions.^[9] Additionally, magnetic shielding using high-permeability materials is employed to prevent flux trapping in the superconducting components, which could otherwise degrade performance and introduce unwanted noise.^[10] At these operating conditions, dominant noise sources include phonon noise from thermal fluctuations across the thermal link to the heat bath and Johnson noise arising from the TES resistance itself.^[7] The thermal fluctuation noise, a fundamental limit on energy resolution, is characterized by the root-mean-square energy fluctuation given by

\Delta E = \sqrt{k_B T^2 C},

where k_B is the Boltzmann constant, T is the operating temperature, and C is the heat capacity of the detector.^[11] This noise term sets a baseline for the achievable sensitivity in TES measurements.^[4]

Historical Development

Invention and Early Concepts

The concept of superconducting bolometers, which laid the groundwork for transition-edge sensors (TESs), emerged in the 1940s, with D. H. Andrews demonstrating the first transition-edge bolometer in 1941 using a current-biased tantalum wire to measure an infrared signal.^[12] Theoretical proposals, such as the nonisothermal superconducting bolometer described by Wolfgang Franzen in 1963 and composite designs by John Clarke and colleagues in 1977, demonstrated how Joule heating and thermal feedback could enhance detector sensitivity beyond traditional resistive elements, though practical limitations in materials and readout hindered widespread adoption.^[13]^[14] In the 1990s, Kent Irwin and colleagues at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) revived and advanced these ideas, proposing the voltage-biased TES as a high-resolution cryogenic detector exploiting electrothermal feedback in the superconducting transition. Their 1995 theoretical work outlined how constant-voltage biasing stabilizes operation near the transition edge, achieving energy resolutions far superior to semiconductor-based detectors for particle and photon detection. This innovation was motivated by the need for sub-electronvolt energy resolution in applications like X-ray and infrared astronomy, where traditional semiconductor detectors, such as Si(Li), were limited by fundamental noise floors and lacked scalability for high-throughput spectroscopy. The first experimental demonstration of a voltage-biased TES prototype came in 1996, when Irwin, Gene C. Hilton, David A. Wollman, and John M. Martinis reported X-ray detection using a superconducting microcalorimeter that exhibited the predicted electrothermal feedback, resolving manganese K-alpha lines with an energy resolution of 32 eV at 6 keV. This work, conducted at NIST, marked the practical realization of the TES, with Hilton contributing key expertise in device fabrication and Martinis in low-noise readout techniques. Subsequent refinements by Irwin, Hilton, and later collaborators like Joel N. Ullom further solidified the feedback mechanism, establishing TESs as a cornerstone for cryogenic sensing.

Key Milestones and Advancements

In the 2000s, significant progress in transition-edge sensor (TES) technology focused on enabling large-scale arrays through advanced readout techniques. A pivotal development was the introduction of SQUID-based time-division multiplexing (TDM), which allowed for the efficient readout of thousands of TES pixels by sequentially sampling signals, reducing wiring complexity from individual channels to a shared flux-locked loop. This was demonstrated in a 32-channel system achieving low noise and high bandwidth, paving the way for scalable detector arrays in astronomical instruments.^[15] During the 2010s, TES integration into major cosmic microwave background (CMB) experiments marked a key milestone in practical deployment and performance enhancement. The Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT) incorporated TES bolometer arrays starting around 2008, enabling high-angular-resolution measurements of CMB anisotropies with multichroic detectors sensitive across millimeter wavelengths.^[16] Similarly, the South Pole Telescope (SPT) adopted TES arrays in its upgrades, such as SPT-3G by 2017, which featured over 2,600 pixels per array for polarization-sensitive observations, achieving noise-equivalent temperatures near the photon noise limit. Concurrently, TES microcalorimeters achieved energy resolutions below 1 eV for soft X-rays, as demonstrated in 2019 with devices resolving 0.7 eV at low energies, enabling precise spectroscopy for applications like material science and astrophysics.^[17]^[18] Recent advancements up to 2025 have emphasized material optimizations and expanded capabilities for extreme sensitivity. Enhancements in Mo/Au bilayer compositions have enabled higher operating temperatures, with critical temperatures reaching 190 mK in designs for upgraded CMB instruments, improving thermal stability and reducing cooling demands while maintaining sharp transitions.^[19] In neutrino physics, TES arrays in the HOLMES experiment measure electron capture spectra of ^{163}Ho with an average energy resolution of 6 eV FWHM, setting the tightest upper limit on electron neutrino mass at <27 eV/c² (90% CL) through calorimetric techniques that capture the full decay energy.^[20] Post-2020 developments include scaling TES arrays beyond 10,000 pixels, as planned for the Origins Space Telescope's focal planes, which support multiplexed readout for broadband spectroscopy—progress not yet fully reflected in general references.^[21] Overcoming key challenges has further driven TES maturation. Efforts to reduce cosmic ray loading in ground-based CMB arrays, such as implementing muon veto systems and software glitch flagging in SPT and ACT, have minimized event rates from high-energy particles, preserving data integrity and boosting effective observing efficiency by up to 40% in affected pixels. Fabrication yield improvements, through refined bilayer deposition and uniformity controls, have increased functional pixel rates to over 90% in kilopixel arrays, as achieved in BICEP/Keck detectors by optimizing superconducting film processes.^[17]^[22]

Device Components

Superconducting Thermometer

The superconducting thermometer serves as the core sensing element in a transition-edge sensor (TES), consisting of a thin superconducting film biased at the edge of its resistive transition to detect minute temperature changes with high sensitivity. Common material choices include transition-metal alloys such as titanium (Ti), niobium (Nb), and molybdenum (Mo), as well as superconducting/normal-metal bilayers like Mo/Au or Ti/Au, which enable precise tuning of the critical temperature T_c to around 100 mK through the proximity effect.^[23]^[24]^[25] These materials are selected for their ability to maintain superconductivity at cryogenic temperatures while exhibiting a sharp resistive transition when voltage-biased. The key characteristic of the thermometer is the abrupt increase in resistance near T_c, quantified by the steep temperature dependence dR/dT, which enhances detection sensitivity. This sharpness is captured by the dimensionless parameter \alpha = (T/R) (dR/dT), typically exceeding 100 in optimized devices to achieve low noise and high energy resolution.^[26] High \alpha values arise from the material's intrinsic properties and careful control of film thickness and composition during deposition. Fabrication involves depositing the thin films (often 100-300 nm thick) onto a substrate, followed by lithographic patterning to form meander or spiral geometries that increase the effective electrical path length and surface area while minimizing volume for low heat capacity.^[9]^[25] These structures are typically etched using techniques like reactive ion etching to ensure uniformity and reproducibility across arrays. The thermometer's low electron heat capacity C(T) \propto T, dominated by the electronic contribution with weak electron-phonon coupling at millikelvin temperatures, contributes to a fast intrinsic response time \tau = C/G, where G is the thermal conductance to the heat bath.^[27] This rapid thermal recovery, often on the order of microseconds, is essential for high-speed operation in multiplexed detector arrays.

Absorber

The absorber in a transition-edge sensor (TES) functions as the primary component for capturing incident radiation, converting photons or particles into heat through photoelectric absorption for high-energy events like X-rays or calorimetric absorption for lower-energy optical photons.^[28] This thermalization process ensures that the deposited energy raises the temperature of the TES thermometer, enabling precise energy measurement.^[4] Materials for the absorber are selected based on the target wavelength to maximize stopping power while minimizing heat capacity. For X-ray detection, high atomic number metals such as gold or bismuth are commonly used, often electroplated to achieve thicknesses around 6.5 μm for efficient absorption at energies like 6 keV.^[29] In contrast, for ultraviolet wavelengths, superconducting metals like niobium are employed due to their compatibility with cryogenic operation and effective absorption in thin films.^[30] For optical applications, bilayer structures of gold and titanium, typically 10 nm Au over 20 nm Ti, are integrated to tune absorptivity at specific wavelengths such as 1550 nm.^[31] Design features emphasize optimizing thickness and volume for complete energy capture, with optical absorbers often sized to a quarter-wavelength over the refractive index (λ/4n) to enhance efficiency in resonant cavities.^[31] Thermalization efficiency in these structures approaches 100% through careful microstructure control, such as large grain sizes in electroplated films, ensuring rapid and uniform heat distribution without significant loss.^[29] The absorbed energy E is given by E = \int \alpha(\omega) I(\omega) \, d\omega, where \alpha(\omega) is the frequency-dependent absorptivity and I(\omega) is the incident intensity spectrum.^[32] Coupling mechanisms typically involve direct deposition of the absorber onto the TES thermometer for intimate thermal contact or attachment via a thin membrane or stem to minimize parasitic heat paths while maintaining high efficiency.^[33] In cantilevered array designs, symmetric stem geometries further optimize this interface, achieving filling fractions of 95-97% for uniform response across pixels.^[29]

Thermal Isolation and Conductance

Thermal isolation in transition-edge sensors (TESs) is essential for achieving high sensitivity by weakly coupling the sensor to its cryogenic heat bath, typically resulting in thermal conductances G on the order of 1–10 nW/K at operating temperatures around 100 mK.^[34] These low values ensure that absorbed energy causes significant temperature rises in the TES without rapid dissipation. The thermal links are commonly designed as narrow legs or suspended membranes to control phonon heat flow. Materials such as amorphous silicon nitride (SiN_x) are widely used due to their low thermal conductivity at millikelvin temperatures; for example, legs with thicknesses of 0.2 \mum, widths of 0.7–1.0 \mum, and lengths of 1–4 \mum provide the required isolation while supporting the device structure.^[35] Diamond-like carbon films are also employed in some designs for their tunable mechanical and thermal properties, further reducing conductance in phononic-limited regimes.^[36] The thermal conductance G quantifies the heat flow and is given by G = \frac{dP}{dT}, where P is the power dissipated to the bath. In dielectric supports like SiN, conduction is phonon-mediated and follows a power-law dependence P \approx K (T^\kappa - T_b^\kappa), yielding

G \approx \kappa K T^{\kappa - 1},

with \kappa \approx 5 typical for these materials at cryogenic temperatures; here, T is the TES temperature, T_b is the bath temperature, and K is a geometry- and material-dependent constant.^[7] Minimizing G is crucial for maximizing TES responsivity, as the current responsivity S scales inversely with G according to S = -\frac{L}{I R G}, where L is the electrothermal loop gain, I is the bias current, and R is the TES resistance.^[7] Lower G thus amplifies the electrical signal for a given energy deposition, enhancing detection limits in applications requiring high energy resolution. Fabricating these structures involves challenges such as managing residual stress in the membranes, which can induce strain affecting the superconducting transition and device uniformity. Techniques like low-temperature deposition, annealing, and precise etching help mitigate stress to below 10 MPa, ensuring reliable suspension without buckling or cracking.^[37] The value of G also sets the thermal time constant \tau = \frac{C}{G}, where C is the total heat capacity of the TES island; this trade-off allows designers to tune response times from microseconds to milliseconds by adjusting link geometry.^[7]

Operation and Readout

Biasing Mechanism

Transition-edge sensors (TESs) are typically operated under voltage bias rather than current bias, as the former enables stable negative electrothermal feedback that linearizes the response and improves sensitivity. Current bias is less common due to its tendency to produce positive feedback, leading to thermal runaway and instability in the operating regime.^[4] This preference for voltage biasing stems from the need to maintain the TES resistance near the midpoint of its superconducting-to-normal transition, where the device's temperature sensitivity is maximized. The biasing circuit consists of the TES connected in parallel with a low-value shunt resistor R_s, where R_s \ll R (the TES resistance), forming a low-impedance voltage source. This setup is coupled to a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) amplifier to provide low-noise readout of current changes while ensuring the voltage across the TES remains constant. The bias power dissipated in the TES, which sets its operating temperature, is given by P_{\text{bias}} = V^2 / R, where V is the applied bias voltage and R is the TES resistance.^[38]^[39] The operating point is chosen such that the TES resistance R \approx R_{\text{normal}} / 2, where R_{\text{normal}} is the normal-state resistance, positioning the device in the steepest portion of its resistance transition for optimal sensitivity. At this point, the logarithmic temperature sensitivity parameter \alpha = (T / R) (dR / dT) > 1, ensuring strong electrothermal feedback that dominates thermal conduction to the heat bath.^[4] To maintain stability, the bias must avoid bistable regions where the device's I-V characteristic intersects the load line at multiple points, potentially causing hysteresis or latching. This bistability arises near the critical temperature T_c, and is mitigated by selecting a shunt resistance and bias voltage that keep the operating current below the critical current I_c(T). Near T_c, the critical current follows I_c(T) = I_{c0} \left[ 1 - \left( \frac{T}{T_c} \right)^2 \right], where I_{c0} is the zero-temperature critical current, ensuring single-valued stable operation.^[40]^[4]

Electrothermal Feedback

The electrothermal feedback in a transition-edge sensor (TES) arises from the strong temperature dependence of the sensor's resistance near its superconducting transition, enabling a self-regulating mechanism under constant voltage bias. When incident radiation deposits energy, raising the TES temperature, the resistance increases sharply. This reduces the current through the device, thereby decreasing the Joule heating power (P = I²R, but with fixed V, P = V²/R). The resulting cooling effect counteracts the initial temperature rise, stabilizing the operating point and preventing thermal runaway.^[41] The strength of this negative feedback is quantified by the loop gain L, defined as L = α P_bias / (G T), where α = (T / R) (dR / dT) is the steepness parameter (typically α ≫ 1 in the transition region), P_bias is the bias power, G is the thermal conductance to the heat bath, and T is the TES temperature. For well-designed TES devices, L ≫ 1, which compresses the intrinsic thermal time constant τ = C / G (with C the heat capacity) to an effective value τ_eff ≈ τ / L. This feedback extends the device's bandwidth from the natural thermal response (often milliseconds) to the kilohertz range, allowing faster signal recovery.^[41] A key benefit of electrothermal feedback is the linearization of the TES response: the output current change becomes directly proportional to the input signal power, simplifying signal processing and improving energy resolution. In the high-loop-gain limit, the device's speed and linearity enable applications requiring high dynamic range and low noise, such as single-photon detection.^[41] The linear current response can be derived from the steady-state power balance equation. Under voltage bias, the total electrical power delivered to the TES equals the sum of the bias power and any signal power absorbed: P_total = P_bias + ΔP = V I, where V is fixed. For small perturbations in equilibrium, the differential form is dP = I dV + V dI = 0 (since dV = 0). Thus, V dI + dP = 0, yielding ΔI / ΔP = -1 / V. This shows that the fractional current change directly measures the signal power, independent of the detailed thermal parameters when feedback is strong.^[41]

Signal Readout Methods

The primary method for reading out the current signal from a transition-edge sensor (TES) involves superconducting quantum interference devices (SQUIDs), which serve as highly sensitive null detectors in a flux-locked loop configuration to measure small changes in TES current with minimal added noise.^[42] In this setup, the TES is typically coupled to a superconducting transformer that converts the current to magnetic flux, which the DC SQUID then detects and amplifies through feedback to maintain operation at its most sensitive point, achieving flux sensitivities on the order of $10^{-6} \Phi_0 / \sqrt{\mathrm{Hz}}.^[42] To enable readout of large TES arrays, multiplexing techniques are essential, with time-division multiplexing (TDM) and frequency-division multiplexing (FDM) being the most widely adopted SQUID-based approaches. In TDM, signals from multiple TESs are sequentially sampled by rapidly switching the flux input to a summing SQUID using superconducting switches, allowing hundreds of channels to share a single readout chain while preserving the electrothermal feedback dynamics.^[43] FDM, on the other hand, assigns a unique bias frequency to each TES (typically in the 1–5 MHz range), with the resulting current signals modulated onto these carriers and separated using LC resonator circuits before summation and detection by a SQUID array, enabling simultaneous readout of up to thousands of pixels with low crosstalk (less than 0.01).^[44] Alternative readout methods for TES arrays include microwave SQUID multiplexing, where TES signals modulate microwave carriers via flux-tuned Josephson junctions in SQUIDs, offering potential scalability beyond baseband techniques for applications requiring high channel counts.^[45] However, SQUID-based systems remain the standard for TES due to their unmatched low-noise performance. The readout bandwidth is determined by the TES response time and SQUID slew rate, supporting effective noise equivalent power (NEP) values as low as \sqrt{4 k_B T^2 G} (where k_B is the Boltzmann constant, T is the TES temperature, and G is the thermal conductance to the bath), with systems capable of handling signals up to 1 MHz for fast transient events in x-ray or particle detection.^[4]^[43]

Performance Characteristics

Advantages

Transition-edge sensors (TES) offer exceptional sensitivity for detecting photons and particles, achieving energy resolutions that approach the fundamental thermodynamic limits set by phonon noise. The full width at half maximum (FWHM) energy resolution is approximated by the formula

\Delta E_\text{FWHM} \approx 2.35 \sqrt{\frac{k_B T^2 C}{\alpha}},

where k_B is the Boltzmann constant, T is the operating temperature, C is the heat capacity of the absorber, and \alpha = \frac{T}{R} \frac{dR}{dT} characterizes the sharpness of the resistive transition.^[41] This performance enables sub-electronvolt resolutions for X-ray energies around 6 keV, such as 4.22 eV demonstrated in the HOLMES experiment.^[41] TES detectors provide a broad operational bandwidth extending from DC to the MHz regime, which supports both high-resolution spectroscopy and time-resolved imaging without the need for additional dispersive elements.^[41] Bandwidths up to 100 MHz have been realized using superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) readout arrays, allowing versatile detection across optical to millimeter wavelengths.^[41] The negative electrothermal feedback inherent to TES operation linearizes the response, yielding a dynamic range exceeding four orders of magnitude in input power or energy.^[46] This capability, demonstrated in γ-ray spectrometry over 20–200 keV, ensures accurate measurement of signals varying widely in intensity.^[46] TES technology excels in scalability, supporting uniform large-format arrays with more than $10^3 pixels through time- or frequency-division multiplexing factors up to 2000.^[41] Representative implementations include 3840-pixel arrays for the Athena X-IFU focal plane and 16,000-pixel systems in the South Pole Telescope (SPT-3G), enabling high aggregate photon flux handling that surpasses the total throughput of many single-pixel single-photon detector approaches. Recent plans, such as the Line Emission Mapper (LEM) with 14,000 pixels, further demonstrate scaling potential.^[41]^[47]

Limitations

Transition-edge sensors (TES) require cryogenic cooling to temperatures typically below 100 mK to maintain operation in the superconducting transition region, relying on complex systems such as dilution refrigerators or adiabatic demagnetization refrigerators that impose high costs and logistical challenges, thereby restricting portability and broad deployment.^[4]^[48] The limited cooling power available at these milli-Kelvin stages, often under 100 mW, further complicates scaling to large arrays by increasing thermal loads from associated readout electronics and wiring.^[4] Fabrication of TES demands precise deposition of superconducting thin films, where defects and inhomogeneities—such as variations in film thickness or composition—can significantly reduce device yield.^[4] Such imperfections not only lower overall production efficiency but also introduce excess noise, compromising performance uniformity and reliability in multiplexed configurations where aliasing from readout crosstalk can exacerbate signal degradation.^[4] A key operational constraint is the limited dynamic range of TES, arising from saturation effects at elevated photon fluxes or energy inputs that exceed the device's thermal capacity, typically on the order of 10 pW, leading to nonlinear response and temporary loss of sensitivity.^[49] Following saturation, the thermal recovery time, typically spanning microseconds (1–5 μs), further limits the maximum count rate and hinders applications involving high event densities, as the sensor must fully equilibrate before detecting subsequent signals. Recent advancements, such as normal metal heat-sinks, have reduced recovery times to ~40–460 ns.^[30]^[50] While traditional TES designs face these cryogenic and performance hurdles, post-2020 advancements incorporating higher critical temperature materials, such as YBCO with Tc ≈ 92 K, enable operation at liquid nitrogen temperatures (≈ 77 K) using more accessible Stirling cryocoolers, thereby alleviating some cooling demands at the expense of ongoing challenges in film uniformity and detection efficiency.^[9]

Applications

Astrophysics and Cosmology

Transition-edge sensors (TES) play a pivotal role in detecting the faint B-mode polarization of the cosmic microwave background (CMB), a primordial signal predicted by cosmic inflation theories that encodes information about the early universe's gravitational waves. Ground-based experiments like BICEP3, a 95 GHz refracting telescope at the South Pole, utilize arrays of polarization-sensitive TES bolometers to measure degree-scale CMB polarization with high sensitivity, enabling the isolation of B-modes from galactic foregrounds such as dust emission.^[51] These TES detectors, operating at cryogenic temperatures, achieve noise-equivalent temperatures below 5 μK√s, crucial for constraining tensor-to-scalar ratios as low as r < 0.01.^[52] The Simons Observatory (SO) advances this effort with extensive TES arrays deployed across small and large aperture telescopes in Chile's Atacama Desert, targeting B-mode detection through high-resolution millimeter-wave mapping. SO's Large Aperture Telescope incorporates over 62,000 TES bolometers spanning 27–270 GHz, providing arcminute-scale resolution—approximately 2.4 arcminutes at 90 GHz—to survey 40% of the sky and achieve unprecedented precision in E- and B-mode power spectra.^[53] This configuration supports photon-noise-limited performance, essential for distinguishing inflationary B-modes at amplitudes of 30–90 nK from lensing and foreground effects.^[54] As of 2025, the Large Aperture Telescope achieved first light in early 2025 and is conducting initial science observations.^[55] In submillimeter and millimeter-wave bolometry, TES enable precise measurements of CMB spectral distortions, offering complementary probes of cosmology beyond polarization. The Primordial Inflation Explorer (PIXIE), a proposed NASA mission, employs multimode polarization-sensitive TES bolometers in a Fourier transform spectrometer to map the CMB spectrum and linear polarization with parts-per-million accuracy across 15–600 GHz.^[56] These detectors operate in a photon-noise-limited regime, achieving sensitivities sufficient to detect μ-type distortions from energy injections at redshifts z > 10^5, which inform models of inflation, recombination, and dark matter interactions.^[57] TES bolometers also facilitate far-infrared spectroscopy for tracing galaxy evolution through dust-obscured star formation and interstellar medium dynamics. The HAWC+ instrument on the Stratospheric Observatory for Infrared Astronomy (SOFIA), which operated until its retirement in 2022, integrated dual TES arrays to measure polarized far-infrared continuum emission at 50–400 μm, resolving magnetic field structures in galactic and extragalactic sources.^[58] This capability enabled studies of protostellar cores and high-redshift galaxies, revealing how magnetic fields regulate gas collapse and feedback processes over cosmic time.^[59] In X-ray astronomy, TES microcalorimeters provide high-resolution spectroscopy for studying extreme astrophysical phenomena. The Resolve instrument on the XRISM mission, launched in 2023, features a 36-pixel TES array achieving approximately 7 eV full width at half maximum (FWHM) resolution at 6 keV, enabling detailed observations of black hole accretion, supernova remnants, and galaxy clusters.^[60] The future Athena mission's X-ray Integral Field Unit (XIFU), scheduled for launch in the 2030s, will employ 3840 TES pixels to deliver 2.5 eV resolution at 6 keV across a wide field of view.^[61]

Particle and Nuclear Physics

Transition-edge sensors (TES) are pivotal in particle and nuclear physics for detecting individual particles and rare events, offering sub-electronvolt energy resolution that surpasses traditional semiconductor detectors. These cryogenic devices measure temperature rises from energy deposits in absorbers, enabling precise spectroscopy of low-energy interactions relevant to neutrino properties and dark matter candidates. By operating in the superconducting transition region, TES provide fast response times and high sensitivity, essential for distinguishing signal events from backgrounds in underground laboratories.^[4] In neutrino mass measurements, TES enhance bolometric detectors for neutrinoless double beta decay (0νββ) searches, which constrain the effective Majorana neutrino mass if the process is observed. The CUORE experiment employs an array of TeO₂ crystals as thermal absorbers, read out primarily by neutron transmutation doped thermistors, but integrates TES-based cryogenic light detectors to capture ~100 eV Cherenkov photons emitted by α particles, enabling particle identification and rejection of surface backgrounds with >99% efficiency. This approach improves the experiment's sensitivity to 0νββ in ^{130}Te, setting limits on neutrino masses below 0.06–0.18 eV depending on nuclear matrix elements. Future iterations, such as the CUPID experiment, plan to couple TES directly to enriched TeO₂ or alternative absorbers for full bolometric readout at ~100 eV resolution, aiming for half-life sensitivities beyond 10^{27} years and tighter neutrino mass bounds.^[62]^[63]^[64] TES microcalorimeters excel in X-ray spectroscopy for nuclear physics, providing energy resolutions of ~1 eV FWHM at 6 keV, far superior to silicon drift detectors (~150 eV). At synchrotron facilities like the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF), TES arrays map fluorescence from trace elements in samples, resolving fine structures in atomic transitions for studies of nuclear decays and excited states. In laboratory settings, they enable high-precision measurements of X-ray emission lines from radioactive sources, aiding in the calibration of nuclear models and the search for exotic decays. For instance, Mo/Au bilayer TES have demonstrated 0.7–2.3 eV resolution across 1–6 keV, supporting investigations into forbidden transitions in heavy nuclei.^[65]^[66]^[67] For dark matter detection, the SuperCDMS experiment deploys TES on silicon or germanium absorbers to sense athermal phonons from nuclear recoils expected from weakly interacting massive particle (WIMP) interactions, achieving thresholds below 10 eV and resolutions enabling recoil energy reconstruction up to hundreds of keV. The TES, patterned as meanders on the absorber surface, couple to quasiparticle diffusion or phonon collection, allowing discrimination of WIMP signals from electron recoils via ionization yield comparisons, with efficiencies exceeding 90% for nuclear recoils. Recent prototypes have set leading limits on WIMP masses from 1 GeV to TeV scales, excluding cross-sections down to 10^{-44} cm² in some regions.^[68] Additionally, the TESSERACT experiment, advancing in 2025, utilizes highly sensitive TES detectors to probe light dark matter candidates with masses below 1 GeV, opening new search regimes.^[69] Event reconstruction in TES arrays leverages the characteristic pulse shapes for precise timing, with rise times of microseconds allowing sub-millisecond event localization in multi-pixel setups, crucial for vetoing cosmogenic backgrounds in neutrino and dark matter experiments. The energy resolution stems from statistical fluctuations in the number of quasiparticles or phonons produced, approximated by

\frac{\Delta E}{E} \approx \frac{2.35}{\sqrt{N}},

where N is the number of quasiparticles generated proportional to the deposited energy E, and 2.35 converts the standard deviation to full width at half maximum. This limit, approached in optimized TES with low noise, underscores their utility for resolving closely spaced spectral features in particle identification.^[66]^[4]

Other Scientific Uses

Transition-edge sensors (TES) have been employed as bolometers to characterize thermal properties of thin films at cryogenic temperatures. In on-chip thermometry setups, TES devices enable precise measurements of temperature-dependent heat capacities in materials such as SiO₂, by detecting minute changes in absorbed power through electrothermal feedback.^[70] For instance, niobium thin films' thermal conductance has been quantified using TES-based detectors, revealing sub-kelvin transport behaviors critical for superconducting device design.^[71] Recent studies on lanthanum strontium copper oxide (LSCO) thin films demonstrate TES bolometers achieving high sensitivity for evaluating bolometric figures of merit, aiding in the optimization of high-temperature superconductors.^[72] In quantum sensing applications, TES detectors facilitate hybrid systems for readout in circuit quantum electrodynamics (QED), where they complement microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKID) to enhance photon detection fidelity.^[73] For qubit noise spectroscopy, TES microcalorimeters measure correlated charge noise in superconducting qubits, providing insights into decoherence mechanisms by resolving low-energy events with high temporal resolution.^[74] These capabilities support fault mitigation in quantum processors, where TES arrays detect environmental perturbations affecting qubit states.^[75] In 2025, Xanadu and Applied Materials initiated collaboration to develop high-volume-compatible fabrication for TES in scalable photonic quantum systems, targeting single-photon number resolving detection.^[76] TES-based X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy holds nascent potential for medical imaging, particularly in non-invasive tissue analysis. High-resolution TES microcalorimeters enable elemental mapping of biological samples, distinguishing trace metals in tissues with energy resolutions below 5 eV, surpassing traditional semiconductor detectors.^[77] This approach could advance diagnostics for conditions involving metal accumulation, such as neurodegenerative diseases, though clinical integration remains exploratory due to cryogenic requirements.^[78] Emerging uses include superconducting bolometers with transition-edge sensor (TES) capabilities for fast response in fusion diagnostics. These devices are proposed as high-flux neutron detectors in tokamak experiments for tomographic reconstruction of plasma ion temperature distributions, with potential energy resolutions enabling sub-10% uncertainty in temperature gradients.^[79] In quantum metrology, advances in TES photon-number-resolving detectors support precision measurements, such as unsupervised counting of few-photon states for enhanced interferometry and sensor networks.^[80] These developments underscore TES versatility in scaling quantum-enhanced measurements beyond traditional domains.^[4]

References

[1]
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2411.01968.pdf
[2]
Transition Edge Sensors (TES) - MIT
A transition-edge sensor is a thermometer made from a superconducting film operated near its transition temperature Tc. While in its transition from ...
[3]
https://doi.org/10.1063/1.113674
[4]
Transition Edge Sensors: Physics and Applications - MDPI
Transition Edge Sensors (TESs) are amongst the most sensitive cryogenic detectors and can be easily optimized for the detection of massive particles or photons.
[5]
Transition edge sensors for bolometric applications: responsivity ...
Apr 24, 2008 · Equation (1) suggests that a change in equilibrium rf power will produce changes in both the equilibrium TES current I 0 and resistance R 0 ⁠.
[6]
Transition-Edge Sensors - SpringerLink
Jul 9, 2005 · Superconducting transition-edge sensors (TES) have emerged as powerful, energy-resolving detectors of single photons from the near infrared through gamma rays.
[7]
[PDF] Development of transition edge sensor detectors optimized for ...
For typical T ≥ 80. K visible and infrared (VISIR) detector operating temperatures, there will always be sufficient thermal energy in the semiconductor to ...
[8]
Superconducting transition edge bolometer for high-flux neutron ...
Dec 14, 2023 · The detector environment is pumped to a vacuum of 10 − 4 mbar to limit convective heat transfer.
[9]
Mitigation of the Magnetic Field Susceptibility of Transition-Edge ...
A TES is a cryogenic detector that can be used to measure the energy of a photon or particle with very high resolving power by utilizing the steep temperature- ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[10]
Thermal models and noise in transition edge sensors - AIP Publishing
Apr 10, 2009 · SOURCES OF NOISE. In our models we include electrical read-out noise, Johnson noise in the TES itself, and thermal fluctuation noise between the ...
[11]
Time-Division SQUID Multiplexers | NIST
Feb 1, 2002 · SQUID multiplexers (MUX) make is possible to build arrays of thousands of low-temperature bolometers and microcalorimeters based on ...
[12]
[PDF] Characterization of Transition Edge Sensors for the Millimeter ...
For a subset of TES bolometers, we measure their I-V curves at multiple bath temperatures to obtain the parameters Ksb, nsb and Tt, assuming Kts is large so ...
[13]
Performance of Al-Mn Transition-Edge Sensor Bolometers in SPT-3G
Jul 27, 2019 · SPT-3G is a polarization-sensitive receiver, installed on the South Pole Telescope, that measures the anisotropy of the cosmic microwave ...
[14]
https://pubs.aip.org/aip/apl/article/30/12/664/45692/Composite-superconducting-transition-edge
[15]
Calorimetric experiment achieves tightest bound on electron ...
Oct 31, 2025 · The HOLMES experiment uses an array of 64 transition-edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters operated at approximately 95 mK in a ³He/⁴He dilution ...
[16]
Transition-edge sensor detectors for the Origins Space Telescope
OSS has six focal planes, each with ∼10,000pixels ∼ 10,000 pixels . ... Many TDM schemes are deployed in the field for reading out kilopixel-scale arrays of TES ...Missing: post- | Show results with:post-
[17]
Antenna-coupled TES Bolometer Arrays for BICEP2/Keck and SPIDER
Sep 20, 2010 · Following our progress in improving detector parameters uniformity across the arrays and fabrication yield, our main effort has focused on ...
[18]
First results from Mo/Au transition-edge sensor X-ray calorimeters
No intermetallic compound formation at the Mo/Au interface is expected for temperatures below 800°C and negligible interdiffusion is anticipated through the ...Missing: MoAu | Show results with:MoAu<|control11|><|separator|>
[19]
Fabrication of Superconducting Transition Edge Sensors based on ...
Aug 6, 2025 · We have developed a new type of x‐ray detector based on a superconducting transition‐edge thermometer operated near 100 mK. A ...Missing: alloys | Show results with:alloys
[20]
[PDF] Development of a transition-edge sensor bilayer process providing ...
Jan 30, 2023 · Transition-edge sensors (TESs) are thermal detectors in which a superconducting film that is electrically biased in the superconducting-to- ...
[21]
Optimization of transition-edge calorimeter performance
... parameter α = ( T / R ) dR/dT where R is the sensor resistance. For simplicity, we take β = ( I / R ) ∂R/∂I to be zero, although this quantity is known to be ...
[22]
[PDF] Transition Edge Sensors
Superconducting Transition Edge Sensors (TES). R self regulated working point. T. Electro-thermal feedback. K. D. Irwin, Appl. Phys. Lett. 66, 1945 (1995) shunt.
[23]
Characterizations of the electrothermal parameters of a transition ...
In this paper, we report characterizations of the electric and thermal parameters of a TES μ-calorimeter made from proximately coupled Mo and Au films.Missing: milestone | Show results with:milestone<|control11|><|separator|>
[24]
[PDF] Absorber Materials for Transition-Edge Sensor X-ray ...
We show that by incorporating absorbers possessing large grain size, including electroplated gold and electroplated gold/electroplated bismuth, into our current.
[25]
[PDF] Faster recovery time of a hot-electron transition-edge sensor by use ...
Detection of single infrared, optical, and ultraviolet photons using superconducting transition edge sensors ... thick niobium (Tc 9.5 K). On top of the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[26]
[PDF] An optical transition-edge sensor with high energy resolution - arXiv
Apr 5, 2022 · Abstract. Optical transition-edge sensors have shown energy resolution for resolving the number of incident photons at the telecommunication ...
[27]
Extending single-photon optimized superconducting transition edge ...
Oct 2, 2012 · Typically, it is sufficient to use a two-body thermal model to describe the temperature evolution of the electrons and phonons in the TES.
[28]
Impact of the Absorber-Coupling Design for Transition-Edge-Sensor ...
Oct 29, 2021 · Transition-edge sensors (TESs) are very sensitive detectors of energy that utilize the sharpness of a superconductor normal-to-superconducting ...
[29]
Mapping of the resistance of a superconducting transition edge ...
Feb 17, 2017 · This gives the device a high thermal conductance to the substrate G ≈ 5.8 nW/K at 100 mK. The bias circuit for the TES is also shown in Fig. 1.Missing: typical | Show results with:typical
[30]
Transition edge sensors with few-mode ballistic thermal isolation
We show that it is possible to calculate the conductance and thermal fluctuation noise accurately from first principles, using only bulk elastic constants, and ...
[31]
Superconducting transition edge sensors with phononic thermal ...
The sensitivity of a low-noise superconducting transition edge sensor (TES) is determined by the thermal conductance of the support structure that connects ...
[32]
Effects of uniaxial stress on Mo and Mo/Cu bilayer superconducting ...
Our results indicate that the direct strain induced changes to the transition temperature are rather small (about +0.3 mK for a 0.1% strain change on a Mo film) ...Missing: MoAu | Show results with:MoAu
[33]
Multiabsorber transition-edge sensors for x-ray astronomy
Assuming only the electrical Johnson noise of the TES and thermal fluctuation noise between the TES and heat bath, the energy resolution ΔEFWHM Δ E FWHM is ...
[34]
[PDF] Transition Edge Sensor Modeling
Put TES in series with an inductor. ○ Current in TES → magnetic flux in inductor. ○ → SQUID measures magnetic flux. ○ → SQUID measures current I.Missing: balance | Show results with:balance<|control11|><|separator|>
[35]
Dependence of transition width on current and critical current in ...
May 22, 2017 · The TES was voltage biased with a shunt resistor of 350 ... G. C.. Hilton. , “. Transition-edge sensors. ,”. Cryogenic Particle Detection. (. 2005. ) ...
[36]
https://pubs.aip.org/aip/jap/article/124/14/144501/155510/Superconducting-transition-edge-sensors-with
[37]
SQUID readout multiplexers for transition-edge sensor arrays
Aug 10, 2025 · Two classes of SQUID multiplexer are being developed for large arrays of cryogenic sensors, distinguished by their operation in either the ...
[38]
[2209.05621] Signal readout for Transition-Edge Sensor X-ray ...
Sep 12, 2022 · This chapter describes three different multiplexed-readout technologies for transition-edge-sensor microcalorimeters.
[39]
https://www.physics.utoronto.ca/~phy2405/TES_modeling.pdf
[40]
Microwave SQUID Multiplexer Demonstration for Cosmic ... - NIH
The µmux is gaining maturity for both bolometric and calorimetric TES applications. In this letter, we focus on the µmux for CMB polarization experiments.
[41]
Transition-Edge Sensors - ResearchGate
Aug 7, 2025 · As mentioned in Irwin and Hilton [5] , the external electrical bias performs work against voltage fluctuations induced by random thermal motions ...
[42]
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/229379618_SQUID_readout_multiplexers_for_transition-edge_sensor_arrays
[43]
[PDF] Dual Transition Edge Sensor Bolometer for Enhanced Dynamic Range
To address this need, we present results on a dual transition edge sensor (TES) device with two operating modes: one for low background, ultrasensitive ...
[44]
[1808.00567] 2017 upgrade and performance of BICEP3: a 95GHz ...
Aug 1, 2018 · BICEP3 is a 520mm aperture on-axis refracting telescope observing the polarization of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) at 95GHz.
[45]
Improved polarization calibration of the BICEP3 CMB polarimeter at ...
Jul 29, 2022 · It is designed to target degree angular scale polarization patterns, in particular the very-much-sought-after primordial B-mode signal, which is ...
[46]
Characterization of the Large Aperture Telescope Receiver - arXiv
Jan 16, 2025 · At the LAT's focal plane, SO will install > > > 62,000 transition-edge sensor detectors across 13 optics tubes (OTs) within the Large Aperture ...Simons Observatory... · 2 Latr Design · 6 Latr And Lat IntegrationMissing: BICEP3 | Show results with:BICEP3
[47]
The Simons Observatory Large Aperture Telescope Receiver
Sep 16, 2021 · The resulting instrument will produce arcminute-resolution millimeter-wave maps of half the sky with unprecedented precision. The LATR is the ...
[48]
Multimode bolometer development for the PIXIE instrument
Aug 9, 2025 · In the following, we report on the design, fabrication, and performance of the multimode polarization-sensitive bolometers for PIXIE, which are ...
[49]
The Primordial Inflation Explorer (PIXIE): Mission design and ... - arXiv
May 30, 2024 · The Primordial Inflation Explorer (PIXIE) is an Explorer-class mission concept to measure the energy spectrum and linear polarization of the cosmic microwave ...Missing: TES | Show results with:TES
[50]
https://pubs.aip.org/aip/apl/article/99/24/241114/122261/Faster-recovery-time-of-a-hot-electron-transition
[51]
[PDF] Transition Edge Sensors for (Far-)Infrared Astronomy
This presentation includes figures from several sources, including: Benford et al., 2004, SPIE Vol. 5498. K. Irwin & G. Hilton, 2005, Topics Appl. Phys.Missing: SPHEREx evolution
[52]
Particle discrimination in TeO2 bolometers using light detectors read ...
Oscillation experiments have confirmed that the three families of neutrinos mix and that at least two of them have a finite mass. However, information on the ...
[53]
[PDF] Multiplexed TES Based Light Detectors using transition edge ...
Jun 21, 2024 · We employ a pioneering Iridium/Platinum bilayer superconducting transition- edge-sensor (TES) technology, operating at temperatures below 40 mK, ...
[54]
[PDF] Latest results from CUORE and prospects for CUPID - CERN Indico
Sep 18, 2025 · CUORE. (0𝜈𝛽𝛽). EDELWEISS. (Dark Matter). Transition Edge Sensor,. TES. • Very high sensitivity. A~100-1000. • Multiplex readout. • Fast rising ...
[55]
Application of a TES micro-calorimeter as high-energy resolution ...
A superconducting transition edge sensor microcalorimeter was tested at the synchrotron radiation beam-line of the ESRF to collect the X-ray fluorescence ...
[56]
A Review of X-ray Microcalorimeters Based on Superconducting ...
A detailed calculation of the minimum energy resolution achievable with a TES calorimeter is possible. After a careful analysis of the thermometer ...Missing: milestone | Show results with:milestone
[57]
Fine pitch transition-edge sensor X-ray microcalorimeters with sub ...
Dec 1, 2015 · The pixels have gold absorbers with dimensions 45 × 45 × 4.2 µm3. We measured an energy resolution of 0.72 ± 0.03 eV full width at half maximum ...
[58]
[PDF] Hunting Dark Matter with SuperCDMS - CERN Indico
Detection. • Measure ionization. • Collect athermal phonons via transition edge sensors (TES). • Electron Recoils (betas, gammas). • Nuclear Recoils (neutrons, ...
[59]
[PDF] Transition Edge Sensor Thermometry for On-chip Materials ... - arXiv
There is a strong suggestion here that a simple power law does not account for the conductance across this measurement range. ... simple power-law across the ...
[60]
Thermal conductance of Nb thin films at sub-kelvin temperatures
Feb 3, 2017 · Thermal conductance of Nb thin films ... Incident radiation changes the temperature of a superconducting island in a transition edge sensor ...
[61]
[PDF] arXiv:2411.19656v1 [cond-mat.supr-con] 29 Nov 2024
Nov 29, 2024 · Let us first present our results for the bolometric performance of LSCO thin films ... Sadleir, and E.J. Wollack, “Transition-edge sensor ...
[62]
[PDF] Transition-Edge Sensors: Enabling Discoveries in Particle Physics ...
Sep 26, 2024 · Recent Advances: TES can detect single electrons, with promising results suggesting similar performance to photon detection. Page 31. 31. Back- ...Missing: milestones advancements
[63]
https://agenda.infn.it/event/37867/contributions/227772/contribution.pdf
[64]
Sensor-Assisted Fault Mitigation in Quantum Computation
Aug 13, 2021 · Transition edge sensor devices. In a TES [15] , the material's effective temperature is set such that the material resides on the ...
[65]
Trends in X-Ray Techniques - Spectroscopy Online
Jul 1, 2017 · Transition-edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeter detectors are capable of high-resolution X-ray emission spectroscopy (XES) that rivals X-ray ...
[66]
Disclo | Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
Transition-Edge Sensor X-Ray Fluorescence (TES-XRF) for High Resolution Material Identification. X-Ray Fluorescence (XRF) is a technique for material ...
[67]
Superconductor based, tomographic, neutron diagnostics for fusion ...
Aug 22, 2024 · The suggested HTS bolometer is a transition edge sensor (TES), which is a well-known technology used in fields such as astrophysics for ...
[68]
Accurate Unsupervised Photon Counting from Transition Edge ...
Nov 8, 2024 · ... Transition Edge Sensor Signals. ... quantum advantages in information processing, communication and metrology.