Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Year One

Year One, designated as 1 AD (Anno Domini, Latin for "in the year of the Lord") or 1 CE (Common Era), constitutes the epochal starting point of the proleptic Julian calendar's Christian era, retroactively established in 525 CE by the monk Dionysius Exiguus to commemorate the approximate year of Jesus Christ's incarnation or birth.^[1]^[2] Dionysius, seeking to supplant the Diocletian era associated with Roman persecution of Christians, calculated this date by aligning it with 753 years after Rome's legendary founding, though his methodology lacked precise astronomical or historical verification and has since been deemed erroneous.^[1]^[3] Empirical evidence from sources like the Gospel of Luke, referencing Herod the Great's reign (ending in 4 BCE), indicates Christ's birth occurred between 6 and 4 BCE, rendering Year One a conventional rather than factual pivot, with no intervening year zero—1 BCE transitions directly to 1 AD.^[3]^[4] This calendrical construct gained traction slowly, achieving widespread use in Western Europe only by the 8th–9th centuries through figures like Bede and Charlemagne, eventually forming the backbone of global chronological standards despite its Christian origins and inaccuracies.^[2]^[3] In the historical context of 1 AD, the Roman Empire under Augustus experienced administrative expansions and frontier stabilizations, including Tiberius's campaigns in Germania, amid a Pax Romana that facilitated trade and cultural exchange across Eurasia.^[1] Concurrently, the Han dynasty in China advanced bureaucratic governance and silk production, while Mesoamerican and South Asian societies developed independent astronomical and artistic traditions, underscoring Year One's role as a arbitrary marker amid diverse, unconnected global developments rather than a universal historical caesura.^[1] The era's defining characteristic lies not in singular events—which remain sparsely documented due to the retrospective application of the dating system—but in its enduring influence on historiography, enabling cross-cultural periodization while prompting modern secular alternatives like CE to mitigate theological bias.^[5]^[2]

Conceptual Definition

Political and Historical Meaning

The designation of Year One (An I in French) marked the commencement of the French First Republic's official chronology, retroactively set to begin on 22 September 1792, the day after the National Convention's abolition of the monarchy on 21 September.^[6] This date, coinciding with the autumnal equinox, symbolized a foundational break from the Gregorian calendar's Christian and monarchical associations, aligning timekeeping with natural astronomical cycles rather than ecclesiastical authority.^[7] Politically, it embodied the revolutionaries' aspiration for total societal regeneration, positing the Republic as the origin point of a new historical epoch defined by rational governance, popular sovereignty, and secular progress, thereby delegitimizing all prior eras as relics of tyranny and superstition.^[8] Historically, Year One spanned from 22 September 1792 to 21 September 1793, encompassing the National Convention's early consolidation of power amid external wars and internal factional strife, including the trial and guillotining of King Louis XVI on 21 January 1793.^[9] The retroactive numbering, formalized amid escalating radicalism, reflected demands voiced since the 1789 storming of the Bastille for a calendar commencing with the "first year of liberty," which intensified dechristianization campaigns by supplanting saints' days and royal anniversaries with civic and agrarian nomenclature.^[7] This temporal reset facilitated the Jacobin-dominated Convention's ideological monopoly, as it implied a tabula rasa that justified purging perceived enemies of the Revolution to preserve the purity of the republican genesis.^[10] In broader revolutionary discourse, Year One signified an archetype of radical rupture, where political actors sought to impose a utopian origin myth, often at the expense of historical continuity and institutional stability; its invocation later echoed in subsequent upheavals, underscoring the perils of enforcing ideological novelty through coercive calendar reform.^[11] Empirical records from the period, including Convention decrees, reveal that while intended to foster national unity and productivity via decimalized metrics, the measure exacerbated administrative chaos and cultural resistance, contributing to its eventual abandonment under Napoleon in 1805.^[12]

Distinction from Calendar Eras

The designation of "Year One" in revolutionary politics signifies a symbolic and ideological rupture with the preceding historical order, marking the inception of a purportedly novel epoch grounded in radical principles such as liberty, equality, and reason, rather than serving as a neutral chronological anchor. This contrasts with calendar eras, which function as systematic year-numbering frameworks tied to a fixed epochal event—often religious, foundational, or imperial—to maintain continuity in dating across generations. For instance, the Anno Domini (AD) era, devised by the monk Dionysius Exiguus in 525 CE, reckons years from the approximate birth of Jesus Christ, integrating subsequent history into an unbroken timeline without implying delegitimization of prior periods.^[3] Similarly, the Roman Ab Urbe Condita (AUC) era counted from the legendary founding of Rome in 753 BCE, embedding events within a continuous civic narrative.^[13] In revolutionary usage, Year One embodies a deliberate rejection of historical continuity, positing the revolution as a tabula rasa that renders the ancien régime obsolete and restarts temporal reckoning to align with enlightened ideals. During the French Revolution, this manifested concretely on 22 September 1792, when the National Convention declared the First Republic and initiated Year I (An I) of the French Republican Calendar, explicitly designed to supplant the Gregorian system's Christian associations and monarchical legacies with a secular structure based on natural cycles and decimal divisions.^[12] The calendar's adoption on 24 October 1793 formalized this shift, with months renamed for agricultural and climatic phenomena (e.g., Vendémiaire for vintage) to evoke rational harmony over divine providence.^[7] This was not merely administrative but propagandistic, aiming to forge a collective consciousness unburdened by "superstitious" traditions, as articulated in revolutionary decrees emphasizing the era's birth from the "reign of reason."^[14] Unlike calendar eras, which accommodate diverse interpretations of their originating events without prescribing societal overhaul—such as the AD system's persistence amid varying Christian doctrines—Year One's invocation carries prescriptive force, demanding allegiance to the revolutionary narrative and often justifying purges of counter-revolutionary elements as relics of a discarded past. This distinction underscores Year One's role as a tool of ideological mobilization, where temporal reset reinforces causal claims of irreversible progress, evident in its rhetorical deployment beyond France, as in Bolshevik declarations framing 1917 as a proletarian Year One to eclipse tsarist history. Empirical challenges to such resets, including the Republican Calendar's abandonment by 1805 under Napoleon due to practical disruptions in trade and agriculture, highlight its fragility as a political construct rather than a enduring chronological standard.^[12]

Origins in the French Revolution

Proclamation of the Republic

The National Convention, elected in the aftermath of the August 10, 1792, insurrection against King Louis XVI that overthrew the constitutional monarchy, convened its first session on September 20, 1792, amid heightened revolutionary momentum following the French victory at the Battle of Valmy on the previous day.^[15] ^[16] This assembly of 749 deputies, drawn from diverse factions including the Girondins and Montagnards, was tasked with drafting a republican constitution and addressing the suspended king's fate.^[17] On September 21, 1792, without formal debate or recorded dissent, the Convention unanimously decreed the abolition of the monarchy by acclamation, stating: "The National Convention decrees that royalty is abolished in France."^[17] This proclamation, ratified in a charged atmosphere where deputies reportedly responded with cries of "Vive la République," effectively established the First French Republic by severing all ties to hereditary rule and royal institutions.^[18] The decision reflected the radical shift driven by popular sans-culotte pressure, fears of counter-revolutionary plots, and the perceived failures of the constitutional experiment under the Legislative Assembly.^[16] The proclamation's immediacy underscored the Convention's intent to institutionalize republican sovereignty, with subsequent measures including the king's imprisonment and the repudiation of feudal privileges.^[17] It marked a causal rupture from the ancien régime, enabling later reforms such as the retroactive designation of September 22, 1792—the day following the decree—as the inaugural day of Year One in the French Republican Calendar, symbolizing a complete temporal and ideological reset from monarchical precedents.^[15] This event, occurring just 13 days after Valmy's morale-boosting triumph over Prussian forces, solidified the Republic's military and political viability against external coalitions.^[16] While the proclamation averted immediate royalist resurgence, it intensified internal divisions, paving the way for the king's trial in December 1792 and the escalation of purges under the Committee of Public Safety.^[17] Primary accounts from Convention records emphasize the decree's brevity and unanimity, contrasting with the assembly's later fractious debates, and highlight its role as the foundational act of republican governance amid widespread European monarchial opposition.^[17]

Ideological Foundations

The declaration of Year One on September 22, 1792, by the National Convention embodied the revolutionaries' conviction that the establishment of the First Republic marked the inception of a fundamentally new historical epoch, severing ties with the monarchical and ecclesiastical past. This reset symbolized a radical regeneration of society, predicated on the principles of popular sovereignty and rational governance, as the abolition of the monarchy on the preceding day rendered the Gregorian calendar's continuity with the ancien régime untenable.^[19]^[20]^[21] Rooted in Enlightenment critiques of absolutism and superstition, the ideological impetus drew from thinkers like Voltaire and Rousseau, who advocated secular reason over divine-right legitimacy and religious chronologies. Revolutionaries viewed the Christian calendar, anchored in events like the birth of Christ, as perpetuating feudal hierarchies and clerical influence, incompatible with the emergent order of liberty, equality, and fraternity. By inaugurating Year One from the Republic's birth, they asserted that true human progress commenced not from mythical or royal origins but from the collective will of the citizenry enacting natural rights.^[22]^[23]^[24] This foundation also reflected anti-clerical aspirations, aligning with the dechristianization campaign that sought to supplant religious festivals and saints' days with civic virtues and natural cycles, thereby fostering a temporal framework conducive to republican virtue. Proponents, including deputies like Fabre d'Églantine, argued that such a break enabled a tabula rasa for moral and social reconstruction, unencumbered by historical precedents of tyranny. Empirical challenges to inherited traditions, such as the irregular Julian-Gregorian discrepancies, further justified the overhaul in favor of a purportedly more rational baseline.^[14]^[25]^[26] Critics within and beyond France, however, contended that this ideological absolutism overlooked the organic evolution of calendars as cultural artifacts, potentially imposing an artificial uniformity that ignored practical agrarian rhythms tied to pre-revolutionary precedents. Nonetheless, the Year One paradigm underscored the revolutionaries' utopian commitment to causal renewal through deliberate human agency, prioritizing ideological purity over incremental reform.^[27]^[28]

Implementation in the Republican Calendar

Design Principles and Structure

The French Republican Calendar was structured on decimal principles to promote rationalism and detach timekeeping from Christian and monarchical influences, aligning it instead with natural cycles and agricultural life.^[29] Proposed by poet Philippe Fabre d'Églantine and adopted by the National Convention on October 24, 1793, the system divided each year into twelve months of exactly thirty days, yielding 360 days, with five supplementary days (jours complémentaires) added at the end to approximate the solar year; a sixth day was intercalated in leap years, which occurred every four years without exception for centuries. This framework emphasized base-10 divisions, replacing the seven-day week with three décades per month, where the tenth day (décadi) served as a day of rest and civic festivals, reducing religious observance.^[7] Months were poetically named by Fabre d'Églantine to evoke seasonal qualities, grouped into quarters: autumnal Vendémiaire (vintage), Brumaire (mist), and Frimaire (frost); winter Nivôse (snow), Pluviôse (rain), and Ventôse (wind); spring Germinal (budding), Floréal (flowers), and Prairial (meadows); summer Messidor (harvest), Thermidor (heat), and Fructidor (fruit).^[30] Each ordinary day within the décades was assigned a unique name tied to rural or artisanal themes—plants and seeds in the first ten days of a month, fruits and trees in the second, and tools or occupations in the third—to foster appreciation for nature and labor over superstition.^[31] The year commenced near the autumnal equinox on September 22 (retroactively set as the start of Year I from the Republic's proclamation in 1792), symbolizing renewal tied to observable astronomical events rather than arbitrary conventions.^[7] Further reforms extended decimalization to time measurement, dividing the day into ten hours of 100 minutes each, with minutes subdivided into 100 seconds, though this met resistance from clockmakers and the public due to incompatibility with existing mechanisms and was largely abandoned by 1795.^[21] The overall design prioritized ideological purity and scientific precision, aiming to "consecrate the agricultural system" and redirect national focus toward productive, secular rhythms, but its rigid structure ignored lunar phases and cultural habits, contributing to uneven adoption.^[31]

Months, Days, and Timekeeping Reforms

The French Republican Calendar replaced the Gregorian months with twelve new names inspired by agricultural and seasonal cycles, beginning with the autumn equinox on 22 September 1792 (retroactively designated as 1 Vendémiaire Year I).^[12] These months each comprised exactly 30 days and were grouped into four seasonal quarters: autumn (Vendémiaire for grape harvest, Brumaire for fog, Frimaire for frost); winter (Nivôse for snow, Pluviôse for rain, Ventôse for wind); spring (Germinal for seeds, Floréal for flowers, Prairial for pastures); and summer (Messidor for harvest, Thermidor for heat, Fructidor for fruit).^[32] The nomenclature aimed to align the calendar with observable natural processes rather than religious or monarchical traditions, though poet Fabre d'Églantine selected the terms based on phonetic and symbolic criteria rather than strict etymology.^[33] Days within months abandoned the seven-day week in favor of the décade, a ten-day cycle decreed by the National Convention on 24 November 1793 to promote decimal rationality and eliminate Sabbath associations.^[7] Each décade consisted of ten consecutive days named numerically: primidi (first), duodi (second), tridi (third), quartidi (fourth), quintidi (fifth), sextidi (sixth), septidi (seventh), octidi (eighth), nonidi (ninth), and décadi (tenth), with the latter designated as a mandatory rest and festival day akin to Sunday but occurring every tenth day instead of seventh.^[34] This structure yielded three décades per 30-day month, totaling 36 décades annually, and was intended to standardize work cycles while fostering civic festivals on décadi.^[35] To reconcile the solar year of approximately 365.25 days, five supplementary days—known as jours complémentaires or sans-culottides (honoring the revolutionary sans-culottes)—were added at the year's end after 30 Fructidor; a sixth jour sans-culottide was intercalated in leap years every four years, coinciding with years divisible by four in the Republican reckoning.^[33] These extra days served as national holidays dedicated to virtues like labor, genius, and reason, rather than integrating into regular décades.^[36] Timekeeping reforms extended decimal principles to the day itself, as proposed by the Committee of Public Instruction and briefly decreed on 24 April 1795, dividing each 24-hour period into ten decimal hours (heures décimales), each hour into 100 decimal minutes, and each minute into 100 decimal seconds.^[37] This system equated one decimal hour to 2.4 traditional hours (144 minutes), rendering clocks and watches incompatible without dual scales or new mechanisms, which few manufacturers produced due to technical challenges and public resistance.^[35] Enforcement was limited to official and scientific contexts, such as the Paris Observatory, and the reform was largely abandoned by 1795 amid complaints over disrupted daily routines, including extended work hours under the new metric.^[21] The failure highlighted practical barriers to decimal time, contrasting with the partial persistence of calendar changes until Napoleon's 1805 edict reverting to the Gregorian system.^[37]

Practical Adoption and Challenges

The French Republican Calendar was formally decreed on 5 October 1793 (14 Vendémiaire Year II) by the National Convention, with its commencement retroactively set to 22 September 1792, marking the establishment of Year One as the autumnal equinox following the abolition of the monarchy.^[22] Implementation required widespread production of almanacs, posters, and clocks adapted to the new system's décades (10-day periods replacing weeks), months named after seasonal phenomena, and supplementary sans-culottides days, but official enforcement was most rigorous during the Reign of Terror, where local committees mandated its use in public records, festivals, and correspondence to symbolize the break from monarchical and ecclesiastical traditions.^[35] Decimal time reforms, dividing days into 10 hours of 100 minutes each, were briefly enforced on dials and documents starting in 1793 but saw negligible voluntary adoption beyond urban revolutionary circles.^[35] Practical challenges emerged immediately from the calendar's misalignment with entrenched social and economic rhythms. The elimination of the seven-day week in favor of décades extended work cycles to nine consecutive days before a rest day, disrupting customary Sunday observances and Catholic rituals, which fueled resentment among rural populations and laborers who prioritized religious attendance over rationalist reforms.^[35] Farmers resisted due to the system's imperfect synchronization with agricultural cycles—despite nature-inspired month names, the fixed 30-day structure and variable equinox start complicated planting and harvest planning in regions with diverse climates, while traditional market fairs, often tied to weekly intervals, suffered from irregular scheduling.^[22] Internationally, the calendar isolated France from European trade partners and diplomatic exchanges, as merchants and envoys struggled with date discrepancies, leading to delays in shipping manifests, treaties, and postal services still reliant on the Gregorian system.^[35] Enforcement waned post-Thermidor as revolutionary fervor subsided, with dual dating becoming common in private and even some official contexts to mitigate confusion, though penalties for non-compliance persisted sporadically until public non-adoption rendered them ineffective.^[22] By 1799, under Napoleon's consulate, concessions to the Catholic Church via the Concordat reinstated Sundays and select holidays, eroding the calendar's ideological purity and highlighting its failure to supplant ingrained habits.^[35] The system was ultimately abolished by imperial decree on 9 September 1805 (22 Fructidor Year XIII), effective 1 January 1806, as Napoleon prioritized administrative efficiency, ecclesiastical reconciliation, and alignment with global norms over deist utopianism, acknowledging the calendar's impracticality amid ongoing resistance and minimal grassroots uptake.^[30]^[22]

Extensions to Other Revolutions

Bolshevik Russia and Soviet Era

The Bolshevik Revolution of October 1917 (November 7 in the Gregorian calendar) marked a radical ideological rupture with the Russian imperial past, with leaders like Vladimir Lenin framing it as the dawn of a proletarian era free from capitalist and tsarist exploitation. In the Declaration of the Rights of the Working and Exploited People, adopted by the Council of People's Commissars on January 16, 1918 (Julian calendar), Russia was proclaimed a Republic of Soviets, vesting all power in workers', soldiers', and peasants' councils and abolishing private land ownership, thereby symbolizing a foundational reset of social and economic structures. This echoed the French Revolution's Year One by positioning 1917 as the origin point of historical progress toward communism, though Bolshevik rhetoric emphasized class struggle over calendrical symbolism.^[38] Unlike the French Republican Calendar's explicit Year I starting from September 22, 1792, the Bolsheviks did not institute a new era numbering system, opting instead for pragmatic alignment with international norms. On February 8, 1918 (Julian), the Soviet government decreed a switch from the Julian to the Gregorian calendar, effective February 14 (skipping 13 days to synchronize with Western Europe), to facilitate trade and administration amid civil war isolation. This reform, signed by Lenin, prioritized utility over symbolic rupture, reflecting the Bolsheviks' focus on survival against White Army counterrevolutionaries and foreign interventions that claimed over 7 million lives by 1922. Historical accounts, such as Victor Serge's Year One of the Russian Revolution (originally serialized 1925–1928), retrospectively designated 1917–1918 as "Year One" to highlight the insurrection's transformative potential, including the dispersal of the Constituent Assembly on January 6, 1918, and the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk's territorial concessions on March 3, 1918, which secured Bolshevik consolidation.^[39] In the broader Soviet era, calendar experiments extended revolutionary timekeeping reforms to erode religious and bourgeois rhythms, though without renumbering years. From 1929 to 1930, a five-day continuous work week (with rotating rest days) was imposed to boost industrial output under the First Five-Year Plan, eliminating traditional weekends and aligning production with atheistic materialism; this affected 58% of workers by 1930 before reverting due to logistical failures like disrupted family and agricultural cycles. A subsequent six-day week from 1931 to 1940, with Stalinist holidays replacing Sundays, further decoupled time from Orthodox Christian observance, but these changes prioritized economic mobilization—yielding steel production rises from 4 million tons in 1928 to 18 million in 1938—over utopian calendrical reinvention. Proposals for a "Soviet revolutionary calendar" in 1930, featuring twelve 30-day months plus five non-working holidays, were shelved amid collectivization famines that killed 5–7 million in 1932–1933, underscoring practical constraints on symbolic resets. These reforms, documented in Central Executive Committee decrees, illustrated an ideological commitment to temporal mastery as a tool for class remolding, yet their abandonment by 1940 signaled a retreat toward stability under wartime exigencies.^[40]

Twentieth-Century Examples

In Fascist Italy, the Era Fascista (E.F.) established a revolutionary calendar era beginning with the March on Rome on October 28, 1922, designated as Anno I E.F. to symbolize the regime's foundational rupture with prior political orders and its evocation of Roman imperial origins. Formally implemented in 1926, the system required official usage in documents, coins, and public inscriptions, where years were dual-dated—e.g., 1932 as "X E.F." or "1932 - X E.F."—to reinforce Mussolini's narrative of national rebirth amid post-World War I instability, with membership in the National Fascist Party reaching over 250,000 by 1921 and expanding thereafter. This temporal innovation persisted until Italy's 1943 armistice with the Allies, after which it was abandoned, reflecting the regime's emphasis on totalitarian synchronization of time with ideology rather than practical decimal reforms.^[41] The Metaxas dictatorship in Greece adopted a similar era starting from the royal coup of August 4, 1936, proclaimed as Year One of the "Regime of the 4th of August," aimed at engineering social cohesion through suppression of strikes—numbering 1,303 in the preceding year—and promotion of ancient Hellenic virtues against perceived Bolshevik threats. Under Prime Minister Ioannis Metaxas, who ruled until his death on January 29, 1941, the calendar supported propaganda efforts like the National Youth Organization (EON), enrolling over 250,000 members by 1939, and cultural policies glorifying Spartan discipline, though economic data showed limited growth with GDP per capita stagnating around 300-400 U.S. dollars equivalent amid authoritarian controls. The era dissolved with the Axis invasion in April 1941, underscoring its role as a tool for regime legitimation in a Balkan context of interwar volatility.^[42] These instances paralleled earlier revolutionary precedents by leveraging calendar resets for ideological consolidation, yet empirical outcomes highlighted implementation challenges: in Italy, adherence waned in rural areas due to entrenched Catholic traditions, while Greece's system faced resistance from intellectuals and yielded no sustained metric reforms, as both regimes prioritized symbolic over functional overhauls amid broader European fascist experiments.^[42]

Ideological and Symbolic Role

Symbolism of Radical Reset

The declaration of Year One on 22 September 1792, coinciding with the establishment of the First French Republic shortly after the abolition of the monarchy on 21 September, instituted a deliberate chronological rupture intended to mark the genesis of a rational, secular polity unencumbered by historical precedents.^[23] This retroactive designation of 1792 as An I (Year One) transformed the autumnal equinox into the symbolic origin point of revolutionary time, aligning the calendar with astronomical precision over ecclesiastical traditions tied to the Julian-Gregorian system.^[25] By erasing numbered continuity from prior eras, the reset embodied an ideological commitment to tabula rasa, positing the Republic as the foundational epoch for regenerating human society through Enlightenment-derived principles of nature and reason.^[23] Central to this symbolism was the dechristianization campaign, which viewed the old calendar's saints' days, Christian holidays, and seven-day weeks as vestiges of superstition and royalist authority perpetuating cyclical deference to divine or hereditary order.^[23] Revolutionaries, including figures like Philippe Fabre d'Églantine who devised the nature-themed months (e.g., Vendémiaire for vintage, Brumaire for mist), sought to supplant these with decimal divisions—ten-day décades and 30-day months—to foster a uniform, productive citizenry oriented toward agrarian virtue and scientific progress rather than ritual observance.^[23] The shift rejected the Gregorian calendar's purported irrationality, aiming not merely to destroy inherited faiths but to instill a "new faith" in rational timekeeping that mirrored the Revolution's cosmological ambitions.^[23] This temporal overhaul represented one of the most extreme efforts in modern history to redefine collective memory, challenging entrenched Western frameworks of periodicity and origin.^[23] Ultimately, the radical reset aspired to an irreversible break, unleashing a regenerative temporal order where festivals honoring virtues like labor and genius would perpetuate revolutionary fervor indefinitely, free from the "weight" of accumulated history.^[43] Proponents believed this rupture would harmonize social reality with natural cycles, ensuring the Revolution's permanence by embedding it in everyday reckoning—government decrees, almanacs, and public life all dated from Year One to reinforce ideological cohesion.^[43] Yet, the symbolism underscored a tension between utopian renewal and practical continuity, as the calendar's imposition highlighted the revolutionaries' drive to impose homogeneity on diverse temporal habits, often through coercive standardization rather than organic adoption.^[25]

Utopian Aspirations Versus Reality

The declaration of Year One on 22 September 1792, marking the birth of the First French Republic, embodied revolutionaries' aspirations for a complete temporal and societal rupture from the monarchical past, aiming to forge a new era grounded in reason, nature, and equality.^[7] Ideologues such as poet Philippe Fabre d'Églantine, who devised the month names evoking agricultural cycles (e.g., Vendémiaire for vintage, Brumaire for mist), sought to align human institutions with empirical observation, supplanting what they viewed as superstitious Gregorian conventions tied to Christianity and aristocracy.^[44] This reset was intended not merely as administrative reform but as a symbolic catalyst for regenerating collective memory, instilling republican virtues through decimal divisions of time and space that mirrored the metric system's rationalism.^[25] Yet these ideals clashed with entrenched realities, as the calendar's imposition from 24 November 1793 onward coincided with the Reign of Terror under the Committee of Public Safety, where non-adherence could invite accusations of counter-revolutionary sentiment.^[37] Practical mismatches exacerbated discord: the 360-day year plus five or six intercalary days (Sansculottides) poorly synchronized with solar cycles, complicating agricultural planning for peasants reliant on lunar phases and traditional saints' days, while merchants faced hurdles in international commerce due to desynchronized ledgers.^[44] Rural and clerical resistance was pronounced, with many clandestinely retaining Gregorian dates for harvests and worship, underscoring the limits of coercive secularization in overriding cultural inertia. The utopian promise of unified, enlightened temporality dissolved into evident failure by the Directory period (1795–1799), as wartime exigencies and economic disarray amplified non-compliance, with urban elites often ignoring the system while rural areas scorned its artificiality.^[25] Napoleon Bonaparte's decree of 22 August 1805 mandated reversion to the Gregorian calendar effective 1 January 1806, citing diplomatic necessities and administrative efficiency over persistent ideological experimentation.^[30] This abrupt termination after little over 12 years highlighted causal disconnects between abstract rationalism and human adaptation: enforced novelty bred alienation rather than harmony, revealing how top-down resets, absent organic buy-in, foster instability rather than the promised rational order.^[44]

Criticisms and Consequences

Association with Violence and Instability

The adoption of the French Republican Calendar, decreed on October 24, 1793, and retroactively commencing Year One from the autumnal equinox of September 22, 1792, occurred at the onset of the Reign of Terror, a phase dominated by the Jacobin-led Committee of Public Safety's campaign of mass executions and purges against internal dissenters.^[22]^[29] This temporal reform, intended to symbolize a break from monarchical and Christian traditions, aligned with policies of de-Christianization that intensified civil conflict, including the suppression of Catholic counter-revolutions.^[29] During the Terror (September 1793 to July 1794), revolutionary tribunals condemned approximately 17,000 individuals to death, primarily by guillotine, while an additional 10,000 perished in prison without trial; broader estimates place total fatalities from executions, drownings, and related violence at 30,000 to 50,000.^[45]^[46] The Law of Suspects (September 17, 1793) facilitated widespread arrests, targeting nobles, clergy, and even moderate republicans, fostering an atmosphere of paranoia and summary justice that eroded legal norms and social cohesion. Concurrently, the Vendée uprising, a royalist and Catholic rebellion erupting in March 1793, faced brutal Republican reprisals; by 1794, scorched-earth tactics, mass drownings at Nantes (over 1,800 victims in a single incident on December 16, 1793), and columned expeditions under generals like Turreau resulted in 117,000 to 250,000 deaths, predominantly civilians, devastating the western region's population and economy.^[47]^[48] Economic turmoil compounded this instability, as wartime mobilization, blockade-induced shortages, and the assignat currency's hyperinflation—reaching over 13,000% devaluation by 1795—triggered famines and urban riots, such as the Prairial uprising in May-June 1795.^[49] The calendar's decimal time experiments, briefly enforced alongside metric reforms, diverted administrative resources amid these crises, symbolizing the Jacobins' prioritization of ideological purity over pragmatic governance.^[50] Critics, including contemporaries like Edmund Burke, later attributed such radical temporal resets to the Revolution's descent into anarchy, arguing they reflected a messianic zeal that justified violence as necessary for societal rebirth, ultimately destabilizing France until Napoleon's 1799 coup.^[51] Externally, the calendar's era overlapped with the expansion of revolutionary wars, declared against Austria and Prussia in 1792 and widening by 1793 to include Britain and others, straining resources and fueling conscription revolts that intertwined with domestic terror. Historians have noted that the ideological drive for a "Year One" zero-point, erasing historical continuity, paralleled the erasure of human lives deemed incompatible with the Republic, contributing to a cycle of instability that persisted beyond the Terror's end on 9 Thermidor Year II (July 27, 1794).^[52] This association underscores how the calendar, rather than a neutral reform, embodied the revolutionary government's coercive absolutism during France's bloodiest internecine phase.^[46]

Long-Term Failures and Rejections

The French Republican Calendar, despite its initial imposition as a symbol of rational reform, encountered persistent resistance that culminated in its formal abolition under Napoleon Bonaparte. On 22 Fructidor Year XIII (September 9, 1805), an imperial sénatus-consulte decreed its end, effective with the reinstatement of the Gregorian calendar on January 1, 1806 (11 Nivôse Year XIV).^[33]^[53] This decision reflected a broader political shift toward stability, as Napoleon's regime prioritized reconciliation with the Catholic Church via the Concordat of 1801, rendering the calendar's dechristianizing features—such as the elimination of saints' days and the seven-day week—politically untenable.^[54] Public adoption faltered due to practical disruptions, particularly the 10-day décade, which supplanted the traditional weekly cycle and Sunday rest, alienating laborers who relied on customary market and religious rhythms for economic and social life. Rural populations, comprising the majority, often ignored the new months' seasonal nomenclature (e.g., Vendémiaire for vintage time), continuing to reference Gregorian equivalents informally, which undermined enforcement outside urban centers.^[21] Economic activities, including trade fairs and agricultural planning, suffered from misalignment with international Gregorian standards, complicating commerce with non-adopting nations and fostering inefficiency in diplomacy and record-keeping.^[55] Post-revolutionary attempts at revival underscored its enduring rejection. During the Second Republic in 1848 and the Paris Commune of 1871, radicals briefly reinstated elements like Year I dating, but these efforts collapsed amid broader counter-revolutionary forces, with the calendar abandoned within months due to the same ingrained cultural habits and lack of popular support.^[37] By the Third Republic (1870–1940), official documents reverted permanently to Gregorian usage, signaling the calendar's failure as a viable long-term system; its decimal time variant had already been discarded by 1795 for similar reasons of impracticality and non-adherence.^[35] This rejection highlighted the limits of imposed rationalism against entrenched traditions, as evidenced by widespread non-compliance even during peak enforcement under the Directory (1795–1799).^[55]

Legacy and Contemporary Relevance

Influence on Modern Political Rhetoric

The declaration of Year One following the establishment of the First French Republic on September 22, 1792, exemplified a rhetorical strategy of temporal rupture, whereby revolutionaries repudiated the monarchical past to inaugurate an era of purported regeneration, erasing prior historical continuity to justify institutional overhaul and cultural reinvention.^[56] This archetype persists in modern radical discourses, where invocations of a "new beginning" or foundational reset serve to delegitimize existing orders, often framing them as obstacles to purity or equity, thereby rationalizing disruptive policies or violence.^[11] In jihadist rhetoric, particularly among groups like ISIS following their 2014 caliphate declaration, the pursuit of a seventh-century Islamic polity mirrors Year One's collectivist utopia, rejecting modern nation-states and Western norms to restore an alleged pristine origin, enforced through terror as "prompt, severe, inflexible justice"—echoing Robespierre's defense of the Committee of Public Safety.^[10] This temporal reset rhetoric portrays contemporary society as apostate, demanding eradication of "internal and external enemies" to birth a global caliphate, with propaganda emphasizing millennial renewal over incremental reform.^[10] Post-colonial theorists adapted similar logic, as in Frantz Fanon's advocacy for decolonization as a violent tabula rasa, liberating the colonized psyche by annihilating settler structures to forge authentic societies—a framework influencing 21st-century activist calls for "dismantling" systems like policing or borders as prerequisites for equity.^[57] Critics of globalist agendas, such as the World Economic Forum's 2020 Great Reset initiative, identify parallels in its blueprint for post-pandemic reconfiguration of economies and governance, likening it to Year Zero pursuits that prioritize engineered utopias over evolved institutions, though proponents frame it as adaptive pragmatism amid crises like climate change and inequality. ^[58] Such rhetoric's enduring appeal lies in its causal promise of causation from destruction to renewal, yet empirical outcomes—from the Reign of Terror's 16,594 executions to ISIS's territorial collapse by 2019—underscore risks of instability when symbolic resets override institutional continuity.^[10]^[59] In scholarly reassessments, this device is critiqued for fostering authoritarianism under egalitarian guises, informing conservative counter-rhetoric that privileges evolutionary change over radical effacement.^[56]

Scholarly Debates and Reassessments

Revisionist historians of the French Revolution, such as François Furet, have reassessed the declaration of Year One in the Republican Calendar—dating from September 22, 1792—as emblematic of an ideological fervor that prioritized abstract regeneration over practical governance, ultimately fostering a cycle of terror and counter-revolution rather than stable liberty.^[60] Furet argued in Penser la Révolution française (1978) that the Revolution's Jacobin phase, symbolized by this temporal reset, transformed political discourse into a messianic pursuit of virtue, detached from empirical social realities, leading to the guillotining of approximately 17,000 individuals during the Reign of Terror from 1793 to 1794 and the subsequent rise of Napoleonic authoritarianism.^[61] This interpretation contrasts with earlier Marxist-influenced narratives that viewed Year One as a progressive rupture from feudalism, instead positing it as a precursor to modern totalitarianism through its rejection of incremental reform.^[62] In contrast, "lyricist" approaches, often aligned with cultural or sympathetic leftist scholarship, maintain that Year One captured a genuine utopian aspiration for equality, interpreting the calendar's decimal time and nature-based months as innovative breaks from monarchical symbolism, even amid chaos.^[62] Scholars like those critiquing revisionism argue this symbolism endured in revolutionary memory, influencing later movements by framing history as a tabula rasa amenable to total redesign, though empirical outcomes—such as the Vendée uprising's death toll exceeding 200,000—undermine claims of net progress.^[56] Hannah Arendt, in On Revolution (1963), further dissected this duality, praising the American Revolution's foundation-building while faulting the French variant's Year One for evoking a void of power that invited violence, as evidenced by the Committee's purges.^[63] Applied to the Bolshevik Revolution, reassessments since the 1991 Soviet collapse have highlighted parallels in attempted societal resets, with scholars analyzing Lenin's 1918 decrees on land and industry as de facto Year One initiatives that erased pre-1917 institutions, resulting in immediate economic collapse: grain production fell 40% by 1921, precipitating famines claiming over 5 million lives.^[64] Archival evidence post-USSR reveals the Red Terror's execution of at least 100,000 opponents by 1922, framing the revolution not as proletarian triumph but as a vanguard-imposed utopia prone to bureaucratic degeneration, as critiqued in works examining the gap between Bolshevik ideals and practices like forced collectivization precursors.^[65] These analyses, drawing on declassified Cheka records, challenge earlier apologetic Soviet historiography by emphasizing causal links between tabula rasa policies and long-term failures, including the 1930s purges that killed 700,000.^[66] Broader scholarly critiques portray Year One motifs as inherently flawed tabula rasa experiments, ignoring entrenched social continuities and human incentives, with empirical patterns across revolutions showing elevated instability: the French case devolved into empire within 12 years, Bolshevik Russia into Stalinist totalitarianism by 1929, and analogous Khmer Rouge Year Zero in Cambodia (1975) yielding 1.5-2 million deaths from starvation and executions by 1979.^[10] Recent reassessments, informed by comparative studies, attribute these outcomes to the hubris of assuming societal blank slates, as opposed to evolutionary adaptations, with data from post-revolutionary GDP contractions (e.g., Soviet Russia's 1920 output at 20% of 1913 levels) underscoring causal realism over ideological optimism.^[67] While some postmodern analyses defend the symbolism as performative resistance, dominant empirical scholarship concludes such resets amplify violence without delivering promised novelties.^[68]

References

[1]
The Year One - The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Oct 1, 2004 · For Dionysius, the birth of Christ represented Year One. He believed that this occurred 753 years after the foundation of Rome. Although this is ...
[2]
Keeping time: The origin of B.C. and A.D. - Live Science
Oct 24, 2024 · "AD" stands for anno domini (Latin for "in the year of the lord"), and it refers specifically to the birth of Jesus Christ. "BC" stands for "before Christ."
[3]
Anno Domini, Before Christ: When Was That Calendar Invented?
Aug 31, 2016 · So Anno Domini, the year of our Lord, is a very easy transition to make, as opposed to dating the year an emperor had reigned in Rome.” Still, ...
[4]
History Of Our Calendar - Webexhibits
There is no year 0. Jesus was born before 4 B.C.E.. The concept of a year "zero" is a modern myth (but a very popular one). In ...
[5]
What Is Year 1 of History? Comparing Jewish, Christian, and Muslim ...
Jan 19, 2025 · In Buddhist convention, year one is when the Buddha died. Year one of “Buddhist Era,” abbreviated BE, traditionally corresponds to 543 BCE.
[6]
Sept. 22, 1792: Day One of Revolutionary Calendar | WIRED
Sep 22, 2011 · The date on the Republican Calendar was 14 Vendémiaire An II (Year 2). It went into effect and became compulsory on Nov. 24 (4 Frimaire An II).
[7]
The French republican calendar
After the storming of the Bastille in July 1789, demands became more vociferous, and a new calendar, to start from "the first year of liberty," was widely ...
[8]
Year One, Then and Now – Corbin K. Barthold - Law & Liberty
Apr 30, 2020 · The Jacobins established Year One, and their country paid for it. So, in the end, did they. There is indeed a sound lesson to be had from this.Missing: meaning | Show results with:meaning
[9]
French Revolution timeline 1792-95 - Alpha History
September 21st: The National Convention votes to introduce a decimalised revolutionary calendar, beginning with Year I of the First Republic. September 23rd ...<|separator|>
[10]
Understanding Tyranny and Terror: From the French Revolution to ...
Jun 30, 2015 · The return to the Year One, a grim collectivist utopia allegedly based on the earliest, purest version of Muslim society in the 7th century. The ...
[11]
[PDF] No Future or Still in Year One? Revisionist versus Lyricist ...
This is because Year One expresses a standpoint from within the revolution- ary situation. It attempts to break the chronological time of events and nar ...
[12]
The Republican calendar - napoleon.org
The Republican year began with the month of Vendémiaire (from the Latin 'vindemia', grape harvest) (22 September to 21 October).
[13]
Calendars and their History - NASA Eclipse
Oct 14, 2012 · Introduction. A calendar is a system of organizing units of time for the purpose of reckoning time over extended periods.
[14]
The French Revolution and the Catholic Church | History Today
The Revolutionary calendar started with the advent of the French Republic (Year 1). The names of its months reflected the seasons and its ten-day week ...
[15]
French Revolution Timeline
September 20. French cannons drive back Prussians at Valmy. September 21. French Republic proclaimed. 1793. January 21. Louis XVI executed. February 1. France ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
[16]
The National Convention - Alpha History
1. The National Convention was the revolutionary government of France, between the abolition of the monarchy in September 1792 and the creation of the Directory ...
[17]
National Convention - Hanover College History Department
“The National Convention decrees that royalty is abolished in France. Proclamation of the Convention to the Nations, December 1792. Editor's Note: The ...
[18]
Proclamation of the first French Republic - CONA Iconography Record
... proclamation of the First French Republic during the French Revolution. Display Date: 21 September 1792. Names: Proclamation of the first French Republic ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
[19]
The 12 Months of the French Republican Calendar | Britannica
Henceforth, the year of the official proclamation of the Republic (1792) would become Year One. In this secular calendar, the twelve months of the year were ...
[20]
1. The First Republic (1792-1804) - Paris: Capital of the 19th Century
The First Republic of France is established on September 22 of 1792. The National Convention is made up of the Girondins, who support the bourgeoisie.
[21]
The French Republican Calendar: How Time was Different
Sep 21, 2018 · The new French Republican calendar was divided into twelve months, each month had 30 days, and the five extra days needed to complete the year ...
[22]
French republican calendar | Revolutionary period, decimal system ...
Sep 29, 2025 · The Revolutionary Convention established the calendar on October 5, 1793, setting its beginning (1 Vendémiaire, year I) to a date nearly a year ...
[23]
Why the French Revolution's “Rational” Calendar Wasn't
May 23, 2018 · Zerubavel (the sociologist) writes that the calendar functioned as a “representation of three main themes of the French Enlightenment: ...
[24]
The ideas of the French Revolution - Alpha History
Sources of revolutionary ideas · Liberty · Equality · Fraternity · Popular sovereignty · Constitutionalism · Natural rights · Anti-clericalism.Sources of revolutionary ideas · Equality · Fraternity · Popular sovereignty
[25]
Introduction - The Calendar in Revolutionary France
So too the French Revolution claimed to start time anew in the form of a new calendar that simultaneously vindicated secular time and affirmed the Revolution's ...Missing: reset | Show results with:reset
[26]
The French Revolutionary Calendar - France Today
Dec 10, 2024 · The Revolutionary calendar was finally abolished on January 1, 1806, after being used for just 12 years. It was briefly revived during the Paris ...The Age Of Reason · A New Calendar · Naming The Months
[27]
If Only the French Republicans Had Known This: The Week as a ...
During the French Revolution and inspired by the Enlightenment, an attempt was made to replace the Gregorian calendar (which was based on 'irrational' ...Missing: reset | Show results with:reset
[28]
The French Revolution – Europe Since 1600: A Concise History
France went from a Catholic absolute monarchy to a radical, secular republic with universal manhood suffrage, a new calendar, a new system of weights and ...7.3 Events Of The Early... · 7.4 ``equality'' · 7.5 The Radical Phase And...
[29]
French Republican Calendar - World History Encyclopedia
Oct 26, 2022 · The Republican calendar was designed to remove all royalist and Christian elements from the French calendar, which were replaced by natural and ...
[30]
The Republican calendar - napoleon.org
Thus the first day of the year, 1 Vendémiaire, was given the name of a fruit: the grape! This was a real headache for the French people who never really got ...
[31]
The Calendar · LIBERTY, EQUALITY, FRATERNITY
The main idea upon which we have based our proposal is to use the calendar to consecrate the agricultural system, to lead the nation back to it, highlighting ...
[32]
[PDF] THE NAMES OF THE DAYS OF THE REPUBLICAN CALENDAR
THE NAMES OF THE DAYS OF THE REPUBLICAN CALENDAR. THE AUTUMN MONTHS. Vendémiaire. Brumaire. Frimaire. 1er. Raisin (Grape). Pomme (Apple). Raiponce (Lambs ...
[33]
French Republican calendar converter
The French Republican calendar had 12 months of 30 days, 3 decades of 10 days each, and 5 extra days (6 in leap years), starting on the autumnal equinox.
[34]
French Revolutionary Calendar - A few good links
The new calendar, based on a report of Fabre d'Églantine, was adopted by the Convention in October, 1793. By it the year began on September 22 of the old ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[35]
France's Republican calendar and the doomed battle to ... - RFI
Sep 27, 2025 · ... Republican year, 1 Vendémiaire, was the day of grapes. The days that followed honoured chestnuts, horses, carrots and parsnips. "As the calendar ...
[36]
REPUBLICAN CALENDAR - HistoryWorld
The five extra days are grouped as holidays at the end of the year and are called sansculottides. (A sans-culotte, meaning 'without knee-breeches', is the ...
[37]
(PDF) The decimalisation of Republican time. The French ...
Jul 18, 2024 · This chapter will focus on the circumstances of the creation, application, and the use of the decimal (time) system, analyse the reaction of ...<|separator|>
[38]
Declaration Of Rights Of The Working And Exploited People
Russia is hereby proclaimed a Republic of Soviets of Workers', Soldiers' and Peasants' Deputies. All power, centrally and locally, is vested in these Soviets. 2 ...Missing: new era
[39]
Victor Serge: Year One of the Russian Revolution (1930)
May 19, 2013 · Written: 1925–1928, Vienna, Leningrad, Dietskoye Seloe. First Published: L'An 1 de la révolution russe, 1930. Source: Year One of the Russian ...Missing: Bolshevik | Show results with:Bolshevik
[40]
New Letters and Dates - Seventeen Moments in Soviet History
... calendar according to which 1792 was declared Year One and weeks lasted ten days. The use of the Julian calendar in Russia throughout the revolutionary year ...
[41]
Fascist Italy on JSTOR
Officially it was year X of the Fascist Era because in 1926 a new calendar came into operation with year I E.F. (Era Fascista) beginning October 1922. The ...<|separator|>
[42]
[PDF] Six calendar systems in the European history from 18th to 20th ...
Apr 30, 2011 · Kairis, the Revolutionary Calendar of the Soviet Union (or 'Bolshevik calendar'), the fascist calendar in Italy and the calendar of the Metaxas ...
[43]
The French Republican Calendar: Time, History and the Revolutionary Event
### Summary of Symbolic Power of the Republican Calendar
[44]
The French Republican Calendar - Wiley Online Library
Dated 'Year One of the Reign of Reason', it erased the Christian chronology and also replaced the saints of the Gregorian calendar with secular and non ...<|separator|>
[45]
What Led to France's Reign of Terror? - Britannica
By the time the Reign of Terror reached its conclusion, in July 1794, some 17,000 people had been officially executed, and as many as 10,000 had died in prison ...
[46]
Reign of Terror - World History Encyclopedia
Nov 1, 2022 · It is estimated that the total death toll during the ten-month Reign of Terror rests anywhere between 30-50,000. Remove Ads. Advertisement. The ...
[47]
The Vendée uprising - Alpha History
The Vendée was the epicentre of the largest counter-revolutionary uprising of the French Revolution and its people would pay a heavy price for their resistance.Reasons for rebellion · Indifference to the revolution · Violence breaks out
[48]
Wars of the Vendée | French Revolution, Royalist Uprising ...
Sep 29, 2025 · On October 17 the main Vendéan army (about 65,000) was heavily defeated at Cholet and fled north across the Loire, leaving only a few thousand ...
[49]
Economic consequences of revolutions: Evidence from the 1789 ...
Dec 2, 2017 · This column uses extensive evidence from the French Revolution to show that the effects vary across the country and over time.Missing: 1793-1794 | Show results with:1793-1794
[50]
France's Brief Experiment With Decimal Time
Jan 2, 2022 · The calendar was to commemorate the era of Liberty in France. If you recall anything about the French Revolution, Reign of Terror, the rise of ...Missing: context | Show results with:context
[51]
Jacobins and Terror in the French Revolution (Chapter 8)
For a revisionist view of violence in the American Revolution, see Holger Hoock, Scars of Independence: America's Violent Birth (New York: Crown Publishing, ...
[52]
Evidence from the French Republican Calendar by Megan Stewart
Feb 18, 2025 · Existing work nds that violence, formal education, or elite co-optation are eective tools of revolutionary social change. This paper presents an ...Missing: instability | Show results with:instability
[53]
The French Republican Calendar: Everything to Know - Ancestry.com
Feb 16, 2023 · Napoleon abolished the French Republican Calendar on 1 January 1806, about a year-and-a-half after he took power. This means the calendar was ...<|separator|>
[54]
The French Revolutionary Calendar - by kingflum - ScrewDownCrown
Apr 25, 2024 · The French Revolutionary Calendar, a failed 18th-century attempt to remake society by radically restructuring time, offers a cautionary tale ...
[55]
In 1792, France Made A New Calender Based On Science and ...
Apr 17, 2025 · Known as the French Republican calendar, it featured 12 months, each 30 days long and divided into three 10-day cycles similar to weeks, called décades.
[56]
The evolution of the modern revolutionary tradition - MIT Press Direct
Jul 3, 2014 · ... French revolutionary calendar in which the year of the execution of the king was counted as Year One. Its aim is not the replacement of one ...
[57]
Frantz Fanon's Political Thought on Tabula Rasa A ... - Sage Advance
Jan 2, 2024 · Tabula rasa substitutes the existing world into a new world that accommodates black subjects as human beings who deserve to repossess all of ...Missing: rhetoric | Show results with:rhetoric
[58]
[PDF] EVILution of Communism Workshop | New Discourses
Aug 10, 2024 · Eventually killed for pushing a line that the French Revolution hadn't been radical ... “Year Zero”. Allude to Great Reset and French Rev. Mao's ...
[59]
Spectacles of Sovereignty in Digital Time: ISIS Executions, Visual ...
Nov 20, 2017 · Emwazi turns up in another hi-tech ISIS production released in November of the same year, one of 22 executioners wielding knives who behead ...
[60]
François Furet - The French Revolution Revisited - jstor
Everything o value in the French Revolution was already there in 1789. Farther to the Left, and a generation later, Edgar Quinet re- discovered the same ...
[61]
Historian: François Furet - Alpha History
Furet refuted Marxist theory and resurrected the idea that the French Revolution might have been driven by political aims as much as by social conditions or ...
[62]
No Future or Still in Year One? Revisionist versus Lyricist ...
Jun 1, 2016 · Research Article| June 01 2016. No Future or Still in Year One? Revisionist versus Lyricist Approaches to the French Revolution Available.
[63]
[PDF] Hannah-Arendt-On-revolution-Penguin-Books-1990.pdf
establishment of the revolutionary,calendar in which the year of the execution of the king and the proclamation of the republic was counted as the year one.
[64]
(PDF) The Russian Revolution as Ideal and Practice Failures ...
The Russian Revolution as Ideal and Practice Failures, Legacies, and the Future of Revolution: Failures, Legacies, and the Future of Revolution. January 2020.Missing: reassessments | Show results with:reassessments
[65]
[PDF] The Bolshevik Revolution: One Hundred Years After
Claiming that the Bolshevik Revolution is a tragedy does neither mean that it was no revolution nor that it was flawed from the very beginning. To clarify its ...
[66]
October 1917: How it all went wrong (news article)
Oct 25, 2017 · Following the October Revolution of 1917, the Bolsheviks attempted a radical social and economic transformation of Russia. However, by the early ...
[67]
Thermidor? (Chapter 6) - The Anatomy of Revolution Revisited
The Bolshevik coup d'état of October 1917, by abruptly “injecting” socialism into a backward, peasant-dominated country whose “bourgeois” revolution had in some ...
[68]
Farewell to Revolution | Cultural Politics - Duke University Press
Jul 1, 2014 · If mass revolution and modernism are encapsulated in history, and there is no sense now of a new beginning, a Year One, is the gesture of ...