Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Hanfu Movement

The Hanfu Movement is a cultural revival effort primarily among young to restore and promote the wearing of hanfu, the traditional clothing styles of the Han ethnic group that prevailed from antiquity through the until supplanted by Manchu-influenced attire during the Qing era (1644–1912). Initiated in 2003 when resident Wang Letian publicly donned a Han-style , drawing both ridicule and inspiration, the movement coalesced through online forums and , evolving from a fringe into a widespread phenomenon emphasizing ethnic heritage, aesthetic expression, and resistance to historical cultural erasure under foreign dynastic rule. By the late 2010s, participation had surged to millions, fueled by platforms like Douyin and , with adherents organizing festivals, tea ceremonies, and daily wear to foster personal and collective identity tied to pre-Qing traditions. The movement's growth aligned with state encouragement of traditional culture under , including official endorsement of "Chinese National Costume Day" in 2018, though it has sparked debates over Han-centric nationalism versus broader multi-ethnic narratives, as well as international disputes, such as claims of appropriation in Korean origins and Western fashion incidents like the 2022 controversy. Economically, it has spawned a burgeoning industry, with the global hanfu market valued at approximately USD 1.5 billion in 2023 and projected to double by 2032, predominantly driven by female consumers (over 70%) seeking empowerment through historical garb. While celebrated for revitalizing tangible links to imperial-era craftsmanship and rituals, critics highlight its selective romanticization of dominance, potentially exacerbating ethnic tensions in China's diverse polity.

Definition and Core Elements

Definition of Hanfu

Hanfu (漢服), literally translating to "Han clothing," denotes the traditional attire historically worn by the ethnic group, the majority population of comprising approximately 91% of its citizens. This clothing system originated over 4,000 years ago and evolved through successive dynasties under Han rule, such as the (206 BCE–220 CE), (618–907 CE), (960–1279 CE), and Ming (1368–1644 CE), reflecting aesthetic, social, and ritual norms of those periods. Unlike later garments influenced by non-Han dynasties, Hanfu emphasizes layered ensembles without Manchu queue or tight-fitting elements imposed during the Qing era (1644–1912). Core structural features of Hanfu include the cross-collar (jiaoling youren) design, where the right overlaps the left, secured by ties or belts rather than buttons, promoting a loose, flowing . Garments typically consist of an upper jacket () paired with a skirt or ( or ), often topped by a (), with wide sleeves facilitating graceful movement and symbolizing and through fabric quality, colors, and . Natural materials like , , and predominate, dyed in earth tones or vibrant hues denoting status, with accessories such as sashes, hairpins, and pendants completing the ensemble. In contemporary usage, particularly within revival contexts, Hanfu excludes form-fitting styles like the (), which derives from Manchu changpao and accentuates the body with slits and narrow cuts, contrasting Hanfu's emphasis on voluminous layers and ethnic Han continuity. This distinction underscores Hanfu's role as a marker of pre-Qing , prioritizing historical fidelity over syncretic or foreign-influenced modifications.

Historical and Aesthetic Characteristics

Hanfu denotes the indigenous system of the , originating in the pre-Qin period and persisting until the Ming Dynasty's conclusion in 1644. Its earliest documented forms trace to the Dynasty (c. 1046–771 BCE), where the —a deep robe integrating (upper garment) and (lower skirt) via side seams—embodied Confucian ideals of wholeness and ritual propriety. This style emphasized flat, rectangular cutting patterns derived from weaving techniques, avoiding the curved tailoring of later Western influences. Over dynasties, Hanfu evolved while retaining core elements: parallel or cross-collars (jiazhao, right lapel over left), waist sashes (rather than buttons), and layered ensembles for status differentiation. Aesthetically, Hanfu prioritized harmony with natural forms, loose silhouettes, and flowing drapery, reflecting Taoist principles of fluidity and Confucian hierarchy through fabric quality, color, and ornamentation. Upper garments featured wide sleeves (often exceeding 1 meter in circumference) and high collars, while lower components included pleated skirts () for women or trousers () for men, secured by bands. Materials were predominantly in graduated weights—heavier for outer layers, lighter for linings—dyed per the Five Elements theory: black for (north), red for fire (south), yellow for earth (center), white for metal (west), green for wood (east), with exclusivity on bright yellow. Patterns incorporated auspicious motifs like clouds, dragons, or phoenixes via or , scaling complexity with rank; commoners favored plain or geometric designs. Historically, stylistic shifts mirrored socio-political changes: the (206 BCE–220 CE) refined into separate yi-shu ensembles for practicality; Tang (618–907 CE) introduced bolder, Hu-influenced volumes with ballooning sleeves and vibrant palettes amid cosmopolitan prosperity; (960–1279 CE) adopted narrower, straight-cut robes under Neo-Confucian restraint, emphasizing scholarly restraint; and Ming (1368–1644) revived Song austerity with formalized (parallel-collar robes) and aoqun (jacket-skirt sets), banning ostentatious elements to enforce moral order. These adaptations maintained causal ties to functions—e.g., wider sleeves for ceremonial gestures—while adapting to climatic and technological shifts, such as increased use post-Song for affordability.

Historical Background

Han Clothing Prior to Qing Conquest

Han clothing, referred to as , emerged during the pre-Qin period, with foundational forms developing in the (c. 1046–256 BCE), where the —a one-piece garment combining upper and lower clothing—established the deep, cross-collared silhouette characteristic of later styles. This attire emphasized loose fits, wide sleeves, and layered robes, reflecting Confucian ideals of ritual propriety and social hierarchy. During the Han dynasty (206 BCE–220 CE), clothing retained the cross-collar (right lapel over left) and straight silhouettes, often featuring silk fabrics in earth tones for commoners and brighter hues for elites, with accessories like sashes denoting status. Subsequent periods saw refinements: the Wei, Jin, and Southern-Northern dynasties (220–589 CE) introduced more flowing robes influenced by nomadic interactions, while the Sui and Tang dynasties (581–907 CE) favored open, elaborate designs, including the women's (short jacket over pleated skirt) with high waists and wide belts, incorporating Central Asian motifs amid cosmopolitan exchanges. The Song dynasty (960–1279 CE) shifted toward narrower sleeves and simpler, scholarly aesthetics, prioritizing functionality and Neo-Confucian restraint, though court attire maintained layered formality. Under Yuan Mongol rule (1271–1368 CE), Han styles persisted among the populace despite official adoption of Mongol elements like narrow robes, preserving ethnic distinctions. The Ming dynasty (1368–1644 CE) revived pure Han forms, mandating round collars for officials, embroidered dragons for emperors, and prohibiting foreign influences to assert cultural orthodoxy, with women's attire featuring aoqun (jacket and skirt) ensembles. This pre-Qing Han clothing system, codified by the 15th century, integrated ethical symbolism—such as red for joy and black for formality—until the Manchu conquest in 1644 disrupted its dominance.

Manchu Impositions Under Qing Rule

The , established by the Manchu conquest of the Ming empire in , sought to consolidate control over the majority through cultural mandates that targeted visible markers of identity, including hairstyle and dress. , acting for the young , issued the Tifayifu on July 21, 1645, requiring all adult men to shave the forehead and temples, retaining hair only at the back to form the Manchu (a single long braid), and to adopt Manchu riding attire in place of traditional robes. This symbolized submission to Manchu , with non-compliance punishable by ; the specified a ten-day for implementation, after which enforcement involved mass executions in resistant areas such as and Jiading in 1645, where tens of thousands perished. Manchu clothing, known as qizhuang, emphasized practicality for horseback warfare with close-fitting, one-piece robes (such as the changshan or magua jacket over trousers), right-side fastening, and narrow sleeves, contrasting sharply with the loose, cross-collared, wide-sleeved Hanfu prevalent under the Ming. The edict extended these impositions to civilians, officials, and the military, prohibiting Ming-style garments in official and public contexts to erode Han cultural distinctiveness and prevent covert resistance; Manchu bannermen were tasked with oversight, reporting violations that could result in beheading or enslavement. While the queue was enforced more uniformly across the empire—extending to southern regions by 1646—clothing mandates allowed limited private retention of Han styles initially, though official adoption of Manchu dress became mandatory for bureaucratic roles, fostering gradual hybridization but prioritizing Manchu forms in imperial decrees and sumptuary laws. These impositions reflected the Manchu strategy of ethnic dominance amid numerical minority status, with only about 2-3 million Manchus ruling over 100-150 million by mid-century; refusal rates were high in early conquest phases, contributing to demographic losses estimated in the millions from executions and uprisings tied to cultural coercion. Over subsequent reigns, such as Kangxi (1661-1722), exemptions were occasionally granted to ethnic minorities or monks, but the core policy persisted, embedding Manchu aesthetics into state symbolism and suppressing as a marker of pre-conquest until the dynasty's fall in 1912.

Resistance and Compromises During Qing Era

Upon entering in 1644 following the collapse of the , the Manchu Qing rulers issued decrees mandating that men shave the front of their heads and braid the remaining hair into a , while adopting Manchu-style , under the stark : "keep your hair and lose your head, or keep your head and lose your hair." This Tifayifu (剃发易服) policy, formalized in an on 28 June 1645, symbolized submission to Manchu authority and aimed to erase visible distinctions between conquerors and conquered. Non-compliance was punishable by death, resulting in widespread executions during the early conquest phase. Resistance was immediate and intense, particularly among Ming loyalists in southern and central China, where cultural identity tied to traditional hairstyles and attire represented continuity with heritage. In , province, local scholars and defied the order, fortifying the city and holding out for 81 days in 1645 before its fall, after which Qing forces massacred an estimated 70-80% of the population, numbering tens of thousands. Similar uprisings occurred in Jiading and other cities, contributing to the deaths of hundreds of thousands during suppressions; many officials and elites opted for rather than alter their appearance, viewing it as a betrayal of Confucian rites and ancestral customs. Armed holdouts in remote areas and among remnants prolonged defiance into the 1660s, though military superiority eventually enforced broad compliance. Han women faced less rigorous enforcement, as the primarily targeted men to break patriarchal symbols of resistance; they retained Ming-style attire—short jackets over long skirts—well into the Kangxi (1661–1722) and Yongzheng (1722–1735) reigns, preserving elements of in private and rural contexts. Official policy distinguished genders, allowing female continuity to avoid alienating the population further, though Manchu influences gradually seeped in via urban elites and intermarriage. Compromises arose from practical necessities and incomplete control: in rural hinterlands, enforcement waned, permitting hybrid garments blending Han loose robes with Manchu slits for mobility, while men concealed full hair under hats in informal settings at personal risk. By the mid-Qianlong era (1735–1796), the had normalized among men, but underlying resentment endured, manifesting in literary critiques and periodic revolts; fighters in 1851 explicitly severed queues as anti-Manchu defiance, underscoring the hairstyle's role as a enduring emblem of imposed otherness rather than . These dynamics reflected a coerced equilibrium, where overt revival remained suppressed to maintain dynastic stability.

Origins and Development Timeline

Precursors to the Modern Revival

Following the Xinhai Revolution and the establishment of the Republic of China in 1912, early efforts to revive traditional attire surfaced amid nationalist sentiments rejecting Qing-era Manchu customs. On March 5, 1912, provisional president issued an edict promoting the cutting of queues, a symbolic rejection of forced Manchu hairstyles imposed since the , which facilitated broader discussions on restoring pre-Qing clothing styles. In 1913, linguist and educator Qian Xuantong, appointed as Zhejiang's Minister of Education, publicly donned the —a deep-cross-collared robe—and a black gauze cap during official duties, advocating for its adoption as national dress through his publication "A Study on Shenyi Cap and Outfit." This act drew from precedents and aimed to reassert Han ethnic identity, though it elicited mixed public reactions ranging from curiosity to ridicule. During Yuan Shikai's short-lived Hongxian Empire from 1915 to 1916, imperial court ceremonies featured Ming-style Han robes to evoke historical legitimacy and distance from Manchu traditions, with Yuan himself appearing in such attire for rituals like celestial worship. These initiatives, however, faltered due to competing priorities of Western-style modernization, the rise of the changshan and suits as practical alternatives, and insufficient institutional support, leading to their marginalization by the 1920s May Fourth Movement's emphasis on scientific and democratic reforms over traditional aesthetics. Sporadic intellectual advocacy persisted among revolutionaries and scholars, but no sustained movement materialized until online cultural discussions in the late and early .

Emergence in the 2000s

The Hanfu movement crystallized in 2003 with the public appearance of Wang Letian, an electrical engineer from , province, who on November 22 wore a self-made —a traditional Hanfu style consisting of a long robe with crossed collar and right-side fastening—in urban streets, the first such documented instance in contemporary after over three centuries of absence from everyday wear. This act, inspired by online discussions on platforms like the Hanwang forum, symbolized a deliberate effort to revive pre-Qing dynasty Han ethnic attire amid growing interest in historical authenticity. Wang's initiative stemmed from personal research into ancient texts and patterns, reflecting a response to perceived cultural discontinuities imposed during the Qing era. Photographs of Wang's outing circulated rapidly through nascent forums, catching the eye of Zhang Congxing, a journalist for Singapore's newspaper, who interviewed him and published a feature that amplified awareness both domestically and abroad. The article, appearing in late , is credited with catalyzing broader participation by connecting isolated enthusiasts and prompting recreations of garments from dynastic periods like the , , and . This media exposure intersected with China's expanding online infrastructure, where forums and blogs facilitated pattern-sharing, sewing tutorials, and debates on stylistic fidelity, fostering a among urban youth educated in and . By the mid-2000s, the movement remained niche, confined largely to sporadic public outings and virtual communities numbering in the low thousands, driven by motivations to reclaim identity suppressed under Manchu rule rather than commercial or institutional backing. Early adherents, often college students or professionals, organized informal gatherings and advocated for 's ritual and ethical underpinnings, viewing it as a counter to Westernized modern dress and a assertion of cultural continuity in post-reform China's economic ascent. These foundations laid the groundwork for subsequent expansion, with November 22 retrospectively designated as Hanfu Day to commemorate Wang's pioneering step.

Expansion in the 2010s

During the , the movement transitioned from a primarily online to a more visible public phenomenon, fueled by platforms such as and emerging short-video apps like Douyin. Enthusiasts leveraged these tools for sharing historical research, tutorials, and event promotions, which accelerated awareness among urban youth. Tieba's Hanfu forum saw user growth of approximately 100,000 annually from 2011 onward, fostering communities that organized local gatherings and costume-making workshops. A pivotal event was the inaugural Xitang Hanfu Culture Week in November 2013, held in the ancient town of Xitang, Province, and initiated by Taiwanese lyricist Fang Wenshan. This annual festival featured parades, performances, and educational sessions on Han clothing styles, drawing thousands and establishing a model for regional Hanfu celebrations that blended tourism with cultural revival. Subsequent years saw similar events proliferate, including homage activities and poetry recitals tied to traditional festivals. By the latter half of the decade, participation surged, with enthusiasts reaching 2 million in 2018, doubling from the previous year according to surveys by community accounts like Hanfu Zixun on . The market reflected this momentum: national consumers exceeded 2 million by 2019, supporting an industry valued at about 1.09 billion , predominantly in affordable garments priced 100-300 that captured over 60% of sales. initiatives, such as the Communist League's designation of a National Costume Day in 2017, further encouraged public engagement by promoting ethnic attire sharing online, aligning with broader efforts to emphasize traditional values.

Mainstream Growth in the 2020s

The movement experienced accelerated mainstream adoption in during the , driven by rising enthusiast participation and commercial expansion. By 2022, the number of Hanfu wearers surpassed 10.16 million, up from approximately 6 million in 2021, reflecting a year-over-year increase of over 69%. Among , the enthusiast base nearly doubled from 3.56 million in 2019, fueled by amplification and pursuits. The domestic market reached 12.54 billion RMB in 2022, growing 23.4% from the previous year, with revenue projected to expand further amid sustained demand. Public visibility surged through organized events and festivals, embedding in everyday and celebratory contexts. During the 2024 Spring Festival, -clad participants flocked to venues like Shanghai's for lantern fairs, turning traditional sites into focal points for the attire. Annual gatherings, such as culture weeks in historic towns, drew thousands, promoting experiential tourism and communal rituals. In educational settings, schools and universities began integrating into curricula and ceremonies, with students donning it for cultural appreciation activities by the mid-2020s. Urban normalization advanced, particularly in cities like , where appeared in street fashion blended with contemporary styling, signaling broader societal acceptance beyond niche circles. This growth coincided with economic prosperity enabling cultural pursuits, though participation remained concentrated among in tier-1 and tier-2 cities, comprising about 59% of consumers from top urban areas as of 2023. Market analyses indicate sustained trajectory, with global revenue valued at 1.1 billion USD in 2024 and forecasted to reach 3.2 billion USD by 2033 at a 12.8% CAGR.

Cultural and Social Dimensions

Revival of Ethical-Ritual Traditions

The Hanfu movement incorporates the revival of ethical-ritual traditions by linking attire to Confucian (ritual propriety), which historically prescribed garments to delineate social roles, enforce , and cultivate moral virtues such as and self-restraint. Traditional Hanfu designs, including layered robes and wide sleeves that allowed hands to be concealed, symbolized dignity, reserve, and ethical composure, aligning with Confucian ideals of harmonious conduct and moral refinement. In contemporary practice, movement participants wear specific variants for rituals like ancestral worship, weddings, and seasonal sacrifices, aiming to restore these proprieties amid perceptions of ethical erosion in urbanized society. Revival efforts extend to organized festivals and educational programs that integrate with ritual education. Annual events such as Hanfu Day and the National Silk and Festival feature ceremonial processions, etiquette demonstrations, and "Hanfu Nights" where participants enact historical rites, fostering communal adherence to Confucian norms of propriety and . In schools, initiatives like themed days or curricula introduce alongside lessons on dynastic rituals, with students learning to perform bows, seating arrangements, and garment adjustments as embodied ethical training. These activities draw from Confucian texts like the , which outlined clothing's role in ritual systems, adapting them to promote virtues in daily interactions. Scholars such as Wang Xianchong emphasize Hanfu's inherent ceremonial attributes, noting that garments like the —a one-piece evoking and square imagery—symbolize disciplined guidance and societal order, encouraging wearers to internalize ethical discipline through aesthetic and postural cues. Movement advocates argue this revival counters modern by reinstating as a framework for moral education, with online communities and local societies developing protocols for Hanfu-appropriate behaviors in public spaces. Empirical participation data, including over 9 million consumers by 2023, indicates growing adoption in contexts, though critics question its depth amid commercialization.

Social Value and Identity Affirmation

The Hanfu movement enables participants to affirm their ethnic identity as by donning attire symbolizing pre-Qing imperial traditions, thereby fostering a tangible connection to ancestral heritage and countering perceived cultural discontinuities from historical foreign impositions. Practitioners report deriving psychological fulfillment from this embodiment, viewing as a medium for existential and cultural continuity in a modernizing . This identity affirmation often manifests in grassroots gatherings, such as street performances and festivals, where wearers collectively reenact rituals, reinforcing shared values like and hierarchical etiquette derived from Confucian principles. Socially, the movement cultivates communal bonds among diverse age groups, particularly youth and women, who constitute a majority of adherents, by providing platforms for social interaction outside state-sanctioned narratives. Events like Hanfu Days, observed annually since the early , draw thousands to public spaces in cities such as and , promoting interpersonal networks based on mutual cultural recognition rather than . This has measurable impacts, including enhanced and cultural confidence among participants, as evidenced by surveys linking Hanfu engagement to stronger national identification amid pressures. Critically, the movement's emphasis on Han-centric symbolism has been interpreted as a form of soft , redirecting ethnic pride toward broader Chinese unity while subtly resisting Western dominance. Sources attribute this to post-2000s online forums where initial resistance to "Manchufied" modern dress evolved into affirmative projects, though empirical data underscores voluntary participation driven by intrinsic over . In multi-ethnic contexts, it affirms Han majority without explicit exclusion, aligning with state discourses on harmonious , yet grounded in verifiable revival of artifacts from , , and Ming eras.

Economic and Broader Influence

Market Expansion and Commercialization

The commercialization of accelerated in the and gained momentum in the , transforming a niche cultural revival into a structured industry supported by platforms, specialized manufacturers, and retail expansion. Major producers include Mei Te Er Clothing, Sijin Clothing, and Chengmeng Industrial, which have scaled production to meet rising demand through online marketplaces like and . By 2023, the global market—predominantly driven by Chinese consumption—was valued at approximately USD 1.5 billion, with projections estimating growth to USD 3.8 billion by 2032 at a (CAGR) of about 11%. In , the domestic market reached 12.54 billion yuan (approximately USD 1.8 billion) in 2022, reflecting a 23.4% year-on-year increase, fueled by promotion and seasonal events such as festivals. Annual sales surpassed 5 billion RMB by the mid-2020s, supported by a five-year CAGR of around 25%, with women's apparel comprising over 60% of total revenue due to broader appeal in everyday and ceremonial wear. Brands like Minghuatang, Hankesilu, and Zhiyuji have commercialized the sector by offering standardized designs, accessories, and options, expanding from digital sales to offline channels including pop-up shops and flagship stores in urban centers. Consumer purchasing patterns underscore market maturity, with 47.8% of buyers in acquiring 1–2 times per quarter and 27.8% biannually, often through integrated ecosystems combining clothing, jewelry, and experiential services like photography studios. This expansion has spurred , with industry M&A activity totaling around USD 200 million over the past three years, enabling larger firms to consolidate supply chains and innovate in fabric technology for affordability and durability. Economic ripple effects include job creation in apparel and , as -themed districts in cities like attract visitors, though precise employment figures remain undocumented in available industry analyses.

Impact on Fashion and Global Perceptions

The Hanfu movement has significantly influenced contemporary fashion by reviving traditional silhouettes and motifs, leading to the emergence of neo-Hanfu styles that blend historical aesthetics with modern functionality. Designers have incorporated elements such as flowing robes, layered garments, and intricate embroidery from , , and Ming dynasties into everyday apparel, fostering trends like the Neo-Chinese style that reinterprets heritage for urban lifestyles. This integration has emphasized comfort through adaptations like simplified skirts and modern fabrics, enabling Hanfu variants to transition from ceremonial wear to casual street fashion. Market dynamics underscore this fashion impact, with the Hanfu sector expanding rapidly due to consumer demand for culturally resonant clothing; the global market reached approximately USD 1.2 billion in 2024, projected to grow to USD 2.8 billion by 2033 at a of over 10%. In China, annual sales exceed 5 billion RMB, reflecting a 25% CAGR over the past five years, driven by platforms and brand innovations that mass-produce accessible designs using contemporary manufacturing techniques. Globally, the movement shapes perceptions of as a vibrant, enduring rather than static , serving as a for through digital influencers and cultural exports. Hanfu's visibility at international events and among communities promotes appreciation for pre-modern , countering Western-dominated narratives with assertive displays of ethnic . However, its rise elicits mixed views, with some international observers interpreting it as a nationalist resurgence amid China's geopolitical , though empirical adoption metrics—such as growing online searches and events—indicate genuine cultural revival influencing global trendsetters.

Controversies and Critical Perspectives

Debates on Authenticity and Innovation

Within the Hanfu movement, a central contention revolves around the definition of , pitting purists—who prioritize strict adherence to historical —against innovators who advocate for adaptations to enhance wearability and contemporary appeal. Purists, aligned with what scholars term the "reversionary camp," insist on reconstructing Hanfu based on archaeological relics, ancient portraits such as the Daoliantu, and textual descriptions of dressing codes from rites, arguing that deviations undermine cultural legitimacy and invite appropriation by other traditions, as seen in disputes over Korean hanbok influences in 2020. This stance draws from limited but verifiable historical records spanning over 4,000 years, though gaps in documentation—exacerbated by the attire's suppression for approximately 400 years following the —necessitate evidence-based inference rather than invention. In contrast, reformists and designers contend that rigid reconstruction renders Hanfu impractical for modern life, favoring innovations like simplified silhouettes (e.g., A-, X-, or H-shapes for better mobility), synthetic fabrics over for affordability, and blended patterns incorporating floral or animal motifs to align with current aesthetic preferences. They invoke , noting historical precedents of —such as climatic adjustments in Ming-era designs—and pragmatic philosophies akin to Deng Xiaoping's emphasis on functionality over , positing that and adoption outweigh purist ideals in reviving a dormant . Critics of these changes, including some academics, highlight insufficient historical in many recreations, where modern versions often omit dynastic-specific markers like social hierarchies or regional variations, prioritizing visual allure over evidentiary precision. These debates extend to structural elements, with purists decrying alterations to traditional cross-collar robes or layered ensembles as dilutions of ethnic essence, while innovators argue such flexibility prevents Hanfu from remaining confined to museums or ceremonial use, as evidenced by its integration into and daily since the movement's origins in the early . Empirical challenges include the of intact artifacts, compelling both sides to rely on interpretive sources like murals, yet reformists' market-driven outputs—projected to grow the industry beyond RMB 10 billion by —demonstrate 's role in sustaining interest amid incomplete historical data. Ultimately, the tension reflects broader causal dynamics: purism safeguards against anachronistic fantasy, but unchecked innovation risks commodifying into generic apparel disconnected from its ritualistic roots.

Accusations of Nationalism and Responses

Critics of the Hanfu movement have accused it of fostering ethnic nationalism, arguing that its emphasis on pre-Qing dynasty attire promotes a Han-centric that marginalizes China's ethnic minorities. Kevin Carrico, in observations from 2018, described many participants as nationalists seeking the "thrill" of traditional , with the movement's focus on heritage sometimes spilling into and patronizing attitudes toward non-Han groups, such as or . This critique posits that reviving revives narratives of historical victimhood under Manchu Qing rule, potentially fueling ethnic resentments in a multi-ethnic where the officially promotes unity under a broader . Chinese intellectual Zhang Xian has further criticized as a "fictitious totem" that reveres orthodoxy, severing emotional ties to the inclusive national fabric by idealizing an ethnocentric past over modern . Such accusations gained traction amid reports of enthusiasts endorsing theories about a supposed Manchu resurgence, framing the movement within a binary of "heroic resistance" against "barbaric" outer influences, which some analysts link to broader supremacist rhetoric. These concerns are amplified by the movement's alignment with state-sanctioned cultural revivalism post-2012, where events have intersected with patriotic displays, raising fears of instrumentalized ethnic pride under centralized authority. Proponents respond by characterizing the movement as a benign form of that strengthens national cohesion without ultranationalist excess, emphasizing its role in restoring historical pride amid globalization's cultural erosion. Academic analyses describe revival as "soft "—assertive yet de-ethnicized—where participants prioritize aesthetic and revival over political exclusion, with public perception viewing it as recreational rather than aggressively ideological. Advocates argue that moderate , as embodied in , counters historical self-abasement imposed by 20th-century , fostering a "lost national spirit" that unifies rather than divides, evidenced by its integration into mainstream events like school uniforms and festivals without widespread ethnic backlash. In defense, movement figures and scholars contend that accusations overlook empirical participation data, where Hanfu wearers—predominantly urban youth—focus on personal identity affirmation and ethical traditions over ethnic supremacy, with surveys indicating broad appeal as a symbol of civilizational continuity rather than Han exclusivity. They rebut claims by highlighting inclusive adaptations, such as minority groups adopting stylized Hanfu elements, and note that state endorsement since the mid-2010s has domesticated the practice into patriotic education, mitigating radical fringes. Overall, responses frame the as empirically constructive for cultural resilience, with any nationalist undertones seen as a natural byproduct of reclaiming tangible heritage in a historically defined by Han-majority continuity.

Domestic and International Criticisms

Domestically, critics within China have argued that the Hanfu movement promotes ethnic Han chauvinism, potentially exacerbating tensions with the country's non-Han minorities by emphasizing a singular Han cultural identity over the multi-ethnic composition of the People's Republic. This perspective gained traction in discussions around the movement's early 2000s origins, where proponents' focus on pre-Qing dynasty attire was interpreted by some as a subtle rejection of Manchu-influenced historical legacies, fostering patronizing attitudes toward groups like Uyghurs, Tibetans, and Mongols. Additional domestic concerns include the practicality of Hanfu for contemporary lifestyles, with detractors pointing to its layered designs and flowing sleeves as ill-suited for urban work environments, public transport, or physical activities, leading to perceptions of it as an escapist romanticization of imperial-era hierarchies rather than a viable modern alternative. Internationally, the movement has faced scrutiny from and scholars who frame it as a manifestation of state-aligned under the , potentially signaling a broader shift toward ethnocentric policies that prioritize traditions amid rising global tensions. Outlets have highlighted instances where enthusiasts expressed solidarity with Beijing's positions on issues like Hong Kong's 2019 protests, interpreting this as evidence of the movement's alignment with authoritarian narratives rather than organic cultural expression. Academic analyses, often from institutions critical of China's governance, have cautioned that such revivals could legitimize narratives of historical grievance and cultural superiority, drawing parallels to other nationalist resurgences but attributing them to domestic political incentives over sentiment. These views, while citing empirical observations of movement , reflect a pattern in commentary where enthusiasm for traditional elements is frequently contextualized through lenses skeptical of Beijing's , potentially overlooking the movement's decentralized origins predating intensified state endorsement in the 2010s.

Empirical Defenses and Achievements

The Hanfu movement has achieved measurable economic expansion, with the domestic market reaching 14.47 billion in 2023, up from 1.09 billion in 2019, driven by rising consumer demand among demographics. Forecasts project growth to 24.18 billion by 2027, supported by over 2,000 Hanfu societies and production clusters in areas like Caoxian county, which have generated local and development. This reflects successful adaptation of traditional designs to modern , including platforms where Hanfu sales have contributed to broader cultural product sectors. Participation metrics underscore social achievements, as Hanfu enthusiasts grew from 2 million in to over 10.2 million customers by 2022, with events like the Xitang Hanfu Cultural Festival drawing more than 150,000 attendees annually since . Attendance at Hanfu-related activities reportedly increased by over 40% from 2019 to 2021, per data, indicating mobilization without reliance on state mandates. Empirical surveys link Hanfu adoption to heightened cultural identification, with consumers reporting positive effects on purchase intentions through perceived and existential value. Defenses of the movement against charges of parochial are bolstered by studies showing its role in fostering moderate identity cohesion and cultural revival, with participants experiencing enhanced via authentic self-expression in and daily contexts. Affective analyses reveal Hanfu practices as a de-ethnicized vehicle for nationalism, promoting without evidence of intergroup conflict or in quantitative participant data. These outcomes counter critiques by demonstrating tangible benefits in nostalgia-driven consumption and subcultural mainstreaming, transitioning Hanfu from niche to a symbol of youthful cultural continuity.

References

  1. [1]
    Full article: Chinese Women in Hanfu: A Gendered Subject Narrative ...
    May 6, 2025 · While the controversy stemming from the APEC meeting that ignited the Hanfu revival movement was primarily driven by identity concerns ...Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  2. [2]
    Hanfu Movement Sweeps China in Revival of Traditional Culture | BoF
    Sep 20, 2019 · Hanfu is based on the idea of donning costumes worn in bygone eras by China's dominant Han ethnicity. Some of the most popular styles are from the Ming, Song ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
  3. [3]
    Hanfu Market Report | Global Forecast From 2025 To 2033
    The global Hanfu market size, valued at approximately USD 1.5 billion in 2023, is projected to reach around USD 3.8 billion by 2032, growing at an impressive ...
  4. [4]
  5. [5]
    4 Traditional Chinese Clothing and Dress: Hanfu, Qipao...
    the majority of Chinese are of Han ethnicity) is the oldest of China's traditional clothes. Legend traces it back to over 4,000 ...
  6. [6]
    Traditional Han Chinese Clothing, Hanfu - Travel China Guide
    Aug 20, 2025 · Hanfu, a national formal wear, takes its name from the times of the Han Dynasty, and now long out of fashion. A complete set of Hanfu, ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  7. [7]
    Introduction to Traditional Chinese Clothing
    Oct 29, 2024 · Characteristics of Han clothing include very wide sleeves and a loose layered look, with clothes usually consisting of two or three garments, ...Clothing throughout the major... · Han dynasty · Traditional clothing of other...
  8. [8]
    Everything you need to know about traditional Chinese clothing
    Dec 3, 2023 · The word hanfu or hán fú (汉服) literally means “Han ethnicity clothing.” The Han ethnicity is one of more than 50 different ethnic groups ...
  9. [9]
    Hanfu Guide: Explore Styles, History & Where to Wear It in China
    May 12, 2025 · The history of Hanfu stretches back over three millennia, with its origins dating back to the Shang Dynasty (1600–1046 BC). Throughout ...
  10. [10]
  11. [11]
    The history and revival of ancient Chinese hanfu - Infographics
    Nov 17, 2023 · The wearing of ancient Chinese clothing, known as hanfu, has gone rapidly from a niche hobby to a nationwide phenomenon in recent years.
  12. [12]
    Ancient clothing embodies Chinese aesthetics
    Aug 13, 2020 · Ancient Chinese clothing aesthetics included the shenyi's grace, loose fit, Taoist philosophy, and the Five Elements color theory, emphasizing ...
  13. [13]
    An Exploration of the Differences between Chinese and Western ...
    Jun 15, 2022 · This study analyzes the differences in aesthetic standards in Chinese and Western clothing cultures, as well as the differences between Chinese and Western ...
  14. [14]
    [PDF] KANSEI EVALUATION OF HANFU STYLE DIVERSITIES BASED ON ...
    As a result, Hanfu costumes expressed diverse styles in their historical evolution, which included not only the characteristics of solemnity, humility, and ...
  15. [15]
    The ideological background of ancient Chinese clothing culture
    1 Origin of clothing culture - Pre-Qin period. Pre-Qin refers to the historical period before the establishment of the Qin Dynasty (221 BC, 21st century BC).
  16. [16]
    Historical changes of Chinese costumes from the perspective of ...
    Dec 30, 2022 · After the Zhou dynasty, the costume patterns gradually became neat, from abstract to realistic, and there was also a combination of abstract and ...
  17. [17]
    Hanfu — Traditional Clothing of the Chinese Han Majority
    In recent years, when Chinese people talk about Hanfu, they usually mean a long flowing robe with loose sleeves and a belt at the waist. However, Hanfu is a ...
  18. [18]
    Chinese Clothing Through Dynasties: A Traveler's Guide
    May 14, 2025 · The Ming Dynasty saw a revival of Han Chinese traditions, including clothing. Hanfu was reinstated as the official dress, and Mongol styles were ...
  19. [19]
  20. [20]
    The Manchu queue: One hairstyle to rule them all - The China Project
    Jul 21, 2021 · A year later, in June 1645, a revised order required all Chinese in the military to adapt the queue. This was seen as a practical matter, ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
  21. [21]
    Queue | Illustrating Chinese Exclusion
    Apr 1, 2014 · By 1645 the mandate read that “every Chinese man must shave his forehead and begin to grow the queue within ten days or face execution.” The ...
  22. [22]
    [PDF] Control, Allegiance, and Shame in Male Qing Dynasty Hairstyles
    Jan 19, 2022 · This thesis looks at the rise and fall of the Qing queue in Manchu occupied China. ... 20 This 1644 Manchu order, coming from a non-Han group, was ...<|separator|>
  23. [23]
    Traditional Chinese Clothing - People | HowStuffWorks
    Jul 25, 2011 · The Manchu preferred close-fitting styles as opposed to the loose, flowing attire that had been popular. They also imposed rules that were meant ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  24. [24]
    The Brief History of Qing Dynasty Clothing - Newhanfu
    May 22, 2020 · The Qing Dynasty was the last feudal dynasty in China's history, was a time a time of Manchurian and Chinese cultural fusion, especially costume ...
  25. [25]
    [PDF] THE MANCHU QUEUE: A COMPLEX SYMBOL IN CHINESE ...
    May 4, 2022 · The reaction of the population a mere century after the queue edict of the Qing in 1645 demonstrates an already changing perspective on the ...
  26. [26]
    Queue Edict | PDF | Qing Dynasty | Asian Royal Families - Scribd
    The second document describes the 80-day siege of Jiangyin city in 1645 after the local scholars and militia resisted the hair-cutting order, culminating in the ...
  27. [27]
    Body Representations of the Ethnic Minorities on China's ... - jstor
    Likewise, when the Manchu tonsure and costumes were imposed upon Han Chinese males by the Qing con quers, there was a huge and long-lasting resistance.
  28. [28]
    Han Women's Style | Chinese Traditional Dress - Online Exhibitions
    They were permitted to wear their own traditional garments: a coat with skirts. On formal occasions, Han women wore a half length coat or jacket accompanied by ...
  29. [29]
    Beauties under Manchu Rule: Chinese Female Attire of the Early ...
    At the beginning of the dynasty, the Manchu government issued an edict which ordered the populace to change their a ire and hair treatment to a Manchu manner. 3 ...Missing: adoption era
  30. [30]
    Hanfu Movement of the Republican Era
    Nov 9, 2012 · In regards to Hanfu in the Republican era (1911-1949), two major essays are readily available in Chinese, one in academia and one outside.
  31. [31]
  32. [32]
    Hanfu craze: Gen Z revives traditional clothing - Global Times
    Nov 13, 2024 · Enthusiasts often consider 2003 as the year Hanfu began its resurgence, sparked by an ordinary power plant worker who wore Hanfu on the streets ...
  33. [33]
    Hanfu Festival: Hanfu Parade Day on November 22 - Newhanfu
    Nov 22, 2019 · At noon on November 22, 2003, Wang Letian, a power worker, dressed in Hanfu, which disappeared in daily life for 358 years, appeared on the street.
  34. [34]
    When Traditional Hanfu Dress Comes to Contemporary Life
    May 17, 2023 · Wang Letian was introduced to hanfu culture through forums Han Wang, and around 2003, the first hanfu enthusiasts gathered around Han Wang ...
  35. [35]
    A Brief of Actual Results from Chinese Culture Renaissance Mvt.
    Oct 1, 2008 · November 21, 2003: Wang Letian, a Zhengzhou local electical engineer, wears hanfu in public, marking the first instance of Hanfu worn in non ...
  36. [36]
    China's Hanfu Revival - Verve Magazine
    Apr 29, 2022 · While the history of the style can be traced back more than 2,000 years, it now more commonly references the era between 618 to 1644 – the ...
  37. [37]
    汉服复兴之路 History of Hanfu Revival Movement - Tumblr
    On November 22, 2003, an electric engineer by the name of Wang Letian (王乐天) strode through the streets of Deng Zhou wearing a Quju robe . This was the first ...
  38. [38]
    The History of Hanfu Design and Its Influence Today
    Mar 13, 2023 · The Hanfu Movement​​ Wang Letian of Zhengzhou, China, is credited with the resurgence of Hanfu, as he played a significant role in repopularizing ...
  39. [39]
    Wearing pride: Centuries-old Chinese fashion is making a comeback
    Oct 17, 2019 · The movement, which started in the early 2000s as a fringe subculture on online forums and websites, has now stepped out onto the streets.
  40. [40]
    Why young Chinese are sporting 1,800-year-old fashions
    Jan 12, 2019 · Since the Hanfu movement emerged in the early 2000s, some members have framed it as a way to restore Han customs suppressed by ethnic Manchu ...
  41. [41]
  42. [42]
    [PDF] Research on the Hanfu Movement in New Media Environment
    From the decade of 2011 to 2021, the number of Hanfu bar users grew at an average size of about 100,000 a year.
  43. [43]
    2013 Chinese Han Clothing Cultural Week in Xitang - China Daily
    Nov 5, 2013 · 2013 Chinese Han Clothing Cultural Week kicks off in Xitang, an ancient town in East China's Zhejiang province on Nov 1, 2013.
  44. [44]
    Hanfu market grows across China - Chinadaily.com.cn
    Sep 4, 2019 · Statistics from a domestic e-commerce platform showed that hanfu priced at 100-300 yuan took more than 60 percent in market share last year, ...Missing: 2010-2019 | Show results with:2010-2019
  45. [45]
    The Revival of Hanfu: Where Fashion Meets Cultural Renaissance
    Dec 24, 2024 · As of 2022, over 10.16 million people have embraced the art of wearing hanfu, a substantial increase from the 6 million of the previous year.Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
  46. [46]
    China Fashion Heritage: Guochao, Hanfu & Neo-Chinese Style
    Aug 8, 2025 · Hanfu's popularity has seen significant growth, with enthusiasts, particularly among Gen Z, having nearly doubled from 3.56 million in 2019 to ...
  47. [47]
    Authentic well-being in the third space among Hanfu-wearing ...
    This study intends to investigate the authenticity well-being of Hanfu-wearing Chinese tourists. The study integrates mixed qualitative methodologies.
  48. [48]
    For some Spring Festival revelers in China, traditional attire adds an ...
    Feb 12, 2024 · For instance, Yu Garden in Shanghai, which hosts a 40-day Spring Festival lantern fair, has become a popular destination for Hanfu fans. The ...Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
  49. [49]
    5 Important Hanfu Festivals That Hanfu Lover Must Konw - Newhanfu
    Jan 14, 2022 · Xitang Hanfu Culture Week (西唐汉服文化周) is a Hanfu cultural event initiated by Fang Wenshan, with the fundamental purpose of promoting and ...
  50. [50]
    Hanfu in Modern Education: Integrating Traditional Attire into School ...
    Mar 12, 2025 · By integrating Hanfu into modern education, schools can provide students with a deeper appreciation of history, culture, and artistry.Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
  51. [51]
  52. [52]
    Hanfu Market Size, Market Share, Development & Forecast 2033
    Rating 4.4 (62) Hanfu market revenue was valued at USD 1.1 Billion in 2024 and is estimated to reach USD 3.2 Billion by 2033, growing at a CAGR of 12.8% from 2026 to 2033.
  53. [53]
    Wearing History: How Hanfu Reshapes Fashion and Identity
    Jul 31, 2025 · These sleeves weren't merely decorative; their generous cut, allowing hands to be tucked inside, symbolized Confucian ideals of dignity, reserve ...
  54. [54]
    The Revival of Hanfu: Cultural Confidence and Aesthetic Pursuits of ...
    Dec 27, 2024 · Wang highlights how Hanfu's design deliberately integrates elements that promote moral refinement and etiquette. For example, the shenyi, which ...
  55. [55]
  56. [56]
    [PDF] Constructing Modern Ethnic Myth: A Cultural Analysis of the Hanfu ...
    The Hanfu movement has gained in popularity exactly in these ten years due to the emergence of online social networking.
  57. [57]
    the hanfu movement and intangible cultural heritage - Academia.edu
    The so-called "Hanfu Movement" is an emerging transnational youth culture which reinterprets hanfu as the traditional costume of Han Chinese.
  58. [58]
    Soft nationalism in China: The case of Hanfu style - Sage Journals
    Apr 30, 2025 · Hanfu style, for many participants, is associated with national 'cultural rejuvenation' (Zhao, 2018) and understood as 'one facet of the larger ...
  59. [59]
    Hanfu performance and “Embodied Connection” in the Chinese ...
    Jan 11, 2025 · Thus, Hanfu is a cultural symbol embedded with clear nationalist (nationalism) genes. Fan & Ip through tracing the origins of Hanfu and ...
  60. [60]
    An Analysis based on the Hanfu Movement
    May 17, 2023 · Initially, some Hanfu activists attempted to use Hanfu to restore the core status of the Han nation in China. Later, Hanfu became more popular ...
  61. [61]
    Factors Affecting Purchase Intention of Hanfu: Considering Product ...
    Aug 19, 2023 · The results demonstrate that consumers' identification with Hanfu and cultural motivation positively influence object-based and existential authenticity, as ...
  62. [62]
    Hanfu Revival: Cultural Nationalism within CCP Discourse
    Mar 20, 2025 · This blog article argues that the Hanfu revival movement promotes a cultural nationalist identity and is integrated into the mainstream nationalist discourse.
  63. [63]
    (PDF) Modern Chinese Nationalism and the Han Nation
    Aug 6, 2025 · This paper argues that moderate nationalism is conducive to the cohesion of Chinese national identity and the overall cultural revival of modern China.Missing: sources | Show results with:sources
  64. [64]
    [PDF] Hanfu and the Legitimization of Nationalism in Post-2013 China
    Mar 19, 2025 · This thesis suggests that the Hanfu is a Han-Chinese ethno-cultural symbol which incurs pride and nationalist sentiment in the Han-people. In ...
  65. [65]
    Han Fu Market Growing Demands [2022], Analysis By New Entrants ...
    Aug 29, 2022 · The global major manufacturers of Han Fu include Suzhou Mei Te Er Clothing, Chongqing Sijin Clothing, Hangzhou Chengmeng Industrial, ...
  66. [66]
    Traditional Hanfu XX CAGR Growth Analysis 2025-2033
    Rating 4.8 (1,980) Mar 26, 2025 · While precise market size figures for 2025 are unavailable, a reasonable estimate, considering the growth trajectory of similar apparel markets ...Missing: Movement | Show results with:Movement
  67. [67]
    United States Hanfu Market Key Highlights, Investment-Oriented ...
    Sep 1, 2025 · Segment growth is strongest in women's Hanfu apparel, accounting for over 60% of total sales in 2024, attributed to expanding e-commerce ...
  68. [68]
    Women Hanfu 2025 Trends and Forecasts 2033: Analyzing Growth ...
    Rating 4.8 (1,980) May 26, 2025 · This market, estimated at $500 million in 2025, is projected to exhibit a Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of 15% from 2025 to 2033.Missing: Movement | Show results with:Movement
  69. [69]
    Hanfu Charting Growth Trajectories: Analysis and Forecasts 2025 ...
    In stock Rating 4.8 (1,980) Jun 3, 2025 · Let's assume a 2025 market size of $500 million USD, growing at a Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of 15% between 2025 and 2033. This reflects ...Missing: Movement | Show results with:Movement
  70. [70]
    China's Hanfu Industry Consumer Analysis - 2025 - Newhanfu
    Apr 7, 2025 · China's Hanfu Industry Consumer Analysis · 48.5% own 1–3 sets (newcomers exploring Hanfu); · 26.3% own 4–6 sets (established enthusiasts); · 12.7% ...<|separator|>
  71. [71]
    Consumer Behavior and Traditional Hanfu Trends
    Rating 4.8 (1,980) Mar 26, 2025 · The market size is estimated to be USD XXX million as of 2022. 5. What are some drivers contributing to market growth? N/A. 6.Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
  72. [72]
    Hanfu Market Size, Share, Scope, Trends, Growth & Forecast
    Rating 4.6 (46) Hanfu Market size is growing at a moderate pace with substantial growth rates over the last few years and is estimated that the market will grow significantly ...
  73. [73]
    China's Love Of Hanfu Is Here To Stay - Jing Daily
    With the mainland's Hanfu market expected to reach 1.85 billion (12.54 billion RMB) in 2022 and to continue to swell to an impressive 2.82 billion (19.11 ...
  74. [74]
    How Hanfu is Shaping Modern Trends in 2024 - Newhanfu
    Mar 30, 2025 · As Hanfu becomes more integrated into daily life, comfort and functionality have become key considerations. Modern Mamianqun designs are no ...
  75. [75]
    Hanfu Market Size, Growth & Forecast Report - 2033
    Feb 26, 2025 · The global Hanfu market was valued at approximately USD 1.2 billion in 2024 and is anticipated to reach USD 2.8 billion by 2033, ...
  76. [76]
    Putting China's Traditional Hanfu on the World Stage - WWD
    Nov 25, 2020 · A resurgence of traditional culture and a fast-growing overseas population fuel a new chapter for Han Chinese ethnic clothing.<|separator|>
  77. [77]
    China's Soft Power Play: Can Fashion and Digital Influencers ...
    Mar 7, 2025 · China is experimenting with a new formula for soft power by integrating fashion, digital influencers, and lifestyle branding.
  78. [78]
    How Traditional Chinese Fashion Shapes Global Perceptions
    Jul 15, 2025 · This rise reflects China's growing influence through cultural diplomacy, where fashion becomes a quiet yet powerful tool to shape perceptions abroad.Missing: international | Show results with:international
  79. [79]
    The Resurgence of Hanfu: Embracing Tradition in the Modern World
    Nov 15, 2023 · Narrowly speaking, Hanfu refers to “Han Dynasty clothing”. Broadly speaking, the concept of Hanfu includes the traditional ancient clothing from ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  80. [80]
    Hanfu Beyond China, The Global Influence - Newhanfu
    Dec 14, 2023 · Their influence extends beyond the digital realm, contributing to the resurgence of Hanfu as a symbol of cultural identity. Hanfu in Global.
  81. [81]
    [PDF] THE RISE AND FALL OF A CULTURAL MOVEMENT By Leiyi Lin
    Hanfu is an ethnic costume for the Han people in China. The Hanfu revival is a cultural movement to revive Hanfu and Han culture.
  82. [82]
    Hanfu sees revival as elegant Chinese look wins new admirers
    Jun 17, 2019 · ... and academics doubt the authenticity of modern adaptations of hanfu, claiming that the followers did not do sufficient historical research ...
  83. [83]
  84. [84]
    What is a HanFu| Something You Need to Know - WuKong Education
    Jul 17, 2025 · Why is HanFu important to Chinese culture? The term “Hanfu” refers to the historical dress of the Han people for all of history before the Qing ...<|separator|>
  85. [85]
    Rediscovering Hanfu: A Cultural Phenomenon in Modern China
    Jul 21, 2024 · Modern Hanfu, often labeled as "imitation traditional clothing" by experts like Professor Huang Qiang, blends traditional elements with ...Missing: precursors | Show results with:precursors
  86. [86]
    Can Hanfu Break Free from Tradition in Love's Freedom? - Newhanfu
    Oct 9, 2025 · Some purists argue that any alteration dilutes cultural authenticity, while others believe that without adaptation, these beautiful garments ...
  87. [87]
    A Retro Fashion Statement in 1,000-Year-Old Gowns, With ...
    Nov 22, 2018 · Hanfu followers' dedication to celebrating Han identity can spill into chauvinism and patronizing attitudes toward China's ethnic minorities, ...<|separator|>
  88. [88]
    The Great Han, Race, Nationalism, and Tradition in China Today ...
    In essence, Carrico believes that "members of the Han Clothing Movement are racial nationalists dedicated to celebrating the idea of China" (17). He sees it as ...
  89. [89]
  90. [90]
    Hanfu is More than a Costume: How China's Contradictory Imperial ...
    Nov 23, 2021 · The rise of the Hanfu movement and the debate over China's identity thus symbolises the contradictory nature of the legacies of China's imperial dynasties.
  91. [91]
    Modern Hanfu: Embracing Traditional Chinese Fashion - LTL Beihai
    Dec 12, 2023 · Modern Hanfu || Criticisms. Despite its growing popularity, the Hanfu Movement has faced some controversies. Some argue it romanticizes the past ...<|separator|>
  92. [92]
    Aesthetics,Traditions,Nationalism--What're the undertones of Hanfu ...
    May 7, 2021 · For example, some Hanfu organisations declared their criticism against the Anti-extradition movement in Hong Kong and its independence issue.
  93. [93]
    Traditional Chinese costumes fuel consumption growth
    Oct 29, 2024 · The Hanfu market size reached 14.47 billion yuan in 2023 and is expected to soar to 24.18 billion yuan by 2027. Caoxian county in east China's ...
  94. [94]
    (PDF) Research on the Hanfu Movement in New Media Environment
    The development and dissemination of the Hanfu movement are primarily supported by new media technologies and social networking services, such as Weibo.
  95. [95]
    Full article: Decoding cultural expressions in Hanfu design: a Kansei ...
    Academic research underscores Hanfu's contributions to the tourism economy through its historical significance, cultural relevance, and aesthetic appeal ...
  96. [96]
    [PDF] The Research on the Comparison of Hanfu Fashion Short Videos on ...
    Statistics showed that China's Hanfu enthusiasts increased from 2 million in 2018 to 3.6 million in 2019 and is expected to reach 6.9 million in 2021, with ...Missing: growth | Show results with:growth
  97. [97]
    Hanfu becomes a chic during traditional Chinese festivals - Xinhua
    Jan 25, 2020 · In 2018, the number of hanfu fans reached 2.04 million, up 72.9 percent year on year, according to a report on China's hanfu industry released ...
  98. [98]
    Clothing fit for a people - Chinadaily.com.cn
    Mar 3, 2018 · The annual Hanfu Cultural Festival held in the ancient scenic town of Xitang, Zhejiang province, draws more than 150,000 visitors. The event is ...
  99. [99]
    From Subculture to Mass Culture? How Hanfu Became a Focus of ...
    Nov 28, 2023 · This includes the resurgence of Hanfu, neo-Chinese clothing, Chinese-style makeup, traditional Chinese snacks, tea culture, and the revival of ...