Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

BioShock 2

BioShock 2 is a video game developed primarily by and published by 2K Games. Released on February 9, 2010, for and , with the Microsoft Windows version following on February 11, it serves as the sequel to the 2007 title and is set approximately eight years later in the submerged libertarian city-state of . In the game, players control Subject Delta, the first successful Big Daddy-Little Sister pairing, who awakens in 1968 to rescue his bonded , , from Rapture's new ruler, Sofia Lamb, amid a society fractured by ideological conflicts between and collectivism. emphasizes exploration of Rapture's decaying environments, combat using rivet guns, drills, and ADAM-derived plasmids for genetic augmentation, and moral choices involving harvesting or saving Little Sisters for resources. The title introduced a 10-player multiplayer mode allowing customization as various Big Daddies and Splicers, set in parallel narratives to the single-player campaign, alongside features like research camera mechanics for unlocking abilities. A remastered version launched in 2016 for PlayStation 4, Xbox One, and PC as part of the BioShock: The Collection, incorporating DLC such as Minerva's Den, which focuses on a supercomputer subplot and received acclaim for narrative depth. Critically, BioShock 2 garnered strong reviews for its immersive storytelling, atmospheric audio design, and expanded lore on Rapture's downfall, achieving scores in the low 80s across platforms, though some reviewers critiqued it for iterative rather than revolutionary design compared to . Commercially successful, it contributed to the franchise's legacy by deepening philosophical undertones while maintaining the series' blend of , mechanics, and ethical dilemmas.

Synopsis

Setting

BioShock 2 takes place in 1968 within the underwater city of , eight years after the events of the original . , constructed in the late 1940s by Andrew Ryan as an isolationist embodying Objectivist principles of and free enterprise, had already descended into by 1960 due to socioeconomic collapse, a smuggling operation exploiting the genetic material , and a violent civil war. By 1968, the city's infrastructure is in severe disrepair, with widespread flooding, structural failures, and pervasive violence from ADAM-mutated inhabitants called Splicers. Following the power vacuum left after prior conflicts, Sofia Lamb, a and proponent of collectivist , has assumed control over much of through her cult-like Rapture Family. Lamb's contrasts sharply with Ryan's , emphasizing communal sacrifice and the harvesting of Little Sisters—young girls genetically engineered to gather from sea slugs—for the supposed greater good of a hive-mind collective. The setting explores dilapidated districts such as Pavilion, Fontaine Futuristics, and , each showcasing the remnants of Rapture's former grandeur amid bio-luminescent depths and retro-futuristic design.

Plot

The single-player campaign of BioShock 2 centers on Subject Delta, a Big Daddy who awakens in the submerged city of and embarks on a quest to reunite with his genetically bonded , Eleanor Lamb. Eleanor has been taken by her mother, Sofia Lamb, a who leads a promoting collectivist ideals and plans to harvest Eleanor's accumulated to create a hive-mind embodying the city's collective experiences. Guided initially by audio messages from and assisted by the opportunistic entrepreneur Augustus Sinclair, Delta traverses Rapture's impoverished districts, such as Pauper's Drop and Siren's Alley, combating psychotic Splicers and enforcers loyal to . Along the way, encounters other Little Sisters gathering from corpses and faces recurring moral dilemmas: rescuing them to restore their humanity or harvesting their ADAM for greater power, decisions that impact development and the story's outcome. Key antagonists include Grace Holloway, Eleanor's former guardian turned Sofia devotee, whose backstory evokes sympathy and allows for player choices to spare or eliminate her. The narrative builds to a confrontation in Sofia's stronghold at Persephone, where Delta must overcome enhanced threats like Big Sisters and resolve the paternal bond with Eleanor, leading to one of several endings determined by prior choices regarding Little Sisters and antagonists. This storyline explores themes of individualism versus collectivism, contrasting sharply with the objectivist philosophy of Rapture's founder, Andrew Ryan, from the prior game.

Gameplay

Single-player elements

The single-player campaign casts the player as Subject Delta, an Alpha Series genetically bonded to Eleanor Lamb, navigating the decaying underwater city of ten years after the events of the original . Gameplay emphasizes combat enhanced by abilities—genetic modifications providing elemental powers like electricity (Electro Bolt) or fire (Incinerate), powered by —and a selection of eight weapons including the melee , for rivet projectiles, , , , , , and Research Camera. A key innovation allows dual-wielding any weapon alongside a , facilitating rapid hybrid attacks such as stunning foes with electricity before firing, which reduces input lag compared to the original game's sequential use. Central to progression is the ADAM resource, a rare genetic material harvested through interactions with 14 Little Sisters encountered throughout the campaign. Upon defeating a protecting Big Daddy, players adopt the Little Sister, escorting and defending her as she drains ADAM from two nearby corpses in defensive sequences against attacking splicers, yielding 60-80 ADAM per body depending on player actions and upgrades. After gathering, the Little Sister processes the ADAM at a vent, prompting a moral choice: harvesting her for 160 ADAM kills her but maximizes resources for upgrades, while rescuing provides 80 ADAM plus later gifts (e.g., extra ADAM, tonics, and weapons) and influences the ending toward themes of redemption. Rescuing at least three early sisters unlocks the Protedcted gene tonic for increased gathering efficiency, balancing the trade-off. ADAM funds purchases at Gatherer's Gardens for 11 plasmids (expandable to eight slots), gene tonics offering passive buffs like increased health or EVE efficiency, and health stations. Weapons upgrade at 40 Power to the People stations, enhancing damage, ammo capacity, or adding features like adhesive rivets. persists for controlling turrets, bots, and vending machines at discounts, initially via melee but later with the Hack Tool for remote activation; the Research Camera captures enemy photos to unlock damage multipliers and exclusive tonics. Big Sisters introduce agile, plasmid-wielding encounters demanding environmental tactics and quick plasmid switches.

Multiplayer mode

BioShock 2's multiplayer mode introduces competitive online play set during the , where players assume the role of plasmid test subjects recruited by entrepreneur Augustus Sinclair to field-test enhancements from Sinclair Solutions. Matches occur across recreated locations from , such as the Medical Pavilion and Neptune's Bounty, emphasizing fast-paced combat with weapons, s, and gene tonics. Unlike the single-player campaign, multiplayer lacks a narrative-driven structure but includes loading screen quotes and a introductory cutscene framing the conflict between factions loyal to Andrew Ryan and those aligned with Atlas. The mode supports up to 10 players per match, with gameplay centered on earning ADAM through kills, assists, and objective completion to level up and unlock customization options including new weapons, plasmids, and tonics. Progression allows persistent character development across sessions, enabling players to specialize in offensive, defensive, or utility builds via gene tonics that modify abilities like health regeneration or plasmid efficiency. Team-based modes divide participants into Ryan or Atlas factions, promoting strategic coordination in objectives, while free-for-all variants focus on individual survival and scoring. Seven distinct game modes are available, including deathmatch variants, capture-the-flag styled "Capture the Sister" where teams secure and escort a Little Sister proxy, and resource-grab modes like Team ADAM Grab. Additional features include for public lobbies, private games for up to 10 participants, and hackable systems or vending machines that provide tactical advantages during rounds. A update added an eighth mode, "Salvage," expanding objective-based play. Official online servers for the original release were discontinued following the shutdown of supporting platforms like in July 2014 on PC, rendering public unavailable, though offline or community-hosted servers enable continued access on compatible systems. The 2016 remastered version omits multiplayer entirely, preserving only single-player elements.

Development

Conception and pre-production

Following the commercial and critical success of BioShock in August 2007, publisher 2K Games pursued a sequel to capitalize on the franchise's established world of Rapture and its philosophical themes. Irrational Games, led by Ken Levine, declined direct involvement, with Levine shifting focus to new projects including what would become BioShock Infinite. Instead, 2K formed a new studio, 2K Marin, in Novato, California, comprising veterans from the original BioShock team to handle primary development. 2K Marin began pre-production on BioShock 2 in November 2007 with a core team of eight developers, expanding to a peak of around 86 personnel across supporting studios like and for multiplayer elements. Jordan Thomas, who had served as a lead level designer on BioShock's Fort Frolic area under Levine, was appointed creative director, emphasizing a that humanized the -Little Sister dynamic by positioning the player as a Big Daddy —specifically, the Alpha Series prototype Subject Delta. This core concept emerged early to differentiate the sequel from the original's human survivor perspective, focusing on themes of bonding, , and parental protection within Rapture's decaying society under antagonist Sofia Lamb. Pre-production involved prototyping on a heavily modified inherited from the first game, with initial efforts centered on validating the gameplay loop, including drill-based combat and interactions, while adapting Rapture's aesthetic for a post-civil war timeline approximately eight to ten years after the original events. The small team structure encouraged cross-disciplinary collaboration, though challenges arose from the engine's age and limited resources compared to Irrational's setup, prompting iterative designs for player agency in narrative choices. 2K Games formally announced BioShock 2 in August 2008 at Games Convention, confirming as lead developer.

Core design and implementation

The core design of BioShock 2 centered on positioning the player as an Alpha Series , designated Subject Delta, which fundamentally shaped mechanics around protection, melee combat, and symbiotic relationships with Little Sisters. This choice stemmed from a desire to explore the protector dynamic from an insider's perspective, leading to implementational features like adopting Little Sisters for ADAM harvesting sequences, where players defend them during gathering or combat encounters with enemies such as Big Sisters. The Big Daddy role necessitated adjustments to enemy scaling and player durability, enabling heavier armor, a drill arm for primary attacks, and environmental interactions that emphasized Rapture's underwater decay without breaking immersion. Combat implementation integrated weapons and plasmids more fluidly than in the predecessor, allowing players to equip one weapon and two plasmids simultaneously for rapid switching without dedicated hand swaps, thus supporting aggressive, hybrid playstyles. Weapons featured upgrade paths via research and gene tonics, with the drill exemplifying melee depth through spinning attacks and environmental rivet utilization, while plasmids like Electro Bolt enabled chaining with gunfire for emergent tactics. Enemy AI was developed through an agile, iterative process involving cross-disciplinary teams, prioritizing early prototyping to refine behaviors for foes like the Brute Splicer—designed for tank-like charges—and Big Sister, emphasizing speed and aerial assaults to create dynamic threats. This framework maximized iteration cycles, tracing evolutions from basic scripts to polished, context-aware responses that adapted to player actions in Rapture's confined spaces. Hacking mechanics were streamlined into a pipe-connecting minigame that permitted in-combat engagement without full pauses, using tools like the Hack Tool for remote or instantaneous overrides on security bots, turrets, and safes, enhancing risk-reward tension during fights. Level implementation supported non-linear exploration with layered paths and verticality, leveraging the Big Daddy's bulk for traversal challenges while embedding via audio logs and environmental storytelling. Technically, the game ran on a modified Vengeance Engine derived from 2.5, with frozen code from the original requiring custom workarounds for new features like multiplayer integration and UI elements built on unsupported Flash libraries, which constrained but focused optimization efforts.

Art, audio, and technical aspects

The art direction for BioShock 2 built upon the original game's influences, introducing a concept termed "Deco Devolution," which incorporated twisted forms suggesting , decay, and technological augmentation into the architectural and character designs. This evolution was documented in the 168-page art book Deco Devolution: The Art of BioShock 2, featuring chapters on Rapture's citizens, environments, and splicers, highlighting the deteriorated state of the underwater city. Hogarth de la Plante served as environment , assuming additional co-art director duties after the official art director's departure during , overseeing memorable spaces that emphasized Rapture's crumbling . Audio development featured returning composer , who employed an aleatoric style characterized as "controlled chaos," involving orchestral improvisation to evoke tension and unpredictability in Rapture's ambiance. Schyman's score integrated leitmotifs, such as for the character and for Subject Delta, enhancing emotional narrative layers. , led by Kamper, utilized tracks from vintage sound effects records and custom tools within the system for dynamic mixing, randomization of ambiences via multi-stereo streams, and processing layered animal recordings (e.g., birds, , dolphins) to craft the Big Sister's eerie vocals. Techniques emphasized Rapture's creaking deterioration and non-diegetic elements reflecting splicer madness, with close collaboration between Kamper, creative director Jordan Thomas, and Schyman to align audio with gameplay progression. Technically, BioShock 2 employed the Vengeance Engine, a heavily modified of 2.5 carried over from the first game, which had been effectively frozen during the original's development and proved outdated by standards. This choice expedited single-player implementation due to familiarity but presented limitations in shaders, lighting, and streaming, complicating enhancements. Multiplayer development, handled by , required building core code from scratch atop this engine variant, as 2K Marin's modifications lacked multiplayer foundations, ensuring cohesion with the single-player experience while addressing performance hurdles on , , and PC platforms released on February 9, .

Themes and philosophy

Ideological critiques

BioShock 2 extends the series' examination of ideological extremes by portraying collectivist altruism through antagonist Sofia Lamb, a who advocates sacrificing individual for the "greater good" of Rapture's , drawing inspiration from utilitarian thinkers like and . Lamb's regime enforces this philosophy via ADAM-induced hive-mind control and human experimentation, such as repurposing orphaned girls into Little Sisters to harvest genetic material for collective salvation, illustrating how altruistic ideals devolve into totalitarian parasitism when individuals are treated as expendable resources. Analyses interpret this as a procedural critique of , where maximizing aggregate utility justifies ethical atrocities, paralleling but inverting BioShock's scrutiny of by emphasizing enforced over unchecked . The game's mechanics reinforce this through player choices involving Little Sisters, where "harvesting" yields immediate power gains at the cost of child exploitation, mirroring Lamb's prioritization of ends over means and highlighting causal failures in collectivist systems absent voluntary cooperation. However, some critiques argue the portrayal sidesteps core socialist tenets like economic redistribution, instead fabricating a transhumanist of selfhood that equates absolute collectivism with quasi-religious rather than critiquing directly. Broader scholarly examinations frame BioShock 2's ideology as rejecting extremism in toto, using narrative and gameplay to demonstrate how any philosophy, when absolutized, erodes human agency and fosters dystopia, independent of left- or right-leaning labels. This approach has drawn objections for oversimplifying altruism as inherently manipulative, potentially underplaying real-world variants where voluntary mutual aid sustains communities without coercion, though the game's sci-fi amplification of human flaws via genetic addiction provides a causal mechanism for ideological collapse applicable to both individualism and collectivism. Developers emphasized ethical ambiguity in player decisions to avoid didacticism, allowing outcomes shaped by personal agency rather than prescriptive moralizing.

Ethical dilemmas and player agency

In BioShock 2, the central revolves around the player's decisions regarding Little Sisters, young girls genetically modified to harvest from the dead in . As Subject Delta, a , the player must choose between harvesting a Little Sister—killing her to extract a large quantity of for upgrades—or adopting her briefly to allow Brigid Tenenbaum to intervene and save her life, yielding a smaller reward plus additional gifts from Tenenbaum. Harvesting prioritizes personal power and survival in the hostile environment but perpetuates the cycle of central to Rapture's downfall, while rescuing aligns with at the cost of immediate strength, reflecting a between and moral restraint. These choices extend beyond mechanics to influence Eleanor Lamb, Delta's genetic daughter and successor, who witnesses and internalizes the player's actions as a form of parental guidance. Rescuing all Little Sisters fosters benevolence in Eleanor, enabling endings where she deploys her accumulated powers to heal or aid humanity; conversely, harvesting instills selfishness, leading to tyrannical outcomes where she dominates the surface world. Supplementary decisions—such as sparing or executing figures like (a former anti-Big Daddy militant), Stanley Poole (a deceptive radio host), or Gil Alexander (a deranged scientist)—further modulate Eleanor's ethos, determining whether she exhibits mercy (sparing Sofia Lamb) or justice (executing her) in the finale, with statues in the ending sequence symbolizing the player's legacy. Full rescues combined with at least one act of mercy yield the most redemptive conclusion, underscoring how isolated ethical lapses can corrupt broader influence. Player manifests through these branching paths, which provide tangible narrative consequences absent in more deterministic structures, framing the Big Daddy-Little Sister bond as a for parenthood where actions model values for the "child." Unlike illusory choices in prior games, BioShock 2 ties to long-term : consistent rescues empower Eleanor to redistribute ADAM globally for societal benefit, while inconsistencies produce hybrid dystopias, emphasizing that moral consistency, not binary good-evil, drives outcomes. This system critiques collectivism under Sofia Lamb by contrasting it with individualistic responsibility, where player-driven ethics either redeem or doom Rapture's remnants.

Release and versions

Initial launch

BioShock 2 was released worldwide on February 9, 2010, for Microsoft Windows, , and platforms. The title had been delayed from its initial target of November 3, 2009, in and October 30, 2009, internationally, to allow additional development time. Published by 2K Games and primarily developed by , the game launched amid anticipation as a to the 2007 original, with marketing emphasizing its underwater setting in and new gameplay elements like Big Sister encounters. Initial commercial performance was strong, with the game shipping three million units globally within three weeks of release. In the United States, it topped NPD sales charts for February 2010, driven largely by version sales exceeding 500,000 units that month. In the , BioShock 2 debuted at number one on the all-formats chart for the week ending February 13, 2010, surpassing recent releases like . Pre-launch discussions included concerns over (DRM), particularly involving and integration on PC, which initially suggested activation limits and online requirements that sparked backlash among potential buyers. 2K Games responded by scaling back these measures, limiting to a one-time integrity without installation caps or persistent online for single-player modes. These adjustments mitigated some pre-release hesitancy, though some PC users reported authentication hurdles tied to external services during early play. No widespread technical failures disrupted the console launches.

Downloadable content

BioShock 2 featured two primary single-player downloadable content expansions released by 2K Games. The first, Protector Trials, launched on August 3, 2010, for and , followed by a PC release on March 14, 2011. This DLC consists of 18 challenge-based trials across six repurposed levels from the base game, plus six bonus rounds unlocked after completion, where players control a tasked with harvesting from Little Sisters while defending against waves of splicers under equipment restrictions. Each trial limits players to specific weapons and plasmids, emphasizing strategic combinations for survival and high ADAM yields to achieve top rankings. The second expansion, Minerva's Den, debuted on August 31, 2010, for consoles and May 31, 2011, for PC via and later . Set in Rapture's computational hub, it offers a self-contained campaign playable as , a new type, introducing fresh mechanics such as the weapon, Gravity Well , and encounters with Lancer Big Daddies. The spans multiple levels focused on intellectual and technological themes within Rapture's lore, providing approximately 4-6 hours of content with enhanced storytelling elements compared to the base game's expansions. Additional multiplayer-focused DLC packs, including map expansions like The Little Sister's Nightmare and , were released periodically between February and August 2010 for consoles, adding new arenas and achievements but ceasing support after the servers' discontinuation. These were bundled in some editions but emphasized competitive modes over narrative depth. Both single-player DLCs were later integrated into the BioShock 2 Remastered collection released in 2016, with Minerva's Den receiving specific graphical and performance updates.

Remastered edition and updates

BioShock 2 Remastered was released as part of : The Collection on September 13, 2016, for , , and Microsoft Windows, with international availability on September 16. The collection bundled the original game with its Minerva's Den and Protector Trials downloadable content, alongside remastered versions of the first and . Ports for macOS and followed in August 2017 and May 2020, respectively. Technical enhancements in the targeted visual and performance upgrades, including native at 60 frames per second on consoles, improved textures, enhanced lighting effects, and reduced pop-in for environmental elements compared to the 2009 originals. These changes preserved core mechanics without altering levels, narrative, or player agency, focusing instead on fidelity to the source material while addressing aging graphical limitations. On PC, the initially required the 2K Launcher but later removed this via updates as of November 2024. Post-release patches addressed stability and compatibility issues. Collection Patch 1, deployed October 6, 2016, for PC versions of BioShock and BioShock 2 Remastered, fixed various bugs including graphical occlusion culling errors. A 2017 update resolved crashes during interactions, subtitle toggling failures, and other runtime errors, though player reports indicated mixed success in eliminating all stability problems. Additional unannounced updates appeared in June 2024 on , potentially including minor fixes, while earlier 2016 patches targeted crashes triggered by spacebar prompts. These efforts aimed to mitigate platform-specific issues like those on Windows, without introducing new content or balancing changes.

Reception and analysis

Critical responses

BioShock 2 received generally positive reviews from critics upon its release on February 9, 2010, for and , and March 9, 2010, for PC, with aggregate scores ranging from 86 for the version to 88 for the and PC versions based on dozens of reviews each. Reviewers frequently praised the game's atmospheric return to the underwater city of , refined mechanics, and integration of narrative elements like the Big Daddy-Little Sister dynamic into gameplay choices. IGN awarded it a 9.1 out of 10, highlighting how "story, setting, and gameplay are expertly blended to create an experience that's as thought-provoking as it is entertaining." Critics noted improvements in combat fluidity and player agency, such as the ability to wield weapons and plasmids simultaneously, which enhanced engagement over the original 's more rigid systems. gave it an 8.5 out of 10, describing it as "an all at once beautiful, disturbing, and thought-provoking experience that stays with you after you've shut it off," particularly commending the moral dilemmas posed by harvesting or rescuing Little Sisters. However, some reviews critiqued the narrative for lacking the philosophical depth and surprise of the first game, with the protagonist's role as a seen as limiting character development compared to Jack's arc in . Others pointed to repetitive level design and less innovative storytelling, contributing to scores generally lower than the original's 96 average. The game's audio and art direction, including environmental storytelling through audio diaries, were lauded for maintaining immersion, though technical issues like AI inconsistencies drew minor complaints on PC. Overall, while BioShock 2 was viewed as a solid sequel that expanded on its predecessor's mechanics, critics often assessed it as evolutionary rather than revolutionary, solidifying its reputation as competent but overshadowed by the original's novelty.

Commercial outcomes

BioShock 2, released on February 9, 2010, for Microsoft Windows, , and , generated strong initial sales momentum. Within three weeks of launch, publisher reported that the game had shipped 3 million units worldwide, contributing to quarterly net revenue of $163.2 million for the period ending January 31, 2010. In the United States, the Xbox 360 version topped NPD sales charts for February 2010, selling approximately 500,000 copies amid competition from other major titles. Despite this early performance, lifetime sales totaled over 3 million copies across platforms, falling short of Take-Two's internal expectations when benchmarked against the original 's trajectory, which had reached 4 million units by a similar post-launch period. By June 2010, Take-Two's fiscal second-quarter earnings highlighted 's underperformance relative to projections, even as overall company net revenue rose 54% year-over-year to $268 million, buoyed by other franchises. The 2016 remastered edition, bundled in BioShock: The Collection for modern platforms including , , and PC, added to the game's commercial footprint amid renewed interest in the series, though Take-Two has not released platform-specific sales breakdowns for the .

Long-term evaluations and debates

In analyses, BioShock 2 has increasingly been viewed as an underrated that matures the series' emotional and mechanical foundations, shifting focus from the elite-driven of the original to the communal decay among Rapture's underclass under Sofia Lamb's collectivist regime. A 2016 article positioned it as the "human heart" of , crediting its exploration of parental bonds via the Big Daddy-Little Sister dynamic for providing deeper pathos than the philosophical abstractions of BioShock. echoed this in a contemporaneous revisit, arguing that the game's refined mini-games, dual-wield plasmid-riveting , and branching moral outcomes with Eleanor Lamb demonstrate gameplay evolution that initial reviews undervalued due to sequel fatigue. Debates over its narrative depth compared to BioShock center on whether its ideological pivot—from Ayn Rand-inspired to a of altruism's extremes—feels derivative or more grounded. Proponents, including a 2015 analysis, contend it excels by humanizing Rapture's survivors through family themes and player-driven choices that yield tangible long-term consequences, such as Eleanor's fate influencing endings, surpassing the first game's more static "Would You Kindly?" reveal in agency. Critics, however, argue it dilutes philosophical rigor, with antagonist Lamb's arc seen as less intellectually provocative than Andrew Ryan's, leading to perceptions of shallower ; a 2019 Wisecrack examination framed this as a tension between "deep" systemic commentary and "dumb" elements. The multiplayer mode, featuring competitive Big Daddy battles across Rapture locales, remains a point of contention, often critiqued for diluting the single-player focus and aging poorly without ongoing support post-2010 shutdown of servers. In contrast, the 2010 Minerva's Den DLC garners near-universal long-term acclaim for its self-contained story on computation and free will, with tighter pacing and atmospheric design frequently rated superior to the core campaigns of both BioShock titles. Remastered releases in 2016 prompted further reevaluations, with players noting enhanced visuals and stability that affirm its endurance, though some hardware-specific bugs in updates sparked minor backlash. Overall, by 2025, fan and critic consensus in forums and videos leans toward BioShock 2 as the most replayable for its iterative improvements, challenging early dismissals as a lesser follow-up developed externally by 2K Marin rather than Irrational Games.

Legacy

Influence on the BioShock series

BioShock 2 expanded the core gameplay mechanics of the original by introducing a playable protagonist, which emphasized heavy melee combat with the iconic drill and enhanced combinations for more dynamic enemy encounters. These refinements, including improved weapon upgrading and systems, represented iterative advancements in the series' framework with elements, achieving greater fluidity in combat pacing compared to the 2007 predecessor. However, Ken Levine, of the first and third entries, opted not to helm the sequel, viewing it as a competent extension of Rapture's narrative by rather than a project aligned with ' evolving focus on narrative innovation, which limited its direct mechanical carryover to . Narratively, 2 deepened the lore of 's societal collapse under Sofia Lamb's collectivist ideology, portraying the consequences of addiction and bonds in greater detail, thereby concluding the underwater city's primary arc eight years after the events of the first game. This expansion influenced the series' thematic continuity, as Infinite's DLC returned to a variant , incorporating elements that implicitly reconcile 2's timeline divergences—such as altered protagonist outcomes—within the broader quantum reality framework established in . The protector-companion dynamic central to 2, involving Subject Delta's bond with Eleanor Lamb, echoed structurally in 's Booker DeWitt and relationship, though prioritized companion AI assistance over direct player control of the guardian role. Despite these contributions, BioShock Infinite diverged by shifting to the airborne Columbia setting, replacing plasmids with vigors and emphasizing linear storytelling over BioShock 2's more open exploration and multiplayer mode, which was not replicated in subsequent titles. Levine's team at Irrational treated Infinite as a thematic evolution rather than a mechanical successor, prioritizing philosophical inquiries into free will and redemption over Rapture's bioethical horrors, thus marking BioShock 2 as a bridge that solidified the franchise's immersive world-building but did not dictate Infinite's design trajectory. The sequel's inclusion in the 2016 BioShock: The Collection remaster underscored its role in preserving series canon, ensuring its events informed fan interpretations of Rapture's full history amid the multiverse lore.

Broader cultural and industry impact

BioShock 2 expanded the franchise's exploration of ideological conflicts by contrasting Andrew Ryan's with Sofia Lamb's collectivism, fostering academic and critical discussions on , social engineering, and the perils of ideological in . This thematic depth prompted analyses in of how player agency intersects with philosophical narratives, emphasizing personal relationships over abstract doctrines as a counter to both unchecked and coercive . In the industry, the game's Minerva's Den, released on August 31, 2010, significantly influenced the development of "" genres by prioritizing atmospheric exploration, audio logs for backstory, and minimal to heighten narrative immersion, elements echoed in titles like (2016) and Tacoma (2017). Its refined and systems, allowing extensive character customization with over 10 active abilities and passive buffs, contributed to evolving standards for ability synergies in first-person shooters and action-RPG hybrids, as seen in subsequent 2K titles. The multiplayer mode, launched with 6 maps and expanding to 16 via updates through 2011, demonstrated viable integration of lore-driven competitive play in single-player-focused series, though servers were discontinued on January 10, 2014, limiting long-term adoption. Culturally, portrayals of characters like , a black preacher leading a , invited scrutiny of racial and religious dynamics in dystopian fiction, linking in-game events to historical U.S. themes of civil rights and faith-based movements. evaluations, such as those marking the game's 15th anniversary on February 9, 2025, highlight its enduring loop—combining hacking minigames, research camera mechanics, and dynamic enemy AI—as a benchmark for fluid, choice-driven combat that outpaces the original in mechanical polish, influencing replayability discussions in design.

References

  1. [1]
    BioShock 2 - IGN
    Rating 9.1/10 · Review by IGNSummary ; Publishers. 2K Games, Feral Interactive ; Franchises. BioShock ; Features. Online ; Platforms. Macintosh Xbox 360 PC PlayStation 3 ; Genres. Shooter ...
  2. [2]
    Save 85% on BioShock™ 2 Remastered on Steam
    Rating 3.0 (11,113) In BioShock 2, you step into the boots of the most iconic denizen of Rapture, the Big Daddy, as you explore through the decrepit and beautiful fallen city.
  3. [3]
    2K Games Announces BioShock 2 Now Available Worldwide - IGN
    Feb 9, 2010 · Building upon the original game that shipped more than three million units worldwide, BioShock 2 delivers a single and multiplayer video game ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  4. [4]
  5. [5]
    BioShock: The Timeline of Its World, Rapture, and Columbia Explained
    Oct 20, 2023 · BioShock 2 picks up in 1968. Rapture is barely functioning and Sofia Lamb—the last surviving member of Rapture's inner council—and her cult have ...
  6. [6]
    How to Play the BioShock Games in Chronological Order - IGN
    Sep 16, 2025 · For those looking for a linear way to play through BioShock's full narrative, here's a quick runthrough of the BioShock series in chronological order.
  7. [7]
    Making Another Dive Into Evils of the Deep - The New York Times
    Mar 5, 2010 · BioShock took players beneath the Atlantic to the underwater Art Deco dystopia known as Rapture in a fearless, mesmerizing depiction of Randian ...<|separator|>
  8. [8]
    BioShock 2 is the underrated human heart of the BioShock trilogy
    Jun 30, 2016 · BioShock's focus was primarily on the elites of Rapture, while BioShock 2 spends its time walking amongst the poor. The villain's philosophy is ...<|separator|>
  9. [9]
    BioShock 2 Official Site – Return to Rapture | 2K Games
    See Rapture before it was reclaimed by the ocean. Engage in combat throughout iconic environments in locations such as Kashmir Restaurant and Mercury Suites.
  10. [10]
    Subject Delta - BioShock Wiki - Fandom
    Delta has the ability to use Plasmids, and can wield them simultaneously with his weapons. His suit's gloves have openings on his fingertips and palms designed ...BioShock 2 · Eleanor Lamb · Persephone
  11. [11]
    Every Weapon In BioShock 2, Ranked - TheGamer
    Apr 8, 2022 · Every Weapon In BioShock 2, Ranked · 7 The Hack Tool · 6 The Spear Gun · 5 The Launcher · 4 The Drill · 3 The Machine Gun · 2 The Shotgun · 1 The Rivet ...
  12. [12]
    Plasmids - BioShock 2 Guide - IGN
    Aug 3, 2012 · Cyclone Trap. Level 1,, Throws lesser enemies into the air and drops 'em like ragdolls, letting you attack them while they're limp.
  13. [13]
    Bioshock 2: Single Player Review - GameFAQs
    Rating 88% (93) Mar 1, 2010 · Ultimately, you play as a Big Daddy, who is separated from his Little Sister, and quest through the game to get her back. Gameplay You will be ...<|separator|>
  14. [14]
    “Bioshock 2 – Single Player” Review
    Feb 20, 2010 · So, let's start with the enhanced mechanics. There are some immediately evident improvements over the first game. Dual wielding is the greatest ...
  15. [15]
    BioShock 2: Little Sister's and gathering ADAM - Gamepressure.com
    May 22, 2022 · You will find out who the Little Sisters are, how to get rid of their guards (Daddies), whether it is worth killing or saving Little Sisters, as well as how to ...
  16. [16]
    So wait.. You can search for up to 2 ADAM corpses PER Little Sister?
    Rating 88% (93) Feb 22, 2010 · If you rescue the Little Sisters 4 times, you get a tonic that makes Little Sisters gather 60 ADAM from each body. That extra 20 ADAM really ...Does anyone else really hate gathering ADAM in Bioshock 2?Little Sisters and gathering Adam - BioShock 2 - GameFAQsMore results from gamefaqs.gamespot.com
  17. [17]
    Review: BioShock 2 (single player) - Engadget
    Feb 8, 2010 · Not only does the defense mechanic feel fresh, but it also makes the choice of rescuing the Little Sisters a bit tougher when you know how much ...
  18. [18]
  19. [19]
    Weapons and Upgrades - BioShock 2 Guide - IGN
    Feb 9, 2010 · Weapons and Upgrades ; Machine Gun ; Because it's hard to score head shots with the machine gun, you'll go through a lot of ammo trying to kill ...
  20. [20]
    First BioShock 2 Multiplayer Details - IGN
    May 8, 2009 · The multiplayer game will take place during the fall of Rapture as players take on the role of Plasmid test subjects for Sinclair Solutions.<|separator|>
  21. [21]
    BioShock 2 Multiplayer Detailed | Shacknews
    May 8, 2009 · Experience points earned--presumably by smashing faces--unlock more weapons, gene tonics and plasmids with which to customise your character.
  22. [22]
    BioShock 2 fact sheet details both single and multiplayer aspects
    Jun 5, 2009 · Genetically Enhanced Multiplayer – Earn experience points during gameplay to earn access to new Weapons, Plasmids and Tonics that can be used to ...
  23. [23]
    BioShock 2 Multiplayer guide - Steam Community
    Apr 22, 2017 · There are seven different game modes included in BioShock 2. Each supports up to ten players. Team-based game modes divide the players into two ...
  24. [24]
    Games for Windows Live to shut down July 2014 ... - PC Gamer
    Aug 19, 2013 · An update to the Age of Empires Online support page revealed that Games for Windows Live will shut down July 1, 2014.
  25. [25]
    No Multiplayer ? :: BioShock 2 Remastered General Discussions
    Sep 15, 2016 · Its been known that they will *not* bring back the multiplayer in the remaster version. That's why you still have the original game in case ...
  26. [26]
    Interview: 2K Marin creative director Jordan Thomas on BioShock 2
    Jan 28, 2010 · As the creative director of 2K Marin, the studio behind BioShock 2, Jordan Thomas is all too familiar with the challenge. With development now ...Missing: conception pre- history
  27. [27]
    Beyond the sea: Devs look back at the influential BioShock 2
    We caught up with some of the developers from BioShock 2 for lessons and memories from the game's development.Missing: conception production history
  28. [28]
    Take-Two opens 2K Marin, former BioShock devs reportedly on staff
    Dec 17, 2007 · The terse announcement of 2K Marin's formation will be followed up with game announcements early next year according to insiders we've spoken to ...
  29. [29]
    BioShock 2 Release Date Announced - IGN
    Sep 18, 2009 · 2K Games has revealed that BioShock 2, the sequel to 2K Boston's critically-acclaimed 2007 hit, will be released worldwide on February 9, 2010.
  30. [30]
    Rebuilding Rapture: Choices And BioShock 2 - Game Developer
    The original Ken Levine-led BioShock had high expectations, but even greater success than anyone expected -- it was a mainstream hit, and welcomed a huge ...<|separator|>
  31. [31]
    BioShock 2 Plasmid Showcase - IGN
    Feb 4, 2010 · Unlike the first game, you're not required to swap between plasmid and weapon use, which makes things a little easier for when you're trying to ...
  32. [32]
    The AI of BioShock 2: Methods for Innovation and Iteration - GDC Vault
    Overview: This session proposes design goals for creating great AI in action games, from theory to practice. It then describes an agile, iterative process ...
  33. [33]
    BioShock 2's Improved Hacking Minigame Keeps You Properly ...
    Jun 18, 2021 · The hacking improvement makes you feel far more immersed in the city of Rapture. It enables you to stay in the fight while also desperately trying to hack ...
  34. [34]
    Unreal Engine 2.5 Still Brings Rapture Alive in Bioshock 2
    Bioshock 2, which pushes the visuals that wowed critics and gamers alike in the first game, is still running on Unreal Engine 2.5 definitely speaks to the ...
  35. [35]
    [PDF] Deco Devolution The Art Of Bioshock 2
    Delve into the Art Deco influences and their twisted, decaying evolution in BioShock 2. Explore the game's masterful use of architectural decay to create ...
  36. [36]
    Deco Devolution: The Art of BioShock 2: 2k Games - Amazon.com
    Book details · Print length. 168 pages · Language. English · Publisher. 2K Games · Publication date. January 1, 2010.
  37. [37]
    BioShock 2 Q & A: "It's More Personal This Time" - IGN
    Dec 9, 2009 · It was a pleasant surprise, then, to meet Hogarth De La Plante, environment art director and co-art director from 2K Marin, at a special Sony ...
  38. [38]
    Behind The Score: BioShock 2 - Game Informer
    Jan 18, 2010 · There is the aleatoric style, which Schyman describes as a “controlled chaos” or improvisation among members of the orchestra, in this case ...
  39. [39]
    Exclusive Interview with Michael Kamper, Audio Lead of BioShock 2
    Mar 1, 2010 · For sound design, I used tracks from old sound effects records, sfx ... I also worked closely with our Creative Director, Jordan Thomas ...
  40. [40]
    Remaster still on unreal 2 engine? :: BioShock General Discussions
    Sep 11, 2016 · Bioshock is 9 years old and the UE2 engine suffers from huge limitations like outdated shaders, streaming issues, bad lighting and many other things.<|separator|>
  41. [41]
    Unreal Engine 2.5 Still Brings Rapture Alive in Bioshock 2
    Goode said the Digital Extremes team had to build all of the multiplayer code for Bioshock 2 because the modified Unreal Engine 2.5 technology that 2K Marin ...
  42. [42]
    Of Philosophy in 'Bioshock 2': Some Words from the Devs - PopMatters
    Feb 10, 2010 · Unlike other Big Daddies, Delta is not enslaved to the city and is able to make a number of ethical decisions, which shape the outcome of the ...
  43. [43]
    Bioshock 2 Warns Against Utilitarianism - CBR
    Oct 12, 2023 · Bioshock 2 specifically works in opposition to Bioshock in the philosophy at its core which is collectivist utilitarianism. As opposed to ...
  44. [44]
    The New Utopian: Social Connections in Bioshock 2 - Giant Bomb
    Jun 7, 2023 · Bioshock 2 is evidence that games can not only criticise external ideologies but also imagine ideologies internal to themselves and criticise ...
  45. [45]
    Ideology in Bioshock: A Critical Analysis | Press Start
    Mar 11, 2019 · This paper will analyse the Bioshock series, with a particular focus on the treatment of ideology within these games. This popular and ...
  46. [46]
    Secret Endings - BioShock 2 Guide - IGN
    Feb 9, 2010 · The main choice that affects your ending is whether you rescue or harvest the little sisters that you deal with. You can deal with only one ...
  47. [47]
    The morality of Bioshock 2 | GameLuster
    Sep 6, 2015 · Bioshock 2 provides so much thought into morality and how exactly we should and whether we truly did the right thing in our choices.Missing: explained | Show results with:explained
  48. [48]
    Morally charged acts *SPOILERS* - BioShock 2 - GameFAQs
    Rating 88% (93) Feb 15, 2010 · Harvest/Save Little Sisters: Obviously, Harvest is evil, Save is good. Kill/Spare Grace Holloway: Again, pretty clean. Kill/Spare Stanley Poole: ...
  49. [49]
    Bioshock 2: Choice and Parenthood - Vigaroe
    Apr 26, 2019 · Harvest all the Little Sisters and kill everyone, and Eleanor decides selfishness is the thing to do. Mix your messages, with killing some ...Missing: dilemmas agency
  50. [50]
    BioShock 2 Pushed Back To 2010 - IGN
    Jul 13, 2009 · BioShock 2 was originally scheduled for release in North America on November 3, 2009, but now it seems as though that will change. Take-Two CEO ...<|separator|>
  51. [51]
    BioShock 2 Ships 3 Million, GTA IV Sales Top 15 Million - IGN
    Mar 3, 2010 · BioShock 2 has shipped 3 million copies. Take-Two also announced that the original BioShock released in 2007 has now sold over four million units.Missing: initial | Show results with:initial
  52. [52]
    February NPD: BioShock 2, Xbox 360 Top the Charts - WIRED
    Mar 11, 2010 · The Xbox 360 version of BioShock 2 topped the sales charts in February, moving half a million copies in a month packed with big game releases.
  53. [53]
    UK charts: BioShock 2 overthrows Mass Effect 2 from number one
    Feb 15, 2010 · The BioWare RPG lands at eight with a 58 percent drop in sales. The top three is rounded off by Just Dance and FIFA 10.
  54. [54]
    2K pares down BioShock 2 DRM: SecuROM all but gone now
    Jan 25, 2010 · SecuROM will now only be used to verify the integrity of the game disc at launch. There will be no SecuROM-imposed installation limitations.
  55. [55]
    BioShock 2 DRM Scale Back More Confusing | Rock Paper Shotgun
    Jan 25, 2010 · Over the past two days, I've fielded a lot of questions and concerns about the DRM for both the retail and digital versions of BioShock 2.
  56. [56]
    Whats with all the hate on this game? :: BioShock 2 General ...
    Jun 23, 2016 · When Bioshock 2 first launched looong time ago, it had a rather draconian DRM. Coupled with authentification problems, many people who ...
  57. [57]
    BioShock 2 DLC - Giant Bomb
    Feb 9, 2010 · The DLC adds 6 maps and 6 achievements. DLC name, Protector Trials. Platform, PC. Release date, March 14, 2011. Developers. Publishers, 2K Games.
  58. [58]
    Downloadable Content - BioShock 2 Walkthrough & Guide
    Rating 88% (93) Sep 18, 2024 · In The Protector Trials, the player must complete a series of Little Sister defense sequences across six different maps while restricted to ...
  59. [59]
    Bioshock 2's Protector Trials DLC Impressions - IGN
    Jul 28, 2010 · The Protector Trials has a story, but it's not tied together in any typical narrative structure. Rapture's Dr. Tenenbaum has brought you -- an ...<|separator|>
  60. [60]
    Protector Trials - Bonus Trials - BioShock 2 Walkthrough & Guide
    Rating 88% (93) Sep 18, 2024 · Downloadable Content. Protector Trials - Bonus Trials. After completing all eighteen Protector trials, the bonus rounds will be unlocked.
  61. [61]
    Bioshock 2 Protector Trails A+ Rank guide - Steam Community
    May 10, 2021 · This guide i will point out the difficult part in each trail and help someone incase they need it. The Basics YOU are weaker than you think try to use cover as ...
  62. [62]
    Bioshock 2: Minerva's Den release date announced - PC Gamer
    May 18, 2011 · On May 31 we'll finally be able to get our hands on the Minerva's Den DLC for Bioshock 2. The expansion pack will go live on the Games for Windows Marketplace ...Missing: list | Show results with:list
  63. [63]
    Save 50% on BioShock 2 - Minerva's Den Remastered - Steam
    In stock Rating 4.5 (670) Sep 15, 2016 · Minerva's Den offers a new BioShock story, new tools, the Ion Laser, Gravity Well Plasmid, and a new Lancer Big Daddy enemy.<|separator|>
  64. [64]
    BioShock 2: Minerva's Den DLC Review - IGN
    Sep 1, 2010 · Minerva's Den is a better experience than its parent game. 2K Marin has used BioShock 2 as a platform to deliver a final, moving, personal story set in the ...
  65. [65]
    BioShock: The Collection Official Site - 2K Games
    BioShock: The Collection contains all single-player content from BioShock, BioShock 2, and BioShock Infinite, all single-player add-on content.<|control11|><|separator|>
  66. [66]
    The remastered BioShock collection looks better, but not different
    Aug 17, 2016 · BioShock: The Collection will be released on September 13th (September 16th internationally) on Xbox One, PlayStation 4, and PC for $59.99. ...
  67. [67]
    BioShock 2 Remastered - PCGamingWiki
    Oct 16, 2025 · Early release uses 2K Launcher but no longer required now as of 26 November 2024. Includes the original BioShock 2. Includes the original ...
  68. [68]
    BioShock 2 Patches
    Released October 3, 2013 (PC). Added BioShock 2 and Minerva's Den to Steam. Collection Patch 1. Released October 6, 2016 (PC, BioShock and BioShock 2 Remastered) ...
  69. [69]
    Remastered 1/2 PC released After a year of silence on stability issues
    Dec 6, 2017 · This patch claims to fix some of the stability issues, although reports are mixed on its success. Bioshock Remastered was released September 16 ...
  70. [70]
    Game update 2024 :: BioShock 2 Remastered General Discussions
    Jun 25, 2024 · Just had an update for 1 and 2 remastered show up, however there is no information on what was done. Has anyone else seen this or know whats ...
  71. [71]
    After Dec. 20 Patch Still Crashing :: BioShock 2 Remastered General ...
    Dec 20, 2016 · Still crashing when i start a new game and have to press the spacebar, only difference I see now is the opening cinematic with the little ...
  72. [72]
    BioShock 2 Reviews - Metacritic
    Bioshock 2 is another epic piece of story-telling laid over a set of core mechanics that, for now, still feels fresh and ahead of the curve.Critic ReviewsBioShock 2 user reviews
  73. [73]
    BioShock 2 Review - IGN
    Rating 9.1/10 · Review by Charles OnyettFeb 9, 2010 · It's a game in which story, setting, and gameplay are expertly blended to create an experience that's as thought-provoking as it is entertaining.
  74. [74]
    BioShock 2 Review - GameSpot
    Rating 8.5/10 · Review by Lark AndersonFeb 8, 2010 · BioShock 2 is an all at once beautiful, disturbing, and thought-provoking experience that stays with you after you've shut it off.
  75. [75]
    BioShock 2 ships 3 million, GTAIV sells 15M, Take-Two tops targets
    Mar 4, 2010 · BioShock 2 ships 3 million, GTAIV sells 15M, Take-Two tops targets. Undersea sequel hits milestone as publisher reports lower-than-expected loss ...Missing: initial | Show results with:initial
  76. [76]
    Take-Two: BioShock Hit 4M Units, BioShock 2 Drove Sales
    Irrational Games' 2007 hit BioShock has now exceeded 4 million units sold, according to publisher Take-Two -- and part of that success was spurred by 2K ...
  77. [77]
    Take-Two Q2 revenue up to $268M, BioShock 2 sales 'lower than ...
    Jun 8, 2010 · Net revenue of $268 million represented an increase of 54 percent over the $174.3 million recorded during the same quarter last year; a change ...Missing: commercial | Show results with:commercial
  78. [78]
    Revisiting the underrated BioShock 2 and finding that time has been ...
    Dec 29, 2016 · In BioShock we visited the underwater city of Rapture in the wake of a civil war, and the place was just about hanging together. Eight years ...
  79. [79]
    Why 'BioShock 2' Is the Best 'BioShock' - VICE
    Apr 14, 2015 · But BioShock 2's protest is against design-by-committee, against games being made anodyne on purpose. It's testament to the game's writing that ...
  80. [80]
    BioShock 2: Is It Deep or Dumb? – Wisecrack Edition - YouTube
    Aug 3, 2019 · Get your personalized rate, TODAY! Go to https://upstart.com/wisecrack Thanks to Upstart for sponsoring this episode! Subscribe to Wisecrack ...Missing: critique | Show results with:critique
  81. [81]
    Wot I Think: Bioshock 2 | Rock Paper Shotgun
    Feb 8, 2010 · Bioshock 2 is, I must stress, a strong first-person shooter: great-looking, varied and often incredibly nasty combat, ...<|separator|>
  82. [82]
    BioShock games' "quality of life" updates actually break them on the ...
    Sep 5, 2022 · BioShock Remastered, BioShock 2 Remastered and BioShock Infinite have all fallen afoul of some questionably titled “quality of life” updates ...
  83. [83]
    Levine: Why I passed on BioShock 2 | Eurogamer.net
    Aug 12, 2010 · "I think it's a very talented team," he said, "and I think it fulfilled the mission of completing the story of Rapture." Oli Welsh saw BioShock ...
  84. [84]
    Ken Levine On Skipping Bioshock 2 & His Thoughts On The Game
    Aug 13, 2010 · Irrational's Ken Levine Was Happy With Bioshock 2, But Didn't Feel Like It Was The Right Project For Irrational.
  85. [85]
    We Don't Get Sequels Like BioShock 2 Anymore - TheGamer
    Feb 9, 2025 · 15 years later, every sequel is more like BioShock Infinite. That isn't to say that Infinite has been influential on game design in a meaningful ...<|separator|>
  86. [86]
  87. [87]
    Bioshock 2 and the Power of Influence - Christ and Pop Culture
    Mar 5, 2010 · Bioshock 2 reminded me that ideologies don't save people. Salvation, in Bioshock 2 comes on a more personal level. Rapture itself, is beyond ...Missing: impact | Show results with:impact
  88. [88]
    How 'BioShock 2: Minerva's Den' Helped Shape Walking Simulator ...
    Sep 16, 2016 · Of all the ways that BioShock changed video games, its influence on the so-called walking simulator may be the most unexpected.
  89. [89]
    BioShock 2 Multiplayer
    Each supports up to ten players. Team-based game modes divide the players into two factions: those fighting for Andrew Ryan and those battling under Atlas. Each ...Medical Pavilion · Loading Screen Quotes · Siren Alley · Neptune's Bounty
  90. [90]
    Race in Rapture: Black Characters in BioShock 2 and Minerva's Den
    Feb 10, 2011 · The article examines the portrayals of Grace Holloway and Charles Porter and traces their connection to larger historical and cultural themes in US society.
  91. [91]
    15 Years Later, BioShock 2 Still Offers the Series' Best Gameplay
    BioShock 2 turns 15 years old today, but its stellar gameplay fundamentals have not even been slightly tarnished by the passage of time.