Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Social experiment

A social experiment is a type of in and that systematically investigates human responses to manipulated social situations, often to test theories of , , or under controlled conditions. These studies typically involve participants unaware of the full experimental nature, employing or staging to elicit natural reactions, with the aim of isolating causal factors in . The origins of social experiments trace back to the late 19th century, with Norman Triplett's 1898 study on social facilitation, where children performed better at tasks in the presence of others, marking one of the earliest empirical probes into group effects on individual performance. Mid-20th-century experiments expanded this foundation, including Solomon Asch's 1951 conformity studies demonstrating participants' tendency to align judgments with incorrect group consensus, Stanley Milgram's 1961 obedience research revealing high compliance rates in administering simulated shocks, and Philip Zimbardo's 1971 Stanford Prison Experiment simulating roles that led to abusive dynamics. These works profoundly shaped understanding of conformity, authority, and situational influences on behavior, influencing fields from education to policy. Despite their impact, social experiments have sparked significant ethical controversies, particularly regarding participant deception, psychological distress, and lack of , prompting stricter institutional review standards post-1970s. High-profile cases like Milgram's and Zimbardo's faced criticism for inducing harm without adequate safeguards, while later scrutiny has questioned methodological rigor, including demand characteristics and poor replicability, contributing to broader doubts about the reliability of some classic findings amid 's replication challenges. Modern approaches increasingly favor ethical alternatives like simulations or field studies with to balance insight with participant welfare.

Definition and Methodology

Core Definition and Objectives

A social experiment is a research procedure in , , or related fields that systematically manipulates social variables—such as group pressures, authority cues, or environmental incentives—to observe and infer their causal effects on participants' behaviors, attitudes, or interactions. This approach contrasts with purely observational methods by incorporating elements of , such as to and conditions when feasible, to minimize factors and enhance . In settings, experiments often simulate social scenarios with standardized protocols; variants embed interventions in real-world contexts to capture naturalistic responses. The core objectives encompass testing theoretical predictions about social phenomena, including conformity dynamics, obedience thresholds, and intergroup conflict triggers, thereby validating or refining models of human motivation rooted in environmental contingencies rather than innate traits alone. For example, experiments aim to quantify how situational factors override dispositional explanations, as evidenced in studies isolating peer influence on perceptual judgments. In policy-oriented applications, objectives extend to evaluating intervention impacts, such as randomized trials measuring employment outcomes from income support variations, to discern net causal effects amid baseline trends. Ultimately, social experiments pursue empirical rigor to uncover replicable patterns in social causality, prioritizing designs that yield quantifiable differences between groups while acknowledging limitations like demand characteristics or scaling challenges from lab to . This focus supports broader goals of advancing predictive accuracy in social forecasting and countering unsubstantiated narratives with data-driven insights.

Classification of Types

Social experiments are typically classified by their methodological setting and degree of researcher control, which influences their (ability to infer ) and (generalizability to real-world contexts). The primary categories include laboratory experiments, field experiments, and natural experiments. This typology originates from experimental research traditions in and , where laboratory settings prioritize control over variables, field settings balance manipulation with realism, and natural settings exploit exogenous variations without direct intervention. Laboratory experiments conduct manipulations in artificial, controlled environments to isolate causal effects, often involving small groups of participants under direct observation. These yield high through and elimination of confounds but may suffer from low due to unnatural settings, such as staged interactions in windowless rooms. Examples include studies where participants judge line lengths amid confederate pressure, demonstrating how overrides individual perception in contrived scenarios. Field experiments introduce researcher-controlled manipulations into everyday environments, enhancing while retaining some through , though confounds like unobserved behaviors persist. Conducted in public spaces or organizations, they test phenomena like or ; for instance, researchers have placed lost letters in neighborhoods to measure return rates as proxies for community , revealing contextual effects on . These differ from labs by embedding interventions in participants' natural routines, as seen in studies mailing surveys with varying sender cues to assess response biases tied to stereotypes. Natural experiments observe outcomes from naturally occurring, quasi-random variations without researcher manipulation, relying on events like policy shifts or disasters for "as-if" randomization to approximate . Lacking direct control, they prioritize and are common in for large-scale analysis, such as comparing crime rates before and after unexpected policing changes or evaluating lottery-based housing relocations on child outcomes. While is lower due to potential selection biases, statistical methods like difference-in-differences help mitigate threats, as in assessments of hikes' employment impacts across bordering regions. Additional distinctions arise in scale and discipline: micro-level experiments focus on individual or small-group dynamics in , while macro-level ones in or involve populations, such as randomized trials testing income supplements' labor effects on thousands over years. Quasi-experiments, a hybrid, use non-random assignment but control via matching, bridging natural and true experimental designs in observational data-heavy fields.

Experimental Designs and Causal Inference

Social experiments typically employ true experimental designs, such as randomized controlled trials (RCTs), where participants are randomly assigned to to minimize and enable estimation of average treatment effects. In these designs, researchers manipulate an independent variable—such as exposure to social norms or group incentives—and measure outcomes like behavioral compliance or attitude change, with ensuring groups are comparable on unobserved confounders. Field experiments, conducted in real-world settings like workplaces or communities, enhance over laboratory analogs but introduce risks of spillover effects where treatment influences control participants through social interactions. Quasi-experimental designs are prevalent when ethical or logistical constraints preclude , such as in evaluations mimicking experiments via discontinuity—assigning based on a cutoff score—or difference-in-differences, which compares pre- and post-intervention changes across treated and untreated groups. These approaches approximate causal effects by controlling for time-invariant confounders but remain vulnerable to if parallel trends assumptions fail. Within-subjects designs, where individuals experience multiple conditions sequentially, control for individual heterogeneity but risk carryover effects in contexts involving learning or . Causal inference in social experiments relies on the potential outcomes , which defines the effect as the difference between observed outcomes under and counterfactual outcomes under , estimated via statistical ing or instrumental variables to address noncompliance. For instance, orthogonal designs decompose effects into direct and indirect components, isolating peer influence in ed treatments while assuming no higher-order interactions. Robustness checks, including sensitivity analyses for hidden confounders, are essential, as social behaviors often exhibit heterogeneity moderated by unobserved traits like or position. Key challenges include interference, where one unit's treatment affects another's outcome, violating stable unit treatment value assumption and biasing estimates upward in clustered social settings. Ethical barriers limit destructive manipulations, favoring observational proxies over pure experiments, while low statistical power from small samples or noisy social data hampers detection of subtle effects. External validity falters when lab-induced behaviors fail to replicate in diverse populations, as evidenced by inconsistencies in obedience studies across cultures. Despite these, designs incorporating clustered randomization or sharp instruments strengthen claims, prioritizing empirical replication over theoretical priors.

Historical Development

Early Precursors and Philosophical Roots

, the founder of , laid early philosophical groundwork for applying empirical methods to social phenomena in the early . In his (1830–1842), Comte argued that society should be studied scientifically, akin to the natural sciences, through observation of verifiable facts and laws governing (order) and dynamics (change). He conceptualized "social experiments" not as deliberate interventions but as natural perturbations—such as revolutions or economic crises—that disrupt equilibrium, allowing observers to infer underlying social laws from the observed effects. John Stuart Mill advanced this framework in A System of Logic (1843), dedicating Book VI, Chapter 7 to "the chemical, or experimental, method in the social sciences." Mill adapted inductive canons—methods of agreement, difference, joint method, residues, and concomitant variations—for amid social complexity, where direct manipulation of variables is often infeasible due to ethical constraints and interdependent causes. He advocated "experiments of circumstance," or natural quasi-experiments, such as policy changes or historical events, to isolate causal factors, while cautioning against contrived human trials that could impose undue "annoyance and restraint." These ideas built on , including David Hume's emphasis on causation through constant conjunction and Francis Bacon's advocacy for inductive experimentation, but applied them to and institutions. Earlier thinkers like (1796–1874) employed statistical averages to discern "," treating aggregate data as proxies for experimental control, yet deliberate social manipulation remained rare and ethically contested, as noted by in 1852, who deemed it incompatible with human autonomy. This philosophical emphasis on indirect, observational presaged modern social experiments by prioritizing causal over speculative metaphysics, though actual controlled trials awaited 20th-century technological and institutional shifts.

20th Century Emergence in Psychology and Sociology

In psychology, the 20th century marked the transition of social experimentation from isolated precursors to a systematic discipline, with Floyd Allport's 1924 textbook Social Psychology establishing the field on empirical foundations by prioritizing laboratory tests of individual behavior in social contexts, such as responses to crowds and suggestion. Allport critiqued earlier introspective and holistic approaches, advocating quantifiable measures of phenomena like social facilitation, which built on but surpassed Norman Triplett's 1898 bicycle racing study through controlled replications involving multiple subjects and conditions. This experimental paradigm emphasized causal inference via manipulation of variables like group presence, setting the stage for mid-century expansions in attitude measurement and cognitive processes. Kurt Lewin's contributions in further solidified experimental rigor, introducing field theory to examine dynamic group forces through interventions like his 1939 studies on styles in clubs, where democratic versus autocratic atmospheres causally influenced member output and satisfaction, with productivity dropping 50% under conditions. Lewin's quasi-experimental designs, often conducted in applied settings post-emigration to the in 1933, demonstrated how environmental "valences" drive behavior, influencing over 100 subsequent studies on morale and while highlighting ethical tensions in manipulating social realities. These efforts differentiated from sociology by focusing on psychological mechanisms rather than macrosocial structures. Sociology's adoption of experimental methods lagged, with pioneering efforts in the facing over and the discipline's for observational surveys, yet early interventions variables like institutional effects on amid heated methodological disputes. Ernest Greenwood's 1945 Experimental Sociology: A Study in Method formalized the approach, defining it as deliberate social manipulations to isolate causal factors—such as tweaks on outcomes—while critiquing prior "ex post facto" analyses for lacking controls, though acknowledging barriers like participant reactivity and generalizability. Greenwood reviewed over 50 purported sociological experiments, validating few as truly controlled, which underscored psychology's lead in and informed sociology's shift toward hybrid field trials by mid-century.

Expansion into Policy and Economics Post-1960s

In the late 1960s, the pioneered the application of large-scale randomized controlled trials to evaluate social welfare policies, spurred by the initiatives under President . The Office of Economic Opportunity funded the New Jersey Income Maintenance Experiment from 1968 to 1972, the first major effort to use to assess a (NIT) scheme, assigning 1,357 low-income urban families to treatment arms with varying income guarantees (up to $3,100 annually for a family of four) and tax-back rates (50–70%) or to a control group receiving standard . This approach addressed longstanding challenges in observational data, where confounded estimates of policy impacts on behavior, providing cleaner causal evidence through experimental variation. The experiment's outcomes revealed modest labor supply reductions: secondary earners, particularly wives, cut work hours by 10–20%, while primary male earners showed negligible responses, yielding an overall 5–7% decline across households; youth in treatment groups also increased school enrollment by about 14%. Treatment families experienced elevated marital instability, with separation rates 40–60% higher among whites, suggesting income transfers could disrupt family dynamics in ways not anticipated by proponents of unconditional aid. These results, robust across subsequent NIT trials like the Seattle–Denver experiment (1970–1982, involving 4,800 families), indicated smaller work disincentives than critics feared but highlighted trade-offs in family structure and human capital formation. By 1976, over 35 such experiments had evaluated policies in welfare, housing, and education, with the four primary NIT studies alone costing $110 million in benefits and administration. The founding of the Manpower Demonstration Research Corporation (MDRC) in 1974 institutionalized this methodology, conducting randomized evaluations of job training programs like Supported Work (1975–1977), which tested subsidies for high-risk groups and informed targeted employment interventions. In health economics, the RAND Health Insurance Experiment (1974–1982) randomized 5,800 individuals across six sites to free care or cost-sharing plans (0–95% coinsurance), finding that higher patient payments reduced utilization by 20–30% with little average health detriment, though poorer chronically ill subgroups fared worse without full coverage. These policy trials bridged to by supplying empirical benchmarks for models of incentives and selection, influencing labor and research; for example, NIT evidence of work responses shaped the design of the in 1975, favoring work-conditioned transfers over pure guarantees to minimize disincentives. Experimental findings often constrained expansive reforms, as causal estimates exposed behavioral elasticities—such as labor supply sensitivity to marginal tax rates—that theoretical predictions alone could not validate, fostering a paradigm of evidence-based policymaking over ideological priors. By the , this expanded into and training evaluations, like the Job Training Partnership Act studies, laying groundwork for field experiments in and .

Notable Psychological Experiments

Conformity, Obedience, and Authority Studies

Sherif's autokinetic effect experiments, conducted in 1935, examined conformity in ambiguous perceptual situations. Participants viewed a stationary pinpoint of light in a darkened room, which appeared to move due to the autokinetic illusion. Individually, estimates of movement distance varied widely, but when placed in groups of three (with others being confederates who provided consistent false estimates), participants converged toward the group's erroneous norm, demonstrating informational social influence and norm formation. Asch's conformity studies, published in 1951, shifted focus to unambiguous tasks. In groups of eight, only the real participant was unaware that the others were confederates instructed to give incorrect answers on simple line-length matching judgments. Over 12 critical trials, approximately 75% of participants at least once, yielding to the majority's wrong response on about 32% of trials overall, highlighting despite clear perceptual evidence against it. Replications, such as a 2023 study, have confirmed similar rates of conformity around 35% under controlled conditions. Criticisms include potential demand characteristics, where participants might suspect the setup, though the findings underscore humans' tendency to prioritize over independent judgment in group settings. Milgram's obedience experiments, begun in 1961 and reported in 1963, investigated compliance to authority directives potentially causing harm. Participants, acting as "teachers," were instructed by an experimenter in a Yale lab to administer electric shocks to a "learner" (an actor feigning pain) for incorrect answers in a memory task, with voltages escalating from 15 to 450 volts labeled as "dangerous" or "XXX." Despite protests, 65% of 40 participants obeyed fully to the maximum, and all reached 300 volts, illustrating agentic state where individuals defer responsibility to authority. Partial replications, such as Burger's 2009 study stopping at 150 volts, yielded comparable obedience rates of 70% continuing past initial protests. The experiments sparked ethical debates over deception, stress (many participants showed signs of distress), and lack of informed consent, influencing stricter institutional review board standards, though proponents argue the insights into situational pressures outweigh harms given debriefing. Zimbardo's , initiated August 14, 1971, explored authority dynamics by assigning 24 male student volunteers to roles as guards or prisoners in a simulated jail in Stanford's basement. Within days, guards exhibited abusive behaviors—dehumanizing prisoners through push-ups, deprivation, and psychological tactics—while prisoners became passive or rebellious, leading to early termination after six days due to emotional breakdown. Zimbardo, acting as superintendent, acknowledged his role in escalating the situation. Recent analyses and failed replications, including Le Texier's 2018 revelations of coaching and incomplete data, question its validity, suggesting results stemmed from demand characteristics and experimenter bias rather than alone, diminishing claims of pure situational . Ethical violations, including inadequate oversight and participant harm, further eroded its standing as robust evidence. These studies collectively reveal how social pressures—informational in ambiguity, normative in clarity, and hierarchical in authority—can override personal convictions or moral restraints, informing understandings of phenomena like bystander apathy or institutional abuses. However, laboratory constraints limit generalizability, and ethical reforms prioritize participant welfare, tempering interpretations with caution against overattributing behavior to situations absent dispositional factors.

Aggression, Imitation, and Social Learning

In the 1961 Bobo doll experiment conducted by Albert Bandura and colleagues, 72 preschool children (36 boys and 36 girls, aged 37 to 69 months) from Stanford University Nursery School observed adult models interacting with an inflatable Bobo doll either aggressively or non-aggressively. The aggressive model punched the doll, struck it with a mallet, kicked it, and verbally abused it while receiving no punishment, whereas the non-aggressive model ignored the doll and played quietly with other toys. Children were divided into groups exposed to live models or no model (control), and later frustrated before being allowed to play in a room containing the Bobo doll and other toys. Those who observed the aggressive model exhibited significantly more imitative physical and verbal aggression toward the doll, including novel acts not directly modeled, compared to controls, with boys showing more physical imitation than girls. This demonstrated observational learning of aggression without direct reinforcement, supporting Bandura's social learning theory that behaviors are acquired through modeling, attention, retention, reproduction, and motivation. Bandura extended these findings in 1963 experiments comparing live versus filmed models, involving 265 children who viewed aggressive acts toward the Bobo doll either in person, via real-time film, or cartoon animation. Results showed equivalent levels of across modalities, with filmed producing robust modeling effects similar to live demonstrations, suggesting that symbolic could transmit aggressive scripts effectively. A follow-up incorporated consequences for the model: children imitated punished less than rewarded or neutral , indicating vicarious modulates learning. These studies collectively established as a for acquiring aggressive repertoires, influencing later on violence effects, though causal links to real-world behavior remain debated due to the experiments' focus on doll-directed acts rather than interpersonal harm. Critics argue the experiments' artificiality limits generalizability, as the Bobo doll's design encouraged rough play irrespective of modeling, and the lab setting may have elicited demand characteristics where children inferred aggression was expected during free play. Measurements relied on observed doll interactions rather than ecologically valid aggression metrics, potentially inflating imitation effects without evidencing intent for harm or long-term behavioral change. Replications and meta-analyses on observational learning affirm short-term modeling of novel aggressive responses, but broader applications to societal violence, such as from television, show inconsistent causal evidence, with factors like family environment and individual traits often mediating outcomes more strongly than isolated modeling. Despite methodological constraints, the experiments shifted paradigms from purely drive-based aggression theories (e.g., frustration-aggression hypothesis) to cognitive-social models emphasizing learned scripts and environmental cues.

Self-Control, Delay, and Individual Traits

The , conducted by psychologist and colleagues starting in the late 1960s, examined children's capacity for as a measure of . Preschoolers aged approximately 4 to 6 years were seated alone in a room with a single (or similar treat) and instructed that they could eat it immediately or wait up to 15 minutes for a second one upon the experimenter's return. Roughly one-third of participants resisted temptation and waited the full duration, while others succumbed earlier or sought distractions like averting gaze or self-soothing behaviors. Initial analyses linked waiting time to cognitive strategies, such as redirecting attention away from the reward rather than direct suppression, suggesting self-control involves active inhibitory processes. Longitudinal follow-ups through adolescence and adulthood revealed correlations between delay ability and positive outcomes, including higher SAT scores (average 210-point difference), lower , reduced substance use, and better academic and social functioning. These findings positioned delayed gratification as a proxy for a stable individual trait of , predictive of life success independent of IQ in early models. Meta-analyses across observer, parent, and self-reports confirmed self-control's role in financial planning, health behaviors, and achievement, with effect sizes indicating it explains variance in outcomes beyond in some cohorts. Subsequent replications, however, qualified these claims. A 2018 study by Tyler W. Watts and colleagues with 900 diverse children found raw correlations between waiting and later achievement but near-zero after adjusting for family income, mother's education, and cognitive ability at age 4. Similarly, a 2021 analysis emphasized that apparent effects largely reflected affluence and environmental stability, with lower-income children rationally opting for immediate rewards due to prior experiences of unreliable promises. Experimental manipulations of environmental reliability—such as varying experimenter dependability before the task—further showed that perceived trustworthiness modulates delay, implying the test captures context-sensitive more than an innate trait. These insights highlight self-control's interplay with individual traits like , which bolsters inhibitory capacity, though can undermine it via heightened . Twin and longitudinal data affirm moderate (around 30-50%) for self-control measures, yet social experiments underscore its malleability through situational cues, challenging purely dispositional views. In group contexts, in-group identity has been shown to enhance delay when rewards align with collective norms, linking self-control to social traits like affiliation needs. Overall, while self-control remains a consequential , its experimental reveals causal influences from socioeconomic and reliability factors, tempering claims of unidimensional .

Sociological and Group Dynamics Experiments

Intergroup Conflict and Cooperation

The Robbers Cave experiment, conducted by Muzafer Sherif and colleagues in 1954 at a summer camp in Oklahoma, examined the emergence of intergroup conflict among 22 boys aged 11 to 12, divided into two groups of 11: the Eagles and the Rattlers. In the first phase, each group formed strong in-group bonds through cooperative activities like camping and sports, fostering group identity without intergroup contact. The second phase introduced competition via tournaments in baseball, tug-of-war, and other events, with prizes awarded only to winners, leading to rapid escalation of hostility including name-calling, flag burning, and raids on the opposing camp. This demonstrated that realistic competition over scarce resources causally generates intergroup conflict, supporting realistic conflict theory, which posits that such antagonism arises from incompatible goals rather than inherent prejudice. To resolve the conflict, the third phase introduced superordinate goals requiring cooperation, such as jointly solving a breakdown by pulling a truck to dislodge a blockage and renting a movie truck stuck in mud, which reduced and promoted intergroup friendship as measured by sociometric choices. alone, like shared meals, initially worsened tensions, underscoring that mere without shared objectives fails to mitigate . These findings, detailed in Sherif's 1961 analysis, have informed strategies, though replications have varied due to the experiment's small sample and field setting. In contrast, Henri Tajfel's experiments in the early 1970s revealed intergroup bias emerging from categorization alone, without competition or prior interaction. Adolescent boys at a school were arbitrarily assigned to groups based on preferences for abstract paintings by Klee or Kandinsky, then anonymously allocated points between members using matrices that allowed favoritism without personal gain. Participants consistently maximized in-group benefits and discriminated against out-groups, with mean allocations favoring in-groups by 1.25-1.78 units on average across conditions, supporting social identity theory's emphasis on derived from group membership. This paradigm, replicated in over 20 studies, highlights how even trivial distinctions trigger , challenging views that conflict requires material stakes. Subsequent experiments combining elements, such as Aronson's jigsaw method in 1978 classrooms, induced by interdependent tasks where students taught segments to mixed-ethnic groups, reducing via positive interdependence and reduced anxiety. Field studies in conflict zones, like a 2015 Rwanda radio intervention exposing 473 participants to narratives promoting reconciliation, showed modest reduction (effect size d=0.22) through vicarious intergroup , though long-term effects waned without reinforcement. These designs collectively affirm that while often stems from resource rivalry or needs, demands structured interdependence, with empirical outcomes varying by context and measurement.

Bystander Effects and Social Influence

The bystander effect describes the inverse relationship between the number of potential helpers present at an emergency and the likelihood that any one of them will intervene, a phenomenon rooted in social psychological experiments demonstrating how group presence inhibits individual action. This effect gained prominence after the 1964 stabbing death of Kitty Genovese in New York City, where newspaper accounts claimed 38 witnesses failed to act despite hearing her cries, though subsequent investigations revealed fewer direct observers and that at least two neighbors contacted police, indicating the story's role as a catalyst rather than precise empirical basis. Pioneering laboratory studies by Bibb Latané and John M. Darley in 1968 isolated key mechanisms, including diffusion of responsibility—wherein perceived responsibility dilutes as the number of bystanders increases—and social influence through pluralistic ignorance, where individuals defer to the apparent consensus of inaction among others, misinterpreting it as evidence the situation is not urgent. In Latané and Darley's seminal seizure simulation experiment, female undergraduate participants believed they were participating in a group discussion on life in college via intercom, but were isolated in individual rooms; they heard a confederate feign an epileptic seizure escalating to apparent unconsciousness. When participants thought they were alone with the victim, 85% sought help within three minutes by notifying the experimenter; this dropped to 62% if they believed one other bystander was present and to 31% if two others were involved, with response times lengthening correspondingly. A parallel "smoke-filled room" study exposed participants to smoke seeping from a wall vent while waiting for an experimenter; alone, 75% reported the smoke within the first two minutes, interpreting it as a fire risk, but in groups of three including two passive confederates who ignored it, only 38% ever reported it and just 10% did so quickly, as social cues from non-reacting peers fostered pluralistic ignorance about the threat's severity. These findings underscored processes, where bystanders evaluate not only through personal assessment but by observing peers' responses, leading to coordinated inaction if ambiguity persists; for instance, in the seizure setup, participants hesitated longer when hearing no immediate outcry from supposed co-bystanders. Latané and Darley proposed a five-stage decision model for bystander —noticing the event, interpreting it as an , assuming personal responsibility, knowing how to help, and implementing action—each stage vulnerable to that amplify hesitation. Subsequent replications, such as those examining versus friend presence, confirmed that familiarity reduces , with friends more likely to intervene due to heightened personal accountability, highlighting relational factors in . Empirical robustness persists across contexts, though real-world applications reveal moderators like clear cues or direct appeals overriding the effect.

Workplace and Organizational Behaviors

The Hawthorne studies, conducted from 1924 to 1932 at the in , represent an early large-scale investigation into social influences on . Initially focused on the impact of physical conditions like illumination on output, researchers observed that worker rose during experimental manipulations—such as increased or decreased lighting—and persisted even when conditions reverted or worsened, suggesting that attention from observers and altered social dynamics, rather than environmental factors, drove the changes. Subsequent phases, including the relay assembly test room experiments with 13 women from 1927 to 1928, examined variables like rest breaks, work hours, and group incentives; improved across conditions, attributed to enhanced group cohesion, supervisory rapport, and . The bank wiring observation room study from 1931 to 1932, involving 14 male workers, revealed informal group norms restricting output to avoid rate-busting or rate-busting perceptions, highlighting how and social hierarchies shaped behavior independently of incentives. These findings spurred the in , emphasizing social and psychological factors over Taylorist efficiency models, though methodological critiques later emerged. A 2014 systematic review of 92 studies found limited evidence for a robust Hawthorne effect, estimating its magnitude at a small 0.28 standard deviation increase in performance under observation, with effects varying by context and often confounded by demand characteristics or unmeasured variables like expectancy bias. Despite debates over data interpretation—such as small sample sizes and lack of randomization—the studies demonstrated causal roles for in sustaining output, influencing modern views that informal norms and perceived attention can override material incentives. Building on such insights, s have provided causal evidence for targeted interventions in organizational settings. In a 2013 randomized at a large involving 270 employees, unannounced public recognition via peer-nominated awards for high performers increased subsequent output by 13.8% over six months compared to controls, with effects persisting without financial incentives and linked to heightened from approval rather than . Similarly, a 2023 with call center agents tested weekly performance feedback; treated groups receiving individualized comparative data showed a 5-10% productivity gain, mediated by revised effort beliefs and reduced miscalibration, underscoring how transparent comparisons alter self-perception and causal attributions of ability. Experiments on group composition reveal affecting coordination and . A 2020 field experiment in teams randomized gender distributions, finding that token women (one per mixed-gender team) exerted 30% less on collective decisions than women in majority-female teams, resulting in lower overall team productivity due to diluted voice and pressures, independent of individual skill differences. These results align with sociological evidence that minority status amplifies in hierarchical organizations, though effects diminish in high-trust or flat structures. Collectively, such experiments affirm that organizational behaviors emerge from interplay of observation, norms, and relational cues, often yielding persistent gains when interventions leverage intrinsic social motivators over extrinsic controls.

Policy and Large-Scale Intervention Experiments

Health, Insurance, and Resource Allocation

The Health Insurance Experiment (HIE), conducted from 1974 to 1982, randomized over 5,800 individuals from approximately 2,000 households across 12 U.S. sites to one of six plans varying in cost-sharing levels, from free care to 95% . This design isolated causal effects of generosity on healthcare utilization, expenditures, and outcomes, revealing that higher cost-sharing reduced outpatient visits by about 25-30% and hospital admissions by 10-15%, lowering overall spending without significant adverse effects on for the average enrollee. However, free care improved outcomes for low-income participants with chronic conditions, such as better control, while inducing through excess utilization among healthier groups. These results underscored inefficiencies in fully subsidized , as shifted toward low-value care without proportional gains. The Oregon Health Insurance Experiment (OHIE), initiated in 2008, leveraged a lottery system to randomly allocate approximately 30,000 adults access to expansion slots, providing a on public insurance effects amid constrained budgets. Winners experienced increased healthcare utilization, including preventive services and emergency visits, alongside reduced out-of-pocket spending and financial strain, but showed no statistically significant improvements in objective physical health measures—such as , levels, or control—over the first 15-24 months. benefits emerged, with lower rates, yet overall mortality rates remained unchanged, suggesting expanded coverage reallocates resources toward service use rather than transformative health impacts in the short term. Long-term follow-ups confirmed persistent null effects on physical outcomes, challenging assumptions of insurance as a direct lever for . These experiments highlight tensions in , where expansions boost —evident in RAND's elasticity and Oregon's 35-40% rise in visits—but yield diminishing marginal returns on , particularly for non-poor or non-chronically ill populations. Policymakers must weigh such evidence against ideological pressures favoring universal coverage, as empirical causal estimates reveal trade-offs like opportunity costs for alternative interventions, such as targeted programs. In resource-scarce systems, findings from these RCTs support prioritizing cost-sharing mechanisms to curb overuse while safeguarding vulnerable subgroups, aligning allocation with verifiable outcome improvements over volume-driven models.

Education and Early Childhood Programs

The Perry Preschool Project, conducted from 1962 to 1967 in , randomly assigned 123 low-income, predominantly African American children aged 3-4 to either a high-quality program or a control group. The intervention emphasized and parent involvement, lasting 2.5 years with home visits; follow-up data through age 40 revealed treated participants had higher high school graduation rates (67% vs. 45%), reduced arrest rates (45% fewer felonies), and increased earnings (averaging $7,656 more annually), yielding an of 7-10% per dollar invested. These outcomes persisted into midlife, with intergenerational benefits including improved child school achievement among participants' offspring, though program scale-up challenges limit broad replication. The Carolina Abecedarian Project, launched in 1972 in , provided intensive early education and family support from infancy through 5 to 111 at-risk children via . Treated children showed persistent IQ gains (4-5 points into adulthood), higher (36% degree vs. 14% in controls by 30), and better health metrics, including lower and risks. Peer-reviewed analyses confirm causal links to reduced teen parenthood and increased , attributing effects to enriched exposure and caregiver responsiveness, though small sample size (n=57 per group) tempers generalizability. Tennessee's Project (Student-Teacher Achievement Ratio), implemented from 1985 to 1989, randomly assigned over 11,000 kindergarteners across 79 schools to small classes (13-17 students), regular classes (22-25), or regular with aides. Small-class students gained 0.2-0.3 standard deviations in math and reading scores by grade 3, with larger effects for and low-income subgroups; long-term tracking indicated higher and , equivalent to a 3-4 boost. However, independent reanalyses highlight potential biases from non-random teacher assignments and fading effects post-assignment, with nonexperimental data showing inconsistent class-size benefits elsewhere. Head Start, a federally funded initiative for low-income children since 1965, has undergone multiple evaluations, including a 2005-2010 randomized impact study of 5,000 participants. Short-term cognitive gains appeared in assessments, but most faded by , with no sustained effects on or socio-emotional outcomes by ; critics cite persistent null long-term impacts on or in rigorous trials, questioning amid $12 billion annual costs. Select reanalyses claim subgroup benefits like reduced special education placement (by 8-10%), yet overall evidence reveals limited causal persistence compared to intensive models like , potentially due to variable program quality and scale dilution. These experiments underscore that targeted, high-fidelity interventions yield stronger returns than broad implementations, prioritizing skill-building over mere access.

Welfare, Poverty, and Mobility Interventions

The Negative Income Tax (NIT) experiments, conducted in the United States from 1968 to 1982 across multiple sites including New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Indiana's Gary, Seattle-Denver, and rural Iowa-North Carolina, tested guaranteed cash payments phased out as earnings rose to assess impacts on work effort, family stability, and poverty reduction. These randomized controlled trials involved thousands of low-income families, offering benefits equivalent to 35-65% of the federal poverty line with guarantee levels varying by family size and location, simulating a universal basic income alternative to traditional welfare. Empirical results indicated modest reductions in labor supply, with secondary earners (primarily wives) showing the largest declines—up to 17% fewer hours worked in some cohorts—while primary earners exhibited smaller effects around 5%. Overall, family earnings fell by approximately 5-10%, though poverty rates decreased due to transfers; however, long-term data from the Seattle-Denver experiment revealed slight reductions in adult children's earnings, suggesting intergenerational work disincentives. Family dissolution rates rose by 40-50% in experimental groups, attributed to reduced economic pressures for maintaining marriages, though causal links remain debated given selection into participation. The Moving to Opportunity (MTO) experiment, initiated by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development in 1994 across , , , , and , randomized over 4,600 low-income families from high-poverty to receive housing vouchers restricted to low-poverty neighborhoods (experimental group), unrestricted Section 8 vouchers (Section 8 group), or no voucher (control). The intervention aimed to test whether relocating to areas with lower crime, better schools, and higher improved outcomes like , , and intergenerational . Short-term findings (through 2002) showed no significant or gains for adults but reductions in and among women who moved, alongside decreased exposure to for youth. Long-term analysis using tax data, published in 2016, revealed substantial benefits for children: those under age 13 at who moved experienced 31% higher household incomes by age 26, with boys gaining up to 46% and reduced single parenthood; effects were negligible or negative for older youth and girls, highlighting age-sensitive neighborhood influences on accumulation. These gains stemmed from causal reductions in exposure to poor role models and toxic environments rather than direct resource transfers, though take-up rates were low (under 50%) due to logistical barriers like moving costs. Subsequent replications and extensions, such as Creating Moves to pilots in the , confirmed MTO's core insights: incentives like search assistance boosted relocation rates to 50-60%, yielding similar gains for young children without adverse adult effects. Unlike NIT's focus on incentives, which empirically prioritized over sustained labor participation, interventions underscore environmental causation in persistence, with benefits accruing primarily through altered developmental trajectories rather than financial liquidity alone. Academic analyses, often from institutions with leanings, emphasize positive externalities while downplaying null adult results, yet raw data from administrative records affirm modest overall policy given high implementation costs and variable .

Ethical Considerations

Deception, Consent, and Participant Harm

is frequently employed in social experiments to elicit natural behaviors and avoid demand characteristics, where participants might alter actions if aware of the study's hypotheses, yet this practice inherently undermines fully by withholding or misrepresenting key aspects of the procedure. Psychologists justify such methods when alternative designs are infeasible and potential benefits outweigh risks, provided no foreseeable physical pain or severe emotional distress occurs and thorough follows to restore understanding and address any adverse effects. The American Psychological Association's permit only after determining its necessity and ensuring participants are not personally targeted in ways that could induce lasting , emphasizing post-study explanations that clarify deceptions and offer opportunities for withdrawal of data. Informed consent in these contexts is compromised, as participants cannot provide true voluntary agreement without complete disclosure, leading to debates on whether partial or postponed revelation suffices ethically; analysis shows deception often conflicts with valid consent unless rigorously mitigated through IRB oversight and evidence that participants would not have declined participation if informed. For instance, in Stanley Milgram's 1961 obedience experiments at Yale University, 40 male participants aged 20-50 were led to believe they administered electric shocks up to 450 volts to a learner (actually a confederate) for incorrect answers, with 65% complying to the maximum despite apparent screams and silence suggesting fatality, resulting in acute stress including profuse sweating, trembling, stuttering, and three seizures. While Milgram debriefed subjects, revealing the setup and offering psychological support, critics argued the absence of prior warnings about potential distress violated consent principles, though follow-up surveys indicated 84% later viewed the study positively for its insights into authority. Participant harm manifests primarily as temporary psychological distress rather than permanent damage, with empirical tests finding no significant negative impacts on or mood from deception itself, though individual vulnerabilities can amplify effects. The 1971 , conducted by with 24 male undergraduates randomly assigned as guards or prisoners in a simulated jail, escalated beyond expectations due to role immersion, with guards imposing humiliating treatments like push-ups and , prompting early termination after six days amid emotional breakdowns and . Participants were screened for psychological stability and consented to discomfort but not the full intensity or indefinite duration, raising concerns over and inadequate safeguards against harm, exacerbated by Zimbardo's dual role as superintendent. mitigated some effects, yet the episode highlighted risks of situational pressures overriding . Other cases underscore privacy invasions as a harm vector; in ' 1960s study, the sociologist covertly observed anonymous public sex acts between men, recorded license plates to trace 100 participants' home addresses via ministerial contacts, and surveyed them under without revealing prior , exposing risks of and social repercussions in an era of . This breached norms, as identities were not anonymized, potentially endangering participants' safety and reputations, though Humphreys argued the data advanced understanding of victimless behaviors without direct . Institutional review boards now mandate risk-benefit assessments, prohibiting if it foreseeably causes distrust in science or violates , with alternatives like or simulations preferred when viable to preserve . Despite these frameworks, historical experiments demonstrate that while short-term harms predominate, the causal chain from to broader societal mistrust remains empirically contested, informing stricter protocols without fully curtailing methodologically essential inquiries.

Institutional Review and Long-Term Consequences

Institutional Review Boards (IRBs), established under the of 1974 in response to ethical abuses like the , mandate ethical oversight for human subjects research, including social experiments, by evaluating risks, benefits, , and equitable subject selection per the Belmont Report's principles of respect for persons, beneficence, and justice. In social and behavioral contexts, IRBs permit limited if risks are minimal and occurs, but they often classify studies like surveys or interviews as requiring full review despite low harm potential. Social science researchers frequently encounter IRB processes ill-suited to their field, as regulations derived from biomedical models impose excessive , forms, and assessments on minimal-risk activities such as anonymous questionnaires or public observations, resulting in approval delays averaging 8-30 days for expedited reviews and deterring junior scholars through . The has critiqued this mismatch, noting IRBs' frequent lack of expertise leads to irrelevant demands, like mandating written for oral histories, and recommends greater disciplinary representation on boards to streamline low-risk approvals. Oversight failures highlight gaps; for instance, the 2012 Facebook-Cornell study manipulated news feeds of approximately 689,000 users to induce mood changes without obtaining or securing prior IRB approval, with Cornell's IRB later claiming exemption due to indirect researcher involvement, though rules require for such subjects interventions. Similarly, some field experiments in , such as unsolicited voter mobilization tactics targeting half of Black voters in a , bypassed and , inadvertently suppressing turnout without ethical safeguards. Long-term consequences for participants in social experiments are generally limited when protocols include proper debriefing, as empirical tests of deception show no enduring effects on self-esteem (measured via Rosenberg Scale), positive/negative affect (PANAS), or institutional trust. In Stanley Milgram's 1961 obedience studies, a one-year follow-up survey of participants revealed no widespread long-term psychological harm, with most reporting the experience as valuable despite acute stress like anxiety or nervous laughter during shocks up to 450 volts. Broader societal repercussions include diminished public confidence in research institutions and unintended policy distortions; unreviewed large-scale manipulations, as in the case, risk amplifying emotional vulnerabilities in subpopulations like adolescents without recourse, prompting calls for updated standards incorporating " for societies" to mandate notification for interventions affecting communities. Historical lapses, such as the Monster Study inducing in orphans , demonstrate rare but severe lasting harms like persistent speech impediments, underscoring causal links between inadequate review and avoidable individual . These outcomes have driven reforms like enhanced journal policies, though compliance remains inconsistent in field settings.

Balancing Scientific Gain Against Risks

Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) mandate that risks to participants in social experiments must be reasonable in relation to anticipated benefits, as outlined in U.S. federal regulations under 45 CFR 46.111, which require minimization of risks and evaluation of whether they justify the knowledge gained. This assessment distinguishes direct benefits to participants—such as educational insights or monetary compensation—from indirect societal benefits, like advancing understanding of to inform or prevent atrocities. In behavioral research, risks often include psychological distress from or induction, weighed against probabilistic harms from everyday life, with minimal risk defined as not exceeding those in routine procedures. The Belmont Report (1979) emphasizes beneficence, requiring researchers to maximize possible benefits while minimizing harms through systematic risk-benefit analysis, though it notes the metaphorical nature of "balancing" due to qualitative differences between individual harms and collective scientific gains. For instance, Stanley Milgram's 1961 obedience experiments demonstrated that 65% of participants administered what they believed were lethal electric shocks under authority pressure, yielding enduring insights into compliance mechanisms relevant to events like the Holocaust, with follow-up studies showing no long-term harm despite acute stress reported by 84% of subjects. Proponents argue the societal value—illuminating causal pathways of destructive obedience—outweighed transient discomfort, as debriefing mitigated effects, though critics contend initial risk underestimation reflected inadequate foresight into emotional impacts. Philip Zimbardo's 1971 , halted after six days due to escalating abuse among mock guards and prisoner distress, highlighted situational forces in but faced scrutiny for methodological flaws amplifying harms without proportional novel insights, as effects were already partially known. Ethical frameworks thus prioritize prospective harm probability and severity, rejecting approval if risks exceed those in non-research contexts without compelling justification, such as in trauma-focused studies where re-exposure risks PTSD exacerbation despite potential therapeutic precedents. Challenges in risk-benefit analysis for social experiments include subjectivity in valuing diffuse scientific contributions against tangible harms, with non-therapeutic designs often inflating societal benefits to offset individual exposures, potentially leading to biased approvals in fields prone to overclaiming generalizability. Community-engaged adds layers, balancing group-level gains—like policy improvements from interventions—against collective risks such as , requiring explicit consideration of to avoid exploiting vulnerable populations. Ultimately, approvals hinge on evidence that experiments cannot achieve aims through less risky means, ensuring causal knowledge from controlled manipulations justifies ethical costs only when empirical validity holds.

Criticisms and Methodological Limitations

Replication Failures and Overstated Claims

The replication crisis in psychological science, including social experiments, has revealed that many influential findings do not hold up under repeated testing with rigorous methods. The Reproducibility Project: Psychology (2015), a collaborative effort to replicate 100 experiments from leading journals, found that only 36% of replications yielded statistically significant results consistent with the originals, and successful replications showed effect sizes averaging less than half the original magnitude. This low rate persisted in social psychology subsets, where experiments testing conformity, obedience, and group dynamics—hallmarks of social experiments—frequently failed due to factors like small sample sizes, questionable research practices, and inflated Type I error rates from selective reporting. The (1971), often cited as evidence for the power of situational roles in eliciting abusive behavior, exemplifies both replication failures and overstated causal claims. No peer-reviewed attempt has successfully reproduced its core findings of rapid and guard-prisoner antagonism among unselected participants. A 2002 replication, using similar role assignments, instead observed prisoners organizing resistance and overpowering guards within days, contradicting claims of inherent situational tyranny. Archival reviews further indicate experimenter demand characteristics and direct coaching by inflated outcomes, rendering broad generalizations to real prisons or authority structures empirically unsupported. Other classic social experiments have similarly faced scrutiny for exaggeration. Asch's conformity studies (1951), while partially replicable in basic line-judgment tasks, showed diminished effects in modern settings with reduced social pressure, suggesting original claims of near-universal susceptibility overstated contextual dependencies. Broader analyses attribute such issues to favoring novel, large effects, with meta-analyses estimating that true effect sizes in paradigms are often 20-50% smaller than initially reported. These patterns underscore how initial hype, amplified by media and textbooks despite weak evidence, has propagated misleading narratives about human social behavior.

External Validity and Generalizability Issues

External validity in social experiments pertains to the applicability of findings beyond the specific conditions of the study, encompassing variations in populations, settings, treatments, and outcomes. Unlike , which focuses on within the experiment, assesses whether effects observed in controlled or field trials extend to real-world scenarios or diverse groups. In social experiments, ranging from laboratory-based behavioral studies to large-scale policy interventions, threats to external validity arise from non-representative sampling, artificial constructs, and untested heterogeneity, often leading to overstated or context-bound conclusions. A primary concern is the predominance of samples from Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic () societies, which represent only about 12% of the global population but account for the majority of participants. Henrich, Heine, and Norenzayan (2010) reviewed over 100 studies across domains like , , and , demonstrating that WEIRD individuals exhibit atypical responses—such as heightened and reduced kin-based cooperation—compared to non-WEIRD groups, rendering generalizations to broader humanity unreliable. For instance, fairness in economic games, a staple in social experiments, shows WEIRD participants as outliers in punishing inequity, with effects diminishing or reversing in small-scale or collectivist societies. This , entrenched in academic institutions concentrated in WEIRD nations, systematically skews findings toward unrepresentative norms. Laboratory social experiments exacerbate generalizability issues through contrived environments that elicit characteristics, where participants infer and to perceived experimenter expectations rather than natural behaviors. studies, such as those on or , often fail to replicate outside sterile lab conditions, with real-world analogs showing muted or absent effects due to absent social pressures or stakes. In policy-oriented social experiments, such as randomized controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating or programs, site-specific implementations introduce further limitations; a of RCTs published in top journals from 2000–2014 found that fewer than 20% explicitly addressed generalizability, with effects frequently tied to unique local factors like implementation fidelity or participant , hindering to national scales. Heterogeneity in treatment effects across subgroups or contexts poses additional challenges, as social experiments often report average effects that mask variations by demographics, , or scale. For development RCTs in low-income settings, Baregheh et al. () analyzed 214 trials and identified poor transportability due to unmodeled interactions between interventions and environmental variables, such as institutional or economic shocks, with success in pilot sites rarely sustaining at larger scopes. Methods to mitigate these issues, including pretest similarity assessments or meta-analytic comparisons, remain underutilized, partly because experiments prioritize amid funding pressures for novel demonstrations over broad applicability tests. Consequently, policymakers risk adopting interventions based on fragile , as seen in scaled programs where initial gains evaporate due to unaddressed generalizability gaps.

Ideological Influences and Causal Misattributions

, the primary field conducting controlled social experiments, exhibits a pronounced ideological skew, with self-identified liberals comprising over 80% of researchers and ratios of liberals to conservatives reaching 14:1 or higher in faculty positions as of surveys through the . This demographic homogeneity, documented in multiple professional surveys, fosters conformity pressures that prioritize hypotheses compatible with progressive assumptions, such as the primacy of environmental and systemic factors in over innate or dispositional ones. Consequently, experimental designs may inadvertently embed ideological priors, leading to selective emphasis on variables that confirm egalitarian narratives while sidelining those challenging them, as modeled in frameworks of where data contradicting liberal-favoring theories face heightened skepticism. Such influences contribute to causal misattributions by overemphasizing situational manipulations as sufficient explanations for outcomes, often at the expense of confounding individual differences or selection effects. In classic obedience experiments like Stanley Milgram's 1961 studies, high compliance rates (up to 65% delivering what participants believed were lethal shocks) were attributed predominantly to the authority situation, aligning with anti-authoritarian ideologies that de-emphasize personal agency; however, replications and meta-analyses indicate personality traits like empathy deficits and right-wing authoritarianism predict obedience more robustly than situational factors alone, suggesting an underappreciation of dispositional causality in original interpretations. Similarly, Philip Zimbardo's 1971 Stanford Prison Experiment ascribed prisoner abuse to deindividuating roles and institutional power dynamics, resonating with critiques of systemic oppression; re-evaluations, including archival reviews, reveal experimenter coaching of "guards" to induce hostility and self-selection biases among participants skewed the results, misattributing escalation to situational causality while ignoring demand characteristics and researcher influence. The exacerbates these issues, with only about 25-50% of effects replicating in large-scale efforts like the 2015 Collaboration project, often due to overstated causal claims rooted in ideologically congenial but fragile findings. Ideological may perpetuate such misattributions by discouraging scrutiny of results that affirm priors, such as those implying widespread implicit as a primary driver of ; experiments like resume studies frequently infer from callback disparities, yet fail to control for unobservable confounders like motivation or cultural fit, leading to causal overreach that aligns with narratives prioritizing structural injustice over behavioral or merit-based factors. This pattern underscores how ideological filters in academia—where conservative viewpoints represent under 5% of published perspectives—can distort causal realism, privileging empirical anomalies that support reformist agendas while undervaluing robust, politically inconvenient alternatives.

Informal, Digital, and Natural Experiments

Online and Community-Driven Initiatives

and community-driven social experiments utilize digital platforms to observe emergent behaviors among participants who voluntarily engage, often without formal oversight from researchers. These initiatives harness the scale of the to generate large datasets on , , and in naturalistic settings. Unlike controlled laboratory studies, they frequently arise organically from user interactions, revealing patterns such as faction formation and status driven by shared incentives. A prominent example is Reddit's "The Button," initiated on April 1, 2015, as an April Fools' prank featuring a clickable button with a 60-second that reset upon each press, assigning users colored flairs based on their pressing interval. Over two months, more than one million users participated, forming distinct communities—Blue for those who never pressed, and others like and for varying restraint levels—which engaged in debates, alliances, and identity signaling. The experiment concluded on June 5, 2015, when the reached zero after persistent pressing, demonstrating how minimal rules can foster and curiosity-driven participation, though self-selection limited generalizability. In massively multiplayer online games like , launched in May 2003, player-driven economies and politics create ongoing social experiments with thousands of concurrent users managing virtual assets exceeding real-world value in trillions of in-game currency. Alliances wage large-scale conflicts, such as the 2017 "World War Bee," involving coordinated strategies that mirror real geopolitical tensions and economic incentives. analyzing player data from 2013–2018 found that in-game role specialization—e.g., combat versus industry—correlates with players' real-world socioeconomic factors, like employment status, validating virtual worlds as proxies for testing causal links in without ethical barriers to . These dynamics highlight emergent and but suffer from selection effects, as participants are predominantly young males with gaming affinity. Such initiatives offer causal insights into unscripted behaviors at low cost but face methodological challenges, including unverifiable participant motivations and echo-chamber amplification within platforms. Empirical studies of these experiments underscore their value in revealing first-mover advantages and network effects, yet caution against overextrapolation due to non-representative samples.

Media and Viral Social Tests

Media outlets have produced programs staging public scenarios to test social responses, often disseminating findings through broadcast and online platforms for broad visibility. ABC's What Would You Do?, which debuted on February 20, 2008, exemplifies this approach by concealing cameras in everyday settings to capture unscripted reactions to fabricated ethical dilemmas, such as witnessing discrimination or potential child endangerment. Hosted by John Quiñones, the series has aired over 300 segments across more than a dozen seasons as of 2023, prompting viewers to reflect on their own likely actions while highlighting variances in bystander intervention based on factors like victim demographics. These televised tests prioritize real-time behavioral observation over controlled variables, yielding anecdotal insights into social norms but facing criticism for potential actor influence on outcomes and lack of participant akin to formal protocols. Production teams intervene post-scenario to reveal the setup, mitigating some but not addressing broader issues in public filming. Viral social tests on digital platforms extend this format, leveraging algorithms for rapid dissemination and large-scale . In a prominent initiative, researchers manipulated news feeds for 689,003 English-speaking users over one week, reducing exposure to positive or negative emotional content to assess effects. Published in , the study found that diminished positive posts correlated with 0.07% fewer positive updates from affected users, evidencing non-verbal emotional transmission through networks, though effect sizes remained small. This experiment ignited debates on corporate overreach, as alterations occurred without explicit , relying instead on ; ethicists argued it breached guidelines like those from the by potentially inducing distress without safeguards. Mainstream coverage amplified scrutiny, underscoring tensions between platform-driven "experiments" and traditional research standards, with subsequent policy shifts at mandating reviews for similar studies. User-generated viral tests, such as staged public pranks or trust challenges shared on and , proliferate but often lack methodological rigor, with editing and inflating dramatic responses to align with creators' narratives. Analyses of these videos reveal inconsistencies, undermining claims of and raising concerns over manufactured outrage for views rather than genuine behavioral inquiry. Despite popularity—some garnering millions of views—they contribute minimally to empirical knowledge, serving more as than verifiable social probes.

Unintended Large-Scale Natural Experiments

Unintended large-scale experiments emerge when exogenous events, such as disasters or shocks, generate quasi-random variation in conditions, allowing researchers to isolate causal effects on behaviors like , , and formation without intentional design. These scenarios leverage real-world perturbations to test hypotheses on human responses, often revealing dynamics unattainable in lab settings due to scale and . Unlike deliberate experiments, they arise from historical contingencies or uncontrolled interventions, providing empirical leverage for through methods like difference-in-differences or instrumental variables. Natural disasters exemplify such experiments by disrupting communities unevenly, enabling comparisons between affected and unaffected groups. A study of Hurricane Hugo's 1989 impact on households used pre- and post-event survey data to demonstrate short-term surges in weak ties for resource sharing, followed by long-term reinforcement of strong familial bonds as primary support mechanisms, highlighting adaptive social restructuring under stress. Similarly, analysis of the exploited spatial variation in damage to show temporary boosts in inter-group cooperation for survival, but persistent declines in generalized trust toward outsiders years later, underscoring limits to prosocial spillover. These findings, drawn from longitudinal network data, illustrate how acute shocks can accelerate tie formation while eroding broader if recovery lags. Military draft lotteries during the (1969–1972) functioned as an unintended randomization mechanism, assigning service eligibility by birth date to over 27 million men, which researchers later exploited to estimate causal impacts on life trajectories. Eligible cohorts experienced a 10–15% earnings penalty persisting into middle age, alongside elevated divorce rates and health impairments like PTSD, attributed to disrupted accumulation and trauma exposure rather than . This quasi-experimental design, validated through regression discontinuity, revealed how involuntary service altered social outcomes, including reduced family stability and , informing debates on conscription's societal costs. Pandemics like have yielded natural experiments via differential implementations across regions, testing compliance and behavioral adaptation. Variation in U.S. state-level restrictions from March 2020 onward showed stricter measures correlating with 20–30% drops in mobility and temporary rises in online social , but also heightened and declines, with non-compliance higher in low-trust areas per survey data. Ethically fraught, these observations—analyzed via synthetic controls—exposed trade-offs in enforced distancing, such as eroded community bonds without proportional behavioral shifts in high-autonomy contexts, challenging assumptions of uniform policy responsiveness.

Impact and Broader Implications

Contributions to Understanding Human Behavior

Social experiments have illuminated mechanisms of obedience, conformity, and intergroup dynamics, revealing how situational pressures can override individual moral reasoning and predispose people toward harmful or irrational actions. Stanley Milgram's 1961 obedience studies, for instance, demonstrated that 65% of participants administered what they believed to be lethal electric shocks (up to 450 volts) to a learner under directives from an authority figure, underscoring the potency of hierarchical commands in eliciting compliance even against personal ethics. This finding advanced agency theory, positing that individuals in subordinate roles often shift responsibility to superiors, diffusing personal accountability for destructive behavior. Subsequent partial replications, such as Jerry Burger's 2009 study halting at 150 volts, confirmed high continuation rates (82.5% past initial protests), affirming the robustness of obedience under perceived authority despite ethical constraints on full replication. Conformity experiments by in the early 1950s further exposed the influence of group consensus on perception and judgment, with participants yielding to incorrect majority opinions on comparisons in 37% of critical trials overall, and up to 75% conforming at least once across groups. These results delineated normative influence—conforming to gain social approval—and informational influence—deferring to perceived group expertise—highlighting how social validation can distort objective reality assessment, a dynamic evident in everyday under . Modern extensions, including a 2023 replication with visual tasks, replicated core rates, reinforcing its applicability to contemporary processes. Muzafer Sherif's 1954 Robbers Cave experiment with adolescent boys illustrated , where competition over resources escalated intergroup hostility—manifesting in name-calling, raids, and vandalism—while shared superordinate goals, such as repairing a , fostered reconciliation and positive relations. This demonstrated that and stem not from innate outgroup but from tangible rivalries, resolvable through cooperative interdependence, informing models of in diverse societies. Philip Zimbardo's 1971 , though methodologically contested, provided early evidence for situational determinism in role adoption, as randomly assigned "guards" rapidly exhibited and abusive tactics—such as psychological —toward "prisoners" within days, suggesting environmental cues and power asymmetries amplify tendencies beyond dispositional traits. The study's termination after six days due to emotional distress underscored how institutional roles can erode , influencing discourse on and , where good individuals perform evil under systemic pressures. Collectively, these paradigms shifted emphasis from personality-centric explanations to contextual factors in behavioral prediction, laying groundwork for social psychology's situational paradigm while prompting scrutiny of experimental artifacts.

Policy Applications and Unintended Consequences

Social experiments have informed by providing empirical tests of interventions prior to widespread implementation, particularly in areas like and alleviation. In the United States, randomized controlled trials conducted in the and , such as the New Jersey Graduated Work Incentive Experiment and the Seattle-Denver Income Maintenance Experiment, examined the effects of guaranteed annual income on labor supply, finding that recipients reduced work hours by approximately 5-15% but experienced improved health and educational outcomes for children. These findings influenced debates on , contributing to the design of programs like the , which aimed to mitigate work disincentives observed in the trials. Similarly, European policymakers have adopted social experimentation to assess labor market interventions, as outlined in methodological guides emphasizing small-scale testing to evaluate efficacy before scaling, such as pilots for active labor market policies in the early . Behavioral experiments derived from social psychology have also shaped policy through "nudges" and mechanism tests, with governments establishing units like the UK's Behavioural Insights Team in 2010 to apply findings on decision-making biases to areas like tax compliance and energy conservation. For instance, default opt-in mechanisms for pension enrollment, informed by experiments on inertia, increased participation rates from around 60% to over 90% in the UK by 2012. However, such applications often rely on social psychology findings, many of which face replication challenges; a 2015 large-scale replication effort found only 36% of 100 prominent psychological studies reproduced original effect sizes, raising doubts about the reliability of nudge-based policies extrapolated from non-replicable lab results. Unintended consequences arise when experimental findings are misapplied or overlook broader causal dynamics, leading to policies that produce suboptimal or counterproductive outcomes. Early welfare experiments, while revealing work disincentives, underestimated family structure effects, with some trials showing increased marital instability that was not fully anticipated, complicating scaling. The replication crisis exacerbates this by allowing overstated claims from low-powered studies to influence resource allocation; for example, interventions like growth mindset training, hyped for educational despite inconsistent replications, have been rolled out in U.S. schools with mixed results, diverting funds from more robust alternatives. Additionally, behavioral policies can generate spillover effects, such as control group resentment or Hawthorne-like reactivity, where awareness of experimentation alters behavior beyond the intended intervention, as noted in evaluations of nudges during the . These issues underscore the need for causal realism in interpreting experiments, as ideological preferences in academia may amplify non-replicable findings aligned with preferred narratives while downplaying null results.

Future Directions Amid Replication and Ethical Scrutiny

Researchers in and related fields are increasingly prioritizing methodological reforms to counteract replication failures, such as mandating preregistration of protocols and promoting multi-site collaborations to increase sample and statistical . A six-year investigation published in 2023 successfully replicated 16 novel findings by enforcing practices like data transparency and hypothesis pre-specification, achieving higher fidelity than traditional approaches and highlighting the potential for these tools to restore . These efforts address core issues like p-hacking and underpowered designs, which empirical audits have shown undermine up to 50% of published effects in the . Ethical oversight has intensified following historical abuses, with Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) now requiring detailed risk assessments for deception-based paradigms, though field experiments often evade full compliance due to real-world exigencies. A 2020 analysis of field studies revealed widespread lapses in documentation and , prompting recommendations for standardized ethical templates adaptable to and settings. To reconcile scrutiny with progress, scholars propose hybrid designs that leverage passive observational data from large-scale platforms—such as interactions—reducing direct participant manipulation while enabling via variables or discontinuity. Emerging directions include harnessing computational simulations and to pre-test experimental manipulations virtually, minimizing ethical risks from failed pilots and enhancing before human involvement. Interdisciplinary integration with and favors natural experiments, like policy rollouts exploited for quasi-random variation, over contrived lab scenarios to bolster amid persistent replication shortfalls. These approaches, coupled with incentives for registered reports in journals, aim to cultivate a ecosystem where verifiable trumps anecdotal impact, though systemic biases in funding and publication—favoring novel over replicable results—must be confronted through policy reforms.

References

  1. [1]
    Social Experiments and Studies in Psychology - Verywell Mind
    Mar 15, 2023 · A social experiment is a type of research performed in psychology to investigate how people respond in certain social situations.
  2. [2]
    Social Experiment - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
    Social experiments are defined as field trials of a policy or social intervention where participants are randomly assigned to different treatment groups, ...
  3. [3]
    Social Psychology Experiments - Explaining Human Nature
    Social psychology experiments can explain how thoughts, feelings and behaviors are influenced by the presence of others.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  4. [4]
    Taking Another Look at the Roots of Social Psychology
    Jan 13, 2012 · Social psychology students have read that Norman Triplett did the first social psychology experiment in 1889, when he found that children reeled in a fishing ...
  5. [5]
    The Most Famous Social Psychology Experiments Ever Performed
    Nov 14, 2023 · Some of the most famous social psychology experiments include Asch's conformity experiments, Bandura's Bobo doll experiments, the Stanford prison experiment, ...
  6. [6]
    5 Famous Social Psychology Experiments - Labvanced
    1. Solomon Asch's Experiments on Conformity · 2. Bobo Doll Experiment by Albert Bandura: Social Learning Theory · 3. Stanford Prison Experiment by Philip Zimbardo.
  7. [7]
    [PDF] The 25 Most Influential Psychological Experiments in History
    Albert Bandura conducted the Bobo Doll Experiment to prove that human behavior is largely based upon social imitation rather than inherited genetic factors. In ...
  8. [8]
    The 10 Most Controversial Psychology Studies Ever Published | BPS
    Sep 19, 2014 · The Stanford Prison Experiment · The Milgram "Shock Experiments" · The "Elderly-related Words Provoke Slow Walking" Experiment (and other social ...
  9. [9]
    Psychology's Ethical Dilemmas: 10 Ethically Dubious Experiments
    This article embarks on a journey through ten such psychological experiments that have blurred the lines between scientific pursuit and ethical integrity.Introduction · Ethically Dubious Psychology... · The Monster Study (1939)
  10. [10]
    Research Methods in Social Psychology - Noba Project
    Learning Objectives · Describe the key features of basic and complex experimental designs. · Describe the key features of field experiments, naturalistic ...
  11. [11]
    The social psychology of perception experiments: Hills, backpacks ...
    In an experiment, participants asked to wear a heavy backpack commonly deduce that the explicit purpose of the backpack is to affect their perception. The best ...Missing: core | Show results with:core
  12. [12]
    [PDF] Social Science Research: Principles, Methods, and Practices
    The scientific method must satisfy four key characteristics: Logical: Scientific inferences must be based on logical principles of reasoning. Confirmable: ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  13. [13]
    https://www.tutor2u.net/psychology/reference/types-of-experiment-overview
  14. [14]
    Experiments in Sociology - An Introduction - ReviseSociology
    Jan 13, 2016 · There are three main types of experimental: The Laboratory experiment, the field experiment and the comparative method. Laboratory Experiments ...
  15. [15]
    Experimental Method In Psychology
    Sep 25, 2023 · An experiment is an investigation in which a hypothesis is scientifically tested. An independent variable (the cause) is manipulated in an ...
  16. [16]
    https://online-learning-college.com/knowledge-hub/gcses/gcse-psychology-help/research-methods/
  17. [17]
    What is a field experiment? | University of Chicago News
    A field experiment is a research method that uses some controlled elements of traditional lab experiments, but takes place in natural, real-world settings.
  18. [18]
    Reading: Experiments | Sociology - Lumen Learning
    There are two main types of experiments: lab-based experiments and natural or field experiments.
  19. [19]
    True, Natural and Field Experiments | IB Psychology
    Sep 29, 2016 · True experiments control variables and randomize participants. Field experiments manipulate variables in natural settings. Natural experiments ...
  20. [20]
    Experiments – An Introduction to Research Methods in Sociology
    There are different experiment designs. In the classic experiment, the effect of a stimulus is tested by comparing two groups: one that is exposed to the ...
  21. [21]
    8.1 Experimental design: What is it and when should it be used?
    Experiments are an excellent data collection strategy for social workers wishing to observe the effects of a clinical intervention or social welfare program.8.1 Experimental Design... · Learning Objectives · Types Of Experimental Design
  22. [22]
    Exploring Experimental Designs in Social Psychology
    Jun 30, 2024 · Experimental designs play a crucial role in social psychology by allowing researchers to test hypotheses and uncover causal relationships ...Types Of Experimental... · True Experimental Designs... · Addressing Threats To...
  23. [23]
    The past, present, and future of experimental methods in the social ...
    Our review covers the core features of experiments that facilitate causal inference, and we offer numerous examples of different experimental designs and the ...Abstract · Theory Testing And... · Sampling
  24. [24]
    An Introduction to the Quasi-Experimental Design (Nonrandomized ...
    May 1, 2025 · Quasi-experimental design strategies are those that, while not incorporating every component of a true experiment, can be developed to make some inferences.Introduction · Figure 1 · Posttest-Only Design With A...
  25. [25]
    Causal Inference in the Social Sciences - Annual Reviews
    Apr 22, 2024 · It has become more interdisciplinary, and the focus has been more specifically on methods for credibly estimating causal effects in a wide range ...
  26. [26]
    Counterfactuals and Causal Inference: Methods and Principles for ...
    Alternative estimation techniques are first introduced using both the potential outcome model and causal graphs; after which, conditioning techniques, such as ...
  27. [27]
    Causal Inference of Social Experiments using Orthogonal Designs
    Sep 12, 2022 · We present a novel application of orthogonal designs that addresses the particular challenges arising in social experiments.
  28. [28]
    Research on Matching Methods for Causal Inference ... - Kosuke Imai
    Jan 11, 2025 · In this project, we develop matching methods that can help empirical researchers conduct reliable and efficient causal inference in both experimental and ...
  29. [29]
    [PDF] Social Networks and Causal Inference - HSPH Content
    In spite of these challenges, several attempts have been made to develop formal approaches to infer causation.
  30. [30]
    Causality and Causal Inference in Social Work - PubMed Central
    However, qualitative methods have also been used in social work research to make causal inferences linking two sets of phenomena.
  31. [31]
    Causal inference on human behaviour - Johns Hopkins University
    The challenges include our ambiguous causal language and thinking, statistical under- or over-control, effect heterogeneity, interference, timescales of effects ...
  32. [32]
    Auguste Comte's Positivism: Foundation of Sociology as a Science
    Nov 3, 2023 · He suggested that sociologists could study “natural experiments” – situations where social conditions change naturally, allowing researchers to ...
  33. [33]
    None
    ### Summary of Key Historical Origins of Social Experimentation
  34. [34]
    SOL Book 6, Chapter 7, John Stuart Mill, A System of Logic - LAITS
    A System of Logic. John Stuart Mill. Book 6. The Logic of the Moral Sciences. Chapter 7. Of the Chemical, or Experimental, Method in the Social Sciences.
  35. [35]
    Mill's methods | Deductive Reasoning, Inductive ... - Britannica
    Oct 18, 2025 · Mill's methods, Five methods of experimental reasoning distinguished by John Stuart Mill in his System of Logic (1843).
  36. [36]
    John Stuart Mill as a social science founder - Understanding Society
    Aug 31, 2009 · Putting his vision simply, science consists of the discovery of general causal laws based on systematic empirical observation. It lays the ...
  37. [37]
    [PDF] Floyd H. Allport (1890-1978) - American Psychological Association
    But it was not until the appearance of Allport's Social Psychology in 1924 that we had a text based heavily on experimental and research studies. This text made ...
  38. [38]
    1.1 Defining Social Psychology: History and Principles
    The earliest social psychology experiments on group behavior were conducted before 1900 (Triplett, 1898), and the first social psychology textbooks were ...
  39. [39]
    [PDF] shaping the field kurt lewin and experimental psychology in
    Since the early 1930s, Kurt Lewin becomes increasingly interested in the treatment of social phenom- ena. At that time, he employs the concept of “quasi ...
  40. [40]
    Kurt Lewin: The Foundations of an Academic Life - Sage Journals
    May 6, 2024 · In 1939, Lewin appears suddenly to move his focus from children to adults and from laboratory experiments to changing behavior in the real ...
  41. [41]
    The Development of Experimental Sociology (Chapter 2)
    Nov 23, 2024 · The first sociological experiments have been conducted in the second and third decades of the twentieth century, accompanied by a fierce ...Missing: 20th | Show results with:20th
  42. [42]
    Ernest Greenwood - University of California
    His dissertation, “Experimental Sociology: A Study in Method” (1945), later published as a book, became a seminal text in the emerging fields of sociology and ...
  43. [43]
    [PDF] 2015.36392.Experimental-Sociology-A-Study-In-Me..
    Dr. Greenwood has studied all the writers who believed they had produced experimental evidence on sociological problems, and he deserves praise for having spent ...
  44. [44]
    NEW JERSEY INCOME-MAINTENANCE EXPERIMENT, VOLUME 1 ...
    A NONTECHNICAL DESCRIPTION IS PROVIDED OF THE NEW JERSEY INCOME MAINTENANCE EXPERIMENT, WITH EMPHASIS ON SUBJECT AND SITE SELECTION AND THE PROJECT'S OPERATIONS ...
  45. [45]
    The New Jersey Income Maintenance Experiment - jstor
    The New Jersey Income Maintenance Experiment was designed to estimate the extent to which workers in poor families would be induced.
  46. [46]
    [PDF] Randomization and Social Policy Evaluation Revisited
    In the early 1960s, Heather Ross, then a graduate student at MIT, proposed a large scale randomized trial to gauge the effects of NIT. The Office of Economic ...
  47. [47]
    [PDF] Lessons from the Income Maintenance Experiments: An Overview
    The New Jersey ex- periment was the first large-scale attempt to test a policy initiative by randomly assigning individuals to alternative programs, and random.
  48. [48]
    Evidence from an Income-Maintenance Experiment
    The results provide empirical evidence that a change in economic situation does affect marital events in low-income populations. Widespread interest in ...<|separator|>
  49. [49]
    [PDF] The New Jersey Income Maintenance Experiment
    Estimates of the effects of tax and income guarantee values on hours worked by white males in the New. Jersey income maintenance experiment are presented ...
  50. [50]
    The Changing Role of Social Experiments in Policy Analysis - jstor
    Since 1968 more than thirty-five social policy experiments have been conducted in the United States. During this period through. 1976 these experiments were ...
  51. [51]
    [PDF] HRD-81-46 Income Maintenance Experiments: Need To Summarize ...
    The New Jersey experiment, for example, tested guaranteed income plans on a total sample of 1,357 families. The experiment's results, however, were based on an ...
  52. [52]
    Our History - MDRC
    MDRC was founded in 1974, initially focused on employment programs, and has expanded into education, criminal justice, and other areas, becoming a leader in ...Missing: experiments | Show results with:experiments
  53. [53]
    RAND's Health Insurance Experiment (HIE)
    The RAND Health Insurance Experiment (HIE) showed that modest cost sharing reduces use of services with negligible effects on health for the average person.Bibliography · Instructions · Contact Us
  54. [54]
    The RAND Health Insurance Experiment, Three Decades Later - PMC
    Between 1974 and 1981, the RAND experiment provided health insurance to more than 5,800 individuals from about 2,000 households in six different locations ...
  55. [55]
    Field Experiments in Economics: The Past, The Present, and The ...
    Sep 19, 2008 · This study presents an overview of modern field experiments and their usage in economics. Our discussion focuses on three distinct periods of field ...
  56. [56]
    [PDF] The Politics and Practice of Social Experiments | MDRC
    the negative income tax (NIT), health insurance, and ...
  57. [57]
    Setting up social experiments: the good, the bad, and the ugly
    Oct 20, 2010 · Since the 1960s, social experiments have been increasingly used in the United States to determine the effects of pilots and demonstrations as ...
  58. [58]
    [PDF] Social Experiments in the Labor Market - UCLA Economics
    Large-scale social experiments were pioneered in labor economics, and are the basis for much of what we know about topics ranging from the effect of job ...
  59. [59]
    [PDF] A Study of Some Social Factors in Perception - MIT
    It is his task to study the genetic development of these social and cultural effects in the individual, the perceptual problem of how the individual responds to ...
  60. [60]
    Social Influence
    Muzafer Sherif (1935, 1936) used the autokinetic effect to study conformity and the establishment of group norms or standards of behavior. The autokinetic ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  61. [61]
    A replication and extension of the Asch experiment | PLOS One
    Nov 29, 2023 · The results were very surprising: on average 35% of the real subjects followed the opinions of the confederates even if their answer was ...Missing: criticisms | Show results with:criticisms
  62. [62]
    A Systematic Review of Research on Conformity
    Jul 18, 2024 · While recent studies confirm the prevalence of conformity across diverse contexts, echoing Asch's seminal findings (1951), the review emphasizes ...
  63. [63]
    More shocking results: New research replicates Milgram's findings
    Mar 1, 2009 · Milgram found that, after hearing the learner's first cries of pain at 150 volts, 82.5 percent of participants continued administering shocks; ...Missing: methods | Show results with:methods
  64. [64]
    [PDF] BEHAVIORAL STUDY OF OBEDIENCE' - Columbia University
    This article describes a procedure for the study of destructive obedience in the laboratory. It coruists of ordering a naive S to administer increasingly.Missing: methods issues
  65. [65]
    [PDF] Replicating Milgram - American Psychological Association
    In addition to their scientific value, the obedience studies generated a great deal of discussion because of the ethical questions they raised (Baumrind, 1964; ...
  66. [66]
    Using new revelations about the Stanford prison experiment to ...
    In August 1971 ... Briefly, the BBC prison study was an attempt to replicate ... Philip Zimbardo's response to recent criticisms of the Stanford prison experiment .
  67. [67]
    [PDF] REFLECTIONS ON THE STANFORD PRISON EXPERIMENT
    Was the SPE study unethical? No and Yes. No, because it followed the guidelines of the Human. Subjects Research Review Board that reviewed it and approved it ( ...
  68. [68]
    Science Correcting Itself | Ongoing Controversies
    Critics claim that Zimbardo and his colleagues influenced the results and used participant behavior that they knew was not authentic to make inaccurate claims ...
  69. [69]
    Bandura, Ross, & Ross (1961) - Classics in the History of Psychology
    The model laid the Bobo doll on its side, sat on it and punched it repeatedly in the nose. The model then raised the Bobo doll, pick up the mallet and struck ...
  70. [70]
    Albert Bandura's experiments on aggression modeling in children
    In these experiments, children observed adults, in vivo or in vitro, as well as cartoons, behaving aggressively toward a large, inflated doll (clown) named “ ...
  71. [71]
    Did the Bobo Doll Studies Teach Us About Aggression?
    Mar 21, 2020 · It's a toy that is entirely intended to be hit. Hitting a Bobo doll tells us nothing about physical aggression toward other people in the real ...
  72. [72]
    Bandura's Bobo Doll Experiment - Psychologist World
    The experiment revealed that children imitate the aggressive behavior of adults. The findings support Bandura's social learning theory, which emphasises the ...
  73. [73]
    What the Bobo Doll Experiment Reveals About Kids and Aggression
    Jan 27, 2025 · The Bobo doll experiment, led by Albert Bandura, found that children learn aggression through observation. But, there are many criticisms of ...
  74. [74]
    An integrative theoretical understanding of aggression: a brief ... - NIH
    This article reports on the classic empirical studies that demonstrated that youth who are exposed to models behaving aggressively not only imitate the ...Figure 1 · Observational Learning · Environmental Influences<|separator|>
  75. [75]
    Stanford Marshmallow Test Experiment - Simply Psychology
    Sep 7, 2023 · The study suggested that gratification delays in children involved suppressing rather than enhancing attention to expected rewards.
  76. [76]
    The Marshmallow Experiment and the Power of Delayed Gratification
    The children who were willing to delay gratification and waited to receive the second marshmallow ended up having higher SAT scores, lower levels of substance ...
  77. [77]
    The significance of self-control - PNAS
    Self-control measured with observer, parent, teacher, and self-report ratings during the first decade of life predicts income, savings behavior, financial ...<|separator|>
  78. [78]
    Revisiting the Marshmallow Test: A Conceptual Replication ... - NIH
    We replicated and extended Shoda, Mischel, and Peake's (1990) famous marshmallow study, which showed strong bivariate correlations between a child's ability ...
  79. [79]
    New Study Disavows Marshmallow Test's Predictive Powers
    Feb 24, 2021 · Questions about the real predictiveness of marshmallow tests never dampened Mischel's support for teaching kids delay of gratification skills. ...
  80. [80]
    The influence of environmental reliability in the marshmallow task
    This study is an extension of an experiment where the reliability of children's environment was manipulated before children completed the Marshmallow Task.<|control11|><|separator|>
  81. [81]
    Personality traits and self-control: The moderating role of neuroticism
    Aug 21, 2024 · Previous studies suggest that conscientiousness and extraversion enhance self-control, whereas neuroticism hampers it.
  82. [82]
    Identifying the individual differences of trait self-control
    Researchers agree that there are differences in levels of trait self-control across individuals, and that these differences are demonstrated in early childhood.
  83. [83]
    Children Delay Gratification and Value It More When Their In-Group ...
    We examined the influence of group membership on self-control behavior by testing whether in-group identity influences children's tendency to delay ...Missing: criticisms | Show results with:criticisms
  84. [84]
    A New Approach to the Marshmallow Test Yields Complicated ...
    Jun 5, 2018 · The “marshmallow test” – the famed psychological experiment designed to measure children's self-control – may not predict life outcomes as much as previously ...
  85. [85]
    Robbers Cave Experiment | Realistic Conflict Theory
    Sep 27, 2023 · The Robbers Cave experiment, conducted by Muzafer Sherif in the 1950s, studied intergroup conflict and cooperation among 22 boys in Oklahoma.
  86. [86]
    What Was the Robbers Cave Experiment in Psychology? - ThoughtCo
    Aug 26, 2024 · The Robbers Cave experiment was a famous psychology study that looked at how conflict develops between groups.
  87. [87]
    The Robbers Cave experiment Muzafer Sherif social psychology
    Muzafer Sherif and others' Robbers Cave experiment into intergroup conflict and co-operation psychology realistic conflict theory differentiation.
  88. [88]
    The Foundations of Intergroup Conflict Research: The Robbers ...
    Jun 22, 2021 · This article briefly summarizes the Robbers Cave experiment and its findings. Question(s):. Research was conducted by Muzafer Sherif to answer ...
  89. [89]
    Minimal Group Paradigm Study experiments Henri Tajfel
    The Minimal Group Paradigm is a methodology employed in social psychology to investigate the minimal conditions required for discrimination to occur between ...
  90. [90]
    The origins of the minimal group paradigm. - APA PsycNet
    The minimal group paradigm, published by Henri Tajfel and his colleagues in the early 1970s, is a widely used experimental technique for studying intergroup ...
  91. [91]
    Minimal Group Procedures and Outcomes | Collabra: Psychology
    Dec 21, 2023 · Research using the Minimal Group Paradigm has demonstrated the power of arbitrary group membership to produce prejudice and discrimination ...
  92. [92]
    Social Identity Theory In Psychology (Tajfel & Turner, 1979)
    Oct 5, 2023 · The minimal group paradigm remains a widely-used tool. Yet ... In-group bias in the minimal inter-group situation: A cognitive motivational
  93. [93]
    [PDF] Reducing Intergroup Prejudice and Conflict Using the Media: A Field ...
    A yearlong field experiment in Rwanda tested the impact of a radio soap opera featuring messages about reducing intergroup prejudice, violence, and trauma in 2 ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  94. [94]
    Inter-Group Conflict and Cooperation: Field Experiments Before ...
    Several studies have shown increased in-group altruism and social cohesion in response to violent conflict, in which individuals who had experienced violence ...Introduction · Materials and Methods · Analysis · DiscussionMissing: key | Show results with:key
  95. [95]
    Bystander intervention in emergencies: Diffusion of responsibility.
    The presence of other bystanders reduced the individual's feelings of personal responsibility and lowered his speed of reporting.
  96. [96]
    The Bystander Effect Started from a Lie - McGill University
    Oct 2, 2025 · Kitty Genovese's murder inspired researchers to study why people don't always come to someone's help, especially when they see other bystanders ...
  97. [97]
    From Empathy to Apathy: The Bystander Effect Revisited - PMC - NIH
    The bystander effect, the reduction in helping behavior in the presence of other people, has been explained predominantly by situational influences on ...
  98. [98]
    [PDF] 15.4 john m. darley and bibb latané - Psychology|University of Miami
    One problem they have found is that the larger a crowd of people is, the less likely one of them will help in an emergency. Darley and Latané explain this.
  99. [99]
    23.2: Latané And Darley's Model Of Helping - Social Sci LibreTexts
    Nov 21, 2020 · Darley and Latané (1968) had study participants work on a communication task in which they were sharing ideas about how to best adjust to ...Noticing · Interpreting · Taking ResponsibilityMissing: details | Show results with:details
  100. [100]
    Inhibiting effects of friends and strangers on bystander intervention
    Latané and Darley, 1968. B. Latané, J.M. Darley. Group inhibition of bystander intervention in emergencies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 10 ( ...<|separator|>
  101. [101]
    Social relations and presence of others predict bystander intervention
    Half a century of research on the “bystander effect” suggests that the more bystanders present at an emergency, the less likely each of them is to provide help.
  102. [102]
    Hawthorne Effect In Psychology: Experimental Studies
    Feb 13, 2024 · The Hawthorne effect refers to a tendency in some individuals to alter their behavior in response to their awareness of being observed.Hawthorne Studies · Elton Mayo's Experiment · Bank Wiring Observation...
  103. [103]
    Systematic review of the Hawthorne effect: New concepts are ...
    This study aims to (1) elucidate whether the Hawthorne effect exists, (2) explore under what conditions, and (3) estimate the size of any such effect.
  104. [104]
    Field Experiments in Organizations - Annual Reviews
    Field experimentation, although rare, is the sterling-gold standard of organizational research methods. It yields the best internally valid and generalizable ...
  105. [105]
    [PDF] Employee Recognition and Performance: A Field Experiment
    This paper reports the results from a controlled field experiment designed to investigate the causal effect of unannounced, public recognition on employee ...
  106. [106]
    Performance feedback and productivity: Evidence from a field ...
    Jan 1, 2023 · We theorize that employees use the performance feedback they receive to reassess their beliefs about the marginal benefit of their effort.
  107. [107]
    A Field Experiment in Gender, Influence, and Group Dynamics | IZA
    In this paper, we investigate whether token women are disadvantaged compared to women on majority-women mixed-gender teams.
  108. [108]
    Innovation with field experiments: Studying organizational behaviors ...
    We argue that field experiments can bridge these approaches, bringing causality to field research and developing organizational theory in novel ways.
  109. [109]
    https://oxfordre.com/business/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780190224851.001.0001/acrefore-9780190224851-e-284
  110. [110]
    The RAND Health Insurance Experiment, Three Decades Later
    Between 1974 and 1981, the RAND health insurance experiment provided health insurance to more than 5,800 individuals from about 2,000 households in six ...
  111. [111]
    40 Years of the RAND Health Insurance Experiment
    In the early 1970s, the effects of cost sharing took center stage in the national health care debate. Back then, the debate focused on free, universal health ...
  112. [112]
    The Health Insurance Experiment: A Classic RAND Study Speaks to ...
    Dec 6, 2006 · In a large-scale, multiyear experiment, participants who paid for a share of their health care used fewer health services than a comparison ...
  113. [113]
    Oregon Health Insurance Experiment | NBER
    Medicaid substantially reduced the prevalence of depression, but had no statistically significant effects on blood pressure, cholesterol, or cardiovascular risk ...
  114. [114]
    The Oregon Experiment — Effects of Medicaid on Clinical Outcomes
    May 2, 2013 · This randomized, controlled study showed that Medicaid coverage generated no significant improvements in measured physical health outcomes in the first 2 years.
  115. [115]
    Oregon Health Insurance Experiment - Results | NBER
    In the first one to two years of coverage, Medicaid improved self-reported health and reduced depression, but had no statistically significant effect on several ...
  116. [116]
    The Oregon experiment--effects of Medicaid on clinical outcomes
    May 2, 2013 · This randomized, controlled study showed that Medicaid coverage generated no significant improvements in measured physical health outcomes in the first 2 years.
  117. [117]
    Defenders of Medicaid cuts are misunderstanding a study I worked on
    Jul 3, 2025 · The results from the OHIE indicated no statistically significant impact of Medicaid on several physical health measures or on mortality.
  118. [118]
    What Does the RAND Health Insurance Experiment Tell Us About ...
    Jul 15, 2008 · The HIE found that, on average, there were minimal or no adverse health consequences associated with higher cost sharing.
  119. [119]
    The Oregon Health Insurance Experiment in the United States
    They found that Medicaid coverage increased health care use, including use of preventive services and visits to emergency departments; reduced financial strain; ...
  120. [120]
    The Rate of Return to the High/Scope Perry Preschool Program - PMC
    Estimates of the rate of return to the Perry program are widely cited to support the claim of substantial economic benefits from preschool education programs.
  121. [121]
    Perry Preschool at 50: What Lessons Should Be Drawn and Which ...
    Sep 19, 2024 · The evidence is clear: investments in high-quality early childhood education and parental engagement can deliver returns even 50 years later.Missing: results | Show results with:results
  122. [122]
    The Lasting Effects of Early-Childhood Education on Promoting the ...
    Jun 1, 2024 · This paper demonstrates the long-term intragenerational and intergenerational benefits of the HighScope Perry Preschool Project, ...
  123. [123]
    The Effect of an Early Education Program on Adult Health - NIH
    We explored whether a successful randomized controlled trial of early education, the Carolina Abecedarian Project (ABC), which enrolled infants from 1972 to ...
  124. [124]
    The Effects of Two Influential Early Childhood Interventions on ... - NIH
    We present evidence that both the Perry and the Abecedarian interventions have statistically and substantively significant effects on the health and healthy ...
  125. [125]
    Adult outcomes as a function of an early childhood educational ...
    Adult (age 30) educational, economic, and social–emotional adjustment outcomes were investigated for participants in the Abecedarian Project, a randomized ...
  126. [126]
    [PDF] The Tennessee Study of Class Size in the Early School Grades
    The Tennessee class size project is a three-phase study designed to determine the effect of smaller class size in the earliest grades on short-term and long- ...
  127. [127]
    The Tennessee study of class size in the early school grades
    The Tennessee class size project is a three-phase study designed to determine the effect of smaller class size in the earliest grades on short-term and long- ...
  128. [128]
    Some Findings from an Independent Investigation of the Tennessee ...
    The nonexperimental evidence uniformly indicates no consistent improvements in achievement with class size reductions.
  129. [129]
    [PDF] Head Start Impact Study Final Report
    This is the final report of the Head Start Impact Study, prepared for the Administration for Children and Families, and the result of several years of work.
  130. [130]
    Head Start Earns an F: No Lasting Impact for Children by First Grade
    Jan 21, 2010 · Overall, the evaluation found that the program largely failed to improve the cognitive, socio-emotional, health, and parenting outcomes of ...Missing: term criticism<|separator|>
  131. [131]
    Does Head Start work? The debate over the Head Start Impact ...
    Jun 14, 2019 · New research reanalyzes the Head Start Impact Study and finds that Head Start does improve cognitive skill.
  132. [132]
    Negative Income Tax - Institute for Research on Poverty
    A negative income tax is an experimental approach to poverty reduction, inspired by federal plans in the 1970s. Earned Income Tax Credit is a more recent ...
  133. [133]
    [PDF] The negative income tax: would it discourage work?
    Experiments tested if negative income tax would discourage work, but evidence is uneven. There was no work requirement, and benefits were not fully reduced by ...
  134. [134]
    Welfare versus Work under a Negative Income Tax: Evidence from ...
    Proponents viewed a Negative Income Tax as a replacement for traditional welfare with stronger work incentives and reduced poverty.
  135. [135]
    Income Maintenance Experiment in Seattle and Denver
    Price and Song (2018) estimate that the NIT reduced labor earnings of the parents and also led to a slight decrease in child earnings in adulthood. On net, ...
  136. [136]
    Overview of the Final Report of the Seattle-Denver Income ...
    Apr 30, 1983 · The purpose of the summary is to provide an overview of the rationale behind the income maintenance experiments in general and SIME/DIME in ...
  137. [137]
    Moving To Opportunity - HUD User
    The findings of MTO highlight the complexity of issues facing low-income families in urban areas and the positive role housing mobility programs can play in ...
  138. [138]
    Moving To Opportunity | NBER
    Moving to Opportunity (MTO) is a major randomized housing mobility experiment sponsored by the US Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).
  139. [139]
    [PDF] The Effects of Exposure to Better Neighborhoods on Children
    The Moving to Opportunity (MTO) experiment offered randomly selected families living in high- poverty housing projects housing vouchers to move to lower-poverty ...
  140. [140]
    Evaluating the Impact of Moving to Opportunity in the United States
    Moving to Opportunity in Boston: Early Results of a Randomized Mobility Experiment ... Audio: The Moving to Opportunity demonstration's long-term findings.
  141. [141]
    Creating Moves to Opportunity - Poverty Action Lab
    Long-term analysis of the Moving to Opportunity (MTO) experiment finds that young children (under age 13) whose families were randomly provided vouchers to move ...<|separator|>
  142. [142]
    Exploring the Ethics and Psychological Impact of Deception in ...
    Our study empirically tested the hypothesis that deception in psychological research negatively influences research participants' self-esteem, affect, and ...
  143. [143]
    Ethical principles of psychologists and code of conduct
    Ethics Code also outlines standards of professional conduct for APA members and student affiliates ... Research ; and 8.07, Deception in Research .) 4.04 ...
  144. [144]
    Reading the Ethics Code more deeply
    Apr 1, 2009 · Ethical Standard 8.07, Deception in Research, illustrates how the Ethics Code incorporates our profession's core values in resolving ethical dilemmas.
  145. [145]
    Deceiving Research Participants: Is It Inconsistent With Valid ...
    Nov 5, 2022 · Analysis of these arguments reveals that deception is frequently, but not always, inconsistent with obtaining valid consent for research.
  146. [146]
    Milgram Shock Experiment | Summary | Results - Simply Psychology
    Mar 14, 2025 · Ethics: Milgram's use of deception raised serious questions about the ethics of psychological research. Participants believed they were causing ...Milgram's Experiment (1963) · Milgram's Agency Theory · Experiment Variations
  147. [147]
    Ethics, deception, and 'Those Milgram experiments' - PubMed
    Critics who allege that deception in psychology experiments is unjustified frequently cite Stanley Milgram's 'obedience experiments' as evidence.
  148. [148]
    The infamous Stanford prison experiment was flawed – so why is it ...
    Jan 13, 2025 · Investigating the Stanford Prison Experiment: History of a Lie ... 'Guards' in the Stanford prison experiment subjected the 'prisoners' to various ...
  149. [149]
    Ethical Issues With the Stanford Prison Experiment - Aithor
    Mar 22, 2024 · Lack of Informed Consent ... The participants were not given information about what the study would involve when they were invited to take part.
  150. [150]
    Philip Zimbardo's Response to Recent Criticisms of the Stanford ...
    In other words, it is simply not the case that the SPE prison consultant referred to the study as a lie. 2. The staff's instructions for guards to be "tough" ...<|separator|>
  151. [151]
    [PDF] Controversies Surrounding Laud Humphreys' Tearoom Trade
    Laud Hum- phreys' Tearoom Trade (1970) did not violate the deeper ethical and social concerns of sociology, expressed in the concepts of beneficence and ...
  152. [152]
    Controversies surrounding Laud Humphreys' Tearoom trades? An ...
    ٠٦‏/٠٨‏/٢٠٢٥ · Argues that Humphrey's tearoom trade study, misinforms readers as much as it informs, regarding moral and ethical foundations for research with human subjects.
  153. [153]
    Research Involving Deception
    In general, deception is not acceptable if, in the judgment of the IRB, the participant may have declined to participate had they been informed of the true ...
  154. [154]
    Deception in Experiments: Revisiting the Arguments in Its Defense
    Deception is commonly used to increase experimental control. Yet, its use has provoked concerns that it raises participants' suspicions.
  155. [155]
    History of IRB - Committee For the Protection of Human Subjects
    The recognition of the need for guidelines dealing with human subjects in research emerged following the Nuremberg trials.
  156. [156]
    The History of the Belmont Report | 2020 | IRB Blog
    Aug 3, 2020 · The National Committee released The Belmont Report in 1979, which identifies basic ethical principles underlying biomedical and behavioral human subjects ...
  157. [157]
    Institutional Review Boards: Purpose and Challenges - PMC
    IRBs are charged with providing an independent evaluation that proposed research is ethically acceptable, checking clinical investigators' potential biases, and ...
  158. [158]
    Social and Behavioral Research - UCSF IRB
    Mar 3, 2025 · The IRB will review the study to determine whether there are sufficient protections to ensure that risks to subjects are no greater than minimal ...
  159. [159]
    Institutional Review Boards and Social Science Research | AAUP
    This report addresses the government's rules for protecting human beings who are the subjects of social science research.
  160. [160]
    Facebook's Emotion Experiment: Implications for Research Ethics
    Jul 21, 2014 · The study raises several critical questions. Did it violate ethical standards of research? Should such social media company studies be reviewed ...Missing: oversight | Show results with:oversight
  161. [161]
    https://www.pnas.org/content/111/24/8788.full.pdf
  162. [162]
    Ethics in field experimentation: A call to establish new standards to ...
    Nov 23, 2020 · A large number of social science field experiments do not reflect compliance with current ethical and legal requirements that govern research with human ...
  163. [163]
    2.3 The case for the defence | OpenLearn - The Open University
    Milgram also conducted a follow-up survey of the participants one year after the study, to ensure that there was no long-term harm (Colman, 1987). The results ...
  164. [164]
    In Milgram's studies (1963) were the volunteers alright after?
    Feb 25, 2014 · Some of these participants suffered psychological effects such as emotional discomfort, uncontrolled laughter, and anxiety including anxiety over future life ...<|separator|>
  165. [165]
    What Are The Top 10 Unethical Psychology Experiments?
    Sep 9, 2019 · 9. The Monster Study (1939). The Monster Study is a prime example of an unethical psychology experiment on humans that changed the world.
  166. [166]
    Conducting Risk-Benefit Assessments and Determining Level of IRB ...
    Nov 30, 2020 · In evaluating risks and benefits, the IRB Committee will consider only those risks and benefits that may result from the research, as ...
  167. [167]
    POTENTIAL INDIVIDUAL BENEFITS AND RISKS OF RESEARCH
    The ethical justification for exposing participants to risks is the social and scientific value of research, namely the prospect of generating the knowledge ...
  168. [168]
    Determining Minimal Risk in Social and Behavioral Research - NCBI
    Consequently, IRBs often evaluate research as greater than minimal risk if there is a very small probability that the research may produce harm of high ...
  169. [169]
    Read the Belmont Report | HHS.gov
    Jul 15, 2025 · It is commonly said that benefits and risks must be "balanced" and shown to be "in a favorable ratio." The metaphorical character of these terms ...<|separator|>
  170. [170]
    The Stanley Milgram Experiment: Understanding Obedience
    May 3, 2023 · The Milgram experiment was designed to test people's willingness to obey authority, even when that obedience caused harm to others.
  171. [171]
    Some of psychology's most influential studies were also completely ...
    Oct 24, 2014 · Some of psychology's most influential studies were also completely unethical · 1) The “Little Albert” study · 2) The Milgram Shock Experiment 5.
  172. [172]
    The Inappropriate Use of Risk-Benefit Analysis in the Risk ...
    Applying the risk-benefit calculus to non-therapeutic procedures inevitably leads to inaccurate risk assessments and ethically problematic claims, examples of ...Missing: criticisms | Show results with:criticisms
  173. [173]
    Full article: Which Benefits Can Justify Risks in Research?
    Jan 5, 2024 · This paper aims to reconsider the different types of research benefits, and their position in risk-benefit assessments.
  174. [174]
    For the Good of the Group? Balancing Individual and Collective ...
    Balancing risks and benefits is a necessary ethical task for social science researchers. Community psychologists must often consider risks and benefits not ...
  175. [175]
    Risks & Benefits | Human Research Protection Program (HRPP)
    The Board is tasked with weighing the benefits of the study against the risks to participants; for many studies, the overall benefit may not be great.Missing: guidelines | Show results with:guidelines
  176. [176]
    Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science
    Aug 28, 2015 · We conducted a large-scale, collaborative effort to obtain an initial estimate of the reproducibility of psychological science.Missing: social | Show results with:social
  177. [177]
    Reproducibility Project: Psychology - OSF
    We conducted replications of 100 experimental and correlational studies published in three psychology journals using high-powered designs and original materials ...
  178. [178]
    Have Results From the Stanford Prison Experiment Been Replicated ...
    May 14, 2019 · Methodological Issues: The original study lacked rigorous controls and standardized procedures, making it difficult to replicate with precision.
  179. [179]
    Science Correcting Itself | Replication Failures
    Stanford Prison Experiment ... The BBC conducted a replication of the study and found almost the opposite result; the prisoners ended up overpowering the guards.
  180. [180]
    Stanford Prison Experiment: why famous psychology studies ... - Vox
    Jun 13, 2018 · Replication attempts at the Stanford prison study, on the other hand, have been a mess.
  181. [181]
    Which Social Psychology Results Were Successfully Replicated in ...
    Aug 30, 2015 · The project aimed to replicate a representative set of 100 studies from top journals in social and cognitive psychology. The replication studies ...
  182. [182]
    The replication crisis has led to positive structural, procedural, and ...
    Jul 25, 2023 · Box 1 Why research fails to replicate. This box outlines some ... & Wicherts, J. M. The prevalence of statistical reporting errors in psychology ( ...
  183. [183]
    Concerns About Replicability Across Two Crises in Social Psychology
    Apr 13, 2025 · I will discuss five underlying reasons: 1) the publication of studies that failed to replicate highly cited findings in the field, 2) the ...
  184. [184]
    External Validity - Annual Reviews
    May 11, 2021 · External validity captures the extent to which inferences drawn from a given study's sample apply to a broader population or other target ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  185. [185]
    The weirdest people in the world? - PubMed
    The findings suggest that members of WEIRD societies, including young children, are among the least representative populations one could find for generalizing ...
  186. [186]
    Most people are not WEIRD - Nature
    Jun 30, 2010 · To understand human psychology, behavioural scientists must stop doing most of their experiments on Westerners, argue Joseph Henrich, Steven J.
  187. [187]
    Uses of artificial and composite treatments in experimental methods
    Yet social science experiments are often criticized for their lack of external validity, especially the limited generalizability to real-life settings. We ...
  188. [188]
    Policy evaluation, randomized controlled trials, and external validity ...
    This paper systematically reviews the extent to which policy evaluations based on RCTs published in top economic journals establish external validity.
  189. [189]
    Generalization in the Tropics – Development Policy, Randomized ...
    Mar 22, 2018 · Yet, if an RCT is to inform policy, it is critical to establish external validity. This paper systematically reviews all RCTs conducted in ...
  190. [190]
    [PDF] How to Examine External Validity Within an Experiment
    inform external validity in two senses. ... Making the most out of programme evaluations and social experiments: Accounting for heterogeneity in programme impacts ...
  191. [191]
    Ideological bias in social psychological research. - APA PsycNet
    This chapter reviews and critically evaluates the evidence suggesting that: (1) liberals are disproportionately represented in social psychology.
  192. [192]
    Is research in social psychology politically biased? Systematic ...
    Contrary to predictions, conservatives were slightly less (rather than more) likely to see scientific research reports as biased against their group and beliefs ...
  193. [193]
    [PDF] A Model of Political Bias in Social Science Research - Sites@Rutgers
    Mar 9, 2020 · Political bias in social science manifests as theories favoring liberals, skepticism against challenging data, and overrepresentation of ...
  194. [194]
    interpreting the replication crisis in psychology as a social dilemma ...
    In this paper, we argue that the “crisis” be interpreted as a disciplinary social dilemma, with the problem facing early-career researchers being especially ...Missing: ideological | Show results with:ideological
  195. [195]
    Implications of ideological bias in social psychology on clinical ...
    Ideological bias is a worsening but often neglected concern for social and psychological sciences, affecting a range of professional activities and ...
  196. [196]
    Reddit's the button has reached zero - Brookings Institution
    Reddit's Aprils Fools prank turned unintended social experiment is now over. As we have written in the past Reddit originally created the button as a joke.
  197. [197]
    Reddit's mysterious button experiment is over - The Guardian
    Jun 8, 2015 · After two months, and more than a million clicks, the weirdest social experiment on the internet is over: Reddit's Button has hit zero.
  198. [198]
    Reddit Explains the Mystery Behind 'The Button' - NBC News
    Jun 9, 2015 · Social-news site Reddit launched a button with a countdown timer that quickly became an intensely debated mystery.<|separator|>
  199. [199]
    More than just a game: The link between EVE Online and the real ...
    Jan 21, 2020 · EVE Online connects to the real world through player friendships, real-life skills, and the use of external and internal capital, sometimes ...
  200. [200]
    On the connection between real-world circumstances and online ...
    Oct 21, 2020 · Virtual worlds involving social and economic interactions are particularly useful to test social and economic theories. Using data from EVE ...
  201. [201]
    The case of EVE Online | PLOS One - Research journals
    Oct 21, 2020 · Virtual worlds involving social and economic interactions are particularly useful to test social and economic theories. Using data from EVE ...
  202. [202]
    Player behavior in the online game EVE Online may reflect real ...
    Oct 21, 2020 · Despite these limitations, the study results strongly suggest that virtual worlds can be useful to experiment and test social and economic ...
  203. [203]
    Eve Online's great experiment - Raph Koster
    Mar 21, 2008 · Governance is challenging. And I think that social worlds frame challenge as an obstruction, whereas game worlds frame challenge as fun. When I ...
  204. [204]
    I have seen 'What would you do?' The ABC reality show that ... - Quora
    Jan 27, 2014 · Do shows like What Would You Do (WWYD) compare to some of these experiments? I think there are four aspects that might be compared.What are some examples of cool, funny, or interesting social ... - QuoraWhat are some good social experiments to conduct in public? - QuoraMore results from www.quora.com
  205. [205]
    Experimental evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion ...
    We show, via a massive (N = 689,003) experiment on Facebook, that emotional states can be transferred to others via emotional contagion, leading people to ...Missing: communities | Show results with:communities
  206. [206]
    Facebook emotion study breached ethical guidelines, researchers say
    Jun 30, 2014 · Researchers have roundly condemned Facebook's experiment in which it manipulated nearly 700,000 users' news feeds to see whether it would affect ...
  207. [207]
    Do research ethics need updating for the digital age?
    Oct 1, 2014 · The study on "massive-scale emotional contagion through social networks" (PNAS, June 17, 2014) generated significant debate in both public and ...
  208. [208]
    Facebook Manipulates Our Moods For Science And Commerce - NPR
    Jun 30, 2014 · Scientists published a paper revealing that in 2012, Facebook researchers conducted a study into emotional contagion.
  209. [209]
    The Big Problem With All of Those Viral 'Social Experiment' Videos
    Nov 24, 2014 · Viral 'social experiment' videos designed to capture the Internet's fickle attention and shine the spotlight on troubling issues faced every day.
  210. [210]
    Natural experiment | Observational Study & Benefits - Britannica
    Situations that may create appropriate circumstances for a natural experiment include policy changes, weather events, and natural disasters. Natural experiments ...
  211. [211]
    6. Natural Experiments and Quasi-Experiments - APSA Educate
    One example of a natural experiment was conducted in Brazil: researchers wanted to know if voters punish politicians when they discover that politicians are ...
  212. [212]
    A natural experiment of social network formation and dynamics - PNAS
    May 11, 2015 · This paper presents an empirical analysis of the short- and long-term causal effects of a hurricane on social structure.Missing: unintended | Show results with:unintended
  213. [213]
    Natural experiments shed light on people's resilience to extreme ...
    Jun 26, 2023 · Natural experiments hinge on identifying an uncontrolled but opportune 'intervention', typically of a kind or on a scale that could not – ...
  214. [214]
    The Accidental Experiment That Changed Men's Lives - Avela
    Dec 2, 2019 · The Vietnam draft lotteries functioned as a randomized experiment—which has allowed social scientists to study its life-changing effects ...
  215. [215]
    Understanding the Ethics of Natural Experiments in a Pandemic - PMC
    Pandemics invite natural experiments: testing hypotheses by observing the effects of interventions without manipulating exposure to the intervention.Missing: scale | Show results with:scale
  216. [216]
    [PDF] What are 'natural experiments' - The Scottish Government
    Natural experiments are observational studies which can be undertaken to assess the outcomes and impacts of policy interventions.
  217. [217]
    Asch Conformity Line Experiment - Simply Psychology
    May 15, 2025 · Solomon Asch experimented with investigating the extent to which social pressure from a majority group could affect a person to conform.Procedure · Findings · Conclusion · Strengths
  218. [218]
    The power of social influence: A replication and extension of ... - NIH
    Nov 29, 2023 · In this paper, we pursue four goals: First, we replicate the original Asch experiment with five confederates and one naïve subject in each group.
  219. [219]
    Stanford Prison Experiment: Zimbardo's Famous Study - Verywell Mind
    Apr 30, 2024 · 5 It could not be replicated by researchers today because it fails to meet the standards established by numerous ethical codes, including the ...Overview · Participants · Setting and Procedure · Results<|separator|>
  220. [220]
    Demonstrating the Power of Social Situations via a Simulated Prison ...
    Jun 8, 2004 · The research, known as the Stanford Prison Experiment, has become a classic demonstration of situational power to influence individual attitudes, values and ...
  221. [221]
    Contesting the “Nature” Of Conformity: What Milgram and ... - NIH
    Nov 20, 2012 · Understanding of the psychology of tyranny is dominated by classic studies from the 1960s and 1970s: Milgram's research on obedience to ...
  222. [222]
    [PDF] Are Social-Policy Experiments Worthwhile?
    problems and unforeseen or unintended consequences often limit or pervert the impact of well-intended policy choices is becoming in- creasingly apparent ...
  223. [223]
    Experimentation and Social Welfare Policymaking in the United States
    Nov 1, 2007 · To summarize, when MDRC first began in the early 1970s, common sense, good intentions, and good ideas were the basis for making social policy ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
  224. [224]
    [PDF] Social Experimentation – A Methodological Guide for Policy Makers
    Sep 26, 2011 · The principle of social experimentation is to test a policy intervention on a small population so as to evaluate its efficacy before ...
  225. [225]
    Behavioral public policy: past, present, & future - Oxford Academic
    Aug 5, 2025 · Behavioral public policy (BPP) applies behavioral insights to aid policy-making and implementation. Emerging from the interest in nudges in ...
  226. [226]
    Behavior Science Contributions to Public Policy - NIH
    Mar 14, 2023 · Behavior science has a long history of influencing public policy. Numerous scholars have used behavioral principles in experimental and applied research.
  227. [227]
    A Meta-Psychological Perspective on the Decade of Replication ...
    Jan 5, 2020 · It also suggests that flaws in replication studies are some- times responsible for replication failures. However, it is impossible to generalise ...
  228. [228]
    Concerns About Replicability Across Two Crises in Social Psychology
    During the first replication crisis, the dominant belief was that replication failures should be attributed to an incomplete understanding of the conditions ...Abstract · Is there a crisis? · Replication Crisis · Lack of Incentives for...Missing: ideological | Show results with:ideological
  229. [229]
    How Can Experiments Play a Greater Role in Public Policy?
    Nov 18, 2019 · Policymakers should carefully evaluate the results of policy experiments, and should avoid scaling programs before there is sufficient evidence of efficacy.
  230. [230]
    Amid a replication crisis in social science research, six-year study ...
    Nov 13, 2023 · Amid a replication crisis in social science research, six-year study validates open science methods · Replicating 16 new discoveries · More ...
  231. [231]
    More social science studies just failed to replicate. Here's why this is ...
    Aug 27, 2018 · The remainder either failed or yielded inconclusive data. And again, the replications that did work showed weaker effects than the original ...
  232. [232]
    Ethics in field experimentation: A call to establish new standards to ...
    Nov 23, 2020 · A large number of social science field experiments do not reflect compliance with current ethical and legal requirements that govern research ...
  233. [233]
    Replication issues in social experiments: lessons from US labor ...
    The paper reviews what has been learned from replications where random assignment was used in six instances: income maintenance experiments, unemployment ...Missing: solutions | Show results with:solutions
  234. [234]
    The replication crisis has led to positive structural, procedural, and ...
    The replication crisis has highlighted the need for a deeper understanding of the research landscape and culture, and a concerted effort from institutions, ...