Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Underdevelopment

Underdevelopment describes the protracted economic stagnation and low human welfare prevalent in numerous nations, characterized by per capita incomes typically below $1,500 annually, heavy dependence on subsistence agriculture employing over 60% of the labor force, and rudimentary infrastructure that constrains trade and innovation.^[1]^[2] This condition manifests in high rates of malnutrition, illiteracy exceeding 40% in adults, and life expectancies under 65 years, distinguishing it from development where structural transformations enable rising productivity and diversified economies.^[3]^[4] Empirical analyses trace underdevelopment's persistence to initial geographic endowments, such as land abundance relative to population, which historically engendered high inequality by concentrating wealth among elites and fostering extractive institutions that prioritize rent-seeking over broad-based investment.^[5]^[6] These factors impede human capital formation and technological diffusion, creating self-reinforcing cycles where low savings and capital accumulation perpetuate low growth, as evidenced in cross-country regressions linking early inequality to contemporary income levels.^[7] Unlike transient poverty, underdevelopment endures across centuries due to institutional lock-in, where weak property rights and political centralization deter entrepreneurship and public goods provision.^[8] Debates on causation highlight tensions between structuralist views emphasizing external dependencies and evidence-based accounts stressing endogenous failures, with peer-reviewed studies increasingly validating the primacy of inclusive institutions and factor distributions over exogenous shocks or aid inflows.^[9]^[10] While some narratives in academia amplify colonial exploitation, rigorous econometric work reveals that pre-colonial patterns and post-independence policies better explain variance in outcomes, underscoring the need for causal realism in policy design.^[11] Defining features include demographic pressures from high fertility rates outpacing productivity gains and vulnerability to commodity price volatility, which exacerbate fiscal fragility in resource-dependent states.^[12]

Definition and Measurement

Core Concepts and Distinctions

Underdevelopment constitutes a structural condition marked by chronically low economic productivity per capita, constrained technological diffusion, and institutional arrangements that undermine secure property rights and incentives for innovation and investment. This differs from the mere absence of advanced infrastructure or high output, as it reflects systemic failures in resource allocation and governance that hinder sustained growth, often perpetuating cycles where productive surpluses are diverted rather than reinvested.^[13]^[1] Key distinctions arise from its persistence relative to transient deprivations: poverty typically signifies acute material shortages, such as those induced by natural disasters or market shocks, which may resolve through external aid or recovery mechanisms, whereas underdevelopment embeds such conditions in enduring institutional frailties that favor extractive elites over broad economic participation. For instance, World Bank data delineates low-income economies—proxies for underdevelopment—with GNI per capita below $1,085 (2021 thresholds), correlating to GDP per capita (PPP) often under $2,500, where chronic stagnation contrasts with episodic poverty in higher-income contexts.^[14]^[15] This causal framing prioritizes verifiable institutional dynamics, such as weak enforcement of contracts enabling elite capture, over normative labels like "backwardness," which imply cultural determinism without empirical grounding.^[16]^[17] Underdevelopment thus avoids conflation with deliberate policy opt-outs, such as resource conservation strategies in high-potential economies, by focusing on empirically observable barriers to productivity enhancement; fragile institutions, for example, manifest in regulatory voids that deter capital accumulation, distinct from voluntary low-output equilibria.^[13] Empirical contrasts highlight this: acute poverty from events like floods affects even resilient economies temporarily, per World Bank vulnerability assessments, while underdevelopment correlates with multi-decade per capita income plateaus below global medians, enabling elite extraction without countervailing pressures for reform.^[18]^[16]

Indicators and Empirical Metrics

Underdevelopment is commonly assessed through economic output metrics, with gross domestic product (GDP) per capita serving as a primary indicator of average living standards and productive capacity. World Bank data tracks GDP per capita in current U.S. dollars, revealing persistent gaps between developed and underdeveloped economies; for instance, many sub-Saharan African nations hovered below $2,000 in 2023, compared to over $50,000 in high-income countries.^[19] Annual GDP growth rates further highlight stagnation, where rates below 2-3% in low-income countries fail to outpace population growth, perpetuating per capita declines.^[20] These metrics emphasize aggregate productivity but require disaggregation to avoid masking internal disparities, such as urban-rural divides in resource allocation. The Human Development Index (HDI), compiled by the United Nations Development Programme, aggregates three dimensions: a long and healthy life (measured by life expectancy at birth), access to knowledge (mean and expected years of schooling), and a decent standard of living (gross national income per capita in purchasing power parity terms).^[21] Scores range from 0 to 1, with values below 0.55 classifying countries as low human development, often correlating with underdeveloped status in regions like South Asia and sub-Saharan Africa. However, the equal weighting of components imposes arbitrary trade-offs that undervalue economic productivity relative to non-market factors like longevity, potentially overstating progress in equality-focused metrics while underemphasizing output-driven sustainability.^[22] Critics note that HDI omits direct measures of innovation or efficiency, limiting its utility for causal analysis of underdevelopment.^[23] Productivity indicators, particularly total factor productivity (TFP), provide deeper insights into efficient resource use beyond capital and labor inputs. TFP growth, calculated as residual output unexplained by factor accumulation, has stagnated or declined in many developing economies since the 2008 global financial crisis, contributing to only 20-30% of growth in middle-income countries versus higher shares in advanced economies.^[24] Empirical studies across low-income developing countries show TFP averaging near zero or negative post-2010, signaling inefficiencies in technology adoption and allocation that perpetuate underdevelopment.^[25] Unlike GDP, TFP highlights endogenous barriers, such as misaligned incentives, making it a critical metric for evaluating long-term potential. Institutional quality indices, like the Heritage Foundation's Index of Economic Freedom, score countries on rule of law, government size, regulatory efficiency, and market openness, with higher scores (above 70) linked to sustained GDP per capita growth exceeding 2% annually.^[26] Analysis of panel data from 1995-2024 reveals that improvements in economic freedom correlate with 1-2 percentage point higher growth rates, as freer economies facilitate investment and trade; conversely, scores below 50, common in underdeveloped states, align with output contraction.^[27] This index underscores how property rights and fiscal restraint signal productive environments, outperforming purely output-based metrics in predictive power for convergence.^[28] Governance fragility is quantified by the Fund for Peace's Fragile States Index (FSI), which aggregates 12 indicators across social (e.g., demographic pressures, refugees), economic (e.g., uneven development), political (e.g., state legitimacy), and cohesion (e.g., ethnic tensions) categories, scored from 0 (stable) to 120 (highly fragile).^[29] Countries scoring above 90, such as Yemen (111.7 in 2023) or Somalia (111.3), exemplify underdevelopment through indicators of public service failures and human rights violations, derived from conflict assessment frameworks.^[30] The FSI's methodology, using open-source data and expert validation, reveals governance as a leading signal of economic vulnerability, with fragile states exhibiting 5-10% lower annual growth.^[31] Empirical metrics carry caveats, as aggregates can obscure policy-induced mismanagement; Venezuela illustrates this, with GDP per capita plummeting from $15,943 in 2014 to under $2,000 by 2021 despite vast oil reserves, reflecting a 73% contraction from crisis onset due to expropriations and hyperinflation.^[32]^[33] Overreliance on resource wealth without institutional safeguards distorts indicators, necessitating cross-validation with productivity and freedom scores to discern true underdevelopment drivers.^[34]

Historical Context

Pre-Modern and Colonial Roots

Prior to widespread European contact, many regions destined for persistent underdevelopment exhibited institutional and organizational patterns that constrained economic surplus and innovation. In sub-Saharan Africa, political structures were highly fragmented, dominated by small chiefdoms, segmentary lineages, and stateless societies rather than expansive, centralized empires capable of sustaining long-distance trade or technological accumulation. Ethnographic data from the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample reveal that 98 of 186 sampled African societies operated without centralized authority, with political hierarchy typically limited to one or two layers, fostering frequent inter-group conflict and impeding scale economies. ^[35] ^[36] This fragmentation, compounded by environmental pressures and internal slave trading networks, locked societies into Malthusian traps where population growth eroded productivity gains, as evidenced by stagnant per capita output over centuries. ^[37] In parts of Asia, pre-modern tributary systems, exemplified by China's imperial framework from the Han dynasty onward (circa 206 BCE–220 CE), emphasized hierarchical tribute extraction from agrarian bases and bureaucratic control, which prioritized stability over competitive markets and private enterprise. While enabling cultural and technological diffusion within the Sinosphere, these systems subordinated merchant activities to state oversight, limiting incentives for sustained innovation beyond periodic bursts, such as Song-era advancements (960–1279 CE). ^[38] Historical GDP reconstructions underscore Eurasia's relative advantage: the Maddison Project estimates indicate that in 1000 CE, East Asia and India together comprised over 50% of global GDP share, driven by dense populations and hydraulic agriculture, while sub-Saharan Africa's contribution hovered below 5%, reflecting lower institutional capacity for surplus mobilization. ^[39] ^[40] Geography influenced these patterns—such as Africa's disease burdens and Asia's riverine centralization—but causal primacy lay in the failure to evolve inclusive rules protecting property and contracts, which Eurasia partially achieved through fragmented yet competitive polities. Colonialism, commencing with Portuguese voyages in the 15th century and intensifying through the 19th-century Scramble for Africa, did not originate underdevelopment but selectively entrenched extractive institutions in societies lacking robust pre-colonial foundations. High settler mortality in tropical zones, averaging over 200 deaths per 1,000 Europeans annually in places like the Congo basin, deterred permanent settlement and prompted governance focused on short-term extraction via coerced labor and monopolies, as formalized in the Acemoglu-Johnson-Robinson settler mortality hypothesis. ^[41] ^[42] The Belgian Congo (1885–1960), under Leopold II's personal rule until 1908, epitomized this: forced rubber quotas via the Force Publique militia extracted vast revenues—equivalent to 1.5% of Belgium's GDP by 1900—while decimating local populations (estimated 10 million excess deaths) and building no infrastructure for broad-based growth. ^[43] ^[44] Conversely, low-mortality settler colonies like Australia (from 1788) imported European inclusive norms, granting representative assemblies by 1856 and fostering property rights that propelled divergence. ^[42] Persistence of these institutions post-independence—evident in Africa's median GDP per capita stagnating at ~$1,000 (1990 dollars) from 1960–2000 versus Australia's rise to $20,000—highlights how colonialism amplified, rather than supplanted, pre-existing institutional frailties. ^[45]

Post-Colonial Independence and Stagnation

Following the wave of decolonization after World War II, numerous African and Latin American nations pursued statist economic policies, including nationalizations and import substitution industrialization (ISI), which often exacerbated governance challenges inherited from colonial eras. In Zambia, for instance, the government under President Kenneth Kaunda nationalized the copper mining industry between 1969 and 1971, taking control of assets that previously generated over 90% of export earnings; however, mismanagement, rising production costs, and a sharp decline in global copper prices from the mid-1970s onward led to economic contraction, with the sector's contribution to GDP falling from peaks above 50% in the early 1970s.^[46]^[47] Similar patterns emerged across sub-Saharan Africa, where post-independence growth faltered due to elite-led resource extraction and protectionist barriers that stifled competition and innovation. Empirical data underscore the stagnation: sub-Saharan Africa's real GDP per capita grew at less than 0.5% annually from 1965 to 1989, a period encompassing most independences, while Latin America's ISI strategies yielded initial manufacturing gains in the 1950s but devolved into inefficiency, balance-of-payments crises, and per capita growth averaging under 2% by the late 1970s, culminating in the 1980s debt crisis.^[48]^[49] These outcomes contrasted sharply with East Asian economies, where per capita growth exceeded 5% over the same timeframe, driven by export orientation rather than inward-focused substitution.^[48] ISI's failures stemmed from over-reliance on state-directed allocation, which fostered rent-seeking among post-colonial elites and neglected productivity-enhancing reforms, amplifying institutional voids left by abrupt colonial withdrawals. In divergence, Singapore's post-1965 independence trajectory illustrates the impact of market-oriented pivots: facing expulsion from Malaysia and lacking natural resources, the government established export processing zones, minimized trade distortions, and attracted foreign direct investment through low taxes and macroeconomic stability, propelling GDP per capita from approximately $500 in 1965 to $14,500 by 1991.^[50]^[51] This approach addressed governance gaps by prioritizing meritocratic administration and private sector incentives, avoiding the elite capture prevalent in statist models elsewhere, and highlighting how independence presented opportunities for institutional rebuilding that many developing nations forewent in favor of ideological interventions.^[52]

Mid-20th Century Shifts Including the Green Revolution

The mid-20th century marked a period of intensified international efforts to address underdevelopment in newly independent nations through agricultural innovations and foreign aid inflows, particularly from the 1960s onward. These interventions, often modeled on post-World War II successes like the Marshall Plan in Europe, aimed to boost productivity and avert famines but yielded mixed results, with short-term output gains frequently giving way to persistent stagnation in many regions. Empirical data from the era reveal that while targeted technological transfers increased yields in select areas, broader economic transformations stalled due to institutional barriers, including insecure land tenure that undermined farmer incentives.^[53]^[54] Central to these shifts was the Green Revolution, spearheaded by agronomist Norman Borlaug, who developed semi-dwarf, high-yielding wheat varieties in Mexico during the 1940s and 1950s through selective breeding for disease resistance and responsiveness to fertilizers. These varieties were disseminated to India and Pakistan starting in 1965-1966 amid acute food shortages, leading to rapid adoption where infrastructure and inputs were available. In India, wheat production rose from 12 million metric tons in 1965 to 20 million metric tons by 1970, with average yields per hectare climbing from approximately 0.8 tons in the early 1960s to over 2 tons by the late 1970s, averting predicted mass starvation and enabling food self-sufficiency in cereals. Similar gains occurred in rice production via hybrid varieties from the International Rice Research Institute, though wheat saw the most pronounced increases due to fewer ecological constraints.^[55]^[56]^[57] However, adoption remained uneven across regions and farm sizes, largely attributable to land tenure insecurities that disincentivized smallholders from investing in costly inputs like irrigation and fertilizers. In areas with fragmented or state-controlled land systems, such as parts of South Asia and sub-Saharan Africa, larger landowners captured disproportionate benefits, exacerbating rural inequalities and limiting diffusion to marginal producers who comprised the majority. Comparative evidence underscores the role of secure property rights: Taiwan's post-1949 land reforms, which redistributed holdings to owner-operators, facilitated Green Revolution technologies' integration, yielding sustained productivity surges into the 1970s. In contrast, Ethiopia's communal tenure arrangements during the 1960s-1980s hindered similar innovations, resulting in minimal yield gains despite aid-supported seed programs, as farmers lacked collateral for credit or long-term investment horizons.^[58]^[59]^[60] Parallel to these agricultural efforts, official development assistance (ODA) to developing countries surged from the early 1960s, reaching annual totals exceeding $20 billion by the late 1970s in constant dollars, often framed as catalytic for industrialization akin to European reconstruction. Initial GDP per capita growth accelerations were observed in recipients like India (averaging 3-4% annually in the 1960s-1970s), but these proved transient, with many economies reverting to stagnation by the 1980s amid debt accumulation and aid dependency. Critiques of dependency theory, which attributes underdevelopment primarily to external exploitation, highlight its oversight of endogenous factors like distorted local incentives under weak governance; for instance, aid-financed inputs in the Green Revolution succeeded where property rights aligned farmer efforts with market signals, but faltered elsewhere due to elite capture and moral hazard from subsidized resources, rather than solely imperial structures. Such perspectives, drawn from neoclassical analyses, emphasize that overattributing outcomes to foreign interventions ignores causal chains rooted in domestic institutional quality.^[61]^[62]^[63]

Theoretical Explanations

Geographical and Environmental Factors

Geographical factors have been invoked to explain patterns of underdevelopment, with proponents arguing that continental orientations, climate zones, and natural endowments shape long-term economic trajectories. In Guns, Germs, and Steel (1997), Jared Diamond posits that Eurasia's east-west axis facilitated the diffusion of crops, livestock, and technologies across similar latitudes, conferring advantages in food production, disease resistance, and military capabilities that propelled its dominance over other regions.^[64] This environmental determinism suggests geography predetermines societal outcomes by influencing agricultural potential and epidemiological exposure, with vertical north-south axes in Africa and the Americas hindering comparable advancements.^[65] Empirical studies reveal correlations between environmental conditions and growth but underscore their limited causality. Higher latitudes and temperate climates correlate with stronger economic performance, as extreme heat in tropical regions impairs labor productivity and agricultural yields; for instance, a nonlinear relationship shows optimal temperatures around 15°C for economic activity, with deviations reducing output.^[66] Tropical diseases, such as malaria, exacerbate this by debilitation workforces and deterring investment, with countries facing severe malaria in the late 20th century experiencing growth rates less than one-fifth those of non-affected peers from 1965 to 1990.^[67] However, analyses indicate these effects operate indirectly through institutional channels rather than direct geographical mandates, as policies and governance mediate environmental burdens.^[68] Natural resource endowments illustrate geography's paradoxical role, often termed the "resource curse," where abundance correlates with underperformance. Sachs and Warner (1995) found that economies with high natural resource exports to GDP ratios in 1971 exhibited significantly lower growth rates over subsequent decades, attributing this to Dutch disease, rent-seeking, and neglected diversification; oil-rich nations like Venezuela and Nigeria exemplify stagnation despite vast reserves, with per capita incomes trailing resource-poor comparators.^[69]^[70] This challenges deterministic views by highlighting how resource windfalls distort incentives, fostering volatility and weak institutions over inherent locational deficits. While geography imposes constraints—such as disease prevalence or climatic variability—these are not fate-sealing, as human agency enables adaptation. Singapore, a tropical entrepôt lacking arable land or resources, achieved high-income status post-1965 through strategic trade policies, infrastructure investment, and institutional reforms, overcoming environmental hurdles via globalization and human capital focus.^[71] Critiques of geographical determinism in development economics emphasize that overreliance on such factors overlooks endogenous responses, with evidence showing institutional quality explaining more variance in outcomes than latitude or endowments alone; tropical underperformance weakens once controlling for governance, underscoring geography as a modifiable constraint rather than an inexorable barrier.^[72]^[68]

Modernization and Endogenous Growth Theories

Modernization theory, as articulated by Walt Rostow in his 1960 work The Stages of Economic Growth, conceptualizes development as a linear progression through five distinct phases: a traditional agrarian society characterized by low productivity and limited investment; preconditions for take-off involving infrastructural buildup and external influences like trade; the take-off stage of rapid industrialization; the drive to maturity with diversified economic structures; and finally, the age of high mass consumption focused on services and consumer goods.^[73] The pivotal take-off phase, spanning about two to three decades, hinges on surging domestic savings and investment rates reaching 10-20% of gross national product (GNP), which ignites self-reinforcing capital accumulation, entrepreneurial activity, and sectoral shifts toward manufacturing.^[74] This stage transitions economies from stagnation to sustained growth by leveraging internal savings mobilization and market-oriented resource allocation, as evidenced by historical cases like Britain's industrialization in the late 18th century and Japan's post-Meiji Restoration expansion.^[73] Endogenous growth theories, emerging in the late 1980s as extensions of the neoclassical Solow-Swan model (1956), shift the emphasis from exogenous technological progress to internally generated drivers such as human capital formation and knowledge creation.^[75] Unlike the Solow framework, where long-run growth depends on unexplained external factors, models by Robert Lucas (1988) highlight human capital externalities—spillovers from skilled workers enhancing overall productivity—and Paul Romer (1990) stresses the non-rivalrous nature of ideas, enabling increasing returns to scale through research and development (R&D) investments.^[76] These theories posit that policies fostering education, innovation incentives, and secure property rights for intellectual outputs can perpetually elevate growth rates by amplifying total factor productivity (TFP) without diminishing marginal returns constraining accumulation.^[77] Empirical validation appears in the East Asian "miracle" economies, where internal factors propelled rapid convergence from underdevelopment. South Korea, for instance, achieved average annual real GNP growth of 9.3% from 1962 to 1979, fueled by domestic savings rates exceeding 25% of GNP, heavy investments in universal education (literacy rising from 22% in 1945 to near 100% by 1980), and export-led strategies that integrated markets and human capital into global value chains.^[78] Similarly, Taiwan's GNP expanded by 360% between 1965 and 1986, with average growth of 8.7% from 1952 to 1982, driven by comparable emphases on technical training and private sector innovation rather than resource endowments.^[79] Cross-country analyses confirm that human capital, proxied by years of schooling, positively correlates with TFP growth in developing nations, explaining up to 30-50% of output variations through enhanced worker efficiency and adaptive capacities.^[80] These patterns underscore how endogenous mechanisms—via high private returns to effort and knowledge—outpace state-directed alternatives in generating persistent per capita income gains.^[81]

Dependency and Exogenous Exploitation Perspectives

Dependency theory posits that underdevelopment in peripheral economies results from their subordinate integration into the global capitalist system, where resources systematically flow outward to enrich core industrial nations at the periphery’s expense. Originating in Latin America during the mid-20th century, the theory was advanced by economists affiliated with the United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC), including Raúl Prebisch, who in a 1950 United Nations report highlighted the long-term deterioration in terms of trade for primary commodity exporters compared to manufacturers, attributing this to structural rigidities in global demand and supply dynamics.^[82]^[82] Paul Baran, in his 1957 analysis The Political Economy of Growth, contended that potential economic surplus in underdeveloped nations is diverted by foreign investors and local comprador elites toward non-productive uses like luxury imports or repatriated profits, rather than domestic capital accumulation for industrialization.^[83] André Gunder Frank further developed these ideas in his 1966 essay and subsequent works, introducing the phrase "development of underdevelopment" to argue that capitalist expansion actively impoverishes the periphery by fostering dependency on raw material exports while suppressing local manufacturing.^[83] Core-periphery dynamics form the theory's central framework: core countries, leveraging technological advantages and market power, extract value through unequal exchange, perpetuating a satellite-metropolis relationship originally rooted in colonial extraction but sustained post-independence via trade imbalances and foreign investment.^[83] Proponents emphasized Latin America's historical experience, where colonial legacies of monoculture exports—such as sugar in Brazil or nitrates in Chile—evolved into modern dependencies, with multinational corporations controlling key sectors and repatriating profits exceeding local reinvestments.^[83] The theory highlights verifiable vulnerabilities in commodity-dependent economies, where primary goods like coffee or minerals subject exporters to price volatility; for instance, Latin American countries faced terms of trade declines averaging 0.5% annually from 1950 to 1970, exacerbating balance-of-payments crises and limiting import substitution efforts.^[82] However, dependency perspectives have exhibited empirical limitations in explaining trajectories where initially peripheral states achieved sustained growth, such as the East Asian economies of South Korea and Taiwan, which from the 1960s onward pursued aggressive export-led industrialization despite early reliance on core markets and aid, attaining GDP per capita increases of over 7% annually through the 1980s without conforming to predicted entrapment.^[83]^[83] This disconnect underscores the theory's challenges in anticipating endogenous policy shifts that disrupted purportedly inexorable dependency cycles.^[83]

Institutional and Governance Frameworks

Inclusive economic institutions, characterized by secure property rights, impartial rule of law, and broad incentives for innovation and investment, foster sustained prosperity, whereas extractive institutions concentrate economic and political power among elites, discouraging productive activity and perpetuating poverty.^[84] This distinction, central to the framework developed by Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson, posits institutions as the root cause of long-term developmental divergences, with empirical evidence showing that countries adopting inclusive frameworks experience higher long-run growth rates compared to those entrenched in extractive ones.^[85] Cross-country analyses reveal strong positive correlations between governance quality—particularly enforcement of contracts, protection of property rights, and low corruption—and GDP per capita growth; for instance, improvements in regulatory quality and rule of law, as measured by the World Bank's Worldwide Governance Indicators (WGI), are associated with accelerated economic expansion in developing nations.^[86] Conversely, high corruption levels, captured in WGI's Control of Corruption dimension, impose a significant drag on growth, reducing investment and distorting resource allocation in underdeveloping economies.^[87] The discontinued World Bank's Doing Business reports similarly highlighted how ease of enforcing contracts and registering property correlates with higher growth trajectories, underscoring property rights as a causal enabler rather than mere correlate.^[88] Post-1990s transitions provide stark contrasts: Central and Eastern European countries, such as Poland and the Czech Republic, implemented institutional reforms emphasizing rule of law and privatization post-communism, achieving average annual GDP growth exceeding 4% from 1990 to 2014 through integration into market-oriented frameworks.^[89] In contrast, Zimbabwe's 2000 fast-track land reforms dismantled property rights by seizing commercial farms without compensation, triggering agricultural collapse, hyperinflation peaking at 89.7 sextillion percent in November 2008, and a 50% GDP contraction between 2000 and 2008, as elites prioritized political control over economic incentives.^[90] Extractive institutions endure due to elite incentives favoring short-term rents over broad-based growth; ruling coalitions resist inclusive reforms that dilute their privileges, creating path dependence reinforced by captured judiciaries and bureaucracies, as evidenced in persistent underdevelopment despite resource endowments or aid inflows.^[91] This dynamic explains why reversals to extractive governance, even after temporary openings, revert trajectories toward stagnation, prioritizing causal mechanisms of elite self-preservation over historical or exogenous excuses.^[92]

Cultural and Behavioral Influences

Cultural values such as levels of interpersonal trust, individualism versus collectivism, and orientations toward long-term planning have been empirically linked to variations in economic development across countries, independent of institutional quality. In a study of European regions, higher prevalence of cultural traits like trust, respect for others, and confidence in others' good intentions—measured through survey responses on moral values—correlated positively with per capita income and economic performance, suggesting these values facilitate cooperation and investment in human capital. Cross-country analyses using Hofstede's cultural dimensions framework reveal that societies scoring higher on individualism, which emphasizes personal initiative and autonomy over group conformity, exhibit stronger associations with GDP per capita and long-run growth rates compared to more collectivist societies.^[93]^[94] Work ethic, conceptualized as a disposition toward diligence, delayed gratification, and productivity, further underscores culture's role; Max Weber's 1905 thesis posited that the Protestant ethic—valuing asceticism and rational pursuit of worldly success as signs of divine favor—catalyzed capitalist development in Northern Europe by promoting reinvestment over consumption. Empirical extensions affirm analogous behavioral patterns in non-Western contexts, where cultures fostering strong work ethics, such as Confucian emphases on perseverance in East Asian economies, correlate with sustained growth, while lower work ethic metrics in regions like sub-Saharan Africa align with persistent underdevelopment. Data from migrant populations provide evidence of cultural portability: immigrants from high-trust, individualistic origin countries often achieve higher economic outcomes in host nations than those from low-trust, collectivist backgrounds, even after controlling for education and skills, indicating that behavioral norms transfer across borders and influence success.^[95] These findings challenge cultural relativism by demonstrating measurable causal impacts of values on outcomes, as evidenced by econometric models isolating culture's effects from geography or history. For instance, long-term orientation—a dimension combining thrift, persistence, and future planning from Hofstede's framework and Inglehart's World Values Survey—predicts higher innovation and savings rates, key drivers of growth in panel data across 50+ countries.^[96] Yet culture is not immutable; incentives like property rights and education can shift values over generations, as observed in post-reform China where exposure to market norms increased individualism scores and productivity.^[97] In underdeveloping contexts, persistent low trust and collectivism hinder entrepreneurship and contract enforcement, perpetuating poverty traps unless behavioral adaptations are incentivized.

Empirical Evidence and Critiques

Evidence Supporting Internal Factors

Empirical studies employing instrumental variables have provided robust evidence that internal institutional quality, rather than geography or external exploitation, drives long-term economic performance. In a seminal analysis, Acemoglu, Johnson, and Robinson (2001) used European settler mortality rates during the colonial era as an instrument for institutional development, finding that locations with lower mortality led to the establishment of inclusive property rights and constraints on executive power, which in turn explain up to 75% of the variation in current income levels across former colonies, while geographic factors like latitude show no significant effect once institutions are controlled for.^[41] This approach addresses endogeneity by leveraging exogenous variation in colonizer incentives, confirming that extractive institutions persist and hinder growth independently of resource endowments or trade patterns.^[42] Growth accounting decompositions further underscore the primacy of internal factors through total factor productivity (TFP), which captures efficiency gains from institutions, human capital, and innovation rather than mere factor accumulation. Cross-country analyses reveal that TFP differences account for the majority of output growth variances between high- and low-income nations, often exceeding 50-80% in explanatory power when comparing rapid developers like East Asia to stagnant economies in sub-Saharan Africa, where capital and labor inputs alone fail to explain divergences.^[98] These residuals are tied to endogenous policies fostering secure property rights and rule of law, as opposed to exogenous shocks or aid inflows, which show negligible TFP impacts in regression frameworks.^[99] The framework advanced in Acemoglu and Robinson's Why Nations Fail (2012) synthesizes such evidence, arguing that inclusive economic institutions—characterized by secure property rights, incentives for investment, and creative destruction—underpin prosperity, with historical reversals like the divergence between Nogales, Arizona, and Nogales, Sonora, illustrating how internal governance trumps shared geography and culture.^[100] Empirical extensions, including natural experiments from colonial legacies and post-independence reforms, demonstrate that nations adopting extractive systems stagnate, while shifts toward inclusivity correlate with sustained growth accelerations, independent of natural resources or foreign intervention.^[101] Post-World War II recoveries in Europe and Japan highlight how internal reforms, rather than external aid, propelled rapid rebounds. Germany's Wirtschaftswunder was driven primarily by domestic deregulation, currency reform under the 1948 Deutsche Mark introduction, and labor market liberalization, with internal resource reallocation explaining over 80% of the growth surge from 1948-1950, while Marshall Plan aid constituted less than 5% of GDP and followed rather than preceded recovery.^[102] Similarly, Japan's post-war miracle stemmed from enterprise reforms and property rights enforcement under U.S. occupation guidance, but sustained by endogenous productivity gains, not aid dependency, as TFP contributions dominated output expansion through the 1950s.^[103] Recent meta-analyses reinforce the causal primacy of internal property rights protections. A 2024 global study on land use efficiency found that stronger titling and enforcement regimes boost productivity by 10-20% across developing regions, with institutional security explaining more variance in outcomes than climatic or trade variables.^[104] Another econometric review of OECD and EU countries confirms a positive, statistically significant link between property rights indices and per capita GDP growth, with coefficients indicating that a one-standard-deviation improvement in rights security yields 0.5-1% annual growth gains, upheld across fixed-effects models controlling for external factors.^[105] These findings, drawn from panel data spanning 2000-2020, affirm that endogenous institutional reforms remain the dominant driver of convergence, countering narratives emphasizing perpetual exploitation.^[106]

Critiques of External Exploitation Narratives

Critics of dependency theory and similar external exploitation narratives argue that such frameworks oversimplify the causes of underdevelopment by attributing stagnation primarily to global capitalist structures, thereby downplaying the role of domestic policy choices and institutional failures. For instance, the theory posits that peripheral economies are locked into unequal exchange with core nations, perpetuating poverty, yet this overlooks cases where integration into global markets fostered rapid industrialization and growth. Dependency proponents like André Gunder Frank predicted that export-oriented strategies would reinforce subordination, but empirical outcomes contradicted these forecasts, as evidenced by the failure to anticipate successful peripheral development paths.^[107]^[108] The East Asian Tigers—South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, and Hong Kong—provide a stark counterexample, achieving average annual GDP growth rates exceeding 7% from the 1960s to the 1990s through export-led models that dependency theory deemed exploitative and unsustainable. South Korea, in particular, defied predictions of perpetual underdevelopment by leveraging foreign markets and technology transfers while implementing disciplined domestic industrial policies, as analyzed by Alice Amsden, who highlighted how state intervention enabled learning and upward mobility within the international division of labor rather than entrapment. These economies transitioned from labor-intensive exports to high-tech manufacturing, increasing their global export shares and demonstrating that "dependent" roles could yield autonomy and prosperity when paired with internal discipline, undermining claims of inevitable exploitation. Terms-of-trade data further challenge the Prebisch-Singer hypothesis central to dependency thought, with developing country exporters of manufactures experiencing relative price improvements; for example, their share of world exports rose from 16% in 1990 to 30% by 2017, enabling greater import purchasing power.^[107]^[108]^[109] Foreign aid, often framed in exploitation narratives as a tool of neocolonial control, has been critiqued for generating perverse incentives that entrench poor governance rather than alleviating underdevelopment. Economist Peter Bauer argued in the 1970s that aid flows distort local economies by subsidizing inefficient elites and bureaucracies, fostering dependency on handouts over productive investment, as seen in stagnant aid-recipient nations where corruption absorbed resources without spurring growth. This "perversity" dynamic excuses internal mismanagement by externalizing blame, normalizing a victimhood mentality that impedes self-reliant reforms. Recent analyses of China's post-1978 trajectory reinforce this, attributing its escape from poverty—lifting over 800 million people since Deng Xiaoping's internal market liberalization—to domestic deregulation and incentive structures, not mitigation of supposed external predation, thus validating critiques of overreliance on exploitation explanations in the 2020s.^[110]^[111]

Comparative Case Studies

Botswana's post-independence trajectory exemplifies effective resource management and institutional stability in averting underdevelopment. Upon gaining independence in 1966, the country leveraged diamond discoveries, particularly from the Orapa mine in 1967, to fuel sustained growth, achieving the world's highest per capita income growth rate of over 7% annually from 1965 to 1999 through prudent fiscal policies, low corruption, and inclusive institutions that distributed resource rents broadly rather than concentrating them among elites.^[112]^[113] This contrasts sharply with resource-rich peers, where similar windfalls exacerbated inequality; Botswana's real GDP per capita rose from approximately $70 in 1960 to over $3,000 by 1999, underpinned by rule of law and property rights enforcement.^[114] Chile's economic reforms initiated after the 1973 military coup demonstrate the impact of market-oriented policies on poverty alleviation. Under the "Chicago Boys" advisors, the regime privatized state enterprises, liberalized trade, and stabilized finances, yielding average annual real GDP growth of 6.2% from the late 1970s onward, with per capita income quadrupling to $23,000 by 2015—the highest in Latin America during that span.^[115]^[116] Poverty rates fell from 45% in the early 1980s to under 10% by the 2010s, attributed primarily to growth rather than redistributive programs, though inequality persisted due to skill-biased wage effects from openness.^[116] These outcomes highlight how reducing state intervention and fostering competition can reverse stagnation, differing from protectionist models in the region. South Korea's transformation from war-devastated poverty to industrial powerhouse underscores endogenous policy choices in export-led industrialization. Following the Korean War, real GDP expanded at over 8% annually from 1962 to 1989, rising from $2.3 billion to $204 billion, driven by land reforms, education investments, and chaebol support conditional on export performance rather than import substitution.^[117]^[78] By prioritizing human capital and incentives for efficiency, South Korea escaped the middle-income trap, with manufacturing exports surging from negligible levels in the 1960s to global leadership in electronics and automobiles by the 1990s.^[118] In contrast, Venezuela's descent since Hugo Chávez's 1999 election illustrates resource mismanagement and statist interventions leading to collapse. Despite vast oil reserves comprising 95% of exports, GDP contracted by over 75% from 2013 to 2021 under Chávez and Nicolás Maduro, fueled by nationalizations, price controls, and fiscal deficits monetized via money printing, resulting in hyperinflation peaking at 1.7 million percent in 2018.^[33]^[119] Poverty surged to 96% by 2021, as oil production halved from mismanagement and corruption, rejecting diversification for patronage distribution that entrenched elite capture without productive investment.^[120] The Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) embodies the resource curse through elite capture and weak institutions. Endowed with minerals worth trillions, including cobalt and coltan, the DRC's GDP per capita stagnated below $600 since independence in 1960, with conflicts displacing millions and revenues siphoned by kleptocratic networks under leaders like Mobutu Sese Seko and successors.^[121]^[122] From 1990 to 2020, resource extraction boomed but funded warlordism rather than infrastructure, perpetuating a cycle where abundance correlates with governance failure and 73% poverty rates.^[123] Haiti's chronic underdevelopment stems from entrenched governance breakdowns and corruption, rendering external aid ineffective. Since independence in 1804, elite predation and political instability have eroded state capacity, with post-2010 earthquake aid of $13 billion yielding minimal reconstruction due to embezzlement and impunity, as evidenced by only 9% of funds reaching intended projects.^[124]^[125] GDP per capita hovers around $1,700, with deforestation and insecurity compounding institutional voids that prioritize factional control over public goods provision.^[126] Rwanda's post-1994 recovery offers a nuanced case of authoritarian efficiency yielding growth but risking cronyism. GDP has expanded at over 6% annually since 2000, reducing poverty from 77% in 2001 to 38% by 2017 through centralized planning, anti-corruption enforcement, and foreign investment in sectors like tourism and tech.^[127]^[128] However, critics note that President Paul Kagame's model concentrates power in the ruling Rwandan Patriotic Front, suppressing dissent and fostering elite rents via state-owned enterprises, potentially undermining long-term innovation and stability akin to other personalized regimes.^[129]^[130] This balance illustrates how strongman governance can catalyze catch-up growth but invites vulnerabilities from limited accountability.

Policy Responses and Outcomes

Foreign Aid and Intervention Critiques

Foreign aid to developing countries, totaling over $2.3 trillion in official development assistance from OECD Development Assistance Committee donors between 1960 and 2020, has yielded minimal sustained economic growth in recipients, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa. Economists like Dambisa Moyo argue in Dead Aid (2009) that this influx perpetuates dependency by substituting for domestic revenue mobilization, enabling corruption and poor governance without incentivizing reforms, as evidenced by Africa's per capita income stagnation despite aid surges post-1960.^[131] Similarly, William Easterly critiques aid in works like "Can Foreign Aid Buy Growth?" (2003), finding no robust correlation between aid inflows and GDP growth across panels of developing nations, attributing failures to planners' top-down approaches that ignore local knowledge and accountability.^[132] Empirical studies highlight moral hazard effects, where aid inflows reduce government incentives for tax collection and institutional quality, as cross-country regressions show higher aid levels correlating with governance deterioration, including weakened rule of law and increased corruption perceptions.^[133] Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of aid programs, such as those evaluating cash transfers and infrastructure projects in Africa, often reveal short-term consumption boosts but long-term inefficiencies, including crowding out private initiative and failure to scale due to elite capture or unsustainable funding.^[134] The "Big Push" model, exemplified by Jeffrey Sachs' Millennium Villages Project in 2000s Africa—which invested heavily in bundled interventions like fertilizers and clinics—failed to generate lasting poverty traps escape, with evaluation data showing no significant outperformance over control villages in growth or welfare metrics after initial inputs waned.^[135]^[136] While targeted aid has successes, such as Gavi Alliance vaccine programs averting millions of child deaths through improved immunization coverage in low-income countries from 2000 onward, these gains are domain-specific and do not translate to broader economic development, as health improvements alone fail to address productivity or investment barriers.^[137] Critics contend such narrow wins mask systemic flaws, with dependency risks outweighing benefits; Easterly and Moyo advocate shifting toward private investment and trade, which empirical growth accounting links more reliably to sustained per capita income rises in aid-dependent contexts.^[138] Overall, aid's track record underscores inefficiencies from fungibility and lack of conditionality enforcement, favoring alternatives that build endogenous capacities over perpetual transfers.^[139]

Market Liberalization and Successes

Market liberalization in developing economies has frequently correlated with accelerated GDP growth and poverty alleviation through enhanced incentives for production, investment, and trade. Deregulation of prices, reduction of trade barriers, and privatization of state enterprises have enabled resource allocation based on comparative advantages, fostering export-led expansion and domestic efficiency gains. Empirical studies attribute these outcomes to the removal of distortions that previously suppressed entrepreneurial activity and foreign direct investment.^[140] China's shift from central planning to market-oriented reforms beginning in 1978 exemplifies these dynamics, with annual GDP growth averaging over 9% through the subsequent decades, lifting nearly 800 million people out of extreme poverty. The establishment of special economic zones and gradual opening to international trade stimulated manufacturing and agricultural productivity, as farmers gained property rights over output and firms responded to global competition. Similarly, India's 1991 reforms, which dismantled the "License Raj" system of industrial controls and lowered import tariffs from over 100% to around 50%, propelled average annual GDP growth from a pre-reform "Hindu rate" of 3-4% to 6-7% in the following years. These changes expanded manufacturing exports from $18 billion in 1991 to over $300 billion by 2015, creating millions of jobs in sectors like information technology and textiles.^[141]^[142] Vietnam's Doi Moi policy, initiated in 1986, mirrored these successes by liberalizing prices, encouraging private enterprise, and integrating into global markets, yielding average annual GDP growth of 6.5% from the late 1980s onward and reducing poverty from 61% in 1993 to 37% by 1998. In Chile, post-1975 market-oriented policies including trade openness and privatization drove average annual growth of 7.2% from the mid-1980s to 1997, transforming it from a high-inflation economy to one of Latin America's most dynamic. WTO accessions among developing countries further amplified these effects, with trade liberalization post-accession associated with higher growth rates and poverty declines, as evidenced by increased exports and employment in export-oriented industries. Globally, extreme poverty rates fell from 36% in 1990 to 10% by 2015, a reduction linked to trade expansion in liberalizing economies rather than isolated aid flows.^[143]^[144]^[140]^[145] While these transitions often initially widened income inequality—evidenced by rising Gini coefficients, such as from 0.28 to 0.46 in China between 1981 and 2015—long-term data indicate improved intergenerational mobility and absolute gains for the poor through job creation and falling consumer prices for imported goods. Critics argue short-term dislocations, like rural-urban wage gaps, but econometric analyses affirm that liberalization's net causal impact on welfare exceeds that of protectionist alternatives, with poverty headcounts declining faster in open economies.^[146]^[147]

Institutional Reforms and Governance Improvements

Following the Rose Revolution in November 2003, Georgia implemented sweeping anti-corruption reforms, including the dismissal of the entire traffic police force of over 30,000 officers and the introduction of merit-based recruitment with substantial salary increases, which reduced petty bribery incidents from widespread prevalence to only 2% of citizens reporting payments by 2010.^[148] These measures, combined with judicial and public administration overhauls, correlated with a sharp decline in perceived corruption as measured by Transparency International's index, improving from 18th percentile in 2003 to 55th by 2012, alongside average annual GDP growth exceeding 9% from 2004 to 2007.^[149] Difference-in-differences analyses of such localized anti-corruption shocks in developing contexts, including Georgia's police reform, demonstrate causal boosts to local economic activity by reducing extortion barriers, with treated regions showing 10-15% higher firm entry rates compared to controls.^[150] In Estonia, post-independence reforms from 1991 onward established a comprehensive e-governance system by 2000, enabling digital public services that streamlined bureaucracy, cut administrative costs equivalent to 2% of GDP annually through e-signatures and online portals, and enhanced transparency in procurement to curb graft.^[151] This digital infrastructure, including the X-Road data exchange platform launched in 2001, supported rule-of-law enforcement by automating audits and reducing discretionary official interactions, contributing to Estonia's governance score rising from below 50th percentile in World Bank indicators in the early 1990s to over 90th by 2010, alongside FDI inflows increasing from under 1% of GDP in 1995 to peaks above 10% by 2006.^[152] Empirical linkages from Worldwide Governance Indicators (WGI) data show that a one-standard-deviation improvement in rule-of-law scores predicts 20-30% higher FDI-to-GDP ratios in panel regressions across developing economies, as stronger property rights and contract enforcement mitigate investor risks.^[153] However, incomplete institutional reforms often yield muted outcomes, as seen in Latin American cases where partial anti-corruption and judicial changes in the 1990s—such as Mexico's 1996 judicial autonomy laws or Brazil's 1999 administrative streamlining—failed to dismantle entrenched elite capture, resulting in persistent corruption perceptions above 50th percentile on WGI metrics and subdued growth averaging under 3% annually through the 2000s.^[154] Meta-analyses of public sector reforms indicate that anti-corruption drives without concurrent enforcement capacity-building, as in these partial Latin American efforts, achieve only 10-20% reductions in graft indices versus 50%+ in comprehensive cases like Georgia, underscoring the causal necessity of holistic implementation to sustain economic gains.^[155] Such failures highlight that superficial legal tweaks, absent political commitment to uproot patronage networks, reinforce underdevelopment by eroding investor confidence and perpetuating inefficient resource allocation.^[156]

Contemporary Developments

Globalization and Trade Dynamics

Globalization accelerated in the post-1990s era through institutional frameworks like the World Trade Organization (WTO), enabling developing countries to integrate into international supply chains by exploiting comparative advantages in low-cost labor and resource endowments.^[157] This shift facilitated the fragmentation of production, where stages of manufacturing were distributed across borders, boosting efficiency and scale in export-oriented industries.^[158] China's accession to the WTO on December 11, 2001, marked a pivotal example, as tariff reductions and market access propelled its merchandise exports from $266 billion in 2001 to $1.76 trillion by 2010, underscoring how trade liberalization can catalyze export-led industrialization in previously insulated economies.^[159]^[160] Empirical analyses consistently link trade openness to enhanced economic performance in developing contexts, with IMF assessments indicating that liberalization contributes to GDP gains disproportionate to those in industrial nations, often amplifying growth through technology diffusion and capital inflows.^[157] For instance, cross-country regressions show that a one-percentage-point increase in trade-to-GDP ratios correlates with higher per capita income growth, particularly in economies adopting outward-oriented policies post-1990.^[161] While protectionist critiques highlight short-term job displacement in vulnerable sectors—such as textile manufacturing in sub-Saharan Africa amid Asian competition—aggregate welfare effects remain positive, as cheaper imports reduce input costs for downstream industries and expand employment in export hubs.^[162]^[163] General equilibrium models further quantify these net benefits, estimating that trade shocks, despite localized disruptions, elevate overall consumption and productivity via reallocation toward competitive activities.^[164] Fair trade advocacy, which imposes premiums and standards to address perceived inequities, contrasts with unrestricted exchange by restricting volume and raising barriers, often yielding inferior outcomes for producers compared to unfettered market access.^[165] Evaluations reveal that fair trade certifications incur high administrative costs, with only a fraction of premiums—sometimes less than 20%—reaching smallholders, while limiting scalability and innovation incentives inherent in voluntary, price-driven transactions. In contrast, empirical evidence from liberalizing episodes affirms that voluntary trade, grounded in mutual gains from specialization, outperforms interventionist schemes by fostering broader participation and sustained efficiency improvements, debunking zero-sum narratives that undervalue the causal role of comparative advantage in development trajectories.^[166]^[167]

Recent Trends in Poverty Reduction (2000-2025)

Between 2000 and 2019, the global share of people living in extreme poverty—defined by the World Bank as less than $2.15 per day in 2017 purchasing power parity—fell from 28.4 percent to 8.7 percent, reducing the absolute number from approximately 1.7 billion to 650 million and marking a decline exceeding 50 percent in the rate.^[168] This progress was concentrated in Asia, where rapid economic expansion through domestic policy shifts toward market incentives and industrialization lifted over a billion individuals above the threshold, contrasting with slower gains or stagnation in sub-Saharan Africa.^[168]^[169] The COVID-19 pandemic disrupted these trends starting in 2020, reversing gains for the first time in decades with an estimated net increase of 70 million people in extreme poverty by 2021 due to lockdowns, supply disruptions, and employment losses in informal sectors.^[168] Global extreme poverty stabilized at around 9.3 percent in 2022 before edging toward 9.9 percent projected for 2025, with absolute numbers at 839 million in 2024 amid uneven regional recoveries led by Asia's export-oriented rebounds.^[170]^[171] In China, internal anti-poverty campaigns combined with sustained growth reduced extreme poverty to near zero by 2020, contributing over 75 percent of global reductions in the period and demonstrating the efficacy of targeted governance interventions like infrastructure investment and rural relocation programs.^[172]^[141] Progress aligned with Sustainable Development Goal 1 (SDG 1) targets included a rise in electricity access from roughly 78 percent of the global population in 2000 to over 91 percent by 2024, enabling productivity gains in agriculture and small enterprises that supported poverty escapes, though 730 million people—mostly in rural Africa—remained unconnected.^[173] Effective governance structures, such as transparent fiscal responses and institutional capacity for aid distribution, proved causal in post-pandemic resilience, allowing countries with stronger rule-of-law frameworks to achieve faster per capita income recoveries and limit poverty spikes compared to those hampered by corruption or weak administration.^[174]^[175] While relative inequality measures like Gini coefficients rose in some fast-growing economies due to urban-rural divides, absolute deprivations declined markedly, underscoring that poverty reduction prioritizes lifting baselines over equalizing outcomes amid resource scarcity.^[168] Projections to 2030 indicate that sustaining internal reforms in trade openness and property rights could halve remaining extreme poverty if pre-2020 trajectories resume, though climate shocks and geopolitical tensions pose risks absent adaptive institutions.^[176]^[177]

References

[1]
Difference between Developed and Underdeveloped Economy
Jun 20, 2022 · An underdeveloped economy means that have low per capita income, a high rate of unemployment, a high growth rate of the population, low rate of production.
[2]
Characteristics of an Underdeveloped Countries: Top 14 ...
Underdeveloped countries are characterized by lack of industrial development. The pace of industrialisation in these countries is very slow due to lack of ...
[3]
Characteristics of Underdeveloped Countries - Urban Studies
May 6, 2024 · What exactly makes a country “underdeveloped”? · The agricultural dependency trap · The capital formation crisis · The savings-investment gap ...
[4]
Development & Under-Development - Revision World
They have low economic growth, little capital to invest, and high levels of unemployment and underemployment. There is little, or no, formal education, with low ...
[5]
Inequality does cause underdevelopment: Insights from a new ...
This paper confirms with cross-country data that agricultural endowments predict inequality and inequality predicts development.
[6]
The Persistence of Underdevelopment: Institutions, Human Capital ...
Sep 4, 2006 · This paper tries to reconcile these two views by arguing that the underlying cause of underdevelopment is the initial distribution of factor endowments.
[7]
[PDF] Inequality does Cause Underdevelopment: New evidence
This paper argues that inequality causes underdevelopment, finding a causal link from inequality to underdevelopment, and that commodity endowments predict the ...
[8]
[PDF] development and underdevelopment: 1500 1 2000 - Economic History
Underdevelopment is a long)term phenomenon, one of the most persistent in economics. Many countries have been underdeveloped for two hundred years T since the ...
[9]
[PDF] The Importance of History for Economic Development
In Dell's setting, not enough (rather than too much) concentration and inequality in land ownership was the cause of long-term economic underdevelopment. 3.
[10]
(PDF) Development and underdevelopment from the perspective of ...
Jan 15, 2021 · This article aims to study the conceptual evolution of the notions of development and underdevelopment in the light of modern evolutionary economics.
[11]
[PDF] Underdevelopment, Resource Scarcity, and Environmental ...
Fluctuating food and energy prices put people and governments to the test, while the demand for resources—notably water and energy—increases due to un-.
[12]
(PDF) Economic Underdevelopment And Sustainable Development ...
Aug 5, 2025 · This paper deals with the various factors that condition underdevelopment in the world. It suggests some alternatives and points out the potential ...
[13]
Underdevelopment - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
Underdevelopment is defined as a condition characterized by weak political and social institutions, which impedes effective governance and regulation, ...
[14]
World Bank country classifications by income level for 2024-2025
Jul 1, 2024 · Explore the updated World Bank country income classifications for 2024-2025, highlighting GNI per capita shifts and global economic trends.
[15]
Low-Income Countries 2025 - World Population Review
2021 GNI per capita of up to $1,085 · Lower-middle-income economies — 2021 GNI per capita of $1,086 to $4,255 · Upper-middle-income ...
[16]
Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty ...
Extractive institutions are the historical norm. ... There is no quick fix for institutional weakness, only the possibility that steady encouragement and chance ...
[17]
[PDF] Institutional causes, macroeconomic symptoms: volatility, crises and ...
formation of extractive states, and today the presence of weak institutions, as these extractive institutions persist. This reasoning suggests that proxies ...
[18]
Extreme Poverty is Rising Fast in Economies Hit by Conflict, Instability
Jun 27, 2025 · Conflict and instability are taking a devastating toll on the 39 economies afflicted by them, driving up extreme poverty faster than ...Missing: underdevelopment | Show results with:underdevelopment
[19]
GDP per capita (current US$) - World Bank Open Data
GDP per capita (current US$) Country official statistics, National Statistical Organizations and/or Central Banks; National Accounts data files.
[20]
https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.KD.ZG
[21]
Human Development Index (HDI)
The HDI simplifies and captures only part of what human development entails. It does not reflect on inequalities, poverty, human security, empowerment, etc. The ...Human development · Documentation and downloads · The 2025 Human... · News
[22]
[PDF] REPORT 2023/2024 | Human Development Reports
The 2023/2024 report addresses "global gridlock" and polarization, aiming to enable people to feel more in control and act on shared challenges.
[23]
What Are the Criticisms of the Human Development Index (HDI)?
Critics argue that the HDI assigns weights to certain factors that are equal tradeoffs when these measurements may not always be equally valuable. For example, ...
[24]
Back to Basics: Total Factor Productivity in - IMF eLibrary
Sep 3, 2024 · Recent IMF research shows that TFP growth has slowed around the world since the global financial crisis. In low-income developing countries, it ...Missing: stagnation | Show results with:stagnation
[25]
The Role of Total Factor Productivity Growth in Middle-Income ...
Apr 4, 2018 · We examine the importance of total factor productivity (TFP) growth in middle-income countries (MICs) based on cross-country panel data for ...
[26]
Index of Economic Freedom: About the Index
Explore the Index of Economic Freedom to gauge global impacts of liberty and free markets. Discover the powerful link between economic freedom and progress.
[27]
[PDF] 2025 index of - economic freedom - The Heritage Foundation
Feb 4, 2025 · Undeniably, countries moving toward greater economic freedom tend to achieve higher growth rates of per capita GDP over time. Throughout all ...
[28]
The Impact of Economic Freedom on Economic Growth? New ...
Their panel analysis showed that economic freedom has a positive impact on GDP level/growth. In some cases, different groups of countries and the criteria for ...
[29]
Methodology | Fragile States Index
The Fragile States Index (FSI) produced by The Fund for Peace (FFP), is a critical tool in highlighting not only the normal pressures that all states experience ...
[30]
Fragile States Index | The Fund for Peace
P1: State Legitimacy · P2: Public Services · P3: Human Rights and Rule of Law ... Methodology · FAQ · The Fund for Peace · Contact Us · Support Us · Donate.Country Dashboard · Global Data · Indicators · Methodology
[31]
[PDF] Fragile States Index Annual Report 2020. - The Fund for Peace
The Fragile States Index (FSI) is an annual ranking of 178 countries based on the different pressures they face that impact their levels of fragility. The Index ...
[32]
GDP per capita (current US$) - Venezuela, RB | Data
GDP per capita (current US$) - Venezuela, RB. Country official statistics, National Statistical Organizations and/or Central Banks; National Accounts data files ...
[33]
Why did Venezuela's economy collapse? - Economics Observatory
Sep 23, 2024 · GDP per capita bottomed in 2020 once the economy had contracted 73% from the start of the crisis and has been flat or up slightly on the ...
[34]
Venezuela, RB - World Bank Open Data
Economic ; GDP (current US$) · Most recent value. (2014 billion). 482.36. (2014 billion) ; GDP per capita (current US$) · Most recent value. (2014). 15,943.6. (2014).
[35]
[PDF] Political centralization in pre-colonial Africa - Scholars at Harvard
Jan 25, 2013 · It ranges from 1 which indicates a stateless society (98 cases) up until. 4 which indicates the number of layers of political hierarchy which ...
[36]
Political centralization in pre-colonial Africa - ScienceDirect.com
In this paper we investigate the empirical correlates of political centralization using data from the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample.
[37]
[PDF] Working Paper No. 141 PRE-COLONIAL POLITICAL ...
The effects of pre-colonial history on contemporary African development have become an important field of study within development economics in recent years. In ...
[38]
Tributary system | Definition, China, History, & Example - Britannica
Tributary states typically received China's protection as well as economic benefits, such as the right to trade with China. Until the founding of the Ming ...
[39]
[PDF] Maddison style estimates of the evolution of the world economy
The Maddison database on Historical Statistics of the World Economy has probably the widest coverage of data on GDP per capita across countries and over time ...Missing: Eurasia | Show results with:Eurasia
[40]
[PDF] The West and the Rest in the World Economy: 1000–2030
From the year 1000 Ad to. 1820, world economic growth was predominantly extensive. Most of the GdP increase went to accommodate a four-.<|separator|>
[41]
The Colonial Origins of Comparative Development: An Empirical ...
In places where Europeans faced high mortality rates, they could not settle and were more likely to set up extractive institutions. These institutions persisted ...
[42]
[PDF] The Colonial Origins of Comparative Development - MIT Economics
The regression shows that mortality rates faced by the settlers more than 100 years ago explains over 25 percent of the variation in current institutions.4 We ...
[43]
Belgium begins to face brutal colonial legacy of Leopold II
Nov 23, 2019 · King Leopold II of Belgium ruled the Congo Free State with a tyranny that was peculiarly brutal even by the cruel and deeply racist standards of European ...
[44]
[PDF] The Colonial Origins of Comparative Development: An Empirical ...
We exploit differences in European mortality rates to estimate the effect of institu- tions on economic performance.
[45]
[PDF] NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES THE COLONIAL ORIGINS OF ...
We hypothesize that settler mortality affected settlements; settlements affected early in- stitutions; and early institutions persisted and formed the basis of ...
[46]
[PDF] Copper mining in Zambia - The developmental legacy of privatisation
Oct 3, 2007 · At its peak in the late 1960s and early 1970s, copper mining accounted for more than 80% of the country's foreign exchange earnings, over 50 ...
[47]
Mismanaged mineral dependence: Zambia 1970–90 - ScienceDirect
Zambia, like other copper producers, took the high late 1960s copper price as the norm and regarded the mid-1970s mineral price fall as an aberration.
[48]
[PDF] Economic Development Patterns and Outcomes in Africa and Asia
Nov 2, 2007 · Over the period 1965–89, real GDP per capita annual growth of the Sub-Saharan Africa (hereafter. SSA) averaged less than 0.5% compared to over 5 ...
[49]
Industrialization in Latin America: Successes and Failures - jstor
Successes and Failures. Werner Baer. This paper examines Latin America's development strategy based on import substitution industrialization (ISI). I shall ...Missing: evidence Africa
[50]
How Lee Kuan Yew transformed Singapore | World Economic Forum
Mar 23, 2015 · These efforts of the premier saw Singapore's per capita GDP jump from around US$500 in 1965 by a staggering 2800% to US$14,500 by 1991. ...
[51]
The Singapore Model of Industrial Policy: Past Evolution and ...
The Singapore model emphasizes minimal price distortions, openness to trade, investment, technology, macroeconomic stability, high savings and investment.<|control11|><|separator|>
[52]
"An Economic History of Singapore: 1965-2065*" - Keynote Address ...
Aug 5, 2015 · By 1975, Singapore had established a substantial industrial base, with manufacturing's share in GDP climbing to 22% from 14% in 1965. The ...
[53]
Norman Borlaug – Nobel Lecture - NobelPrize.org
In both India and Pakistan the rapid increase in yields per hectare of wheat has been the major thrust of the green revolution. Increases in rice yield also ...
[54]
Towards a New Green Revolution
The gains in production were dramatic: world cereal yields jumped from 1.4 tonnes per hectare in the early 1 960s to 2.7 tonnes per hectare in 1989-91. Over the ...
[55]
The Green Revolution: Norman Borlaug and the Race to Fight ... - PBS
Apr 22, 2025 · In the case of Mexico, he increased productivity dramatically. Once the new varieties of wheat were widely reproduced, you saw diminished ...
[56]
India transforms wheat for the world - CIMMYT
Oct 16, 2023 · Wheat grain yield in Indian farmers' fields rose yearly by more than 1.8 percent—some 54 kilograms per hectare—in the last decade, a remarkable ...
[57]
The impact of the Green Revolution on indigenous crops of India
Oct 1, 2019 · The Green Revolution in India was initiated in the 1960s by introducing high-yielding varieties of rice and wheat to increase food ...
[58]
II. Land Tenure Relationships in the Context of the Green Revolution
The experience, so far, shows an extremely uneven distribution of the fruits of the Green Revolution among the different classes of the rural population and ...
[59]
[PDF] Green Revolutions for Africa - Chatham House
Technological options are discussed first, then institutional needs, particularly the requirements for better-functioning markets and appropriate land tenure.
[60]
The forthcoming Joe Studwell book on Africa - Marginal REVOLUTION
Sep 21, 2025 · In broad terms, the story went like this: Taiwan redistributed land to the peasantry, which significantly increased the nation's agricultural ...Missing: property | Show results with:property
[61]
Trends in official development aid: A review of ODA during 1961-77 ...
Jun 1, 1977 · The total volume of official development assistance (ODA) from the developed to the developing nations has risen steadily since the early 1960s.Missing: surges impact
[62]
[PDF] Foreign aid's impact on economic growth - LSU Scholarly Repository
A United Nations study in 1994 found that income in some aid recipient countries had literally fallen. This study looked at over one hundred countries that had ...Missing: surges | Show results with:surges
[63]
The Success and Failure of Dependency Theory - jstor
By ignoring analytical or neoclassical economics, dependency theory denies its adherents both an adequate understanding of how an economy functions at a ...Missing: critiques Green
[64]
'Guns, Germs and Steel': Jared Diamond on Geography as Power
In an interview with National Geographic, scientist Jared Diamond argues that geography shaped how history unfolded across the world.
[65]
Guns Germs & Steel: Variables. The Story of... - PBS
He argued that continents which were easily traversible, such as Europe encouraged trade among different people and stimulated development. In this section ...
[66]
Temperature variability and long-run economic development
The results suggest that daily temperature levels have a non-linear effect on economic activity with an optimal temperature around 15 degrees Celsius.
[67]
https://oxfordre.com/environmentalscience/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780199389414.001.0001/acrefore-9780199389414-e-514
[68]
[PDF] NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES TROPICS, GERMS, AND CROPS
We find no evidence that tropics, germs, and crops affect country incomes directly other than through institutions, nor do we find any effect of policies on ...
[69]
Natural Resource Abundance and Economic Growth | NBER
Dec 1, 1995 · In this paper we show that economies with a high ratio of natural resource exports to GDP in 1971 (the base year) tended to have low growth rates.
[70]
From Venezuela to Nigeria: mapping the resource curse | August 2021
Aug 19, 2021 · The resource curse is the phenomenon whereby countries underperform economically despite an abundance of natural resources, resulting in ...
[71]
The History of Singapore's Economic Development - ThoughtCo
May 8, 2025 · By embracing globalization, free-market capitalism, education, and pragmatic policies, the country has been able to overcome its geographic ...
[72]
(PDF) The Role of Geography in Economic Development: A Critical ...
Mar 18, 2025 · This article examines the multifaceted relationship between geography and economic development, analysing both historical patterns and contemporary evidence.
[73]
International Development Patterns, Strategies, Theories ...
Rostow penned his classic Stages of Economic Growth in 1960, which presented five steps through which all countries must pass to become developed.
[74]
[PDF] ROSTOW'S THEORY - Government College for Girls, Ludhiana
This stage is the outcome of Take-off stage. ... country. Continuous growth of investment- Investment rate rises to 10-20% of GNP production, thus, happens to.Missing: percentage | Show results with:percentage
[75]
Economic Growth: Endogenous & Solow Models
Aug 19, 2024 · Unlike the Solow model, which treats technological progress as exogenous, endogenous growth theory argues that technological progress is ...
[76]
[PDF] Paul Romer: Ideas, Nonrivalry, and Endogenous Growth
Romer developed endogenous growth theory, emphasizing that technological change is the result of efforts by researchers and entrepreneurs who respond to ...
[77]
[PDF] NBER Working Paper Series IDEAS AND GROWTH Robert E. Lucas ...
A theory of endogenous growth should offer more than a pretty story about pa- rameters that, in practice, we simply treat as unalterable givens. It should ...
[78]
[PDF] The Korean Miracle (1962-1980) Revisited
In the period of 1962-1979, Korea's real GNP and exports grew at the average annual rates of 9.3 and 33.7%, respectively. As shown in Table 2-2, the growth ...
[79]
[PDF] East Asian miracle - World Bank Documents & Reports
Seningly, the rapidly growing economies in East Asia used many of the same poficy instruments as othcr developing economies, but with greater success.
[80]
(PDF) The Role Of Human Capital And Total Factor Productivity In ...
The aim of this study is to test the existence of a positive relationship between the human capital and economic growth in a group of countries.
[81]
Economic Issues 1 -- Growth in East Asia
Figure 1 shows that in this comparison the growth rates of output per person of Hong Kong, Korea, and Taiwan Province of China were very high in the 1960-75 ...
[82]
[PDF] Prebisch-Singer Redux - International Trade Commission
revisits the argument of Prebisch (1950) that, over the long term, declining terms of trade would frustrate the development goals of the region. This paper ...
[83]
[PDF] Dependency Theory - Institute for New Economic Thinking
May 23, 2017 · The forces driving and entrenching dependence are not only global or metropolitan; they are local as well. If in the 1960s and the 1970s, the ...
[84]
The Wealth—and Poverty — of Nations | Cato Institute
Summarizing their case, the authors write, “Nations fail today because extractive economic institutions do not create the incentives needed for people to save, ...<|separator|>
[85]
[PDF] INSTITUTIONS AS A FUNDAMENTAL CAUSE OF LONG-RUN ...
Abstract. This paper develops the empirical and theoretical case that differences in economic in- stitutions are the fundamental cause of differences in ...
[86]
Worldwide Governance Indicators - World Bank
It helps countries increase economic growth, build human capital, and strengthen social cohesion. ... Control of Corruption. Click here for a non-technical ...World Bank's reproducibility... · Interactive Data Access · Documentation · FAQMissing: impact | Show results with:impact
[87]
The impact of corruption on economic growth in developing ...
The study's empirical results show that corruption hinders the economic growth of those developing countries.
[88]
[PDF] Doing Business 2020 - World Bank Documents & Reports
Research demonstrates a causal relationship between economic freedom and gross domestic product (GDP) growth, where freedom regarding wages and prices, property ...
[89]
[PDF] 25 Years of Transition: Post-Communist Europe and the IMF
Oct 24, 2014 · The past 25 years have seen a dramatic transformation in Europe's former communist countries, resulting in their reintegration into the global ...
[90]
[PDF] The Economic Decline of Zimbabwe
For the past decade, Zimbabwe has been experiencing an economic decline that has resulted in an inflation rate of 231 million percent and an unemployment ...
[91]
Persistence of Power, Elites, and Institutions
The model can imply a pattern of captured democracy, whereby a democratic regime may survive but choose economic institutions favoring an elite. The model ...Missing: extractive underdevelopment
[92]
Nobel-Winning Insights from Daron Acemoglu and His Collaborators
Apr 7, 2025 · Acemoglu and Robinson (2012) argue that elites maintain extractive institutions to protect their privileged positions. Over time, these ...
[93]
Does culture affect long-run growth? | CEPR
Sep 21, 2010 · This column argues that countries with a more individualist culture have enjoyed higher long-run growth than countries with a more collectivist culture.
[94]
[PDF] Relationships among Cultural Dimensions, National Gross Domestic ...
Economic development has been found to be related to cultural values. Other studies have found a relationship between culture and environmental sustainability.
[95]
Migration, Diversity, and Economic Growth - ScienceDirect.com
In this article we investigate the extent to which cultural diversity affects economic growth, using novel data on bilateral migration stocks, that is the ...Missing: portability | Show results with:portability
[96]
[PDF] Dimensionalizing Cultures: The Hofstede Model in Context
This article describes briefly the Hofstede model of six dimensions of national cultures: Power Distance, Uncertainty Avoidance, Individualism/Collectivism, ...
[97]
Individualism–collectivism, governance and economic development
In this article, I argue that the individualist–collectivist dimension can also affect development through its impact on the quality of government.
[98]
Back to Basics: Total Factor Productivity
TFP is an important macroeconomic statistic for two reasons. First, improvements in living standards must come from growth in TFP over the long run. This is ...Missing: variance | Show results with:variance
[99]
[PDF] Growth Accounting, Total Factor Productivity and Approximation ...
... TFP variation and its share in economic growth lies directly in the growth accounting method and use of total differential for solving the dynamics for ...
[100]
[PDF] They provided an explanation for why some countries are rich and ...
Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson and James Robinson have contributed innovative research about what affects countries' economic prosperity in the long run.
[101]
[PDF] Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty
Acemoglu and Robinson lay out a convincing theory of almost everything to do with economic development. Countries rise when they put in place the right pro- ...
[102]
The Myth of the Marshall Plan and Its Effects on Growth
Mar 19, 2019 · The economic recovery of Germany after World War II was driven by mostly internal resources, explains Tamas Vonyo in a paper.
[103]
Economic Recovery: Lessons from the Post-World War II Period
Sep 10, 2012 · There was a massive, swift, and beneficial switch from a wartime economy to peacetime prosperity; resources flowed quickly and efficiently from ...
[104]
Global property rights and land use efficiency - PMC - PubMed Central
Oct 2, 2024 · The study examines how land property rights impact land use efficiency (LUE) globally, based on the SDG 11.3.1 indicator. Secure rights improve LUE.
[105]
Property Rights and Economic Growth: OECD & EU Country Analysis
Jul 25, 2024 · This study conducted by Ceyhun Haydaroglu investigates the complex relationship between property rights and economic growth.
[106]
[PDF] Property rights and economic growth - Volume 41, Issue 3
Sep 23, 2020 · Abstract. This paper examines the role of property rights and other factors to the growth of real gross domestic product (GDP) per capita.
[107]
Does the East Asian "Miracle" Invalidate Dependency Theory?
Jan 10, 2024 · The phenomenal growth enjoyed by the 4 Asian Tigers, namely Singapore, Hong Kong, South Korea and Taiwan, call into question the validity of dependency theory.
[108]
Is Dependency Theory Relevant in the Twenty-First Century?
Aug 17, 2022 · Furthermore, Amsden (2003) criticised the dependency theory for suggesting the impossibility of achieving development within the international ...
[109]
Trade has been a powerful driver of economic development and ...
Feb 12, 2023 · From 1990 to 2017, developing countries increased their share of global exports from 16 percent to 30 percent; in the same period, the ...
[110]
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1723262
[111]
https://www.worldscientific.com/doi/full/10.1142/9789814569989_0001
[112]
[PDF] An African Success Story: Botswana1 - MIT Economics
Jul 11, 2001 · Abstract: Botswana has had the highest rate of per-capita growth of any country in the world in the last 35 years.
[113]
Botswana: The Pragmatic Path to Prosperity
Apr 15, 2024 · The Orapa mine catapulted Botswana's economy forward: for the thirty years between 1965 and 1995, Botswana had the fastest rate of economic ...
[114]
Botswana Overview: Development news, research, data | World Bank
Oct 2, 2025 · Botswana's economy, historically anchored in prudent fiscal management and robust institutions, has sustained growth for nearly four decades ...
[115]
[PDF] Macroeconomic Stability and Income Inequality in Chile
Real GDP growth had averaged 6.2 percent per year, unemployment fell to 6.3 percent from a peak of 30 percent in 1982, and export growth surged.
[116]
The Fall of Chile | Cato Institute
Between 1975 and 2015 per capita income in Chile quadrupled to $23,000, the highest rate in Latin America (CNP 2016).Missing: post- | Show results with:post-
[117]
SOUTH KOREA'S ECONOMIC MIRACLE | Facts and Details
South Korea's real gross GDP expanded by an average of more than 8 percent per year, from US$2.3 billion in 1962 to US$204 billion in 1989.
[118]
https://koreanculture.org/korea-information-economy
[119]
Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate
In recent years, Venezuela has suffered economic collapse, with output shrinking significantly and rampant hyperinflation contributing to a scarcity of basic ...What is a petrostate? · How does Venezuela fit the... · How did Venezuela get here?
[120]
How Maduro and Chavez wrecked Venezuela's economy
Aug 1, 2024 · Maduro's allies and apologists, as well as America's critics, love to claim that American sanctions are responsible for Venezuela's collapse.
[121]
The “Resource Curse” and the Democratic Republic of Congo
May 16, 2025 · This paper examines the DRC's experience with the resource curse ... From independence to this day, the country has suffered from elite capture ...
[122]
[PDF] The Resource Curse: A Look into the Implications of an Abundance ...
May 28, 2018 · The purpose of this research was to find a connection between the resource curse in the Democratic Republic of the Congo and the continued ...
[123]
DR Congo: Cursed by its natural wealth - BBC News
Oct 9, 2013 · The Congo has been utterly cursed by its natural wealth. The Congo is a massive country, the size of Western Europe. Henry Morton Stanley is ...
[124]
Haiti's Troubled Path to Development | Council on Foreign Relations
The Caribbean state has weathered multiple foreign interventions, chronic political instability, social unrest, and devastating natural disasters.
[125]
Haiti crisis: Insecurity fuelled by corruption and impunity
Apr 9, 2024 · “The urgency to confront the twin issues of corruption and governance failures is paramount. Accountability and anti-corruption efforts ...
[126]
Full article: Haiti in the Balance – Why Foreign Aid Has Failed and ...
Jul 22, 2009 · Governance failures are analysed in terms of a lack of government capacity, poor aid administration, weak financial management, ineffective tax ...
[127]
[PDF] Rwanda: an effective development model, rising to the challenge of ...
How sustainable is the Rwandan model? Conclusion. Rwanda has come a long way since the 1994 genocide. Since the 2000s, its GDP has grown at one of the highest.
[128]
The Disorder of 'Miracle Growth' in Rwanda: Understanding the ...
This chapter analyses how Rwanda has achieved near miracle growth rates of above 6 per cent (excluding 2003 and 2013) since 1994.
[129]
Rwanda's post-genocide model prioritises security over freedom ...
Apr 24, 2024 · Lastly, in economics, critics argued the strategy pursued sought simply to entrench and enrich the ruling party. While the regime has ...
[130]
Thirty Years After Rwanda's Genocide: Where the Country Stands ...
Apr 3, 2024 · After the 1994 genocide in Rwanda, the country has made tremendous strides toward peace and development. But critics say these have come at the cost of ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[131]
https://www.tutor2u.net/economics/reference/what-are-the-main-arguments-put-forward-in-dead-aid-by-dambisa-moyo
[132]
Can Foreign Aid Buy Growth? - American Economic Association
Can Foreign Aid Buy Growth? William Easterly. Economic research on foreign aid effectiveness and economic growth fre- quently becomes a political football ...Missing: critiques | Show results with:critiques
[133]
Publication: Aid Dependence and the Quality of Governance
The author's analyses of cross-country data provide evidence that higher aid levels erode the quality of governance.
[134]
Increasing Aid Effectiveness: A Role for Randomised Control Trials?
Aug 21, 2007 · Banerjee and colleagues argue that aid should be subject to the rigours of Randomised Control Trials (RCTs) to increase efficiency and efficacy.Missing: inefficiency hazard
[135]
The Big Push Failed - Marginal REVOLUTION
Oct 16, 2018 · In 2004, Jeff Sachs and co-authors revived an old theory to explain Africa's failure to develop, the poverty trap, and an old solution, ...Missing: critique | Show results with:critique
[136]
Jeffrey Sachs' Failure to Eradicate Poverty in Africa - Pacific Standard
Sep 17, 2013 · The Not-So-Great Professor: Jeffrey Sachs' Incredible Failure to Eradicate Poverty in Africa. Howard W. French. September 17, 2013. Jeffrey ...
[137]
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4182652
[138]
[PDF] The tragedy of foreign aid is not that it didn't work
The tragedy of foreign aid is not that it didn't work; it was never really tried. A group of well- meaning national and international bureaucracies ...
[139]
Is too much foreign aid a curse or blessing to developing countries?
Aug 29, 2022 · The empirical inconclusive findings concerning the relationship between foreign aid and economic growth created skepticism among researchers ...
[140]
[PDF] TRADE AND POVERTY REDUCTION: - World Trade Organization
It highlights how trade openness has clear, positive impacts on poverty reduction. For example, trade can benefit the poor by reducing the price of what they ...
[141]
China Overview: Development news, research, data | World Bank
Since China began to open up and reform its economy in 1978, GDP growth has averaged over 9 percent a year, and almost 800 million people have lifted ...
[142]
Impact of the 1991 Economic Reforms on India's Growth and ...
Mar 5, 2025 · Before 1991, India's GDP growth rate was sluggish, averaging around 3-4% per year. Post-reforms, the economy witnessed accelerated growth, with ...
[143]
Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction in Viet Nam
Vietnam's economic growth, driven by reforms, reduced poverty from 61% in 1993 to 37% in 1998, with the poorest quintile's income increasing more than the top ...
[144]
How Chile Successfully Transformed Its Economy
Sep 18, 2006 · From the mid-1980s to the Asian crisis in 1997, the Chilean economy grew at an average annual rate of 7.2 percent, followed by an average annual ...
[145]
Global poverty reduction is slowing, regional trends help ...
Nov 5, 2020 · Between 1990 and 2015 the global rate of extreme poverty fell at a rate of about 1 percentage point per year, from 36.2% to 10.1%, more than ...
[146]
Evolution and stages of China's economic inequality from 1978 to ...
Jul 20, 2023 · The results show that China's economy achieved rapid growth at an average annual growth rate of 9.4% in 1978–2018. Due to the spatial ...
[147]
Trade and Poverty Reduction: New Evidence of Impacts in ... - WTO
This publication presents eight case studies to reveal how trade can help to reduce poverty in developing countries.
[148]
Fighting Corruption in Public Services : Chronicling Georgia's Reforms
This book chronicles the anticorruption reforms that have transformed public service in Georgia since the Rose Revolution in late 2003. The focus is on the ...
[149]
[PDF] Executive Summary Georgia has made sweeping economic reforms ...
Since 2003, Georgia has significantly improved its ranking in Transparency International's. Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) report. In 2013, Georgia's CPI ...
[150]
[PDF] You Say You Want a (Rose) Revolution? The Effects of Georgia's ...
To combat corruption at the local level, Saakashvili's government shocked the nation by firing the nation's entire police force of over 30,000 officers. There ...
[151]
Estonia PM: Country Saves 2% of GDP by Going Digital
May 3, 2016 · “Estonia saves two percent of GDP by signing things digitally,” he said. “Imagine if it could go global.” Since regaining its independence in ...Missing: post- | Show results with:post-
[152]
[PDF] Estonian e-Government Ecosystem: Foundation, Applications ...
2008 did impact Estonia's economy by decreasing the GDP growth to 14.7% in 2009. Since 2010 economic growth has turned positive again – in 2014 Estonian economy.
[153]
[PDF] Assessing the role of governance indicators on foreign direct ...
Dec 16, 2024 · A study analyzing the impact of political governance, which contains six WGI, on FDI inflow, separately for groups of countries based on income ...
[154]
[PDF] Growth and Reforms in Latin America: A Survey of Facts and ...
An increasingly popular view argues that reforms failed to stimulate growth in Latin America ... institutions that fail to protect entrepreneurs from the threat ...
[155]
Public sector reforms and their impact on the level of corruption
The main objective of this review is to identify what works in curbing corruption in the public sector, by meta‐analyzing the findings of published and ...
[156]
The Failed Law of Latin America - ResearchGate
Aug 9, 2025 · As a result, no amount of simple law reform can undo such a constant and irrepressible image of failure. Viewed this way, Latin America's failed ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[157]
Global Trade Liberalization and the Developing Countries
Many developing countries have substantially increased their exports of manufactures and services relative to traditional commodity exports: manufactures have ...
[158]
[PDF] Exploring the Sectoral Effects for Developing Countries - WP/00/17
Table 5 also shows that regardless of the openness index used, the effect of trade variables is insignificant for low-growth sectors. Thus opening of ...
[159]
How Influential is China in the World Trade Organization?
China experienced explosive trade growth after joining the WTO. Driven in part by tariff reductions, China's trade in goods jumped from $516.4 billion in 2001 ...
[160]
12 The Impact of WTO Accession in: China - IMF eLibrary
On the export side, China receives most-favored-nation (MFN) treatment from most countries; the main constraints on its exports that will be affected by ...Abstract · Background · The Sectoral Impact · The Macroeconomic Impact
[161]
Trade and economic growth in developing countries: Evidence from ...
This study investigates how trade openness affects economic growth in developing countries, with a focus on sub-Saharan Africa (SSA).
[162]
[PDF] Trade and Inclusive Growth, WP/21/74, March 2021
Trade openness is associated with poverty reduction (Figure 7), at least indirectly by raising growth and income, although the impact depends on institutions ...
[163]
The Winners and Losers from Trade
Sep 30, 2019 · Trade may increase job growth on net; however, the gains are not evenly distributed across the labor market. While some workers will find new ...Missing: empirical | Show results with:empirical
[164]
Despite Job Losses, U.S. Benefitted from Surge of Trade with China
Aug 9, 2019 · A new study by Yale SOM's Lorenzo Caliendo suggests that other sectors benefitted, leading to a net increase in US welfare.Missing: evidence global displacement
[165]
[PDF] Evaluating the Criticisms of Fair Trade - Lowimpact.org
Criticisms include that Fair Trade uses misleading evidence, lacks rigor, has inaccurate governance understanding, and fails to engage with evidence on its ...
[166]
Trade openness and economic growth: a cross-country empirical ...
This paper demonstrates that trade liberalization does not have a simple and straightforward relationship with growth using a large number of openness measures.
[167]
[PDF] Theory and Empirical Evidence Linking International Trade to ...
In this article, we review recent theoretical and empirical studies that link in- ternational trade flows and trade policies to aggregate (economy-wide) ...
[168]
Poverty - Our World in Data
The chart shows the number of people in extreme poverty, with projections until 2030 produced by World Bank researchers based on economic growth forecasts.Missing: chronic acute
[169]
Economic poverty trends: Global, regional and national
While at a global level extreme poverty declined between 1990 and 2019, this trend did not occur everywhere. Both the proportion and number of people living in ...
[170]
June 2025 global poverty update from the World Bank: 2021 PPPs ...
Jun 5, 2025 · Based on nowcasted estimates, global extreme poverty is projected to decrease from 10.5 percent in 2022 to 9.9 percent in 2025 (see Figure 1).
[171]
September 2025 global poverty update from the World Bank
Sep 30, 2025 · As of 2024, 839 million people lived in extreme poverty – an upward revision of approximately 22 million people compared to the June 2025 data ...
[172]
Lifting 800 Million People Out of Poverty – New Report Looks at ...
Apr 1, 2022 · Over the past 40 years, China has lifted nearly 800 million people out of poverty, accounting for more than 75 percent of global poverty ...Missing: 2000-2025 | Show results with:2000-2025
[173]
Access to Energy - Our World in Data
At a global level, the share of people with access to electricity has been steadily increasing over the last few decades. In 2000, 2 in 10 people lacked access ...Missing: 2000-2025 | Show results with:2000-2025
[174]
Good governance can speed up post-COVID economic recoveries
Oct 6, 2022 · During the pandemic and after, demands on the role of government have increased, while confidence in government has fallen.
[175]
The COVID-19 pandemic and economic recovery - ScienceDirect.com
Nov 30, 2024 · Governments' response brought to the limelight the role that governance plays in mitigating the economic shrinking effects of a pandemic.
[176]
Poverty, Prosperity, and Planet Report 2024 - World Bank
Today, almost 700 million people (8.5 percent of the global population) live in extreme poverty - on less than $2.15 per day. Progress has stalled amid low ...Overview Figures · Publication · Background PapersMissing: chronic acute
[177]
SDG Goals - No poverty - United Nations Statistics Division
Slow and uneven progress on poverty reduction may leave hundreds of millions in extreme poverty by 2030 · If current trends continue, only one third of countries ...