Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Tithing

Tithing is a religious practice entailing the contribution of one-tenth of agricultural produce, livestock, spoils of war, or income to a deity, priesthood, temple, or charitable causes, with precedents in ancient Near Eastern civilizations such as Mesopotamia and Egypt where it functioned as a form of tribute or tax, and later formalized as a legal requirement under the Mosaic covenant for the Israelite theocracy to sustain the Levites, national festivals, and the indigent.^[1]^[2]^[3] The earliest biblical precedent appears in Genesis 14:20, where Abraham voluntarily presented a tenth of war spoils to Melchizedek, priest-king of Salem, predating the Mosaic Law and reflecting a pre-Israelite custom of sacral offerings in the region.^[2]^[4] Under the Torah, multiple tithes were mandated—primarily the Levitical tithe allocated to non-inheriting priests (Numbers 18:21-24), a festival tithe for communal worship (Deuteronomy 14:22-27), and a triennial poor tithe (Deuteronomy 14:28-29)—effectively aggregating to approximately 20-23% of annual yield in an agrarian economy, serving both religious and social welfare functions within a unified national-religious system.^[5]^[6] In Christianity, tithing lacks explicit endorsement as a binding New Testament ordinance, with the epistles instead advocating sacrificial, proportionate, and cheerful giving motivated by grace rather than legal compulsion (2 Corinthians 9:7), though Jesus referenced the Pharisees' scrupulous tithing while critiquing their neglect of justice and mercy (Matthew 23:23).^[7]^[8] Scholarly analyses, including those from Reformed and evangelical perspectives, contend that the tithe's temple-centric rationale ceased with the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple and the advent of the new covenant, rendering it non-obligatory for believers, though some denominations continue to uphold a 10% guideline as a baseline for stewardship amid debates over prosperity teachings that causally link tithing to material blessings, often unsubstantiated by empirical outcomes or unaltered Pauline principles.^[9]^[7]^[8] Historically, post-biblical tithing evolved into monetary contributions in medieval Europe as a church tax enforced by secular authorities, contributing to Reformation-era grievances over clerical wealth accumulation, yet persisting in various Protestant and Latter-day Saint traditions as a voluntary discipline despite lacking uniform scriptural mandate.^[10]^[11]

Definitions and Terminology

Etymology

The English term "tithe" derives from Old English teogoþa, denoting "a tenth," with the verbal form teogothian or tēothian meaning "to take a tenth."^[12]^[13] This root reflects the numerical basis of the practice, emphasizing a literal one-tenth portion of agricultural produce, livestock, or later income, as formalized in ecclesiastical contexts by the early 12th century.^[12] "Tithing," as the gerund or noun form referring to the act of levying or paying a tithe, emerged in Middle English from Old English tēoþung or tēoðung, combining the tithe concept with suffixes indicating action or collection.^[13] In religious usage, it specifically describes the obligation to contribute this tenth to support clergy, temples, or communal welfare, distinct from secular applications like the Anglo-Saxon administrative "tithing" (a group of ten households for mutual surety), though both share the decimal etymon.^[12] The term's adoption in Christian liturgy parallels its biblical Hebrew antecedents, such as ma'aser (tenth part), but the English nomenclature crystallized during the translation and codification of church laws in medieval England, around the 10th–11th centuries.^[13]

Core Concepts and Variations

Tithing constitutes the practice of allocating one-tenth of one's income, produce, or increase to religious or communal purposes, a principle rooted in ancient agrarian economies where such portions supported temple personnel, festivals, and the needy.^[14]^[6] The term derives from the concept of a "tenth," reflecting a standardized proportion intended to ensure systematic provision rather than arbitrary giving.^[12] In its biblical formulation, tithing served as a divine ordinance under the Mosaic Law, mandating Israelites to set aside portions of harvests and livestock for Levites—who lacked land inheritance—and priests, as detailed in Leviticus 27:30-32 and Numbers 18:21-24.^[15]^[16] Variations in tithing practices emerge primarily from scriptural interpretations and historical adaptations across Abrahamic traditions. In Judaism, the system encompassed multiple distinct tithes: the first tithe (ma'aser rishon) of 10% given annually to Levites; a second tithe (ma'aser sheni) for personal consumption during pilgrimage festivals or redeemed for equivalent value; and a poor tithe (ma'aser ani) replacing the second in the third and sixth years of the sabbatical cycle, totaling approximately 20-23% over seven years when accounting for priestly heave-offerings (terumah).^[17]^[16] These were agricultural obligations tied to the Land of Israel, ceasing with the Temple's destruction in 70 CE, though rabbinic tradition adapted principles into charitable giving (tzedakah).^[17] Christian interpretations diverge significantly, with no explicit New Testament mandate for a 10% tithe on income, as the practice was covenantal to Israel and fulfilled in Christ, shifting emphasis to voluntary, proportional giving from the heart (2 Corinthians 9:7).^[15]^[9] Some Protestant denominations, particularly in evangelical circles, advocate "storehouse tithing" based on Malachi 3:10, applying 10% of modern monetary income directly to church operations, viewing non-compliance as robbing God.^[14] Others, including Reformed theologians, regard it as an Old Testament shadow superseded by grace-based generosity exceeding the tithe, without legal compulsion.^[6] These differences often hinge on whether tithing is seen as an eternal principle of stewardship or a ceremonial law obsolete post-resurrection.^[9]

Biblical Foundations

Old Testament Mandates

In the Torah, tithing (ma'aser in Hebrew, meaning "tenth") was mandated as a form of tribute from agricultural produce and livestock, declared holy to Yahweh and integral to Israel's covenant obligations. Leviticus 27:30-33 specifies that every tithe of seed from the ground, fruit from trees, and livestock—counting every tenth animal passing under the shepherd's rod without selection for quality—belongs to the Lord; redemption required adding one-fifth of the value, underscoring its sacred status.^[18]^[19] This provision applied to Israel's agrarian economy, exempting non-agricultural income explicitly but implying a principle of proportional giving from increase.^[20] Numbers 18:21-32 designates the Levites' inheritance as all tithes in Israel, in exchange for their tabernacle service, excluding them from land allotments; the Levites, in turn, were required to offer a tenth of received tithes—prioritizing the best portions—to Aaronic priests, with the remainder for Levitical sustenance.^[21]^[22] This system ensured cultic personnel's support without taxation, while prohibiting Levites from secular work, and reinforced hierarchical distribution within the priesthood.^[23] Deuteronomy 14:22-29 outlines an annual tithe of field yield, to be consumed in Yahweh's presence at the central sanctuary for rejoicing with family and Levites; if distance precluded transport, it could be converted to silver for equivalent purchases there.^[24] Every third year, this tithe—or an equivalent—was stored locally for Levites, resident aliens, orphans, and widows, prohibiting neglect to invoke divine blessing on Israel's endeavors.^[25] Deuteronomy 26:12-15 mandates a declaration after the third-year tithing, affirming compliance and invoking Yahweh's favor, framing it as obedience to command without withholding.^[26]^[27] These provisions balanced personal/family consumption, priestly support, and social welfare, with rabbinic traditions later interpreting the triennial tithe as additional or substitutive, potentially exceeding 10% overall annually.^[16]^[15]

New Testament Teachings on Giving

The New Testament presents giving primarily as a voluntary act motivated by love, grace, and generosity rather than a legalistic obligation like the Old Testament tithe. Unlike the Mosaic law's requirement of a tenth for temple support and the poor, New Testament instructions emphasize giving according to one's means and heart's decision, without specifying a fixed percentage. This approach aligns with the new covenant's focus on internal transformation over external ritual, as articulated in epistles addressing church practices.^[15]^[28] Jesus' teachings on giving highlight sacrificial generosity and critique hypocritical adherence to tithing without deeper virtues. In Matthew 23:23 and Luke 11:42, Jesus rebukes Pharisees for meticulously tithing herbs while neglecting justice, mercy, and faithfulness, stating they should have practiced the latter without omitting the former; however, this endorsement occurs in a context of affirming the law's righteousness before its fulfillment in his death and resurrection, not as a binding command for his followers under the new covenant.^[29]^[30] The parable of the widow's offering in Mark 12:41-44 and Luke 21:1-4 praises a poor widow who gave two small coins—all she had—over wealthy donors giving from surplus, illustrating that true giving measures by sacrifice and proportion to resources, not nominal amount.^[31] Jesus also instructs the rich young ruler in Mark 10:17-21 to sell possessions and give to the poor to gain treasure in heaven, underscoring detachment from wealth as a discipleship requirement, though this serves as an individual call rather than universal mandate.^[32] Apostolic writings further develop giving as systematic, proportionate, and joyful support for ministry and the needy. Paul in 2 Corinthians 9:6-7 teaches that generous sowing yields generous reaping, urging believers to give as predetermined in their hearts, "not reluctantly or under compulsion," since "God loves a cheerful giver," prioritizing motivation over quota.^[31] In 1 Corinthians 16:1-2, he directs churches to set aside offerings weekly "as he may prosper," ensuring planned, income-based contributions for collection and relief of saints.^[33] Acts depicts early Christians holding possessions in common, selling property to distribute proceeds equally among believers facing need, as in Acts 2:44-45 and 4:32-37, reflecting a communal ethos of radical sharing under the Spirit's impulse, though not without exceptions like Ananias and Sapphira's deception.^[34] Hebrews 7:1-10 references Abraham's tithe to Melchizedek as typological of Christ's superior priesthood, but uses it illustratively without prescribing tithing for the church.^[35] Overall, New Testament giving principles—voluntariness, proportionality to prosperity, and aim at equality among believers (2 Corinthians 8:13-15)—contrast with Old Testament compulsion, fostering liberty in stewardship while warning against greed and promoting eternal perspective on resources (Matthew 6:19-21). No explicit command for tithing appears in post-resurrection directives, with emphasis instead on exceeding legal minimums through grace-enabled liberality.^[36]^[7]

Historical Development

Ancient Near Eastern and Pre-Biblical Origins

Practices akin to tithing, involving the payment of a tenth of agricultural produce, livestock, or other goods to deities, temples, or rulers, are attested in ancient Near Eastern civilizations predating the composition of biblical texts. These offerings served both sacral and administrative functions, often blending religious devotion with royal taxation to support temple economies and elite intermediaries between humans and gods. Evidence derives primarily from cuneiform administrative records, which document systematic collections rather than sporadic voluntary gifts.^[37]^[38] In Mesopotamian societies, including Sumerian city-states, the earliest references to such tenth-payments appear in texts from the Third Dynasty of Ur around 2000 BCE, where approximately 90% of surviving documents on the topic originate from this period. The Akkadian term ešrētu denoted a one-tenth levy, payable in kind to local rulers or temples, reflecting a standardized tax on income or harvest yields that predates Israelite mandates by centuries. Babylonian, Assyrian, and earlier Sumerian records similarly indicate that free citizens contributed a tenth of their produce or earnings to divine institutions, with temples maintaining warehouses for storage and redistribution.^[39]^[40]^[41] Ugaritic texts from the 14th–13th centuries BCE provide detailed evidence of grain tithes paid by village communities to royal authorities, functioning as a compulsory obligation rather than purely religious vow. These records, including those specifying tithes to both the king and gods, parallel later biblical formulations but emphasize fiscal support for the palace and cultic personnel over communal feasting.^[42]^[43]^[44] Among the Hittites, tithes manifested as tribute exacted from vassal states to suzerain kings, underscoring a political dimension where the tenth served to affirm hierarchical allegiance and fund imperial temples. Egyptian sources corroborate similar levies on harvests to honor gods and pharaohs, integrating the practice into broader systems of divine kingship and temple sustenance across the region.^[45]^[1]

Post-Biblical Evolution in Judaism and Early Christianity

In rabbinic Judaism, following the compilation of the Mishnah around 200 CE, tithing laws for agricultural produce were systematically codified to ensure compliance with biblical mandates within the Land of Israel, including the separation of terumah (a portion for priests, typically 1/40 to 1/60 of the yield) and various ma'aserot such as ma'aser rishon (first tithe for Levites) and ma'aser sheni (second tithe consumed in Jerusalem or redeemed for monetary value).^[17] ^[46] Tractates like Terumot and Ma'asrot in the Mishnah prescribed precise procedures, such as liberal givers allocating 1/30 for terumah per the School of Shammai, while prohibiting consumption of untithed produce (tevel).^[17] After the Second Temple's destruction in 70 CE, these practices adapted amid ritual impurity concerns: terumah separation largely ceased due to priests' disputed purity, ma'aser sheni redemption involved dedicating a coin that was then discarded rather than spent in Jerusalem, and ma'aser rishon could be consumed by non-Levites if lineage verification failed.^[46] The Jerusalem Talmud (c. 400 CE) and Babylonian Talmud (c. 500 CE) further debated tithing's applicability, affirming its biblical status only under full national settlement in Israel but extending rabbinic oversight to supervised produce in Israel; outside Israel, agricultural tithing did not apply to local goods.^[46] A related custom, ma'aser kesafim—allocating 10% of monetary profits, gifts, or inheritances to charity—emerged as a rabbinic enactment rather than biblical law, traced to Talmudic references like Ta'anit 9a and patriarchal precedents, serving as a voluntary extension for urbanized or diaspora Jews.^[46] ^[47] In early Christianity, tithing did not carry mandatory force during the apostolic era (c. 30–100 CE), where communal sharing of resources prevailed without fixed percentages, as described in Acts 4:32–35, emphasizing voluntary distribution to meet needs among believers.^[48] Church fathers like Irenaeus (c. 130–202 CE) contrasted Jewish tithing as a constrained legal obligation with Christian liberty to freely share all possessions with the poor, urging believers to exceed the tithe through generous almsgiving rather than adhere to it minimally.^[49] Similarly, Clement of Alexandria (c. 150–215 CE) viewed Old Testament tithes as instructive for piety and detachment from greed but framed Christian giving as unbound by such quotas, prioritizing holistic stewardship.^[49] By the third and fourth centuries, figures like Tertullian (c. 155–240 CE) and Origen (c. 185–254 CE) stressed almsgiving as an antidote to avarice and a path to spiritual purity, without prescribing tithing as a rule; Tertullian advocated despising hoarded wealth in favor of patient endurance through charity, while Origen linked alms to atonement without referencing tithes.^[50] John Chrysostom (c. 349–407 CE) later exhorted exceeding Jewish tithes under the New Covenant, citing risks of divine disfavor for lesser giving amid orphans' and widows' needs.^[49] Tithing's institutionalization accelerated in the sixth century, with the Synod of Mâcon (585 CE) incorporating it into canon law as an expected church support mechanism, marking a shift from purely voluntary practices to formalized obligations influenced by Old Testament parallelism.^[48]

Medieval and Reformation Periods

In the medieval Catholic Church, tithing was established as a compulsory ecclesiastical obligation by the 6th century, with the Council of Tours in 567 issuing the first recorded legislation mandating it as a divine precept inherited from Old Testament law to support clergy and church needs.^[51] The Third Council of Mâcon in 585 reinforced this requirement across Frankish territories, viewing non-payment as a grave sin equivalent to sacrilege.^[52] By the late 8th century, civil enforcement supplemented canon law through Charlemagne's capitularies, which imposed secular penalties for evasion, integrating tithing into feudal obligations where lords collected and remitted portions to ecclesiastical recipients.^[51] Tithes typically comprised 10% of annual produce or earnings, categorized as predial (great tithes from immovables like grain, hay, and wood), mixed (small tithes from land-nurtured goods such as wool, milk, and foals), and personal (from personal labor or trades like fishing and milling).^[51] In England, pre-Norman laws under kings like Æthelstan and Edgar recognized tithes as customary, with the Statute of Westminster in 1285 affirming their legal status and directing payments primarily to parish rectors, who allocated one-fourth to church repairs, one-fourth to the poor, and the rest for personal maintenance.^[51] Enforcement involved both spiritual sanctions, such as excommunication, and temporal measures like distraint of goods, though evasion persisted due to economic hardships and disputes over valuation, fostering resentment among peasants who bore the brunt amid clerical wealth accumulation.^[51] The Protestant Reformation marked a theological pivot away from tithing as mandatory divine law, with Martin Luther dismissing it in works like "How Christians Should Regard Moses" (1525) as a non-binding Mosaic ordinance superseded by New Testament principles of voluntary generosity. John Calvin, while citing Malachi 3 to affirm tithing's exemplary role in acknowledging God's sovereignty over possessions, subordinated it to proportionate, cheerful giving under grace rather than coercion, as outlined in his commentaries and Geneva practices where church support derived from state subsidies and free contributions.^[53] ^[54] Practically, however, tithes endured as fiscal mechanisms in many Protestant regions; in Lutheran Germany, they transitioned into state-enforced church taxes, while in Anglican England, they remained legally obligatory post-1534 break with Rome, funding parochial clergy until commuted to rent-charges in 1836 amid agrarian reforms.^[55] This retention reflected pragmatic needs for ecclesiastical maintenance in established churches, diverging from reformers' ideals of non-compulsory stewardship and highlighting tensions between doctrinal purity and institutional continuity.^[56]

Modern Institutionalization (19th-21st Centuries)

In the 19th century, the institutionalization of tithing in Christianity shifted markedly due to the disestablishment of state-supported churches and the rise of voluntary congregational funding. In England, the Tithe Commutation Act of 1836 replaced traditional in-kind tithes with fixed monetary rentcharges based on average grain prices, facilitating more predictable revenue for the Church of England while reducing agrarian conflicts, though compulsory elements persisted until the Tithe Act of 1925 fully abolished them.^[57] In the United States, following the early 19th-century separation of church and state, Protestant denominations increasingly promoted tithing as a biblical standard for self-sustaining ministries, embedding collections for "tithes and offerings" into regular worship services amid revivalist movements.^[58] Restorationist groups formalized tithing as a doctrinal requirement during this period. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints received a revelation on July 8, 1838, defining tithing as an initial surplus offering of property followed by one-tenth of annual "interest" (interpreted as income or increase), which became central to church finances and eligibility for temple ordinances by the late 19th century.^[59] Similarly, Seventh-day Adventists adopted "systematic benevolence" in 1859, evolving by the 1870s into a tithing system of one-tenth of income to support ministers, formalized as a core practice though not initially a fellowship test until the 20th century.^[60] In the 20th and 21st centuries, evangelical and Pentecostal traditions amplified tithing's institutional role through teaching and media, viewing it as a faith principle yielding divine blessings, with churches allocating funds for operations, missions, and clergy salaries.^[61] In Judaism, tithing retained an agricultural focus without broad institutional revival outside Israel; post-1948, Israeli law under the Chief Rabbinate requires Jewish farmers to separate terumah (priestly gifts) and ma'aser (tithes) from produce like grains and fruits grown in designated areas, sold or discarded ritually to comply with halakha, though exemptions apply to non-observant or imported goods.^[46] This practice supports symbolic rabbinic allocations rather than literal Levitical needs, contrasting with Christianity's monetary adaptation.^[17]

Tithing in Judaism

Scriptural and Rabbinic Basis

In the Torah, tithing, known as ma'aser, is mandated primarily for agricultural produce grown in the Land of Israel, serving to support the Levites, foster communal rejoicing in Jerusalem, and aid the needy.^[46]^[17] The commandments appear in Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy, with the first explicit allocation to the Levites following the Korach rebellion, as stated in Numbers 18:21: "To the children of Levi, behold I have given all the tithes in Israel as an inheritance for the work which they perform, the work of the Tent of Meeting."^[46] These tithes apply biblically to grain, wine, and oil, though rabbinic extension covers other fruits and vegetables.^[46] The system begins with terumah, a priestly portion separated first from the crop, followed by the tithes proper. Leviticus 27:30-33 declares, "A tithe of everything from the land, whether of the seed of the land or of the fruit of the trees, is the Lord's; it is holy to the Lord," establishing the sanctity of the tithe from land produce and livestock.^[17] After terumah, Ma'aser Rishon (first tithe) requires one-tenth of the remaining produce to be given to the Levites, who lack territorial inheritance and perform Temple service; the Levites then allocate one-tenth of this (terumat ma'aser) to the priests.^[46]^[17] Numbers 18:24 specifies this as their inheritance in lieu of land.^[46] Ma'aser Sheni (second tithe), taken from the residue after Ma'aser Rishon, comprises another tenth in the first, second, fourth, and fifth years of the sabbatical cycle, to be consumed by the owner and family in Jerusalem for ritual rejoicing, promoting spiritual connection to the Temple.^[46]^[17] Deuteronomy 14:22-27 commands: "You shall tithe all the yield of your seed... and you shall eat before the Lord your God... that you may learn to fear the Lord your God always."^[46] If transport is impractical, it may be redeemed for coinage, adding 20% value, to purchase food and drink in the holy city.^[46] In the third and sixth years, Ma'aser Ani (poor tithe) replaces Ma'aser Sheni, directing the tenth to Levites, strangers, orphans, and widows within local settlements to ensure their sustenance.^[46]^[17] Deuteronomy 14:28-29 instructs: "At the end of every three years... you shall bring forth all the tithe of your yield... and the Levite... and the stranger, the fatherless, and the widow... shall come and eat and be satisfied."^[46] No tithes apply in the sabbatical seventh year, when fields lie fallow and produce is ownerless.^[46] Rabbinic literature, particularly the Mishnah tractates Ma'aserot and Ma'aser Sheni, codifies these biblical laws, specifying liable produce (e.g., from the stage of edibility), separation procedures, and prohibitions against consuming tevel (untithed items).^[62]^[63] Ma'aserot details tithing triggers, such as for grains by Rosh Hashanah and fruits by Tu B'Shvat, while Ma'aser Sheni governs redemption and consumption rules, including biur ma'asrot—ceremonial disposal of undistributed tithes in the fourth and seventh years post-Passover.^[46]^[62] The Talmud further interprets ambiguities, such as extending obligations rabbinically beyond biblical grains, wine, and oil, but ties full applicability to Jewish-majority settlement in Israel.^[46] These enactments emphasize precise ritual purity and communal equity, rendering untithed produce biblically forbidden for benefit.^[17]

Historical and Contemporary Practices

In the rabbinic period following the Second Temple's destruction in 70 CE, tithing practices were codified in the Mishnah, including tractates such as Terumot and Ma'aserot, which detailed the separation of terumah for priests and ma'aser rishon for Levites from agricultural produce like grain, wine, oil, fruits, and vegetables grown in the Land of Israel.^[17] ^[64] During the Second Temple era, tithes were often centralized in Jerusalem under figures like Ezra and Nehemiah, with evidence of enforcement extending to diaspora communities in places like Egypt and Babylon, where proceeds were sometimes sent to the Temple.^[64] Post-Temple, the obligation to separate ma'aser sheni (second tithe, for consumption in Jerusalem in years 1, 2, 4, and 5 of the sabbatical cycle) was adapted by redeeming it with a coin, which was then discarded rather than consumed, while ma'aser rishon separation persisted but distribution to Levites became debated due to concerns over ritual purity and verifiable Levite lineage.^[46] ^[17] Medieval rabbinic authorities further evolved these practices, with Maimonides (1138–1204 CE) in his Mishneh Torah prescribing ma'aser kesafim—the tithing of monetary income—as a standard mitzvah of donating 10% of earnings, viewing 20% as ideal for exceptional charity, though its status ranged from rabbinic enactment to customary minhag rather than strict biblical law.^[46] This monetary extension addressed non-agricultural economies in the diaspora, where produce tithing held no halakhic force, transforming biblical agricultural mandates into broader charitable imperatives.^[17] In contemporary Orthodox Judaism within Israel, tithing remains obligatory for produce grown by Jews in Eretz Yisrael during non-sabbatical (shemitta) years, rendering untithed items (tevel) forbidden for consumption until separated; ma'aser rishon is allocated to verified Levites, while other tithes support scholars or the poor, with thousands of recognized Kohanim and Levites facilitating distribution despite practical challenges.^[64] ^[65] Enforcement varies by community observance, but rabbinic consensus upholds the biblical-rabbinic framework for local agriculture, excluding imported or non-Jewish-grown produce.^[64] Outside Israel, contemporary practices emphasize ma'aser kesafim as a voluntary yet highly encouraged custom, where observant Jews, particularly in Orthodox circles, donate approximately 10% of net income to tzedakah, prioritizing the poor, yeshivot, or Torah study, though not extending to mandatory produce tithing absent the Land's sanctity.^[46] ^[65] This aligns with Talmudic views that full biblical tithing requires national settlement in Israel, rendering diaspora observance rabbinic or exemplary rather than compulsory, with some authorities like Rabbi Yair Hayyim Bacharach (1638–1702) reinforcing it as a wealth-preserving mitzvah.^[46]

Tithing in Christianity

Patristic and Denominational Interpretations

In the patristic era, interpretations of tithing reflected a transition from Old Testament mandates to New Testament principles of voluntary generosity, with evidence indicating mixed endorsement rather than uniform obligation. Clement of Alexandria (c. 150–215 AD) praised tithes of fruits and flocks as instilling piety toward God and curbing covetousness.^[49] Irenaeus of Lyons (c. 130–202 AD), however, argued that Christ replaced the law's tithe requirement with a call to share all possessions with the poor, emphasizing communal support over fixed percentages.^[66] By the late fourth century, figures such as Ambrose of Milan, Jerome, and Augustine advocated tithing as a normative practice for clergy support and almsgiving, with no recorded patristic opposition during 366–400 AD, though not all fathers addressed or personally practiced it.^[67] This period lacked enforced tithing systems, prioritizing apostolic teachings on cheerful, proportional giving as in 2 Corinthians 9:7.^[68] Catholic teaching holds that tithing, rooted in Old Testament passages like Leviticus 27:32, imposes no strict 10% obligation under the New Covenant, instead requiring support for the Church according to one's means as a precept of the faith.^[69] The Catechism underscores stewardship through almsgiving and material aid to ecclesiastical works, without mandating a percentage, viewing excessive fixation on 10% as potentially legalistic.^[70] Historically, Catholic clergy received tithes in feudal Europe until secularization, but modern practice relies on voluntary contributions rather than enforced collection.^[51] Eastern Orthodox interpretations similarly reject tithing as a binding Mosaic law post-Christ, framing it instead as a voluntary act of stewardship and conscience, akin to fasting or prayer, to sustain parishes without legal compulsion.^[71] The Orthodox Church in America notes its Old Testament origins but stresses New Testament freedom in giving, with some contemporary advocates promoting 10% as a spiritual discipline for healing and blessing, though not universally required.^[72] OrthodoxWiki highlights a recent revival of tithing rhetoric in some parishes as an expression of divine ownership, yet ancient tradition prioritizes proportional offerings over fixed tithes.^[73] Among Protestant denominations, views diverge sharply, with Reformation leaders largely deeming Old Testament tithing non-binding under grace, though many modern groups encourage it as a guideline. Martin Luther rejected tithing as an eternal command, treating it as a superseded civil tax and urging Christians to give freely beyond any percentage for gospel support. John Calvin referenced Malachi 3 to affirm tithing's role in reminding believers of God's ownership but did not enforce it as obligatory, favoring voluntary contributions calibrated to need.^[53] Denominations like Seventh-day Adventists and Methodists uphold tithing as a core doctrine for church funding, with surveys showing strong belief in 10% giving among evangelicals, though actual compliance varies widely.^[74] Reformed and Baptist traditions often prioritize New Testament passages like 2 Corinthians 8–9, viewing tithing as a helpful minimum but not a covenantal requirement, critiquing mandatory systems as akin to Old Testament legalism.^[15]

Prosperity Gospel and Grace-Based Alternatives

The prosperity gospel, emerging prominently in the United States during the 1950s Healing Revivals led by figures like Oral Roberts, posits that tithing and sacrificial giving function as "seed faith" investments that activate divine promises of material wealth, physical health, and success.^[75] Proponents such as Kenneth Copeland, Creflo Dollar, and Joel Osteen teach that Malachi 3:10 guarantees multiplied returns on tithes, framing poverty as a curse breakable through faithful financial obedience rather than a potential aspect of Christian suffering.^[76] This doctrine, influenced by earlier New Thought metaphysics and post-World War II Pentecostalism, emphasizes positive confession and giving as mechanisms to compel God's blessings, with tithing often portrayed as the minimum entry to prosperity.^[77] Evangelical critics, including those from The Gospel Coalition and Ligonier Ministries, argue that the prosperity gospel distorts biblical atonement by extending Christ's work to eradicate material poverty as a "sin," thereby promoting a transactional view of God that undermines grace and ignores New Testament examples of apostolic hardship, such as Paul's lack in 2 Corinthians 11:27.^[78] They contend it fosters exploitation, as evidenced by scandals involving high-profile preachers soliciting funds under promises of supernatural returns, which disproportionately burdens lower-income adherents while enriching leaders.^[79] Even some former proponents, like Creflo Dollar in 2022, have recanted strict tithing mandates, admitting past teachings overemphasized Old Testament law at the expense of New Testament freedom.^[80] In contrast, grace-based alternatives within evangelical Christianity reject mandatory tithing as an Old Covenant obligation fulfilled in Christ, advocating instead for voluntary, cheerful giving guided by 2 Corinthians 9:6-7, where generosity flows from gratitude rather than compulsion. Theologians like John Piper describe the tithe as a historical "gateway" to cultivate liberality but not a binding rule under the new covenant, emphasizing proportional, sacrificial contributions that exceed 10% for many believers as an outflow of heart transformation by the Holy Spirit.^[81] This approach, echoed in Reformed and Baptist traditions, prioritizes stewardship for gospel advance over personal enrichment, warning against legalism while encouraging empirical patterns of increased giving among grace-oriented congregations, as observed in studies of sacrificial donors.^[82] Critics of prosperity teachings, such as Russell Moore, highlight how grace-focused giving avoids the manipulation inherent in "health and wealth" promises, fostering accountability through transparent church governance rather than charismatic appeals.^[78]

Analogues in Other Religions

Islamic Zakat

Zakat constitutes one of the five pillars of Islam, mandating eligible Muslims to donate a specified portion of their accumulated wealth annually as an act of purification and social welfare.^[83] Unlike tithing's focus on agricultural produce or income at a 10% rate, zakat applies primarily to idle wealth exceeding a minimum threshold known as nisab, calculated at 2.5% to promote circulation of resources and prevent hoarding.^[84] This obligation derives from Quranic injunctions, such as Surah Al-Baqarah 2:43 linking zakat to prayer, and was formalized during the Prophet Muhammad's time in Medina around 622 CE, evolving from voluntary charity in Mecca to a structured levy by 631 CE with detailed rules.^[85] The nisab threshold, set by prophetic tradition, equates to the value of 85 grams of gold or 595 grams of silver, adjusted for current market prices; wealth below this incurs no zakat, while qualifying assets include cash savings held over one lunar year (hawl), gold and silver holdings, business inventory, and certain investments, but exempts personal residences, vehicles, and debt obligations.^[86] Calculation involves deducting liabilities from total eligible assets, then applying the 2.5% rate—for instance, on $10,000 in savings above nisab, zakat amounts to $250—typically paid during Ramadan or upon reaching the hawl to ensure timely redistribution.^[87] Scholarly consensus among major schools of jurisprudence (Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanbali) affirms this rate from hadith narrations, such as the Prophet's directive to pay one-fortieth of wealth, emphasizing individual self-assessment over centralized collection in modern contexts.^[88] Quran 9:60 enumerates eight categories of recipients: the poor (fuqara), needy (masakin), zakat administrators, new converts, those in bondage, debtors, wayfarers, and those striving in Allah's cause, restricting distribution to these to target systemic poverty rather than general benevolence.^[89] Historically, under early caliphs like Abu Bakr (r. 632–634 CE), zakat enforcement involved state collectors dispatching to provinces, funding public welfare and military exemptions for payers, though contemporary practice largely relies on personal or institutional channels amid varying national implementations, such as Saudi Arabia's Zakat and Tax Authority mandating 2.5% on Saudis' wealth since 1980s regulations.^[90] This framework aims at economic equity, with studies noting zakat's potential to reduce inequality by redistributing stagnant wealth, distinct from tithing's ecclesiastical tithe which historically supported clergy and temples.^[91] Non-payment constitutes a major sin, underscoring zakat's spiritual imperative alongside its material role in fostering communal solidarity.^[92]

Practices in Other Faiths

In Sikhism, dasvandh—literally meaning "tenth part"—requires adherents to donate one-tenth of their income, either financially or through service (seva), to support religious institutions, community welfare, and the Guru's mission, a practice instituted by Guru Nanak in the 16th century and codified in Sikh codes of conduct.^[93] ^[94] This systematic giving parallels tithing by allocating resources for gurdwara maintenance, langar (communal kitchens), and charitable causes, with contemporary Sikhs often directing contributions to organizations like the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, which managed over 100 million rupees in donations for welfare programs in Punjab as of 2023.^[95] Hindu traditions historically featured tithing-like contributions of one-tenth of income to temples or priests, widespread in ancient India for sustaining religious sites and rituals, though modern practice emphasizes voluntary dāna (charitable giving) without a fixed obligation.^[96] In texts like the Manusmriti (circa 200 BCE–200 CE), such gifts supported Brahmanical institutions, but empirical surveys indicate that only about 20-30% of contemporary Hindus report regular temple donations equivalent to 5-10% of income, often tied to festivals rather than annual mandates.^[97] Buddhist dāna functions as an ethical practice of generosity to cultivate detachment from materialism, involving offerings to monks, stupas, or the needy without a prescribed percentage or institutional tithe requirement.^[98] Originating in the Buddha's teachings around the 5th century BCE, it prioritizes intent over quantity, as evidenced in Pāli Canon texts like the Dāna Sutta, where giving merits spiritual progress; modern Theravāda communities in Southeast Asia sustain monasteries through voluntary alms rounds, with studies showing average household contributions equating to 2-5% of income in rural Thailand.^[99] Other traditions, such as Zoroastrianism and Jainism, lack formalized tithing equivalents, relying instead on discretionary alms or temple fees; for instance, Zoroastrian priests receive variable offerings during rituals like jashan ceremonies, while Jains stress dāna for karmic purification without quantified mandates.^[100] The Bahá'í Faith mandates Huqúqu'lláh, a 19% levy on net worth exceeding a basic threshold after savings, payable to the Universal House of Justice for global administrative and charitable purposes, implemented progressively since its revelation in 1871.^[101]

Controversies and Debates

Obligation Under the New Covenant

The New Testament contains no explicit command for Christians to tithe ten percent of their income, distinguishing Christian giving from the mandatory tithes prescribed under the Mosaic Law for ancient Israel.^[28]^[15] Instead, apostolic instructions emphasize voluntary, proportionate, and joyful contributions to support ministry and the needy, as seen in passages like 1 Corinthians 16:1-2, which calls for setting aside a sum "in keeping with income" on the first day of the week, and 2 Corinthians 8-9, which urges generosity without compulsion.^[28]^[102] This shift aligns with the New Covenant's fulfillment of the old ceremonial and civil laws, including those sustaining the Levitical priesthood, which ceased with the temple's destruction in 70 AD and Christ's establishment of a new priesthood.^[28]^[36] Jesus references tithing in critiques of the Pharisees, such as Matthew 23:23 and Luke 11:42, where he affirms giving a tenth of herbs but rebukes neglecting "the more important matters of the law—justice, mercy and faithfulness."^[103] These statements, made before the cross, address Jewish audiences still under the old covenant and do not impose tithing as a perpetual mandate for his followers.^[15] Similarly, Hebrews 7 recounts Abraham's tithe to Melchizedek as a prefiguration of Christ's superior eternal priesthood, implying that even Levi "paid tithes" through Abraham, but this typology underscores the obsolescence of Levitical tithes rather than requiring a fixed percentage under the new order.^[104]^[28] Proponents of ongoing tithing obligation often cite these passages or pre-Mosaic examples like Abraham's voluntary gift (Genesis 14:20), arguing for a timeless principle of firstfruits giving amplified under grace.^[105] However, such interpretations lack direct New Testament endorsement and risk conflating illustrative narratives with prescriptive rules, as the epistles prioritize "cheerful" giving determined "not reluctantly or under compulsion" (2 Corinthians 9:7), with blessings tied to sacrificial generosity rather than a legal minimum.^[15]^[106] Theological consensus among Reformed and evangelical scholars holds that while tithing may serve as a practical benchmark for some, it imposes no binding obligation, freeing believers to give according to means and conviction while guarding against legalism.^[28]^[33] This view counters claims in certain charismatic circles that equate non-tithing with robbery (citing Malachi 3:8-10 out of context), which impose old covenant curses on new covenant grace.^[15]

Exploitation and Accountability Issues

Instances of exploitation in tithing practices often involve religious leaders diverting funds intended for communal or ministerial purposes toward personal enrichment or unfulfilled promises. In the United States, churches classified under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code are exempt from filing Form 990 annual information returns, which other nonprofits must submit to disclose finances publicly, thereby limiting external oversight and transparency.^[107]^[108] This exemption, intended to protect religious autonomy, has been criticized for enabling potential misuse without mandatory audits or detailed reporting to congregants or regulators.^[109] A prominent recent example is the class-action lawsuit filed against Gateway Church in Southlake, Texas, on October 4, 2024, by four congregants alleging financial fraud and misappropriation of millions in tithes. The suit claims the megachurch promised to allocate 15% of tithes to overseas ministry work but failed to do so, instead using funds for other purposes amid leadership scandals, including sexual abuse allegations against founder Robert Morris.^[110]^[111] Following these revelations, the church reported a 35-40% decline in tithing by November 2024, leading to staff layoffs and operational challenges.^[112]^[113] In contexts emphasizing prosperity theology, tithing is frequently promoted as a mechanism to secure divine financial blessings, which critics contend pressures lower-income adherents into disproportionate giving while leaders amass wealth. For instance, some prosperity gospel proponents have faced scrutiny for lifestyles funded by congregational donations, though convictions for fraud remain infrequent due to the lack of regulatory mandates.^[114] Voluntary standards from organizations like the Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability (ECFA) encourage audited financials and donor transparency, but adherence is not universal among evangelical churches, exacerbating accountability gaps. Such issues have prompted calls for internal reforms, including congregational access to budgets and independent audits, to rebuild trust without governmental overreach.^[115]

Empirical Studies on Personal and Communal Effects

Empirical research on the personal effects of tithing reveals primarily correlational patterns rather than causal mechanisms for financial prosperity. A survey of 4,413 self-identified tithers conducted between 2009 and 2013 found that 80% carried no unpaid credit card balances, 74% had no car payments, and 28% were entirely debt-free, suggesting lower debt levels compared to broader population averages for non-tithers.^[61] However, this data derives from a non-random constituency sample of church-affiliated respondents, limiting inferences about causation; disciplined financial habits may predispose individuals to both tithing and debt avoidance rather than tithing directly improving finances. Claims of supernatural financial returns, as promoted in some prosperity teachings, lack robust empirical backing, with studies on religious giving showing no consistent evidence of material enrichment beyond baseline economic behaviors.^[116] On psychological dimensions, tithing as a form of structured generosity aligns with broader findings that prosocial giving enhances well-being. Neuroimaging research indicates that acts of generosity activate reward centers in the brain, correlating with increased subjective happiness independent of recipient outcomes.^[117] Religious participation, which often includes tithing, is associated with higher life satisfaction and lower depressive symptoms, potentially mediated by community ties and purpose derived from giving.^[118] Yet, specific to tithing, evidence remains indirect; while generous donors report greater fulfillment, the mandatory 10% threshold may impose stress on lower-income adherents without proportionally amplifying these benefits, as psychological gains from giving plateau beyond modest amounts.^[119] Communal effects of tithing center on resource allocation to church operations and welfare programs, though outcomes vary by institutional efficiency. Tithers collectively contribute over $50 billion annually to U.S. churches, funding local aid, education, and outreach that can bolster community cohesion.^[61] A 2005 analysis of congregational giving suggested that tithing practices encourage broader philanthropy, potentially extending benefits to non-church entities.^[120] However, a 2024 county-level study using Mormon temple dedications as a proxy for heightened tithing adherence (required for temple access) found no significant reduction in poverty rates from 2010 to 2018, employing difference-in-differences models controlling for demographics and economics across 829 U.S. counties.^[116] This null result implies that centralized tithing distribution may prioritize institutional priorities over targeted poverty alleviation, highlighting accountability challenges in opaque religious finances.^[121]

Broader Societal Contributions and Critiques

In the United States, an estimated 10 million tithers donate over $50 billion annually to religious and charitable causes, comprising 97% church general offerings, 95% missions support, and 87% benevolence programs that aid vulnerable populations such as the unemployed (31% of tithers contribute) and homeless (29%).^[61] This influx sustains religious institutions' delivery of social services, including education, healthcare, and poverty alleviation, often provided irrespective of recipients' faith, and accounts for 32.8% of total charitable giving in 2006 ($96.8 billion) or 72% in 2005 per alternative estimates.^[122] Such funding bolsters community infrastructure and missionary efforts (71% tither support), fostering social cohesion and direct welfare in locales where secular alternatives may be limited. Critiques highlight tithing's regressive structure, as the uniform 10% rate imposes a heavier relative burden on lower-income households—tithers themselves averaging lower incomes than non-tithers—compared to progressive models that scale with ability to pay.^[123]^[124] County-level analyses of tithing-intensive Mormon communities, using temple dedications as a proxy for concentrated donations from 2010 to 2018, reveal no statistically significant poverty reductions, with difference-in-differences models showing null or insignificant effects after controlling for demographics and economics, thus questioning claims of macroeconomic uplift.^[116] Broader debates note potential inefficiencies, such as opaque allocation in centralized systems or crowding out by government programs, though religious providers' effectiveness in service delivery remains contested against secular benchmarks.^[122] Despite tithers' personal financial advantages like reduced debt (80% credit-card free), these do not translate to verifiable communal prosperity gains beyond baseline philanthropy.^[61]

References

[1]
Tithing System: Types, History and Purpose - Vanco Payments
Feb 19, 2024 · Tithing is a portion of income, often one-tenth, given to a religious institution to support its material needs, and is a freewill offering.
[2]
Tithe Definition: Breaking Down the Origins of Giving 10%
Aug 28, 2025 · Tithing made it's first appearance in the Bible when Abraham gave one-tenth of the spoils of war to Melchizedek, the priest-king of Salem ( ...Origin of Tithing · Old Testament vs. New... · Why Tithe Today? · How to Tithe
[3]
Biblical Teaching About the Tithe - Westminster Media
Mar 5, 2025 · Tithes were an ancient tradition in the Bible (and more broadly in the ancient Near East). In the Book of Genesis, Abraham gave to the priest- ...Missing: etymology | Show results with:etymology
[4]
The Origin of Tithing - Church of God Evening Light
May 13, 2015 · The true origin of tithing is unknown, but early examples include Abraham and Jacob. It was later part of the law for Israelites in Canaan.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[5]
Tithe Definition, Types & Purpose - Lesson - Study.com
Ancient Israel was an agrarian society, so tithing in the bible was based on agricultural harvest (Deuteronomy 14:22). A tithe is not the same as an offering.What is Tithe? · Tithes Purpose · Importance of Paying Tithes · Types of Tithes
[6]
What Does the Bible Say about Christian Tithing? by R.C. Sproul
The Bible says tithing is returning one-tenth of one's increase to the Lord, supporting the work of God, and not giving it to the local church only.
[7]
Tithing: Is it New Testament? (Revisited) - Christian Research Institute
Jun 10, 2009 · The doctrine that tithing is New Testament effectively undermines much of what the New Testament actually has to say about giving.
[8]
Is tithing a justifiable development in the Christian church?
May 11, 2021 · This article argues that Christians are not obligated to pay tithes because tithing, as part of the temple worship system whose existence ended with Christ's ...
[9]
Why Tithing is Biblical but it's Not Christian - Relearn.org
Jun 17, 2019 · While tithing is biblical it is not Christian. This was strictly a practice for the nation of Israel under the Old Covenant which has been fulfilled by Jesus ...
[10]
When Did the Church Start Tithing Money Instead of Objects? by
The financial tithe, commanded in Malachi 3, was viewed by early New Testament leaders as a commandment of God, a mark of spiritual maturity, and God's ...
[11]
Chapter 9: The Law of Tithing
The law of tithing is one-tenth of all interest (profit, compensation, increase), which is voluntary but an obligation if one loves the Lord.Teachings Of Howard W... · The Law Of Tithing Existed... · Paying Tithing Brings Great...<|separator|>
[12]
Tithe - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
Tithe, from Old English teogoþa meaning "a tenth," originated c.1200 as a tenth part of goods paid to clergy, also a verb meaning to give or impose this ...
[13]
TITHING Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster
Etymology. Middle English, from Old English tēothung, from teogothian, tēothian to tithe, take one tenth ; First Known Use. before the 12th century, in the ...
[14]
What is the Defintion and Meaning of Tithe in the Bible?
Sep 13, 2024 · The term "tithe" means "tenth." Tithing refers to the practice of giving 10% of one's income or resources to the church or religious community.
[15]
What does the Bible say about Christian tithing? - Got Questions
Jun 30, 2025 · The actual “tithe” is an Old Testament command to Israel, but giving to support the work of ministry, as well as giving to those in need, is ...What is the difference between... · Does the teaching on tithing in... · Cheerful giver
[16]
The Three Tithes of the Old Testament - Ministry Magazine
The Three Tithes of the Old Testament · 1. The Levitical, or sacred tithe (Num. 18: 21, 24). · 2. The tithe of the feasts (Deut. 14:22-27). · 3. The tithe for the ...
[17]
Tithing - My Jewish Learning
The Hebrew Bible mandates a complicated system of tithes, known as terumah and ma'aser, that are set aside for the priests, the Levites and the poor.
[18]
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Leviticus+27%3A30-33&version=ESV
[19]
Leviticus 27:30 Thus any tithe from the land, whether from the seed ...
Leviticus 27:30 teaches that a literal tenth of every agricultural increase in Israel already belonged to God, whether grain or fruit. By commanding this tithe ...<|separator|>
[20]
Q&A: The Old Testament Tithe? - Third Millennium Ministries
There were three tithes under the Old Covenant: (1) the Levite, (2) Festival, and (3) Poor. These were mandated by the Law. A brief history will help us ...
[21]
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Numbers+18%3A21-32&version=ESV
[22]
Numbers 18:21 Behold, I have given to the Levites all the tithes in ...
Behold, I have given to the Levites all the tithes in Israel as an inheritance in return for the work they do, the service of the Tent of Meeting.
[23]
Enduring Word Bible Commentary Numbers Chapter 18
A tenth of the tithe: The Levites themselves were not excused from tithing. They were also to give a tenth of the tithe, and the best of them given as the tenth ...
[24]
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Deuteronomy+14%3A22-27&version=ESV
[25]
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Deuteronomy+14%3A28-29&version=ESV
[26]
Deuteronomy 26:12 When you have finished laying aside a tenth of ...
“When you have finished paying all the tithe of your increase in the third year, the year of tithing, then you shall give it to the Levite, to the stranger, to ...
[27]
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Deuteronomy+26%3A12-15&version=ESV
[28]
7 Reasons Christians Are Not Required to Tithe - The Gospel Coalition
Mar 28, 2017 · What does the Old Testament say about tithing? Abraham gave a tenth of his spoils of war to Melchizedek (Gen. 14:20), and Hebrews appeals to ...Tgc Asks · Tithing In The Old Testament · Why Tithing Is Not Required...
[29]
Tithing in the New Testament - Ministry Magazine
The one and only reference to tithing by our Lord is found in Matthew 23:23, where Christ endorsed it as a part of religious duty.
[30]
In Luke 11:42 and Matthew 23:23 did Jesus endorse tithing for all ...
Feb 14, 2013 · While tithing is mentioned in the New Testament it's mentioned incidentally in connection to other issues and not of itself given emphasis.<|separator|>
[31]
https://www.crossway.org/articles/10-key-bible-verses-on-giving/
[32]
What does the New Testament say about giving? - Boundless.org
Sep 17, 2013 · Jesus told the rich man to give all that he had (and went on to promise immense spiritual rewards to those who give everything to follow Him ( ...
[33]
To Tithe or Not to Tithe? A New Testament Guide to Generous Giving
The New Testament does provide several examples and principles of giving that can guide us in our stewardship and giving.
[34]
New Testament Giving - Thomas Nelson Bibles | 2 Corinthians 8-9
Nov 20, 2018 · We ought to give willingly ( 2 Corinthians 8:12; 9:2) and cheerfully, “not grudgingly or of necessity” (2 Corinthians 9:7). It is a privilege to share in the ...
[35]
Does the Bible Command Tithing? - Faith Fellowship
Tithing is mentioned three times in the New Testament, but is never prescribed and is only incidental to other teachings (Matthew 23:23, Luke 18:12, Hebrews 7:1 ...Missing: sources | Show results with:sources<|separator|>
[36]
Can a Church Require Tithing? - Desiring God
Nov 14, 2024 · The short answer is that I do not think tithing is a New Testament requirement the way “love your neighbor as yourself” is a New Testament requirement.Missing: scholarly sources
[37]
Tithes | Encyclopedia.com
As may be learned from i Samuel 8:15, 17 and from Ugarit (in the aforementioned example), the tithe could also be a royal tax which the king could exact and ...<|separator|>
[38]
Seeking Precedent for Tithing to the Jerusalem Priesthood
The Akkadian word ešrētu represents a one-tenth tax. There is evidence that the tax was sometimes paid to the local ruler or king and sometimes to the temple.
[39]
https://brill.com/downloadpdf/book/9789004494039/B9789004494039_s009.pdf
[40]
The Confusion of Tithing and the Tithing of Confusion - Academia.edu
... practice of tithing existed in Mesopotamia as early as 2100 BC. Beyond Mesopotamia, tithing or similar practices were observed in various ancient civilizations.
[41]
The Biblical case for tithing - Ministry Magazine
The Babylonians, Assyrians, Egyptians, and Sumerians paid a tenth of their incomes to their gods as a fixed rule centuries before God through the prophet ...Missing: Mesopotamia pre-
[42]
[PDF] TITHING IN UGARIT AND THE PENTATEUCH - Semantic Scholar
Tithing Texts from Ugarit (ca. 14th–13th Centuries BCE). The ancient ... A first tithe consisted of the tithe to the Levites/tithe of tithes to the priests.Missing: Ebla Hittite
[43]
On Tithe Paid in Grain in Ugarit - jstor
tithe paid to the royal authorities by the village communities of Ugarit in general, and the grain-tithe in particular. The existence of such institutions was ...Missing: historical | Show results with:historical
[44]
Tithing in Ugarit and the Pentateuch - possible implications for Africa
The tithe in Ugarit is of direct relevance to the Pentateuch tithe, especially to its for- mulation and application in the Old Testament. In comparing the ...
[45]
Tithing in the Torah and Today - Bya Mukama
Apr 6, 2019 · In the ancient kingdoms like Mesopotamia and among the Hittites, tithes were tributes paid by the vassal kingdoms to their Suzerains. A vassal ...
[46]
Maaser - Tithing in Torah and Jewish Law - Chabad.org
Maaser, giving one tenth part of something given to charity, appears often in the Torah. But how does tithing work, and what is its history?
[47]
The Meaning of Ma'aser Kesafim and Tithing - Colel Chabad
Apr 4, 2024 · In the Torah, the first five books of the Hebrew Bible, there are several mentions of tithing as an act of righteousness and obedience to God.<|separator|>
[48]
The Ancient Rise and Recent Fall of Tithing - Christianity Today
Aug 8, 2008 · This view of tithing, known as parallelism, gained prominence in the church around the sixth century. Many non-Jewish and pre-Christian ...
[49]
6 Quotes on Tithing from the Early Church - Pushpay
Clement of Alexandria (c. 150–215 AD) ... “The tithes of the fruits and of the flocks taught both piety towards the Deity and not to covetously grasp everything.
[50]
CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Alms and Almsgiving - New Advent
According to the creed of Christianity, almsgiving implies a material service rendered to the poor for Christ's sake.Missing: Origen | Show results with:Origen
[51]
CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Tithes - New Advent
The payment of tithes was adopted from the Old Law, and early writers speak of it as a divine ordinance and an obligation of conscience. The earliest positive ...
[52]
Tithing – CERC - Catholic Education Resource Center
The Church viewed tithes as in accord with divine law since they were instituted by God Himself. The practice of tithing fluctuated throughout Europe. After the ...
[53]
Calvin and Tithes - Slave of the Word
Feb 17, 2006 · John Calvin (1509–1564) claimed, based upon Malachi 3, that God had instituted tithing so that His people would be continually reminded that everything ...
[54]
Tithes & Offerings | Reformed Books Online
And hence it follows that the way of tithing in the Old Testament was not a natural or moral law. For no law appointed in the Gospel is inconsistent with any ...
[55]
Histories of Tithes: Religious Controversy and Changing ... - JHI Blog
Feb 18, 2015 · The early church was supported by charity rather than legal requirement. Only in the late medieval church were tithes enforced. In his defense ...
[56]
The History of Tithing in Evangelicalism - Go to Heaven Now!
Aug 28, 2020 · The Protestant Reformation and Opposition to Tithes. Martin Luther said of the tithe: “But the other commandments of Moses, which are not by ...
[57]
Tithes - The National Archives
The 1836 Tithe Commutation Act required tithes in kind to be converted to more convenient monetary payments called tithe rentcharge. The Tithe Survey was ...
[58]
The History of Tithing in Evangelicalism - Kingdom Winds
Mar 17, 2021 · Luther liked the idea of a tithe as a civil tax since it would be a much lighter burden than the taxes of his day.
[59]
Tithing - The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
In the July 8, 1838, revelation, the Lord answered the Saints' question with these instructions: first, the Saints should make a one-time donation of all their ...
[60]
Highlights of the Beginning of the Tithing System
Systematic benevolence, as first proposed and adopted by the Sabbathkeeping Adventists in 1859, comprised a systematic plan of giving not only on a ...
[61]
[PDF] Truths About Tithers - ECFA
There are an estimated 10 million tithers in America that donate more than $50 billion annually to religious and charitable causes.
[62]
Ma'aserot - Jewish Virtual Library
The tractate contains five chapters. Chapter 1 defines the types of produce liable to tithing (1–4), the stage of growth at which they become liable, and when, ...
[63]
Ma'aser Sheni | Texts & Source Sheets from Torah, Talmud ... - Sefaria
MISHNAH: Of profane and Second Tithe coins that were strewn around, what one collected goes to Second Tithe until complete, the remainder is profane.
[64]
Terumot and Ma'aserot - Jewish Virtual Library
After terumah and the first tithe were set aside, a second tithe had to be given of the remainder. In the first, second, fourth, and fifth years of the ...
[65]
Do Jews still tithe today? | Rabbi Ari Shvat | Ask the Rabbi - yeshiva.co
Oct 29, 2021 · Yes, we have thousands of recognized Levites and Kohanim and we still tithe (there are many details involved), but it's only on fruits and vegetables grown in ...
[66]
Quotes about Tithing from Christian History
The Lord ... instead of the law enjoining the giving of tithes, [told us] to share all our possessions with the poor. (Against Heresies IV:13:3).
[67]
Six Advocates of Tithing between 366-400 - Slave of the Word
Mar 10, 2006 · Six Church Fathers between 366 and 400 advocated tithing with none arguing against it. Constantine (ca 325 AD) had a large impact on Christianity while he was ...Missing: patristic | Show results with:patristic
[68]
Was tithing 10% required or encouraged by the early church?
Oct 26, 2011 · Not every Church Father taught on tithing. Not every Church Father tithed. The early church did not require tithes, they were given freely.
[69]
Father Kenneth Doyle: What's the Catholic view on tithing? Should a ...
May 25, 2022 · There is, though, no strict obligation for Catholics to tithe. Tithing is based on several Old Testament passages, such as Leviticus 27:32, ...
[70]
Are Catholics Required to Tithe 10 Percent of Their Income to the ...
Catholics are under no obligation to tithe a certain percentage of their income to the Church. The Church does require the following:
[71]
Tithing - Questions & Answers - Orthodox Church in America
Tithing, as you correctly observe, is the Old Testament injunction to set aside 10% of all one possesses for the work of the Lord.
[72]
Yes, Orthodox Christians Should Tithe. Regularly.
Apr 29, 2025 · One important note: Not all Church Fathers taught on the subject of tithing, nor did all Church Fathers tithe. The patristic evidence on the ...
[73]
Tithe - OrthodoxWiki
In recent years, tithing has been revived in Orthodox Churches as a form of stewardship that God requires of Christians. The primary argument is that God has ...<|separator|>
[74]
Study Reveals Which Denominations Hold Strongest Beliefs on Tithing
May 3, 2023 · A national survey finds that most Protestant churchgoers believe in tithing 10% of their income, but following through varies widely.
[75]
What Is the Prosperity Gospel? - Ligonier Ministries
Jul 10, 2023 · Kenneth Copeland, Benny Hinn, Joel Osteen, T.D. Jakes, John Hagee, Creflo Dollar, Paula White, Joyce Meyer, and Juanita Bynum are a few of the ...Missing: tithing proponents
[76]
9 Things You Should Know About the Prosperity Gospel
Sep 2, 2023 · Joe Carter explains the background and tenets of the prosperity gospel, as well as why Christians should be aware of this false teaching.
[77]
Prosperity Gospel Born in the USA - The Gospel Coalition
Jun 4, 2015 · The prosperity gospel is built on a quasi-Christian heresy, popular in the late 19th and early 20th centuries in the United States, known as New Thought.
[78]
5 Errors of the Prosperity Gospel - The Gospel Coalition
Jun 5, 2015 · In light of Scripture, the prosperity gospel is fundamentally flawed. At bottom, it is a false gospel because of its faulty view of the ...
[79]
5 Critical Errors of the Prosperity Gospel - Christ and Culture
The driving force behind this teaching on giving is what teacher Robert Tilton referred to as the “Law of Compensation.” According to this law, which is ...
[80]
Prosperity Preacher Creflo Dollar: My Past Teaching on Tithing 'Was ...
Jul 7, 2022 · Creflo Dollar, the American televangelist and and pastor of World Changers Church International, is offering a few edits to some of his past ...
[81]
Money-Giving-Amount - Grace Quotes
The tithe is God's historical method to get us on the path of giving. In that sense, it can serve as a gateway to the joy of grace giving.
[82]
Seven Principles for Christian Giving | Ray Fowler .org
Christian giving should be: 1) regular giving, 2) participatory giving, 3) intentional giving, 4) proportional giving, 5) anticipatory giving, 6) effective ...
[83]
Zakat: changing the framework of giving | Islamic Economic Studies
Feb 28, 2023 · Zakat is one of the five pillars of Islam. In Arabic, zakat means growth and purification. In a religious context, zakat refers to the spending ...
[84]
(PDF) Zakat as a Measure of Social Justice in Islamic Finance
Aug 8, 2025 · Each Muslim calculates his or her own Zakat individually. Generally, this involves the payment each year of two and a half percent of one's ...
[85]
History of Zakat in Islam from Origin to Modern Practices
Origin of Zakat in Islam ... Trade goods Zakat: 2.5% of value. The Qur'an 9:60 revealed clear Zakat rules and identified the Zakat recipients in 9 AH (631 CE).
[86]
[PDF] Your guide to understanding and calculating - Zakat
What is Nisab? Nisab is a minimum threshold of wealth. The Nisab was set by the Prophet Muhammad. (peace be upon him) at a rate equivalent to: 87.48 grams of ...
[87]
[PDF] Calculating Zakat - Hidaya Foundation
The literal meaning of Zakat is “to purify, to grow, and to increase.” It is an obligatory act of charity ordained by Allah, Subhanahu Wa Ta'ala (The. Glorified ...
[88]
[PDF] Calculation of Zakat on Financial Assets for American Muslims
Oct 9, 2024 · This chapter reviews the foundational concepts of zakat, the Quranic and Prophetic guidance on its practice, and the evolving scholarly ...
[89]
What Does the Quran Say About Zakat?
Aug 19, 2021 · The Quran states Zakat is an integral part of Islam, linked to prayer, and is given to the poor and indigent, and those who work on ...
[90]
[PDF] For the Religious Rulings (Fatwa) for Individual Zakat
Apr 6, 2023 · Zakat is the third pillar of Islam, and one of its great foundations. Allah Almighty has placed Zakat on equal footing with prayer in the Holy ...<|separator|>
[91]
(PDF) Zakat in Islamic Wealth Management - ResearchGate
This chapter reviews the concept of zakat, its levying structure, its rules and objectives and the economic impact of its distribution.
[92]
Christian Tithe vis-a-vis Islamic Zakat Concept - Academia.edu
The findings is, tithe and zakat has same objectives, that is, a human prosperity. But, both of these differences in collecting and distribution procedure. A ...
[93]
Understanding Dasvandh: Sikh Tradition of Giving
Dasvandh is a Sikh practice of giving one-tenth of earnings for community welfare and religious support, a religious obligation for community resources.
[94]
About Dasvandh and Tithing - Sikh Dharma International
Dasvandh, which literally means “tenth part”, is the tithing practice of contributing a portion of your earnings in the name of your Guru or spiritual source.
[95]
Sikhs and Dasvandh - SikhNet
Jul 18, 2023 · DASVANDH or Dasaundh, lit. a tenth part, refers to the practice among Sikhs of contributing in the name of the Guru one-tenth of their ...
[96]
Hinduism's Online Lexicon - A-Z Dictionary - Academia.edu
" The traditional Hindu practice of tithing, giving one-tenth of one's income to a religious institution. It was formerly widespread in India. In ancient ...
[97]
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Hinduism/Daily-offerings
[98]
Dana: The Practice of Giving - Access to Insight
Function of Giving Giving is of prime importance in the Buddhist scheme of mental purification because it is the best weapon against greed (lobha), the first ...
[99]
307 - Dana, the Paramita of Generosity: Buddhist Teachings on ...
Jul 8, 2025 · Dana, generosity or giving, is the first Mahayana Buddhist paramita. “Paramita” is usually translated as “perfection,” and literally means “that ...
[100]
What is tithing? Do most religions have an equivalent of ... - Quora
Mar 8, 2023 · ... give to our synagogues, yeshivot, mikvaot, etc. In Judaism, tithing is in addition to charity. So we give 10% plus other amounts to charity.What is the relation and similarities between Zoroastrianism ... - QuoraIs there any similarities between Religions that all faiths can agree ...More results from www.quora.com
[101]
Comparing Denominations and Religions that Tithe - Tithing.com
Sep 21, 2007 · An ironic list of how these cults, denominations, and religions compare to one another. Catholic, Mormon, Baptist, Baha'i, Methodist, Presbyterian, Pentecostal ...
[102]
Tithing in the New Testament: What Does It Say? - Tithe.ly
In Biblical times, the Israelites were asked to tithe their crops and livestock because they didn't have the paper bills and checks of today. They were largely ...
[103]
Is Tithing Required in the New Covenant? - GCI Archive
Now let us consider whether tithing is required in the new covenant. Tithing is mentioned only three or four times in the New Testament. Jesus acknowledged ...
[104]
Hebrews 7:1-12 and Tithing for Christians by Matodzi Lawrence ...
Sep 2, 2022 · The Levites were commanded to collect tithes from the rest of Israel, yet their ancestor Abraham paid a tithe to Melchizedek. The superiority ...
[105]
Is Tithing for New Covenant Believers? - Transform
Feb 18, 2014 · The tithe is never mentioned in the New Testament as a pattern for Christian giving. Rather, the New Testament pattern is proportionate giving–which may be ...
[106]
How can I become a more cheerful giver? | GotQuestions.org
Mar 14, 2025 · As Paul stated, “God loves a cheerful giver” (2 Corinthians 9:7). Cheerful giving, therefore, should be a way of life for the Christian who ...
[107]
Filing Requirements for churches and religious organizations - IRS
Aug 20, 2025 · Generally, tax-exempt organizations must file an annual information return (Form 990 PDF or Form 990-EZ PDF).
[108]
Church vs. Religious Charity Tax Law - Exploring the Differences ...
Feb 12, 2024 · This is one of the most critical differences, and that's that a church never files Form 990 with the IRS. This means, essentially, that churches ...
[109]
What Ministries Should Know About IRS Form 990 - StartCHURCH
Churches typically do NOT have to file 990 tax returns. Section 6033(a)(3)(A)(i) exempts churches, their integrated auxiliaries, and conventions of churches ...
[110]
Lawsuit alleges Gateway Church committed financial fraud with ...
Oct 4, 2024 · A suit filed Oct. 4 accuses the church of falsely claiming 15% of tithes would go to overseas ministry ... abuse-allegations/">Morris resigned</a> ...
[111]
Gateway Church accused of misusing tithes in new class-action ...
Oct 7, 2024 · In a class-action lawsuit filed Friday, four church members accuse Gateway Church of misappropriating millions of dollars in donations, known as a tithe.
[112]
Gateway Church Faces 35-40% Tithing Decline Amid Leadership ...
Nov 19, 2024 · Gateway Church Faces 35-40% Tithing Decline Amid Leadership Scandals ... church was shaken by allegations of sexual abuse by founding pastor ...
[113]
Megachurch reportedly slashing staff following pastor abuse scandal
Nov 18, 2024 · A Texas megachurch embroiled in an abuse scandal involving its former pastor has announced it will be slashing staff following a dramatic drop in tithes.
[114]
The Prosperity Gospel and the Financial Crisis — Martin E. Marty
Dec 7, 2009 · Rosin shows how many pastors of this school of thought served as agents of unscrupulous lenders and home-sellers, guiding their parishioners to ...
[115]
Handling Your Church's Finances with Transparency and Integrity
Sep 30, 2022 · Churches should lean into transparency about how money is allocated and spent. A church should be transparent not only about its intentions but its actions.
[116]
The Elusive Economic Blessings of Tithing: Mormon Temples and ...
Apr 3, 2024 · A limited economics literature examines the relationship between religious practices such as tithing and economic outcomes such as poverty.
[117]
A neural link between generosity and happiness - PMC - NIH
Jul 11, 2017 · Generous behaviour is known to increase happiness, which could thereby motivate generosity. In this study, we use functional magnetic resonance imaging.Missing: empirical religious
[118]
Religious Communities and Human Flourishing - PMC
Participation in religious services is associated with numerous aspects of human flourishing, including happiness and life satisfaction, mental and physical ...
[119]
[PDF] The Science of Generosity
Another study looked at the effects of giving and receiving emotional support (such as making their spouse feel loved and cared for or listening to them when ...Missing: tithing | Show results with:tithing
[120]
Financial future may be brighter for those who tithe - The Source
Feb 2, 2005 · “Increased appeals and teaching about tithing or planned giving may lead congregation members to give more to other community organizations,” ...
[121]
[PDF] The Elusive Economic Blessings of Tithing: Mormon Temples and ...
Abstract. This paper examines the relationship between Mormon temples and county-level poverty rates in the United States. The Mormon church teaches that ...
[122]
[PDF] Religious Giving - Science of Generosity
Hoge. (1994) cites numerous studies correlating religious orthodoxy with increased religious giving. (e.g., Greeley, McCourt, and McCready 1976; Hoge and Polk, ...
[123]
Tithing and religious charitable giving in America: Applied Economics
While the likelihood of religious giving increased with income, the likelihood of tithing fell dramatically. As a group, tithers had less income, but were ...
[124]
Tithing is Regressive - Faith+Lead
Oct 16, 2023 · Our economy today is not comparable to the economy in biblical times, and tithing can be an oppressive practice.