Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Progressive Christianity

Progressive Christianity is a theological and within liberal Protestantism that emerged prominently in the late , characterized by efforts to reconcile Christian faith with contemporary progressive values, including emphasis on , , and inclusivity toward marginalized groups, often at the expense of traditional doctrines such as the of Christ, , and the exclusivity of through . This approach views primarily as a moral exemplar and wisdom teacher rather than a literal divine savior who performed miracles or rose bodily from the dead, prioritizing human experience, reason, and cultural adaptation over claims or historical . Rooted in 19th-century liberal and reactions against fundamentalist revivalism, the movement gained traction in the early 2000s amid postmodern influences, seeking to present as intellectually viable in by downplaying sin's gravity and emphasizing ethical imperatives like economic equality and LGBTQ+ affirmation. Key figures include retired Episcopal bishop , who advocated rejecting creedal formulas as outdated; evangelical-turned-progressive ; and activist theologians like , who integrate faith with left-leaning policy advocacy. While proponents claim it revitalizes for modern audiences by fostering compassion and questioning rigid dogmas, critics from evangelical and perspectives argue it constitutes "another " that erodes core Christian tenets, undermines scriptural authority, and correlates with membership declines in adopting mainline denominations. Empirical observations, such as stagnating or shrinking congregations in progressive-leaning bodies compared to growth in biblically conservative ones, underscore debates over its sustainability, though its cultural influence persists in ecumenical dialogues and public .

Definition and Core Beliefs

Fundamental Principles

Progressive Christianity articulates its fundamental principles through flexible, non-dogmatic frameworks that prioritize personal experience, ethical action, and inclusivity over adherence to historic creeds or scriptural inerrancy. A primary such framework is the Core Values issued by the Center for Progressive Christianity in 2022, which replaced earlier formulations like the 2003 "8 Points" and emphasize ' teachings as a pathway to holistic rather than exclusive salvific truth. These values reflect an evolving approach, intended to spark dialogue and accommodate diverse interpretations, but critics from orthodox Christian perspectives argue they sideline core biblical doctrines such as human sinfulness and in favor of optimistic . The first core value posits that emulating Jesus' way fosters experiences of sacredness, wholeness, and interconnectedness among all life forms, while affirming the presence of a divine in multiple religious traditions beyond alone. This principle shifts focus from Jesus' unique role as divine redeemer—central to creeds like the Nicene (325 AD)—to his example as a guide compatible with . A second principle calls for inclusive communities that affirm differences in theology, age, race, , , socioeconomic class, and ability, rejecting exclusion based on doctrinal conformity. Proponents view this as embodying ' compassion, yet detractors contend it undermines biblical standards on sexuality and morality, as evidenced by progressive endorsements of practices like since the 2003 consecration of as an openly gay bishop. Subsequent values advocate striving for , , and selfless through systemic change; integrating scientific insights while safeguarding environmental ; and pursuing lifelong that favors open questioning over fixed absolutes. These align with progressive on issues like climate policy—such as support for the 2015 among affiliated groups—and , but empirical analyses of outcomes, including mixed results from justice-oriented interventions (e.g., urban renewal programs showing persistent inequality gaps per U.S. data from 2020), highlight causal complexities often overlooked in favor of ideological commitments. Overall, these principles frame faith as adaptive moral progress, diverging from traditional emphases on and .

Distinction from Traditional Christianity

Progressive Christianity distinguishes itself from traditional Christianity primarily through a reinterpretation of core doctrines that prioritizes alignment with contemporary ethical standards, scientific understandings, and social progress over strict adherence to historical . Whereas traditional —encompassing evangelical, , and conservative Protestant traditions—upholds the as the inerrant and authoritative Word of , progressive variants view it as a human-inspired collection of texts subject to cultural and historical critique, allowing for metaphorical or contextual interpretations that adapt teachings to modern contexts. This shift often leads to questioning foundational events like the literal bodily , which traditionalists affirm as historical fact essential to faith, while progressives may treat it as symbolic or experiential, varying by individual belief. On the nature of sin, traditional emphasizes and personal moral accountability, deriving from biblical texts like Romans 3:23 and upheld by doctrines from early church councils, with 78% of conservative leaders rejecting leniency for unrepentant according to surveys of pastoral views. Progressive , by contrast, tends to de-emphasize individual culpability in favor of systemic injustices, reinterpreting as primarily societal rather than inherent human against God, which aligns with broader cultural emphases on inclusivity over judgment. Regarding salvation, traditional frameworks center on through Christ's death and , accessible by through alone as articulated in creeds like the Nicene and in evangelical statements such as the of 1974, with 79% of adherents affirming exclusive reliance on Christ's work per recent worldview inventories. Progressives often expand this to include universalist leanings or ethical , where salvation involves efforts and moral improvement, potentially diminishing the necessity of orthodox repentance and faith in favor of lived , as seen in critiques from theologians like Roger Olson who argue this severs ties to classical . Ethical applications, particularly on , further highlight the divide: traditional maintains prohibitions on and fluidity based on literal readings of passages like Leviticus 18:22 and 1 Corinthians 6:9-10, viewing them as timeless moral standards reflective of God's design. approaches reinterpret these as culturally bound, advocating full affirmation of LGBTQ+ identities and practices, with data showing 78-89% support for such inclusions among self-identified progressives in surveys from 2022. This extends to issues, where traditionalists prioritize biblical fidelity amid cultural pressures, while progressives integrate movements like environmental or racial equity initiatives as central to discipleship, often subordinating scriptural to experiential validation.

Historical Origins and Evolution

Precursors in Liberal Theology

Liberal theology emerged in the early as a response to rationalism and scientific advancements, seeking to reinterpret Christian doctrine through reason, , and human experience rather than literal or claims. This movement prioritized adapting faith to modern culture, viewing traditional orthodoxy as incompatible with empirical knowledge and ethical progress. In , (1768–1834) is widely recognized as its foundational figure, arguing in his 1799 work On Religion: Speeches to Its Cultured Despisers that consists of an immediate feeling of absolute dependence on the divine, independent of propositional or . Schleiermacher's emphasis on subjective experience over objective revelation influenced subsequent theologians to apply higher criticism to scripture, treating the as a product of historical evolution rather than divinely dictated truth, which undermined doctrines like and . By the mid-19th century, liberal theology spread to the , where it intersected with reformist impulses amid industrialization and . Theologians like Horace Bushnell (1802–1876) softened Calvinist emphases on , promoting a developmental view of Christian nurture over conversion experiences. This paved the way for the movement in the 1880s–1910s, which reframed the kingdom of God as a terrestrial ethical order achievable through . (1861–1918), a Baptist minister influenced by his experiences in New York's Hell's Kitchen slums, articulated this in Christianity and the Social Crisis (1907), asserting that ' teachings demanded systemic reforms against capitalism's excesses, such as child labor and monopolies, rather than eschatological judgment or individual . viewed as structural—embedded in economic and political institutions—echoing earlier liberals' causal shift from personal morality to societal causation. These precursors distinguished liberal theology from by de-emphasizing , , and in favor of immanent divine action and moral , trends that progressive Christianity later amplified with greater focus on inclusivity and . However, critics, including contemporaries like , charged that such adaptations diluted Christianity's supernatural core to accommodate , a tension persisting into modernist-fundamentalist controversies of the . denominations, such as Presbyterians and Methodists, increasingly adopted these views, fostering denominations open to progressive evolutions by mid-century.

Mid-20th Century Developments

In the aftermath of , the ecumenical movement gained momentum among denominations, culminating in the establishment of the in 1948, which united over 140 denominations in promoting Christian unity and addressing global social issues such as , , and international peace. In the United States, the formed in 1950 as a successor to the Federal Council of Churches, emphasizing cooperative action on domestic concerns like civil rights and , reflecting a continuation of priorities adapted to postwar industrial and racial challenges. These bodies prioritized ethical activism over doctrinal uniformity, often aligning with secular progressive causes, though critics noted this sometimes subordinated orthodox theology to political advocacy. Theologically, the mid-century period saw an initial dominance of neo-orthodoxy, led by figures like Karl Barth and Reinhold Niebuhr, which critiqued the optimistic rationalism of earlier liberal theology by reasserting divine transcendence and human sinfulness amid the horrors of totalitarianism and atomic warfare. Niebuhr's The Nature and Destiny of Man (1941-1943), widely influential through the 1950s, advanced "Christian realism," urging pragmatic engagement with power structures while rejecting utopian social progressivism as naive. However, by the early 1960s, radical theological trends emerged, challenging even neo-orthodox foundations; John A. T. Robinson's Honest to God (1963) advocated demythologizing biblical language to align with modern secular experience, drawing on Dietrich Bonhoeffer's ideas of a "world come of age." A pivotal development was the "Death of God" theology, popularized in the mid-1960s by thinkers like Thomas J. J. Altizer and William Hamilton, who argued that traditional theism had become culturally untenable in a secular, post-Holocaust world, urging Christianity to embrace atheism as a liberating step toward ethical humanism. Altizer's The Gospel of Christian Atheism (1966) contended that God's "death" enabled a dialectical incarnation fully realized in the world, influencing a shift toward experiential faith over supernatural claims. This movement gained mainstream attention via Time magazine's April 8, 1966, cover story "Is God Dead?", which highlighted its resonance with 1960s countercultural skepticism, though it faced backlash for undermining core Christian doctrines like divine sovereignty. Harvey Cox's The Secular City (1965) complemented this by celebrating urbanization and secularization as fulfillments of biblical prophecy, prioritizing social transformation over metaphysical speculation. Socially, mainline churches increasingly engaged civil rights and anti-war efforts; the National Council of Churches endorsed the 1963 March on Washington, where clergy participated alongside Martin Luther King Jr., framing racial justice as a gospel imperative. By the late 1960s, opposition to the Vietnam War drew progressive clergy into protests, with denominations like the United Methodist Church passing resolutions condemning U.S. policy in 1966-1968, marking a fusion of theological liberalism with leftist activism that accelerated membership declines in orthodox-leaning congregations. These developments laid groundwork for later progressive emphases on inclusivity and justice, often at the expense of traditional soteriology, as evidenced by declining adherence to confessional standards in seminaries like Union Theological Seminary.

Late 20th to Early 21st Century Expansion

In the late 1980s and 1990s, Progressive Christianity gained organizational structure amid reactions to the rise of conservative , such as the founded in 1979, prompting liberal Protestants to articulate distinct theological and social commitments. The , established in 1985 by biblical scholar Robert Funk, exemplified this shift by employing historical-critical analysis to evaluate the authenticity of ' sayings in the Gospels, concluding that only about 18% of attributed words were likely original, which reinforced progressive emphases on metaphorical scripture interpretation over literalism. Participants like and popularized these methods through publications, influencing a generation of and to prioritize ' ethical teachings on justice and inclusion. A pivotal institutional development occurred in 1994 with the founding of for Progressive Christianity by priest James Rowe Adams at the of St. John the Divine in , aimed at networking congregations open to questioning traditional doctrines while affirming inclusivity and social activism. This organization, renamed ProgressiveChristianity.org in 2010, developed the "8 Points of Progressive Christianity," outlining principles like embracing diverse human experiences and seeking community through compassion rather than creedal conformity, which spread via conferences, online resources, and partnerships with mainline churches. Concurrently, the Emergent Church movement, emerging from evangelical roots in the late , blended postmodern sensibilities with progressive themes, as leaders like critiqued fundamentalist certainty and advocated responsive to . Into the early , denominational bodies accelerated adoption of progressive stances on sexuality and justice, despite ongoing membership declines in mainline —from approximately 26 million adherents in 1990 to under 14 million by 2020 across major groups like the and . The 's 2003 consecration of as the first openly gay bishop in symbolized this expansion, affirming same-sex relationships and prompting schisms but also galvanizing progressive networks globally within . Similarly, the in 2005 became the first major U.S. denomination to endorse equal marriage rights for same-sex couples, framing it as an extension of ' inclusive ministry. These actions, alongside increased on environmental stewardship and anti-poverty initiatives through groups like , extended progressive influence into broader cultural and political discourses, even as numerical growth stalled amid .

Theological Distinctives

Interpretation of Scripture

Progressive Christians generally reject the doctrine of , viewing the Bible not as the verbatim word of free from error but as a collection of ancient texts shaped by human authors within specific historical, cultural, and literary contexts. This stance contrasts with evangelical affirmations of Scripture's total truthfulness, as articulated in documents like the 1978 , by prioritizing empirical analysis of textual origins over claims of divine dictation. Instead, they affirm the Bible's inspirational value for ethical guidance and personal transformation, while acknowledging instances where its content conflicts with modern , such as cosmological accounts in . A core interpretive tool is the historical-critical method, which examines the 's development through scholarly lenses like , , and to discern layers of composition and editorial influence. Theologian , a prominent figure in progressive circles, described this approach as reading the "again for the first time," urging interpreters to set aside premodern assumptions of literal factuality in favor of metaphorical and parabolic meanings that resonate with contemporary experiences of and . For instance, narratives like the are often treated as symbolic expressions of hope and communal renewal rather than historical events requiring empirical verification, as argued by , who views the entire biblical corpus as "parabolic" in nature. This method facilitates reinterpretations that align scriptural themes with progressive ethical priorities, such as emphasizing ' teachings on mercy and inclusion over Levitical purity codes or apocalyptic warnings of judgment. Passages on sexuality, for example, are contextualized as products of ancient honor-shame cultures rather than timeless mandates, enabling affirmations of diverse relationships that traditional literalism would preclude. Critics from perspectives, including evangelical scholars, contend that such selectivity undermines the Bible's unified authority, reducing it to a malleable for cultural accommodation rather than divine . Nonetheless, progressive interpreters maintain that this approach fosters a dynamic responsive to evolving understandings of and social equity, as evidenced in resources from organizations like ProgressiveChristianity.org.

Views on Christ and Salvation

Progressive Christianity typically portrays Jesus Christ as a and ethical teacher whose life exemplifies radical , , and opposition to oppressive systems, rather than as the divine incarnate who performed or literally rose from the dead. Influential theologians such as describe Jesus as a "Jewish mystic" and "spirit person" whose relevance lies in his teachings on the kingdom of God as a present reality achievable through human action, downplaying claims of pre-existence, , or bodily as metaphorical or mythological developments in early church tradition. Similarly, John Shelby Spong, a retired , argued that traditional doctrines like the and represent outdated theistic frameworks incompatible with modern rationality, proposing instead that Jesus embodied a universal human potential for God-consciousness without unique divinity. These interpretations prioritize the "" reconstructed through critical scholarship over the Christ of creedal orthodoxy, often viewing accounts as symbolic narratives shaped by post-Easter faith communities rather than eyewitness reportage. On salvation, progressive perspectives largely reject penal substitutionary atonement—the notion that Christ's death satisfied divine wrath for human —as a morally problematic theory implying cosmic or divine . Instead, is reframed as a this-worldly of personal and societal transformation, where following ' example of , inclusivity, and resistance to liberates individuals from and fosters communal wholeness. This aligns with influences from , emphasizing deliverance from systemic oppression like poverty or over forensic justification or escape from eternal punishment. Many progressives embrace or , asserting that is accessible to all humanity through diverse paths, not confined to explicit faith in Christ's atoning work, as exclusivity contradicts ' inclusive ethic. Critics from evangelical traditions contend these views dilute the New Testament's portrayal of as reconciliation with a holy through Christ's unique , reducing it to moralism without transcendent efficacy. While not monolithic, such emphases reflect a broader shift toward immanent, ethical over rescue.

Eschatology and Afterlife

In progressive Christianity, eschatology is frequently reinterpreted through a lens of realized or inaugurated eschatology, where the kingdom of God is understood as partially present in Jesus' life, teachings, and ongoing social justice efforts rather than primarily a future cataclysmic event. This draws from mid-20th-century liberal theological influences, such as C.H. Dodd's concept of realized eschatology, which posits that biblical prophecies of the end times were fulfilled in Christ's ministry, emphasizing ethical transformation in the here-and-now over literal apocalyptic scenarios like the rapture or millennial reign. Adherents often view end-times imagery in texts like Revelation as symbolic of systemic oppression's defeat through human agency, aligning with broader commitments to environmental stewardship and equity as manifestations of divine reign. Views on the afterlife diverge significantly from evangelical emphases on eternal conscious torment, with many progressive Christians rejecting as a place of unending punishment on grounds that it contradicts a conception of divine love as unconditionally inclusive. — the belief that all humanity will ultimately be reconciled to —gains traction, as articulated by theologians like , who frames salvation as Christo-centric restoration for all, and William Paul Young, whose 2007 novel The Shack (selling over 20 million copies by 2017) portrays no eternal separation from . Rob Bell's 2011 book Love Wins further popularized this by questioning punitive , arguing for hopeful inclusivity based on 's pursuing . While some progressives affirm (where the unsaved cease to exist post-) or remain agnostic about post-mortem details, favoring focus on earthly flourishing, these positions collectively diminish traditional notions of final as retributive, reframing in terms of communal rather than individual fate. This spectrum reflects a of metaphorical over literalism, though it varies widely among adherents, with no uniform binding the movement.

Ethical and Social Emphases

Inclusivity and Human Diversity

Progressive Christianity emphasizes a of inclusiveness that seeks to embrace across sexual orientations, identities, ethnicities, and abilities, viewing such variety as reflective of divine creation rather than a barrier to full participation in faith communities. Adherents prioritize creating welcoming spaces for marginalized groups, often through "open and affirming" policies that reject exclusion based on identity. A core aspect involves affirmation of LGBTQ+ individuals, with progressive congregations supporting same-sex marriages and the of openly , , bisexual, and . This position holds that biblical texts addressing same-sex relations, such as those in Leviticus or Romans, are contextually limited to ancient cultural practices like or , not consensual adult relationships, thereby elevating ' ethic of love over literal prohibitions. Organizations within the movement, like ProgressiveChristianity.org, promote resources framing God's love as radically inclusive, encouraging vocal advocacy for LGBTQ+ rights and safe spaces free from conversion efforts or celibacy mandates. Beyond sexuality and gender, inclusivity extends to racial and ethnic , with progressive Christians often integrating efforts into and community life, interpreting scriptural calls for as mandates against systemic inequalities. and are similarly affirmed, with emphasis on and viewing differences as opportunities for communal enrichment rather than deficits. This approach, while self-described as countering historical Christian exclusivity, aligns with broader cultural shifts toward , prompting critiques that it subordinates doctrinal fidelity to contemporary social norms.

Social Justice Priorities

Progressive Christians often identify as a primary mandate derived from ' ministry to the marginalized, interpreting passages like Luke 4:18-19—where announces liberation for the oppressed—as a blueprint for contemporary activism. This framework, articulated in the updated 8 Points of Progressive Christianity, includes a to "work toward and among all people," encompassing efforts to dismantle systemic barriers rather than focusing solely on personal piety. A core priority is economic justice, with emphasis on alleviating through for redistributive policies, such as debt forgiveness and fair wages, rooted in prophetic calls like Amos 5:24 for justice to roll like waters. Groups like , established in 1971, have campaigned against , highlighting statistics such as the 2023 U.S. data showing 11.5% of Americans in , and linking it to biblical ethics of Jubilee-year in Leviticus 25. Racial justice features prominently, with progressive Christians addressing structural racism through support for initiatives like the , co-led by Rev. since 2018, which targets intersections of poverty and race, citing the 2022 data indicating Black households hold 15.4% of White household wealth on average. This draws from historical progressive evangelical engagements since the 1970s, which critiqued racial hierarchies as antithetical to Galatians 3:28's equality in Christ. Peace and anti-militarism constitute another focus, opposing U.S. military interventions—such as the from 2003—and promoting non-violence based on ' in Matthew 5:9, with organizations like mobilizing against defense budgets exceeding $800 billion annually as of 2023, arguing they divert resources from human needs. Immigration reform ranks high, advocating humane policies for refugees and undocumented migrants, invoking :35's welcome of the stranger, amid data from the 2021-2023 period showing over 2.5 million encounters at the U.S. southern border, framed as opportunities for compassionate solidarity rather than restriction.

Environmental and Economic Concerns

Progressive Christians frequently interpret biblical themes of stewardship, such as Genesis 2:15's command to "till and keep" the garden, as imperatives for addressing contemporary , including anthropogenic and . This perspective emphasizes through policy advocacy, such as reducing carbon emissions and transitioning from fossil fuels, viewing ecological crises as moral failures requiring systemic repentance and for affected communities. For instance, resources from ProgressiveChristianity.org call for public policies that preserve natural resources while critiquing overconsumption in affluent societies. Similarly, the , a with strong progressive influences, has launched Climate Hope Affiliates since 2020 to foster local chapters combating alongside social injustices, framing these efforts as extensions of prophetic traditions. Environmental engagement often aligns with broader activism, including direct actions like those by Christian Climate Action, founded in the UK but influential in progressive circles, which organizes protests against infrastructure to embody "loving the " as essential Christian witness. However, these emphases draw from sources like the ' doctrines on creation care, which integrate environmentalism with social equity but have been noted for prioritizing alarmist narratives over balanced assessments of policy trade-offs, such as the economic costs of rapid decarbonization estimated at trillions globally by bodies like the IPCC. Empirical data from Pew Research indicates that while 29% of religious respondents link environmental care to stewardship, progressive-leaning groups more readily endorse human-caused climate dominance, potentially influenced by institutional alignments with secular environmental movements rather than solely scriptural . On economic concerns, Progressive Christianity underscores justice for the marginalized, deriving from prophets like —who condemned economic exploitation—and ' preferential , to advocate for redistributive policies addressing . Proponents, including theologians in journals like the Journal of Religion and Society, argue that true entails economic fairness, supporting measures like living wages, debt forgiveness akin to , and critiques of unchecked as idolatrous. Organizations such as Good Faith Media have, as of September 2025, urged progressive Christians to champion policies for economic equity, including anti-poverty initiatives and reduced tied to socioeconomic factors, positioning these as mandates over individualistic teachings. This economic focus often manifests in calls for structural reforms, with figures asserting that "economic justice is the heart of ," yet such views frequently parallel secular agendas without robust engagement of evidence on policy outcomes, such as expansions' mixed impacts on rates documented in long-term U.S. data showing persistent despite trillions in transfers since the . Critiques from economic analyses, including historical reforms, highlight risks of over-reliance on state intervention, which can stifle and personal agency—core to market-driven reductions that lifted over a billion globally from between 1990 and 2015 per figures—potentially subordinating biblical emphases on diligence and charity to ideological redistribution. Nonetheless, these concerns reflect Progressive Christianity's commitment to holistic , integrating economic equity with environmental sustainability under a framework of God's preferential care for the vulnerable.

Denominational and Institutional Presence

Mainline Protestant Engagement

Progressive Christianity has found its strongest institutional foothold within denominations, which historically emphasized social reform and theological liberalism, evolving into explicit adoption of progressive emphases on inclusivity, scriptural reinterpretation, and justice-oriented ethics. These denominations, comprising groups such as the (UCC), , Presbyterian Church (USA) (PCUSA), (ELCA), and the progressive faction of the [United Methodist Church](/page/United_Methodist Church) (UMC), represent a shift from 19th-century movements toward contemporary progressive stances, often prioritizing cultural adaptation over traditional doctrinal boundaries. The exemplifies deep engagement, with policies affirming LGBTQ ordination and since the early 2000s, including the 2003 consecration of as the first openly gay bishop, which prompted global Anglican tensions but solidified progressive alignment domestically. Similarly, the UCC endorsed equal marriage rights for same-sex couples in 2005, positioning itself as an early institutional proponent of emphases central to progressive Christianity. The PCUSA advanced progressive theology by amending ordination standards in 2011 to permit LGBTQ clergy and redefining marriage in church constitutions by 2015, reflecting a denominational pivot toward ethical inclusivity over confessional orthodoxy. The UMC's engagement culminated in a 2024 General Conference decision to lift bans on ordaining and performing same-sex marriages, following decades of internal conflict that led to over 7,600 U.S. congregations disaffiliating by late 2023—approximately one-quarter of its 30,000 domestic churches—primarily conservatives departing for bodies like the . This underscores progressive Christianity's institutional traction, as the remaining UMC leadership emphasized compatibility with evolving social norms. Empirical data from Pew Research indicate affiliation fell from 18% of U.S. adults in 2007 to 14% by 2019, with ongoing declines linked by analysts to doctrinal , though overall Christian identification stabilized around 62-64% by 2024. Seminaries affiliated with these denominations, such as Union Theological Seminary and Harvard Divinity School, further embed progressive Christianity through curricula prioritizing liberation theology, environmental ethics, and deconstructive biblical hermeneutics, training clergy who integrate these into parish life. Despite membership erosion—mainline churches lost 39% of their relative U.S. share since the 1960s—progressive emphases persist in advocacy arms like denominational social justice commissions, which lobby on issues from immigration reform to climate policy, often framing them as extensions of prophetic biblical mandates.

Influence in Other Christian Traditions

Progressive Christianity has exerted limited influence on evangelical traditions, primarily through historical figures and fringe movements that blend social activism with evangelical emphases on personal conversion and . In the mid-20th century, progressive evangelicalism represented a mainstream strand in the United States, advocating for civil rights and social reform while maintaining core doctrines like the inspiration of Scripture; however, by the , conservative resurgence marginalized it, associating with cultural accommodation over doctrinal fidelity. Former President exemplified this waning tradition, integrating evangelical piety with progressive policies on poverty and peace, yet his views on issues like diverged from emerging evangelical norms, contributing to the movement's eclipse by the Religious Right. Contemporary attempts to revive progressive elements within , such as through the "," often face rejection for prioritizing cultural relevance—e.g., affirming LGBTQ+ identities—over traditional interpretations of and , leading to predictions of its marginalization. In , progressive Christianity's impact manifests in post-Vatican II liberal theology, which emphasizes and but remains constrained by the Church's magisterial authority and unchanging doctrines on , , and morality. The Second Vatican Council (1962–1965) opened doors to interpretive flexibility, fostering groups advocating for women's roles and aligned with priorities, yet core teachings on issues like and same-sex unions have resisted adaptation, as evidenced by repeated papal reaffirmations. Pope Francis's pastoral style, with gestures toward inclusivity such as outreach to divorced Catholics and migrants, has been interpreted by some as progressive influence, but his doctrinal conservatism—e.g., upholding —has left progressive Catholics feeling sidelined amid hierarchical pushback. Empirical data from church growth studies indicate that parishes embracing progressive reforms, like selective inclusivity on gender issues, correlate with stagnation or decline, contrasting with vibrant conservative communities. Eastern Orthodoxy exhibits the least penetration by progressive Christianity, owing to its emphasis on patristic tradition, conciliar authority, and resistance to modernity's ethical shifts. While isolated American Orthodox voices advocate for compatibility with or social compassion in ways echoing progressive themes, the tradition broadly rejects reinterpreting Scripture or liturgy to accommodate contemporary norms on sexuality or gender, viewing such efforts as Western imports eroding apostolic deposit. In jurisdictions like the , progressive moral fluency—e.g., on economic —has influenced , but substantive changes remain rare, with synods upholding traditional stances on and as of 2023. Fringe online communities claiming "progressive " exist but lack institutional endorsement, underscoring the tradition's causal prioritization of unchanging over cultural dialogue.

Criticisms and Controversies

Doctrinal Critiques from Conservatives

Conservative theologians and denominations, such as those affiliated with the and evangelical institutions like , argue that progressive Christianity undermines core orthodox doctrines by prioritizing cultural accommodation over scriptural fidelity. They contend that progressives often reject the Bible's inerrancy and , treating it instead as a fallible human document subject to selective reinterpretation, which allows dismissal of teachings on topics like and moral absolutes. For instance, , president of , has described progressive variants as revealing a fundamental opposition to historic Christian truth, exemplified by organizations like the Center for Progressive Christianity that promote views incompatible with evangelical commitments to the Bible's authority. On , critics like John MacArthur, pastor of , assert that progressive emphases dilute the full divinity of Jesus Christ, portraying him more as an ethical exemplar or social revolutionary than the eternal Son who performed literal miracles, including the and bodily . MacArthur warns that such deconstructions lead to heretical churches where the gospel of Christ's is absent, reducing to moralism without supernatural redemption. Conservatives maintain that this shift erodes the exclusivity of through faith in Christ's atoning death and , as articulated in passages like John 14:6 and Acts 4:12, favoring instead inclusivist or universalist frameworks that minimize the necessity of personal conversion. Regarding and , evangelical critiques highlight progressive tendencies toward denying original 's depth and the reality of eternal hell, often reinterpreting these as metaphors for temporal rather than objective divine realities. This, according to sources like , results in a shallower that conflates with societal improvement, neglecting the biblical emphasis on and justification by alone. and others argue that such views align more with than apostolic teaching, as evidenced by progressive affirmations of universal reconciliation without regard for unrepentant , contravening doctrines affirmed in creeds like the Nicene and at councils such as in 451 AD. These critiques frame progressive Christianity not as a legitimate but as a departure from the once delivered to the saints, per Jude 1:3.

Charges of Cultural Conformity

Critics of Progressive Christianity argue that it prioritizes alignment with contemporary secular over fidelity to biblical teachings, effectively inverting the transformative role of . This charge posits that progressive interpretations reinterpret or de-emphasize scriptural doctrines—such as those on , , and —to accommodate societal shifts, rather than subjecting to scriptural . For example, the of same-sex relationships and gender transitions in many progressive circles is viewed as capitulation to post-1960s norms, diverging from passages like Leviticus 18:22 and 1 Corinthians 6:9-11, which traditionally prohibit such practices. Proponents of this , including apologist , contend that this results in a "lowered view of the ," where scripture is treated as a culturally relative document subject to modern revision rather than an authoritative standard. A related accusation involves the movement's of progressive political priorities, such as expansive and redistribution, which critics like those at the describe as interpreting the "through the lens of culture" instead of using it to evaluate cultural trends. This is exemplified in the de-emphasis of eternal judgment or in favor of or , aligning with secular humanism's aversion to punitive concepts; theologian , in his 2022 book Against Liberal Theology, labels such adjustments as that undermines by subordinating to experiential or societal validation. Similarly, the has highlighted how progressive emphases on inclusivity often eclipse calls to , fostering a therapeutic faith that mirrors therapeutic prevalent in Western since the mid-20th century. These charges extend to institutional outcomes, where denominations adopting progressive stances—such as the Church's 2003 consecration of an openly bishop—have experienced membership declines exceeding 20% from 2000 to 2020, which detractors attribute to eroded doctrinal distinctiveness and cultural mimicry rather than robust evangelism. Critics like those at Impact 360 Institute argue this conformity erodes Christianity's countercultural witness, as outlined in Romans 12:2's exhortation against worldly patterns, turning the into a "trend-chasing" variant that ebbs with cultural tides rather than anchoring in unchanging truth. While progressives counter that such adaptations reflect ' inclusive ministry, opponents maintain this overlooks the New Testament's pattern of both and with .

Empirical and Sociological Assessments

Mainline Protestant denominations, which have increasingly incorporated progressive theological emphases since the mid-20th century, have experienced steeper membership declines compared to evangelical counterparts. According to Pew Research Center's 2025 Religious Landscape Study, mainline Protestants constituted 18% of U.S. adults in 2007 but only 11% by 2024, a drop of over 40%, while evangelicals fell from 26% to 23% over the same period. This disparity aligns with Gallup data showing U.S. overall declining from 70% in 1999 to 47% in 2020, with mainline groups losing ground faster due to factors including theological on issues like sexuality and scriptural authority. Sociological analyses attribute part of this to reduced intergenerational transmission of faith in liberal-leaning families, where religious liberals exhibit the lowest worship attendance and child-rearing practices that prioritize over doctrinal . Empirical studies on attendance reveal that progressive congregations struggle with retention and engagement. Data from the General Social Survey indicate that among frequent churchgoers, conservative identifiers outnumber s by ratios exceeding 2:1, with weekly attenders being 52% conservative versus 25% ; even in liberal churches, regular participation correlates with shifting views toward . Researchers like Ryan Burge note that while liberal Christians show higher political activism—such as protesting or contacting officials—they attend services less consistently, contributing to institutional fragility. This pattern challenges assumptions of growth through cultural accommodation, as mainline bodies have hemorrhaged members since the , coinciding with progressive shifts, whereas conservative groups maintain higher vitality through emphasis on . Sociological assessments of broader impacts highlight mixed outcomes. Progressive emphases on have elevated political engagement among adherents, yet empirical evidence links regular religious practice—irrespective of denomination—to positive social stability, including lower rates and higher civic participation, effects more pronounced in doctrinally conservative settings. In contrast, progressive communities foster niche support for marginalized groups, such as LGBTQ individuals, but face critiques for diluting core Christian distinctives, correlating with accelerated ; for instance, mainline seminaries report enrollment drops exceeding 50% since 2000, reflecting broader institutional erosion. These trends suggest that while progressive Christianity appeals to a subset seeking alignment with secular , it underperforms in sustaining communal vitality and faith transmission relative to traditionalist alternatives, as evidenced by persistent "nones" growth absorbing disproportionate mainline defectors.

Key Figures and Movements

Influential Theologians and Authors

(1931–2015), a biblical scholar and canon theologian at Trinity Episcopal Cathedral, advanced progressive interpretations of Christianity through historical-critical analysis of the , emphasizing a metaphorical rather than literal reading of its narratives. In works such as Meeting Jesus Again for the First Time (1994), Borg portrayed as a "spirit person" and wisdom teacher whose life exemplified radical social critique rather than divine atonement for sin, influencing many to reconcile faith with modern scholarship. His co-founding of the in 1985, which voted on the authenticity of ' sayings using scholarly criteria, further popularized demythologizing approaches, though critics contended it undermined scriptural authority by dismissing miracles and as historical events. John Shelby Spong (1931–2021), an bishop of from 1979 to 2000, challenged doctrines in books like Rescuing the Bible from (1991), rejecting the , , and bodily as pre-scientific myths incompatible with empirical evidence. Spong advocated for inclusivity toward LGBTQ individuals, ordaining the first openly gay priest in a in 1989, and framed Christianity as an evolving human construct focused on ethical living over supernatural claims. His views, drawn from liberal theology and influenced by figures like , prioritized experiential faith and social ethics, yet drew accusations of reducing Christianity to by denying core creedal elements affirmed in councils like in 325 CE. Matthew Fox (b. 1940), a former silenced by the in 1993 for heterodox teachings, developed Creation Spirituality as an alternative to fall/redemption paradigms, stressing divine immanence in nature and human creativity over . In Original Blessing (1983), Fox integrated medieval mystics like with ecological and indigenous perspectives, promoting rituals like the Techno Cosmic Mass to foster awe and justice-oriented activism. Ordained in the [Episcopal Church](/page/Episcopal Church) in 1994, his framework influenced progressive environmental theology, though it faced critique for blending with elements and sidelining Christ's redemptive role, as evidenced by his 95 Theses (2021) echoing Luther's but reoriented toward planetary healing. Richard Rohr (b. 1943), a Franciscan and founder of for Action and , has shaped contemplative thought via non-dualistic interpretations in The Universal Christ (2019), positing Christ as cosmic presence in all creation rather than exclusively the ' salvific death. Rohr's emphasis on and appeals to those seeking mystical depth amid doctrinal disputes, with his writings cited in surveys of influencers for bridging Eastern spirituality and Christian practice. Brian McLaren (b. 1956), an emergent church leader, furthered narrative theology in A New Kind of Christianity (2010), questioning and while advocating adaptive faith responsive to cultural shifts, influencing younger progressives through his reframing of as communal . These figures collectively prioritize experiential and ethical reinterpretations, often at variance with patristic orthodoxy, as documented in theological critiques assessing their impact on denominational .

Organizations and Conferences

ProgressiveChristianity.org operates as a nonprofit network offering resources, educational materials, and community connections for individuals and groups exploring progressive approaches to Christian faith, emphasizing critical inquiry, inclusivity, and initiatives. It maintains partnerships with entities such as the Charter for Compassion, which promotes global movements for empathy and ethical action, and the Westar Institute, dedicated to scholarly analysis of biblical texts through historical and cultural lenses. Sojourners, founded in 1971 as a faith-rooted , focuses on mobilizing around issues like alleviation, racial , and , drawing from scriptural interpretations that prioritize systemic change over individual salvation. The organization publishes content and lobbies policymakers, claiming influence on U.S. through coalitions like the Circle of Protection established in 2011 to safeguard social programs. The Progressive Christian Alliance functions as an inclusive network of communities interpreting ' teachings through lenses of and spiritual openness, supporting local gatherings that reject traditional doctrinal rigidities in favor of experiential faith practices. Similarly, the Convergence Music Project develops worship resources aligned with progressive themes, producing songs and materials for churches emphasizing justice and diversity. Conferences serve as key venues for progressive Christian dialogue and renewal. The Southern Lights Conference, an annual event since at least 2022, convenes attendees for workshops, performances, and discussions aimed at rethinking faith amid cultural shifts, with the 2025 gathering held January 17-19 in Hilton Head, South Carolina, attracting speakers focused on community resilience. The Converging conference, organized by the Convergence Music Project, targets musicians, clergy, and activists with sessions on inclusive worship, justice-themed songwriting, and theological innovation; its 2025 iteration ran October 15-18 in Columbus, Ohio, featuring talks on resistance and resilience through faith expression. The Wild Goose Festival, affiliated through progressive networks, hosts multiday events blending arts, , and , drawing thousands to explore contemplative and socially engaged , though attendance figures remain modest compared to evangelical counterparts.

Membership Dynamics and Decline

denominations, which have increasingly incorporated progressive Christian emphases on , inclusivity, and reinterpretation of traditional doctrines, have experienced sustained membership declines over recent decades. According to data from 2025, mainline Protestants constituted 11% of U.S. adults, down from 18% in 2007, reflecting a sharper drop compared to evangelical Protestants, who fell from 26% to 23% over the same period. This decline has persisted amid broader U.S. , with mainline groups losing millions of adherents since the mid-20th century; for instance, aggregate mainline membership has not kept pace with U.S. , which doubled since 1950, leading to thousands of church closures. Membership dynamics reveal patterns of aging congregations and low retention, particularly among younger generations. Empirical surveys indicate that mainline churches struggle with generational replacement, as progressive theological shifts—such as de-emphasizing orthodox doctrines like biblical inerrancy—correlate with reduced transmission of faith to children and lower conversion rates. Denominational reports highlight net losses through deaths outpacing births and conversions, with one analysis noting a 27% drop in a representative mainline body from 2000 to 2020, falling below 2 million members. Retention challenges are exacerbated by internal divisions over progressive stances on issues like sexuality and gender, prompting conservative exits to evangelical or non-denominational alternatives, further eroding base membership. The decline's pace has accelerated in correlation with intensified progressive adoption; an Associated Press analysis in 2025 linked such theological evolutions to both membership erosion and financial strains in mainline bodies, with attendance and giving plummeting faster than in doctrinally conservative counterparts. While overall Christian affiliation decline has slowed since 2020—stabilizing around 60-65% of adults—mainline segments continue contracting due to these dynamics, contrasting with modest stability or growth in evangelical groups that maintain firmer adherence to historic creeds. Sociological assessments attribute part of this disparity to progressive Christianity's alignment with broader , which diminishes its distinct appeal amid rising "nones" (religiously unaffiliated), who now comprise 28% of adults and disproportionately include those from liberal backgrounds.

Interactions with Broader Culture

Progressive Christianity interacts with broader culture by aligning theological emphases with contemporary priorities, including advocacy for LGBTQ+ inclusion and racial equity. Progressive denominations, such as the and the , have affirmed same-sex marriages since 2005 and 2015, respectively, enabling clergy to officiate such ceremonies and ordaining openly LGBTQ+ individuals. This reflects a broader cultural shift toward acceptance of diverse sexual orientations, with progressive congregations often displaying and hosting affirming events to signal welcome. In political spheres, progressive Christians engage against movements like , framing their faith as compatible with democratic pluralism. As of October 2025, groups such as ProgressiveChristianity.org promote liturgies and resources emphasizing inclusivity and justice, countering nationalist interpretations through public statements and activism. Their involvement in issues like alleviation and anti-war efforts draws from historical traditions, partnering with secular organizations on prevention and climate initiatives. Media and arts representations of progressive Christianity often highlight its adaptive stance, portraying it more favorably than conservative variants in outlets discussing faith's role in modern society. Progressive voices utilize to disseminate inclusive messages, influencing cultural discourse on amid . However, this engagement frequently incorporates , prioritizing experiential authenticity over doctrinal absolutes, as evidenced in theological writings that reinterpret biblical texts to accommodate evolving societal norms on and .

References

  1. [1]
    What is progressive Christianity? - Reformed Theological Seminary
    Nov 3, 2020 · Progressive Christianity views Jesus as a moral example, focuses on moralism, and downplays sin, viewing people as not very fallen.
  2. [2]
    [BONUS] Progressive Christianity vs. Evangelical Christianity
    Oct 17, 2022 · They discuss how progressive Christians and evangelicals differ over the deity of Christ, nature of the Scriptures, and the resurrection of Jesus.
  3. [3]
    [PDF] A BIBLICAL RESPONSE TO PROGRESSIVE CHRISTIANITY By ...
    May 13, 2020 · This qualitative historical research will identify core Christian beliefs that refute the primary ideologies of progressive Christianity.
  4. [4]
    How We Got Here: A History of Progressive Christianity
    About progressive Christianity. In the early 2000s, some Christian leaders attemptes to adapt Christianity to the post-modern mindset.
  5. [5]
    A Brief History of Progressive Christianity (in America)
    Dec 3, 2024 · In short, progressive Christianity in America started largely as a reaction to the emotionalism of eighteenth-century revivalism and its morally ...
  6. [6]
    Progressive Christian Movement - Entry | Timelines | US Religion
    Lastly, progressive Christianity has a wide range of prominent self-identifiers, including John Spong, Tony Campolo, Jim Wallis, and Cornel West. Interactive ...
  7. [7]
    Another Gospel? - Think Biblically - Biola University
    Apr 30, 2021 · As Childers explains, progressive Christianity is a popular movement that holds a different view of the gospel, biblical authority, and a range ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  8. [8]
    Deconstructing Progressive Christianity: Point #3 - John Piippo
    Mar 15, 2021 · Progressive Christianity diminishes the authority of the Bible. It undermines faith, especially the faith of young believers.<|control11|><|separator|>
  9. [9]
    'Progressive' Christianity: Even Shallower Than the Evangelical ...
    Mar 7, 2020 · Progressive Christianity is seen as similar to MTD, with "wokeness" as morality, therapy as path to happiness, and a "kingdom without the King" ...
  10. [10]
    The Core Values of Progressive Christianity – ProgressiveChristianity
    Oct 8, 2023 · Welcome to our latest updated version of our Core Values – previously called the 8 Points of Progressive Christianity.
  11. [11]
    How to Recognize Progressive Christianity Through Theology
    Progressive Christians generally reject the doctrine of original sin, trading it for a concept called “Original Blessing” or “Original Goodness.”Missing: principles | Show results with:principles
  12. [12]
    [PDF] Thesis: Progressive Christianity - Scholars Crossing
    “Most progressive Christians do not base their religion on strict obedience to the Bible, nor do they feel a strong need to encourage others to accept their.
  13. [13]
  14. [14]
    How 'Progressive' Can a Christian Get? - Desiring God
    Dec 10, 2021 · And the reason the word progressive has taken on the meaning it has is because it has come to imply a progress away from the truth and toward ...
  15. [15]
    [PDF] clash of convictions: examining divergences among traditional and
    Sep 19, 2024 · Traditional and progressive Christians present substantial contrasts in interpreting and applying core principles, encompassing biblical ...
  16. [16]
    Progressive vs Orthodox Christian Conceptions of Sin - Chris Northcott
    Oct 4, 2024 · So-called progressive Christianity is known for its revision of Christian teachings otherwise regarded as “traditional” or “conservative.” ...Missing: distinctions | Show results with:distinctions
  17. [17]
    A Warning for Progressive Christians: Interview with Dr. Roger Olson
    Jun 13, 2022 · Progressive Christianity is today most often a label used by (mostly) youngish Christianity who consider themselves “hip” and disconnected from ...Missing: distinctions | Show results with:distinctions
  18. [18]
    What is progressive theology? | GotQuestions.org
    Oct 31, 2024 · Progressive theology's priority of conforming to contemporary social values over the Bible signals a sharp departure from orthodox approaches to ...
  19. [19]
    "The Sources of Fundamentalism and Liberalism Considered ...
    Frieddrick Schleiermacher, the ninteenth century theologian, has been called the precursor of the liberal movement. When Schleiermacher stressed the primacy of ...
  20. [20]
    Kantian Concepts, Liberal Theology, and Post-Kantian Idealism - jstor
    A century of pre-ritschlian liberal theology centered on Kant, schleiermacher, and hegel fell out of this definition; more importantly for twentieth-century ...<|separator|>
  21. [21]
    A History of Liberal Christianity since the 19th Century and Its Impact ...
    Apr 11, 2021 · Liberal theology grew out of Enlightenment rationalism and ... progressive Christianity. Historically, liberal Christianity has also ...
  22. [22]
    [PDF] The First Faith-Based Movement: The Religious Roots of Social ...
    The paper opens with a brief exposition of the historical, religious and intellectual context from which the social gospel emerged, followed by a textual ...Missing: precursors | Show results with:precursors
  23. [23]
    The Rise of Protestant Liberalism - Tabletalk Magazine
    Schleiermacher's radical proposal that Christianity must adapt to its cultural milieu was the first of many liberal capitulations to evolving worldviews.
  24. [24]
    Progressive Ideology and the Downfall of Mainline Denominations
    May 8, 2024 · Traditionalist Christianity, spurned by the modernist leaders of mainline churches, is the best hope for the future.
  25. [25]
    Ecumenical Movement - Entry | Timelines | US Religion
    By the mid-20th century, the ecumenical movement continued with the founding of the World Council of Churches in 1948 as well as increasing ecumenical efforts ...
  26. [26]
    Before the Religious Right - Juicy Ecumenism
    Jun 6, 2022 · But for me, ecumenism is at the heart of both theological and political trajectory of this community from about World War I until the 1960's.
  27. [27]
  28. [28]
    "God Is Dead" Controversy - New Georgia Encyclopedia
    A popular debate over whether “God is dead” was occasioned by the so-called radical theology propounded in the 1960s.
  29. [29]
    “Death of God Theology” - Frame-Poythress.org
    May 17, 2012 · In the mid-1960s, counter-cultural radicalism was echoed in theology as a few thinkers adopted Nietzsche's slogan, “God is dead.” Thomas J. J. ...
  30. [30]
    Could God die again? | Nathan Schneider - The Guardian
    Oct 4, 2009 · "Death of God" theology was a movement that reached its peak in April 1966, when Time magazine published what became one of its biggest-selling ...
  31. [31]
    The Social Gospel and the Progressive Era, Divining America ...
    By the middle of the second decade of the twentieth century, the Progressive movement had begun to become more diverse in its sources and participants. In ...
  32. [32]
    The Regrets and Hopes of a (Just Barely) Baby Boomer Liberal ...
    Jan 11, 2023 · McKibben does have regrets about the loss of the liberal Christian mainline he knew. He is saddened how the balanced individualism which, in his view (a view ...Missing: theology developments
  33. [33]
    Keeping the Faith: Why a Progressive Faith Strategy ... - Proteus Fund
    Jan 21, 2025 · Since the rise of the “Moral Majority” in the late 1970's many in the progressive movements have abandoned the idea that faith can be ...<|separator|>
  34. [34]
    The False Teachers: Marcus Borg - Tim Challies
    Apr 9, 2014 · In 1985 Robert Funk founded the Jesus Seminar ... Progressive Christianity which differs from Evangelical Christianity in a number of important ...
  35. [35]
    Our History – ProgressiveChristianity
    Jan 23, 2024 · In 1994, ProgressiveChristianity.org began as The Center for Progressive Christianity; in 2010, we changed our name to ProgressiveChristianity.
  36. [36]
    Mainline Decline: 1990 to 2020 (#1989) - So What Faith
    May 18, 2022 · Mainline Protestant decline from 1990-2020 saw the Presbyterian Church (USA) decline by 58%, United Church of Christ by 52%, and Episcopal ...Missing: liberal 1980-2020
  37. [37]
    Chapter 1: The Changing Religious Composition of the U.S.
    May 12, 2015 · Today, just 15% of all U.S. adults identify with mainline Protestant churches, down from 18% in 2007. By comparison, evangelical Protestantism ...Missing: liberal 1980-2020
  38. [38]
    Does the Bible Matter? Progressive Christians and Scripture
    Jun 18, 2014 · The progressive Christian view of the Bible affirms: sometimes the Bible is wrong. Often this is implicit rather than explicit. It would be ...
  39. [39]
    Reading the Bible and the way of salvation - Progressive Christianity
    Apr 15, 2020 · The Core Values of Progressive Christianity · Leadership and ... We approach the Bible from a historical/critical method. We look at ...
  40. [40]
    PATHWAYS Theological Education, Inc. – ProgressiveChristianity
    The Core Values of Progressive Christianity · Leadership and Staff ... Using the historical-critical method of biblical interpretation, this course ...
  41. [41]
    Is the Bible Inerrant? Guest Post by Mike Licona
    In my journey, I have moved towards a John Dominic Crossan understanding of the Bible. As Crossan puts it, the Bible is parabolic from Genesis 1:1 to ...
  42. [42]
    What the Bible Is - The Marcus J Borg Foundation
    Jan 22, 2014 · Not affirming biblical inerrancy is one of the defining characteristics of progressive Christianity. In another sense, it is an issue. Many of ...
  43. [43]
    Minority View – ProgressiveChristianity
    Sep 9, 2022 · Progressive Christians are perfectly comfortable holding faith and science in harmony. For example, they believe God created the world but did so through the ...
  44. [44]
    Jesus viewed as a 'radical political critic' by scholar and author ...
    Oct 10, 2007 · "I see Jesus as a Jewish mystic," said scholar Marcus Borg, a leader in progressive Christian scholarship, in an interview Oct. 8.
  45. [45]
    Progressive Christianity Resource - The Marcus J Borg Foundation
    Reimagining a realistic and progressive Christianity for the 21st century. Built upon the historical and theological research of Marcus Borg.
  46. [46]
  47. [47]
    John Shelby Spong: In Memoriam - The Bart Ehrman Blog
    Oct 9, 2021 · But Spong did deny these views and insisted that other Christians needed to do so as well if they wanted to live and think as modern, educated, ...
  48. [48]
    John Shelby Spong | Fillmore Faith - TruthUnity.net
    Feb 4, 2024 · He was known for his progressive and controversial views on Christianity ... In sessions held at Unity Institute's 2008 Lyceum, Bishop Spong ...
  49. [49]
    Jesus: The Life, Teachings, and Relevance of a Religious ...
    $$11.89Jun 2, 2015 · In concluding his book, Marcus Borg stresses that how we see Jesus “affects how we see Christianity” and “shapes what we think the Christian ...
  50. [50]
    Beyond Atonement Theology – ProgressiveChristianity
    May 4, 2020 · Within the world of progressive Christianity, it is amazing how the ... In our Christian tradition, Jesus dying for our sins is known as atonement ...
  51. [51]
    What does salvation mean in Progressive Christianity?
    May 7, 2022 · “salvation” meant believing certain things in order to get certain rewards, especially the assurance of going to heaven.
  52. [52]
    Post-Progressive Christianity: Part 7, Salvation
    Jul 10, 2019 · Progressive Christianity does have a vision of salvation. Specifically, the progressive Christian view of Jesus' death is that Jesus is a moral exemplar.
  53. [53]
    Progressive Christians: Where and How They Differ with Jesus
    May 18, 2021 · Most progressives I know do not deny this; they simply believe Jesus had a wrong view of Scripture that was current for an Israelite in his time ...Missing: traditional | Show results with:traditional
  54. [54]
    Why Are Progressive Christians Attracted to Universalism?
    Dec 2, 2019 · Progressive Christians are drawn to a universal salvation for all people. There could be several reasons, such as religious pluralism, on which everyone has ...
  55. [55]
    How Do We Define 'Progressive Christianity'? - Religion Unplugged
    Aug 2, 2022 · PC, as defined by some of its leaders, denies the absolute authority of Scripture, stating that it is not the infallible word of God.
  56. [56]
    The Atonement is Core Christianity - John Piippo
    Oct 8, 2021 · Christ's death on a cross was the atoning sacrifice that reconciled us to God. The ethos of progressive Christianity is to deny this.
  57. [57]
    Progressive Christians: Beware of Liberal Theology (Part Two)
    Jul 19, 2022 · Liberal theology rejects the traditional doctrine that salvation comes to human beings through the atonement and resurrection accomplished in ...<|separator|>
  58. [58]
    Realized Eschatology | Walvoord.com
    Realized eschatology, introduced by C.H. Dodd, views eschatology as already fulfilled in Christ's life, death, and resurrection, with the kingdom of God ...
  59. [59]
    Living In The Now And Not Yet: Toward A Theology Of Progressive ...
    Jun 15, 2011 · Many of us who are seeking a faithful progressive Christianity are no more satisfied by a faith that apologizes for itself by fixating on a ...
  60. [60]
    What Do Progressive Christians Believe? - White Horse Inn
    Feb 10, 2021 · This movement seeks to re-interpret the Bible, re-assess historic doctrines, and re-define core tenets of the faith.
  61. [61]
    The Tragedy of Universalism: Why Not Everyone Is Saved
    Progressive Christianity often proclaims, “Love wins,” but avoids the biblical realities of sin, wrath, and hell. Teachers like Rob Bell have popularized ...
  62. [62]
    A few questions about progressive Christianity. : r/OpenChristian
    Feb 25, 2023 · There's a very wide range of eschatological beliefs among progressive Christians. ... Eschatology is the theology of death, afterlife and ...Progressive Christian take on hell? : r/OpenChristian - RedditAre these beliefs on the afterlife just cope? : r/OpenChristian - RedditMore results from www.reddit.com
  63. [63]
    The Eight Points in Process: Point Three – Theology and Spirituality ...
    20 Eyl 2012 · Progressive Christianity aspires toward a lively inclusiveness that transforms opposites into contrasts as it looks for holiness everywhere. The ...
  64. [64]
    Progressive Christianity: We're Open and Affirming!
    Apr 10, 2018 · Progressive Christians are open and affirming of LGBTQ+ individuals, as the Bible doesn't consider being LGBTQ a sin, and all people are ...
  65. [65]
    Why all Christians should support LGBTQ persons - Where Peter Is
    Jun 30, 2023 · Many progressive churches perform same-sex marriages, ordain openly gay ministers, and embrace theologies that allow for a more inclusive sexual ...
  66. [66]
    Progressive Voices of Faith: Creating LGBTQ+ Welcoming and ...
    Jun 15, 2023 · Progressive faith communities should support LGBTQ+ rights, be vocal, create safe spaces, and be active in support, not neutral, and ensure ...
  67. [67]
    I'm a Progressive Christian - Bayside Church
    6 May 2021 · Progressive Christianity is defined by several characteristics: a willingness to question, acceptance of human diversity; a strong emphasis on social justice.
  68. [68]
    Are Progressive Christians Countercultural? - STR.org
    Jan 9, 2024 · A progressive Christian claims that advocating for pro-gay and pro-trans theology is countercultural and courageous, but is it?
  69. [69]
    The Eight Points By Which Progressive Christianity Has Been Defined
    The task of Practical Theology can be presented as that of continually seeking mediatory paths, by means of mutual critical dialogue.Missing: 1980-2010 | Show results with:1980-2010
  70. [70]
    Updated 8 Points of Progressive Christianity – ProgressiveChristianity
    Jan 17, 2020 · Updated 8 Points of Progressive Christianity · By calling ourselves progressive Christians, we mean we are Christians who… · Leave A Comment ...
  71. [71]
    Social Justice Is a Christian Tradition — Not a Liberal Agenda
    Aug 11, 2015 · Sojourners is committed to faith and justice even in polarized times. Will you join us on the journey?Missing: priorities | Show results with:priorities
  72. [72]
    Progressive Christianity: The Cure for Pulpit Politics - Medium
    Aug 13, 2025 · Co-led by Rev. Dr. William Barber II, this national movement fights systemic racism, poverty, ecological devastation, and militarism. Faithful ...Missing: priorities LGBTQ
  73. [73]
    Progressive Evangelicals and the Pursuit of Social Justice | CFT
    Let's hope so. © 2015 by Christian Feminism Today. TAGS; Evangelical Issues · Historical Feminists · Progressive Christianity · Social Justice · Facebook.
  74. [74]
    Sojourners
    With our weekly newsletter you'll get the latest faith and justice news, commentary, and opportunities to take action.Magazine · Faith in Action for Social Justice · Latest Articles · Write for Sojourners!Missing: priorities | Show results with:priorities
  75. [75]
    Minority View - United Methodist Insight
    Aug 2, 2022 · Progressive Christians affirm full inclusion of LGBTQ people into the church, including same-sex couples and gay clergy. They point out that ...
  76. [76]
    Hope For Environmental Stewardship – ProgressiveChristianity
    As faithful stewards, we are obliged to do what we can individually, and to call for public policies that preserve the natural riches of our nation and our ...
  77. [77]
    Climate Hope Affiliates - United Church of Christ
    Through this new program, we are starting local chapters across the country to address the interconnected crises of climate change and societal injustice.<|separator|>
  78. [78]
    Christian Climate Action – Direct action, public witness for the climate
    We are a community of Christians supporting each other to take meaningful action in the face of imminent and catastrophic, anthropogenic climate breakdown.
  79. [79]
    Facts V Myths – Christianity and Climate Change
    Mar 13, 2025 · There's the National Association of Evangelicals' biblical call to address climate change, the National Council of Churches doctrine of ...
  80. [80]
    1. Religious beliefs about Earth and the environment
    Nov 17, 2022 · The most common response was related to stewardship, including preserving, loving or caring for the environment and people (29%). Many also said ...<|separator|>
  81. [81]
    A Progressive Christian Revolution - Good Faith Media
    Sep 17, 2025 · Progressive Christianity seeks to understand and embrace the authentic message of Jesus and to make progress towards the radical vision for the ...
  82. [82]
    Exploring Economic Justice Through a Progressive Christian Lens
    Oct 9, 2025 · Do Progressive Christians think about economic justice? Well, economic justice is the heart of the gospel. Actually, probably the heart of ...
  83. [83]
    The Progressive Critique of Free Markets: A Response
    Aug 1, 2018 · In short, Progressives argued that the moral core of the free market was deeply immoral. In our day, Ely's particular approach to economics ...
  84. [84]
    What We Believe - The Episcopal Church
    As Episcopalians, we believe in and follow the teachings of Jesus Christ, whose life, death, and resurrection saved the world.The Way of Love · The Book of Common Prayer · What We Do · Holy Communion
  85. [85]
    The Progressive Fundamentalism of the PCUSA - MinistryWatch
    Jul 25, 2024 · As one of the more theologically liberal Reformed groups, the PCUSA has been drifting in this direction for some time. More remarkable is how ...
  86. [86]
    Why thousands of congregations are leaving the United Methodist ...
    Dec 27, 2023 · Factions within the denominations split over disagreements in theology, namely, how the church considers LGBTQ+ ministers and congregants. In ...
  87. [87]
    People are quitting the United Methodist Church over its views on ...
    Dec 23, 2023 · Roughly a quarter of its 30,000 congregations in the U.S. are leaving over the church's views on marriage, sexuality and its position on LGBTQ ...
  88. [88]
    Decline of Christianity in the U.S. Has Slowed, May Have Leveled Off
    Feb 26, 2025 · Both Protestant and Catholic numbers are down significantly since 2007, though the Protestant share of the population has remained fairly level ...IV. Social and political views · Executive summary · Religious Landscape Study
  89. [89]
    Mainline Churches: The Real Reason for Decline - First Things
    Mar 1, 1993 · Nationwide data gathered in the mid-1960s showed that mainline Protestants not only held less orthodox views than did evangelicals, they also ...
  90. [90]
    Progressive and conservative evangelicals : r/OpenChristian - Reddit
    Oct 18, 2023 · Roughly until the 1970s progressive evangelicalism was the mainstream position of evangelicals in the USA. It wasn't as progressive as we would ...Leaving Evangelical Christianity Versus Becoming A Progressive ...Are there a lot of evangelical Christians who hold progressive views?More results from www.reddit.com
  91. [91]
    Jimmy Carter: The Last Progressive Evangelical - POLITICO
    Dec 29, 2024 · Progressive evangelicalism traces its roots to the teachings of Jesus in the New Testament and to a much earlier era in American history. Jesus ...
  92. [92]
    Are Progressives the New Evangelicals? - ifaqtheology
    Aug 12, 2022 · Let me make a prediction: Progressive Christianity will not become the new evangelicalism. When a departing evangelical runs out of ...
  93. [93]
    Progressive Christianity - Wikipedia
    Progressive Christianity, as described by its adherents, is characterized by a willingness to question tradition, acceptance of human diversity, a strong ...
  94. [94]
    After Pope Francis, Progressive Christians Feel Vulnerable
    Apr 24, 2025 · Catholics and Protestants who saw Pope Francis as a guiding moral figure are losing their voice.
  95. [95]
    How Could Pope Francis's "Progressive" Stances Impact the ...
    Oct 28, 2023 · Many liberal Catholics and some Vatican bureaucrats strongly supported the pope's openness to same-sex blessings. New Ways Ministry, an ...
  96. [96]
    Progressive Catholicism's Impact on Church Growth - Facebook
    Nov 21, 2023 · The increase in new Catholics is a positive sign, and it's exciting to see more people find solace and meaning in their faith. This trend ...Catholic Church's Progressive Changes and Impact on ChristianityRethinking what being Christian and Catholic means - FacebookMore results from www.facebook.com
  97. [97]
    Are there "progressive" Orthodox Christians that interpret the Bible ...
    Apr 7, 2020 · There are plenty of Orthodox priests and thinkers who believe evolution (or at least a form of it) is compatible with Christianity. Others do ...Eastern Orthodoxy and progressive values : r/RadicalChristianityWhat issues could a socially liberal convert face in the Eastern ...More results from www.reddit.com
  98. [98]
    The progressive captivity of Orthodox Churches in America
    Jun 12, 2013 · Christianity's secular counterpart – Progressive morality – has impressive fluency in the language of human compassion, in which ideas that ...
  99. [99]
    Progressive Orthodox Christianity | Facebook
    The Church teaches us to live the Gospel daily, not just in words, but in how we love, forgive, and persevere. Whether you're new to Orthodoxy or have grown up ...
  100. [100]
    The Center for Progressive Christianity: Take a Closer Look
    Nov 5, 2003 · The Center's founder is James R. Adams, for almost three decades ... Christians should see The Center for Progressive Christianity, not ...
  101. [101]
    Christian Deconstruction, Part 1 - Grace to You
    May 28, 2023 · There are heretical churches where the gospel is not taught, the deity of Christ is not believed—modern, liberal churches, we might call them.
  102. [102]
    What do Evangelical Christians think about progressive ... - Quora
    Jan 22, 2022 · Evangelicals believe in the centrality of the conversion or “born again” experience in receiving salvation, in the authority of the Bible as ...
  103. [103]
    What are the Cultural Signs of Progressive Christianity?
    Progressive Christianity tends to ebb and flow with culture, rather than following the historic Christian tradition of upholding biblical truth.
  104. [104]
    The Dangerous Progression of Progressive Christianity
    Jan 25, 2024 · At its core, then, progressive Christianity is dangerous because while it pursues its mission to have no belief be better than any other, it ...
  105. [105]
    5 Signs Your Church Might be Heading Toward Progressive ...
    ... evangelical Christianity, this takes the form of the "penal" theory ... against progressive Christianity. You state: "Historically, Christians have ...
  106. [106]
    [PDF] PROGRESSIVE CHRISTIANITY - Give - The Light FM
    Save the morality, ditch the doctrine. These same currents came to the United States and exploded on the church scene in the early 20th century. Liberals ...
  107. [107]
    Progressive Christians: Beware of Liberal Theology | ifaqtheology
    Jul 15, 2022 · Liberal theology adjusts doctrines to modern claims, is not biblical, and views the Bible as not authoritative, and Jesus as a religious human, ...Missing: accommodationism | Show results with:accommodationism
  108. [108]
    Why Progressive Christianity Can't Bring Reformation
    Oct 13, 2020 · The problem is never to get away from the Bible. The problem that progressive Christianity is more Bible. The problem of racist Christianity is ...
  109. [109]
    Christianity & Progressivism: A Pastor's Perspective
    A movement which has been and continues to be aimed at redefining the Mission of the Evangelical and Reformed Church as well as its Message.Missing: beliefs | Show results with:beliefs
  110. [110]
    A Defense of Progressive Christianity | by Eric Sentell - Medium
    Mar 10, 2022 · According to the critics, progressive Christians elevate personal happiness and fulfillment above the objective standards stated in the Bible.Missing: fundamental principles
  111. [111]
    5 Ways to Counter Progressive Christianity
    May 27, 2022 · “Progressive Christianity imitates culture, but Christians should imitate Jesus by recognizing and making a strong stand against the false ...
  112. [112]
    U.S. Church Membership Down Sharply in Past Two Decades
    Apr 18, 2019 · This article compares church membership data for the 1998-2000 and 2016-2018 periods, using combined data from multiple years to facilitate ...
  113. [113]
    Transmission of Faith in Families: The Influence of Religious Ideology
    Between groups, however, the differences are similar to those seen for children. Specifically, religious liberals have the lowest levels of worship attendance ( ...
  114. [114]
    There Is Almost No 'Liberalizing Religion' in the United States
    Jul 29, 2024 · Among yearly attenders, the conservatives start to take over compared to liberals (36% vs 25%). Among weekly attenders, 52% are conservative, ...
  115. [115]
    Attending church — even liberal ones — makes Americans more ...
    almost any church, even the liberal ones — makes people more conservative, Ryan Burge, an analyst of religion ...
  116. [116]
    Are Liberal Christians More Politically Engaged than Conservative ...
    Mar 11, 2024 · A liberal Christian was more than twice as likely to attend a protest or march (13% vs 5%), six points more likely to contact a public official, ...
  117. [117]
    Liberal-leaning churches are shrinking - Deseret News
    Jul 29, 2024 · Liberal-leaning churches are shrinking compared with many conservative churches. Membership data across faiths challenges those who argue that alignment with ...
  118. [118]
    Why Religion Matters: The Impact of Religious Practice on Social ...
    Strong and repeated evidence indicates that the regular practice of religion has beneficial effects in nearly every aspect of social concern and policy.<|control11|><|separator|>
  119. [119]
  120. [120]
    Marcus Borg – ProgressiveChristianity
    Borg, a professor of religion at Oregon State University, describes an alternative to fundamentalists' so-called "literal" readings of scripture. (He believes ...Missing: interpretation | Show results with:interpretation<|separator|>
  121. [121]
    John Shelby Spong – ProgressiveChristianity
    John Shelby Spong, bestselling author and Episcopal bishop of Newark, NJ, challenges the doctrine of the virgin birth, tracing its development in the early ...
  122. [122]
    Bishop John Shelby Spong: An Appreciation | Westar Institute
    Nov 10, 2021 · In his books on the New Testament, especially in Liberating the Gospels, Spong supported the theories of Michael Goulder, a British scholar and ...
  123. [123]
    CREATION SPIRITUALITY — Welcome from Matthew Fox
    In my book Original Blessing, published in 1983, I offer a list that contrasts the two traditions of Fall/Redemption Religion and Creation Spirituality.
  124. [124]
    Creation Spirituality - Daily Meditations with Matthew Fox
    CS is about recovering nature and all of creation as sacred again. It reaches back to the earliest humans who were struck with the awe of their existence.
  125. [125]
    Who Are The Nation's Top Progressive Christian Leaders? - Patheos
    Jul 27, 2022 · These are the Christian Leaders who are the most influential among Progressive Christians: Richard Rohr – His book The Universal Christ might be in the running ...
  126. [126]
    Who are the Rising Stars of Progressive Christianity?
    Jan 9, 2017 · The leading figures who came to my mind are the Jim Wallises, Brian McLarens, and Doug Pagitts of progressive Christianity who we already know.
  127. [127]
    Progressive Christianity - Monergism |
    Roots in Liberal Theology (19th Century): The roots of Progressive Christianity lie in liberal theology, which emerged in the 19th century, particularly through ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
  128. [128]
    Partner Organizations – ProgressiveChristianity
    Jun 16, 2025 · Progressive Christians Uniting (PCU) is a social justice and faith organization dedicated to amplifying hope and actions individuals can take ...
  129. [129]
    History of Sojourners
    In 2011, Sojourners co-founded the Circle of Protection, a group of Christian organizations and churches committing to protecting from budget cuts government ...
  130. [130]
    Our History | Sojourners
    In 1995, Sojourners founded Call to Renewal, with many other partners and organizations, to specifically focus on poverty by uniting churches and faith-based ...
  131. [131]
    Progressive Christian Alliance – an inclusive community ministering ...
    Welcome to the Progressive Christian Alliance. We are a network of people who strive to follow the teachings of Jesus. We come from various Christian ...
  132. [132]
    Convergence Music Project
    Convergence Music Project represents a "worship renaissance," bringing together a new generation of songwriters who are writing songs that are theologically ...
  133. [133]
    Southern Lights Conference
    On January 12 to 14, 2024, find respite in a sacred space to reimagine your faith and leave enriched, renewed, and challenged.
  134. [134]
    Southern Lights Conference (@SLConference25) / X
    Join us for the January 17-19, 2025 Southern Lights Conference for an Adventure in Progressive Christianity! Hilton Head, South Carolina ...
  135. [135]
    CONVERGING 2025 – ProgressiveChristianity
    Sep 3, 2025 · Sing Truth: Leadership For Resistance and Resilience. 3 Days of Powerful Talks, Inspiring Music, Provocative Workshops & Community-Building ...
  136. [136]
    Converging 2023 - Convergence Music Project
    Join us in Nashville, TN for Converging 2023, a gathering for musicians, pastors, worship leaders and anyone interested in justice-building, inclusive and ...
  137. [137]
    Mainline Protestantism's Fall? - Juicy Ecumenism
    Aug 25, 2025 · The membership of Mainline Protestant denominations has declined by millions, and thousands of churches have closed. Many more thousands of ...Missing: 2020-2024 | Show results with:2020-2024
  138. [138]
    The Decline of Mainline Churches in America - Ready to Harvest
    Oct 21, 2024 · By 2020 they fell under the two million mark to 1,861,000, or a 27% decline since 2000. That puts them in the same realm of decline as the ...
  139. [139]
    Progressive theology linked to Protestant decline, AP reports
    Mar 21, 2025 · Progressive theological shifts may be contributing to the steep declines in both membership and finances that mainline Protestant denominations in the United ...
  140. [140]
  141. [141]
  142. [142]
    The portrayal of religion in current media - The California Aggie
    Mar 18, 2020 · More progressive versions of Christianity, however, fare better in the public eye. For example, the first episode of the second season of ...
  143. [143]
    (DOC) Progressive Christian Social Media.docx - Academia.edu
    This essay explores how my wife, Rev. Abigail A. Henrich, and I use social media to advance progressive Christianity and inform people about Grace Community ...
  144. [144]
    The Cultural Signs of Progressive Christianity - Impact 360 Institute
    Progressive Christianity tends to flow with societal norms, removing biblical boundaries on sexuality, and using critical theory to recalibrate power.