Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Apache


The Apache are a group of culturally and linguistically affiliated Native American peoples who speak Southern Athabaskan languages and traditionally inhabited the arid landscapes of the American Southwest, including regions now encompassing Arizona, New Mexico, Texas, and northern Mexico.
Comprising subgroups such as the Western Apache (including White Mountain, San Carlos, and Tonto bands), Chiricahua, Mescalero, Jicarilla, and Lipan, they migrated into the area between approximately 1000 and 1500 AD, adapting to desert and mountain environments through semi-nomadic practices of hunting wild game, gathering mescal and other plants, and raiding for horses and captives to support their mobile bands.
Renowned for their martial prowess and guerrilla tactics, the Apache mounted prolonged resistance against Spanish colonization starting in the 16th century, Mexican independence forces, and U.S. military campaigns, with key leaders including Cochise and Geronimo of the Chiricahua band leading raids and defensive wars that defined the Apache Wars from 1849 to 1886.
These conflicts, driven by territorial encroachment, resource competition, and reprisals for Apache raiding economies that included scalping bounties and captive-taking, culminated in the Apache's forced surrender and relocation to reservations, yet tribal nations endure today, managing lands in Arizona, New Mexico, Oklahoma, and Texas while navigating federal policies and cultural preservation efforts.

Name and Etymology

Origins of the Term "Apache"

The exonym "Apache" derives from the Zuni term apachu, meaning "enemy," which applied to Athabaskan-speaking nomadic groups encountered as raiders in the Southwest. This usage reflects the perspective of settled communities viewing the mobile hunter-gatherers as adversaries, rather than a self-designation by the groups themselves. Spanish colonizers adopted and transliterated the term from Zuni and other languages, applying it broadly to unrelated nomadic bands perceived as threats to settlements and trade routes. European records first attest the term in Spanish documents around the early , such as "Apachu de Nabajo" in references to peoples east of the San Juan River in the 1620s, distinguishing them from groups. Earlier Spanish expeditions, like Vázquez de Coronado's in 1540–1542, encountered proto-Apache precursors termed Querechos—nomadic bison hunters in the —but did not yet use "Apache," reserving it for later identifications of raiding populations. The label thus carried inherent derogation, equating the groups with enmity and lawlessness from the vantage of both indigenous sedentary societies and European intruders, without denoting unified tribal identity. In contrast, the Athabaskan bands designated as "Apache" employed autonyms like or Ndee, translating to "the people," underscoring their own conceptions of and unbound by the exonym's adversarial framing. This disconnect highlights how the term originated externally, imposed on diverse, linguistically related peoples spanning modern , , and , rather than emerging from their internal ethnonyms or social structures.

Alternative Names and Self-Designations

The Apache bands employed diverse endonyms reflective of their localized identities, with no overarching self-designation encompassing all groups as a unified "Apache" entity; instead, most variants translated to terms denoting "the people" in their Athabaskan dialects, underscoring linguistic and regional fragmentation rather than cohesion. Western Apache bands, such as the White Mountain and San Carlos, commonly used Ndee or Indé, directly meaning "the people," to refer to themselves, a usage documented in ethnographic records from the late 19th and early 20th centuries that emphasized band autonomy over broader alliances. Eastern Apache groups exhibited similar variability, with the Jicarilla employing Jicarilla Dindéi or Haisndayin ("people who came from below"), terms rooted in oral traditions of emergence narratives specific to their northern and southern territories, as recorded in early anthropological fieldwork. The Lipan, ranging across the southern Plains into , incorporated Tinde or Indeh ("the people") in self-references, often qualified by descriptors like łépai ("light gray") to denote their band, per tribal historical accounts. Chiricahua bands favored Ndé or dialectal forms like Néndé and Héndé, again signifying "the people," with no evidence of hierarchical pan-Apache terminology in pre-contact or early contact-era self-perceptions derived from explorer journals and missionary reports. Spanish colonial documents from the 16th to 18th centuries, such as those from the Coronado expedition onward, aggregated these disparate bands under the exonym "Apache" for punitive campaigns and administrative mapping, conflating fluid, non-hierarchical local identities into a monolithic category for convenience, as evidenced by inconsistent band listings in archival records from and missions. American ethnographies, including those by figures like Edward E. Dale in the , corroborated this through interviews revealing band-specific naming without imposed unity, highlighting how external records prioritized conflict narratives over indigenous self-concepts. This diversity persisted into the reservation era, where groups like the retained Ndé variants, rejecting outsider unification as an artifact of colonial expediency rather than empirical social reality.

Historical Naming Difficulties

Spanish colonial records from the 16th and 17th centuries applied the term "Apache" broadly to nomadic raiders preying on Pueblo settlements and Spanish outposts, often without distinguishing Athabaskan-speaking groups from other mobile peoples, leading to conflation with non-Apache entities like early Comanche or Ute bands. For example, Francisco Vázquez de Coronado's 1541 expedition described "Querechos" as buffalo-hunting nomads in the Texas Panhandle, later retroactively associated with Apache precursors, though contemporary accounts lacked precise linguistic or cultural differentiation. Terms like "Faraon" or "Vaquero" were interchangeably used for hostile Apache subgroups east of the Rio Grande, reflecting Spanish administrators' focus on raid patterns rather than internal group coherency. Fluid alliances exacerbated these issues, as Apache bands formed temporary partnerships with Utes and s against shared enemies like or , only to fracture amid competition for horses and territory; by the early 1700s, Comanche expansion displaced many Apache groups southward, yet records inconsistently attributed raids to "Apaches" regardless of shifting coalitions. Mexican-era documents perpetuated this, lumping diverse bands under generic labels based on perceived enmity, ignoring autonomous band-level decision-making where one group's truce did not bind others. Such nomenclature prioritized settler security concerns over indigenous social structures, where band membership remained porous and alliances opportunistic. In the 19th century, U.S. Army reports compounded inaccuracies by aggregating disparate bands—and occasionally Navajos or Goshutes—under the "" umbrella for operational simplicity, emphasizing collective threat levels over ethnolinguistic distinctions or self-designations like Ndee ("the people"). This lumping contributed to erratic population estimates, with figures fluctuating due to untracked band fluidity and migrations, as dissatisfied individuals readily joined rival groups. Inconsistencies in spelling and orthography, stemming from field agents' phonetic renderings, further obscured identities; names like "Limita," "Conejero," or "Trementina" appeared for possibly overlapping eastern bands but faded as only "Lipan" and "" endured into U.S. documentation. The Office of Indian Affairs responded by compiling a standardized list of approximately 270 tribal names by the late 1800s, including variants, to streamline treaty-making and administration, though exclusions persisted for fluid or minor bands. Overall, these naming practices mirrored external biases toward viewing Apaches as undifferentiated adversaries, distorting records of their decentralized, adaptive polities.

Tribes and Bands

Eastern Apache Groups

The Eastern Apache groups encompassed the , Lipan, and (also called Apache or Naisha), who historically occupied territories east of the continental divide, spanning the southern and adjacent uplands in present-day , , , , and . These groups diverged from Western Apache bands through greater integration of Plains cultural practices, including horse-mounted communal hunts, use of tipis, and alliances with non-Apache Plains tribes, adaptations accelerated after Spanish introduction of horses in the late . The maintained seminomadic bands in the and surrounding plains of southern and northern from at least the early , combining foraging, small-scale agriculture influenced by neighbors, and raiding for sustenance and trade. Spanish colonial records document their presence in the region by the 1720s, with conflicts against and peoples shaping their mobility. The Jicarilla Reservation, established in 1887, covers 879,917 acres in north-central , where the tribe sustains economic activities including oil and gas leasing alongside cultural preservation efforts. The Lipan Apache, the easternmost Apachean people, ranged across the and southern Plains of from the , initially exploiting herds and engaging in trade with coastal groups before incursions disrupted their economy. By the , relentless warfare with , settlers, and later Texan militias reduced their numbers drastically; U.S. military campaigns in the 1870s, including cross-border raids into , scattered survivors southward, with an estimated 300 individuals remaining by 1875. Lipan descendants maintain cultural continuity through family networks in and , rejecting claims of tribal extinction. The Plains Apache, a numerically small band linguistically tied to other Apacheans, migrated onto the southern Plains by the 16th century and forged a protective alliance with the Kiowa around 1700, adopting tipis and Plains sign language while preserving Athabaskan speech and matrilineal clans. This confederation endured through the 19th century, with joint resistance against U.S. expansion culminating in the 1867 Medicine Lodge Treaty, which confined them to reservations in Indian Territory (Oklahoma). The federally recognized Apache Tribe of Oklahoma, descended from these Plains Apache, numbers fewer than 500 members today, centered in Anadarko.

Jicarilla Apache

The are a Southern Athabaskan-speaking people historically occupying regions in northern and southern , classified among the Eastern Apache groups. Their name, derived from "jicarilla" meaning "little basket," reflects their renowned skill in crafting small, watertight coiled baskets used for carrying water and other purposes. Traditionally nomadic hunter-gatherers, they subsisted on game such as deer, , and , supplemented by wild plants, with limited and in hides, meat, and basketry with neighboring like Taos and Picuris. The tribe is divided into two primary bands: the Olleros, or "potters," associated with mountain and valley terrains in the west, and the Llaneros, or "plains people," who ranged eastward toward the . Early interactions with Europeans began in the , marked by raids against Spanish settlements in response to encroachments and slave-taking expeditions, continuing through Mexican rule after 1821. Conflicts intensified with U.S. expansion following the Mexican-American War, culminating in the Jicarilla War of 1849–1855, where U.S. Army forces engaged Jicarilla bands in skirmishes across northern . A signed on July 31, 1855, at Abiquiu, , established U.S. recognition of Jicarilla lands and provisions for protection, though violations by settlers persisted. By 1887, the Jicarilla were confined to a reservation in north-central , expanded in subsequent years to encompass approximately 879,917 acres, primarily in Rio Arriba and surrounding counties, with tribal headquarters at Dulce. The Jicarilla Apache speak the Jicarilla dialect of the Apachean language branch, part of the Athabaskan family, with efforts ongoing to preserve it amid English dominance. As of recent records, the enrolled population numbers about 3,403 members, with most residing on the . The tribal has transitioned from ranching and subsistence to include gaming operations, oil and gas leasing, , and , supporting under a ratified in 1937. Cultural practices emphasize matrilineal clans, traditional ceremonies like the Girl's Puberty Rite, and of natural resources, including a large herd managed for .

Lipan Apache

The Lipan Apache, an Eastern subgroup of the Apache peoples, historically occupied the Southern Plains extending from southern through northwest and into , with primary territories in central and eastern by the . They divided into bands such as the Forest Lipan, who settled in northeastern from the to the upper , and the Plains Lipan, who ranged along the upper and Concho rivers. As nomadic hunters, they adapted hides for clothing, tents, and other necessities, transitioning to mounted warfare and raiding after acquiring horses from sources in the early 1600s, which positioned them among the first Plains groups to do so. Lipan society emphasized kinship-based bands led by chiefs selected for prowess in raiding and diplomacy, with cultural practices including matrilineal clans and ceremonies tied to seasonal migrations for hunting and gathering mescal, roots, and wild game. Spanish colonial records from the 1700s document frequent conflicts with settlers and rival Comanche, who displaced Lipan bands westward; by 1762, Spanish missions in Coahuila housed Lipan refugees, though many resisted assimilation and continued raids into Texas. U.S. expansion in the 19th century intensified pressures, culminating in military campaigns; in 1873, U.S. forces under Ranald Mackenzie crossed the Rio Grande to attack allied Lipan and Kickapoo villages, scattering survivors. By 1875, their population had dwindled to approximately 300 individuals across scattered Texas and Mexican communities. In the , Lipan survivors integrated with Mescalero Apache on reservations or formed enclaves in and , preserving oral traditions amid loss of federal recognition. The Lipan Apache Tribe of Texas, representing persistent communities in and the Valley, maintains cultural continuity through advocacy for land rights and heritage, though exact contemporary population figures remain unenumerated in official records due to historical and lack of tribal enrollment criteria. Ethnohistorical analyses highlight their resilience, with descendants numbering in the thousands across mixed-heritage families in , , and .

Plains Apache (Kiowa Apache)

The , also known as the or Kiowa Apaches, are a small Southern Athabaskan-speaking historically ranging across the southern in areas of present-day southwestern Oklahoma, the , and northeastern . Their language, a divergent of the Apachean subfamily, is with only a handful of fluent speakers remaining as of the early . They maintained a nomadic buffalo-hunting lifestyle, utilizing tipis and horses acquired through trade and raiding, while distinguishing themselves from neighboring Plains s through their Athabaskan linguistic and cultural roots. Originating from Athabaskan groups near the , the migrated southward in pursuit of bison herds, separating from related bands and reaching the of before continuing to the Southern Plains by the late 17th century. They formed a symbiotic alliance with the around this period, functioning as a de facto band within Kiowa society for protection against larger foes like the , with minimal intermarriage but shared practices such as the sun dance and camp circles. This partnership endured through conflicts, including participation in the on November 25, 1864, and culminated in joint treaties with the , such as the Treaty of Camp Holmes in 1837 and the of 1867, which confined them to a reservation in southwestern . Culturally, the Plains Apache emphasized warrior societies, medicine people, and women's roles in managing tipis and family goods, alongside four principal dancing societies: Kasowe, Manatidie, Klintidie, and Izuwe. Post-reservation allotment under the Dawes Act reduced their communal lands from nearly 3 million acres to about 32,643 acres by the early 20th century, prompting cultural adaptations amid boarding school policies and land loss. Today, they are federally recognized as the Apache Tribe of Oklahoma, with tribal headquarters in Anadarko and an enrollment of approximately 1,800 members concentrated in Caddo and Comanche counties. The tribe preserves traditions like the Blackfoot Dance and Rabbit Dance while addressing language revitalization efforts.

Western Apache Groups


The Western Apache groups include the Western Apache proper along with the Chiricahua and Mescalero Apache, forming the southern division of Apache peoples distinguished from eastern groups like the Jicarilla and Lipan by dialect and adaptive practices to arid Southwest environments. These groups shared Athabaskan linguistic origins, matrilineal social structures, and economies blending foraging, hunting, raiding, and supplementary farming, with populations adapting to rugged terrains in Arizona, New Mexico, and northern Mexico since at least the 16th century. The Western Apache subtribes—White Mountain, San Carlos, Cibecue, Northern , and Southern —occupied the mountains and high desert (32–35°N, 109–112°W), encompassing headwaters of the , , Little , and Gila rivers. Their subsistence integrated 40% wild plants, 35% game such as deer, and 25% , involving seasonal migrations and wickiup shelters. Over 50 matrilineal clans, grouped into three phratries, enforced and , supporting flexible band-level organization for resource exploitation and defense. By the 1980 , White Mountain numbered 6,870 on the Fort Apache Reservation, while San Carlos totaled 5,795 on their reservation.
The ranged across southeastern , southwestern , and , structured into bands including the Bedonkohe (led by ), Chokonen (led by ), Chihenne (led by and ), and Nehdni (led by ), each comprising local groups of roughly 30 extended matrilineal families handling autonomous governance, warfare, and ceremonies. With a pre-contact population of 1,000–1,500, they migrated southward from Athabaskan northern origins, arriving in the Southwest by approximately 1500, coinciding with incursions, and sustained themselves via hunting, gathering, and limited . The Mescalero Apache foraged across southern and western , deriving their name from heavy use of mescal agave hearts for sustenance, and lived as nomadic hunters and warriors in temporary wickiup brush shelters. Ethnographer documented five intermarrying bands—Nataina, Tuetinini, Tsihlinainde, Guhlkainde, and Tahuunde—each led by a chief and subchief. Their current reservation boundaries were formalized in 1873 in , following displacement from broader ranges.

Western Apache

The Western Apache are Southern Athabaskan-speaking indigenous peoples whose traditional homeland centers on the mountainous regions of east-central Arizona, including areas around the White Mountains, Black River, and San Carlos Valley. They lack a distinct native self-designation as a unified group, instead referring to themselves collectively as Ndee ("the people"), a term shared with other Apache groups. Ethnographers classify them into five main bands: White Mountain (or Coyotero), Cibecue, San Carlos, Northern Tonto, and Southern Tonto, each with localized dialects and adaptive subsistence strategies suited to diverse terrains from high plateaus to desert fringes. Western Apache society is matrilineal, with , , and traced through the mother's line, organized into over 60 exogamous clans grouped into three phratries derived from ancient founding lineages. Their economy historically combined of corn, beans, and with deer and small game, gathering wild plants, and seasonal raiding for horses and goods, reflecting adaptation to arid environments while maintaining mobility. Spiritual beliefs center on neutral supernatural powers inherent in natural phenomena, invoked through rituals like vision quests and curing ceremonies led by knowledgeable practitioners, rather than a centralized priesthood. Contemporary Western Apache populations total approximately 25,000 enrolled members across federal reservations established in the , including the White Mountain Apache Tribe of the Fort Apache (about 15,000 members), San Carlos Apache Tribe (enrollment over 15,000, with roughly 10,000 residing on-reservation), and smaller Tribe at Camp Verde. The , comprising mutually intelligible dialects, persists with around 6,000 speakers, though intergenerational transmission faces challenges from English dominance. Since contact in the , they navigated colonial disruptions to networks, later resisting U.S. campaigns until reservation confinement by 1886, while preserving cultural practices amid economic shifts to , , and gaming.

Chiricahua Apache

The Chiricahua Apache constituted a major band of Southern Athabaskan-speaking peoples, primarily occupying territories in southeastern Arizona, southwestern New Mexico, and northern Sonora, Mexico, encompassing rugged mountain ranges and desert lowlands conducive to their mobile lifestyle. Subdivided into four principal bands—Bedonkohe, Chokonen, Chihenne, and Nednhi—each maintained distinct local groups of 10 to 50 families, adapting to specific locales like the Chiricahua Mountains or Warm Springs areas. Prior to intensified conflicts in 1861, their population numbered around 1,200, sustained through hunting large game such as deer and antelope, gathering wild plants including mescal, and limited horticulture of corn, beans, and squash, supplemented by raiding for horses and goods. Chiricahua social structure emphasized matrilineal clans and extended family units, with leadership emerging from skilled warriors and rather than hereditary chiefs; decisions involved among band headmen. Religious practices centered on animistic beliefs, with ceremonies invoking power through chants, pollen blessings, and vision quests to ensure success in warfare or healing. Dwelling in portable wickiups framed by poles and covered in brush or hides, they relocated seasonally to exploit resources, fostering resilience against environmental and external pressures. Prominent figures like , a Chokonen band leader in the mid-19th century, and (Goyathlay), a Bedonkohe warrior and born around 1829, exemplified resistance to , conducting guerrilla campaigns against , , and U.S. forces until Geronimo's surrender in 1886. Post-confinement at sites like Fort Marion and Barracks, survivors were allocated to the Mescalero Apache Reservation in or emerged as the in , where descendants preserve cultural elements amid federal recognition challenges. By the late , warfare and disease had diminished their numbers to over 2,000 individuals of descent, reflecting adaptation rather than extinction.

Mescalero Apache

The Mescalero Apache, self-designated as Nde or Indé ("the people"), constitute a Southern Athabaskan-speaking band traditionally inhabiting the Sacramento Mountains, Sierra Blanca, and adjacent regions of south-central , with seasonal extensions into western and . Their name derives from the term for their staple use of mescal agave (), whose crowns were harvested, roasted in earthen pits, and consumed as a primary carbohydrate source, supplemented by and bear grass. As nomadic hunter-gatherers, they pursued , , , and smaller game while employing expert guerrilla tactics and horsemanship adapted after introduction of in the . Historical records indicate the Mescalero's early presence in the Southwest by the 16th century, with interactions escalating into raids against Spanish settlements from the 1700s onward, driven by competition for resources and resistance to encroachment. During the Mexican period post-1821 and U.S. territorial expansion after 1848, they participated in the broader Apache Wars, including a notable 1861 victory over Confederate troops at Fort Davis and alliances with leaders like Victorio of the Warm Springs band. Post-1870s subjugation, disbanded groups from Lipan, Chiricahua, and other Apache bands merged with Mescalero survivors, forming the basis of the contemporary tribe. The U.S. government established the Mescalero Apache Reservation on May 27, 1873, encompassing 463,000 acres primarily in Otero County, New Mexico, where remaining bands were consolidated by military escort. The modern Mescalero Apache Tribe, federally recognized since 1873, comprises descendants of the titular band alongside Lipan and sub-bands, with an enrolled population of approximately 7,000 as of recent estimates. Tribal governance emphasizes sovereignty, with economic self-sufficiency achieved through enterprises such as the Inn of the Mountain Gods resort-casino and Ski Apache, generating revenue from on lands. Cultural preservation includes maintenance of traditional practices like agave harvesting and ceremonies tied to sacred sites in the Sierra Blanca massif, despite pressures from historical and policies. Notable figures include Wendell Chino, tribal president from 1959 to 1998, who expanded holdings through land purchases and litigated for resource rights.

Relations with Neighboring Peoples

The Apache maintained complex, often opportunistic relations with neighboring indigenous groups, characterized by alliances against common foes, territorial competitions, and resource-driven raids rather than ideological enmity. Athabaskan-speaking kin such as the frequently cooperated with bands in raids on sedentary communities, exploiting the latter's agricultural surpluses and vulnerability following disruptions; for instance, warriors, allied with Apaches, pillaged villages in the 17th and 18th centuries to acquire , textiles, and . Such collaborations stemmed from shared linguistic and cultural ties, enabling coordinated strikes on weaker, more stationary targets to supplement mobile foraging economies. Conflicts with equestrian Plains tribes like the intensified after the widespread adoption of around 1700, as and raids displaced Apache groups from buffalo-rich territories in and the , driving them southward into more arid zones. These clashes centered on control of horse herds and grounds, with Comanche expansion—fueled by superior horse-breeding and warfare tactics—eclipsing Apache influence on the Southern Plains by the mid-18th century, as evidenced by reports of Apache retreats and Comanche dominance in trade networks. Raiding patterns prioritized economic gain, targeting settlements with undefended livestock or crops, reflecting a pragmatic calculus of risk and reward over ethnic vendettas. Interactions with Spanish colonial and early populations blended predation and commerce, with bands conducting raids on northern and missions for horses, tools, and , whom they then or traded back through established networks for guns, cloth, and metal . Pre-independence trade fairs, such as those at Taos and Pecos, facilitated exchanges where Apaches delivered or —often women and children—for payments or sale, sustaining Apache economies amid environmental and integrating captives into when ransoms failed. This captive economy, documented in archival records from the 1750s onward, underscored raiding as a rational resource extraction strategy against softer colonial frontiers, rather than indiscriminate aggression.

Origins and Prehistory

Linguistic and Genetic Evidence

The form the Southern Athabaskan (also termed Apachean) subgroup within the broader Athabaskan family of the , spoken by groups originating from northern . Glottochronological methods, which estimate divergence times based on lexical retention rates, place the split of proto-Southern Athabaskan from Northern Athabaskan varieties at approximately 1000 years , or around 1000 , indicating a proto-Apachean language emerging in the centuries prior to their documented presence in the Southwest. This aligns with linguistic reconstructions showing shared innovations, such as specific verb morphology and tone systems, unique to Apachean dialects but absent in more northern relatives like or Gwich'in. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) analyses of Apache and closely related Navajo populations reveal predominant haplogroups A2, B2, C1, and D1—founding Native American lineages derived from migrations—with subclade frequencies (e.g., elevated C1c and A2a) that cluster them genetically nearer to northern Na-Dene speakers than to pre-Athabaskan Southwest groups like the or . Y-chromosome studies further support this, showing Athabaskan-specific markers (e.g., haplogroup C-P39 derivatives) at higher frequencies among Apacheans compared to Uto-Aztecan or Puebloan neighbors, with overall autosomal profiles indicating limited pre-contact from local Southwest populations, consistent with a migratory influx disrupting established agricultural societies rather than gradual assimilation. Such genetic distinctiveness, combined with the recency of linguistic divergence, refutes notions of prolonged in-situ evolution and points to a directed expansion from Canadian or Alaskan proto-Athabaskan hearths southward, likely involving displacement of resident groups. Apache oral traditions, corroborated by linguistic retentions of northern toponyms and migratory motifs, depict ancestral movements marked by conflict and raiding against predecessors, reflecting a mobile, martial adaptation suited to subarctic-to-arid ecological shifts rather than peaceful tropes advanced in some mid-20th-century ethnographies influenced by assimilationist paradigms. This warrior-oriented ethos in origin narratives aligns causally with genetic evidence of minimal , suggesting competitive exclusion during phases around 1200–1500 CE, as inferred from ceramic and microblade artifact discontinuities in the . Empirical data thus prioritize a model of aggressive proto-Apachean dispersal over diffusionist alternatives lacking supporting phylogenies.

Migration into the Southwest

Proto-Apachean groups, descendants of Northern Athabaskan-speaking peoples from the and , entered the American Southwest from the north between approximately 1300 and 1500 CE, as evidenced by archaeological finds of mobile tool kits, including projectile points and campsites, in regions like and the southern Plains that precede their appearance in core Southwest territories. This involved small, kin-based bands adapting to arid environments through , , and opportunistic raiding, rather than organized or mass displacement of local populations. The proto-Apachean influx aligned with the decline and abandonment of Jornada Mogollon sites in southern and around 1400–1450 CE, following prolonged droughts that disrupted agricultural systems and led to the depopulation of villages and pueblos previously occupied by these sedentary farmers. Incoming groups exploited the resulting ecological vacancies by establishing seasonal camps in mountainous and riparian zones, employing adaptive strategies such as resource raiding from remnant Puebloan communities to supplement wild plant gathering and , without evidence of widespread cultural overthrow. Oral histories among historic bands, corroborated by linguistic divergence patterns, describe ancestral journeys southward across rivers and mountains, motivated by the pursuit of game-rich territories amid northern resource pressures. By the early 1600s, Apache acquisition of horses—initially through with bands who obtained them from colonial outposts and intermediaries—transformed their mobility, enabling extended raiding circuits, swift retreats into rugged terrain, and efficient transport of goods across the Southwest's diverse landscapes. This adaptation amplified their foraging radius and tactical flexibility, allowing bands to thrive in marginal environments where prior sedentary groups had faltered, as documented in early accounts of horse-mounted "Querechos" (proto-Apache) dominating southern Plains routes by mid-century.

Early Interactions with Puebloans and Others

The earliest recorded interactions between proto-Apache groups and peoples occurred during the Coronado expedition of 1540–1542, when Spanish explorers encountered the Querechos, nomadic hunters identified by historians as ancestors of the Plains Apaches, in the southern High Plains region of present-day and . These Querechos inhabited the , living in tipi-like structures made from tanned hides and specializing in procurement, which they processed for trade. They exchanged products with the Teyas, semi-sedentary groups possibly related to Puebloan or Caddoan speakers, facilitating indirect economic ties to settled agricultural communities in the Southwest. As Athabaskan-speaking groups, including early , migrated southward into the Southwest during the 15th and 16th centuries, they established direct trade networks with villages, bartering meat, hides, and later horses for , , and other agricultural goods. These exchanges reflected the complementary economies of nomadic hunters and sedentary farmers, though underlying tensions arose from resource competition in arid environments prone to . Spanish colonization disrupted these patterns by discouraging -Apache trade and compelling Pueblos to redirect to colonial authorities, fostering Apache resentment and escalating raids on villages for foodstuffs and captives. Following the of 1680, which expelled Spanish forces from and weakened Pueblo defenses amid famine and crop failures, groups intensified raids on villages to acquire corn, tools, and technology. This period marked a shift toward dominance in the regional power dynamics, as they leveraged mobility—enhanced by obtained through raiding—to extract resources systematically, often targeting stored harvests and fields. While some interactions involved coerced arrangements resembling protection against rival nomads like Utes or Navajos, primary evidence emphasizes initiative in these opportunistic seizures rather than mutual alliances.

Historical Conflicts

Wars with Spanish Colonizers

colonists in initiated conflicts with groups through slave raids in the early 17th century, capturing dozens for labor in mines despite royal bans, as in 1659 when Governor Bernardo López de Mendizábal dispatched over 70 men and women for sale. These enslavements provoked retaliatory strikes, such as the 1653-1656 raids on Jemez that killed 19 and captured 35, alongside theft of horses and . The introduction of horses around 1600 transformed warfare, enabling mobile hit-and-run tactics; by 1608, raids on herds had so discouraged that they petitioned to abandon the . proliferation under ranching further incentivized depredations, with Apaches stealing 200 animals near El Paso in 1682 alone, depleting herds and forcing into vulnerability. To counter guerrilla raids, erected presidios like those requested in for frontier defense and formalized in to shield pueblos, yet these outposts proved ineffective against nomadic attackers exploiting vast terrains for ambushes and swift withdrawals. parties plundered missions and settlements, as in 1672-1679 incursions that depopulated six pueblos including Cuarac and Humanas through herd theft and killings of Christian Indians, contributing to over 450 famine deaths in Humanas by 1668 amid disrupted . punitive campaigns frequently failed due to overextension, with troops unable to match mobility or prevent recurring strikes on isolated garrisons and herds. By the late 18th century, amid Comanche threats and drought, Spanish policy shifted under Comandante General Bernardo de Gálvez's 1786 regulations, establishing eight peace outposts (establecimientos) near presidios where approximately 2,000 Apaches, including Mescaleros in 1787 and Chiricahuas in 1790, settled for rations, gifts, and captive returns in exchange for ceasing raids. These arrangements provided temporary pacification through provisioning rather than conquest, but both parties violated terms—Apaches via opportunistic small-scale raids during shortages, Spaniards through inconsistent supplies—sustaining low-level conflict into the early 19th century. Apache hit-and-run efficacy, rooted in horsemanship and terrain knowledge, consistently outpaced Spanish efforts, as evidenced by persistent depredations despite militarized frontiers.

Conflicts with Mexican Independence Era

Following Mexico's achievement of independence from in 1821, Apache conflicts with Mexican authorities intensified as the new government, facing economic difficulties and political instability, discontinued the Spanish colonial system's subsidies and presidios that had previously restrained Apache raiding. This policy vacuum allowed various Apache groups, including the and Gila Apaches, to expand cross-border incursions into , , and adjacent territories, targeting , , and supplies with greater frequency and scale than during the late era. Raiding activity surged in the , reaching a peak in the , as bands exploited disarray from internal wars and weak garrisons to plunder ranchos, camps, and trails. These operations resulted in thousands of deaths—approximately 5,000 killed and 4,000 displaced between 1820 and 1835 alone—and contributed to the depopulation of rural districts, with particularly devastated as settlements were abandoned amid relentless depredations from 1831 to 1849. warriors, organized in mobile bands, struck deep into territory along plunder trails southward, seizing horses and cattle from major ranch systems and disrupting silver trade routes, which crippled local economies and halted demographic expansion in the north. Mexican responses underscored their desperation and limited capacity for sustained campaigns. In , Sonora's government established bounties of 100 pesos for an adult male , 50 pesos for a female, and 25 pesos for a child, a measure that evolved from earlier incentives and spurred irregular scalp-hunting parties, though it often failed to distinguish between raiders and peaceful Apaches. Chihuahua similarly authorized scalp expeditions, as evidenced by a 1849 company of over 50 hunters operating across the border into territories. Such tactics reflected broader Mexican vulnerabilities, including fiscal insolvency and preoccupation with central rebellions, enabling Apaches to maintain tactical superiority until the onset of the U.S.-Mexican War in redirected external pressures.

Apache Wars Against the United States

The against the commenced in earnest after the Mexican-American War (1846–1848), as American settlers and military forces entered territories long utilized by Apache bands for raiding and sustenance in the Southwest. The 1848 transferred vast areas from to U.S. control, exposing Apache groups to intensified encroachment by miners, ranchers, and overland emigrants seeking resources like water sources, grazing pastures, and mineral deposits. These economic pursuits directly competed with Apache lifeways, which relied on mobility and periodic raids for livestock and goods, prompting retaliatory strikes on isolated settlements and wagon trains. Military dispatches from the era document how such expansion disrupted Apache access to traditional economic niches, escalating from sporadic skirmishes in the late 1840s to sustained campaigns by the . The 1853 Gadsden Purchase, acquiring approximately 29,670 square miles of land in present-day and for $10 million to secure a southern route, markedly heightened border raids by bands exploiting the porous U.S.- frontier. Apaches targeted emerging camps and ranches, seizing and vital to their operations, while U.S. authorities abrogated prior Mexican obligations to curb such incursions, shifting full responsibility northward. This period saw empirical spikes in depredations, with Army reports noting dozens of attacks annually on supply lines and outposts, driven by the realist imperative of resource scarcity rather than abstract hostilities. Apache resilience manifested in leveraging and strongholds, evading conventional pursuits and prolonging conflicts despite numerical disadvantages. U.S. Army responses evolved into resource-denial strategies, including the systematic destruction of wickiups, stored foodstuffs, and cultivated fields to erode raiding capacity, as detailed in operational logs from frontier departments. By the 1860s, efforts like the Bosque Redondo internment (1864–1868) aimed to concentrate and other Apache groups on the , but logistical failures—crop shortfalls from alkaline soil and drought, compounded by disease and inadequate rations—led to mass escapes, with most Mescaleros fleeing by early 1865. Scale underscored the mismatch: Apache warrior bands rarely exceeded a few hundred across dispersed groups, confronting U.S. forces that committed thousands of troops from multiple regiments, backed by allied scouts, over the war's span. Through the and into the , sustained campaigns reflected settler demands for secure expansion, with units employing pack-mule logistics for deep penetrations into arid terrains, yielding high casualties—over 1,600 documented in the alone—against fewer than 400 U.S. military losses in comparable engagements. This asymmetry highlighted causal drivers: adaptability prolonged resistance, but overwhelming U.S. manpower and industrial supply chains, fueled by booms and drives, systematically degraded their operational base.

Key Leaders and Resistance Strategies

Apache resistance during the relied on guerrilla tactics, emphasizing mobility, terrain advantage, and small-unit raids to counter numerically superior U.S. forces. Leaders like coordinated multi-band operations, allying with figures such as to launch coordinated ambushes and evade large-scale engagements, preserving warrior numbers through hit-and-run maneuvers in the . These strategies exploited the Apaches' intimate familiarity with arid landscapes, allowing bands to disperse into remote canyons and reemerge for opportunistic strikes, often targeting supply lines and isolated settlements. Geronimo exemplified evasion tactics in his 1885-1886 campaign, leading a small band across the U.S.- border to outmaneuver pursuers, with U.S. troops numbering around 5,000 covering thousands of miles in futile chases through hostile terrain. Raiding served as a pragmatic economic mechanism, procuring horses for enhanced mobility—essential for sustaining nomadic warfare—and livestock to supplement dwindling resources disrupted by encroachment, rather than purely destructive intent. warriors leveraged skills, including proficiency in early on, which provided rapid, accurate fire superior to unreliable firearms in hit-and-run scenarios, enabling them to harass foes before retreating. Allied scouting networks, drawing from sympathetic bands like certain groups prior to their enlistment by U.S. forces, facilitated on enemy movements, though such collaborations were fluid and often reversed. However, internal fractures undermined cohesion; divisions between reservation-compliant bands and hostiles led to betrayals, with some Apaches serving as U.S. scouts—such as Tonto recruits tracking renegades—providing critical that enabled decisive captures. Captive narratives and diaries document Apache practices of torturing prisoners, including slow deaths by arrows or exposure, as or to deter pursuit, reflecting the brutal reciprocity of raiding economies rather than exceptional . These elements highlight resistance as a resource-constrained calculus, effective in prolonging conflict but vulnerable to infiltration and overextension.

Surrender and Forced Relocation


Geronimo, leader of a small band of Chiricahua Apache, surrendered to General Nelson A. Miles on September 4, 1886, in Skeleton Canyon, Arizona Territory, marking the effective end of organized Apache resistance against the United States. This capitulation followed a campaign intensified by U.S. Army pursuits enabled by telegraph networks for coordinating troop movements across vast terrains and the adoption of repeating rifles, which provided superior firepower over the Apaches' traditional weapons and limited ammunition supplies. Despite Apache tactics of evasion and ambush, these technological and logistical edges allowed the U.S. forces to wear down the warriors through relentless pressure, culminating in Geronimo's decision after evading capture for months. Following the surrender, approximately 500 Chiricahua Apache, including and his followers, were designated prisoners of war and transported eastward to for confinement, with Geronimo's group held at near Pensacola and others at Fort Marion in St. Augustine. Unaccustomed to the , the prisoners experienced sharp increases in mortality from and other respiratory illnesses, with at least 24 deaths recorded in the first year alone and over a third succumbing rapidly in some subgroups. In 1887, the survivors were relocated to Barracks in , where disease continued to claim lives, including that of warrior from . By 1894, the remaining Chiricahua were divided and transferred: many to the Fort Sill area in Oklahoma Territory alongside Comanche and Kiowa reservations, while select groups, such as Mescalero Apache swept up in the 1886 captures, were permitted returns to reservations in New Mexico and Arizona starting in 1888. These relocations reflected U.S. policy to disperse resistant elements away from ancestral lands, prioritizing containment over rehabilitation, with the Oklahoma placement intended as a permanent exile for the most defiant. The process underscored the logistical exhaustion of Apache bands, outmatched by the U.S. military's capacity for sustained operations across borders.

Reservation Era and Adaptation

Establishment of Reservations

The government's reservation policy in the 1870s sought to concentrate Apache bands on designated lands to curtail raiding and facilitate assimilation, reflecting a paternalistic approach that prioritized federal control over tribal autonomy. The San Carlos Reservation, established by in along the in , was intended to house multiple groups including Western Apache, Yavapai, and Chiricahua bands, totaling over 1.8 million acres but featuring arid terrain prone to and inadequate infrastructure. This site quickly earned the moniker "Hellhole" among Apaches due to harsh environmental conditions, disease outbreaks, and administrative failures, prompting widespread escapes and resistance; for instance, Chiricahua Apaches forcibly relocated there in 1876-1877 largely deserted amid poor rations and health crises. Federal ration systems, meant to enforce dependency and encourage sedentary farming, often faltered under mismanagement, as seen in the 1884 winter when supplies failed to reach San Carlos residents despite promises, exacerbating starvation and factional desertions that prolonged conflicts into the . Such paternalistic oversight—rooted in assumptions of superior administrative capacity—causally contributed to elevated mortality from infectious diseases like and , with reservation confinement disrupting traditional mobility and foraging that had sustained Apache populations. By the late 1890s, similar reservations like Fort Apache (formally separated from San Carlos in 1897) housed remaining bands, but overall Apache numbers had declined sharply from pre-reservation estimates of around 10,000 amid wars and relocations to approximately 6,000 by 1900, underscoring the policy's empirical toll through disease and nutritional deficits rather than success. The General Allotment Act of 1887 (), enacted February 8, further entrenched fragmentation by dividing lands into individual 160-acre parcels for heads of households, with "surplus" acres opened to non- settlement, eroding communal tenure central to Apache matrilineal and resource use. Applied to Apache reservations, this measure accelerated land loss—contributing to a national pattern of over 90 million acres alienated from tribes by 1934—while fostering dependency on inconsistent federal aid, as allottees lacked capital or tools for viable agriculture in marginal soils, critiquing the act's flawed causal premise that private ownership would inherently promote self-sufficiency. By the , these policies had confined most surviving Apaches to reservations like San Carlos, , and Jicarilla, marking a shift from nomadic resistance to enforced sedentism amid ongoing demographic pressures.

Cultural Suppression and Resistance

Following the surrender of Apache leaders like Geronimo in 1886, the United States government intensified efforts to assimilate Apache populations on reservations through policies aimed at eradicating traditional cultural practices. Boarding schools, such as the Carlisle Indian Industrial School established in 1879, forcibly removed Apache children from their families, with groups like the Chiricahua Apache arriving in 1886 for "training" that included cutting their hair, issuing military-style uniforms, and prohibiting the use of native languages. These institutions enforced English-only instruction and Western customs under the explicit philosophy of "kill the Indian, save the man," resulting in documented cases of physical punishment for speaking Apache dialects and high rates of illness and death among students due to poor conditions and separation from kin. The federal government further suppressed Apache culture through the 1883 Code of Indian Offenses, which criminalized traditional religious ceremonies, dances, and healing rites on reservations, enforcing instead Christian missionary influences and individualized family structures alien to matrilineal kinship systems. This legal framework reflected a broader strategy post-Apache Wars, where agents monitored and punished adherence to customs deemed "heathenish," leading to the clandestine preservation of sacred knowledge by elders. Apache resistance manifested in selective, covert adaptations that preserved core identity amid coercion, including the secret transmission of oral traditions, songs, and rituals despite surveillance. While government programs promoted farming as a means of sedentary , some Apache bands pragmatically incorporated limited —drawing on pre-reservation influences from neighbors— to sustain communities on marginal reservation lands, demonstrating agency rather than wholesale capitulation. Influences from movements like the , which spread to southwestern tribes in the early 1890s promising cultural renewal, encouraged sporadic Apache participation in round dances as symbolic defiance, though suppressed by authorities fearing renewed unrest. These strategies allowed partial cultural continuity, countering total by balancing overt with hidden .

Economic Shifts and Government Policies

The of 1934 facilitated the establishment of formal tribal councils among several Apache groups, enabling structured self-governance and economic organization on reservations. For instance, the Mescalero Apache Tribe adopted a tribal constitution under the , consolidating Mescalero, Chiricahua, and Lipan bands into a unified entity with an eight-member council, elected president, and vice president serving two-year terms, which supported coordinated resource management and enterprise development. Similarly, the San Carlos Apache Tribe's modern governmental framework originated from IRA provisions, allowing tribal input on federal projects and promoting business cooperatives over prior allotment policies that fragmented lands. These councils shifted economic focus from pre-reservation raiding and nomadic toward regulated and incipient labor, though implementation varied by due to differing rates. While stock reduction programs under the primarily targeted overgrazing on lands, analogous federal interventions affected herds to enforce sustainable grazing, paralleling broader efforts to transition from subsistence to commercial operations. groups on reservations like San Carlos faced pressure to cull , reducing reliance on traditional that had supplemented raiding economies, and redirecting labor toward off-reservation seasonal work in and by . This causal shift prioritized ecological limits and market integration over unchecked expansion, averting but constraining self-sufficient animal-based income streams akin to experiences. Empirical data from the era indicate cattle holdings dropped significantly post-intervention, compelling in alternative crafts like basketry and for tourist markets, though yields remained marginal without . Post-World War II relocation programs, formalized by the 1952 vocational training initiatives and the 1956 Indian Relocation Act, encouraged Apache individuals to migrate to centers like and for industrial jobs, aiming to foster through into the broader economy. Over 122,000 , including Apaches, relocated between 1940 and 1960, with approximately 31,000 receiving assistance for housing and placement; however, many encountered mismatches and cultural , leading to high and rather than sustained labor . For Apache participants, this causally undermined reservation-based by depleting labor pools needed for tribal crafts and , while outcomes often trapped families in subsidized , as evidenced by persistent return migration rates exceeding 50% within five years due to inadequate preparation for competitive job markets. In the , termination policies threatened to dissolve federal recognition for certain tribes, ending and services, but Apache groups successfully averted inclusion through lobbying and demonstrated economic viability. House Concurrent Resolution 108 of 1953 initiated termination for over 100 tribes, transferring lands out of and eliminating aid, yet major Apache entities like the White Mountain and Jicarilla maintained via organized and partial adoption of wage economies, avoiding the fate of terminated groups that lost over a million acres collectively. This preservation enabled continued shifts toward reservation wage labor, with and San Carlos Apaches increasingly engaging in tribal , tourism crafts, and off-reservation by the late 1950s, reflecting pragmatic over policy-induced dissolution. Tribal hiring preferences in these enterprises underscored entrepreneurial responses to pressures, prioritizing internal labor retention against external relocation incentives.

Modern Era

Tribal Sovereignty and Legal Battles

The shift toward tribal in the post-World War II era marked a departure from earlier assimilationist policies, enabling Apache tribes to assert greater control over internal affairs while navigating federal oversight. The Indian Civil Rights Act of 1968, enacted as Title II of the broader Civil Rights Act, extended key constitutional protections—such as , equal protection, and freedom from unreasonable searches—to individuals within tribal jurisdictions, subject to tribal sovereignty limits like one-year maximum detention without federal habeas review. This legislation addressed documented abuses in some tribal governance but preserved tribes' inherent authority, applying to Apache nations like the San Carlos and without diminishing their adjudicative powers. The Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975 further empowered tribes by authorizing contracts and compacts for managing federal programs previously handled by the , including health, education, and resource development. implementations included the Tribe's assumption of education services in the and San Carlos control over programs, yielding measurable outcomes like improved school retention rates from 60% to over 80% in participating districts by the 1990s, though administrative challenges persisted due to funding shortfalls. Legal affirmations of bolstered these efforts; in Merrion v. Tribe (1982), the U.S. upheld the tribe's authority to impose severance taxes on non-Indian oil and gas lessees, reinforcing inherent powers over resources. Similarly, New Mexico v. Tribe (1983) preempted state hunting regulations on lands, prioritizing federal-tribal compacts. Water rights litigation exemplified empirical victories amid ongoing disputes. Under the Winters doctrine reserving water for reservations, Apache tribes pursued settlements in the 1990s; the San Carlos Apache Tribe Water Rights Settlement Act of 1992 quantified the tribe's entitlements at 28,000 acre-feet annually, ratified a compact with , and established a $62 million trust fund for , averting protracted . The Jicarilla Apache Tribe's parallel 1992 settlement secured 2,908 acre-feet from the , enabling economic diversification. These compacts resolved claims dating to 19th-century reservations but required federal appropriations, with delays in funding exposing vulnerabilities to congressional inaction. Criticisms of tribal implementations highlight tensions between and . Tribal courts, while , have drawn for procedural opacity, as ICRA's remedies rely on rather than direct oversight, leading to inconsistent enforcement. Specific cases underscore internal governance issues; in Nation proceedings documented in Gallegos v. Jicarilla (ongoing as of 2020s filings), plaintiffs alleged pervasive misconduct in tribal police and judicial processes, including suppression, prompting calls for enhanced ICRA habeas without eroding . Such instances, while not representative of all tribes, reflect causal challenges from limited external audits, contributing to reluctance in fully delegating programs despite gains.

Oak Flat Mining Controversy

The Oak Flat mining controversy centers on the proposed project, an underground targeting one of the world's largest undeveloped deposits beneath Oak Flat, a 2,400-acre parcel of land in . In December 2014, Section 3003 of the authorized the U.S. Department of the Interior to transfer Oak Flat and adjacent lands to Mining LLC—a of Rio Tinto and —in exchange for 5,344 acres of private land elsewhere in , facilitating projected to yield 1.9 billion pounds of annually for at least 40 years. Proponents emphasize the project's role in securing domestic critical minerals essential for , , and technologies, amid global vulnerabilities. Opposition, led by the nonprofit Apache Stronghold representing San Carlos Apache Tribe members and other Western Apaches, contends that Oak Flat—known as Chi'chil Biłdagoteel—is a sacred site integral to religious practices, including ceremonies for rites, offerings, and ancestral connections dating back . Activists argue the mine's block-cave extraction method would collapse the surface into a 2-mile-wide, 1,125-foot-deep crater, permanently destroying these features and violating the (RFRA) and First Amendment by substantially burdening religious exercise without adequate justification. The U.S. Forest Service's Final , released June 17, 2025, acknowledges direct and permanent damage to cultural resources and groundwater depletion in a water-stressed region, with potential affecting up to 5 square miles, though it proposes like relocation of some artifacts and water monitoring. Critics, including environmental groups, highlight risks of contaminating aquifers, drawing parallels to historical legacies in . In Stronghold v. United States, filed in 2021, courts consistently ruled against the plaintiffs, finding the land exchange served compelling government interests in and security that outweighed religious claims under RFRA's exceptions for management. The Ninth Circuit upheld this in March 2024, and the denied on May 27, 2025, with Justices Gorsuch and dissenting on grounds that prior precedents undervalued free exercise protections; a petition for rehearing was denied in October 2025, effectively clearing the path for transfer absent further intervention. Economically, the project is forecasted to create 1,500 direct jobs with $149 million in annual payroll, plus 2,200 indirect jobs, generating $61 billion in economic output over its life and $120 million yearly in state-local taxes, bolstering Arizona's -dependent communities. Historically, territories overlapped mineral-rich zones where policies favored expansion, including 19th-century displacements for prospectors, underscoring recurring tensions between tribal cultural priorities and extraction imperatives on public lands. prioritization of mineral development reflects causal realities of , where copper demand—driven by —necessitates domestic production over preservation of sites with contested sacred status among multiple groups.

Recent Land Exchanges and Claims

In November 2024, the Yavapai-Apache Nation completed a land exchange with the U.S. Forest Service, acquiring approximately 3,200 acres of National Forest System lands adjacent to its reservation near , in exchange for 4,782 acres of non-contiguous inholdings. This transaction nearly tripled the tribe's trust land holdings from 1,810 acres to over 5,000 acres, enabling improved land consolidation, expanded housing opportunities, and enhanced management of cultural and natural resources without relying on prolonged litigation. The exchange, negotiated over decades, prioritized practical benefits such as contiguous acreage for tribal over symbolic disputes, resulting in verifiable increases in reservation territory that support economic independence. Similarly, the Mescalero Tribe proposed a land swap with the State Land Office in 2025, seeking to reacquire ancestral lands designated as state trust properties in exchange for equivalent value parcels. This initiative aims to restore traditional territories while adhering to state revenue requirements, demonstrating a strategy of mutual exchange that yields tangible territorial gains rather than indefinite claims. Such agreements have empirically expanded footprints in the , countering historical diminishment through targeted negotiations that secure usable assets. The U.S. Supreme Court's decisions in 2025, including denials of petitions in Apache Stronghold v. , rejected arguments for halting land transfers based solely on religious objections, affirming that federal processes prevail absent substantial evidence of irreparable harm. These rulings underscore a causal pattern where persistent litigation has shifted toward asset recovery via settlements and exchanges, as seen in the Yavapai-Apache case, rather than vetoing developments outright, thereby fostering pragmatic expansions in tribal land bases. For the San Carlos Apache Tribe, ongoing water rights implementations from prior settlements have indirectly bolstered land claims by quantifying usufructuary entitlements, though recent emphases remain on yielding concrete allocations over expansive .

Economic Developments

The of 1988 enabled tribes to establish through tribal-state compacts negotiated in the 1990s, marking a pivotal shift toward gaming as an economic engine for self-sufficiency. The Apache Tribe's Inn of the Mountain Gods Resort and , operational since 2002, generates annual revenues estimated at $36.5 million, supporting tribal services and per capita distributions. Similarly, the Nation's Apache Nugget contributes through slot machine revenues, though it ranks among the lower earners among tribes, with fiscal year 2018 slots at under $10 million. The San Carlos Apache Tribe's Apache Gold has funded scholarships and job creation, injecting millions into reservation economies. Gaming has modestly reduced on successful Apache reservations, creating hundreds of jobs and lowering rates from over 50% in the pre-IGRA era to 20-40% in gaming-active tribes like the Mescalero and San Carlos, though overall reservation unemployment remains elevated at around 40-50% due to and limited diversification. Revenues support , clinics, and , yet critics note uneven benefits, with elite tribal capturing disproportionate shares via salaries and contracts, exacerbating internal inequalities. Problem has also risen, straining community resources despite regulatory oversight. Complementing gaming, resource-based economies persist on Western Apache lands, particularly timber harvesting and livestock . The White Mountain Apache Tribe's forestry operations yield $30-40 million annually, employing over 500 tribal members in and milling. San Carlos Apache lands prioritize timber over since the 1940s, generating income amid federal oversight of sustainable yields. These sectors promote self-reliance but face environmental constraints and market volatility. Despite these gains, Apache tribes exhibit partial self-sufficiency, with and resources offsetting some federal reliance but not eliminating it; annual federal transfers for , and welfare exceed $100 million across major reservations, underscoring ongoing dependence amid high rates above 40%. Tribes invest revenues in diversification, such as and , to reduce vulnerability to gaming fluctuations.

Cultural Revitalization Efforts

Apache tribes, particularly the White Mountain Apache, have sustained and promoted the Crown Dance (also known as Gaan or Mountain Spirit Dance) through organized performances at cultural events, festivals, and educational programs in the , with groups like the White Mountain Apache Crown Dancers conducting ceremonies that invoke ancestral spirits and reinforce community bonds. These efforts, documented in public demonstrations as recent as 2023, emphasize transmission to youth via structured rehearsals and participation, yielding measurable participation rates at tribal events exceeding dozens of performers annually. However, such revivals adapt traditional forms to contemporary venues, including intertribal gatherings, amid ongoing generational knowledge gaps from prior policies. Immersion-based cultural education initiatives, such as those integrated into youth programs on reservations like , prioritize hands-on learning of ceremonial practices, storytelling, and resource stewardship, with facilities like the Mescalero Cultural Campus established to centralize these activities since the early 2000s. These programs report enrollment of school-aged children in structured sessions, fostering skills in traditional crafts and rituals, though empirical assessments indicate variable retention rates influenced by economic migration and English-dominant schooling. Repatriation under the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA) of 1990 has driven Apache efforts to reclaim sacred objects from museums, as seen in the and San Carlos Apache tribes' prolonged dispute with the over 77 items, including ceremonial masks, initiated around 2009 and unresolved by 2013 due to debates on whether artifacts qualify as inalienable cultural patrimony or retain scientific value for study. While partial returns have occurred—contributing to tribal museums' collections—disputes underscore causal tensions between repatriation's cultural imperatives and museums' arguments for retention to preserve empirical data on pre-contact practices, with federal review committees mediating but not always resolving claims swiftly. Overall, these revitalization measures reflect selective adaptation rather than wholesale restoration, as historical via boarding schools and has eroded uniform transmission, with success metrics like event attendance and object returns coexisting alongside persistent losses in esoteric knowledge. Tribal prioritizes pragmatic outcomes, such as integrating traditions into and for , over idealized preservation amid demographic shifts.

Culture and Society

Social Structure and Kinship

Apache societies were organized into autonomous bands and groups, emphasizing flexibility and in rather than centralized or hereditary chiefs. Leaders, often selected for demonstrated , raiding , and persuasive , held contingent on group approval and could be challenged or replaced if faltered. This structure supported adaptive responses to nomadic pressures, with bands operating independently across territories while forming temporary alliances for warfare or ceremonies. Kinship was predominantly matrilineal among groups like the Western Apache, with descent traced through the mother's line and membership in determined matrilineally. Clan exogamy was rigorously observed, prohibiting within the same clan to forge inter-clan ties and extend reciprocal obligations. Residence patterns were typically matrilocal, where a relocated to his wife's family's camp, reinforcing maternal associations and cooperation in daily survival. This system promoted social cohesion within local groups of 20–30 , varying slightly by subgroup; for example, leaned bilateral, organizing relations generationally with self-reciprocal terms beyond parent-child bonds. Gender roles maintained division of labor but allowed situational flexibility, particularly in warfare where men led raids while women occasionally scouted, tracked enemies, or defended camps during absences. Notable women like , sister of Chief , exemplified this by using intuitive abilities to locate foes and participating in , diverging from routine female duties to aid band security. Such roles underscored the pragmatic adaptability of Apache , prioritizing survival over rigid norms.

Subsistence Economy

The subsistence economy prior to reservation confinement centered on a mobile, opportunistic strategy combining , gathering, and minimal , with raiding serving as a key mechanism for resource acquisition from sedentary neighbors. provided approximately 35% of the diet for groups like the Western Apache, focusing on deer and other game pursued by small bands using , and communal drives, while avoiding and certain animals deemed . Gathering wild contributed around 40% of caloric intake, emphasizing seasonal exploitation of mescal hearts roasted in large pits, piñon nuts and berries harvested in late fall, acorns, beans, and fruit, which supported band movements across arid terrains. Limited accounted for the remaining dietary portion in some Apache subgroups, such as small irrigated fields under one cultivating corn, beans, and , but Mescalero Apache eschewed farming entirely, relying instead on trade or raids with communities for , beans, squashes, and . This aversion to large-scale stemmed from the causal priority of : sedentary farming would constrain band dispersal needed for tracking game migrations and exploiting dispersed wild resources, rendering groups vulnerable to rivals. Raiding, viewed as rational predation, exploited asymmetries between Apache and the fixed assets of agriculturalists, yielding not only foodstuffs but also and , thereby optimizing caloric returns without investment in . The introduction of by colonizers in the mid-16th century, with widespread adoption by the late 1600s, fundamentally enhanced this system by amplifying mobility and logistical capacity. facilitated rapid traversal of Southwest landscapes, enabling extended pursuit of like for plains-oriented groups and transforming raiding from sporadic acquisition to a surplus-generating enterprise, where stolen herds and goods exceeded immediate needs and could be traded or accumulated. This shift causally decoupled subsistence from environmental limits, prioritizing predatory extraction over self-sufficient production and solidifying nomadic flexibility as the economic core.

Hunting, Gathering, and Agriculture

The Apache subsistence economy centered on hunting and gathering wild resources, supplemented by limited agriculture in select groups. Men typically conducted hunts using self-bows made from mulberry or cedar wood strung with sinew, paired with arrows fletched from turkey feathers and tipped with stone or bone points for larger game such as deer and elk, while throwing sticks—curved wooden clubs hurled with spin—were employed for pursuing rabbits and other small mammals. Hunting deer involved individual or paired stalking, often with disguises like deer-head masks, and adherence to rituals such as avoiding certain plants to maintain scent neutrality and orienting the carcass eastward post-kill to honor spiritual protocols. Women handled gathering, focusing on ethnobotanical staples like (mescal), which provided a nutrient-dense source through labor-intensive processing: crowns were excavated in May or June using sharpened sticks, then roasted for 24-36 hours in shallow pits lined with stones, , and firewood covered by grass and hides, yielding a fibrous, sweet pulp that could be pounded, dried, and stored in parfleches for months. Other gathered items included fruits, hearts (similarly pit-roasted and fermented), pods for flour, and wild seeds, with seasonal campsites shifting to exploit peak availability across arid mountains and plains. Agriculture was sporadic and marginal, practiced mainly by groups like the Jicarilla and Western Apache in sheltered canyons with digging sticks to plant small plots of corn, beans, , and pumpkins, often acquired via raids on or settlements rather than innovation; fields received minimal tending, such as occasional weeding or floodwater diversion, and yields were insufficient to support settled villages. This hybrid system reflected adaptation to the Southwest's variable , where foraging yielded high caloric returns from mescal—up to several hundred pounds per communal pit roast—but demanded intensive seasonal labor without reliable surpluses. The reliance on wild resources fostered chronic variability in food supply, as nomadic mobility tracked ephemeral and cycles but exposed bands to droughts or poor mast years, generating periodic shortages that strained local and incentivized external acquisition strategies over intensified farming. Empirical accounts from early 20th-century ethnographers note that mescal processing, while efficient for short-term storage (one crown equating to 10-20 pounds of edible product), could not buffer against broader ecological fluctuations without supplementary inputs, underscoring the causal link between foraging's inherent unpredictability and the Apache's semi-migratory patterns.

Raiding Practices and Warfare

Apache raiding constituted a core economic strategy, supplementing hunting and gathering through targeted acquisition of , , and goods from and settlements, particularly from the late 17th to mid-19th centuries. Raiding parties, typically comprising 5 to 15 warriors from local bands, emphasized mobility and surprise via small-group ambushes and , often striking at dawn or in remote areas to disable mounted defenders and seize herds before retreating into rugged terrain. was paramount, as equines—initially obtained through raids on —enhanced transport, warfare capability, and trade value, enabling Apache bands to sustain nomadic lifestyles in resource-scarce environments despite limited . Captives formed another key raiding objective, with women and children frequently integrated into Apache society as laborers, spouses, or adoptees to bolster band demographics and productivity, as evidenced in accounts like that of , captured in 1851 and tattooed per custom before partial assimilation. Adult male captives, conversely, were often subjected to ritualized —such as staking, volleys, or slow burning—serving as , deterrence, or communal rather than , which was rarer and typically limited to high-value exchanges with settlers. These practices, far from romanticized notions of restrained conflict, reflected pragmatic brutality: integration expanded kin networks amid high mortality, while executions minimized threats, though historical narratives from European observers may exaggerate for propagandistic effect. Raiding extended to inter-band feuds among Apache groups, where competition fueled ambushes and theft, alternating with and perpetuating cycles of retaliation that fragmented alliances. Economically, such activities sustained dispersed bands by redistributing via stolen goods and captives, but causally provoked escalated and Mexican countermeasures—including bounties and punitive expeditions—that verged on eradication efforts, underscoring raiding's role in provoking existential threats rather than mere survival harmony.

Religion and Cosmology

Apache cosmology centers on a pervasive life force or power, known as diyin, which permeates the natural world and can be harnessed by individuals through visions, rituals, or direct encounters with supernatural entities. This power is not abstract mysticism but tied to observable outcomes such as protection from enemies, success in hunting, or recovery from illness, with acquisition often requiring solitary quests in remote locations where seekers fast and await revelatory dreams or spirit visitations. Shamans, or diyin, derive their abilities from these sources, enabling them to diagnose and treat ailments by manipulating supernatural influences, though misuse of such power for personal gain classifies one as a witch (ilkashn). The Mountain Spirits, or Ga'an, hold a prominent role as benevolent intermediaries sent by the creator deity Usen (Life Giver) to instruct the in harmonious living and defense against threats. In ceremonial dances, masked performers embody these spirits, channeling their protective essence through rhythmic movements, chants, and symbolic to invoke , heal the sick, or safeguard the community during times of peril, as documented in ethnographic accounts of Western Apache practices. These rituals emphasize , where the dancers' precise emulation of spirit attributes purportedly transfers efficacy to participants, fostering empirical correlations between ceremony and survival advantages in arid environments. Beliefs surrounding underscore a causal in avoiding malevolent remnants of the deceased. Ghosts ( in related Athabaskan traditions, adapted by Apache) are viewed as resentful entities capable of inflicting harm on the living, prompting strict taboos such as rapid abandonment of dwellings where occurs and avoidance of the deceased's name or possessions to prevent spirit attachment. Among the Chiricahua Apache, the spirit embarks on a four-day to the , during which survivors observe purification rites to neutralize any lingering malice, reflecting a pragmatic aversion to unseen causal agents of misfortune rather than abstract . In the , some Apache bands exhibited , blending traditional power quests with elements of or the (incorporating sacraments for visionary insight), particularly post-reservation era when influences intersected with frameworks for healing and . This adaptation, observed in ethnographic studies of Mescalero and Jicarilla groups, preserved core causal mechanisms—like power acquisition for tangible benefits—while integrating Christian narratives of , though traditional cosmology remained dominant in ceremonial contexts.

Material Culture

Housing and Clothing


Apache dwellings, known as wickiups, were dome- or cone-shaped structures typically measuring 10-12 feet in diameter and 9-10 feet in height, constructed for semi-nomadic use. Women built these using peeled green willow or oak poles driven into the ground and arched to form the frame, covered with thatched brush or bear grass bound by yucca strands, with an excavated interior floor 12-18 inches deep and a smoke hole at the apex. Functionality prioritized portability and rapid assembly, allowing relocation of poles to new sites, with added animal hides or canvas for winter insulation against cold. Summer variants included open brush shades with wattle sides. Traditional clothing emphasized durability from local hides, suited to arid environments and . Men wore buckskin breechcloths in summer and full outfits including long and in winter, paired with high moccasins featuring hard soles, upcurving toes, and soft uppers extending to the thighs. Women donned two-piece buckskin dresses or short hip-length with V-necks, often beaded in red, white, and black patterns with tin pendants, alongside matching moccasins. Post-contact, Apaches incorporated commercial cloth for and dresses while retaining buckskin for ceremonial wear, reflecting pragmatic adaptation to traded goods without abandoning functional hide-based designs.

Tools and Technology

Apache tools derived from lithic materials emphasized sharpness and for and , with prized for its fracturing to razor edges in points and knives, sourced from regional volcanic deposits and knapped into blades for cutting hides or . Archaeological assemblages confirm 's prevalence in Southwestern sites associated with ancestral Apache, used in composite tools like hafted scrapers for functionality in semi-arid resource extraction. Weapons included sinew-backed bows 4-5 feet long, reed-shaft s tipped with flint or points often poisoned for efficacy in warfare or , and rawhide-wrapped stone war clubs. Basketry represented advanced vegetal technology, with women coiling or twining , , , or into watertight jars, burden carriers, and storage vessels, pitched for liquid containment and featuring geometric designs for structural integrity. These served multifunctional roles in transport and food preparation, evidencing empirical adaptations to gathering economies. Post-contact, Apaches integrated metal implements like iron knives and axes obtained through raiding or , enhancing cutting efficiency over stone while —adopted by the early —facilitated expanded tool transport and warfare logistics, altering material dependencies without supplanting core lithic and traditions.

Housing and Clothing

Traditional Apache housing primarily consisted of wickiups, semi-permanent dome-shaped or conical structures built for mobility in arid and semi-arid environments of the American Southwest. These dwellings were constructed using a framework of flexible poles, typically from oak or willow trees, driven into the ground in a circular pattern and bent inward to form the dome, with additional poles lashed crosswise for support using sinew or plant fibers. The exterior was covered with layers of brush, grass, reeds, or occasionally hides to provide insulation and weather protection, allowing quick assembly and disassembly suited to the Apache's nomadic or semi-nomadic lifestyle. Wickiups varied slightly by Apache group and region; for instance, Western Apache wickiups often featured a bulged conical shape with carefully selected curved poles for structural integrity, as observed in ethnographic studies on the . Some Plains-oriented Apache bands, such as the Apache, adopted tipis influenced by interactions with Plains tribes, using hide-covered pole frames for greater portability during extended raids or hunts. These structures were typically oriented with entrances facing east to align with cultural beliefs about the dawn and renewal. Apache clothing was crafted from animal hides, predominantly buckskin from deer or antelope, reflecting practical needs for durability, warmth, and camouflage in rugged terrains. Men traditionally wore breechcloths secured with a belt, paired with leggings and moccasins for mobility, and in cooler seasons, added buckskin shirts or tunics often fringed for functionality and decoration. Women donned two-piece outfits including a poncho-like blouse with a circular yoke and fringe along the sides, complemented by skirts or dresses, all made from tanned buckskin to allow freedom of movement for gathering and child-rearing tasks. Adornments included beads, shells, and quills for ceremonial or status purposes, with variations across groups; for example, men sometimes incorporated yellow pollen-dyed buckskin bands over the shoulder for distinction. By the mid-19th century, trade introduced cloth elements like skirts for women and white shirts with red for men, blending indigenous techniques with European textiles while retaining core buckskin components for everyday use. Moccasins, essential for foot protection over rocky ground, were soft-soled with hard uppers in some designs, often decorated with painted or quilled patterns denoting band affiliation.

Tools and Technology

The Apache relied on a variety of traditional weapons for and warfare, primarily the , which were crafted from locally available materials. Bows were constructed from or mulberry wood, often reinforced with sinew for added strength and flexibility. Arrows featured shafts of wood or , tipped with stone points prior to contact, and were carried in buckskin quivers slung over the left shoulder for right-handed drawing. Other weapons included lances for thrusting, war clubs made from wood or , and stone-tipped spears, reflecting adaptations to their mobile, raiding-based lifestyle across arid terrains. Post-contact, Apaches incorporated metal arrowheads and firearms like muskets, enhancing their effectiveness against settlers and rival groups. Daily tools encompassed stone and bone implements for processing food, hides, and wood. Stone axes, bone knives, wooden mallets, and hand scrapers were used for butchering game, scraping hides, and , with stone tools persisting into the historic period due to their durability and cultural continuity despite metal alternatives. For among groups like the Western Apache, simple digging sticks served as primary implements for planting crops such as corn and beans in river valleys. Technological practices in crafting extended to basketry and , essential for storage and transport in their semi-nomadic existence. Apache women wove burden baskets using a twining technique with or shoots, forming conical shapes for carrying gathered , , or , often dyed with extracts for decoration. , though less emphasized than among neighboring Pueblos, involved coiled construction of jars and bowls from local clays, fired in open pits to create utilitarian vessels for cooking and storage. These technologies underscored the Apache's resourcefulness, leveraging natural materials without reliance on until influence.

Languages

Athabaskan Language Family

The Apache languages constitute the Southern Athabaskan (also termed Apachean) subgroup within the Athabaskan family, which forms the largest branch of the Na-Dene language phylum spanning western North America. The Na-Dene phylum, first hypothesized by Edward Sapir in 1915 based on shared lexical and morphological resemblances such as pronouns and verb paradigms, links Athabaskan with Eyak (extinct) and Tlingit, while the inclusion of Haida remains debated due to insufficient cognate density for robust phylogenetic support. Linguistic trees derived from glottochronology and shared innovations typically position Northern Athabaskan languages (spoken across Alaska, Yukon, and subarctic Canada) as the earliest diverging branch, followed by Pacific Coast Athabaskan (in Oregon and northern California), with Southern Athabaskan emerging later as a cohesive clade evidenced by innovations like the merger of certain proto-vowel contrasts. This divergence pattern aligns with archaeological and genetic data suggesting proto-Athabaskan speakers originated in the Mackenzie River basin around 2000–1000 BCE before southward migrations. Athabaskan languages, including Apachean varieties, exhibit polysynthetic structures where a single form encodes , object, tense, , , and elements through up to four prefix zones and a disyllabic , yielding thousands of variants per for nuanced descriptions. This complexity arises from agglutinative prefixation, with "disjunct" prefixes (iterative, thematic) positioned distally and "conjunct" prefixes (valency, classifier) proximally, a template reconstructed to Proto-Athabaskan via comparative reconstruction of over 200 cognate sets. Many Athabaskan languages, particularly in the south, developed register tones (high, low, rising, falling) through tonogenesis, where Proto-Athabaskan fricatives and glottals conditioned pitch distinctions on vowels, as documented in systematic comparisons of stem alternations across branches. For instance, low-tone markers in Southern forms correlate with lenited consonants in Northern cognates, supporting a unitary innovation model over independent developments. Comparative vocabularies from 20th-century fieldwork, building on Edward Sapir's and Harry Hoijer's analyses of Apachean stems (e.g., motion verbs like łééch'ąąʼí 'run around' shared across and with regular sound shifts), confirm the family's internal coherence while highlighting Apachean as a terminal branch with accelerated divergence rates, possibly due to contact-induced borrowing during post-Proto-Athabaskan expansions. Phylogenetic models using lexical retention rates estimate Apachean split from Northern ancestors around 1000–1500 years ago, with bootstrap support for exceeding 80% in distance-based trees incorporating 100+ basic vocabulary items. These reconstructions privilege regular sound correspondences, such as the shift of Proto-Athabaskan ł to Apachean sh in environments before high vowels, over sporadic resemblances that could reflect borrowing.

Dialectal Variations

The Apache languages, part of the Southern Athabaskan branch, feature dialectal variations aligned with historical band territories, broadly dividing into Western and Eastern groupings as classified by linguist Hoijer in 1938. The Western group encompasses and the dialects of Western Apache bands, including San Carlos, White Mountain, Cibecue, and varieties, which exhibit partial to high among speakers due to shared phonological and grammatical structures. In contrast, Eastern dialects—spoken by Jicarilla, Lipan, and (Kiowa Apache)—diverge more significantly, with reduced to Western forms, often requiring prior exposure for comprehension. A Southwestern subgroup, comprising and dialects, occupies an intermediate position; these are mutually intelligible within the pair but distinct from both Western and Eastern clusters, reflecting band-specific lexical and phonetic innovations. These barriers stem from limited inter-band communication, as Apache groups occupied separate territories across the arid Southwest's mountain ranges and deserts, fostering independent evolution of variants through geographic separation. Dialects incorporate loanwords from , introduced via colonial contact, particularly for post-16th-century items like horses (*ba'ííłééchąąʼí, from Spanish avallar) and metal tools, integrating seamlessly into verb complexes while preserving core Athabaskan . Such borrowings vary by band exposure to Spanish missions and settlements, with Eastern dialects showing fewer due to later or less intense interactions compared to Southwestern groups.

Current Status and Revitalization

Apache languages, part of the Southern Athabaskan branch, are classified as endangered by linguistic assessments, with fluent speakers concentrated among elders and proficiency rates low among younger generations across dialects such as , Mescalero-Chiricahua, and . For instance, Mescalero-Chiricahua had fewer than 150 fluent speakers as of estimates from the early , a figure indicative of ongoing decline given the aging speaker base and limited intergenerational transmission. , spoken by communities on reservations in , similarly faces erosion, with revitalization challenged by the scarcity of child acquirers despite total L1 speaker counts in the low thousands. Revitalization initiatives in the 2020s include tribal-led programs emphasizing immersion and community engagement. The Mescalero Tribe resumed its language program in 2025 with weekly vocabulary initiatives, cultural events like gatherings tied to linguistic practice, and school-integrated teaching by dedicated instructors. Similarly, the San Carlos Tribe secured a federal Living Languages Grant Program award of between $200,000 and $300,000 in December 2023 to support documentation, curriculum development, and instruction aimed at halting loss. Broader federal support through the has distributed over $15 million since 2020 to various tribes, including Apache groups, for materials like textbooks, flashcards, and teacher training, though these efforts often prioritize cultural preservation over widespread functional use. Despite such programs, the practical utility of Apache fluency remains constrained by the dominance of English in intertribal, economic, and national contexts, where small speaker networks—typically under 15,000 per major dialect—limit domains of application beyond ceremonial or familial settings. Grant-dependent funding introduces vulnerabilities, as initiatives like those in and San Carlos rely on periodic federal allocations rather than self-sustaining community mechanisms, potentially undermining long-term viability amid shifting priorities. Fewer than 1,000 young fluent speakers exist across dialects, underscoring the gap between enrollment in language classes and achieved proficiency.

Population and Demographics

Historical Population Estimates

Estimates of Apache populations prior to sustained European contact are challenging due to the groups' decentralized, nomadic structure and reliance on oral traditions rather than written records. Spanish explorers and missionaries in the late 17th century, such as those documenting interactions in and , placed the total population in the Southwest at approximately 5,000 around 1680, encompassing early subgroups like the Jicarilla, Lipan, and bands. This figure reflects a sparse distribution across arid territories, sustained by raiding, hunting, and gathering rather than , which constrained growth beyond small sizes of 50-200 individuals. By the 1700s, population levels likely ranged from 5,000 to 10,000 across Southwest Apache groups, as inferred from colonial reports on raiding parties and encounters, though direct censuses were rare and often underestimated mobile populations. Epidemics, including outbreaks transmitted via trade networks with and settlements as early as the 1630s, began eroding numbers before intensive U.S. involvement, with mortality rates potentially exceeding 50% in affected bands due to lack of immunity. Ongoing intertribal conflicts, such as with Comanches and Utes who acquired and firearms from Europeans, further limited demographic recovery, as raiding economies prioritized mobility over and large-scale reproduction. Into the , U.S. reconnaissance and counts documented sharper declines amid escalated warfare. Western Apache subgroups totaled fewer than 5,000 by mid-century, per ethnographic syntheses of military and trader observations. The , for instance, numbered about 1,200 just before the erupted in 1861, reflecting cumulative losses from Mexican campaigns and diseases like in the 1830s-1850s. By 1880, following intensified U.S. military operations that killed or displaced thousands, the remaining non- Apache population hovered around 4,000-5,000, with many subgroups fragmented and total tribal estimates constrained by surrender policies and confinements. These figures, drawn from dispatches and early tallies, underscore how sustained guerrilla resistance, while tactically effective, proved demographically unsustainable against industrialized firepower and scorched-earth tactics.
Period/GroupEstimated PopulationKey Factors/Source Basis
Late 17th century (total Southwest Apaches)~5,000Spanish mission and expedition logs; nomadic structures.
1700s (Southwest bands)5,000-10,000Colonial raiding reports; pre-epidemic baselines.
Mid-19th century (Western Apache)4,000-5,000U.S. military estimates; territorial analyses.
1861 (Chiricahua)~1,200Pre-war U.S. surveys.
~1880 (non-reservation total)~4,000Army campaign records; war-induced reductions.

Contemporary Tribal Enrollment

Enrollment in Apache tribes is determined by individual federally recognized tribal governments, typically requiring proof of descent from historical tribal rolls and a minimum blood quantum, such as one-quarter Apache blood for the Tonto Apache Tribe or three-eighths for the Jicarilla Apache Tribe. This genealogical criterion distinguishes formal tribal membership from broader self-identification as Apache in U.S. Census data, where cultural affinity or partial ancestry may suffice without documented lineage. Blood quantum thresholds, inherited from federal policies like the Indian Reorganization Act of 1934, prioritize biological continuity but have sparked debates over exclusion of culturally assimilated descendants, as tribal sovereignty allows each nation to define its polity independently of federal oversight. Major Apache tribes report the following enrolled memberships based on recent official figures:
TribeEnrolled MembersSource
3,403BIA Jicarilla Agency data
5,230Tribal presentation to , 2023
White Mountain ApacheOver 12,000Inter Tribal Council of Arizona
Yavapai-Apache Nation2,596Tribal website, 2019 census
110Inter Tribal Council of Arizona
Fort Sill Apache650Tribal and library guide data
These figures exclude smaller bands and do not aggregate to a unified "Apache" total, as no central authority exists; overlaps with other tribes like are minimal due to separate enrollment rolls. A significant portion of enrolled Apache members reside off-, mirroring broader Native American patterns where % live outside reservation boundaries and 72% in or suburban settings, driven by economic factors such as limited reservation . This dispersal facilitates access to jobs and but poses causal challenges to cultural transmission, as physical separation from reservation-based ceremonial sites and elders reduces immersion in traditional practices, despite efforts via organizations. Reservations, while concentrating administrative services and land-based economies, can inadvertently dilute nomadic heritage through sedentary dependency and intermarriage, altering structures central to Apache .

Health and Socioeconomic Indicators

Health indicators among Apache tribal members reflect broader disparities experienced by and (AI/AN), with at birth averaging 70.6 years in 2021, compared to 78.8 years for the total U.S. population. Southwestern tribes, including Apache groups in and , face compounded risks from environmental factors on reservations and limited access to care, contributing to elevated mortality from chronic conditions. Diabetes prevalence is markedly higher, with diagnosed rates among AI/AN adults served by the () reaching 16.1% after age adjustment, over twice the national average of 7.4%. In areas like the service region, which encompasses tribes such as the San Carlos and White Mountain , accounts for disproportionate morbidity, linked to genetic predispositions, shifts from traditional diets, and socioeconomic barriers to prevention. Alcohol-related disorders affect 7.1% of , with in the past month reported by nearly 25%, and contributing to leading causes of death including injuries and on reservations. Socioeconomic conditions exacerbate health outcomes, with poverty rates on many Apache reservations exceeding 40%, as evidenced by historical from the San Carlos Apache Tribe showing 77% poverty in 2004 amid persistent underemployment. Overall AI/AN poverty stands at 25.4%, double the U.S. rate, driven by reservation isolation and limited economic diversification. Tribal gaming, operational since the 1990s under the , has generated revenues supporting jobs and services—such as scholarships and infrastructure on the San Carlos Apache —but benefits are uneven, with per capita distributions not fully alleviating inequality or unemployment rates hovering above 20% in some communities. IHS reports highlight ongoing challenges like inadequate housing and sanitation on reservations, which perpetuate cycles of poor despite federal funding.

Notable Individuals

Historical Warriors and Leaders

, born circa 1793, emerged as a prominent leader of the Mimbreño band of Apaches in the early , forging coalitions among Apache groups to counter incursions into their territories in present-day and . His strategic alliances extended to his son-in-law , enabling coordinated raids that inflicted significant losses on forces, with Apache warriors leveraging intimate knowledge of rugged terrain for hit-and-run tactics that minimized direct confrontations. These efforts demonstrated tactical acumen in sustaining resistance against numerically superior adversaries, though alliances often fractured due to opportunistic shifts, such as bands accepting temporary truces for material gains from settlers. Cochise, leader of the Chokonen band from the 1850s, inherited and expanded these coalitions following the in 1861, which ignited prolonged conflict with U.S. forces after the erroneous hanging of Apache hostages. Under his command, Apache warriors conducted guerrilla operations that evaded capture, with U.S. Army expeditions prior to the 1880s achieving few decisive successes despite deploying hundreds of troops, as Apaches exploited mobility and local intelligence to disperse and regroup. Cochise's leadership maintained band cohesion through 1872, when he negotiated a on ancestral lands, but internal opportunism—such as defections for U.S. annuities—undermined unified resistance. Victorio, a Warm Springs active in the 1870s, exemplified evasion tactics by leading approximately 90 warriors and families to escape the San Carlos Reservation in 1879, initiating a campaign of raids across and that terrorized settlements while avoiding encirclement. His forces repeatedly outmaneuvered U.S. and Mexican troops, sustaining operations through superior and adaptive strikes, with capture eluding large-scale pursuits until technological advances like telegraphs facilitated coordinated responses in the 1880s. Victorio's death in 1880 at Tres Castillos stemmed from betrayal by local scouts, highlighting how opportunism within allied networks often compromised strategies. Geronimo, a Bedonkohe warrior under ' early influence, rose in the 1870s-1880s employing similar guerrilla methods, commanding small bands that inflicted disproportionate casualties relative to their size—requiring over 5,000 U.S. soldiers for his 1886 . Pre-1880s engagements underscored resilience, with low rates attributable to decentralized command and mastery, though flaws like intra- vendettas and selective alliances with authorities for personal advantage eroded long-term cohesion.

Modern Figures and Activists

Ned Anderson served as chairman of the San Carlos Apache Tribe from 1978 to 1984 and initiated campaigns for the of 's remains from , , to tribal lands in , proposing independent verification of burial practices and grave integrity. In 1983, Anderson collaborated with White Mountain Apache leaders to inspect 's grave, confirming no visible disturbance but fueling investigations into unverified claims that at Yale held the warrior's skull, which gained media attention without conclusive repatriation under the later-enacted NAGPRA. His efforts underscored persistent disputes over Apache ancestral remains, though some descendants opposed relocation, prioritizing site preservation. Wendsler Nosie Sr., a San Carlos Apache elder and former tribal vice chairman, founded Apache Stronghold in 2014 to protest the federal land transfer of Chi'chil Biłdagoteel (Oak Flat) to for a massive underground mine, which would collapse the sacred site used for puberty rites, , and ancestral ceremonies. Nosie has maintained a continuous camp at the location, framing the fight as a defense of First Amendment religious freedoms under the (RFRA); initial district court injunctions in 2021 were overturned by the Ninth Circuit in 2023, and the U.S. denied twice, most recently on October 7, 2024, allowing the transfer to proceed despite dissents from Justices Gorsuch and Thomas. His activism, joined by family members including granddaughter Naelyn Nosie, has mobilized national support but faced setbacks amid arguments that economic benefits from copper mining—estimated at billions in revenue—outweigh site destruction, though Nosie contends this ignores irreversible cultural loss. San Carlos Apache tribal leaders, including figures overseeing the Apache Gold and Resort opened in 1995, have driven as an economic engine generating over $100 million annually in revenue by 2020, funding and services amid high tribal rates exceeding 40%. However, internal criticisms have emerged, with community members alleging profiteering and chronic mismanagement of funds dating back decades, contributing to federal interventions like the 2014 receivership of tribal assets due to and disputes, though courts have upheld operations as sovereign enterprises. These tensions highlight causal trade-offs in tribal , where profits enable autonomy but have not uniformly alleviated socioeconomic challenges rooted in historical land loss and federal dependency.

References

  1. [1]
    White Mountain Apache Language Issues
    White Mountain Apache (WMA) is an Athabaskan language; Athabaskan language subgroups are Northern, Pacific Coast, and Southern Athabaskan.Missing: territory | Show results with:territory
  2. [2]
    Apache Southwest Indians - Alliance for Networking Visual Culture
    Apr 30, 2015 · The Western Apache of Arizona are comprised of four different groups, the White Mountain Apache, San Carlos Apache, Tonto Apache, and Yavapai Apache.
  3. [3]
    Apache • Museum of Northern Arizona
    The Western Apache arrived in the Southwest between 1000-1500 A.D., were originally hunters/gatherers, and were defeated in 1886. Many still live in Arizona.
  4. [4]
    Apache Indians - Texas State Historical Association
    Sep 29, 2020 · The Apaches were nomadic and lived almost completely off the buffalo. They dressed in buffalo skins and lived in tents made of tanned and ...
  5. [5]
    Apache Before 1861 - Chiricahua National Monument (U.S. National ...
    Aug 10, 2023 · The Chiricahua Apache were nomadic people (until recently) who lived in quickly constructed wikiups. Wikiups provided shelter from all the elements.
  6. [6]
    The Apache Wars Part II: Geronimo - Chiricahua National Monument ...
    Aug 19, 2018 · Geronimo was not a chief, but a medicine man of the Bedonkehe band of the Chiricahua Apache. He would eventually become their leader.
  7. [7]
    Apache Warriors | History Detectives - PBS
    Apache warriors were nomadic, initially peaceful, but became powerful riders and raiders, especially for horses, and were powerful by 1692. They were later ...<|separator|>
  8. [8]
    Our Culture - Official Website of the Mescalero Apache Tribe
    Tribal History. Hundreds of years ago, long before white men came to this land, these mountains, plains and deserts belonged to the Mescalero Apaches.
  9. [9]
    [PDF] Navajo Origins - UNM Digital Repository
    Jan 27, 2021 · tled farmer, much as the term Apache was employed in later times, or as "Chichimecos" was used in Mexico to designate. ·any warlike people. · .
  10. [10]
    Ndee - Native-Languages.org
    "Ndee" is an alternate name for the Apache tribe. It comes from an Apache word meaning "the people," and is one of the names Apache people use to refer to ...Missing: Indee | Show results with:Indee
  11. [11]
    The Chiricahua Apache - Fort Bowie National Historic Site (U.S. ...
    Jul 10, 2021 · The origin of the name "Apache" probably stems from the Zuñi "apachu." Apaches in fact referred to themselves with variants of "nde," simply ...Missing: endonym | Show results with:endonym
  12. [12]
    Indee - Native-Languages.org
    "Indee" is an alternate name for the Apache tribe. It comes from an Apache word meaning "the people," and is one of the names Apache people use to refer to ...
  13. [13]
    Jicarilla | Encyclopedia.com
    The Jicarilla are an American Indian group whose names for themselves, "Haisndayin" and "Dinde," have been translated as "people who came from below" and " ...Missing: self- | Show results with:self-
  14. [14]
    http://www.lipanapache.org/LAT/e-name.html
  15. [15]
    Inde (Apache) Literature - Indians.org
    The Jicarilla (Tinde) range over southeastern Colorado, northern New Mexico, and northwest Texas, with the Lipan occupying territory directly to the east of the ...
  16. [16]
    [PDF] Tribal Histories - the Texas Department of Transportation FTP Server
    Jul 13, 2022 · During the early eighteenth century several distinct bands emerged in the Spanish record from the general term, “Apache” (Dunn 1911). The ...
  17. [17]
    Amistad NRA: American Indian Tribal Affiliation Study (Phase 1 ...
    Apr 24, 2007 · Unfortunately, he equates the Padouca with Comanche, a common error that has been perpetuated. The Padouca were plains Apaches.
  18. [18]
    Kiowa Apache Indians - Texas State Historical Association
    Nov 17, 2020 · The Kiowa Apache Indians, a small group of Athabascan (Apachean)-speaking people, ranged the area of present southwestern Oklahoma and the ...
  19. [19]
    History - Apache Tribe of Oklahoma
    Known historically as the Ka-ta-kas, and later as the Kiowa Apaches, they are descendants of Apache groups who have inhabited the Plains since the 16th century.Missing: territory | Show results with:territory
  20. [20]
    Jicarilla Apache Nation - Keepers of the River - Ten Tribes Partnership
    The Jicarilla Apache Nation Indian Reservation spans more than 879,917 acres in north central New Mexico. The Reservation is located in the upper reaches of ...
  21. [21]
    Our Sacred History - Lipan Apache Tribe of Texas
    The Lipan Apache Tribe claimed the land farthest east of all the Apache tribes. By the 1600s, the Lipan Apache lived on the grassy plains of North Texas. At ...
  22. [22]
    Lipan Apache - Fort Davis National Historic Site (U.S. National Park ...
    Oct 30, 2021 · The Lipan ranged across the Southern Plains from southern Kansas to northwest Texas. Lipan were among the first of the Plains Indians to obtain horses.Missing: Tinde | Show results with:Tinde<|separator|>
  23. [23]
    Jicarilla Apache Tribe - Access Genealogy
    Jicarilla (Mexican Spanish: `little basket'). An Athapascan tribe, first so called by Spaniards because of their expertness in making vessels of basketry.Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
  24. [24]
    Apache and Navajo Tribes and Nations of New Mexico
    The Jicarilla Apache people, whose name means "little basket maker," were nomadic before European contact and they traded with Taos and Picuris Pueblos.
  25. [25]
    Jicarilla War - Wikipedia
    The Jicarilla War began in 1849 and was fought between the Jicarilla Apaches and the United States Army in the New Mexico Territory.
  26. [26]
    Treaty with the Jicarilla Apache, 1855 - Tribal Treaties Database
    The United States agree to set apart and withhold from sale, for the use of the Jicarillas, for their permanent homes, and hereby guarantee to them the ...
  27. [27]
    Jicarilla Agency | Indian Affairs
    The Jicarilla Agency serves the Jicarilla Apache Nation, with about 3,403 members, and has branches like Facilities Management and Forestry.
  28. [28]
    Government - Jicarilla Oil & Gas Administration
    The Jicarilla Apache Nation is governed by its Revised Constitution. Oil and gas activities are governed by Jicarilla Apache Nation Code Title 18 - Oil & Gas.<|separator|>
  29. [29]
    Jicarilla Apache Nation - New Mexico Tourism Department
    They wandered and traded as far east as Kansas until they settled deep in the northern Sangre de Cristo Mountains in the mid-1720s. The Jicarilla Apache Nation ...
  30. [30]
    Lipan Apache Culture in Historical Perspective - jstor
    LITTLE IS KNOWN concerning many aspects of Lipan Indian culture. Field work by Opler, Gifford, and Hoijer2 on the Mescalero Reservation.
  31. [31]
    History Timeline - Lipan Apache Tribe of Texas
    A timeline of the Lipan Apache Tribe history from contact to 1903.Missing: Tinde | Show results with:Tinde
  32. [32]
    89(R) HB 4732 - Committee Report (Substituted) version - Bill Analysis
    The Lipan Apache Tribe of Texas is the present-day incarnation of a proud people who have lived in Texas and northern Mexico for more than 300 years.Missing: population | Show results with:population
  33. [33]
    Those Who Stayed Behind: Lipan Apache Enclaved Communities
    PDF | On Jul 1, 2019, Oscar Rodriguez and others published Those Who Stayed Behind: Lipan Apache Enclaved Communities | Find, read and cite all the research you
  34. [34]
    Alonzo Chalepah Plains Apache Collection - Sam Noble Museum
    The Plains Apache language, spoken by the Plains Apache people living mainly in the western part of Oklahoma, is incredibly endangered. One of the last native ...
  35. [35]
    PLAINS APACHES | Encyclopedia of the Great Plains
    Today, we are recognized as the Apache Tribe of Oklahoma. This name was established in 1972 when the Kiowa, Comanche, and Apache tribes officially separated.Missing: history population
  36. [36]
    Medicine Lodge Creek Treaty on View at NMAI | National Archives
    Nov 28, 2023 · The decision stated the government had the right to cancel treaties with Native Americans and to dissolve the Kiowa, Comanche, and Apache ...<|separator|>
  37. [37]
    Apache Tribe of Oklahoma | The Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History ...
    The official enrollment stood at 1,802 in the year 2000. Dianna Everett. See Also Browse Entries Learn More Citation. See Also. AMERICAN ...
  38. [38]
    Western Apache - Summary - eHRAF World Cultures
    Western Apache includes the subtribes White Mountain, San Carlos, Cibecue, Northern Tonto, and Southern Tonto. They were defined as a single cultural unit ...
  39. [39]
    Mescalero Apache Tribe – Access Genealogy
    Mooney 1 records the following divisions: Nataina; Tuetinini; Tsihlinainde; Guhlkainde; Tahuunde. These bands intermarry, and each had its chief and suhchief.<|separator|>
  40. [40]
    Mescalero Apache Tribe commemorates reservation boundaries ...
    Jun 6, 2023 · The Mescalero Band, who were named by the Spanish after seeing this group harvest the sweet, savory mescal hearts, was one of several bands of ...
  41. [41]
    Indigenous History in the Borderlands: Apache - LibGuides
    Oct 1, 2025 · For self‐ reference the word ndee – nnee “man, person, Apache” may be used.” Today, San Carlos renders the autonym as Ndeh and White Mountain as ...Missing: endonyms | Show results with:endonyms<|separator|>
  42. [42]
    “CHAPTER” in “The Social Organization of the Western Apache”
    These divisions are Jicarilla Apache, Lipan Apache, Kiowa-Apache, Mescalero Apache, Chiricahua Apache, and Western Apache, Although the Navaho are always ...
  43. [43]
    Post-Contact Social Organization of Three Apache Tribes.
    There are 62 Western Apache clans. These derive from three archaic clans, on which basis they are grouped into phratries. Clans are associated with the clan ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  44. [44]
    Western Apache - Religion and Expressive Culture
    Apaches believe that a number of supernatural powers associated with natural phenomena exist. These powers are neutral with respect to good and evil.
  45. [45]
    White Mountain Apache Tribe - Arizona Memory Project
    The White Mountain Apache Tribe now consists of approximately 15,000 members. Many live here on our Tribal lands, but others live and work all over the country ...
  46. [46]
    FAQ | SAN CARLOS APACHE TRIBE - OFFICIAL WEBSITE
    What is the population of the tribe? San Carlos Apache tribe, has a population on the reservation of approximately 10,815 persons: According to the U.S. census.
  47. [47]
    https://www.ethnologue.com/language/apw/
  48. [48]
    Apache, Western Language (APW) - Ethnologue
    The language is used as a first language by all adults in the ethnic community, but not all young people. It is not known to be taught in schools.
  49. [49]
    History & Culture - OFFICIAL WEBSITE - san carlos apache tribe
    In the late sixteenth century, the Western Apaches made contact with Spanish explorers who moved northward and interrupted ancient trade connections.Missing: divisions | Show results with:divisions
  50. [50]
    Chiricahua Apache - Summary - eHRAF World Cultures
    The Chiricahua Apache are an Athapskan-speaking Native American group who may have originally migrated to the Southwest from western Canada.
  51. [51]
    History and Traditional Culture - Fort Sill Apache Tribe
    The Fort Sill Apache Tribe was relocated to Oklahoma. Today, the tribal members proudly stand as survivors and descendants of the Chiricahua Apache tribe.
  52. [52]
    Mescalero Apaches - Guadalupe Mountains National Park (U.S. ...
    The Mescaleros, or Nde (In-deh) as they called themselves, hunted mule deer, elk, and bighorn sheep, and harvested plants including, agave, sotol, and bear ...Missing: territory | Show results with:territory
  53. [53]
    Mescalero Apache - Summary - eHRAF World Cultures
    Mescalero Apache is one of the Southern Athapaskan languages. It is mutually intelligible to speakers of other Apachean languages and Navajo and is related to ...Missing: territory | Show results with:territory
  54. [54]
    [PDF] Mescalero Apache History in the Southwest - UNM Digital Repository
    It was finally decided to remove one of these renegade bands under Victorio to the Mescalero reserve, but Victorio was not willing to come. However, in June.of ...
  55. [55]
    Mescalero Apaches - Fort Davis National Historic Site (U.S. National ...
    Oct 30, 2021 · One of the most notable Mescalero victories against Fort Davis troops occurred in August 1861 when the post was manned by Confederate forces.
  56. [56]
    Mescalero Apache | Land Acknowledgment Toolkit — NMAHC
    Sacramento Mountains, Otero County. Current Population: 7,000. Pre-Contact Population: Estimates put the total population of all Apache tribes at 100,000.
  57. [57]
    Home - Official Website of the Mescalero Apache Tribe
    The Mescalero people were nomadic hunters and gathers and roamed the Southwest. They were experts in guerrilla warfare and highly skilled horsemen. The women ...Our Culture · Career Openings · News · Mescalero Apache Cultural...
  58. [58]
    Sacred Sites Sustaining Tribal Economies: The Mescalero Apache
    The Mescalero Apache traditional homelands were what is now known as central New Mexico. Sierra Blanca, along with three other mountains surrounding the ...
  59. [59]
    Navajo Conflicts - US-History.com
    The Navajo were a predacious tribe of some 50 clans who, frequently with their Apache allies, regularly pillaged the Pueblo and later the Spanish and Mexican ...<|separator|>
  60. [60]
    Indigenous peoples of the American Southwest - Navajo, Apache ...
    Sep 6, 2025 · The Navajo occupied a portion of the Colorado Plateau adjacent to Hopi lands. The Apache claimed the basin and range country east and south of the Plateau.
  61. [61]
    [PDF] relations between comanches and lipans from white contact to early ...
    Soon after 1700 the Spaniards reported that the Comanches and Utes were raiding the Apaches and pushing them southward.
  62. [62]
    Comanche Indians - Texas State Historical Association
    Oct 9, 2020 · Comanches raided Spanish settlements for horses to trade to Anglo-American traders entering Texas from the United States. Those Americans ...
  63. [63]
    https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc2816/m2/1/high_res_d/dissertation.pdf
  64. [64]
    [PDF] Spanish Relations with the Apache Nations East of the Río Grande.
    Comanche nation, allied with their cousins the Utes began to make inroads into land traditionally held by the Apaches. To the east, traditional enemies of ...
  65. [65]
    Indians in American-Mexican Relations Before the War of 1846
    Indian raids, especially by Apache, Navajo, Ute, Comanche and Kiowa, caused problems for Mexico. American treaties and trade increased these raids, and they ...Missing: naming | Show results with:naming
  66. [66]
    The Captive - El Palacio Magazine
    The Southwestern slave trade—both a cause and consequence of the long war between the Apaches and Mexico—took a ghastly human toll, with thousands of Apache men ...
  67. [67]
    [PDF] UC Berkeley - eScholarship
    Over a millennium ago Athabas- kan-speaking groups migrated into northwestern California and southwestern Oregon from a northern point of origin several hundred ...
  68. [68]
    Native American mtDNA prehistory in the American Southwest - Malhi
    Jan 22, 2003 · This study examines the mtDNA diversity of the proposed descendants of the multiethnic Hohokam and Anasazi cultural traditions, ...
  69. [69]
    Reconciling migration models to the Americas with the variation of ...
    Aug 12, 2013 · In this study we evaluated migration models to the Americas by using the information contained in native mitochondrial genomes (mitogenomes) ...Missing: contact | Show results with:contact
  70. [70]
    Y-chromosome analysis reveals genetic divergence and ... - PNAS
    May 14, 2012 · The data suggest that Canadian Eskimoan- and Athapaskan-speaking populations are genetically distinct from one another.Missing: minimal | Show results with:minimal
  71. [71]
    High-Resolution SNPs and Microsatellite Haplotypes Point to a ...
    Single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) analysis indicated that three major haplogroups, denoted as C, Q, and R, accounted for nearly 96% of Native American Y ...<|separator|>
  72. [72]
    [PDF] material cultural correlates of the athapaskan expansion
    Apr 2, 2012 · At least nine different Northern and Southern Athapaskan languages have a variant of the same term for 'clay pot' or 'kettle' (Table 6-4) ...
  73. [73]
    Na Dene/Athapaskan archaeology and linguistics - Academia.edu
    The earliest archaeological evidence of Na Dene migration is associated with microblades, dating back to 9500 BCE. The Apachean migration to the Southwest ...
  74. [74]
    Early Apache in the Southern Southwest, pp. 120 –142. In Ancient ...
    In this paper I present evidence that proto-Apacheans (represented archaeologically by Avonlea points) were in eastern Colorado by the 13th century and the ...
  75. [75]
    Features - Walking Into New Worlds - September/October 2020
    There is, in fact, growing archaeological evidence for ancestral Apachean groups moving into the greater Southwest as early as the 1300s. Archaeologist Deni ...
  76. [76]
    (PDF) Athapaskan Migration to the North American Southwest
    May 19, 2020 · During the 1930s, the Edward Sapir's linguistic research made it possible to determine that the migration flowed from north to south, but this ...
  77. [77]
    (PDF) Jornada Mogollon Water Reservoir Below the Organ Mountains
    Sep 28, 2016 · Two radiocarbon dates from deep reservoir fill deposits indicate that infilling probably began in the late 1300s–1400s (cal A.D.).
  78. [78]
    Jordan: Southwestern Chronology
    1450-1550 Migration of Navajo and Apache into the Southwest from the north. ... Earliest archaeological evidence of Navajo presence in Upper San Juan area ...
  79. [79]
    Horse Trading Among Nations - Washington, D.C.
    The Pueblo, Navajo, Apache, Ute, Comanche, and Shoshone were some of the first Native peoples to acquire horses. The objects shown here represent the ...Missing: 1600s | Show results with:1600s
  80. [80]
    Equine History - Return to Freedom
    By 1659, settlements reported being raided for horses, and in the 1660s the “Apache” were trading human captives for horses. The Pueblo Revolt of 1680 also ...
  81. [81]
    Ute | Encyclopedia.com
    At first the Ute wandered their territory on foot, hunting and gathering food. In the 1600s they acquired horses from the Spanish, and their lives underwent a ...
  82. [82]
    Landis Project - Texas Beyond History
    Researchers argue that the Querechos were almost certainly Plains Apaches, whereas the Teyas were most likely Caddoan speakers. Following the Coronado ...
  83. [83]
    Coronado's Querechos and Teyas in the Archaeological Record of ...
    These groups, referred to as Querechos and Teyas, were prototypic Plains nomads, specializing in the hunting and processing of bison, whose products they traded ...Missing: proto- | Show results with:proto-
  84. [84]
    Can anyone help me with sixteenth-century occurrences of the ...
    Jul 14, 2013 · The Keres pueblos apparently called Apaches "Kirayash" or "Q'irauash"; this could well be the root of the word "Querechos". As for the time ...
  85. [85]
    [PDF] The Beginning of the Apache Menace of the Southwest
    "12 An alliance between the. Apaches and the Pueblo Indians, such as those which were common later on, may have been the cause of Onate's appar- ently erroneous ...
  86. [86]
    New Mexico History : The Pueblo Revolt of 1680
    Ongoing crop failure and famine, absent the Spanish military presence, led to increasingly frequent and aggressive attacks by Apache, Navajo, Comanche and Ute ...
  87. [87]
    “9. Western Apaches” in “Cycles of Conquest: The Impact of Spain ...
    The Mescaleros of later history were in part at least the Mimbreño Apaches of the early Spanish records. The early focus of Apache raiding which most affected ...
  88. [88]
    [PDF] The Spread of Spanish Horses in the Southwest
    Jan 27, 2021 · Apache raiding on Spanish herds ensued. By 1608 the settlers were so discouraged that they requested permission to return to New Spain.2 It ...
  89. [89]
    The Spanish Frontier in Colorado and New Mexico, 1540-1821 ...
    Nov 20, 2008 · Invariably campaigns against these tribes were failures. This was because, with the exception of the Moqui, the natives were raiders who could ...
  90. [90]
    Rethinking the Establecimientos: Why Apaches Settled on Spanish ...
    Apache negotiations involved securing food rations, gifts, and recovery of captives in exchange for peace. Environmental stressors like drought influenced ...Missing: details | Show results with:details<|separator|>
  91. [91]
    [PDF] The Apaches in the History of the Southwest - UNM Digital Repository
    Jan 1, 1975 · In the 1830'S the. Apaches returned to their old ways, and their raids became more destructive than ever, reaching their peak in the 1840'S. The ...
  92. [92]
    Indigenous Sonora: Four Centuries of Warfare (Part 2)
    Sep 6, 2025 · The first Apache raids on Sonora appear to have taken place during the early part of the late Seventeenth Century. They sustained themselves ...<|separator|>
  93. [93]
    [PDF] Apache Plunder Trails Southward, 1831-1840
    Feb 9, 2021 · In November, 400 Mogollon Apaches surged down the. Sierra Madre. Some raiding parties went westward into. Sonora. Others struck along the Silver ...Missing: depopulation | Show results with:depopulation
  94. [94]
    Independent Indians and the U.S.-Mexican War | History Cooperative
    These quiet but persistent traders also conducted a lucrative trade in captives, and likely provided the lion's share of guns and munitions to the southern ...
  95. [95]
    [PDF] The Scalp Hunt in Chihuahua—1849 - UNM Digital Repository
    In October, when the company'was campaigning fromEI Paso across southern New Mexico to Ben Moor Peak and beyond, it consisted of thirty Mexicans, twenty-seven ...
  96. [96]
    [PDF] The U.S. Government and the Apache Indians, 1871-1876 - DTIC
    The conflict stemmed from complex factors, was a traditional insurgency, and the US had a short military campaign but lacked a balanced national strategy.Missing: empirical data
  97. [97]
    Gadsden Purchase, 1853–1854 - Office of the Historian
    The United States Government agreed to work toward preventing American raids along Mexico's border and Mexico voided U.S. responsibility for Native American ...
  98. [98]
    [PDF] Apaches and the mining menace: Indian-White conflicts in ...
    Nov 16, 2022 · The Mescaleros Apaches were one of the first Apache groups to face military retaliation for their raids against Rio Grande settlements in 1854- ...
  99. [99]
    raiders' mayhem - Baja Arizona History
    The Gadsden Purchase Treaty of December 1853 abrogated Article XI of the ... ” Yet this rescinding of the legal obligation to take responsibility for Apache raids ...
  100. [100]
    [PDF] The Apache Campaigns. Values in Conflict - DTIC
    review the engagements between the Apache and the U. S. Army as presented in official records and other historical accounts. These pages will give first a ...
  101. [101]
    [PDF] Chapter 4: The Military Seeks Control - National Park Service
    tactics that worked against both the Mescaleros and Navajos at Bosque Redondo. The money was allocated to buy food, clothing, and supplies. As occurred in ...
  102. [102]
    Bosque Redondo Memorial at Fort Sumner Historic Site
    Hundreds of Mescalero Apaches were also interned there. The Navajos lost 20 percent of the tribe due to the insufferable conditions. Determined a failure in ...
  103. [103]
    Wars for Empire: Apaches, the United States, and the Southwest ...
    Jan 1, 2019 · In the 1860s alone, more than 1,600 Apaches were killed in war, which is in contrast to an estimated 108 US soldiers and 244 Anglo civilians ( ...
  104. [104]
    [PDF] Irregular Warfare in the American West: The Geronimo Campaign
    Crook's tactical innovations enabled his units to relentlessly harass the enemy until they could no longer sustain the fight. Crook's protege, Lieutenant ...
  105. [105]
    Those Who Served: The U. S. Army on the Frontier
    One historian writes, “At any given time during this period, fewer than 12,000 soldiers occupied the region exceeding 2 million square miles and occupied some ...
  106. [106]
    Cochise 1812-1874 - PWNA - Partnership With Native Americans
    The Apache Wars began. Cochise joined with Mangas Coloradas and led a guerilla campaign against U.S. and Mexican forces. After a significant defeat where ...
  107. [107]
    The Apache Wars Part I: Cochise - National Park Service
    Apr 7, 2023 · Finding or defeating Chief Cochise had proven futile for the U.S. Army. The strategy shifted to relocating him and the Chiricahua Apache to ...
  108. [108]
    Apache Wars, Summary, Facts, Significance
    May 26, 2024 · ... Apache-Mexico Wars, started in the 17th Century when colonists from New Spain established settlements in New Mexico. In 1821, Mexico ...
  109. [109]
    Indian Bows - True West Magazine
    Sep 25, 2015 · In the early days of the frontier, it was even superior to the settler's firearms. While the bow predates recorded history, some historians feel ...<|separator|>
  110. [110]
    The Apache Wars | History of the Apache in Verde Valley - Sedona.net
    The Apache Wars began with Spanish scalp bounties, escalated with Cochise's revenge, and ended with Geronimo's surrender, driven by land encroachment and use ...
  111. [111]
    [PDF] A Strategic and Cultural Analysis of General George Crooks Use of ...
    Conclusion: The use of Apache scouts as auxiliary forces during Crook's second Apache campaign was extremely effective and unique in contrast to how the ...
  112. [112]
    Mary Smith, An Affecting Narrative of the Captivity and Sufferings of ...
    Popular through the colonial and early national periods, Indian captivity narratives were filled with graphic details of torture, potential cannibalism, and ...Missing: diaries | Show results with:diaries
  113. [113]
    Apache Wars: History, Commanders, & Major Facts
    Oct 16, 2024 · Figures like Geronimo and Cochise have become symbols of Native American resistance and resilience. The wars also highlight the broader ...
  114. [114]
    Geronimo surrenders | September 4, 1886 - History.com
    On September 4, 1886, Apache leader Geronimo surrenders to U.S. government troops. For 30 years, the Native American warrior had battled to protect his tribe's ...
  115. [115]
    1886: Apache armed resistance ends; Geronimo surrenders
    Goyathlay, a powerful Apache leader, also known as Geronimo, hands his rifle to a U.S. general in surrender. When his tribe had been relocated to a ...
  116. [116]
    Mirrors on the Mountains - Warfare History Network
    Something needed to be done to improve military communications. The Apaches had already learned to cut the copper telegraph wires between forts sometimes ...Missing: defeat | Show results with:defeat
  117. [117]
    [PDF] In Search of an Elusive Enemy: The Victorio Campaign - DTIC
    The campaign also shows the American soldier can adapt to harsh conditions and win against an elusive and deadly enemy, in this case the Apache. The Mimbres ...
  118. [118]
    [PDF] THE BATTLE OF BIG DRY WASH: Arizona's Last Great Apache Fight
    relations in the Southwest. The roots of the Big Dry Wash fight date back to the killing of an obscure Apache medicine man named Nockaydelklinne at.
  119. [119]
    Apache Incarceration - Castillo de San Marcos National Monument ...
    Apr 20, 2022 · The Apache prisoners were confined at the fort for just over one year. After a year, the group was moved to Alabama and then later to Fort Sill ...Missing: exile | Show results with:exile
  120. [120]
    Geronimo (person) | The Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and ...
    GERONIMO (ca. 1829–1909). A Chiricahua Apache religious and military leader, Geronimo was born in the 1820s, perhaps near present Clifton, Arizona.
  121. [121]
    After Geronimo surrendered, his people were crammed into this ...
    Aug 15, 2025 · Twenty-four died from disease in just one year. Children were born in captivity while others were torn from their families and sent to boarding ...Missing: exile | Show results with:exile
  122. [122]
    Geronimo - Wikipedia
    Gerónimo was a military leader and medicine man from the Bedonkohe band of the Ndendahe Apache people. From 1850 to 1886, Geronimo joined with members of ...Geronimo (exclamation) · Geronimo, Arizona · Geronimo (disambiguation) · Arizpe
  123. [123]
    Apache chief Geronimo: Florida's biggest tourist trap in 1886
    Sep 14, 2025 · Lozen, the famous Apache woman warrior and sister of Chief Victorio, caught tuberculosis at Mount Vernon Barracks and died before the move to ...Missing: mortality | Show results with:mortality
  124. [124]
    Apache, Fort Sill | The Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture
    The American Indian tribe known today as the Fort Sill Apache was moved to Oklahoma in 1894 after continuing nearly a decade of imprisonment and exile.
  125. [125]
    Geronimo, Apache villagers held at Alabama's Mount Vernon were ...
    Sep 7, 2016 · In 1894, the Apaches were relocated to Fort Sill, where they remained captive until 1914. Although they had been told they would be confined for ...
  126. [126]
    [PDF] THE INCARCERATION OF THE CHIRICAHUA APACHES, 1886-1914
    The United States government incarcerated a large group of Chiricahua Apaches for twenty-seven years, from 1886 to 1914. The Chiricahuas were prisoners of war ...
  127. [127]
    Exiled to Indian Country: Fort Sill Apache Tribe - Cherokee Phoenix
    Apr 4, 2020 · The Chiricahua Apaches were the last to resist US government control of the American Southwest and were held as prisoners of war in exile for nearly a decade ...Missing: tuberculosis | Show results with:tuberculosis
  128. [128]
    Our History | SAN CARLOS APACHE TRIBE - OFFICIAL WEBSITE
    In 1872, the United States created Camp San Carlos for the purpose of concentrating and detaining thousands of Yavapai, Chiricahua, and Western Apache from ...
  129. [129]
    Yavapai and Tonto Apaches - National Park Service
    The Yavapai and the Western Apaches lived similar ways of life, as nomadic hunters and gathers, but they represented completely different linguistic groups.Missing: subgroups | Show results with:subgroups
  130. [130]
    [PDF] San Carlos Agency collection - Arizona Historical Society
    Poor planning resulted in no supply issued to the Indians during the hard winter of 1884. Such mismanagement resulted in factional desertion of the reservation.Missing: disease | Show results with:disease
  131. [131]
    Arizona: San Carlos Apache - Partnership With Native Americans
    In 1876 the U.S. government attempted to move the Chiricahua Apaches from their homeland to the San Carlos Reservation, but the Indians refused to relocate and ...
  132. [132]
    Apaches - History, Modern era, The first apaches in america
    The San Carlos Reservation and Fort Apache Reservation were administratively divided in 1897. ... Apaches have suffered devastating health problems from the last ...
  133. [133]
    [PDF] Native American Women and the Dawes Act of 1887 - Harvard DASH
    The policy of the Dawes Act disrupted the family structure and roles of women within historically matrilineal societies such as the Apache and Ojibwe peoples.Missing: impact | Show results with:impact
  134. [134]
    The Devastating Impact of the Dawes Act on Native Americans
    Nov 10, 2021 · The Dawes Act was directly responsible for the loss of 90 million acres of Native American land, effectively abolishing tribal self-governance ...
  135. [135]
    Government Boarding Schools Once Separated Native American ...
    Jun 19, 2018 · The Carlisle Indian Industrial School was a government-backed institution that forcibly separated Native American children from their parents.
  136. [136]
    Apache | Carlisle Indian School Digital Resource Center
    Cemetery information and mortuary documents related to Jim Foxcatcher (Fox catcher), a member of the Apache Nation. Nation: Apache, Apache ...
  137. [137]
    Chiricahua Apache Students After Training at the Carlisle Indian ...
    These Chiricahua Apache students were photographed at the Carlisle Indian School, near Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, four months after their arrival.
  138. [138]
    How Boarding Schools Tried to 'Kill the Indian' Through Assimilation
    Aug 16, 2017 · The US government forced tens of thousands of Native American children to attend “assimilation” boarding schools in the late 19th century.
  139. [139]
    An Apache ceremony for the ages | Searchlight New Mexico
    Sep 6, 2023 · Tribal ceremonies like these were outlawed by the U.S. government under the 1883 Code of Indian Offenses, an attempt to eliminate “heathenish” ...
  140. [140]
    The Devastating History of Native American Boarding Schools
    ... Apache Indians After Training at the Carlisle Indian School, 1886. Photographs of American Military Activities, ca. 1918 – ca. 1981, Records of the Office ...
  141. [141]
    The long and fierce struggle of the Apaches | Culture | EL PAÍS English
    Jun 5, 2023 · They could not abide being confined. Three facets seemed to condition Apache culture: plunder, revenge (and honor) and superstition (and taboos) ...
  142. [142]
    11.1 The Ghost Dance movement and its spread to the Southwest
    The Ghost Dance movement spread rapidly among Native American tribes in the Southwest, including the Navajo, Apache, and Comanche, in the early 1890s; The ...
  143. [143]
    [PDF] The Struggle for Sovereignty at San Carlos: A Decision-Making ...
    services)-had organized the rally to protest alleged widespread corruption and mismanagement by several members of the tribal council. Just three weeks ...
  144. [144]
    [PDF] The Indian Reorganization Act (W'heeler-Howard Act) June 18, 1934
    The Act aimed to conserve Indian lands, extend rights to form organizations, establish a credit system, grant home rule, and provide vocational education.
  145. [145]
    [PDF] Tribal Self-Government and the Indian Reorganization Act of 1934
    The IRA of 1934 was significant legislation affecting Indians, impacting tribal self-government, which is based on original tribal sovereignty, not federal ...
  146. [146]
    Native American Urban Relocation | National Archives
    Sep 24, 2025 · BIA pledged assistance with locating housing and employment. Numerous Native Americans made the move to cities. They struggled to adjust to life ...
  147. [147]
    Stride toward Freedom: The Relocation of Indians to Cities, 1952-1960
    Over 122,000 Indians moved to cities between 1940-1960, with 31,000 receiving help under the 1952 program, due to poor reservation economies and low income.
  148. [148]
    The 1950s plan to erase Indian Country | Uprooted - APM Reports
    Nov 1, 2019 · In 1956, in response to criticism of the relocation program, Congress passed the Indian Relocation Act, or Public Law 959. It added vocational ...
  149. [149]
    Bureau of Indian Affairs Records: Termination | National Archives
    Sep 9, 2024 · Termination ended federal recognition of affected tribes and the federal aid and services that came with that recognition. It also ended federal ...
  150. [150]
    Mescalero Apache - Economy
    In this century there has been a steady increase in wage work on and off reservation. Tribal enterprises practice Indian preference in hiring. ... There are also ...
  151. [151]
    Merrion v. Jicarilla Apache Tribe | 455 U.S. 130 (1982)
    The District Court, consolidating the actions, entered a permanent injunction, ruling that the Tribe had no authority to impose the tax, that ...
  152. [152]
    New Mexico v. Mescalero Apache Tribe | 462 U.S. 324 (1983)
    The application of New Mexico's laws to on-reservation hunting and fishing by nonmembers of the Tribe is preempted by the operation of federal law.
  153. [153]
    [PDF] Gallegos v. Jicarilla Apache Nation - Tribal Supreme Court Project
    Without any discussion on the allegations raised in. Gallegos' complaint about rampant pervasive corruption within the JAN PD, Judge Johnson concluded: "Nor can ...
  154. [154]
    Apache Tribe's 'Erin Brockovich'; PART FIVE - ICT News
    government corruption that starts at the tribal level and leads directly to the White House. Chappabitty also said he can see an old pattern that has pitted ...
  155. [155]
    Apache Stronghold v. United States - Becket Fund
    Apache Stronghold is fighting to save their sacred land at Oak Flat from destruction by a Chinese-owned mining company.Missing: rackets Pueblo tribute evidence
  156. [156]
    Protecting Oak Flat and Tribal Religious Practices (Apache ...
    The nonprofit organization Apache Stronghold initially brought the case to protect a sacred place the Apache call Chí'chil Biłdagoteel, which translates into ...Missing: rackets Pueblo evidence
  157. [157]
    Oak Flat is Sacred to Western Apache. The Trump Administration ...
    Apr 18, 2025 · The Trump administration on Wednesday signaled it intends to approve a land transfer that will allow a foreign company to mine a sacred Indigenous site in ...
  158. [158]
    Apache Stronghold v. United States, No. 21-15295 (9th Cir. 2024)
    The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled in favor of the United States in a dispute over the planned transfer of a site, Oak Flat, of ...<|separator|>
  159. [159]
    [PDF] 24-291 Apache Stronghold v. United States (05/27/25)
    May 27, 2025 · The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied. JUSTICE. ALITO took no part in the consideration or decision of this petition.
  160. [160]
    [PDF] Economic Benefits Fact Sheet - Resolution Copper
    BENEFITS. EACH YEAR. DIRECT EMPLOYEES. 1,500. INDIRECT JOBS. 2,200. 3,700TOTAL JOBS. AT FULL PRODUCTION,THE MINE ANTICIPATES. SUPPORTING. CREATING LOCAL JOBS.
  161. [161]
    Pinal Apaches, Miners, and Genocide in Central Arizona, 1859-1874
    The San Carlos Apache Tribe is a leading defender of Oak Flat, a large public campground on the western flanks of the Pinal Mountains east of Phoenix.Missing: empirical competition
  162. [162]
    Oak Flat Timeline: Native American vs. pro-mining interests | AP News
    Jun 28, 2023 · The nonprofit Apache Stronghold considers the land sacred and say it should be preserved for religious ceremonies. The project is on hold ...
  163. [163]
    Land Exchange - Yavapai-Apache Nation
    The Yavapai-Apache Nation Federal Land Exchange involves the proposed exchange of about 4,782 acres of largely unspoiled National Forest inholdings owned by the ...
  164. [164]
    Yavapai-Apache Nation swaps lands with U.S. Forest Service ... - KJZZ
    Nov 8, 2024 · Prescott National Forest Supervisor Sarah Clawson (left) and Yavapai-Apache Nation Chairwoman Tanya Lewis sign a land exchange on Nov. 4, 2024.
  165. [165]
    Yavapai-Apache Nation, U.S. Forest Service agree to land swap
    Nov 4, 2024 · The new land will more than double the tribal nation's trust lands from 1,810 to 5,011 acres, although the total is still a shadow of what the ...
  166. [166]
    Proposed Land Exchange with Mescalero Apache Tribe
    BACKSTORY: The Mescalero Apache Tribe has proposed a land exchange to receive certain ancestral lands that are now state trust lands. The State Land Office ...
  167. [167]
    Proposed land swap being discussed between Mescalero Apache ...
    Sep 29, 2025 · “The Mescalero Apache Tribe proposed a land exchange with New Mexico State Land Office that would return certain ancestral lands to the Tribe.
  168. [168]
    Supreme Court refuses to hear Apache Stronghold's religious ... - KJZZ
    Oct 7, 2025 · The U.S. Supreme Court will not reconsider the nonprofit Apache Stronghold's effort to preserve sacred lands from a massive copper mining ...Missing: controversy | Show results with:controversy
  169. [169]
    Apache Stronghold v. United States (2025) - Free Speech Center
    Jun 2, 2025 · In Apache Stronghold v. U.S., the Supreme Court refused to hear a religious freedom case challenging a law that allowed mining on Apache ...
  170. [170]
    Water Rights & Trust Fund Program | SAN CARLOS APACHE TRIBE
    The Water Rights & Trust Fund Program provides project administration to the Water Rights Settlement Projects from the 1992 Water Rights Settlement Act.
  171. [171]
    Inn of the Mountain Gods Resort and Casino Information
    Revenue, $36.5 million ; Employees, 295 (131 on RocketReach) ; Founded, 2003 ; Address, 287 Carrizo Canyon Rd, Mescalero, New Mexico 88340, US ; Phone, (575) 464- ...
  172. [172]
    New Mexico tribes see slot revenue growth | News | taosnews.com
    Sep 4, 2018 · Its slot revenues were $166.7 million in the 2018 fiscal year. The Jicarilla Apache Nation rakes in the least money of the gaming tribes. Clark ...
  173. [173]
    [PDF] THE ECONOMIC IMPACT OF TRIBAL GAMING IN ARIZONA, 2014
    Sep 23, 2015 · Today the San Carlos Apache Tribe uses revenues from the casino to fund scholarships and provide employment opportunities on the reservation, ...
  174. [174]
    Casino revenues haven't helped most Indians - Tampa Bay Times
    Sep 3, 2000 · Despite new gambling jobs, unemployment on reservations with established casinos held steady around 54 percent from 1991 to 1997 as many of the ...
  175. [175]
    [PDF] THE IMPACT OF INDIAN GAMING ON EDUCATIONAL ...
    Aug 27, 2009 · The Mescalero Apache tribe is struggling to make profits through Indian gaming and their education measures fall in between these two control ...
  176. [176]
    Jicarilla Apache Nation leaders targeted over financial losses
    Aug 9, 2018 · The Jicarilla Apache Nation suffered more than $2 million in losses at one of its casinos in New Mexico and some tribal citizens want to see their leaders held ...
  177. [177]
    The Impact of Gaming on the Indian Nations in New Mexico
    Aug 6, 2025 · Gaming has had a positive economic and social impact on the gaming pueblos and tribes in New Mexico, especially for the more urbanized nations.<|separator|>
  178. [178]
    Self-Determination and Resources: A Survey of U.S. Indian Forestry
    Mar 16, 2010 · The White Mountain Apache's logging and sawmill operation provides over 500 jobs to tribal members and brings in $30 to $40 million annually.
  179. [179]
    [PDF] Economic, social, and cultural aspects of livestock ranching on the ...
    Land losses and herd size cutbacks undoubtedly pushed many people into the cash-based economy of wage work (West 1982). Over the years there was a notable trend ...
  180. [180]
    [PDF] Federal Funding and Unmet Needs In Indian Country Federal ...
    This study reveals that federal funding directed to Native Americans through programs at these agen- cies has not been sufficient to address the basic and very ...
  181. [181]
    [PDF] The Economic Impact of Tribal Government Gaming in Arizona
    In 2007, the Tohono O'odham ca- sino supported about 3,000 jobs and injected more than $25 mil- lion into the economy. The Tonto. Apache Tribe casino in Payson.
  182. [182]
    Apache Crown Dancers - Video (U.S. National Park Service)
    Dec 3, 2023 · The Apache Crown Dance is a ceremonial dance that celebrates ancestors, community, and traditions while honoring gifts from the Creator.Missing: revival | Show results with:revival
  183. [183]
    Solstice Saturday: Joe Tohonnie Jr. and the Apache Crown Dancers
    Jul 7, 2023 · Joe Tohonnie Jr. and the Apache Crown Dancers (White Mountain Apache) from Whiteriver, Arizona, celebrate the ... program was recorded in ...Missing: revival | Show results with:revival
  184. [184]
    Mescalero Cultural Campus: - Official Website of the Mescalero ...
    -Cultural Center -Head Start Program -Historic Preservation Office. This is a fantastic opportunity to learn about the upcoming developments ...Missing: initiatives | Show results with:initiatives
  185. [185]
    The piloting of a culturally centered American Indian family ...
    Dec 22, 2017 · The Mescalero Apache Family Listening Program (MAFLP) is a culturally centered family prevention program with third, fourth, and fifth graders; a parent/ ...
  186. [186]
    Apaches' Dispute With American Museum of Natural History
    Aug 19, 2013 · Four years ago, the American Museum of Natural History agreed to return to the Apaches 77 objects from its collection, including headwear, ...
  187. [187]
    Apache Battle NYC Natural History Museum Over Sacred Objects
    A persistent disagreement has kept 77 objects from being returned to the Apaches from the American Museum of Natural History for the last four years.
  188. [188]
    Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Review ...
    Feb 7, 2007 · The dispute focused on whether 33 items (catalogue records) in the possession or control of the Field Museum are “objects of cultural patrimony ...
  189. [189]
    [PDF] Ecological Restoration and the Revitalization of the White Mountain ...
    Apr 27, 2009 · The main argument of this dissertation is that the White Mountain Apache Tribe‟s appropriation of ecological restoration played a vital role in ...
  190. [190]
    Departments & Programs - Official Website of the Mescalero Apache ...
    Cultural Resources. Mescalero Apache Cultural Center & Museum · The Mescalero Apache Tribe Language Program. Historical Preservation ... Early Childhood Program ...Missing: initiatives | Show results with:initiatives
  191. [191]
    “III. CLANS” in “The Social Organization of the Western Apache”
    The Western Apache also declare that wherever women have married they have introduced their clan. They insist that the Chiricahua have White Mountain clans ...
  192. [192]
    [PDF] THE SOCIAL DIVISIONS AND ECONOMIC LIFE OF THE WESTERN ...
    The clan system of the Western Apache is not so easy to fit into the sequence formed by the already described social divisions. Whereas each of the groups ...
  193. [193]
    Apache Warrior Women | Gouyen, Lozen, Dahteste
    Apache women held prominent roles in Apache society. Women often accompanied warriors on raids, took up arms to defend their people, counseled men in battle ...
  194. [194]
    [PDF] braver than most and cunning in strategy
    is the study of the alternative roles of Apache women. It is all too often that Native American women are viewed as "squaws" and mere supporting characters ...
  195. [195]
    Western Apache - Economy
    By the 1950s most of the non-Indians who were running livestock on Indian land had been forced off, and the tribes themselves started cooperative herding ...Missing: timber | Show results with:timber
  196. [196]
    https://plans.txdot.gov/pub/txdot-info/env/toolkit/415-07-rpt.pdf
  197. [197]
    Tree rings reveal persistent Western Apache (Ndee) fire stewardship ...
    Aug 18, 2025 · Western Apache myths and legends further connect Ndee fire stewardship and knowledge to dry pine forests. In traditional stories, before Ndee ...Missing: timber livestock
  198. [198]
    [PDF] Tribal Histories - the Texas Department of Transportation FTP Server
    Jul 3, 2020 · The Mescalero Apache Tribe today is comprised of descendants from many different bands, because the survivors of the Indians Wars sought refuge ...Missing: population | Show results with:population
  199. [199]
    [PDF] Notes on the History and Adaptation of the Apache Tribes Author(s)
    horse. If we assume raiding to be the main business of these people, perhaps ... a raiding economy, were continually forced to defend themselves ...
  200. [200]
    Apache - Prehistoric Texas - Texas Beyond History
    Aug 1, 2005 · When the Apache were first encountered by the Spanish, they were described as hunters and gatherers with a focus on bison hunting.
  201. [201]
    [PDF] III. The Ethnobiology of the Chiricahua and Mescalero Apache
    The customs pertaining to the hunting of deer will serve as an example. ... as those of bear grass (Nolina microcarpa), mescal (Agave parryi), and amole ...
  202. [202]
    Plains Apache Ethnobotany - University of Oklahoma Press
    The traditional Apache economy centered on hunting, gathering, and trading with other tribes. Throughout their long history the Apache lived in or traveled to ...Missing: practices | Show results with:practices
  203. [203]
    American Indian Film Gallery: Apache Cooking
    Apr 30, 2015 · The Western Apache were hunters and gatherers. They learned agriculture from neighboring tribes, but practiced it on a very small scale ...Missing: techniques processing
  204. [204]
    THE AUTUMN OF FORAGING IN THE LITTLE GREEN VALLEY - jstor
    Given these considerations, one would expect several food plants represented at Apache winter camps. These include maize, beans, juni nuts, walnuts, and ...
  205. [205]
    War of a Thousand Deserts: Indian Raids and the U.S.-Mexican War ...
    This is American history, Mexican history, and Indian history. To ... Indians, had been buying horses stolen from northern Mexico and encouraging raids.
  206. [206]
    [PDF] Horses in the Southwest (18-3)
    New Mexico's first executions occurred during. Oñate's initial year in Santa Fe, when two Indians were hanged for attempted horse theft. Yet, contrary to ...
  207. [207]
    Matthew Luckett's Book Explores Horse Stealing on the Western ...
    Oct 28, 2020 · For a time, horse stealing and raids were a reciprocal response, according to Luckett. “If someone stole your horses then you would go steal ...
  208. [208]
    Apache Captives' Ordeal - HistoryNet
    Jun 12, 2006 · When Apache warriors swooped down on the defenseless Oatman family in sunbleached Arizona in 1851, the harrowing nightmare was just beginning.Missing: integration ransom
  209. [209]
    Captives of American Indians - Texas State Historical Association
    ... torture in retaliation. When warfare developed between Europeans and American Indians, White captives were taken for the same reasons and, in addition, to ...Missing: integration rituals
  210. [210]
    Torture among Native Americans | Research Starters - EBSCO
    Torture among Native Americans has historical roots in the practices of various indigenous tribes, where it was often directed towards enemies, captives, and ...Missing: ransom | Show results with:ransom
  211. [211]
    [PDF] THE EVOLUTION OF THE TREATMENT OF CAPTIVES BY THE ...
    32This account of Father Bressani's torture comes from. Ibid., 39:59-73; 26:33-51. 3 3 Ibid., 34:27-33. 3 4 This account of Radisson's captivity comes from.
  212. [212]
    Raiders of a Lost Art? Apache War and Society - ResearchGate
    Aug 7, 2025 · Apache principles of war were a product of a social organization, which was geared towards raiding and warfare, based upon a clear set of ...
  213. [213]
    apache religion and ceremonies - AAA Native Arts
    Agents of powers are called diyin (shaman). Those who have their knowledge secretly and use it for their own ends are witches, or ilkashn. In the past there ...
  214. [214]
    Ga'an: The Sacred Mountain Spirits of the Apache People - Aniwa
    Rating 4.8 (4) The Apache Crown Dancers are channels of the Ga'an, meaning they allow the Sacred Mountain Spirits to embody them. Men are the only ones who are able to learn ...
  215. [215]
    The Apache Ga'an Dance – Second Face - Mask Museum
    The dancers represent mountain spirits during the ceremony and, as such, embody sacred beings. There are various myth stories surrounding the ga'an. One is that ...
  216. [216]
    Apache Ga'an Dance - Texas Cowboy Art by Mike Capron
    Apr 28, 2024 · The dancers represent mountain spirits during the ceremony and, as such, embody sacred beings. There are various myth stories surrounding the ga ...
  217. [217]
    Appeasing the Dead - Traditions of Conflict
    Apr 16, 2022 · The spirit of the deceased is believed to be malign and resents being deprived of the company of his family and band and will revenge himself on anybody whom ...
  218. [218]
    Indians 101: Treatment of death among Southwestern cultures
    Oct 15, 2020 · With regard to the Chiricahua Apache, at death the spirits begin a four-day journey to the spirit world. For the Chiricahua, open burial sites ...
  219. [219]
    Religiosity and Spiritual Engagement in Two American Indian ...
    The Native American Church​​ A prominent example of syncretic religions is the NAC, or Peyote Way. Its practices, which have roots in pre-Columbian traditions, ...
  220. [220]
    Religion on the Reservation · Native Americans Then and Now
    The modern Kiowa religious landscape is a blend of Christian, peyote, and traditional beliefs. The majority of members identify as Christian.
  221. [221]
    [PDF] Material Culture of the Pima, Papago, and Western Apache
    The limited materials used for house building may be indicated. BASKETRY ... clothing, and food, and rectangular baskets for medicines and magical objects.
  222. [222]
    American Indian Film Gallery: Apache Dwellings
    Apr 30, 2015 · A traditional Apache dwelling is called a “wickiup.” Wickiups are dome-shaped structures built out of oak or willow poles, that are driven into the ground.
  223. [223]
    American Indian Film Gallery: Apache Clothing
    Apr 29, 2015 · Traditional Apache women's clothing consisted of buckskin dresses, and men's traditional clothing consisted of breechcloths during the summer and a buckskin ...Missing: deerskin tunics
  224. [224]
    Unveiling the Ancient Mystique of Apache Stone Artifacts
    Jun 14, 2025 · Apache artisans used a variety of materials, including obsidian, flint, jasper, and other types of stone. The choice of material often depended ...
  225. [225]
    At what point in time did native Americans stop making arrowheads ...
    Aug 27, 2023 · The adoption of European weaponry into traditional tool kits happened at different times throughout the Americas. Plus there have been ...<|separator|>
  226. [226]
    Students in Southwest History class build a traditional wickiup
    Feb 3, 2020 · The class learned that Apaches and other primarily nomadic tribes built wickiups for shelter by using any type of sapling (about 3-4” in diameter) and sinew or ...
  227. [227]
    What Is A Wickiup? | California Trail Interpretive Center
    Jun 24, 2023 · It is typically constructed using a framework of sturdy branches and covered with a combination of bark, reeds, grass, or animal hides. This ...
  228. [228]
    The Construction of a Wickiup on the Fort Apache Indian Reservation
    or not all the materials necessary for construction are collected beforehand. These materials consist of poles, leafy branches, a large supply of bear grass.
  229. [229]
    Clothing - Fort Sill Apache Tribe
    Apache women traditionally wore a 2-piece buckskin outfit with a poncho like blouse decorated with fringe on the side. It would feature a circular yoke with ...Missing: deerskin | Show results with:deerskin
  230. [230]
    Apache Tribe Clothing - The History Junkie
    Jun 23, 2019 · Apache women wore buckskin dresses, and over time, that progressed to calico skirts and dresses. This change was due to Mexican influence.
  231. [231]
    1882 Chiricahua Apache - Forensic Fashion
    To distinguish themselves from others, says Dutton, the Warm Springs men wore a buckskin band over the right shoulder, colored yellow with the sacred pollen of ...<|separator|>
  232. [232]
    Our Sacred History-Lipan Apache Weapons
    Lipan Apache used bows, arrows with metal arrowheads, lances, muskets, and possibly war clubs. Bows were made of cedar or mulberry wood.
  233. [233]
    What were some tools used by the Apache tribe?
    Before European contact, the Apache used stone axes, bone knives, wooden mallets, stone-tipped spears, bows and arrows, and stone hand scrapers. After, they ...
  234. [234]
    Native American Stone Tool Technology and Use in the Historic ...
    Native Americans used stone tools for food procurement, processing, and maintenance, even in historic times, due to functionality, cultural reasons, and lack ...
  235. [235]
    R3 Food — Work 4 - Native American Art Teacher Resources
    Apache basketweavers used a twining method to weave sumac or willow shoots into sturdy, long-lasting baskets. Twining is a type of basketry construction created ...Missing: tools agriculture implements
  236. [236]
    Athabaskan language family | History, Characteristics & Dialects
    Sep 26, 2025 · Athabaskan language family, one of the largest North American Indian language families, consisting of about 38 languages.
  237. [237]
    Na-Dené languages | Athabaskan, Tlingit & Haida - Britannica
    The Athabaskan family is a branch of the Athabaskan-Eyak subgroup of the Na-Dené language phylum, which was named for the words for 'person' in Tlingit and ...
  238. [238]
    The Athabaskan (Dene) Language Family (Chapter 23)
    The languages are usually divided into three geographic groups, northern Athabaskan, southern Athabaskan or Apachean, and Pacific Coast Athabaskan.
  239. [239]
    [PDF] Domains of Interpretation within the Athabaskan Verb: Semantic
    The Athabaskan languages share a common verbal morphology characterized by polysynthesis and rich paradigmatic alternations. The verb has been commonly assumed ...
  240. [240]
    [PDF] Krauss (2005) Tonogenesis Tables: IPA Transcription
    There is a single (so far) Athabaskan language with a three-tone system, Tsuut'ina (Sarcee), which Krauss lists with the L-marked languages, also worthy of ...
  241. [241]
    [PDF] Tone-prominence interaction in Hän Athabaskan - UCLA Linguistics
    Athabaskan verbs are generally analyzed as a case of position class morphology. ... Low tone cannot spread to an unmarked (high tone) verb stem. An example of ...
  242. [242]
    Apachean languages - Britannica
    The Navajo language is an Apachean language in the Athabaskan language family. At some point in prehistory the Navajo and Apache migrated to the Southwest from ...
  243. [243]
    [PDF] The Phylogenetic Status of Pacific Coast Athabaskan
    There were differences in the tree topologies as well: the strict clock finds a clade with 67% support that includes the Northern and Apachean languages to the ...
  244. [244]
    The Chronology of the Athapaskan Languages
    The second column indicates, for each date interval, the number of divergences of. Pacific Coast and Northern languages. ... 1938, The Southern. Athapaskan ...
  245. [245]
    The phonological hierarchy of the White Mountain dialect of Western ...
    Hoijer (1938) finds that the Apachean languages may be classed into an eastern and a western group. The western group being composed of Navajo, Western Apache ...
  246. [246]
    (PDF) Phonetic structures of Western Apache - Academia.edu
    Western Apache is a Southern Athabaskan language spoken primarily on the San Carlos and White Mountain Apache Reservations in east central Arizona.
  247. [247]
    [PDF] What Language Did The Apache Speak
    Some Apache languages are mutually intelligible to varying degrees, but others are distinct enough that speakers may not easily understand each other without ...<|separator|>
  248. [248]
    Southern Athabaskan languages - Wikipedia
    Self-designations for Western Apache and Navajo are N'dee biyat'i, and Diné bizaad or Naabeehó bizaad, respectively. There are several well-known historical ...
  249. [249]
    5.1 Apache groups and their distinct cultural identities - Fiveable
    From the fierce Chiricahua led by Cochise to the skilled Mescalero basketmakers, Apache diversity challenges the idea of a single "Apache" identity. This ...Missing: nomenclature fluid
  250. [250]
    HISPANISMS IN SOUTHWEST INDIAN LANGUAGES - jstor
    "The Functions of Spanish Loanwords in 19th-century. Sources on the Western Apache Language." In III Encuentro de Lingüística en el Noroeste, 1: Lenguas ...
  251. [251]
    [PDF] Hispanisms in Southwest Indian Languages - Gwern
    O'odham show large numbers of loanwords. In the uplands and the Rio. Grande Valley, where Spanish was once a second language for some Indians, it has now been ...
  252. [252]
    Apache, Mescalero-Chiricahua Language (APM) - Ethnologue
    Mescalero-Chiricahua Apache is an endangered indigenous language of the United States and Mexico. It belongs to the Eyak-Athabaskan language family.Dashboard · Want To Know More? · Ethnologue Subscriptions<|separator|>
  253. [253]
    Apache, Jicarilla Language (APJ) - Ethnologue
    This visualization shows the approximate size of this language community, using five general ranges for a quick visual sense of scale. Need exact figures?Summary · Dashboard · Want To Know More?
  254. [254]
    Mescalero Apaches work to save language - Deseret News
    Nov 9, 2011 · Last year, officials estimated that fewer than 150 tribal members were fluent in the Mescalero Apache dialect or its linguistic cousin, ...
  255. [255]
    We are excited to announce that the Apache Language Program ...
    Aug 8, 2025 · Join us as we celebrate and preserve our rich cultural heritage through the Apache language. ... Today, our Mescalero Apache language and cultural ...
  256. [256]
    Ndé Bizaa' - Official Website of the Mescalero Apache Tribe
    What are our specific goals, given the mission? › Increase the number of tribal members who know and use Apache. (Increase the number of fluent Apache speakers.).
  257. [257]
    San Carlos Apache to receive Native language revival grant
    Dec 26, 2023 · The Living Languages Grants are awarded by the Indian Affairs Office of Indian Economic Development and range in value from $200,000 to $300,000 ...Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s<|control11|><|separator|>
  258. [258]
    Living Languages Grant Program (LLGP) | Indian Affairs
    It has awarded $5.723 million in total Living Languages Grant Program funding to 20 American Indian and Alaska Native Tribes and Tribal Organizations.Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
  259. [259]
    Book Review: Wars for Empire - HistoryNet
    May 24, 2018 · The author examines why it dragged on so long, considering the combined population of the Apache tribes totaled no more than 10,000, of whom ...<|separator|>
  260. [260]
    Native American disease and epidemics - Wikipedia
    By the mid-eighteenth century the disease was affecting populations severely enough to interrupt trade and negotiations. Thomas Hutchins, in his August 1762 ...
  261. [261]
    [PDF] CONSTITUTION of the TONTO APACHE TRIBE
    Membership of the Tribe shall include all persons who have enrolled on the official census of the tribe. Those persons in title to enroll on such official ...
  262. [262]
    Bureau of Indian Affairs Records: Tribal Rolls | National Archives
    Jul 21, 2025 · On This Page · Records Overview · Allotment Rolls · Annuity Rolls · Census Rolls · Judgment Rolls · Removal Rolls · Tribal Enrollment Today.Wallace Rolls of Cherokee... · Roblin Rolls of Non... · California Indian Enrollment...
  263. [263]
    White Mountain Apache Tribe | Inter Tribal Council of Arizona
    The Tribe has over 12,000 members located on nine major reservation communities. Whiteriver, the capital, is the largest community with over 2,500 residents.
  264. [264]
    The Yavapai-Apache Nation is located in the Verde Valley of ...
    With 2,596 total enrolled tribal members (April 2019 numbers) with over 750 residents living in the five (5) tribal communities.
  265. [265]
    Tonto Apache Tribe - Inter Tribal Council of Arizona |
    The total population of the Tonto Apache Reservation is approximately 140 of which 110 are enrolled tribal members. 102 members live on the reservation (Tonto ...
  266. [266]
    Federally Recognized Tribes in NM: Ft. Sill Apache Tribe
    Oct 19, 2022 · Tribal member enrollment, which requires a 1⁄16 minimum blood quantum (equivalent to one great-great-grandparent), stands at 650. The tribe ...
  267. [267]
    Indian Entities Recognized by and Eligible To Receive Services ...
    Jan 8, 2024 · This notice publishes the current list of 574 Tribal entities recognized by and eligible for funding and services from the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA)Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
  268. [268]
    Most Native Americans live in cities, not reservations. Here are their ...
    Sep 4, 2017 · 78% of Native Americans live off-reservation, and 72% live in urban or suburban environments. Those policies had devastating effects.Missing: migration | Show results with:migration
  269. [269]
    Native American Urbanization and Socio-Economic Integration in ...
    Native American urbanization has been internal reservation-to-city migration. This recent migratory current raised the urban portion of the Native. American ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  270. [270]
    Social Determinants of Health Among American Indians and Alaska ...
    May 20, 2024 · In 2021, life expectancy at birth was 70.6 years for AIANs, lower than that for APIs (84.1), Hispanics (78.8), non-Hispanic Whites (76.3), and ...
  271. [271]
    [PDF] IHS Indian Health Disparities
    The American Indian and Alaska Native people have long experienced lower health status when compared with other Americans. Lower life expectancy and the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  272. [272]
    New study shows decrease in diabetes prevalence for American ...
    Apr 29, 2020 · The prevalence of diagnosed diabetes in American Indian and Alaska Native adults decreased significantly from 2013 to 2017, according to a new study.
  273. [273]
    Substance Abuse Statistics for Native Americans
    May 2, 2025 · 7.1% of Native Americans have an alcohol use disorder. Nearly 25% of Native Americans report binge drinking in the past month. Native Americans ...Missing: Apache | Show results with:Apache
  274. [274]
    [PDF] SAN CARLOS APACHE TRIBE
    May 3, 2004 · We suffer from a poverty level of 77%. 2. Page 3. -. Percentages. 76.0 ... of tribal enrollment data in calculating Indian Housing Block Grant ...
  275. [275]
    https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Portals/7/combat-studies-institute/csi-books/occasional-paper-5-in-search-of-an-elusive-enemy.pdf
  276. [276]
    [PDF] American Indian Population and Labor Force Report - BIA.gov
    In 2003, Indian individuals employed but earning wages below the poverty level decreased by 772 between 2001 (132,500) and 2003 (131,728), and the overall.
  277. [277]
    "Review of <i>Mangas Coloradas: Chief of the Chiricahua Apaches ...
    Inch by inch Sweeney drags readers through the military life and times of one of the Chiricahua Apaches' most noted leaders Mangas Coloradas.
  278. [278]
    Cochise – Strong Apache Leader - Legends of America
    In 1856, Cochise became the principal war leader of the Chokonen band after the death of its chief, Miguel Narbona, and the peace between the Apache and the ...
  279. [279]
    [PDF] In Search of an Elusive Enemy: The Victorio Campaign
    The defiant Apache chief Victorio was the principal threat to Western ... The few who escaped, including aged Apache medicine man Nana, joined another ...
  280. [280]
    Victorio's War - HistoryNet
    Sep 3, 2008 · Known as the "greatest Indian general" ever, he terrorized settlers and the army, surpassing Geronimo's feats and ferocity.
  281. [281]
    TRIBES SEEK RETURN OF GERONIMO'S REMAINS TO APACHE ...
    Oct 23, 1982 · Anderson said he would propose research by an ''impartial'' group into three questions. ''First, was Geronimo buried according to Apache custom?Missing: repatriation | Show results with:repatriation
  282. [282]
    The Strange Saga of Geronimo's Skull - Santa Fe Reporter
    Jul 1, 2009 · In 1983, Ned Anderson, the same San Carlos chairman, along with Ronnie Lupe, his counterpart with the White Mountain Apache Tribe, traveled to ...
  283. [283]
    Speak Your Piece: Geronimo Remains | The Daily Yonder
    May 11, 2009 · Another group of Geronimo's descendants has also filed suit-opposing repatriation; they would like the Apache warrior's remains to stay where ...
  284. [284]
    Apache Stronghold
    " - Wendsler Nosie Sr. ... Justice Gorsuch wrote a dissent joined by Justice Thomas, calling the decision “a grievous mistake.” This is not the end for Oak Flat— ...
  285. [285]
    BREAKING: Apache Stronghold asks Supreme Court to save Oak Flat
    Sep 11, 2024 · Wendsler Nosie Sr. of Apache Stronghold. “We pray the Justices will protect Oak Flat and ensure that our place of worship is not treated ...
  286. [286]
    'On death row,' fate of Oak Flat now in the hands of U.S. Supreme ...
    Mar 21, 2025 · “This is a war on all religious ways if you believe in God,” said Wendsler Nosie Sr., founder of the nonprofit Apache Stronghold. “Native ways, ...<|separator|>
  287. [287]
    Oak Flat | Chi'chil Biłdagoteel | NIWRC
    Through the organization Apache Stronghold, Naelyn joins her grandfather, Wendsler Nosie, former Chairman of the San Carlos Apache Tribe, mother Vanessa Nosie, ...
  288. [288]
    Apache Gold Casino & Resort - OFFICIAL WEBSITE
    The San Carlos Apache Tribal Gaming Enterprise consists of two casino properties: the Apache Gold Casino and Resort, located 5 minutes east of Globe.Missing: modern leaders<|separator|>
  289. [289]
    Tribe in crisis | Premium News | wmicentral.com
    Just remember it's not the Apache people that are responsible for the mismanagement of federal and tribal funds. This has been going on for over fifty years.
  290. [290]
    [PDF] Response to The Mescalero Apache Indians and Monitored ...
    Yes, the Tribe doggedly pursues and aggressively negotiates prospective business ventures. Yes, we should be free to consider and pursue economic options on our ...